pt primo indo ikan semester report of seafood savers ......this district contributes 22% to the...

PT Primo Indo Ikan Semester Report of Seafood Savers Membership

Summary of Improvement Development of tuna in Larantuka, Indonesia (May 2017 – October 2017)

Saraswati Adityarini - Capture Fisheries Officer for Skipjack, Tuna and Tuna Like Commodities

General Information 1. Location : East Flores District

First Survey : December 5th, 2017

Second Survey : October 8th, 2018

Numbers of Fish : The total number of fleets in skipjack and yellowfin tuna fishing that are recorded as parts of PT

Primo Indo Ikan supply chain is 17

2. Fishing Method

- Minimum harvest size : Yellowfin Tuna is 20Kg/, skipjack is 1 kg/ ekor

- Fishing method : Pole and Line; Handline

- Price Range : IDR 15.000/Kg for skipjack and IDR 45.000/Kg for tuna

The fish trading is directly done from the fishers to the company. The flow is the captain of pole and line informs PT Primo Indo Ikan that the fishers

are able to provide fish and vessel is ready to be landed. The staff and the PIC from QC division will go to the fishing base located in PPI Amagarapati

and have the transaction in the deck. During the transaction process, staff of PT Primo Indo will measure, record catch result data and make individual

tagging consisting of date entering the vessel, name of vessel, fish number, weight, grade, the type of product and line of vessel. Meanwhile, due to

the more number of catch result of skipjack, the tagging is done right after the fish is stored in cold storage in the factory. The grading process is

based on the quality of measured fish. After this process, the catch result is distributed to the factory taking around 45 minutes.

3. Capacity of Production

Based on the capture fisheries statistics of Nusa Tenggara Timur (NTT) Province in 2016 the skipjack production in East Flores District reached 935

tons and 418 tons for yellowfin tuna. This district contributes 22% to the skipjack production and 14% to yellowfin tuna production in Nusa Tenggara

Timur. During May – December 2017, the skipjack production of PT Primo Indo Ikan is 721.582 kg and yellow fin tuna is 19.212 kg with 891 trips.

Comparing the production data of PT Primo Indo Ikan with the production data of the East Flores statistics data, PT Primo Indo Ikan contributed 77%

to the skipjack production and 5% to the yellowfin tuna production.

4. Additional Information

a. A BMP-skipjack and Data Compliance training was held on December 5th, 2017 attended by 23 fishers of PT Primo Indo Ikan with the average

pre-test score was 56.7 and post-test 69.6. In addition, there was increasing score of knowledge on skipjack fishing techniques using pole and

line fishing gear 19% with compliance score was 63.65%.

b. PT Primo Indo Ikan has recorded the catch result data using logbook format provided by the government and submitted the mandatory Catch

Certificate document. In the following years, PT Primo Indo Ikan will strengthen the logbook record method more than at fisher level.

c. The Indonesian Constitution Number 23 Year 2014 obligating companies to have permit issued by the Fisheries Office of Nusa Tenggara Timur

affects the vessel permit for pole and line fishing gear in Larantuka causing an inefficient time, effort and cost. Meanwhile, there is no

representative of the Fisheries Office of NTT Province to solve the problem. In addition, the Fisheries Office of East Flores District does not

have authority either to issue vessel permit or other documents required in the pole and line fishing practice.

No Name of Fleet Tonnage Measurement Number

1 Yulien 01 GT. 26 No. 1164/Mma

2 Flotim 33 GT. 22 No. 85/OOf

3 Inka 698 GT.30 No. 56/00a

4 Flotim 12B GT. 22 No. 82/OOf

5 Flotim19 GT.22 No.10/00f

6 Ard 07 GT 20 No. 57/OOf

7 NB 47 Delvino GT. 6 No. 761/K.41

8 NB 28/ Deo Gratia GT. 13 No. 113/00f


10 NB 63 GT. 13 No. 112/OOf

11 Bahtera Flotim 3-13 GT. 19 No.6966/Bc

12 NB 119 GT. 13 No. 121/OOf

13 Bahtera Flotim 2-13 GT. 19 No.6965/Bc


15 Flotim31 GT. 22 No. 88/Oof

16 Bahtera Krukab GT. 26 No. 496/Ab

17 Anugerah Mina 09 GT. 13 No. 105/OOf

Detail Evaluation of PT Primo Indo Ikan Membership on the Implementation of Fisheries Improvement Program (FIP):

DETAIL ACTION (for the Seafood Savers member)

OUTPUT AND INDICATOR FOR DETAIL ACTION

(for the Seafood Savers member)

ACTION LEAD & PARTNERS

SEAFOOD SAVERS

stage EVALUATION RESULT

FOLLOW UP PLAN / ISSUE

INTERMEDIATE

1. Logbook data collection (CPUE analysis) is continued for handline and pole and line fishing gear *LINK 1.2.3 A,B Preliminary action of data collection :

identifying the vessels of PT Primo Indo Ikan which uses handline pole and line fishing gear

identifying whether any vessel of PT Primo Indo Ikan is listed in RFMO

Logbook data is available and updated periodically. The data covers (target and non-target): - weight - length tuna - bycatch - bait - maturity of gonad - number of fleets (effort) - composition catch of handline and pole and line

PIC : WWF-Indonesia PIV : PT Primo Indo Ikan Action : Nelayan anggota

PT Primo Indo Ikan Larantuka PT Primo Indo Ikan has recorded the catch result data using logbook format provided by the government and submitted the mandatory Catch Certificate document. In the following years, PT Primo Indo Ikan will strengthen the logbook record method more than at fisher level.

Improving the logbook record of fishers of PT Primo Indo Ikan

2. Correlating the logbook data with data of The Fisheries of NTT Province *LINK 1.2.3 A,B

The logbook data is listed in the statistic data of East Flores Fisheries Office and NTT to support the availability of

WWF-Indonesia, Fisheries Office of NTT, Fisheries Office of East Flores

The involvement is not directly, but PT Primo Indo Ikan has reported logbook to have the

Meeting to synchronize and integrate logbook with the fisheries data report scheme from the fisher level to district and province level is required.

Correlating the intern logbook form with the logbook of the Fisheries Office of Province and National Committee on Fish Stock Assessment

regional and provincial fisheries statistic document

mandatory Catch Certificate.

3. Advocation to the Fisheries Offices of East Flores district to provide enumerator for tuna data collection *LINK 1.2.3 C

Logbook is done by the local government

Fisheries Offices of East Flores, Fisheries Offices of NTT,WWF-Indonesia

Has not been fully implemented

Meeting to synchronize and integrate logbook with the fisheries data report scheme from the fisher level to district and province level is required.

1. Conducting socialization to all fishers about: a.Ministerial Decree of Marine and Fisheries Number 107 Year 2015 about RPP-TCT and its letter b. Ministerial Decree 47/2016 * the coverage of fisher is bigger and better *LINK 1.2.2 B, 1.2.3 C, 2.3.2.B - integrating fishing practice accordingly with the harvest control rule and harvest strategy in the FMA 713 by the sub-directorate of ZEEI - to all vessels operating in FMA 573 aiming to make them follow the control rule mechanism of IOTC if the vessels are already listed and the control mechanism

Tuna fishers know, understand and implement all regulation stated on the Ministerial Decree of Marine and Fisheries Number 107 Year 2015 about RPP-TCT and its letter

Fisheries Offices of East Flores, Fisheries Offices of NTT, WWF-Indonesia, Advisory Agency, PT Primo Indo Ikan


A meeting to socialize fishers of PT Primo Indo Ikan to implement regulation stated on the Ministerial Decree of Marine and Fisheries Number 107 Year 2015

is available and adopted by the Indonesian government

1. Consulting the harvest strategy of tuna target (compiled in P1.1.1) at stakeholder level. *LINK 3.1.1

The rules of utilization strategy for targeted shrimp supported by fishermen covers: (1) reducing utilization plan if the stock status is reaching reference point limit, (2) adopting the uncertainties principles and precautionary approach (3)regular evaluation mechanism towards management performance done by related internal and external stakeholder and (4) short term and long term objectives.

Fisheries Offices of East Flores, Fisheries Offices of NTT, Fishers


A meeting to discuss action plan of PT Primo Indo Ikan and to gain inputs and agreement between stakeholders.

2. The company issues an internal policy to only buy tuna from handline fishing gear based on the rules in the harvest strategy document. *LINK 1.2.1, 1.2.3 C, 2.3.2.B

An internal policy to only buy tuna from handline fishing gear based on the rules in the harvest strategy document is available.

PT Primo Indo Ikan

An internal policy about catch result regulation is available. The minimum catch result for skipjack is 1kg, while yellowfin tuna is 20 kg.

A National Harvest strategy for skipjack and tuna is available and going to be socialized and adopted.

1. Drafting a protocol of data collection (supporting activities 1.1.1)

Protocol of data collection agreed by the National Committee on Fish Stock Assessment, Pusriskan, The Fisheries Offices at Province and District level.

WWF Data form use the logbook form of Ministerial Decree 28/2014, but is at industrial level.

The data form is developed based on the fishing scale of pole and line fleets in East Flores District which later on being discussed and agreed by the National Committee on Fish Stock Assessment, Pusriskan,

The Fisheries Offices at Province and District level.

2. Data collection is regularly conducted *LINK 1.1.1. A,B

Scientific data is available Fishers, Fisheries Offices at Province level, NTT

The company get involved in several stock research including stock estimation and harvest strategy analysis by regularly collecting data as well.

The company is participating to some researches supporting this action plan.

3. Internal policy of the company obligating middlemen to provide tuna catch result document in the transaction process with the company *LINK 1.1.1 C

Record document is attached in every transaction between the company and middlemen

PT Primo Indo Ikan

The company has implemented the record system done by the fishers without involving middlemen and ownership of a complete document and vessel permit

The company will have internal policy to strengthen the record and report system of the fishers.

Conducting an assessment on the aspects of Principle 1.2.4

Result of assessment is available

WWF Indonesia learning center

The company has contributed to data collection for tuna’s bait species stock analysis assessment

1. Conducting RBF assessment for primary species from the tuna fishing (relevant with 1.1.1)

The availability of primary species productivity’s information (average of age and size of gonad, average of maximum age and size, fecundity, reproduction strategy, tropic level) and targeted shrimp susceptibility (overlap areal, overlap vertical, selectivity, post-harvest death)


The company has contributed to data collection for RBF assessment of primary species of skipjack using pole and line in East Flores District done by Kristen Artha Wacana Kupang University

The assessment result will be disseminated and consulted publicly in East Flores District

2. Conducting public consultation to assess the susceptibility of primary species towards overfishing (PSA assessment) relevant with 1.1.1

Information about susceptibility status towards overfishing and it management strategy


Has not been implemented

Will be conducted in an appointed time discussed in the action plan meeting with all related stakeholders in East Flores District.

Relevant with P1.1.1., primary species has been assessed by RBF assessment and the result is inserted in the harvest strategy document

Recommendation result is included in the harvest strategy document

Learning Center, Fishers, Fisheries Offcice of East Flores District and NTT



Public consultation on the recommendation result of RBF assessment )relevant with P1.1.1) this public consultation is supported by regulation and or assessment related to primary species in pole and line and handline fishing practice

Recommendation for management is agreed by all stakeholders




Conducting RBF assessment (PSA, SICA, CSA) towards primary species (relevant with RBF assessment conducted for P1.1.1.)

Recommendation for management is available based on RBF assessment relevant with P1.1.1


Has been conducted and the company had contributed to the data collection process for RBF assessment of primary species, skipjack pole and line in East Flores done by Kristen Artha Wacana Kupang University


Public consultation on the recommendation result of RBF assessment )relevant with P1.1.1)





1. Conducting RBF assessment for secondary species from the tuna fishing (relevant with 1.1.1) Including bait

The availability of secondary species productivity’s information (average of age and size of gonad, average of maximum age and size, fecundity, reproduction strategy, tropic level) and targeted shrimp susceptibility (overlap areal, overlap vertical, selectivity, post-harvest death)


RBF assessment for secondary species and bait has not been conducted


2. Conducting public consultation to assess the susceptibility of secondary species towards overfishing (PSA assessment) relevant with 1.1.1

Information about susceptibility status towards overfishing and the management strategy




Relevant with P1.1.1., secondary species has been assessed by RBF assessment and the result is inserted in the harvest strategy document

Recommendation result is included in the harvest strategy document




Public consultation on the recommendation result of RBF assessment) relevant with P1.1.1





Conducting RBF assessment (PSA, SICA, CSA) towards primary species (relevant with RBF assessment conducted for P1.1.1.)

Recommendation for management is available based on RBF assessment relevant with P1.1.1




Public consultation on the recommendation result of RBF assessment )relevant with P1.1.1


Learning Center, Fishers, Fisheries Offcice


Will be conducted in an appointed time discussed in the action plan meeting with all

of East Flores District and NTT

related stakeholders in East Flores District.

Conducting biological assessment of ETP species in FMA 713 and 573

The availability of ETP species productivity’s information (average of age and size of gonad, average of maximum age and size, fecundity, reproduction strategy, tropic level) and targeted shrimp susceptibility (overlap areal, overlap vertical, selectivity, post-harvest death)

University, Fishers



2. Conducting public consultation to assess the susceptibility of ETP species towards overfishing (PSA assessment) relevant with 1.1.1

Information about susceptibility status towards overfishing and the management strategy

University, WWF, Fishers, Fisheries Offcice of East Flores District



Conducting academic research to draft management strategy for ETP species *LINK 2.3.3

Academic research to draft management strategy for ETP species and its stock recovery system is available

University, WWF



Consulting the draft od ETP species management regulation at fishers level

The ETP species management regulation is supported by fishers

WWF, University, Fishers


Will be implemented after the academic research for ETP species management strategy is conducted

Consulting the draft od ETP species management regulation at regional level *LINK 2.4.2 C

The ETP species management regulation is agreed at regional level

WWF, University, Fishers, Fisheries Offices of East Flores District



Encouraging the availability of regulation about ETP species management at district level

Regulation about ETP species management is available

WWF, University, Fishers, Fisheries Offices of East Flores District



Conducting catch composition research based on the available logbook data mentioning the existence of caught ETP species *LINK 2.3.2.A

Catch composition report based on the available logbook data mentioning the existence of caught ETP species is available

University, WWF



Conducting RBF assessment towards the impact of target tuna species caught using handline fishing gear

A scientific report about the impact of target tuna species caught using handline fishing gear

Learning Center Has not been implemented


Socializing the regulation about habitat management at fisher level based on the RBF assessment result in point 2.4.1

The habitat management regulation is supported by the fishers

WWF, PT Primo Indo Ikan , University, Fishers



Consulting the draft of habitat management regulation at KKPN Laut Sawu level

The draft is approved at the KKPN Laut Sawu level




Encouraging the availability of regulation about the related habitat management at KKPN Laut Sawu level

A regulation supporting the habitat management is available




*LINK 2.3.2C,D

Conducting RBF (CSA- Consequence Spatial Analysis)) assessment towards the impact of tuna target fishing activity caught using handline

A scientific report about the impact of tuna target fishing activity caught using handline



Conducting RBF assessment towards the ecosystem status

A scientific report about the ecosystem status of RBF assessment is available



Conducting public consultation to assess the ecosystem of tuna target using RBF (SICA)

An information about ecosystem status of tuna target and it management strategy is available

Learning Center, Fishers, WWF, Fisheries Offcice of East Flores District and NTT



Conducting public consultation about zonation

Legality of prohibited zone and the zonation map of tuna harvest is available

Learning Center, Fishers, WWF, Fisheries Offcice of East Flores District and NTT



Socializing the prohibited zone to all local communities including providing the communication tools (billboard, poster, pamflet)

The local communities understand and comply with the prohibited zone regulation

Learning Center, Fishers, Fisheries Offcice of East Flores District and NTT, WWF and PT Primo Indo Ikan



Conducting data collection assessment periodically

A scientific report about the the impact of targeted shrimp harvest towards the main ecosystem (main trophy, predator, competitor, community composition) based on biennial periodic data is available

University, Fishers, WWF



1. Conducting the advocation process of baits in Larantuka to the Fisheries Offices at District and Province level 2. Encouraging the registration of Rumpon or Fish Aggregating Devices based on the regulation of Indonesian MMAF particularly related to amnesty which is going to be implemented in 2018

Learning center, WWF



Strengthening the capacity of fishers in the fisheries management *LINK 3.2.3

1. The legality of fisher group in East Flores is available 2. The legality of fisheries practice is available (registered document, fishing permit and logbook record) 3. The availability of fisheries management scheme besides monitoring the harvesting area of tuna fishers in East Flores

WWF PT Primo Indo Ikan

The company strongly supports the efforts of completing documents

The company will establish an internal policy to strengthen the record and report scheme of the fishers

Strengthening the role of KKPN Laut Sawu trough team building and training on sustainable fisheries management as an agency for tuna management in East Flores and its surrounding area

Improvement of the role and leadership of KKPN Laut Sawu as an agency for tuna management

WWF PT Primo Indo Ikan



Encouraging the establishment of POKMASWAS (Community Surveillance Group) at KKPN Laut Sawu level *LINK 3.1.2

Community Surveillance Group (POKMASWAS) at district/regional level which has monitoring scheme, regulation and surveillance on shrimp fishing management as well as authority to enforce the rules is established

WWF Fisheries Office at District Level, Fisheries, PT Primo Indo Ikan

The Fisheries Offices of NTT Province has issued 17 POKMASWAS in East Flores. The total number of POKMASWAS in NTT Province is 264

There is a need to strengthen the role of POKMASWAS and the monitoring scheme, regulation and it surveillance in order to have a more effective monitoring, controlling and surveillance program.

Inserting the regular monitoring/evaluation points into the Tuna Fisheries Management Plan at national level *LINK 3.1.1

The regular monitoring/evaluation points is inserted into the Tuna Fisheries Management Plan at national level (for instance, once a year)

University, BPPL, WWF


Will be discussed in several meetings of tuna fisheries management including the National FIP tuna review.

pt primo indo ikan semester report of seafood savers ......this district contributes 22% to the...

Documents