proven techniques for optimizing fp&a processes
TRANSCRIPT
U N I F I E D P E R F O R M A N C E M A N A G E M E N T
Proven Techniques for
Optimizing FP&A Processes
Peri Pierone
CEO
Agenda
2
• The Strategic Role of Finance
• Axiom Research
• Keys to Improving Management Reporting
• Keys to Improving Planning
3
The Strategic Role of Finance….
How is that evolving in your organization?
As a Data Steward Increasingly ‘own’ data to drive decisions Own ‘non-GL’ systems, (i.e., cost accounting)
As a Partner to Operations Educating managers on cost realities Supporting the monitoring function (policing)
As a Strategic Advisor to the Organization Being more agile and responsive to needs Supporting data-driven decision making
4
Analytic Capability
Efficiency & Control
Scorekeeper
• Reporting• Accuracy• Retrospective• Disconnected
StrategicPartner
• Advising• Growth focused• Risk aware• Present & future• Connected
Controller
• Gatekeeper• Expense focused• Governance• Retrospective
Analyst
• Measuring• Planning• Calculating• Modeling• Past and future
The Evolving Role of Finance
Quadrant 4Embodies all the characteristics of the other three quadrants plus leadership and outbound activities
Question #1
5
2013 Research Demographics
5%
32%
23%
7%
7%
4%5%
17%
Role in the Organization
CFO
Finance VP/Director
Financial Analyst
Budgeting/Reporting
IT
Executive
Consultant
Other
15%
10%
25%
12%
38%
Company Size
$0-$50M
$50-$100M
$100-$500M
$500M-$1B
$1B+
* 2013 Axiom EPM Survey
6
Market Research
2014 Performance Management Priorities
Performance Initiatives
Providing more insightful reporting and analysis to support decision making
Understanding key drivers of profitability across various dimensions (customer, channel etc.)
Cost containment and efficiency
Improving and shortening budgeting and planning process
Scenario modeling to analyze the impact of various drivers, initiatives and risk factors
Linking long-range strategic planning and forecasts to short-term operational plans
Becoming a better strategic partner to the business
Streamlining the financial consolidations and close process21%
23%
35%
41%
47%
48%
53%
76%
0% 20% 40% 60% 80%Axiom EPM 2013 Performance Management Survey
7
Challenge #1: More Insightful Reporting
• Provide more insightful reporting and analysis to support decision making
Management reporting
Ad hoc end user reporting
Legal/Statutory reporting
Prepackaged eternal reporting (SEC formats, XBRL etc.) 13%
16%
59%
94%
0% 50% 100%
Which areas of reporting are most important for you to address?
8
What is your Most Significant Reporting Challenge?
27%
19%
16%
14%
8%
7%
6% 3%Ability to pull data from multiple data sources
Accessing clean, consistent and trusted data
Ability to "drill" into reports and understand details
Need for better dashboards and visualizations
Ability to deliver meaningful ad hoc analysis
Ease of report creation
Ability to integrate with MS Office Etc.
Other
9
Report Example Financial and OperationalQuestion #2
10
Showcasing Effective Use of Visualization
Question #3
11
Add Intelligence to Reporting*
Customer
Wait
Times
Relevancy
Tolerance
Trend
!Early alert
!
Call to Action
ForecastImpact
Unplanned
Staff Turnover
Increased 14%
AdditionalContext
Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3
* Courtesy of David Axson - Accenture
Question #4
12
Survey Research on Budgeting
12%
26%
28%
19%
8%7%
How long is your budgeting process?
1 - 2 months2 - 3 months3 - 4 months4 - 5 months5 - 6 monthsGreater than 6 months
32%
8%36%
13%
6%
What is the most important factor impacting your budgeting timeline?
Internal business processes
Technology (or lack thereof)
Lack of resources
Iterating and negotiating to reach an acceptable plan
The number of participants
Other (please specify)* 2013 Axiom EPM Survey
Question #5
13
Axiom Thought Leadership
Proven Approaches to Improving the Planning Process
Reduce the size of the chart of accounts
Driver-based intelligent modeling
– Financials are outcomes and should be treated as such
Scenario-based planning – sensitivity analysis
Initiative-based planning
Introduce Rolling forecasts
1
2
3
4
5
14
Ideas for Improving the Budget Cycle Time – COA Reduction
1. Streamline the input required –take a more calculation rich approach
2. Reduce the size of your chart of accounts1. Detail does not equal accuracy
0% 20% 40% 60%
50 - 100
100 - 200
201 - 300
>300
# of Accounts in Budget
Question #6
15
Best Practices in Planning
Driver Based Planning Revenue / COS / Margin
Gross Margin AnalysisModel: A4 2013MY JAN FEB
Unit Forecast Wholesale Pricing Manufacturer’s Cost Per Unit Stats – Options,
Freight, Port Processing, Incentives etc.
Audi A4
16
Key Drivers:
• Number of Agents
• Applications Per Agent
• Policies In Force
• Rate Changes
• Commission Rates
• Customer Retention
•Consumer/Producer Price Index
• Loss Frequency
• Loss Severity
• Claim Cycle Time
• # of Claims
• # of Adjusters
• # of Underwriters
• # of Customer Service Reps
Driver-based Planning is the Key – Insurance Example
INVESTMENT INCOME
Net Investment Income Earned
Net Realized Capital Gains (Losses)
Net Investment Gain (Loss)
OTHER INCOME
Net Gain (Loss) from Agents’ or Premium Balances Charged Off
Finance and Service Fees Not Included in Premiums
Aggregate Write Ins for Miscellaneous Income
Total Other Income
Dividends to Policyholders
Net Income, after Dividends to Policyholders
Federal & Foreign Income Taxes Incurred
Net Income
ROA / ROE
UNDERWRITING INCOME
Written/Earned Premiums
Losses Incurred
Loss Expenses Incurred
Other UW Expenses Incurred
Aggregate Write Ins for Underwriting Deductions
Net Underwriting Gain (Loss)
Question #7
17
Best Practices in Planning
Scenario Planning and Uncertainty
The notion of uncertainty is at the crux of both finance and risk management domains Even so when it comes to strategic planning, budgeting and forecasting, most
practitioners are content with completing the “the budget” or “the forecast” without addressing the issue of uncertainty
There is false sense of security when underlying assumptions are treated as facts vs. assumptions – masking both exposure and opportunity
90% 8%…Of the organizations surveyed take
at least 2 months to complete a budget – many more than 4 months
…Only 8% of organizations surveyed do scenario planning regularly.
Source: Business Finance, April 2012
18
Easiest to set up and process
Useful in quantifying the impact of a particular DV
Can be a great educational tool
Primary criticism is its simplicity – market variables seldom move on a stand-alone basis
Best Practices in Planning
Single Variable Sensitivity Analysis Question #8
19
Best Practices in Planning
Initiative Based Scenario Planning
Forecasting Methods Include:
Examples:
• Statistically-Driven Modeling• Payor Mix and Revenue Forecasting• Labor Rate & Efficiency Targets• Cost Modeling
• Re-Design ER, Flow Thru Implications• Expand Cardiac Cath Lab• Open an OP Urgent Care (Northside)
Analysis Contains:
1. Income Statement2. Balance Sheet3. Cash Flow4. Key Ratios
Consolidated Results
Base Case(Conservative)
Initiative #1
Initiative #3
Initiative #2
Initiative #4
Base CaseGiven current trends, what is our financial outlook 3-10 years?
InitiativesAs we prioritize growth or cost containment initiatives, what is the incremental impact?
ScenariosWhat is the impact on our baseline projections given the initiatives we’ve proposed?
Question #9
20
Q1 2013
Q2 2013
Q3 2013
Q4 2013
Q1 2014
Q2 2014
Q3 2014
Q4 2014
Feb Forecast
May Forecast
Aug Forecast
Nov Forecast
Actual Forecast Out Period
Rolling nature provides consistent business outlook Tends to be more accurate than aspirational budgets Enables waterfall analysis and trending
Best Practices in Planning
Rolling Forecasts Question #10
21
Score Your Organization
• Count the “Xs” for each column and write result in each column box
• Multiple each column total by its column multiplier
• Sum the multiplied totals for the five columns into a single score
22
Performance Management Assessment
0 – 17EPM Novice
• Reporting & analytics aren’t providing the value they could
• The organization likely lives on spreadsheets
• Planning processes are not well evolved
18 – 34EPM Intermediate• Your organization has
some insightful reporting
• Likely good investments in enabling technology
• You’ve moved beyond simple budgeting
34 – 50EPM Expert
• The analytical nature of your reporting is impressive
• Technology is well leveraged
• Planning processes are highly evolved