Punishment Driven Development #pdd

Louise Elliott@IvanaTerrorBull

#agileinthecity

When

Then

Who’s to blame?

An Experiment…

An Experiment…

Low High

Scenario 1

John is at a football game when he sees another fan, called Steve, wearing a scarf supporting the opposing team. John tells Steve to take the scarf off. Steve refuses and John hits him in the face.

Blamew

orthiness

Punishment

Bonus

Bonus

Bonus

Bonus

Bonus

Bonus

Why do we punish people?

Why do we punish people?

- To put other people off doing the same thing- So that the individual won’t do it again- For retribution- To compensate the victim

Scenario 2

John and Steve are hunting in the woods. Despite the fact that John has followed all safety rules his shotgun misfires, accidentally hitting Steve in the side. Steve dies before John can fetch help.

Blamew

orthiness

Punishment

Odd man out

Blame the BA

Scenario 3

John drives a security van containing money. One day Steve kidnaps John’s daughter and threatens to kill her if John doesn’t give Steve the money. John gives Steve the money from his van and his daughter is returned safely.

Blamew

orthiness

Punishment

Yes but…

Hansei

Scenario 4

John planned to kill his mother for the inheritance. He dragged her to bed and lit her oxygen mask with his cigarette, hoping to make it look like an accident. His mother’s clothes caught fire and she burnt to death.

Blamew

orthiness

Punishment

Self-punishment

Personal Kaizen

Angry man

Scenario 5

John and Steve are friends who share a competitive streak. They frequently play tennis together. One day when they are playing Steve easily defeats John 2 games in a row. In frustration, John returns the ball particularly hard and it hits Steve in the eye.

Blamew

orthiness

Punishment

(Buckholts et al, 2015)

(Buckholts et al, 2015)

Dorsolateral Prefrontal Cortex

over controlling people

over punishing mistakes

over putting others in their place

over changing their behaviour

People

People DrivenDevelopment

#pdd

linkedin.com/in/louiseelliott @IvanaTerrorBull

Louise Elliott