(ps) project specific criteria - broward county, florida · (ps) project specific criteria ......

MAST ARMS CONVERSION PROJECT RLI No. N1030013R1

EVALUATION CRITERIA

of 27

(PS) PROJECT SPECIFIC CRITERIA PS 1. ORGANIZATIONAL CHART – PROVIDE A PROJECT SPECIFIC ORGANIZATIONAL CHART FOR THE DESIGN-BUILD TEAM SHOWING KEY PERSONNEL, FIRMS, AND AREA OF ASSIGNED EXPERTISE. PROVIDE CHART ON AN 11” X 17” FOLDED PAGE.

FLORIDA SAFETY CONTRACTORS, INC. HORSEPOWER ELECTRIC INC. STATE CONTRACTING &

ENGINEERING CORP. TRAFFIC CONTROL

DEVICES, INC. WEEKLEY ASPHALT

PAVING, INC. WORLD FIBER

TECHNOLOGIES, INC. Please see organizational chart attached at the end of this section.

See Section 6, Appendix 1 for Organizational Chart

Please see organizational chart attached at the end of this section.

Please see the organizational chart on page 3 of the Project-Specific Criteria Section.

Please see the organizational chart immediately after page 23 Section Three.

The WF Team‘s 11x17 folded Organizational Chart is included behind Tab 1. Organizational Chart.

PS 2. DESCRIBE QUALIFICATIONS AND REVELANT EXPERIENCE OF DESIGN BUILD TEAM, INCLUDING FDOT PREQUALIFICATIONS AND KEY PERSONNEL TO BE ASSIGNED TO THE PROJECT. PROVIDE RESUMES. ABILITY OF DESIGN-BUILD TEAM PERSONNEL -DESCRIBE THE QUALIFICATIONS AND RELEVANT EXPERIENCE OF THE PROPOSED DESIGN-BUILD TEAM, INCLUDING ANY FDOT PREQUALIFICATIONS INDIVIDUAL FIRMS MAY POSSESS. DESCRIBE THE QUALIFICATIONS OF ALL KEY DESIGN AND CONSTRUCTION PERSONNEL THAT ARE TO BE ASSIGNED TO THIS PROPOSED PROJECT. INCLUDE RESUMES FOR KEY PERSONNEL (TWO-PAGE MAX.). AT A MINIMUM, INCLUDE THE FOLLOWING PERSONNEL: a) DESIGN PROJECT MANAGER b) DESIGN ROADWAY EOR c) DESIGN STRUCTURES EOR d) DESIGN EOR – EACH SPECIALTY e) CONST. PROJECT MANAGER f) CONST. DESIGN-BUILD COORDINATOR g) CONST. ROADWAY SUPERINTENDENT h) CONST. STRUCTURES SUPERINTENDENT i) CONST. SUPERINTENDENT – EACH SPECIALTY

FLORIDA SAFETY

CONTRACTORS, INC. HORSEPOWER ELECTRIC INC. STATE CONTRACTING & ENGINEERING CORP.

TRAFFIC CONTROL DEVICES, INC.

WEEKLEY ASPHALT PAVING, INC.

WORLD FIBER TECHNOLOGIES, INC.

See profiles of Florida Safety Contractors and Kimley-Horn and Associates and resumes for key team members attached at the end of the Project-Specific Criteria Section. Team is FDOT prequalified in both construction and design – Refer to Summary of DB Teams’ FDOT Prequalification’s.

See Section 7, Appendix 2 for FDOT Prequalification Letters See Section 7, Appendix 2, Page 6 for Resumes Team is FDOT prequalified in both traffic signal construction and design. Refer to Summary of DB Teams’ FDOT Prequalification’s.

See Attached Narrative of Team Experience. See attached team resumes.

Team is prequalified in construction, survey, and minor design - Refer to Summary of DB Teams’ FDOT Prequalification’s.

See the ability of the D-B team information beginning on page 4. Please see the additional ability of the D-B team information beginning on page 4. Resumes for our DBT are included in Section 5 of this RLI. Team is FDOT prequalified in both traffic signal construction and design - Refer to Summary of DB Teams’ FDOT Prequalification’s.

See the ability of the D-B team information beginning on page 17 in Section Three. Resumes for the DBT are also included in Section Three of the RLI. Team is FDOT prequalified in both traffic signal construction and design - Refer to Summary of DB Teams’ FDOT Prequalification’s.

The WF’s Team summary and detailed professional resumes for key personnel are included behind Tab 2. Ability of Design-Build Team Personnel.

Team is FDOT pre-qualified in traffic signal construction and design - Refer to Summary of DB Teams’ FDOT Prequalification’s.


EVALUATION CRITERIA

of 27

PS 3. PAST PERFORMANCE - DESCRIBE EXPERIENCE ON PROJECTS OF SIMILAR NATURE, SCOPE, AND DURATION ALONG WITH EVIDENCE OF SATISFACTORY COMPLETION, BOTH ON TIME AND WITHIN BUDGET, FOR THE PAST FIVE (5) YEARS FOR EACH OF THE KEY INDIVIDUAL FIRMS ON THE DESIGN-BUILD TEAM.

PROVIDE A MINIMUM OF THREE (3) REFERENCES FOR FIRM’S SIMILAR PROJECTS WITH NAMES, ORGANIZATIONS, PHONE NUMBERS, AND EMAIL ADDRESSES. REFERENCES WILL BE CONTACTED.

FLORIDA SAFETY





In Project-Specific Criteria Section both Florida Safety Contractors (FSC) and Kimley-Horn and Associates provided past projects of a similar nature and references.

See Section 8, Appendix 3 for Past Performance – Projects of Similar Nature Also, in Section 8 is a listing of references and projects for both Horsepower Electric and Calvin, Giordano & Associates

See attached Past Performance Chart provided which lists projects for each of the three key firms on their team.

See past performance and references information beginning on page 8 of the Project-Specific Criteria Section.

See past performance and references information beginning on page 65 of the Past Performance Section Four.

The WF Team‘s references and similar project lists are included behind Tab 3. Past Performance.


EVALUATION CRITERIA

of 27

PS 4. LOCATION – IDENTIFY OFFICE LOCATIONS RESPONSIBLE FOR BOTH THE DESIGN AND CONSTRUCTION.





TECHNOLOGIES, INC. Construction Florida Safety Contractors 3500 Burris Road Davie, FL 33314 Design Kimley-Horn and Associates, Inc. 5200 NW 33rd Avenue, Suite 109 Ft. Lauderdale, FL 33309-6398 Tierra South Florida, Inc. (CBE) 2209B NE 54th Street Fort Lauderdale, Florida 33308 Stoner and Associates, Inc. (CBE) 4341 SW 62nd Avenue Davie, Florida 33314 TBE Group, Inc., DBA Cardno TBE 3427 NW 55th Street Fort Lauderdale, Florida 33309

Construction Horsepower Electric, Inc. 8105 West 20 Avenue Hialeah, Florida 33014 Design Calvin, Giordano & Associates, Inc. (CGA) 1800 Eller Drive, Suite 600 Fort Lauderdale, Florida 33316 Lakdas/Yohalem Engineering, Inc. (CBE) 2211 NE 54th Street Fort Lauderdale, Florida 33308 RADISE International, LC (CBE) 4152 West Blue Heron Blvd., #228 Riviera Beach, Florida 33404

Construction State Contracting & Engineering Corp. 3800 N 29th Avenue Hollywood, Florida 33020 Signal Technology and Installation Corp. 5061 Oakes Road Davie, Florida 33314 Design Joseph Roles and Associates, Inc. 7501 NW 4th Street, Suite 101 Plantation, Florida 33317 RADISE International, LC (CBE) 4152 West Blue Heron Blvd., #228 Riviera Beach, Florida 33404 DeRose Design Consultants, Inc. 470 S. Andrews Avenue Pompano Beach, Florida 33069

Construction TCD (main office) 242 North Westmonte Drive Altamonte Springs, Florida 32714 407.869.5300 TCD (Broward County office) 4712 NE 12th Avenue Oakland Park, FL 33334 Compass Point Surveyors, PL (CBE) 806 Franklin Street Clearwater, Florida 33756 Design Atkins (Broward County office) 3230 West Commercial Boulevard, Suite 100 Ft. Lauderdale, Florida 33309-3400 Professional Service Industries, Inc. 6500 NW 12th Avenue Fort Lauderdale, Florida 33309

Construction Weekley Asphalt Paving, Inc. 20701 Stirling Road Pembroke Pines, Florida 33332 American Lighting & Signalization, Inc. 11639 Davis Creek Road Jacksonville, Florida 32256 AMPCO Electric, Inc. (CBE) 3949 SW 12th Court Fort Lauderdale, Florida 33312 Design Keith and Schnars, P.A. 6500 North Andrews Avenue Fort Lauderdale, Florida 33309 CES Consultants, Inc. (CBE) 14361 Commerce Way Suite 103 Miami Lakes, Florida 33016 TBE Group, Inc., DBA Cardno TBE 3427 NW 55th Street Fort Lauderdale, Florida 33309

Construction World Fiber Technologies, Inc. 4070 Nine McFarland Drive Alpharetta, GA 30004 Local Office Address 2800 N 30th Avenue, Suite A Hollywood, Florida 33020 ASC Logic, Inc. 4000 Hollywood Blvd., Suite 555-South Hollywood, Florida 33021 Design F.R. Aleman & Associates, Inc. 10305 NW 41st Street Suite 200 Miami, Florida 33178 Michael Baker, Jr. (aka LPA Group, Inc.) 2000 Palm Beach Lakes Blvd. Suite 600 West Palm Beach, Florida 33409 CES Consultants, Inc. (CBE) 14361 Commerce Way Suite 103 Miami Lakes, Florida 33016


EVALUATION CRITERIA

of 27

PS 5. LIST RESPONDENT/PRIME’S QUALIFYING AGENT FOR THE BUSINESS ORGANIZATION PER F.S. 489.119 OR F.S. 471.023, AND PROVIDE COPIES OF THEIR CERTIFICATES. INCLUDE CERTIFICATE OF AUTHORIZATION FOR BUSINESS ORGANIZATION (FOR 471.023).





TECHNOLOGIES, INC.

Florida Safety Contractors, Inc. (FSC) did not include proof of licensing with their submittal, however they submitted upon request proof of their current license application with the State of Florida. FSC is currently approved as a Certified General Contractor as of August 22, 2012.

Henry Martinez – General Contractor CGCB01285 Hector Ortiz – Electrical Contractor EC0001153 See the pages immediately following Project-Specific Criteria for Certificates of Authorization and Business Licenses

Timothy M Smith – General Contractor CGC1505600 GC License Certificate provided immediately following Project-Specific Criteria.

Bernard Paul Beckner – General Contractor CGC1520736 GC License Certificate details provided immediately following Project-Specific Criteria.

Barry Tod Workman – General Contractor CGC1518050 GC License Certificate and Certificate of Corporation provided in Section Four - Past Performance.

Michael R. Holt, P.E. – Professional Engineer P.E. License No. 63152 Professional Engineer License Certificate and Certificate of Authorization provided in the Licenses Section.

PS 6. VOLUME OF WORK PREVIOUSLY AWARDED TO EACH FIRM BY BROWARD COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS - LIST ALL PROJECTS WITH BROWARD COUNTY DURING THE PAST FIVE (5) YEARS – COMPLETED AND ACTIVE.





TECHNOLOGIES, INC. None Contract P0920408C1 (Project No. 5384)

Mast Arm Signal Construction for 5 Intersections ($990,860) Contract L1005402B1 Roadway and Traffic Miscellaneous Construction ($8,569,385)

None – see Attachment R in Section F. None - Volume of work awarded to prime: TCD has been awarded NO Broward County BCC contracts as a prime in the past five years.

Total Volume of Work for Nine (9) projects over the last five (5) years is listed on Page 157 as $33,626,964.33.

None - World Fiber has not been awarded any work by the Broward County Board of Commissioners in the last five (5) years and therefore does not have any completed nor active projects at this time.


EVALUATION CRITERIA

of 27

(CP) COMPANY PROFILE CP 1. SUPPLY LEGAL FIRM NAME, HEADQUATERS ADDRESS, LOCAL OFFICE ADDRESSES, STATE OF INCORPORATION, KEY FIRM CONTACT NAMES WITH PHONE NUMBERS AND EMAIL ADDRESSES.





TECHNOLOGIES, INC. Legal Firm Name Florida Safety Contractors, Inc., was incorporated in Florida in 2003. Headquarters Florida Safety Contractors, Inc. 11825 Jackson Road Thonotosassa, FL 33592 Phone: (813)982-9172 Fax: (813)982-9183 South Florida Office Florida Safety Contractors, Inc. 3500 Burris Road Davie, FL 33314 Phone: To Be Determined Fax: To Be Determined Key Contacts Kevin Reichart, President (813) 982-9172 [email protected] John P. Coyne (954) 325-0529 [email protected] Mark Jackson (941) 737-3562 [email protected]

HORSEPOWER ELECTRIC INC. 8105 W 20 Ave Hialeah FL 33014 Florida Incorporated Humberto Ortiz 305-345-5347 [email protected] Michael Martinez 305-345-5370 [email protected]

State Contracting & Engineering Corp Headquarters and Local Address: 3800 N. 29th Avenue Hollywood, FL 33020 Incorporated in Florida Tim Smith – President (954) 923-4747 [email protected] Barry Transleau – Vice President (954) 923-4747 [email protected] Paul Carty – Vice President (954) 923-4747 [email protected]

Legal Firm Name (Construction Firm) Traffic Control Devices, Inc. Headquarters Address 242 North Westmonte Drive Altamonte Springs, FL 32714 Local Office Address 4712 NE 12th Avenue Oakland Park, FL 33334 State of Incorporation Florida Key Firm Contacts Rob Rebert Design-Build Estimator Ph. 407.869.5300 Email [email protected] Legal Firm Name (Design Firm) Atkins North America, Inc. Headquarters Address 4030 West Boy Scout Boulevard, Suite 700 Tampa, Florida 33607 Telephone: 813.282.7275 Local Office Address 3230 West Commercial Boulevard, Suite 100 Fort Lauderdale, Florida 33309-3400 Telephone: 954.733.7233 State of Incorporation Florida Key Firm Contacts Dominic Novello III, PE Senior Group Manager 954.733.7233 [email protected]

Please see Section 4 - Page 72 Legal Firm Name (Construction Firm) Weekley Asphalt Paving, Inc. 20701 Stirling Road Pembroke Pines, FL 33332 [email protected] Office: 954-680-8005 Fax: 954-680-8671 State of Incorporation Florida Key Firm Contacts: 1) Daniel D. Weekley Cell: 954-444-1054 Home: 954-434-8907 Fax: 954-680-8930

[email protected] 2) Justin Morgan Cell: 954-931-5594 Home: 954-680-5285 Fax: 954-680-8671 [email protected] 3) Tod Workman Cell: 954-444-3600 Fax: 954-680-8671 [email protected]

Legal Firm Name: World Fiber Technologies, Inc. Headquarters Address: 4070 Nine McFarland Drive Alpharetta, GA 30004 Local Office Address: 2800 N 30th Avenue, Suite A Hollywood, FL 33020 State of Incorporation: GA Key Firm Contacts: 1) Mike Holt 770.619.0118, ext 144 [email protected] 2) Mark Battle 770.619.0118, ext 102 [email protected]

mailto:[email protected]




EVALUATION CRITERIA

of 27

CP 2. SUPPLY FIRM’S FEDERAL ID NUMBER AND DUN AND BRADSTREET NUMBER.





TECHNOLOGIES, INC. FEIN: 571191566 Dun and Bradstreet: 780364621

FEIN: 59-2502221 Dun and Bradstreet: 15-274-9388

Federal ID: 65-0405645 Dun and Bradstreet No: 82-490-4312

Federal ID Number TCD: 59-1858994 Atkins: 59-0896138 D&B Number TCD: 09-3604452 Atkins: 07-728-3752

FEID #590753039 D&B #00-413-9887

Federal ID No: 58-2354516 Dun and Bradstreet No: 01-908-6052

CP 3. IS THE INTERESTED FIRM LEGALLY AUTHORIZED, PURSUANT TO THE REQUIREMENTS OF THE FLORIDA STATUTES, TO DO BUSINESS IN THE STATE OF FLORIDA?

YES NO

FLORIDA SAFETY





Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes


EVALUATION CRITERIA

of 27

CP 4. ALL FIRMS ARE REQUIRED TO PROVIDE BROWARD COUNTY THE FIRM'S FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AT THE TIME OF SUBMITTAL IN ORDER TO DEMONSTRATE THE FIRM'S FINANCIAL CAPABILITIES. FAILURE TO PROVIDE THIS INFORMATION AT THE TIME OF SUBMITTAL MAY RESULT IN A RECOMMENDATION BY THE DIRECTOR OF PURCHASING THAT THE RESPONSE IS NON-RESPONSIVE.

Re: CP 4 - EACH FIRM SHALL SUBMIT ITS MOST RECENT TWO (2) YEARS OF FINANCIAL STATEMENTS FOR REVIEW. THE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS ARE NOT REQUIRED TO BE AUDITED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS. WITH RESPECT TO THE NUMBER OF YEARS OF FINANCIAL STATEMENTS REQUIRED BY THIS RLI, THE FIRM MUST FULLY DISCLOSE THE INFORMATION FOR ALL YEARS AVAILABLE; PROVIDED, HOWEVER, THAT IF THE FIRM HAS BEEN IN BUSINESS FOR LESS THAN THE REQUIRED NUMBER OF YEARS, THEN THE FIRM MUST DISCLOSE FOR ALL YEARS OF THE REQUIRED PERIOD THAT THE FIRM HAS BEEN IN BUSINESS, INCLUDING ANY PARTIAL YEAR-TO-DATE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS. THE COUNTY MAY CONSIDER THE UNAVAILABILITY OF THE MOST RECENT YEAR’S FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AND WHETHER THE FIRM ACTED IN GOOD FAITH IN DISCLOSING THE FINANCIAL DOCUMENTS IN ITS EVALUATION. ANY CLAIM OF CONFIDENTIALITY ON FINANCIAL STATEMENTS SHOULD BE ASSERTED AT THE TIME OF SUBMITTAL. (SEE BELOW)

*****ONLY “IF” CLAIMING CONFIDENTIALITY*****

THE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS SHOULD BE SUBMITTED IN A SEPARATE BOUND DOCUMENT LABELED "NAME OF FIRM, ATTACHMENT TO PROPOSAL PACKAGE, RLI# - CONFIDENTIAL MATTER". THE FIRM MUST IDENTIFY THE SPECIFIC STATUTE THAT AUTHORIZES THE EXEMPTION FROM THE PUBLIC RECORDS LAW. CD OR DVD DISCS INCLUDED IN THE SUBMITTAL MUST ALSO COMPLY WITH THIS REQUIREMENT AND SEPARATE ANY MATERIALS CLAIMED TO BE CONFIDENTIAL.

FLORIDA SAFETY





See Financial Memo See Financial Memo

See Financial Memo

See Financial Memo

See Financial Memo

See Financial Memo


EVALUATION CRITERIA

of 27

CP 5. THE COUNTY WILL CONSIDER A VENDOR'S LITIGATION HISTORY INFORMATION IN ITS REVIEW AND DETERMINATION OF RESPONSIBILITY. ALL VENDORS ARE REQUIRED TO DISCLOSE TO THE COUNTY ALL "MATERIAL" CASES FILED, PENDING, OR RESOLVED DURING THE LAST THREE (3) YEARS PRIOR TO THE SOLICITATION RESPONSE DUE DATE, WHETHER SUCH CASES WERE BROUGHT BY OR AGAINST THE VENDOR, ANY PARENT OR SUBSIDIARY OF THE VENDOR, OR ANY PREDECESSOR ORGANIZATION. IF THE VENDOR IS A JOINT VENTURE, THE INFORMATION PROVIDED SHOULD ENCOMPASS THE JOINT VENTURE (IF IT IS NOT NEWLY-FORMED FOR PURPOSES OF RESPONDING TO THE SOLICITATION) AND EACH OF THE ENTITIES FORMING THE JOINT VENTURE. FOR PURPOSE OF THIS DISCLOSURE REQUIREMENT, A “CASE” INCLUDES LAWSUITS, ADMINISTRATIVE HEARINGS AND ARBITRATIONS.

A CASE IS CONSIDERED TO BE "MATERIAL" IF IT RELATES, IN WHOLE OR IN PART, TO ANY OF THE FOLLOWING:

1. A SIMILAR TYPE OF WORK THAT THE VENDOR IS SEEKING TO PERFORM FOR THE COUNTY UNDER THE CURRENT SOLICITATION;

2. AN ALLEGATION OF NEGLIGENCE, ERROR OR OMISSIONS, OR MALPRACTICE AGAINST THE VENDOR OR ANY OF ITS PRINCIPALS OR AGENTS WHO WOULD BE PERFORMING WORK UNDER THE CURRENT SOLICITATION;

3. A VENDOR'S DEFAULT, TERMINATION, SUSPENSION, FAILURE TO PERFORM, OR IMPROPER PERFORMANCE IN CONNECTION WITH ANY CONTRACT;

4. THE FINANCIAL CONDITION OF THE VENDOR, INCLUDING ANY BANKRUPTCY PETITION (VOLUNTARY AND INVOLUNTARY) OR RECEIVERSHIP; OR

5. A CRIMINAL PROCEEDING OR HEARING CONCERNING BUSINESS-RELATED OFFENSES IN WHICH THE VENDOR OR ITS PRINCIPALS (INCLUDING OFFICERS) WERE/ARE DEFENDANTS.

NOTWITHSTANDING THE DESCRIPTIONS LISTED IN PARAGRAPHS 1 – 5 ABOVE, A CASE IS NOT CONSIDERED TO BE "MATERIAL" IF THE CLAIMS RAISED IN THE CASE INVOLVE ONLY GARNISHMENT, AUTO NEGLIGENCE, PERSONAL INJURY, WORKERS' COMPENSATION, FORECLOSURE OR A PROOF OF CLAIM FILED BY THE VENDOR.

FOR EACH MATERIAL CASE, THE VENDOR IS REQUIRED TO PROVIDE ALL INFORMATION IDENTIFIED, ON THE “LITIGATION HISTORY” FORM. (ATTACHMENT J)

FLORIDA SAFETY





Florida Safety Contractors, Inc. has not been involved in any litigation since its inception in 2003. Please see “Attachment J” at the end of this section. See Litigation Memo

NONE 1. None 2. None 3. None 4. None 5. None

Attachment J is Not Applicable (See Page 56) See Litigation Memo

State Contracting has had no litigation in the past 3 years related to items 1 through 5 below. In the spirit of full disclosure, we have attached Form J for a pending 3rd party complaint. See Litigation Memo

TCD has no material cases in the last three years to report in its litigation history. Please see Attachment J on page 35. See Litigation Memo

Please see Section 4

See Litigation Memo

World Fiber has completed Attachment J: Litigation History, the executed form is included behind Tab 4. Required Forms.

See Litigation Memo


EVALUATION CRITERIA

of 27

CP 6. HAS THE INTERESTED FIRM, ITS PRINCIPALS, OFFICERS, OR PREDECESSOR ORGANIZATION(S) BEEN DEBARRED OR SUSPENDED FROM BIDDING BY ANY GOVERNMENT DURING THE LAST THREE (3) YEARS? IF YES, PROVIDE DETAILS.

YES NO





TECHNOLOGIES, INC. No No No No. No No

CP 7. HAS YOUR COMPANY EVER FAILED TO COMPLETE ANY WORK AWARDED TO YOU? IF SO, WHERE AND WHY?

YES NO





TECHNOLOGIES, INC. No No No No

No No

CP 8. HAS YOUR COMPANY EVER BEEN TERMINATED FROM A CONTRACT? IF SO, WHERE AND WHY?

YES NO





TECHNOLOGIES, INC. No No No No. No No

CP 9. INSURANCE REQUIREMENTS: REFER TO THE SAMPLE CERTIFICATE OF INSURANCE ATTACHMENT K. IT REFLECTS THE INSURANCE REQUIREMENTS DEEMED NECESSARY FOR THIS PROJECT. IT IS NOT NECESSARY TO HAVE THIS LEVEL OF INSURANCE IN EFFECT AT THE TIME OF SUBMITTAL BUT IT IS NECESSARY TO SUBMIT CERTIFICATES INDICATING THAT THE FIRM CURRENTLY CARRIES THE INSURANCE OR TO SUBMIT A LETTER FROM THE CARRIER INDICATING UPGRADE AVAILABILITY.





TECHNOLOGIES, INC.

Compliant

Compliant

Compliant

Compliant

Compliant

Compliant


EVALUATION CRITERIA

of 27

(LR) LEGAL REQUIREMENTS LR 1. STANDARD AGREEMENT LANGUAGE: IDENTIFY ANY STANDARD TERMS AND CONDITIONS WITH WHICH THE INTERESTED FIRM CANNOT AGREE. IF NO, YOU NEED TO SPECIFICALLY IDENTIFY THE TERMS AND CONDITIONS WITH WHICH YOU ARE TAKING EXCEPTION SINCE THEY WILL BE DISCUSSED WITH THE SELECTION COMMITTEE. PLEASE BE AWARE THAT TAKING EXCEPTIONS TO THE COUNTY’S STANDARD TERMS AND CONDITIONS MAY BE VIEWED UNFAVORABLY BY THE SELECTION COMMITTEE AND ULTIMATELY IMPACT THE OVERALL EVALUATION OF YOUR SUBMITTAL.





TECHNOLOGIES, INC. Yes (Agree) Yes (Agree) Yes (Agree) Yes (Agree) Yes (Agree) Yes (Agree)

LR 1A. AGREEMENT LANGUAGE FOR INDEMNIFICATION: INDEMNIFICATION WILL BE STATED AS FOLLOWS IN THE FINAL AGREEMENT AND WILL NOT BE SUBJECT TO NEGOTIATION:

CONTRACTOR SHALL INDEMNIFY AND HOLD HARMLESS COUNTY, ITS OFFICERS AND EMPLOYEES, FROM LIABILITIES, DAMAGES, LOSSES, AND COSTS, INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO, REASONABLE ATTORNEY’S FEES, TO THE EXTENT CAUSED BY THE NEGLIGENCE, RECKLESSNESS, OR INTENTIONALLY WRONGFUL CONDUCT OF CONTRACTOR AND PERSONS EMPLOYED OR UTILIZED BY CONTRACTOR IN THE PERFORMANCE OF THIS CONTRACT. THESE INDEMNIFICATIONS SHALL SURVIVE THE TERM OF THIS CONTRACT. TO THE EXTENT CONSIDERED NECESSARY BY CONTRACT ADMINISTRATOR AND COUNTY ATTORNEY, ANY SUMS DUE CONTRACTOR UNDER THIS CONTRACT MAY BE RETAINED BY COUNTY UNTIL ALL OF COUNTY’S CLAIMS FOR INDEMNIFICATION PURSUANT TO THIS CONTRACT HAVE BEEN SETTLED OR OTHERWISE RESOLVED, AND ANY AMOUNT WITHHELD SHALL NOT BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT OF INTEREST BY COUNTY.





TECHNOLOGIES, INC. Yes (Agree) Yes (Agree) Yes (Agree) Yes (Agree) Yes (Agree) Yes (Agree)

LR 2. CONE OF SILENCE: THIS COUNTY’S ORDINANCE PROHIBITS CERTAIN COMMUNICATIONS AMONG VENDORS, COUNTY STAFF, AND SELECTION COMMITTEE MEMBERS. IDENTIFY ANY VIOLATIONS OF THIS ORDINANCE BY ANY MEMBERS OF THE RESPONDING FIRM OR ITS JOINT VENTURERS. THE FIRM(S) SUBMITTING IS EXPECTED TO SIGN AND NOTARIZE THE CONE OF SILENCE CERTIFICATION (ATTACHMENT L).





TECHNOLOGIES, INC. No violations. Please see “Attachment L” at the end of this section.

No Violations See Page 8 for Attachment L, Cone of Silence Certification

Respondent did not identify any violations of the Cone of Silence Ordinance. Respondent provided “See Attachment L for Executed Certification” and certifies that it agrees to comply with the requirements of this ordinance.

Respondent did not identify any violations of the Cone of Silence Ordinance. Respondent provided “Please see Attachment L, Cone of Silence, on page 44” and certifies that it agrees to comply with the requirements of this ordinance.

Respondent did not identify any violations of the Cone of Silence Ordinance. Respondent provided “Please see Section 4” on page 136 and certifies that it agrees to comply with the requirements of this ordinance.

Respondent did not identify any violations of the Cone of Silence Ordinance. World Fiber has completed Attachment L: Cone of Silence Certification. The executed form is included behind Tab 4. Required Forms.


EVALUATION CRITERIA

of 27

LR 3. PUBLIC ENTITY CRIMES STATEMENT: A PERSON OR AFFILIATE WHO HAS BEEN PLACED ON THE CONVICTED VENDOR LIST FOLLOWING A CONVICTION FOR A PUBLIC ENTITY CRIME MAY NOT SUBMIT AN OFFER TO PERFORM WORK AS A CONSULTANT OR CONTRACT WITH A PUBLIC ENTITY, AND MAY NOT TRANSACT BUSINESS WITH BROWARD COUNTY FOR A PERIOD OF 36 MONTHS FROM THE DATE OF BEING PLACED ON THE CONVICTED VENDOR LIST. SUBMIT A STATEMENT FULLY DESCRIBING ANY VIOLATIONS OF THIS STATUTE BY MEMBERS OF THE INTERESTED FIRM OR ITS JOINT VENTURERS.





TECHNOLOGIES, INC. No member of Florida Safety Contractors has been placed on any convicted vendor lists.

No Violations State Contracting has no violations of “Public Entity Crimes”, nor do any of its owners or employees.

TCD has no violations to report. Respondent did not identify any violations of the Public Entity Crimes Statement. Respondent provided “Please see Section 4” on page 137 and signed the public entity crimes statement.

World Fiber has no violations of this statute.

LR 4. NO CONTINGENCY FEES: BY RESPONDING TO THIS SOLICITATION, EACH FIRM WARRANTS THAT IT HAS NOT AND WILL NOT PAY A CONTINGENCY FEE TO ANY COMPANY OR PERSON, OTHER THAN A BONA FIDE EMPLOYEE WORKING SOLELY FOR THE FIRM, TO SECURE AN AGREEMENT PURSUANT TO THIS SOLICITATION. FOR BREACH OR VIOLATION OF THIS PROVISION, COUNTY SHALL HAVE THE RIGHT TO REJECT THE FIRM’S RESPONSE OR TERMINATE ANY AGREEMENT AWARDED WITHOUT LIABILITY AT ITS DISCRETION, OR TO DEDUCT FROM THE AGREEMENT PRICE OR OTHERWISE RECOVER THE FULL AMOUNT OF SUCH FEE, COMMISSION, PERCENTAGE, GIFT, OR CONSIDERATION. SUBMIT AN ATTESTING STATEMENT WARRANTING THAT THE RESPONDER HAS NOT AND WILL NOT PAY A CONTINGENCY FEE TO ANY COMPANY OR PERSON, OTHER THAN A BONA FIDE EMPLOYEE WORKING SOLELY FOR THE FIRM, TO SECURE AN AGREEMENT PURSUANT TO THIS SOLICITATION.





TECHNOLOGIES, INC. Respondent provided “Please see attached statement at the end of this section” and submitted an attesting statement that states Florida Safety Contractors, Inc. has not and will not pay a contingency fee.

Horsepower Electric Inc. hereby attest we will not pay a contingency fee to any company or person to secure an agreement pursuant to this solicitation.

State Contracting Does not pay contingency fees. See Attached Statement that SCEC has not and will not pay a Contingency Fee.

Respondent provided “Please see attesting statement on page 45.” and submitted an attesting statement that states Traffic Control Devices, Inc. has not and will not pay a contingency fee.

Respondent provided “Please see Section 4” on page 138 and submitted an attesting statement that states Weekley Asphalt ,Inc. has not and will not pay a contingency fee.

World Fiber has not and will not pay a contingency fee to any company or person, other than a bona fide employee working solely for the firm, to secure an agreement pursuant to this solicitation.

LR 5. IF THIS BOX IS CHECKED, THEN THE PROVISIONS OF THE BROWARD COUNTY LIVING WAGE ORDINANCE 2008-45, AS AMENDED, (“LIVING WAGE ORDINANCE”) WILL APPLY TO THIS AGREEMENT. IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE LIVING WAGE ORDINANCE, CERTAIN EMPLOYERS WHO DO BUSINESS WITH THE COUNTY SHALL PAY A LIVING WAGE TO ITS EMPLOYEES WHO WORK ON SERVICE CONTRACTS PROVIDING COVERED SERVICES IDENTIFIED UNDER THE LIVING WAGE ORDINANCE. (ATTACHMENT M)





TECHNOLOGIES, INC. N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A


EVALUATION CRITERIA

of 27

LR 6. DRUG FREE WORKPLACE: 1. DO YOU HAVE A DRUG FREE WORKPLACE POLICY?





TECHNOLOGIES, INC. Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

LR 6. DRUG FREE WORKPLACE: 2. IF SO, PLEASE PROVIDE A COPY OF YOUR DRUG FREE WORKPLACE POLICY IN YOUR PROPOSAL.





TECHNOLOGIES, INC. Drug Free Workplace Policy attached at the end of this section after attachment “N”.

See Section 3 / Page 9 for Drug Free Workplace Policy

Not required per attachment N. Firm was requested to submit Drug-Free Policy.

Please see TCD’s policy beginning on page 47.

Drug Free Work place policy attached on Pg 139.

World Fiber has included a copy of our Drug-Free Workplace Policy behind Attachment N: Drug-Free Workplace Certification in Tab 4. Required Forms.

LR 6. DRUG FREE WORKPLACE: 3. DOES YOUR DRUG FREE WORKPLACE POLICY COMPLY WITH SECTION 287.087 OF THE FLORIDA STATUTES?





TECHNOLOGIES, INC. Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

LR 6. DRUG FREE WORKPLACE: 4. IF YOUR DRUG FREE WORKPLACE POLICY COMPLIES WITH SECTION 287.087 OF THE FLORIDA STATUTES, PLEASE COMPLETE THE DRUG FREE WORKPLACE POLICY CERTIFICATION FORM. ATTACHMENT N





TECHNOLOGIES, INC. Please see “Attachment N” at the end of this section.

Yes See Page 18 for Attachment “N” - Drug Free Workplace Policy Certification

Respondent provided “See attachment N” and indicated that they are in compliance with section 287.087 of the Florida Statutes.

Yes Attachment N is included on page 46.

Yes Yes


EVALUATION CRITERIA

of 27

LR 6. DRUG FREE WORKPLACE: 5. IF YOUR DRUG FREE WORKPLACE POLICY DOES NOT COMPLY WITH SECTION 287.087OF THE FLORIDA STATUTES, DOES IT COMPLY WITH THE DRUG FREE WORKPLACE REQUIREMENTS PURSUANT TO SECTION 21.31.A.2 OF THE BROWARD COUNTY PROCUREMENT CODE?





TECHNOLOGIES, INC. N/A Yes N/A N/A N/A Yes

LR 6. DRUG FREE WORKPLACE: 6. IF SO, PLEASE COMPLETE THE ATTACHED DRUG FREE WORKPLACE POLICY CERTIFICATION FORM.





TECHNOLOGIES, INC. N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A

LR 6. DRUG FREE WORKPLACE: 7. IF YOUR DRUG FREE WORKPLACE POLICY DOES NOT COMPLY WITH SECTION 21.31.A.2 OF THE BROWARD COUNTY PROCUREMENT CODE, ARE YOU WILLING TO COMPLY WITH THE REQUIREMENTS SECTION 21.31.A.2 OF THE BROWARD COUNTY PROCUREMENT CODE?





TECHNOLOGIES, INC. Yes Yes N/A Yes N/A Yes

LR 6. DRUG FREE WORKPLACE: 8. IF SO, PLEASE COMPLETE THE ATTACHED DRUG FREE WORKPLACE POLICY CERTIFICATION FORM. (ATTACHMENT N)

FAILURE TO PROVIDE A NOTARIZED CERTIFICATION FORM IN YOUR PROPOSAL INDICATING YOUR COMPLIANCE OR WILLINGNESS TO COMPLY WITH BROWARD COUNTY'S DRUG FREE WORKPLACE REQUIREMENTS AS STATED IN SECTION 21.31.A.2 OF THE BROWARD COUNTY PROCUREMENT CODE MAY RESULT IN YOUR FIRM BEING INELIGIBLE TO BE AWARDED A CONTRACT PURSUANT TO BROWARD COUNTY'S DRUG FREE WORKPLACE ORDINANCE AND PROCUREMENT CODE





TECHNOLOGIES, INC. Form provided on Page 42 of 54. From Provided in Section 3 - Page 18. N/A. Form Provided. Attachment N is included on page 46. Form provided on Pg. 147.

World Fiber has completed Attachment N: Drug-Free Workplace Certification, the executed form is included behind Tab 4. Required Forms.


EVALUATION CRITERIA

of 27

LR 7. NON-COLLUSION STATEMENT: BY RESPONDING TO THIS SOLICITATION, THE VENDOR CERTIFIES THAT THIS OFFER IS MADE INDEPENDENTLY AND FREE FROM COLLUSION. VENDOR SHALL DISCLOSE ON THE “NON-COLLUSION STATEMENT FORM” (ATTACHMENT O) TO THEIR BEST KNOWLEDGE, ANY BROWARD COUNTY OFFICER OR EMPLOYEE, OR ANY RELATIVE OF ANY SUCH OFFICER OR EMPLOYEE AS DEFINED IN SECTION 112.3135(1) (C), FLORIDA STATUTES (1989), WHO IS AN OFFICER OR DIRECTOR OF, OR HAD A MATERIAL INTEREST IN, THE VENDOR’S BUSINESS, WHO IS IN A POSITION TO INFLUENCE THIS PROCUREMENT. ANY BROWARD COUNTY OFFICER OR EMPLOYEE WHO HAS ANY INPUT INTO THE WRITING OF SPECIFICATIONS OR REQUIREMENTS, SOLICITATION OF OFFERS, DECISION TO AWARD, EVALUATION OF OFFERS, OR ANY OTHER ACTIVITY PERTINENT TO THIS PROCUREMENT IS PRESUMED, FOR PURPOSES HEREOF, A PERSON HAS A MATERIAL INTEREST IF THEY DIRECTLY OR INDIRECTLY OWN MORE THAN 5 PERCENT OF THE TOTAL ASSETS OR CAPITAL STOCK OF ANY BUSINESS ENTITY, OR IF THEY OTHERWISE STAND TO PERSONALLY GAIN IF THE CONTRACT IS AWARDED TO THIS VENDOR. FAILURE OF A VENDOR TO DISCLOSE ANY RELATIONSHIP DESCRIBED HEREIN SHALL BE REASON FOR DEBARMENT IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE PROVISIONS OF THE BROWARD COUNTY PROCUREMENT CODE.





TECHNOLOGIES, INC. Please see “Attachment O” at the end of this section.

See Page 19 for Attachment O, Non-Collusion Statement

See Attachment O. Please see Attachment O on page 60. Please see Section 4. Attachment “O” – Non-Collusion Statement Form provided on Pg 148.

World Fiber has completed Attachment O: Non-Collusion Statement form. The executed form is included behind Tab 4. Required Forms.

LR 8. SCRUTINIZED COMPANIES LIST CERTIFICATION: ANY COMPANY, PRINCIPALS, OR OWNERS ON THE SCRUTINIZED COMPANIES WITH ACTIVITIES IN SUDAN LIST OR ON THE SCRUTINIZED COMPANIES WITH ACTIVITIES IN THE IRAN PETROLEUM ENERGY SECTOR LIST IS PROHIBITED FROM SUBMITTING A BID, PROPOSAL OR RESPONSE TO A BROWARD COUNTY SOLICITATION FOR GOODS OR SERVICES IN AN AMOUNT EQUAL TO OR GREATER THAN $1 MILLION. THEREFORE, IF APPLICABLE, EACH COMPANY SUBMITTING A BID, PROPOSAL OR RESPONSE TO A SOLICITATION MUST CERTIFY TO THE COUNTY THAT IT IS NOT ON EITHER LIST AT THE TIME OF SUBMITTING A BID, PROPOSAL OR RESPONSE. THE CERTIFICATION FORM IS REFERENCED AS “SCRUTINIZED COMPANIES LIST CERTIFICATION” (ATTACHMENT P) AND SHOULD BE COMPLETED AND SUBMITTED WITH YOUR PROPOSAL BUT MUST BE COMPLETED AND SUBMITTED PRIOR TO AWARD.





TECHNOLOGIES, INC. No violation. Please see “Attachment P” at the end of this section.

See Page 20 for Attachment P, Scrutinized Companies List Certification

See Attachment P. Please see Attachment P on page 61. Please see Section 4. Attachment “P” – Scrutinized Companies List certification provided on Pg. 149.

World Fiber has completed Attachment P: Scrutinized Companies List Certification. The executed form is included behind Tab 4. Required Forms.


EVALUATION CRITERIA

of 27

PREVIOUS CONTRACT EXPERIENCE WITH PROPOSER FROM CONTRACT CENTRAL SYSTEM COUNTY (PER CONTRACT CENTRAL DATABASE SEARCH)





TECHNOLOGIES, INC. VS0000010275 - FLORIDA SAFETY CONTRACTORS, INC. Prime Vendor Summary No Open End Contracts No Fixed Contracts No Vendor Performance Evaluations No Purchase Orders

VC0000026093 - HORSEPOWER ELECTRIC INC Prime Vendor Summary Open End Contracts - Open: 1 Total $0.00 Expired: 0 Amt Used: $0.00 Fixed Contracts - Open: 1 Total $990,860.00 Closed: 0 Total: $0.00 No Vendor Performance Evaluations Purchase Orders: 1 POs With A Total Amt Of: $990,860.00 Paid To Dt: $0.00 Balance: $990,860.00

VC0000035131 - STATE CONTRACTING & ENGINEERING CORP Prime Vendor Summary No Open End Contracts Fixed Contracts - Open: 0 Total $0.00 Closed: 1 Total: $17,167,787.51 3 Evaluations Have Been Completed For a Overall Average Of: 3.42 Year 2000 = 2.70 Year 2003 = 3.78 Year 2004 = 3.78

• One (1) of the evaluations contained an answer rated 1and/or 2.

• There were 23 evaluation questions within the one (1) evaluation which contained an answer rated 1 and/or 2. There is 1 out of 23 questions rated with a #2 – Poor and 0 out of 23 questions rated with a #1 – Unsatisfactory.

Purchase Orders: 1 POs With A Total Amt Of: $51,373.09 Paid To Dt: $51,373.09 Balance: $0.00

VC0000023203 - TRAFFIC CONTROL DEVICES Prime Vendor Summary No Open End Contracts No Fixed Contracts 2 Evaluations Have Been Completed For A Overall Average Of: 4.35 (Year: 1990) None of the Evaluations contained an answer rated 1 and/or 2. No Purchase Orders

VC0000020425 - WEEKLEY ASPHALT PAVING INC Prime Vendor Summary Open End Contracts - Open: 2 Total $12,874,305.00 Expired: 5 Amt Used: $31,574,936.18 Fixed Contracts - Open: 1 Total $2,963,972.67 Closed: 26 Total: $8,020,010.18 29 Evaluations Have Been Completed For A Overall Average Of: 3.31 (includes current and older evaluations)

• Nine (9) of the evaluations contained an answer rated 1and/or 2.

• There were 156 evaluation questions within the nine (9) evaluations which contained an answer rated 1 and/or 2. There are 19 out of 156 questions rated with a #2 – Poor and 10 out of 156 questions rated with a #1 – Unsatisfactory.

Purchase Orders: 941 POs With A Total Amt Of: $49,041,509.59 Paid To Dt: $36,844,955.53 Balance: $12,196,554.06

VS0000002687 - WORLD FIBER TECHNOLOGIES INC Prime Vendor Summary No Open End Contracts No Fixed Contracts No Vendor Performance Evaluations No Purchase Orders


EVALUATION CRITERIA

of 27

(R) REFERENCES FLORIDA SAFETY CONTRACTORS

HORSEPOWER ELECTRIC STATE CONTRACTING & ENGINEERING CORP.

TRAFFIC CONTROL DEVICES WEEKLEY ASPHALT PAVING WORLD FIBER

Reference Contact Information:

Contact 1: Mike Scanlon Title of Contact: Hillsborough County Project #C-0185-09; Race Track Road Reference Organization: City of Tampa Reference Project: City of Tampa

Contact 1: Donald Little Title of Contact: Reference Organization: F.D.O.T District 4 Reference Project: FDOT T4321 Powerline Road

Contact 1: .Matt Carlock Title of Contact: Reference Organization: District 4 FDOT Reference Project: Design-Build Soundwall

Contact 1: Michael Ruland Title of Contact: Resident Engineer Reference Organization: FDOT District Five Reference Project: Daytona Beach Construction

Contact 1: Charlie Dodge Title of Contact: Reference Organization: City of Pembroke Pines Reference Project: Roadway Improvements for various locations along the Pembroke Rd. corridor…

Contact 1: Doug Burkhart Title of Contact: GEC program manger Reference Organization: FDOT - District 1 Reference Project: 430138-1-52-01

R1. WAS THE FIRM THE PRIME CONTRACTOR?

Yes Reference did not reply back Reference did not reply back Yes Yes Yes

R2. WERE YOU SATISFIED WITH THE FIRM’S OVERALL PERFORMANCE?

Yes Reference did not reply back Reference did not reply back Yes Yes “This is a design-build contract (#E1J49). The contract notice to proceed was issued on June 10, 2012. The contract duration is 276 days. The schedule submitted by the firm indicates a project end date of November 26, 2012. Design work is nearing completion, Construction activities have not yet started.”

R3. WAS THE PROJECT COMPLETED ON TIME?

Yes Reference did not reply back Reference did not reply back Yes Yes “The project is in process.”

R4. WAS THE PROJECT COMPLETED WITHIN THE APPROVED BUDGET?


R5. DID THE FIRM WORK WELL WITH THE OWNER?



EVALUATION CRITERIA

of 27





Contact 1: Mike Scanlon Title of Contact: Hillsborough County Project #C-0185-09; Race Track Road Reference Organization: City of Tampa Reference Project: City of Tampa

Contact 1: Donald Little Title of Contact: Reference Organization: F.D.O.T District 4 Reference Project: FDOT T4321 Powerline Road

Contact 1: .Matt Carlock Title of Contact: Reference Organization: District 4 FDOT Reference Project: Design-Build Soundwall

Contact 1: Michael Ruland Title of Contact: Resident Engineer Reference Organization: FDOT District Five Reference Project: Daytona Beach Construction

Contact 1: Charlie Dodge Title of Contact: Reference Organization: City of Pembroke Pines Reference Project: Roadway Improvements for various locations along the Pembroke Rd. corridor…

Contact 1: Doug Burkhart Title of Contact: GEC program manger Reference Organization: FDOT - District 1 Reference Project: 430138-1-52-01

R6. DID THE FIRM RESPOND TO OWNER/REGULATORY AGENCY IN A TIMELY MANNER?


R7. DID THE FIRM SUPERVISE AND COORDINATE THE WORK OF THE SUBCONTRACTORS EFFECTIVELY?


R8. HOW WOULD YOU CHARACTERIZE THE QUALITY OF THE SERVICES RENDERED? EXCELLENT, VERY GOOD, GOOD, FAIR, POOR

Excellent Reference did not reply back Reference did not reply back Very Good Very Good “The project is in process.”

R9. GIVEN THE OPPORTUNITY, WOULD YOU HIRE THIS FIRM AGAIN FOR A SIMILAR SERVICE?

Yes Reference did not reply back Reference did not reply back N/A. “We select our contractors by low bid advertisement.”

Yes “The project is in process.”


EVALUATION CRITERIA

of 27

(R) REFERENCES


FLORIDA SAFETY CONTRACTORS



Contact 2: Brian McKishnie Title of Contact: District Construction Engineer Reference Organization: FDOT District 7 Reference Project: FDOT District 7 Design/Build Push Button Contract

Contact 2: Rafael Ballestero Title of Contact: Deputy Director of Construction Reference Organization: City of Delray Beach Reference Project: Mast- Arm Traffic Signalization

Contact 2: Bo Sanchez Title of Contact: Reference Organization: Sawgrass Expressway Reference Project: Sawgrass Expressway – Design-Build 8 Toll Ramp Conversions

Contact 2: Tom Crossman Title of Contact: Reference Organization: FDOT District Two Reference Project: FDOT District Two, Traffic Signal Pushbutton Contract (FDOT#E2L84).

Contact 2: Brad Salisbury Title of Contact: Reference Organization: FDOT District 6 Reference Project: Improvements to SW 8 St. and the SR-821 Interchange (HEFT) Ramp

Contact 2: Chad Williams Title of Contact: P.E. Reference Organization: FDOT - District 3 Reference Project: I‐10/110 FREEWAY MANAGEMENT SYSTEM, DESIGN‐BUILD


Brian attached the CPPR rating for FSC Several areas were evaluated and FSC’s score is a 100%.

Yes Yes Yes Reference did not reply back Yes














EVALUATION CRITERIA

of 27

(R) REFERENCES


FLORIDA SAFETY CONTRACTORS



Contact 2: Brian McKishnie Title of Contact: District Construction Engineer Reference Organization: FDOT District 7 Reference Project: FDOT District 7 Design/Build Push Button Contract

Contact 2: Rafael Ballestero Title of Contact: Deputy Director of Construction Reference Organization: City of Delray Beach Reference Project: Mast- Arm Traffic Signalization

Contact 2: Bo Sanchez Title of Contact: Reference Organization: Sawgrass Expressway Reference Project: Sawgrass Expressway – Design-Build 8 Toll Ramp Conversions

Contact 2: Tom Crossman Title of Contact: Reference Organization: FDOT District Two Reference Project: FDOT District Two, Traffic Signal Pushbutton Contract (FDOT#E2L84).

Contact 2: Brad Salisbury Title of Contact: Reference Organization: FDOT District 6 Reference Project: Improvements to SW 8 St. and the SR-821 Interchange (HEFT) Ramp

Contact 2: Chad Williams Title of Contact: P.E. Reference Organization: FDOT - District 3 Reference Project: I‐10/110 FREEWAY MANAGEMENT SYSTEM, DESIGN‐BUILD









Excellent Very Good to Excellent Very Good Reference did not reply back Excellent





EVALUATION CRITERIA

of 27




Contact 3: Wayne Gilmartin Title of Contact: Resident Engineer Reference Organization: Semper Fi Services Reference Project: Polk Co. Project #10-003-CAR; CR-37B

Contact 3: Mr. Jeffrey L. Skidmore Title of Contact Reference Organization: City of Weston Public Works Dept. Reference Project: : Mast-Arm School Flashers @ Somerset Charter School

Contact 3: Neyda Otero Title of Contact: Director of Construction Management Reference Organization: PineCrest School CM @ Risk Reference Project: Risk New Chilled Water HVAC Power Plant.

Contact 3: Jonathan Sands Title of Contact: District Construction Engineer Reference Organization: FDOT District One Reference Project:

Contact 3: Javier Bejarano Title of Contact: FDOT Project Manager Reference Organization: Weekly Asphalt Paving FDOT District 4 Reference Project: SR 70 (Commercial Blvd.) from SR 817 (University Drive) to NW 64 Ave., Mast Arms, Signaliztion,

Contact 3: Keith Bryant Title of Contact: Traffic Engineering Manager Reference Organization: Bay County, Florida Reference Project: ADVANCED TRAFFIC MANAGEMENT SYSTEM, PHASES 1, 2 & 3, DESIGN‐BUILD


Yes Yes Yes Reference did not reply back Yes Yes


Yes Yes Yes Reference did not reply back Yes “Weekly Asphalt Paving Inc. staff are aware of the customer service satisfaction and they make a great effort to accomplish it.”

Yes




Yes Yes Yes Reference did not reply back Yes “Final payment was less that original contract amount.”

Yes


Yes Yes “Horsepower Electric has successfully completed several projects for the City of Weston over the past 14 years. “

Yes Reference did not reply back Yes Yes


EVALUATION CRITERIA

of 27




Contact 3: Wayne Gilmartin Title of Contact: Resident Engineer Reference Organization: Semper Fi Services Reference Project: Polk Co. Project #10-003-CAR; CR-37B

Contact 3: Mr. Jeffrey L. Skidmore Title of Contact Reference Organization: City of Weston Public Works Dept. Reference Project: : Mast-Arm School Flashers @ Somerset Charter School

Contact 3: Neyda Otero Title of Contact: Director of Construction Management Reference Organization: PineCrest School CM @ Risk Reference Project: Risk New Chilled Water HVAC Power Plant.

Contact 3: Jonathan Sands Title of Contact: District Construction Engineer Reference Organization: FDOT District One Reference Project:

Contact 3: Javier Bejarano Title of Contact: FDOT Project Manager Reference Organization: Weekly Asphalt Paving FDOT District 4 Reference Project: SR 70 (Commercial Blvd.) from SR 817 (University Drive) to NW 64 Ave., Mast Arms, Signaliztion,

Contact 3: Keith Bryant Title of Contact: Traffic Engineering Manager Reference Organization: Bay County, Florida Reference Project: ADVANCED TRAFFIC MANAGEMENT SYSTEM, PHASES 1, 2 & 3, DESIGN‐BUILD






Excellent Excellent Excellent Reference did not reply back Excellent Excellent


Yes Yes Yes Reference did not reply back Yes “I would like to work with Weekley Asphalt Inc in any future project.”

Yes


EVALUATION CRITERIA

of 27

(R) REFERENCES KIMLEY-HORN AND ASSOCIATES, INC.

CALVIN, GIORDANO & ASSOCIATES, INC.

DEROSE & TOM HALL ATKINS KEITH & SCHNARS, P.A. (K&S) F.R. ALEMAN & ASSOCIATES, INC.

Contact 4: Adriana Manzanares Title of Contact: Project Manager Reference Organization: FDOT District Four Reference Project: SR A1A/Collins Ave. From 26th St. to Harding Ave.

Contact 4: Sonia Torres Title of Contact: City Engineer Reference Organization: City of Lauderdale Lakes Reference Project: Weston Road/Meridian Blvd Traffic Signal Design

Contact 4: Richard Meister Title of Contact: Reference Organization: Isle of Capri Reference Project: Isle of Capri Temporary Traffic Signal Plans.

Contact 4: Chris Nolen Title of Contact: Reference Organization: FDOT District Five Reference Project: Volusia County Mast Arm Replacement Design-Build

Contact 4: Donovan Pessoa Title of Contact: Reference Organization: FDOT District IV Reference Project: Andrews Avenue Segments 2 & 3, Broward County, FL

Contact 4: John Foglesong Title of Contact: Reference Organization: Broward County Port Everglades Reference Project:


Yes Yes Reference did not reply back

Reference did not reply back Reference did not reply back

"Unfortunately, given that we have a current open contract with your prime consultant, I will be unable to provide this."







Reference did not reply back Reference did not reply back "Unfortunately, given that we have a current open contract with your prime consultant, I will be unable to provide this."









EVALUATION CRITERIA

of 27




Contact 4: Adriana Manzanares Title of Contact: Project Manager Reference Organization: FDOT District Four Reference Project: SR A1A/Collins Ave. From 26th St. to Harding Ave.

Contact 4: Sonia Torres Title of Contact: City Engineer Reference Organization: City of Lauderdale Lakes Reference Project: Weston Road/Meridian Blvd Traffic Signal Design

Contact 4: Richard Meister Title of Contact: Reference Organization: Isle of Capri Reference Project: Isle of Capri Temporary Traffic Signal Plans.

Contact 4: Chris Nolen Title of Contact: Reference Organization: FDOT District Five Reference Project: Volusia County Mast Arm Replacement Design-Build

Contact 4: Donovan Pessoa Title of Contact: Reference Organization: FDOT District IV Reference Project: Andrews Avenue Segments 2 & 3, Broward County, FL

Contact 4: John Foglesong Title of Contact: Reference Organization: Broward County Port Everglades Reference Project:








Very Good Excellent Reference did not reply back






EVALUATION CRITERIA

of 27




Contact 5: John Thompson Title of Contact: FDOT project manager Reference Organization: FDOT District Four Reference Project: SR 710 improvements

Contact 5: Denise Barrett Title of Contact: Director of Communications Reference Organization: City of Weston Reference Project: Weston Road/Meridian Blvd Traffic Signal Design

Contact 5: Joseph Najjarian Title of Contact: Reference Organization: Reference Project: Sunrise Blvd./SR-7 Interchange Traffic Signals

Contact 5: Jacqueline Kassel Title of Contact: Chief of Transportation Engineering Reference Organization: City of Newport Reference Project: City of Newport News Design Services for Mast Arm Conversion

Contact 5: Judy Solaun-Gonzalez Title of Contact: Reference Organization: FDOT District 6 Reference Project: NW 122nd Street Bridge Widening, Miami-Dade County

Contact 5: Jennifer Barrow Title of Contact: Reference Organization: FDOT - District 6 Reference Project: Mast Arms Conversion Projects (Design Build)


Yes Yes Reference did not reply back Reference did not reply back Yes Yes


Yes “The consultant has been very responsive during the design and construction phases to RFI’s, changes to criteria and scopes, and public involvement”

Yes “CGA and Traffic Engineer Jeff Maxwell have and continue to provide excellent services. Services included survey, lighting, traffic engineering and signal warrant analysis.”

Reference did not reply back Reference did not reply back Yes Yes




No “Project budgets have changed due to local inputs on projects and to criteria change, not due to the design consultant”

Yes Reference did not reply back Reference did not reply back Yes Yes


EVALUATION CRITERIA

of 27




Contact 5: John Thompson Title of Contact: FDOT project manager Reference Organization: FDOT District Four Reference Project: SR 710 improvements

Contact 5: Denise Barrett Title of Contact: Director of Communications Reference Organization: City of Weston Reference Project: Weston Road/Meridian Blvd Traffic Signal Design

Contact 5: Joseph Najjarian Title of Contact: Reference Organization: Reference Project: Sunrise Blvd./SR-7 Interchange Traffic Signals

Contact 5: Jacqueline Kassel Title of Contact: Chief of Transportation Engineering Reference Organization: City of Newport Reference Project: City of Newport News Design Services for Mast Arm Conversion

Contact 5: Judy Solaun-Gonzalez Title of Contact: Reference Organization: FDOT District 6 Reference Project: NW 122nd Street Bridge Widening, Miami-Dade County

Contact 5: Jennifer Barrow Title of Contact: Reference Organization: FDOT - District 6 Reference Project: Mast Arms Conversion Projects (Design Build)


Yes Yes “The City and firm have an excellent working relationship with open dialoge and continual progress reporting.”

Reference did not reply back Reference did not reply back Yes “I don’t understand this question.”


Yes “The firm was very responsive” Yes Reference did not reply back Reference did not reply back Yes Yes




Very Good Excellent Reference did not reply back Reference did not reply back Very Good Excellent


Yes Yes “The City continues to contract with Calvin Giordano for services.”

Reference did not reply back Reference did not reply back Yes Yes


EVALUATION CRITERIA

of 27




Contact 6: Anson Sonnett Title of Contact: Reference Organization: FDOT District Four Reference Project:

Contact 6: Joe McLaughlin Title of Contact: Reference Organization: City of Pembroke Pines Reference Project: I-75/Pines Blvd Traffic Signal Designs for 5Intersections

Contact 6: Richard Welch Title of Contact: Reference Organization: Broward County Aviation Department Reference Project: Air handler unit Replacement

Contact 6: Mike Kennon Title of Contact: Reference Organization: City of Raleigh Reference Project: City of Raleigh Morgan Street Two-Way Conversion

Contact 6: Patricia Roebling Title of Contact: Reference Organization: City of Port St. Lucie Reference Project: Becker Road and Crosstown Parkway Interchanges over I-95, St Lucie County, FL

Contact 6: Dong Chen Title of Contact: P.E. Reference Organization: FDOT - District 4 Reference Project:

R1. WAS THE FIRM THE PRIME CONTRACTOR

Reference did not reply back Yes “Yes” DeRose was the Consultant that did the design and construction administration. Hilll York installed the units (Contractor).

Reference did not reply back Reference did not reply back No “The consultant served as the engineering firm to the prime contractor.”


Reference did not reply back Yes Yes Reference did not reply back Reference did not reply back Yes


Reference did not reply back No Calvin Giordano’s portion of the project was completed on time. The road contractor had problems

Yes Reference did not reply back Reference did not reply back Yes


Reference did not reply back No “Calvin Giordano’s portion of the project was completed within budget. The road contractor had Problems”

Yes Reference did not reply back Reference did not reply back Yes




EVALUATION CRITERIA

of 27




Contact 6: Anson Sonnett Title of Contact: Reference Organization: FDOT District Four Reference Project:

Contact 6: Joe McLaughlin Title of Contact: Reference Organization: City of Pembroke Pines Reference Project: I-75/Pines Blvd Traffic Signal Designs for 5Intersections

Contact 6: Richard Welch Title of Contact: Reference Organization: Broward County Aviation Department Reference Project: Air handler unit Replacement

Contact 6: Mike Kennon Title of Contact: Reference Organization: City of Raleigh Reference Project: City of Raleigh Morgan Street Two-Way Conversion

Contact 6: Patricia Roebling Title of Contact: Reference Organization: City of Port St. Lucie Reference Project: Becker Road and Crosstown Parkway Interchanges over I-95, St Lucie County, FL

Contact 6: Dong Chen Title of Contact: P.E. Reference Organization: FDOT - District 4 Reference Project:




Reference did not reply back “Calvin Giordano only did the design. Another firm did the field supervision.”

Yes Reference did not reply back Reference did not reply back Yes “This firm had supervision over other engineering efforts.”


Reference did not reply back Very Good Excellent Reference did not reply back Reference did not reply back Very Good



DESIGN BUILD - MAST ARMS CONVERSION PROJECTSSUMMARY OF DB TEAM'S FDOT PREQUALIFICATIONS FDOT WEBSITE REVIEW PERFORMED ON: 8/20/2012CONTRACTOR AND CONSULTANT

REF. NO.WORK CLASS

FDOT PREQUALIFICATION FLORIDA SAFETY CONTRACTORS, INC. TEAM HORSEPOWER ELECTRIC INC. TEAM STATE CONTRACTING & ENGINEERING

CORP. TEAMTRAFFIC CONTROL DEVICES, INC.

TEAM WEEKLEY ASPHALT PAVING, INC. TEAM WORLD FIBER TECHNOLOGIES, INC. TEAM

TEAM MEMBERS LISTED Kimley Horn and Associates, Inc. Calvin, Giordano & Associates, Inc. DeRose Design Consultants*** Atkins North America, Inc. Keith and Schnars, P.A. F.R. Aleman & Associates, Inc.

Stoner and Associates, Inc. Lakdas/Yohalem Engineering, Inc. Joseph Roles & Associates Professional Service Industries, Inc. CES Consultants, Inc. Michael Baker, Jr. Inc. (aka LPA Group, Inc.)

Cardno TBE, Inc. Radise International, Inc. Radise International, Inc. Compass Point Surveyors, PL American Lighting & Signalization, Inc. CES Consultants, Inc.

Tierra South Florida, Inc. Signal Technology and Installation Corp. Cardno TBE, Inc. ASC Logic, Inc.

Stoner & Associates, Inc.

CONTRACTOR PREQUALIFICATION

1 Traffic Signals Florida Safety Contractor's Horsepower Electric, Inc. State Contracting & Engineering Corp. and Signal Technology Traffic Control Devices, Inc. Weekley Asphalt, Inc. and American Lighting

& Signalization, Inc. WORLD FIBER TECHNOLOGIES, INC.

2 Computerized Traffic Control Systems Florida Safety Contractor's Horsepower Electric, Inc. Signal Technology and Installtion Corp. Traffic Control Devices, Inc. Weekley Asphalt, Inc. and American Lighting & Signalization, Inc. WORLD FIBER TECHNOLOGIES, INC.

3 Electrical Work Florida Safety Contractor's Horsepower Electric, Inc. State Contracting & Engineering Corp. and Signal Technology Traffic Control Devices, Inc. Weekley Asphalt, Inc. and American Lighting

& Signalization, Inc. WORLD FIBER TECHNOLOGIES, INC.

CONSULTANT PREQUALIFICATION

1 3.1 Minor Highway Design Kimley Horn and Associates, Inc. Calvin, Giordano & Associates, Inc. Joseph Roles and Associates, Inc. Atkins North America, Inc. Keith and Schnars, P.A. F.R. Aleman & Associates, Inc.

2 4.1.1 Miscellaneous Structures Kimley Horn and Associates, Inc. Lakdas/Yohalem Engineering, Inc. Atkins North America, Inc. Keith and Schnars, P.A. Michael Baker, Jr. Inc. (aka LPA Group, Inc.)

3 7.3 Signalization Kimley Horn and Associates, Inc. Calvin, Giordano & Associates, Inc. Atkins North America, Inc. Keith and Schnars, P.A. F.R. Aleman & Associates, Inc.

4 8.1 Control Surveying Kimley Horn and Associates, Inc. Calvin, Giordano & Associates, Inc. Refer to Note 5 below. Atkins North America, Inc. Keith and Schnars, P.A. F.R. Aleman & Associates, Inc.

5 8.2 Design, Right-of-Way, and Construction Surveying Kimley Horn and Associates, Inc. Calvin, Giordano & Associates, Inc. Refer to Note 5 below. Atkins North America, Inc. Keith and Schnars, P.A. F.R. Aleman & Associates, Inc.

6 9.1 Soils Exploration Tierra South Florida, Inc. Radise International, Inc. Radise International, Inc. Professional Service Industries, Inc. CES Consultants, Inc. CES Consultants, Inc.

7 9.2 Geotechnical Classification Lab Testing Tierra South Florida, Inc. Radise International, Inc. Radise International, Inc. Professional Service Industries, Inc. CES Consultants, Inc. CES Consultants, Inc.

8 9.4.1 Standard Foundations Studies Tierra South Florida, Inc. Radise International, Inc. Radise International, Inc. Professional Service Industries, Inc. CES Consultants, Inc. CES Consultants, Inc.

NOTES: 1 Prequalifications listed are based on major scopes of work for this project and are not all-inclusive.

2 RLI did not require specific work class prequalifications to be submitted (requested firms to describe the qualifications and relevant experience of the proposed Design-Build Team, including any FDOT prequalifications individual firms may possess).

3 Firms listed may have other FDOT prequlifications that are not listed.

4 Blank boxes indicate that Design Build Team memebers listed in the RLI Submittal did not posses specific FDOT Prequalification listed.

5 Stoner & Associates previously prequalified in items 8.1 and 8.2 (2009-2010); vendor is currently resubmitting for FDOT prequalification.

*** DeRose Design Consultants is currently in process to apply for FDOT prequalifications.

(ps) project specific criteria - broward county, florida · (ps) project specific criteria ......

Documents