purpose of today’s presentation - didi.dk/sitecollectiondocuments/downloadboks - lokale...
TRANSCRIPT
1
Efficient handling of agents and distributors in the USSeptember 3, 2008
2
Purpose of today’s presentation
What I would like to accomplish today ….
• Tell the Toms Group history in the US – and our strategy going forward -successes and challenges
• Elucidate do’s and don'ts when doing business in the US
• Discuss how to effectively handle distributors and agents in the US
• Answer a lot of questions
2
Agenda
1) Introduce Toms Group / Anthon Berg
2) Present Toms Group’s strategy for the US
3) Illustrate the complexities in setting up a US operation
4) Discuss key factors for success in the US
Agenda
1) Introduce Toms Group / Anthon Berg
2) Present Toms Group’s strategy for the US
3) Illustrate the complexities in setting up a US operation
4) Discuss key factors for success in the US
3
5
Setting the scene
Toms Group …
• … develops, manufactures and sells high quality confectionery products
• … has a broad product assortment covering all confectionery categories, i.e. markets chocolate, licorice and sugar confectionery products
• … is the market leader in Denmark and has a ‘stronghold’ position in the Nordic area
• … is owned by Gerda and Victor B. Strands Foundation (Toms Gruppen Foundation)
• … has an annual turnover of approximately DKK 1,5 billion
• … produces an annual chocolate and sugar confectionery tonnage ofapproximately 30,000 MT
• … employs approximately 900, seasonal dependent
6
Strategizing for the future
Gold in 2012 Decomposing the strategy
Clear financial goals:• Turnover: DKK 2 billion• EBIT % ≥ 10
Values – we believe in:• Change • Simplification• Openness• Value-adding as well as responsible behavior!
Five strategic themes:• Consumer Insight• Innovation• Effective Supply Chain• Partnerships• Cooperation and personal development
4
7
Proactively taking a CSR role
Global compact
World Cocoa Foundation
Fair TradeEducation project
GhanaFermentation
8
Strategizing for Anthon Berg
Anthon Berg wants to be one of the world’s leading brands within ‘High End
Chocolate’
By utilizing our core competence in treating cocoa beans to make
sophisticated chocolates, it is the aim to manifest Anthon Berg as being a chocolate mentor who excites the modern life
indulgers
‘Brand Essence’
Anthon Berg is the Brand that is ..”Always a surprisingly special experience for
your senses”
Anthon Berg represents the unexpected …
Anthon Berg is… more than meets the eye… more than the tongue tastes… more the nose smells… more than the fingers sense… more than you expected
The small unexpected detail in the product, the packaging or the marketing that takes you by subtle surprise
Uncompromising, Aesthetic, Surprisingly special
• Our consumers are modern life indulgers
• Our consumers are open-minded often travelling people with an interest in what's aesthetic, interior decorating, fine dining, travels, wine and design
Target GroupVision
Mission
5
Agenda
1) Introduce Toms Group / Anthon Berg
2) Present Toms Group’s strategy for the US
3) Illustrate the complexities in setting up a US operation
4) Discuss key factors for success in the US
10
USA – #1 confectionery market globally
Global confectionery market – 2005100% = USD 126.2 bill.
20.5% US
US confectionery market – 2005100% = USD 25.9 bill.
54.9% Chocolate31.6%
Sugar
Gum
13.5%
Share of global market:•Chocolate: 20.9%•Sugar: 19.9%•Gum: 20.6%
20 times larger than Denmark
6
11
2007
Our history and strategies in the US
2006
2005
2004
2003
2002
• The US business is build on cooperation agreements with five regional importers• A Costco deal is settled ‘on the side’. A new agent approached us.
2001
2000
<2000
• The regional importers could not purchase full containers of products (lacked scale) and sales were not impressive – we decided to make a strategic partnership with a new importer to focus our effort. Euro-American Brands was chosen. The five regional distributors, however, kept exclusive regional deals
• The strategy of Toms Group changes to focus more on the Scandinavian and British markets. As a result, the export department in
Toms Group sees huge changes. The US remains a focus market, though.• The business with EAB is institutionalized
• We are not satisfied with EAB’s performance. It is decided that EAB employs a ‘Toms Group exclusive’ sales person to be a brand champion and increase sales. The salary of this person is split 50/50
• The exclusivity deal with the five regional distributors are cancelled
• The 50/50 set-up proves not to be ideal and Toms recruit the sales person as a consultant working 100% for Toms Group. She handles the Clubs and works with EAB to optimize distributor business
• We attend the exhibition, ECRM, to gain contact to national accounts. Succeeds to contact Target. We wants volume sales, and best way to get that fast is with national accounts
• We continue to court national accounts direct and cut out our importers role in these cases • The exchange rate is a challenge
• We develop a clear US strategy and decide to establish Anthon Berg Inc in New York through DI• Our sales person starts her own business, Just Clubs Consulting, and represent us at club level
• Anthon Berg Inc is established. Henning Kallesen is placed in New York from 01022008.• Wins the largest US drugstore, Walgreens, as a new customer.
12
The US foundation – six strategy pillars
Ensure long-term availability of core and associated products facilitating the US expansion
Broaden the product portfolio – but remain a niche Anthon Berg chocolate player offering unique products
Go-to-market directly targeting national/regional chains and indirectly (with importer) targeting the distributors
Keep current two-hub distribution set-up allowing for flexibility, while pursuing cost-efficient improvements
Products
Go-to-market model
Distribution and logistics
Productionand
capacity
Enhance execution power by scaling up moderately with sales and marketing resources (customer proximity)
Organizational execution
Intensify the brand building via an augmented – yet focused and targeted –marketing effort
Brands and marketing
7
13
A product profile adjusted to the US
Inside
(core product)
Outside
(packaging)
European appeal
US appeal
US appeal
European appeal
Main challenge!
14
A broader – but still focused – product portfolio
Special,
unique
products
‘Mass’products
2006B 2010S
Today
Going
forward
Illustrative product
direction
Existing
products
Loafs
Creamy
Coffee
Liqueurs
Finished
concept
Mint sachet
Royal Tin
Ganache
Origins
New liqueurs
Examples
New ideas
Cocktails
Non-alcoholic
Chocolate
Therapy
Health
Raw marzipan
Private label
8
15
A regional approach
Washington
Oregon
California
Nevada
Idaho
Montana North Dakota
ArizonaNew Mexico
Texas
Oklahoma
Louisiana
South Dakota
Nebraska
Utah
Wyoming
Colorado Kansas Missouri
Arkansas
Missis-
sippi Alabama Georgia
Tennessee
KentuckyVirginia
West
Virginia
Illinois Indiana
Ohio
Iowa
Minnesota
Michigan
Wisconsin
Pennsylvania
New York
Maine
9
8
North Carolina
South
Carolina
Florida
3
Alaska
Hawaii
4
1. Maryland
2. Delaware
3. New Jersey
4. New York
5. Connecticut
6. Rhode Island
7. Massachusetts
8. New Hampshire
9. Vermont
Focus onspecific regions
Focus onnational chains
5
7
6
1 2
Where the consumers of high-end chocolate live
16
A number of channel alternatives exist
Low
High
Low High
Illustrative channel
opportunity
Fit with Anthon Berg image/positioning
Opportunity for
scale/volume
1
2a2b
3
4
5
6
8
Independent/specialty stores
Clubs / mass merchandisers
Walmart
Drugstores
Supermarkets
Department stores
Dollar discounters
Convenience
Internet
1
2a
2b
3
4
5
6
7
8
7?
Strategic channel alternative
9
17
Three channels are prioritized
Mass merchandisers and clubs
• Access to volume (strong Q4 sales) and they represent the least complicated business model:– Full truck loads– ‘Easy’ shipments– No listing fees/slotting fees
• We have proven that we can handle them• We get good product display and have full control over initial
product penetration
Rationale
Drugstores
• Access to volume business• Drugstores sell a lot of candy• Simple distribution• We get broad distribution leading to increase in brand
recognition• Drugstores have good image in consumers mind
Supermarkets
• Nationally large volumes• Longer listings• More brand recognition• We can get other products listed (more SKUs)
1
2
3
Key factors for success
• Right packaging• Right pricing• Ability to create for one region at
a time
• Ability to create power-wings• Right packaging and sell unit
sizes• Right pricing• Advertising money
• Ability to create a set of products (3 to 6 skus) to go into the confectionery set that will sell
• Slotting money• Advertising money
18
Mapping of potential customers
Other retailers
Existing
customer
Department
stores
• -
National
Existing
relations
Good fit – but
no contact (yet)
Mass
merchandisers
and clubs
Drug stores
Supermarkets
Existing
customer
• -
• -
Regional
Existing
relations
Good fit – but
no contact (yet)
• -
10
Agenda
1) Introduce Toms Group / Anthon Berg
2) Present Toms Group’s strategy for the US
3) Illustrate the complexities in setting up a US operation
4) Discuss key factors for success in the US
20
Our co-packing and distribution set-up
7
Comment
• Our two hubs are in principle located rightly to cater for customer requirements
• Besides our two hubs, we capitalize on the customers individual distribution centers
• We must continuously ensure that the transport costs represent best buy
US
Washington
Oregon
California
Nevada
Idaho
Montana North Dakota
ArizonaNew Mexico
Texas
Oklahoma
South Dakota
Utah
Wyoming
Colorado Kansas
Alaska
Hawaii
Nebraska
Georgia
Indiana
Michigan
Wisconsin
Florida
South
Carolina
Maine
Virginia
North Carolina
Louisiana
Missouri
Arkansas
Alabama
Iowa
Minnesota
Missis
-sippi
Kentucky
Illinois
Tennessee
Ohio
New York
Pennsylvania
West
Virginia
34
1
8
9
2
5 6
1. Maryland; 2. Delaware; 3. New Jersey; 4. New York; 5. Connecticut;
6. Rhode Island; 7. Massachusetts; 8 New Hampshire; 9. Vermont
11
21
Co-Packing in the US
22
Sales set-up prior to strategy
Set-up
EAB
Focus
Our exclusive importer
Just Clubs Consulting
Toms Group broker for Clubs
Club Store Link
Our ‘background’ consultant
Opportunity
Military, Ethnic distributors, major distributors, Cost Plus, every day distribution at national accounts
Costco, Sam’s Club & BJ’s
Costco
Rationale:
We saw a big potential for Anthon Berg which our distributor did not pursue
Considered changing distributor but the choice is limited due to a very small ratio of imported confectionery
12
23
Go-to-market sales strategies
Go-to-market sales strategies
Direct
• Broker/Agent
• Own subsidiary
• Direct from sales team in Denmark
• Joint venture/partner alliance with own staff locally
Indirect
• Importer/market distributor
• Channel distributor
• Regional distributor
• Distributor with product focus
Past preferred model
24
A two-facetted go-to-market strategy
Go-to-
market
model
Indirectly
Directly
Using EAB as an importer handling
regional distributors and smaller specialty customers
Handling selected national and regional accounts on our own or through a broker
Cooperation
13
25
Our focus
Direct Store Delivery (DSD)
Manufacturer
3rd Party DistributorDirect to Chain DC Delivery
Note: Many players distribute directory to the wholesale club store, as it is similar to a DC
We focus on two distribution models -but it is complex!
Manufacturer
Retailer DCs
Manufacturer
Importer
Internet
Internet
Channels:GrocerySpecialty StoresTheatres
GroceryMass MerchantsChain DrugWholesale Club
Convenience (C-store distributors)
Chain Drug, Mass, Traditional (Candy and Tobacco distributors)
Grocery (Wholesale Grocers)
Vending, Specialty Food, Foodservice (Specialty distributors)
Hub Hub
Retailer DCs
Regional distributor
More value-add activities in the US
More marketers ‘on the ground’ to handle customer requirements (e.g. packaging) and monitor operations
Show commitment to customers
26
Two different pricing/costing models
Go-to-
market
model
Indirectly
Directly
1,00
0,30
0,39
0,51
2,20
0,00
0,50
1,00
1,50
2,00
2,50
Toms Group price
Distributor/ importer
fee
Brokerfee
Retailer fee
Consumer price
0%
30%
30%
30%
1,00
0,00 0,15
0,69
1,84
0,00
0,50
1,00
1,50
2,00
Max
15%
Max
60%
Example in USD
Example in USD
Difference
0.36
Illustrative example
14
27
New set-up
Set-up
EAB
Focus
Our exclusive importer
Just ClubsConsulting
Toms Group broker for Clubs
Club Store Link Our ‘background’ consultant
Hanson & FasoToms Group broker for
Walgreens
Opportunity
Military, Ethnic distributors, major distributors, Cost Plus, every day distribution at national accounts
Costco, Sam’s Club & BJ’s
Costco
Walgreens
Anthon BergInc.
Direct business with national accounts
CVS, Rite Aid, Target, Whole Foods, Trader Joe’s, Starbucks etc.
28
Getting a clear distribution of responsibility in place
Mass merchandisers and clubs
Channel
Drugstores
Supermarkets
Department stores
Convenience
Regional distributors
Toms Group EAB
On certain accounts, we will work with EAB on a situation-by situation basis
Owns and is responsible
2007/08 2007/08
15
29
Consider forward
integration (acquisition of partner – own subsidiary)
Grow partner
Switch ‘entry mode’ into
own subsidiary (new
management is necessary)
Our partners are key for success –continuous evaluation is needed
Market Potential
LowPartner
performanceHigh
Market potential
Low
High
Maintain position
Grow Partner
Maintain
Get new partner
Maintain position
Consider ‘Low cost’mode
Exit
Partner evaluation model
30
Some advise on set-up
Set - up
• Investigate the right distribution set-up thoroughly – it is complex!
• Choose your partners with care – you must be able to trust them, but DO get a contract in place quickly
• Find the right partners – and pay them well! Incentive programs work
• Make sure your business is important to your partner
• Invest in training the key people at your partner
• Create strong relationships with your partners at all levels
• Do not give market exclusivity. Nobody can cover the whole market
• Evaluate your partners and distributors on a regular basis
• Commit to annual business plans and review them
• Choose partners who are specialists on the major retailers
16
Agenda
1) Introduce Toms Group / Anthon Berg
2) Present Toms Group’s strategy for the US
3) Illustrate the complexities in setting up a US operation
4) Discuss key factors for success in the US
32
What does it take?
KFS’s
• Be competitive – Optimize the value chain
• Find your niche – you can not compete with the multinationals on price! (Tailor made premium products)
• High quality and service level – remember long lead time
• Get commitment at executive level (capacity issues & production before PO’s)
• Be willing to take a risk – big volume
• Travel to the market often and build a strong network
• Invest in market research and understanding of the market
17
33
What does it take?
KFS’s
• Be patient & persistent – it takes time
• Don’t underestimate the cultural difference
• Understand what motivates people – ‘Money makes the world go around’
• Make sure to have the right legal advise (Contracts, product liability etc.)
• Remember, you are a very small player (you must do everything better than the multinationals)
• Be very well prepared
• Be reliable
The sky is the limit!