question: answer - le.utah.govle.utah.gov/documents/2011.formallegalopinion.district57.pdf1 this...

30
This formal legal opinion responds to your request for my formal 1 opinion as General Counsel to the Legislature. The question posed and answered by this legal opinion requires an evaluation of the law and a review and determination of certain facts. The conclusion reached in this opinion is based upon that factual review and determination. Michael E. Christensen Director John L. Fellows General Counsel Utah State Capitol Complex House Building, Suite W210 PO Box 145210 Salt Lake City, Utah 84114-5210 Phone (801) 538-1032 Fax (801) 538-1712 www.le.utah.gov FORMAL L EGAL OPINION Attorney-Client Protected Document 2011-01 Issued January 18, 2011 Final Version Question: Based upon your evaluation of the law and the official House Legislative District maps, is Craig Frank a representative from Utah House District 57? 1 Answer: Craig Frank is not a representative from Utah House District 57. A review of the legal boundaries of House District 57 contained in the official maps enacted by the Legislature establishes that Craig Frank does not live within the boundaries of House District 57. Therefore, Article VI, Section 5 of Utah's Constitution prohibits his continued service in the office of representative because he has ceased to be a legal resident of House District 57 and is disqualified from service in the office as a matter of constitutional law. GENERAL FACTS Craig Frank was appointed to represent Utah House District 57 in 2003. He was elected to represent that district in 2004, and reelected in 2006, 2008, and 2010. At the time he was appointed to represent House District 57, and for the elections of 2004, 2006, and 2008, he was a resident of Pleasant Grove. On or about January 1, 2009, Representative Frank moved to the northern portion of the city of Cedar Hills. The question to be answered by this legal opinion is whether, after he moved in 2009, he was still a legal resident of House District 57 and, therefore, still eligible to hold office. Craig Frank does not dispute that he changed his legal residence in January, 2009. He has stated that his current legal residence is 10808 North La Costa, Cedar Hills, Utah, 84062. According to Craig Frank, on Friday, January 7, 2011, he was testing a computer application available on the Utah House of Representative's website. If a person types in a street address, that application identifies the Utah State Representative and Utah State Senator who represents persons who reside at that address. Representative Frank typed in his own address: much to his

Upload: dangkhuong

Post on 14-May-2018

216 views

Category:

Documents


2 download

TRANSCRIPT

This formal legal opinion responds to your request for my formal1

opinion as General Counsel to the Legislature. The question posed andanswered by this legal opinion requires an evaluation of the law and a reviewand determination of certain facts. The conclusion reached in this opinion isbased upon that factual review and determination.

Michael E. ChristensenDirector

John L. FellowsGeneral Counsel

Utah State Capitol ComplexHouse Building, Suite W210

PO Box 145210Salt Lake City, Utah

84114-5210Phone (801) 538-1032

Fax (801) 538-1712www.le.utah.gov

FORMAL LEGAL OPINIONAttorney-Client Protected Document

2011-01Issued January 18, 2011

Final Version

Question: Based upon your evaluation of the law and the official HouseLegislative District maps, is Craig Frank a representative fromUtah House District 57?1

Answer: Craig Frank is not a representative from Utah House District 57.A review of the legal boundaries of House District 57 containedin the official maps enacted by the Legislature establishes thatCraig Frank does not live within the boundaries of HouseDistrict 57. Therefore, Article VI, Section 5 of Utah'sConstitution prohibits his continued service in the office ofrepresentative because he has ceased to be a legal resident ofHouse District 57 and is disqualified from service in the officeas a matter of constitutional law.

GENERAL FACTS

Craig Frank was appointed to represent Utah House District 57 in 2003. Hewas elected to represent that district in 2004, and reelected in 2006, 2008, and2010. At the time he was appointed to represent House District 57, and for theelections of 2004, 2006, and 2008, he was a resident of Pleasant Grove. On orabout January 1, 2009, Representative Frank moved to the northern portion ofthe city of Cedar Hills. The question to be answered by this legal opinion iswhether, after he moved in 2009, he was still a legal resident of House District57 and, therefore, still eligible to hold office. Craig Frank does not dispute thathe changed his legal residence in January, 2009. He has stated that his currentlegal residence is 10808 North La Costa, Cedar Hills, Utah, 84062.

According to Craig Frank, on Friday, January 7, 2011, he was testing acomputer application available on the Utah House of Representative's website.If a person types in a street address, that application identifies the Utah StateRepresentative and Utah State Senator who represents persons who reside atthat address. Representative Frank typed in his own address: much to his

For an example of Census Blocks with attached population figures for the area in2

question, see Exhibit A, Map - Census Blocks with Population Figures, attached.

"No later than the annual general session next following the Legislature's receipt of the3

results of an enumeration made by the authority of the United States, the Legislature shall dividethe state into congressional, legislative, and other districts accordingly." Utah Const. art. IX, §1.

surprise, the application identified Representative John Dougall as the Utah HouseRepresentative for that address rather than Representative Frank. Believing that there was anerror in the computer application, Representative Frank called the Chief Clerk of the Utah Houseof Representatives and requested that the computer application be fixed. Instead, the question ofwhether Representative Frank was a legal resident of his district arose.

REDISTRICTING FACTS

Redistricting is like a giant jigsaw puzzle. The United States Census Bureau divides the state intomore than 74,000 closed polygons, called Census Blocks, to each of which is attached specificpopulation data. A Census Block is the smallest geographic unit to which population is attached.2

In redistricting, the Utah Legislature combines Census Blocks to create congressional,legislative, and state school board districts that meet population equality and other requirementsestablished by the United States Constitution and by the United States Supreme Court. BecauseCensus Bureau data does not identify where the population resides within a Census Block, theLegislature, when redistricting, does not modify or split census blocks.

Because of the importance of Census Blocks, the United States Census Bureau works hard toestablish appropriate Census Block boundaries. Before each decennial census is conducted, theCensus Bureau establishes a deadline by which cities, towns, counties, school districts, and otherlocal governments must provide data that identifies their legal boundaries. The Census Bureauuses these legal boundaries to create Census Block boundaries. In the year after the decennialcensus, the Census Bureau provides the final Census Block boundaries and the populationassociated with those Census Block boundaries to each state. The Utah Legislature relies on theCensus Block boundaries established by the United States Census Bureau and uses thepopulation figures attached to each of those Census Blocks in its redistricting process. Changesto municipal boundaries that are not reflected in the census data sent to Utah for redistricting inthe year after the decennial census are not used by the Utah Legislature in redistricting.

ANALYSIS

Article IX, Section 1 of the Utah Constitution grants unrestricted authority to the UtahLegislature to divide the state into congressional, Utah Senate, Utah House of Representatives,and state school board districts.3

See House of Representatives Redistricting Plan, Ch. 1, 2001 Laws of Utah 2nd Spec.4

Sess. (codified as Utah Code Ann. §§ 36-1-201, 36-1-203, 36-1-204 (2010)); State Board ofEducation Redistricting Plan, Ch. 2, 2001 Laws of Utah 2nd Spec. Sess. (codified as Utah CodeAnn. §§ 20A-14-101 to -103 (2010)); Senate Redistricting Plan, Ch. 5, 2001 Laws of Utah 2ndSpec. Sess. (codified as Utah Code Ann. §§ 36-1-101 to -105 (2010)); Congressional ThreeMember Plan, Ch. 6, 2001 Laws of Utah 2nd. Spec. Sess. (codified as Utah Code Ann. §§ 20A-13-101 to -104 (2010)).

Utah Code Ann. § 36-1-202 (2010).5

In its Second Special Session in September and October of 2001, the Utah Legislature exercisedthat authority and enacted laws establishing new congressional, Utah Senate, Utah House, andstate school board districts.4

In conjunction with establishing the new House district boundaries, the Legislature establishedthe data on which it would rely to draw the maps. Utah Code Ann. Section 36-1-201 states "[t]heLegislature adopts the official census population figures and maps of the Bureau of the Census ofthe United States Department of Commerce developed in connection with the taking of the 2000national decennial census as the official data for establishing House district boundaries." Thelines on the map produced from the official census data (attached as Exhibit B, Map - CedarHills North Municipal Boundary from Data Provided by the U.S. Census Bureau) show the legalmunicipal boundary of Cedar Hills. Those lines are also Census Block boundaries for that area ofUtah County.

Relying upon official census data, the Legislature drew maps creating new boundaries for all 75Utah House Districts. The Legislature drew district boundaries to ensure that each district waswithin the population range mandated by the United States Constitution and by United StatesSupreme Court cases elaborating on those constitutional requirements. In late 2001, theLegislature passed House of Representatives Redistricting Plan, House Bill 2001 3rd Sub.(attached as Exhibit C, H.B. 2001 3rd Substitute, House of Representatives Redistricting Plan),which established the boundaries for Utah House Districts. Maps showing the boundaries of eachHouse District were included as part of the bill. One of those maps (found on page 25 of thislegal opinion) shows the boundary between House District 27 and House District 57.

During the Second Special Session, the Utah Legislature also enacted statutes designating thelegal boundaries of Utah House districts. According to Section 36-1-202, "[t]he legal boundariesof House districts are contained in the official maps on file with the lieutenant governor's office."The Legislature directs itself to "file copies of the official maps enacted by the Legislature, andany other relevant materials, with the lieutenant governor's office." It also provides that "[w]henquestions of interpretation of House district boundaries arise, the official maps on file in thelieutenant governor's office shall serve as the indication of the legislative intent in drawing theHouse district boundaries."5

Following the Second Special Session, the Office of Legislative Research and General Counsel,at the direction of the Utah Legislature, produced a publication entitled 2001 Redistricting in

Utah State Legislature, Office of Legislative Research and General Counsel, 20016

Redistricting in Utah (2002).

Id. at 1.7

Id. at 508, 651.8

Id. at 2.9

Utah, and subtitled Official Maps of District Boundaries. On page 1 of that publication, under6

the heading "Official Record," the document states "[u]nless modified, district boundariesestablished by the Utah Legislature and represented in this report will be in effect for the 2002elections and will remain in effect until the next redistricting process is completed." The7

Legislature provided the Lieutenant Governor with the official copy of that publication.

Besides the maps contained in H.B. 2001 3rd Sub., the publication contains additional maps thatzoom in to show more detail for particular House District Boundaries. Pages 508 and 651of thatpublication (attached as Exhibits D, Map - Utah House District 27 Southern Boundaries, and E,Map - Utah House District 57 Boundaries) show more clearly the boundary lines between HouseDistricts 27 and 57. A comparison of Exhibit B with Exhibits D and E shows that, generally, the8

northern boundary of House District 57 follows the municipal boundary of Cedar Hills ascontained in the maps produced by the data provided by the United States Census Bureau.

Portions of the northern boundary of District 57 are labeled "City Bndry" on the maps attached asExhibits D and E. On page 2 of the publication, under the heading "Identification of BoundaryLines," the publication states:

"The maps in this report identify every boundary of each district….A district boundary that coincides with a municipal boundary islabeled 'City Bndry' only where there is no other correspondinggeographic feature. The labels for this type of boundary oftenalternate between 'City Bndry' and the names of road or othergeographic features."9

This language establishes that the maps in the report establish the official boundary lines for eachhouse district. The term "City Bndry" is simply a label identifying where the boundary lies forthe residents of the area and the county clerk.

In preparing this formal legal opinion, the Office of Legislative Research and General Counselproduced a map using Census Bureau data and State Geographic Information Database data(attached as Exhibit F, Map - Legislator Residences and House District Boundaries) thatidentifies:• Craig Frank's residence;• the current municipal boundaries of Cedar Hills; and

• the boundary dividing House District 27 from House District 57 established by theLegislature in H.B. 2001 3rd Sub. and in the official maps on file in the LieutenantGovernor's office.

That map clearly establishes that Craig Frank's legal residence is in House District 27, not HouseDistrict 57.

Utah Constitution Article VI, Section 5 provides that "[a] person elected or appointed to theoffice of senator or representative may not continue to serve in that office after ceasing to be aresident of the district from which elected or for which appointed." Despite being elected as aRepresentative by the residents of House District 57, Craig Frank is not a legal resident of thatdistrict. Consequently, the Utah Constitution prohibits him from serving in that office.

CONCLUSION

The Utah Constitution prohibits Craig Frank from continuing to serve in the office ofrepresentative from House District 57 because his legal residence is not within the boundaries ofthat district according to the lines on the official maps enacted by the Utah Legislature.

John L. FellowsGeneral Counsel

F:\USERS\MANAGE\Phalin\John F. Documents\Formal Legal Opinion Frank.wpd

Highland

Cedar Hills

American Fork

Pleasant Grove

Highland

0

17

0

27

0

0

110

154

7

0

41

7

14

0

1

100

189

43

0

420

347

68

320

34

65

0

0

31

0

10

9

33

175

121

0

56

51

59

0

8

136

0

19

9

0

2

46135

38

56

0

15

576

0

3

94

317

4085

0

3

0

074

0

9

43

17

99

0

160

78

0

4

0

135

101

0

5

101

10

170

0

9

51

0

0

24

28

53

8

0

0

659

27

9

22

85

10

0

51

0

38

147

0

80

0

9371

2

0

109

142

0

51

18

22

33

0

0

4

0

105

0

10

0

0

70

101

45

41

35

7

33

48

17

10

39

48

0

44

36

15

35

36

33

0

0

0

18

0 57

0

68

43

77

0

31

0

0

2

49

12

59

102

0

0

39

6

1

9

38

33

22

39

0

40

49

17

35

0

48

3

234

7 0

12

0

00

15

0

15

20

0

16

20

0

0

0

300

2913

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

9

0

0

38 0

0

0

0

Legend

Census2000_blocks

Census2000_cities

American Fork

Cedar Hills

Highland

Pleasant Grove

CHELSEALLOYD
Typewritten Text
CHELSEALLOYD
Typewritten Text
Exhibit A -- Map - Census Blocks with Population Figures
CHELSEALLOYD
Typewritten Text
CHELSEALLOYD
Typewritten Text

Highland

Cedar Hills

American Fork

Pleasant Grove

Highland

Legend

Census2000_blocks

Census2000_cities

American Fork

Cedar Hills

Highland

Pleasant Grove

CHELSEALLOYD
Typewritten Text
Exhibit B -- Map - Cedar Hills North Municipal Boundary from Data provided by the U.S. Census Bureau
CHELSEALLOYD
Typewritten Text
CHELSEALLOYD
Typewritten Text
CHELSEALLOYD
Typewritten Text
CHELSEALLOYD
Typewritten Text
CHELSEALLOYD
Typewritten Text

Enrolled Copy H.B. 2001

HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES

REDISTRICTING PLAN

2001 SECOND SPECIAL SESSION

STATE OF UTAH

Sponsor: Gerry A. Adair

This act modifies statutory provisions governing Utah House of Representatives districts.

This act eliminates current boundaries and establishes new boundaries. This act establishes

certain maps as the legal boundaries of House districts and establishes procedures for

addressing omissions and uncertain boundaries. This act takes effect on January 1, 2002 for

purposes of nominating and electing members of the Utah House of Representatives and on

January 1, 2003 for all other purposes.

This act affects sections of Utah Code Annotated 1953 as follows:

ENACTS:

36-1-201, Utah Code Annotated 1953

36-1-202, Utah Code Annotated 1953

36-1-203, Utah Code Annotated 1953

36-1-204, Utah Code Annotated 1953

REPEALS:

36-1-4, as last amended by Chapter 112, Laws of Utah 1999

36-1-5, as last amended by Chapter 10, Laws of Utah 1997

Be it enacted by the Legislature of the state of Utah:

Section 1. Section 36-1-201 is enacted to read:

Part 2. Utah House of Representatives

36-1-201. Utah House of Representatives -- District boundaries.

(1) The Utah House of Representatives shall consist of 75 members, with one member to

be elected from each Utah House of Representatives district.

(2) (a) The Legislature adopts the official census population figures and maps of the

Bureau of the Census of the United States Department of Commerce developed in connection with

the taking of the 2000 national decennial census as the official data for establishing House district

CHELSEALLOYD
Typewritten Text
CHELSEALLOYD
Typewritten Text
CHELSEALLOYD
Typewritten Text
CHELSEALLOYD
Typewritten Text
CHELSEALLOYD
Typewritten Text
Exhibit C -- H.B. 2001 Third Substitute, House of Representatives Redistricting Plan
CHELSEALLOYD
Typewritten Text
CHELSEALLOYD
Typewritten Text

H.B. 2001 Enrolled Copy

- 2 -

boundaries.

(b) The numbers and boundaries of the House districts are designated and established by the

maps attached to the bill that enacts this section.

Section 2. Section 36-1-202 is enacted to read:

36-1-202. Official maps of House districts.

(1) (a) The Legislature shall file copies of the official maps enacted by the Legislature, and

any other relevant materials, with the lieutenant governor's office.

(b) The legal boundaries of House districts are contained in the official maps on file with

the lieutenant governor's office.

(2) When questions of interpretation of House district boundaries arise, the official maps on

file in the lieutenant governor's office shall serve as the indication of the legislative intent in drawing

the House district boundaries.

(3) (a) Each county clerk shall obtain copies of the official maps for the clerk's county from

the lieutenant governor's office.

(b) Each county clerk shall establish voting precincts and polling places within each House

district according to the procedures and requirements of Section 20A-5-303.

(4) Maps identifying the boundaries for House districts may be viewed on the Internet at the

lieutenant governor's website.

Section 3. Section 36-1-203 is enacted to read:

36-1-203. Omissions from maps -- How resolved.

(1) If any area of the state is omitted from a Utah House of Representatives district in the

maps enacted by the Legislature, the county clerk of the affected county, upon discovery of the

omission, shall attach the area to the appropriate House district according to the requirements of

Subsections (2) and (3).

(2) If the area is surrounded by a House district, the area shall be attached to that district.

(3) If the area is contiguous to two districts, the area shall be attached to the district that has

the least population, as determined by the official census population figures and maps of the Bureau

of the Census of the United States Department of Commerce developed in connection with the taking

Enrolled Copy H.B. 2001

- 3 -

of the 2000 national decennial census.

(4) Any attachment made under Subsection (1) shall be certified in writing and filed with

the lieutenant governor.

Section 4. Section 36-1-204 is enacted to read:

36-1-204. Uncertain boundaries -- How resolved.

(1) As used in this section, "affected party" means:

(a) a representative whose Utah House of Representatives district boundary is uncertain

because the identifying feature used to establish the district boundary has been removed, modified,

or is unable to be identified or who is uncertain about whether or not he or another person resides

in a particular House district;

(b) a candidate for representative whose House district boundary is uncertain because the

identifying feature used to establish the district boundary has been removed, modified, or is unable

to be identified or who is uncertain about whether or not he or another person resides in a particular

House district; or

(c) a person who is uncertain about which House district contains the person's residence

because the identifying feature used to establish the district boundary has been removed, modified,

or is unable to be identified.

(2) (a) An affected party may file a written request petitioning the lieutenant governor to

determine:

(i) the precise location of the House district boundary;

(ii) the number of the House district in which a person resides; or

(iii) both Subsections (2)(a)(i) and (ii).

(b) In order to make the determination required by Subsection (2)(a), the lieutenant governor

shall review the official maps and obtain and review other relevant data such as census block and

tract descriptions, aerial photographs, aerial maps, or other data about the area.

(c) Within five days of receipt of the request, the lieutenant governor shall review the maps,

obtain and review any relevant data, and make a determination.

(d) When the lieutenant governor determines the location of the House district boundary,

H.B. 2001 Enrolled Copy

- 4 -

the lieutenant governor shall:

(i) prepare a certification identifying the appropriate boundary and attaching a map, if

necessary; and

(ii) send a copy of the certification to the affected party and the county clerk of the affected

county.

(e) If the lieutenant governor determines the number of the House district in which a

particular person resides, the lieutenant governor shall send a letter identifying that district by

number to:

(i) the person;

(ii) the affected party who filed the petition, if different than the person whose House district

number was identified; and

(iii) the county clerk of the affected county.

Section 5. Repealer.

This act repeals:

Section 36-1-4, House districts -- Definitions -- Numbers and boundaries of districts --

Resolving omissions and ambiguity.

Section 36-1-5, Official maps of House districts.

Section 6. Effective date.

This act takes effect on January 1, 2002 for purposes of nominating and electing members

of the Utah House of Representatives and on January 1, 2003 for all other purposes.

Beaver

Box ElderCache

Carbon

DaggettDavis

Duchesne

Emery

Garfield

Grand

Iron

Juab

Kane

Millard

Morgan

Piute

Rich

Salt Lake

San Juan

Sanpete

Sevier

Summit

Tooele

UintahUtahWasatch

Washington

Wayne

Weber

1

23 45

6 81321 25

53

74

54

55

56

67

68

75

70

69

72 73

71

I-70

Main

Uzona Ave

Skyline

Dr

State Route 95

Mine

rsville

Hwy

I-15

F S 056

5500 E

Dike R

d

State

Route

24

State Route 14

I-80

Bear River

I-70

I-15

I-80

Counties

DistrictsCities

mwilson
Enrolled Copy H.B. 2001 Utah House of Representatives - Statewide Overview

67 891011

12

131415

1617181920

2122 23

292624

252840303135333432 36

41

38

53

443749

394347 4645524250 4851

56

27

6258596061 636466

65

57

I-15

11800 S

Dike Rd

Mill Creek

I-80

5600 W

Lake Creek RdSheep Ln

Ten Mile Pass Rd

State Highway 92

I-215

Beer Creek

300

E

3500 S

2000

W

7800 S

4000

W

700

E

Burch Creek

Steed Creek

900

E

Centerville Creek

Canyon Rd

400 S

1700 S

4100 S

400 N

Jorda

n Rive

r

13800 S

1300 S

Holmes Creek

9400 S

Main St

7000 S

Hill Field Rd

800

E

Weber

6200 S

900 East StHa

rriso

n Blvd

1400

E

Skye Dr

I-80

I-80

I-15

I-15

1300 S

1

67

54

Counties

DistrictsCities

mwilson
Enrolled Copy H.B. 2001 Utah House of Representatives - Tooele, Weber, Davis, Salt Lake, and Utah Counties - Overview

Bear River

Brigham CityCorinne

DeweyvilleElwood

Fielding

Garland

Honeyville

Mantua

Perry

Plymouth

Portage

Tremonton

Willard

Amalga

Clarkston

Cornish

Hyde Park

Hyrum

Lewiston

LoganMendon

Millville

Newton

Nibley

North Logan

Paradise

Providence

Richmond

River Heights

Smithfield

Trenton

Wellsville

Garden

Laketown

Randolph

Woodruff

North OgdenPleasant View

2

34

5

7 8

Highway 101

Dike Rd

Bear

River

2400 North

200 N

5600 S

River Ln

7200

W

Stink Creek Rd

Highway 142

4200 N

Sam Fellow Rd

State Route 101

Little Creek Rd

Bear River

Counties

DistrictsCities

mwilson
Enrolled Copy H.B. 2001 Utah House of Representatives - Box Elder, Cache, and Rich Counties

East Carbon

Helper

Price

Scofield

SunnysWellington

Castle Dale

Clawson

ClevelandElmo

Emery

Ferron

Huntington

Orangeville

Fairview

nt Pleasant

67

70

I-70

Skylin

e Dr

Vicor R

eef Rd

Horse Bench Rd

Green River Cutoff Rd

Ferron Creek

Birch Creek

Buckhorn Draw RdHuntington Creek

Mead

's Wa

sh

Sand

Benc

h Loo

p

Dutch Flat Rd

North

Salt W

ash

Nine M

ile Ca

nyon

Rd

Victor

Ree

f Rd

Whitmore Park Rd

Castle Valley Ridge Rd

Utah Railway

Counties

DistrictsCities

mwilson
Enrolled Copy H.B. 2001 Utah House of Representatives - Carbon and Emery Counties

Bountiful

Centerville

Clearfield

Clinton

Farmington

Fruit HeightsKaysville

Layton

North Salt Lake

South WeberSunset

Syracuse

West Bountiful

West Point

Woods Cross

Salt Lake City

Uintah11

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

23 24

I-15

Mill Creek

I-215

2000

W

Steed Creek

Centerville Creek

1700 S

Holmes Creek

Hill Field Rd

Redwood Rd

Weber

Main St

2100 N

State St

800 N

Combe Rd

2200 S

Fort Ln

Middle Fork Kays Creek

Baer

Creek

200 S

Antelope Dr

650 E

2600 S

Skyline

Dr

Unite

d Stat

es H

ighwa

y 89

Goggin Drain

1000 N

500

W

Dry Creek

So Fork

Mueller Park Rd

700 S

Rosewood

Ln

1900

W

Gentile St

Weber River

Mutton Hollow Rd

1000

W

Gordon Ave

Francis Peak Rd

1450 N

900 N

500 S

I-15

500

WHill Field Rd

I-15

Counties

DistrictsCities

mwilson
Enrolled Copy H.B. 2001 Utah House of Representatives - Davis County

Myton

Roosevelt

Ballard

5500 E

White Rocks Canyon Rd

Duchesne River

White Rocks Hwy

1500 S

Dry Gulch Creek

Ouray S

chool C

anal

State Route 121

3000 N

7500 E

White Rocks Hwy5500 E

DuchesneCounty

UintahCounty

54 55

Counties

DistrictsCities

mwilson
Enrolled Copy H.B. 2001 Utah House of Representatives - Duchesne and Uintah Counties

Castle Valley

Moab

I-70

State Highway 128

Sego

Can

yon R

d

Thom

pson

Cyn R

d

500 W

I-70

69

55

Counties

DistrictsCities

mwilson
Enrolled Copy H.B. 2001 Utah House of Representatives - Grand County

BrianCedar City

EnochI-15

State Route 14

Main

St

Mine

rsville

Hwy

Winn Hollow

Center St

Braffits Creek

Old US

Hwy 9

1

Fiddlers Canyon Dr

State Route 14

72

73

Counties

DistrictsCities

mwilson
Enrolled Copy H.B. 2001 Utah House of Representatives - Iron County

Scofield

Emery

Ferro

Eureka

Levan

Mona

Nephi

Rocky Ridge

Fillmore

Holden

Leamington

Oak

Scipio

Centerfield

Ephraim

Fairview

Fayette

Fountain Green

Gunnison

Manti

Mayfield

Moroni Mount Pleasant

Spring City

Sterling

Wales

Aurora

Redmond

Salina

Sigurd

Elk RidgeGenola

Goshen

Mapleton

PaysonSalem

Santaquin

Spanish Fork

Woodland Hills

6465

67

70

Main

I-15

Skyline Dr

Beer Creek

Farmer's Fwy

Canyon Rd

Birch Creek

Manti Canyon Rd

United States Highway 89

800

E14

00 E Spanish Fork River400 S

68

6466

56 541

Counties

DistrictsCities

mwilson
Enrolled Copy H.B. 2001 Utah House of Representatives - Juab and Sanpete Counties

Bountiful

North Salt Lake

Woods Cross

Bluffdale

DraperHerriman

Holladay

Midvale

Murray

Riverton

Salt Lake City

SandySouth Jordan

South Salt Lake

Taylorsville

West Jordan

West Valley

AlpineDraper

Highland

20

23

29

26

24

28

40

30313533

3432 36

41

38 4437

49

3943

47 4645

52

42

50 48

51

27

I-80

I-15

11800 S

Mill Creek

5600

W

I-215

300

E

3500 S

900 E

ast S

t4800 S

7800 S

4000

W

700

E

1300

W

900

E

400 S

4100 S

State Highway 92

Center St

Jorda

n Rive

r

13800 S

1300 S

9400 S

11400 S

7000 S

Union Pacific Railroad

Redwood Rd

6200 S

State

St

800

E

Fort Union Blvd

Skye Dr

7500 S

7200

W

1300

E

2100 N

4500 S

Bell Canyon Creek

Parleys Creek

2100 S Expy

6400

W

1700

East

4700 S4430 S

8680 S

Highway U-111

2200 S

Bengal Blvd

3200

W

4800 South

3300 S

600 S

900

W

9800 S

Parkway Blvd

2600 S

Vine St

2700 E

Bang

erter

Hwy

Goggin Drain

3650 S

9000 S

445 E

9400 S St

Dry Creek

So Fork

2000

East

2100 S

4800

W

1700

EVir

ginia

St

2700

W

Mueller Park Rd

Plata Way

12300 S

7420 S

1175

W

10000 South

10600 S

500 E

ast

North Jordan Canal

Lake Park Blvd

1300

East

12400 S

5615 S

Highland Dr

3100 S

400 South

Nila Way

5400 S

Bryce

Dr

700

W

2000 E

7200 S

900 N

300

E30

0 E

2700

W

I-15I-15

State Highway 92

I-15

3500 SI-15

1300

E

I-215

Jorda

n Rive

r

I-15

11400 S

4000

W

800

E

1300

East

700

E

3500 S

10600 S

Mill Creek

I-215

Jordan

River

4800

W

4100 S

2225

Counties

DistrictsCities

mwilson
Enrolled Copy H.B. 2001 Utah House of Representatives - Salt Lake County

Emery

Antimony

Fillmore

Holden

Kanosh

Meadow

Oak

Scipio

Circleville

JunctionKingston

Marysvale

Centerfield

Ephraim

Fayette

Gunnison

Manti

Mayfield

Sterling

Annabella

Aurora

Elsinore

Glenwood

Joseph

Koosharem

Monroe

Redmond

Richfield

Salina

Sigurd

Bicknell

LoaLyman

Torrey

70

Skyline Dr

F S 056

I-70

F S 042 F S 01

5Monroe Mtn Rd

F S 64

0

Last Chance Creek

F S 053

Farmer's Fwy

Manti Canyon Rd

F S 141

State R

oute 7

2

Monro

e Mtn

Rd

73

68

67

Counties

DistrictsCities

mwilson
Enrolled Copy H.B. 2001 Utah House of Representatives - Sevier County

Alta

Coalville

Francis

Kamas

Oakley

Park City

Provo

Charleston

HeberMidway

Park City

Wallsburg

62

6365

I-80

Lake Creek RdUnited States Highway 40

Highway 40

Old Hwy 40State Route 248

53

54

64

27

46

25

Counties

DistrictsCities

mwilson
Enrolled Copy H.B. 2001 Utah House of Representatives - Summit and Wasatch Counties

Grantsville

Stockton

Tooele

21

22

I-80

Sheep LnMain

St

Settlement Canyon Rd

State Route 112

Sixmile Creek

Barneys Creek

State Route 1

38

1

13

50

42

Counties

DistrictsCities

mwilson
Enrolled Copy H.B. 2001 Utah House of Representatives - Tooele County

Bluffdale

Draper

Riverton

Alpine

American Fork

Cedar Hills

Draper

Mountain

Elk RidgeGenola

HighlandLehi

Lindon

Mapleton

Orem

Payson

Pleasant Grove

Provo

Salem

Santaquin

Saratoga Springs

Spanish Fork

Springville

Vineyard

Woodland Hills

Charles

Midway

41 51

56

27

62585960

61 63

6465

57

I-15

State Highway 92

Beer Creek

300

E

Canyon Rd

400 N

13800 S

Center St

800

E14

00 E

1600 N

400 S

High L

ine Ca

nal Rd

5600 W

75 E

8000 S

150

W

State St

100 N

500 N

Unive

rsity

Ave

400 E

1300

W

300 W

1200 N

1000 E

University Pky

1150 S

1200 E

2300 N

200 S

1600

W

300 N

860

E

350

W

Slate Canyon

250

E

Carte

rville

Rd

2400 N

2600 N

970 East

100

EI-1

5

I-15

State Highway 92

I-15

Center St

I-15

State H

ighway 9

2

54

6667

52

Counties

DistrictsCities

mwilson
Enrolled Copy H.B. 2001 Utah House of Representatives - Utah County

Kanarraville

Enterprise

Hildale

HurricaneIvins

La VerkinLeeds

New Harmony

Rockville

St. George

Santa Clara

Springdale

Toquerville

Virgin

Washington

74

7571

Uzona Ave

I-15

State Route 14

Highway 18East Fork Virgin River

State

Route

300

Virgin River

1700 North

Indian Hills Dr 73

72

Counties

DistrictsCities

mwilson
Enrolled Copy H.B. 2001 Utah House of Representatives - Washington County

Clinton South WeberSunset

Farr West

Harrisville

Marriott-Slaterville

North Ogden

Ogden

Plain City

Pleasant View

RiverdaleRoy

South Ogden

Uintah

Washington Terrace

West Haven

7

9

10

11

12Burch Creek

2nd St

Weber

1200

Wes

t St

1200

W

Harri

son B

lvd

30th St

4400 S

Combe Rd

1900

W

800 N

Midland

Dr

Harrisville Rd

2550 North St

12th St

7th St

36th St

Washington Blvd

Hinkley Dr

Brigham Ogden Canal

4000 S

600

E

I-15

Mountain Rd

Ogden River

Weber River

Darling St

Wall Ave

2175

Wes

t St

775 East St

4800 S

4300

Wes

t St

Plain

City C

anal

6200 S

4200 S

3300 South St

Uinta Central Canal

Gram

ercy A

ve

33rd St

Harri

son B

lvd7th St

Brigh

am O

gden

Cana

l

1900

W

4300

Wes

t St

12th St

800 N

Wash

ington

Blvd

Wash

ington

Blvd

1900

W

8

2

6

13

Counties

DistrictsCities

mwilson
Enrolled Copy H.B. 2001 Utah House of Representatives - Weber County

�������

���������������������

����������������������

����������������������

�������

��������

���� ��������

������� �������

� �������

������

������

�����

���� �������

����������

������

� �������

� �������

�������

� �������

!"���#$���%

� �������

������� ������

������

&����� ������������

������

������

������

&����

'# ( #�)�������

�����

������

�����

*+��

�����

�����

��������

��� �������

����

��������������

�����������

� ��� ����

�����",���(���-��,�� .�,�

����������� �� ) ,� #����������"� �,

/����) ,� #,

!0������,1�#%�����,� %���,

� �,

CHELSEALLOYD
Typewritten Text
Exhibit D -- Map - Utah House District 27 Southern Boundaries
CHELSEALLOYD
Typewritten Text
CHELSEALLOYD
Typewritten Text

����������

���������������

������

������ ����������������� �

��������������� ��������

�������������

���

����

��������������������

������������������

������������������

�����

������� ������� �

������� �

�������

������� �

������� �

������� �

������� �

����� !"����

#����$

�������%�������&'�� ���(����

�����$ ������� �

�����

�����$

�����$

�� �%������������ ��������

)*�� �(�����

�����

������

������ ����

�������

������������

���������

�����������

+����,����-���.��������/��

CHELSEALLOYD
Typewritten Text
Exhibit E -- Map - Utah House District 57 Boundaries
CHELSEALLOYD
Typewritten Text
CHELSEALLOYD
Typewritten Text

Highland

Cedar Hills

American Fork

Pleasant Grove

HighlandFrank

Dougall

27

57

62

Cedar Hills

Highland

Pleasant Grove

American Fork

Alpine

Legend

Legislator Residence

Census2000_blocks

SGID_Current City Boundaries

Census2000_2001 House

Census2000_cities

American Fork

Cedar Hills

Highland

Pleasant Grove

CHELSEALLOYD
Typewritten Text
Exhibit F -- Map - Legislator Residences and House District Boundaries
CHELSEALLOYD
Typewritten Text
CHELSEALLOYD
Typewritten Text