refutation of some objections on the verse 5:47 of quran

7/24/2019 REFUTATION OF SOME OBJECTIONS ON THE VERSE 5:47 OF QURAN

1/35

1

A COMMENTARY ON THE VERSE 5:47 AND REFUTATION OF OBJECTIONS ON THEHOLY QURA:NIC VERSE IN REGARD TO THE STATED VERSE.

THE Vere 5:47 ! "#$e% &$$e'($e) $" *e )!$"r$e) &%) e+er&, "*-e$!"% &re&$$e'($e) $" *e '&)e "% $/e Vere.

S"'e (e"(,e 0/" /&+e ,e#$ $/e #",) "# I,&' /&+e &," ,&!'e) $/&$ $/! +ere'&)e )"*$ !% $/e!r '!%) &%) &e) $/e' $" ,e&+e I,&:'.

T/e &r2'e%$ ! 2!+e% !% $/e #",,"0!%2 #"r':3

T/e +ere 5:47 r2e$/ C/r!$!&% $" J)2e #r"' &% "%e "# $/e Ne0 Te$&'e%$&,G"(e,16. /e% C/r!r$!&% J)2e #r"' &% "%e "# $/e Ne0 Te$&'e%$&, G"(e,

$/e 8%) $/&$ Qr&:% "%$r&)!$e$/ e&/ "%e "# $/e' "% )!9ere%$ !e &%) e&/"%e "# $/e' "% $/e !e "# r!8!"%.

S" !% $/e -)2e'e%$ "# Ne0 Te$&'e%$&, G"(e, Qr&:% ! %"$ $re. I# Qr&:% ! %"$$re $/e% !$ ! #&,e. S!%e &% $/!%2 $/&$ ! %"$ $re ! #&,e.

S" !% & e%e Qr&:% !'(,!e$/ !$ "0% #&,e/"").;T/e e%e ! (("e) $" *e &%!%)!re$ "%$r&)!$!"%/e*e,e&+e !% Qr&:% "r )"e %"$ *e,e&+e !% Qr&:% & Re&, D!+!%e S(ee/= &$,e&$

%)er$&%) $/! +ere "rre$, 0!$/ "$ &% )!$"r$!"% .T/! 0"r? ! )"%e 0!$/ $/e (!r!$ $/&$ !$ /&,, @I%/&: @ALLH &!$ *"$/ N"% M,!'&%) M,!' $" %)er$&%) $/e Me&2e O# Qr&:% !% !$ (r"(er (er(e$!+e = &%)*e &+e) #r"' &$$e'($e) )!$"r$!"%.

THE VERSE 5:4:3


2/35

I% $/e!r #""$$e( e Se%) I:&: ;Ie">Ye/&>I/>>< S"% O# M&r&';M!r!&'>M&r!'>M< C"%8r'!%2 $/e T&r&/ ;T"r&/< $/&$ /&) "'e (r!"r $" H!'A%)

e G&+e H!' @I%-!:, ;E&22e,!"%< !% 0/!/ 0& G!)&%e &%) ,!2/$ &%) C"%8r'&$!"%

"# T&r&/;T"r&/< $/&$ /&) "'e (r!"r $" !$ &%) &*)'"%$!"% $" G) #e&r!%2.

THE VERSE 5:47:3

Le$ $/e e"(,e "# @I%-!:,;E&22e,!"%< J)2e * $/&$ $/&$ @ALLH H&$/ Re+e&,e)Se%$)"0%6 $/ere!% .

A%) 0/" " e+er /&$/ %"$ J)2e * $/&$ $/&$ @ALLH /&$/ re+e&,e) Se%$6 !%$" $/e'$/e% / (e"(,e &re $r&%2re"r.

THE VERSE 5:4.A%) e /&+e Se%$ D"0% ;Re+e&,e)< $" T/ee $/e B""? ;N"%, @A, Qr&:%< !% Re&,!$"%8r'!%2 $/e Sr!($re ;B""?< 0/!/ &'e (r!"r $" I$ &%) M/&!'!%&% "+er$/e'. S" J)2e &'"'2 $/e' * /&$ @ALLH Re+e&,e) = &%) #",,"0 %"$ $/e!r +&!%)e!re )!+er2!%2 #r"' Re&,!$ ;Tr$/< $/&$ H&$/ C"'e $" T/ee.

N"$e :3 T/e "r) e ! e) & & ,r&, O# M&-e$. S" !$ ! !% M&-&! ;Se"%)&r @6AA< .

N"$e: T/e "%"%&%$&, I "# L&$!% ! (r"%"%e) & Y "# E%2,!/ "r J "# Ger'&%. B$ %"$ & J "# E%2,!/ $/e C"%"%&%$&, D!(/$/"%2 B); in *P02

I% &% &e $/e "%)!$!"% "# E&$ r!$ ! )r"((e).

;O%, & '&,, ("r$!"% "# Ne0 Te$&'e%$&, G"(e, "%$&!% 0"r) "# Ie" r!$"


5/35

5

Cor!h Preliminary:=

T/e 0"r) E&22e,!"% )e8%!$e, &%) er$&!%, (ree)e $/e #"r Ne0 Te$&'e%$&,B!"2r&(/!e. T/ere &re e+er&, !rre#$&*,e e+!)e%e !% C/r!$!&% Gree? Sr!($re=0/!/ (r"+e 0!$/ er$&!%!$ $/&$ $/e 0"r) E&22e,!"% (re e!$e) $/e #"r Ne0

Te$&'e%$&, B!"2r&(/!e "# Ie" r!$".E+!)e%e #r"' Ne0 Te$&'e%$&, B""?.

1< M&$ 4: &:3

0nd *eso#s %en! !hro#'h o#! 3alili 5alili9 , !eachin' in !heir Fe%ishG Syna'o#'es

5S:0/H-40


6/35

T/! E(!$,e 0& 0r!$$e% *e#"re $/e (er!") "# &% Ne0 Te$&'e%$&, B!"2r&(/ O#Ie" r!$".

T/ee &re -$ #"r e&'(,e /"e% #r"' & %'*er "# / re#ere%e #"%) !%Ne0 Te$&'e%$&, B""?.

F!#$/ re,!'!%&r

Ie" r!$" %e!$/er r"$e H!'e,# %"r D!$&$e) /! )!!(,e &%) 8r$ #",,"0er $"0r!$e $/e E&22e,!"%.

Qr&:% %e!$/er ,&!'e$/ $/&$ Ie" r!$" '&)e & "( "# $/e E&22e,!"% $/&$ /e(re&/e) &%) $&2/$ %"r ,&!'e$/ $/&$ Ie" r!$" "r)ere) /! )!!(,e $" '&?e"%e. T/e E&22e,!"% 0/!/ Ie" r!$" H!'e,# re&/e) &%) T&2/$ 0&"%+ee) &%) ree!+e) !% #"r' "# Or&, Tr&)!$!"% *e#"re &$$e'($ 0ere '&)e $" 0r!$e!$ )"0%.

T/e Or&, Tr&)!$!"% &%) N&rr&$!"% "%$!$$e) $/e ("r$!"% "# $/e Or&, E22&,!"%=0/!/ 0& (r!"r $" E22&,!"% &$& "'e "%e e,e.

See T/!r) re,!'!%&r.

H"0 e+er *&e) "% $/e E&22e,!"% $&2/$ &%) (re&/e) * Ie" r!$" H!'e,#=$/e (er"%&, 0"r) "# Ie" r!$" =&%) /! )ee) &%) )"!%2 0ere &," !%,)e) !%$/e $er' E&22e,!"% &$ & ,e$$er $&2e.

B $/e $!'e $/e 8r$ "# $/e #"r Ne0 Te$&'e%$&, B!"2r&(/!e 0& 0r!$$e%= $/e /&)*ee% !%,)e) . B$ $/! %e+er 'e&% $/&$ $/e $er' !% $/e #"r'er 'e&%!%2 0&

e&e) &%) er&e) #r"' $/e '!%) "%e #"r &,,.[Note:= Some objection makers claim that the word Biography cannot be applied to New Testamental Gospels . This is based on their self

proclaimed denition of the word Biography. They ha!e imposed self proposed conditions to e"cl#de New Testamental Gospels from the

the term Biography [$:l Biographies%. &ne sho#ld reject the s#ch redenings of well known terms. 'ow e!er if some one insists on these

newly imposed conditions in the denition of the word Biography( then s#ch a person may call term a Gospel as a Semi Biography or an

)lmost Bography. B#t in this article the word Biography is #sed and the self proposed condition in the denition of the word Biography

is rejected s#ch that it is not possible to reject NewTestamental Gospels from being Biographies.%

.#r/a:n #se!h !he %ord *nIi:, in !his 1erse s!ric!ly "or !he E&22e,!"%!a#'h! andreached )y *eso#s +ris!os


7/35

7

This is !he only reason !ha! !he %ord E#a''elion 53JKLMN9 is s!a!ed in $e%

Tes!amen!al 3osels and o!her )ooVs cons!i!#!in' *!2 See Cor!h Preliminary "or

some eamles2

Se1en!h Preliminary:=

Cor di(eren! +a!as i2e &io'rahies accordin' !o "o#r di(eren! a#!hors %ere I#s!"o#r di(eren! a!!em!s !o %ri!e !he E#a''elion !a#'h! and reached )y *eso#s

+ris!os


8/35

I# "%e $)!e Vere 5:4 &%) 5:4 !'(&r$!&,, e+er $/!%2 *e"'e e+!)e%$.

The Xerse Y:ZO

A%) !% $/e!r #""$$e(= e e%$ I:&: ;Ie"< S"% O# M&r&' ; M&r!'< "%8r'!%2$/e T&r&/ ;T"r&/


9/35


10/35

1

So #d'e amon' !hem )y !ha! 0__`<


11/35

11

I$ ! e,# e+!)e%$ $/&$ !% $/e (er!") "# A("$,e &%) A("$",! F&$/er $/e 0"r)E&22e,!"% 0& %"$ e) #"r $/e Ne0 Te$&'e%$&, B!"2r&(/!e O# M&$$&! Mer=L?& &%) I"/&%%"%= !'e $/ee A("$,e &%) A("$e, F&$/er 0ere $/e 'e% 0/"e!$/er ,!+e) (r!"r $" $/e (er!") "# "'("!$!"% "# $/ee #"r B!"2r&(/!e "r !% $/e(er!") "# "'("!$!"% "# $/e *!"2r&(/!e.I% $/! (er!") "# $!'e !.e $/e !% +er

e%$r !% 0/!/ $/ee 0"r? 0ere "'("e) = $/e 0"r) E&22e,!"% 0& %"$ e)#"r 0r!$$e% re"r) "# re,&$e) $" Ie" r!$" *$ $" $/e G,&) T!)!%2 = e,,Me&2e = G"") Ne0 e$. "%er%!%2 Ie" r!$". T/&$ ! $/e re&"% $/&$ $/e0"r) E&22e,!"% ! %"$ e) #"r $/e 0r!!$e% re"r) "# Ie" r!$" * $/e Ne0

Te$&'e%$&, &$/"r "# $/e #"r *!"2r&(/!e !% Ne0 Te$&'e%$ I$e,#.


12/35

1

I% "'e $r&%,&$!"% "# Ne0 Te$&'e%$' $/e 0"r) E&22e,!"% ;G< !$r&%,&$e) & G"(e, ; !% E%2,!/< = E&%2e,!% ;!% L&$!%< @I%-!:, ;!% AFU ,&%2&2e0"r) "# $/e re(e$!+e AFU ,&%2&2e!% 0/!/ Ne0 Te$&'e%$ ! $r&%,&$e).

;AFU L&%2&2e3 L&%2&2e 0/!/ e Ar&*! Sr!($ !% (r!%!(,e= ,!?e er!&% e$.!%2,e 'e&%!%2 $/r"2/ "$ /! 0"r? ;E(!$,e


15/35

15

T/e 0"r) E&22e,!"% $/ /&+e e+e% )!9ere%$ 'e&%!%2 & & Te/%!&, $er'. T")! $/e e "# $/e 0"r) E&22e,!"% (r!"r $" Ie" r!$" LIE L[[ e$ !*e"%) $/e "(e "# $/e (ree%$ )!!"%.

O%e '& re&,, $/&$ !$ /& *ee% $&$e) $/&$ $/e 0"r) E&22e,!"% ! e) !% e+er&,

'e&%!%2 e+e% & & Te/%!&, Ter'.I$ ! re!re) $" re(e&$ !$ !% "'e "$/er $,e $" re#re/ $/e 'e'"r!e "# re&)er "#$/! 0"r?.

THE FIRST USE OF THE TERM:3

T/e 0"r) E&22e,!"% 0& & $e/%!&, $er' (r!"r $" $/e &((e&r&%e "# &% Ne0Te$&'e%$&, B""? !% 2e%er&, &%) $/e #"r Ne0 Te$&'e%$&, B!"2r&(/!e !% (&r$!,&r.

I$ 0& & $e/%!&, $er' #"r $/e D!+!%e G"") 'e&2e= 0"r) =e(re!"% &%)$!)!%2 e$ re+e&,e) $" Ie" r!$".

T/e "r&, Te$ "# E&22e,!"% 0& "%$!$$e) "# D!+!%e "r) &%) %"$ "# /'&% "r!2!%1e 1:16.

I$ "%$e%$ 0ere (r",&!'e) =(re&/e) = $&2/$= &%) !%#"r'e) * Ie" r!$" #"r$/e 8r$ $!'e.

T/ere 0& "%, O%e E&22e,!"% &%) *e!)e !$ $/ere 0& %" E22&,!"%. E+e% ,e"%) $/! %!e%e "# re+e&,e) E&22e,!"% $&$e) &*"+e.

T/ $/e "r) E&22e,!"% !% $/e )r!%2 $/e M!%!$r "# Ie" r!$" H!'e,# '&*e e(ree) & #",,"0:3

T/e D!+!%e G"") T!)!%2 &%) Re+e&,e) G,&) Me&2e re&/e) =T&2/$ &%)r",&!'e) * Ie" r!$" &'"%2 $/e (e"(,e )r!%2 H! er!") "# M!%!$r.

A$ "'e (er!") ,&$$er '&% $/!%2 0ere #e) &%) &))e) 0!$/ $/e "%$e%$ "# $/e$&$e) &*"+e E&22e,!"% (r")!%2 & e"%) 'e&%!%2 "# $/e $er' E&22e,!"% 0/!/0&

Re,&$!+e, '"re 2e%er&, $/e% $/e !%!$!&, 'e&%!%2 $&$e) &*"+e. 46

F"r e&'(,e $/e (er"%&, 0"r) "# Ie" = H! )ee) &%) )"!%2= e+e%$ "%er%!%2

&*"$ H!' 0ere &," &))e) !% $/e $&$e) &*"+e 'e&%!%2 "# $/e $er' ;& $/e 8r$'e&%!%2


16/35

1

A $/!r) 'e&%!%2 0& (r")e) 0/e% 0"r) "# D!!(,e= F!r$ F",,"0er &%) $/e!r&$ &%) e+e%$ 0ere &))e) $" $/e $er' $&$e) &*"+e.

, (r")e) & #"r$/ 'e&%!%2 0/e% /e &))e) (r"e)re=&$!+!$!e &%)ee$!"% "# $/e (r",&'&$!"%&%) &%) (re&/!%2 !% &))!$!"% $" $/e $&$e) &*"+e

'e&%!%2 ;& $/e 8r$ 'e&%!%2 "r e"%) 'e&%!%2


17/35

17

T/e re,&$!"% "# $/e $er' !% Ne0 Te$&'e%$&, 0"r? '& *e '"re 2e%er&, !% "'e(,&e *$ %"$ !% &,, (,&e.

Tr&e "# $/e 'e&%!%2 $&$e) &*"+e !% $/e *""? "# Ne0 Te$&'e%$.

T/e 0"r) E&22e,!"% & )e!2$&$!%2 D!+!%e Mee2e &%) "r) Re+e&,e) $" Ie"

r!$" /& *ee% &((,!e) $" & %'*er "# %&rr&$!+e &%) $r&)!$!"%.

E+e% )r!%2 $/e (er!") "# M!%!$r "# Ie" r!$".

M&r 1:14

N"0 $er $/&$ I"/% 0& !% r!"%= Ie" &'e !%$" G&,!,ee (re&/!%2 $/eE&22e,!"% ;G< "# $/e !%2)"' "# De!$>G").

T/! +ere )"e /e0 $/&$ Ie" r!$" H!'e,# (re&/e) "'e $/!%2 &,,e)E&22e,!"%.

M&r 1:15

A%) &!%2= T/e $!'e ! #,8,,e)=&%) $/e !%2)"' O# G") ! &$ /&%) : re(e%$ Ye= &%)*e,e&+e !% $/e E&22e,!"% ;G/e ! !%$ere$e) $" ee !$.

N"0 "%!)er $/&$ $/e 0"r) E&22e,!"% ;G< ! e) !% $/e 'e&%!%2 "# &",,e$!"% "# &,, S%"($! Ne0 Te$&'e%$&, G"(e,.

T/e 'e&%!%2 "# $/e +ere%)er )!!"% *e"'e & #",,"0:3

Ver!, I & %$" "=/ere"e+er $/! COLLECTION OF FOUR NE TESTAMENTALGOSELS /&,, *e (re&/e) $/r"2/ "$ $/e 0"r,) = $/! &," $/&$ /e /&$/ )"%e/&,, *e ("?e% "# /er #"r & 'e'"r!&, "# /er .

O%e &2&!% $/! 'e&%!%2 ! $r!$, !%"rre$ &%) &%%"$ *e /"e% &'"%2 $/ee+er&, 'e&%!%2 "# $e/%!&, $er' E&22e,!"% #"r $/! +ere.

E+e% !% $/e (er!") "# D!!(,e 0/e% Ie" r!$" 0& %" '"re 0!$/ $/e' $/ee'e&%!%2 &%%"$ *e /"e%.

T" (r"+e $/! $/!%2 "%e '& $&?e "'e e%$e%e #r"' $/e E(!$,e "# , ;&,


22/35

C"%!)er $/e 'e&%!%2 "# $/e e%$e%e !% $/e E(!$,e "# , %)er )!!"% ",,"0:3

I% $/e )& 0/e% G) /&,, J)2e $/e Seere$ "# 'e% * Ie" r!$" &"r)!%2 $"' G"(e,A"r)!%2$"LUA>LUE.

O*+!", $/! 'e&%!%2 ! & !%"rre$ & !% &% *e. I$ '& *e %"$e) $/&$ $/ere &re"'e 2r"%) ("% 0/!/ , ",) & $/e G"(e, "# L?& & /! G"(e, !%e

L?& 0& %"$ "%, /! /!!&% *$ &," /! D!!(,e. r"*&*,e !# %"$ er$&!% $/&$ /e'!2/$ /&+e '&% $/!%2 !% /! 0"r? 0/!/ /e '!2/$ /&+e /e&r) #r"' /! $e&/er,. A L?& 0& /! )!!(,e &$ ,e&$ !% "'e e%e= %" "%e &% "%$r&)!$ , !#/e 0",) /&+e ,&!'e) $/&$ $/! G"(e, &"r)!%2 $" L?& ! /! G"(e,.

B$ !$ ! er$&!%, !%"rre$ $/&$ , 'e&%$ G"(e, A"r)!%2 $" /!!&% L?& !%R"' :1.

Se+e%$ee%$/ re,!'!%&r:3T/e &'e ! $re ;SeeS!$ee%$/re,!'!%&r


23/35

T/e #"r G"(e, &re %e+er re#ere) !% Ar&*! Sr!($re %,e &%) "$/er0!e $/ere !& )e'&%) "# "%$e$.

< T/e "%$e$ "# $/e +ere 2"e$/ &2&!%$ $/! 'e&%!%2.

T/e +ere 4:4 SAYTH

e G&+e H!' @I%-!:, ;E&22e,!"%< !% 0/!/ 0& G!)&%e &%) ,!2/$ &%)C"%8r'&$!"% "# T&r&/.

Qr&:% ! )e8%!$e, &%) er$&!%, re#err!%2 $" $/e @I%-!:, $/&$ 0& 2!+e% $" Ie"r!$" &%) G"(e, "# Mer 0& ("$er!"r !% $!'e $" $/e E&22e,!"% (re&/e)=$&2/$ =(r",&!'e) &%) re("r$e) * Ie" r!$r".

T/! "'(,e$e$/ $/e (r""#.

Q.E.D

E!2/$ee%$/ re,!'!%&r:3

A< I% re2&r) $" $/e Qr&:%! +ere %)er )!!"% $/ere '& &r!e & e$!"% $/&$/"0 & C/r!$!&% &% #",,"0 $/e E&22e,!"% $/&$ 0& (re&/e) &%) $&2/$ * Ie"r!$" !# /e &e($ Qr&%! &)+!e 0!$/ "$ *e,!e+!%2 Qr&:&% & & D!+!%e B""?\

T/&$ ! !# /e &e($ $/e Qr&:%! &)+!e & re&"%&*,e "% r&$!"%&, 2r"%).. S!%e/e /& %" &e $" $/e E&22e,!"% !% Tr&)!$!"% $/&$ 0& &+&!,&*,e $" $/e C/r!$!&%"# $/e 8r$ Ge%er&$!"%.

B$ $/! ! & e$!"% %"$ &% "*-e$!"%. S" &% &%0er $" $/! e$!"% ! *e"%) $/e"(e "# $/! &r$!,e "% ,"2!&, 2r"%) = !%e $/e "(e ! $r!$, ,!'!$e) $" &%0er

$/e O*-e$!"% $&$e) &*"+e= &%) %"$ $" &%0er &% e$!"%. S!%e & e$!"% !"'e $/!%2 "$/er $/&$ &% "*-e$!"%. B$ !% "r)er $" "'(,e$e $/e )!!"% !$ !re!re) $" re(, $/! e$!"% & 0e,,.

H"e e+er $/ere &re "'e ("!%$ 0/!/ '$ *e %"$e) $" %)er$&%) $/e $/eQr&:%! S$&$e'e%$.

T/e Qr&%! &)+!e ! $/&$ $/e C/r!$!&% /",) #",,"0 $/e Me&2e =r",&'&$!"% = &%) Te&/!%2 "# Ie" r!$" = /!/ He "%)$e) H!'e,#)r!%2 H! er!") "# M!%!$r.

G"(e, "# Ne0 Te$&'e%$ &re %e!$/er $/e ",,e$!"% "# 'ere S&!%2 "# Ie"r!$" %"r $/e ",,e$!"% "# 'ere H! Te&/!%2 &%) re&/!%2.

T/e "%$&!% e+er&, &))!$!"% '&$er!&, . F"r e&'(,e H! &$ =)ee) &%) )"!%2e$. & 0e,,.


24/35

4

B$ $/! ! %"$ 0/ere $/e $"(. T/ere &re '&% '&$er!&, e+e% !% &))!$!"% $" $&$e)&*"+e '&$er!&,.

O%e '& $r $" 8%) $/e E&22e,!"% $/&$ Ie" r!$" (re&/e) = $&2/$ &%)(r",&!'e) H!'e,#.

O%e '& $r $" 8%) "$ $/e E&22e,!"% 0/!/ Ie" r!$" H!'e,# (re&/e) &%)$&2/$ )r!%2 H! M!%!$r #r"' &,, &+&!,&*,e "re $/e% $r $" #",,"0 $/eE&22e,!"% = 0/"e ("r$!"% &re &$$ere) !% )!9ere%$ "re.

I# "'e "%e )!"*e $/e D!+!%e "r) O# E&22e,!"% /!/ 0& re+e&,e) $" H!' &%)re&/e) * H!' $/e% / & (er"% 0/" " e+er /e '& *e $r&%2ree e+e%&"r)!%2 $" T/e E&22e,!"% re&/e) * Ie" r!$".

I# $/! &)+!e "# Qr&:% 0& &e($e) $" 8%) $/e "r$!"% "# E&22e,!"% !% $/e$&$e) &*"+e 'e&%!%2= $/e ree&r/ &*"$ r"$" G"(e, ,!?e QG"(e, = Tr&)!$!"%O# E&22e,!"% e$ 0",) /&+e *e2% !% C/r!$!&%)"' &$ & '/ e&r,!er (er!") "#

$!'e.

Fr$/er !% $/! &e "%e 0",) /&+e #"%) $/&$ T/e E&22e,!"% !% $/e $&$e) &*"+e'e&%!%2 )"e %"$ "%$r&)!$ Qr&:% = &%) &% &((&re%$ "%$r&)!$!"% 0",) /&+e*ee% re'"+e) * $/e "rre$ !%$er(re$&$!"% "# $/e re"r)e) $r&)!$!"% "# E&22e,!"%.

A Qr&:%! Vee ! %"$ (e&?!%2 &*"$ $/e e$r& '&$er!&, !%e $/e '& *e (&r$"# E&22e,!"% !% "$/er 'e&%!%2 *$ %"$ !% $/e $&$e) &*"+e 'e&%!%2 = Qr&% )"%"$ "%!)er $/e' & "'e $/!%2 Re+e&,e) $" Ie" r!$r" H!'e,#.

B< I$ ! & +er $r"%2 r"*&*!,!$ $/&$ Ie" r!$" S("?e Ar&'&! &%) T/e

E&22e,!"% Re+e&,e) $" H!' 0& !% Ar&'&! &%) N"$ I% Gree?. B$ $er &,, $/! ! &r"*&*!,!$ &%) N"$ & er$&!%$. I$ &%%"$ *e ,&!'e) 0!$/ er$!$)e $/&$ T/eE&22,!"% 0& %"$ !% Gree?.;5+!& H",r"(/e$. S" Qr&:% ! !%2 $/e $er' 0/!/ Qr&:% )"e e. S" "%e '$ %"$

'! $/! ("!%$. Ne2,e$!%2 $/! (e!&, ("!%$ !'(,!e & )!$"r$!"% !% $/e Me&%!%2 O#Qr&:%. T/e R,e LA: MASHA:H:AH FIL @IS:TI:LA:H ; TO QUARELL OVER THE TERMS%&'3Y"r"rI"rI"rJ;Ger

,(/&*e$Ar&*! A # " ! ()


32/35

;16I% $/! 0"r? $/e ,e$$er J ! $r!$, e) #"r $/e "%"%&%$&, )!(/$/"%2 &%) %"$ #"r $/e "%) "# Y. I%'&% %"% !% (&r$!,&r &%) 0"r) !% 2e%er&, $/e ,e$$er J ! re+er$e) $" "r!2!%&, I 0/!/ ! &C"%"%&%$ 0/e% !$ *e2!% & 0"r) !% 2e%er&, &%) & ,,&*,e !% (&r$!,&r. T/e re&"% ! $/&$ !$ "r!2!%&,"%) "# Y ! /&%2e) * $/e %e0 "%) "# C"%"%&%$&, D!(/$/"%2. S" & "%"%&%$&, /&%2e !% $/e"%) /& "rre). 6 T/e Gree? %"% Ie" ! e) #"r $/e Me!&/ !%e !$ ! $/e "!&, %"% "# !%$/e Gree? Ne0 Te$&'e%$. I$ ! (re#erre) "+er "$/er +&r!e%$ "# H! N"% !% ,&%2&2e 0/!/ e

r!($ )er!+e) #r"' L&$!% r!($.

refutation of some objections on the verse 5:47 of quran

Documents