r the orchestral ledger in the louise hanson- dyer … · work, sibelius’s valse triste, first...
TRANSCRIPT
97
ReseaRch RepoRt
TheOrchestralLedgerintheLouiseHanson-DyerMusicLibrary,UniversityofMelbourne
Alison Rabinovici
IftheUniversitythinksthenew-styleviolinharmfultomusicinAustralia,onlyanactofParliamentforbiddingitwillhelpthem.�
Theauthorofthesewords,pennedin�9�2,wasCharlesEvelynCreasyJensenManby,violinteacher,entrepreneur,inventor,andoccasionalborrowerfromtheUniversityofMelbourneConservatoriumMusicLibrary.ThestoryofthisirascibleandpassionatemanemergedfromthepagesofanorchestralledgerregisterintheraremusiccollectionoftheLouiseHanson-DyerMusicLibrary.Theregisterisdated�9�0,anddetailstheorchestralmusiccollectionoftheConservatoriumofMusicLibrary—scoresandpartsthatarestillonthelibraryshelvestoday.Initspagesarerecordedthenamesofpeopleandorganisationswhoborrowedfromthelibraryover a period of nearly fifty years, from 1911 to 1954. This extraordinary document provides uniqueinformationaboutthoseborrowers:whoborrowedwhat,whenandhowoften.Itisanimportantprimarysourceforinformationaboutprogrammingandperformance,andhencereceptionofmusicinMelbourneovertheperiodinquestion.Asastartingpointforresearchintothelivesofborrowersandthehistoryoftheorchestrasforwhoseusetheyborrowedorchestral parts and scores, the register is invaluable. Through examination of the recorded datesofloansandreturns,theregisterofferseasyaccesstopressreviewsoftheconcertsforwhichthemusicwasused.Theregisterisalsoanimportantsourceofinformationaboutearlytwentieth-centurylibrarysystemsandresources.2
�‘TheUniversityandtheNew-styleViolin,’Music and Dramatic News2(December�9�2):�66.2Foralibrarian’sviewofsuchdocuments,seePeterThompson,‘”DoesitMatteriftheUsersareActuallyDead?”ADatabasetoReconnectwiththeBorrowersandCollectionofaHundredYearOldLibrary,’paperpresentedatVALA2006,�3thBiennialConferenceofVALA–Libraries,TechnologyandtheFuture(previouslyVictorianAssociationofLibraryAutomation), Melbourne,February2006.
98 Context 29 & 30 (2005)
A fieldwork placement for the subject ‘History in the Field’ (Department of History) with Dr Andrew Brown-May and Dr June Senyard offered me the opportunity to complete the first phaseintheconservationmanagementprogramoftheorchestralledgerand,additionally,tobeginresearchbasedoninformationthatemergedduringtheinitialconservationprocess.The project came under the umbrella of Helen Arnoldi, Student Projects Coordinator, Cultural Collections,andEvelynPortek,musiclibrarian.WendyWalters,CoordinatorofConservationPrograms,providedanintroductiontoconservationmethodsandprocedures.
This research report offers first of all, a description of the register, secondly, briefly details the preservation procedure and finally offers a short account of some of the preliminary research that the register has inspired. Although for assessment purposes the project was completed, theregisterasasourceofinformationaboutnetworksestablishedbetweentheUniversityandthe local community remains an on-going research project. In particular, I continue to work on theItalianconnections,thestoryofCharlesManby,andonthehistoryofsomeofthesuburbanorchestrasthatarelistedintheregister.
Apparently,theregisterhasalwaysbeenlocatedintheMusicLibrary.Itisanimpressiveartefact in its own right, and was made by the Melbourne firm of E. Whitehead & Co., ‘Stationers,GeneralPrintersandAccountBookManufacturers.’Alabelonthefrontcovergivesthedateas27August�9�0(seeFigure�).Looselyheldtogetherbetweentwocloth-coveredhard covers by metal rods, the 870 pages (approximately 30cm by 42cm) show the combined effects of age, neglect, inappropriate storage, insect damage, rust and water damage (seeFigure 2). Many of the leaves have badly damaged edges; folding, foxing, creasing is obvious, as is discoloration and a degree of brittleness of many of the exposed page edges. Dusty and disintegrating,itisnotpossibletoturnthepageswithoutriskingfurtherdamage,hencetheneedtocarefullylifteachpage,oneatatime,tobegintheconservationprocess.
Figure 1. OrchestralLedger,labelinsidefrontcover.
Research Reports 99
Eachorchestralworkisallocatedanindividual,numberedpage.Eachpageliststhetitle,composer,publisher,shelflocation,cost,hiringcharge,anddetailsofthepartsheld.A‘Remarks’sectionnotesdetailssuchasthenameofthedonorandthedateofdonationordateofpurchase.Thenamesofborrowersarelisted,oftenwiththenameoftheorganisationwithwhichtheywereassociated.Informationislistedincolumns,asshowninFigure3.Despitethedilapidatedstate of the register, no pages are missing from the 475 pages processed to this time.
Figure 3.PagelayoutoftheOrchestralLedger.
TITLE COMPOSER PUBLISHER
COLUMN SHELFNO. SCORES VOCALSCORES
CHORUSPARTS
APROXCOST
HIRINGFEE
DETAILSOFORCHESTRALPARTS
REMARKS
Loanedto:
DocketNo.
Forwardedper.
Date ReceiptNo.
Remarks DateReturned
Remarks
The register first lists symphonies, in alphabetical order according to composer, followed by tonepoemsandsymphonicpoems,concertos,overtures,marches,dances,operaticpreludes,suites,balletmusic,oratorios,andmoreconcertos,also inalphabeticalorderaccordingtocomposer. Sixty-eight of the 470 items were never borrowed; many were borrowed only a fewtimes,andanumberweremuchindemand.Amongtheworksborrowedonmorethanthirty occasions were Beethoven’s Symphony no. 5, Schubert’s ‘Unfinished’ Symphony, the
Figure 2. OrchestralLedger,showingitspoorstateasat2August2006.
�00 Context 29 & 30 (2005)
tonepoemFinlandia by Sibelius (see Figure 4), Mendelssohn’s Violin Concerto in E minor, and overturetoA Midsummer Night’s Dream,theoverturetotheMarriage of FigarobyMozart,theMerry Wives of Windsor overturebyNicolai,theRosamundeoverturebySchubert,Sibelius’sRomance inCandValse Triste, thesecondsetofHungarian DancesbyBrahms(forty-threetimes),theballetsSilviabyDelibesandLe CidbyMassenet,and‘ThreeDancesfromHenry VIII’ by Edward German. Hardly surprisingly, heading the list at a massive sixty-six loans, wasHandel’sMessiah.
Figure 4.OrchestralLedger,page66,recto:TonePoem,Finlandia—Sibelius.
Theconservationprocessinvolvedcarefulseparationofindividualsheetsfromtheregister,brush cleaning and vacuuming with a HEPA-filter industrial vacuum cleaner, and placement of sheets in individual archival quality mylar sleeves (see Figure 5). Dirt and insect remains wereremovedwherepossiblewitheitheravinyleraserorpulverisedvinyl.Wherenecessary,sheetswerestabilisedandtearsmendedwitharchivaltape.
The very process of restoring and preserving the pages of the register involved thedeconstruction of this object, and with that, the potential loss of some of the information that couldbereadfromitasanartefactofmaterialculture,wherethisrelatestoitsconditionpriortotreatment.Butthereisnodoubtthatinordertoaccesstheimportantwritteninformationthat the document contained—inaccessible in its present state—the conservation processandtheconsequentre-formationoftheregisterwascompletelynecessary.Eachpage,andwhere necessary both sides, was photographed after cleaning, so that eventually registerpage information can be accessed as high quality images on CD. The register itself wasphotographedatvariousstagesofwork-in-progresssothatarecordremainsoftheregisterinitsoriginalcondition.
Research Reports �0�
Figure 5.SheetsfromtheOrchestralLedgerafterconservationtreatment.
Working from both the original pages and from photographic images, I am currentlyentering data into an Excel worksheet under the column headings detailed above in Figure 3. The ultimate aim is to make the completed photographic record and searchable databaseaccessibleforresearch.Todate,pagenumber,work,composerandthenumberofborrowersrecorded on 475 pages has already been processed. The complete list of all loan and return information for each page will take much longer to enter, as many works were heavilyborrowed. Figure 6 provides an example of the borrowing record for one popular orchestral work,Sibelius’sValse Triste, first borrowed in 1910 and last borrowed in 1951.
Among major borrowers were the ABC orchestras, the Melbourne University Conserva-toriumorchestras,andteachersfromtheConservatorium.MusicwasalsolenttotheMarshall-Hall Conservatorium,Albert Street Conservatorium (Melba Conservatorium), the NewConservatorium(Melbourne),theElderConservatoriumofMusic(Adelaide)andtheNSWStateConservatoriumofMusic(Sydney).MusicwassentinterstatetoorchestrasinAdelaide,Toowoomba, Brisbane, Newcastle, Hobart, Launceston, Sydney, Canberra and Perth, andwithinVictoriatoBendigo,Geelong,Warrnambool,YallournandBallarat.MelbournesuburbanorchestrasincludedthosefromKew,Williamstown,Heidelberg,Malvern,SouthMelbourne,Ivanhoe andAlphington, to the South Suburban Orchestral Society, Zelman MemorialOrchestra,andtheorchestrasoftheMusicians’Union,theVictorianRailwaysInstitute,theVictorianProfessionalOrchestraandanumberoftheatreorchestras.OnoccasionmusicwassentbyseatoNewZealand.
It is obvious from this list alone that there is enormous potential for research projects into many aspects of the musical fabric of early twentieth-centuryAustralia, particularlyinMelbourne.Theresearchoutcomesbasedon the informationultimatelyavailableviaasearchable database and the photographic images promises to be both fascinating and extremely wide-ranginginscope.AcomparativestudyofMelbournesuburbanorchestraswouldseemtobe one possible starting point. While the Zelman Memorial Orchestra has been the subject of abook,3andtheWilliamstownSymphonyOrchestrareceivesabriefmentioninaworkabout
3DonFairweather,Your Friend, Alberto Zelman: The Story of Alberto Zelman and the Zelman Memorial Symphony Orchestra (Melbourne: The Orchestra, 1984).
�02 Context 29 & 30 (2005)
Alla
n &
Co.
Mr.
Chu
rch
13/0
3/19
1012
/01/
1911
Hei
nick
e O
rche
stra
Ade
laid
e6/
02/1
913
7/07
/191
3M
usic
ians
’ Uni
on6/
02/1
913
7/07
/191
3M
rG
.B
riglia
Mel
bour
neG
. Brig
lia31
/03/
1917
1/11
/191
7M
rB
eauc
ham
pJa
s. M
artin
s18
/11/
1918
4/12
/191
8M
rH
esel
ovM
r. W
. R. B
owm
an21
/02/
1919
2/06
/191
9M
rC
has
Man
byM
elbo
urne
3/04
/192
26/
06/1
922
Uni
vers
ity H
igh
Sch
ool
Mel
bour
ne12
/03/
1923
3/08
/192
3Y.
M.C
.A.
Ben
digo
post
7/09
/192
31/
11/1
923
Mis
sJo
anW
ebb
23/0
3/19
249/
02/1
924
Y.M
.C.A
.B
endi
go18
/10/
1924
28/0
2/19
25C
onve
nt o
f Mer
cyF
itzro
y23
/11/
1925
27/1
1/19
25A
udito
rium
Ele
ctric
The
atre
Com
pany
not
cal
led
for
27/0
7/19
2627
/07/
1926
New
cast
le S
ymph
ony
Orc
hest
ra1/
10/1
926
28/0
2/19
27M
rw
.La
mbl
e17
/06/
1927
5/07
/192
7M
iss
Nug
ent
Atk
inso
n sn
. Oak
leig
h (M
rs?)
22/0
3/19
2820
/04/
1928
Con
vent
of M
ercy
Fitz
roy
for
Mis
s Li
neha
m17
/08/
1928
7/12
/192
8M
iss
Nug
ent
???
5/04
/192
98/
04/1
929
Mel
bour
ne S
ymph
ony
Orc
hest
ra15
/02/
1930
28/0
2/19
30V
icto
rian
Pro
fess
iona
l Orc
hest
raM
r. B
riglia
3/04
/193
07/
04/1
930
A.B
.C.
Mr.
P. C
ode
4/03
/193
120
/03/
1931
Laun
cest
on C
once
rt O
rche
stra
Laun
cest
onP
ost t
o M
r. A
.E. F
rost
9/04
/193
118
/08/
1931
A.B
.C.
Mr.
Fra
illon
26/0
1/19
321/
03/1
932
A.B
.C. (
Chi
ldre
ns c
once
rt)
Syd
ney
E. C
happ
le (
rail)
18/0
7/19
355/
08/1
935
Aun
read
able
self
27/0
3/19
3623
/05/
1936
Met
hodi
st L
adie
s’ C
olle
geC
. Zie
bell
4/06
/193
610
/06/
1936
A.B
.C.
Mel
bour
neM
r. B
raid
24/0
6/19
37H
eide
lber
g S
ymph
ony
Orc
hest
raH
eide
lber
gM
r. W
ilkie
21/0
7/19
3823
/01/
1939
Alb
ert S
t Con
serv
ator
ium
Eas
t Mel
bour
ne E
. Sto
ck31
/01/
1940
2/05
/194
0A
lber
t St C
onse
rvat
oriu
mE
ast M
elbo
urne
Mr.
Cra
wfo
rd16
/11/
1943
10/1
2/19
43M
rS
hugg
??
Mr
Leo
Col
lins
(Arm
y)
calle
d fo
r30
/08/
1944
5/10
/194
4M
rH
ecto
rC
raw
ford
T. W
right
21/1
1/19
4411
/12/
1944
Mr
G.
Logi
e S
mith
[Hei
delb
erg
Sym
ph]
post
20/0
5/19
474/
02/1
948
Juni
or S
ymph
ony
Orc
hest
rapo
st14
/02/
1948
19/1
2/19
49B
alla
rat E
ast
Bal
lara
tM
r. F
iddi
an27
/02/
1951
3/11
/195
2
Figure 6.OrchestralLedger,page3�8,Valse Triste—Sibelius.
Research Reports �03
thesuburb,4nocomparativestudyhasbeendoneofamateurorchestralplayinginMelbourne.Someofthequestionsthatcouldbeaddressedmightinclude:
• WhendidorganisedamateurorchestralplayingemergeinMelbourne?• Whatweretheprecipitatingfactors?• Whatfactorscontributedtothesuccess(orlackofsuccess)oftheorchestras?• Whoweretheconductorsandwhatwastheirmusical/socialbackground?• Whatfactorscontributedtothecollapseofsomeoftheorchestras?• Whatfactorscontributedtothelong-termsurvivalofsomeoftheseorchestras(suchas
theZelmanMemorialOrchestra,MalvernSymphonyandHeidelbergSymphony)?• Whatwastheinteraction/interfacebetweenprofessional/amateurmusicians?
Amongthesuburbanamateurorchestras,theWilliamstownOrchestralSocietywasoneof the most prolific and regular borrowers. Also recorded in the register as the Williamstown Symphony Orchestra, it came into existence about 1924.5ItwasconductedbyChristianJohnLauer(�897–�97�),residentinWilliamstownformostofhislife.6Lauerwasanaccountantbyprofession,7andhadbeenastudentofAlbertParkes(bornin�868)forbothviolinandviola.Parkeswasasuccessfulandverybusyteacherandviolinist,andfatherofCecilParkes,billedwhenyoungasMelbourne’schild-prodigyviolinist.Byallaccounts,oneofthereasonsforthesuccessoftheWilliamstownorchestrawasthecohesionofthestringsection,mostofwhomwerestudentsofAlbertParkes.8Perhaps,also,Lauer’sactiveinvolvementwithinthelocalcommunityplayedapart.9
OnerathercharmingcharacteristicofLauerwashisunfailinghabitofarrivinginpersonatthemusiclibrarytocollecttheorchestralscoresandparts.�0Onecanimaginehimtakingthetram from his city office down Elizabeth Street to the Conservatorium during his lunch time, ormakinghiswaythereafteradayatwork.Theorchestra’srelativesuccessmayhavehadsomethingtodowiththeconcertprogrammes,whichwerealwaysofitemsfromthe‘mostborrowed’list.Anotherpossiblereasonfortheorchestra’ssuccesswasthelong-standingParkesfamilyconnection,withAlbertParkesasteacherofmanymembers,KinsgleyParkesasorchestralleaderandCecilParkesassoloistwiththeorchestraonmanyoccasions.Perhapsahighlightofthe orchestra’s history was the performance in 1934 of the MessiahintheWilliamstownTownHall.Pressreviewsreportthat�,200peopleattendedtheperformance,whichwasorganisedbyLaueraspartofthe‘BacktoWilliamstown’celebrationsofthatyear.��
4SeeGregorMcShane,Prodigy: Cecil Parkes, Melbourne’s Violin Virtuoso (Auckland:BrickRow,�99�).5‘OrchestraEmerging:Williamstown’sInterestingBody,’Australian Musical News�6(July�927):�8.6 Biographical dates in this report are drawn from the following sources: ‘Digger Federation Index: Victoria, 1889–1901’ and ‘Digger Death Index: Victoria, 1921–1985,’ State Library of Victoria (CDRom), ‘Cemetery Index’ State Library of Victoria, and the website of the National Archive of Australia, <http://www.naa.gov.au>.7Sands & McDougall’s Melbourne & Suburban Directory(Melbourne:SandsandMcDougall,variousyears).8‘OrchestraEmerging,’�8.9 Lauer was the Honorary Organiser of the ‘Back to Williamstown Celebrations’ in 1934 (Williamstown Courier, 6 October 1934: 5), and was president of the Williamstown Lawn Tennis Association, 1932–1937 (Williamstown Advertiser, 25 June 1932,6March�937).�0Lauer’sandtheWilliamstownorchestra’sborrowingsintheorchestralregisteralwaysindicate‘self’inthe‘Forwardedper’column.��‘TheMessiah,’Williamstown Courier, 24 November 1934: 1.
104 Context 29 & 30 (2005)
AcomparisonwiththeMalvernSymphonyOrchestrawouldbeenlightening,asitwasformedat roughly the same timeas theWilliamstownorchestra,was similarly successful(ifnotmoreso),andthepersonnelofthestringsectionwere, inthemain,studentsoftheconductor,WilliamMallinson.Areadingofcontemporaryreportsandreviewsoftheseamateurorchestraspointstotheirroleasafertilegroundforthedevelopmentofplayersontheirwaytowards a professional career as orchestral players. It also indicates a lively mix of amateur andprofessionalorsemi-professionalplayerswithintheranksofthesuburbanorchestras.
SuspectingthattheremightbeaninterestingItalianlinkwiththeUniversity,Iselectedthenamesof ‘A.DiGilio’and‘G.Briglia’ formoredetailedresearch.Bothwereviolinistsand conductors, and with their stories, a fascinating chapter in Melbourne’s musical andimmigration history emerged. August Di Gilio (1897–1950) was listed as a borrower, sometimes withnootherdetails.By�930,hisnamewaslistedagainstKewSymphonyOrchestra.Thename of Guiseppe Briglia (1878–1960) first appeared in 1915 as a borrower, but by 1930 the name‘Briglia’wasassociatedwiththeVictorianProfessionalOrchestra.ThiscouldpossiblyhavebeenCarloBriglia,sonofGiuseppe.
BoththeBrigliaandDiGiliofamilieswerepartoftheItaliansettlementofCarltoninthe�880sand�890s,Brigliaarrivingwithhisfamilyin�900andDiGiliobeingborninCarltonin�897.ManyofCarlton’sItalianimmigrantsweremusiciansfromthevillagesofMariscovetereand Viggiano in the Basilicata region of southern Italy. These villages were noted in theperiod 1860 to 1880 for the migration of musicians—largely violinists and harpists—to major urbancentresoftheworldtoperformasitinerantstreetmusicians.Thisinvolvedakindofcontractingsystemforchildmusicians,whowereapprenticedorindenturedtoapadrone,ormaster, by parents, and the plight of these child street musicians became a major topic in both theFrench,ItalianandAmericanpressinthe�860sand�870s.�2TwodocumentedpadronioftheperiodinbothFranceandAmericawereAgostinoDiGiliaandAntonioBriglia,bothfromMariscovetere.BrigliaappearedtohavebeenparticularlynotoriousandhisactivitiesarewelldocumentedintheAmericannewspapers,ofteninaparticularlysensationalistmanner(seeFigure7).�3TheNew York TimesreportedthatoneofthetwolittlegirlswhowerebroughttoAmericabyBrigliafromCalabriawas:
compelledbyBrigliatoplaytheviolinalldayinthestreets,andtogivehimallthemoneysheearned;thatheallowedhertoeatonlyonceaday,givingherthenonlybread,andnotenoughofit;healsocompelledthemtoundressandsleepinthesameroomwithhimself.14
In Melbourne a decade later, police reports expressed concern about the number of young Italianchildmusiciansonthestreetswhoseparentsorguardians‘refusedtogiveanyparticularsregardingthemselvesortheiroffspring.’15
�2JohnE.Zucchi,The Little Slaves of the Harp: Italian Child Street Musicians in Nineteenth-century Paris, London and New York(Montreal:McGill–Queen’sUP,�992).�3 See, for example, ‘Child Slavery: A Brutal Italian Task-master Brought to Grief—Parents Selling their Children—anItalianFagin,’Daily Evening Bulletin,30July�873;‘ThePadroneSystem,’ Chicago Tribune,28February�886:9;‘ThePadroneSystemFlourishesinChicago’sItalianSection,’Owyhee Avalanche,2�January�898.14‘Briglia:ThePadrone,’New York Times, 14 July 1878: 12.15PolicereportbyConstableRobertWardley,‘RelativetoItalianBoysSingingandPerformingintheStreets,’No.�Division,RussellStreetStation,Melbourne,�7August�888,reproducedin[‘FromOurArchives’]‘ItalianBoysBuskingintheStreets—�888,’Italian Historical Society Journal��.�(January/June2003):32.
Research Reports 105
TheabsorbingworkofJohnZucchionitinerantItalianmusiciansinLondon,ParisandNew York suggests strongly that an exploration of the same themes in the Australian context wouldbeworthwhile.�6Itismyintentiontofurtherpursuethisaspectofyoungmusiciansperforming in the streets of Melbourne. Preliminary exploration raises further questions about thecircumstancesofthesettlementofmusiciansfromtheBasilicataregioninCarltonaroundtheturnofthecentury.
The exceptional talent of August Di Gilio (see Figure 8) on both violin and flute was recognisedearlyinMelbourne.HewonanumberofprizesattheSouthStreetEisteddfod
�6Zucchi,Little Slaves of the Harp.
Figure 7. ‘ThePadroneSystem,’ Owyhee Avalanche,2�January�898.
�06 Context 29 & 30 (2005)
(Ballarat),�7gainedadiplomafromtheUniversityofMelbournein�922,�8andbecameahighlyrespectedteacherandviolinist,�9bothwithintheItalianandinthebroadermusicalcommunityofMelbourne.GiuseppeBrigliawasalsohugelyactivewithintheItaliancommunity,andwidelyrespected,bothforhispersonalandhismusicalqualities.HissonCarlo,alsoaviolinist,continuedthetraditionofaddingtotherichnessofmusicallifeinMelbourne.
Among borrowers who appeared at first sight to be unaffiliated with either the University or a suburban orchestra, Charles Manby (1870–1944) was certainly one of the more interesting (seeFigure9).Englishborn,ManbywasateacherattheConservatoriumfrom�903to�907andagainfrom�930to�939.20Heappearstohavehadanacrimoniousrelationshipwithuniversityauthorities,andwasnothingifnottactlesswithhisopinionsinprint.Manby’smainclaimto
�7‘BallaratCompetitions,’Australian Musical News 2.5 (1912): 124.�8 University of Melbourne: The University Conservatorium of Music—Prospectus, 1926 (Melbourne: TheUniversity,�926).�9AngeloCandelaandRomildaLauricella,transcriptionof‘InterviewwithAngeloCandela’(Melbourne,1985), Monash University Collection.20Peter J.Tregear, The Conservatorium of Music University of Melbourne: An Historical Essay to Mark Its Centenary, 1895–1995 (Parkville:CentreforStudiesinAustralianMusic,�997).
Figure 8. AugustDiGilio,portraitintheAustralian Musical News,January�926,page�9.
Research Reports �07
Figure 9.CharlesManby,portraitinthe Australian Musical News, �9�8,page30.
fame was the invention of a fretted ‘resonant hollow stopped [H.S.] fingerboard’ for which he registeredthreepatentsonthreecontinents.2� The fretted fingerboard was cause for much of thecontroversyamonghiscolleagues,andwiththeuniversityauthoritiesinthe�920s.22
Manby’s new fingerboard was not only fretted (see Figure 10), but was also colour coded (seeFigure��),andrelateddirectlytothepublicationofhisSérénade Italienne,whichappeared
2�CharlesManby,‘AnImprovedFingerboardforViolinsorLikeStringInstruments,’GreatBritain:Patentno. 7732, 1912; ‘Finger-Board for Violins or Like String Instruments,’ United States: 1914, ‘Improvements in and Relating to the Fingerboards of Violins, and Like Stringed Instruments,’ Australia, 1924.22Seevariousarticlesthroughout�922,inparticular:‘TheManbyPositiveSystem:SomePointedCriticismbyS.GibsonandtheAnswerbyC.Manby,’Australian Musical News 11 (1922): 373–75; C. Manby, ‘Violin MethodCriticised:FactsofInterestandValuetoViolinStudentsBroughtoutbytheControversy,’Australian Musical News�2(�922):��6; ‘ViolinMethodControversy:TheEditor’sJudgement,’Australian Musical News 12 (1922): 153–55.
�08 Context 29 & 30 (2005)
in�9��,withpositionsmarkedandprintedincolours(seeFigure�2).23AcopyofthisworkisheldintheLouiseHanson-DyerMusicLibrary,raremusiccollection.ItbearsannotationsinManby’sownhand.Preliminary findings indicate that Charles Manby was an important figure in music pedagogy in Australia, specifically in violin teaching. His contribution to the field of music education was significant and has not as yet received the attention it deserves.
The 1910 orchestral register is, indeed, a most exciting document. It promises to be a fertile sourceforinformationaboutandresearchintomanyaspectsofAustralianmusicperformanceand reception in the first half of the twentieth century. Early indications suggest thatinformationintheregisterwilladdmateriallytoanewassessmentoftheroleoftheUniversityConservatoriumofMusicwithinthemusicallifeofMelbourne.Awebofconnectionbeginstoemerge,placingtheConservatoriumlibraryatthecentreofavitalandenergeticmusicallifeoutsidetheuniversity,aswellaswithinthewallsofacademia.TheLibraryappearstohavebeenanimportantsourceofmusicforbothamateurorchestrasandprofessionalmusicians,bothfromaneducatedBritishorGermantradition,andfromtheItaliancommunity,whowereprofessionalmusiciansalthoughmanyofthemlackedaformalmusiceducation.ThestoryoffamiliessuchastheDiGiliosandtheBrigliasshowsalsothegradualengagementofayoungergenerationwithformalmusicaleducationandwithmusicalemploymentacrossawidespectrumoftraditionsandgenres.Theorchestralregisteritselfmayyetprovetobeaninvaluabledocumentinitsownright.
23Manby sent a copy of his new work to the Federal Government Copyright Office on 25 August 1911, andcopyrightwasregisteredasof��Septemberthatyear.NationalArchivesofAustralia,seriesaccessionnumberA�336/�(literarycopyrightno.2068).
Figure 10. The fingerboard from a Manby violin.
Research Reports �09
Figure 11. AManbyviolinintheworkshopofRogerBuckmaster,Melbourne,showingthecolouredandfretted fingerboard (photographed with permission of Roger Buckmaster).