r. testi piaggio & c. spa – italy () · dynamic simulation in vehicle enginering - may 20 -...

26
Dynamic Simulation in Vehicle Enginering - May 20 - 21, 2010 - St. Valentin, Austria Dynamic simulation of a starter support R. Testi Piaggio & C. SpA – Italy (www. piaggio. com) ME

Upload: others

Post on 29-Jun-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: R. Testi Piaggio & C. SpA – Italy () · Dynamic Simulation in Vehicle Enginering - May 20 - 21, 2010 - St. Valentin, Austria Company profile – Piaggio Group A few figures •one

Dynamic Simulation in Vehicle Enginering - May 20 - 21, 2010 - St. Valentin, Austria

Dynamic simulation of a starter support

R. Testi

Piaggio & C. SpA – Italy (www. piaggio. com)

ME

Page 2: R. Testi Piaggio & C. SpA – Italy () · Dynamic Simulation in Vehicle Enginering - May 20 - 21, 2010 - St. Valentin, Austria Company profile – Piaggio Group A few figures •one

Dynamic Simulation in Vehicle Enginering - May 20 - 21, 2010 - St. Valentin, Austria

Presentation outline

• Company profile • Object of the study • Analysis methodology • Results • Synopsis

Page 3: R. Testi Piaggio & C. SpA – Italy () · Dynamic Simulation in Vehicle Enginering - May 20 - 21, 2010 - St. Valentin, Austria Company profile – Piaggio Group A few figures •one

Dynamic Simulation in Vehicle Enginering - May 20 - 21, 2010 - St. Valentin, Austria

Company profile – Piaggio Group

Business areas

2- wheelers

Commercial Vehicles

Engines

Spare parts and accessories

Page 4: R. Testi Piaggio & C. SpA – Italy () · Dynamic Simulation in Vehicle Enginering - May 20 - 21, 2010 - St. Valentin, Austria Company profile – Piaggio Group A few figures •one

Dynamic Simulation in Vehicle Enginering - May 20 - 21, 2010 - St. Valentin, Austria

Company profile – Piaggio Group

Brands managed

Page 5: R. Testi Piaggio & C. SpA – Italy () · Dynamic Simulation in Vehicle Enginering - May 20 - 21, 2010 - St. Valentin, Austria Company profile – Piaggio Group A few figures •one

Dynamic Simulation in Vehicle Enginering - May 20 - 21, 2010 - St. Valentin, Austria

Company profile – Piaggio Group

A few figures

• one of the world’s 4 top manufacturers of two- wheel motor vehicles

• consolidated leadership position on the European 2- wheeler market

• over 7, 000 employees • facilities: Pontedera (Pisa- Italy); Scorzè (Venice- Italy);

Mandello del Lario (Lecco- Italy); Barcelona (Spain); Baramati (India); Vinh Phuc (Vietnam)

• R&D centres: Italy, Spain, China and India • Joint venture with Zongshen: Foshan (China) • vehicle sold in 2009: 607, 700 • net revenues in 2008: 1 , 486. 9 million Euro

Page 6: R. Testi Piaggio & C. SpA – Italy () · Dynamic Simulation in Vehicle Enginering - May 20 - 21, 2010 - St. Valentin, Austria Company profile – Piaggio Group A few figures •one

Dynamic Simulation in Vehicle Enginering - May 20 - 21, 2010 - St. Valentin, Austria

Presentation outline

• Company profile • Object of the study • Analysis methodology • Results • Synopsis

Page 7: R. Testi Piaggio & C. SpA – Italy () · Dynamic Simulation in Vehicle Enginering - May 20 - 21, 2010 - St. Valentin, Austria Company profile – Piaggio Group A few figures •one

Dynamic Simulation in Vehicle Enginering - May 20 - 21, 2010 - St. Valentin, Austria

Starter support

Object of the study

Small 4- wheeled vehicle Engine

Trouble- shooting activity

Page 8: R. Testi Piaggio & C. SpA – Italy () · Dynamic Simulation in Vehicle Enginering - May 20 - 21, 2010 - St. Valentin, Austria Company profile – Piaggio Group A few figures •one

Dynamic Simulation in Vehicle Enginering - May 20 - 21, 2010 - St. Valentin, Austria

Object of the study

Failure during bench test

CAE simulation

New design

Psysical prototype

Page 9: R. Testi Piaggio & C. SpA – Italy () · Dynamic Simulation in Vehicle Enginering - May 20 - 21, 2010 - St. Valentin, Austria Company profile – Piaggio Group A few figures •one

Dynamic Simulation in Vehicle Enginering - May 20 - 21, 2010 - St. Valentin, Austria

Presentation outline

• Company profile • Object of the study • Analysis methodology • Results • Synopsis

Page 10: R. Testi Piaggio & C. SpA – Italy () · Dynamic Simulation in Vehicle Enginering - May 20 - 21, 2010 - St. Valentin, Austria Company profile – Piaggio Group A few figures •one

Dynamic Simulation in Vehicle Enginering - May 20 - 21, 2010 - St. Valentin, Austria

Analysis methodology

CAD software Geometry

Safety factor Modal content (Craig-Bampton

)

Components’ stiffness evaluation

FEM software FEM software

Multibody software

Modal coordinates

Durability software

Dynamic simulation

Page 11: R. Testi Piaggio & C. SpA – Italy () · Dynamic Simulation in Vehicle Enginering - May 20 - 21, 2010 - St. Valentin, Austria Company profile – Piaggio Group A few figures •one

Dynamic Simulation in Vehicle Enginering - May 20 - 21, 2010 - St. Valentin, Austria

FEM analysis - Components’ stiffness evaluation

Rubber bushings

Bench test

O- ring

Page 12: R. Testi Piaggio & C. SpA – Italy () · Dynamic Simulation in Vehicle Enginering - May 20 - 21, 2010 - St. Valentin, Austria Company profile – Piaggio Group A few figures •one

Dynamic Simulation in Vehicle Enginering - May 20 - 21, 2010 - St. Valentin, Austria

FEM analysis - Components’ stiffness evaluation – O- ring (1 /2)

FEM model

Rigid surfaces

Rigid bodies in FEM model

Undeformed O- ring

O- ring stiffness curve

Preload

Page 13: R. Testi Piaggio & C. SpA – Italy () · Dynamic Simulation in Vehicle Enginering - May 20 - 21, 2010 - St. Valentin, Austria Company profile – Piaggio Group A few figures •one

Dynamic Simulation in Vehicle Enginering - May 20 - 21, 2010 - St. Valentin, Austria

FEM analysis - Components’ stiffness evaluation – O- ring (2/2)

Analysis steps: O- ring preload Radial stiffness evaluation

Page 14: R. Testi Piaggio & C. SpA – Italy () · Dynamic Simulation in Vehicle Enginering - May 20 - 21, 2010 - St. Valentin, Austria Company profile – Piaggio Group A few figures •one

Dynamic Simulation in Vehicle Enginering - May 20 - 21, 2010 - St. Valentin, Austria

FEM analysis - Components’ stiffness evaluation

Rubber bushings

Bench test

O- ring

Page 15: R. Testi Piaggio & C. SpA – Italy () · Dynamic Simulation in Vehicle Enginering - May 20 - 21, 2010 - St. Valentin, Austria Company profile – Piaggio Group A few figures •one

Dynamic Simulation in Vehicle Enginering - May 20 - 21, 2010 - St. Valentin, Austria

FEM analysis - Components’ stiffness evaluation - Bushings

Bench test

FEM model

Dummy linear material Dummy Young’s modulus

Page 16: R. Testi Piaggio & C. SpA – Italy () · Dynamic Simulation in Vehicle Enginering - May 20 - 21, 2010 - St. Valentin, Austria Company profile – Piaggio Group A few figures •one

Dynamic Simulation in Vehicle Enginering - May 20 - 21, 2010 - St. Valentin, Austria

Analysis methodology

CAD software Geometry

Safety factor Modal content (Craig-Bampton

)

Components’ stiffness evaluation

FEM software FEM software

Multibody software

Modal coordinates

Durability software

Dynamic simulation

Page 17: R. Testi Piaggio & C. SpA – Italy () · Dynamic Simulation in Vehicle Enginering - May 20 - 21, 2010 - St. Valentin, Austria Company profile – Piaggio Group A few figures •one

Dynamic Simulation in Vehicle Enginering - May 20 - 21, 2010 - St. Valentin, Austria

FEM analysis – Modal content evaluation

Bench test Flex bodies in dynamic model Support system

Test rig

Bushing material from component’s simulation

Page 18: R. Testi Piaggio & C. SpA – Italy () · Dynamic Simulation in Vehicle Enginering - May 20 - 21, 2010 - St. Valentin, Austria Company profile – Piaggio Group A few figures •one

Dynamic Simulation in Vehicle Enginering - May 20 - 21, 2010 - St. Valentin, Austria

Analysis methodology

CAD software Geometry

Safety factor Modal content (Craig-Bampton

)

Components’ stiffness evaluation

FEM software FEM software

Multibody software

Modal coordinates

Durability software

Dynamic simulation

Page 19: R. Testi Piaggio & C. SpA – Italy () · Dynamic Simulation in Vehicle Enginering - May 20 - 21, 2010 - St. Valentin, Austria Company profile – Piaggio Group A few figures •one

Dynamic Simulation in Vehicle Enginering - May 20 - 21, 2010 - St. Valentin, Austria

MBS analysis – Modal coordinates evaluation (1 /2)

MBS model

Flex bodies

Gas forces

Page 20: R. Testi Piaggio & C. SpA – Italy () · Dynamic Simulation in Vehicle Enginering - May 20 - 21, 2010 - St. Valentin, Austria Company profile – Piaggio Group A few figures •one

Dynamic Simulation in Vehicle Enginering - May 20 - 21, 2010 - St. Valentin, Austria

MBS analysis – Modal coordinates evaluation (1 /2)

MBS model

Test rig actuator

Constant angular velocity actuation

Localized strain field

Partial crankcase meshing justified

Max torque Max power Max speed

Page 21: R. Testi Piaggio & C. SpA – Italy () · Dynamic Simulation in Vehicle Enginering - May 20 - 21, 2010 - St. Valentin, Austria Company profile – Piaggio Group A few figures •one

Dynamic Simulation in Vehicle Enginering - May 20 - 21, 2010 - St. Valentin, Austria

Presentation outline

• Company profile • Object of the study • Analysis methodology • Results • Synopsis

Page 22: R. Testi Piaggio & C. SpA – Italy () · Dynamic Simulation in Vehicle Enginering - May 20 - 21, 2010 - St. Valentin, Austria Company profile – Piaggio Group A few figures •one

Dynamic Simulation in Vehicle Enginering - May 20 - 21, 2010 - St. Valentin, Austria

Analysis methodology

CAD software Geometry

Safety factor Modal content (Craig-Bampton

)

Components’ stiffness evaluation

FEM software FEM software

Multibody software

Modal coordinates

Durability software

Dynamic simulation

Page 23: R. Testi Piaggio & C. SpA – Italy () · Dynamic Simulation in Vehicle Enginering - May 20 - 21, 2010 - St. Valentin, Austria Company profile – Piaggio Group A few figures •one

Dynamic Simulation in Vehicle Enginering - May 20 - 21, 2010 - St. Valentin, Austria

Durability analysis

Chosen options Uniform Material Law for fatigue properties Critical plane for multiaxial stress states reduction Relative stress gradient effect taken into account

Safety factor distribution

Critical regions

Good agreement between simulation and

experimental evidence

CAE procedure used to assess a new support

configuration behaviour

Page 24: R. Testi Piaggio & C. SpA – Italy () · Dynamic Simulation in Vehicle Enginering - May 20 - 21, 2010 - St. Valentin, Austria Company profile – Piaggio Group A few figures •one

Dynamic Simulation in Vehicle Enginering - May 20 - 21, 2010 - St. Valentin, Austria

New support configuration

Submitted to the same CAE procedure

Page 25: R. Testi Piaggio & C. SpA – Italy () · Dynamic Simulation in Vehicle Enginering - May 20 - 21, 2010 - St. Valentin, Austria Company profile – Piaggio Group A few figures •one

Dynamic Simulation in Vehicle Enginering - May 20 - 21, 2010 - St. Valentin, Austria

Durability analysis on new configuration

Safety factor distribution

Min value from < 1 to 1 . 9 New configuration

brought to test bench

No failures

Old New

Page 26: R. Testi Piaggio & C. SpA – Italy () · Dynamic Simulation in Vehicle Enginering - May 20 - 21, 2010 - St. Valentin, Austria Company profile – Piaggio Group A few figures •one

Dynamic Simulation in Vehicle Enginering - May 20 - 21, 2010 - St. Valentin, Austria

Main output

Fatigue performance

Synopsis New engine Bench test

failure CAE

troubleshooting

CAE procedure proved to be reliable

Dynamic analysis needed to evalute stress tensor time- history

New design soundness proved by simulation

Thank you for your patience!

No failure of new design after bench

test