rawls - two concept of rules

8/10/2019 Rawls - Two Concept of Rules

1/28

! " # ! "$# %"""& '"(") #" % '"(") #"# "") %# " % ! *" )" &" "%""" % " " "& $" " ")"" +" %""" #,( & $% % " &$")$$ # #$" - *"") %(

"# .#- " )# # " #" " "$# "$# %""" ! $ )") %%

""#""$ )" &'" " . #%""( &$% )" " " " " "$ % &")" - #$" ! " %""" "," ""#""$ " ( " $- " $ *"" # "%#% $# '%)$ #%"" &'" % $ %$"

! #% #" #) # " #$ $") ( #$

"."( ""% &( ($ # " %" " # $." % % % " )". "."( " ## /*$ $( "- )$ % #" #" % #"$ %""" " # 0$1 %"" '" " &- !!! !! "( ! " #( % &( /" " % # %2 3% 45 ! ! %4 / " $( & #)% 6 7" - " # )#% " 2 " " 8 9#$ !##" 7# :"( 67" . !!! ! %%"" #)$ )". &(9#$ # # .# # $ %""" " 4 %2 3% 45 &- ;! *"" # 5 %""" " %$


2/28

"$# %""" " &( ( " #) ""#" ." #)#% # ." " $(

%"& # *" ")"" %""" $( &

.#-% ! $ )") %" " # 8 " "$# %"")"") & '""" # # #" % '""" #"# " ") %# " # " $- " #( " %""" $ & $% % " " )" &"

! &' "$ " ") )

" ."" ) # ( & #&")$# ," #& & " & %")# # # "$ " '""& 7 . % #% #$ #" & " " &""" 8( . #'% "$ "#( " "## ##"") "%# & "% )" " %""( " " '""" "$ .#"#)$ # " . & )". &( $# "# & # $ ( # )# 2 '"""" " % " !

#$"% %""" & ""#" ." " ( " # % " " #""

D# # # $( ( # # '""" "$ + $( ##"&". ." " "$ " '""% )#% #)%") $#""$ ! " $#( "") # % #)% # " ##" " #)%") #"$"% & "% #$ " )" % .#"( ##" "$ %% %#."( " "# # #)%# # "$ " $#(

"# # % % " " "##". ( , "") "$

+ $( ""#" ." % #"" &() # &() % ( # , #

+" " # &") #."% B"1 #%2 # ## .# # " " $( #$#- # "$"# " E ! "%# $## ," % #( $ %"# #)$ ! . #"% %"" "$ % #$" )# #""#""$


3/28

$#" # %"" "$ " '""& ( &(## #&& , $""") "

%." " #%# +#) $$"% " # #. "%#" # %"%") % !"$ & #$ ".( "# "( " " '""& #" " "

! . % $") ." .#( #)( $- " & $ # ##)$ % %# ( & #"% D#$ $("#%#( #$#- " " &." #" " ! $)") # " " " $ %"")" &

'"(") #" ($ # & "% % #%

% '"(") #"# " " %# #2""#" #)$ # ##" " #)#% ," " " ##"&". #)$ " "" #"## #"#

+ $") #( ) # & " %""" &( "$)"") # $") # ," " 6 -+( " '" (#%(F # # G #&&% &- $% 0 %( #"% % % )"( 1( " '" (#%( G % -% %"# ," $( +( % # " '"F

# $") # # )% #$ &% # #$ %") ") % $- "( # 2 # #" %1 & & ) &% ") % " # # .#( %"# ,"# 8 ," $"H ## $ ! - ( "% ## $ # " - "%# # ," - ( . """ "$ +( % " # ## (( #)".") #F

# ( " #"# $ " "%

## $ # $ & " )"( % " )"(& - ! " - &- '%) - &- '#( - &- % ( " .""% "$ # $") %"% $ " & "% % " "$ " & " % &( " &") - % ") ( # ."" "

8 # % . """ "$ "% #$$% % .#" ) " " & " "


4/28

) &( "% )"# % &( $ " # ($ "$#"( "% #$

#"") %# " " " . , " )# ##") "# "(

8 ( '%) % )"# % "%"# "" % - " %"# %"#" # # '""" '%) % &

'%) % "- ##"&". ."2 '""" "% )"# % & )"# % "- ""#" ." & ." . " " " " % & " "")% "". # . & & "% #)$2 %1 """ " %"# ."

( # %") %"# " " %"# %" %"% %"#( " # ($ # $- #"$"

8 $") ( .# ""#" ." " $#%$ " " " $# %$ " #

'%) ##" )"#1 " # %#$" "8 )"# %"% . % ") " #"# ."" ") # # $ & & % ( """ " " ".. ##"&"." #"# ! " # #"$"

($ # "" % #$ # " #"# % & '""& &( #)$ ##"&". ## %"" # # ## $ # $"$ " # % %"" . % " ") $( & % &(""#" #)$2 & " %"% . %"%% $") #-") " #"# "##"&". " #$

# " )%#% &( ." "$ " ," "$ 8 %"")" "

'%) % )"# % %"")" "#%"# " " # ($ # " $- 2 % %"# # "%#"" % ( & #% # # " % %#

C %"# # #)$ # "% %"# " 8( -") %"# & " #" " #)#% $ # *% " %"# "! " " 7&& % %


5/28

.# " & "#% " $")'""" "$ 8 #" ." &(

"$#% %." $-") $ ( %"# ""G " #( & " "$F + " # #

# " "%


6/28

# &" "(2 # ""#" )#% """)#") # % & '""%?

))% ( #"") ##"&". % ""#" '""" "$ $ # & "% . % ( # # .# ##," " #" % ! %. #$"%# "" $

D"# " %"# "" ## #"#" ' $- #% #""" & ##"&""F +" ( ," # " ""#"#"" " % #"#" " .- # )"( " ( " "" "# %$%

"% %#. & "%F # " %""( # #"$" # '""% ""#")#% " " ( # $ " #"#" ""#" & % #"& " " " #"$" "" # " ( ##% ### % #$ % #% " "( ,(##"&"" ( %( # "% %#. & "% " ( %( " # #) " ( " %

% ," " # ""#""$ %1 '"(

$ 8 "# " )" '""" " ""( %% % & % '"( # % #&"##(""" #"&"" $( & % % ""#" ##$ % $- " $# $2 ""#" % '"( ( ") "$ "2 % ""#" $( "$ # )" " &( "$ %#% """ ") " "#" ) # % ## " " )"( %

?G$ %" ##%") "#( #."" #"$" # " # #."" " % " )" % " % $ $ "#( 0 " $") * % " ( "$ )" " &' #$# ##." " # ! $ " # " " .# ) " )". '%) " %"%") # " " # $ &". & " # '%)1 &" " ," $ ( # % ) # % #" #."" '%) " & )% . & %(."% % % " # 2 % + >.# @C E#- A 4


7/28

""#" " '"(") $") . '""%"$ " $( " " # ,"

.# " # ""#" " '"(") "$ 1% #)$ " $$" "$ ") """ #") " # " " " # )% "( ## " "$ 7# )#( "1 ""#"$$"% " #"" ") $( #" " $#( "". # %1 F #"&""# ""% % # " ( ""#"#"" #$ '"(") $ * &( %%") " #""" %"#"& #" #") "%"."% $%%#"#" " )# &" "( &

)# &" "( &' #" 1 #")$( & ."% C " ! "- " ""#"#% #"#" " $# $"% # ! % #) " #+ ! " # " ( #.") ""#" #"" #$ '"(") $# $-") " $ "-( % $( &( ")""#""$ " ( " # %""" & '""" """ % '""" #"#" "") %# "

! &)" &( %"") """ "$

# " "% # "$ .# " )( %#".% $ #$ #") ""H )#% ."% # ."" .") & &"% &( #"#%") % # #."%% %#"." "##"% &( #)"H% ) #"" # #( "" & % %( # # #"( % &- #"# "$ " %""""" ! %#% &( "$ ," "# ""#" #)$ $( & % '"( """

"%( %"# #$ " % % "% # %#&"##(

" ," " & #% ! "- &( -") #"#" "%# ") #$ ##"

G( " ""#" ! %#% 0&& 0$ G$ 6 7" %6"%)"- / # "$ # $"% &( 0&&2 **."""


8/28

""#" $ % # '""% " """)

" ( % ( #. # " # ") &)## " " " % "%# " % "$ " $ & #( #.". G "$ -"% .#( # #"$ &$ $$ % #"$" & ) " $") & ")( *%" *$ ) " $ " #) )" "$% & #$% # ".#( ) )"(2"%% " % ( " & "% " ""#"1"$1 & .""$ "$ % . & "-( # $$" #"$ " #2 " # # " % & #( %## % ##

"""

##" " #(") # # " ""#" #)$ % '"( -") " " % &)#( %$%2 % ""#""$ '"" $G "# ##"1 #)$ " " $- %""" & '""" )# ($ #" " """ % '""" #"#"" # #"# &( .#" "" '& " " %$""# $ " &$ #( #

- # $ ##" - + " " # & #"( #"# " %"% " $ & "% " .#( & ."% " )"(F ! " # )"# # '%) # &%( #". ""H # F ! " #( #" - " %"% $# % &( #"( # " $ " " # """ 9" - ") %1 - """ " '""" " &"))%2 % ""#" #"" " """ %1 - # " " '""& ""#" )#% #

8 " " %#% " " # #$.

##"1 #)$ " 8 $ %#"& $# #( " " " *$ )) % - # # " " "-( .") " """ % & # &" "( " ) # 8 $ " .) ) "1 ," "

" 38*#% 5


9/28

% & )% ") " # %"% $") . " "# # #

#( "$)" """ " $( "$ " " "" &( " .#"( ##) #" # %$" " $.# ( # "" %") % & " &"# "( %"#" "" " "$"% .# &( # ( $( %$ " $ %#) #% # " "$ . "$"# " " ( #) "$ % " "$ # + $("$)" "" .") %"#"#( #"( #

'%) ")# # " " " " "

$""# '" % $$" )"#8 #"H " "..% " ")

H#% # .#( )# D# *$ - "# ""F 0 " # # "# "# #"H%F 0 " "$" #"- "..% " ") ($" %"F 0 " ."% )".") (")# $ %"#" #"" " ( ("-F ! %%"" "%#" " " &." "$ . .#( %"# "% #% "# ($ "$ " %'"% " ( " & #"

# ."% $ & "% # "% ( "%# # # ( % ##( # "$ ( "%# # $ 1 ( "$ $ ! "# """ % ( #- % #$ #"- "..% " " " $ # " % #. # / ""#" '""" # " """ " $"-(

! " )# %# %"") # "$ % " """ ""#"

'""" " ")( %& 8 # # " "

"$ #- "- -"% #" ($ &( #") #" ( # ##$ " " " $". #."%") $ " % %") # %"") # #" " "$ " #- " " (2 """" - # # *$ """ " " " " " "-( . & $ " #" ($ " $( " # #" ")


10/28

) #%$ #$ %( %( % # #" $") # )#% &( "

! " # ( ""#" #"" """" " #"H #"# " # " %)# "

'"(") $ ##"1 *$ )" "&""( &( ""%"" % &( " #" #"# 0"#)$ " ( % " " & # # ""#"#)$ " '"( """ &"( #"&" % # # #$" "" *#" -"% %"#" " #"# G #,"#$ .") &"% #&"##( # #"# %"" " """ #" $- '""" $ "-( )

#)

!!! "%# ," #$" &'"

""#""$ " " " #$" $ & " " "&".% ""#" ." # $- #$" ( )#% " % - " " % - "" &( -") " " #"H $ )% 6 " - ," +( % ! - #$"F ""#" # " %#% & %") " "

. & , /% " # " "% ," #")(

)( " #" ($ )) # ," ""#" "%#" "# "$ " #"" !" "#") 6"#


11/28

" " ( " " &")" - #$" "#)#%%

C # #"" ""#""$ # # % $"$ #"&% ""#" " "%#""..") #" #$"-") ! " " (# % #) $") "- " " $ & %$"% #"( & -") #$" $# #"( " $")$ # ." # G "%# $##( " " ( #( - " "# " " . #" $-") #$" #$"# $ ") ( -") " #$" #"# & " " -") " #$"

" . #" " 6" #" " )# ""#". % " -") 1 #$" ( #"( %$) " " %$ & '""% " -") 1 #$" ! ."# "%"."% #$" " "%# * #" #$"") " # #" &")" - #$" # " ( .#( #) ""#""%#" " .# -") $ % " " "# ," #" # # - #$" "" ( # % . # #"# - &( " % $ '"( 1 -") "

! " ( #" " " ." &")" -#$" " % #

#"""H% " % .# )# . #" #$"") ""#" )#% # $& $ . " " )## % "$)" " &&"& &( -") #$" ## # $") & # #$"# % #) -") " #$"

'""% %") "# /% #$"# % #) " " ( $# ") %.) &( -") #$" ! # )

#$"# " % % & %"% & " ." ""#" "%#" " " "

( 5 % 4 "8*#% ! - ""#" % " #)$ * + /:"-#%$"%) " :#&$ & 7#1 .#" ""#""$ " " $"%) ? $( -%) " % # " " ""#"2 % " "## "# ." ##( " " "% ( 4


12/28

"$# #" %% & & ! "- " #") "# " #")

)" , " )# % " ##*" E " " *#$( %"" ") # 1#)$ -"% "$)"% $ #"" % " % & %#"&% 8 " ""% "- " %"# # $ %# *" %"% &( #" " " " # % & , " )# #"# # " % "#$ # "# %"" " #" # )# &"% G #"( " #")" "-") " #"- #) # # %% -")

#$" &( )# , D# )#""#" % " #$"# " " % % &( #" $-") #$"

)". ## ##)$5D"# % ".#"$ %$) % #" #$"") &( "# - #$" 8 - #$" #$ " $ #"( & " "1 # - #$" (%$) #" " ""( # #" &")" 6% % $# "$# ! "- #" ," " ( #$" " "1 -

. & $% * #$"# % #$" " #$" $- " %(") # #") %") 4! " # "%#" #") #" %1 ") #$"# % ( " # #$" " &"%") # #$" ," " -") " #" $ "##. ( , $ & - #$"" #") ( #"- &") #%2 & &")" "$ -% 0 " " %& #

5 # &" #$" " %"% )" "4 " ?? ! # " 7&& :"$% % 5 % " / ! 7% $$ 9""#""$ 3= 8 " %" ##"1 *$" " 3 41 *$ " %#"&% "$( $ %(") # $- #$" # ##"1 *$ 5 # " $ C# : *$ " * " $# #"" % " "$"# 7&&1 /# *$ " &") % $") " "% &( &,( %" 6 % & %#"% #)$ C6$" $ &". " "


13/28

#" .# ") " #"# 2 #"( " # #" &")" # " " &" !

$ ""#" &")" -#$" & ( ##"%

D#$ ! . "% " " " "$ # ! $ )") ( & #)$ %##)$ ( " $- %""" &

'""" #" % '""" #"# "") %# " % ## ( " $"- -") "# )#% #$"# "- ##"1 "" " "%" ##"" ") ""#" "%#" "%"%") # - " #$" G " "%#

#" #$"") " " ! "- " " " # )# %"#" #$"# !%% " #" " &%" 1 " " #% """#" % #%" "%#" " #%# # $(& "% % % #%"% " %. # # &."""#" %.) " .") #" " %" #$"# % ( )# ""#" #""" #% " " #" " $( & '""% # "") #%"#( # ##"") " " ""#" # "# $") ##( & )". " #)") )$ #

&& " "#( ' " " # " #)") " % &)% " .#" # & (# " )$ ##( "%#" # # " $-") $.## # ! " $"- "- " #" "

'""% ""#" )#% #$"# $ .$ "( ""#" #)$ %"% # # - " #$" #" #&"% " )# %2% " " # #" % " ## &. #)$ # "% " ""#" ." "% #$"# " &% " % ( " ""

""#" #"" " -") " " & " #$"# " &% & #$"%")") " $#" " "$

! " ( " #"# %"# # - 1 #$"F 8 # G % "

+ ! . "% " " #)# $ $ ""% " 0$1"$# %"" " &- !!! "" 2 % # 4


14/28

%" # .#" * *" % %" # %#% &( % " " "$# #

#" ( 1 ? ;#" % # -") 1 #$" # % & $) $ # "1 )# ""#" )#% #$"# #( )" " & . ) # $( & % , -") 1 #$" % . &5 .# +" # # $( $*"" # "%# #( %" )#% "1 % " - ") ," % ( $ -% ( - " #$"#"% "$( -") " & F /$")

" #( " "# % " &" #& " % "%# "&""( $"- ! "- % ," # # - " $ ( !#$" " ##" "#$ ! % & "% $ % " * " ## *" %"%1 %#% % #" " %" #$" "$ ! "% # " * %## "$2 # " " # ( " ) #$" & ##% " " * " .") #" % & " #" %"% " *

! " %& # ""#" ." .#( #"% %$" % , &"%") &( "% . & *#$( .#2 % ""#" % &""% % $ #" 1 )% % $" #% " #( ( % % #" " '""% &( #.") "# - # ""2 % " ( # # " %#% &-)#% "#$ %# " " " *% & "% % "% "%% " & ( % 6% "#$ ) . " # " # " #."%

# " $( " & " #% " #" % #$ 1 &")" G " # % % &( #" $ & % " )# " ") #"# ""#" )#% " #"" ""#""$. ) " #"( "..

? D# %"" 0 6"%)"- ! " %23% ? &- !!! ."


15/28

# " ""#""$ #" &( " '""" "$ " " $( '"( $ ," "

" " #$" " %"# " " ""#""$ # &")" - #$" 8 #)"H% &")" - 1 #$" % ""#""$ #"$"& /% & # ( # "$"& " "## ""#" ." #"( %") # $ "( ") .#( #"# " )#""#" )#% G $ "## ""#""$ " " (F! " # ! . %"% "## " " " (

!!!6 # ! . #"% "$# %"""

& '""" #" % '""" #"# " ") %# " &( "%"") " %"""$") & % %% ""#""$ )" )%")&'" 8 $") & $% %"" " "&( (") ""#" "%#" % & %#% (") #" " "# " % #"# "") %# $ * "# #" %$" " 8$") ( " " $%""% #$ " " #

"%#% $# "" % " ) G #% & ) "#") ," " #" ")"" " ## &." %""" % - " # )#% ""#""$ , #"# $( ( & %"%% )# ""#")#%! #) " $"- $( & % "

6 # ! " " " 7# %#" " *#( % " "( 6 # *$ " 5 # " " "% $ !$ $#( &% ##$ " " " "%" " $ " " #% )# "& $ )% " 9".# $("" ! " "$# #$$ $ ! . % """#" # #)( "#% " " """ ( # $) %") $" % "" #" "# %( % ( # "#,( ##$# "#% " #" "# 9""#""$ "#"() )# " # ." "( % " "$( " #($ $ "" (" " $%# ""#"#"" ," #( ) % % #"#" # '%)") """" #" % &" # #)") ##$ ! " # ## # " " #( $% ""#""$ " " " #$ D# %""


16/28

$"".") )" # #"2 % " ! $ )") *$" " # (

") $ "" ""#" #( " " #$ ")""

%""" ! $ )") $$#( ." ! #)#% # " ") ( # %"% % " #"# &( (") ""#" #""2 ## %"# " %"% $ #"# " $ ( % # " & ### "$"# #."( %"%% " " " #" -"% $ %"" " & $% "# &( $# %"# "$ # &( %"# # $ "$ !

# #,( ) # " #$% .# # ! . % " " $$#(." & # # "#% $$#" %""##".% &( "" ""#" #"" #"# # #)#%% ## #"# . & % )#% & ##( %"%% " #" ( ) # ( % ( "

# # .# ") " & " ( ") #"" ""#" #(

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


17/28

# )#( $"% + $ $# , "".

% )". "% % %#$" " # %.)"! #( #( %( "" # "%"."% #( %( " &) " " %#" #)#% ") "$" " " %# "#)#% ") "$" " $") "$"# # "##% % %)% " $$#( # % % #$" " # #( %'% ""( # 5 8 $") "- /" $ &'" &( ") #" " #2 % # %"% "% G " " # % " " ! )#"( ## "" #F " " ))% &( " %( 8# % ## ""( ") #"F ! %1 -2 & )) $$#( ." " " &, #$#- 0 ( "%#

"" , ") "%"."% % @$( ""A" " "$ #"" # 5 G % .# % "F 0" " &") %$"% "( ") % ") " &'" " ," " "$)"% "( # ## &( '# % $#" , # #(@$( ""A % $"". ! # #( # "$ @$( ""A % & $&%"% " - ! ##( $"". "$ # % & *#% &( #" # % #&&( & ( " " # % # " # 54 0 ) ! # *#" % ." #"# # 6 # *#" % ." #"#% %$ ." " "# ))% # $"% &(

#% *#" % ." # ## %# " #$#% " 5 ##( & #%( # % ( "%"."% #$(" #.#") # &( " ( #&"%2 # " #") % ##(") # $"% $# %"#" "%#" " ( # # @$( ""A ##( " #"# # 6-") )#( $% " "."&( @$( ""A &( # &( # 5 # J54 ! % #& #$#- "" $$#( ." D## /" $ % " $#".(## ## % "" "%#" $( ") )#3-") # #$ " % "##% # " # % "- " "*"& + % ## %"$" ## %"#(

" # # # "%2 % , & # -%) % &""( # ? /"1 ." ""#") & " $( $ #" "% "% ( #$ "

! &- ;! *"" # 7" %"")" #( & "" '%) % )"# % " %") )) %"""& # 0.# %"")" "" "# %"# & # " ( # #%(&"% % # $ #$ # ).# &,% !1 # "# "$ % - $*"$ "( )"# (" # ! # $$#( " " .#( #(


18/28

" .") # %#". #$ "$"# % ## % %"% $# ,"-( "

##% %"" " #$ # ! "$"# %"%1## % & #,"#% ( ""#" #""%"#( &( % # ##") %"" % &

% D# *$ ( # % ( % & -#.""( ( # $% # $ $# 0 ( (" $# " " " " #" 2 ( #. %$"" #" $% % & % "% $$$ ## ! "" # $$#( "

# " 7"1 # $ &'" /" "%#% 0# - # ##" #$ #" ""(2 %#( # #$#% %$#- % %"#" ( # &% ) *#"% $- " #( ( ""#" #"" " ! # 7" ## - ""#" #"" " %'%"") &$") $# # 0 - # " " ""#" #""%"#( #"# 8 #" ." % ## #"" %"% " ( $- #" " " &! % & % " " # ? 7"1 %""" ""#""$ $- ""#" #"" ( $#"( " # % # $% %""" " # # " # #") " ( #$ " @$( ""A % " "" #%

$$#( ." ! #)# ( 8


19/28

%"" $% #"# # )"( #"# # 6" # )" "# " #$ % (

""#" #"" $( " #"# # .# "$"# " $( *" # # # " #.#") + # "#% #)"H") #"# #"# # &") # " .# $ # " " ( " $" $ #" # #$ # # & %#"& #"# #"# #,"" # # # " # #)#%") # # : # ( /1 % G1 ## " # #$ 1+.# / % G1 $( & %#"&% /1 % G1 # # # " # 1+.# / % G1 # # # # "

( &%( # " $- #" " # " #

"# " "%# # # $*"$ " % #" "" ( # " #(") %"% # $ " ( " " " " & -% % 6 # # % %"% ""#")#% % # #(2 % &" " % # "- " #$ # -% &( $ ( " " " " % "$ " " " $1 &")

( " % -") " " " % $1 ") "$# ") & %#"&% # # # " "# ##$ " " # ## %1#,"# )") #" " " # " # "" " $ &( (") $$#( ." #"# # )"( #"# #

> # " " #"" ( "% #"%# ## # % ," # # " " ## " " #"# / # # )"% % "% $(- # " %"" # $") . & $"- "

(") ""#" #"" ) # " ," %%# # # " " & " " # # # " # & ( ""#" #"" #(% (2 # " % . "$ % )"% 8 "." "( #" ""#" % & "( "# " " # "% ""#" #"" %"#(% $( % " ### &( 8 # %# " "( " " # # #$% #. "% "#") "%( #" %"" #"# )"%


20/28

" . & &" % % &( *#" )#" ! " " ." # " "##") $

$*"$ # $&2 % " " %& (") " $$#( " %"% ( % & % #/#)") " #)#%% # " " ( " $"- $-" %") "(

)# # - ") #$ 8 ""#% "$") #) "-( #" )". # $( & #"% *# ## %"" " %"" % & ##".% " # ##( ( ""#" #"" &( ! "$ &( %#) # " )". ## %"" # " "$

"-"% $-") $"- &( (") ""#"#"" %"#( 1 " )## "-"% $-") $"- &( ") # % " "%#"% # )#( % & '""% " #)") "%" )# # ! " ( )# # $") &% # $$#( ." ! " " $- .# - (") ""#" #"" &( # " &( #(") # # %") " ) """ "$ " # %% " -") # " #% " $$#( " "

" " # " " - # )"% # $*"$ # )#"H" #$ *#" % $") & "% "% " *##%"#( # # " # )#"H" " % % $## & #% " $#" # ) " "" " #"# *" " #%# # #"# "

# " # ! " #" "8 " ." # # "#% %"") #" :#" # # .#" # & $ " " $( #

% #1 %"%") % ""#" )#% &( % " % $ #%"&."# &( #(") # # " " &% " / #". #"H " #,"#% " &"$ #" """ #$ "."(2 % #$ " #" #"( ".. &%"" "( "#" % #%" )#% ! " $#- #" &") ) )) " " ".. &")"#% " # " %" " % " $%


21/28

# ## &."# ))% " " ))% " #" #)"H # %"") " #

& - "$( %#"&") ))% " #" " &. " " "$( ( " ( #&(") # " " " " #" # # &"( - % %#% %""".2 % " "" # #" & ) % &% ("% # #" 8 " " # # )#"H" #$ %"" "%"."%(") ""#" #"" %"#( % "%%( ### #"# 8 ##( # %" #"% # $. &' ""#" #""

"$# %"# & " ( "")# " ""#" #( % #." ( ! "%# %"# & " " #."(%"%

! # " $$#( ." # #" #)"( #"# #"# " " & # & #"# " ") %# # #" # " #" " & $% ## " #"# # # ") " "(") #" #$ "##" .#" " &"") " #

# % + $( "- # #" %"")" $. % C " $ &( (") #" " )"( #"# #"# " " )". ( #" "" #$ " $. #"# " "% & - ") %# " # )". # " #" % & # # " # #" ! " ""% &( #" " " )"("$"& ##$ $ "% )") #."%% &( #" # # " #" % #,"" ##"" # "% .# % .#

$.$ $- " " #$ " " #" "" + % " & %#"&% " $ (

8 $( "# " " ## )$ && 7( " ##$ " )$ && % &( # " # # # " )$ # D# *$ # & # # ") "#( % " %G & # #"- # %# - # $- ### # &-2 ) % #" ") " #


22/28

#$& " "%") " &) $"") )#%#% 6#"-") ") & &-") # "

" ( " )$ C $# # %"% %"% % & %#"&% ") & # #"-") # %#") - % & %#"&% (")&& % # "$ & %") " # #"-#" " " )$ #" " )"( #"# #"# # " #" #$ ###") " ""% &( " -

#" ." % "#( %"# " #"( " # %"% ##"( ") # " #"# )) " #"

##$ " ""% &( #" $ ##" # ! % " " #"#" "" # " ( % " * # " %" " ## " %1 $- # # #" ," # # # #" ##( " # " $ " #$ "%"% &( #" ! $ # #" ," &% "$( %"%1 %#% "" " " ") ! ##$ " ""% &( #" ( )""$ ," # #

#" " 0 % ! ) & $-") "F" " " "#% &( &."# *% (# "

)$ ! ( )$ %1 # # )$ )"% " & " #"# ! )$ && " # - ! . # #"-F " % &$% -") # 2 % " % # # ( $ " " ) " % & & # "$ . # #"-

8 $") " " $"- ( #" " )"( #"# #$ " " "" )#% " # # .# " " ") %# #" % & #)( ""% ( # 1 #" "# G#" # #" % $- #" # " #" " # # " .") &))% % &") ))% " " " "& ,""" " " ##& " %1 # "$ ( )". #"# " #$ """% &( #" # #" " "1 $$#("# " $ & # #"# # - $") #$ " ) # &( (") ""#" #"" "%"#(


23/28

## # " % & $ -"%( - '- 8$") % && % & )$ " # #"-

# % "% #2 & "# # )"% " & " #"# % ,""# "&""( #"# #"#

% $ # " $#" " $$#( " " " # #$ & "% # #" # )"% %"% #"# ##( '%)% &( $ ")# " #"" /% "# ,""" " )#"( # " #"#*" ( # #" / $# # )## #" $ & # " #%") ##

#" " $# # # -"% #"")%# "2 # " $ & # " " $# # &" %#%") #" /)" #"# & *" # #" / *" " ## ,"""# ## """ #

! #$ . "% & #" " # " # " ))% " #" % " " -%( % % # " " -% %% % " *" # % " " ###") ,"# #" 0 ( " " " " " ""% &(

#" % " ## $ # & "- " "& + $ ))% " #" " ,#"%& " " $ $ ,"# "# %1- " ))% " " +( # ( " ##( ( "$F! #$"% ( "$ %( # %1 - #" "8 %1 $ '"( 1 #"# " *" # " " " #% " #" # # " " " " ( )" )") #" 1#"# " " %#"&% " " 8( &( ## #" " %") *" # %% 1

" #"# " " " " #" "%" " ! " " % "1 ") %"# ," "&") #"% # " '""% " ") #" #" #") " + ) " #" "") #(") #" " " #( ." G

/ "" '- " $ #$( G$ + ! # #"-# # $( ## #- )% & ! % & " " &


24/28

) " #"# " %"% &( #" # "") % & ## # #") #"#

" # " ( ," # "1 # #" " # %1 - " " &") ))% " " " & #% " $*"$ " $( & - "") ## %"" %"%% )#% % )".") ) &( .") "," # # )#% #( # %"" "

! $# " # ! . %"% $$#( " $" ")"" %""" & '"(") #" % '"(") "

") %# " 8 " ." # # #)#%% )"% # " " "%" "%( #" %"" )".#"# " "" ""#"#"" % ("% 8 " #"" " )"% # %"#% $ "" ## " 1$# " &") #% " ( ( # %"#% ## ( % " #" # -") &( #"H & G #"" " % " %"% &( #" ," #)#%") 1 " " " " # % &(

## # " %" #" ! - ," # 1 " %#) %$) $ " $#% )% #"""H # # " ##$# % $$#( " % ( " %""" " % .#"# #$ #)$ ##" 8 " # " " % " ! ## ""#" #"" $ " " % " %"% &( #" ( #" )# ""#" #)$ # ."& "

" %"%

0 % #$#- ( #$" - ( # %F + "# ") #"( % " #$"# % "1 % &( #" ") #"# )# ""#")#% 6 "% " "%# "$ " " $#% #"""H % ) #" .") "% ," "#") $. #$ " #."( $% " # $("%# ""#" #)$ "% #"2 & % " " # # #)$ # ") )# ""#" %


25/28

6$ ,""" # #( " ! . "% D"# ! $(. -% $$#( % #" " #

" ( $ % & # # % " # ( # #"( # # ! % # $ " ! " #"" ""#""$ $- " $"- "# "##)$ )" ""#""$ # $$#( " # #" 6$ # " " " $# #2 % # # # #" # " #" % $*"$ % # $&

6%( # # ## %""" & $% ""(") # %""" " % & $% " #"%#") # ," %""" " ! . %# #

$ #. # ## " $# ! . %"%% # "%% & *".

D"( # " & $( %#" & " " " &%"" " "$"& %"% " " # ""& 8 * %#" " ( % (# "( "-( " " " "..% #" """ )$ # % +")" "% " # + ! . % " $"H % # " # "$"% # " #

!;+ ! . #"% &( %"")"") &

" # " # " ( #)#%") # " " "%# #"# )# ""#")#%2 # # " # " " % %$" %"#" * "# # $. #"H "! )) %( " %") "( "# # " #% " $$#( " " $( . &"%% "# ")"" %"""

& '"(") #" % '"(") #"# " ")%# "2 % " % &( $"##") )" # ## # " ) #"# "") %# #" % &( ") # # "

" #" # " # D# % % $- " "$"& - #% )". -"% #$" " & & - # % )". ## " ) #" % #$"# " - " #$" 98*#% ! # 5 # *$


26/28

#" " " #" " $ & &' ""#" #""

! " #( "% #%"" ""#""$ "$ % #$" # # #"9%# " $$#( " " " # "" ($ % $% #$" $( %"% % " #"# ""#")#% 8 " )# %"#" %"% #"# ""#" )#% " "$"& " #"2 % %"#" % . " " %"% &( #" ) '%) $( . %"#" %#$" ( "" #" "$" #%"" &'"

""#""$ " ! . %"% # #"&" '%) % . $% #$" "% $# #"( %"% #"# ""#" )#% G " ""#""$ )# " " #" % "$ % #$"") # #" " #"&" " )"( #%%

"$ % #$"") # #" " &(% ,"! #$"") " " &( #$ #% ! #$" " ##$". # " # )") #" % ##"" %"% &( " 6(")

#% ! #$" " ( & #$"") )". *" #" ! % & % "## # $"") " #% " $$#( " ! " % ( # *$ # #$" % & - %. #" #$ " &") % " & & - 1 #$"2 # # # #%( %#%") - 1 #$" # #"" # %1 . & ( #$"")

! $ # & )#% # %"") #$"")# %""% % 1 " ( #

#"( %% 1 $# #"") ## " " "-( # " "%#& .#"" " ( %#% #" % #$ # #)$ " " & D#*$ %"# #"( .#" % # &- # ' % # ."& # "-( #" $)# " %"# &-)#% G "##". .#"" " &) #" #$"") )# ""#" % " ."& #$"# " " # # #%"" &'" " !


27/28

. %"% /% " ! " $- " " ""#" ." )# " #" " #

$ " ##" # " ") " ."" " # $ & % "# " #" #$"") # " ( # #"

:"$ " # # # $( " " , . " " $1 &") "%" # #" 8 " &( "%#") %""" "$ " ! ). %"") ##"1#"""$ ""#""$ %""" # % ## ") #$ #") ""H # % # #" % # " *"

"% )") ) ($ ! " $( " # " # "% ##" D# *$ " "% # ") # #")% "- " # """ ##( ! ""$"& ( "$ " # %#"& #"#" " " ###") " " % ""% &( #" :"$ " $. " ))$ % # $* #" " $- ) #%# $ ") " # #$ # "$ # # )#%" # $ " ## #"(

$( " "% & # " $"- "##" ! . & (")

" " " #" # )" 8 $") "- ! $ $-") %""" & '"(") #" %

'"(") #"# " ") %# " ".. " %"" " % "" "% " " % -"% #."$ ! $") $ ! $ (") # # " #" " "( #."% %#% '""" #" "2 ## # &"% &( $ % " %" & '""%

" "##" " "#( #) " ! . &$-") " ## )" " & # " , "$# " #(2 & " " " % #"# "# "" "% ! " "$( # #$ " """% &( #" # " '""" "& #"# " #"# # . &( ## #" ! " " " " " ."# #"% *" " " ## #" # " "#.# & %# " # # # %


28/28

#" 1 "( 8 & #%" "-& " " ""% &( #" &' 1

#%""$ $ & " #" % 1 $

! . #"% " ""#" ." )#" #" " # # " " "##"5 #$ " " ( " . " #$.# #%"" &'" ! . ## #"% )" # %""" & '"(") #" %

'"(") " ") %# " " % " #"" # % & %#% ) #)#% # #" " #% " $$#( ." +(

%") "( $( & ""% #)#% $ !. %"% # # " # ."%( .#( % %% #,"# # #

5 / ! . #%( % " " ( ( ( # " "##" C# % ! # %" " " )# # "" % ( * ( % - " # )#% " " $( % $# # ! " $( ") #".( " $# " # %"% &( #" % #" " " $##. %#%") ) % )"- #)$ " " $#$* # $# #)$ 9""#""$ $ & "% %"#" # %%") % %& "# % " & # %""( " "##") " ##(

rawls - two concept of rules

Documents