region a wireless propagation study€¦ · swc nc - ecc technologies 2. your presenter education...
TRANSCRIPT
REGION A WIRELESS PROPAGATION STUDY
SOUTHWEST COMMISSION, NC| OCTOBER 2019
Agenda
❑Your Presenter
❑Scope of Study
❑Current Results
❑Work in Process
❑Conclusions
SWC NC - ECC TECHNOLOGIES 2
Your Presenter▪ Education
▪ ECU BSBA Accounting/Computer Sci. | NCSU MS Economics
▪ Professional▪ Ernst & Whinney
▪ Sequent Computer Systems (IPO / IBM) [Large computer sys]
▪ Vanguard Cellular (IP) / ATT) [Original cellular provider]
▪ The Southern Company [Fortune 50 energy company]
▪ GTE (pre-Verizon) [Wireless data – CDPD and 1G]
▪ BellSouth (ATT) [Strategic planning, e-biz, large biz]
▪ ITO [Start up wholesaler of comms. circuits]
▪ ECC Technologies
▪ Selected Consulting▪ Charlotte Hornets
▪ Water Systems, Inc.
▪ East Tennessee Brain & Spine
▪ Palmetto Behavioral Health
▪ Waste Industries
SWC NC - ECC TECHNOLOGIES 3
▪ ECC Selected Clients▪ The Southwest Commission
▪ The Albemarle Commission
▪ State of Georgia
▪ Carroll EMC
▪ Madison County, NY
▪ Harnett County, NC
▪ Roanoke EMC
▪ Piedmont EMC
▪ Tidewater EMC
▪ EnergyUnited
▪ Flint Energies
▪ Cowetta Fayetta EMC
▪ MCNC Network
▪ Lumbee River EMC
▪ The Southern Tier Network
Scope Items▪ Identify areas of need using Phase 1 info
▪ Inventory vertical assets, map and identify
▪ Identify and map known fiber assets
▪ Conduct drive-by and visits on publicly owned vertical assets
▪ Contact asset owners
▪ Examine county tower ordinance s
▪ Identify RF frequencies in use
▪ Develop strategies for potential projects
▪ Present findings
SWC NC - ECC TECHNOLOGIES 4
ECC’s Responsibilities❑ Execute to support the goals of the
SouthWest Commission, which, in turn, aid each of the Counties.
❑ Support all viable, proven technologies.
❑ Support all proven, service providers.
❑ Support all voices in the communityworking together for broadband.
❑ Ensure focus is on information which is relevant, valuable and actionable.
❑ Continually ensure cost/value are parts of discussions.
SWC NC - ECC TECHNOLOGIES 5
Identify Areas of Need - 2017 BAAT▪ Broadband Assessment &
Aggregation Tool
▪ 4,689 residential responses
▪ 154 commercial responses
SWC NC - ECC TECHNOLOGIES 6
Selected Download Rates
0 – 4 Mbps
4 – 10 Mbps
10 – 25 Mbps
25 – 50 Mbps
Identify Areas of Need
SWC NC - ECC TECHNOLOGIES 7
Residential Commercial
2019 GREAT Grant Awards in SW NC❑Sky Wave ▪ Swain County
▪ Macon County
❑Sky-Fi▪ Jackson County
❑Morris Broadband▪ Macon County
SWC NC - ECC TECHNOLOGIES 8
Connect America Fund (CAF II) ❑ Shaded Blue Area is
the eligible area
❑ Dark Blue is the funded areas
SWC NC - ECC TECHNOLOGIES 9
Fiber Advantages and Providers
❑ Unlimited Bandwidth ❑ Telecom Standard for Backbone
Infrastructure between cities and communications towers
❑ Discrete / Independent Networks
❑ Multiple Users – both service providers, public organizations, enterprise and others
❑ Metro, Regional and Long haul
❑ Ring Redundancy
❑ Regional Fiber Providers❑ BalsaamWest / MCNC
❑ North Georgia Network (NGN)
❑ Morris Broadband, Zito Media, Murphy CATV, Cablevision and Northland
❑ Incumbents
◦ AT&T
◦ Charter
◦ Frontier
◦ Windstream
SWC NC - ECC TECHNOLOGIES 10
Fiber Routes in SW North Carolina
❑ Sources of Informationo GeoTelo Fiber Locatoro ECC Field Study in
Cherokee and Swain Counties
o Provider websites
SWC NC - ECC TECHNOLOGIES 11
Inventory and Map Vertical AssetsOver 400 records identified from 5 sources – with some duplications
SWC NC - ECC TECHNOLOGIES 12
Sources
County Information
State FirstNet Database
American Tower
Crown Castle
FCC Registration
Radio Propagation Samples
SWC NC - ECC TECHNOLOGIES 13
❑Map is based on 477 Info and2017 BAAT Survey
❑Compare data and look for areas in need
❑Towers were selected as examples
Propagation Mapping – Baseline
SWC NC - ECC TECHNOLOGIES 14
❑ Only Wireless Towers▪ 70% height (approx. 40M)
▪ Various Tower Owners
▪ Attempted to evaluate otherstructures – tanks et al
❑ Radio▪ Cambium PMP 450i
▪ Quality parameters – standard
❑ Antenna ▪ Gain 35 dbi
▪ Frequency 5,700 Mhz
▪ Tilt 4 degrees
Cherokee County – Sample Site 01
SWC NC - ECC TECHNOLOGIES 15
Fain Mtn Tower (Bill Forsyth) – Murphy, NC
Clay County – Sample Site 02
SWC NC - ECC TECHNOLOGIES 16
SBA Towers – Hayesville, NC
Graham County – Sample Site 03
SWC NC - ECC TECHNOLOGIES 17
Crown Castle –Robbinsville, NC
Haywood County – Sample Site 04
SWC NC - ECC TECHNOLOGIES 18
SBA Towers –Waynesville, NC
Jackson County – Sample Site 05
SWC NC - ECC TECHNOLOGIES 19
Crown Atlantic –Savannah, NC
Macon County – Sample Site 06
SWC NC - ECC TECHNOLOGIES 20
Crown Castle – Bryson City, NC
Swain County – Sample Site 07
SWC NC - ECC TECHNOLOGIES 21
SBA Towers – Nantahala, NC
Who Owns Towers in Western NC?
SWC NC - ECC TECHNOLOGIES 22
❑Private – Tower Owners▪ American Tower
▪ Crown Atlantic
▪ Crown Castle
▪ SBA
▪ Radio Stations
❑Public – County, City, Town • Wireless and Water Tanks
❑State – NC State Hwy Patrol VIPER System
Local Providers
SWC NC - ECC TECHNOLOGIES 23
o Incumbents –▪ AT&T, Charter, Frontier and Windstream typically will not do anything
until competition forces them to improve service.
o Alternative Providers - WISPs and others in the areao Sky-Fi – WISP in Jackson Countyo Sky Wave – WISP in Swain Countyo Sky Tech – WISP in Cherokee & parts of Clay Counties (River
Street)o Skyrunner – WISP in Ashville Haywood and Jackson Countieso Zito Media - Corp in PA, landline provider in Graham and
Swain Countieso Eastern Band of Cherokees Broadband – Wireless and land
line provider in Swain and Jackson Countieso Morris Broadband – Land Line provider in Macon County, GA
based companyo BalsamWest – WISP and land line provider in Cherokee, Clay,
Graham, Jackson, Macon and Swaino NGN (BREMC) – Land line provider in Cherokee County
Understand Providers Perspective❑Cost to provide broadband:o Tower lease (RAD)
o Tower climber
o Cabling
o RF equipment at the tower
o Switching equipment at the tower▪ Lease space / power
o Transport (circuit or dark fiber)
o Route to aggregation point
o Route to peering point
❑Purchase Network equipmento Spares
o Repairs
oMTTR
SWC NC - ECC TECHNOLOGIES 24
❑Networko Network management
o Network security
o 24 x 7 availability
❑End Usero Equipment
o Installation and configuration
o Billing AND collection
o 24 x 7 network AND device support
o Dispatch if required
o Spares
❑Regulatory & Legalo Reporting
o Frequency Management
Identify Frequencies Used
SWC NC - ECC TECHNOLOGIES 25
5 GHz Unlicensed PTMP and Backhauls PTP• LOS only• More spectrum than 3 GHz
11 GHz & 18 GHz Licensed Backhauls PTP• Licenses are easily obtained• Great throughput, high reliability
24 Ghz Backhauls PTP• Unlicensed• High throughput• Suffer from possible rain fade so reliability is an
issue on longer links• Low cost
2.4 GHz Unlicensed PTMP• Frequency is saturated and unusable in most
areas for WISPs
2.5 GHz Licensed PTMP• Better choice for penetration, non line of sight
(NLOS)• Best performance due to no interference• Hardest license to get
3.65 GHz License• Nationwide licenses not being issued by FCC• Better than 5 GHz for NLOS• Available product lines utilizing LTE technology
with best NLOS up to 3 miles in foliage
Fixed W/L Equipment Manufacturers
SWC NC - ECC TECHNOLOGIES 26
Manufacturer CostProviderSupport Frequencies
Baicells Medium Distributor 2.5, 3.5 and 5.8 (LTE) Ghz
Cambium Medium Direct & Distributor 900 Mhz, 2, 3 and 5Ghz
MikroTik Low Direct & Distributor 2.4 and 5 Ghz
Mimosa Low Direct & Distributor 4.9 to 6.4 Ghz
Radwin High Direct 2.x, 3.x, 4.9, 5.x, 6.4GHz
Ubiquiti Low Distributor 900 Mhz, 2.4, 3 and 5 Ghz
Telrad High Direct 2.3GHz, 2.5GHz, 3.5GHz(LTE) 5 Ghz
ECC is asking each vendor to model the seven sites previously shown in this slide – preferably using theirproprietary applications. This will allow a vendor, technology, topology, pricing and response comparison for the above listed companies.
Project Next Steps (WIP)
SWC NC - ECC TECHNOLOGIES 27
▪Conduct drive by visits of public assets
▪Continue to identify frequencies used
▪Develop strategies for potential projects
▪ Set meetings with potential alternative providers
• What are your plans for SWC?
• Use BAAT with alternate providers
▪Continue to meet with Counties and other interested parties
▪Complete Phase 2 report and present findings
Next Steps❑ Set a stairstep project plan to advance broadband
▪ Mitigate risk to the participants
▪ Understand the financial and operating constraints of providers
▪ Understand the current deployment environment
▪ Consider potential partners
❑ Consider opportunity to partner or participate in Grant applications▪ County involvement only
▪ Service Provider
▪ Council of Government
▪ Golden Leaf
▪ Electric Cooperative
▪ Other entities such as an agricultural cooperative
▪ Consider the creation of a Cooperative to apply for Federal Grants from both USDA and the FCC
SWC NC - ECC TECHNOLOGIES 28
Questions!
SWC NC - ECC TECHNOLOGIES 29
Thank You!SOUTHWEST COMMISSION NC | OCTOBER 2019