questions for discussion · 6/26/2012 · intro: a lot of people are talking about the future of...
TRANSCRIPT
Questions for discussion
Old news 1. What part have newspapers played in history? 2. Why is running a newspaper expensive? 3. How do newspapers make money? 4. What are some benefits of newspapers over radio or TV news bulletins? 5. How has the internet changed the way we get news? 6. What has Fairfax Media announced recently? 7. Why are some people concerned about how journalism will be affected? 8. What do you think the future of newspapers is? Explain your answer. 9. Do you think people will want to pay for online news? Why of why not? 10. What do you understand more clearly since watching the BtN story?
Post a message on the Behind the News Guestbook http://www.abc.net.au/btn/
Rhino trade 1. Explain what is meant by the following statement: `The rhinos horn may be
their main weapon, but it’s also their biggest threat.’ 2. How much per kilogram can rhino horn be worth on the black market? 3. What is rhino horn used for? 4. What is a poacher? 5. Why have some conservationists been cutting the horns off rhinos? 6. What does the wildlife vet compare dehorning rhinos to? 7. What are rhino horns made of? 8. Why do some people want the legalisation of the rhino horn trade? 9. Do you think rhinos should be dehorned? Explain your answer. 10. What are some other solutions to the problem? Post your ideas on the BtN
Guestbook.
Find five interesting facts about rhinos and draw an illustration for one of the facts.
Soft drinks
1. Discuss the Soft drinks story with another student. 2. Why is the mayor of New York City concerned about obesity? 3. In your own words, describe what he plans to do. 4. What has happened to the size of soft drinks over the years? 5. The super size ban would also affect diet soft drinks. True or false? 6. Apart from soft drinks, what other drinks would be affected? 7. Why are some people opposed to the ban? 8. Some drinks that can contain large amounts of sugar are not included in the
plan. What are they? 9. Do you think super size soft drinks should be banned? Explain your answer. 10. What else could be done to address the obesity problem?
EPISODE 18
26TH
JUNE 2012
` Should super size soft drinks be banned?’ Vote in the BtN online poll
http://www.abc.net.au/btn/
Modern maps
1. Briefly summarise the Modern maps story. 2. What part have maps played over the years? 3. The art and science of making maps is called
a. Topography b. Cartography c. Orienteering
4. How were maps made many years ago? 5. How has technology changed map making? 6. Global Positioning System is also known as… 7. People learning map making today do far more than make maps. What else
do they learn? 8. What sorts of unusual places are being mapped? 9. What do you think the future of maps is? 10. What was surprising about this story?
People use maps to locate reference points. Give some examples of reference points on maps.
Weird water 1. What was the main point of the story? 2. What is the chemical formula for water? 3. Why is water described as `sticky’? 4. Water is the only substance on earth that occurs naturally as a solid, liquid
and gas. True or false? 5. What happens to the water molecules as they go from a solid to a liquid to a
gas? 6. Why do we need water to survive? 7. The human body is around ___________ per cent water. 8. Water covers almost three quarters of the Earth’s surface, so why is it so
important to save it? 9. Give your own reasons why we need to conserve water. 10. Illustrate an aspect of the BtN story.
Find out some interesting facts about water by doing the water quiz http://www.abc.net.au/water/fun/
Rhino trade
Focus Questions
1. Explain what is meant by the following statement: `The rhinos horn may be their main weapon, but it’s also their biggest threat.’
2. How much per kilogram can rhino horn be worth on the black market? 3. What is rhino horn used for? 4. What is a poacher? 5. Why have some conservationists been cutting the horns off rhinos? 6. What does the wildlife vet compare dehorning rhinos to? 7. What are rhino horns made of? 8. Why do some people want the legalisation of the rhino horn trade? 9. Do you think rhinos should be dehorned? Explain your answer. 10. What are some other solutions to the problem? Post your ideas on the BtN
Guestbook.
Rhino trade
Negotiate with students how many activities they will need to complete from each section.
Remember and understand
Find five interesting facts about rhinos and draw an illustration for one of
the facts.
The following words relate to the rhinoceros. What does each word mean?
pachyderm
endangered
herbivore
extinction
poach
Show on a map where rhinos are located in the world.
Find out more about a rhinos eyesight, hearing and sense of smell. Write a
brief description of each.
Apply and Analyse
Rhinoceros’ horns are made of keratin fibres – the same material found in hair, fingernails and scales. What do you think the functions of the horn are?
What are some of the special adaptations that the rhino has to help it survive in its environment? (Include information about a rhino’s horn, skin, feet, ears, nose and lip.)
EPISODE 18
26TH
JUNE 2012
Learning Area
Society and Environment
Key learning
Students will research the issue of dehorning rhinos as a way to help protect the species.
What other animals are poached for a valuable body part? How has the problem been addressed and could the same approach be taken with the rhinos?
Evaluate and create
Do you think the idea to dehorn rhinos to reduce the number of poachers killing the animals would work? Are there any other solutions to the problem? Explain your answer to a group of students in your class.
How many species of rhinos are there and which ones are endangered? Create a creature feature about a species of rhino. Include general information, behaviour, habitat, number in the wild and in captivity.
Find out the similarities and differences between black and white rhinos. Make a Venn diagram (two overlapping circles) to compare and contrast the two species’.
Related Research Links
ABC 730 - Scientists call for legal rhino horn trade http://www.abc.net.au/7.30/content/2012/s3524580.htm Behind the News – Rhino rap http://www.abc.net.au/btn/story/s2750870.htm UN Works – Endangered species: Rhinoceros
http://www.un.org/works/OLD/environment/animalplanet/rhino.html
Rhino Resource Centre – Rhino species
http://www.rhinoresourcecenter.com/species/
Slimming soft drinks Focus Questions
1. Discuss the Slimming soft drinks story with another student. 2. Why is the mayor of New York City concerned about obesity? 3. In your own words, describe what he plans to do. 4. What has happened to the size of soft drinks over the years? 5. The super-size ban would also affect diet soft drinks. True or false? 6. Apart from soft drinks, what other drinks would be affected? 7. Why are some people opposed to the ban? 8. Some drinks that can contain large amounts of sugar are not included in the
plan. What are they? 9. Do you think super size soft drinks should be banned? Explain your answer. 10. What else could be done to address the obesity problem?
Slimming soft drinks
Ask students to brainstorm a list of food and drinks they consume that contain sugar. Which is the most common food and drink on the list? Discuss with students what the nutritional value of soft drinks is. What is meant by the term `empty calories’? How does it relate to soft drinks? Students will be analysing a selection of drinks and calculating how many teaspoons of sugar are in each drink. They will then use the information to create a public education campaign to make people more aware about the sugar content in some drinks. Sometimes sugar is called something else on the nutrition information on food and drink packaging. Students research what some other words for sugar are. (Fructose, dextrose, sucrose, maltose, corn syrup, honey, glucose, molasses) Use the nutritional information on drink labels to convert sugar content from grams to teaspoons; 1 teaspoon = 4 grams. Choose four types of drinks
Soft drink
Juice
Flavoured milk
Other (iced tea, energy drink etc) Record the: Serving size Sugar (grams) Energy (kilojoules) What did they find surprising about the results? Students can share their findings
in the form of a public education campaign.
EPISODE 18
26TH
JUNE 2012
Learning Area
Health and Physical Education
Key learning
Students will create a public education campaign to raise awareness of the sugar content in some drinks.
Discuss with students different approaches that could be taken about the issue.
Here are some examples:
Create a cartoon/animation, using celebrities or humour to get the
message across or shock tactics.
Include a logo, jingle or gimmick to help get the message across.
Students share their public education campaigns with other students in the school.
Related Research Links
ABC Lateline – NYC closer to banning supersize soft drinks
http://www.abc.net.au/lateline/content/2012/s3524654.htm
Better Health Channel – Sugar
http://www.betterhealth.vic.gov.au/bhcv2/bhcarticles.nsf/pages/Sugar
BtN: Episode 18 Transcript
26/6/12
On this week's Behind the News
We look at an unusual solution to stop poachers killing rhinos.
Why super size soft drinks are being targeted in the fight
against obesity.
And we look at the future of map making as technology takes
over.
Hi I'm Nathan Bazley, welcome to Behind the News. Also on the show
today a group of scientists turn to rock music to teach kids about
water. But before all that.
Old News
Reporter: Sarah Larsen
INTRO: A lot of people are talking about the future of newspapers.
It's been a lot harder for newspapers to make money in recent years
mainly because people can now get their news online for free. Last
week two of Australia's biggest media companies announced some
big changes. Sarah takes a look at that announcement and what it
could mean for the future of newspapers.
PAPER BOY: Extra! Extra! Read all about it!
SARAH LARSEN, REPORTER: Before there was Twitter and 24 hour news there was this.
The morning and evening papers set the news agenda and broke the stories that changed history.
It took a lot of people to publish a paper, a lot of time and a lot of money, but they were profitable. People would pay a lot to put an ad in the paper knowing their message would get to thousands.
Over the years newspapers got some competition. First there was radio which could give up to date information as it happened then TV, where you could actually see the news unfold.
But newspapers survived and even today there are plenty of people who like to start the day like this.
REPORTER: The good thing about a newspaper is that you can fit a lot more information here than you can into a radio TV news bulletin. I can take my time, decide what I want to read when I want to read it.
But the internet is changing everything. Now you access information from all over the world whenever you want. You don't have to pay for it and you don't have to wait for it to be delivered. Nowadays when news breaks it usually breaks online and that's where we heard this last week.
GREG HYWOOD, CEO, FAIRFAX MEDIA (Fairfax Digital): The days of the huge printing plants built for our legacy print classified business are well and truly over. There will be redundancies.
That announcement was made by the boss of Fairfax Media, Australia's second biggest newspaper business.
It publishes the Age in Melbourne, the Sydney Morning Herald and the Financial Review.
But lately business hasn't been going so well and Fairfax is making big changes. It's going to close some of its printing presses and send some jobs overseas to save money. 1900 people will lose their jobs.
Australia's biggest news organisation, News Limited, is also making changes.
It's merging newsrooms, cutting jobs and buying online media.
MIKE SMITH, FORMER EDITOR, THE AGE: I think this is the biggest thing in newspapers for a hundred years. This is the end of the golden age of newspapers. The big question though is whether it also means the end of the golden age of journalism
For the moment there aren't any plans to actually close the major newspapers. But some are wondering if these changes are the beginning of the end for newspapers as we know them.
And there are questions about how that will affect journalism; whether reporters will still have the time and money they need for quality reporting.
But the newspaper companies say they're just trying to adapt to a changing world.
They're hoping their online editions will help business grow. But making money online can be more difficult. There's a lot of competition for ad space here.
From next year News Limited will start charging for access to some of its sites and some reckon Fairfax might follow.
They're hoping people will be willing to pay for the newspaper even if it isn't made of paper any more.
But at least for now there are still some who prefer it the old fashioned way.
Presenter: Let's see what else is making the news. Here's Tash with
the Wire.
The Wire
A boat carrying around 200 asylum seekers capsized off Christmas
Island last week. Authorities rescued 110 people, but up to 90 people
are feared dead. The survivors have been taken to the Christmas
Island detention centre.
*****
Egypt has a new President. Mohammed Mursi is the first
democratically elected leader in the country's history. Mr Mursi is
from a group called the Muslim Brotherhood. That group was banned
when Egypt's last president, Hosni Mubarak, was in power. The
current military regime says it will hand over power by the start of
next month.
*****
And WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange is still trying to avoid
extradition to Sweden where he faces criminal charges. He's hiding
out in the Ecuadorian embassy in London. He's asked Ecuador to
grant him political asylum, which would mean he would live there and
not be extradited. Ecuador is considering the request.
Rhino Trade
Reporter: Nathan Bazley
INTRO: You might have heard before that rhinos are often killed for
their horns. The poachers sell the horns for money. Well some
conservationists have come up with an unusual solution to the
problem. But not everyone thinks it's a good idea. Let's see what it is.
NATHAN BAZLEY, REPORTER: They are one animal you certainly
wouldn't want to face off against. With their massive front horn,
rhinoceroses sure look pretty intimidating.
But while it may be their main weapon, it's also their biggest threat.
Because their horn is the main reason many are killed.
They may not look all that valuable, but on the black market, rhino
horn can be worth as much as $60,000 a kilo. It's been used for
thousands of years in some traditional Asian medicines. But
unfortunately, the easiest way for poachers to get it is to kill the
animal. And so far this year, more than 200 have died for this very
reason. That doesn't have to be the case though.
Take a close look at these rhinos and you'll notice something pretty
interesting. They're all hornless and they're all still alive and healthy.
Well this one is about to be pretty sleepy.
This private game farm has had trouble with poachers coming in and
killing rhinos for their horns. So they decided the best way to stop it
was to remove the temptation.
MARTINE VAN ZIJIL LANGHOUT, WILDLIFE VET: Dehorning is
the same as clipping your nail or clipping the hoof of a horse. As long
as you don't go in the tissue, it's not invasive for the animal.
NATHAN: Well okay, they do use a saw instead of clippers, so it's
probably not exactly like clipping your nails. But rhino horns are
made of keratin, which is the same protein that forms our nails and
hair.
Within a few minutes it's all done and they say the animal doesn't feel
it much at all. But this tactic would take a lot of work to carry out in
the wild. So some say the next step would be the legalisation of the
trade of rhino horns, so that proper businesses could be set up to
harvest the horns safely.
The South African Government is looking at how this horn trading
could be made legal, while making sure poachers couldn't profit from
it. One idea so far is to genetically track where every horn comes
from. And if the government make it work, they'll stand to make a lot
of money from it too, because they have a huge stockpile of rhino
horns that they've seized, just sitting around.
But of course, some other conservationists say this isn't the way to go.
KIRSTY BREBNER, ENDANGERED WILDLIFE TRUST: Having seen
it done and just seeing basically the majesty of that animal taken
away, it affected me psychologically, so how does the baby then come
back and see its mum with no horns?
So is this a case of having to be cruel to be kind? Or is there a better
way?
Presenter: Even though they say it's not cruel it doesn't seem ideal. Do
you have a better idea? Let us know on the guestbook on the BtN
website.
Quiz 1
Now we're going to have a story about soft drinks next. But first let's
have a quiz about them.
The question is:
What gas is used to make the bubbles in fizzy drinks?
Carbon dioxide
Nitrous oxide
Helium
Answer: Carbon dioxide
Slimming Soft drinks
Reporter: Nathan Bazley
INTRO: Nitrous Oxide is laughing gas and helium is the light gas
that goes in party balloons. Drinking too many fizzy drinks can be a
big reason for obesity. So much so that over in America the mayor of
New York wants to put a limit on the size of soft drink people can
buy. So how bad can a bit of soft drink actually be? Let's find out.
KID: Hey!
POLICE: I'm with the Soft Drink Police Department. You're busted!
KID: Chill out. It's just soft drink!
Just soft drink?!
NATHAN BAZLEY, REPORTER: Not if you're walking through New
York, where soon enough, soft drink could be a crime.
Welcome to the big apple. A big city of bright lights, screaming at you
to eat, drink and be happy. As you can see, serving sizes here aren't
exactly small. But that's not the only thing that's big in New York.
More than half of the population are overweight and 6000 people a
year die from obesity related illnesses. So the city mayor has decided
to do something about it. He's targeted super sized soft drinks.
MICHAEL BLOOMBERG, NEW YORK MAYOR: Now there are many
factors that contribute to childhood obesity, but the single biggest is
soda.
When McDonalds first opened in the 1950s in the US, you could only
buy a drink that was about 200mls - less than a measuring cup. At the
peak in 2003, the two biggest sizes were 946 millilitres, and a
whopping 1.2 litres! Now the sizes are smaller, but the smallest is still
355 millilitres - almost double what was available in the 50's and it's
called a kids size! It's a pretty common story in other outlets too.
The plan is to limit any soft drink bought from a restaurant, fast food
store, movie theatre or stadium to 473mls. Any bigger would be
against the rules.
NATHAN: That's about this much. But it might surprise you to learn
that in this bottle of soft drink, there would still be roughly 13
teaspoons of sugar! In the US, some restaurants serve drinks three
times the size, which means you'd be looking at about 40 teaspoons of
sugar!
The plan won't affect diet soft drinks, because they don't contain any
sugar. But it will affect some other drinks you might not have thought
of.
THOMAS FARLEY, NYC HEALTH COMMISSIONER: Sport drinks,
energy drinks, sweetened teas and coffees, sweetened fruit drinks, so
called vitamin water.
That's because despite not always tasting as sweet, all of those drinks
can still contain heaps of sugar. Not that many New Yorkers seem to
care all that much.
NEW YORK RESIDENT: My wife, personally she drinks two litres of
soda every day and she's very thin like you.
NEW YORK RESIDENT: I'm gonna do what I want to do, period.
NEW YORK RESIDENT: I don't think that anybody government
official has the right to tell us what to eat or drink.
That's where most of the opposition to this plan comes from. While
others say soft drinks are being unfairly targeted, because in many
cases, orange juice can have almost as much sugar as soft drinks.
Milkshakes can have more, but neither are banned. And on the food
side of things, you'd get more sugar in a chocolate bar or doughnut
than you would in a glass of soft drink.
But it's an interesting debate. What do you think should come first,
health or the freedom to drink up big?
Presenter: OK let's make that our poll this week.
Online Poll
The question is:
Should super size soft drinks be banned? To vote just head to our
website.
Last week we ran the story of the Olympic swimmers who posted a
picture on Facebook of them posing with guns. They were punished.
We asked you if you thought they should have been.
28 per cent thought yes and 72 per cent thought no, they shouldn't
have been punished. Thanks for voting.
Modern Maps
Reporter: Sarah Larsen
INTRO: Helping you to find your way in the world is a competitive
business. Recently Apple announced that it's going to take on Google
Maps and develop its own mapping software. Technology like that is
changing the way we think about maps and it got us wondering how
map making has changed over the years? Here's Sarah.
WIZARD: The hill of doom lies 350 leagues to the east
HOBBIT: Um. I'm pretty sure it's west
WIZARD: No it's east
HOBBIT: The map says west.
HOBBIT: You're reading it upside down
HOBBIT: No I'm not
SARAH LARSEN, REPORTER: If you've got somewhere important to
go a good map is a valuable thing. For millennia maps have shaped
the world as we've known it. Leading the way to treasures, new lands,
and helping us to see our place in the world
The art and science of making maps is called cartography and it's
changed a lot over the years. In the old days maps were drawn by
hand. Cartographers would carefully observe and measure the land
around them, make some calculations, and try to draw what they saw
to scale. Some were pretty accurate like these charts that Captain
Cook made of Australia and New Zealand. But eventually we found
ways of making sure we got it right. Planes could take photos from the
sky and computers meant maps didn't have to be drawn by hand
anymore. Then there were satellites which let you see the earth below
and even find your place on it with the Global Positioning System.
Now finding where you are and where you're going is as simple as
clicking a button.
REPORTER: Image what Captain cook would have thought of Google
Maps! As programs like this get more popular paper maps are getting
less common. But that doesn't mean we don't need map makers
anymore.
MADDIE: You can turn off the vector and we can show the hills, road
and vegetation.
Maddie is learning the skills needed by today's map makers who do
far more than just cartography.
PAUL: Cartography was the science of making maps and these days
we take it far beyond that we make maps we make survey plans we
make 3D images which we draw over digital terrain model so we can
see what the terrain looks like at any point.
While the maps are made on computer programs there are a lot of
skills to learn. They learn how to analyse information from all
different sources and how to take measurements on the ground.
PAUL: This is a total station Sarah it measures distances and
directions to points and that enables us to get the co-ordinates of a
feature that we're going to put on a map.
Those maps are used by all sorts of people from town planners to
mining engineers. There are maps that track water courses and
vegetation, maps used by telecommunications companies and
fisheries. And while all the continents may have been found there are
still explorers of sorts mapping the places that haven't been seen
before. Like the bottom of the ocean or the minerals under the earth.
As long as we have places to go and treasures to find there will always
be a need for maps. There's just less excuse than ever before for losing
your way.
KIDS ARGUING
HOBBIT: Right wait a minute, this thing's got GPS. It's that way.
HOBBIT: Told you it was west
Presenter: OK let's have a quiz about that.
Quiz 2
The question is:
What do contour lines represent on a map?
Boundaries
Elevation
Scale
Answer: Elevation
And that kind of detail on a map is called topography. OK, let's take a
look at some of the big sport stories this week. Tash has the Score.
The Score
Italy is through to the semi-finals of Euro 20-12! In the match against
England, neither team could score during regular time, so it was
decided in a penalty shoot- out. With England missing two shots, Italy
advances to the semi-final to play Germany. Spain will play Portugal
in the other game.
Miami Heat has beaten Oklahoma Thunder, to win its second NBA
championship in six years! The home team won the best-of-seven
series 4 games to 1. Star player Lebron James scored 26 points.
GRAB: These fans - oh my god you guys are unbelievable, and this is a
dream come true.
******
Black Caviar the undefeated Aussie horse has won its first race
overseas. But at Royal Ascot in England it didn't go as well as many
fans would have hoped. Instead of a convincing win, she just scraped
through. The jockey said it was his fault for relaxing at the end but
scans have shown that Black Caviar was suffering from a slight back
injury
Weird Water
Reporter: Sarah Larsen
INTRO: We're always being told to save water. But at home and at
school is that a message you take seriously? One science group is
trying to teach kids to stop wasting water. As Alfie reports they've
made the liquid the star of its own stage show!
ALFIE TIEU, REPORTER: When you think of liquid gold you might
think of this, but many others think of this.
We've all heard the saying, "Water is precious," but do you know why?
BOY: I know that water is wet and everything's slippery when it's
covered in water.
This isn't a lesson in drama. These school kids are getting a science
lesson.
Soaked is a show put on by SA Water
MALE PERFORMER: A scientific rock concert that surfs the waves of
everyone's favourite fluid.
FEMALE PERFORMER: Banana milkshakes!
They reckon water is so awesome they're keen to share some of its
weird secrets. For example, did you know that water is sticky?
FEMALE PERFORMER: Honey is sticky. Water is wet.
MALE PERFORMER: And sticky!
What they're talking about is water molecules, the two Hs and the O
that you might have heard about. They're actually attracted to each
other, so with just a little encouragement drops of water can stick
together. That's why a bottle with two holes can be made to spurt one
stream of water.
Water is also unusual because it's the only substances on earth that
occurs naturally as a solid, liquid and a gas. In a solid, water
molecules don't have very much energy so they kind of just vibrate
around like this. But in a liquid they have more energy so they're able
to move around each other a bit more freely. In a gas, water
molecules go nuts, moving around each other very quickly. And then
there are the really important facts about water, like how we need it to
live.
MALE PERFORMER: Without water, no life!
FEMALE PERFORMER: No life? What, no puppies? No kitties? No
staphylococcus aureus?
MALE PERFORMER: What?
FEMALE PERFORMER: No flesh-eating bacteria?
The human body is around 60 per cent water. Your blood is 92 per
cent water and even your bones are 22 per cent water.
GIRL: Water is like, water is essential to living, it's just the way our
bodies are designed to have to use water, and most of the other things
we drink have in some way come from water. Like with milk, cows
drink water and they produce milk so everything sort of has water in
it.
But water covers almost three quarters of the earth's surface, so why
is it so important to save it?
It's because only a two-and-a-half percent of that water is fit to drink.
MALE PERFORMER: And of that two and a half percent 68.9 percent
is trapped as permanent ice, so in glaciers as permafrost. 30.8
percent is trapped underneath the ground and we can use a bit of
that, but it's mainly this stuff here, water in lakes and rivers.
The kids got thinking about why we need to conserve water.
BOY: It's a resource that can easily go over the years.
BOY: You need to know the scientific side of it. Because imagine if
you didn't know the scientific side of it, it's just like this drink to some
people.
With a bit of music, a bit of science and a lot of laughs, these guys are
helping to inspire the next generation of scientists, while getting kids
to appreciate the stuff that comes out of the tap!
Closer
That's it for the show. You can jump onto our website if you want to
get more info on any of the stories. You can send us your comments
and don't forget to vote in this week's poll. I'll see you next time.