r&d update: coastal resilience metrics &€¦ · mission; proxy indicators for port...

22
217 217 217 200 200 200 255 255 255 0 0 0 163 163 163 131 132 122 239 65 53 110 135 120 112 92 56 62 102 130 102 56 48 130 120 111 237 237 237 80 119 27 252 174 .59 “The views, opinions and findings contained in this report are those of the authors(s) and should not be construed as an official Department of the Army position, policy or decision, unless so designated by other official documentation.”

Upload: others

Post on 02-Oct-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: R&D Update: Coastal Resilience Metrics &€¦ · mission; proxy indicators for port function and performance of navigation channel. How can RSM actions improve preparations and recovery

217217217

200200200

255255255

000

163163163

131132122

2396553

110135120

1129256

62102130

1025648

130120111

237237237

8011927

252174.59

“The views, opinions and findings contained in this report are those of the authors(s) and should not be construed as an official Department of the Army position, policy or decision, unless so designated by other official documentation.”

Page 2: R&D Update: Coastal Resilience Metrics &€¦ · mission; proxy indicators for port function and performance of navigation channel. How can RSM actions improve preparations and recovery

OUTLINE

• What is resilience?• What are some best practices for resilience?• How is resilience measured?• R&D Update: Coastal Resilience Metrics &

Applications• Project I: Southeastern Seaboard Ports and

Hurricane Matthew• Project II: Dune and Beach Resilience

Parameters• Project III: Pilot Coastal Resilience Index

2

Page 3: R&D Update: Coastal Resilience Metrics &€¦ · mission; proxy indicators for port function and performance of navigation channel. How can RSM actions improve preparations and recovery

RESILIENCE FOR COASTAL SYSTEMS 3

Definition of Resilience: the capacity to • Anticipate and plan for disruptions, • Resist loss in operations and/or absorb the impact

of disturbances or stressors, • Rapidly recover afterwards, and • Adapt to short- and long-term stressors, changing

conditions and constraints.

Page 4: R&D Update: Coastal Resilience Metrics &€¦ · mission; proxy indicators for port function and performance of navigation channel. How can RSM actions improve preparations and recovery

RESILIENCE FOR COASTLINES – EXAMPLE BAY COMMUNITY

4

• Prepare - Anticipate weak links, be ready to recover, build partnerships.• Resist - Provide diverse and redundant protection.• Recover - Ensure availability of alternatenetworks, prepare independent and complimentary components

•Adapt – foster natural and human actions to facilitate adaptation

Page 5: R&D Update: Coastal Resilience Metrics &€¦ · mission; proxy indicators for port function and performance of navigation channel. How can RSM actions improve preparations and recovery
Page 6: R&D Update: Coastal Resilience Metrics &€¦ · mission; proxy indicators for port function and performance of navigation channel. How can RSM actions improve preparations and recovery
Page 7: R&D Update: Coastal Resilience Metrics &€¦ · mission; proxy indicators for port function and performance of navigation channel. How can RSM actions improve preparations and recovery
Page 8: R&D Update: Coastal Resilience Metrics &€¦ · mission; proxy indicators for port function and performance of navigation channel. How can RSM actions improve preparations and recovery

PROJECT I: IMPACTS OF HURRICANE MATTHEW ON THE SOUTHEASTERN SEABOARDKatherine Touzinsky, Brandon Scully, Marin Kress, Ned Mitchell, ERDC-CHL

RSM and Resilience: Define resilience metrics for navigation mission; proxy indicators for port function and performance of navigation channel. How can RSM actions improve preparations and recovery for coastal storms?

8

Page 9: R&D Update: Coastal Resilience Metrics &€¦ · mission; proxy indicators for port function and performance of navigation channel. How can RSM actions improve preparations and recovery

TANKER AND CARGO VESSEL HEAT MAPS9

Page 10: R&D Update: Coastal Resilience Metrics &€¦ · mission; proxy indicators for port function and performance of navigation channel. How can RSM actions improve preparations and recovery
Page 11: R&D Update: Coastal Resilience Metrics &€¦ · mission; proxy indicators for port function and performance of navigation channel. How can RSM actions improve preparations and recovery
Page 12: R&D Update: Coastal Resilience Metrics &€¦ · mission; proxy indicators for port function and performance of navigation channel. How can RSM actions improve preparations and recovery

12

PROJECT II: DUNE AND BEACH RESILIENCE METRICSMarty Durkin, SAJ

RSM & Resilience - Suggest resilience metrics for dune and beach Coastal Storm Risk Management (CSRM) and RSM projects using Beach-fx output data

Page 13: R&D Update: Coastal Resilience Metrics &€¦ · mission; proxy indicators for port function and performance of navigation channel. How can RSM actions improve preparations and recovery

DUNE & BEACH RESILIENCE METRIC 13

• Buffer width (BW) – a measurement similar to the USGS Beach Closure. The combined horizontal distance of the dune width, seaward dune slope, and berm width.

• Based on the simplified representative profiles used in the Beach-fx

Page 14: R&D Update: Coastal Resilience Metrics &€¦ · mission; proxy indicators for port function and performance of navigation channel. How can RSM actions improve preparations and recovery

BUFFER WIDTH OVER 50 YEARS FROM BEACH-FXCALCULATIONS

14

+00’dune_+60’berm+10’dune_+40’berm+20’dune_+20’bermFWOP

Page 15: R&D Update: Coastal Resilience Metrics &€¦ · mission; proxy indicators for port function and performance of navigation channel. How can RSM actions improve preparations and recovery

BUFFER WIDTH OVER TIME15

Page 16: R&D Update: Coastal Resilience Metrics &€¦ · mission; proxy indicators for port function and performance of navigation channel. How can RSM actions improve preparations and recovery

16

PROJECT III: PILOT COASTAL RESILIENCE INDEXNicole Elko, ASBPA, Quin Robertson and Zhifei Dong, CB&I

RSM and Resilience: Create the groundwork for a national coastal resilience tool to help understand how RSM and CSDR actions change local and regional resilience

Page 17: R&D Update: Coastal Resilience Metrics &€¦ · mission; proxy indicators for port function and performance of navigation channel. How can RSM actions improve preparations and recovery

METHOD – BEACH PARAMETERS

• Pilot CRI considers five beach parameters: Protective Width (PW), Protective Elevation (PE), Volume Density (VD), Wave Runup (WR), Crest Freeboard (CF)

• Developed scripts to process LIDAR data or beach surveys to extract parameters and create profile plots:

17

“Buffer Width”

Page 18: R&D Update: Coastal Resilience Metrics &€¦ · mission; proxy indicators for port function and performance of navigation channel. How can RSM actions improve preparations and recovery

COASTAL RESILIENCE INDEX (CRI) MODEL18

Page 19: R&D Update: Coastal Resilience Metrics &€¦ · mission; proxy indicators for port function and performance of navigation channel. How can RSM actions improve preparations and recovery

CALCULATING CRI FOR DELRAY BEACH, FL19

32 survey datasets between 1975 and 20166 periodic beach (re)nourishment projects and 2 storm repair projectsStorm and wave parameters set as constant during calculation CRI<1.5, Low resilience; 1.5<CRI<2.0, Medium resilience; CRI>2.0, High resilience

Page 20: R&D Update: Coastal Resilience Metrics &€¦ · mission; proxy indicators for port function and performance of navigation channel. How can RSM actions improve preparations and recovery

DELRAY BEACH APPLICATION20

May 1973 before the first project August 2016

Page 21: R&D Update: Coastal Resilience Metrics &€¦ · mission; proxy indicators for port function and performance of navigation channel. How can RSM actions improve preparations and recovery

21

RSM & RESILIENCE - CONCLUSION