rainwater harvesting in cincinnati: a sewer district’s ...s/reynoldssession14.22.13.pdfsystem...

15
METROPOLITAN SEWER DISTRICT OF GREATER CINCINNATI Rainwater Harvesting in Cincinnati: A Sewer District’s Perspective Andrew Reynolds Environmental Planner The Metropolitan Sewer District of Greater Cincinnati April 24, 2013

Upload: others

Post on 25-Jul-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Rainwater Harvesting in Cincinnati: A Sewer District’s ...s/ReynoldsSession14.22.13.pdfsystem during rain events, which can reduce the likelihood of CSOs and thereby reduce total

METROPOLITAN SEWER DISTRICT OF GREATER CINCINNATI

Rainwater Harvesting in Cincinnati: A Sewer District’s Perspective

Andrew Reynolds Environmental Planner

The Metropolitan Sewer District of Greater Cincinnati

April 24, 2013

Page 2: Rainwater Harvesting in Cincinnati: A Sewer District’s ...s/ReynoldsSession14.22.13.pdfsystem during rain events, which can reduce the likelihood of CSOs and thereby reduce total

METROPOLITAN SEWER DISTRICT OF GREATER CINCINNATI

MSD’s Sewer Network

• Publicly Owned & Operated Wastewater Utility Serving Southwest Ohio (Hamilton County)

• Serves a Population of about 855,000 – 230,000 Residential

and 250 Industrial Users

– Operates 7 Wastewater Treatment Plants; treating 70 Billion Gallons/yr

Page 3: Rainwater Harvesting in Cincinnati: A Sewer District’s ...s/ReynoldsSession14.22.13.pdfsystem during rain events, which can reduce the likelihood of CSOs and thereby reduce total

212 Combined Sewer Overflow (CSO) Locations 78 Sanitary Sewer Overflows (SSOs) Locations

11.5 billion gallons

MSD’s Environmental Challenge

Page 4: Rainwater Harvesting in Cincinnati: A Sewer District’s ...s/ReynoldsSession14.22.13.pdfsystem during rain events, which can reduce the likelihood of CSOs and thereby reduce total

METROPOLITAN SEWER DISTRICT OF GREATER CINCINNATI

History of Consent Decree

Page 5: Rainwater Harvesting in Cincinnati: A Sewer District’s ...s/ReynoldsSession14.22.13.pdfsystem during rain events, which can reduce the likelihood of CSOs and thereby reduce total

o Capturing some or all of the rainwater that hits a building’s roof or other on-site impervious surfaces reduces peak stormwater flows in the combined sewer system

o Reduced peak flows lessen the strain on MSD’s collection

system during rain events, which can reduce the likelihood of CSOs and thereby reduce total overflow volume

o MSD is under a federal consent decree to reduce CSOs o Potential for public-private partnerships and raising

community awareness about stormwater

METROPOLITAN SEWER DISTRICT OF GREATER CINCINNATI

Why is Rainwater Harvesting Important to MSD?

Page 6: Rainwater Harvesting in Cincinnati: A Sewer District’s ...s/ReynoldsSession14.22.13.pdfsystem during rain events, which can reduce the likelihood of CSOs and thereby reduce total

METROPOLITAN SEWER DISTRICT OF GREATER CINCINNATI

Concerns & Future Challenges

100

120

140

160

180

200

220

240

260

o Trends of declining number of accounts and declining usage per account (revenue stability)

o When rainwater harvesting is implemented, need to ensure

accurate billing for sewer treatment services provided (revenue stability and treatment capacity)

Volume in CCF per Account

Page 7: Rainwater Harvesting in Cincinnati: A Sewer District’s ...s/ReynoldsSession14.22.13.pdfsystem during rain events, which can reduce the likelihood of CSOs and thereby reduce total

Simplified Rainwater Harvesting Diagram

Total Rainfall Captured

- Building Usage

= Net Capture

To se

wer

syst

em

*Not drawn to scale

Page 8: Rainwater Harvesting in Cincinnati: A Sewer District’s ...s/ReynoldsSession14.22.13.pdfsystem during rain events, which can reduce the likelihood of CSOs and thereby reduce total

Direct Impact

Projects

• Large & Regional Scale – business case evaluations

• MSD as the implementer • 100% ratepayer funded • Owned and operated by MSD to

support its core mission • Remove liability of stormwater

Enabled Impact

Projects

• Anticipated annual stormwater runoff capture volume of 40 MG

• MSD partners with property owners to offset the cost of installation

• Integrated Bioinfiltration practices, green roofs, pervious/porous paving as part of watershed solutions

Inform & Influence

• Programmatic Elements to support sustainable infrastructure solutions

• Advisory Committee • Comprehensive Plan • Land Development Code Updates

Page 9: Rainwater Harvesting in Cincinnati: A Sewer District’s ...s/ReynoldsSession14.22.13.pdfsystem during rain events, which can reduce the likelihood of CSOs and thereby reduce total

METROPOLITAN SEWER DISTRICT OF GREATER CINCINNATI

Enabled Impact Projects

o Over 30 public/private green infrastructure projects throughout the Lower Mill Creek watershed

o Over 40 MG stormwater captured per year (already installed) o Example of how public

and private benefits can be realized by sustainable projects

Page 10: Rainwater Harvesting in Cincinnati: A Sewer District’s ...s/ReynoldsSession14.22.13.pdfsystem during rain events, which can reduce the likelihood of CSOs and thereby reduce total

METROPOLITAN SEWER DISTRICT OF GREATER CINCINNATI

Rainwater Harvesting- Complementary Programs

o Green Roof Loan Program Partnership with Cincinnati Office of Environmental Quality (OEQ)

and Ohio Environmental Protection Agency (OEPA) Low-interest loans for green roof construction

o Rain Barrels

o 55-gallon barrels available for purchase through MSD

Page 11: Rainwater Harvesting in Cincinnati: A Sewer District’s ...s/ReynoldsSession14.22.13.pdfsystem during rain events, which can reduce the likelihood of CSOs and thereby reduce total

METROPOLITAN SEWER DISTRICT OF GREATER CINCINNATI

Sustainability LENS

o Screening and benchmarking tool o Promotes integrated planning solutions within a watershed

context in support of sustainable separation o Evaluation of green and gray infrastructure for wet

weather improvement program using principles of sustainability o Economic viability o Environmental stewardship o Social values

o Sustainable LENS will include: o Integration of water quality & quantity goals & needs o Maintain or enhance environment through a technology-based solutions o Promotes environment protection, economic growth, and enhance quality of life

Currently developing planning tools to help facilitate private investments

Page 12: Rainwater Harvesting in Cincinnati: A Sewer District’s ...s/ReynoldsSession14.22.13.pdfsystem during rain events, which can reduce the likelihood of CSOs and thereby reduce total

METROPOLITAN SEWER DISTRICT OF GREATER CINCINNATI

Modeling Effectiveness & Maximizing Benefits

12.5100

5003,338

0.0%20.0%

40.0%

60.0%

80.0%

100.0%

250

1,500

6,000

24,000

Non-potable Water Usage (gal)

Net Capture

Cistern Volume

(gal)

Net Capture for Roof Area of 5,000 ft2

80.0%-100.0%

60.0%-80.0%

40.0%-60.0%

20.0%-40.0%

0.0%-20.0%

o Currently developing planning tool/model to simulate peak flow reduction benefits paired with private benefits of rainwater harvesting systems

o Sample (Excel) model output based on user inputs of roof size, daily non-potable water use, and proposed cistern size

o Can help minimize

$/gallon invested by building owners

Axes not to scale

Page 13: Rainwater Harvesting in Cincinnati: A Sewer District’s ...s/ReynoldsSession14.22.13.pdfsystem during rain events, which can reduce the likelihood of CSOs and thereby reduce total

METROPOLITAN SEWER DISTRICT OF GREATER CINCINNATI

Rainwater Harvesting Legislation Process o GCWW, the City Planning and Buildings and City

Health Departments, and other stakeholders w/ MSD o Task force led to the adoption of the new

rainwater harvesting legislation Considerations for broader use o Rainwater harvesting systems

o Potentially removing metering requirements and establishing a flat billing structure for single-family homes

o Commercial users o Specifications for ensuring adequate billing of

use – i.e. require user to install and maintain calibrated metering system

Page 14: Rainwater Harvesting in Cincinnati: A Sewer District’s ...s/ReynoldsSession14.22.13.pdfsystem during rain events, which can reduce the likelihood of CSOs and thereby reduce total

METROPOLITAN SEWER DISTRICT OF GREATER CINCINNATI

Moving Forward

o MSD along with other stakeholders will continue to educate residents and business owners about the joint benefits to them and to MSD that can be realized through rainwater harvesting

o Assistance is available to anyone who has questions about

the new legislation and what opportunities are available for their home or business

Page 15: Rainwater Harvesting in Cincinnati: A Sewer District’s ...s/ReynoldsSession14.22.13.pdfsystem during rain events, which can reduce the likelihood of CSOs and thereby reduce total

METROPOLITAN SEWER DISTRICT OF GREATER CINCINNATI

THANK YOU

www.projectgroundwork.org Contact Information: [email protected] 513-244-5572