public meeting and hearing presentation · 2020. 9. 5. · skype meeting controls .,_ ft . w~ ea~...
TRANSCRIPT
Welcome
Chlor-Alkali Superfund Site Public Meeting & Hearing
Wednesday, June 10, 2020
7 PM
Skype Meeting Controls
ft EA~ United Stares .,_w~ Environmental Protection ,,.,. Agency
Chlor·-Alkali
Super·fund Site Public Meeti11g and Hear·ing For technical assistance with
Skype, contact Rosa Beato at
617-918-1940
leavethe Call
7
Case Team Introductions
For EPA:
• Melissa Taylor, EPA Section Chief, NH/RI Superfund Section
• Darryl Luce, EPA Project Manager for the Chlor-Alkali Superfund Site
• Sarah White, EPA Community Involvement Coordinator
• Rosa Beato, IT support
For NHDES:
Drew Hoffman, NHDES Site Manager
Robin Mongeon, NHDES Federal Sites Section Supervisor
Agenda
• Description of Meeting/Hearing Purpose and Scope
• Participant Instructions for Public Meeting
• Public Meeting Portion followed by a Question and Answer Session
• Participant Instructions for Formal Public Hearing
• Formal Public Hearing (will be recorded)
• Closure of Public Hearing
• How to submit comments
Public Meeting and Formal Public Hearing Description and Scope
EPA is having this Public Meeting and Hearing to:
1. Describe the different options or alternatives EPA evaluated for the cleanup of the Chlor Alkali site and present EPA’s preferred alternative; and
2. To accept oral public comments on this proposed cleanup plan during the Formal Public Hearing, which will become part of the Public Record.
The Public Comment Period to provide comments started on June 3, 2020 and will run through July 3, 2020. EPA is seeking input on all the alternatives and the rationale for the preferred alternative.
Your lines will be muted during the presentation to minimize background noise.
Presentation will be followed by a question and answer period.
The Moderator will take questions via Skype (through the chat box or for those wishing to speak their question). You may enter your question in the chat box at any time during the presentation.
The phone lines will then be opened for any questions
When speaking your question, remember to unmute before speaking and then mute your line after your question
Since the Public Hearing that follows the question and answer period will be the forum used to solicit comment, please limit your questions to clarification questions on the presentation only
Public Meeting Participant Instructions
- ,---
-
Chlor-Alkali Facility (former) Superfund Site Berlin, New Hampshire
Legend
0 200
F
Androscoggin River Risk
• Sediment and surface water
are clean and pose no risk.
• No adverse effect to wildlife.
• Eating Fish from the River
poses a risk to the public.
SOIL CONTAMINANTS AND RISK AT THE CHLOR-ALKALI SITE
Cell House Landfill contents: Benzo(a)pyrene, Dioxin/Furan, and Mercury. Future unacceptable risk to public health if cap fails and landfill contents exposed. No Current risk.
Eastern Facility Study Area soils: Polyaromatic Hydrocarbons (PAHs), Dioxin/Furans, and mercury. Present in hotspots. Current unacceptable risk to public health (Trespassers, Workers). Future unacceptable risk to residents.
Southern Facility Study Area soils: Similar to EFSA: hotspot occurrences and contaminants but includes PCBs, lead, arsenic, and chromium. Risk similar to that in the EFSA.
o ....
0
.~ i '
-------------------------------------------------------------- ' -----------~ ------------ ------------------------~J------------I I I I
Contaminated Groundwater at the Chlor-Alkali Site • The primary contaminants are
Volatile Organic Compounds that include Chloroform, Carbon disulfide, and Trichloroethene.
• Inorganic contaminants include Mercury, Arsenic, Lead and Manganese.
• Contaminants within the CHP Landfill are not migrating to the river.
• GROUNDWATER USE AS DRINKING WATER POSES AN UNACCEPTABLE RISK.
Mercury Plume Summary Volatile Organic Plume Summary
EPA’s Evaluation of Remedial Alternatives
Threshold Criteria
• Protection of Human Health and the Environment.
• Compliance with Applicable and Relevant or Appropriate Requirements (ARARs).
Balancing Criteria
• Long-term effectiveness and permanence.
• Reduction of toxicity, mobility or volume through treatment.
• Short-term effectiveness.
• Implementability.
• Cost.
> State & Community Acceptance.
FOUR AREAS OF CONTAMINATION AND THE REMEDIAL ALTERNATIVES
1. CHP Landfill contents
• No-Action
• Maintain & Monitor existing cap
2. Androscoggin River mercury
• No-Action
• Keep recovering mercury
3. Groundwater outside the Landfill
• No-Action
• Treat contaminants in the aquifer
4. Hotspot soil contamination in the Southern & Eastern Facility Study Areas
• No-Action
• Fencing and deed restrictions
• Soil cap and deed restrictions
• Excavation and removal
• Off-Site disposal at an approved facility
• On-Site disposal beneath the existing landfill cap
* Green shading denotes EPA’s proposed remedy for each of the contaminated areas.
J',--------------------------------------------,
EP A's Remedial Alternatives fo1· the Areas of Contamination at the Site
EPA's remedy evaluation c1ite1ia Overall Protection of Human Health and the Environment Compliance with ARARs Long-term effectiveness and
ermanence Reduction of toxicity, mobility or volume throu h treatment Shoi1-term effectiveness Ability to Implement
= ·-Q
...-... Maintain ~~ &I ..._,, = l\ilonitor z
Landfill
V
Contaminated Ground,vater
Monitor T1·eat Inside Outside
Landfill Landfill
Contaminated Soil Install Excavate
Fence & Soil & Restrict Cap, Remove
V V
V
V V V V V V
V V V V V V V V V
Community and State Acceptance will be determined after the comment period Cost (in thousands) $0 $720 1,200 $900 $1 ,600 $285 $700 $560
* ,Green shading denotes EPA 's proposed remedy f or each of the contaminated areas.
V indicates that the altemati, e nieets that criterion - blanks indicate the alternati, e does not meet that criterion
NEXT STEPS • July 3, 2020: the public
comment period closes.
• September 2020: EPA expects to issue a cleanup decision in a Record of Decision.
• Winter 2020/2021: EPA begins scoping remedial design/ remedial action.
QUESTIONS ?
Use Chat/Conversation box in Skype to submit Questions and Comments on Presentation
If unable to view the Chat box, click on the chat icon, located on the bottom left corner from the Skype presentation, as shown here➔
EPA Public Hearing Chlor-Alkali Superfund site
Wednesday, June 10, 2020
" "
Participant Instructions for the Public Hearing
The Hearing will be recorded to become a part of the public record.
EPA will be accepting comments only. EPA will not respond to comments or questions during the Hearing.
If you would like to speak, type “I’d like to make an oral comment” in the Skype chat box to cue the Moderator.
The Moderator will read your name.
When you hear your name, unmute your line to speak.
Identify yourself and your address or your association (contractor, City Official, etc.) and then make your oral comment.
We will open up the phone line for oral comments once comments on Skype have been received. Please follow the same process for identifying yourself.
EPA WILL NOT be responding to comments taken during the Hearing but will provide responses in the Record of Decision.
How to submit comments on EPA’s Proposed Plan
30 Day comment period. EPA will accept comments until July 3, 2020
Send your comments via:
Mail: Darryl Luce,
US EPA Region 1;
5 Post Office Square,
Mail Code: SEMD 07-01
Boston, MA 02109
FAX: 617-918-0336 Email: [email protected]
EPA voice mail box: Phone number: 617-918-1122.
Copies of the Proposed Plan and other information regarding the
Chlor-Alkali Facility (former) Superfund Site may be found at:
www.epa.gov/superfund/chloralkali