punctuation -- why it's interesting!ejb1/punct-park-st.pdf · punctuation old / modern...

36
Punctuation Punctuation – Why it’s Interesting! Park St. School, July, 2005

Upload: others

Post on 22-Aug-2020

7 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Punctuation -- Why it's Interesting!ejb1/punct-park-st.pdf · Punctuation Old / Modern Punctuation By which it appears, that except at the curve, marked A. where I took a trip to

Punctuation

Punctuation – Why it’s Interesting!

Park St. School, July, 2005

Page 2: Punctuation -- Why it's Interesting!ejb1/punct-park-st.pdf · Punctuation Old / Modern Punctuation By which it appears, that except at the curve, marked A. where I took a trip to

Punctuation

When?

Earth (5 BYA) 5 followed by 9 zerosLife (3 BYA) 3 followed by 9 zerosBipedal Hominids (8 – 5 MYA) 8 followed by 6 zerosSpeech (2 MYA – 50KYA) 2 followed by 6 zerosWriting (4 KYA) 4000 years agoPunctuation (2 KYA) 2000 years ago

Page 3: Punctuation -- Why it's Interesting!ejb1/punct-park-st.pdf · Punctuation Old / Modern Punctuation By which it appears, that except at the curve, marked A. where I took a trip to

Punctuation

The First Writing, 2000 BC

Page 4: Punctuation -- Why it's Interesting!ejb1/punct-park-st.pdf · Punctuation Old / Modern Punctuation By which it appears, that except at the curve, marked A. where I took a trip to

Punctuation

Anglo-Saxon, 500 AD

Page 5: Punctuation -- Why it's Interesting!ejb1/punct-park-st.pdf · Punctuation Old / Modern Punctuation By which it appears, that except at the curve, marked A. where I took a trip to

Punctuation

Transliteration / Translation

No/hwaethre aelmihtig. ealra wolde. Adam/e Euan.arna/ofteon. faeder aet frymthe. peah pe hie him fromswice. ac/he/him to/frofre. letaethere forthwesan.hyrstedne hrof. halgum tunglum. y/him grundwe-lan. ginne sealde. het/pam sinhiwum. saes/y eorthan.tuddorteondra. teohha gehwilcre. to/woruld nytte.waestmas. fedan.Yet the Almighty Father would not take away from Adam and fromEve, at once, all goodly things, though He withdrew His favourfrom them. But for their comfort He left the sky above themadorned with shining stars, gave them wide-stretching fields, andbade the earth and sea and all their teeming multitudes to bringforth fruits to serve man’s earthly need.

Page 6: Punctuation -- Why it's Interesting!ejb1/punct-park-st.pdf · Punctuation Old / Modern Punctuation By which it appears, that except at the curve, marked A. where I took a trip to

Punctuation

Transliteration / Translation

No/hwaethre aelmihtig. ealra wolde. Adam/e Euan.arna/ofteon. faeder aet frymthe. peah pe hie him fromswice. ac/he/him to/frofre. letaethere forthwesan.hyrstedne hrof. halgum tunglum. y/him grundwe-lan. ginne sealde. het/pam sinhiwum. saes/y eorthan.tuddorteondra. teohha gehwilcre. to/woruld nytte.waestmas. fedan.Yet the Almighty Father would not take away from Adam and fromEve, at once, all goodly things, though He withdrew His favourfrom them. But for their comfort He left the sky above themadorned with shining stars, gave them wide-stretching fields, andbade the earth and sea and all their teeming multitudes to bringforth fruits to serve man’s earthly need.

Page 7: Punctuation -- Why it's Interesting!ejb1/punct-park-st.pdf · Punctuation Old / Modern Punctuation By which it appears, that except at the curve, marked A. where I took a trip to

Punctuation

Printing / Literacy – Tristram Shandy 1760

Page 8: Punctuation -- Why it's Interesting!ejb1/punct-park-st.pdf · Punctuation Old / Modern Punctuation By which it appears, that except at the curve, marked A. where I took a trip to

Punctuation

Old / Modern Punctuation

By which it appears, that except at the curve, marked A. where Itook a trip to Navarre,—and the indented curve B. which is theshort airing when I was there with Lady Baussiere and her page,—Ihave not taken the least frisk of a digression...By which it appears that – except at the curve marked A., where Itook a trip to Navarre, and the indented curve B., which is theshort airing when I was there with Lady Baussiere and her page – Ihave not taken the least frisk of a digression...

Page 9: Punctuation -- Why it's Interesting!ejb1/punct-park-st.pdf · Punctuation Old / Modern Punctuation By which it appears, that except at the curve, marked A. where I took a trip to

Punctuation

Old / Modern Punctuation

By which it appears, that except at the curve, marked A. where Itook a trip to Navarre,—and the indented curve B. which is theshort airing when I was there with Lady Baussiere and her page,—Ihave not taken the least frisk of a digression...By which it appears that – except at the curve marked A., where Itook a trip to Navarre, and the indented curve B., which is theshort airing when I was there with Lady Baussiere and her page – Ihave not taken the least frisk of a digression...

Page 10: Punctuation -- Why it's Interesting!ejb1/punct-park-st.pdf · Punctuation Old / Modern Punctuation By which it appears, that except at the curve, marked A. where I took a trip to

Punctuation

Ambiguity: Word Boundaries

Isawaseesawontheseashore

Isawaseesawontheseashore

Isawaseesawontheseashore

I saw a seesaw on the sea shore

Page 11: Punctuation -- Why it's Interesting!ejb1/punct-park-st.pdf · Punctuation Old / Modern Punctuation By which it appears, that except at the curve, marked A. where I took a trip to

Punctuation

Ambiguity: Word Boundaries

Isawaseesawontheseashore

Isawaseesawontheseashore

Isawaseesawontheseashore

I saw a seesaw on the sea shore

Page 12: Punctuation -- Why it's Interesting!ejb1/punct-park-st.pdf · Punctuation Old / Modern Punctuation By which it appears, that except at the curve, marked A. where I took a trip to

Punctuation

Ambiguity: Word Boundaries

Isawaseesawontheseashore

Isawaseesawontheseashore

Isawaseesawontheseashore

I saw a seesaw on the sea shore

Page 13: Punctuation -- Why it's Interesting!ejb1/punct-park-st.pdf · Punctuation Old / Modern Punctuation By which it appears, that except at the curve, marked A. where I took a trip to

Punctuation

Ambiguity: Word Boundaries

Isawaseesawontheseashore

Isawaseesawontheseashore

Isawaseesawontheseashore

I saw a seesaw on the sea shore

Page 14: Punctuation -- Why it's Interesting!ejb1/punct-park-st.pdf · Punctuation Old / Modern Punctuation By which it appears, that except at the curve, marked A. where I took a trip to

Punctuation

Ambiguity: Garden Paths

Charles the First walked and talked half an hour after his headwas cut off

Charles the First walked and talked. Half an hour after, hishead was cut off.

I told the girl that the boy kissed a story

I told the girl that the boy kissed, a story.I told the girl who the boy kissed a story.

Page 15: Punctuation -- Why it's Interesting!ejb1/punct-park-st.pdf · Punctuation Old / Modern Punctuation By which it appears, that except at the curve, marked A. where I took a trip to

Punctuation

Ambiguity: Garden Paths

Charles the First walked and talked half an hour after his headwas cut off

Charles the First walked and talked. Half an hour after, hishead was cut off.

I told the girl that the boy kissed a story

I told the girl that the boy kissed, a story.I told the girl who the boy kissed a story.

Page 16: Punctuation -- Why it's Interesting!ejb1/punct-park-st.pdf · Punctuation Old / Modern Punctuation By which it appears, that except at the curve, marked A. where I took a trip to

Punctuation

Ambiguity: Garden Paths

Charles the First walked and talked half an hour after his headwas cut off

Charles the First walked and talked. Half an hour after, hishead was cut off.

I told the girl that the boy kissed a story

I told the girl that the boy kissed, a story.I told the girl who the boy kissed a story.

Page 17: Punctuation -- Why it's Interesting!ejb1/punct-park-st.pdf · Punctuation Old / Modern Punctuation By which it appears, that except at the curve, marked A. where I took a trip to

Punctuation

Ambiguity: Garden Paths

Charles the First walked and talked half an hour after his headwas cut off

Charles the First walked and talked. Half an hour after, hishead was cut off.

I told the girl that the boy kissed a story

I told the girl that the boy kissed, a story.I told the girl who the boy kissed a story.

Page 18: Punctuation -- Why it's Interesting!ejb1/punct-park-st.pdf · Punctuation Old / Modern Punctuation By which it appears, that except at the curve, marked A. where I took a trip to

Punctuation

Punctuation and Speech

Without her contributions to the school would be small.

Without her, contributions to the school would be small.

My great-great-great-great-grandfather | was a jockey.

My great-great-great-great grandfather, was a jockey.

The girl fell | the boy pushed her.

The girl fell – the boy pushed her.

The girl fell. The boy pushed her.

Page 19: Punctuation -- Why it's Interesting!ejb1/punct-park-st.pdf · Punctuation Old / Modern Punctuation By which it appears, that except at the curve, marked A. where I took a trip to

Punctuation

Punctuation and Speech

Without her contributions to the school would be small.

Without her, contributions to the school would be small.

My great-great-great-great-grandfather | was a jockey.

My great-great-great-great grandfather, was a jockey.

The girl fell | the boy pushed her.

The girl fell – the boy pushed her.

The girl fell. The boy pushed her.

Page 20: Punctuation -- Why it's Interesting!ejb1/punct-park-st.pdf · Punctuation Old / Modern Punctuation By which it appears, that except at the curve, marked A. where I took a trip to

Punctuation

Punctuation and Speech

Without her contributions to the school would be small.

Without her, contributions to the school would be small.

My great-great-great-great-grandfather | was a jockey.

My great-great-great-great grandfather, was a jockey.

The girl fell | the boy pushed her.

The girl fell – the boy pushed her.

The girl fell. The boy pushed her.

Page 21: Punctuation -- Why it's Interesting!ejb1/punct-park-st.pdf · Punctuation Old / Modern Punctuation By which it appears, that except at the curve, marked A. where I took a trip to

Punctuation

Punctuation and Speech

Without her contributions to the school would be small.

Without her, contributions to the school would be small.

My great-great-great-great-grandfather | was a jockey.

My great-great-great-great grandfather, was a jockey.

The girl fell | the boy pushed her.

The girl fell – the boy pushed her.

The girl fell. The boy pushed her.

Page 22: Punctuation -- Why it's Interesting!ejb1/punct-park-st.pdf · Punctuation Old / Modern Punctuation By which it appears, that except at the curve, marked A. where I took a trip to

Punctuation

Punctuation and Speech

Without her contributions to the school would be small.

Without her, contributions to the school would be small.

My great-great-great-great-grandfather | was a jockey.

My great-great-great-great grandfather, was a jockey.

The girl fell | the boy pushed her.

The girl fell – the boy pushed her.

The girl fell. The boy pushed her.

Page 23: Punctuation -- Why it's Interesting!ejb1/punct-park-st.pdf · Punctuation Old / Modern Punctuation By which it appears, that except at the curve, marked A. where I took a trip to

Punctuation

Punctuation and Speech

Without her contributions to the school would be small.

Without her, contributions to the school would be small.

My great-great-great-great-grandfather | was a jockey.

My great-great-great-great grandfather, was a jockey.

The girl fell | the boy pushed her.

The girl fell – the boy pushed her.

The girl fell. The boy pushed her.

Page 24: Punctuation -- Why it's Interesting!ejb1/punct-park-st.pdf · Punctuation Old / Modern Punctuation By which it appears, that except at the curve, marked A. where I took a trip to

Punctuation

Punctuation and Speech

Without her contributions to the school would be small.

Without her, contributions to the school would be small.

My great-great-great-great-grandfather | was a jockey.

My great-great-great-great grandfather, was a jockey.

The girl fell | the boy pushed her.

The girl fell – the boy pushed her.

The girl fell. The boy pushed her.

Page 25: Punctuation -- Why it's Interesting!ejb1/punct-park-st.pdf · Punctuation Old / Modern Punctuation By which it appears, that except at the curve, marked A. where I took a trip to

Punctuation

Ambiguity: Meaning

The teacher who I met at the parents’ evening was very polite.

The teacher, who I met at the parents’ evening, was verypolite.

the teacher returned the homework cried

??The teacher, returned the homework, cried.

The teacher who was returned the homework cried.

Page 26: Punctuation -- Why it's Interesting!ejb1/punct-park-st.pdf · Punctuation Old / Modern Punctuation By which it appears, that except at the curve, marked A. where I took a trip to

Punctuation

Ambiguity: Meaning

The teacher who I met at the parents’ evening was very polite.

The teacher, who I met at the parents’ evening, was verypolite.

the teacher returned the homework cried

??The teacher, returned the homework, cried.

The teacher who was returned the homework cried.

Page 27: Punctuation -- Why it's Interesting!ejb1/punct-park-st.pdf · Punctuation Old / Modern Punctuation By which it appears, that except at the curve, marked A. where I took a trip to

Punctuation

Ambiguity: Meaning

The teacher who I met at the parents’ evening was very polite.

The teacher, who I met at the parents’ evening, was verypolite.

the teacher returned the homework cried

??The teacher, returned the homework, cried.

The teacher who was returned the homework cried.

Page 28: Punctuation -- Why it's Interesting!ejb1/punct-park-st.pdf · Punctuation Old / Modern Punctuation By which it appears, that except at the curve, marked A. where I took a trip to

Punctuation

Ambiguity: Meaning

The teacher who I met at the parents’ evening was very polite.

The teacher, who I met at the parents’ evening, was verypolite.

the teacher returned the homework cried

??The teacher, returned the homework, cried.

The teacher who was returned the homework cried.

Page 29: Punctuation -- Why it's Interesting!ejb1/punct-park-st.pdf · Punctuation Old / Modern Punctuation By which it appears, that except at the curve, marked A. where I took a trip to

Punctuation

Ambiguity: Meaning

The teacher who I met at the parents’ evening was very polite.

The teacher, who I met at the parents’ evening, was verypolite.

the teacher returned the homework cried

??The teacher, returned the homework, cried.

The teacher who was returned the homework cried.

Page 30: Punctuation -- Why it's Interesting!ejb1/punct-park-st.pdf · Punctuation Old / Modern Punctuation By which it appears, that except at the curve, marked A. where I took a trip to

Punctuation

Ambiguity: Meaning

The teacher who I met at the parents’ evening was very polite.

The teacher, who I met at the parents’ evening, was verypolite.

the teacher returned the homework cried

??The teacher, returned the homework, cried.

The teacher who was returned the homework cried.

Page 31: Punctuation -- Why it's Interesting!ejb1/punct-park-st.pdf · Punctuation Old / Modern Punctuation By which it appears, that except at the curve, marked A. where I took a trip to

Punctuation

Ambiguity: Meaning

The teacher who I met at the parents’ evening was very polite.

The teacher, who I met at the parents’ evening, was verypolite.

the teacher returned the homework cried

??The teacher, returned the homework, cried.

The teacher who was returned the homework cried.

Page 32: Punctuation -- Why it's Interesting!ejb1/punct-park-st.pdf · Punctuation Old / Modern Punctuation By which it appears, that except at the curve, marked A. where I took a trip to

Punctuation

Ambiguity: Meaning

The teacher who I met at the parents’ evening was very polite.

The teacher, who I met at the parents’ evening, was verypolite.

the teacher returned the homework cried

??The teacher, returned the homework, cried.

The teacher who was returned the homework cried.

Page 33: Punctuation -- Why it's Interesting!ejb1/punct-park-st.pdf · Punctuation Old / Modern Punctuation By which it appears, that except at the curve, marked A. where I took a trip to

Punctuation

Ambiguity: Meaning

The teacher who I met at the parents’ evening was very polite.

The teacher, who I met at the parents’ evening, was verypolite.

the teacher returned the homework cried

??The teacher, returned the homework, cried.

The teacher who was returned the homework cried.

Page 34: Punctuation -- Why it's Interesting!ejb1/punct-park-st.pdf · Punctuation Old / Modern Punctuation By which it appears, that except at the curve, marked A. where I took a trip to

Punctuation

Ambiguity: Meaning

The teacher who I met at the parents’ evening was very polite.

The teacher, who I met at the parents’ evening, was verypolite.

the teacher returned the homework cried

??The teacher, returned the homework, cried.

The teacher who was returned the homework cried.

Page 35: Punctuation -- Why it's Interesting!ejb1/punct-park-st.pdf · Punctuation Old / Modern Punctuation By which it appears, that except at the curve, marked A. where I took a trip to

Punctuation

Jane Straus, The Blue Book of Grammar and Punctuation

9)a)Paul Simon sang, ”I am a rock, I am an island.”b)Paul Simon sang, ”I am a rock; I am an island.”c)Paul Simon sang, I am a rock; I am an island.d)Paul Simon sang I am a rock, I am an island.You must have studied hard. Good job!Sorry, the correct answer is xA Punctuation Test

Page 36: Punctuation -- Why it's Interesting!ejb1/punct-park-st.pdf · Punctuation Old / Modern Punctuation By which it appears, that except at the curve, marked A. where I took a trip to

Punctuation

Lynne Truss, Eats, Shoots and Leaves

It was a dark stormy night., / No commaThe Punctuation Game