real estate roundtable university of enver 3-10-16 · • seller: bankruptcy estate (all-cash) ......

23
EXECUTIVE REAL ESTATE ROUNDTABLE UNIVERSITY OF DENVER 3-10-16

Upload: others

Post on 24-Jun-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: REAL ESTATE ROUNDTABLE UNIVERSITY OF ENVER 3-10-16 · • Seller: Bankruptcy Estate (all-cash) ... • Denver/Boulder is under-housed by approx. 60,000 homes (T. Thibodeau, CU Boulder)

EXECUTIVE REAL ESTATE ROUNDTABLE – UNIVERSITY OF DENVER – 3-10-16

Page 2: REAL ESTATE ROUNDTABLE UNIVERSITY OF ENVER 3-10-16 · • Seller: Bankruptcy Estate (all-cash) ... • Denver/Boulder is under-housed by approx. 60,000 homes (T. Thibodeau, CU Boulder)

INTRODUCTION - OREAD CAPITAL & DEVELOPMENT

2

Page 3: REAL ESTATE ROUNDTABLE UNIVERSITY OF ENVER 3-10-16 · • Seller: Bankruptcy Estate (all-cash) ... • Denver/Boulder is under-housed by approx. 60,000 homes (T. Thibodeau, CU Boulder)

OREAD CAPITAL COLORADO PORTFOLIO

Provenance

Somerset Meadows

Anthem Colorado

Rocking Horse

to be renamed

Inspiration Colorado

Sierra Vista

3

Page 4: REAL ESTATE ROUNDTABLE UNIVERSITY OF ENVER 3-10-16 · • Seller: Bankruptcy Estate (all-cash) ... • Denver/Boulder is under-housed by approx. 60,000 homes (T. Thibodeau, CU Boulder)

ANTHEM COLORADO

44

Page 5: REAL ESTATE ROUNDTABLE UNIVERSITY OF ENVER 3-10-16 · • Seller: Bankruptcy Estate (all-cash) ... • Denver/Boulder is under-housed by approx. 60,000 homes (T. Thibodeau, CU Boulder)

ANTHEM COLORADO

55

Page 6: REAL ESTATE ROUNDTABLE UNIVERSITY OF ENVER 3-10-16 · • Seller: Bankruptcy Estate (all-cash) ... • Denver/Boulder is under-housed by approx. 60,000 homes (T. Thibodeau, CU Boulder)

ANTHEM COLORADO

66

Page 7: REAL ESTATE ROUNDTABLE UNIVERSITY OF ENVER 3-10-16 · • Seller: Bankruptcy Estate (all-cash) ... • Denver/Boulder is under-housed by approx. 60,000 homes (T. Thibodeau, CU Boulder)

INSPIRATION COLORADO

7

Page 8: REAL ESTATE ROUNDTABLE UNIVERSITY OF ENVER 3-10-16 · • Seller: Bankruptcy Estate (all-cash) ... • Denver/Boulder is under-housed by approx. 60,000 homes (T. Thibodeau, CU Boulder)

INSPIRATION COLORADO

8Rendering Only, Subject to Change

Page 9: REAL ESTATE ROUNDTABLE UNIVERSITY OF ENVER 3-10-16 · • Seller: Bankruptcy Estate (all-cash) ... • Denver/Boulder is under-housed by approx. 60,000 homes (T. Thibodeau, CU Boulder)

INSPIRATION COLORADO

9Rendering Only, Subject to Change

Page 10: REAL ESTATE ROUNDTABLE UNIVERSITY OF ENVER 3-10-16 · • Seller: Bankruptcy Estate (all-cash) ... • Denver/Boulder is under-housed by approx. 60,000 homes (T. Thibodeau, CU Boulder)

The ‘Capital C’ Community

10

Page 11: REAL ESTATE ROUNDTABLE UNIVERSITY OF ENVER 3-10-16 · • Seller: Bankruptcy Estate (all-cash) ... • Denver/Boulder is under-housed by approx. 60,000 homes (T. Thibodeau, CU Boulder)

OREAD ACTIVITY – FOUNDING TO PRESENT

11

• December 2011: Oread acquires Anthem Colorado, Broomfield (1,500 remaining lots)

• Seller: Pulte Homes (all-cash)

• Financial Partner: Wheelock Street Capital

• Oread developed & operated for 3 years; sold to Newland Communities in March 2015

• December 2012: Oread acquires Provenance, NE Longmont (227 lots)

• Seller: Mile High Bank (purchased defaulted note)

• Financial Partners: 2 non-Oread individuals

• Oread repositioned plat (eliminated TND) sold entire subdivision to Lennar Homes in July 2014

• April 2013: Oread acquires Somerset Meadows, SW Longmont (350 lots)

• Seller: Bankruptcy Estate (all-cash)

• Financial Partner: Wheelock Street Capital

• Oread: Entitled and Platted 4 Filings; Sold the Filings to 4 different homebuilders from 2013-2016

• January 2014: Oread acquires Rocking Horse (Inspiration), Douglas County (1,750 lots)

• Seller: Lennar Homes and a local JV (cash and other consideration)

• Financial Partner: Wheelock Street Capital

• After extensive entitlement and development, sold to Newland Communities in March 2015

• December 2015: Oread acquires The Canyons, Castle Pines (2,000 lots)

• Seller: a partnership containing various parties, including the Alpert family (cash and other consideration)

• Oread simultaneously sells The Canyons to Shea Homes

Page 12: REAL ESTATE ROUNDTABLE UNIVERSITY OF ENVER 3-10-16 · • Seller: Bankruptcy Estate (all-cash) ... • Denver/Boulder is under-housed by approx. 60,000 homes (T. Thibodeau, CU Boulder)

CASTLE PINES, DOUGLAS COUNTY, COLORADO

THE CANYONS AT CASTLE PINES

Page 13: REAL ESTATE ROUNDTABLE UNIVERSITY OF ENVER 3-10-16 · • Seller: Bankruptcy Estate (all-cash) ... • Denver/Boulder is under-housed by approx. 60,000 homes (T. Thibodeau, CU Boulder)
Page 14: REAL ESTATE ROUNDTABLE UNIVERSITY OF ENVER 3-10-16 · • Seller: Bankruptcy Estate (all-cash) ... • Denver/Boulder is under-housed by approx. 60,000 homes (T. Thibodeau, CU Boulder)

LOCATOR MAP

14

Page 15: REAL ESTATE ROUNDTABLE UNIVERSITY OF ENVER 3-10-16 · • Seller: Bankruptcy Estate (all-cash) ... • Denver/Boulder is under-housed by approx. 60,000 homes (T. Thibodeau, CU Boulder)

AERIAL MAP – NORTHWEST VIEW

15

Page 16: REAL ESTATE ROUNDTABLE UNIVERSITY OF ENVER 3-10-16 · • Seller: Bankruptcy Estate (all-cash) ... • Denver/Boulder is under-housed by approx. 60,000 homes (T. Thibodeau, CU Boulder)

AERIAL VIEW – SOUTH VIEW

16

Page 17: REAL ESTATE ROUNDTABLE UNIVERSITY OF ENVER 3-10-16 · • Seller: Bankruptcy Estate (all-cash) ... • Denver/Boulder is under-housed by approx. 60,000 homes (T. Thibodeau, CU Boulder)

SOUTH SUBURBAN SUBMARKET OVERVIEW

17

MERIDIAN & STEPPING STONEShea, Richmond American, KB$455K ASP260 Net Sales in 2014251 VDL (12 Months); 939 Future Lots

HEIRLOOMStandard Pacific $538K ASP52 Net Sales in 2014123 VDL (24 Months); 0 Future Lots

SIERRA RIDGE (new)Meritage, Lennar$485K ASP101 Net Sales in 1H2015 (Jan - June 2015)278 VDL (20 months); 554 Future Lots

NORTH DOUGLAS SUBMARKET- Few Remaining Projects - $905K Detached ASP- 258 Starts in 2014- 272 VDL (15.5 Months)

DOUGLAS-PARKER SUBMARKET- Move-up production homes- $477K Detached ASP- 727 Starts in 2014- 1,514 VDL (24.1 Months)

RIDGEGATECentury, Berkeley$818K Detached ASP74 Net Sales in 201417 VDL (3 Months)6,000 Future Lots

*Note: Data from 2Q15 Metrostudy; for Detached Homes only, no Attached Homes included.

BACKCOUNTRYShea, Paragon$852K Detached ASP91 Net Sales in 2014114 VDL (12 Months)170 Future Lots

Page 18: REAL ESTATE ROUNDTABLE UNIVERSITY OF ENVER 3-10-16 · • Seller: Bankruptcy Estate (all-cash) ... • Denver/Boulder is under-housed by approx. 60,000 homes (T. Thibodeau, CU Boulder)

DENVER MSA COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT: THE GOOD

18

• Colorado is a Brand

• CO is #1 craft brewing in US. We're cool.

• Marijuana is a positive and negative, but it certainly is shaping the Brand

• Robust Job Growth: “Homes are where Jobs Go to Spend the Night”

• Demographics Drive Demand

• Millenials: Colorado now first choice among 25-34 year olds

• Millenials: They are going to have kids and move to suburbs (maybe suburban infill).

• “Nearly 22 million more people were renting in MSA’s around the U.S. in 2014 than in 2006 and

much of that increase was driven by growth in suburban renters…” WSJ, 3/10/16, citing

NYU’s Furman Center Study. The increase in rentership rate has peaked, and was largely driven

by repairing (and building) of consumers’ balance sheets.

• Boomers: Boomers have all the money – wealthiest generation ever. Nationally, 10,000 boomers

a day turn 65. 12,000 Millenials turn 30 every day. People mostly likely to buy houses at those

ages. The difference is that Boomers actually have the money to buy those homes.

• Cheap, cheap, cheap capital (home mortgages, development/building loans, equitys)

• Denver/Boulder is under-housed by approx. 60,000 homes (T. Thibodeau, CU Boulder)

Page 19: REAL ESTATE ROUNDTABLE UNIVERSITY OF ENVER 3-10-16 · • Seller: Bankruptcy Estate (all-cash) ... • Denver/Boulder is under-housed by approx. 60,000 homes (T. Thibodeau, CU Boulder)

DENVER MSA COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT: THE BAD

19

• Low Volumes: with all the Good factors, how in the world are we still below the long-term

Denver/Boulder average for SFD construction? Approximately 10,000 permits in 2015 (vs. approx.

12,000 long-term average).

• Cost Increases: Since 2013, hard costs, soft costs, fees, water, etc. have increased the total costs of a

SFD home by approximately 50%. If increased land/lot prices are included, total costs have increased

nearly 60% per house. As a result, new single family detached homes are an average of $500,000

(and the ‘A & B’ locations are absorbing the price increases). However, the builders are not making

any higher margins than in 2013! This has resulted in a low-volume, flat-margin environment

concentrated in A & B submarkets.

• Affordability: Denver MSA Housing prices threaten growth - our median price is 50% higher than

US.

• Builders taking Development Risk – and they’re not getting paid for it:

• Land developers like Oread able to shift risk in this 'good market' by selling platted and engineered lots

(undeveloped).

• Typically developers still have to develop spine/master infrastructure, but in some cases (Colliers Hill,

Sterling Ranch), the builders are essentially funding or actually CONSTRUCTING the master

infrastructure as well.

• Builders are now self-developing 80% of their lots, taking on incremental development risk, and not

being paid for it, as their margins are not reflecting development profit (in addition to building profit).

Page 20: REAL ESTATE ROUNDTABLE UNIVERSITY OF ENVER 3-10-16 · • Seller: Bankruptcy Estate (all-cash) ... • Denver/Boulder is under-housed by approx. 60,000 homes (T. Thibodeau, CU Boulder)

DENVER MSA COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT: THE BAD

20

For the cities below, median single-family home resale prices today are on average 4.6 times the median household income, up from 3.5 in 2000 but down from 5.5 in 2005.

9.0

7.5

5.7 5.75.1 5.0 5.0

4.2 4.1 4.0 3.9 3.9 3.7 3.5 3.4 3.3 2.9 2.83.5

5.5

3.94.6

Sa

n F

ran

cis

co

Lo

s A

ng

ele

s

Mia

mi

Ne

w Y

ork

Bo

sto

n

De

nve

r

Seattle

Un

ite

d S

tate

s

Wa

sh

ing

ton

, D

C

Au

stin

Ph

oen

ix

Orlan

do

Na

sh

vill

e

Ho

usto

n

Da

llas

Ch

ica

go

Atla

nta

Ind

ian

ap

olis

20

00

Ave

rag

e

20

05

Ave

rag

e

20

10

Ave

rag

e

20

15

Ave

rag

e

Median Resale Single-Family Home Price as a Multiple of Median Household Income, 2015

Source: Moody’s; RCLCO. Note: Historical average is for the set of cities surveyed here, not the U.S. overall.

Page 21: REAL ESTATE ROUNDTABLE UNIVERSITY OF ENVER 3-10-16 · • Seller: Bankruptcy Estate (all-cash) ... • Denver/Boulder is under-housed by approx. 60,000 homes (T. Thibodeau, CU Boulder)

DENVER MSA COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT: THE BAD

21

• Municipalities have NO CLUE that these aren't the 'good old days’:

• Aggressively increasing fees (impact fees, building fees, water fees, sewer fees)

• Pushing code and architectural upgrades

• Ivy Zelman estimates Denver is now among 5 worst MSA’s in U.S. for longest

entitlement/approval timelines.

• Common municipal wisdom: 'residential development costs the city money, while commerical

development makes the city money'. Community development and homebuilding regarded as a

'necessary evil.’

• Other Fixed Costs in addition to Municipal Fees are too High:

• Standard Operating Procedure is to sub-excavate each lot (or build structural foundations) to

avoid getting sued on foundation issues.

• Every house in CO has to have a basement (buyer psychology).

Page 22: REAL ESTATE ROUNDTABLE UNIVERSITY OF ENVER 3-10-16 · • Seller: Bankruptcy Estate (all-cash) ... • Denver/Boulder is under-housed by approx. 60,000 homes (T. Thibodeau, CU Boulder)

SUMMARY

22

• So....the high fixed costs in Denver MSA prevent building anything but move-up

product in the strongest submarkets. The attainable house is a rare sight indeed in

the Metro area these days other than in distant exurban locations, and even then it

is rare unless the land is legacy land (land that has been owned at a low basis for a

long time, e.g. Oakwood’s Green Valley Ranch).

• In summary, it has been a great cycle to be a land holder and/or developer in strong

submarkets but not that great to be a builder.

• The imbalance of supply and demand for attainably-priced homes can only last so

long. I think this resolves itself in a few possible ways:

• Denver homebuilding/development industry will figure out a way to deliver attainable

houses to the surge of Boomers and Millenials, by increasing density (construction

defect legislative reform) and/or cooperation by municipalities with fees, etc.; or

• Denver will become like San Francisco where home ownership is realistically only

feasible for upper middle class move-up / luxury buyers.

Page 23: REAL ESTATE ROUNDTABLE UNIVERSITY OF ENVER 3-10-16 · • Seller: Bankruptcy Estate (all-cash) ... • Denver/Boulder is under-housed by approx. 60,000 homes (T. Thibodeau, CU Boulder)

THE “MISSING MIDDLE” OF SCALE AND PRICE

23

Missing middle housing is “a range of multi-unit or clustered housing types

compatible in scale with single-family homes that... provides a solution to the

mismatch between the available U.S. housing stock and shifting

demographics combined with the growing demand for walkability.”

Source: RCLCO; Opticos Design