putting cities on the world map puca-latts workshop 25.xiputting cities on the world map puca-latts...

32
Pung Cies On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16 Cies on the World Map – a Projecon Issue Michael Hebbert

Upload: others

Post on 06-Jun-2020

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Putting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xiPutting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16 Edouard Herriot (1872- 1957) Mayor of Lyon 1905-1957 Prime Minister

Putting Cities On The World MapPUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16

Cities on the World Map – a Projection IssueMichael Hebbert

Page 2: Putting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xiPutting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16 Edouard Herriot (1872- 1957) Mayor of Lyon 1905-1957 Prime Minister

Putting Cities On The World MapPUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16

François Mitterand & Gaston Defferre1981

Page 3: Putting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xiPutting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16 Edouard Herriot (1872- 1957) Mayor of Lyon 1905-1957 Prime Minister

Putting Cities On The World MapPUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16

Greater London Council official gift to London-Paris ESRC-CNRS research network participants 1984

Page 4: Putting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xiPutting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16 Edouard Herriot (1872- 1957) Mayor of Lyon 1905-1957 Prime Minister

Putting Cities On The World MapPUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16

Greater London Council abolition 1986 – followed by interregnum of 33 municipalities

Page 5: Putting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xiPutting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16 Edouard Herriot (1872- 1957) Mayor of Lyon 1905-1957 Prime Minister

Putting Cities On The World MapPUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16

Since 2000: directly elected Mayor & GLA – 'speaking for London'

Page 6: Putting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xiPutting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16 Edouard Herriot (1872- 1957) Mayor of Lyon 1905-1957 Prime Minister

Christian Lefèvre

Ernesto d'Albergo

Bernard JouveLefèvre C & d'Albergo E (2007) 'Why cities are looking abroad and how they go about it' EPC Government & Policy Vol 27 pp317-326

CITTA – Cities as International and Transnational ActorsESF Network 2003-2005

Page 7: Putting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xiPutting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16 Edouard Herriot (1872- 1957) Mayor of Lyon 1905-1957 Prime Minister

CITTA – Cities as International and Transnational ActorsESF Network 2003-2005

Lefèvre C & d'Albergo E (2007) 'Why cities are looking abroad and how they go about it' EPC Government & Policy Vol 27 pp317-326

choices,choices,choices. . .

Page 8: Putting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xiPutting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16 Edouard Herriot (1872- 1957) Mayor of Lyon 1905-1957 Prime Minister

CITTA – Cities as International and Transnational ActorsESF Network 2003-2005

Ewen S and Hebbert M (2007) 'European Cities in a networked world during the long 20C'EPC Government & Policy, Vol 25, pp 327-340

Page 9: Putting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xiPutting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16 Edouard Herriot (1872- 1957) Mayor of Lyon 1905-1957 Prime Minister

Putting Cities On The World MapPUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16

Émile Vinck, 1870-1950founder, UIV- IULA, Ghent 1913launched Le Mouvement Communal 1914

http://opac.amsab.be/Record/PR.001495

Page 10: Putting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xiPutting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16 Edouard Herriot (1872- 1957) Mayor of Lyon 1905-1957 Prime Minister

Patrizia Dogliani (2002) 'European Municipalism in the First Half of the Twentieth Century: the Socialist Network', Contemporary European History ii, 4, 573-596

Putting Cities On The World MapPUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16

Sir Patrick Geddes:municipal science or

'civics'

Charles Bulsmunicipalism and collective memory

Edgard Milhaud:municipalism as cooperative

economy

Page 11: Putting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xiPutting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16 Edouard Herriot (1872- 1957) Mayor of Lyon 1905-1957 Prime Minister

Putting Cities On The World MapPUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16

Hendrik Christian AndersenCitta Mondiale 1913

Page 12: Putting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xiPutting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16 Edouard Herriot (1872- 1957) Mayor of Lyon 1905-1957 Prime Minister

Putting Cities On The World MapPUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16

Hendrik Christian AndersenCitta Mondiale sculptures inVilla Hélène, Rome

Page 13: Putting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xiPutting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16 Edouard Herriot (1872- 1957) Mayor of Lyon 1905-1957 Prime Minister

Putting Cities On The World MapPUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16

. . . et l’autre histoire:projections/promotions individuelles

boosterism

Page 14: Putting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xiPutting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16 Edouard Herriot (1872- 1957) Mayor of Lyon 1905-1957 Prime Minister

Boosterism in Wichita, Kansas, from Stephen V. Ward (1998) Selling Places : Marketing and Promotion of Towns and Cities 1850-2000

Putting Cities On The World MapPUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16

Page 15: Putting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xiPutting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16 Edouard Herriot (1872- 1957) Mayor of Lyon 1905-1957 Prime Minister

Grand Junction, Colorado by James McConnell School Supplies, Denver, 1894http://www.gjsentinel.com/outdoors/articles/cartographers-often-engaged-in-boosterism-to-map-our-state

Putting Cities On The World MapPUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16

Page 16: Putting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xiPutting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16 Edouard Herriot (1872- 1957) Mayor of Lyon 1905-1957 Prime Minister

title page from Charles F Lummis's Land of Sunshine (1894)https://sites.oxy.edu/special-collections/amer-frontier/index

Putting Cities On The World MapPUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16

Page 17: Putting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xiPutting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16 Edouard Herriot (1872- 1957) Mayor of Lyon 1905-1957 Prime Minister

Putting Cities On The World MapPUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16

Henry Aldridge (1909) The Case for Town Planning

Page 18: Putting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xiPutting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16 Edouard Herriot (1872- 1957) Mayor of Lyon 1905-1957 Prime Minister

Putting Cities On The World MapPUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16

Edouard Herriot (1872- 1957)Mayor of Lyon 1905-1957

Prime Minister of France 1924, 1926, 1932 Dans ma longue vie publique, le problème qui m’a

le plus constamment occupé est celui de l’administration de la ville de Lyon

Projecting the city both through local projectsand through global partnership

Page 19: Putting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xiPutting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16 Edouard Herriot (1872- 1957) Mayor of Lyon 1905-1957 Prime Minister

Putting Cities On The World MapPUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16

projecting cities on the world map

an issue for collective, collaborative action ?

or for solo warriors ?

Page 20: Putting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xiPutting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16 Edouard Herriot (1872- 1957) Mayor of Lyon 1905-1957 Prime Minister

Putting Cities On The World MapPUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16

the New Municipalism

‘nations talk, cities act’

Bruce Katz, Benjamin Barber, Michele Acuto, Warren Magnusson

Page 21: Putting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xiPutting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16 Edouard Herriot (1872- 1957) Mayor of Lyon 1905-1957 Prime Minister

Putting Cities On The World MapPUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16

1982 Mayors for Peace1985 Metropolis1990 ICLEI1991 Eurocities2004 CGLU 2006 C40

Page 22: Putting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xiPutting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16 Edouard Herriot (1872- 1957) Mayor of Lyon 1905-1957 Prime Minister

Putting Cities On The World MapPUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16

the appeal to history

1913 UIV1648 Treaty of Westphalia1358 Hanseatic League400 BC Athens (et cetera)

Page 23: Putting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xiPutting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16 Edouard Herriot (1872- 1957) Mayor of Lyon 1905-1957 Prime Minister

Putting Cities On The World MapPUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16

the alternative tradition

city as solo warrior

projection as boosterism

Page 24: Putting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xiPutting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16 Edouard Herriot (1872- 1957) Mayor of Lyon 1905-1957 Prime Minister

Putting Cities On The World MapPUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16

John Clancy, leader of Birmingham City Council

‘thinks his city needs its own Foreign Office’

Page 25: Putting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xiPutting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16 Edouard Herriot (1872- 1957) Mayor of Lyon 1905-1957 Prime Minister

Warnaby G (2008) 'Why place marketers should understand cartography' Journal of Place Management & Development Vol 1, Issue 2, pp214-226

Putting Cities On The World MapPUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16

Page 26: Putting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xiPutting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16 Edouard Herriot (1872- 1957) Mayor of Lyon 1905-1957 Prime Minister

Putting Cities On The World MapPUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16

Guggenheim Museum Bilbao, by Frank Gehry, 1997

a beguilingly successful precedent

‘iconic architecture & the Bilbo Effect’

Beatriz Plaze (2006) ‘The Return on Investment of the Guggenheim Museum Bilbao’ IJURR 30. 2. 452-467

Page 27: Putting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xiPutting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16 Edouard Herriot (1872- 1957) Mayor of Lyon 1905-1957 Prime Minister

Putting Cities On The World MapPUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16

projecting Manchester’s image at the MIPIM property fair in Cannes – gold models of real estate

Page 28: Putting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xiPutting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16 Edouard Herriot (1872- 1957) Mayor of Lyon 1905-1957 Prime Minister

Putting Cities On The World MapPUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16

Barcelona Olympics1992

demonstrable success of projectionthrough iconic buildings, sports and cultural events

Simon Anholt (2007) Competitive Identity – the New Brand Management for Nations Cities and Regions

Competitive Identity Theory – the hexagon model

Page 29: Putting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xiPutting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16 Edouard Herriot (1872- 1957) Mayor of Lyon 1905-1957 Prime Minister

Putting Cities On The World MapPUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16

Devreint L, Boulton A, Brunn S, Derudder B and Witlox F (2011) ‘Searching for Cyberspace : the position of major cities in the information age’ Journal of Urban Technology 18, 1, 73-92

year by year the number and size of cities grows

& so does the flow of information

intensifying the challenge of C.I.

Page 30: Putting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xiPutting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16 Edouard Herriot (1872- 1957) Mayor of Lyon 1905-1957 Prime Minister

Putting Cities On The World MapPUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16

Mori Memorial Foundation Institute for Urban Stratgies Global Power City Index 2016 <http://mori-m-foundation.or.jp/english/ius2/gpci2/index.shtml>

in the context of ecological transition, economic globalisation, and information saturation

projection onto the world map is both a competitive and a collaborative challenge

Page 31: Putting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xiPutting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16 Edouard Herriot (1872- 1957) Mayor of Lyon 1905-1957 Prime Minister

Putting Cities On The World MapPUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16

Lyon - more than 100 years of successful civic projection . . .

Page 32: Putting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xiPutting Cities On The World Map PUCA-LATTS Workshop 25.xi.16 Edouard Herriot (1872- 1957) Mayor of Lyon 1905-1957 Prime Minister