recent aashtoware / bridgeware developmentssp.bridges.transportation.org/documents/2011 scobs... ·...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developmentssp.bridges.transportation.org/Documents/2011 SCOBS... · Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developments AASHTO SCOBS T-19 Meeting Norfolk–](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081217/5f9a3ab0dead393c514cf630/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developments
AASHTO SCOBS T-19 MeetingNorfolk– May 2011
![Page 2: Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developmentssp.bridges.transportation.org/Documents/2011 SCOBS... · Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developments AASHTO SCOBS T-19 Meeting Norfolk–](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081217/5f9a3ab0dead393c514cf630/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Virtis/Opis Project
FEA Investigative Study
![Page 3: Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developmentssp.bridges.transportation.org/Documents/2011 SCOBS... · Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developments AASHTO SCOBS T-19 Meeting Norfolk–](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081217/5f9a3ab0dead393c514cf630/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Introduction
• Investigative study requested by Virtis/Opis Task Force.
• Addition of 3D (FEA) capabilities into Virtis/Opis for the 2011-2012 work plan.
• This work will also consider curved girder analysis.
• It will include details for modeling and loading both straight and curved steel girders.
![Page 4: Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developmentssp.bridges.transportation.org/Documents/2011 SCOBS... · Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developments AASHTO SCOBS T-19 Meeting Norfolk–](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081217/5f9a3ab0dead393c514cf630/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Basic Questions That Were Asked During the Investigative Study
1. What finite element modeling techniques are currently used for straight and curved multi-girder steel superstructures for:• Deck• Beam• Deck-to-beam connection• Cross-frames?
2. What techniques are used for applying the live load (both truck and lane) to the model?
3. How are the resulting actions resolved for specification checking?
Eight Technical Sources were consulted.
![Page 5: Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developmentssp.bridges.transportation.org/Documents/2011 SCOBS... · Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developments AASHTO SCOBS T-19 Meeting Norfolk–](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081217/5f9a3ab0dead393c514cf630/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
1a. What finite element modeling techniques are currently used for straight and curved multi-girder steel
superstructures?
51
2
Deck Element Type
ShellBrickBoth
![Page 6: Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developmentssp.bridges.transportation.org/Documents/2011 SCOBS... · Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developments AASHTO SCOBS T-19 Meeting Norfolk–](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081217/5f9a3ab0dead393c514cf630/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Recommendation
• For the deck, a shell element is recommended.
• A shell element is currently used in Virtis/Opis for the deck.
• Additional testing may be required for curved bridge applications.
![Page 7: Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developmentssp.bridges.transportation.org/Documents/2011 SCOBS... · Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developments AASHTO SCOBS T-19 Meeting Norfolk–](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081217/5f9a3ab0dead393c514cf630/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
1b. What finite element modeling techniques are currently used for straight and curved multi-girder steel superstructures?
6
2
Beam Element Type
ChordCurved
![Page 8: Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developmentssp.bridges.transportation.org/Documents/2011 SCOBS... · Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developments AASHTO SCOBS T-19 Meeting Norfolk–](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081217/5f9a3ab0dead393c514cf630/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Recommendation
• For the beam, straight chorded elements are recommended.
• The length of the elements will be a function of the girder depth and possibly the degree of girder curvature.
• A shell element is recommended for the girder web.
• Beam elements are recommended for each flange.
![Page 9: Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developmentssp.bridges.transportation.org/Documents/2011 SCOBS... · Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developments AASHTO SCOBS T-19 Meeting Norfolk–](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081217/5f9a3ab0dead393c514cf630/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
1c. What finite element modeling techniques are currently used for straight and curved multi-girder steel superstructures?
3
3
2
Deck-to-Beam Connection Element
SpringOffsetBeam
![Page 10: Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developmentssp.bridges.transportation.org/Documents/2011 SCOBS... · Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developments AASHTO SCOBS T-19 Meeting Norfolk–](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081217/5f9a3ab0dead393c514cf630/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Recommendation
• For the deck-to-beam connection, a line element (beam) is recommended.
![Page 11: Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developmentssp.bridges.transportation.org/Documents/2011 SCOBS... · Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developments AASHTO SCOBS T-19 Meeting Norfolk–](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081217/5f9a3ab0dead393c514cf630/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
1d. What finite element modeling techniques are currently used for straight and curved multi-girder steel superstructures?
3
2
2
1
Cross-frame Element
Truss and BeamTrussBeamShell
![Page 12: Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developmentssp.bridges.transportation.org/Documents/2011 SCOBS... · Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developments AASHTO SCOBS T-19 Meeting Norfolk–](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081217/5f9a3ab0dead393c514cf630/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Recommendation
• For the cross-frames, separate beam elements for each individual member of the cross-frame are recommended.
• Depending on the connections, the beam element will either provide the desired degree of rigidity in the connections or they will be released to represent a truss element.
• A beam element can be used to model both rigid connections and pinned connections.
• It is therefore more versatile than a truss element.
![Page 13: Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developmentssp.bridges.transportation.org/Documents/2011 SCOBS... · Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developments AASHTO SCOBS T-19 Meeting Norfolk–](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081217/5f9a3ab0dead393c514cf630/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
2. What techniques are used for applying the live load (both truck and lane) to the model?
• Option 1 – Place the truck and/or lane at all possible locations and save the controlling effects
• Option 2 – Develop an influence surface, and then place the truck and/or lane at all possible locations and save the controlling effects
• Option 3 – Develop an influence surface, develop a way to find only the controlling peaks and valleys, and then place the truck and/or lane in those regions only to determine the controlling effects
• Option 4 – Other
![Page 14: Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developmentssp.bridges.transportation.org/Documents/2011 SCOBS... · Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developments AASHTO SCOBS T-19 Meeting Norfolk–](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081217/5f9a3ab0dead393c514cf630/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
2. What techniques are used for applying the live load (both truck and lane) to the model?
11
31
2
Analysis Technique
Option 1Option 2Option 3Option 2&3Option 4
![Page 15: Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developmentssp.bridges.transportation.org/Documents/2011 SCOBS... · Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developments AASHTO SCOBS T-19 Meeting Norfolk–](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081217/5f9a3ab0dead393c514cf630/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Recommendation
• It is recommended that two techniques be developed for applying live load to the model:• Technique 1 – Develop an influence surface, and
then place the truck and/or lane at all possible locations and save the controlling effects (brute force method)
• Technique 2 – Develop an influence surface, develop a way to find only the controlling peaks and valleys, and then place the truck and/or lane in those regions only to determine the controlling effects
• If both techniques are developed, then Technique 1 can be used to test Technique 2
![Page 16: Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developmentssp.bridges.transportation.org/Documents/2011 SCOBS... · Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developments AASHTO SCOBS T-19 Meeting Norfolk–](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081217/5f9a3ab0dead393c514cf630/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
3. How are the resulting actions resolved for specification checking?
43
1
Resolution Technique
Calculate moments from stresses at flange tips
Only publish stresses with no specification checksCalculate moments indirectly from deflections
![Page 17: Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developmentssp.bridges.transportation.org/Documents/2011 SCOBS... · Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developments AASHTO SCOBS T-19 Meeting Norfolk–](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081217/5f9a3ab0dead393c514cf630/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Recommendation
• Further study of what actions will be produced by Virtis/Opis for the various elements that are being recommended for use.
• Further study of what actions are required for specification checking.
![Page 18: Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developmentssp.bridges.transportation.org/Documents/2011 SCOBS... · Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developments AASHTO SCOBS T-19 Meeting Norfolk–](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081217/5f9a3ab0dead393c514cf630/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Additional Information Provided During Interviews
• MDX is based on a 2D analysis.• DESCUS is based on a traditional grid analysis,
which is also a 2D analysis.
![Page 19: Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developmentssp.bridges.transportation.org/Documents/2011 SCOBS... · Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developments AASHTO SCOBS T-19 Meeting Norfolk–](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081217/5f9a3ab0dead393c514cf630/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
• Will the finite element analysis be based on linear analysis or non-linear analysis?
• This decision affects the entire analysis process. • A combination of the two approaches is also an
option.
Additional Information Provided During Interviews
![Page 20: Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developmentssp.bridges.transportation.org/Documents/2011 SCOBS... · Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developments AASHTO SCOBS T-19 Meeting Norfolk–](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081217/5f9a3ab0dead393c514cf630/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
• Linear analysis• Based on elastic behavior• Small-deformation approach• Simplest approach• Based on basic beam theory
• Non-linear analysis• A second-order approach • Does not require that plane sections remain plane • More complicated• Solution may be iterative
Additional Information Provided During Interviews
![Page 21: Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developmentssp.bridges.transportation.org/Documents/2011 SCOBS... · Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developments AASHTO SCOBS T-19 Meeting Norfolk–](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081217/5f9a3ab0dead393c514cf630/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
States’ Survey Results
Substructure Software
![Page 22: Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developmentssp.bridges.transportation.org/Documents/2011 SCOBS... · Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developments AASHTO SCOBS T-19 Meeting Norfolk–](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081217/5f9a3ab0dead393c514cf630/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
What types of software does your state use to perform substructure analysis?
2 In-house software20 Commercial software29 Both
![Page 23: Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developmentssp.bridges.transportation.org/Documents/2011 SCOBS... · Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developments AASHTO SCOBS T-19 Meeting Norfolk–](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081217/5f9a3ab0dead393c514cf630/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
If commercial software is used by your state to perform substructure analysis, which programs does your state use? Check all that apply.
6 BridgeWare Opis Substructure0 BRUFEM
15 STAAD15 SAP 20004 Florida Pier5 Georgia Pier
13 FB-Pier/MultiPier32 RC-PIER5 BRASS PIER (LRFD)
Other commercial software used: GT-STRUDL, VBent, ABLRFD, BPLRFD, PAPIER, Penn DOT software, SHAFT, LARSA. COM624, WinRECOL, MATHCadd, WEAP, and RESSA
![Page 24: Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developmentssp.bridges.transportation.org/Documents/2011 SCOBS... · Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developments AASHTO SCOBS T-19 Meeting Norfolk–](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081217/5f9a3ab0dead393c514cf630/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
What software does your state utilize for pile and drilled shaft lateral load analysis?
3 DFSAP44 L-Pile21 COM624P16 FB-Pier
Other software used: Driven, ALLPILE, GROUP, RC-PIER, DS SAP, and Strain Wedge
![Page 25: Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developmentssp.bridges.transportation.org/Documents/2011 SCOBS... · Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developments AASHTO SCOBS T-19 Meeting Norfolk–](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081217/5f9a3ab0dead393c514cf630/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
What substructure design features does your state feel are currently notavailable in commercial software and need to be developed?
Strut and Tie MethodMicropile DesignDrilled Shaft DesignWave Load DesignSkew Effects for StiffnessTie Beam DesignTrapezoidal Columns and Pier ShapesAbility to Perform Load CombinationsSoil Structure Interaction and AnalysisLateral Spread AnalysisLiquefaction AnalysisScour Analysis
![Page 26: Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developmentssp.bridges.transportation.org/Documents/2011 SCOBS... · Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developments AASHTO SCOBS T-19 Meeting Norfolk–](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081217/5f9a3ab0dead393c514cf630/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
Element Migrator Update
![Page 27: Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developmentssp.bridges.transportation.org/Documents/2011 SCOBS... · Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developments AASHTO SCOBS T-19 Meeting Norfolk–](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081217/5f9a3ab0dead393c514cf630/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
Element Migration
• The “Element Migrator” will mass convert CoRE elements to new elements.
• Will handle State developed elements.• Recommend migrating existing elements
and then checking.• Migrator is software / DB independent and
free to AASHTO states.• Difficulty with SMART Flags.
![Page 28: Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developmentssp.bridges.transportation.org/Documents/2011 SCOBS... · Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developments AASHTO SCOBS T-19 Meeting Norfolk–](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081217/5f9a3ab0dead393c514cf630/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
Migrator Visual User Interface Mockup
Rule Edit Area
Rule Selector
Menu Area (*)
Input & Output File Selection/Actions
Actions
Activity Messages
![Page 29: Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developmentssp.bridges.transportation.org/Documents/2011 SCOBS... · Recent AASHTOWare / BridgeWare Developments AASHTO SCOBS T-19 Meeting Norfolk–](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081217/5f9a3ab0dead393c514cf630/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
Questions & Comments
Thanks for your continued support