proposed philippine jury law

411
1 NATIONAL JURY LAW & PROCEDURES Master Judicial Procedural Enforcement Law and Rules To Enable the People To Exercise their Sovereign Deciding Power in Justice. TABLE OF CONTENTS DESCRIPTION PAGE NO. THE PREAMBLE - The Reason, Basis, and Objective of the Jury Law . . . . 1 ARTICLE I - Adoption of the Jury System . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 Section 1 - Authority for the Creation of the Jury System . . . . . . . . 3 Section 2 - Democratic master and servant relationship . . . . . . . . . 3 Section 3 - Whistle Blower Protection . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 Section 4 - Prior Indictment of Accused Before Trial of Accused . . . 4 Section 5 - Validity of Jury Provision . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 Section 6 - Transparency Requirements in Public Service . . . . . . . . 4 Section 7 - Jury Duty of Citizens . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 Section 8 - Superiority of Public Initiative Over Congressional . . . . . 5 Section 9 - Coverage and Jurisdiction of the Jury Systems . . . . . . . . 5 Section 10 - No Public Official Is Immune from Jury Action . . . . . . . . 5 Section 11 - No Preferential Jail Accommodation shall be Permitted To Any Accused Public Official . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 Section 12 - Punishment for Discriminatory Jail Accommodation Of Accused Public Official or Any Person . . . . . . . . . . . 6 Section 13 - Violator of Section 11 and 12 if Impeachable official shall be ground for his impeachment . . . . . . . . . 6

Upload: mcamello

Post on 21-Dec-2015

69 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

DESCRIPTION

Draft of the Proposed Philippine Jury Law.

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

1

NATIONAL JURY LAW & PROCEDURES

Master Judicial Procedural Enforcement Law and Rules

To Enable the People To Exercise their Sovereign Deciding Power in Justice.

TABLE OF CONTENTS DESCRIPTION PAGE NO.

THE PREAMBLE - The Reason, Basis, and Objective of the Jury Law . . . . 1

ARTICLE I - Adoption of the Jury System . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3

Section 1 - Authority for the Creation of the Jury System . . . . . . . . 3

Section 2 - Democratic master and servant relationship . . . . . . . . . 3

Section 3 - Whistle Blower Protection . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4

Section 4 - Prior Indictment of Accused Before Trial of Accused . . . 4

Section 5 - Validity of Jury Provision . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4

Section 6 - Transparency Requirements in Public Service . . . . . . . . 4

Section 7 - Jury Duty of Citizens . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5

Section 8 - Superiority of Public Initiative Over Congressional . . . . . 5

Section 9 - Coverage and Jurisdiction of the Jury Systems . . . . . . . . 5

Section 10 - No Public Official Is Immune from Jury Action . . . . . . . . 5

Section 11 - No Preferential Jail Accommodation shall be

Permitted To Any Accused Public Official . . . . . . . . . . . . 6

Section 12 - Punishment for Discriminatory Jail Accommodation

Of Accused Public Official or Any Person . . . . . . . . . . . 6

Section 13 - Violator of Section 11 and 12 if Impeachable

official shall be ground for his impeachment . . . . . . . . . 6

Page 2: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

2

Section 14 - Punishment of Private Citizen in violation of

Anti-discrimination in jail accommodation . . . . . . . . . . . . 7

ARTICLE II - TYPES AND PRINCIPLES OF THE NATIONAL JURY LAW. . . . 8

Section 1 - Grand Jury and Trial Jury are

the Types of Jury Systems. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8

Section 2 - Jury System shall serve as the Common Front

of the People to Prevent Graft and Corruption . . . . . . . . . 8

Section 3 - No Person or Public Official has power to order

Disclosure Name of Juror or Stop Jury Function . . . . . . . 9

Section 4 - Selection of Jurors by Lottery is Mandatory.

Selection by Appointment Shall Be Void . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9

Section 5 - Trial Defense Attorney Absolutely Prohibited

from Representing Multiple Accused Clients. . . . . . . . . . . 9

Section 6 - Joint liability of Government Entity

and Its Agent in serving the Public . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10

Section 7 - Juries Shall have the Power to

Function In Time of Martial Law . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10

Section 8 - Indemnity to Jurors In the Event of

Injury or Death Arising from Jury Service . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11

Section 9 - Any Person Found Guilty of Serious Criminal Offense

Barred from Occupying Public Office Regardless of

Of Presidential Pardon and Forfeit Retirement Benefits . . 13

Section 10 - Juror, or his heir, claiming indemnity entitled to Hire his

Attorney on Contingency at Government Expense . . . . . . 13

Section 11 - Client-Attorney contract with contingency attorney’s fee . . 13

Section 12- Mandatory for Lawyers to open “Clients’ Trust Account” . . 13

Page 3: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

3

ARTICLE III - THE GRAND JURY. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14

Section 1 - The Sovereign Power of the Grand Jury . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14

Section 2 - The Power of the Grand Jury

To Function is Self-Autonomous . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14

Section 3 - The Composition of the Grand Jury . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14

Section 4 - Qualification of the Members of the Grand Jury . . . . . . . . . 14

Section 5 - Functions of the Grand Jury . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16

Section 6 - Grand Jury to Function with Utmost Secrecy . . . . . . . . . . . 17

Section 7 - Public Contact with Grand Jury or

Grand Jurors is Absolute Prohibited . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17

Section 8 - Certain Objects Any Person is Absolutely Prohibited

from Bringing into the Grand Jury Room . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18

Section 9 - Division of a Province or City Into Grand Jury Districts . . . . 18

Section 10 - Authority Responsible in Dividing a Province

Or City Into Grand Jury Districts . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18

Section 11 - Period To Commence Designation of Grand District

Construction of Grand Jury Rooms And Facilities . . . . . . . 18

Section 12 - Sanctions On Authorities Who Fail to Comply

with Duty to Designate and Create Grand Jury

District and Facilities. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19

Section 13 - Disauthorization of Treasurers and Paymasters To

Pay Salaries and Allowances of Authorities For

Non-Compliance of Duties under the Jury Law . . . . . . . . 19

Section 14 - Criminal Liability of Treasurers or Paymasters For

Non-Compliance of his Duties under the Jury Law. . . . . . . 19

Section 15 - Secrecy of the Location of the Grand Jury Room . . . . . . . . 20

Page 4: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

4

Section 16 - The Public and Public Officials Are Absolutely

Prohibited From Entering a Grand Jury Room . . . . . . . . . . 20

Section 17 - Requirement in Presenting a Criminal Complaint

Before the Grand Jury by a Government Prosecutor

Or By a Lawyer in Behalf of his Complaining Client . . . . . . 20

Section 18 - Victims, Eyewitness, Taxpayer’s Group May Initiate

Criminal Complaint Directly with Grand Jury . . . . . . . . . . . 20

Section 19 - In Filing Criminal Complaint With Grand Jury a

Separate List of Witnesses, Apart of Complaint,

Must be Attached to the Complaint . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21

Section 20 - Personal Delivery Requirements In Filing a

Private Criminal Complaint with the Grand Jury . . . . . . . . . 21

Section 21 - Strict Secrecy in Filing Complaint Is Required.

Must be filed before 3:00 P.M. on Working Day . . . . . . . . . 21

Section 22 - Anybody involved in filing of complaint with Grand

Jury is required to keep Matter Strictly Confidential . . . . . 22

Section 23 - No lawyer, prosecutor, fiscal, or third party is allowed

to cross examine a witness before the Grand Jury. . . . . . . 22

Section 24 - Statutory Standard Grand Jury Instruction . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23

Section 25 - Role of Government in the Function of the Grand

Jury is Strictly Advisory and Has no Control over . . . . . . . . 52

Section 26 - Subpoena Powers of the Grand Jury.

Enforceable Anywhere in the Philippines . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 52

Section 27 - Secrecy of the filing of the GJ criminal indictment. . . . . . . . 52

Section 28 - Grand Jury Jurisdiction To Investigate and To File

Indictment In Court. No Judge has the Power to

Restrain the Function of the Grand Jury . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 53

Section 29 - The Power of the Grand Jury to File Disciplinary

Complaints against licensed professionals . . . . . . . . . . . . . 53

Page 5: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

5

Section 30 - Affidavit Not Required to Initiate Grand

Jury Criminal or Disciplinary Actions. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 53

Section 31 - Swearing witness - The Grand Jury as a

Group or its members individually has power

to administer Oath of a Witness . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 54

Section 32 - Location and Set Up of the Grand Jury Room. . . . . . . . . . 54

Section 33 - Executive Judge Is Principally Responsible in

Organizing the Grand Jury or Grand Juries in

His Judicial District . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 54

Section 34 - Clerk of Court or Jury Commissioner of the Executive

Judge Is Responsible of Maintaining the Grand Jury

Room and Facilities in his District. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 54

Section 35 - All Proceedings of the Grand Jury are Strictly

Confidential Even if Martial Law is Declared . . . . . . . . . . . 54

Section 36 - Grand Jury Records cannot be subject to Subpoena

Duces Tecum or Writ of Habeas Records. Its Members

Cannot be Arrested Until End of their Term of Office. . . . . . 55

Section 37 - Grand Jury Members, Clerk of Court, Executive

Judge Cannot be Compelled to Disclose Any

Matters for publicity relating to the Grand Jury . . . . . . . . . . 55

Section 38 - Violation by any Person or Public Official of Section 36

With Violent Means, Force, or Threat or Intimidation is

Criminally liable for the Crime of Obstruction of Justice . . . 55

Section 39 - No Banking Secrecy Law Can Prevent Execution and

Compliance of Grand Jury Subpoena, Subpoena

Duces Tecum or Examination of Bank Records . . . . . . . . . 55

Section 40 - Grand Jury Invitation by Summons of Any Expert

For Official, Professional Consultation or Advice. . . . . . . . . 55

Page 6: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

6

Section 41 - Grand Jury Indictment Shall Disqualify any

Person From Aspiring to Hold a Public Office

By Election Or by Appointment . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 55

Section 42 - The Inaugural Formation of the Grand Jury

Is Strictly Confidential and Conducted by the

District Executive or Regional Trial Judge . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 56

Section 43 - Security of Personal Records of Grand Jury

Members And Safekeeping Responsibility of

their Inaugural Judge . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 56

Section 44 - Falsification of Collective Decision by any Grand Juror

or Officer Is Liable for Indictment for the Crime of

Obstruction of Justice by any Succeeding Grand Jury. . . . . 57

Section 45 - Requirements For Filing of Accusations in Court as

Originally initiated by the Government To Secure

Prior Grand Jury Review and Approval . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 57

Section 46 - Grand Jury Shall Finish Investigation and Indictment In

45 days from receipt of the case from the Government . . . . 57

Section 47 - Liability of Prosecutor for failure to comply with

his duty in the preceding Section 45 upon direct

complaint with the Grand Jury by the crime victim . . . . . . . 57

Section 48 - Grand Jury proceedings cannot be publicized.

Only one (1) witness is admitted for questioning

with no right of assistance from prosecutor . . . . . . . . . . . . 57

Section 49 - Person who testify before the grand jury

has duty to tell the truth mandatorily to all

questions by grand jury members . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 57

Section 50 - Power of Grand Jury to issue subpoena or subpoena

duces tecum. No person has the right to appear

before a Grand Jury unless served with subpoena. . . . . . . 58

Page 7: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

7

Section 51 - Person appearing as witness or invitee before the

grand jury has legal obligation and right to refuse

disclosure to his superior or subordinate officers of

matters he learned at the grand jury proceedings. . . . . . . . 58

Section 52 - Employer or officers of employer’s liability for

discrimination of employee for testifying

before a Grand Jury. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 58

Section 53 - Liability for disobedience or refusal to testify before

the Grand Jury upon receipt of subpoena, subpoena

duces tecum or summons . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 58

Section 54 - Liability of any person or public official in preventing

a witness from testifying before the Grand Jury. . . . . . . . . . 58

Section 55 - No law or any rule can prohibit a Grand Jury from

exercising the sovereign power of the people in its

efforts to investigate serious crimes. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 58

Section 56 - Absolutely, no one is exempt from Grand Jury

Investigation under the National Jury Law. . . . . . . . . . . . . . 59

IMMUNITY IN CERTAIN BRIBERY CASES

Section 57 - Immunity from prosecution in bribery. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 59

(a) When giver is a private citizen and

Recipient is a public official; . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 59

(b) When giver is a public official and the

recipient Is likewise a public official or a

A voter to elect candidate for public office. . . . . . . . . . 59

Section 58 - Void written or unwritten agreement

in bribery crimes in Section 57(a) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 59

Section 59 - Void written or unwritten agreement

In bribery crimes in Section 57(b) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 60

Page 8: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

8

Section 60 - Power of the Grand Jury To Indict for obstruction of

justice of any person or public official who refuses

to appear in an investigation before a Congressional

Committee or Body . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 60

Section 61 - Power of the Grand Jury To indict for obstruction of

Justice of any person or public official who disobeys

Certain Writs issued by Judicial Authorities . . . . . . . . . . . . 60

Section 62 - Power of the Grand Jury to Indict for obstruction of

justice of any person who disobeys a subpoena or

subpoena duces tecum issued by certain Government

Commissions to investigate graft and corruption . .. . . . . . 60

Section 63 - Limitation of Grand Jury Powers; No absolute duty to

inform crime suspect; Crime suspects have no right to

send his attorney to a grand proceedings. . . . . . . . . . . . . . 60

Section 64 - Grand Jury Investigations not bound by hearsay rules

Of evidence; Has no power to employ deceptive tactics. . . 60

Section 65 - A matter dropped from investigation by a grand jury

shall not prevent a future grand jury from reopening

the same matter for further investigation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 60

Section 66 - Criminal investigations and indictments initiated by

Government Departments and Agencies are subject to

approval by the Grand Jury in the form of an indictment . . 61

Section 67 - Grand Jury Advertisement Invitation for Anonymous

Crime Tipsters and Whistle Blowers Without disclosing

Their names or identity to the Grand Jury . . . . . . . . . . . . . 61

Section 68 - Enforcement of Grand Jury subpoena and other

process outside its jury district to any public official,

employee or citizen outside its jury district . . . . . . . . . . . . . 61

Section 69 - Outside the Grand Jury premises, the Clerk of Court

has the sole authority to allow, or deny, any person

or public official to enter the Grand Jury Room . . . . . . . . . 61

Page 9: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

9

Section 70 - Clerk of Court has power and authority to disarm any

person, public official, or witness who is entering the

Grand Jury room to testify in the grand jury proceedings . . 61

Section 71 - Filing of Grand Jury Indictment; Issuance of Arrest

Warrant; Arrest of Accused; All Activities held in Secret . . 62

(a) Upon completion of the preparation of the indictment,

the grand jury foreman shall summon the Clerk of

Court on Form GJ-41 in Section 99 to file indictment. . 62

(b) Clerk of Court shall keep filing of indictment with

utmost secrecy. He shall make no publicity . . . . . . . . 62

(c) Within 2 working days from filing date of indictment,

Presiding Judge shall issue arrest warrant to take

the accused into government custody. . . . . . . . . . . 62

(d) If presiding judge refuse to issue arrest warrant,

he must return the indictment within 2 days to

grand jury with legal reason . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 62

(e) Arresting Officer within 5 working days from date

he received the arrest warrant from the issuing

judge, shall execute arrest of the accused; Shall

keep arrest in secret; Make no announcement . . . . . . 62

(f) Within 2 hours after taking the accused into

custody, the Arresting Officer shall take the

accused for booking in jail for detention . . . . . . . . . . . . 62

(g) Jail Warden to inform the attorney or closest

relative of the accused or the intake officer

of the Public Attorney’s Office . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 62

Section 72 - Criminal Liability for undue interference in the issuance

or execution of arrest warrant over the accused . . . . . . . . 63

Section 73 - After the filing of grand jury indictment, government

prosecutor shall have further duty to discover more

evidence and continue keeping matter confidentially. . . . . . 63

Page 10: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

10

INVESTIGATION AND INDICTMENT OF PUBLIC OFFIC IALS

Section 74 - Indictment of the President and other

Public officials by the Grand Jury . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 64

Section 75 - Trial Procedure if accused after arraignment fails or

Refuse to appear at the trial in spite of notice to him or

his counsel; Liability of Defense Counsel for failure to

attend personally or for boycotting the trial . . . . . . . . . . . . . 64

Section 76 - Presidential Succession, If President is convicted.

Imprisonment; Possible Avoidance of Incarceration . . . . . . 65

(a) If the President is found guilty and convicted,

the Vice-President shall automatically become

President upon finality of his conviction . . . . . . . . . . . . 65

(b) The convicted President may avoid incarceration if

He complies with conditions in sub-sections (c), (d),

(e), (f) and (g), of this Section 76 of this Jury Law . . . . 65

(c) He shall prepare and Form GJ-51 as prescribed

in Section 99, Article III, of the National Jury Law . . . . 65

(d) He shall disclose in Form GJ-51 all money bank

deposits and real estate and personal property in

the PH and in every country around the world . . . . . . . 65

(e) He shall disclose in Form GJ-51, all confirmed

and verifiable liabilities and indebtedness in his

last SALN . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 65

(f) The total amount of compensation, salaries or wages,

in the entire length of his government service shall

be deducted from his net Assets . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 65

(g) He shall pay in full with cash on a Bank Manager’s

Certified Check the net amount of his liability as

computed in sub-section (f) in this Sec. of Article III . . 65

Page 11: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

11

Section 77 - Should the convicted president attempt to conceal any

of his assets with falsified SALN, he shall incur an

additional criminal liability for Obstruction of Justice . . . . . . 65

Section 78 - The 30-day period to resign and to pay his monetary

liability cannot be extended for any reason. Transfer

Of Assets shall be void. His discharge from insolvency

Shall be denied. Barred for life to hold a public office . . . . 66

Section 79 - Indicted President shall lose power to declare martial

law. Martial law declaration holds him personally

responsible for criminal acts of army and police officers

based on command responsibility doctrine . . . . . . . . . . . . . 66

Section 80 - Execution of Arrest Warrant Against the President;

His presidential powers are suspended; Barred from

exercising his prerogatives directly or indirectly . . . . . . . . . . 66

Section 81 - After the President is Arrested, the Arresting Officer

shall promptly inform the Vice-President. They shall

contact the Chief Justice for oath taking of VP as . . . . . 66

Section 82 - VP after oath taking, presidential powers automatically

devolved on the Acting President and shall then

announce his assumption of presidential powers . . . . . . 66

Section 83 - VP to inform the People of President’s indictment

and arrest and mentioning the crimes the President

has allegedly committed . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 66

Section 84 - Members of Arm Forces of the Philippines and

Philippine National Police shall automatically channel

support and loyalty to Acting President . . . . . . . . . . . . . 67

Section 85 - When execution of arrest warrant upon the

President is deemed constructively complete . . . . . . . . 67

Section 86 - Refusal of an indicted public official to surrender upon

arrest shall be deemed fugitive from justice, shall be

liable for crime of obstruction of justice, his attempted

official acts shall be void . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 67

Page 12: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

12

Section 87 - Rule suspending and succession of official powers of

an indicted president shall likewise apply to all other

indicted public, legislative, and judicial officials . . . . . . . . 67

Section 88 - Payment Authorization by indicted Official Void.

Payment of public expenditure including salaries

and wage of officials and employees shall not be

paid unless approved by success to his position . . . . . . . . . 67

Section 89 - Treasurer or paymaster has no authority to pay

expenses and salaries of officials and employees;

Shall be personally accountable for payments made . . . . . 68

Section 90 - A successor to the convicted or resigned president

shall serve in office no more than longer than the

unexpired term of such president . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 68

Section 91 - Author of a preemptive malicious impeachment

complaint in Congress purposely to frustrate an

impending bonafide impeachment complaint shall

be liable for the crime of obstruction of justice . . . . . . . . . . 68

GRAND JURY INVESTIGATION OF JAIL FACILITIES

Section 92 - Grand Jury on its own initiative may investigate jail

facilities in its own Jury District . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 68

(a) Demand from Warden to provide list of jail

staff with names, home addresses, pay rates . . . . . . . 68

(b) List of Inmates, case number, length of

Incarceration, cell location, etc. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 68

(c) A post card size picture of the common

mess hall of the inmates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 68

(d) A post card size picture of the inmate toilets. . . . . . . . . 68

Page 13: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

13

(e) Failure of the Warden or Jail Director to submit

desired information shall warrant indictment for

the crime of obstruction of justice . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 68

Section 93 - Start Up Instruction to the Grand Jury to

Investigate a jail facility in his jury district . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 69

THE FORGIVING CLAUSE AND

THE PURGATORY CLAUSE

Section 94 - Forgiving Clause -

(a) An official or employee of the government may

be forgiven for abstaining from acts of corruption

after adoption of Jury Law. Certain requirements . . . . 69

(b) Execution of Form GJ-51 in Sec. 99, Art III and

Form TJ-134 in Sec. 2, Art. X is mandatory. . . . . . . . . 69

Section 95 - Pending Cases and the Purgatory Clause . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 69

(a) The accused in pending bribery case may avail of

benefits of forgiving clause under preceding Sec.

94(a)&(b). . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 69

(b) Forgiving Clause not Applicable to crimes of

Obstruction of Justice, electoral terrorism or

Electoral fraud, brigandage, and many others . . . . . . . 70

(c) Continuing acts of bribery after passage of jury law

Not entitled to the benefits of forgiving clause . . . . . . . 70

(d) Continued possession of ill-gotten wealth,

Unless crime suspect execute Form GJ-51,

Sec. 99, Art III, etc. Art. X, shall disqualify

the accused from benefits of Forgiving Clause . . . . . . 70

(e) An accused already been arraigned before effective

date of Jury Law, but trial not yet started shall be

required to stand trial before a trial jury. . . . . . . . . . . . 70

Page 14: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

14

Section 96 - If Grand Jury investigate staff member of the court

where GJ members were recruited, the case shall

be filed in a different court house . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 71

Section 97 - A Provision in the Omnibus Election Code in conflict

With National Jury Law shall be superseded or

repealed by the provision of the National Jury Law . . . . . 71

(a) No law or court order can stop a Grand Jury from

investigating or indicting a public official who had

been proclaimed as election winner and suspected

to have won by fraudulent means . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 71

(b) Any public official or notary public who administers

the oath of office for a manifestly fraudulent winner

in an election for public office may be held criminally

liable for obstruction of justice . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 71

(c) A participant in the act of violating the rules in (a)

and (b) above, if found guilty, shall suffer the

maximum penalty provided by the election law of

the National Jury Law . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 71

Section 98 - Preserving the identity of a witness from

disclosure prior to the giving of his testimony

in a criminal trial is required . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 71

(a) A prosecution witness subpoenaed by Grand

Jury enjoys absolute anonymity until he has

been sworn to testify in a jury or bench trial . . . . . . . . . 71

(b) No such witness shall be called to testify in a

civil trial until a verdict is handed down in the

criminal trial against the accused . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 71

(c) Any person who shall disclose the identity of a

witness who has testified before a grand jury shall

be liable for the crime of obstruction of justice . . . . . . . 71

(d) Prosecutor has obligation to disclose the number,

but the name, of his witnesses and estimated length

of time they testify on direct examination before the

witness is sworn to testify at the trial. . . . . . . . . . . . . . 72

Page 15: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

15

(e) Once a prosecution witness has been sworn and has

given his true name and identity, the start of his

testimony shall not be postponed to another hour or

day until completion with over time if necessary . . . . . 72

(f) If estimated that no direct or cross examination

prosecution can be completed on same day he

is sworn due to time constraint said witness shall

be sworn on the first hour of the next court day to

allow him to start his testimony . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 72

(g) Once prosecution witness has been sworn to testify,

he shall promptly be afforded immediate protection

by enrolling him in the Witness Protection Program . . 72

Section 99 - The Grand Jury Table of Forms.

Find the Page locator of the forms at . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .72

Section 100 - Creation of the Position for Community Deputy

Prosecutors, referred to as CDP, to be recruited

From Private Practicians Lawyers with prior

Court Trial Experience for at least 3 years . . . . . . . . . . . . 211

Section 101 - Qualification of the Community Deputy Prosecutor

and required preparation to prosecute criminal

cases in jury trials . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 211

Section 102 - CDP Application Form. This is a Durable

w Form which means that Applicant Cannot

alter its terms. How to Apply for CDP . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 211

Section 103 - The promissory undertaking of the CDP to serve . . . . . . . 211

Section 104 - CDP Application to be submitted personally

and entered in a raffle bin at the Provincial

or city fiscal’s office . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 212

Section 105 - Newspaper Advertisement to Invite CDP Applicants . . . . 212

Section 106 - Registry Record Form for assigned Cases to the CDP . . 213

Page 16: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

16

Section 107 - Creation of the Position of Deputy Public Defenders

for Indigent Accused or Minor. To ensure availability

of Deputy Public Defenders to defend at the trial of

suspected indigent crime offenders or minors. . . . . . . . . 213

Section 108 - Qualification of the Deputy Public Defender

and required preparation to act as defense

Counsel in jury trials . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 213

Section 109 - Deputy Public Defender’s Application Form. This is

a Durable Form. It cannot be modified by Applicant . . . . . 213

Section 110 - The promissory undertaking of the

Deputy Public Defender to serve . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 214

Section 111 - The Deputy Public Defenders’ Pool. Where and

How to Submit Applicant’s Application Form . . . . . . . . 214

Section 112 - Newspaper Advertisement to Invite

Applicants to the Public Defenders’ Pool . . . . . . . . . . . 215

Section 113 - Registry Record for Assigned Cases to Deputy

Public Defenders. Provincial or City Public Attorney’s

Office Shall be Responsible to keep this Record. . . . . . 215

Section 114 - Guide for Fast track adaptation

to the criminal jury trials . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 215

ARTICLE IV - THE TRIAL JURY . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 218

Section 1 - The Trial Jury . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 218

(a) Composition of a Trial Jury

And Qualification of Jurors. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 218

(b) The Jury Commissioner (or Clerk of Court)

His Duties in Inviting and Management of Jurors. . . . 218

(c) Summons for Citizens to Serve for Jury Duty . . . . . . . 218

Page 17: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

17

Section 2 - Confidential Proceedings Prior to

the Actual Event of the Jury Trial . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 218

(1) The Confidential “In Chamber Conference”

a day or two before actual jury trial begins . . . . . . . . 219

(2) The actual event of the jury trial shall start with the

impaneling of the jurors. Followed by Issuance of

Statutory Basic Trial Jury Instruction . . . . . . . . . . . . . 219

(3) In the court room, the true names of the jurors

shall not be disclosed. They will be addressed

or identified with the Identity Code Number for

security reasons . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . 219

Section 3 - The first location where juror shall be assembled will be

at the Jury Assembly Room, called the “JAR”, under the

management of the Jury Commissioner or Clerk . . . . . . . .219

Section 4 - At the JAR: Filling up of Impaneling Question Sheet

(or IQS) form by the Jurors for deposit in Raffle Bin#2 . . . 219

Section 5 - How to Use The IQS and the ICN: Through the IQS,

the trial lawyers and the presiding judge shall determine

whether a juror is acceptable to serve or not . . . . . . . . . . 219

Section 6 - After accomplishing his Form TJ-109A , the juror shall

then submit it back to the Commissioner or Clerk of

Court who shall drop the same in a separate lottery bin,

designated as “Lottery Bin #2", for jurors who appeared

for jury service . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 220

Section 7 - Before the jurors are called in, members of the public

or media shall not be permitted any vacant seat in the

Jury Trial Court Room (JTCR) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 220

Section 8 - At exactly 9:00 A.M., the Commissioner or Clerk

shall retrieve from the raffle bin the IQS Forms

TJ-109A, one at a time, a number of jurors sufficient

for impaneling the jury. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 220

Page 18: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

18

Section 9 - At the JTCR, the IQS shall, again, be entered in

a lottery bin in the desk of the presiding judge which

shall then be retrieved one at time until 12 jurors

shall be picked to serve for jury service . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 221

Section 10 - Jury Impaneling shall be strictly confidential.

Televising Is absolutely forbidden until

completion of jury impaneling . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 221

Section 11 - Impaneling of Jurors is the exclusive joint prerogative

by the Jury Presiding Judge and the opposing counsels

in the case. Violation is punishable for obstruction of

justice . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . 221

Section 12 - Challenge to the Jurors, aka Voi Dire. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 221

(a) The procedure of choosing jurors by lottery for the

second time. When juror’s ICN is called, the owner

of said ICN shall respond and sit in the jurors’ seat.

PJ to ask some questions to the seated juror . . . . . . 221

(b) After PJ questioning, he asks opposing lawyers to

or decline any of the seated jurors. This process

requires no arguments. PJ ministerially thanks and

excuses a juror from serving . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 222

(c) The Sheriff to lead back declined jurors to the Jury

Commissioner for possible reassignment in another

case for jury trial . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 222

Section 13 - The prosecutor and defense attorneys each

have 7 preemptory right to decline a juror with

or without cause. No lawyer is permitted to decline

more than 7 jurors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 222

Section 14 - The first 12 jurors chosen shall sit as regular jurors and

the last 3 chosen shall serve as alternate reserves . . . . . 222

Section 15 - After the jury is impaneled and declined jurors are

sent back to the JAR, PJ shall admit people not party

to the case and media to the Jury Trial Court Room . . . . 222

Page 19: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

19

Section 16 - Empowerment of the Trial Jury . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 222

(1) PJ to proceed issuance of basic jury instruction

as prescribed in Form TJ-108. Instruction will be

interpreted simultaneously in the local dial of jurors. . 222

(2) The presiding judge shall enforce court discipline

and to rule on the admission of evidence in the

course of the jury trial . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 222

(3) Except during the presentation of the evidence at

the trial, PJ has no authority to partake in the jury

discussion and in deciding the case. The power to

determine facts of case belongs to the Jury. . . . . . . . 222

Section 17 - Any person or public official who shall contact a 3rd

party with purpose of influencing a juror in making his

decision is criminally liable for the crime of obstruction

of justice . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 222

Section 18 - The 3rd party referred to in the preceding section

who interferes directly or indirectly on a jury in a case

at hand is also liable for the crime of obstruction of

justice . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 222

Section 19 - A Juror subject of solicitation has legal obligation to

report the solicitor for investigation to a grand jury.

Failure to do so, juror liable for obstruction of justice . . . . 222

Section 20 - A 3rd Party who has received from a public official or

government employee any solicitation with the view of

influencing a juror in deciding case at hand shall . . . . . . . 224

Section 21 - A Juror who has been influenced in deciding a case

at hand in which he has seated at as a juror is liable

of the crime of obstruction of justice. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 224

Section 22 - A Jury Presiding Judge is under legal obligation to

report to the grand jury any act of solicitation to

influence the decision of the jury over which he is . . . . . . 224

Page 20: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

20

Section 23 - A lawyer in a case at hand who contacts a public

official to help secure a favorable judgment in his

case before a trial jury or a judge is liable for . . . . . . . . . 224

Section 24 - A person found guilty of the act of obstruction of

justice as defined in the preceding Sections 17,

18, 19, 20, 21, 22 and 23, of this Article, Article IV . . . . . 225

Section 25 - If the accused is found guilty of a crime associated

with the crime of obstruction of justice that carries

with a higher penalty, such penalty shall be imposed. . . . 225

Section 26 - An act or omission over a mandatory duty defined

as a crime of obstruction of justice in this Law shall

prescribe at the end of ten (10) years and . . . . . . . . . . . . 225

Section 27 - A subordinate government employee or officer has

The authority and mandatory obligation to secretly

report to a grand jury for investigation and. . . . . . . . . . . . 225

Section 28 - The findings of fact by the trial jury shall be final and

shall not be subject of review on appeal. An error of

law may be appealed by either party to a case . . . . . . . 225

Section 29 - Any justice of a Sandiganbayan may act

as a presiding judge over a jury trial . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 225

PRO TEMP JURY PRESIDING JUDGE

Section 30 - Creation of the Position for Pro Temp Jury

Presiding Judge And Payment of his Services . . . . . . . 226

(1) Creation of Pro Temp Jury Presiding Judge and

Courts where they will be qualified to preside . . . . . 226

(2) Compensation for the services of Pro Temp

Jury Presiding Judge shall be paid through the

“Unconditional Non-transferable Redeemable

Judicial Voucher, known as the “Form GJ-27" . . . 226

Page 21: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

21

Section 31 - Qualification of the Pro Temp Jury PJ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 226

Section 32 - How to Apply for the Position of Pro Temp Jury PJ . . . . . 226

Section 33 - The promissory undertaking in the Application

by the Pro Temp Jury Presiding Judge . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 227

Section 34 - Law and Ethics Required for Pro Temp Jury PJ . . . . . . . 228

Section 35 - How To Invite Private Practicians Lawyers to

become members of the Pro Temp Jury PJ Pool . . . . . 228

CIVIL JURY TRIAL

Section 36 - Civil jury trials- Pleadings & Practices . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 228

Section 37 - Prohibition and Criminal Liability of any person,

Judge justice or any public official in influencing

any juror or jury which way to decide a case . . . . . . . . . . 230

Section 38 - Prohibition and Criminal Liability of any Prosecutor,

Counsel for the Plaintiff or Counsel for the defendant

to influence a juror or jury outside of court or jury trial

after he has rested his case. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 230

Section 39 - Prohibition and Criminal Liability of any judge,

justice, or his staff member from participating in

the deliberation of a jury in arriving at its verdict . . . . . . . 230

Section 40 - Filing Fee on indigent litigant . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 230

Section 41 - Pauper Litigants and Contingent Attorney’s Fee . . . . . . . 230

ARTICLE V - DEFINITION OF TERMS AND COMPLIANCE . . . . . . . . . . . . . 231

Section 1 - Definition of “Obstruction of Justice” and Penalties . . . . . 231

Section 2 - Preventing witnesses from testifying. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 231

Section 3 - Altering, destroying, suppressing or concealing

any paper, record, document, or object with intent. . . . . . 231

Page 22: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

22

Section 4 - Harboring or concealing, or facilitating the escape of

any person he knows, or has reasonable ground to . . . . 231

Section 5 - Publicly using a fictitious name for the purpose of

concealing a crime, evading prosecution or the

execution of a judgment . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 231

Section 6 - Delaying the prosecution of criminal cases by

Obstructing the service of process or court . . . . . . . . . . . 231

Section 7 - Making or presenting an oral statement or testimony

under oath or using any record, document, paper or. . . . 231

Section 8 - Soliciting, accepting, or agreeing to accept any benefit

in consideration of abstaining from, discontinuing, or . . . 232

Section 9 - Threatening directly or indirectly another with the

infliction of any wrong upon his person, honor or . . . . . . 232

Section 10 - Giving of false or fabricated information to mislead

or prevent the law enforcement agencies from

apprehending the offender or from protecting the . . . . . . 232

Section 11 - Contacting by a lawyer or an associate or friend of

such lawyer with a public official for the purpose of

securing the influence of such public official to . . . . . . . . 232

Section 12 - Active or passive co-operation of an employer, job

supervisor or co-employee with any person or public

official to influence the decision of its employee . . . . . . . 232

Section 13 - Failure of a juror to comply with his mandatory duty

to report within thirty (30) days to a grand jury from

the date of his receipt of any direct solicitation or . . . . . . 232

Section 14 - Failure of an employer, job supervisor, or co-employee

of a juror to comply with his mandatory obligation

within thirty (30) days from the receipt by such . . . . . . . . 232

Section 15 - A decision by a juror in a jury trial based on a solicited

decision by any person, public official, employer, job

supervisor or co-employee regardless of whether . . . . . . 232

Page 23: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

23

Section 16 - Failure of a presiding judge in a bench trial or jury trial

of his mandatory obligation to report to a grand jury

within thirty (30) days of his receipt of a solicitation . . . . . 233

Section 17 - Failure of a government prosecutor to comply with his

mandatory duty to commence government criminal

accusation of the act of securing the grand jury

indictment . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 233

Section 18 - Disobedience by any public official or person of a writ

of amparo, writ of habeas corpus, or writ of habeas

data issued by the Supreme Court, Court of Appeals . . . 233

Section 19 - Disobedience by any public official or person of a

subpoena, subpoena duces tecum or summons

issued by the Ombudsman, Commission on Audit, etc. . . 233

Section 20 - Intentional failure of a person or witness of his

obligation to tell the truth in his testimony before

a grand jury . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 233

Section 21 - Disclosure to another person or public official, or

failure by a witness, also known as “invitee”, to

comply with his legal obligation to strictly keep in . . . . . . 233

Section 22 - Disobedience or refusal by any person or public

official to testify before a grand jury by disregarding

his receipt of a subpoena, etc. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 233

Section 23 - Preventing by any person or public official of a

witness from testifying before a grand jury by any

means of aiding witness for any purpose. . . . . . . . . . . . . 233

Section 24 - Termination, demotion in rank or position or

relocation of employment of a witness who has . . . . . . . 234

Section 25 - Refusal by a witness who is a giver or an offeror in the

crime of bribery to testify before the grand jury against

the recipient of his bribe and such witness has been . . . . 237

Section 26 - Interference or participation in court or from

elsewhere by telephone, email communication,

or by any electronic device by any person . . . . . . . . . . . . 234

Page 24: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

24

Section 27 - Failure of a trial presiding judge in a jury trial to

comply with his mandatory duty to report to the

grand jury within thirty (30) days of the act of . . . . . . . . 234

Section 28 - Failure of a subordinate officer or employee in

the public service to perform his mandatory duty

within thirty (30) days of his knowledge . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 234

Section 29 - Failure or neglect of a police or military officer to

comply with his personal mandatory obligation to

provide preference of protection to a citizen . . . . . . . . . . 234

Section 30 - Omission, deviation or alteration by the presiding

judge in the reading or issuance of the statutory

basic jury instruction of the National Jury Law. . . . . . . . . 234

Section 31 - Failure or refusal by a presiding judge to comply with

his mandatory duty to report to the grand jury within

thirty (30) days of the dismissal of a criminal case . . . . . 234

Section 32 - Surreptitious attendance or intrusion in the formation

proceedings of a grand jury by any person or public

official or government employee or permission by . . . . . 235

Section 33 - The arrest or detention of a person with or without

cause who is a juror in a grand jury or trial jury

while reporting to and from between his place . . . . . . . . 235

Section 34 - Purposely delaying by a vehicle driver or operator

in delivering a juror whom he has provided a ride,

whether paid or as a courtesy passenger, . . . . . . . . . . . 235

Section 35 - An open announcement by a driver or transportation

operator by means of a visible placard in his vehicle

to the effect that he is a provider for a courtesy ride

for a juror or jurors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . 235

Section 36 - Failure of a person to appear to testify as a witness

in a civil or criminal trial before a court of law who

has been properly served and has received. . . . . . . . . . 235

Page 25: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

25

Section 37 - Willful refusal or failure of a person, public official, or

an official of a responsible party by the use of an or

dilatory act or acts or act of defalcation of funds . . . . . . 235

Section 38 - Departure from the Philippines by a person or

public official for a foreign jurisdiction or country

for any purpose knowing that he has committed . . . . . . . 235

Section 39 - Suppression by, or failure of, a government or

private prosecutor or fiscal, or by a presiding judge

in conspiracy with such government or private . . . . . . . . 236

Section 40 - Public display or parading of a crime suspect

as a publicity exhibit prior to conviction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 236

Section 41 - Forcing a crime suspect to confess his alleged

crime by any person or public officer through

torture or any forceful means . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 236

Section 42 - Failure of a lawyer or lawyers of the president in

attending at the scheduled firm trial date of the

president who has been criminally indicted . . . . . . . . . . 236

Section 43 - Disclosure or publicity of additionally discovered

evidence or names of witnesses to any person or

member of the media by a government prosecutor . . . . . 236

Section 44. Preparation by, or dictation of, an

attorney in making an affidavit of desistance

contrary to the intended will of the affiant victim. . . . . . . 236

Section 45 - Conversation by an attorney with a trial juror on duty

on any matter outside the jury trial proceedings while

a case at hand is still in progress prior to the reading. . . . 237

Section 46 - Failure of the lead attorney or counsel of the president

to attend a firm date of trial when the president is on

trial before a trial jury upon the indictment by . . . . . . . . 237

Section 47 - The act of filing by any person of a preemptive

impeachment complaint in Congress against the

convicted president with the view of protecting . . . . . . . . 237

Page 26: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

26

Section 48 - The act of preventing or discouraging, in any

manner, a citizen who has receive a summons

for jury duty from serving as a juror in a jury trial . . . . . . 237

Section 49 - The act of disclosing or gossiping about a grand jury

investigation by any witness who has received a grand

jury summons or who has testified before said Body. . . . 237

Section 50 - The act of knowingly participating in any sham or mock

judicial trial, hearing or proceedings for the purpose of

harassment shall be criminally punishable as . . . . . . . . . 237

Section 51 - Filing a complaint before a prosecutor's office or before

a grand jury or before a court of law knowing that such

act is based on a completely false allegation of facts . . . 237

Section 52 - Liability of the lawyer who shall provide legal assistance

in committing the act or acts described in the immediate

preceding Section 50, or Section 51, knowing that the

action of his client is a total falsity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 237

Section 53 - Any member of a grand jury who shall be criminally

liable for committing the crime of bribery shall be

deemed a public officer as defined in Article 210 . . . . . . 238

Section 54 - The act of any indicted government official referred to

in Article III, Section 74 in refusing to be taken into

government custody by an arresting officer . . . . . . . . . . 238

Section 55 - Violation of the prohibited acts in Article I of this Law

shall subject the violator liable for the crime of

obstruction of justice and penalty of imprisonment . . . . . 238

Section 56 - Any surreptitious act of giving a false testimony

or official report by an investigator, to cover-up

the commission of a crime . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 238

Section 57 - Interference and intrusion into the jury by a presiding

judge or a member of his office staff, or by prosecuting

attorney or defense attorney, after the case has been

submitted for jury deliberation and decision . . . . . . . . . . . 238

Page 27: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

27

Section 58 - “Employer” shall mean any natural person who hired

the juror to perform a certain job with, or without, pay

for the former’s personal affairs or business regardless

of length of time of employment for such person . . . . . . . 238

Section 59 - “Job supervisor” shall mean any person towards

whom the juror receives instructions in executing

his job at any given time or location . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 238

Section 60 - “Co-employee” shall mean any person with whom

the juror is employed in the same employer or

organization of any nature or purpose . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 239

Section 61 - Definition of “Public official” or “public officer” as used

in the context of the National Jury Law who occupies

a position in any government instrumentality . . . . . . . . . . 239

Section 62 - Definition of “Public service” in the context of the

National Jury Law and Procedures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 239

Section 63 - Debarment: Situations leading to the lose of

one’s professional license or position in a

government instrumentality. Verify sub-sections

(a), (b), (c), and (d) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 239

Section 64 - Right of subrogation and monetary reimbursement of

criminal and civil liability in favor of the government over,

and from, acts of public official. Read more details in

sub-sections (a), (b), (c) and (d) under this section . . . . . 240

Section 65 - Obstruction of Justice after the fact - Reckless

negligence or intentional failure of a person or

public official to prevent occurrence of a serious

offense by reason of his title or position. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 241

Page 28: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

28

ARTICLE VI - NATIONAL JURY MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY . . . . . . . 242

Section 1 - The Management Authority charged with the

implementation and functioning of the National

Jury Law & Procedure . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 242

Section 2 - Name of the Management Authority: The “National

Jury Management Authority” and may be known in

brief as the “NJMA”. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 242

Section 3 - Procedures on How to Start and Conduct The Jury Trial . . 242

Section 4 - Submitting the case to the Jury

for deliberation and decision . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 246

ARTICLE VII - MANDATORY TRIAL BY JURY AND EXCEPTIONS . . . 247

Section 1 - Trial By Jury shall become mandatory

upon passage of the National Jury Law . . . . . . . . . . . . 247

Section 2 - Plea bargaining; Requirements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 247

Section 3 - Liability of by judge or any public official

for intervening in plea bargaining. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 248

Section 4 - Role of Judge ministerial once condition and

terms of agreement for bargaining are fully

complied as required by law. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 248

Section 5 - Conditions for Acceptance of PBA . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 248

Section 6 - Judge No power to approve PBA before victim is paid

of Indemnity Damage and Government for Penalty

Fine is paid with certified bank manager’s check. . . . . . . 249

Section 7 - Indemnity for damage to victim and penalty fine to

government not extinguished with insolvency and

bankruptcy of crime offender . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 249

Page 29: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

29

Section 8 - Penalty to be imposed if accused

plead guilty to multiple criminal charges. . . . . . . . . . . . . . 249

Section 9 - If accused plead guilty to lesser offense and

allowed to post bail, accused must surrender

his passport to court. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 249

Section 10 - In crimes punishable with imprisonment less than

one year, accused may be tried with no jury before

a judge unless he requests for jury trial . . . . . . . . . . . . . 250

Section 11 - If accused found guilty, refuses to execute Form

GJ-51 and Form TJ-134, shall incur criminal liability

for obstruction of justice with penalty of 15 years of

imprisonment in jail without the possibility of parol . . . . . . 250

ARTICLE VIII - QUALIFICATION FOR TRIAL JURY MEMBERS . . . . . . 251

Section 1 - Qualification for Members of Trial Jury . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 251

Section 2 - Government official or employee, close relatives

or lawyer are disqualified from seating as trial jurors . . . . 251

Section 3 - Jury or jurors cannot be compelled to explain

explain reason for its, or their, verdict. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 251

Section 4 - Retired government official or employee qualified

to sit as juror after 24 months of his retirement from

government service. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 251

Section 5 - Person convicted of crime involving moral

turpitude barred from jury service . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 252

Section 6 - Person claiming royalty or nobility status

cannot qualify for jury service . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 252

Section 7 - No citizen shall be served with summons

for jury duty more than once each year . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 252

Page 30: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

30

Section 8 - A citizen summon for jury duty entitled

to jury fee for reporting to court even if

not seated as a juror in a jury trial. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 252

Section 9 - The rate of the trial juror's fee shall be

equivalent to the legal minimum wage rate. . . . . . . . . . . . 252

ARTICLE IX - FUNDING THE JURY SYSTEM,

SECURITY, AND RELATED MATTERS. . . . . . . . . . . . . . 253

Section 1 - Congress shall appropriate Jury funds

upon recommendation of the National

Jury Management Authority. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 253

Section 2 - Additional Funding for the Jury System . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 253

SECURITY MATTERS

Section 3 - Armed services of government have

paramount duty to protect citizens serving

as jurors over and above public servants. . . . . . . . . . . . . 254

Section 4 - Armed service personnel liable for

obstruction of justice for failure to

provide protection to a juror or jury. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 254

Section 5 - Citizen on jury duty not subject to arrest in

going to court and from home to serve . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 255

TRANSPORTATION FOR JURORS

Section 6 - Passenger transportation operators

have obligation to provide transportation

services to a citizen who is serving as a juror. . . . . . . . . . 255

NOON TIME MEAL FOR JURORS

OF THE TRIAL JURY

Section 7 - Transportation provider or driver is forbidden to

announce or publish that it is specially providing

transportation for Jurors to preserve juror identity . . . . . . 256

Page 31: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

31

Section 8 - Trial Jurors’ Noon Time Meal at government expense . . . 256

Section 9 - Responsibility of Jury Commissioner or Clerk of

the Clerk of Court to enter into a contract with

food servers to feed jurors. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 256

Section 10 - Eatery Location and Noon Meal Time . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 256

NOON TIME MEAL FOR THE

MEMBERS OF THE GRAND JURY

Section 11 - Noon Time Meal For the Members of

the Grand Jury at government expense . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 257

Section 12 - It shall be the duty of the Clerk of Court to enter

into a contract with a food caterer to serve the

meals for the grand jurors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 257

Section 13 - The grand jurors’ food shall be rationed and

delivered to the Clerk of Court with the aid

of his deputy. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 257

Section 14 - Form TJ-129 shall similarly be used for the

food ticket for the members of the Grand Jury

which shall be paid via the Form GJ-27. . . . . . . . . . . . . . 257

ARTICLE X - TRIAL JURY TABLE OF FORMS AND

PRINTABLE FORMS( Index of Forms) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 258

Section 1 - Table of the Trial Jury Forms and Index. . . . . . . . . . . . . . 258

ARTICLE XI - IMPLEMENTING AUTHORITY OF THE

NATIONAL JURY LAW AND PROCEDURES . . . . . . . . . 360

Section 1 - The National Jury Management Authority,

Composition, Officers, Power and functions. . . . . . . . . . . 360

Section 2 - Creation of Reserve pool for pro-temp presiding

jury trial judges, community deputy prosecutors,

defense attorneys for indigent persons . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 361

Section 3 - Creation of the position of Jury Commissioner . . . . . . . . 362

Page 32: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

32

Section 4 - Proceeding the case for jury trial. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 362

Section 5 - The sovereignty of the people serving as jurors . . . . . . . 366

Section 6 - The “Confidential In Chamber Conference” . . . . . . . . . . 366

Section 7 - Prohibition against forcing fellow juror which way

to decide matter; Replacement of Juror who is

scared to write his vote to decide the case . . . . . . . . . . . 367

Section 8 - The jury Deliberation and verdict. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 367

Section 9 - General penalty guidelines In Relating

to the Majority Verdict Rule . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 368

Section 10 - Rules in Televising a Jury Trial. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 370

Section 11 - Claimed jury trial anomalies; How to pursue

abusers; Filing of appropriate indictment . . . . . . . . . . . . 371

Section 12 - Safety and Security against possible dangers

of threats or violence at the trial location . . . . . . . . . . . . . 371

Section 13 - Civil atmosphere required in jury trials. Witnesses

required civilian attire including police, military or

security agency personnel. Any witness wearing

any military or police uniform will be barred from

testifying in a jury trial . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 372

Section 14 - Sealing personal information of the jurors . . . . . . . . . . . . 372

Section 15 - Appeal from Jury Verdict; Finding of facts by Jury

not subject to review on appeal. Only issue of law

including jury instruction may be appealed for review . . . 372

Section 16 - Accelerated implementation of the National Jury

Law; Volunteer jurors for Grand Jury and Trial Jury . . . . 372

Section 17 - Understanding the contexts of provisions . . . . . . . . . . . . 374

Section 18 - Mail and franking privilege of Jury letters and

documents for mailing and postal deliveries . . . . . . . . . . 374

Page 33: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

33

Section 19 - Any person convicted of serious crime referred to

In this Law barred from occupying any public office. . . . . 374

Section 20 - This Jury Law does not imply in any way the

abrogation of the power of judicial, legislative

or executive officials in issuing subpoena or

other similar legal customary processes . . . . . . . . . . . . . 374

ARTICLE XII - JURY TRIAL INTERPRETERS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 375

Section 1 - Professionalizing and Certification of Trial Jury

Court Interpreters in the respective localities

Around the Country . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 375

Section 2 - The interpreter’s rate of pay recommendation . . . . . . . 376

Section 3 - Highest Standard of Confidentiality Required

for Jury Trial and Court Interpreters . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 376

ARTICLE XIII - EFFECTIVITY OF THE NATIONAL JURY LAW . . . . . . . . . . 377

Section 1 - Serious Crimes Committed Prior to Effectivity

of the National Jury Law & Procedure . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 377

Section 2 - Disposition of Pending Cases on Serious Crimes

In Court and In Investigation Agencies of the

Government Upon Approval of the this Jury Law . . . . . . 377

Section 3 - Prosecutor’s Liability For Delay in Pursuing

Criminal Cases assigned to him . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 377

Section 4 - Existing Jury Systems, if any, shall be converted

to the procedures of the National Jury Law after

its enactment. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 377

Section 5 - Reacquisition by true owners of land deprived by

land grabbers via fake certificates of title issued

fraudulently in the office of registrar of deeds . . . . . . . . 377

Section 6 - Pre-Audit Requirements of Government Payments . . . . 378

Section 7 - Effectivity Date of the enactment of Jury Law . . . . . . . . 378

Section 87 - Date Approved by the People ________________ . . . . 378

Page 34: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

1

NATIONAL JURY LAW & PROCEDURES

TO ENABLE THE FILIPINO PEOPLE TO PARTICIPATE

IN THE ADMINISTRATION OF THEIR JUSTICE SYSTEM

AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES.

PREAMBLE

ONE : WHEREAS, Article II, Section 1, of the Philippine Constitution has declared that

the “Philippines is a democratic and republican state. Sovereignty resides in the People and all

government authority emanates from them,” And implying therefore that the Filipino People have

the right and power to participate in the governance of their country as a democratic state;

TWO: WHEREAS, the administration of justice in the Judicial Branch is an essential part

of governance in which the Filipino People requires to participate as a matter of right equally as

much as much as they participate in the governance of their Legislative and Executive Branches

by means of their secret ballots;

THREE: WHEREAS, the participation of the People in the governance of justice can only

be secured and orderly accomplished by means of establishing the Jury System of Justice in

which their secret jury ballots can be counted in making their decision shall be used under the

supervision, guidance, education and protection by a presiding judge;

FOUR: WHEREAS, the Bill of Rights of the Filipino People in their constitution has been

substantially copied from the Bill of Rights of the People under the United States constitution as

well as the Philippine procedural rules of court have likewise been substantially copied from the

United States federal procedural rules of court, it is appropriate that the Philippine Jury System

shall be generally patterned after the United States Federal Jury System into which the peculiar

local culture, customs and tradition of the Filipino People shall be blended and respected.

FIVE: WHEREAS, Adoption of a National Jury Law & Procedures shall serve as the means

of uniting the Filipino People, Christians, Muslims and other Tribes alike, in their quest for social

justice and to ensure success in their efforts to completely prevent government graft and

corruption, to stop abuses of powerful public officials, other lawlessness, and disunity of the

people which their Government alone is incapable of accomplishing;

SIX: WHEREAS, The adoption of a National Jury Law & Procedures will give due

Page 35: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

2

recognition and respect to the sovereign power and authority of the common and ordinary

Christians, Muslims, and other Ethnic citizens from their leaders, nationally and locally, regardless

of their official ranks, power and nobility of such leaders and will serve as a basic solution to the

on-going Muslim-Christian conflict in the southern Philippines as well as in preventing

discrimination between wealthy Christians and Muslims against the lowly Christians and Muslims;

SEVEN : WHEREAS, The GRAND JURY and TRIAL JURY Systems have been proven

as the most effective and powerful government anti-graft and corruption and anti-lawlessness

device as perfected and used successfully in the United States and in its states, counties and

cities as a part of their democratic system of government for more than 230 years now;

SEVEN: WHEREAS, The People of the Philippines are now mature enough to discern

between right and wrong in the dispensation of justice under proper judicial supervision, protection

guidance and education as well as in the law enforcement in their localities; and are likewise now

capable of serving as jurors, respectively, in a Grand Jury and Trial Jury Systems of Justice with

even more knowledge and capability to do so than the American people 230 years ago;

EIGHT: WHEREAS, The peace and order in the Philippines has been steadily

deteriorating with its present government monopolized system of justice system under the

exclusive and abusive control of powerful and wealthy corrupt government officials and political

dynasties;

NINE: WHEREAS, Adoption of a National Jury Law & Procedures shall serve as a shield

and protection for judges in the administration of justice and discriminatory judgments arising from

undue interference of powerful abusive public officials and politicians; and

TEN: WHEREAS, Adoption of a National Jury Law & Procedures offers the best peaceful

alternative to maintain civility and honesty in their government against armed and violent rebellion

and shall serve as a preventive measure against declaration of martial law;

NOW, THEREFORE, The Sovereign People of the Philippines, by the Grace of their

Creator, hereby propose to seek and declare their approval and do ordain the adoption of the

Grand Jury and Trial Jury systems of Justice pursuant to the process of Republic Act 6735 with

the other pertinent provisions therein, and in Article VI, Section 32, of the Philippine Constitution

to have a deciding power in the administration of justice in their respective localities.

Page 36: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

3

ARTICLE I

ADOPTION OF THE JURY SYSTEMS

Section 1. This Law shall implement Article II, Section 1, of the Constitution by the

establishment of the Jury System of Justice to enable the People of the Philippines to participate

in the practice and administration of their justice system, to serve as their sovereign and master

procedural judicial enforcement law and procedures, to enhance the national unity of the Filipino

People and as a basic solution to prevent graft and corruption in the government.

This Law shall be known as the “National Jury Law & Procedures of the Philippines,” and

may be briefly cited as the “National Jury Law”, or“Jury Law”, or “JL”, or “this Jury Law”. Its

operation shall transcend, obtain and cover, jurisdiction upon the following entities without

exception:

(a) The entire governance, branches and services of, and every person in, the Philippines,

national and local, and their public officials and employees; and

(b) All government owned or controlled corporations, or quasi-government corporation and

its officials and employees.

Section 2. Democratic master and servant relationship-

(a) This Jury Law shall recognize the common people of the Philippines as the masters in

their democratic government. Any person rendering public service shall be servant to, and of, the

people. Threatening defiance by such servant against this declaration shall be subject to a quo

warranto by jury trial, or by impeachment, for removal from office for an act of treason to his oath.

(b) It shall be the prime duty of the government to educate the people which shall include

their education in the observance of elementary justice by the setting up of jury instructions. A

jury instruction shall be composed with the use and application of simplified definition of legal

terms, words and phrases into the common day to day use by the people in their local dialect.

(c) Any public servant referred to, or contemplated in, this Law shall pay his full and high

respects to, and dignity of, every citizen or person of the Philippines regardless of the economic

Page 37: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

4

status, rich or poor, gender or color, lingual accent, tribe, or aesthetic appearance, of such citizen

or person.

Section 3. Whistle Blower Protection -

(a) No member of the arm and police services, or of a civil office of the government

regardless of his inferior or junior rank or title, shall be charged for insubordination, demotion or

transferred of his position or location of job, deprived of promotion, terminated from office,

reduction of his compensation or pension or vacation benefits, or punished in any manner for

reporting any anomaly or criminal acts or any act of injustice, either as an anonymous tipster,

whistle blower to the media or an open complaining witness against a member of his organization

for discrimination, corrupt or graft practices, regardless of the rank and title of his fellow member

or of any public official of the government. Violation of this mandate shall render the violator

punishable for the crime of obstruction of justice upon investigation and indictment by a Grand

Jury as created in Article III and with reference to Article V, Section 2, of the National Jury Law.

(b) Except for his customary first and last name or nickname, no person shall have the right

to demand or ask, or be demanded or be asked, that he should be described or labelled or named

as a person with a powerful status, rank, title or position in the government or his profession,

royalty or nobility in society, in criminal, civil, or disciplinary matters for or against him.

(c) No person shall be described or identified with the name of his religion or creed, or

ethnicity, or lingual accent in a criminal or civil or administrative disciplinary action, for or against

him and any reference thereto shall not be admissible in evidence at any investigation, indictment,

or court or administrative proceeding or jury trial, jury deliberation or jury verdict.

Section 4. Six (6) months after the adoption of the National Jury Law, no person accused

of a crime punishable with a minimum imprisonment of one (1) year or more as contemplated

elsewhere in Article I of this Law shall be compelled to face trial in court or jury, unless the

accusation against him shall have been reviewed and approved by the grand jury in the form of

a grand jury indictment. When the phrase “criminal defendant” is used in this law, it shall mean

the same as the “accused” as used in other criminal laws.

Section 5. If any portion of this Law is declared invalid, its remaining provisions shall

continue and remain to operate to achieve its basic purpose.

Section 6. It is hereby mandated that every person who serves in any instrumentality of the

Page 38: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

5

Philippine Government shall act with transparency, truthfullness, and faithfulness to his

constituency.

Section 7. Every citizen who is qualified to serve as a juror under this Law and who has

received summons for jury duty shall have the mandatory obligation to appear in court. No prior

education of any law, rule, instruction, or regulation of any kind or nature or political party or

religious affiliation shall be required as a condition for issuance of a summons for jury duty to any

citizen. Failure of such citizen to obey his summons to appear in court shall be held liable for

contempt of court or for obstruction of justice in the discretion or recommendation by a Jury

Commissioner or Clerk of Court.

Section 8. Any amendment to, modification of, or any act to abolish, or any comparative

law enacted by Congress or decreed by executive order of the President or other means, to over

ride this law, or any other law enacted by the people of the Philippines through the initiative or

referendum process, shall remain invalid unless submitted to the people for approval in

accordance with the initiative or referendum rules of Republic Act 6735.

Section 9. No person who has committed a serious crime punishable by one year or more

of imprisonment under the laws of the Philippines shall have the right to claim exemption from the

operation and jurisdiction of this Law regardless of his citizenship, membership in any private or

public organization of Philippine society, royalty, nobility, or fraternity or sorority, or any

government position, membership or service in any national or local government instrumentality,

department, branch or office, civil or military or police, or organization or unit and regardless of

whatever means such person has acquired his position, membership or service, by election,

appointment, or by usurpation of power, military coup, or any legal or forceful means.

Section 10. No Immunity from Jury Operation of Offenders of Crime Punishable by One

Year of Imprisonment or More in Jail -

(a) No immunity from investigation and indictment, or from hearing and conviction, in a

criminal action, for a crime or crimes punishable by imprisonment in jail for one year or more

committed within the territorial jurisdiction of the Philippines under this Jury Law shall be granted

to any official in the national government and local government units or government

instrumentality, including but not limited to, the president, vice-president, the ombudsman, the

president of the senate and each senator, the speaker and each member of the house of

representatives, the chief justice and each of the associate justices of the supreme court and all

appellate justices and judges in the lower courts or echelon of the Philippine justice system, the

Page 39: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

6

chief of staff of the armed forces of the Philippines and each officer or enlisted person below his

rank, and the director general of the Philippine national police and each officer or subordinates

below his rank, a governor, provincial board member, city or municipal mayor, barangay captain

or member of any local council member, notwithstanding any law, presidential decree, or rule to

the contrary.

(b) Any public official or person as described in the preceding paragraph (a) who has

committed any crime shall be deemed to have acted without authority in committing said alleged

crime. When charged or indicted for the crime, he shall be deemed to have acted in his private

capacity and any act he shall perform to mitigate or eliminate his criminal liability using the power

and authority of his office during the pendency of the criminal case against him shall be void.

Additionally, he shall be charged for the commission of the crime of Obstruction of Justice.

Section 11. No person, or public official, or government employee, regardless of his rank,

title, or position in the government, or title of nobility or royalty in the community, is hereby

permitted or authorized to give any order to provide preferential detention or prison facility or

prison cell to any person who has been arrested or who is under government custody for the

alleged commission of a crime and/or who has been convicted of such crime punishable by

imprisonment regardless of his rank, title or position in the government, or a private citizen who

claims to possess with royalty, nobility or wealth privileges in society unless such detention or

prison facility is likewise open to accommodate indigent detainees or convicted felons. This

proscription shall not apply to food, medicine prescribed by his physician, and clothing in kind

given, or brought in, by a close relative within two degrees of blood or marital relationship as

defined by the Family Law with, or to, the incarcerated person subject to inspection by jail

authorities.

Section 12. Any public official or government employee as described in the foregoing

Section 11 who shall violate the proscription in said section, upon indictment by a Grand Jury shall

suffer removal or termination from public service and shall be forever barred from holding any

public position, national or local, in the Philippine Government of any type, political, appointive,

temporary or honorary and shall further forfeit any and all retirement benefits from public service

upon conviction of the crime of obstruction of justice in addition to the lose of his retirement

benefits.

Section 13. If the public official referred to in the foregoing Sections 11 and 12, is

removable solely by impeachment, his violation of said Section 11 shall serve as a ground for his

impeachment, and shall likewise suffer the penalty imposed in Section 12 if charged for

Page 40: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

7

obstruction of justice and found guilty in a separate criminal action against him.

Section 14. If the person is a private citizen who shall give aid and comfort to the detainee

or convicted felon, such person in his private capacity who violates the proscription referred to in

Section 11, shall be liable for the crime of obstruction of justice with the pertinent minimum

penalty of said crime upon indictment by a Grand Jury. Such person shall likewise be barred

forever from seeking any public position, national or local, of any type, political, appointive,

temporary or honorary in the Philippines.

Page 41: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

8

ARTICLE II

TYPES AND PRINCIPLES OF

THE NATIONAL JURY SYSTEM

TYPES OF THE JURY SYSTEM

Section 1. The Jury System shall consist of two separate types, namely, the Grand Jury

and the Trial Jury, with powers to decide independently from government control.

(a) The Grand Jury shall serve as the direct sovereign guardian of the People of the

Philippines against lawlessness and shall function confidentially, in their behalf, as their secret

independent investigating and indicting arm in court. Its secret operation shall further serve as

the people’s counter-measure against secret commission of crimes by crime offenders. For this

purpose, a serious crime is defined as a criminal offense punishable by law with imprisonment

in jail by one (1) year or more; and

(b) The Trial Jury shall serve as a “group judge” which shall decide by majority rule, with

supervision by a jury presiding judge in criminal and civil matters in court trials to prevent

potential arbitrary or whimsical judicial decisions. It shall further serve as a shield for a presiding

judge in performing his judicial functions against intrusion, interference, or obstruction of justice,

by any powerful abusive national or local public official.

PRINCIPLES OF THE JURY SYSTEM

Section 2. The Jury System shall serve as a judicial device to put up a common front of

the Filipino People in their struggle against the pervasive discrimination, graft and corruption in

any branch of service of the government as well as against other serious crimes. The functions

of the jury system shall be accomplished according to an established set of Jury Instructions with

the following objectives:

(a) To achieve unity of the Filipino People. There shall be only one uniform set of jury

instructions that shall be adopted and it shall be consistently applied without deviation in all

criminal investigations and judicial proceedings all throughout the Philippines regardless of

culture and ethnicity of the parties involved in a case;

Page 42: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

9

(b) To attain the goal of eradicating discrimination or government graft and corruption,

membership in the juries shall be exclusively chosen randomly by lottery from the adult citizens

in the private sector in their respective legislative district, and;

(c) To keep total independence of juries from government control or monopoly by public

officials and politicians in the administration of justice, no approval by any government official,

or person claiming status of royalty or nobility shall be required to permit a citizen to serve as a

juror in either juries. The power to approve or disapprove the seating or unseating of a juror shall

preemptively belong to either counsels of the parties, or to any party if unrepresented by counsel,

involved and shall be ministerially implemented and respected in an actual case in court by the

presiding judge.

(d) To provide direct massive support by the people for the Judicial Branch of the

government in its function to enforce justice through the secret jury ballots of the people in the

similar basic idea that the functions of the Executive and Legislative branches of the government

are derived from the support of the people via their secret electoral ballots and to enhance the

check and balance of power among said government branches to prevent abuses by government

officials.

Section 3. No person, media member or media group, public official of any title, position,

or rank, civil or military, judge, justice, prosecutor, ombudsman, royalty or nobility by reason of

his religion or tradition or claim of supreme status in a community or government entity shall have

the right to ask, demand, or request, for issuance of a court order on the following matters:

(a) The publication or announcement of any name or identity of any citizen who shall serve

as a member of the grand jury or a trial jury; and

(b) To prevent any jury as organized under this Law from exercising its powers and

independent prerogatives to bring a serious crime offender before the bar of justice.

Section 4. Membership in either Juries shall be chosen by lottery from among registered

voters in their respective legislative districts in accordance with the procedures adopted for either

the grand jury or trial jury. A jury formed with appointed members by any public official or by any

nobility or royalty, directly or indirectly shall be invalid and without power to function.

Section 5. Prevention of Conflict of Interest of legal counsels.

Page 43: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

10

(a) In all criminal trials, either by jury or bench trial, no defense counsel, or lawyers in the

same law firm acting as defense counsels, shall be permitted to undertake the defense of two

or more accused suspected offenders, directly or indirectly, who are charged on the same

alleged criminal act or acts to prevent potential conflict of interests, known or unknown, towards

any of his or their clients or between, and/or among, his or their, clients.

(b) Any attorney who shall violate this provision shall be criminally liable of the crime of

obstruction of justice, and shall be subject to disciplinary action for disbarment regardless of

whether such defense counsel or counsels shall have been convicted, or not, of the crime of

obstruction of justice and regardless of the location of their law firms within and around the

country.

Section 6. Joint liability of Government Entity and Its Agent in serving the Public -

The government entity or public office including any government owned or controlled or

quasi-government corporation shall be jointly and severally held liable on, and with, the civil

liability of a public official or government employee by the use, abuse, or semblance, of his

authority in representing any of said entities actually or impliedly, who has caused injury or death

to a person through the negligence, recklessness, or intentional tortuous, act of such public

official or government employee or government instrumentality in serving the public.

Section 7. Power and right of juries to function in times of declaration of martial law or

man-made emergency-

(a) The sovereign right and power of the Filipino People in accordance with Article II,

Section 1, of the constitution to conduct grand jury and trial jury proceedings shall not be

abrogated or disturbed by the declaration of martial law or man-made emergency. Man-made

emergency shall include, but not limited to, rebellion, insurrection, or sedition.

(b) All personnel of the armed forces of the Philippines or the Philippine National Police

assigned to serve the people shall have the joint duty and obligation to afford protection to the

members of the grand juries and trial juries as well as the integrity of their jury proceedings.

(c) Any public official or member of such armed services referred to in the immediate

preceding sub-paragraph (b) shall be liable for indictment of the crime of obstruction of justice

by the grand jury and punishment from five (5) to seven (7) years of imprisonment in jail upon

conviction by a trial jury in addition to such other crimes and punishment by any of such official

Page 44: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

11

or member of said armed services shall have committed.

(d). Declaration of martial law shall not serve as a license to violate the human rights and

well being of any person or citizen, or interfere in the functions of the grand jury and trial juries,

by any public official or person including, but not limited to the President and such other officials

or persons under his command.

Section 8. When a juror in a grand jury or trial jury who, in the course, or arising out, of jury

service is injured so as to be unable to perform his normal daily living activities for 10 days or

more, or dies, regardless of fault, shall be entitled to monetary indemnity. If the injury or death

of the juror took place outside the course of jury service and the evidence of his injury or death

shows that it was motivated with hate, revenge, or vindictiveness of the liable party against the

juror, this monetary indemnity shall, nonetheless, inure to the benefit of the juror or to his next

of kin. This provision shall be liberally construed in favor of the injured juror or to his next of kin.

(a) If the juror dies in the course, or arising out, of jury service, or under such other

circumstances mentioned in the preceding paragraph, such juror shall be entitled to a monetary

indemnity in the amount of two hundred thousand (P200,000.00) pesos, free of income tax.

(b) If the death or injury of the juror is the result of the negligence, or intentional or

reckless or wanton act of any person, or public officer, acting as an agent in performing the

function, of a private organization or corporate entity, or of a government instrumentality or entity,

said person, or public officer, and the private organization or corporate entity, or government

instrumentality such person or public officer is representing shall be jointly and severally liable

to pay the next of kin of the deceased juror.

(c) The private organization, corporate entity, or government instrumentality shall have

the right of reimbursement against such person, or public officer who has directly caused the

death or injury of the juror. Government instrumentality as used in this Law is hereby meant to

cover all government agencies and instrumentality and government owned or controlled

corporations and quasi-government corporations all over the Philippines.

(d) If the juror is injured by reason of the act or acts by another is incapacitated to perform

his activities for daily living as determined by a treating doctor of his choice, the indemnity shall

not be more than two hundred (P200,000.00) thousand pesos, depending on the severity of his

disability, but not, less than fifty (P50,000.00) thousand pesos, free from income tax.

Page 45: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

12

(e) The indemnity payment shall be promptly paid to his heirs or next of kin of the juror in

case of death or to the disabled or incapacitated juror from the funds of the Philippine

Government or private entity without awaiting for reimbursement of such funds from the party

who is ultimately responsible for the death of, or injury to, the juror.

(f) To ensure payment of the claim of an injured juror, or next of kin of a deceased juror,

the Philippine Government, or private entity, shall be responsible to obtain a master insurance

policy with a reputable liability insurance carrier to answer and to pay its jury liability for the

benefit of a juror or jurors serving for jury duty under this Law.

(g) The amount of premium referred to in the immediate preceding subparagraph (e) shall

be negotiated by and between the respective representatives of the Government and the liability

insurance carrier.

(h) Failure of the Philippine Government, or private entity, to secure said insurance liability

policy shall not in anyway prevent or delay the payment of the juror’s benefit directly from its own

general funds and in such event the claimant may pursue his claim by civil action by jury trial.

Should he prevail, his award shall be increased by forty percent (40%) over his original claim for

benefits to cover the attorney’s fee of his legal counsel.

(I) The same additional award shall be granted to the claimant if the insurance liability

carrier fails or delays to pay the claimant. Payment of the claim is deemed delayed if it remains

unpaid beyond thirty (30) days, excluding Saturdays, Sundays and Official Holidays, upon the

date of presentation of a written demand for payment by the claimant with the Philippine

Government or government instrumentality..

(j) No special or official form of the written demand shall be required in order for the

claimant to collect his award or benefits provided that it is supported by a certification by the

Clerk of Court indicating that the juror was injured and the medical record of his treating physician

or hospital authority, or has met his death and supported by a death certificate issued by the

Local Civil Registrar, arising out of, or in the course of, or during the period of , jury service.

(k) The claim of the injured juror, or of the next of kin of the deceased juror, shall prescribe

after ten (10) years from the date of injury or death of the juror. If such claim has been

commenced prior to the lapse of said period, the same shall be enforceable until the award is

fully satisfied or paid.

Page 46: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

13

(l) “In the course of jury service” or “arising out of jury service” shall include the period in

which the subject matter of the jury proceedings is still in progress regardless of whether the

injury or death of the juror occurred in the premises of the trial court or grand jury investigation

room or whether the juror was going to court or grand jury room from home and back from court

or grand jury room to home during the continuance of the jury proceedings.

(m) The Philippine Government or it’s liability insurance carrier shall have the right to a

reimbursement of its payment from the personal funds of a public officer or government agent

or a party at fault or heirs of such party who has inflected injury or death upon the juror within the

period of ten (10) years from the date of injury or death of the juror.

(n) Any public officer or government agent of the Philippine Government requiring the

need to carry a firearm of any type in the performance of his duty is hereby required by this Law

to carry an umbrella liability insurance policy with at least two hundred (P200,000.00) thousand

pesos to pay his financial responsibility under this law.

Section 9. Any person found guilty either in a trial by jury or in a bench trial, or who has

pleaded guilty, for committing the crime of obstruction of justice, or any serious criminal offense

of any type, shall forfeit and lose for life all privileges and benefits from occupying any public

office regardless of his being a recipient of a presidential clemency or pardon.

Section 10. Any person claiming for benefits under this Jury Law shall be entitled to an

additional award from the obligor on his claim to cover attorney’s fee in the event that such

claimant is forced to secure the assistance of an attorney on contingency basis to obtain his

award regardless of whether the matter is litigated in court or not. The attorney’s fee shall be

one-third (1/3) of the total award if not litigated, or forty percent (40%) if litigated in court. If the

attorney is unsuccessful of obtaining the award for his client, he shall have no recourse for

payment of his attorney’s fee from his client-claimant.

Section 11. Notwithstanding any law, rule, or decree, to the contrary, any contract entered

into by and between a lawyer and a client to litigate a claim for monetary benefit on contingency

basis under this law shall be valid and enforceable before any court of law or by arbitration or

mediation. If claimant loses, attorney has no right to claim for his fee against his client.

Section 12. It is hereby made mandatory that every lawyer who handles money claim for

clients shall open a special bank account, named as “Clients’ Trust Account”, into which money

received for a client is deposited at all times and be ready for investigation by a Grand Jury. None

of the client’s money shall be commingled with his operational business or personal checking

account or be kept in any other place. Intentional violation or omission of this rule shall render

the lawyer strictly liable for disbarment regardless of any damage suffered by his client.

Page 47: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

14

ARTICLE III

THE SOVEREIGN GRAND JURY

Section 1. The Sovereign Power of the Grand Jury -

(a) Article III of this National Jury Law shall be referred to as the "Grand Jury Law". The

basic power of the grand jury is hereby derived, and shall directly emanate, from the sovereign

power of the People in Article II, Section 1, of the Constitution over their government officials.

(b) The records of grand jury membership and investigation records shall not be subject

to the subpoena powers emanating from, but not limited to, the Legislative, Executive, Judicial

branches of the government or from the media or from any government instrumentality, or

government controlled corporation, or quasi-government corporation.

Section 2. Except for the judicial supervision in the initial formation and inauguration of

each Grand Jury, the power of the Grand Jury to function and decide shall be self-autonomous

and shall require no review from any government authority. It shall act as a direct top secret anti-

crime agent of the sovereign people in their respective localities. It shall have the power to

exercise the public functions stated in the sections below.

Section 3. Composition - The Grand Jury shall be composed of twenty-three (23)

members. They shall be randomly chosen by lottery from among applicant citizens belonging to

the private sector and its members shall serve anonymously. The Grand Jury and its members

shall be free from government control. Upon qualifying for membership, its members shall take

an oath of secrecy and their identity shall be kept absolutely secret which shall not be announced

or disclosed to the public or media in any manner or to any public official or to any person.

Section 4. Grand Jury Membership Qualification -

(a) Each member shall at least be a college graduate of any bachelor’s degree from any

college or university, must be twenty three (23) years of age of either gender and has not been

a member of a fraternity, sorority, or mista, and shall receive compensation for each day of jury

service at double the rate of the minimum wage law plus free noon time meal and round trip

transportation from home to his place of grand jury service at government expense.

(b) The following persons shall be disqualified from grand jury membership:

(1) Prior or current membership in any college or university fraternity or sorority;

(2) Person suffering from any mental impairment;

(3) Conviction of any crime punishable by imprisonment for six months or more;

(4) Any lawyer or public official or employee in any government instrumentality;

Page 48: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

15

(5) A son, son-in-law, daughter, or daughter-in-law

of a public official or government employee;

(6) A father or father-in-law, or mother or mother-in-law

of a public official or government employee;

(7) A brother or brother-in-law, or a sister or sister-in-law

of a public official or a government employee;

(8) A nephew or niece, uncle or aunt, of a public official or employee of any

government instrumentality;

(9) A person currently facing a criminal accusation of any kind in court;

(10) A member of a grand jury in the last 12 months;

(11) A person who has served in the government during the past 12 months;

(12) A person who has been recommended, or has been assisted or,

sponsored by a public official or by anybody in preparing or in filing

his/her application for grand jury membership;

(13) A member or employee of a media, news, or publishing organization; and

(14) A member of a royal clan or ruling family or political dynasty, or datu, bai, or

sultan and anyone claiming as a member of such royal clan or ruling family

or political dynasty, or datu, bai, or sultan;

(c) Upon entering grand jury service, each and all members of the grand jury shall be

required to take an oath of secrecy and confidentially before an Executive Trial Judge who shall

supervise the formation and inauguration of the Grand Jury as follows:

“GRAND JUROR’S SECRECY OATH

"I will support the Constitution of the Philippines and all laws made in pursuance

thereof and in conformity therewith,

"I will diligently inquire into, and true presentme nt make, of all public offenses

against the people of the Philippines, committed or triable within its territory and

boundaries of which the Grand Jury shall have or ca n obtain legal evidence.

"I will confidentially keep my own counsel, and tha t of my fellow grand jurors and

Page 49: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

16

of the government, and will not disclose the testim ony of any witness examined before the

Grand Jury, nor anything which I or any other grand juror may have said, nor the manner

in which I or any other grand juror may have voted on any matter before the Grand Jury.

"I will present no person through malice, hatred or ill will, nor leave any

unpresented through fear, favor, or affection, or f or any reward, or the promise or hope

thereof;

"But in all my presentments I will present the trut h, the whole truth, and nothing but

the truth, according to the best of my skill and un derstanding, so help me God."

Section 5. Functions of the Grand Jury - The following are the powers and functions of

the Grand Jury:

(a) The power, without need of government supervision, approval or permission, to

secretly investigate serious crimes, punishable by law with imprisonment in jail of one year or

more or death, and to indict or accuse in court any crime suspect upon its finding of probable

cause that such person may have committed a serious crime. No grand jury investigation and

indictment shall be subject to review or pre-trial hearing by any government prosecutor,

ombudsman, justice or judge.

(b) The power to approve or disapprove a criminal indictment initiated by the government

against any suspected crime offender over his commission of an offense punishable by

imprisonment in jail for one year or more. No person shall be forced to face a bench or jury trial

in court unless the criminal accusation against him shall have been approved by, and upon, a

grand jury indictment.

(c) The power to issue subpoena, subpoena duces tecum, or summons upon any person

or any government official or employee, officer of a banking institution, or director or officer of a

government controlled corporation or quasi government corporation, to compel the attendance

of a witness in its secret investigation room. The subpoena, subpoena duces tecum, or

summons, issued by a grand jury shall be enforceable anywhere in the Philippines.

(d) The power of the Grand Jury to issue subpoena, subpoena duces tecum, or summons

shall require no further need of a court order for service and execution upon a person, or to any

location or institution anywhere in the Philippines.

(e) The power to file an indictment in court for obstruction of justice against any person

who shall disobey, ignore or disregard its subpoena, subpoena duces tecum, or summons.

Page 50: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

17

(f) Government funds or money believed to have been deposited in, and commingled with,

or not, in the personal and private funds or money in any private or government bank in the name

of any public, legislative, judicial, military or police official, nationally or locally, shall enjoy no

immunity from grand jury secret investigation or scrutiny regardless of any banking secrecy law,

decree, or rule, to the contrary.

(g) Exception: The Grand Jury is not a court of law. It, or its members, shall have neither

power to compel the appearance or attendance in its investigation before said Body of a

suspected criminal offender nor the power to order his detention pending its investigation. Not

being a court, grand jury proceedings shall not be bound by the hearsay rules of evidence.

Section 6. Secrecy of Grand Jury Activities - All the proceedings of the Grand Jury shall

be conducted with strict and absolute confidentiality. Its members shall be bound by their oath

of secrecy and none of them shall disclose or be forced to disclose, or make contact with, any

person or any public official, pertaining to the investigation activities and records of the Grand

Jury. The records, electronic or stenographic notes and transcripts, of its proceeding shall not

be subject to subpoena, subpoena duces tecum, summons, or any communications by any

public or legislative or judicial official from any of the branches of the government or government

instrumentality, national or local, or any officer or director of any government owned or controlled

corporation or quasi-government corporation.

Section 7. Public Contact with Grand Jury or Grand Jurors is prohibited -

(a) No person, lawyer, or government employee, or any public or judicial official of any

rank, title, position, or power, or person of nobility or royalty, shall have the right to contact or

interfere in any manner, directly or indirectly, the Grand Jury or any of its members, unless he

shall have received a subpoena, subpoena duces tecum or summons from the Grand Jury.

(b) The grand jury subpoena, subpoena duces tecum, summons, indictments and other

forms of communications of the Grand Jury shall be signed personally with the authenticated

SIDN, or Security Identification Number, by its Foreman, Secretary, or any of its members. Their

names shall not be spelled out in said documents to maintain secrecy of their identity and

confidentiality of grand jury proceedings.

(c) The Clerk of Court shall have the responsibility of serving the subpoena, subpoena

duces tecum, summons, indictments and other forms of the Grand Jury communication and in

securing the proof of service of such documents in behalf of the Grand Jury.

(d) Every recipient or holder of a Grand Jury document including but not limited to a

subpoena, subpoena duces tecum, summons, grand jury indictment, and any other paper or

papers, has the obligation to keep in secret and complete confidentiality of the same for

Page 51: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

18

compliance of any directive contained therein and shall refrain from commenting on its content

or text or from distributing, copying, publishing, or announcing the same by any means to any

other person, or persons or party, or entity or to any member of the media. Any violator of this

provision shall be liable for obstruction of justice and punishable by imprisonment from 3 to 5

years in jail.

Section 8. No person or any witness, regardless of his power, rank, title, or position in the

government, shall be permitted to carry or bring into the grand jury room any cell phone, camera,

or firearm of any type. Violator of this rule shall be subject to an automatic indictment for

obstruction of justice upon discovery at any time during or after such person or witness is

testifying or has testified in the grand jury room. When enforcing this rule or provision of the

Grand Jury Law, the sovereign authority of the people under Article II, Section 1, of the

constitution, is hereby directly conferred upon the Clerk of Court to which every person, public

or judicial official of the land, regardless of title, position, rank and power in the government, shall

be bound to respect and obey. Such Clerk of Court shall be immune from disciplinary, criminal

or civil liability in enforcing his power and authority pursuant to this section of the National Jury

Law.

Section 9. Every province or city in the Philippines shall be divided into several grand jury

districts according to the following criteria:

(a) A province or city shall have at least one (1) gand jury district;

(b) A province or city shall be divided into such number of grand jury districts in which

each grand jury district shall be serving a population of approximately two hundred fifty thousand

(250,000) residents;

Section 10. The provincial board of each province, or the city council of each city, shall

determine the actual number of grand jury districts and their geographical location in their

respective jurisdictions. To provide maximum secrecy of operation, and anonymity of the identity

of the members, of grand juries, the provincial and city grand juries shall have joint and

concurrent jurisdiction to investigate crimes and crime offenders in each others territorial

jurisdiction. Each grand jury shall, however, operate independently from each other and shall

have the option to file its indictment in any regional, metropolitan, city or municipal court wherever

it chooses to within the city or province or neighbouring city or province.

Section 11. Within thirty (30) days from the date this jury law takes effect, the Provincial

Board and city councils shall promptly designate the general court location, district number but

not a specific address or room number or symbolic mark or identity, for each Grand Jury, taking

into account the proximity of the number and group of municipalities in the case of the province,

Page 52: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

19

or barangays in the case of cities, it is intended to serve. Within six (6) months from the date

this jury law takes effect, the Provincial Board and City Council or Councils, as the case may be,

shall further, respectively, provide secret grand jury rooms, chairs and desks, computers with

access to the Internet, copying machine, office supplies, and other miscellaneous facilities

required to operate each grand jury;

Section 12. In the event that the Provincial Board and the Provincial Governor, in the case

of a province, or the City Council and City Mayor, in the case of a city, or any member of such

provincial board or city council, or any officials acting in their behalf, who shall fail to comply with

their duties in designating their Grand Jury Districts and in creating the required grand jury rooms,

equipment, supplies, and other facilities for the full operation of their respective grand juries, after

six months of the effectivity of the National Jury Law, such officials shall be barred from collecting

their salaries, allowances, or any remuneration until such time that they have complied with their

duties as ordained herein.

Section 13. Disauthorization of Treasurers and Paymasters To Pay Salaries and

Allowances of Authorities Who Fail to Implement the Creation of Grand Jury Facilities -

(a) No provincial or city treasurer or any paymaster or cashier in his, or their, behalf shall

have the authority to pay the salaries, allowances, or any remuneration of any member of the

provincial board, or member of the city council, and the governor or mayor or any other officials

acting in their behalf or capacity as described in the foregoing Section 12, unless any of such

officials has submitted a certification from the appropriate official of the building engineering

department of his province or city indicating that the required grand jury rooms, equipment,

supplies, and other facilities for the full operation of their respective grand juries shall have been

put in place and made functional in fact.

(b) Upon the effectivity of the National Jury Law, the Clerk of Court of the Executive Judge

who organized the Grand Jury is hereby authorized to negotiate with the President, or Director,

or Owner of a college or university within his judicial district to enter into a contract to rent, at

government expense, one of the class rooms with one online computer and a printer of his

school which must be unmarked for use to serve as a temporary grand jury room until such time

that the government is able to provide a permanent grand jury room within its judicial district. For

this purpose, Form GJ-27, the “Unconditional Non-transferable Redeemable Judicial Voucher”,

shall be used as a medium for the payment of the agreed rentals for the grand jury room, one

online computer with a printer. The secrecy set up of the room shall be similar, or equal, to the

secrecy standard as required of this Jury Law.

Section 14. Any provincial, or city treasurer, cashier or paymaster shall be personally

liable criminally for malversation of public funds under Article 217 as amended by Republic Act

1060 who fails to follow the proscription in the foregoing Section 13 and shall make a

Page 53: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

20

disbursement of government funds to pay the salaries, allowances, or any remuneration of any

member of the provincial board, or member of the count council, or to the governor or to the

mayor or any officials acting in their behalf or capacity in violation of their public duties as

described in the foregoing Section 12. No provincial or city treasurer shall be terminated from

service for enforcing this provision. Any public official who shall threatened the subject treasurer

for removal from his job to force payment of money demanded shall be liable for obstruction of

justice or for such other appropriate criminal action against such public official,

Section 15. The grand jury room shall be unmarked or without identification of any kind,

and adequately provided with sufficient lighting and air conditioning with its windows securely

locked and covered from public view. The room shall be secured from any bugging or spying or

surveillance devices, its ingress and egress door should pass through the general entrance door

behind the audience seats of a court room, which shall be known only and exclusively to, and by,

the Court Presiding Judge, the Sheriff and Supervising Clerk of Court of the building where such

courtroom is located;

Section 16. The members of the general public, including but not limited to any public

official from the legislative, executive, or judicial branches of the government, or police or army

services, or any official or director of any government owned or controlled corporation as well as

quasi-government corporation shall have no direct access to the grand jury room and grand jury

members. The persons exclusively permitted to enter said room are solely limited to the

members of the grand jury. Any person summoned or subpoenaed as a witness for questioning

before the Grand Jury shall be ushered into the grand jury room by the Sheriff or Clerk of Court,

no more than one at a time, regardless of whether the witness is a public official, or not, of any

rank, title or position, in the national, provincial, city, municipal, or barangay government. Except

for the Grand Jury members, the name of the witness ushered to the grand jury room must be

recorded in a confidential log book kept by the Supervising Clerk of Court of the Courthouse.

The log book shall not be disclosed to any member of the general public or media, or any public

official, except to, and upon demand by, the current or future grand jury;

Section 17. Any criminal complaint or accusations emanating from a government

prosecutor’s office, the Ombudsman, or by a lawyer in behalf of his client, shall be accompanied

with a completely prepared Grand Jury Indictment Form and it shall conform to the format of the

prescribed grand jury form in Section 99, Article III, of the National Jury Law. The text in the said

forms may be modified to satisfy jurisdictional issues affecting particularly the subject case or

cases for a specific accusation.

Section 18. Direct accusation by victims of crimes, including taxpayers in general as

victims, of theft of public funds or misuse of public vehicle or equipment, before the Grand Jury

may be initiated privately as follows:

Page 54: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

21

(a) An eyewitness to, or a victim and/or his successor-in-interest or next of kin in case of

death of the victim arising from a serious crime committed by the crime offender; or

(b) Any informal group of media reporters numbering three or more members in behalf of

a victim of a serious crime who is a media crime reporter; or

(c) An inmate in jail whether a detainee or convicted prisoner, or his friend or relative in

behalf of said inmate, for being confined in an unsanitary or filthy jail unfit for human confinement

with wanton or reckless disregard to his health and dignity as a human being by a jail keeper or

warden, may file an appropriate criminal accusation against the suspected crime offender directly

with any district grand jury in his locality by himself or with the assistance of a lawyer in preparing

his or their accusation. Any citizen or any member of the public media or press who may have

noticed of the unsanitary or filthy jail may secretly send his information to any grand jury in his

province or city for grand jury investigation of such unsanitary or filthy jail condition.

(d) The form of the accusation under this section should conform with the prescribed

sample grand jury forms in Section 99, Article III, of the National Jury Law.

Section 19. Separate List of names of 2 witnesses attached to complaint for filing with grand jury is required -

In all, and any, instances of filing of a written criminal accusation with the Grand Jury, a

list, separate and apart from the complaint form, of at least two (2) names and address of

credible or eye witnesses to the commission of the alleged criminal act or acts shall be attached

and submitted together with said accusation to the Grand Jury. Except for the blank lines which

are solely reserved for use by the Grand Jury, none of the named witnesses in the list shall

appear or be written anywhere in the criminal accusation form. Without the separate list and

names and addresses of witnesses, the Grand Jury shall not entertain the said complaint.

Section 20. Filing of complaint must be delivered to Clerk of Court-

A representative of the accusing government agency, hereinafter referred to as the

“Prosecutor” or the Private Lawyer who assisted the preparation of the private complaint of the

crime victim, shall file the complaint by personal delivery to the Clerk of Court, the officially

designated contact officer with the Grand Jury. Under no condition that such Prosecutor or

Private Lawyer shall have any direct contact or audience with any member of the Grand Jury.

Section 21. Filing of complaint with the Grand Jury

must be kept strictly confidential -

A submission of any written complaint or accusation or any other material for delivery

Page 55: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

22

to the Grand Jury shall be filed secretly, confidentially inspected, and sealed in an envelope or

container with appropriate size jointly by the Prosecutor of the provincial or city fiscal’s office, or

by the Private Lawyer in behalf of a private complaining party with the Clerk of Court without the

presence of any third party or person. The outside of the envelope or container shall be plainly

addressed or marked as “GRAND JURY” and promptly delivered personally by the Clerk of Court

to the Grand Jury. No delivery to the Clerk of Court of such complaint or accusation shall be

made later than 3:00 o’clock in the afternoon on any official business working day.

Section 22. Anybody involved in assisting the filing of complaint with grand jury is required to keep the matter strictly confidential -

By this Jury Law, any person, public official, or lawyer, who is, or has been, involved

in preparing or the filing of any accusation or complaint with the Grand Jury on any matter

whatsoever is absolutely forbidden to disclose, gossip, reveal, announce, or publish, publicly or

privately, such matter to any person, or to any member of his family or to any public official, Any

violator of this rule shall be subject to indictment for obstruction of justice by the Grand Jury.

Section 23. No lawyer, prosecutor, fiscal, or third party is allowed to cross examine a witness before the Grand Jury -

The Grand Jury shall have no judicial power to conduct a trial and any person subpoenaed

or summoned to testify therein shall not be subject to a cross-examination by a third party or any

lawyer in behalf of his client or prosecutor, or fiscal.

Section 24. The Grand Jury shall act and function in accordance with the Statutory

Standard Grand Jury Instruction provided in the herein following page which shall be read and

issued to the Grand Jury by the Executive Judge with assistance of his Clerk of Court:

Page 56: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

23

“THE REGIONAL TRIAL COURT

Office of the Executive Judge

_________________________________________Street and City Addresss

STATUTORY STANDARD GRAND JURY INSTRUCTIONS

List below only the SIDN of each juror)

Juror SIDN ______ Juror SIDN ______ Juror SIDN ______

Juror SIDN ______ Juror SIDN ______ Juror SIDN ______

Juror SIDN ______ Juror SIDN ______ Juror SIDN ______

Juror SIDN ______ Juror SIDN ______ Juror SIDN ______

Juror SIDN ______ Juror SIDN ______ Juror SIDN ______

Juror SIDN ______ Juror SIDN ______ Juror SIDN ______

Juror SIDN ______ Juror SIDN ______ Juror SIDN ______

Juror SIDN ______ Juror SIDN ______ (No more than 23)

"Honorable Ladies & Gentlemen of the Grand Jury:

(1) I welcome you for reporting to this court session today. You are about to embark on

an interesting and a very honorable secret mission. I am pleased to announce that this court has

accepted your oath to fulfill your obligation to act collectively and secretly as a Grand Jury during

the next six calendar months beginning today (mark "X" for the proper period) from

(_)-January to June, year _________

(_)-July to December, year ________

in the Grand Jury you applied for membership.

(2) (a) Your collective act as a grand jury is sovereign which is intrusted to you by the people

of your Grand Jury District pursuant to their sovereign power and authority in Article II, Section

1, of the Constitution. It has been conferred to you upon taking your oath of office.

(b) Every person serving in the government is your public servant regardless of his public

position, title or rank, or title of nobility or royalty. Your role is to secretly investigate serious

crimes committed by each and every public servant or any private person of society who may

have committed a crime. You may, then, file the appropriate indictment or accusation in court

against the offender of the crime upon your finding of a probable cause that he has committed

the crime.

(c) This Grand Jury is absolutely independent from any government control and you need

Page 57: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

24

not seek or ask the permission of any public official, judge, justice, or prosecutor or ombudsman,

military officer or government official or anybody else, to commence your criminal investigation

and in filing your criminal indictment in court.

(3) My first and most important instruction is to tell you that you are on a top secret

mission and sacrificially dangerous or sometimes life threatening. Keep this secret by all means

and you must not let anybody know who you are. Your safety and success of your protection and

the protection of your family and fellow members in the grand jury depends on your discipline in

keeping this secrecy. You must remember that you are bound by your oath of secrecy. On my

part, I assure you that I will keep your records confidentially and I will be depositing your personal

records or any copy thereof in a vault with a bank to securely keep your records and in no other

place within 24 hours after I have sworn you in office as required by our Grand Jury Law. Your

records shall not be retrieved or disclosed unless by the subpoena from a Grand Jury.

(4) My second important instruction is that you must not tell or disclose your true name

to your fellow members in this grand jury and no one from among you shall have the right to

demand to know each others real name. If it happens that some of you may already have known

each others name, I still require you to call or address each other with your SIDN or Security

Identification number which you already have when you were chosen earlier today.

(5) As a juror, you may be investigating your own fellow juror for some reason, just as

much as you will be investigating the conduct of any person or government official or crime

offender regardless of his rank, power, title or position or nobility or royalty in the community. If

you learn or know that any of your fellow members in this grand jury has committed a crime of

any kind or of any act of corruption, or who has falsified his application for grand jury membership

as a grand juror, I hereby instruct you to act as a tipster or as a witness to report such fellow

member to the next succeeding grand jury for investigation and or indictment after your current

term of service expires.

(6) The only name you shall use and sign in all your official transactions as jurors is your

SIDN which is the acronym for Security Identification Number.

(7) You are hereby vested with power through your collective decision to enforce decency

and discipline in the government service and all criminal laws to keep peace and decency of our

community. You may use English, Tagalog, or any dialect or a combination of said languages

or dialects that you or any person or witness you deal with fully understand in the conduct of your

official business.

(8) Your power to investigate crimes is superior in all respects than any investigation

conducted by other persons or officials, group, or entity in the government such as the

Ombudsman, the National Bureau of Investigation, or the Philippine National Police, among

Page 58: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

25

others, and you must bear it with dignity befitting of the sovereign power of the people which has

been directly conferred and entrusted to you to exercise and practice. You must keep a superior

attitude, without arrogance, in a tactful or reasonable manner and never show any subservience

when conducting your official business with any person or public official you shall be dealing with

regardless of his rank, title, or position in the government or title of nobility or royalty in the

community. As a group in the Grand Jury you must act as a master and not as a servant in

dealing with any person or public official of any rank or power or position, or with any person of

nobility or royalty.

(9) By the Rules of the National Jury Law, I have been commissioned to inform, and to

confer, as I am now informing and conferring, upon you of your powers, duties and privileges.

(10) You must know each other only by your SIDN, acronym for “Security Identification

Number”, and I hereby forbid you from revealing your SIDN to any person who is not a member

of this grand jury. Conversely, you are prohibited from impersonating yourself with the use of

another’s SIDN. You must not exhibit your SIDN to the public except for your pass of entering

the grand jury room and in signing your official acts on certain documents or in collecting your

compensation for jury service.

(11) Whenever you enter the grand jury room, you must not converge in group at its door

to prevent inviting attention and curiosity by outsiders or the media. If asked what you are doing,

simply say politely: “I cannot comment on your question”. Speak no further and walk away

promptly. You must casually stay far from each other when you enter your room and you must

not allow anyone to take a picture of yourself.

(12) Instruction to organize the grand jury. Your first order of business shall be the

designation of your officers who shall be chosen by and from among your members and who

shall likewise swear before this court in the coming few minutes their oath of office in addition to

your Oath of Secrecy. Your officers shall have a great responsibility to perform and all of you are

required to cooperate and to assist in the discharge of that responsibility. It is essentially

important that you thoroughly read Article III of the National Jury Law and familiarize yourselves

with the use of the Grand Jury Forms which you will find in Section 99, Article III, of the National

Jury Law

(13) Your officers shall consist of a Foreman who shall act as your presiding officer, your

Assistant Foreman who shall act in the absence of the foreman, the Secretary and the Recording

Secretary. You shall address each other as the case may be as "Mr. Foreman, Mr. or Ms.

Secretary, or Mr. GJ #______" and others as "Mr. or Ms. Witness Mr. or Ms. Stenographer, Mr.

or Ms. Interpreter." In this service, you must learn and make yourself accustomed to know and

call each other by your SIDNs as your security identity names.

Page 59: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

26

(14) If, in the course of your term of office, you find the need to reorganize your

leadership upon your mutual agreement and approved by a majority of your members or upon

motion by a member or officer, duly seconded by another member or officer, and approved by

a majority of your members, you may do so, and proceed to elect your new officers. In such

event you shall inform the executive judge through the clerk of this court for its record and

information on Form GJ-44 and attach therewith a blank form of Form GJ-35 for completion by

the executive judge.

(NOTE for inducting Executive Judge: To speed up the designation process of choosing the grand juryofficers, the Executive Judge shall solicit volunteers to act as candidates for foreman, vice foreman,secretary and recording secretary. The Executive Judge may profound questions on any matter todetermine the capabilities of the volunteering leaders and thereafter he shall ask other members to voteby raising their hands who among the volunteers will they elect as their grand jury officers. A vote of 12or more in favor of the nomination shall be elected. Before proceeding, the Executive Judge shall takenote of the chosen grand jury officers by their designated SIDN. Thereafter, the judge will administer theoath of the officers of the grand jury as shown below.)

(15) "Do you solemnly swear individually and collectivel y that you will accept your

obligation freely, without any mental reservation o r purpose of evasion; and that you will

well and faithfully discharge the duties of your of fice in this Grand Jury in which you are

about to enter. So God help you" and your response shall be: "I, and we, do."

(16) Nature and source of power of the members of the grand jury:

(17) Your membership in the grand jury is derived from your citizenship in our democratic

society. It has been made evident by our constitution in Article II, Section 1, which states that:

"The Philippines is a democratic and republican State. Sovereignty resides in the people and all

government authority emanates from them." What this means is that the People are the Masters

and they are the source of power of each and all public officials as public servants.

(18) This court will take notice that you are now duly organized as a Grand Jury.

Regardless of your position, each of you as a member of the Grand Jury shall have one vote for

the purpose of determining your collective decision or resolution over a given matter. You must

cast your vote by secret ballot. Your foreman or secretary shall have no individual power to

decide for, or in behalf of, your group as a Grand Jury and any attempt by either grand jury

officers to do so shall be invalid and inoperative. Each of you must memorize your powers and

obligations as grand jury members. Henceforth, this court or any other court, or any government

official, shall have no further participation in approving or disapproving your decision to

investigate or indict a suspected crime offender. This grand jury shall be self-autonomous and

it shall decide independently from any government control or supervision.

Page 60: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

27

(19) The function of the grand jury consists of two alternative parts to ensure that no

person shall be indicted of an alleged crime by arbitrary decision of the accuser:

First, it has the power to prevent criminal indictment against any person in court if it is

based on improper, illegal or capricious motive of the accuser or for lack of probable cause.

Second, it has the power to ensure that a criminal indictment is filed in court against a

crime offender where there is probable cause or reasonable ground to believe that the suspect

is guilty of the crime. A finding that no probable cause exist, or a finding of probable cause, by

the grand jury shall not be subject to review with preliminary investigation of a judge or a

prosecutor. Your collective decision to indict in court is final. Your decision not to indict is

tentative and you may proceed to indict when warranted by additional evidence you may have

subsequently discovered.

(20) To find the forms you need in your operation, always refer to Section 99, Article III,

of the National Jury Law.

(21). Grand Jury business hours and Security Matters -

(22) Your business hours shall be from 9:00 o'clock in the morning until 5:00 o'clock in the

afternoon and your noon time break shall be from 12:00 noon up to 1:00 o'clock in the afternoon.

It is mandatory that you wear a barong tagalog whenever you report to the grand jury

investigating room as a symbol of your authority. Without it, your foreman is hereby authorized

to refuse recognition of your presence in the investigating room and your compensation in such

occasion will not be paid.

(23) If you deem it necessary for your protection and security of the vicinity of your place

of operation, your foreman shall contact and request the National Police Director of the Philippine

National Police for deployment of the needed police personnel nearby but not inside your grand

jury investigation room. Use the prescribed form, Form GJ-28, in Section 99, Article III, of the

National Jury Law Your foreman shall have joint supervision over the police personnel.

(24) Powers and duties of the foreman of the grand jury. Your foreman shall lead and

shall be responsible in the management, discipline and operation of the grand jury. He shall

preside all grand jury sessions. He must keep a Permanent Grand Jury Membership Record on

prescribed Form GJ-4, in Section 99, Article III, of the National Jury Law. He shall have the power

to demand prompt attendance of all grand jury members.

(25) Exactly at 9:00 o'clock in the morning of each business day, your foreman shall

promptly convene the grand jury session. Each member attending a grand jury session shall

personally sign in the attendance sheet, the prescribed Form GJ-5, in the presence of the

Page 61: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

28

foreman with his SIDN and the foreman must write in the exact time such member reported at

the grand jury room.

(26) In the afternoon at the end of the session, the foreman shall further write in the exact

time such member leaves the grand jury session room. He shall keep a record of juror's absence

on Form GJ-6. He shall have the power to approve and recommend payment of the per diem of

each grand juror. The foreman shall have the power to assign cases using Form GJ-7 to each

grand juror or a group of 2 or more grand jurors for personal attention and investigation of a case.

(27) He shall keep a log record on Form GJ-31 of each and all cases this Grand Jury is

pursuing. No new case number shall be assigned to a prior docketed or numbered case. He shall

set up the plans to investigate government entities on Form GJ-8 or public officials on Form GJ-9.

In the absence of the foreman, the vice-foreman shall perform the duties of the foreman.

(28) The foreman shall have the power to recommend to the Executive Judge the

termination of service by a grand juror for inexcusable failures to attend two or more grand jury

sessions or for insubordination or gross violation of grand jury confidential rules or instruction.

His recommendation shall be written on Form GJ-23.

(29) Conversely, any six (6) members of this grand jury shall have the power to

recommend on Form GJ-24 to the Executive Judge of this court for the expulsion of its foreman

for: (a) inexcusable failures to attend two or more grand jury sessions; (b) frequent or habitual

tardiness in reporting to the Grand Jury Investigation Room; (c) for drunkenness or substance

abuse; (d) for bribery; (e) close association with public officials suspected of committing

corruption or who is a potential subject of grand jury investigation for corrupt or graft practices;

or (f) for the commission of a crime.

(30) The role of the Secretary and other Members of the Grand Jury:

(31) The Secretary shall: Prepare your daily agenda on Form GJ-33 in consultation with

the foreman; Assist the foreman in preparing the needed daily attendance record of the grand

jury members on Form GJ-5 which he or she shall keep secure in a receptacle and shall not be

appended to the next day's daily attendance sheet. No further entry shall be made on daily

attendance sheet once it is placed in the secured receptacle.

(32) The secretary shall help, or coordinate with, the Clerk of Court to prepare the per

diem vouchers each pay day for all the grand jurors for submission to the Executive Judge of this

Regional Trial Court. The secretary shall be the principal custodian of the records and the

required forms for use of the grand jury.

Page 62: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

29

(33) The Secretary shall: (a) Prepare your daily agenda on Form GJ-33 in consultation

with the foreman; (d) Assist the foreman in preparing the needed daily attendance record of the

grand jury members on Form GJ-5 which he or she shall keep secure in a receptacle and shall

not be appended to the next day's daily attendance sheet and no further entry shall be made on

daily attendance sheet once it is placed in the secured receptacle.

(34) The Members of the Grand Jury shall take an active role in recommending to the

foreman the investigation and indictment of crime offenders that come to their knowledge. When

a member is assigned by the foreman to take charge of a particular case, such member shall

have the duty to find the names and addresses of witnesses and suspected crime offender.

(35) Any six (6) members of this grand jury shall have the power to recommend on Form

GJ-34 to the Executive Judge of this court for the expulsion of its secretary for: (a) inexcusable

failures to attend two or more grand jury sessions; (b) frequent or habitual tardiness, among

others; (c) in reporting to the Grand Jury Investigation Room; (d) drunkenness or substance

abuse; (e) for bribery or close association with public officials suspected of corruption or potential

subject of grand jury investigation for corrupt or graft practices; or (f) for the commission of a

crime.

(36) Recording Secretary - Powers and duties of the recording secretary: Your recording

secretary shall be (a) responsible in recording the interrogation sessions with witnesses before

the grand jury. (b) He must prepare the electronic recording devices for the session. No

interrogation session of the grand jury shall proceed unless its tape recorder, recording device,

is actually functioning for the exclusive review by its grand jury members.

(37) The recording secretary shall have the power to recommend for the hiring of a

stenographer. The foreman shall provide a security ID number to the stenographer which he shall

record on Form GJ-32, the non-GJ Member Master Designation Registry. The Stenographer

shall not be an employee in any government office or government instrumentality. His

stenographic transcript shall not be subject to subpoena or subpoena duces tecum by any

branches of the government or any government instrumentality, and all of such transcripts shall

be kept in the security vault of the Grand Jury.

(38) The stenographer may either record the grand jury proceedings actually during the

session or the stenographer may transcribe the tape record of the proceedings whichever will be

convenient for the grand jury. The stenographer’s compensation or fee shall be paid on Form

GJ-64. Refer to Section 99, Article III, of the National Jury Law to find the form.

(39) You must remind your stenographer that he or she is bound by the confidentiality

requirements of the grand jury.

Page 63: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

30

(40) This is your greatest opportunity to serve your community. Take advantage of it with

pride.

(41) I am emphasizing to you, once again, that you have been randomly chosen to serve

as an organized group, known as the Grand Jury.

(42) Your grand jury membership is your opportunity to enforce the rule of law in our

justice system. By this Instruction, you are empowered to secretly investigate and indict in court

any person who has committed a serious crime, punishable by imprisonment for one (1) year

ore more, or by death, regardless of his fame, nobility, royalty, wealth, rank position or title, if

any, in our government or society in this jury district.

(43) You will have the opportunity to secretly investigate crimes and to file criminal

charges in court against crime offenders by means of an indictment without seeking approval of

any government prosecutor or the Ombudsman.

(44) Dissolution of the Grand Jury - I must caution you at this stage, however, that your

term of office is not absolute. Your group as a grand jury may be easily dissolved before the end

of your term for jury duty just as easily as you were chosen today and appointed as members of

the grand jury.

(45) If, in the course of your service, it appears that this Grand Jury is unable to faithfully

perform its powers and duties by reason of disloyalty, apparent corruption or lack of interest in

discharging the duties imposed on it by these Statutory Grand Jury Instructions, this grand jury

may be dissolved by a declaration to do so by your own members;

(46) Any 10 members of your group regardless of official position shall have the power

to jointly present to the executive judge of this court a "Declaration For Dissolution" of this Grand

Jury using Form GJ-29 stating therein the reason for their declaration. They must attach a blank

form, Form GJ-30, to their Declaration for ready use by the Executive Judge.

(47) Thereupon, the executive judge shall order you to show cause within 2 days,

excluding Saturdays, Sundays, and Holidays, from date of filing the declaration why the grand

jury should not be dissolved. By the same date of the filing of the Declaration for Dissolution, the

declarant members shall likewise lay a copy thereof on the desk of their foreman.

(48) Excluding the members who presented the Declaration of Dissolution, there shall be

at least 13 of your members and officers present in court who must show up to resist the

declaration of dissolution, and they must all jointly rebut the allegation in the declaration. Their

rebuttal must be supported by the records of the grand jury to show the forms they have

accomplished, the number of witnesses they have interrogated so far, the indictments or

Page 64: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

31

memorandum of non-indictments they had decided on.

(49) This court shall order dissolution of the grand jury automatically by either failure to

appear with the desired attendance of 13 members or lack of accomplishments of the grand jury

as shown by its records in spite of your quorum and, in which case, this court will issue its

appropriate order with finality on Form GJ-30.

(50) You will be paid of your per diems up to the day the court ordered your dissolution

if shown in your Form GJ-5 that you have actually attended sessions of the grand jury. You will

likewise be placed under investigation and indictment by the successor Grand Jury if it appears

that you have falsified or forged your records in collecting your per diems.

(51) The executive judge shall thereupon order the Clerk of this Court to padlock the

Grand Jury Investigation Room and forthwith he shall further issue an order to the Clerk of Court

to make an announcement for a drawing at a certain date of names of Grand Jury applicants

remaining in the "Grand Jury Membership Application Raffle Bin" following the date of the

notification of your dissolution.

(52) The executive judge shall follow the same procedure beginning with Instruction No.

(1) of this Statutory Grand Jury Instruction to install the new set of grand jury members.

(53) No person or public official of any rank, position, or power, or title of nobility has the

right to remove you as a member of your group, except upon an accusation for falsification of a

public document in a written complaint, if you commit such an act in connection with your

investigation, or for the commission of a felony and such complaint shall have been investigated

by another grand jury.

(54) When you are performing your jury duty, you must feel superior in authority, but

politely, to any person or public or judicial official who appears before your group regardless of

his rank or position in the government or title of nobility or royalty.

(55) When performing your duties officially as a grand jury, you are representing the

sovereign power of the people within your jurisdiction and you are entitled to a higher dignity by

virtue of your authority than any high government official whom you may permit or subpoena to

appear before this grand jury. You are his Master and he is your Servant.

(56) Primarily, you will investigate crimes that are punishable by a minimum imprisonment

of at least 12 months or more in jail or by death. You will serve in our judicial district as a direct

crime indicting entity and agent in behalf of, and your power to act officially comes directly from,

the Sovereign People of your district, pursuant to Article II, Section 1, of the Philippine

Constitution. It states that "Sovereignty resides in the People and all government authority

Page 65: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

32

emanates from them.” Your territorial jurisdiction is coextensive with the legislative district in

which this court is located.

(57) Under certain circumstances you may also investigate crimes outside your regular

district and file your indictment in any other criminal court of law of the Philippines.

(58) The Grand Jury System has been enacted to enable the people, through you as a

Grand Jury, to exercise their sovereignty and authority over our government and government

officials. By this Rule, you are instructed to function secretly and confidentially as the people's

secret counter-device against crimes committed in secret.

(59) You must not use your personal telephone or cellphone in making calls relating to

your grand jury investigation to prevent your identities from being traced to your telephone.

(60) You must conduct your interrogation only within the confines of your secret hearing

room and you shall interrogate one witness at a time only. You shall not interrogate witnesses

by group. You must admit to your grand jury room just one (1) witness at a time for questioning.

(61) Your power to investigate pursuant to Article II, Section 1, of the Philippine

Constitution is sovereign. Your power to act will not be restrained by the inter-departmental

boundaries among the legislative, executive and judicial departments of the government as well

as in such other public or quasi-public instrumentality, national, regional autonomous, provincial,

city, municipal and barrio governments whose officials may have committed serious crime within

your province or city.

(62) You have, without seeking permission or authorization from any government

authority, the power on your own original initiative to investigate upon receiving a complaint from

the public and indict in court against:

(a) Any public official regardless of his rank or position in the government, or any person

in the private sector regardless of his title of nobility or royalty, who may have committed a

serious crime of any nature within your jury jurisdiction. Additionally, you shall have the power

to investigate and indict in court any person or public official or employee outside your jury district

if his act or conduct violates the life, liberty and pursuit of happiness of any person who is a

resident within your jury jurisdiction or if his act or conduct threatens or obstructs the flow of

commerce, peace and tranquility of any government entity within your jury jurisdiction.

(b) Additionally, you likewise have the right and power to approve all accusations originally

initiated by the government including but not limited to the accusations by the Ombudsman or

its deputy, or provincial or city prosecutors or fiscals against serious crime offenders before said

Page 66: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

33

indictment can be accepted for filing in court in accordance with Article III, Section 5(b) of the

National Jury Law.

(63) You have the exclusive power, right and duty to secretly investigate and decide to

file in court all criminal indictments as your findings may warrant in all forms of government

anomalies, graft and corruption, plunder, money laundering, serious crimes or offenses

punishable by imprisonment in jail for one year or more including but not limited to murder,

robbery, grand theft, tax evasion, human rights abuses, acts of fraud or violence in the conduct

of electing public officials.

(64) You will act as direct collective agent of the master of society, the sovereign people,

in your province or district on matters that are within your authority to investigate. You are not

agents under the government and you are not agents under any government official.

(65) Except by this Grand Jury Instruction that I am conferring upon you, no public official

by any definition, civil or military, has the power to command or give orders to you to do or not

to do your job in the Grand Jury.

(66) You must, therefore, independently carry out your official responsibilities with

extreme care peacefully and with dignity befitting of your sovereign position that you have derived

from the sovereign people in your district. You must address each of your fellow members as

honorable officials in performing your duties.

(67) At the end of your 6-month term of service, you shall desist from handling new and

pending cases which shall then be taken over by the new set of grand jury members for

reprocessing or deliberation and decision.

(68) Through your foreman and your secretary, you shall turn over all pending and

unfinished cases, or matters you have not filed with actual indictment in court, and all your grand

jury records to the new set of members of the grand jury.

(69) Your investigative and indictment powers to act are limited. You have no power to

perform any act beyond the powers stated in this Grand Jury Instruction.

(70) Use the prescribed forms required during your Grand Jury Questioning of a Witness.

You must thoroughly familiarize yourselves with the use of Form GJ-39. This is the most

important, “the heart of your job”, in going after crime offenders of society. It is found in Section

99, Article III, of the National Jury Law.

Page 67: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

34

(71) Each time you report for jury duty, you must have with you your Form GJ-38, your

SIDN validated ID, issued to you by the Executive Judge. Never lose that document. You will not

be recognized or allowed by your police protectors to enter your Grand Jury Investigation Room

without it.

(72) If any of you fail to report for jury duty for two or more consecutive business days

without legal justification, you will be subject to dismissal by this court from your grand jury

membership upon the recommendation of your foreman on prescribed Form GJ-23.

(73) Quorum -

(74) To officially act as a Grand Jury, a quorum of at least 14 of your members must be

present and you must have registered in your attendance record on prescribed Form GJ-5 as

soon as you get inside your investigating room. If you fail to register, your attendance will not be

recognized and there will be no basis to pay your per diems on such date.

(75) If you have a quorum of 14 members present, you must be unanimous with your 14

votes to decide to indict in court a crime suspect of your investigation. If you are threatened with

bodily harm or force to do, or not to do, by any of your fellow members in the grand jury, for the

reason that the act to do, or not to do, is manifestly illegal or against any law, it is mandatory that

you report to your succeeding grand jury or another grand jury for such threat of harm or force

upon yourself.

(76) For this purpose, your foreman with the assistance of your secretary must take a roll

call of all your members present and you should personally write down your SIDN in the Grand

Jury Daily Attendance Form GJ-5. It will be certified to under penalty of perjury jointly by your

foreman and your secretary with their respective SIDNs.

(77) If your foreman or acting vice foreman fails to report for jury duty for two or more

consecutive business days without legal justification, any three (3) of your regular members may

recommend to this court for his termination on prescribed Form GJ-24.

(78) Certification of Medical Illness -

(79) If you claim serious injury or illness as the cause of your absence, you must provide

this court a medical certification on prescribed Form GJ-20 from your treating physician stating

truthfully under penalty of perjury the exact nature of your illness or injury that requires you a rest

and absence from grand jury duty. Nonetheless, even if you are truly ill according to your

doctor’s certification and you are absent from grand jury service for five (5) days or more, you will

be terminated from your grand jury membership by your regular members by the use of Form GJ-

23.

Page 68: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

35

(80) Without said certification, or if the certificate is a forgery, your request for an excuse

for your absence from jury duty will be denied and this court shall forthwith remove you from your

membership in the Grand Jury. You will be replaced by picking another grand jury membership

application from the remaining applications in the grand jury membership application raffle bin.

If your foreman or acting vice foreman is terminated from jury service, a selection of such officers

will be conducted with supervision by the executive judge of this court.

(81) Each of you will have one vote to cast regardless of your position as a foreman or

secretary to be counted in determining your collective decision and your decision must be arrived

at after your deliberation or discussion. Your vote must be written secretly on a proper Jury Ballot

and prescribed in Form GJ-14 and signed with your SIDN and date of signing. In voting for an

indictment, at least 14 affirmative votes shall support your indictment. None of you should know

each others vote.

(82) You are prohibited to make a decision by flipping a coin. You must keep your

deliberation privately and you must absolutely disallow any person who is not your fellow member

to be present in your discussion or deliberation to indict a crime suspect.

(83) If a high government official wish to see you, you must politely decline to meet such

person or official by stating that you are forbidden to receive any advice or instruction regardless

of the rank and power in the government of such person. For this purpose, you must use the

Form GJ-50 to decline the request.

(84) If in the communication of such official, he is asking for information about your

investigation on any matter, you must politely decline to provide the requested information stating

that you have no power or obligation under the grand jury Law to disclose any information on any

subject of your investigation. For this purpose, you shall write your response letter as prescribed

in Grand Jury Form GJ-65.

(85) You may optionally, in lieu to the foregoing GJ Instructions (83) and (84), instead

issue a summons, using Form GJ-52 to the official seeking a meeting with you or requesting

information or certain records in the custody of the Grand Jury and place him in the witness stand

under oath for questioning by the members of the Grand Jury but you must not disclose or you

must not give the information he is asking. Get more information from him instead. However,

DO NOT USE this option if he is a crime suspect. Use Instruction No. (83) or (84), as the case

may be.

(86) Your first task upon receiving an information about a crime:

(87) Upon receipt for the first time of a report of a crime or complaint from a victim, or

from a prosecutor or an anonymous informant, you must promptly inform your foreman about the

Page 69: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

36

case. Your foreman shall thereupon record and assigned a "Grand Jury Case Number" for the

case on the prescribed log record known as "Foreman's Case Intake Record And Assigned

Cases to Jurors" on Form GJ-31.

(88) You are required to act in presenting a criminal accusation in court, called an

Indictment on an appropriate prescribed Form GJ-15, GJ-16, or GJ-17 (as the case may be)

upon complaint by, and in behalf of, crime victims, witnesses, police or prosecutors against crime

offenders based on your independent decision.

(89) You need not seek the approval by any other government authority whatsoever to

make your decision and you shall not be bound necessarily by the recommendation of such, or

any, other government official or authority. You must first investigate the matter to make your

decision based on your independent findings of facts and evidence.

(90) Your decision to indict or approval of your indictment, or return of an indictment, must

be based on your finding of a probable cause that the suspected offender is guilty of a crime.

Probable cause is a situation where a crime is committed and you have a reasonable belief that

the suspected offender has committed, and is guilty of, the crime. It is not necessary that you

gather a set of evidence with proof beyond reasonable doubt to support your indictment. A

natural human reaction or statement resulting from a sudden or surprising event can be

considered an evidence.

(91) Required Number of Votes to Present Indictment in Court - To approve or return an

indictment, there must be at least an affirmative secret vote of 14 members gathered out of all

those present at your session to indict. If you are unable to reach 14 votes, you should obtain

additional evidence or find and call or recall a witness for clarification of an issue that prevents

you in finding a probable cause for your indictment, otherwise, you will simply pass and write a

“Memorandum of No Indictment” on prescribed Form GJ-18. When you are confronted with a

difficult decision to make, you must review and adhere to your oath of office. Consult and review

your Form GJ-25 to arrive at your good faith decision one way or the other.

(92) You have the power to hire the services of a stenographer who will record your

proceedings and/or you may order for the purchase of an electronic recording device to record

your proceedings all at government expense. You must submit your request for a stenographer

or to purchase a recording device with the clerk of this court;

(93) You are immune from civil liability for your collective acts as a grand jury but you may

still be charged individually for committing any criminal act as defined by law. Your grand jury

membership is a mere privilege and it is not a matter of right. You are hereby reminded that you

can be summarily removed upon recommendation on prescribed Form GJ-23 by your foreman

to the executive judge of this court.

Page 70: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

37

(94) You are not a lawmaking body. It is not within your powers to make laws, rules or

regulation except only as to such rules for the internal and orderly conduct by and among

yourselves.

(95) For matters you wish to investigate, you may take leads from newspapers or any

media including online or Internet publications about serious crimes committed within your

jurisdiction.

(96) Your jurisdiction is coextensive with the legislative district in which this regional trial

court is located;

(97) You may use the prescribed form known as "Extract Record from Anonymous Report,

referred to as Form GJ-11 in recording the various information you have gathered about the

crime. It is part of your job to determine the address or residence or job location of the subject

of your investigation and the names of possible witnesses.

(98) You may publish your invitation for anonymous reporters or tipsters of crimes using

the form "Invitation for Anonymous Crime Informants" prescribed as Form GJ-10 to submit their

confidential crime information to the Clerk of Court or in the "Citizen's Secret Crime Reports Drop

Box" located in the lobby of this court house about the name and address of the suspect, his job,

if known, the crime he committed, and names and addresses of witnesses to the crime. Form GJ-

10 is a highly valuable means of finding witnesses to the crime that you are engaged to

investigate.

(99) You shall avoid mentioning the name of the suspected offender in your published

invitation. You need not ask for the reports to be signed. Any time of the business day, your

secretary shall pull out all contents of the "Drop Box" and write or stamp on each of them the

date you received a report of any type.

(100) You may work as a team of 2 or more members on a case in your office with

supervision of your foreman and you need not go out to the fields in your investigation. You

should rely on the information given by the testimony of witnesses the tipsters and whistle

blowers have named in their report whom you shall subpoena for secret questioning in your

grand jury room.

(101) Once you have recorded a case in your Form GJ-31, you must finish its

investigation within forty-five (45) days, excluding Saturdays, Sundays and Holidays, from the

date you have recorded the matter on Form GJ-31 or from the date of your receipt of a complaint.

Your job on a particular case is deemed completed by filing your Indictment in court with the use

of the appropriate prescribed Form GJ-15, GJ-16, GJ-17, or Form GJ-18 , as the case may be.

Page 71: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

38

(102) You shall file your indictment in court confidentially. You have the choice to file your

indictment with the clerk of this court or in any other clerk of court with another trial court within

this judicial district or in any other district. You may inquire from the clerk of this court the

locations of other trial courts in this judicial district.

(103) You need not go out in person from your investigation room for the filing of your

court indictment. You simply summon the clerk of this court, or clerk of another court, where you

wish to file your indictment. For this purpose, you shall use and fill in the prescribed “Summons

Form”, Form GJ-41, and present the same to the Clerk of Court of the court where you wish to

file your indictment.

(104) You shall not disclose, gossip, or publish, or announce, outside your fellow members

any information regarding your investigation on any matter. You must absolutely keep your

proceedings strictly confidential or secretly at all times.

(105) As a reminder, you have the sovereign power to approve or disapprove felony

accusations filed by a government prosecutor. Before accepting the complaint from the

prosecutor, you must, for your convenience, require the prosecutor to pre-accomplish on

prescribed Form GJ-15, or Form GJ-16, or Form GJ-17, as the case may be, and to speed up

your processing in approving the indictment.

(106) Before you approve complaints or accusations filed by government prosecutors, you

must require the appearance before you of the government witnesses for your direct examination

or questioning in your grand jury room with such witnesses or seek other evidence by subpoena

or by subpoena duces tecum by using prescribed Form GJ-12.

(107) You shall submit to the clerk of this court your subpoena who shall forthwith assign

the server of your subpoena to the witnesses.

(108) In the event that you find any inconsistency or conflict between the information

provided to you by government prosecutors or investigators and testimony of a victim or witness

to a crime, you may consider the testimony of the victim or direct witness more believable or you

may summon the Prosecutor to clarify certain inconsistencies in the evidence. Use Form GJ-52

for this purpose to require the appearance of the Prosecutor.

(109) Optionally, you have the additional power to designate any competent citizen, or any

public official, police, or military officer, to serve your subpoena or subpoena duces tecum other

than through the Clerk of Court. Nonetheless, you must always ask the Clerk of Court of this

Courthouse to serve your subpoena or subpoena duces tecum, or summons, for your

convenience.

Page 72: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

39

(110) Your power to issue subpoena or subpoena duces tecum is sovereign to compel

attendance of any witness or production of documents regardless of his rank, title, or position in

the government or any private citizen or person of nobility in the community in connection with

your investigation. If such witness refuses to obey or ignores your subpoena, you may indict such

witness for obstruction of justice using prescribed Form GJ-16 upon proof or evidence that you

have validly served such witness with your subpoena.

(111) Should you find that a witness has testified falsely before you as a grand jury, you

may indict such witness for perjury, or for obstruction of justice using prescribed Form GJ-16 or

Form GJ-17, as the case may be, if his testimony has been intended to delay, frustrate, prevent,

or confuse the grand jury in its investigation of a case or to cover-up the criminal act of a crime

suspect. At the start of his testimony, you must admonish the witness of his liability and penalty

for obstruction of justice, should he provide you with false or misleading information.

(112) You must present at least two (2) witnesses to prove your indictment for perjury or

obstruction of justice against the subject witness; or

(113) You must present at least three (3) of your members to serve as witness who will

testify to prove that such witness had given you untruthful or evasive information, In such event

any of your members who will testify to support your indictment shall be assigned with another

SIDN as a witness by registering such member in your Form GJ-32;

(114) You must allow no lawyer, or any public official, military or police officer, any

member of the media, a person of nobility or royalty, or anyone to appear with the witness in your

investigating room. You must admit only one (1) witness at a time in your grand jury room for

questioning. If such lawyer or anyone of such personalities will forcefully get inside or remain

inside your grand jury investigation room, or advises a witness to refuse to testify before you, you

have the power to file an indictment for obstruction of justice against such attorney or anyone of

such personalities by using the prescribed Form GJ-17 for that purpose.

(115) You must discuss and deliberate among yourselves alone secretly or confidentially

as a group and only in your exclusive deliberating room. Violation of this rule will invalidate your

decision to charge the object of your indictment.

(116) You must avoid discussing or debating with any person, witness, public official,

police, investigator, prosecutor, or any lawyer. Simply inform any of such persons that the grand

jury has no authority to discuss investigation matters in the presence of non-grand jury members.

(117) The Clerk of this Court will assist you in finding your investigating room at which

place, no one, except yourselves exclusively will be allowed to occupy in performing your official

business.

Page 73: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

40

(118) You must inspect each day, and demand, that your room is not being tapped with

illegal surveillance or bugging devices.

(119) Other than the witness you have summoned for questioning, you must absolutely

disallow anyone else to enter your room without your prior summons or subpoena.

(120) No public official of any rank or position in the government has the right, and you

must not allow anyone, to change or control your decision to indict, or not to indict, any person.

(121) You must not be intimidated by the fact that the person you are dealing with, or the

subject of your investigation, is a lawyer or a law practitioner or any other professional

practitioner, or any public official of any rank, title or position in the government or any person of

nobility.

(122) When acting as a group in your capacity as a Grand Jury, you carry the sovereign

power and authority of the people in your grand jury district which comprises the same

congressional district over which you have jurisdiction to act in accordance with Article II, Section

1, of the Constitution.

(123) You have the power to require a witness who will testify before you to take an oath

or affirmation but you have no power to extract a statement from a witness with force or

intimidation or with a display of any firearm or weapon anywhere in your investigation

environment.

(124) Your foreman will preside over your interrogation session who may assign, or allow,

anyone of you to profound questions to the witness. You must record your investigation

proceedings electronically or by a stenographer or both.

(125) Conducting your first interrogation of a witness-

(126) Before calling your first actual questioning session with a witness, you must conduct

a practice session among yourselves. You must make sure that you have a stenographer and

an electronic recording device to record your practice proceeding. Follow the instructions in Form

GJ-39. Mastery of this form will give you more confidence in dealing with any witness.

(127) You must show your proficiency to the witness to gain respect for the Grand Jury

by any person who appears before you. You must be respectful but firm in dealing with such

person or witness. You may use English, Tagalog, or local dialect most easily understood

between you and the witness.

Page 74: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

41

(128) Procedure in the interrogation of your witness:

(129) Prepare by filling in your Form GJ-13, interrogation quorum and witness appearance

form.

(130) Consult the prescribed interrogation form, Form GJ-39 and follow the instructions

in that form to conduct your interrogation of your witness. You must memorize a certain short

paragraph in the form.

(131) All of you must memorize at heart the instructions in the said form. Familiarize

yourselves of all the grand jury forms.

(132) I instruct you to use the current entire week for holding classes in your grand jury

room to learn the Jury Systems with your foreman acting as your lead instructor. Make sure that

you accomplish Form GJ-5, your attendance record at your Grand Jury Room to enable you to

collect your per diems.

(133) Beginning on Monday, next week, with the help of the clerk of court, I instruct you

to advertise, using Form GJ-10, to invite anonymous crime informants to submit secret crime

reports of the particular crime you wish to investigate.

(134) When a member starts to speak, he must first address the foreman to ask his turn

to speak with the witness and such member must raise to display his SIDN for all your

co-members and the witness to see. Your SIDN should be printed in block type on a half-size

regular short bond paper, exactly a dimension of 8-1/2 and 5-1/2 inches. The numbers shall be

printed 3-1/2 inches in height and must centrally occupy 6 inches across the paper.

(135) Proceed to Form GJ-39 to prepare for your witness today.

(The following topics are NOT TO BE READ to the witness) (These topics are being read

to you for your instruction)

(136) You are required that no indictment is filed in court until you are convinced as a

group that the case being filed is factually supported by direct, clear and convincing evidence

according to your own independent findings and judgment and not on the basis of rumors or

political inducements from any source whatsoever.

(137) You must arrive at your independent decision only after a confidential and careful

deliberation among yourselves absolutely without the presence of anybody whatsoever who is

not a member of this Grand Jury.

Page 75: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

42

(138) When a crime suspect has committed several offenses, prepare a separate criminal

complaint or information for each offense committed; Alternatively, consult a government

prosecutor in your district and request for help in preparing the complaint. Use Form GJ-52 to

summon the Prosecutor to appear in your grand jury hearing room.

(139) When there are several crime suspects who conspired in the commission of a crime,

consult a government prosecutor in your district and request for help in preparing the complaint.

Use Form GJ-52 to summon the Prosecutor to appear in your grand jury hearing room.

(140) In a crime where the suspected offender may have enriched himself, you must

consider further investigation and indictment for tax evasion crimes.

(141) You may refer to taxation laws among which, but not limited to, Republic Acts 7642

and 8424 as amended. You may issue a summons to a tax accountant to seek professional

advice, at government expense, prior to your filing of your criminal indictment for tax evasion. Use

Form GJ-55.

(142) You must admonish the tax expert to keep your consultation with strict secrecy and

avoid disclosing the name of the suspected offender and the names of witnesses.

(143) To arrive at your official decision to indict or to accuse the crime suspect with two

or more criminal offenses, you must perform separate voting session for every indictment of each

crime. Your decision to indict must be based on a "Probable Cause."

(144) Elements of Probable Cause -

(145) A probable cause of the crime exists when you have found a basis or fact which lead

you to reasonably conclude that the suspected offender is guilty of the crime.

(146) Your belief shall be derived from the fact that the witness, among others, personally

saw the act of the offender in committing the crime, or that the witness personally heard the

offender saying that he committed the criminal act.

(147) You may likewise consider how far or near the witness was at the scene of the crime

or when the witness heard the crime offender stated of the commission of his crime. Take into

consideration lighting or darkness of the location of the crime to show how visible to the witness

the occurrence of the crime was.

(148) You may also consider how much access or control the witness had with the

records, things or object in the possession of, or belonging to, the suspected offender at the time

of the commission of the crime.

Page 76: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

43

(149) Before writing your secret vote, you must follow the procedures below and certified

under oath by your foreman with no one else present in the grand jury room but exclusively

among you that compose your quorum.

(150) Review the transcript or rehear the tape recorded testimony of the witness;

(151) Reexamine all pieces of evidence or documents in your possession relating to the

case and how the witness has obtained them;

(152) Carefully examine the elements and definition of the law that you think the

suspected offender has violated. You must have a basic understanding of Articles 1 to 113 of

Book One of the Revised Penal Code of the Philippines. They all generally apply in concept to

any type of crimes that you will be dealing with.

(153) When you write your indictment or accusation, the specific words that you basically

use to associate with the offender are: "willfully," "unlawfully," "feloniously," "knowingly." You

must attempt to "read" the mind of the offender whether his thoughts during the commission of

his crime were associated with such words.

(154) Crimes, except for strict liability crimes, have two basic elements, things the

prosecutor has to prove to convict the accused: "a guilty mind" and "a guilty act."

(155) The prosecutors and judges are required to show those elements to the trial jury to

prove your accusation against the accused crime offender.

(156) After you have done the foregoing routines, your foreman shall randomly create two

opposing groups called "Anti-Indictment Group" and "Pro-Indictment Group" with equal number

of memberships. Your foreman shall exclude himself from any group and preside your

proceedings. He must stay neutral and avoid arguing with any member of either group. He must

strictly follow this rule. (1) Firstly, the foreman shall call for volunteers for membership in the

"Anti" group. (2) If there are not enough volunteers for that group, he shall appoint any member

from the remaining group into the "Anti" group regardless of the personal opinion of such

member to favor indictment. Those who serve in the "Anti" group shall, nonetheless, secretly vote

as they wish either for or against the indictment.

(157) Your foreman should solicit arguments from the members of each opposing groups

by asking specific questions in the following manner:

(158) He should ask the members of the "Anti" group with a questions such as: (1) "Why

do you think that the suspected offender may not be guilty in this case? (2) Are you aware of a

law that may excuse him from criminal liability? (3) What possible defense or defenses you think

Page 77: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

44

the suspected offender has in this case? (4) From the testimony of the witnesses, did any of

them said that his knowledge of the crime is based only from the information he heard from some

one else and not on his own observation? (5) Testimony on someone else's knowledge is a

hearsay evidence and will not be admissible at the trial of this case. (6) Does the documentary

evidence in our hands directly show the guilt of the suspect? If not, we need to know? (7) Would

you want, before we vote to indict the suspected offender, to do more research? (8) Please

speak up and let us all listen to what you say." The foreman should allow the "Anti" speaker to

talk without interruption from anyone. He must allow as many "Anti" speakers who wish to talk

against the indictment or in defense of the suspected offender.

(159) After addressing the “Anti” group, your foreman should now direct his attention to

the "Pro" group. His question to the "Pro" shall be: (1) "Do you find in the evidence or in the

testimony of the witness(es) a probable cause or reasonable ground for us to believe that the

suspect is guilty of the crime? (2) Did the witness say that he actually saw the commission of the

crime by the offender? (3) Does the documentary evidence directly show the guilt of the suspect?

If yes, please let us know." (4) Have you searched the laws that may excuse him from criminal

liability? (5) Would you want to do more research, before we vote to indict the suspected

offender? If, so, call for an informal voting by raising hands. (6) Please speak up and let us all

listen to what you say." The foreman should allow everyone who wish to speak for the indictment

of the suspected offender to talk without interruption from anyone.

(160) If you doubt about the guilt of the suspected offender, it is your obligation to do

more legal research or consult a competent criminal law lawyer before you vote in your decision.

You must use hypothetical situations and avoid mentioning real names of persons who are

involved in the case you are investigating. Should you intend to retain such attorney to prosecute

the matter and he accepts the case as private prosecutor, then you need to let him know the real

names of the real people who are involved in your case.(CAUTION: He might be a DECOY or

spy for the crime suspect.)

(161) If the issue is to do more research and it is preventing you to decide one way or the

other, you shall come to a secret vote in the research issue. If the research issue is in the

negative, then you come to a secrete balloting to determine whether to indict or not to indict and

write the proper form, either Form GJ-15 or Form GJ-18.

(162) Even if there is no anti-indictment speaker, your foreman must still ask the required

questions to the Pro-Indictment Group. It is important that each grand juror understands that he

must personally find probable cause or reasonable ground for a belief that the suspect is guilty

of the crime for indictment.

(163) It is not necessary that you convince your opposing members to vote in the side of

your argument. Think of yourself as a solo judge with the obligation to find the probable cause,

Page 78: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

45

or lack of it, and let your total collective votes determine the decision of the grand jury and not

the individual opinion of its members. It must be a decision arrived at collectively without force

or tyranny from any of your members.

(164) After the speakers have talked, your foreman should announce to proceed, if you

are convinced that you had investigated and examined enough the evidence and witness/es to

make your final decision by secretly casting the vote of each and all members and officers

including the foreman of the grand jury.

(165) Use the prescribed Form GJ-14 to cast your ballot. Upon completing your ballot, fold

and submit it to your secretary. The secretary shall not open or count your votes until everyone

has submitted his/her ballot and only then shall the secretary shall read the number of the “Yes”

votes and of the “No” votes. Thereupon, the foreman shall announce to the Grand Jury members

the decision to indict or not to indict the suspected offender.

(166) It is required that you arrive at with at least 14 "yes" decision votes of your members

to return an indictment in court. In such event, you shall chose and write your indictment on Form

GJ-15, GJ-16, or GJ-17 (as the case may be);

(167) If you arrive at with at least 14 "no" votes, then you shall prepare your Grand Jury

Memorandum of "No Indictment" on Form GJ-18. In such event, you shall simply archive the

matter without further comment as if the matter was not investigated to allow another set of a

new grand jury to reopen and further investigate the matter.

(168) If any of your members feels that there is an urgent need to reopen the matter for

further investigation, such as calling or finding more witnesses, or gathering more evidence, he

shall make an oral motion to do so during any session of the grand jury. If the motion is seconded

and approved by a simple majority in which a quorum is present, then the case will remain open

for further investigation. Your foreman shall then assign the matter to a member or group of 2 or

members to pursue the matter. Use Form GJ-10 to invite more anonymous crime informants.

(169) For filing your indictment in court, prepare and sequentially arrange your indictment

documents as follows:

(a) The Indictment or Complaint duly signed with foreman’s SIDN;

Use Form GJ-15; Form GJ-16, or Form GJ-17, as the case may be.

(b) Form GJ-19, List of Exhibits;

(c) The Exhibits in the same sequence as listed on Form GJ-19.

Make an extra copy of your Indictment and the Exhibit List for your Grand Jury file. Thereafter,

serve your summons to the Clerk of Court on Form GJ-41 to come to your Grand Jury Room to

Page 79: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

46

pick up your indictment.

(170) At your Grand Jury Room, confer with the Clerk of Court and have him and your

Foreman jointly inspect all documents and exhibits. Upon submission of the entire documents,

have the Clerk of Court stamp with the Court Filing Stamp on the Indictment and the Exhibit List

as well the Docket Case Number on both the original and your grand jury file copy.

(171) It is essential that the stamp date of the filing with the Clerk of Court of your

indictment must be within the period of your Grand Jury period of service.

(172) Your foreman shall remind the Clerk of Court that the filing of the grand jury

indictment must be kept highly confidential and shall in no case be disclosed or announced to

the media or to the public until such time that the accused has already been taken into custody

upon execution of the warrant of arrest issued by the judge based on the filing of the indictment

against him.

(173) Instruction for secrecy of investigation - It is imperative that your criminal

investigations be conducted secretly and strictly confidential.

(174) The purpose of this secrecy rule is to prevent the crime suspect from becoming a

fugitive from justice;

(175) To protect the constitutional innocence of the crime suspect from trial by publicity;

(176) To prevent the suspect or victim or their respective sympathizers from tampering any

evidence or of threatening, harassing or harming potential witnesses;

(177) To protect both the victim and crime suspect from harming each other or by their

followers.

(178) To protect you, the members of the grand jury, from threats or harassments or harm

by heavily armed or highly influential or publicly powerful suspects of crimes and by their crime

sympathizers and accomplices or their private armies;

(179) To prevent potential trial jurors from prejudging the guilt or innocence of the crime

suspect once they are called in to serve as jurors;

(180) To protect judges and government prosecutors and private investigators from illegal

or unethical interference, threats, harassment, or physical harm from highly armed or powerful

or wealthy vindictive elements of society; and

Page 80: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

47

(181) To encourage potential crime informers and whistle blowers to secretly report to the

grand jury any criminal wrong doings in their workplace, neighbourhood, organizations, and

grafters among their circle of friends.

(182) Optional and exceptional notification to suspect prior to filing of grand jury indictment

- If in your opinion, nothing in the above confidential precautionary policy measures will be used

or taken advantaged of by the suspect, in any way, to interfere in your investigation of a crime

such as when the suspect may have been positively known for being a peaceful or pacific person

in the community and with no known ties with abusive highly armed elements in the community,

or he is not associated or friendly with highly suspected corrupt powerful or high official or

officials of the government, you may, but not necessarily, notify the crime suspect, or subject of

your crime investigation, using Form GJ-36. Use your sound discretion.

(183) You may likewise notify the suspect using Form GJ-36 if, after you have

interrogated the witness or witnesses presented by the complaining party, in your opinion, it

appears that the contemplated accusation is clearly whimsical, capricious, or illegal and merely

used to harass or embarrass the alleged crime suspect by the accuser.

(184) You cannot be compelled individually or as a group to allow a criminal suspect

under investigation or his attorney or any person or public official to be present with you in the

grand jury investigation room to cross-examine a witness. Preventing a criminal suspect from

being present at your investigation proceedings to cross examine a witness before you does not

deprive him of his "day in court" because this grand jury is not a court.

(185) If the crime suspect presents a written statement, such statement shall be filed with

the Clerk of this court and you must require that the statement be accompanied with a "Certificate

of Truthfulness" prescribed in Form GJ-26. Any attachment therewith shall be serially numbered

at the bottom right hand margin of the page attached and the clerk of court shall deposit the

same in the "Citizen's Secret Crime Reports Drop Box" for pick up by the Secretary of the Grand

Jury.

(186) You shall not allow under any circumstance any person or public official,

magistrate, judge, commissioner, officer, or employee of any government branch, tribunal, court,

commission, instrumentality, any police or military organization, to interfere with your functions

or to inspect any record in your custody.

(187) A grand jury is a direct repository guardian of the sovereign power of the people

and its records shall not be retrieved by subpoena duces tecum. You may either dispose of any

matter for investigation by the filing of your indictment or by issuing a memorandum of no

indictment and no one shall compel you to do either way.

Page 81: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

48

(188) You have the power to file an indictment for obstruction of justice on prescribed

Form GJ-17 against any person or public official, regardless of his rank or position, or any of his

agents, delegates or deputies, officially or unofficially, who may communicate with any of you,

directly or indirectly, to interfere in any manner, intercede in behalf of the suspected offender, or

to impede or in anyway frustrate the conduct of your official business or investigation.

(189) You have the discretion to ignore the interrupter of your proceedings or file outright

an indictment for obstruction of justice by the use of Form GJ-17, or with any other appropriate

indictment, against him if the interruption is accompanied with a violent act, threat of force, threat

of physical harm or death against any of your members or member of your families.

(190) You have the power to issue a hold departure order notice with the Bureau of

Immigration or with the Secretary of Foreign Affairs or to any of their deputies against any person

or public official whom you may contemplate to investigate for, or to call as a witness in, the

commission of a serious crime to prevent such person from leaving the country until such person

shall have been cleared of his criminal liabilities or that said person is no longer a potential

witness in the investigation of such serious crime. You shall use the prescribed Form GJ-40,

Grand Jury Hold Departure Order Notice, for this purpose. Any person or public official who shall

disobey, ignore, or violate your hold departure order shall be liable for the crime of obstruction

of justice.

(191) You are entitled to a compensation and it will be paid in the form of a voucher as

prescribed in Form GJ-27, found in Section 99, Article III, of the National Jury Law. You may

cash in with a cashier at any government treasury or cashier or any bank. The voucher will be

prepared in the middle and end of each month and delivered to you by the Clerk of this Court and

approved by the Executive Judge of this Regional Trial Court. Additionally, if you are seriously

injured, or in case of death your next of kin, are further entitled to an indemnity regardless of fault

of your injury or death arising out of, or in the course of, jury service in accordance with Article

II, Section 7 of the National Jury Law.

(192) You are not allowed to accept or receive any form of compensation, money or

anything of value or pleasure, from any person, company, corporation, public official, government

entity or any other entity whatsoever under any term or condition, except the per diem and injury

or death indemnity benefits you are entitled to by the National Jury Law.

(193) You have the obligation and the power to investigate and file an indictment in court

for any crime committed by your fellow members in the grand jury including acts of bribery

against any member of your group or falsification of his application for grand jury membership,

if warranted by evidence. If you are unable to investigate or indict such erring fellow member

during your term of office, any one of you must secretly report the matter to the next succeeding

Grand Jury upon, or after, the expiration of your term of office.

Page 82: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

49

(194) In the crime of bribery, you must indict or file a criminal indictment for bribery

against the recipient of the bribe who is a public official, if the giver of the bribe is a private

citizen. In such case, you may offer in writing, using prescribed Form GJ-21, to exempt or

immunize such giver or offeror from prosecution on the condition that he shall testify against the

recipient of his bribe. Should the giver or offeror of the bribe refuses to testify after serving him

with the written offer of immunity from prosecution, you shall file an indictment for obstruction of

justice against such giver or offeror using prescribed Form GJ-17 in Section 99, Article III, of the

National Jury Law, even if you may be unable to file an indictment for bribery against the

recipient.

(195) In the crime of bribery, if the bribe giver or offeror is a public official or a candidate

for election, or for an appointment to a public office, and the recipient of the bribe is likewise a

public official, or a voter during an election for a candidate, or a person recommending for

appointment of an aspirant, to hold a public office, you may offer in writing, using prescribed

Form GJ-22 in Section 99, Article III, of the National Jury Law, to exempt the recipient from

prosecution for bribery on the condition that such bribe recipient shall testify against the giver or

offeror of the bribe. Should such bribe recipient refuse to testify against the bribe offer, you shall

charge the bribe recipient for the crime of obstruction of justice using Form GJ-17 even if you

cannot charge the giver or offeror of the crime of bribery.

(196) Should any of you disagree over the majority decision of your fellow members in

an official session wherein a quorum is present, whether you were present or not at said official

session, you must not in any manner individually or unilaterally override, suppress, prevent, or

in any manner, frustrate by use of force, or threat of force, or by the use of disrespectful

language, the implementation of such majority decision. Should you, as a member of such body,

violate this instruction, you will be held personally liable for the crime of obstruction of justice

using Form GJ-17 in the Grand Jury Table of Forms in Section 99, Article III, of the National Jury

Law.

(197) In making your decision, you must disregard the position, nobility, royalty, or rank

in the government, or wealth, profession, religious faith, or social standing in the community, of

the person under your investigation. You must consider solely his acts in committing an offense

or crime on the basis of the evidence and the law that you find as the sole and only factor in

arriving at your decision. You must avoid giving special treatment to such person more than you

would give to another with the same or equal dignity upon an ordinary person.

(198) Upon motion by any of your members in reference to, or upon complaint by a victim

or witness of, a serious crime that has been investigated and dismissed by a prior Grand Jury,

you shall have the power to investigate anew the same matter and to present an indictment in

court against the suspected offender if warranted by your finding of probable cause.

Page 83: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

50

(199) In preparing your indictment, you may refer, but not limited, to the laws listed and

cited following this instruction:

(200) Presidential Decree Number 1829 as amended;

(201) Republic Act 386, Article 3, of the Civil Code as amended;

(202) The Revised Penal Code of the Philippines, Act 3815 as amended;

(203) The Anti-Graft and Corrupt Practices Act, Republic Act 3019 as amended;

(204) The Crime of Plunder, Republic Act 7080 as amended.

(205) The Anti-Money Laundering Law, Republic Act 9160 as amended; and

(206) Government Procurement reform Act, Republic Act 9184 as amended;

(207) Such other laws defining an act as a criminal offense and punishable by

imprisonment in jail for one year or more, including but not limited to child abuse laws, illegal

gambling laws and other criminal laws.

(208) For educating yourselves relating to your investigation and indictments, you may

visit the e-library of the Philippine Supreme Court web site by searching on line the phrase:

“Philippine Supreme Court Library.”

(209) You may, in preparing your indictment, consult a lawyer, CPA, or other

professionals for advice during your en banc session with no other person or witness present but

only with your members exclusively. You shall present hypothetical scenarios or questions to

such consultants but you shall not disclose any name of the object of your investigation or

indictment, or of the name of the witness or witnesses you may call, or may have called. You

shall ask the consultant to keep your consultation and the subject of your consultation strictly

confidential. Whether advised or not, consultants shall have the ethical duty to keep any grand

jury consultation with strict confidentiality under pain of disciplinary action for disbarment or

license forfeiture including criminal liability for obstruction of justice. For your appointments with

said consultants, you will find the prescribed appointment forms, namely: Forms GJ-52; GJ-53;

GJ-54; GJ-55; GJ-56; GJ-57; GJ-58; GJ-59; GJ-60; GJ-61; GJ-62; and GJ-63.

(210) For the purpose of unifying the people in the country to prevent lawlessness in any

form, you may proceed with your action in the manner as indicated in the numbers in the next

Statutory Grand Jury Instructions :

Page 84: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

51

(211) You may investigate a crime in another jury district, or congressional district, of any

province or city in any other part of the country upon receiving a complaint from a resident of

such district regardless of whether he is a crime victim or not if, in your opinion, the said crime

may affect or jeopardize, or has affected or has jeopardized, in any manner the peace, security,

economy, commerce, transportation of the people and finances of the local government in your

district.

(212) If two or more grand juries of different congressional districts are investigating the

same crime involving the same offender or offenders, the first grand jury which has taken prior

action to investigate said crime shall have the right to continue to pursue the matter until it has

filed its indictment in court over the said matter.

(213) You may file your criminal indictment against the offender of a crime committed in

a different district in a trial court within your own district or in another district if, in your opinion,

no fair trial of the case may be obtained in the district where the alleged crime was committed.

(214) You have the power to issue a subpoena, or subpoena duces tecum, or summons

to any officer of a bank regarding an account to determine any ill-gotten wealth of the subject of

your investigation notwithstanding any bank secrecy law, rule or policy, to the contrary regardless

of whether said bank is located in another grand jury district from your own. Use the prescribed

Form GJ-12.

(215) Prior to your embarking in the indictment of suspected crime offenders pertaining

to graft and corruption and other theft or malversation of funds and property, you need to consult

Section 93 of the National Jury Law.

(216) Refer to Section 94 of the National Jury Law for crimes that are punishable before

and after its enactment. Among others, the include crime offenders of electoral fraud or

terrorism, murder, robbery, arson, chastity crimes, and other crimes that violate human rights are

not forgiven .

(217) You have the perpetual power to launch a criminal action against any suspected

crime offender punishable under Republic Act 3019, known as the Anti-Graft Law, who shall

continue to keep the fruits of his crimes such as real or personal property including money bank

accounts locally or in foreign countries after this National Jury Law has taken.

(218) Go to Section 91 in connection with graft and corruption in jailhouses or jail

institutions. They are the most overlooked anomalies in the government in which public funds

use to buy food for inmates are often lost without trace. Victims in these institutions are afraid

to complain. Therefore, even in the absence of a complaint from any victim in a jail facility, you,

Page 85: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

52

the Grand Jury, have the power to initiate investigations of jail anomalies upon your induction in

office without waiting for a complaint from victims of said facilities.

CERTIFICATION BY THE INSTRUCTING JUDGE

“I certify under my official oath that I have person ally read to the Grand Jury the

foregoing instructions this ______ day of _________ ____, 20___ without any deviation to

the said instruction. I further certify that each m ember of said Body has been furnished

an authenticated and signed copy by my hand of said instructions and a translation

thereof in the local dialect of my district. I fina lly certify that I have provided each member

of said Body in booklet form the entire copy of the Rules of the Jury System.

Signature : _____________________________

Printed Name: _____________________________

Official Title : Executive Regional Trial Judge"

End of the Form For the

The Statutory Standard Grand Jury Instruction

___________________________________________________________________________

Section 25. The power and authority of the Grand Jury is hereby derived directly from the

sovereign power and authority of the people in Article II, Section 1, of the Constitution. The role

of the government in the functioning of the grand jury to investigate crimes and to indict in court

suspected crime offenders shall be advisory and it shall in no case control the deciding power

of the grand jury.

Section 26. The Grand Jury shall have the power to issue subpoena or subpoena duces

tecum, or summons, and any disobedience thereto by the witness upon whom said processes

have been directed, and served, shall render such witness criminally liable for obstruction of

justice with punishment by imprisonment from three to five years in jail. Such legal processes

shall be enforceable anywhere in the Philippines.

Section 27. Secrecy of the filing of the criminal indictment.

(a) The filing of the grand jury indictment shall, and must, be kept absolutely confidential

by the clerk of court and shall, in no case, be disclosed or announced prematurely to the media

or to the public until such time that the accused has already been taken into custody upon

execution of the warrant of arrest issued by the judge based on the criminal indictment filed in

his court by the Grand Jury against the said accused.

Page 86: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

53

(b) Any party who has been aggrieved by the premature announcement of the filing of

said indictment in violation of this section may file a criminal complaint for Obstruction of Justice

with the Grand Jury against the clerk of the court before whom said indictment was filed in

addition to the filing of other indictments against liable parties for such other crimes that have

arisen that has proximately caused injury or death to the aggrieved party.

Section 28. The Grand Jury shall have the power to secretly investigate any and all

crimes punishable by law with imprisonment for at least one year, or more, in jail, or by death,

and to file an indictment in court upon its finding of probable cause that the alleged crime may

have been committed by the suspected crime offender or offenders. No judge or justice shall

have the power to over rule the finding by the Grand Jury of probable cause that the crime may

have been committed by the alleged offender of the crime and based on such issue, a judge or

justice shall have no power to refuse to issue a warrant of arrest on the grand jury indictment

against the suspected crime offender.

Section 29. The power of the Grand Jury to pursue disciplinary complaints against

licensed professionals -

(a) The Grand Jury shall have the power to secretly investigate any complaint for

administrative disciplinary action against a licensed professional for ethical misconduct including

but not limited to lawyers before the Supreme Court, physicians before the Medical Board, and

other licensed professionals before the government licensing boards which issued their

certificates authorizing to practice their professions.

(b) After the administrative disciplinary action has been filed by the Grand Jury before

the proper licensing board against the licensed professional for ethical misconduct, the

Ombudsman shall have the responsibility to pursue the action before the Supreme Court, in the

case against lawyers or before the proper licensing boards in the case of the other license

professionals.

Section 30. Criminal and disciplinary actions initiated by the Grand Jury shall require no

prior execution of an affidavit of a witness or witnesses.

(a) In the event that an affidavit is presented by any party to a case, such affidavit shall

have no evidential value unless the signer has confirmed and shall have been confidentially

cross-examined orally by the members of the Grand Jury in a secret grand jury proceeding.

(b) In criminal and disciplinary actions, trials and hearings shall proceed by direct

testimony of witnesses or complaining parties against the accused in criminal trials or

respondents in disciplinary actions without prejudice to the submission of exhibits as part of the

evidence by the respective parties to a case.

Page 87: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

54

(c) Once the matter has been set for trial or hearing, no postponement fore more than

three (3) days, Saturdays, Sundays, and Holidays, excluded, shall be allowed.

(d) The government prosecutors or the Ombudsman shall have the responsibility of

providing the needed transportation and costs, at government expense, to secure and assure

attendance of witness to prove their complaints or accusations. The prosecutor or deputy

prosecutor or the deputy Ombudsman in charge of pursuing the case shall be liable for contempt

of court for failure to make arrangement for the transportation of his witnesses in attending the

court trial or hearing of his or their case.

Section 31. Swearing witnesses - The Grand Jury as a Group or its members individually

shall have the power to administer the swearing of any witness who shall testify in a Grand Jury

proceeding.

Section 32. A grand jury secret investigation room shall be set up in each grand jury

district. A lone grand jury district shall be coterminous with a congressional district. Such room

shall be located as close as possible where the court of the executive trial judge is located. It

shall be adequately spacious to accommodate seats with small desk for 23 members, an

executive table and chair for its foreman, a desk with a high speed computer with monitor, printer,

copier and chair for its secretary, a small desk and chair for one witness. It shall further be

provided with a large black board, a records vault and a secret complaint drop box

opening-receptacle enough to receive a one-fourth (1/4) inch-thick envelope 9" X 13" on a wall

near the entrance door to the grand jury room. Furthermore, the grand jury investigation building

and room shall be provided with air conditioning and shall be closed from public view and

secured against eavesdropping gadgets.

Section 33. The District Executive Judge shall be principally responsible in organizing the

grand jury of his district with the assistance of his clerk of court. The Provincial Board and/or City

Council along with their Executive Officials or the Governor in case of the Province or the City

Mayor in case of the City, shall have the principal responsibility to provide the needed grand jury

investigation rooms and all essential equipment, furniture, computers, tape recorders, and every

thing else needed for the efficient functioning of the grand jury upon demand by the Executive

Judge.

Section 34. Upon completion of the set up of the grand jury facilities, it shall be the

responsibility of the Clerk of Court of the said Executive Judge to maintain said facilities in

operating condition at all times and shall be constantly aware that no bugging or spying devices

are installed in the grand jury room or its immediate vicinity.

Section 35. All proceedings by and before the grand jury shall be kept strictly confidential

exclusively among its members, regardless of the declaration of martial law or state of

emergency.

Page 88: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

55

Section 36. No person or public official or court or any government agency, entity, or

instrumentality shall have the power to order by subpoena or subpoena duces tecum, by any

other writ, or presidential order, to publish or scrutinize the records of the grand jury or to

investigate or arrest any of its members for any alleged wrongful or criminal act before the end

of his term of office. The violator of this rule or provision shall be liable for indictment for

obstruction of justice by the Grand Jury.

Section 37. No member of the grand jury or the Clerk of Court or the Executive Judge

shall be compelled to disclose the identity of another grand juror or any of its grand jury records

to any member of the public or any executive, legislative, or justice official of the government.

Section 38. Any person or public official by use of forceful or violent means or threats or

intimidation who shall violate any of the provision of Section 36 of the National Jury Law shall be

liable for the crime of obstruction of justice and shall be punishable by imprisonment for a period

from five (5) to seven (7) years in jail upon the indictment by the grand jury.

Section 39. Notwithstanding any banking secrecy law including but not limited to Republic

Act 6426, presidential decree, banking rule or policy to the contrary, no bank officer or bank

record of any form or kind shall be immune from a grand jury subpoena, subpoena duces tecum,

examination or investigation.

Section 40. The grand jury may invite by summons any licensed professional or expert,

including but not limited to any lawyer, certified public accountant, medical doctor or engineer

who is an expert on the matter that is the subject of its investigation to appear in its secret

investigation room to obtain legal or technical assistance in pursuing its investigation or in

formulating its indictment, PROVIDED that if such lawyer or professional has any reason to

believe that the object of investigation by the grand jury is his client or relative by blood or affinity,

he must ethically decline to further provide any professional assistance to the grand jury by

stating the reason of his declination. If such lawyer or professional ignores his obligation to

decline further service or help to the Grand Jury, he shall be subject to disbarment or revocation

of his license to practice his profession in addition to his criminal liability for obstruction of justice.

Section 41. Disqualification-

(a) Any person who has been indicted by a grand jury shall lose his privilege or right to

run for, or to be appointed in, any public office including but not limited to government owned or

controlled, or quasi government, corporation, unless he shall have been acquitted in a jury trial

on the merits from said indictment at the time he files his candidacy, or get appointed, to any of

such offices. Dismissal of the indictment by technicality to accommodate, or paved the way for,

the accused to run for, or get appointed to, said office, shall not restore such privilege or right to

aspire to hold a public office or position.

Page 89: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

56

(b) The power of the Grand Jury shall not be, in any way, prevented or stopped from

performing its official functions by any government activity including, but not limited to, election

of public officials, declaration of martial law, or man-made calamity or emergency.

Section 42. Formation and Inauguration of the grand jury -

(a) The inaugural formation of a grand jury and administration of oath of office of its

members shall be held strictly confidential where no person or public official or government

employee shall be permitted to attend or observe, except that the inauguration of said Body shall

be officiated by an Executive Judge in his court room with the assistance of his clerk of court and

at which time he shall issue the grand jury instruction that shall govern the official conduct of its

members and power of the grand jury. Such judge shall have no power to approve or disapprove

the decision of a grand jury to investigate or to indict a crime suspect.

(b) Any person or public official or government employee who shall surreptitiously intrude

in the foregoing proceeding or any clerk of court or presiding executive judge who shall permit

such person or public official or government employee to observe or intrude in the said

proceeding shall be liable for investigation and indictment for obstruction of justice by a grand

jury.

Section 43. Security of the records of the members of the grand jury; personal obligation

of the inducting judge to the members of the grand jury; liability of judge for disclosing records

of grand jurors-

(a) Upon taking the oath of office of the grand jurors, each member of the grand

jury shall be conferred with Security Identity Code Number, briefly called SIDN, by their inaugural

judge for use in their official acts instead of their real names. Said judge shall keep their records

strictly confidential which he must deposit promptly in a secured vault with a publicly accredited

bank in his locality within 24 hours from the time he sworn in to office the grand jury members

and said records shall not be retrieved or disclosed unless upon the subpoena by a Grand Jury.

(b) It shall be unlawful for the Executive Judge or any employee or officer of his

court to keep personal custody of the application and personal records, or a copy thereof, of the

members of the grand jury who took his, or their, oath of office before said judge. Violation of

this rule shall subject said judge or any of employee or officer of his court criminally liable under

Article 226 of Act 3815, the Revised Penal Code of the Philippines, as amended.

(c) Additionally, said judge shall be liable for disciplinary action in the form of

removal from the bench and disbarment, and tort damages in the event of serious physical injury

as defined in Article 365 of Act 3815, the Revised Penal Code of the Philippines, as amended,

or death, suffered by a member of the grand jury as the result of the violation or negligence by

such judge in complying with this rule.

Page 90: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

57

Section 44. Any member or officer of the grand jury who shall falsify the collective

decision of its members to indict or not to indict a subject of its investigation shall be liable for the

crime of obstruction of justice and shall be punishable by imprisonment from five (5) to seven (7)

years in jail upon the indictment by any of the succeeding grand juries.

Section 45. Any and all criminal accusations on a serious crime originally initiated by a

government investigator and ready for filing in court shall secure a review and approval by the

grand jury in the form of a grand jury indictment prior to its filing in court including, but not limited

to, accusations by the Ombudsman, all agencies or prosecutors of the Department of Justice

or National Bureau of National Investigations. In such event, the government prosecutor or agent

shall submit to the Grand Jury all pieces of evidence and exhibits in his custody in the case and

shall conform to the requirements of Section 19, Article III, of the National Jury Law within thirty

(30) working days from the date the criminal complaint was filed with his department or office by

the victim or complaining witness.

Section 46. If the accused is in the custody of the government, the grand jury shall

promptly commence the investigation of the case by calling any or all witnesses by subpoena,

subpoena duces tecum, or summons, to secure sufficient evidence or probable cause to support

a grand jury indictment. The grand jury shall finish its investigation and indictment within forty-five

(45) days from the date of its receipt of the government accusation from the clerk of court

otherwise it must issue an order to dismiss said accusation.

Section 47. If the accused is in custody and the complaining prosecutor fails to comply

with the requirement within the period prescribed in the preceding Section 45, the accused shall

be entitled to an immediate release from custody upon petition of the accused and the

complaining prosecutor shall be liable for indictment for obstruction of justice upon direct

complaint before the grand jury by the victim of a crime or the next of kin of such victim if the

victim dies as the direct result of the crime.

Section 48. No government or private agency, public official, court or judge, or any

person, shall have the power to demand the publication of any grand jury proceedings. Any such

proceedings shall exclusively be attended in by no other than the members of the grand jury,

sitting en banc, and one witness at a time for questioning. Such witness shall have no right to

invite the attendance of an attorney for his assistance and no government prosecutor shall have

the right to accompany him to procure his statements in the grand jury investigation room. All

information elicited from the witness shall come out from the questions of the grand jury or its

members.

Section 49. Any person or witness who testifies before a grand jury shall have the

Page 91: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

58

mandatory legal obligation to tell the truth in his testimony. Any violation of this rule shall subject

such witness to a criminal indictment by the grand jury for obstruction of justice.

Section 50. The grand jury shall have the power to issue a subpoena or subpoena duces

tecum on any person or public official it may deem a possible witness to a crime or a custodian

of any record or thing for its investigation of a crime. No person shall have the right to appear

before a grand jury unless invited by the grand jury on a subpoena, subpoena duces tecum, or

summons.

Section 51. Any person or public official, hereinafter referred to in this section and in the

next following section as the “invitee”, when required to appear before the grand jury as a witness

or invitee by means of a subpoena, subpoena duces tecum, or summons shall have the legal

obligation and the right to refuse disclosure any matter he has learned at the grand jury

proceeding over inquiries from his superior or subordinate officers, associates or family

members. Violation of this rule, directly or indirectly, by the witness or invitee shall subject him

liable for indictment of obstruction of justice by the grand jury.

Section 52. Any person, employer, or public official, or member of a board of directors or

board of trustees of a corporate entity, quasi-government entity, or government owned or

controlled corporation who shall initiate the termination, demotion in rank or position or relocation

of employment or position, of the invitee from his employment or public position for having

received a subpoena, subpoena duces tecum, or summons, or for appearing or giving his

testimony before a grand jury shall be liable for indictment by the grand jury for obstruction of

justice.

Section 53. Any person or public official who shall disobey or refuse to testify before the

grand jury upon receipt of a subpoena or subpoena duces tecum or summons shall be liable for

indictment by the grand jury for obstruction of justice.

Section 54. Any person or public official who shall prevent a witness from testifying before

a grand jury who has received a summons, subpoena or subpoena duces tecum from the grand

jury by any means including aiding such witness to leave the country or by detaining such witness

for any purpose shall be liable for indictment by the grand jury for obstruction of justice.

Section 55. No law, executive or legislative or judicial order, classified or unclassified

confidential record or memorandum, or court rule, shall prevent, bar, or prohibit, a grand jury to

exercise the sovereign power and authority of the people in its grand jury district in its efforts to

investigate serious crimes committed by any person or any executive, or legislative, or judicial

judicial officials including but not limited to judges and justices, board of directors or officers of

a government owned or controlled, or quasi-government corporation.

Page 92: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

59

Section 56. No claim of public position, title or rank in the government, profession,

royalty, nobility, religious affiliation or creed, custom, tradition, or political party affiliation, shall

exempt any person who has committed a serious crime or offense as defined by the National

Jury Law from a grand jury investigation and indictment or administrative disciplinary action.

IMMUNITY IN CERTAIN BRIBERY CASES

Section 57. Immunity from prosecution in bribery-

(a) The grand jury, through its subpoena, subpoena duces tecum, or summons, shall have

the power to grant immunity from prosecution to a giver in bribery who is a private citizen and the

recipient of his bribe is a national or local public or government official including but not limited

to any official in the executive, or legislative, or judicial official or judge or justice of a court, or

member of the army or police services, or officer or director of a government owned and

controlled, or quasi-government, corporation. If such giver and private citizen refuses to testify

against the recipient of his bribe, such giver shall be liable for criminal prosecution for obstruction

of justice and, if convicted, shall suffer to penalty of imprisonment for the period from five (5)

years to seven (7) years in jail. Such giver shall further suffer from disqualification to aspire to

hold a public office of any type including a position in any government owned or controlled or

quasi-government corporation. In this context, a private citizen is a person who does not hold

or occupy a government position, job, or commission of any type.

(b) If the bribe giver is a public official or a holder of a public position of any rank, power,

title or position including but not limited to a position in a government owned or controlled, or

quasi-government corporation, with the expectation that he shall gain undue favor directly or

indirectly from the recipient of the bribe who is likewise a public official, or a voter to elect a

candidate for a public office, or a person to recommend an appointment for an aspirant to hold

a public office, the grand jury may offer in writing to grant immunity to, or exempt from,

prosecution the recipient of the bribe on the condition that such recipient shall testify against the

giver of the bribe. If such recipient of the bribe refuses to testify against the giver or offeror of

his bribe, such bribe recipient shall be liable for criminal prosecution for obstruction of justice and,

if convicted, he shall suffer penalty of imprisonment for the period from five (5) years to seven

(7) years in jail. Such recipient shall further suffer from disqualification to aspire to hold a public

office of any type including a position in any government owned or controlled or quasi-

government corporation.

Section 58. Any written or unwritten agreement made by the grantee of immunity from

prosecution who is a private citizen promising to refrain from testifying against the recipient of his

Page 93: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

60

bribe who is a public official or officer under the preceding Article III, Section 57(a) of the National

Jury Law shall be void.

Section 59. Any agreement made by the grantee of immunity from prosecution who is a

public official or officer or an election voter promising to refrain from testifying against the giver

or offerror of a bribe who is a public official or officer referred to in Article III, Section 57(b) of the

National Jury Law shall be void.

Section 60. The grand jury shall have the power to indict for obstruction of justice of any

person or public official who refuses to testify before any Congressional Body or Committee in

an investigation of crime or for any act of corruption or anomaly in the government in aid of its

legislation upon submission of a complaint to the grand jury of such Body or Committee.

Section 61. The grand jury shall have the power to indict for obstruction of justice any

person or public official who shall disobey a writ of amparo, writ of habeas corpus, or writ of

habeas data issued by the Supreme Court, Court of Appeals, Sandiganbayan, Regional,

Metropolitan, City, or Municipal, or Municipal Circuit Courts, Shari’a District or Circuit Courts.

Section 62. The grand jury shall have the power to indict for obstruction of justice any

person or public official who shall disobey a subpoena, subpoena duces tecum, or summons

issued by the Ombudsman, Commission on Audit, Commission on Elections, Civil Service

Commission, Commission on Human Rights, through their deputies, in matters within their

respective jurisdictions to investigate upon complaint by any of such entities.

Section 63. No crime suspect shall be compelled to testify before a grand jury nor shall

any witness or person be compelled to incriminate or testify against himself. A grand jury shall

have no power to order the detention of a crime suspect. A grand jury has no power to act as a

trier of fact. The Grand Jury is not a court of law and it shall have no absolute duty to inform a

crime suspect of a grand jury investigation or proceedings against him. Conversely, a crime

suspect shall have no right to send his attorney to appear in his behalf to cross-examine a

witness in grand jury investigations.

Section 64. The Grand Jury shall not be bound to observe the strict rules of court on

hearsay evidence. Gathering of evidence by the grand jury shall not be limited by the hearsay

rule, but it has no liberty to employ deceptive, forceful or intimidatory tactics.

Section 65. A matter that has been dropped from investigation by a grand jury shall not

necessarily prevent a future grand jury with a new set of members from reopening the same

matter for further investigation and eventual indictment of the suspected offender when

warranted by the discovery of additional evidence or witness showing probable cause that the

Page 94: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

61

crime suspect has committed a crime. A new set of the members of the grand jury shall have

the power to continue to investigate and to indict the suspected offender on a criminal matter

commenced by, and remains pending at the end of the term of, the out-going members of the

grand jury.

Section 66. Criminal investigations and indictments initiated by the Ombudsman and the

Commission on Human Rights or any other investigatory agencies of the Philippine Government,

national or local, shall be subject to review and approval by a grand jury in the form of an

indictment consonant to, and in representation of the sovereign power of the people in Article

II, , Section 1 of the Constitution which declares that all government authority emanates from the

people.

Section 67. A grand jury may publish in any newspaper of general circulation in its district

to invite anonymous informants of crimes and government corrupt practices including names and

addresses of witnesses or crime victims to send secret reports to the grand jury without

necessarily disclosing the identity of the informant, whistle blower, or tipster.

Section 68. A grand jury may subpoena or summon any public official or employee, or any

citizen, in or outside its district to provide assistance or help in its effort to gather information

regarding any crime which has been committed by the crime suspect which is the subject of its

investigation and indictment.

Section 69. The clerk of court, to the exclusion of anyone else, shall have the sole power

and primary duty to receive and guide any witness summoned or subpoenaed by the Grand Jury

in entering the grand jury investigation room. He shall, under no circumstance whatsoever, allow

more than one witness or person or public official for any purpose to enter a grand jury

investigation room regardless of the power or authority or nobility of such public official or person.

Under no circumstance shall the clerk of court allow any person or public official to enter the

grand jury room unless upon prior issuance of a subpoena or summons by the grand jury.

Section 70. The Clerk of Court shall have the power to disarm any witness or any person,

or public official of any rank, power, position or title, or any person of nobility or royalty who may

appear to enter a grand jury proceeding as a witness. By exercising his power within the scope

of his authority in complying with this provision of the National Jury Law, his rank shall be

paramount and superior to any public official of the Republic of the Philippines or any person of

nobility while performing his duties as such.

FILING OF GRAND JURY INDICTMENT

Section 71. Filing of Grand Jury Indictment; Issuance of Arrest Warrant; And Arrest of the

Accused -

Page 95: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

62

(a) The indictment of a grand jury shall be sealed and filed in a criminal trial court that has

jurisdiction over the case. Upon completion of the preparation of the indictment, the grand jury

foreman shall thereupon summon in writing the Clerk of Court, on a prescribed form, referred to

as Form GJ-41, found in Section 99, the Grand Jury Table of Forms, in this Article of the National

Jury Law, to appear before the grand jury to accept and receive the filing of the Grand Jury

indictment. Any grand jury indictment filed in court shall be deemed properly executed and sworn

under the oath when signed personally by the Grand Jury Foreman with his security identification

number or “SIDN”. He should not sign with his real name.

(b) The Clerk of Court, upon receiving the grand jury indictment, shall keep the filing of

the indictment with utmost secrecy and he, including his office staff, shall, in no case, disclose,

gossip, or announced the filing of the indictment in court, to any person, or public official, the

media or to the public, or any member of the public, until such time that the accused has already

been taken into custody by the Arresting Officer on the basis of the warrant of arrest issued by

the judge on the indictment of the accused.

(c) Within two (2) working days from the filing date of the indictment, the Presiding Judge

of the court where said indictment was filed, shall thereupon personally unseal and examine the

indictment for issuance of the warrant of arrest against the accused. No judge shall have the

power to refuse issuance of a warrant of arrest on a grand jury indictment unless upon his

personal knowledge of a clear and convincing proof that said indictment was fraudulently

procured. The said judge shall have no authority to disclose the indictment until the accused has

been taken into custody by government authorities and he shall, likewise, be liable for obstruction

of justice for prematurely disclosing the indictment of the accused or in the delay of the issuance

of the warrant of arrest of the accused.

(d) If the presiding judge of the court before whom the grand jury indictment was filed

shall refuse to issue a warrant of arrest on the indictment, he must return within two (2) working

days from the filing date of the indictment to the grand jury in writing stating thereon the legal

reason or reasons behind his refusal in issuing the arrest warrant for further consideration or

reinvestigation of the matter by the grand jury. He shall not, under any condition, disclose the

indictment in any manner or the reason to any third party of his refusal to issue the warrant of

arrest on the indictment against the accused.

(e) The Arresting Officer in charge of executing the warrant of arrest, within five (5)

working days from the date he has received the warrant of arrest for the accused issued by the

presiding judge, shall thereupon take the accused into custody. Said arresting officer shall have

no authority to disclose to any person, or any public official, or any member of the media, of his

possession of the warrant of arrest. He shall not ask for permission or approval from any political

official or public official of any rank or power or position or title or any person of nobility or royalty

in taking the accused into custody notwithstanding any law, decree, or executive order, to the

Page 96: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

63

contrary. The arresting officer in disclosing his possession of the warrant of arrest or of his taking

the accused into custody, in violation of this provision of the National Jury Law, shall be liable of

the crime of obstruction of justice upon the complaint of the accused before a grand jury.

(f) No later than two (2) hours upon taking the accused into government custody, the

Arresting Officer shall promptly make a record of his arrest and thereupon turn over the arrested

accused to the Warden of a detention jail for processing, booking, and detention.

(g) The Warden of the detention jail, upon receipt of the person of the accused, shall

promptly process the booking of the accused and without any minute of delay, shall inform the

attorney for the accused, or his closest relative, or the intake officer of the Public Attorney’s

Office if the accused is an indigent or a minor with no close relative. The Warden shall keep a

record of his actions in booking the accused for ready inspection by any interested party. A

warden who, by negligence, fails to perform the required notices as mandated upon him by this

provision of the National Jury Law shall be liable for the crime of obstruction of justice upon

complaint before the Grand Jury by the detained accused or by his close relative or friend.

Section 72. Any person or public official who shall interfere, or attempt to interfere, in any

manner or for any purpose before or after the issuance or execution of a warrant of arrest shall

be criminally liable for the crime of obstruction of justice upon complaint before the grand jury by

an aggrieved party.

Section 73. After the filing of the grand jury indictment in court, the government prosecutor

in charge to pursue the matter to trial, or his successor, shall have the further duty to discover

more evidence, if necessary, for the purpose of proving the guilt of the accused with proof

beyond reasonable doubt. He shall, nonetheless, keep the matter strictly confidential and shall

not publish or disclose in any manner to any person, or public official, or member of the media,

his newly discovered evidence including names of witnesses relating to the same grand jury

indictment.

INVESTIGATION AND INDICTMENT OF PUBLIC OFFICIALS

Section 74. Indictment of the President and other public officials by the Grand Jury-

(1) Indictment of the President - For any serious crime personally or by proxy committed

by the President for obstruction of justice, bribery, plunder, money laundering, human right abuse

or for ordering extra-judicial killing of a person or persons, or for electoral fraud or terrorism in

violation of election laws, or for violation of the Anti-Graft and Corrupt Practices Act in Republic

Act 3019, Government Procurement reform Act in Republic Act 9184, or for violation of Republic

Act No. 1379, the “Act Declaring Forfeiture of Ill-Gotten Wealth of Public Officers and

Employees”, including disobedience to, or prevention of the implementation of, Writ of Habeas

Page 97: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

64

Corpus, Writ of Amparo, or Writ of Habeas Data, issued by any criminal trial court,

Sandiganbayan, Court of Appeals or the Supreme Court or for failure to file his Statement of

Assets, Liabilities and Networth, also referred to as “SALN”, or, if filed, for making false

information therein, a Grand Jury may indict the president regardless of any law, presidential

decree, declaration of martial law, executive order or rule, or high court decision to the contrary

or of any existing prior impeachment. When executing the warrant of arrest against the

President, the Arresting Officer shall directly be endowed with the sovereign power of the people

under Article II, Section 1, of the constitution and shall be free from any criminal or civil liability

in performing his duties under this subsection of the National Jury Law. The indicted president

shall further be liable for acts of obstruction of justice in refusing to voluntarily submit to

government custody upon the execution of the warrant of arrest upon him.

(2) Indictment of other public officials- The above Section 74(1) of Article III, of the

National Jury Law shall apply likewise to any public official or judicial official or justice who is

removable from office by impeachment including but not limited to any public official not subject

to impeachment in all levels and any instrumentality of the government from national down to all

regional, autonomous government, provincial, city, municipal and barrangay governments or

members of local councils of local governments. It also applies to all public officials of any rank,

title, or position, senators and congresspersons, justices, judges of the other branches of the

government as well as officials and employees of quasi-government entities and of the

government owned or controlled corporations of the Republic of the Philippines for any serious

crimes he, or they, may have committed against the People of the Philippines;

(3) Promptly within thirty (30) working days after the criminal defendant has been arrested,

the Government Prosecutor having the duty to prosecute the case shall take steps to freeze the

assets of said criminal defendant including but not limited to money deposits in any bank from

being withdrawn, or real property from being conveyed to any third party and to seize government

vehicle intrusted in his possession. Intentional failure or neglect of such government prosecutor

from complying with his duty herein shall be liable for dereliction of duty pursuant to Article 208

of the Revised Penal Code of the Philippines and for professional disciplinary action.

Section 75. If, without justification after having been arraigned in person before a court,

the accused fails or refuses to subsequently attend in his trial in spite of due notice served on him

or upon his counsel, the trial shall proceed in his absence in accordance with Article III, Section

14(2) of the Constitution. Said trial shall take precedence over any other judicial, executive,

legislative or social matter requiring personal or official attention of the president or such any

other indicted public official. Should his lawyer or lawyers fail to attend, or boycott, the scheduled

trial for any reason, his lead attorney or counsel shall be liable for obstruction of justice and for

disciplinary action upon indictment by the grand jury on complaint by any citizen or any member

of the media.

Page 98: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

65

Section 76. Presidential Succession, If the President is Convicted. Imprisonment, and

Possible Avoidance of Incarceration -

(a) If the President is found guilty, the Vice-President shall automatically become

President upon finality of his conviction, and such convicted President shall be ordered to begin

service time in jail. His conviction shall become final on the last day of the thirty (30) working

days from the date of his jury conviction verdict was read and issued in open court.

(b) The convicted President may avoid incarceration if he chooses to resign voluntarily

from office before his jury conviction verdict shall have become final with full compliance of the

conditions as specified in the next following sub-sections (c), (d), (e), (f) and (g), of this Section

76, Article III, of the National Jury Law.

(c) He shall truthfully and fully prepare and sign a Statement of Assets, Liability and

Networth on Form GJ-51 as prescribed in Section 99, Article III, of the National Jury Law;

(d) He shall disclose in said form, Form GJ-51, all money bank deposits and real estate

and personal property that he and his family had acquired and located both in the Philippines and

in every country around the world;

(e) He shall disclose in said form, Form GJ-51, all confirmed verifiable liabilities and

indebtedness he had declared in his last executed regular public service “Statement of Assets,

Liabilities and Networth” (commonly known as the” SALN”) before the date his current jury

conviction verdict was handed down;

(f) The total amount of lawful compensation, salaries or wages, he had earn since the first

day he entered public service up to time he has served as of the date of his jury conviction verdict

shall have become final shall be computed and deducted from the net amount between his

assets and liabilities as computed in the foregoing sub-sections (d) and (e) in this Section of

Article III of the National Jury Law; and

(g) He shall pay in full with cash on a Bank Manager’s Certified Check the net amount

computed and arrived at in the above sub-section (f) in this Section of Article III of the National

Jury Law.

Section 77. Should the convicted president attempt to conceal any of his assets and

money bank deposits by omitting the same from his SALN, he shall be held liable for the crime

and punishment of obstruction of justice upon indictment by the grand jury and forthwith tried

before a trial jury.

Page 99: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

66

Section 78. The said thirty (30)-day period to resign and divestment process of the

convicted President shall not be extended for any reason. Any transfer of ownership of assets

and money bank deposits referred to during the said period and thereafter, if any, shall be void.

He shall neither be allowed to obtain a discharge of his insolvency or bankruptcy nor shall he be

permitted to occupy any public office.

Section 79. The president indicted with any of the crimes referred to in Section 74(1),

Article III, of the National Jury Law shall lose his power to declare martial law upon the filing in

court of the grand jury indictment of any of said crimes. If for any reason said president succeeds

in declaring martial law, he shall be held personally accountable and criminally liable for every

person or citizen who has become missing, or have been subjected to physical or psychological

harm, tortured or have been killed, during the state of martial law resulting from the hardships

inflicted by the members of the Armed Forces and National Police upon the people, or upon any

person, on the basis of command responsibility.

Section 80. Execution of the warrant of arrest against the President- Upon the execution

of the warrant of arrest against the indicted president, all his presidential powers shall be

automatically suspended. He shall be given the full opportunity to depend himself of all

accusations against him. He shall be barred from exercising directly or indirectly, the

prerogatives of the office of the president.

Section 81. Upon the execution of the warrant of arrest against the indicted president, the

arresting officer shall, at the same time, promptly inform the vice-president of such event.

Immediately thereafter, the arresting officer and the vice-president shall firstly and jointly contact

the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court. If the Chief Justice is unavailable readily, they may

contact any Associate Justice of the Supreme Court, and before him, the vice president shall

take his oath as Acting President pending the final outcome of the criminal indictment and

accusation of the president.

Section 82. Immediately following his taking of the oath as Acting President, the Vice-

President shall address the nation to inform the people and all officials of the Republic of the

Philippines of the state of the presidency. The power of the presidency shall then automatically

devolve upon him.

Section 83. The Vice President as Acting President shall promptly inform the people

through the media including radio and television facilities regarding his assumption of office as

acting president. He shall inform the people that the president has been indicted in court by a

Grand Jury for violation of certain serious crimes. He shall name specifically the crimes for which

the president has been charged with. He shall inform the people that the president has now been

arrested and shall soon face trial in due course before a trial jury of the people.

Page 100: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

67

Section 84. After assumption of the Vice President as Acting President by taking his oath

of office, thereupon, the members and officers of the Armed Forces of the Philippines, the

Philippine National Police, the presidential staff and cabinet secretaries shall automatically

channel their official support and allegiance to the Acting President to continue the peaceful

governance of the country.

Section 85. When execution of arrest warrant is deemed constructively complete - The

execution of the warrant of arrest upon the indicted president or any other public official of the

government from national down to all regional autonomous governments, provincial, city,

municipal and barangay governments as well as all public officials, senators and

congressperson, justices, judges or any of member of their office staffs in the other branches of

the government and officials and employees of quasi-government entities and of the government

owned or controlled corporations of the Republic of the Philippines shall be deemed

constructively complete upon the announcement of the arresting officer to the person of the

subject indictee that such indictee is being placed under arrest by the arresting officer regardless

of whether the person subject of arrest has been restrained, detained, or taken into government

custody, or not.

Section 86. If the arrested president, or any arrested public official referred to in the

preceding Section 84 refuses to be placed into government custody, or fails to voluntarily

surrender for custody, said subject official shall be deemed a fugitive of justice, shall be liable

to a forceful arrest, shall not be granted bail. Additional, he shall further be made criminally liable

for the crime of obstruction of justice and shall suffer punishment by imprisonment in jail for a

period of five (5) years to seven (7) years. An attempt or attempts of an arrested official and as

fugitive of justice to exercise the official functions of his office shall be void and without validity.

Section 87. The rule suspending the president from exercising the powers of his office

upon execution of the warrant of arrest against him shall likewise apply to all public, legislative,

and judicial officials, judges and justices, except public officials and employees covered by the

Civil Service Law. He shall be succeeded by the public official by the applicable law of

succession of his office.

Section 88. Payment Authorization by indicted Official Void - Payment of any public

expenditure including payment of salaries of government officials and employees requiring

approval by the indicted official shall not be approved for payment unless and until the

corresponding voucher or payroll of such expenditure shall have been approved by the acting

official who has taken over the authority, powers and function of the indictee.

Page 101: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

68

Section 89. Any government treasurer or paymaster who shall disburse funds to pay any

public expenditure including payment of salaries and other benefits of officials and employees

relating to the exercise of act or acts of the indicted president, or a public official, such treasurer

or paymaster shall be personally liable and accountable for the public funds so disbursed for

such purpose for lack of authority to make such payment or payments unless their corresponding

vouchers or payrolls shall have been approved by the lawful acting public official in place of the

indicted public official.

Section 90. If the indicted president is convicted or shall resign from office, the

vice-president shall become president to serve the remainder of the term of the convicted or

resigned president.

Section 91. Any person who shall maliciously file a preemptive impeachment complaint

in Congress against the convicted president, or any public official who is removable from public

office by impeachment, with the view of protecting such president, or public official, from being

impeached as a result of his conviction shall be held liable of the crime of obstruction of justice

and shall be liable for punishment by imprisonment in jail for five (5) years to seven (7) years

upon conviction.

GRAND JURY INVESTIGATION OF JAIL FACILITIES

Section 92. The Grand Jury on its own original initiative may engage in the investigation

of jail facilities in its jury district. Its investigation shall be commenced by requiring by way of a

Summons, using prescribed Form GJ-66 upon the Warden, or Jail Director, of a jail facility the

submission within ten (10) days upon demand of the following items which he shall state, verify,

and date under penalty of perjury:

(a) A complete list of names and home addresses of each and all officials and employees

in his facility with their corresponding title, rank, or position in their organization and their average

monthly pay regardless of whether the official or employee is a permanent or temporary

employee.

(b) A complete list of all inmates with their names and case numbers and the length of

time each inmate has been incarcerated in his facility regardless of whether the inmate is already

convicted or not and the identifiable cell location in which inmates are housed.

(c) A post card size picture of the common mess hall of the inmates.

(d) A post card size picture of the inmate toilets.

Page 102: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

69

(e) Failure of the Warden or Jail Director to submit the desired information above shall

warrant his indictment for the crime of obstruction of justice with punishment by imprisonment

in jail from five (5) years to seven (7) years upon conviction in a trial by jury.

Section 93. Upon receipt by the Grand Jury of the items referred to in the immediately

preceding Section 92 above, the Grand Jury Foreman shall thereupon enter in his docket on

prescribed Form GJ-31 and provide the matter with a Grand Jury Case Number. He shall

likewise assign the matter to a Grand Juror using the prescribe Form-7 for further follow up to find

any irregularity in managing the subject jail facility for prompt action.

THE FORGIVING CLAUSE AND THE PURGATORY CLAUSE

Section 94 Forgiving Clause -

(a) No public official or employee shall be held guilty for bribery offense or offenses as

defined by law committed prior to the enactment of this law PROVIDED that such public official

has not committed such offense or offenses after the National Jury Law shall have taken effect,

and PROVIDED FURTHER that such official or employee shall have refunded to the Philippine

Government any public funds or money he has deposited in a bank account privately in his

name or in the name of another account for his benefit, or shall have returned all properties he

shall have illegally taken, stolen, or absconded with, during his term of office, OTHERWISE he

shall be indicted by the grand jury for the said crime or crimes he continued to commit both prior

to, and after, the effectivity of this Law.

(b) To avail of the benefit in the foregoing subparagraph (a) of this section, the public

official or employee shall voluntarily execute Form GJ-51 in Section 99, Article III, and Form TJ-

134 in Section 2, Article X, of the National Jury Law and shall further cooperate by executing the

conveyance to the government of any asset that he may have acquired in violation of the

Revised Penal Code of the Philippines, Act 3815 as amended, the Anti-Graft and Corrupt

Practices Act, Republic Act 3019 as amended, the Crime of Plunder, Republic Act 7080 as

amended, the Anti-Money Laundering Law, Republic Act 9160 as amended and the Government

Procurement reform Act, Republic Act 9184 as amended, minus the total amount of money that

he shall have legally earned from his lawful salaries and emoluments since the start he entered

service in the government until the effective date of the National Jury Law.

Section 95. Pending Cases and The Purgatory Clause -

(a) Cases of bribery that are now pending or undergoing investigation before the

Page 103: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

70

Ombudsman or any government investigator, or trial before any division of the Sandiganbayan,

shall not be prejudiced by the forgiving provision in the preceding Section, unless the accused

shall voluntarily and unconditionally desire to avail of benefits of the immediately preceding

section 94(a)&(b) of this law.

(b) The above forgiving clause shall not apply to cases of obstruction of justice, electoral

terrorism or electoral fraud, brigandage, extortion, murder, chastity crimes and crimes in any form

in violation of human rights, property rights, and voting rights. If property rights involve acts of

land grabbing and the accused is willing to restore or adequately compensate the victim or the

victim’s heirs, the accused shall be permitted to avail of the benefits of the forgiving clause of this

law.

(c) A public official who has committed the crime of bribery whether indicted or not prior

to the enactment of the National Jury Law and has continued to commit the same crime

regardless of whether the bribe giver prior to the enactment of this Law is the same person or

entity or not after the passage of this Law shall be denied of the forgiving benefit offered in the

preceding Section 94 of this Law.

(d) The continued possession and concealment of an ill-gotten wealth or the fruit thereof

which a public official or former public official had derived while in office of the government shall

be deemed a continuance of his crime of government corruption after the enactment of the

National Jury Law and such public official, or former public official, shall be denied of the benefit

offered in the preceding Section 94 of this Law. If he claims that his increase in assets is derived

from his private enterprise, he must prove that said private enterprise has been properly

organized under the rules of the Security Exchange Commission and free from conflict of interest

with his position in the government. He shall further show that the money value representing

increase of his assets has been reported in his income tax returns in the year it was earned or

in his last filing of his Statement of Assets, Liabilities and Networth.

(e) An accused who has already been arraigned on an accusation of a serious crime

before the effective date of this Law, the National Jury Law, but whose bench trial has not yet

commenced with the presentation of a witness, shall be required to stand trial before a trial jury.

Section 96. If a grand jury shall investigate a staff member of the court or a judge of the

court over a serious crime where its members were sworn in at their inaugural formation, such

grand jury shall file its indictment in a different court that has jurisdiction of the crime. If such

grand jury is unable to investigate the criminal matter in issue, a grand jury of another district may

undertake to investigate and file the corresponding indictment in another court upon finding of

probable cause.

Page 104: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

71

Section 97. Grand Jury Investigation of Fraudulently Elected or Proclaimed Public

Officials - Any provisions of the Omnibus Election Code of the Philippines insofar as it runs in

conflict to the National Jury Law is hereby superseded, amended, or repealed, as the case may

be, as follows:

(a) Notwithstanding the proclamation and swearing into office of an alleged elected public

official in any elective public office and suspected of having won his position by any fraudulent

means, as defined by law, no court or commission shall have the power to order the grand jury

to abstain, forbid, prevent or stop from investigating the result in the election of said official and

in the indictment of such proclaimed elected official including any person or public official who

conspired in the fraudulent manipulation in the registration or election of voters and violation of

all, or any, other electoral processes and procedures established by law leading to the

proclamation of the alleged elected public official.

(b) Any public official authorized to administer oath of office or any justice, judge, or

notary public, knowing the invalidity, or who entertains any doubt of the validity, of the election

of a candidate to a public office and who shall administer the oath of office or proclaims the

election of such candidate to a public office shall be subject to investigation and indictment by

the Grand Jury upon its finding of a probable cause for violation of the electoral process.

(c) Any person, public official, justice, judge, or notary public referred to in the preceding

sub-paragraphs (a) and (b) including members and officials of the Commission on Elections,

government prosecutors and members of the National Bureau of Investigation and staff officials

of the Ombudsman involved in the violation of the electoral process as described in the said

foregoing sub-paragraphs in this section upon indictment by the grand jury shall stand and face

trial before a trial jury. If found guilty, the convicted party shall suffer the maximum penalty as

provided by the election laws.

Section 98. Preserving the identity of a witness from disclosure prior to the giving of his

testimony in a criminal trial.

(a) A witness to a crime who has been summoned or served with a subpoena issued by

the grand jury in the investigation of such crime shall enjoy absolute anonymity until such time

that he has been actually sworn and has testified in a criminal court trial either before a jury or

a bench trial. The accused shall have no right to cross examine such witness until the witness

is called and sworn in at the start of a jury trial or bench trial.

(b) No such witness shall be called to testify in a civil trial until a verdict is handed down

in the criminal trial against the accused.

(c) Any member of a grand jury, or any government prosecutor, or a juror in a jury trial,

Page 105: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

72

or any person, public official or not, who shall disclose privately or publicly the identity of a

witness who has testified before a grand jury shall be liable for the crime of obstruction of justice

and shall suffer the penalty of five (5) years to seven (7) years of imprisonment in jail upon his

conviction of such crime.

(d) The prosecutor in a criminal jury trial shall have the obligation to disclose the total

number of his prosecution witnesses and the estimated length of time of his direct examination

of his witness or on each of his witness. Neither the prosecutor shall have the obligation to

disclose, nor the presiding judge has the authority to order the disclosure of, the name of the

witness or witnesses of the plaintiff, prior to the start of the prosecution proceeding or trial and

until a witness is sworn to testify in such proceeding or trial.

(e) Once the prosecution witness is sworn in and his name or identity is disclosed to

testify in such proceeding or trial, no postponement or continuance shall be granted by the

presiding judge until the direct examination on the witness is completed regardless of court time

limitation at five o’clock in the afternoon of the day of trial. In the event of an over time trial, the

presiding judge and all members of his staff including the Sheriff, the prosecuting and defense

attorneys, the members of the jury, and the witness, shall be compensated equal to “time-and-a-

half” over their regular salary or wage.

(f) If it is estimated that no direct, or cross, examination upon the prosecution witness

can be completely done on the same day that he is sworn to testify due to time constraint, such

witness shall continue to enjoy is anonymity until he shall been sworn in promptly early in the

morning of the next continuance trial date to thereupon start his direct testimony.

(g) Once the prosecution witness is sworn in to testify at the trial, the government, through

the prosecution counsel, shall arrange and provide protection for such witness, if necessary,

against any probable harm coming from any party or any person by enrolling such witness for

shelter under the government Witness Protection Program.

Section 99. The Grand Jury Table of Forms. The Grand Jury printable forms are located

in Section 100 following this section. Go to the Page Number of the form to find the printable

form.

GRAND JURY TABLE OF FORMS

(May be Briefly cited as “GJTF”)

The following forms are prescribed for use by the Grand Jury and as part of the Grand

Jury Systems Rules. The “GJ” acronym stands for "Grand Jury". Locate the form using the

page reference below:

Page 106: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

73

FORM ID FORM DESCRIPTION PAGE #

Form GJ-1, GJ Membership Invitation Advertisement Form . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 76

Form GJ-2, GJ Membership Application Form . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 78

Form GJ-3, Receipt of Application for Grand Jury Membership . . . . . . . . . . . 80

Form GJ-4, Active GJ Members Record . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 81

Form GJ-5, Daily Jurors’ Attendance Record . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 82

Form GJ-6, Juror’s Absence Record . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 83

Form GJ-7, Foreman’s Case Assignment Order Form . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 84

Form GJ-8, Entity/Office/Organization Planned for Investigation. . . . . . . . . . . 85

Form GJ-9, Particular Person or Public Official Planned for Investigation . . . . 86

Form GJ-10, Invitation for Anonymous Crime Informants Advertisement. . . . . . 87

Form GJ-11, Extracted Record from Anonymous Report . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 88

Form GJ-12, Grand Jury Subpoena . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 89

Form GJ-13, Grand Jury Interrogation Quorum and Witness Appearance Record . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 92

Form GJ-14, Secret Ballot of the Grand Jury. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 93

Form GJ-15, Grand Jury Indictment - General Form. Sample Form . . . . . . . . . 94

Form GJ-16, Grand Jury Indictment - for Perjury. Sample Form . . . . . . . . . . . . 95

Form GJ-17, Grand Jury Indictment - For OBSTRUCTION OF JUSTICE - Sample Form. . . . . . . . . . . . 96

Form GJ-18, Memorandum of Non-indictment by the Grand Jury . . . . . . . . . . . 97

Form GJ-19, List of Exhibits Form To Support filing of GJ Indictment In Court . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 99

Form GJ-20, Physician's Certificate of Juror's Illness or Injury Form . . . . . . . . . 101

Form GJ-21, Immunity from prosecution to Private Citizen Bribe Giver . . . . . . . 102

Form GJ-22, Immunity from prosecution in Bribery between public officials. . . . 105

Form GJ-23, Foreman's Recommendation to Terminate a Member of the Grand Jury . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 107

Form GJ-24, Members' Recommendation to Expel Foreman of Grand Jury . . . 109

Page 107: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

74

Form GJ-25, Oath of the Grand Juror. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 111

Form GJ-26, Certificate of Truthfulness By the Suspected Offender. Optional Use Only . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 112

Form GJ-27, Unconditional Non-transferable Redeemable Judicial Voucher. . . 114

Form GJ-28, Request by the Grand Jury for Special Police Protection . . . . . . . 115

Form GJ-29, Declaration by GJ Members To Dissolve the Grand Jury . . . . . . . 118

Form GJ-30, Order to Show Cause Why the GJ Shall not Be Dissolved . . . . . . 120

Form GJ-31, Foreman's Master Case Intake Record And Case Assignment . . . 122

Form GJ-32, Non-Member SIDN Master Designation Registry . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 123

Form GJ-33, Agenda Form for Grand Jury Sessions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 124

Form GJ-34, Members' Recommendation to Expel Secretary of the Grand Jury . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 125

Form GJ-35, Authenticated SIDNs of Grand Jury Members for Current Period . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 126

Form GJ-36, Optional Exceptional Notice to Crime Suspect of Investigation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 127

Form GJ-37, Unconditional Redeemable Voucher Accounting. . . . . . . . . . . . . . 130

Form GJ-38, Authenticated Individual Juror's SIDN by the Executive Judge. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 132

Form GJ-39, Grand Jury Instruction and Basic Interrogatory Techniques. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 133

Form GJ-40, Grand Jury Hold Departure Order Notice. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 156

Form GJ-41, Summons to Clerk of Court for court filing of GJ Indictment . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 157

Form GJ-42, Confidential Info about the Witness . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 159

Form GJ-43, Reserved. Unused.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 161

Form GJ-44, Notice of Grand Jury Reorganization of Officers.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . 162

Form GJ-45, Invitation for Lawyers to apply in the CDP Pool. (For Newspaper Advertisement). . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 163

Form GJ-46, Application to Participate in the CDP Pool. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 164

Form GJ-47, Registry for Assigned Cases to the CDP Pool. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 167

Page 108: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

75

Form GJ-48AD, Invitation Advertisement for Deputy Public Defenders For Indigent Accused or Minor.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 168

Form GJ-48AP, Application by Defense Lawyers to defend Indigent Accused or a Minor. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 169

Form GJ-49, Letter requesting payment for CDP Service. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 171

Form GJ-50, Prohibition and Declination to Meet an Unsubpoenaed or Uninvited Grand Jury Visitor . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 172

Form GJ-51, Declaration of Assets and Liabilities. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 173

Form GJ-52, Summons to High Ranking Public Officials, Nobility or Royalty . . . 176

Form GJ-53, Summons to a Lawyer . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 178

Form GJ-54, Summons to a Medical Doctor . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 181

Form GJ-55, Summons to a Certified Public Account (CPA). . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 184

Form GJ-56, Summons to an Engineer. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 187

Form GJ-57, Summons to a Vehicle Mechanic. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 190

Form GJ-58, Summons to a Police Officer . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 196

Form GJ-59, Summons to an Army Officer . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 195

Form GJ-60, Summons to a Navy Officer . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 197

Form GJ-61, Summons to an Air Force Officer . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 199

Form GJ-62, Summons to a Public Official or Government Employee . . . . . . . 201

Form GJ-63, Summons - General Form or Template. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 203

Form GJ-64, Stenographer’s Bill for Transcripts in Grand Jury Proceedings. . . 205

Form GJ-65, Declination by the GJ to Provide Grand Jury Record or Information. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 206

Form GJ-66, Summons for Submission of Jail Facility Records & Pictures . . . . 207

Form GJ-67, Registry for Assigned Cases to Deputy Public Defenders. . . . . . . 210

GRAND JURY FORMS

(Printable Forms, Next following page)

Page 109: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

76

Form GJ-1, GJ Membership Invitation Advertisement Form.

"THE REGIONAL TRIAL COURTOFFICE OF THE CLERK OF COURT

Of the Judicial DistrictWithin the ________ Grand Jury District of the City of ___________________

Street Address: _____________________________________City Address: _______________________________

Newspaper and Bulletin NOTICE To Invite Citizens to Apply for Grand Jury Membership .(Public media, i.e. radio, tv, etc. is authorized to publicly announce this NOTICE)

REGISTERED VOTERS within the Grand Jury District stated above are invited to file

SECRETLY in person their application for Grand Jury Membership in said District located at:

The Clerk of the Regional Trial Court (Ask for “GJ Application Form GJ-2")

At (Street Address) ________________________________________________

Municipal/City/Province: ____________________________________________

Official to accept applications: Clerk of Court or his Deputy. No recommendation is required.

Last day of filing: (_)-December _____, ________ (_)-June ____, _________.

Number of Applicants invited: NO LIMIT. Apply as early as possible. Avoid last day filing.

Number of applicants to be chosen by lottery: 23 citizens to be drawn randomly in court from among the

applicants. Application drawn with absent applicant will be deposited back to the Raffle Bin.

Term of Duty, temporary: Limited to 6 months - January to June, and from July to December.

Compensation per day: Twice the prevailing legal minimum wage. CAUTION: Except to the Clerk of Court,

do not mention your name to anybody else that you are an applicant for grand jury membership.

Date of Lottery: The first business day of (_)-January _____|____|_____ (_)-July _____|____|_____

Hour of lottery to choose grand jury members: To start exactly at 9:00 AM.

Persons admitted to witness the raffle drawing of applications: All Applicant ticket holders only.

Location: The Court Room of ____________________________________________________________

At (Street Address) _____________________________________________________________________

Municipality/City/Province: _______________________________________________________________

QUALIFICATION : (a) Filipino citizen, male or female, at least 23 years old including senior citizens; (b) A registered

voter of the jury district where he will serve as a grand juror; (c) Possessed with a bachelor's degree of any kind froma reputable college or university which he must show by his diploma in submitting his application who has not been amember of any fraternity, sorority or mista in any college, university or military school; (d) Must accept to serve withdouble minimum wage rate; (e) Not a lawyer; (f) Not an official or employee of any government instrumentality; (g)Not a son or son-in-law or daughter or daughter-in-law of an official or employee of any government instrumentality; (h)Not a father or father-in-law or mother or mother-in-law of an official or employee of any government instrumentality; (I)Not a brother or brother-in-law or sister or sister-in-law of an official or employee of any government instrumentality; (j)Not an uncle or aunt or nephew or niece of a government official or employee (k) Not been convicted of a crimepunishable for 6 months or more; (l) Not currently facing a criminal accusation of any kind in court; (m) Not have beena grand jury member in the last 12 months; (n) Not have been retired as a government official or employee within thelast 12 months; (o)) Has not been recommended or assisted by a public official or by anybody in preparing and filing

Page 110: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

77

his application for grand jury membership, (p) Not a member or employee of a media, news, or publishing organization;(q) Not a member of a royal clan or ruling family, or datu, bai, or sultan and/or has no claim for membership of such royalclan or ruling family, or datu, bai, or sultan; and (r); He swears under penalty of perjury in his application that hepossesses all the qualification and none of the disqualification for membership in the grand jury."Governmentinstrumentality"includes government owned or quasi-government entities; and (s) He must submit with his Application

a Clearance Certificate from the National Bureau of Investigation or regional Office. WARNING: You will be secretly

investigated and indicted for perjury or obstruction of justice by a new set of the Grand Jury after your term of service,if you falsely state your qualification in your application. Report any violator to the next incoming Grand Jury for criminalindictment for obstruction of justice.

JOB TO PERFORM : Strictly secret job . No field investigation required. Work inside your secret grand jury room only.

An Executive Judge (EJ) shall instruct you how to perform your work. Your identity will be held in absolute secrecy. Youwill be given a security ID name or SIDN and your name will be secretly held under the custody of the judge which hemust deposit in a bank vault and your record will not be retrieved or disclosed except by subpoena issued by a grandjury. After you are organized and your GJ Instruction issued to you by the EJ, he will have no further supervision in yourmissions. Henceforth, you act and decide independently. This is a sacrificial job of citizens to serve their communityto help get rid of lawlessness and government corruption.

A Grand Jury is a group of private citizens acting under Grand Jury Instruction to collectively decide independently bysecret ballot free from government control to investigate serious or capital crimes including government corruptionpunishable by imprisonment of 12 months or more and to file accusation in court against suspected offenders regardlessof their rank and position in the government or in the community upon their finding of probable cause. You need not askany government approval of your actions. Grand Jury Instruction and empowerment will be officiated and issued by anexecutive judge to you immediately following the drawing of code numbers of the newly chosen grand jury members.

The act of the Grand Jury carries the sovereign act of the people and it is strictly confidential. It obtains cases toinvestigate from tipsters in response to your advertisement in newspapers. Although a grand jury is composed only of23 private citizens and blindly chosen by lottery, they wield more power than a thousand or more public demonstratorsbecause they can secretly file their accusation in court without government approval by the use of the sovereign powerof the people under Article II, Section 1 of the Philippine Constitution. Since grand jurors are private citizens, they cannotbe fired from their existing job. The grand jury has nothing to do with court trials because a grand jury is not a court.

Once the grand jury has filed its indictment in court, its job is done. Thereafter, each case will be pursued for trial in

court by government prosecutors before another jury, called the Trial Jury of 12 private citizens.

Applicants for grand jury membership are mandatorily required to read and understands the Statutory Grand JuryInstruction in Section 24, Article III, of the National Jury Law.

The heirs or next of kin of a member of a grand jury who dies, or is no longer capable to earn for a living, in the courseof jury duty or arising out of jury duty is entitled to a monetary indemnity of two hundred thousand (P200,000) pesos, freeof tax. If incapacitated and survives but still capable to earn a living, he is entitled to an indemnity of fifty thousand(P50,000) pesos payable to the juror, also tax free.

Enter your application in the Raffle Bin for the Grand Jury District Number where you wish to serve. The Clerk of Courtmust provide the raffle bins. The number in your Application, issued to you by the Clerk of Court shall become as yourSecret Identification Number, called “SIDN”, once you are chosen and sworn as a member of the Grand Jury. Do notlose your Application Receipt and Number. This notice has been posted by the Clerk of Court. This will serve as yourentrance admission ticket to the Raffle Court Session.

- End of Invitation Form -

Page 111: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

78

Form GJ-2, GJ Membership Application Form

APPLICATION FOR GRAND JURY MEMBERSHIP

TO THE CLERK OF COURT, __________Grand Jury District of the City of _______________________Street Address: _______________________________________________________________________City/Province Address: __________________________________________________________________

Application for Grand Jury Membership

(Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type)

DO NOT APPLY IF YOU ARE NOT QUALIFIED. VIOLATION SU BJECT TO SEVERE PENALTY.

GREETINGS: Please enter my name for drawing as an Applicant for membership in the Grand Jury of this

District. I am qualified for grand jury membership as shown below and my [_]-NBI or [_]-PNP Clearance

Certificate of the Municipality or City where I reside is herewith [_]-attached:

I am: (a) A Filipino citizen, at least 23 years old; (b) A registered voter and resident of this City and Grand Jury

District; (c) Possessed with bachelor's degree of ____________________ from (name of school)

__________________________________, and I have not been a member of any fraternity, or sorority in any

college, university or military school, not been convicted of any felony, and I am not suffering from any mental

impairment; (d) I am willing to serve as a member of the grand jury with twice the minimum wage pay; (e) I am

not an attorney at law; (f) I am not an official or employee of any government instrumentality; (g) I am not a son

or son-in-law or daughter or daughter-in-law of an official or employee of any government instrumentality; (h)

I am not a father or father-in-law or mother or mother-in-law of an official or employee of any government

instrumentality; (i) Not a brother or brother-in-law or sister or sister-in-law of an official or employee of any

government instrumentality; (j) I have not been convicted of a crime punishable for 6 months or more; (k) I am

not currently facing a criminal accusation of any kind in court; (l) I have not been a grand jury member in the

last 12 months; (m) I have not held, or served in, any public office or government instrumentality during the past

12 months; (n) I have not been recommended or assisted by a public official or by anybody in preparing or filing

my application for grand jury membership, (o) I am not a member or employee of a media, news, or publishing

organization; (p) I am not a member of a royal clan or ruling family, or datu, bai, or sultan and I don’t claim for

membership of such royal clan or ruling family, or datu, bai, or sultan; and (q) I swear under penalty of perjury

in my application that I possess all the qualification and none of the disqualification for membership in the grand

jury."Government instrumentality"includes government owned or quasi-government entities; and (r) I am

submitting herewith my Clearance Certificate from the National Bureau of Investigation or regional Office for

your verification. I fully understand that I am liable for the crime of perjury or of obstruction of justice for any

falsity in this application and I am aware that I can be subject to secret investigation by a new set of members

of the grand jury.

I HAVE FULLY READ AND UNDERSTOOD THE CONTENTS OF THIS APPLICATION.

Signed and executed at _____________________________ on ____________________, year _______.

Signature _____________________________ Printed Name: ___________________________________

Voter's ID#_______________ Phone ____________________ Address ___________________________

Page 112: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

79

Leave this blank . Clerk of Court to fill in - > Grand Juror's SIDN# ____________

To Clerk of Court: You must issue a receipt of this application bearing the above number to Applicant to serve

as his admission ticket in participating in the drawing of new grand jury members. Do not publicize this event.

To Applicant: Keep your receipt and memorize the SIDN# above. This will be your only ticket and number to

identity you for your grand jury membership. Your receipt shall be your ticket to participate in drawing of your

name at the lottery. You will use the same number officially for jury service and other benefits. Wear White

Barong Tagalog and wear a pair of dark eyeglasses when reporting for the drawing of names of applicants and

also at all times when reporting for jury duty. Your admission will be refused, if you fail to wear the prescribed

attire. You must appear dignified.

NOTE: Top Secret

(1) You must not let any body know in applying for Grand Jury Membership. When chosen by raffle or

lottery, you must not disclose for your protection your true name to your fellow juror and you must

not ask the true name of your fellow juror either. You will know each other by your SIDN# only.

(2) Within 24 hours after you are sworn in as a me mber of the Grand Jury, the judge who will swear yo u

in is required by the Grand Jury Law to deposit you r personal record in a bank vault and he or

anyone else cannot retrieve or disclose your record to anyone except upon the subpoena by a

Grand Jury.

- End of Application Form -

Page 113: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

80

Form GJ-3, Receipt of Application for Grand Jury Membership-

Republic of the Philippines

OFFICE OF THE CLERK OF COURT

______ Judicial District of ___________________

THE CITY OF ____________________________

Street Address: _____________________________________

City/Province Address: _______________________________

RECEIPT OF APPLICATION FOR GRAND JURY MEMBERSHIPFOR THE _____ GRAND JURY DISTRICT OF

THE CITY OR PROVINCE OF _____________________

This receipt shall remain valid for any future draw ing of applicants for as long as theapplicant is still qualified for membership at that time. The Clerk of Court must keepthe Application of the Applicant in the Raffle Bin for future drawing until his or hernumber is picked also for as long as he or she is s till qualified for membership.

APPLICATION RECEIPT & COURT ROOM DRAWING TICKET

Grand Juror's SIDN # ______________ (Do not lose this document)

This Application Receipt will acknowledge the submission of your Application for Grand Jury Membership. Thisdocument is non-transferable and highly confidential.

This Application Receipt shall serve as your ticket for entry in the Court Room of the Executive Judge, theHonorable _______________________, where the drawing of the Application for Grand Jury Membership shallbe raffled and picked. Other than the applicants, no one shall be allowed to witness in the drawing of theirapplication. No member of the public, the media, or any public official or employee of the government shall beallowed to witness this event. You must wear: (1) A white Barong Tagalog , and (2) A pair of dark Goggle eye glasses . You will not be

admitted to the court room if you fail to comply with this requirement. Do not allow yourself to be interviewed at any time by any media reporter or any public official, police or armypersonnel upon receiving this Application Receipt for your own protection or for the members of your family.Absolutely no picture taking and no video recording shall be allowed in the Court Room. You will be disqualifiedand ejected from the court for violation.

You are not allowed to bring in any person with you to the court room. Should you attempt to do so, you will bebarred from participating in the drawing of your application.

Only the GJ Applicant with this ticket-receipt will be admitted to the court room.

Grand Jury matters are kept highly confidential for your protection and for all others concerned. Always be awareof any secret or surreptitious infiltration or espionage within your ranks. Be on guard at all times. Always wearyour dark goggles when you are inside your investigating room. Do not reveal your true name to any otherapplicant or member of the Grand Jury.

Thank you for your submitting your Application.

Issuer’s Signature: ________________________________. Date: ______________ (mm/dd/yyyy)

Printed Name : ___________________________________ (Clerk of Court)

-End of Receipt Form -

Page 114: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

81

Form GJ-4, Active GJ Members Record.

"THE GRAND JURY

Of the _______ Jury (Legislative) District of:____________________________________

Grand Jury Term from ___________________ to _____________________Confidential

Active Grand Jury Members Record(Secretary Must Keep this Record Strictly Confidential - Internal Use Only)

(Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type)

INSTRUCTION: 1.You are not allowed to disclose to each other your real name.2. You must write in your own SIDN in this Record

POSITION SIDN TELEPHONE POSITION SIDN TELEPHONE

Foreman Member

Asst Foreman Member

Secretary Member

Recording Secretary Member

Member Member

Member Member

Member Member

Member Member

Member Replacement

Member Replacement

Member Replacement

Member Replacement

Member Replacement

Member Replacement

Member 4 Officers and 19 Members = > - 23 -

Important Note: No more than 23 SIDNs shall be active at the same time. If a member is removed, drawa line over his SIDN and telephone number and enter the SIDN and telephone number of the replacer inthe Replacement Box line.

- End of Form -

Page 115: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

82

Form GJ-5, Daily Jurors’ Attendance Record

THE GRAND JURYOf the _______ Jury (Legislative) District of:____________________________________

Grand Jury Term from ___________________ to _____________________Page ________

Confidential

Form GJ- 5 - Daily Juror’s Attendance Record(Secretary Must Keep this Record Strictly Confidential - Internal Use Only)

(Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type)

Date ___/___/____ Day ___________ Month _________ Year _________

TIME IN SIDN # Suspected Offender Alleged Crime Committed GJ CASE # TIME OFF

- End of Form -

Page 116: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

83

Form GJ-6, Juror’s Absence Record.

THE GRAND JURYOf the _______ Jury (Legislative) District of:

____________________________________Grand Jury Term from ___________________ to _____________________

ConfidentialForm GJ-6 - Juror's Absence Record

(Secretary Must Keep this Record Strictly Confidential - Internal Use Only)(Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type)

Date JurorWas Absent

GJ JurorSIDN

Noted bySec - SIDN

Cause ofAbsence

Reviewed? SIDN ofForeman

Foreman’s Remark

Yes No Approved Disapproved

- End of form -

Page 117: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

84

Form GJ-7, Foreman’s Case Assignment Order Form.

"THE GRAND JURYOf the _______ Jury (Legislative) District of:

____________________________________Grand Jury Term from ___________________ to _____________________

"Confidential”

Foreman's Case Assignment Order Form(Juror Concerned Must Keep this Record Strictly Confidential - Internal Use Only)

GRAND JURY CASE NUMBER ___________(Case Number to be assigned by Foreman originating from Form GJ-30)

(Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type)

From Foreman, ID# ____________ To Juror, ID# _____________

You are hereby directed to pursue the matter described below:______________________________________________________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________________________________

Preliminary plan of action: _______________________________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________________________________

Thereafter, state below your recommendation and target date of completion:

Planned date of completion: Date-__________________ Day of week- ______________________

1. ____________________________________________________________________________________________

2. ____________________________________________________________________________________________

3. ____________________________________________________________________________________________

4. ____________________________________________________________________________________________

5. ____________________________________________________________________________________________

- End of form -

Page 118: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

85

Form GJ-8, Entity/Office/Organization Planned for Investigation

THE GRAND JURYOf the _______ Jury (Legislative) District of:____________________________________

Grand Jury Term from ___________________ to _____________________

ConfidentialForm GJ-8 Entity/Office/Organization Planned for Investigation Record

(FOREMAN Must Prepare and Keep this Record Strictly Confidential - Internal Use Only)

GRAND JURY CASE NUMBER ______________________

(Case Number to be assigned MUST ORIGINATE from Form GJ-30)

(Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type)

Date today: ___________________

Name of Entity/Office/Organization Planned for Investigation - _____________________________________________

Address/Location - _______________________________________________________________________________

__________________________________________________________ Telephone # _________________________

Possible crime/s committed in said organization ________________________________________________________

Reason for planned investigation - ___________________________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________________________________

Possible Witness to subpoena for questioning - Name: __________________________________________________

Address ____________________________________________________________________________________

__________________________________________________________ Telephone # _________________________

Why this witness is vital for questioning - ______________________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________________________________

Matter to be assigned to Juror ID# _________________

With assistance by Juror ID # _____________ and Juror ID # _____________

IMPORTANT: Questioning of a witness must be conducted by the Grand Jury with its entire membership in a scheduledsession. Assigned jurors are prohibited to conduct solo interrogation separately on their own. Grand Jury interrogationshould be done with one witness only at a time. Questioning of more than one witness at a time is prohibited. No attorneyshould be allowed to accompany a witness in the Grand Jury investigation room. No non-juror or outsider should beallowed to observe your interrogation."

- End of Form-

Page 119: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

86

Form GJ-9, Particular Person or Public Official

Planned for Investigation Record.

"THE GRAND JURY

Of the _______ Jury (Legislative) District of:

____________________________________

Grand Jury Term from ___________________ to _____________________

Confidential

Particular Person or Official Planned for Investigation Record

(FOREMAN Must Prepare and Keep this Record Strictly Confidential - Internal Use Only)

GRAND JURY CASE NUMBER ______________

(Case Number originating from Form GJ-30 to be assigned by Foreman)

(Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type)

Date today: ___________________

Name of Particular Person or Official Planned for Investigation _________________________________

Address/Location - ____________________________________________________________________

___________________________________________________ Telephone # _____________________

Possible crime committed by said person or official ___________________________________________

Reason for planned investigation - ________________________________________________________

____________________________________________________________________________________

____________________________________________________________________________________

Possible Witness to subpoena for questioning - Name: ________________________________________

Address______________________________________________________________________________

__________________________________________________ Telephone # _______________________

Why this witness is vital for questioning - ___________________________________________________

____________________________________________________________________________________

Matter to be assigned to Juror ID# _________________

With assistance by Juror ID # _____________ and Juror ID # _____________ IMPORTANT: Questioning of a witness must be conducted by the Grand Jury with its entire membership in a scheduledsession. Assigned jurors are prohibited to conduct solo interrogation separately on their own. Grand Jury interrogationshould be done with one witness only at a time. Questioning of more than one witness at a time is prohibited No attorneyshould be allowed to accompany a witness in the Grand Jury investigation room. No non-juror or outsider should beallowed to observe your interrogation."

- End of form -

Page 120: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

Form GJ-10, Invitation Advertisement for Anonymous Crime Informants.

"NEWS PAPER ADVERTISEMENT TO INVITE WHISTLE BLOWERS”ABOUT COMMISSION OF CRIMES TO THE GRAND JURY

IN THE CITY/PROVINCE OF ______________________

EVERY CITIZEN OR PERSON of this city who has first hand knowledge of the commission of anyserious crime is invited to SECRETLY report his information to the Grand Jury, In crimes of bribery, regardlessof the rank or position in the government of the crime offender, a private citizen who is the giver or offeror inbribery will not be prosecuted for bribery under the rules of Presidential Decree 749 if he will testify against therecipient of his bribe . Only the receiver of the bribe shall be charged. It is not required that you show your namein your report. Do not write your name in the outside of your envelope containing your report. Please do not cometo the grand jury. Grand Jury Rules do not allow grand jurors to see any person who has not received a subpoenaor summons from the Grand Jury. It only needs your written report. Send your report either by mail, or personallydeliver it, to the Clerk of Court, sealed and plainly mark “For Grand Jury” at:_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________Make your report completely as you can. Do some little investigation, if it is possible, but if not, submit whateverinformation you have or know. No need to type. Simply hand print the information. The Grand Jury shall notreveal to the press, media, or anybody, or to any public official any information you will give. Your name will notbe announced in any way. It will be kept very secretly. The job of the Grand Jury is highly confidential:

1. Name of the crime offender - ________________________________________________________________________

2. Office and address where the offender works or lives - ____________________________________________________

________________________________________________________________________________________________

3. Crime he committed __________________________. Name of the victim of his crime ___________________________

________________________________ The approximate date ________________ and time ______________ of the crime.

Place where the crime was committed ___________________________________________________________________

__________________________________________________________. If you have seen how the crime was committed,

please describe here ________________________________________________________________________________.

If the offender is a government official, worker, police, or officer, write the name of his office _________________________

______________ and address _________________________________________________________________________.

________________________________ If he demanded money, write here how much he asked - P___________________.

4. Name of witness eye witness or credible witness _________________________________ Address: Street number and

name _______________________________________________________________ and City _______________________

_________________________________________________________________________________________________.

5. Name of witness eye witness or credible witness _________________________________ Address: Street number and

name _______________________________________________________________ and City _______________________

6. Why and how did you come to know personally the name or identity of the offender of the crime you are reporting? Pleasestate briefly: ________________________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________________________________

Cut out this invitation. Fill it up and mail to the address mentioned above. Do your part and this Grand Jury will secretlyinvestigate the crime which will accuse the offender in court to stand trial before a trial jury of 12 citizens.

Please do your part and help your Grand Jury send to jail all crime offenders in our community. Thanks. The GJ.

-End of form-

Page 121: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

88

Form GJ-11, Extracted Record from Anonymous Report

"THE GRAND JURYOf the _______ Jury (Legislative) District of:

____________________________________Grand Jury Term from ___________________ to _____________________

"ConfidentialForm GJ-11, ExtractED Record from Anonymous Report

(The Assigned Member to a Case Must Prepare and Keep this Record Strictly Confidential - Internal Use Only)

GRAND JURY CASE NUMBER ______________________(Case Number to be assigned by Foreman originating from Form GJ-30)

(Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type)

The information to be written into this form shall be picked up from the information submitted by anonymous informants of crimes:

Name of Offender or Crime Suspect _______________________________________________________________________

Home Address of Suspect - _____________________________________________________________________________

____________________________________________________________________________________________________

Telephone number (if any) ______________________________________________________________________________

Job or Office Name of Suspect - __________________________________________________________________________

Address of Work of Suspect- ____________________________________________________________________________

___________________________________________________________________ Phone # _________________________

Name of Witness or Victim - _____________________________________________________________________________

Address of Witness/Victim - _____________________________________________________________________________

_________________________________________________________________ Phone # __________________________

Date the witness is required to come to testify before the Grand Jury: ____________________________________________

Date the Subpoena was delivered to Clerk of Court for assignment of service - _____________________________________

Name of Clerk of Court ______________________________________________ Telephone - ________________________

Name of Officer assigned to by Clerk of Court to serve the subpoena: ____________________________________________

Name of office or organization of serving officer: _____________________________________________________________

Address of office of serving officer: ________________________________________________________________________

________________________________________________________________ Telephone _________________________

Date of service of subpoena by serving officer to the witness: ___________________________

Name of Current custodian __________________ or whereabouts of the original proof of service of the subpoenato the witness and mark (__)- Herewith attached if already received by the assigned grand juror for the case.

NOTE: You may attach Form GJ-31 of Section 17, of this Rule, the Witness List Form to record additional namesof witnesses you may wish to subpoena in this case."

- End of Form-

Page 122: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

89

Form GJ-12, Grand Jury Subpoena

"THE GRAND JURYOf the _______ Jury (Legislative) District of:

____________________________________Grand Jury Term from ___________________ to _____________________

"Confidential

GRAND JURY SUBPOENA

GRAND JURY CASE NUMBER ________________(Case Number originating from Form GJ-30 shall be assigned by Foreman)

STRICTLY CONFIDENTIAL

In the Matter of the Grand Jury Investigation of: (XXX XXX XXX) Name Withheld per Article III, Section 7(d) of the National Jury Law.

(Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type)

To (Name of witness) _________________________________, greetings:

You are hereby commanded to appear before the Grand Jury of the ___________Jury (Legislative) District

of _________________, on the _______ day of ____________, at the Grand Jury Investigation Room (for

instruction, report to the Clerk of Court, telephone number _____________) in the Court House (indicate

address/city/province where witness will testify) at ___________________________________________

_______________________________________________________________ then and there to testify to

your knowledge in the case which is before this Grand Jury in which (mark the appropriate boxes):

(_)- A certain person named ______________________________ was allegedly (_)killed (_)- seriously

injured (_)robbed (_)subjected to physical torture or abuse (_)Others, specify: _________________

______________________________________________________ in or at (state location of the crime)

____________________________________________________________________________________

(__)- Certain alleged acts of _______________________________________________ have been

committed or had been going on during the period, or sometime prior thereto, (indicate inclusive dates) from

________________ through __________________ and allegedly continuing in the office of, or at, (indicate

location or address) ___________________________________________________________________

____________________________________________________________________________________

and to bring with you the following, it being necessary to use the same as testimony (write below and

itemize by numbering the things, you think, the witness has custody or has physical control of bringing in):

___________________________________________________________________________________

___________________________________________________________________________________

Grand Jury Investigation for: (Nameand nature of crime is withheldpursuant to Article III, Section 7(d) ofthe National Jury Law.)

Page 123: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

90

___________________________________________________________________________________

This Grand Jury will keep your identity absolutely in secret. Your testimony will not be revealed to the public.

You are advised to keep this subpoena strictly confidential. Do not let anybody know about this subpoena.

In a bribery case, if you are a giver or offeror and private citizen, or non-government employed, this Grand

Jury will not charge you for, or you will be exempt from, bribery by authority of Presidential Decree No. 749

if you testify against the recipient of your bribe. With this offer and by this subpoena, if you refuse to testify,

this Grand Jury will accuse you, instead, for obstruction of justice for violation of the National Jury Law

which imposes a penalty of at least three years to five years of imprisonment.

If a third party prevents, or will prevent, you from testifying, you are obliged to testify and you are required

to inform this Grand Jury of the identity and address of such third party regardless of his rank and power

in the government or wealth or fame in the community for investigation and indictment by this Grand Jury

for Obstruction of Justice of such third party for violation of PD No. 1829.

You must appear personally and alone. Do not send your attorney or agent. You are not allowed to bring

in your attorney with you. If your attorney will advise you to refuse to give your testimony without his

presence or insist on staying in the grand jury investigation room, this Grand Jury will charge him for

obstruction of justice and this Grand Jury will indict you for contempt as well as for obstruction of justice for

refusal to testify.

You are absolutely forbidden to carry or bring into the grand jury room any type of cell phone, camera, or

firearm. Violation of this rule will subject you to an automatic indictment for obstruction of justice.

ISSUED BY THIS GRAND JURY THROUGH ITS FOREMAN in the City of _______________, this _______

day of _____________, in the year _________.

Recommended for issuance and signed by SIDN _______, Investigating GJ Member.

Issued and signed by SIDN _______, Grand Jury Foreman. SIDN signatures

validated pursuant to Article III, Section 7(b) of the National Jury Law.

Direction for the service of this subpoena

The Grand Jury to The Clerk of Court of the Regional/Municipal Trial Court of ____________, Greeting: You

are hereby commanded to designate the server of, and return, the within subpoena according to law. Dated

at ___________________________, this ______ day of _____________, _______ in the year of our Lord.

Signed with SIDN# ______, of the Secretary of the Grand Jury

SIDN signature validated per Article III, Section 7(b) of the National Jury Law

PROOF OF SERVICE AND DELIVERY OF SUBPOENA

(After being signed by server, the Original of this document

must be submitted to and kept by the Secretary of the Grand Jury)

Page 124: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

91

1. I served this Subpoena by personally delivering a copy thereof to the person named below: (The

personal server must fill in by handwriting in the blanks hereunder)

(a) Name of Person Served __________________________________________

(b) Address where served __________________________________________

__________________________________________

(c) Date/Time of Delivery: _____________, 20___ ______ ___.M

2. [_]- Non-Service Return of Subpoena (fill in and sign if server is unable to serve): After due search,

careful inquiry, and diligent attempts at the dwelling or usual place of abode or usual place of business

or work, I have been unable to make personal delivery of this Subpoena in this District on the person

named therein for the following reason/s:

________________________________________________________________________________

________________________________________________________________________________

____________________________________________I_____________________________________

I declare under penalty of perjury that this failure to serve this subpoena has not been induced with

conspiracy, bribery, or any form of agreement by this server with the person to be served or with a third

party.

3. Information about the Server or Person serving:

Print Full Name- ______________________________ _ (Must sign below)

Occupation- _______________________________________________________________

Address - __________________________________________, ______________________

Telephone Number/s, __________________________ Fax _________________________

I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the Philippines that the foregoing information is true and

correct (Note: Read carefully before signing. Anyone who falsifies a statement in this document shall be

liable for indictment of perjury or of obstruction of justice and for punishment by imprisonment.

____________________, 20______ _________________________________"

(Date Signed) (Signature)

- End of form -

Page 125: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

92

Form GJ-13, Grand Jury Interrogation Quorum and Witness Appearance Record

THE GRAND JURYOf the _______ Jury (Legislative) District of:

____________________________________Grand Jury Term from ___________________ to _____________________

ConfidentialForm GJ-13 - Grand Jury Interrogation Quorum

and Witness Appearance Record

GRAND JURY CASE NUMBER ________________(Case Number originating from Form GJ-30 shall be assigned by Foreman)

(Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type)

Attendance of 14 Members is required to have a quorum.14 Members is required to vote unanimously to present an Indictment in Court.

For other matters, a majority of a quorum can approve such matters.

Date today: _________________

Name of Witness to Testify: _________________________________, SIDN#(x)________

Instruction: Attending members and officers to sign in with their SIDN in the spaces below:

Members: #______ #______ #______ #______ #______ #______ #________

Members: #______ #______ #______ #______ #______ #______ #________

Members: #______ #______ #______ #______ #______ Record Sec #________

Secretary: #________ Stenographer: #(x)________ Interpreter: #(x)__________ (For # with (x), list his/her name in Form GJ-32. Ask Foreman to obtain SIDN listing in Form GJ-32)

Vice Foreman # __________ Foreman #___________

Juror Principally Assigned to this case, ID #____________

NOTE: Fill up this form for each session in dealing with a particular case. Juror In Charge of this case mustwrite briefly, or summarize, below what this case is all about in his preliminary investigation for advanceinformation of the officers and members of the Grand Jury. Write in English or other language or dialectthat all members and officers of the grand jury will understand:

___________________________________________________________________________________

___________________________________________________________________________________________

___________________________________________________________(Attach additional sheet if necessary)

VOTING RESULT: [_]-APRROVE and write the Indictment [_]-DISAPPROVE. Do not indict.Attached all the Secret Ballots, Form GJ-14, to this File.

Confirming GJ Officers by: Foreman SIDN # ____________ Secretary SIDN#__________

- End of Form -

Page 126: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

93

Form GJ-14, Secret Ballot of the Grand Jury.

"THE GRAND JURYOf the _______ Jury (Legislative) District of:

____________________________________

Grand Jury Term from ___________________ to _____________________

"ConfidentialForm GJ-14 - Secret Ballot of the Grand Jury

GRAND JURY CASE NUMBER ______________________(Case Number originating from Form GJ-30 shall be assigned by Foreman)

(Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type)

NOTE: A grand jury decision to indict must be supported by at least

14 "Yes" votes of the members and officers of the grand jury.

Information for #s 2 thru 7 will be announced by Foreman.

1. Ballot Number ______ <Must be prenumbered and authenticated by Secretary, ID# _______>

2. Date of this Ballot _________________

3. Name of Suspected Offender ______________________________________________________

4. Alleged Crime Committed _________________________________________________________

5. Date of Crime Commission ________________________________________________________ 6. Location of the Crime ____________________________________________________________

7. Name of Victim __________________________ (If minor, don't write name - mark [_] )

Information 8 or 9 below will be marked by GJ Voter or Member/Officer

8. [_]- YES. I indict . I found probable cause or reasonable ground to believe that the suspected offender is guilty of the offense charged.

9. [_]- NO. I refuse to indict . I find no probable cause or reasonable ground to believe that the suspected offender is guilty of the offense charged.

10. Date- ________________ (Refer to No. 2 above). 11. Voter's SIDN ______"

- End of Form -

Page 127: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

94

Form GJ-15, Grand Jury Indictment - General Form. Sample Form

(GRAND JURY INDICTMENT - GENERAL FORM)Complaint filings in court must be type-written. Confer with an attorney

"IN THE __________ TRIAL COURT OF _____________

Branch ______, _____ Judicial District of ____________Number and Name of Street _______________________________

Municipality/City/Zip _________________________________________

CRIMINAL CASE NO. ____________

For (Name of Crime)

GRAND JURY INDICTMENT(GJ Case No. _____________)

The People, through the Grand Jury of the _______ Grand Jury District of the City of _____________, beforethis Court hereby present and file this indictment and alleges that the accused, _______________ <Follow the

customary legal form used in filing criminal complaints before this court. If you think it necessary, you may summon

a government prosecutor to assist you in formulating your complaint. Use Form GJ-52 (Found in Art III, Sect. 99, of

the NJL) to summon the prosecutor, or others. You must caution the prosecutor to keep this matter strictly confidential

and warn him that you will file a complaint against him for obstruction of justice for violating the rule of secrecy of the

Grand Jury system. If he will ask for your real names, inform him that under the rules of the Grand Jury, you are not

allowed to disclose your names to anyone whomsoever. As a member of the Grand Jury, you are required to act with

sovereign dignity directly, pursuant to Article II, , Section 1, of the Constitution, in behalf of the sovereign people you

are representing and you must deal with him as your subordinate public servant regardless of his rank, title, position,

nobility or royalty.>

CONTRARY TO LAW (Cite name of law and section or article number).

This Grand Jury with the Oath of its members finding probable cause that the accused has committed the crimecharged, hereby present this Indictment in Court for the prosecution of said accused.

_________________________, Philippines __________________(Municipality/Province/City) (Date)

WITNESSES (Write only the SIDNs of the witnesses for ths Indictment: THE GRAND JURY: Name of witness to be disclosed only afterswearing to start his/her testimony at the trial. Personally signed by its Foreman

with his/her SIDN #______________1. SIDN# _______ of Witness by Authority of Article III, Section 7(b)2. SIDN# _______ of Witness of the National Jury Law. 3. SIDN# _______ of Witness 4. SIDN# _______ of Witness

- End of Form -

The PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES,

Plaintiff,vs

NAME OF OFFENDER, Accused.

Page 128: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

95

Form GJ-16, Grand Jury Indictment - for Perjury. Sample Form.

(GRAND JURY INDICTMENT - FOR PERJURY or FALSE TESTIMONY)Complaint filings in court must be type-written. Confer with an attorney

"IN THE __________ TRIAL COURT OF _____________Branch ______, _____ Judicial District of ____________

Number and Name of Street _______________________________Municipality/City _________________________________________

CRIMINAL CASE NO. _____________

For PERJURY

GRAND JURY INDICTMENT(GJ Case No. ___________)

The People, through the Grand Jury of the _______ Grand Jury District of the City of ___________,before this Court hereby present and file this indictment and alleges that the accused, _____________,<Follow the customary legal form used in filing criminal complaints for Perjury before this court. If you think it necessary,you may summon a government prosecutor to assist you in formulating your complaint. Use Form GJ-52 (Found in Art III,Sect. 99, of the NJL) to summon the prosecutor, or others. You must caution the prosecutor to keep this matter strictlyconfidential and warn him that you will file a complaint against him for obstruction of justice for violating the rule of secrecyof the Grand Jury system. If he will ask for your real names, inform him that under the rules of the Grand Jury, you are notallowed to disclose your names to anyone whomsoever. As a member of the Grand Jury, you are required to act withsovereign dignity directly, pursuant to Article II, , Section 1, of the Constitution, in behalf of the sovereign people you arerepresenting and you must deal with him as your subordinate public servant regardless of his rank, title, position, nobility

or royalty.> CONTRARY TO LAW (Cite name of law, section or article number of Penal Code)

This Grand Jury with the Oath of its members finding probable cause that the accused has committed the crimecharged, hereby present this Indictment in Court for the prosecution of said accused. _________________________, Philippines __________________(Municipality/Province/City) (Date)

WITNESSES (Write only the SIDNs of the witnesses for ths Indictment: THE GRAND JURY:Name of witness to be disclosed only afterswearing to start his/her testimony at the trial. Personally signed by its Foreman

with his/her SIDN #______________1. SIDN# _______ of Witness by Authority of Article III, Section 7(b)2. SIDN# _______ of Witness of the National Jury Law. 3. SIDN# _______ of Witness 4. SIDN# _______ of Witness

- End of Form -

The PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES,

Plaintiff,vs

NAME OF OFFENDER,

Accused.

Page 129: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

96

Form GJ-17, Grand Jury Indictment - for OBSTRUCTION OF JUSTICE - Sample Form.

(GRAND JURY INDICTMENT - FOR OBSTRUCTION OF JUSTICE)

Complaint filings in court must be type-written. Confer with an attorney or Prosecutor"IN THE __________ TRIAL COURT OF _____________Branch ______, _____ Judicial District of ____________

Number and Name of Street _______________________________Municipality/City/Zip _________________________________________

CRIMINAL CASE NO. _____________

For OBSTRUCTION OF JUSTICE

GRAND JURY INDICTMENT(GJ Case No. _______)

The People, through the Grand Jury of the _______ Grand Jury District of the City of ___________, beforethis Court hereby present and file this indictment and alleges that the accused, _____________, <Follow the

customary legal form used in filing criminal complaints for Perjury before this court. If you think it necessary, you may summona government prosecutor to assist you in formulating your complaint. Use Form GJ-52 (Found in Art III, Sect. 99, of the NJL)to summon the prosecutor, or others. You must caution the prosecutor to keep this matter strictly confidential and warn himthat you will file a complaint against him for obstruction of justice for violating the rule of secrecy of the Grand Jury system.If he will ask for your real names, inform him that under the rules of the Grand Jury, you are not allowed to disclose yournames to anyone whomsoever. As a member of the Grand Jury, you are required to act with sovereign dignity directly,pursuant to Article II, , Section 1, of the Constitution, in behalf of the sovereign people you are representing and you must deal

with him as your subordinate public servant regardless of his rank, title, position, nobility or royalty.>

CONTRARY TO LAW (Cite name of law, section or article number of Penal Code)

This Grand Jury with the Oath of its members finding probable cause that the accused has committed the crimecharged, hereby present this Indictment in Court for the prosecution of said accused. _________________________, Philippines __________________(Municipality/Province/City) (Date)

WITNESSES (Write only the SIDNs of the witnesses for ths Indictment: THE GRAND JURY:Name of witness to be disclosed only afterswearing to start his/her testimony at the trial. Personally signed by its Foreman

with his/her SIDN #______________1. SIDN# _______ of Witness by Authority of Article III, Section 7(b)2. SIDN# _______ of Witness of the National Jury Law. 3. SIDN# _______ of Witness 4. SIDN# _______ of Witness

- End of Form -

The PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES,

Plaintiff,vs

NAME OF OFFENDER,

Accused.

Page 130: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

97

Form GJ-18, Memorandum of Non-indictment by the Grand Jury.

"THE GRAND JURYOf the _______ Jury (Legislative) District of:

____________________________________

Grand Jury Term from ___________________ to _____________________

GRAND JURY CASE NUMBER _____________(Case Number to be assigned by Foreman originating from Form GJ-30)

(Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type)

In the Case of:

Suspected Offender - _________________________________________________________________________

Complaining Party - __________________________________________________________________________

Through: (_)- Government Prosecutor (_)- Personally by complaining party (_)- Anonymous Informant

Witness: (_)- Complaining Party (_)- Others (List all here) - _________________________________________

_______________________________________________________________________________

For alleged crime of - _________________________________________________________________________

Date of commission - ________________________ Location of crime - ________________________________

___________________________________________________________________________________________

MEMORANDUM OF NON-INDICTMENT BY THE GRAND JURYWithout prejudice of reinvestigation if additional prima facie evidence is found.

Date today: _________________

AFTER CAREFUL INVESTIGATION of this matter including interrogation of the witness/es and examination ofdocument/s and other piece/s of thing/s offered as evidence by the complaining party, this Grand Jury (signed byits members with their security Identification numbers) FOUND NO PROBABLE CAUSE or reasonable ground toindict the suspected offender over the alleged crime imputed on him.

Instruction: Attending members and officers must personally sign in with their security ID numbers in the spacesbelow. These ID numbers were issued, and authenticated, by the Executive Judge of the Regional Trial Court of__________________________________:

Members: #_______ #_______ #_______ #________ #_______ #_______ #_______

Members: #_______ #_______ #_______ #________ #_______ #_______ #_______

Members: #_______ #_______ #_______ #________ #_______ Record Sec #_______

Secretary: #______ Vice Foreman # _______ Foreman #_______

Juror Principally Assigned to this case, ID #________

Page 131: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

98

The undersigned, Foreman of this Grand Jury, certifies on his/her oath that the pertinentprocedures of the Grand Jury Standard Instructions of the National Jury Law have been compliedwith before the decision to write this non-indictment was arrived at.

GRAND JURY By Its Foreman and Signed with his/her SIDN # _______Pursuant to Article III, Section 7(b) of the National Jury Law.

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

The undersigned Secretary of this Grand Jury has filed with the Clerk of Court this document,including pieces of evidence presented by complaining party for his serving to the concernedcomplaining party, as follows, to:

(__) - The Government Prosecutor (if the complaint was presented by such entity)

(__) - The Complaining Party (if the complaint was originally submitted by complainant)

(__) - NOTE: If complaint was originally initiated by the Grand Jury or anonymous tipster,serve nobody. Keep the file in the Archive.

In the Municipality/City/Province of________________________________________________this ____________ day of the Month of __________________, Year __________

GRAND JURY By Its Secretary and Signed with his SIDN # ______Pursuant to Article III, Section 7(b) of the National Jury Law.

- End of Form -

Page 132: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

99

Form GJ-19, List of Exhibits Form To Support filing of GJ Indictment In Court.

THE GRAND JURY Of the _______ Jury (Legislative) District of:

_____________________________________

Grand Jury Term from ___________________ to __________________

“Confidential

LIST OF EXHIBITS FORM

(The Assigned Member to a Case Must Prepare and

Keep this Record Strictly Confidential - Internal Use Only)

GRAND JURY CASE NUMBER ______________________

(Case Number originating from Form GJ-31 shall be assigned by Foreman)

(Note: Legible hand-print information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type)

Case Assigned to: Juror SIDN# _________

Name of suspected crime offender _______________________________________________________________

Name of Crime/s Committed __________________________________________________________________

LIST OF EXHIBITS

(Designate the Exhibit Number starting with #-1 and attach a Label or Tag to the Exhibit)

Exhibit

Identification

WITNESS

SIDN# DESCRIPTION OF EXHIBIT PURPOSE: TO PROVE WHAT?

Page 133: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

100

Exhibit

Identification

WITNESS

SIDN# DESCRIPTION OF EXHIBIT

PURPOSE: TO PROVE WHAT?

- End of Form -

Page 134: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

101

Form GJ-20, Physician's Certificate of Juror's Illness or Injury Form.

THE GRAND JURY

Of the _______ Jury (Legislative) District of:

_____________________________________

Grand Jury Term from ___________________ to __________________

Confidential

Form GJ-20 - PHYSICIAN'S CERTIFICATE

OF JUROR'S ILLNESS OR INJURY FORM

(The Attending Physician is required to keep documents strictly confidential)

(Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type)

TO WHOM IT MAY CONCERN:

The UNDERSIGNED PHYSICIAN HEREBY CERTIFIES that the bearer who identified himself/herself as

a Grand Juror with SIDN# ______ has submitted for medical consultation and treatment on (date)

_____________. I have thoroughly examined the patient and it appears that (_)-he (_)-she is suffering

from an acute or serious illness medically described as ______________________________________

___________________________________________________________________________________

__________________________________________________________________________________

I ordered complete home rest or hospital confinement at the _______________________ _____________

for this patient from (date)___________ up to (date) __________. I have kept a medical record of this

patient with his true name in my medical file for ready inspection under the exclusive authorization by the

Grand Jury.

My medical license number is _______________ with the Philippine Government Registry of Physicians

or Board.

This certificate is issued under penalty of perjury that the foregoing information are true and correct this

__________ day of the month of _______________, year _______.

Physician's Signature _________________________________

Physician's printed name ______________________________

Business street address ______________________________________________

Mun/City of ____________________, Province __________________, Philippines

- End of Form -

Page 135: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

102

Form GJ-21, Offer of Immunity to a Witness as Giver or Offeror Who Is a Private Citizen in Bribery to a Public Official.

THE GRAND JURY Of the _______ Jury (Legislative) District of:

_____________________________________

Grand Jury Term from ________________ to ________________

Strictly Confidential

OFFER OF IMMUNITY TO A WITNESS AS GIVER OR OFFEROR

WHO IS A PRIVATE CITIZEN IN BRIBERY AGAINST A PUBLIC OFFICIAL

(Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type)

Name of Private Citizen or Person - ______________________________________________________

Business Street Address - _____________________________________________________________

Municipality/City/Province - _____________________________________________________________

Subject: Offer of Immunity from Prosecution in Bribery by a Private Citizen To a Public Official

Greetings:

You are commanded to keep this communication strictly and absolutely confidential. Should you disobey

this confidential or secret warning this Grand Jury shall indict you for obstruction of justice.

It has been brought to the attention of this Grand Jury that you are a witness or had paid or you were

forced to pay an amount or sums of Bribe Money and/or Property to a certain government official said to

be holding office at (name of government office or instrumentality) ___________________________

_______________________________________________________________________________ in the

street address at ______________________________________________________________________

___________________________________________________________________________________

You are hereby summoned to appear personally before this Grand Jury on (date) _________________

at exactly 10'clock in the morning. You are required to contact the Clerk of Court, telephone number

__________________________ in the Court House of the Executive Judge of the Regional Trial Court

of _________________________. The business office address of said Clerk of Court is located at

__________________________________________________________________________________and

present this subpoena to him. He will lead you to the Grand Jury Room.

Page 136: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

103

The purpose of this subpoena is to arrange or to solicit your promise to testify against the subject public

official wherein you will be given a secret identity name not earlier than until you are sworn in at an actual

jury trial and granted immunity from prosecution for bribery if you shall willingly and truthfully testify in this

matter against the recipient of your bribe.

This subpoena, delivered to you by official service by an authorized server of legal matters, will serve

notice to you that should you refuse to testify in this investigation, you will be liable for criminal indictment

by this Grand Jury for obstruction of justice in violation of the National Jury Law.

FAIL NOT under penalty for Obstruction of Justice.

This letter is issued this _____ day of the month of ____________, year ___________,

BY: THE GRAND JURY, By Its Foreman and Signed with his SIDN#________,

and Validated pursuant to Article III, Section 7(b) of the National Jury Law.

Direction for the service of this Offer of

Immunity from prosecution of a Witness

The Grand Jury to The Clerk of Court of the Regional/Municipal Trial Court of _____________, Greetings:

You are hereby commanded to designate the server of, and return, the within subpoena according to law.

Dated at _____________________, this ____ day of ________, _____ in the year of our Lord, BY:

THE GRAND JURY, Signed with the SIDN#________

of its Secretary by authority of Article III, Sec. 7(b)

of the National Jury Law.

PROOF OF SERVICE AND DELIVERY OF THIS OFFER OF IMMUNITY

(After being signed by server, the Original of this document

must be submitted to and kept by the Secretary of the Grand Jury)

1. I served this Offer by personally delivering a copy thereof to the person named below: (The

personal server must fill in by handwriting in the blanks hereunder)

(a) Name of Person Served ___________________________________________________

(b) Address where served ____________________________________________________

_____________________________________________________

(c) Date/Time of Delivery: ______________, 20____ ________ ___.M

Page 137: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

104

2. [_]- Non-Service Return of Offer of Immunity (fill in and sign if server is unable to serve): After due

search, careful inquiry, and diligent attempts at the dwelling or usual place of abode or usual place

of business or work, I have been unable to make personal delivery of this Offer of Immunity in this

District on the person named therein for the reason that ________________________________

__________ _________________________________________________________________________

_________________________________________________________________________________ ___

___________________________________________________________________________________

__________ __________________________________________________________________________

__________________________________________________________________________________

_____________________________________________________________ and I DECLARE UNDER

PENALTY OF PERJURY that this non-service to the witness was not procured by conspiracy or bribery

with the said witness or with a third party.

3. Information about the Person serving:

Full Name (must sign below) - ____________________________________________________

Occupation - [_]-Official Server [_]- _________________________________________________

Name of organization or business - _________________________________________________

Address - _____________________________________________________________________

_____________________________________________________________________

Telephone Number ______________________ Fax Number _____________________

I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the Philippines that the foregoing information is true

and correct (Note: Read carefully before signing. Anyone who falsifies a statement in this document shall

be liable for indictment of perjury or of obstruction of justice and for punishment by imprisonment.

____________________, 20______ _________________________________

(Date Signed) (Signature)

- End of form -

Page 138: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

105

Form GJ-22, Offer of Immunity From Prosecution To a WitnessIn a Bribery By Public Officials or Election Voter.

THE GRAND JURY of the _______ Jury (Legislative) District of:

_____________________________________

Grand Jury Term from ________________ to __________________

(Strictly Confidential)OFFER OF IMMUNITY FROM PROSECUTION TO A WITNESS IN ABRIBERY BETWEEN PUBLIC OFFICIALS OR ELECTION VOTER

(Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type)

Name of the Public Official- ___________________________________________________________Public Position or Title - ___________________________________________________________Business Street Address - ___________________________________________________________Municipality/City/Province - ___________________________________________________________

Subject: Offer of Immunity to a Recipient in Bribery from Prosecution who is a PublicOfficial or an Election Voter Against A Giver who is a Public Official

Greetings:

You are commanded to keep this communication strictly and absolutely confidential. Should you disobeyor violate this confidential or secret warning, this Grand Jury shall indict you for obstruction of justice.

It has been brought to the attention of this Grand Jury that you had accepted or had been enticed to acceptan amount or sums of money, or property or your placement in a more privileged government position orpromotion to enable the giver or offeror in a bribery transaction to unduly gain more power or privilege orpublic position to the giver or offeror of the Bribe.

Said official and giver or offeror of the bribe is or may be holding office at (name of government office orinstrumentality) _______________________________________________________ with business streetaddress at ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________. You are hereby summoned to appear personally before this Grand Jury on (date) _________________at exactly 10'clock in the morning. You are required to contact the Clerk of Court, telephone number_____________________ in the Court House of the Executive Judge of the Regional Trial Court of_________________________. The business office address of said Clerk of Court is located at__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ andpresent this subpoena to him. He will lead you to our Grand Jury Room.

The purpose of this subpoena is to arrange or to solicit your promise to testify against the subject publicofficial wherein you will be given a secret identity name not earlier than until you are sworn in at a jury trialagainst the public official described above and you will be granted immunity from prosecution for briberyif you shall willingly and truthfully testify in this matter against the described public official above.

This subpoena, delivered to you by official service by an authorized server of legal matters, will servenotice to you that should you refuse to testify in this investigation, you will be liable for criminal indictmentby this Grand Jury for obstruction of justice in violation of the National Jury Law.

FAIL NOT under penalty for Obstruction of Justice.

This letter is issued this _____ day of the month of ____________, year ___________, BY:

THE GRAND JURY

THE GRAND JURY, Signed with the SIDN#________of its Foreman by authority of Article III, Sec. 7(b)of the National Jury Law.

Page 139: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

106

Direction for the service of this Offer of Immunity from prosecution of a Witness

The Grand Jury to The Clerk of Court of the Regional/Municipal Trial Court of _____________, Greetings:You are hereby commanded to designate the server of, and return, the within subpoena according to law.Dated at _____________________, this ____ day of ________, _____ in the year of our Lord, BY: THE GRAND JURY, Signed with the SIDN#________of its Secretary by authority of Article III, Sec. 7(b)of the National Jury Law.

PROOF OF SERVICE AND DELIVERY OF THIS OFFER OF IMMUNITY(After being signed by server, the Original of this document

must be submitted to and kept by the Secretary of the Grand Jury)

1. I served this Offer by personally delivering a copy thereof to the person named below: (Thepersonal server must fill in by handwriting in the blanks hereunder)

(a) Name of Person Served __________________________________________

(b) Address where served __________________________________________

__________________________________________

(c) Date/Time of Delivery: ______________, 20___ ______ _.M

2. [_]- Non-Service Return of Offer of Immunity (fill in and sign if server is unable to serve): After duesearch, careful inquiry, and diligent attempts at the dwelling or usual place of abode or usual placeof business or work, I have been unable to make personal delivery of this Offer of Immunity in thisDistrict on the person named therein for the reason that _________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ and IDECLARE UNDER PENALTY OF PERJURY that this non-service to the witness was not procured by conspiracy or bribery with the said witness or with a third party.

3. Information about the Person serving:

Full Name (must sign below) - _____________________________________________________

Occupation - [_]-Official Server [_]- _________________________________________________

Name of organization or business - _________________________________________________

Address - _____________________________________________________________________

_____________________________________________________________________

Telephone Number ________________________ Fax Number ______________________

I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the Philippines that the foregoing information is trueand correct (Note: Read carefully before signing. Anyone who falsifies a statement in this document shallbe liable for indictment of perjury or of obstruction of justice and for punishment by imprisonment.

____________________, 20______ _________________________________ (Date Signed) (Signature)

- End of form -

Page 140: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

107

Form GJ-23, Foreman's Recommendation to Terminate a Member of the Grand Jury.

THE GRAND JURY of the _______ Jury (Legislative) District of:___________________________________

Grand Jury Term from ___________________ to _____________________

ConfidentialForm GJ-23 - FOREMAN'S RECOMMENDATION

TO TERMINATE A MEMBER OF THE GRAND JURY(Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type)

Date today _______________

The Honorable Executive Judge

Regional Trial Court of _______________________________________________

Municipality/City/Province _____________________________________________

Subject: Recommendation to Terminate Membership of Juror SIDN ________ from the Grand Jury

GREETINGS:

The undersigned is the Foreman of the current Grand Jury.

I respectfully recommend for the termination of the subject for the following reason(s):

[_] - Inexcusable absences jury sessions or proceedings. He/She has now been absent ____times.

[_] - Failed to notify the undersigned in most and/or all occasions of his/her absence. [_] - Refused to provide written justification of his/her absences.

[_] - Insubordination. Refused or neglected to perform the needed action on cases assigned to him/her. This has happened _____ times.

[_] - Violation of Confidentiality of proceedings. Specify: ____________________________________

________________________________________________________________________________________

[_] - Drunkenness and/or drug abuse. Specify: _____________________________________________

[_] - Tardiness in reporting for jury duty. Specify dates and how many times: ______________________________________________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________________________

Page 141: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

108

[_] - Performing field work without prior notification and/or permission.

I recommend that the juror’s per diem be paid up to the date of the issuance of thisrecommendation shown below and none after said date.

The undersigned certifies that he/she has personally served or furnished a copy of thisrecommendation letter to the grand juror concerned this ______ day of the month of______________, year ________.

Respectfully yours,

THE GRAND JURY, Signed with the SIDN#________of its Foreman by authority of Article III, Sec. 7(b)

of the National Jury Law. .

- End of Form -

Page 142: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

109

Form GJ-24, Members' Recommendation to Expel Foreman from the Grand Jury

THE GRAND JURY of the _______ Jury (Legislative) District of:

_____________________________________

Grand Jury Term from ___________________ to _____________________

Confidential

Form GJ-24 - MEMBERS' RECOMMENDATION TO EXPEL FOREMAN FROM THE GRAND JURY

(Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type)

Date today _______________

The Honorable Executive Judge

Regional Trial Court of _______________________________________________

Municipality/City/Province _____________________________________________

Subject: Recommendation to Expel Foreman SIDN _______ from the Grand Jury

GREETINGS:

The undersigned are bonafide Members of the current grand jury.

We respectfully recommend for the expulsion of the subject Grand Jury Foreman for the reasons

stated below (mark the applicable boxes):

[_]- Inexcusable absences jury sessions or proceedings. He/She has now been absent ____

times.

[_] - Failed to notify our secretary in most and/or all occasions of his/her absence.

[_] - He has no explanation to us for his/her frequent absences.

[_]- For close association with public officials suspected of corruption or potential subject of

grand jury investigation for corrupt or graft practices or for the commission of a crime.

Specify: ___ __________________________________________________________________________

___________________________________________________________________________

[_]- Gross ignorance of Grand Jury Standard Instruction. [_]- His agenda is disorganized. Lacks

Page 143: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

110

coordination with the assigned tasks to us, grand jury members.

[_]- Violation of Confidentiality of proceedings. Specify: ____________________________________

___________________________________________________________________________________________

____________________________________________________________________________

[_]- Drunkenness and/or drug abuse. Specify: ______________________________________

____________________________________________________________________________

[_]- Tardiness in reporting for jury duty. Specify dates and how many times: ________________

_____________________________________________________________________________

[_] - Performance of field work without prior planning or coordination.

The undersigned certify that they have personally served or furnished a copy of this

recommendation letter to the grand jury foreman concerned this ____ day of the month of

_________, year ________.

(At least 6 Grand Jurors are required to sign this recommendation)

Respectfully yours,

Grand Juror SIDN _______ Grand Juror SIDN ________ Grand Juror SIDN ________

Grand Juror SIDN _______ Grand Juror SIDN ________ Grand Juror SIDN ________

- End of form -

Page 144: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

111

Form GJ-25, Oath of the Grand Juror .

THE GRAND JURY Of the _______ Jury (Legislative) District of:

_____________________________________

Grand Jury Term from ___________________ to _____________________

Confidential

Form GJ-25 - OATH OF THE GRAND JUROR

"I will support the Constitution of the Philippines and all laws made in pursuance thereof

and in conformity therewith, will diligently inquire into, and true presentment make, of all public

offenses against the people of the Philippines, committed or triable within this municipality or city

as well as within this province, of which the Grand Jury shall have or can obtain legal evidence.

I will keep my own counsel, and that of my fellow grand jurors and of the government, and

will not, except when required in the due course of judicial proceedings or authorized by statute,

disclose the testimony of any witness examined before the Grand Jury, nor anything which I or

any other grand juror may have said, nor the manner in which I or any other grand juror may have

voted on any matter before the Grand Jury.

I will present no person through malice, hatred or ill will, nor leave any unpresented through

fear, favor, or affection, or for any reward, or the promise or hope thereof; but in all my

presentments I will present the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, according to the

best of my skill and understanding, so help me God."

Signed by the Grand Juror with his SIDN __________.

NOTE: The inducting judge must keep this document with the

confidential GJ application records of the subject member.

- End of Form -

Page 145: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

112

Form GJ-26, Certificate of Truthfulness by the Suspected Offender.

THE GRAND JURY Of the _______ Jury (Legislative) District of:

_____________________________________

ConfidentialCERTIFICATE OF TRUTHFULNESS BY THE SUSPECTED OFFENDER

NOTICE to the suspected offender : Filing of this document is voluntary. You are not compelledto file this document with the Grand Jury but if you do so, the text or wording in this form shouldnot be modified or changed. Warning : Do not attach to this form any falsified affidavit ordocument. If you do so, you and anyone who assisted you will be indicted or accused in court bythe Grand Jury for Perjury and/or for Obstruction of Justice. You must consult your lawyer beforesubmitting this document and its attachments to this Grand Jury. Do not appear in person beforethis Grand Jury. Your presence is absolutely not required. This Grand Jury is not a court. It is anindependent secret investigative body in behalf of the people against crime suspected offenders.

(This is a Durable Form. It must not be amended in any way)(Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type)

GREETINGS:

It has come to the attention of the undersigned that he is being investigated by this GrandJury for an alleged crime of _________________________________________________________.

I profess innocence from the imputed crime. I hereby submit the herein attacheddocuments consisting of a total of _____ pages or sheets. I have serially numbered with my ownhand said pages or sheets beginning with number "1" through "_______", the last page,consecutively, at the bottom right hand margin in each page. I have read each numbered pageand I fully understand its content.

[_]- Check this box if applicable: [_] - I was assisted by a lawyer.

Mark the applicable box: The lawyer [_]-is [_]-is not - my attorney in this case.

I believe he/she is a lawyer for: _________________________________________________

The name of the lawyer is: ______________________________________________________

His business address is: _______________________________________________________

In the Municipality/City/Province: ________________________________________________

I declare, affirm and certify under penalty of perjury before this Grand Jury under the lawsof the Philippines that the information given in the document/s herewith attached represent thetruth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth of the matters stated therein. The number on eachpage which I have personally written, as indicated above, signifies that I have verified andauthenticated the said referred documents.

I am submitting this Certificate of Truthfulness for my own defense with no intention to

obstruct, impede, frustrate or delay the apprehension, investigation or prosecution of the prime

Page 146: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

113

criminal suspect or suspects in this case.

Issued on the _______ day of the month of _______________, year ________ in the

Municipality/City/Province of _______________________________________________________

By: (Sign) ___________________________ (Print Name) _________________________

Address _______________________________________________________________

_______________________________________________________________

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

ALTERNATE TO THE FILING OF THIS CERTIFICATE

Instead of filing this Certificate with the Grand Jury, you may submit names and address andoccupation or employment of a witness or witnesses who have personal and direct knowledge ofinformation or facts who will testify truthfully to attest your innocence of the alleged crime beinginvestigated against you but you cannot come along with him/them in the secret GJ investigatingroom - not even your attorney - and DON’T ATTEMPT TO DO SO. Keep this matter absolutelyconfidential.

Name: ________________________________ Occupation: _______________________

Address __________________________________________________________________

Name: ________________________________ Occupation: _______________________

Address __________________________________________________________________

Use additional sheet/s of paper, if necessary, for other witnesses

- End of form -

Page 147: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

114

Form GJ-27, Unconditional Non-transferable Redeemable Judicial Voucher.

REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINESOffice of the National Treasurer of the Philippines

Official Address ________________________

UNCONDITIONAL NON-TRANSFERABLE REDEEMABLE JUDICIAL VOUCHER

UNRJ Voucher Number ____________________ Signed by _______________________, National Treasurer.

Printed in money textured paper and prenumbered under the control and accounting of the National Treasurer of thePhilippines for distribution to the offices of an Executive Judge of the Philippines in the care of his Clerk of Court. It isunlawful to copy or photocopy this voucher in any manner. A copy of this document is valueless and null and void andcriminally unlawful. This voucher form shall be kept in the custody of the Clerk of Court of each judicial district in thecountry.

This voucher is an unconditional non-transferable redeemable obligation of the Republic of the Philippines and promptlypayable upon demand by the payee at any government treasurer’s office or at any bank in favor of, and payable to, andupon presentment of, its payee described and identified below. If a Trial Juror has not been seated in a particularcase, mark “Case#” with “Not Seated” or “N.S. ” or “S” if seated. The Payor, a bank or government treasurer or paymaster shall in turn demand for reimbursement from the Jury Fund in the care of the Supreme Court. The SupremeCourt Jury Fund shall be used to pay to no other than a payee listed below and shall be subject to unannounced auditby an Auditor of the Commission on Audit.

PAY TO:[_]-Grand Juror w/ SIDN# ____________ Membership from: [_]-Jan to June [_]-Jul to Dec Year ___________

[_]-Trial Juror with SIDN#_______________ Court Branch/Sala _______________________________ Case #_________________

[_]-Pro-Temp Judge Name ___________________________________ Court _____________________ Case #_________________

[_]-CD Prosecutor’s Name ___________________________________ Court ______________________ Case #_________________

[_]-PB Def Atty’s Name ____________________________ Court_________________ Case #_____________[_]-Mistaken Convict’s Name _______________________ Court ________________ Case # ____________[_]-Food Caterer’s Name ________________________________________ Court Branch/Sala __________________________

[_]-Ride Providers Name ________________________________________ Court Branch/Sala __________________________

[_]-Other: Payee’s Name ________________________________________ Court Branch/Sala __________________________

In the Amount of (in figures)- P

________________________________________________________________________________

(Amount written in words)

For his/her/its participation with the activities in the governance of justice as marked above in the Court as indicated abovein the following date(s) [_]-__________________________ ________________or [_]-in the case of Grand Juror SIDN-Payee or TrialJuror SIDN-Payee for the period from (date) ________________ to (date) ________________ upon presentment of thisvoucher for payment. The paying cashier, treasury or bank shall thereupon seek reimbursement of the paid voucher fromthe Jury Fund in the custody of the Supreme Court in accordance with the National Jury Law.

PAYMENT APPROVED on date (mm/dd/yyyy) / / BY:

Signature ______________________________________ Printed Name_______________________________________________

Supervising [_]-Regional [_]-Provincial [_]-Metro [_]-City [_]-Municipal [_]-Sharia Trial Judge [_]-Provincial [_]-City FiscalExecutive Judge, Reg.Trial Court (For [_] Grand Jurors [_]-JP Pro Temp Judge [_]-Community Deputy Prosecutor [_]-Deputy Public Defenders Vouchers); [_]- Other Service pertaining to Jury System Law Activities Voucher), at:

Name of Court - ____________________________________________________________________________________

Branch or Sala Number- _____________________________________________________________________________

Address of Court - ___________________________________________________________________________________

___________________________________________________________________________________

Note: Secretly report to your Grand Jury any anomaly or “kick back” committed in using this form. If a bribe solicitor is askingyou to pay a bribe to the solicitor and you have paid the bribe, you will be exempt from prosecution if you report and testify incourt against the recipient of your bribe. Refer to the Standard Grand Jury Instruction provisions.

Page 148: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

115

Form GJ-28, Request by the Grand Jury for Special Police Protection.

THE GRAND JURYOf the _______ Jury (Legislative) District of:

_____________________________

Grand Jury Term from ______________ to ________________

The National Police DirectorPhilippine National PoliceCamp Crame, Quezon City

(HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL)

REQUEST BY THE GRAND JURY FOR SPECIAL POLICE PROTECTION(Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type)

GREETINGS:

This Grand Jury hereby requests your command for police protection upon receipt of this communication. This request is made pursuant to the pertinent rules of the National Jury Law that implements the sovereign

power of the people in Article II, Section 1 of the Philippine Constitution. This request requires strictobservance of the secrecy rules in said section of the Jury Rules beyond the level of secrecy by which you may

have been bound to observe in your organization in view of the highly confidential function of the Grand Jury.This request is: [_]-Urgent [_]-Precautionary.

This Grand Jury is currently investigating, or it is starting to launch an investigation of a crime involving a high

profiled person for a serious offense and said person is believed to be well entrenched by his position, poweror influence in the government or in the community with highly armed followers of undetermined number. Said

person may: [_]-already have known [_]-not have known yet - this Grand Jury investigation.

At this time, the Grand Jury needs (#) __________ police personnel to protect its members in reporting to anddeparting from their grand jury duties. Except for each member of this Grand Jury who must show you his

SIDN# (security identification number) that indicate the period of his grand jury membership and signed by theExecutive Judge of this Jury District, you shall not allow any person or any public official, regardless of his rank

or position in the government or any government instrumentality unless such person or public official is inpossession of a subpoena or summons from this Grand Jury signed by the SIDN# of its foreman or secretary

and such person or official is escorted by the Clerk of Court to enter this Grand Jury Investigation Room.Please contact the Clerk of Court, telephone number _______________, of the court of the Executive Judge

in the Regional Trial Court of ____________________________________________________________ at(municipality/city/province) ______________ __________________________________________for inquiry of

the vicinage of this Grand Jury where the police personnel will be deployed.

This request is issued on this ______ day of the month of __________, year _______, BY:

THE GRAND JURY, Signed with the SIDN#________of its Foreman by authority of Article III, Sec. 7(b)

of the National Jury Law. Page 1 of 3

Page 149: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

116

Direction for the service of this Request for Speci al Police Protection

The Grand Jury to The Clerk of Court of the

Regional/Municipal Trial Court of ________________________ ______________________________,

Greeting: You are hereby commanded to designate the server of, and return, the within request according to

law. Dated at _____________________ ____________, this ____ day of ________________, _______ in

the year of our Lord, BY:

THE GRAND JURY, Personally signed with the

SIDN#________of its Secretary by authority of

Article III, Sec. 7(b) of the National Jury Law.

PROOF OF SERVICE AND DELIVERY OF THIS FOR POLICE PROTECTION

(After being signed by server, the Original of this document

must be submitted to and kept by the Secretary of the Grand Jury)

1. I served this Offer by personally delivering a copy thereof to the person named below: (The personal

server must fill in by handwriting in the blanks hereunder)

(a) Name of Person Served ____________________________________________________

(b) Address where served _____________________________________________________

_____________________________________________________

(c) Date/Time of Delivery: _____________, 20___ __________ _________.M

2. [_]- Non-Service Return of Offer of Immunity (fill in and sign if server is unable to serve): After due

search, careful inquiry, and diligent attempts at the dwelling or usual place of abode or usual place of

business or work, I have been unable to make personal delivery of this Offer of Immunity in this District

on the person named therein for the following reason:

__________________________________________________________________________________

__________________________________________________________________________________

__________________________________________________________________________________

__________________________________________________________________________________

Page 2 of 3

Page 150: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

117

3. Information about the Server or Person serving:

Full Name- ________________________________ (must sign below)

Occupation- [_]-Official Process Server [_]-______________________

Name of Office/Organization - ____________________________________________________

Address - _____________________________________________________________

_____________________________________________________________________

Telephone Number ___________________ Fax Number _______________________

I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the Philippines that the foregoing information

is true and correct (Note: Read carefully before signing. Anyone who falsifies a statement in this

document shall be liable for indictment of perjury or of obstruction of justice and for punishment

by imprisonment.

Date signed: ______________, 20______ Place: ____________________________________

Signature: __________________________ Printed Name ______________________________

Page 3 of 3

Page 151: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

118

Form GJ-29, Declaration of Dissolution of the Grand Jury by its Members.

THE GRAND JURY

Of the _______ Jury (Legislative) District of:

_____________________________

Grand Jury Term from ______________ to ________________

ConfidentialForm GJ-29 - DECLARATION OF DISSOLUTION

OF THE GRAND JURY BY ITS MEMBERS(Blank Form GJ-30 should be attached to this declaration upon filing with the Clerk of Court)

(Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type)

The Honorable Executive Judge

Regional Trial Court of ______________________Jury (Legislative) District of ___________________

Address ___________________________________________________________________________

GREETINGS:

The undersigned 10 members of this Grand Jury, pursuant to its Grand Jury Standard InstructionNumber (46) hereby declare for the dissolution of this Grand Jury. The reasons for this declaration are:

(_)-disloyalty, (_)-apparent corruption (_)-lack of interest to perform the functions - by the majority of itsmembers and officers.

SPECIFICATION TO SUPPORT DECLARATION

[_]-DISLOYALTY: Close association of most of its members with suspected offenders. Add other acts

of disloyalty here: ___________________________________________________________________________

___________________________________________________________________________________________

___________________________________________________________________________________________

[_]-APPARENT CORRUPTION Specify here: [_]-Impulsive gambling [_]-Others__________________

___________________________________________________________________________________________

___________________________________________________________________________________________

Page 1 of 2

___________________________________________________________________________________________

__________________________________________________________________________________

[_]-LACK OF INTEREST TO PERFORM GRAND JURY FUNCTIONS: [_]-Failure to learn or follow

instructions. [_]-Habitual tardiness of members in reporting for jury duty. [_]- Disorganized keeping ofgrand jury records. [_]-Failure to follow up investigation on crimes reported by victims or anonymous

informants. [_]-In the last 4 sessions, there were always 13 or less members present and lack of quorumto do business by the Grand Jury. [_]-Others (Specify)___________________________________________

Page 152: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

119

___________________________________________________________________________________________

___________________________________________________________________________________________

___________________________________________________________________________________________

___________________________________________________________________________________________

__________________________________________________________________________________

___________________________________________________________________________________________

__________________________________________________________________________________

___________________________________________________________________________________________

__________________________________________________________________________________

___________________________________________________________________________________________

__________________________________________________________________________________

___________________________________________________________________________________________

__________________________________________________________________________________

Declaration Date: ________________ Date Filed with Clerk of Court: ____________

The SIDN#s of the 10 members of this Grand Jury seeking its dissolution are as follows:

SIDN#_______ SIDN#_______ SIDN#_______ SIDN#_______ SIDN#_______

SIDN#_______ SIDN#_______ SIDN#_______ SIDN#_______ SIDN#_______

Page 2 of 2

- End of Form -

Page 153: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

120

Form GJ-30, Order to Show Cause Why this Grand Jury Shall Not Be Dissolved.

OFFICE Of The EXECUTIVE JUDGERegional Trial Court of ____________________

Street Address _______________________________________Municipal, City, Provincial Address _____________________________

Grand Jury Term from ______________ to ________________

(Strictly Confidential - Must Not Be Publicized In Anyway)Form 30- ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE WHY THIS

GRAND JURY SHALL NOT BE DISSOLVED

IN THE MATTER OF THE DECLARATIONOF THE DISSOLUTION OF THE GRAND CASE NO. ________________JURY.

DECLARANTS: Grand Jury Memberswith SIDN#s _______ _______ _______ Part "A" - ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE _______ _______ _______ _______ _______ _______ _______ Part "B" - ORDER TO DISSOLVE OR RETAIN THE GRAND JURY X - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - X

PART A - ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE

(Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type)

The members of the Grand Jury with SIDN#s: _______ _______ _______ _______ _______ _______ _______ _______ _______ _______ _______ _______ _______ for their current term of duty [_]-from January through June, year _______ [_]-fromJuly through December, year ______ are hereby all ordered to appear before this court on(date) __________ at (time) _________ o'clock in the [_]-morning [_]-afternoon to showcause why this grand jury shall not be dissolved over and against the allegation of the aboveDeclarants as stated within their herein Declaration dated ____________.

Grand Jury Standard Instruction No. (46) requires that:

1. All 13 of you shall appear before this court as scheduled above; and2. You shall bring in all your Grand Jury records for examination or verification.

Should you fail to comply both requirements 1 and 2 above, this court will find no alternativebut to order with finality in compliance with Grand Jury Standard Instruction No. (46). Part A, the Order to show cause why this Grand Jury shall not be dissolved is hereby issued this______ day of _____________, year ______ for the information and notice to all members of theGrand Jury.

(Signature) _____________________________(Printed) _______________________________(Title) The Executive Judge

Page 154: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

121

PART "B" - ORDER TO [_]-DISSOLVE [_]-RETAIN THE GRAND JURY

(Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type)

This Court held a conference hearing on the Declaration for Dissolution of this Grand Jury as scheduled

above. [_]- ____ members of the Grand Jury appeared without counting the declarants for dissolution.[_]-Said members brought in the following records of accomplishments of the Grand Jury consisting of (list

them here) ________________________________________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

___________________________________________________________________________

They [_]-presented arguments [_]-presented no arguments - disputing the allegations in theDeclaration For Dissolution of the Grand Jury. The findings of this Court are as follows:

1. The required presence of members in court was [_]-complied with [_]-not complied with.

2. The records presented [_]-showed neither substantial accomplishment nor competency of the

current grand jury in the performance of its functions. Specify briefly:

3. Oral arguments presented [_]-has convinced the court [_]-failed to convince the Court -To keep

the members in the remaining term of their office until the end of [_]-June [_]-December this year.The Court found that (specify briefly)

THIS COURT HEREBY ORDERS with finality that the Grand Jury be [_]-Retained. [_]-Dissolved and its

members are hereby further ordered to turn over today all their records to the Clerk of this court for

submission to the succeeding new grand jury members. [_]-The Clerk of Court is ordered to publicly

announce promptly an invitation for the drawing of new set of grand jury members for the balance of the

current term for grand jury duty of the disbanded grand jury members. Prior acts of this Grand Jury shall

remain effective.

Issued this ______ day of _______________, year ___________.

Printed) __________________________ (Signature) _____________________________________

(Title) The Executive Judge

- End of Form -

Page 155: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

122

FORM GJ-31, Foreman’s Master Case Intake Registry - This form should be handled by the Foremanonly.

No action shall be done on a case unless recorded in this registry. Hand-print only.Start your first case also with #-10001 and also continue serially. Start your first page with #-10001 andcontinue serially.

Page No. _________

New Case # DateRecorded

CrimeName

Date ofCrime

Name ofVictim

Name ofSuspect

*DateIndicted

AssignedJuror’s #

NOTES: 1. * Date Indicted, means the date the case was filed in, and stamped by, the clerk of court where it was filed. 2. Bind this record on the left margin. If there are several crimes charged against a single person, enter on one line per case.

Page 156: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

123

Form GJ-32, Non-GJ member SIDN Master Designation Registry.

“THE GRAND JURY Of the _______ Jury (Legislative) District of:

_____________________________________ Page No. _______ (Perpetual Numbering)

(Strictly Confidential)Form GJ-31 - NON-MEMBER SIDN MASTER DESIGNATION REGISTRY(This record must be perpetually passed on to the new set of Grand Jury Members)

(The Foreman and Recording Secretary must have joint custody of this Record)(In the 1st page, start with #3001 and continue serially in perpetuity into the following pages)

Keep this record in the Steel Vault of the Grand Jury. Hand Print the Written Information("Role in this case" - Describe as: "Witness", "Offender", "Victim", "Stenographer", "Translator", Etc.)

AssignedSIDN#

Issue dateof SIDN#

Name of Person to whomthis SIDN is issued

Role In thisCase

GJ CaseNumber

Name ofthe Offender

- End of Form -

Page 157: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

124

Form GJ-33, Agenda Form for Grand Jury Sessions.

THE GRAND JURY Of the _______ Jury (Legislative) District of:

_____________________________________

Grand Jury Term from ___________________ to _____________________

Page No. _______ (Perpetual Numbering)

(Strictly Confidential)

Form GJ-33 - AGENDA FORM FOR GRAND JURY SESSIONS

(Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type)

Legend: "GJ" means "Grand Jury”

AGENDA FOR TODAY - Date: _________________ Day of the Week: _________________

Prepared Jointly By GJ Secretary SIDN#_______ and GJ Foreman SIDN#________

1. GJ Case Number _____________ (To finish yesterday's uncompleted matter)

GJ Member In Charge of the Case: SIDN#_________

2. GJ Case Number _______________ (Obtain the number from Form GJ-31 - ask Foreman)

Name of Offender: _______________________________________ Alias _________________________

Occupation/Profession/Job of the Offender _________________________________________________

Name or description of Crime: _____________________ Law violated: ___________________________

Complaint submitted by: [_]-_____________________________ [_]-Anonymous

Name of Witness: SIDN#_________ (Obtain the number from Form GJ-32 - ask Foreman)

Name of Witness: SIDN#_________ (Obtain the number from Form GJ-32 - ask Foreman)

GJ Member In Charge of the Case: SIDN#_____________

3. Things to do:

[_]- Deliberate and vote to decide. Review the Grand Jury Rules on Deliberation and Decision.

[_]- Prepare Indictment. Review tape record, exhibits, laws, exemption laws.

[_]- Invite attorney or other experts for consultation.

Use hypothetical questions. Don't mention real names.

[_]- Interrogate Witness starting (Time): __________ [_]-AM [_]-PM

[_]- Prepare Form GJ-13

[_]- Prepare Questions, use guide Form GJ-39

[_]- Issue Subpoena to the witness

[_]- Issue Form GJ-10 - Not enough leads. Advertise. Invite anonymous informants.

[_]- Other things to do with this case. Specify: ____________________________________________

________________________________________________________________________________

NOTE: Make sure you bring to completion at least 2 cases a week by filing either an Indictment or Memorandumfor Non-Indictment. You must finish a case within 60 days, excluding Saturdays, Sundays and Holidays from thedate you first docketed or recorded the case on your Form GJ-31. Refer to GJ Standard Instruction No. (38).

- End of Form -

Page 158: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

125

Form GJ-34, Members' Recommendation to Expel Secretary from the Grand Jury.

THE GRAND JURY Of the _______ Jury (Legislative) District of:

_____________________________________Grand Jury Term from ___________________ to _____________________

ConfidentialForm GJ-34 - MEMBERS' RECOMMENDATION

TO EXPEL SECRETARY FROM THE GRAND JURY(Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type)

Date today _______________

The Honorable Executive JudgeRegional Trial Court of _______________________________Municipality/City/Province _____________________________________________

Subject: Recommendation to Expel Secretary SIDN# _______ from the Grand Jury

GREETINGS:

The undersigned are bonafide Members of the current grand jury.We respectfully recommend for the expulsion of the subject Grand Jury Secretary for the reasons stated below:

[_]- Inexcusable absences jury sessions or proceedings. He has now been absent ____ times. [_]- Failed to notify our Foreman in most and/or all occasions of his absence. [_]- He has no explanation to us for his frequent absences.

[_]- For close association with public officials suspected of corruption or potential subject of grand jury investigation for corrupt or graft practices or for the commission of a crime.

[_]- Gross ignorance of Grand Jury Standard Instruction. [_]- His agenda is disorganized. Lacks coordination with the assigned tasks to us, grand jury members.

[_]- Violation of Confidentiality of proceedings. Specify: _____________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________________________

[_] - Drunkenness and/or drug abuse. Specify: ____________________________________________________

[_] - Frequent tardiness in reporting for jury duty. Specify dates and how many times: _____________________

_____________________________________________________________________________________

[_] - Performing of field work without prior planning or coordination.

The undersigned certify that they have personally served or furnished a copy of this recommendation letter to thegrand jury secretary concerned this ____ day of the month _________, year ________.(At least 6 Grand Jurors are required to sign this recommendation).

Respectfully yours,

Grand Juror SIDN _________ Grand Juror SIDN _________ Grand Juror SIDN _________

Grand Juror SIDN _________ Grand Juror SIDN _________ Grand Juror SIDN _________

- End of Form -

Page 159: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

126

Form GJ-35, Authenticated Sidn#s of the Grand Jury Members for the Current Period.

REGIONAL TRIAL COURTOffice of the Executive Judge

________ Jury (Legislative) District of:__________________________________________

(Confidential)

Form GJ-35 - AUTHENTICATED SIDN#s OF THE GRAND JURY MEMBERS FOR THE PERIOD FROM _________________ TO ________________(Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type)

IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE RULES OF THE JURY SYSTEM promulgated by the Supreme Court on (Date)

____________, the following Security Identification Numbers, briefly known as SIDN (no more than 23) are herebycertified and authenticated as valid numbers issued by the undersigned Executive Judge of the above courtfor the members of the Grand Jury in the _____Jury (Legislative) District of _______________________for the period from [_]-JANUARY through JUNE [_]-JULY through DECEMBER - year: ________ :

_______ _______ _______ _______ _______ _______ _______ _______ _______

_______ _______ _______ _______ _______ _______ _______ _______ _______

_______ _______ _______ _______ _______ .

These SIDNs shall be valid for use only within the same period shown on the execution date or stamp filingdate with the Clerk of Court on any document including but not limited to indictments issued by the GrandJury.

The matching actual names respectively for said SIDNs of the members of the Grand Jury are heldby the undersigned with strict confidentiality and no disclosure thereof will be granted except by subpoenaissued by a Grand Jury.

This Authentication Notice is issued for the confidential reference by Judicial and ProsecutingAuthorities for purposes of accepting the validity of the official acts of the Grand Jury in this Jury(Legislative) District.

This will amend the prior Authenticated SIDN#s of the Grand Jury Members for the currentperiod. Issued with the Seal of its Office this _______ day of ______________, year _________. BY:

Printed Name: _____________________________ Signature: ____________________________

Title Executive Regional Trial Judge"

(IMPRESS COURT SEAL BELOW)

- End of Form -

Page 160: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

127

Form GJ-36 - Optional Exceptional Notice to Crime Suspect of Investigation:

THE GRAND JURY Of the _______ Jury (Legislative) District of:

_____________________________________Grand Jury Term from ___________________ to _____________________

ConfidentialForm GJ-36 - Optional Notice

TO CRIME SUSPECT OF INVESTIGATION(Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type)

Name of Suspected Offender - _______________________________________________Street Address - __________________________________________________________

Municipality/City/Province ___________________________________________________

In the matter of the Criminal Complaint by - _____________________________________For (name of alleged crime) _________________________________________________

GREETINGS:

THIS GRAND JURY has received a criminal complaint described above against you.

This notice-letter is sent to you by this Grand Jury as an optional exception to the strict secrecyrules in Grand Jury Investigations and as a matter of discretion and courtesy extended to you. It is likewise

advised that you keep this matter with utmost confidentiality and you must not, in any manner, disclose itto the public or to anyone.

YOU ARE HEREBY REQUESTED to submit to this Grand Jury a response to the said complaint

within 10 days, excluding Saturdays, Sundays and Holidays, from the date you received this Notification.If you profess that you are completely innocent of the charge, you may, but we do not compel you, to do

either or both of the following acts:

First: Enclosed is a form labelled "Form GJ-26, Certificate of Truthfulness by Suspected Offender",and attach to it your written response to the charge or other documents and by complying the requirements

in it. You are not allowed to change the wordings in said certificate. You are not forced to comply with thesubmission of Form GJ-26 and its attachment, but should you submit the form with statements or

information attached to it, none of the information therein must show any falsity or forgery otherwise youmay be charged with perjury. If we find that the false statement therein or forgery is, or are, intended to

mislead, prevent, delay, frustrate, the prosecution of the real suspected offender in this matter, a furtherindictment by this Grand Jury for obstruction of justice may be filed against you for violation of Presidential

Decree No. 1829 as amended.

Second: You may submit name or names and address of witness/es to us your witness who willtruthfully testify to support your declaration of innocence. If you wish to testify before this grand jury, you

may do so but we shall not compel you to testify, and it is your right to refuse to do so. Should you testifyor your witness shall testify, we demand that you or your witness/es to tell the truth, the whole truth and

nothing but the truth otherwise you, or they, may be charged with perjury. If we find that the falsity in your

Page 161: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

128

statement or in the statement of witness/es is, or are, intended to mislead, prevent, delay, frustrate, theprosecution of the real suspect in this matter, a further indictment by this Grand Jury for obstruction of

justice may be filed against you or against your witness for violation of Presidential Decree No. 1829 asamended. If you want them to testify, you must show this Form GJ-36 to any and all of them to let them

read and make them aware of the information in this document.

Should you testify before this Grand Jury, you will not be allowed to bring in your lawyer. Grand JuryRules do not permit us to let your lawyer to accompany you in the Grand Jury Investigation Room. Neither

you nor your lawyer will be allowed to cross-examine witnesses who appear before this Grand Jury.

Should you wish to discuss this matter with your attorney or to witnesses in your favor, you areadvised that you caution your lawyer or your witnesses to keep this matter likewise with utmost secrecy

and away from publicity.

This Notice is issued this _______ day of _______________, year ______ in the Jury(Legislative) District of __________________________________________,

BY:

THE GRAND JURY, Personally signed with the

SIDN#________of its Foreman by authority of Article III, Sec. 7(b) of the National Jury Law.

Direction for the service of this Exceptional Notic e to Suspected Offender

The Grand Jury to The Clerk of Court of the Regional/Municipal Trial Court of _____________,

Greeting s: You are hereby commanded to designate the server of, and return, the within Optional

Exceptional Notice according to law. Dated at _____________, this ____ day of ________, _____ inthe year of our Lord.

THE GRAND JURY, Personally signed with the SIDN#________of its Secretary by authority of

Article III, Sec. 7(b) of the National Jury Law.

Page 162: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

129

PROOF OF SERVICE AND DELIVERY OF THIS EXCEPTIONAL NOTICE TO SUSPECTED OFFENDER

(After being signed by server, the Original of this documentmust be submitted to and kept by the Secretary of the Grand Jury)

1. I served this Offer by personally delivering a copy thereof to the person named below: (Thepersonal server must fill in by handwriting in the blanks hereunder):

(a) Name of Person Served ____________________________________________

(b) Address where served _____________________________________________

________________________________________________________________

(c) Date/Time of Delivery: _____________, 20___ _______ ___.M

2. [_]- Non-Service Return of Exceptional Notice to Suspected Offender (fill in and sign if serveris unable to serve): After due search, careful inquiry, and diligent attempts at the dwellingor usual place of abode or usual place of business or work, I have been unable to makepersonal delivery of this Offer of Immunity in this District on the person named therein forthe following reasons:

3. Information about the Server or Person serving:

Full Name- ____________________________________________________________

(Must sign below) Occupation- _____________________________________________

Address - _____________________________________________________________ __________________________________________________________________________

Telephone Number ____________________ Fax Number _______________

I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the Philippines that the foregoinginformation is true and correct (Note: Read carefully before signing. Anyone who falsifies astatement in this document shall be liable for indictment of perjury or of obstruction of justice andfor punishment by imprisonment.

____________________, 20______ _________________________________" (Date Signed) (Signature)

- End of Form -

Page 163: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

130

Form GJ-37, Voucher Accounting Record of the Clerk of Court

REGIONAL TRIAL COURTOffice of the Clerk of Court

Office of the Executive JudgeGrand Jury for the _______ Jury (Legislative) District of:

__________________________________________

Form GJ-37- VOUCHER ACCOUNTING RECORD OF THE CLERK OF COURT

(Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type)

Name of Clerk of Court:__________________________________Telephone____________________

Name of Court ______________________________________________________________________Address ___________________________________________________________________________

INSTRUCTION: 1. Draw the vouchers in chronological sequence of their serial numbers; 2. Keep spoiled

vouchers in a 3 ring binder of 8-1/2 by 11" size for audit along with this Accounting Record in the same binder;

3. Enter in this record promptly on the same day a voucher is prepared and one voucher only in each line; 4.If a voucher is spoiled, enter voucher number, date, intended payee’s name or SIDN and write the word

"VOIDED" on the " Money Amount" column and “1" under “Voucher Quantity Issued; 5. Clerk of Court must

send a photocopy of this Record every end of the month to the National Treasurer of the Philippines; 6. This

record is subject to audit by COA without prior notice; 7. Any figure in "Quantity Count Difference" should be

explained; 8. Count all lines for voucher forms used including the spoiled forms and enter in the line " issued

to individual payees (including spoiled forms) ."

Voucher Forms Audit Procedures: Period from (date) _____________ to (date) _____________

A- Quantity of Voucher Forms PER BOOKS:

Quantity of forms at beginning balance . . . . . . . . . . . . . . - _____________

Quantity of forms received during the period above . . . . - _____________

Total quantity of forms in stock during the same period . . - _____________

Number of forms used (Read Instruction No. 8 above) . . - _____________

Quantity balance of voucher forms at end of said period . - _____________

B- Quantity of Voucher Forms PER PHYSICAL COUNT . . . . . . - _____________

C- Quantity Difference between Per Books and

Per Physical Count (Custodian has to explain) . . . . . . . . . . . - _____________(?)

Page 164: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

131

Voucher FORMS USED from beginning period through accounting date or audit date:

Accounting or Audit Period from (date) _____________ to (ending date) ______________

VOUCHERNUMBER

DATEDISPOSED

SIDN or NAMEOF PAYEE

PAY PERIOD MONEYAMOUNT

VoucherIssued

1 per lineFROM TO

P

Total Vouchers issued to individual payees (including spoiled forms) per above -> P

Blank voucher forms from Numbers __________ to ___________ issued to Jury Commissioner,

Name: _________________________at _________ Trial Court at _____________________->

TOTAL Voucher Forms issued out by Clerk of Court (Name)__________________________->

- End of Form -

Page 165: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

132

Form GJ-38, Individual Sidn# Validation by the Executive Judge.

"REGIONAL TRIAL COURTOffice of the Executive JudgeJury (Legislative) District of:

__________________________________________

(Confidential)Form GJ-38- INDIVIDUAL SIDN VALIDATION BY THE EXECUTIVE JUDGE:

(Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type)

SUBJECT: SIDN# _________

Grand Juror’s “Gate Pass” to the Grand Jury Room and in

Collecting Payment on His Unconditional Non-Transferable Redeemable Voucher.

(Valid only for the period from ____________ to ___________)

(This document shall become invalid by any erasure in it)

(It is unlawful to copy this document)

The above Security identification Number (SIDN#) has been assigned by this Court to the bearer

for two limited purposes only, namely:

First: To authorize payment of his Unconditional Redeemable Juror's Voucher on Form GJ-27,

made and drawn payable to the same SIDN# and the pay period falls within the validity period of this

validation document.

Second: To authorize his/her entry to the Grand Jury Investigation Room of this Jury (Legislative)

District within the validity period of this document.

The bearer of this document who impersonates the power belonging to the real owner of this SIDN#

shall be subject to criminal prosecution under Article 177 of the Revised Penal Code of the Philippines.

Issued with the Official Seal of this Court on __________________, year _______

(IMPRESS SEAL BELOW)

Signature: _____________________________

Printed Name: __________________________

Title Executive Regional Trial Judge"

- End of Form -

Page 166: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

133

FORM GJ-39, Instruction and Basic Interrogatory Formby the Grand Jury to the Witness

This Form has three (3) parts that you need to work with. They are Part "A", Part "B", and Part "C".

Part “A” is on Page 128Part “B” is on Page 132Part “C” is on Page 151

VERY IMPORTANT: BEFORE you meet your first witness, you must have read and mastered this entire form,

Parts “A”, “B” and C, AT LEAST TWENTY (20) TIMES. That’s correct, 20 TIMES.

The first part, PART "A", is your instruction on how to prepare yourselves for your meeting withthe witness. First of Rule, never discuss, or argue or be showy, among yourselves, in the presence of

a witness to impress the witness. Any difference of opinion among yourselves should be discussedconfidentially and privately among yourselves.

Second Rule, Memorize it. Witnesses are of different stature and ability. A witness may be a

person who would simply like to answer, "yes" or "no", or whatever paper you may want him to sign orwhatever questions you may ask. Such a witness may be easy to handle.

Other witnesses may be very highly educated or skillful, such as a lawyer or a high government

official and would want to argue and put you down. This type of witnesses would be brainy, proficient,sharp and quick but also evasive in giving the information you are asking. And you must have already

memorized the next paragraph that you are about to read. He may neither answer "yes" nor "no". Toovercome such a witness, psychologically, you must be dressed professionally, at least by wearing your

barong tagalog or coat and tie. You must appear professional. Secondly, all of you should be preparedto act like a foreman and you can accomplish this by memorizing the instructions to the witness in Part

"A". You must show that you, too, are professionals and intelligent and you know what you are doing.If anyone of you is being overpowered by such witness, you must stand by and support your foreman.

You must be united at all times and most of all be polite. Here is a frank answer [MEMORIZE ITTONIGHT] to evasive witnesses and memorize it at heart, THEN PRACTICE IT, RECITE OR SAY IT,

IN YOUR NEXT MEETING TOMORROW IN FRONT OF YOUR FELLOW JURORS. DON’T BE SHY:

"Mr./Ms. Witness, we do not make the rules, the ru les of the jury system. The questionswe are asking you have been written or framed by th e Grand Jury Law and we have no choice butgo by them. We are not allowed to change them. The questions are simple questions and theyonly require simple answers. They are not difficul t to answer if you simply tell the truth andnothing but the truth, and the truth shall set you free. We are not allowed to accept evasiveanswers that tend to cover up the truth or to frust rate, prevent, or stop us from performing thefunction of this Grand Jury. We are likewise instru cted by the Rules that should a witness try tofrustrate, prevent, or stop us from pursuing the fu nction of the grand jury, we would simply filea criminal accusation against such witness for Obst ruction of Justice under Presidential DecreeNo. 1829. So, if you want to stop this proceedings by walking away, then we will do what thegrand jury rules have told us to do. Would you wan t us to proceed with our questions? Thechoice is yours. "

The second is Part "B" of Form GJ-39. Part "B" are basic standard questions that have beenprepared for you to ask the witness. You are not allowed to add, diminish, or modify, those questions.

Page 167: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

134

In this Part "B", you will be dealing with five (5) sets of forms which are as follows:

Form GJ-13 - Grand Jury Quorum Record and Case Summary

Form GJ-31 - The form where you obtain your Grand Jury Case

Number to identify which case you are dealing with.

Form GJ-32 - The form where you hide the true name of every one who

has any involvement about the case and it is the source

form for the SIDNs that you issue apart from your own SIDNs.

Form GJ-39 - This is the form where your basic questions have already been written for you by

the Rules of the Jury System. All you need to do through your foreman is to read

each question to the witness and the witness will simply write in his answers in

the copy of this form that you give him at the start of Part "B" to make your job

very easy. Take note that in this form, no name of any person or company or

some public office is written. Their names are designated with SIDN, the

Security ID Number that you provide for the witness and others in Form GJ-32.

Form GJ-42 - Master how to fill up this form. This form is where you will write the true name

of any person who have any kind of involvement in the grand jury proceedings

such as: the witness, primarily including his address and other personal

information; names of other persons mentioned by the witness , etc., and those

names are then registered in Form GJ-32, where they get their SIDN. Their

SIDNs are then used to identify them in Form GJ-39 and their roles and

connections or facts surrounding the crime that is the subject of your

investigation.

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Page 168: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

135

Form GJ-39 (Part "A")- Instruction to the Grand Jury Officers and Members:

1. It requires a lot of creativity to successfully get a full information from the witness. The basicrule therefore is preparation and there is no substitute for preparation. You must not look like a clumsy

confused navigator in the eyes of your witness. MEMORIZE YOUR ROLE, BE PROFESSIONAL.

2. If you cannot think of any question you plan to ask, begin with six (6) skeletal guides. They

are: "What", "why","who", "where", "when," and “how” . Use anyone of these any time, and make

yourself "curious" of whatever the witness say. Be inquisitive to get more information from the witness.You will never run out of questions with these guide questions: Example:

(a) To know about the WITNESS you are dealing with, ask other questions such as: his birth

date, where he lives, school attainment, his friends, job or profession, family: spouse, children, parents;Remember that a grand jury is not a court and you are not covered by the restrictions of the rules of court

such as asking for hearsay information, leading questions. No one and no lawyer can stop you fromasking any question to the witness.

(b) What the witness know about the suspected OFFENDER Had he heard before a person by

the name of the "offender"; How did the witness learn about such person; Has the witness seen suchperson: Where, when, what he was doing, etc. Anything the witness say about the offender, follow up

with another question to clarify what the witness is saying about the offender- it's like cross examination.

(c) What the witness know about the OFFENSE; If you have access to the Internet, searchabout that offense. Or go to the law library of the court near your grand jury room and do research.

Learn its elements. From what you learn in your research, apply the question: what, who, when, etc.

(d) Does the witness know about other witnesses to the crime? Why the witness think that thisother person is a witness to the crime? Always go back to the basic of asking: Who, where, when, how,

and why.

(e) If a witness is very evasive in his/her answers, you may ask the witness: “Would you consideryourself a crime suspect in this case?” If he says: “No”, then follow up with another question “Why?”.

Let him talk and talk. Follow up with: “Do you know the name of other people who can confirm of whatyou are telling us?” If he says “Yes”, then ask: “who” and “address” of that person.

3. Those of you who are listening, while your foreman is dealing with the witness in PART "B" of

Form GJ-39, make yourself curious and write your question to ask once the interrogator or foreman isdone in asking the Part "B" Interrogatories or questions. You need to prepare your questions for Part

"C" session on Form GJ-39. Always keep in mind the "Why", “What”, When, "Where," "Who" And the"How," Write the 5 W’s and 1 H and memorize them from left to right and right to left. Then you will

sound like a lawyer.

4. If there are some conflicting statements the witness said, ask why. Example as to the date,time, and place, or as to who did or did not do an act.

5. Ask questions to find out if the offender may have "good" reason to commit the crime.

6. When you reach Part "C" of Form GJ-39, what makes it easy to ask question is that you are

not interrupted by objections from a defense attorney because no attorney is allowed to appear with the

Page 169: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

136

witness in your investigating room. If the witness is giving a long story, let him talk, and talk, and talk,and make sure what he is saying is being tape recorded.

7. The more the witness talks, the more chances you have to pause questions on him for

clarification or cross examination.

8. Make your session conversational with the witness and make him feel at home so that he willvolunteer to give more information. Watch out if he is "making a story" that may be false. Now, relax,

don't get mad if he is trying to fool you with his fake story to protect the suspect, then you end up"shooting" 2 birds with "one" bullet. Pretend that you believe what he is saying and ask more questions

where he make more lies to you.

9. Ask the witness if there are more witnesses like him and then subpoena those witnesses whoare, or may be, also liars. Then you end up indicting not only 2 offenders but 3 or more of them and

clean up your community against grafters and liars. Is that not beautiful? Enjoy. Have fun! Make yourday!

10. You file indictments for perjury and for obstruction of justice against that witness, and others,

just like what the American people did to a certain U.S. President who was forced to resign on his ownconscience relating to an anomaly known as the Watergate Scandal. After his perjured

witnesses/accomplices were charged with obstruction of justice and got all convicted in court, the saidU.S. President found himself very lonely and had no choice but resigned from office. Who knows, you

will find one with that situation in your district? If you are thinking of somebody now, hold on.Concentrate with your present case yet and then salivate with professionalism and work on the new case

you have in mind promptly.

11. As part of your preparation to interrogate the witness, read Grand Jury Standard Investigation(GJSI) No. (57) because that is where you will find other witnesses outside your territorial jurisdiction.

Make sure that you obtain from the witness all the information that you need to make a wise decision inthe present case.

First Prepare your investigation room settings and be ready to meet your witness:

(a) The witness desk shall be located at the center stage facing the grand jurymembers;

(b) The foreman's desk shall be located on the left side of the witness desk diagonally

facing halfway towards the witness about 2 feet apart from each other's desk.

(c) The secretary's desk shall be located on the right side of the witness deskdiagonally facing halfway towards the witness about 2 feet apart from each other's

desk.

(d) The platform on which the foreman's desk stands should be elevated about 10inches from the floor and the desks of the witness and the secretary shall be

Page 170: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

137

elevated in the same level of about 5 inches from the floor.

(e) The desks of the members shall be arranged in five columns with 4 members onthe first 4 columns and 5 members on the fifth column facing diagonally towards

the witness desk with the front rows at a distance of about 5 feet from the desk ofwitness.

Second: Make two (2) clean copies of Form GJ-39 (Part B). This is the Basic Interrogatory tothe Witness. Also 2 clean copies of attachments as Exhibits.

[_]- Foreman to give one copy set to the witness,

[_]- Foreman to keep the other copy set for himself.

Third : Make one (1) clean copy of Form GJ-42. This is the Witness Confidential Info Sheet. Any SIDN entered in this form must

first be registered in, and obtain from, Form GJ-32.

[_]- Foreman to keep Form GJ-42 at his desk to be filled in by witness after each some questions in

the course of the interrogation session with witness.

Fourth : As soon as the witness comes in, the Secretary will politely usher the witness to the witness desk. No private conversation

at this stage with the witness should be entertained.

Fifth : All members will be seated behind their desks. In the mean time, the foreman stands behind at the back end row in either side of the

column of the members with their SIDNs laid on their desks.

Sixth : The Secretary will now announce:

"This Grand Jury will now open for session. Our foreman, as you see, is identified by his SIDN _______. The SIDN will be explained to our

witness what that means.

Seventh: The foreman shall now take over to preside the session and addresses the witness as follows:

- End of Part “A” of FORM GJ-39 -

Page 171: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

138

(Important: Part "B" must be separated from Part "A")

Form GJ-39 (Part "B")- (Foreman must memorize this part).

BASIC INTERROGATORY BY THE GRAND JURY TO THE WITNESS.Attached to this Form is/are: Exhibit/s [_]-"A" [_]-"B" [_]-"C" [_]-"D" [_]-"E"

Mark Exhibit “A” for first witness; Exhibit “B” for second witness; Exhibit “C”, etc.

"Mr. (or Ms) Witness:

"We welcome you to this Grand Jury.

"The Jury System has been instituted by the National Jury Law and being implemented by theSupreme Court pursuant to its authority in Article VIII, Section 5(5) of the Constitution to speed up our

justice system and make it more effective. There are two juries in our Jury System. The Grand Jury andthe Trial Jury. We are the members of the Grand Jury and we are not a trial jury. We have nothing to

do with the function of the Trial Jury.

The function of the Grand Jury is to secretly investigate crimes under the direct authority of thepeople pursuant to their sovereign power in justice by virtue of their sovereign authority under Article II,

Section 1, of the Constitution. It derives its power directly from the people’ The grand jury hasindependent deciding power apart and above the power of the government to file criminal accusations

in court, called the "indictment", against suspected crime offenders, or it may refuse to file an indictmentcalled the "Memorandum of Non-Indictment" under certain conditions. The government or any high

government official has no authority to change the decision of the grand jury to make an accusation incourt.

"To the contrary, under the National Jury Law, no person can be tried for the commission of an

alleged crime unless the accusation against him shall have been reinvestigated or reviewed by the grandjury and finally approved by means of an indictment by a grand jury.

"The Grand Jury is not a court of law and it is not a trial court. Although it is not a court, the grand

jury as well as its individual members are authorized to administer and accept oath in performing thefunctions in the grand jury. What this means is that before a witness gives his or her testimony in this

grand jury, we are required by the Grand Jury Rules to ask the witness to be sworn in. (Mr. Foremanshall now stand and continue to speak).

"At this point, I request you to swear before this Grand Jury. We will, thereafter, continue with

other instructions and questions that we wish to ask you. (Foreman with raised right hand will requirethe witness to raise his hand and ask the witness):

"DO YOU SWEAR BEFORE THIS GRAND JURY THAT ALL THAT YOU SAY AND WRITE INANSWER TO ITS INTERROGATORIES OR THE QUESTIONS BY ITS MEMBERS SHALL BE THE

TRUTH, THE WHOLE TRUTH, AND NOTHING BUT THE TRUTH?"

Page 172: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

139

Witness should respond: "I DO".

"Take your seat, please. You may speak or write in Tagalog or in your dialect. If you want aquestion translated in Tagalog or in your dialect, please let us know and we will do so.

"This Grand Jury is investigating a crime as follows: (foreman must fill in the following blanks prior

to the day the witness comes in to testify.)

(Generic name of the crime) _________________________ (Examples: Bribery; Murder;Homicide; Election Fraud or Violence; Money laundering; Rape; Robbery; Thief; Arson; Illegal gambling;

Extortion; Malversation of public funds or property; Illegal possession of firearms or explosives; Drugtrafficking; Abduction, Illegal detention; Illegal search of private property; Etc. - You must use, however,

the exact legal name of the crime as defined by law when you file your indictment in court).

"So far, we have already gathered some information about this matter. But this grand jury stillneeds testimony of secret witnesses to support its accusation or indictment in court against the crime

suspect. We have been reliably informed that you are a witness in some way who have knowledge howthis crime happened. It is for this reason why you were issued a grand jury subpoena to testify on

whatever information or any evidence you may have. (Foreman with help of his assigned grand memberto this case must fill in these blanks):__________________________________________________

___________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

_________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

"Here is an official form, Form GJ-42. We ask you to please write in your name, address, and other

blanks that pertains to you personally. I will help you fill in later the other blanks in this form for othernames of persons you may mention in the course of our proceedings. From the information in this form

that you will give us, we will register your name in our Form GJ-32 and from said record we will issue toyou your Security Identification Number, known as your "SIDN." The purpose of the SIDN is to prevent

anyone from knowing that you have testified in this Grand Jury. Your SIDN is the name you will writein all other documents that comes up during our session. This document, Form GJ-42, is strictly

confidential. This grand jury has no authority to give it out to anybody or to any government office asordained by the grand jury secrecy rules. If called in as a witness, your name in this form cannot be

disclosed earlier and at no other time than at the time you are actually sworn in as a witness to start yourtestimony in a trial before a jury of 12 citizens, in the event that a criminal case is filed in court about the

case that this grand jury is investigating. (Before continuing, have the witness accomplish Form GJ-42completely up to the signature blank in it)

Here is another form. It is an Interrogatory form, which as you see, is titled as Form GJ-39 (Part

"B"), described as "BASIC INTERROGATORY BY THE GRAND JURY TO THE WITNESS" and attachedto it is a form designated as "Exhibit - ____" (To be marked for this witness, such as Exhibit 1, and then

Exhibit 2, for the second witness who will testify also later in this case).

"As we go about answering your Interrogatory form, other members will be preparing theirquestions they may wish to ask you for clarification after you have accomplished this Part "B" of Form

GJ-39.

Page 173: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

140

"When it comes to a point where you need to write the name of a person in this form, please letme know before writing his name and I will provide the SIDN for that name which you shall write in this

Interrogatory Form.

"After we are done with Part "B", we, the members of this grand jury, will be asking you in anopen oral question and answer session. This session will be tape recorded by our Recording Secretary.

The tape record in this session shall likewise be kept strictly confidential for hearing exclusively by ourmembers to help us make the decision of the Grand Jury investigation in this case. It is a sort of review

of your answers to the Interrogatories as well as to find out more information from you about the matterwe are investigating. If you wish a question translated or explain to you in the language or dialect that

you speak, please let me know. Let us begin.

Interrogatory No. 1 . Date today: _________________ <- (witness to fill in this blank)

[_]- Write here your SIDN#-__________, the number I just gave you.

Interrogatory No. 2. Currently you are in the Investigating Room of the Grand Jury of the

_______ Jury (Legislative) District of _______________________ <- [ask the foreman of the name to

fill in these two (2) blanks]. A Jury District is coterminous with the Legislative District.

Interrogatory No. 3. By instruction of the Jury System Rules, the members of this Grand Jury,

will demand that the information you give in the following questions or blanks must be the truth, the whole

truth, and nothing but the truth. Just a moment ago, please recall that you raised your right hand whereinyou have sworn in to do so. Do you recall that? Answer: [_]-Yes [_[-No.

(If witness answers "No", request the witness to be sworn in anew before proceeding. If he refuses to

swear in again, do not force him/her to do so. If he/she says "I don't want to testify" or "I do not want anypart of this investigation" do not restrain him and let him leave the Grand Jury Room. Thereafter, you

may simply charge or indict him/her in court for the crime of "Obstruction of Justice" for violation ofPresidential Decree 1829 and to stand trial before a trial jury in court for that crime.)

Interrogatory No. 4. We would like to let you know the meaning of two very important legal

words before we proceed: The word “perjury” and the other is “Obstruction of Justice”.

Interrogatory No. 5. The word “perjury” is the name of the crime for making or stating untruthful

statements after a person swears that he will tell the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth. This

crime is punishable by imprisonment in jail. Do you understand that? Answer: (_)-Yes (_)-No.

Interrogatory No. 6. The words “Obstruction of Justice” is the name of the crime for refusing

to testify or for lying with the intention of misleading, or delaying, or stopping, or preventing, or to confuse

this grand jury in order to fall into making a wrong decision about a criminal matter that it is investigating.Obstruction of justice is punishable by imprisonment in jail from 3 t 5 years.

Do you understand that? Answer: (_)-Yes (_)-No.

Interrogatory No. 7. “Obstruction of justice” also includes the act of testifying to cover-up of the

criminal acts of the offender. It is the act of willfully interfering with the process of justice and law by

influencing, threatening, harming, or impeding a witness, potential witness, or by furnishing falseinformation or otherwise impeding an investigation or legal process.

Page 174: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

141

Do you understand that? Answer: (_)-Yes (_)-No. .

Interrogatory No. 8. We, the members of this Grand Jury, are clearly making you aware that

if you give any false or misleading or untruthful answer to the following questions or blank lines callingfor an information, we will hold you liable for perjury or for obstruction of justice before this Grand Jury.

If you tell a lie to us, this Grand Jury will file an indictment or an accusation in court against you forperjury or for obstruction of justice. If you think you may be confessing a crime you have committed and

may be criminally charged for such crime, you must write the answer "I WANT TO REMAIN SILENT ONTHIS QUESTION" and do not make any other answer to that question.

Do you understand this instruction? Answer: (_)-Yes (_)-No.

Interrogatory No. 9. We would like to ask you to avoid writing names of any person that come

to your mind in stating your answers to this interrogatories. Just like you, we have not written your nameanywhere in this questionnaire but we have given you a Security Identification Number or SIDN to protect

your identity. This Grand Jury will likewise protect the identity of the persons you will refer to us in thecourse of this questioning including any suspected crime offender. The reason for using SIDNs is to

keep our investigation strictly confidential without being known by the public as required by the Rules ofthe Grand Jury System.

Do you understand this instruction? Answer: (_)-Yes (_)-No.

Interrogatory No. 10. When you want to give us a name in connection with this investigation,

write his name in my Form GJ-42 which I will provide to you. I will then list the name in our Form GJ-32and then we will designate an SIDN for that name. Only then shall we ask more questions about the

person whose name matches with the SIDN we have issued. Do you understand this instruction? Answer: (_)-Yes (_)-No.

Interrogatory No. 11. We would like to let you know that we will be sending a subpoena to

another witness who may have known you. The purpose is to corroborate, confirm or deny theinformation you will be giving us in this investigation. It is therefore important that your testimony and

his or her testimony must substantially agree with your answers in this investigation when we askquestions such as: Do you know each other? Have you been working together or not in the same office

or company? Have you been close friends? Has he or she has or has not helped you in finding a job?Have you been doing business together in some manner? Have you talk to each other either over the

phone or face to face? Have you been childhood friends? Where and when did you know each otherfor the first time? Have you been enemies to each other? Have you given him or her a gift at one time

or another? Do you live in the same neighborhood within a distance of about one (1) kilometer from eachother? Have you given a bribe to this person? and other things that reveal close association or knowing

with each other or enmity with each other? To avoid being charged for perjury or for obstruction ofjustice, you must therefore be totally truthful with your answers.

Do you understand what this instruction means? Answer: (_)-Yes (_)-No.

Interrogatory No. 12. Many questions we will be asking you are simple questions that need

simple answer such as a "Yes" or "No". Example: "Do you know anything about a person whose name

is "Name" and works for "Employer X" and you answer "No" when in fact you were working together inthe same department or you were in fact appointed to your job in said organization where the other

person works closely with you? We, therefore, caution you to be careful in giving your "simple" answerin such situations otherwise you could easily commit the crime of perjury or obstruction of justice. Do

you understand this instruction? Answer: (_)-Yes (_)-No.

Page 175: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

142

Interrogatory No. 13. Here is a name of a person I will show you. By any chance, did you

happen to hear or know anything about this person sometime before? Answer: (_)-Yes (_)-No.

(If answer is "Yes", foreman should list the name of this person in Form GJ-42 and further registersaid name in Form GJ-32 to generate his SIDN for entry in the attachment to Form GJ-39, Part "B".

(If the answer is "No", the foreman should announce to the members of the Grand Jury the name

of the person being asked about and inform them that "this witness does not know anything about saidperson." The foreman will then allow members of the grand jury to profound the question again to the

witness during the session for Part "C" of Form GJ-39).

Interrogatory No. 14. We want to make you understand why a grand jury investigation is held

strictly in secret and the reasons are as follows:

(a) To prevent the crime suspect of running away from justice; (b) To protect the constitutional

innocence of the crime suspect from trial by publicity; (c) To prevent the suspect or victim or theirrespective sympathizers from tampering any evidence or of threatening, harassing or harming potential

witnesses; (d) To protect both the victim and crime suspect from harming each other or by theirfollowers. (e) To protect the members of the grand jury from threats or harassments or harm by heavily

armed or highly influential or publicly powerful suspects of crimes and by their crime sympathizers andaccomplices; (f) To prevent potential trial jurors from prejudging the guilt or innocence of the crime

suspect once they are called in to serve as jurors; (g) To protect judges and government prosecutorsand private investigators from illegal or unethical interference, threats, harassments, or physical harm

from highly armed or powerful or wealthy elements of society; and (h) To encourage potential crimeinformers and whistle blowers to secretly report to the grand jury any criminal wrong doings in their

workplace, neighborhood, organizations, and among circle of friends. Do you understand thisInstruction? Answer: (_)-Yes (_)-No. If your answer is "No" please tell me and I will explain this

Interrogatory to you again.

Interrogatory No. 15. Here is a form I will attach and marked as "Exhibit ___" to Form GJ-39

(Part "B"). You are likewise required to accomplish this form. Do you understand this instruction?

Answer: (_)-Yes (_)-No.

Page 176: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

143

Form GJ-39 - Part "B", Exhibit Attachment (Next Pag e)

Instruction in marking Exhibits:

1. If an exhibit has several components and closely related to the same exhibit, example: Page1 and has page 2, marked the first page as “Exhibit 1-A”, the second page as “Exhibit 1-B, and so forth;

2. If the next exhibit is another series of exhibits and closely related with each other, example:

Exhibit 2, mark the first as “Exhibit 2-A”, followed by “Exhibit 2-B”, and so on;

3. If the exhibit is an object or thing and it has a detached part but closely related to it, follow thesame pattern as instructed in Number 1 and 2 above.

4. Generally, be creative in marking your exhibits.

(Continue on the next page)

Page 177: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

144

Form GJ-39 - Part "B", Exhibit Attachment

(Note: Coordinate this form with GJ-Form 31 and GJ- Form 41)

After accomplishment, attach this Sheet to Form GJ-39, Part "B", as EXHIBIT "___"

“THE GRAND JURY Of the _______ Jury (Legislative) District of:

_____________________________________

(To be filled in by the witness in his/her own handwriting - Do not type)Witness to mark the appropriate boxes in the form. Read carefully

and understand before writing the answer to each question.

Date Today _________________ GRAND JURY CASE NO. _______________

I, identified herein with my SIDN as #___________, _____ years old, under penalty of Perjury

and/or Obstruction of Justice, and on my oath before this Grand Jury, truthfully state, that:

1. [_]- I was summoned to testify before this Grand Jury today.

2. [_]- I was informed that the Grand Jury will ask me for information about a crimewhich the foreman has described to me as a case of __________________.

Read carefully the two (2) NOTES BELOW:

[NOTE: If you are testifying to a crime of bribery against a public official, you will be given full exemption

or immunity per Presidential Decree 749 from criminal prosecution if you promise to testify at the trial ofthis case as a prosecution witness against the public official who accepted the bribe from you. If you

refuse to testify, you will be prosecuted instead for Obstruction of Justice for violation of PresidentialDecree 1829.]

[NOTE: The laws on bribery are found in Articles 210, 211, and 212 of the Revised Penal Code of the

Philippines. You will not be prosecuted for bribery under Article 212 of the RPCP because you will beprotected by Presidential Decree 749. Other laws on bribery are found in Republic Act 3019, the

Anti-Graft and Corrupt Practices Act; Section 345 of the Internal Revenue Code, and Section of 3604of the Tariff & Custom Codes.

3. [_]- Are you a giver or offeror in a crime of bribery? Answer: [_]-Yes [_]-No

4. [_]- If your answer is "Yes", continue on Box No. 5, the next box below. If your

answer is "No", go directly to Box No. 15 farther below or in the next page.

Page 178: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

145

5. [_]- I accept the protection and exemption from criminal prosecution granted under

Presidential Decree 749 of any crime relating to the subject crime of bribery in thismatter. I promise to testify as a prosecution witness in the trial against the public official

whom I have given a bribe. I understand that if I refuse to testify for the prosecution, Ican be prosecuted for Obstruction of Justice .

6. [_]- If you are a giver or offeror in the above stated crime of bribery, state the information

called for in the following blanks:

Name of subject official (Do not write name) Write SIDN-_______ (ask foreman)Name of his position or Title ________________________________________________

Name of his office or bureau ________________________________________________Address of his office _______________________________________________________

_____________________________________________________

Did somebody help you in bringing your bribe to the public official?Answer: [_]-Yes [_]-No. If "yes" name of your helper?

((Do not write name) Write SIDN#______ (ask foreman)

7. [_]- I bribed this official:

[_]- Because he does not act on my transaction with his office if I offer him no bribe.

[_]- Because of his official position to make my transactions easier to get through with hisoffice. If I give no money, I get no "honey."

Form of bribe: (1) If money was given, [_]-Amount-______________ Approximately.

[_]-Currency: [_]- Pesos [_]-Dollars [_]-Other-_______________

[_]-Cash [_]-Check & Name of Bank - _______________________

[_]-Bank branch at: _______________________________________

[_]-Date/time of transaction ____________________ approximately.

[_]-City where bribery transaction took place-___________________

[_]-Name of witness to this transaction- Issue SIDN_____________

(2) If property was given: Describe here ______________________ ____________________ [_]-Value- _______________ in [_]-Pesos

[_]-Dollars - If real property, [_]-address - ___________________________________________________________________________

[_]-Titled owner before the real property was given- SIDN________

[_]-If personal property, describe here - ______________________

Registration #________________ Name of government office whereproperty was registered _____________________________

(3) Besides the above transaction, has there been any other money

or property you have given to the same official? [_]-Yes [_]-NoIf "yes" prepare records of said transaction(s) similar to the

Page 179: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

146

information called for above. (As many as you can remember).

(4) Besides the above referenced public official, have you given a

bribe to another public official? Answer: [_]-Yes [_]-NoIf "Yes", give us his name (Do not write) Write SIDN#________

(Ask the foreman).

8. [_]- Are you engaged in any form of business? Answer: [_]-Yes [_]-No.

[_]- If "yes", name of your business- (Don't write name) (Issue SIDN-_________)

[_]- Your position or title in the business- [_]-Owner [_]-President [_]-Manager[_]- Kind of [_]-Product [_]-Service you sell or offer. Give general description

only- _______________________________________________. Do not specify[_]- City or Municipality where you operate your business- __________________

(Don't write exact address, name of city or municipality only).

[_]- If "No", where did you get the money to bribe this government official? Answer: _____________________________________________________________

____________________________________________________________________

[_]- Was there an important reason for bribing this official?Answer: [_]-Yes. [_]-No. Either way you must prepare your answer at the trial in

court. State here the reason for your answer _______________________________________________________

_______________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________

_______________________________________________________

9. [_]- Do you know of other person/s who may have given a bribe to the same publicofficial whom we identified earlier with SIDN ________ in Question No. 7?

Answer: [_]-Yes [_]-No.

10. [_]- If your answer is "Yes" to the preceding question, the name of said person? (Do not write name) Write SIDN#______ (ask foreman)

11. [_]- Any other person you know who have given a bribe to said official?

Answer: [_]-Yes [_]-No.

12. [_]- If your answer is "Yes" to the preceding question, the name of said person? (Do not write name) Write SIDN#______ (ask foreman)

13. [_]- Any other person you know who have given a bribe to said official?

Answer: [_]-Yes [_]-No.

14. [_]- If your answer is "Yes" to the preceding question, the name of said person? (Do not write name) Write SIDN#______ (ask foreman)

- ### -

Page 180: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

147

15. [_]- Have you been induced or encouraged by another with his promise to reward you withsomething to testify in this case? If your answer to this question is "Yes", mark this box

- > [_]-and give us the name of the person: (Don't write here the name) Write hisSIDN#-________ (ask the foreman). If your answer is "No", mark this box [_] and, if so,

do you still consider yourself a witness in this case? Answer: [_]-Yes. [_]-No.

16. [_]- Do you know if there is any lawyer or attorney who has proposed, or asked, facilitated,has received a part of the money you gave to the subject of this investigation?

17. [_]- If your answer is “Yes”, mark this box [_]-and give us the name of the person: (Don’t write

here the name) Write his SIDN#- __________ (ask the foreman). If your answer is "No",mark this box [_] and, if so, do you still consider yourself a witness in this case? Answer:

[_]-Yes. [_]-No.

18. [_]- If your answer to No. 16 is “Yes”, how did you know him? (Please explain in the followingblank lines: ________________________________________________________________________

__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

__________________________________________________________________________________

19. [_]- If your last answer in Box 15 is "No", tell us what other matters you wish to volunteer to say about this case. Explain fully your answer: ___________________________

_______________________________________________________________________________

_______________________________________________________________________________

_______________________________________________________________________________

[_]- If your last answer in Box 15 is "Yes" in what way would you consider yourself a witness?

20. [_]- Answer: Because (mark any or all that apply to you our observation):

[_]- I am the victim in this crime. Explain: __________________________________

_____________________________________________________________.

[_]- I saw what happened. Explain: ___________________________________ ____________________________________________________________.

____________________________________________________________. ____________________________________________________________.

____________________________________________________________.

[_]- I am a dependent of the victim. Explain how are you related to the victim: ____________________________________________________________.

____________________________________________________________. ____________________________________________________________.

____________________________________________________________.

21. [_]- Do you know the offender of this crime? Answer: [_]-Yes [_]-No.If your answer to this question is "Yes", when did you first know such person?

Page 181: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

148

Answer: [_]-Since ______________ or [_]-About _____ [_]-days [_]-weeks

[_]-months [_]-years - ago. [_]-At or after the crime.

22. [_]- How did you come to know him\ or her for the first time?Answer (explain in full) _____________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

_______________________________________________________________________

23. [_]- Have you seen the offender before the crime happened? Answer: [_]-Yes [_]-NoIf "Yes", how many times have you seen the offender?

Answer: [_]- Around ____ times. [_]-Many times. [_]-Every day [_]-Almost every day [_]-Every week [_]-Almost every week

[_]-Every month [_]-Almost every month [_]-Every year [_]-Almost every year [_]-until ________________ ago.

What was your purpose of seeing the offender? Answer (explain in full) ______________

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

_______________________________________________________________________

[_]- If this question is not applicable. [_]- Why? Because: ______________________________________________________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

24. [_]- His/Her name? Answer (Do not write name) Write SIDN______(ask foreman)

25. [_]- Before the subject crime happened, have you spoken with the offender?Answer: [_]-Yes [_]- No. If your answer is "yes" what was the topic of

your conversation? Answer (explain in full) ________________________________________________________________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

_______________________________________________________________________

26. [_]- The date this crime happened? Answer: _______________________________

27. [_]- The approximate time it happened? Answer: _________________________

28. [_]- Did this crime happen inside a building or house? Answer: [_]-Yes [_]-No

29. [_]- If your answer to the preceding question in Box 28 is "Yes", were you likewise inside the building or the house?

Answer: [_]-Yes [_]-No.

30. [_]- If your answer to the preceding question in Box 29 is "Yes", describe the visibility or lighting condition inside from your point of view whether:

Page 182: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

149

[_]- bright [_]-dim [_]-dark. Explain your answer in full- ____________________ _________________________________________________________________________

_________________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________

_________________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________

_________________________________________________________________________

31. [_]- If your answer to the question in Box 28 is "No", explain in what location did this crime happened? Answer in full: ___________________________________

_________________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________

_________________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________

_________________________________________________________________________

32. [_]- Write the: [_]-Street address- ___________________________________________

[_]- Barrio/Municipality/City/_________________________________________________

[_]- Do you know of anybody else who may have witnessed this incident? Answer: [_]- Yes [_]- No.

If your answer is “yes”, his or her name? Write SIDN#__________ (ask foreman) How did you come to know this person? _______________________________________

_______________________________________________________________________

_______________________________________________________________________

_______________________________________________________________________

33. [_]- Fully describe how the offender committed this crime? Answer: _________________

_______________________________________________________________________

_______________________________________________________________________

_______________________________________________________________________

_______________________________________________________________________

_______________________________________________________________________

_______________________________________________________________________

34. [_]- If your answer to Box 21 is "No", is there any other witness

you know who actually knows the offender of this crime?

Answer: [_]-Yes [_]-No.

35. [_]- If you know, where was this witness situated at the commission of the crime?

Answer: [_]-He [_]-She was at ______________________________________________

Page 183: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

150

_________________________________________________________________________

What was the witness doing? Answer fully ______________________________________

_________________________________________________________________________

_________________________________________________________________________

_________________________________________________________________________

_________________________________________________________________________

36. [_]- After the crime was committed have you ever talked with such witness?

Answer: [_]-Yes [_]-No.

37. [_]- If your answer in the preceding question in Box 37 is "yes", how long after

the commission of the crime have you talked with said witness?

Answer: [_]-___ minutes [_]-___ hours [_]-___ days

[_]-___ weeks [_]-___ months [_]-years - after the crime happened.

38. [_]- If your answer to the question in Box 37 is "no", why not?

Answer: Because ______________________________________________________

39. [_]- If your response to the question in Box 34 is "yes", what is the name of the witness?

(Don't write name) Write SIDN#_________ (ask foreman)

Address of this witness ________________________________________________

___________________________________________________________________

____________________________________________________________________

______________________________________ Telephone-____________________

40. [_]- Besides the person identified as SIDN ______, do you know of another person who

actually know the offender of this crime? Answer: [_]-Yes [_]-No. , If you answer

"yes", the name of such person: (Do not write the name) Write ISDN ________ (ask

foreman).

41. [_]- Lastly. Is there anything in this grand jury investigating room that you have seen or

heard any deceptive, forceful, or intimidatory tactic or environment or statement from any

member of this Grand Jury that had forced you to testify falsely?

Answer: [_]-No [_]-Yes. If your answer is “Yes”, please explain here: __________

___________________________________________________________________

___________________________________________________________________

___________________________________________________________________

Page 184: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

151

___________________________________________________________________

___________________________________________________________________

___________________________________________________________________

___________________________________________________________________

___________________________________________________________________

___________________________________________________________________

Sign in here your SIDN _______ and write date today -_______________

(If applicable, see Supplemental “Page 21 and 22”, Anatomy of the Human Body)

- End of this Exhibit -

Page 185: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

_______________________________

_______________________________

_______________________________

_______________________________

_______________________________

_______________________________

______________________________________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________________

_______________________________________________________________________________

_______________________________________________________________________________

_______________________________________________________________________________

_______________________________________________________________________________

_______________________________________________________________________________

_______________________________________________________________________________

_______________________________________________________________________________

_______________________________________________________________________________

_______________________________________________________________________________

________________________________________________________________________________

________________________________________________________________________________

________________________________________________________________________________

________________________________________________________________________________

Page 186: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

153

________________________________________________________________________________

________________________________________________________________________________

________________________________________________________________________________

________________________________________________________________________________

Interrogatory No. 16. Mr./Ms. Witness, before we proceed to the Part "C" of this session, is there any

answer you have given above or in the attached Exhibit “____” that you would want to change?

Answer: [_]-Yes [_]-No.

Interrogatory No. 17. If preceding answer is "Yes" - Please cite the Question Number and write

your correction:

Question No. ____ - Corrected Answer: ________________________________________

_________________________________________________________________________

Reason for the change: ______________________________________________________

Question No. ____ - Corrected Answer: ________________________________________

_________________________________________________________________________

Reason for the change: ______________________________________________________

Question No. ____ - Corrected Answer: ________________________________________

_________________________________________________________________________

Reason for the change: ______________________________________________________

Question No. ____ - Corrected Answer: ________________________________________

_________________________________________________________________________

Reason for the change: ______________________________________________________

Question No. ____ - Corrected Answer: ________________________________________

_________________________________________________________________________

Reason for the change: ______________________________________________________

(Use additional sheet of paper, if necessary. Mark it with above Exhibit #, and “Page 2")

Interrogatory No. 18. If last answer in Interrogatory 17 is “No”, let us now proceed to Part "C"

of Form GJ-39. We wish to remind you that this part is included in your oath to tell the truth in thisinvestigation. You are now free to mention any name that comes to your mind in answering the

questions at this stage.

REMINDER to Mr. Foreman: The attachment EXHIBIT must be completed before proceeding to the

oral questions and answer session.

- End of Part “B” of FORM GJ-39 -

Page 187: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

154

PART “C” OF FORM GJ-39 - ORAL QUESTIONS & ANSWERS WIT H THE WITNESS

Form GJ-39 (Part "C")- Confidential Oral Questions and Answers Session

With the Witness who wrote his/her SIDN as follows:

Witness (Witness to write in his/her SIDN here) -> SIDN ___________

INSTRUCTION:

1. This part (C) shall be conducted after Part "B" is completed. Part C is to record

electronically with a tape recorder the oral questi ons by any grand jury member and the

corresponding oral answers by the witness.

2. The session in this part shall be TAPE RECORDED by the Recording Secretary. The tape

record label shall be marked with the SIDN of the witness. Tape shall be replayed prior to the secret

voting of the grand jury members to make the decision of the grand jury to indict, or not to indict the

suspect. This tape shall be strictly confidential - not subject to disclosure for any reason to any person,

attorney, court, government or non-government, other than to the grand jury officers and members.

3. Every officer and member of the grand jury shall use this part to ask question to the witness

to seek clarification on any statement by witness that such member did not clearly understand as well

as other questions that may arise in the oral question and answer session.

4. The foreman will now proceed by addressing the members:

"Any member of this Grand Jury may now ask his or her question to the witness. He or she may

mention actual name of person or persons relevant to his or question. The witness is likewise free to

mention names as he/she remembers."

(The members must be courteous in speaking with the witness. Avoid insulting remarks.)

A juror will then address the foreman: "Mr. Foreman, I am Juror Number ______. The

question I wish to ask of the witness is this: Mr. or Ms. Witness (State the question)

Another member may follow to ask his question in the same manner.

The foreman must be alert to prevent a question to be asked that has already been asked and

answered by the witness previously unless the question is a call for clarification of the previous answer.

5. After all questions, including the questions in the attached Exhibit, have been taken and

Page 188: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

155

answered, the foreman will conclude and make a statement as follows:

"The session with our witness is now completed. I would like to thank Mr./Ms. Witness SIDN

_____ (smile for SIDN name) for your cooperation. You have done a great service to our community.

We wish you a pleasant day/afternoon/evening or week-end" (and have a parting hand shake with the

witness)

IMPORTANT: You must politely decline to give answe rs to the questions from the witness

and you must not carry on a private conversation wi th the witness after closing your session.

If he still wants to speak inform him that you are taking his additional information under his oath

and the information must also be tape recorded. Record your remark that this information is

in addition to the recorded information already given by the witness earlier.

Page 189: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

156

Form GJ-40, Grand Jury Hold Departure Order Notice.

THE GRAND JURY Of the _______ Jury (Legislative) District of

_____________________________________(Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type)

Highly ConfidentialForm GJ-40 - GRAND JURY HOLD DEPARTURE ORDER NOTICE

The Secretary of Foreign AffairsAnd Branch Service Officers of His Department

The Director of the Bureau of Immigration and His DeputiesAll Around the Philippines

2330 Roxas Boulevard, Pasay City

GREETINGS:

Pursuant to the Statutory Grand Jury Instruction No. (190) to this Grand Jury, and by this Notice, thisGrand Jury commands you to hold the departure from any point in the Philippines of the person namedor identified below and to suspend [_]-his [_]-her passport if any has been issued as of today regardlessof any official or business mission for abroad from an order issued by any government authority untilsuch person is cleared of his criminal responsibility to the people or until such person may no longer berequired to testify before this Grand Jury:

Name of Person - ________________________________________________

Public Position, if any - ________________________________________________

Name of Office - ________________________________________________

Other social standing - ________________________________________________

By this Notice, this Grand Jury hereby places the responsibility upon you: 1. To prevent violationof Presidential Decree 1829, and/or the National Jury Law, the laws against commission of the crimesof Obstruction of Justice and 2. You are hereby bound by the Grand Jury secrecy rules and policies andyou must refrain from announcing privately or publicly the pending investigation by the grand jury of thesubject person in this Notice .

The subject person is under grand jury secret investigation for, or being sought as a witness on,a certain crime defined as a serious offense known as (write name of crime here) ______________________________ and. The matter in this case has been docketed in this Grand Jury as:

GRAND JURY INVESTIGATION No. ___________ (Confidential. Publication not authorized)

This Notice has been issued this ________ day of _________________, year _________,

BY:

THE GRAND JURY, Personally signed with the SIDN#________of its Foreman by authority of Article III, Sec. 7(b) of the National Jury Law.

Page 190: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

157

Direction for the service of this HOLD DEPARTURE ORDER NOTICE The Grand Jury to The Clerk of Court of the Regional/Municipal Trial Court of ___________________, GREETING:You are hereby commanded to designate the server of, and return, the within Notice according to law. Dated at_________________________, this ____ day of ________________, _______ in the year of our Lord, BY:

THE GRAND JURY, Personally signed with the SIDN#________of its Secretary by authority of Article III, Sec. 7(b) of the National Jury Law.

PROOF OF SERVICE AND DELIVERY OF THIS HOLD DEPARTUR E ORDER NOTICE(After being signed by server, the Original of this document

must be submitted to and kept by the Secretary of the Grand Jury)

1. I served this Notice by personally delivering a copy thereof to the person named below: (The personal server must fill in by handwriting in the blanks hereunder)

(a) Name of Person Served - __________________________________________

(b) Gov’t Title or Position - __________________________________________

(c) Name of Office - __________________________________________

(b) Address where served - __________________________________________

__________________________________________

(c) Date/Time of Delivery - _____________, 20___ ______ __.M

2. [_]- Non-Service Return of this Notice. (fill in and sign if server is unable to serve): After due search, carefulinquiry, and diligent attempts at the dwelling or usual place of abode or usual place of business or work,I have been unable to make personal delivery of this HOLD DEPARTURE ORDER NOTICE in thisDistrict on the person named therein for the following reasons:____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

3. Information about the Server or Person serving:

Full Name - ________________________________ (Must sign below)

Occupation - [_]- Professional Process Server [_]-__________________________________

Organization - _______________________________________________________________

Address - _______________________________________________________________

Telephone Number _________________________ Fax Number _________________________

I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the Philippines that the foregoing information is trueand correct (Note: Read carefully before signing. Anyone who falsifies a statement in this document shall be liablefor indictment of perjury or of obstruction of justice and for punishment by imprisonment.

____________________, 20______ _________________________________ (Date Signed) (Signature)

- End of Form -

Page 191: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

158

Form GJ-41, Summons to the Clerk of Court To Accept Filing of Indictment.

THE GRAND JURY Of the _______ Jury (Legislative) District of __________________________

Address ________________________________________________________________

Grand Jury Term from ___________________ to _____________________

(Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type)

Highly Confidential

SUMMONS TO THE CLERK OF COURT TO ACCEPT FILING OF GRAND JURY INDICTMENT.

The Clerk of Court (Mark “X” on the bracket to which court you will file your indictment)(_)- Regional Trial Court of ____________________ (_)- Sharia Trial Court of ___________________(_)- City/Metropolitan Trial Court of ______________ (_)- Municipal Trial Court of ________________Street or Building Address _____________________________________________________________City/Municipal Address ________________________________________________________________

Dear Mr./Ms. Clerk of Court:

You are hereby directed to appear in person before this Grand Jury to accept the filing of an indictmentin court by this Body. The case reference number of the matter is Grand Jury Case No._______________. If you are a clerk of court in the court house different from where this Grand Jury islocated, please contact the clerk of court of the court house at (physical address)_________________________________________________________________________________________________________,telephone No. __________________. He shall then lead and authorize you to enter our Grand Jury Room.

Bring in your filing stamp and your Registry Book wherein this matter will be docketed with the numberof the court case. You are likewise directed to keep this matter strictly confidential as required of the strictrules of secrecy by the National Jury Law.

Fail not under liability for Obstruction of Justice by this Grand Jury.

Very truly yours,

THE GRAND JURY: Personally signed with validated Date Issued - ____________SIDN#________________ of its Foreman by authority of Article III, Section 7(b) of the National Jury Law.

The Clerk of Court in the Same Street Address as this Grand Jury is Located:

GREETINGS:

Please serve this Summons to the Clerk of the Court as marked with “X” above.

Personally signed by the Secretary of this Grand Jury with his SIDN#____________. Date - ________________

By Authority of Article III, Section 7(b) of the National Jury Law.

- End of Form -

Page 192: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

159

Form GJ-42, Witness Confidential Personal Information Sheet.

(Page 1) SIDN-__________ GRAND JURY CASE NO. _______________

“THE GRAND JURY Of the _______ Jury (Legislative) District of

_____________________________________Strictly Confidential

(Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type)WITNESS CONFIDENTIAL PERSONAL INFORMATION SHEET

(To be filled in by the witness in [_]-his [_]-her own handwriting - Do not type)

I CERTIFY AND I ACKNOWLEDGE that I received SIDN ________ from this Grand Jury as my secret witnesscode in a grand jury investigation identified as "Grand Jury Investigation Case No. __________.

Name of Witness: _______________________________________ Nickname: _____________________________

Telephone: __________________Home address: _______________________________________________________

_______________________________________________________________________________________________

Job/Work address: ________________________________________________________________________________

________________________________________________________________________________________________

Date of Birth: ________________ Place of Birth: __________________________________ Gender: (_)-M (_)-F

List Items or documents brought in by witness - _________________________________________________________

_______________________________________________________________________________________________

_______________________________________________________________________________________________

I have written below my signature herein the names I mentioned in the course of my responses to the interrogatories bythe Grand Jury and the Grand Jury correspondingly coded said names with certain SIDNs or Security IdentificationNumbers.

Date today- __________________ (Signature of Witness) _______________________________

Question # inForm GJ-38

Part B Exhibit Name Mentioned by Witness

AssignedSIDN from

Form GJ-32

Possible Linkor

Relation to this Case

[_]- Suspected offender of the crime

Address -> [_]- Helper or Accessory to the crime

Mun/City/Prov [_]- Victim in the crime

Occupation - > [_]- Witness (Do not write in the indictment

Telephone - > as witness if not interrogated by the GJ

[_]- Suspected offender of the crime

Address -> [_]- Suspected offender of the crime

Mun/City/Prov [_]- Victim in the crime

Occupation - > [_]- Witness (Do not write in the indictment

Telephone - > as witness if not interrogated by the GJ

[_]- Suspected offender of the crime

Address -> [_]- Suspected offender of the crime

Mun/City/Prov [_]- Victim in the crime

Occupation - > [_]- Witness (Do not write in the indictment

Telephone - > as witness if not interrogated by the GJ

- Continue on Page 2 of this Form -

Page 193: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

160

- Form GJ-42, Page 2 -

Question # inForm GJ-38

Part B Exhibit Name Mentioned by Witness

AssignedSIDN from

Form GJ-31

Possible Linkor

Relation to this Case

[_]- Suspected offender of the crime

Address -> [_]- Helper or Accessory to the crime

Mun/City/Prov [_]- Victim in the crime

Occupation - > [_]- Witness (Do not write in the indictment

Telephone - > as witness if not interrogated by the GJ

[_]- Suspected offender of the crime

Address -> [_]- Helper or Accessory to the crime

Mun/City/Prov [_]- Victim in the crime

Occupation - > [_]- Witness (Do not write in the indictment

Telephone - > as witness if not interrogated by the GJ

[_]- Suspected offender of the crime

Address -> [_]- Helper or Accessory to the crime

Mun/City/Prov [_]- Victim in the crime

Occupation - > [_]- Witness (Do not write in the indictment

Telephone - > as witness if not interrogated by the GJ

[_]- Suspected offender of the crime

Address -> [_]- Helper or Accessory to the crime

Mun/City/Prov [_]- Victim in the crime

Occupation - > [_]- Witness (Do not write in the indictment

Telephone - > as witness if not interrogated by the GJ

[_]- Suspected offender of the crime

Address -> [_]- Helper or Accessory to the crime

Mun/City/Prov [_]- Victim in the crime

Occupation - > [_]- Witness (Do not write in the indictment

Telephone - > as witness if not interrogated by the GJ

[_]- Suspected offender of the crime

Address -> [_]- Helper or Accessory to the crime

Mun/City/Prov [_]- Victim in the crime

Occupation - > [_]- Witness (Do not write in the indictment

Telephone - > as witness if not interrogated by the GJ

[_]- Suspected offender of the crime

Address -> [_]- Suspected offender of the crime

Mun/City/Prov [_]- Victim in the crime

Occupation - > [_]- Witness (Do not write in the indictment

Telephone - > as witness if not interrogated by the GJ

- End of Form -

Page 194: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

161

Form GJ-43, Reserve. Unused.

Page 195: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

162

Form GJ-44, Notice of Grand Jury Reorganization of its Officers.

THE GRAND JURY Of the _______ Jury (Legislative) District of

_____________________________________

Grand Jury Term from ___________________ to _____________________(Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type)

HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL

NOTICE OF GRAND JURY REORGANIZATION

The Honorable Executive JudgeThru the Clerk of CourtRegional Trial Court of _______________________________Municipality/City/Province ____________________________

GREETINGS:

This Grand Jury respectfully informs this Honorable Court that it has reorganized or changed its leadership who

are now in place with their respective positions as follows:

Foreman - SIDN ________

Vice Foreman - SIDN ________

Secretary - SIDN ________

Recording Secretary - SIDN ________

Members: SIDN ________ SIDN ________ SIDN ________ SIDN ________

SIDN ________ SIDN ________ SIDN ________ SIDN ________

SIDN ________ SIDN ________ SIDN ________ SIDN ________

SIDN ________ SIDN ________ SIDN ________ SIDN ________

SIDN ________ SIDN ________ SIDN ________

Attached is replacement form, Form GJ- 35 for your ready completion.

Date today _______________

Submitted by: Personally signed with the SIDN# __________ ____________ of the New Secretary for the Grand Jury

- End of Form -

Page 196: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

163

Form GJ-45, Invitation for Participation in the Community DeputyProsecutors Pool (aka: CDP) (Form For Newspaper publication advertisement)

The Office of the [_]-City [_]-Provincial Prosecutor[_]-City [_]-Province of _________________________

Address ____________________________________________________________________________________

Date today- ____________________

(Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type)

INVITATION FOR PARTICIPATION IN THE COMMUNITY DEPUTY PROSECUTOR’S POOL

GREETINGS:

The members of the Integrated Bar of the Philippines in good standing who have been engaged

in the private practice of law for three (3) years or more within the ______________ Jury (Legislative)

District of __________________ are hereby invited to participate in the Pool for Community Deputy

Prosecutors (aka: CDP) to act as prosecution trial lawyers in the event of shortage of regular

prosecutors under the supervision of this Office.

The assignment of cases shall be conducted on a lottery basis. The qualification and terms of

participation in the Pool are written in the official application form on Form GJ-45 as prescribed in Section

99, Article III of the National Jury Law. The application form is available in the this Office. The form shall

not be substituted with any personally devised form. This is a durable form which means that it cannot

be modified by the Applicant.

This advertisement has been posted by the ______________ Prosecutor of __________________

__________________________________________________________________________________

- End of Form -

Page 197: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

164

Form GJ-46, Application to Participate in the CDP Pool.

___________________________________________

Attorney at Law - Bar Number _____________

Street Address ____________________________________

Zip/Mun/City/Province _______________________________________

Office Telephone __________________ Cellphone __________________ Fax ________________

Date today __________________

APPLICATION TO PARTICIPATE IN THE CDP POOL

INSTRUCTION: 1. Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type; 2. Staple together

all pages of your application and fold the same inward into 3 equal parts. 3. Staple the folded application at the center of the

upper edge and personally drop it in the CDP Application Raffle Bin in the Office of the Provincial or City Prosecutor. This

application form shall be void if altered in any manner.

The [_]-City [_]-Provincial Prosecutor for the [_]-City [_]-Province of ___________________________________________

Address _________________________________________________________________________

___________________________________________________________________________________

GREETINGS:

I wish to participate in the Pool of Community Deputy Prosecutors in this Jury District and I respectfullyrequest that my application be entered in the Raffle Box Pool in your office for the pool participants.

A: I CERTIFY that:

1. I am a bonafide member of the Integrated Bar of the Philippines. My Bar Number is___________.

2. I have been engaged in the private practice of law for at least three (3) years. My actual yearsof law practice is _____ years as of the filing date of this application.

3. As of the date of the filing of my application, I certify that I have completely devoted a total ofat least 24 hours of self-study of the National Jury Law. I have read and I am thoroughly familiar bothwith the Statutory Basic Grand Jury Instruction in Section 24 and Form GJ-41 of Section 99 in Article III,and the Statutory Basic Trial Jury Instruction on Form TJ-108 in Section 2, Article X of the National JuryLaw. I have actually accomplished a “dry run” preparation in my own handwriting with the following formsby assuming the roles of those who are concerned in preparing or filling up those forms, most particularlythe following: Form TJ-103, Form TJ-109, Form TJ-109A, Forms TJ-110A-B-C-D, a derivative form fromForm TJ-110, Form TJ-111, Form TJ-112, Form TJ-113, Form TJ-114, Form TJ-135, Form TJ-136, FormTJ-137 and Form TJ-138. I further state that I am expertly cognizant of the rudiments in the impanelingof a trial jury and the preemptory challenges of jurors.

B: I PROMISE and WILFULLY AGREE that:

(1) I shall accept an assignment to prosecute before a bench court or a trial jury the type of casesI have specified in my application for CDP pool membership if notified in advance for trial at least thirty(30) calendar days before the trial commencement date. I shall have the option in writing within five (5)calendar days from receipt to decline my nomination on account of close family ties or friendship, priorconfidential social dealing, business or official transaction with the accused. In the absence of such

Page 198: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

165

declination, I bind myself to perform my assignment as CDP. I understand that I will be liable for thecrime of obstruction of justice if I ignore or neglect to perform my duty as a CDP.

(2) I shall keep this matter strictly confidential and I shall make no contact in any manner, directlyor indirectly, with the accused under pain of disciplinary action for disbarment in violation of this rule; and

(3) I shall accept compensation on per diem basis starting with one (1) non-trial day to preparefor trial and for each day that I appear in court to prosecute a case for trial under the UnconditionalRedeemable Judicial Voucher prescribed in Form GJ-27, at the rate of pay equivalent to the hourlycompensation of the last appointed regular prosecutor of the province or city where I shall serve. I shallrefrain from collecting any additional compensation from the victim or complaining witness.

Very truly yours,

Signature ________________________ Attorney at Law

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

I wish to prosecute the following type of cases:

[_]- Government Graft and Corruption;[_]- Electoral fraud and violence;[_]- Money Laundering;[_]- Murder and Homicide[_]- Human Rights Violations[_]- Others (Specify) ___________________

Page 199: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

166

Instruction to the Provincial or City Prosecutor to assign case for Trial by a CDP - Send to CDP Participant 35 calendardays in advance before Trial Date. Pick this application from the Raffle Box, make a photocopy of the application, except the"Dry Run" attachment, and then deposit back the original in the Raffle Box. Fill in the photocopy with information called forbelow and mail it on time to the CDP Participant.

The [_]-City [_]-Provincial Prosecutor

Of the [_]-City [_]-Province of ________________________________

Address _____________________________________________________________

Date: _____________________________

Dear CDP Pool Participant:

You are one of the five (5) participants in the CDP Pool whose names were randomly drawn from the CDP Raffle Box Pool

for assignment to prosecute in the trial of the accused in the criminal case referenced below;

Type of Case: _______________ Case Number _____________ Name of Accused _____________________

______________ Trial Court of __________________ Branch __________ Telephone __________________

For further details Contact (Name) ________________________________ Telephone __________________

in the Office of the Undersigned.

If two or more of you will signify to accept an assignment to prosecute the case, a lottery shall be conducted to finally choose

one (1) CDP to whom the case on (date) ___________ at (time) ________ __.M. in the Office of the Undersigned located at

___________________________________________________ _____________. We will conduct a raffle among those who

signified and the first application picked shall be appointed, or if absent from the reraffle, the assignment shall be awarded to

the next application picked, if applicant is present.

I CERTIFY under penalty of perjury at (mun/city) _____________________ that on this date __________ _____________,

I have sent [_]-by mail to their addresses below with postage prepaid a copy of [_]-by fax this Case Assignment Notice to each

of the following participants of the CDP of this [_]-Province [_]-City.

[_]- Atty. _______________________, street address, zip/municipality/city/province.

[_]- Atty. _______________________, street address, zip/municipality/city/province.

[_]- Atty. _______________________, street address, zip/municipality/city/province.

[_]- Atty. _______________________, street address, zip/municipality/city/province.

[_]- Atty. _______________________, street address, zip/municipality/city/province.

NOTE: If "Atty. Box" is unmarked, "no notice" was sent shall be presumed for such addressee.

Signature _____________________________ [_]-Provincial [_]-City Prosecutor of __________________

Printed Name __________________________

- End of Form -

Page 200: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

167

Form GJ-47, Registry for Assigned Cases to the CDP.

The ProsecutorCity/Province of ________________

Address _______________________ Page _______

ASSIGNED CASES TO THE CDP POOL REGISTRY(Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type)

(Paper Size: 8-1/2 by 11" - Temporarily Keep in a 3-Ring Binder - Book bind upon reaching 2-inched thickness)

DateOf Trial

Name of Accused

Name of Crime

Case Number

NameOf Judge

Name ofCourt

TelephoneNumber

Name of CDP - > Telephone ->

Street Address - >

Mun/City/Province - >

Date Assigned to CDP- > Result - >

Name of CDP - > Telephone ->

Street Address - >

Mun/City/Province - >

Date Assigned to CDP- > Result - >

Name of CDP - > Telephone ->

Street Address - >

Mun/City/Province - >

Date Assigned to CDP- > Result - >

Name of CDP - > Telephone ->

Street Address - >

Mun/City/Province - >

Date Assigned to CDP- > Result - >

Name of CDP - > Telephone ->

Street Address - >

Mun/City/Province - >

Date Assigned to CDP- > Result - >

- End of Form -

Page 201: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

168

Form GJ-48AD, Invitation for Participation in the Deputy Public Defenders’ Pool (For Newspaper publication advertisement)

The Office of the [_]-City Public Attorney [_]-Provincial Public Attorney

[_]-City [_]-Province of _________________________

Address ______________________________________

______________________________________________

Date today- ____________________

(Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type)

INVITATION FOR PARTICIPATION IN THE DEPUTY PUBLIC DEFENDERS’ POOL

GREETINGS:

The members of the Integrated Bar of the Philippines in good standing who have been engaged in the private

practice of law within the Judicial District of __________________ are hereby invited to participate in the Pool of Deputy

Public Defenders to act as defense trial lawyers for indigent accused persons or minors in the event of shortage of regular

public attorneys. The legal services of the Deputy Public Defender shall be paid equal to the minimum rate of pay of the

regular prosecutor in the locality of the district where he is engaged in the practice of law. His services shall be promptly

paid through the “Voucher-27" system, known as the “Unconditional Non-Transferrable Judicial Voucher”.

The assignment of cases shall be conducted on a lottery basis if two or more interested applicants shall submit

their application to serve in the same case and subject to acceptance and consent by the accused. The qualification and

terms of participation in the Pool are written in the official application form on Form GJ-48-AP as prescribed in Section 99,

Article III, of the National Jury Law.

The form shall not be substituted with any personally devised form.

This advertisement has been posted by the ___________________________________ Public Defense Attorney’s

Office at ____________________________________________________________________________________

- End of Form -

Page 202: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

169

Form GJ-48AP, Application to Participate in the Deputy Public Defenders’ Pool

___________________________________________Attorney at Law - Bar Number _____________

Street Address ____________________________________Zip/Mun/City/Province _______________________________________

Office Telephone __________________ Cellphone __________________ Fax ________________

Date today __________________

APPLICATION TO PARTICIPATE IN THE DEPUTY PUBLIC DEFENDERS’ POOL

INSTRUCTION: 1. Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type; 2. Attach herewithyour "dry run" accomplished Form TJ-110A-B-C-D (a derivative from Form TJ-110) and Form TJ-111. 3. After review by the PublicAttorney, staple together the entire batch and fold the same inward into 3 equal parts. Staple the folded application at the center ofthe edge and drop it in the rafflle box; and 4. This application shall be void if any of its conditions is altered in any manner.

The [_]-Provincial [_]-City [_]-PUBLIC ATTORNEY’S OFFICE[_]-City [_]-Province of ________________Address _______________________________________________________________________________________________

GREETINGS:

I wish to participate in the Pool of Defense Attorney in your office in this Jury District and I respectfully request that my applicationbe entered in the Raffle Box Pool in your office for participants in this Pool.

A: I CERTIFY that:

1. I am a bonafide member of the Integrated Bar of the Philippines. My Bar Number is ___________.

2. I have been engaged in the private practice of law for at least 3 years, actually for ____ years, as of the filing of thisapplication.

3. As of the date of the filing of my application, I certify that I have completely devoted a total of at least 24 hours ofself-study of the National Jury Law. I have read and I am thoroughly familiar both with the Statutory Grand Jury Instruction inSection 24 and Form GJ-41 of Section 99 in Article III, and the Statutory Basic Trial Jury Instruction on Form TJ-108 in Section 2,Article X of the National Jury Law. I have actually accomplished a “dry run” preparation in my own handwriting with the followingforms by assuming the roles of those who are concerned in preparing or filling up those forms, most particularly the following: FormTJ-103, Form TJ-109, Form TJ-109A, Forms TJ-110A-B-C-D (a derivative form from Form TJ-110), Form TJ-111, Form TJ-112,Form TJ-113, Form TJ-114, Form TJ-135, Form TJ-136, Form TJ-137 and Form TJ-138. I further state that I am expertly cognizantof the rudiments in the impaneling of a trial jury and the preemptory challenges of jurors.

B: I PROMISE and WILFULLY AGREE that:

(1) I shall accept an assignment to defend an accused before a bench court or a trial jury of the type of cases I have specifiedin my application for Defense Attorney’s pool membership that may come up for trial at least thirty (30) calendar days before thetrial commencement date. I shall have the option in writing within five (5) calendar days from receipt to decline my nomination onaccount of close family ties or friendship, prior confidential social dealing, business or official transaction with the complainingwitness or complainant. In the absence of such declination, I bind myself to perform my assignment as Deputy Public Defender.I understand that I will be liable for the crime of obstruction of justice if I ignore or neglect to perform my duty as a Deputy PublicDefender.

(2) I shall keep this matter strictly confidential; and (3) I shall accept compensation on per diem basis starting with one non-trial day to prepare for trial and for each day that

I appear in court as a defense attorney on a case for trial under the Unconditional Non-Transferrable Redeemable Judicial Voucherprescribed in Form GJ-27, at the rate of pay equal to the minimum rate of pay of a public prosecutor in this province or city computedon an hourly basis. I shall refrain from collecting any additional fee or compensation from the accused for defending said accused.

Very truly yours,

Signature ________________________ Attorney at Law

INSTRUCTION AND CASE ASSIGNMENT FOR TRIAL - Send toPublic Attorney’s Office not later than 35 calendar days before TrialDate. Promptly after drawing this application from the Raffle Box,make a photocopy of the application, except the "Dry Run" attachment, and then deposit back the original in the Raffle Box. Fill inthe photocopy with information called for below and mail it on time to the participant.

I wish to defend an accused in the following type ofcases:

[_]- Government Graft and Corruption;[_]- Electoral fraud and violence;[_]- Money Laundering or [_]- Plunder;[_]- Murder and Homicide or [_]- Juvenile Cases.[_]- Human Rights Violations

Page 203: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

170

The [_]-City [_]-Provincial Public Attorney’s Office

[_]-City [_]-Province of ______________________

Address _________________________________

Date: _____________________________

Dear Defense Attorney’s Pool Participant:

You are one of the five (5) participants in the Defense Attorney’s Pool whose names were randomly drawn from the Raffle

Container Pool for assignment to defend the accused in the criminal case identified below;

Type of Case: _______________ Case Number _____________ Name of Accused _____________________

______________ Trial Court of __________________ Branch __________ Telephone __________________

For further details Contact (Name) ________________________________ Telephone __________________

in the Office of the Undersigned.

If two or more of you will signify to accept an assignment to prosecute the case, a lottery shall be conducted to finally choose the

Defense Attorney to whom the case shall be assigned at (time) ________ __.M. on (date) ___________ in the Office of this Public

Attorney. We will conduct a raffle among those who signified and the first application picked shall be appointed, or if absent from

the reraffle, the assignment shall be awarded to the next application picked, if applicant is present.

PROOF OF SERVICE

I CERTIFY under penalty of perjury at (mun/city) _____________________ that on this date __________ _____________, I have

sent [_]-by mail to their addresses below with postage prepaid a copy of [_]-by fax this proposed Case Assignment Notice to each

of the following defense attorney participants.

[_]- Atty. ________________________, Address: ______________________________________________________________

Phone # ___________________________ Fax #______________________________

[_]- Atty. ________________________, Address: ______________________________________________________________

Phone # ___________________________ Fax #______________________________

[_]- Atty. ________________________, Address: ______________________________________________________________

Phone # ___________________________ Fax #______________________________

[_]- Atty. ________________________, Address: ______________________________________________________________

Phone # ___________________________ Fax #______________________________

[_]- Atty. ________________________, Address: ______________________________________________________________

Phone # ___________________________ Fax #______________________________

Your legal services shall be paid through the “Unconditional Non-Transferrable Redeemable Judicial Voucher, known as the

“Form GJ-27.”

(NOTE: If "Atty. Box" is unmarked, "no notice" was sent shall be presumed for such addressee.)

Signature ________________________________

Printed Name ____________________________

[_]-Provincial [_]-City Prosecutor of __________________

Page 204: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

171

Form GJ-49, Bill for Serving As: [_]-Jury Presiding Pro Temp Judge [_]- Community DeputyProsecutor [_]-Deputy Public Defender for Accused Indigent or Minor.

(Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type)

_________________________________________________(Attorney at Law)

_________________________________________________(Street/Building/Floor Address)

_________________________________________________(Zip/City/Municipal/Provincial Address)

____________________________(Date)

[_]-The Honorable [_]-Executive Regional [_]-Metropolitan [_]-City [_]Municipal [_]-Sharia Trial Judge [_]-The Honorable [_] Provincial [_]-City Fiscal [_]-Public Attorney

Court Branch/Sala/Office ________________________________________________________________

Street/Building Address _________________________________________________________________

Zip/City/Municipal/Provincial Address _______________________________________________________

GREETINGS:

I respectfully request payment for services rendered by the undersigned in acting as a[_]-Jury Presiding Pro-

Temp Judge [_]-Community Deputy Prosecutor [_]-Deputy Public Defender for an Accused Indigent or Minor

in the matter described below. My appointment letter/notice is herewith attached.

Criminal Case Number - _________________________________________________________________________________________

Title/Criminal Defendant - The People vs _______________________________________________________________________

Court Venue _____________________________________________________________________________________________________

St/Mun./City/Prov Address _______________________________________________________________________________________

Time spent in this case: Preparation- ________ hours. Trial ________ hours = Total __________ hours.

Pay Rate as determined in my application to serve as marked (X) above at P__________ per hour.

Payment requested herein: Total hours __________ X P_____________ per hour = P__________________.

I would greatly appreciate your early payment on this bill through Voucher GJ-27.

DECLARATION: I certify under penalty of perjury to the truthfulness of the above information.

Very respectfully yours,

_________________________________________

(Signature)

_________________________________________

(Bar Number)

Verified by ____________________, Clerk of Court.

Approved for payment by: _____________________(Supervising [_]-Judge [_]-Fiscal [_]-Public Attorney)Date: _________________

Page 205: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

172

Form GJ-50, Prohibition and Declination to Meet an UNSUBPOENAED or Uninvited Grand Jury Visitor

“THE GRAND JURY Of the _______ Jury (Legislative) District of

_____________________________________

Grand Jury Term from ___________________ to _____________________(Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type)

HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL

DECLINATION TO MEET AN UNINVITED GRAND JURY VISITOR

Mr/Madam ____________________________Official Designation _____________________Street Address _________________________Municipality/City ________________________

Dear Mr. (Official Designation, Rank, Title or Position) _______________________________________:

In accordance with Statutory Grand Jury Instruction No. (83) in Article III, Section 24, of the National JuryLaw, and by the Oath of Secrecy of its members under the sovereign power of the people in Article II,Section 1, of the Constitution, which this Grand Jury directly represents, this Grand Jury hereby respectfullydeclines to meet you in person unless this Body has issued and served you with a subpoena or subpoenaduces tecum or summons to obtain a vital information from you. Article III, Section 7(a) of the National JuryLaw forbids the Grand Jury to meet you in person.

This is a response to your written request dated _______________ to his Grand Jury.

Very truly yours,

THE GRAND JURY: Personally signed with validated Date Issued - ____________SIDN#___________ of its Foreman by authority of Article III, Section 7(b) of the National Jury Law.

The Clerk of Court(_)- Regional Trial Court of ________________________(_)- Sharia Trial Court of __________________________(_)- City/Metropolitan Trial Court of __________________(_)- Municipal Trial Court of ________________________Street or Building Address _________________________City/Municipal Address ____________________________

Dear Mr. Clerk of Court:

You are hereby directed by this Grand Jury to serve the official, entity, or dignitary, to whom the above letter concerns.You are likewise directed to keep this matter strictly confidential as required by the Grand Jury Law.

Very truly yours,

THE GRAND JURY: Personally signed with validated Date Issued - ____________SIDN#___________ of its Foreman by authority of Article III, Section 7(b) of the National Jury Law.

- End of Form -

Page 206: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

173

Form GJ-51, Declaration of Assets & Liabilities - For National Jury Law use only.

I, the undersigned, being of sound mind and with legal capacity to execute this document,DECLARE to the truthfulness of the following statements under threat of penalty of perjury andobstruction of justice in this document in regard to my Declaration of Assets and Liabilities, asfollows:

ASSETSI - Bank deposits in my name: ______________________________:

(My full name)Philippine Banks:Name of Bank, Account Number, Address, Amount Balance(Itemize each bank according to the above format)

Bank in Foreign Countries:Name of Bank, Account Number, Address, Amount Balance(Itemize each bank according to the above format)

II- Bank deposits in the name of my spouse ______________________________: (Name of my spouse)

Philippine Banks:Name of Bank, Account Number, Address, Amount Balance(Itemize each bank according to the above format)

Bank in Foreign Countries:Name of Bank, Account Number, Address, Amount Balance(Itemize each bank according to the above format)

III- Bank deposits in the name of my son or daughter ___________________________: (Attach supplemental list for other children) (Name of my son or daughter)

Philippine Banks:Name of Bank, Account Number, Address, Amount Balance(Itemize each bank according to the above format)

Bank in Foreign Countries:Name of Bank, Account Number, Address, Amount Balance(Itemize each bank according to the above format)

IV- Bank deposits in the name of my Parent _____________________________________: (List name of parent or parents)

Philippine Banks:Name of Bank, Account Number, Address, Amount Balance(Itemize each bank according to the above format)

Bank in Foreign Countries:Name of Bank, Account Number, Address, Amount Balance(Itemize each bank according to the above format)

V- Bank deposits in the name of a friend _______________________________________: (List name or name/s of friend/s)

Philippine Banks:Name of Bank, Account Number, Address, Amount Balance(Itemize each bank according to the above format)

Page 207: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

174

Bank in Foreign Countries:Name of Bank, Account Number, Address, Amount Balance(Itemize each bank according to the above format)

VI- Real Properties:

Registered under my name in the Philippines:Name, location, Title or Tax Declaration, Area, ValueFrom whom acquired or purchased & year of purchase

Jointly Registered under my name and my spouse in the Philippines:Name, location, Title or Tax Declaration, Area, ValueFrom whom acquired or purchased & year of purchase

Registered in the name of my son/daughter (name) in the Philippines:Name, location, Title or Tax Declaration, Area, ValueFrom whom acquired or purchased & year of purchase

Registered under the name of a friend or relative (give name):Name, location, Title or Tax Declaration, Area, Value

Registered under my name in the (foreign country - what country):Name, location, Title or Tax Declaration, Area, ValueFrom whom acquired or purchased & year of purchase

Registered under the name of my spouse in (what country):Name, location, Title or Tax Declaration, Area, ValueFrom whom acquired or purchased & year of purchase

VII- Personal Properties:

Vehicles (List All)Make, Year Model, Plate #, Normal Location, Value

Jewelry (List All, Itemize)Name, how many pieces, Value

VIII- Total Value of the above assets P______________

IX- LIST OF VERIFIED LIABILITIES (Itemize below)

1. Describe Loan, Name of Creditor, Address, Balance

2. Describe Loan, Name of Creditor, Address, Balance

3. Judgment Creditor: Court Case and Court Location

X- Total Amount of Liability P______________XI- Deduct X from VIII Balance - Net Asset Value P______________

XII- Total Earnings during my entire incumbency in the Government (Itemize below)(Exclude PorkBarrels, Monetary Allowances and other illegal

Page 208: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

175

income) List only your legal incomes

Name of Public Office, Location, Period of Incumbency

XIII- Add Total of Items under XII and enter here - > P______________

XIV- Deduct one half of amount in XIII. Assume that thisamount was spent for food, school, medical the whole time you were occupying public office P______________

XV- Net Balance of Assets or Net Value of Assets P______________

I further declare that I will firmly promise to repay the above amount in Item XV or surrender with properconveyance deeds my assets listed above back to the government no later than (state date).

I furthermore declare that I have not committed any act of corrupt practices since the date the NationalJury Law was enacted.

I am making this declaration with the view of praying for forgiveness from the People of the Philippinesand that I am truly remorseful about my acts of corruption during my incumbency as a public servantfrom (year) to (year) and as of today (date).

I likewise further promise that I will no longer seek any public office or employment in the governmentand I will remain a private citizen the rest of my life.

I understand that if I fail to pay or surrender the assets I promised to pay or surrender on my promisedundertaking, I will be indicted in court by the Grand Jury in this district for violation of Republic Act 3019as well as for obstruction of justice and for all crimes of corruption I may have committed before andafter the National Jury Law took effect. EXECUTED this __________ day of ____________ year ______ in the City/Municipality of

___________________ Province of ____________________.

__________________________________ I have explained to my client the conse-(Signature of Declarant) quences of signing and of not signing__________________________________ this document. Assisted by:(Printed Name of Declarant)

__________________________________ __________________________________________________________________ (Signature of Declarant’s Counsel)(Municipal or City Address of Declarant)

__________________________________________________________________ (Printed Name of Declarant’s Counsel(Official or Public Position of Declarant) ________________________________

(Bar Number of Counsel)

- End of Form -

Page 209: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

176

Form GJ-52, Summons to High Ranking Public Officials, Nobility or Royalty

THE GRAND JURY Of the _______ Grand Jury District of

The Province/ City of ________________________

Grand Jury Term from ___________________ to _____________________

(Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type)

Very Highly Confidential

SUMMONS TO A PROSECUTOR, JUDGE, JUSTICE, CONGRESSMA N, SENATOR,PRESIDENT, GOVERNOR, MAYOR, OR ANY PUBLIC OFFICIAL, NOBILITY OR ROYALTY

(State Name, Title, Rank or Public Position) _______________________________________ Street or Building Address ______________________________________________________City Address ________________________________________________________________

GREETINGS:

You are hereby directed to appear in person alone, without assistance by anyone or lawyer, before thisGrand Jury for consultation of an important matter. The Case Reference Number of the matter is GJ#

_____________. Please contact the clerk of court, telephone No. _________________, whose physicaladdress is at ________________________________________________________________________

___________________________________________________________________________, to set upyour appointment with this Grand Jury. The Clerk of Court shall thereupon inform this Grand Jury of your

appointed date and time. On the day and time for your appearance, please report to the same clerk of courtand sign up in his Log Book. He/She will escort you in entering our Grand Jury Room. Please bring with you

your proper Identification and this summons.

You are ordered to keep this matter strictly confidential as required by Article III, Section 7(d) of the NationalJury Law, a violation of which shall subject you for indictment for Obstruction of Justice.

Very truly yours,

THE GRAND JURY: Personally signed with validated Date Issued - ____________SIDN#___________ of its Foreman by authority of Article III, Section 7(b) of the National Jury Law.

The Clerk of Court:

Please serve the above summons to the subject person therein and promptly inform this Grand Jury ofhis/her arrival date and time.

The Grand Jury Secretary: SIDN# _____________ Date _________________

PROOF OF SERVICE AND DELIVERY OF SUMMONS(After being signed by server, the original of this document

must be submitted to and kept by the Secretary of the Grand Jury)

Page 210: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

177

1. I served this Summons, Form GJ-52, by personally delivering a copy thereof to the person namedtherein and written below: (The personal server must fill in by handwriting in the blanks hereunder)

(a) Name of Person Served ________________________________________________

(b) Address where served ________________________________________________

__________________________________________________________________________

(c) Date/Time of Delivery: _____________, 20___ ______ ___.M

2. [_]- Non-Service Return of Summons (fill in and sign if server is unable to serve): After due search,careful inquiry, and diligent attempts at the dwelling or usual place of abode or usual place ofbusiness or work, I have been unable to make personal delivery of this Subpoena in this District onthe person named therein for the following reason/s:_______________________________________________________________________________

_______________________________________________________________________________

_____________________________________________________________________________

I declare under penalty of perjury that this failure to serve this Summons has not been induced withconspiracy, bribery, or any form of agreement by this server with the person to be served or with a thirdparty.

3. Information about the Server or Person serving:

Print Full Name- ________________________________________ (Must sign below)

Occupation- __________________________________________________________________

Address - ___________________________________________________________________

Telephone Number/s, __________________________ Fax ___________________________

I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the Philippines that the foregoing information is true andcorrect (Note: Read carefully before signing. Anyone who falsifies a statement in this document shall beliable for indictment of perjury or of obstruction of justice and for punishment by imprisonment.

____________________, 20______ _________________________________" (Date Signed) (Signature)

Page 211: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

178

Form GJ-53, Summons to a Lawyer.

THE GRAND JURY Of the _______ Grand Jury District of

The City of ________________

Grand Jury Term from ___________________ to _____________________

(Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type)

Very Highly Confidential

SUMMONS TO A LAWYER

Attorney (State his Name) Atty. _______________________________________________________

Street or Building Address ______________________________________________________City Address ________________________________________________________________

GREETINGS:

You are hereby directed to appear in person alone, without assistance by anyone or lawyer, before thisGrand Jury for consultation of an important matter. The Case Reference Number of the matter is GJ#_____________. Please contact the clerk of court, telephone No. _________________, whose physicaladdress is at ___________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________, to set upyour appointment with this Grand Jury. The Clerk of Court shall thereupon inform this Grand Jury of yourappointed date and time. On the day and time for your appearance, please report to the same clerk of courtand sign up in his Log Book. He/She will escort you in entering our Grand Jury Room. Please bring with youyour proper Identification and this summons.

You are ordered to keep this matter strictly confidential as required by Article III, Section 7(d) of the NationalJury Law, a violation of which shall subject you for indictment for Obstruction of Justice.

Very truly yours,

THE GRAND JURY: Personally signed with validated Date Issued - ____________SIDN#___________ of its Foreman by authority of Article III, Section 7(b) of the National Jury Law.

The Clerk of Court:

Please serve the above summons to the subject person therein and promptly inform this Grand Jury ofhis/her arrival date and time.

The Grand Jury Secretary: SIDN# _____________ Date _________________

Page 212: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

179

PROOF OF SERVICE AND DELIVERY OF SUMMONS(After being signed by server, the original of this document

must be submitted to and kept by the Secretary of the Grand Jury)

1. I served this Summons, Form GJ-53, by personally delivering a copy thereof to the person namedtherein and written below: (The personal server must fill in by handwriting in the blanks hereunder)

(a) Name of Person Served ________________________________________________

(b) Address where served ________________________________________________

_____________________________________________________________________

(c) Date/Time of Delivery: _____________, 20___ ______ ___.M

2. [_]- Non-Service Return of Summons (fill in and sign if server is unable to serve): After due search,careful inquiry, and diligent attempts at the dwelling or usual place of abode or usual place ofbusiness or work, I have been unable to make personal delivery of this Subpoena in this District onthe person named therein for the following reason/s:_______________________________________________________________________________

_______________________________________________________________________________

_____________________________________________________________________________

I declare under penalty of perjury that this failure to serve this Summons has not been induced withconspiracy, bribery, or any form of agreement by this server with the person to be served or with a thirdparty.

3. Information about the Server or Person serving:

Print Full Name- ________________________________________ (Must sign below) Occupation- __________________________________________________________________Address - ___________________________________________________________________Telephone Number/s, __________________________ Fax ___________________________

I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the Philippines that the foregoing information is true andcorrect (Note: Read carefully before signing. Anyone who falsifies a statement in this document shall beliable for indictment of perjury or of obstruction of justice and for punishment by imprisonment.

____________________, 20______ _________________________________" (Date Signed) (Signature)

Page 213: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

180

THE GRAND JURY Of the _______ Grand Jury District of

The Province/ City of ________________

Grand Jury Term from ___________________ to _____________________

VERY HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL

GRAND JURY CASE No. _________________

BILL/INVOICE FOR GRAND JURY CONSULTATION

The Provincial/City Treasurer of _____________________________________________

Street Address ___________________________________________________________

City Address ____________________________________________________________

Dear Mr./Ms. Treasurer:

Please pay this Bill/Invoice to the Bearer who is identified and authenticated as SIDN# ___________ in our

records by the Foreman of this Grand Jury for professional medical consultation in connection with the

above indicated Grand Jury Case Number.

He/She has devoted approximately ________ hours of his/her time in our conference room relating to

certain technicalities in connection with the above case between the hours from _________ __M. and

______________ __M. on (date) ___________________ (day) __________________.

This Grand Jury recommends payment to the Bearer the amount of P______________ pesos in Philippine

Currency as a reasonable compensation for his/her service.

Under Grand Jury Rules of Secrecy, no further detailed information can be disclosed in this document.

Consultant’s SIDN# ______________

Authenticated by:

THE GRAND JURY, Signed with the SIDN#________ Date Issued - ____________of its Foreman by authority of Article III, Section 7(b) of the National Jury Law.

IMPORTANT

1. The SIDN# of the bearer must be obtained from t he GJ’s Registry Form TJ-32. No SIDN# shall be issued unless properly reco rded by the TJ Secretary.

2. The amount to be paid to the consultant must be agreed upon between the Bearer and the TJ Foreman and written in the Bill/Invoice before Bearer leaves the Grand Jury Room.

3. Do not submit a copy of the Summons to the Bill /Invoice when presenting for payment.

- End of Form -

Page 214: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

181

Form GJ-54, Summons to a Medical Doctor.

THE GRAND JURY Of the _______ Grand Jury District of

The Province/City of ________________

Grand Jury Term from ___________________ to _____________________

(Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type)

Very Highly Confidential

SUMMONS TO A MEDICAL DOCTOR

Doctor (State his Name, Title or Position) _______________________________________________

Street or Building Address ______________________________________________________

City Address ________________________________________________________________

GREETINGS:

You are hereby directed to appear in person alone, without assistance by anyone or lawyer, before this

Grand Jury for consultation of an important matter. The Case Reference Number of the matter is TJ#

_____________. Please contact the clerk of court, telephone No. _________________, whose physical

address is at ________________________________________________________________________

___________________________________________________________________________, to set up

your appointment with this Grand Jury. The Clerk of Court shall thereupon inform this Grand Jury of your

appointed date and time. On the day and time for your appearance, please report to the same clerk of court

and sign up in his Log Book. He/She will escort you in entering our Grand Jury Room. Please bring with you

your proper Identification and this summons.

You are ordered to keep this matter strictly confidential as required by Article III, Section 7(d) of the National

Jury Law, a violation of which shall subject you for indictment for Obstruction of Justice.

Very truly yours,

THE GRAND JURY: Personally signed with validated Date Issued - ____________

SIDN#___________ of its Foreman by authority

of Article III, Section 7(b) of the National Jury Law.

The Clerk of Court:

Please serve the above summons to the subject person therein and promptly inform this Grand Jury of

his/her arrival date and time.

The Grand Jury Secretary: SIDN# _____________ Date _________________

Page 215: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

182

PROOF OF SERVICE AND DELIVERY OF SUMMONS(After being signed by server, the original of this document

must be submitted to and kept by the Secretary of the Grand Jury)

1. I served this Summons, Form TJ-54, by personally delivering a copy thereof to the person namedtherein and written below: (The personal server must fill in by handwriting in the blanks hereunder)

(a) Name of Person Served ________________________________________________

(b) Address where served ________________________________________________

_____________________________________________________________________

(c) Date/Time of Delivery: _____________, 20___ ______ ___.M

2. [_]- Non-Service Return of Summons (fill in and sign if server is unable to serve): After due search,careful inquiry, and diligent attempts at the dwelling or usual place of abode or usual place ofbusiness or work, I have been unable to make personal delivery of this Subpoena in this District onthe person named therein for the following reason/s:_______________________________________________________________________________

_______________________________________________________________________________

________________________________________________________________________

I declare under penalty of perjury that this failure to serve this Summons has not been induced withconspiracy, bribery, or any form of agreement by this server with the person to be served or with a thirdparty.

3. Information about the Server or Person serving:

Print Full Name- ________________________________________ (Must sign below) Occupation- __________________________________________________________________Address - ___________________________________________________________________Telephone Number/s, __________________________ Fax ___________________________

I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the Philippines that the foregoing information is true andcorrect (Note: Read carefully before signing. Anyone who falsifies a statement in this document shall beliable for indictment of perjury or of obstruction of justice and for punishment by imprisonment.

____________________, 20______ _________________________________" (Date Signed) (Signature)

Page 216: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

183

THE GRAND JURY Of the _______ Grand Jury District of

The Province/ City of ________________

Grand Jury Term from ___________________ to _____________________

VERY HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL

GRAND JURY CASE No. _________________

BILL/INVOICE FOR GRAND JURY CONSULTATION

The Provincial/City Treasurer of _____________________________________________

Street Address ___________________________________________________________

City Address ____________________________________________________________

Dear Mr./Ms. Treasurer:

Please pay this Bill/Invoice to the Bearer who is identified and authenticated as SIDN# ___________ in our

records by the Foreman of this Grand Jury for professional medical consultation in connection with the

above indicated Grand Jury Case Number.

He/She has devoted approximately ________ hours of his/her time in our conference room relating to

certain technicalities in connection with the above case between the hours from _________ __M. and

______________ __M. on (date) ___________________ (day) __________________.

This Grand Jury recommends payment to the Bearer the amount of P______________ pesos in Philippine

Currency as a reasonable compensation for his/her service.

Under Grand Jury Rules of Secrecy, no further detailed information can be disclosed in this document.

Consultant’s SIDN# ______________

Authenticated by:

THE GRAND JURY, Signed with the SIDN#________ Date Issued - ____________of its Foreman by authority of Article III, Section 7(b) of the National Jury Law.

IMPORTANT

1. The SIDN# of the bearer must be obtained from t he GJ’s Registry Form TJ-32. No SIDN# shall be issued unless properly reco rded by the TJ Secretary.

2. The amount to be paid to the consultant must be agreed upon between the Bearer and the TJ Foreman and written in the Bill/Invoice before Bearer leaves the Grand Jury Room.

3. Do not submit a copy of the Summons to the Bill /Invoice when presenting for payment.

- End of Form -

Page 217: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

184

Form GJ-55, Summons to a Certified Public Accountant.

THE GRAND JURY Of the _______ Grand Jury District of

The Province/City of ________________

Grand Jury Term from ___________________ to _____________________

(Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type)

Very Highly Confidential

SUMMONS TO A CERTIFIED PUBLIC ACCOUNTANT

CPA (State his Name, Title or Position) _________________________________________________

Street or Building Address ______________________________________________________City Address ________________________________________________________________

GREETINGS:

You are hereby directed to appear in person alone, without assistance by anyone or lawyer, before this

Grand Jury for consultation of an important matter. The Case Reference Number of the matter is TJ#_____________. Please contact the clerk of court, telephone No. _________________, whose physical

address is at ___________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________, to set up

your appointment with this Grand Jury. The Clerk of Court shall thereupon inform this Grand Jury of yourappointed date and time. On the day and time for your appearance, please report to the same clerk of court

and sign up in his Log Book. He/She will escort you in entering our Grand Jury Room. Please bring with youyour proper Identification and this summons.

You are ordered to keep this matter strictly confidential as required by Article III, Section 7(d) of the National

Jury Law, a violation of which shall subject you for indictment for Obstruction of Justice.

Very truly yours,

THE GRAND JURY: Personally signed with validated Date Issued - ____________SIDN#___________ of its Foreman by authority of Article III, Section 7(b) of the National Jury Law.

The Clerk of Court:

Please serve the above summons to the subject person therein and promptly inform this Grand Jury of

his/her arrival date and time.

The Grand Jury Secretary: SIDN# _____________ Date _________________

Page 218: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

185

PROOF OF SERVICE AND DELIVERY OF SUMMONS

(After being signed by server, the original of this document

must be submitted to and kept by the Secretary of the Grand Jury)

1. I served this Summons, Form GJ-55, by personally delivering a copy thereof to the person named

therein and written below: (The personal server must fill in by handwriting in the blanks hereunder)

(a) Name of Person Served ________________________________________________

(b) Address where served ________________________________________________

_____________________________________________________________________

(c) Date/Time of Delivery: _____________, 20___ ______ ___.M

2. [_]- Non-Service Return of Summons (fill in and sign if server is unable to serve): After due search,

careful inquiry, and diligent attempts at the dwelling or usual place of abode or usual place of

business or work, I have been unable to make personal delivery of this Subpoena in this District on

the person named therein for the following reason/s:

_______________________________________________________________________________

_______________________________________________________________________________

________________________________________________________________________

I declare under penalty of perjury that this failure to serve this Summons has not been

induced with conspiracy, bribery, or any form of agreement by this server with the person to be

served or with a third party.

3. Information about the Server or Person serving:

Print Full Name- ________________________________________ (Must sign below)

Occupation- ____________________________________________________________

Address - _____________________________________________________________

Telephone Number/s, ________________________ Fax _______________________

I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the Philippines that the foregoing information

is true and correct (Note: Read carefully before signing. Anyone who falsifies a statement in this

document shall be liable for indictment of perjury or of obstruction of justice and for punishment

by imprisonment.

____________________, 20______ _________________________________"

(Date Signed) (Signature)

Page 219: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

186

THE GRAND JURY Of the _______ Grand Jury District of

The Province/ City of ________________

Grand Jury Term from ___________________ to _____________________

VERY HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL

GRAND JURY CASE No. _________________

BILL/INVOICE FOR GRAND JURY CONSULTATION

The Provincial/City Treasurer of _____________________________________________

Street Address ___________________________________________________________

City Address ____________________________________________________________

Dear Mr./Ms. Treasurer:

Please pay this Bill/Invoice to the Bearer who is identified and authenticated as SIDN# ___________ in our

records by the Foreman of this Grand Jury for professional accounting consultation in connection with the

above indicated Grand Jury Case Number.

He/She has devoted approximately ________ hours of his/her time in our conference room relating to

certain technicalities in connection with the above case between the hours from _________ __M. and

______________ __M. on (date) ___________________ (day) __________________.

This Grand Jury recommends payment to the Bearer the amount of P______________ pesos in Philippine

Currency as a reasonable compensation for his/her service.

Under Grand Jury Rules of Secrecy, no further detailed information can be disclosed in this document.

Consultant’s SIDN# ______________

Authenticated by:

THE GRAND JURY, Signed with the SIDN#____________ Date Issued - ____________

of its Foreman by authority of Article III, Section 7(b) of the National Jury Law.

IMPORTANT

1. The SIDN# of the bearer must be obtained from t he GJ’s Registry Form GJ-32.

No SIDN# shall be issued unless properly reco rded by the TJ Secretary.

2. The amount to be paid to the consultant must be agreed upon between the Bearer and

the TJ Foreman and written in the Bill/Invoice before Bearer leaves the Grand Jury Room.

3. Do not submit a copy of the Summons to the Bill /Invoice when presenting for payment.

- End of Form -

Page 220: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

187

Form GJ-56, Summons to an Engineer.

THE GRAND JURY Of the _______ Grand Jury District of

The Province/City of ________________

Grand Jury Term from ___________________ to _____________________

(Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type)

Very Highly Confidential

SUMMONS TO AN ENGINEER

Engineer, (State his Name, Title or Position) _____________________________________________

Street or Building Address ______________________________________________________

City Address ________________________________________________________________

GREETINGS:

You are hereby directed to appear in person alone, without assistance by anyone or lawyer, before this

Grand Jury for consultation of an important matter. The Case Reference Number of the matter is TJ#

_____________. Please contact the clerk of court, telephone No. _________________, whose physical

address is at ________________________________________________________________________

___________________________________________________________________________, to set up

your appointment with this Grand Jury. The Clerk of Court shall thereupon inform this Grand Jury of your

appointed date and time. On the day and time for your appearance, please report to the same clerk of court

and sign up in his Log Book. He/She will escort you in entering our Grand Jury Room. Please bring with you

your proper Identification and this summons.

You are ordered to keep this matter strictly confidential as required by Article III, Section 7(d) of the National

Jury Law, a violation of which shall subject you for indictment for Obstruction of Justice.

Very truly yours,

THE GRAND JURY: Personally signed with validated Date Issued - ____________

SIDN#___________ of its Foreman by authority

of Article III, Section 7(b) of the National Jury Law.

The Clerk of Court:

Please serve the above summons to the subject person therein and promptly inform this Grand Jury of

his/her arrival date and time.

The Grand Jury Secretary: SIDN# _____________ Date _________________

Page 221: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

188

PROOF OF SERVICE AND DELIVERY OF SUMMONS(After being signed by server, the original of this document

must be submitted to and kept by the Secretary of the Grand Jury)

1. I served this Summons, Form GJ-56, by personally delivering a copy thereof to the person namedtherein and written below: (The personal server must fill in by handwriting in the blanks hereunder)

(a) Name of Person Served ________________________________________________

(b) Address where served ________________________________________________

_____________________________________________________________________

(c) Date/Time of Delivery: _____________, 20___ ______ ___.M

2. [_]- Non-Service Return of Summons (fill in and sign if server is unable to serve): After due search,careful inquiry, and diligent attempts at the dwelling or usual place of abode or usual place ofbusiness or work, I have been unable to make personal delivery of this Subpoena in this District onthe person named therein for the following reason/s:_______________________________________________________________________________

_______________________________________________________________________________

________________________________________________________________________

I declare under penalty of perjury that this failure to serve this Summons has not beeninduced with conspiracy, bribery, or any form of agreement by this server with the person to beserved or with a third party.

3. Information about the Server or Person serving:

Print Full Name- ________________________________________ (Must sign below) Occupation- ____________________________________________________________Address - _____________________________________________________________Telephone Number/s, ________________________ Fax _______________________

I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the Philippines that the foregoing informationis true and correct (Note: Read carefully before signing. Anyone who falsifies a statement in thisdocument shall be liable for indictment of perjury or of obstruction of justice and for punishmentby imprisonment.

____________________, 20______ _________________________________" (Date Signed) (Signature)

Page 222: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

189

THE GRAND JURY Of the _______ Grand Jury District of

The Province/ City of ________________

Grand Jury Term from ___________________ to _____________________

VERY HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL

GRAND JURY CASE No. _________________

BILL/INVOICE FOR GRAND JURY CONSULTATION

The Provincial/City Treasurer of _____________________________________________

Street Address ___________________________________________________________

City Address ____________________________________________________________

Dear Mr./Ms. Treasurer:

Please pay this Bill/Invoice to the Bearer who is identified and authenticated as SIDN# ___________ in our

records by the Foreman of this Grand Jury for professional engineering consultation in connection with the

above indicated Grand Jury Case Number.

He/She has devoted approximately ________ hours of his/her time in our conference room relating to

certain technicalities in connection with the above case between the hours from _________ __M. and

______________ __M. on (date) ___________________ (day) __________________.

This Grand Jury recommends payment to the Bearer the amount of P______________ pesos in Philippine

Currency as a reasonable compensation for his/her service.

Under Grand Jury Rules of Secrecy, no further detailed information can be disclosed in this document.

Consultant’s SIDN# ______________

Authenticated by:

THE GRAND JURY, Signed with the SIDN#____________ Date Issued - ____________

of its Foreman by authority of Article III, Section 7(b) of the National Jury Law.

IMPORTANT

1. The SIDN# of the bearer must be obtained from t he GJ’s Registry Form GJ-32.

No SIDN# shall be issued unless properly reco rded by the TJ Secretary.

2. The amount to be paid to the consultant must be agreed upon between the Bearer and

the TJ Foreman and written in the Bill/Invoice b efore Bearer leaves the Grand Jury Room.

3. Do not submit a copy of the Summons to the Bill /Invoice when presenting for payment.

- End of Form -

Page 223: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

190

Form GJ-57, Summons to a Vehicle Mechanic.

THE GRAND JURY Of the _______ Grand Jury District of

The Province/City of ________________

Grand Jury Term from ___________________ to _____________________

(Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type)

Very Highly Confidential

SUMMONS TO A VEHICLE MECHANIC

Mechanic, (State his Name, Title or Position) _____________________________________________

Street or Building Address ______________________________________________________

City Address ________________________________________________________________

GREETINGS:

You are hereby directed to appear in person alone, without assistance by anyone or lawyer, before this

Grand Jury for consultation of an important matter. The Case Reference Number of the matter is GJ#

_____________. Please contact the clerk of court, telephone No. _________________, whose physical

address is at ________________________________________________________________________

___________________________________________________________________________, to set up

your appointment with this Grand Jury. The Clerk of Court shall thereupon inform this Grand Jury of your

appointed date and time. On the day and time for your appearance, please report to the same clerk of court

and sign up in his Log Book. He/She will escort you in entering our Grand Jury Room. Please bring with you

your proper Identification and this summons.

You are ordered to keep this matter strictly confidential as required by Article III, Section 7(d) of the National

Jury Law, a violation of which shall subject you for indictment for Obstruction of Justice.

Very truly yours,

THE GRAND JURY: Personally signed with validated Date Issued - ____________

SIDN#___________ of its Foreman by authority

of Article III, Section 7(b) of the National Jury Law.

The Clerk of Court:

Please serve the above summons to the subject person therein and promptly inform this Grand Jury of

his/her arrival date and time.

The Grand Jury Secretary: SIDN# _____________ Date _________________

Page 224: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

191

PROOF OF SERVICE AND DELIVERY OF SUMMONS

(After being signed by server, the original of this document

must be submitted to and kept by the Secretary of the Grand Jury)

1. I served this Summons, Form GJ-57, by personally delivering a copy thereof to the person named

therein and written below: (The personal server must fill in by handwriting in the blanks hereunder)

(a) Name of Person Served ________________________________________________

(b) Address where served ________________________________________________

_____________________________________________________________________

(c) Date/Time of Delivery: _____________, 20___ ______ ___.M

2. [_]- Non-Service Return of Summons (fill in and sign if server is unable to serve): After due search,

careful inquiry, and diligent attempts at the dwelling or usual place of abode or usual place of

business or work, I have been unable to make personal delivery of this Subpoena in this District on

the person named therein for the following reason/s:

_______________________________________________________________________________

_______________________________________________________________________________

________________________________________________________________________

I declare under penalty of perjury that this failure to serve this Summons has not been

induced with conspiracy, bribery, or any form of agreement by this server with the person to be

served or with a third party.

3. Information about the Server or Person serving:

Print Full Name- ________________________________________ (Must sign below)

Occupation- ____________________________________________________________

Address - _____________________________________________________________

Telephone Number/s, ________________________ Fax _______________________

I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the Philippines that the foregoing information

is true and correct (Note: Read carefully before signing. Anyone who falsifies a statement in this

document shall be liable for indictment of perjury or of obstruction of justice and for punishment

by imprisonment.

____________________, 20______ _________________________________"

(Date Signed) (Signature)

Page 225: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

192

THE GRAND JURY Of the _______ Grand Jury District of

The Province/ City of ________________

Grand Jury Term from ___________________ to _____________________

VERY HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL

GRAND JURY CASE No. _________________

BILL/INVOICE FOR GRAND JURY CONSULTATION

The Provincial/City Treasurer of _____________________________________________

Street Address ___________________________________________________________

City Address ____________________________________________________________

Dear Mr./Ms. Treasurer:

Please pay this Bill/Invoice to the Bearer who is identified and authenticated as SIDN# ___________ in our

records by the Foreman of this Grand Jury for professional vehicular mechanical consultation in connection

with the above indicated Grand Jury Case Number.

He/She has devoted approximately ________ hours of his/her time in our conference room relating to

certain technicalities in connection with the above case between the hours from _________ __M. and

______________ __M. on (date) ___________________ (day) __________________.

This Grand Jury recommends payment to the Bearer the amount of P______________ pesos in Philippine

Currency as a reasonable compensation for his/her service.

Under Grand Jury Rules of Secrecy, no further detailed information can be disclosed in this document.

Consultant’s SIDN# ______________

Authenticated by:

THE GRAND JURY, Signed with the SIDN#____________ Date Issued - ____________

of its Foreman by authority of Article III, Section 7(b) of the National Jury Law.

IMPORTANT

1. The SIDN# of the bearer must be obtained from t he GJ’s Registry Form GJ-32.

No SIDN# shall be issued unless properly reco rded by the GJ Secretary.

2. The amount to be paid to the consultant must be agreed upon between the Bearer and

the GJ Foreman and written in the Bill/Invoic e before Bearer leaves the Grand Jury Room.

3. Do not submit a copy of the Summons to the Bill /Invoice when presenting for payment.

- End of Form -

Page 226: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

193

Form GJ-58, Summons to a Police Officer.

THE GRAND JURY Of the _______ Grand Jury District of

The Province/City of ________________

Grand Jury Term from ___________________ to _____________________

(Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type)

Very Highly Confidential

SUMMONS TO A POLICE OFFICER

Police Officer, (State his Name, Rank or Position) __________________________________________

Street or Building Address ______________________________________________________

City Address ________________________________________________________________

GREETINGS:

You are hereby directed to appear in person alone, without assistance by anyone or lawyer, before this

Grand Jury for consultation of an important matter. The Case Reference Number of the matter is GJ#

_____________. Please contact the clerk of court, telephone No. _________________, whose physical

address is at ________________________________________________________________________

___________________________________________________________________________, to set up

your appointment with this Grand Jury. The Clerk of Court shall thereupon inform this Grand Jury of your

appointed date and time. On the day and time for your appearance, please report to the same clerk of court

and sign up in his Log Book. He/She will escort you in entering our Grand Jury Room. Please bring with you

your proper Identification and this summons.

You are ordered to keep this matter strictly confidential as required by Article III, Section 7(d) of the National

Jury Law, a violation of which shall subject you for indictment for Obstruction of Justice.

Very truly yours,

THE GRAND JURY: Personally signed with validated Date Issued - ____________

SIDN#___________ of its Foreman by authority

of Article III, Section 7(b) of the National Jury Law.

The Clerk of Court:

Please serve the above summons to the subject person therein and promptly inform this Grand Jury of

his/her arrival date and time.

The Grand Jury Secretary: SIDN# _____________ Date _________________

Page 227: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

194

PROOF OF SERVICE AND DELIVERY OF SUMMONS

(After being signed by server, the original of this document

must be submitted to and kept by the Secretary of the Grand Jury)

1. I served this Summons, Form GJ-58, by personally delivering a copy thereof to the person named

therein and written below: (The personal server must fill in by handwriting in the blanks hereunder)

(a) Name of Person Served ________________________________________________

(b) Address where served ________________________________________________

_____________________________________________________________________

(c) Date/Time of Delivery: _____________, 20___ ______ ___.M

2. [_]- Non-Service Return of Summons (fill in and sign if server is unable to serve): After due search,

careful inquiry, and diligent attempts at the dwelling or usual place of abode or usual place of

business or work, I have been unable to make personal delivery of this Subpoena in this District on

the person named therein for the following reason/s:

_____________________________________________________________________________

_____________________________________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________________

I declare under penalty of perjury that this failure to serve this Summons has not been induced with

conspiracy, bribery, or any form of agreement by this server with the person to be served or with a

third party.

3. Information about the Server or Person serving:

Print Full Name- _____________________________________________ (Must sign below)

Occupation- __________________________________________________________________

Address - ______________________________________________________________________

Telephone Number/s, ___________________________ Fax ___________________________

I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the Philippines that the foregoing information is true and

correct (Note: Read carefully before signing. Anyone who falsifies a statement in this document shall be

liable for indictment of perjury or of obstruction of justice and for punishment by imprisonment.

____________________, 20______ _________________________________"

(Date Signed) (Signature)

- End of form -

Page 228: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

195

Form GJ-59, Summons to an Army Officer.

THE GRAND JURY Of the _______ Grand Jury District of

The Province/City of ________________

Grand Jury Term from ___________________ to _____________________

(Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type)

Very Highly Confidential

SUMMONS TO AN ARMY OFFICER

Army Officer, (State his Name, Rank or Position) __________________________________________

Street or Building Address ______________________________________________________City Address ________________________________________________________________

GREETINGS:

You are hereby directed to appear in person alone, without assistance by anyone or lawyer, before thisGrand Jury for consultation of an important matter. The Case Reference Number of the matter is GJ#_____________. Please contact the clerk of court, telephone No. _________________, whose physicaladdress is at ___________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________, to set upyour appointment with this Grand Jury. The Clerk of Court shall thereupon inform this Grand Jury of yourappointed date and time. On the day and time for your appearance, please report to the same clerk of courtand sign up in his Log Book. He/She will escort you in entering our Grand Jury Room. Please bring with youyour proper Identification and this summons.

You are ordered to keep this matter strictly confidential as required by Article III, Section 7(d) of the NationalJury Law, a violation of which shall subject you for indictment for Obstruction of Justice.

Very truly yours,

THE GRAND JURY: Personally signed with validated Date Issued - ____________SIDN#___________ of its Foreman by authority of Article III, Section 7(b) of the National Jury Law.

TheClerk of Court:

Please serve the above summons to the subject person therein and promptly inform this Grand Jury ofhis/her arrival date and time.

The Grand Jury Secretary: SIDN# _____________ Date _________________

Page 229: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

196

PROOF OF SERVICE AND DELIVERY OF SUMMONS(After being signed by server, the original of this document

must be submitted to and kept by the Secretary of the Grand Jury)

1. I served this Summons, Form GJ-59, by personally delivering a copy thereof to the person namedtherein and written below: (The personal server must fill in by handwriting in the blanks hereunder)

(a) Name of Person Served ___________________________________________________

(b) Address where served ___________________________________________________

________________________________________________________________________

(c) Date/Time of Delivery: ________________, 20___ _________ ______.M

2. [_]- Non-Service Return of Summons (fill in and sign if server is unable to serve): After due search,careful inquiry, and diligent attempts at the dwelling or usual place of abode or usual place ofbusiness or work, I have been unable to make personal delivery of this Subpoena in this District onthe person named therein for the following reason/s:_____________________________________________________________________________

_____________________________________________________________________________

_____________________________________________________________________________

I declare under penalty of perjury that this failure to serve this Summons has not been induced withconspiracy, bribery, or any form of agreement by this server with the person to be served or with athird party.

3. Information about the Server or Person serving:

Print Full Name- _____________________________________________ (Must sign below) Occupation- __________________________________________________________________Address - _____________________________________________, ______________________Telephone Number/s, ___________________________ Fax ___________________________

I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the Philippines that the foregoing information is true andcorrect (Note: Read carefully before signing. Anyone who falsifies a statement in this document shall beliable for indictment of perjury or of obstruction of justice and for punishment by imprisonment.

____________________, 20______ _________________________________" (Date Signed) (Signature)

- End of form -

Page 230: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

197

Form GJ-60, Summons to a Navy Officer.

THE GRAND JURY Of the _______ Grand Jury District of

The Province/City of ________________

Grand Jury Term from ___________________ to _____________________

(Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type)

Very Highly Confidential

SUMMONS TO A NAVY OFFICER

Navy Officer,(State his Name, Rank or Position) __________________________________________

Street or Building Address ______________________________________________________City Address ________________________________________________________________

GREETINGS:

You are hereby directed to appear in person alone, without assistance by anyone or lawyer, before thisGrand Jury for consultation of an important matter. The Case Reference Number of the matter is GJ# _____________. Please contact the clerk of court, telephone No. _________________, whose physicaladdress is at ___________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________, to set upyour appointment with this Grand Jury. The Clerk of Court shall thereupon inform this Grand Jury ofyour appointed date and time. On the day and time for your appearance, please report to the sameclerk of court and sign up in his Log Book. He/She will escort you in entering our Grand Jury Room.Please bring with you your proper Identification and this summons.

You are ordered to keep this matter strictly confidential as required by Article III, Section 7(d) of theNational Jury Law, a violation of which shall subject you for indictment for Obstruction of Justice.

Very truly yours,

THE GRAND JURY: Personally signed with validated Date Issued - ____________SIDN#___________ of its Foreman by authority of Article III, Section 7(b) of the National Jury Law.

The Clerk of Court:

Please serve the above summons to the subject person therein and promptly inform this Grand Jury ofhis/her arrival date and time.

The Grand Jury Secretary: SIDN# _____________ Date _________________

Page 231: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

198

PROOF OF SERVICE AND DELIVERY OF SUMMONS(After being signed by server, the original of this document

must be submitted to and kept by the Secretary of the Grand Jury)

1. I served this Summons, Form GJ-60, by personally delivering a copy thereof to the person namedtherein and written below: (The personal server must fill in by handwriting in the blanks hereunder)

(a) Name of Person Served ________________________________________________

(b) Address where served ________________________________________________

_____________________________________________________________________

(c) Date/Time of Delivery: _____________, 20___ ______ ___.M

2. [_]- Non-Service Return of Summons (fill in and sign if server is unable to serve): After due search,careful inquiry, and diligent attempts at the dwelling or usual place of abode or usual place ofbusiness or work, I have been unable to make personal delivery of this Subpoena in this District onthe person named therein for the following reason/s:

_______________________________________________________________________________

_______________________________________________________________________________

_______________________________________________________________________________

I declare under penalty of perjury that this failure to serve this Summons has not been induced with conspiracy, bribery, or any form of agreement by this server with the person to be served or with athird party.

3. Information about the Server or Person serving:

Print Full Name- _____________________________________________ (Must sign below) Occupation- __________________________________________________________________Address - ______________________________________________________________________Telephone Number/s, ___________________________ Fax ___________________________

I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the Philippines that the foregoing information is trueand correct (Note: Read carefully before signing. Anyone who falsifies a statement in this document shallbe liable for indictment of perjury or of obstruction of justice and for punishment by imprisonment.

____________________, 20______ _________________________________" (Date Signed) (Signature)

- End of form -

Page 232: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

199

Form GJ-61, Summons to an Air Force Officer.

THE GRAND JURY Of the _______ Grand Jury District of

The Province/City of ________________

Grand Jury Term from ___________________ to _____________________

(Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type)

Very Highly Confidential

SUMMONS TO AN AIR FORCE OFFICER

Air Force Officer, (State his Name, Rank or Position) _______________________________________ Street or Building Address ____________________________________________________________

City Address _______________________________________________________________________

GREETINGS:

You are hereby directed to appear in person alone, without assistance by anyone or lawyer, before thisGrand Jury for consultation of an important matter. The Case Reference Number of the matter is GJ# _____________. Please contact the clerk of court, telephone No. _________________, whose physicaladdress is at ___________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________, to set upyour appointment with this Grand Jury. The Clerk of Court shall thereupon inform this Grand Jury of yourappointed date and time. On the day and time for your appearance, please report to the same clerk ofcourt and sign up in his Log Book. He/She will escort you in entering our Grand Jury Room. Please bringwith you your proper Identification and this summons.

You are ordered to keep this matter strictly confidential as required by Article III, Section 7(d) of theNational Jury Law, a violation of which shall subject you for indictment for Obstruction of Justice.

Very truly yours,

THE GRAND JURY: Personally signed with validated Date Issued - ____________SIDN#___________ of its Foreman by authority of Article III, Section 7(b) of the National Jury Law. The Clerk of Court:

Please serve the above summons to the subject person therein and promptly inform this Grand Jury ofhis/her arrival date and time.

The Grand Jury Secretary: SIDN# _____________ Date _________________

Page 233: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

200

PROOF OF SERVICE AND DELIVERY OF SUMMONS(After being signed by server, the original of this document

must be submitted to and kept by the Secretary of the Grand Jury)

1. I served this Summons, Form GJ-61, by personally delivering a copy thereof to the person namedtherein and written below: (The personal server must fill in by handwriting in the blanks hereunder)

(a) Name of Person Served ________________________________________________

(b) Address where served ________________________________________________

____________________________________________________________________

(c) Date/Time of Delivery: _____________, 20___ ______ ___.M

2. [_]- Non-Service Return of Summons (fill in and sign if server is unable to serve): After due search,careful inquiry, and diligent attempts at the dwelling or usual place of abode or usual place ofbusiness or work, I have been unable to make personal delivery of this Subpoena in this District onthe person named therein for the following reason/s:

_______________________________________________________________________________

_______________________________________________________________________________

_______________________________________________________________________________

I declare under penalty of perjury that this failure to serve this Summons has not been induced with conspiracy, bribery, or any form of agreement by this server with the person to be served or with athird party.

3. Information about the Server or Person serving:

Print Full Name- _____________________________________________ (Must sign below) Occupation- __________________________________________________________________Address - ______________________________________________________________________Telephone Number/s, ___________________________ Fax ___________________________

I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the Philippines that the foregoing information is trueand correct (Note: Read carefully before signing. Anyone who falsifies a statement in this document shallbe liable for indictment of perjury or of obstruction of justice and for punishment by imprisonment.

____________________, 20______ _________________________________" (Date Signed) (Signature)

- End of form -

Page 234: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

201

Form GJ-62, Summons to a Public Official or Government Employee.

THE GRAND JURY Of the _______ Grand Jury District of

The Province/City of ________________

Grand Jury Term from ___________________ to _____________________

(Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type)

Very Highly Confidential

SUMMONS TO A PUBLIC OFFICIAL OR GOVERNMENT EMPLOYEE

(Name and state his/her Position, Title, or Rank) . __________________________________________

Street or Building Address ____________________________________________________________City Address _______________________________________________________________________

GREETINGS:

You are hereby directed to appear in person alone, without assistance by anyone or lawyer, before thisGrand Jury for consultation of an important matter. The Case Reference Number of the matter is GJ# _____________. Please contact the clerk of court, telephone No. _________________, whose physicaladdress is at ___________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________, to set upyour appointment with this Grand Jury. The Clerk of Court shall thereupon inform this Grand Jury of yourappointed date and time. On the day and time for your appearance, please report to the same clerk ofcourt and sign up in his Log Book. He/She will escort you in entering our Grand Jury Room. Please bringwith you your proper Identification and this summons.

You are ordered to keep this matter strictly confidential as required by Article III, Section 7(d) of theNational Jury Law, a violation of which shall subject you for indictment for Obstruction of Justice.

Very truly yours,

THE GRAND JURY: Personally signed with validated Date Issued - ____________SIDN#___________ of its Foreman by authority of Article III, Section 7(b) of the National Jury Law. The Clerk of Court:

Please serve the above summons to the subject person therein and promptly inform this Grand Jury ofhis/her arrival date and time.

The Grand Jury Secretary: SIDN# _____________ Date _________________

Page 235: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

202

PROOF OF SERVICE AND DELIVERY OF SUMMONS(After being signed by server, the original of this document

must be submitted to and kept by the Secretary of the Grand Jury)

1. I served this Summons, Form GJ-62, by personally delivering a copy thereof to the person namedtherein and written below: (The personal server must fill in by handwriting in the blanks hereunder)

(a) Name of Person Served ________________________________________________

(b) Address where served ________________________________________________

____________________________________________________________________

(c) Date/Time of Delivery: _____________, 20___ ______ ___.M

2. [_]- Non-Service Return of Summons (fill in and sign if server is unable to serve): After due search,careful inquiry, and diligent attempts at the dwelling or usual place of abode or usual place ofbusiness or work, I have been unable to make personal delivery of this Subpoena in this District onthe person named therein for the following reason/s:

____________________________________________________________________________________

____________________________________________________________________________________

____________________________________________________________________________________

I declare under penalty of perjury that this failure to serve this Summons has not been induced with conspiracy, bribery, or any form of agreement by this server with the person to be served or with athird party.

3. Information about the Server or Person serving:

Print Full Name- _____________________________________________ (Must sign below) Occupation- __________________________________________________________________Address - ______________________________________________________________________Telephone Number/s, ___________________________ Fax ___________________________

I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the Philippines that the foregoing information is trueand correct (Note: Read carefully before signing. Anyone who falsifies a statement in this document shallbe liable for indictment of perjury or of obstruction of justice and for punishment by imprisonment.

____________________, 20______ _________________________________" (Date Signed) (Signature)

- End of form -

Page 236: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

203

Form GJ-63, Summons - General Form or Template

THE GRAND JURY Of the _______ Grand Jury District of

The Province/City of ________________

Grand Jury Term from ___________________ to _____________________

(Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type)

Very Highly Confidential

SUMMONS - GENERAL FORM OR TEMPLATE

(Name, Title, Occupation, Profession) ___________________________________________________ Street or Building Address ____________________________________________________________

City Address _______________________________________________________________________

GREETINGS:

You are hereby directed to appear in person alone, without assistance by anyone or lawyer, before thisGrand Jury for consultation of an important matter. The Case Reference Number of the matter is GJ# _____________. Please contact the clerk of court, telephone No. _________________, whose physicaladdress is at ___________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________, to set upyour appointment with this Grand Jury. The Clerk of Court shall thereupon inform this Grand Jury of yourappointed date and time. On the day and time for your appearance, please report to the same clerk ofcourt and sign up in his Log Book. He/She will escort you in entering our Grand Jury Room. Please bringwith you your proper Identification and this summons.

You are ordered to keep this matter strictly confidential as required by Article III, Section 7(d) of theNational Jury Law, a violation of which shall subject you for indictment for Obstruction of Justice.

Very truly yours,

THE GRAND JURY: Personally signed with validated Date Issued - _______________SIDN#___________ of its Foreman by authority of Article III, Section 7(b) of the National Jury Law.

The Clerk of Court:

Please serve the above summons to the subject person therein and promptly inform this Grand Jury ofhis/her arrival date and time.

The Grand Jury Secretary: SIDN# _____________ Date _________________

Page 237: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

204

PROOF OF SERVICE AND DELIVERY OF SUMMONS(After being signed by server, the original of this document

must be submitted to and kept by the Secretary of the Grand Jury)

1. I served this Summons, Form GJ-63, by personally delivering a copy thereof to the person namedtherein and written below: (The personal server must fill in by handwriting in the blanks hereunder)

(a) Name of Person Served ________________________________________________

(b) Address where served ________________________________________________

____________________________________________________________________

(c) Date/Time of Delivery: _____________, 20___ ______ ___.M

2. [_]- Non-Service Return of Summons (fill in and sign if server is unable to serve): After due search,careful inquiry, and diligent attempts at the dwelling or usual place of abode or usual place ofbusiness or work, I have been unable to make personal delivery of this Subpoena in this District onthe person named therein for the following reason/s:

_______________________________________________________________________________

_______________________________________________________________________________

_______________________________________________________________________________

I declare under penalty of perjury that this failure to serve this Summons has not been induced with conspiracy, bribery, or any form of agreement by this server with the person to be served or with athird party.

3. Information about the Server or Person serving:

Print Full Name- _____________________________________________ (Must sign below) Occupation- __________________________________________________________________Address - ______________________________________________________________________Telephone Number/s, ___________________________ Fax ___________________________

I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the Philippines that the foregoing information is trueand correct (Note: Read carefully before signing. Anyone who falsifies a statement in this document shallbe liable for indictment of perjury or of obstruction of justice and for punishment by imprisonment.

____________________, 20______ _________________________________" (Date Signed) (Signature)

- End of form -

Page 238: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

205

Form GJ-64, Stenographer’s Bill for Transcripts in Grand Jury Proceedings.

THE GRAND JURY Of the _______ Grand Jury District of

The Province/ City of ________________

Grand Jury Term from ___________________ to _____________________

VERY HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL

GRAND JURY CASE No. _________________

BILL/INVOICE FOR STENOGRAPHIC SERVICES

The Provincial/City Treasurer of _____________________________________________

Street Address ___________________________________________________________

City Address ____________________________________________________________

Dear Mr./Ms. Treasurer:

Please pay this Bill/Invoice to the Bearer who is identified and authenticated as SIDN# ___________ in the

records of this Grand Jury for serving as Stenographer in its proceedings between the hours from _________

____M. and ______________ ____M. on (date) ___________________ (day) __________________.

This Grand Jury recommends payment to the Bearer the amount of P______________ pesos in Philippine

Currency as a reasonable compensation for his/her service. The transcript of his/her stenographic notes has

already been submitted and deposited in the security vault of this Grand Jury.

Per Grand Jury Secrecy Rules, Article III, Section 6, of the National Jury Law, no other detailed information

can be disclosed in this bill.

Stenographer’s SIDN# ______________.

Authenticated by:

THE GRAND JURY, Signed with his/her SIDN#____________ Date Issued - ____________of its Foreman by authority of Article III, Section 7(b) of the National Jury Law.

IMPORTANT1. The SIDN# of the bearer must be obtained from t he GJ’s Registry Form GJ-32. No SIDN# shall be issued unless properly reco rded by the GJ Secretary.

2. The amount to be paid to the consultant must be agreed upon between the Bearer and the GJ Foreman and written in the Bill/Invoice before Bearer leaves the Grand Jury Room.

3. Do not submit any other document to payor of th is Bill/Invoice when presenting for payment.

- End of Form -

Page 239: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

206

Form GJ-65, Declination by the GJ to Provide Grand Jury Record or Information.

“THE GRAND JURY Of the _______ Jury (Legislative) District of

_____________________________________

Grand Jury Term from ___________________ to _____________________(Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type)

HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL

DECLINATION TO DISCLOSE GRAND JURY RECORDS OR INFORMATION

Mr/Madam ____________________________Official Designation _____________________Street Address _________________________Municipality/City ________________________

Dear Mr. (Official Designation, Rank, Title or Position) _______________________________________:

In accordance with Statutory Grand Jury Instruction No. (84) in Article III, Section 24, of the National JuryLaw, and by the Oath of Secrecy of its members under the sovereign power of the people in Article II, Section1, of the Constitution, which this Grand Jury directly represents, this Grand Jury hereby respectfully declinesto disclose or provide you with the information you have requested. Article III, Section 6, of the National JuryLaw forbids the Grand Jury or its members to disclose any record of its activity or proceedings to any person,or public official, or any entity.

This is a response to your written request dated _______________ to his Grand Jury.

Very truly yours,

THE GRAND JURY: Personally signed with validated Date Issued - ____________SIDN#___________ of its Foreman by authority of Article III, Section 7(b) of the National Jury Law.

The Clerk of Court(_)- Regional Trial Court of ______________________ (_)- Sharia Trial Court of _________________________(_)- City/Metropolitan Trial Court of ________________ (_)- Municipal Trial Court of _______________________Street or Building Address _____________________________________________________________________City/Municipal Address ________________________________________________________________________

Dear Mr. Clerk of Court:

You are hereby directed by this Grand Jury to serve the official, entity, or dignitary, to whom the above letter concerns.You are likewise directed to keep this matter strictly confidential as required by the Grand Jury Law.

Very truly yours,

THE GRAND JURY: Personally signed with validated Date Issued - ____________SIDN#___________ of its Foreman by authority of Article III, Section 7(b) of the National Jury Law.

- End of Form -

Page 240: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

207

Form GJ-66, Summons for Submission of Jail Facility Records & Pictures

THE GRAND JURY Of the _______ Grand Jury District of

The Province/ City of ________________________

Grand Jury Term from ___________________ to _____________________

(Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type)

Very Highly Confidential

SUMMONS TO THE WARDEN OF THE JAILGrand Jury File Number ______________

(Obtain the number from GJ Foreman before signing this document)

(State Name and Title of Position) . . _______________________________________________Street or Building Address ______________________________________________________City Address ________________________________________________________________

GREETINGS:

You are hereby directed to submit to this Grand Jury within ten (10) days from your receipt of this summonsand submit the same in writing on your official letterhead the following information therein:

(a) A complete list of names and home addresses of each and all officials and employees in yourfacility with their corresponding title, rank, or position in your organization and their average monthly payregardless of whether the official or employee is a permanent or temporary or casual employee.

(b) A complete list of all inmates with their names and case numbers and the length of time eachinmate has been incarcerated in his facility regardless of whether the inmate is already convicted or not andthe identifiable cell location in which inmates are housed.

(c) A post card size picture of the common mess hall of the inmates.

(d) A post card size picture of the inmate toilets.

In the bottom of your statement and just above your signature, you must state the following verificationstatement: “In Response to Grand Jury Summons, Case No. ____________, I declare under penalty ofperjury under the laws of the Philippines that the foregoing information, including the objects in the pictures,are true and correct this ____ day of ___________, 20__, in the City of _____________________.”

Printed Name: ___________________________ Title of Position: ____________________________

Signature: ____________________________________________.

Your failure to submit the desired information above shall warrant your indictment for the crime of obstructionof justice with punishment by imprisonment in jail from five (5) years to seven (7) years upon conviction.

You are ordered to keep this matter strictly confidential as required by Article III, Section 7(d) of the NationalJury Law, a violation of which shall subject you for indictment for Obstruction of Justice.

Very truly yours,

THE GRAND JURY: Personally signed with validated Date Issued - ____________SIDN#___________ of its Foreman by authority of Article III, Section 7(b) of the National Jury Law.

Page 241: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

208

The Clerk of Court:

Please serve the above summons to the subject person therein and promptly inform this Grand Jury of his/herarrival date and time.

The Grand Jury Secretary: SIDN# _____________ Date _________________

PROOF OF SERVICE AND DELIVERY OF SUMMONS

(Please see attached or below)

Page 242: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

209

PROOF OF SERVICE AND DELIVERY OF SUMMONS(After being signed by server, the original of this document

must be submitted to and kept by the Secretary of the Grand Jury)

1. I served this Summons, Form GJ-66, by personally delivering a copy thereof to the person named thereinand written below: (The personal server must fill in by handwriting in the blanks hereunder)

(a) Name of Person Served ________________________________________________

(b) Address where served ________________________________________________

__________________________________________________________________________

(c) Date/Time of Delivery: _____________, 20___ ______ ___.M

2. [_]- Non-Service Return of Summons (fill in and sign if server is unable to serve): After due search,careful inquiry, and diligent attempts at the dwelling or usual place of abode or usual place of businessor work, I have been unable to make personal delivery of this Subpoena in this District on the personnamed therein for the following reason/s:_______________________________________________________________________________

_______________________________________________________________________________

_____________________________________________________________________________

I declare under penalty of perjury that this failure to serve this Summons has not been induced withconspiracy, bribery, or any form of agreement by this server with the person to be served or with a third party.

3. Information about the Server or Person serving:

Print Full Name- ________________________________________ (Must sign below)

Occupation- __________________________________________________________________

Address - ___________________________________________________________________

Telephone Number/s, __________________________ Fax ___________________________

I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the Philippines that the foregoing information is true andcorrect (Note: Read carefully before signing. Anyone who falsifies a statement in this document shall be liablefor indictment of perjury or of obstruction of justice and for punishment by imprisonment.

____________________, 20______ _________________________________" (Date Signed) (Signature)

- End of Form -

Page 243: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

210

Form GJ-67, Registry for Assigned Cases to Deputy Public Defenders.

Office of the Provincial/City Public Attorney’s OfficeCity/Province of ________________

Address _______________________ Page _______

ASSIGNED CASES TO THE DEPUTY PUBLIC DEFENDERS’ POOL REGISTRY(Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type)

(Paper Size: 8-1/2 by 11" - Temporarily Keep in a 3-Ring Binder - Book bind upon reaching 2-inched thickness)

DateOf Trial

Name of Accused

Name of Crime

Case Number

NameOf Judge

Name ofCourt

TelephoneNumber

Deputy Public Defender - > Telephone ->

Street Address - >

Mun/City/Province - >

Date Assigned to PD- > Result - >

Deputy Public Defender - > Telephone ->

Street Address - >

Mun/City/Province - >

Date Assigned to PD- > Result - >

Deputy Public Defender - > Telephone ->

Street Address - >

Mun/City/Province - >

Date Assigned to PD- > Result - >

Deputy Public Defender - > Telephone ->

Street Address - >

Mun/City/Province - >

Date Assigned to PD- > Result - >

Deputy Public Defender - > Telephone ->

Street Address - >

Mun/City/Province - >

Date Assigned to PD- > Result - >

- End of Form -

Page 244: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

211

COMMUNITY DEPUTY PROSECUTORS

Section 100. Creation of the Position for Community Deputy Prosecutors - To ensure

availability of prosecutors to pursue the trial of suspected crime offenders and indicted by Grand

Juries and to speed up the disposition of criminal cases, the National Jury Law hereby creates the

position of Community Deputy Prosecutors, also known as the “CDP” in each Judicial District around

the country. A “CDP” shall act as an alternate or substitute to a regular government prosecutor or

fiscal and he shall serve under the supervision of a Provincial or City prosecutor. His services shall

be paid through the prescribed “Unconditional Non-transferable Redeemable Judicial Voucher”,

known as “Form GJ-27.” This form is found in Section 99, Article III, of the National Jury Law.

Section 101. Qualification of the CDP - The Community Deputy Prosecutor shall be a

bonafide member of the Integrated Bar of the Philippines with license to practice law. He shall have

been actually engaged in the practice of law for at least three (3) years as of the date of filing his

application to become a Community Deputy Prosecutor. As of the date of the filing of his

application, he shall certify that he has completely devoted a total of at least 24 hours of self-study

of the National Jury Law. He has read and he is thoroughly familiar both with the Statutory Grand

Jury Instruction in Section 24 and Form GJ-41 of Section 99 in Article III, and the Statutory Basic

Trial Jury Instruction on Form TJ-108 in Section 2, Article X of the National Jury Law. He shall have

actually accomplished a “dry run” preparation in his own handwriting with the following forms by

assuming the roles of those who are concerned in preparing or filling up those forms, most

particularly the following: Form TJ-103, Form TJ-109, Form TJ-109A, Forms TJ-110A-B-C-D (the

derivative form from Form TJ-110), Form TJ-111, Form TJ-112, Form TJ-113, Form TJ-114, Form

TJ-135, Form TJ-136, Form TJ-137 and Form TJ-138. He shall further state that he is expertly

cognizant of the rudiments in the impaneling of a trial jury and the preemptory challenges of jurors.

Section 102. CDP Application Form - CDP Application shall be accomplished in the

prescribed form known as Form GJ-46 and found in Section 99, Article III, of the National Jury Law.

This is a durable form and it cannot be modified or altered by the applicant.

Section 103. The promissory undertaking of the CDP to serve -

(a) The Community Deputy Prosecutor shall promise and shall wilfully agree that he shall

accept an assignment to prosecute before a bench court or before a trial jury the type of cases he

has specified to prosecute in his application for CDP pool membership that may come up for trial at

least thirty (30) calendar days before the trial commencement date. Should he decline to accept the

assignment, he shall communicate in writing and by phone within five (5) calendar days from his

Page 245: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

212

receipt of his nomination on account of close family ties or friendship, prior social dealing, business

or official transaction with the accused otherwise in the absence of such “5-day notice of declination”

he shall be bound by his promise to act on his assignment or he shall be charged of the crime of

obstruction of justice for ignoring to act on his duty as a community deputy prosecutor.

(b) The Community Deputy Prosecutor shall keep his assignment strictly confidential and he

shall make no contact in any manner, directly or indirectly, with the accused under pain of

disciplinary action for disbarment in violation of the grand jury policy of secrecy.

(c) The Community Deputy Prosecutor shall accept compensation on a per diem basis

starting with one non-trial day of service to prepare for trial and for each day that he appears in court

to prosecute a case for trial by means of the Unconditional Redeemable Judicial Voucher as

prescribe in Form GJ-27 in Section 99, Article III, of the National Jury Law, computed at the rate of

pay equivalent to the hourly compensation of the minimum compensation of a regular provincial or

city prosecutor in the locality where he shall serve.

(d) When performing his duty as a community deputy prosecutor, he shall be bound by the

“Code of Conduct and Ethical standards for Public Officials and Employees” according to Republic

Act 6713. It shall be unlawful for the community deputy prosecutor to accept a fee from a witness

or complaining witness outside the compensation referred to in the preceding subsection (c) for his

service when acting in such capacity.

Section 104. The Community Deputy Prosecutors’ Pool - All applications for community

deputy prosecutor shall be submitted to the office of the provincial or city fiscal and shall be

personally deposited by the applicant in a raffle bin, plainly mark and printed as “CDP Application

Raffle Bin” and readable at a distance of eight (8) feet that has been set up by the provincial or city

fiscal. The raffle bin shall be located in the hallway near the entrance to the provincial or city fiscal’s

office wherein each CDP Applicant shall simply drop in his application in the raffle bin. Attorneys

who have dropped in their applications in the CDP Raffle Bin shall comprise as the Community

Deputy Prosecutors’ Pool. No attorney shall be offered to serve as a CDP unless his application has

been entered in the CDP Raffle Bin for random drawing.

Section 105. Invitation Advertisement for Applicants to the CDP Pool - To invite applicants

to the CDP Pool, the Provincial or City Prosecutor shall post an advertisement in a news paper with

a general circulation in the province or city his office is serving. He may likewise post his

advertisement in the Bulletin Boards in the court house where criminal cases are filed or he shall

announce in radio or television stations that are operating in his city or province. The invitation

Page 246: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

213

advertisement shall conform to the prescribed form known as Form GJ-45 and it is found in Section

99, Article III, of the National Jury Law.

Section 106. Registry Record for Assigned Cases to the CDP - The Provincial or City

Prosecutor shall keep a record of his case assignments to the CDP on a prescribed form, known as

Form GJ-47 under Section 99, Article III, of the National Jury Law.

DEPUTY PUBLIC DEFENDERS FOR INDIGENT ACCUSED OR MIN OR

Section 107. Creation of the Position of Deputy Public Defenders for Indigent Accused or Minor-

To ensure availability of Deputy Public Defenders to defend at the trial of suspected indigent crime

offenders or minors accused of crimes and to speed up the disposition of criminal cases, the

National Jury Law hereby creates the position of Deputy Public Defenders for Indigent Accuse Or

Minor, also briefly known as the “Deputy Public Defender” in each Judicial District around the

country. A Deputy Public Defender shall act as an alternate to a regular Public Attorney and he shall

serve under the supervision of the Public Attorney’s Office. His services shall be paid through the

prescribed “Unconditional Non-transferable Redeemable Judicial Voucher”, known as “Form GJ-27.”

This form is found in Section 99, Article III, of the National Jury Law.

Section 108. Qualification of the Deputy Public Defender - The Deputy Public Defender shall

be a bonafide member of the Integrated Bar of the Philippines with license to practice law. He shall

have been actually engaged in the practice of law for at least three (3) years as of the date of filing

his application to become a Deputy Public Defender. As of the date of the filing of his application,

he shall certify that he has completely devoted a total of at least 24 hours of self-study of the

National Jury Law. He has read and he is thoroughly familiar both with the Statutory Grand Jury

Instruction in Section 24 and Form GJ-41 of Section 99 in Article III, and the Statutory Basic Trial

Jury Instruction on Form TJ-108 in Section 2, Article X, of the National Jury Law. He shall have

actually accomplished a “dry run” preparation in his own handwriting with the following forms by

assuming the roles of those who are concerned in preparing or filling up those forms, most

particularly the following: Form TJ-103, Form TJ-109, Form TJ-109A, Forms TJ-110A-B-C-D (a

derative form from Form TJ-110), Form TJ-111, Form TJ-112, Form TJ-113, Form TJ-114, Form TJ-

135, Form TJ-136, Form TJ-137 and Form TJ-138. He shall further state that he is expertly

cognizant of the rudiments in the impaneling of a trial jury and the preemptory challenges of jurors.

Section 109. Deputy Public Defender’s Application Form - A Deputy Public Defender’s

Application shall be accomplished in the prescribed form known as Form GJ-48AP and found in

Section 99, Article III, of the National Jury Law. This is a durable form and it cannot be modified or

Page 247: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

214

altered by the applicant.

Section 110. The promissory undertaking of the Deputy Public Defender to serve -

(a) The Deputy Public Defender shall promise and shall wilfully agree that he shall accept

an assignment to defend an indigent accused or a minor before a bench court or before a trial jury

the type of cases he has specified to defend in his application for Deputy Public Defenders Pool

membership that may come up for trial at least thirty (30) calendar days before the trial

commencement date. Should he decline to accept the assignment, he shall communicate in writing

and by phone within five calendar five (5) days from his receipt of his nomination, and not after the

said five (5) calendar days shall have elapsed, on account of close family ties or friendship, prior

social dealing, business or official transaction with the complaining witness otherwise in the absence

of such “5-day notice of declination” he shall be bound by his promise to act on his assignment or

he shall be charged for the crime of obstruction of justice for ignoring to act on his duty as a Deputy

Public Defender.

(b) The Deputy Public Defender shall keep his assignment strictly confidential and he shall

make no contact in any manner, directly or indirectly, with the complaining witness under pain of

disciplinary action for disbarment in violation of the grand jury policy of secrecy. He shall,

nonetheless, keep his right for the issuance of a subpoena or subpoena duces tecum to compel the

appearance of witnesses to testify in favor of the accused and shall have the right to cross-examine

witnesses who shall testify against the accused.

(c) The Deputy Public Defender shall accept compensation on a per diem basis starting with

one non-trial day of service to prepare for trial and for each day that he appears in court to prosecute

a case for trial by means of the Unconditional Redeemable Judicial Voucher as prescribe in Form

GJ-27 in Section 99, Article III, of the National Jury Law, computed at the rate of pay equivalent to

the hourly compensation of the minimum compensation of a regular provincial or city prosecutor in

the locality where he shall serve.

(d) When performing his duty as a Deputy Public Defender, he shall be bound by the “Code

of Conduct and Ethical standards for Public Officials and Employees” according to Republic Act

6713. It shall be unlawful for the community Deputy Public Defender to accept a fee from the

accused he is defending outside the compensation referred to in the preceding subsection (c) for

his service when acting in such capacity.

Section 111. The Deputy Public Defenders’ Pool - All applications for Deputy Public

Page 248: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

215

Defenders shall be submitted to the office of the provincial or city fiscal and shall be personally

deposited by the applicant in a raffle bin, plainly mark and printed as “Deputy Public Defenders’

Application Raffle Bin” and readable at a distance of eight (8) feet that has been set up by the

Public Attorney’s Office. The raffle bin shall be located in the hallway near the entrance to the Public

Attorney’s Office wherein each Deputy Public Defender Applicant shall simply drop in his application

in the raffle bin. Attorneys who have dropped in their applications in the Deputy Public Defenders’

Raffle Bin shall comprise as the Deputy Public Defenders’ Pool. No attorney shall be offered to

serve as a Deputy Public Defender unless his application has been entered in the Deputy Public

Defenders’ Raffle Bin for random drawing.

Section 112. Invitation Advertisement for Applicants to the Deputy Public Defenders’ Pool -

To invite applicants for membership to the Deputy Public Defenders’ Pool, the Public Attorney’s

Office shall post an advertisement in a news paper with a general circulation in the province or city

his office is serving. He may likewise post his advertisement in the Bulletin Boards in the court

house where criminal cases are filed or he shall announce in radio or television stations that are

operating in his city or province. The invitation advertisement for Deputy Public Defenders shall

conform to the prescribed form known as Form GJ-48AD and it is found in Section 99, Article III, of

the National Jury Law.

Section 113. Registry Record for Assigned Cases to Deputy Public Defenders - The

Provincial or City Public Attorney’s Office shall keep a record of his case assignments to Deputy

Public Defenders on a prescribed form, known as Form GJ-67 under Section 99, Article III, of the

National Jury Law.

Section 114. Guide for Fast track adaptation to the criminal jury trials -

(a) This National Jury Law requires that all incumbent Justices, Judges, Prosecutors, Public

Attorneys with their clerks or secretaries and actively private practicing members of the Integrated

Bar of the Philippines upon approval and enactment of the National Jury Law and Procedures shall

promptly familiarize with the proficiency and qualifications required of applicants for Pro Temp Jury

Presiding Judges, Community Deputy Prosecutors, and Deputy Public Defenders in connection with

criminal jury trials.

(b) The jury forms enumerated below have been devised as guides in submitting to the jury

for deliberation and issuance of jury verdicts in an orderly fashion in criminal jury trials:

(1) Form TJ-103, Summons to citizens for jury service;

Page 249: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

216

(2) Form TJ-108, Statutory Basic Jury Trial Instruction;

(3) Form TJ-109, Management of Jurors reporting for jury service

by the Jury Commissioner or Clerk of Court;

(4) Form TJ-110A, Confidential “In Chamber Conference” by Jury Presiding Judge

with the Prosecution and Defense Attorneys a day or two prior

to the day of impaneling the jury to commence the jury trial;

(5) Form TJ-110B, The Charge Sheet - Information to the Jury as to how many cases

the jurors shall discuss and decide on.

(6) Form TJ-110C, The “LAW & FACT SHEET” Pattern.

(7) Form TJ-110D-1, Law & Fact Sheet - 1st case # vs Accused.

Form TJ-110D-2, Law & Fact Sheet - 2nd case # vs Accused.

Form TJ-110D-3, Law & Fact Sheet - 3rd case # vs Accused.

Form TJ-110D-4, Law & Fact Sheet - 4th case # vs Accused

Form TJ-110D-5, Law & Fact, etc. - If any additional case.

If there is a co-accused, separate Form TJ-110D-1, 2, 3, etc. shall likewise be set

up for him apart from another co-accused. The said items shall be submitted to the Jury

separately one at a time for discussion and decision.

(8) Form TJ-111, The Joint Supplemental Jury Instruction in submitting the cases

to the Jury for discussion and decision and shall have been

developed during the confidential “In Chamber Conference”.

(9) Form TJ-112, Twelve (12) pieces of pre-cut Jury Ballot;

(10) Form TJ-113, The “Guilty Verdict” Sheet;

(11) Form TJ-114, The “Not Guilty Verdict” Sheet

(12) Form TJ-135, List of Exhibits with Exhibits attached, the first set of items

Page 250: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

217

for submission to the jury immediately after the jurors have

chosen their foreman and assistants for review by the jury.

(12) Form TJ-136, Delivery Envelope to the Jury containing the enumerated Items

on each face for every individual case for jury discussion and

decision starting first with Form TJ-110D-1. This envelope shall

delivered to the jury as soon as the jury foreman informs thePresiding

Judge (through the Sheriff on duty at the door of the jury room) that the

jury has already reviewed the exhibits;

(13) Form TJ-137, Verdict Envelope (to contain nothing else but only either Form TJ-113,

the “Guilty Verdict” Sheet or Form TJ-114, the “Not Guilty” Verdict

Sheet). The Foreman shall hold on to this envelope until further

receipt for instruction from the presiding judge. If there Is another

case versus the same accused, another set of Form TJ-136, Delivery

Envelope, shall be submitted to the jury with the next Form TJ-110D-2,

(or Form TJ-110D-3, as the case may be) if more than two or more

cases, one at a time, shall be discussed and to be decided by the jury.

(14) After the Jury has decided all cases, the Jury Foreman shall be prepared to bring forth

to the open court, upon the call by the Presiding Judge, through the Sheriff, all the Form or Forms

TJ-137 containing respectively the Jury Verdict Sheets and properly collated corresponding to each

accused. All other items or documents, such as, but not limited to, the jury ballots, shall be left in

the jury room for gathering by the Clerk or Secretary for safekeeping and court custody.

(15) Thereafter, go back to Form TJ-111 and follow onward from Instruction “Tenth” of said

form until the discharge of the jury from jury duty.

Page 251: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

218

ARTICLE IV

THE TRIAL JURY

Section 1. The Trial Jury -

(a) Composition and Qualification of Jurors - A trial jury shall be composed of twelve (12)

members chosen randomly from among the registered voters in their respective congressional

districts. A trial juror shall be a high school graduate and at least twenty-one (21) years of age with

average intelligence, or a person whose level of education or lifetime practical experience in dealing

with his fellow citizens whose concept or understanding in the fundamentals of rightfulness or

wrongfulness is approximately equivalent to a high school graduate. A trial juror must not be

suffering from any mental impairment or drug addition or controlled substance addiction, or alcohol

addiction. Choosing a person to sit as a trial juror by appointment directly or indirectly shall be void.

(b) The Jury Commissioner - The position of the Jury Commissioner is hereby created who

shall be responsible for inviting citizens to serve for jury duty. His qualification shall be similar to the

qualification of a Clerk of Court and shall have the power to recommend to the Executive Judge in

the hiring of staff to assist in his functions. Every Court House or a Hall of Justice with a cluster of

several jury trial court rooms or branches shall have one Jury Commissioner. In the absence of the

Jury Commissioner, the Executive Judge shall designate one of his Senior Clerks of Court to act and

perform the duties of the Jury Commissioner. A court house with a single branch or sala, the Clerk

of Court of such court house shall act as its Jury Commissioner and shall likewise have the power

to recommend to the Executive Judge of such court house the needed number of staff to assist in

his functions.

(c) Invitation of Citizens to Serve for Jury Duty - The Jury Commissioner (or Clerk of Court)

shall commence in inviting citizens for jury duty by communicating with the Local Election Registrar

whose jurisdiction covers the locality where the Court House is located with the request of supplying

the Jury Commissioner with names of registered voters who reside within the legislative district

where his court is located. For his request, he shall use Form TJ-101, Form TJ-102 along with its

attachment Form TJ-102A, and Form TJ-102B, the pattern forms in procuring the names of citizens

to be summoned for jury duty as prescribed in Article X, Section 1 and Section 2 of the National Jury

Law.

Section 2. Confidential Proceedings Prior to the Actual Event of the Jury Trial -

Page 252: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

219

(1) One, or two days, before the actual event of a criminal jury trial begins, a “Confidential

In-Chamber Conference” shall be convened and presided by the Jury Presiding Judge requiring the

mandatory presence of the prosecuting attorney and the defense attorneys. This conference shall

be conducted according to the Instructions in Form TJ-110A as prescribed in Article X, Sections 1

and 2, of the National Jury Law. Any person or public official who shall forcefully or by intimidation

intrude or interfere in this proceeding shall be held liable and for punishment of imprisonment for

obstruction of justice.

(2) The actual event of the jury trial shall start with the impaneling of the jurors. A juror in

a jury trial shall serve anonymously. His real name shall not be disclosed to the public or to any body

which shall be kept confidentially by the jury commissioner, or by a clerk of court, or by the presiding

judge or by any lawyer as an officer of the court. The Jury Commissioner, or Clerk of Court in the

absence of a Jury Commissioner, shall assign a five (5) digit Identity Code Number, known as “ICN”,

to a juror who has reported for jury service in response to a summons for jury duty.

(3) In the court room, the presiding judge shall identify each juror with his ICN. The

presiding judge or any court personnel shall, in no case, disclose the real name of a juror to the

contending parties or their attorneys all the way from the start the jurors are called in to his

courtroom for empanelling.

Section 3. Upon arrival at the court house of each juror to report for jury service, he shall

be ushered into a Jury Assembly Room , briefly known as the “JAR” under the control and

supervision of the jury commissioner, or the clerk of court. At the JAR, the juror shall submit his

summons for jury service and write his name and summons number in a log book called the JAL

(“Jurors’ Attendance Logbook”), also known as Form TJ-106 and prescribed in Article X, Section 2.

Section 4. The JAR shall be a separate room from the actual jury trial court room. While

the jurors are waiting at the JAR, each of them shall be furnished by the commissioner, or clerk, with

a blank form known as the Impaneling Question Sheet or IQS, or known as Form TJ-109A . The

juror shall be required to fill in the IQS truthfully and that the juror shall be informed that the form

shall be used solely for jury service and for no other purposes. The IQS shall not ask anything what

law or laws the juror knows about.

Section 5. How to Use The IQS and the ICN -

Page 253: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

220

(1) The IQS shall contain a pre-assigned ICN (“Identity Code Number” ) and a pre-printed

card tag shall be attached to it bearing the same ICN with the IQS. The ICN shall serve as the official

name of the juror while on jury service. The size of the card tag shall be one-and-a-half inches in

height by four-and-a-quarter inches in length (1-1/2" X 4-1/4") wherein the ICN shall be printed at

around one inch in height and three inches in length located centrally on the tag. Each juror shall

have a different ICN and no two or more jurors shall have the same number. Upon issuance of the

ICN, the same shall then be promptly recorded by the Jury Commissioner, or Clerk of Court, on

Form TJ-106 corresponding to the registered name of the juror in said form.

(2) The Commissioner or Clerk shall additionally prepare a list of all ICNs corresponding to

the jurors who are called in for impaneling with sufficient copies for distribution to the presiding judge,

the prosecuting attorney and to each defense attorney.

(3) The ICN tags shall be embedded or pinned on the left side of the shirt at the breast level

of each juror. The jurors should be advised to wear their tags only during court sessions and shall

keep the same inside their pockets when getting out of the jury trial court room.

Section 6. After accomplishing his Form TJ-109A , the juror shall then submit it back to the

Commissioner or Clerk of Court who shall drop the same in a separate lottery bin, designated as

“Lottery Bin #2", for jurors who appeared for jury service. Correspondingly, he shall hand over the

accomplished card tag of each juror for the juror’s use and display on his/her shirt during the jury

impaneling. Upon receipt of his ICN, the juror shall then drop his Form TJ-109A in the raffle bin in

the JAR (Jury Assembly Room) under the instruction of the Commissioner or Clerk. All jurors who

have reported for jury duty with a tag receipt shall remain seated in the JAR.

Section 7. Before the jurors are called in to the Jury Trial Court Room (JTCR), no person

shall be permitted to occupy any seat inside the court room except the presiding judge and his court

personnel and the respective lawyers of the parties in the case at hand.

Section 8. At exactly 9:00 A.M., the Commissioner or Clerk shall then raffle and retrieve

from the raffle bin of the IQS Forms TJ-109A, one at a time, and shall announce the ICN of the juror

whose IQS has been drawn. The holder of the ICN corresponding to the retrieved Form TJ-109A,

along with other jurors whose Form TJ-109A have been called, shall then get ready to move and

be lead by the Commissioner or Clerk in going to the JTCR (Jury Trial Court Room). The

Commissioner or Clerk of Court in the JAR shall bring in exactly twenty-nine (29) jurors to the JTCR

for jury impaneling if there is only one (1) accused to be tried by the jury. If there are two or more

Page 254: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

221

criminal defendants who shall be jointly tried in the jury trial, the Commissioner or Clerk of Court shall

bring in for impaneling an additional seven jurors for each accused to choose from for impaneling

to allow every accused for his attorney to exercise his full seven (7) preemptive right to decline

certain jurors from sitting in his case.

Section 9. After all the required number of jurors from which the jury impaneling shall be

picked have entered the JTCR, they will be seated in the vacant audience seats to wait for

impaneling instructions. The corresponding Form TJ-109A of the jurors shall be entered again in

another raffle box by the Clerk or Secretary at the JTCR. Thereupon, all the 29 jurors shall be asked

by the Clerk to stand and to raise their right hand to take their oath as follows:

“Do you swear to tell the truth, the whole truth and nothing

but the truth in the impaneling of this jury?” (and each and

all jurors shall respond) “I do”.

Section 10. Impaneling of the Jury - Impaneling of the jury shall be held confidentially and

shall not be televised. The court room seating arrangement shall conform to the court room layout

as designed in Form TJ-133 shown in the printable trial jury forms in Article X, Section 2 of the

National Jury Law. Should the presiding judge allow a television broadcast of the jury trial, the

members of the television crew and their camera equipment shall be located in the designated

stationary area indicated in Form TJ-133. The Television crew and the TV reporter shall have no

privilege to move around inside the court room or to make any comment during the trial.

Section 11. Except for the presiding judge along with the prosecutor or attorney for the

plaintiff and the defense attorney, no other person or public official of any rank, power, position, or

title, nobility or royalty shall have the authority to interfere or participate in the impaneling of the

jurors or in the conduct of the jury trial. Violation of this provision of the National Jury Law shall

subject the violator for direct contempt of court or for obstruction of justice upon indictment by a

Grand Jury, and punishment by imprisonment in jail for the period of five (5) years to seven (7)

years, if convicted.

Section 12. Challenge to the Jurors:

(a) Following the oath taking of the called-in jurors, the presiding judge shall then order

his clerk to retrieve randomly for the second time, and one at a time, the Form TJ-109A from his

court room raffle box. He shall then announce the ICN on the form, and the juror ICN owner shall

Page 255: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

222

be asked to raise his right hand. The juror shall not be asked to stand and thereupon the presiding

judge shall randomly choose to ask some any, but not necessarily all, questions in the juror’s Form

TJ-109A, to randomly confirm the juror’s answers.

(b) After the presiding judge is done with his questions, he shall then ask each of the

opposing lawyers if either lawyer would exercise his right to challenge the juror by asking his own

questions to the juror to determine if he shall accept, or decline, the juror to sit in his case. If any

lawyer declines a juror, he will simply ask the presiding judge, without argument, by saying: “Your

Honor, I respectfully decline juror #______ from sitting in my case.” And the presiding judge shall

ministerially inform the juror by saying: “Mr/Ms Juror, we thank you for coming to this court. You will

not be required to sit as a juror in this case. Please go back to the room of the Jury Commissioner

or Clerk for further instruction. ”

(c) The judge, with an assist from the court sheriff, shall hand back to the declined juror

his Form TJ-109A and shall be asked to sit in one of the vacant audience seats and wait for further

instruction. After 15 jurors shall have been chosen and seated, the Sheriff shall led the declined

jurors back to the Jury Commissioner or Clerk of Court at the JAR (Jury Assembly Room) for further

call by the Commissioner or Clerk for: (1) Possible assignment to another jury trial court room in

which case his Form TJ-109A shall be entered back in the Lottery Bin #2 at the JAR; or (2)

Collection of his, or their, Juror’s Service Fee for the day on Form GJ-27.

Section 13. Each party to a case for trial, through his attorney, shall be entitled to exercise

his preemptory challenge to no more than seven (7) prospective jurors with, or without, cause and

without argument to unseat or decline and replace an impaneled juror before the final impaneled

jurors are sworn in to serve. No additional challenge shall be allowed to a party who has used up

all his right to challenge or decline a juror.

Section 14. The first twelve (12) jurors chosen shall sit as regular jurors while the last three

(3) jurors shall sit as alternate reserve jurors if, in case, one or more of the regulars shall defunct for

any reason. The three (3) alternates shall likewise be required to hear the entire trial proceeding

along with the regular jurors and in the discussion inside the jury deliberation room but none of the

alternate reserve jurors can vote, unless one or more of the regulars is, or are, unable to complete

his jury service. After jury impaneling, an alternate reserve juror shall be picked by lottery from

among them to serve as regular juror when the need shall arise.

Section 15 Once the jury impaneling with the total fifteen (15) jurors is completed, and the

Page 256: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

223

declined jurors have been sent back to the Jury Assembly Room, only then shall the persons who

are not a party to the case, including the members of the media, shall be permitted to enter the court

room and occupy its vacant audience seats.

Section 16. Empowerment of the Trial Jury -

(1) Instruction to the Impaneled Jurors - The presiding judge shall then proceed to empower

the Jury by reading to the jurors the Statutory Basic Jury Instruction, known as “SBJTI”, as

prescribed on Form TJ-108 in Article X, Sections 1 and 2, of the National Jury Law. At this stage,

the presiding judge shall issue by reading to educate the jurors with the SBJTI. The presiding judge

of the Jury is prohibited to deviate or modify this statutory instruction except in the context where it

allows him to do so. This Instruction shall be contemporaneously interpreted by a professionally

qualified interpreter in the local dialect of the jurors from its English text and vice versa. Thereafter,

the jury trial shall then proceed according to the procedure in Article VI, Section 3(e).

(2) The presiding judge shall enforce court discipline and to rule on the admission of

evidence in the course of the jury trial;

(3) The presiding judge shall have neither power to participate with the jurors in their

deliberation and in deciding the matter at hand as heard by the jury nor the power to over rule,

change, modify or invalidate the verdict of the jury. The Jury shall have the exclusive authority to

find the facts pertaining to the case at hand.

Section 17. Any person or public official who shall contact an employer, job supervisor or

a co-employee of a trial juror with the view of influencing the decision of such juror on a matter being

tried before a jury trial shall subject such person or public official liable for obstruction of justice with

punishment and fine as provided in Section 24 hereunder of Article IV, of the National Jury Law.

Section 18. Any employer, job supervisor or co-employee who shall co-operate with, actively

or passively, upon the instigation of, any person or public official to influence the decision of a juror

on a matter being tried before a jury trial shall render such employer, job supervisor or co-employee

liable for obstruction of justice with punishment and fine as provided in Section 24 hereunder of

Article IV, of the National Jury Law.

Section 19. Any juror in a jury trial who shall have received any direct solicitation from any

person, public official, job supervisor, or co-employee, with the view of influencing his decision,

Page 257: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

224

regardless of whether he was swayed in making his decision or not in a jury trial shall have the

mandatory obligation to secretly report within thirty (30) days from the date he received such

solicitation to a grand jury for investigation. His failure to comply shall render him liable for the crime

of obstruction of justice with punishment and fine as provided in Section 24 hereunder of Article IV,

of the National Jury Law.

Section 20. Any employer, job supervisor, or co-employee who has received from a public

official or government employee any solicitation with the view of influencing a juror of his decision

in a jury trial who is an employee of such employer, or subordinate of such supervisor, or friend of

such co-employee shall have a mandatory obligation to report within 30 days of receiving such

solicitation to a grand jury for investigation and indictment for obstruction of justice of such public

official or government employee. Failure of such employer, job supervisor, co-employee to comply

with his duty in this Section shall render such employer, job supervisor or co-employee liable for

obstruction of justice with punishment and fine as provided in Section 24 hereunder of Article IV, of

the National Jury Law.

Section 21. Any juror who shall decide in a jury trial on the basis of the solicitation of any

person, public official, employer, job supervisor or co-employee regardless of whether he has been

offered, or has received a bribe, or not, shall be liable for obstruction of justice with punishment and

fine as provided in Section 24 hereunder of Article IV, of the National Jury Law.

Section 22. Any presiding judge in a jury trial, who shall receive any solicitation from any

person or public official with the view of influencing the decision of a case in his court or of the jury

over whom he is presiding, shall have the mandatory duty to report within thirty (30) days from the

date of receiving such solicitation to the grand jury for investigation and indictment for obstruction

of justice. Failure of such presiding judge to comply with his obligation in this section shall be liable

for obstruction of justice with punishment and fine as provided in Section 24 hereunder of Article IV,

of the National Jury Law.

Section 23. Any lawyer who participates in a judicial proceedings or a jury trial shall have

the mandatory obligation to refrain from contacting a public official with the view of securing the

influence of such public official in obtaining a decision or judgment in favour of his case from a judge,

presiding judge, or trial jury regardless of whether such public official is a party or not to his case.

Such lawyer in violation of this provision shall be liable for obstruction of justice and disbarment with

punishment and fine as provided in Section 24 hereunder of Article IV, of the National Jury Law.

Page 258: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

225

Section 24. Any person found guilty of the act of obstruction of justice as defined in the

preceding Sections 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, and 23, of this Article, Article IV of the National Jury Law,

shall suffer the penalty of prision mayor in its maximum period and fine ranging from one hundred

thousand pesos (P100,000.00) to ten million pesos (P10,000,000.00) pesos. If the accused found

guilty holds a government position in any capacity of the Republic of the Philippines or in any

government owned or controlled corporation or a quasi-public entity, such person shall forfeit his

office and shall further suffer perpetual disqualification from holding any public position in the

government or government owned or controlled corporation or quasi-public entity.

Section 25. If the accused is found guilty of a crime associated with the crime of obstruction

of justice that carries with a higher penalty, such penalty shall be imposed.

Section 26. An act or omission over a mandatory duty defined as a crime of obstruction of

justice in this Law shall prescribe at the end of ten (10) years from the date of such act or omission.

Section 27. Any subordinate officer or employee in the government service shall have the

power and mandatory duty to secretly report any act or omission defined in this Law as a crime of

obstruction of justice or any other criminal act including act of corruption or violation of human rights

defined by any law committed by his superior officer or co-employee to a grand jury for investigation

and indictment. Failure of such subordinate officer or employee to perform his duty within thirty (30)

days from his knowledge of such act or omission or any other criminal act including act of corruption

or violation of human right of his superior officer or co-employee shall likewise be liable for

obstruction of justice and indictment by a grand jury.

Section 28. The findings of fact by the trial jury shall be final and shall not be subject of

review on appeal. If such findings shall result in the imposition of death penalty, the penalty shall be

automatically reduced to life in prison. An error of law may be appealed by either party to a case.

Section 29. Any justice of a Sandiganbayan may act as a presiding judge over a jury trial.

Page 259: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

226

PRO TEMP JURY PRESIDING JUDGE

Section 30. Creation of the Position for Pro Temp Jury Presiding Judge And Payment of

his Services -

(1) To ensure availability of presiding judges to conduct criminal jury trials, and to speed

up the disposition of criminal cases as constitutionally ordained, the National Jury Law hereby

creates the position of Pro Temp Jury Presiding Judge and shall be known as “Pro Temp Jury PJ”.

He shall act as a temporary or substitute jury presiding judge in a criminal jury trial in the event of

the unavailability or absence of a regular judge or justice in the Sandiganbayan, Regional Trial

Courts, Shari’a District Courts, Metropolitan Trial Courts, City Trial Courts, Municipal Trial Courts,

any Criminal Circuit Courts, or in Land Ownership Registration disputes in the Courts of First

Instance.

(2) The services of the Pro Temp Jury PJ shall be paid through the prescribed

“Unconditional Non-transferable Redeemable Judicial Voucher”, known as “Form GJ-27”. A sample

of this form is found in Article III, Section 99, of the National Jury Law.

Section 31. Qualification of the Pro Temp Jury PJ - The Pro Temp Jury PJ shall be a

bonafide member of the Integrated Bar of the Philippines with license to practice law. He shall have

been actually engaged in the practice of law for at least three (3) years. As of the date of the filing

of his application, he shall certify that he has completely devoted a total of at least 24 hours of

self-study of the National Jury Law. He has read and he is thoroughly familiar both with the Statutory

Grand Jury Instruction in Section 24 and Form GJ-41 of Section 99 in Article III, and the Statutory

Basic Trial Jury Instruction on Form TJ-108 in Section 2, Article X of the National Jury Law. He shall

have actually accomplished a “dry run” preparation in his own handwriting with the following forms

by assuming the roles of those who are concerned in preparing or filling up those forms, most

particularly the following: Form TJ-103, Form TJ-109, Form TJ-109A, Forms TJ-110A-B-C-D, Form

TJ-111, Form TJ-112, Form TJ-113, Form TJ-114, Form TJ-135, Form TJ-136, Form TJ-137 and

Form TJ-138. He shall further state that he is expertly cognizant of the rudiments in the impaneling

of a trial jury and the preemptory challenges of jurors.

Section 32. The Pro Temp Jury Presiding Judge Application Form - The application of the

the Pro Temp Jury Presiding Judge shall be accomplished on Form TJ-107A found in Article X,

Section 2 of the National Jury Law. Form TJ-107A is a durable form and it shall not be modified or

Page 260: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

227

altered in any manner by the applicant.

Section 33. The promissory undertaking in the Application of the Pro Temp Jury Presiding

Judge-

The Pro Temp Jury Presiding Judge shall promise and wilfully agree as follows:

(1) He shall start to serve as Pro Temp Jury Presiding Judge within seventy-two (72) hours

from the date of his receipt of an assignment notice from any court room of the court district in which

he has submitted his application for pool membership.

(2) He shall accept compensation on a per diem basis starting with one non-trial day per

diem to prepare for trial under the Unconditional Redeemable Judicial Voucher prescribed on Form

GJ-27 at the rate of pay equivalent to the computed hourly compensation of the last appointed

regular presiding judge of the province, city or municipality where he shall serve.

(3) The assignment notice served upon the attorney-nominee on a particular case shall

be subject to a random drawing with five (5) competing participants from the raffle bin in the Pool

of the Pro Temp Jury Presiding Judge.

(4) Should the attorney-nominee accept the assignment and another or more attorney-

nominees likewise signify his or their willingness to accept the assignment, his and all their names

will further be raffled together again in a special raffle bin and the first name pulled out therefrom

shall be appointed as Jury Presiding Pro Temp Judge on the case set for trial.

(5) If, at the time of reraffle another criminal case pending in the same court has been set

and ready for jury trial has come to the knowledge of the Clerk of Court and the attorney-nominee

or nominees shall be interested to sit as Pro Temp Jury PJ on such another case, a further reraffle

shall be conducted by the Clerk of Court with among the remaining nominees present on such

occasion to choose the Pro Temp Jury PJ for the jury trial of such other case. If he is a lone waiter,

he shall be assigned to serve as the Pro Temp Jury PJ.

(6) The attorney-nominee or nominees who failed to get the appointment shall further

agree that his, or their, application(s) shall be redeposited back in the raffle bin for future redrawing

on other assigned criminal cases for jury trial in the future.

Page 261: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

228

Section 34. An attorney performing his duty as a Pro Temp Jury PJ. shall be bound by the

“Code of Conduct and Ethical standards for Public Officials and Employees” according to Republic

Act 6713. It shall be unlawful for such attorney to demand for a fee from any of the parties in which

he has served in his capacity as Pro Temp Jury PJ on their case.

Section 35. Invitation Advertisement for Applicants to the Pro Temp Jury PJ Pool -

(1) To invite applicants to the Pro Temp Jury PJ Pool, the Clerk of Court of his Judicial

District shall post an advertisement in a news paper with a general circulation in the province or city

covering his court jurisdiction. He may likewise post his advertisement in the Bulletin Boards in the

court house where criminal cases are filed or he shall announce in radio or television stations that

are operating in his city or province.

(2) The invitation advertisement shall conform to the prescribed form, known as Form TJ-

107, in Article X, Sections 1 and 2, of the National Jury Law.

CIVIL JURY TRIAL

Section 36. Civil jury trials-

(1) All pleadings and practices under current rules of court shall remain the same including

appeals on an issue, or issues, of law, except that the findings of fact by the jury shall be final and

shall not be subject to review on appeal. The Rules in Form TJ-122 shall serve as a guide in Civil

Jury Trials.

(2) The attorneys representing the respective parties in a civil case shall privately meet jointly

in-chamber for pretrial conference with the presiding judge wherein they shall submit a simplified

format in summary form of their pleadings for approval by the presiding judge for use as instruction

to the jury.

(3) All pleadings and their summaries at the top of each page shall be clearly marked as

“THIS DOCUMENT IS NOT AN EVIDENCE”.

(4) All pleadings and their summaries shall be translated into the local dialect of the jurors.

(5) The same jury oath and instruction in the National Jury Law shall be used for civil jury

Page 262: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

229

trials, except as to those instructions that are exclusively applicable to criminal jury trials.

(6) The parties may use such principles or forms applicable in the United States Federal

Rules of Civil Procedure provided that they are not in conflict with any Philippine law, rule, or Civil

Procedure.

(7) A Civil Trial Jury shall be composed of twelve (12) jurors and their selection shall be

conducted in the same procedure as in the impaneling of a criminal trial jury. The party obtaining

seven (7) or more votes in its favor shall be the prevailing party. In case of a tie vote, the defendant

shall prevail.

(8) If a civil case involve highly technical issues, not within the grasp of a high school

graduate, the parties may stipulate that the selection of jurors may be limited to college graduates

of any degree. In this event, the civil claim complaint shall state that the summons for jury service

shall so state “For College Graduates Only” for the guidance of citizens in receiving the summons.

(9) The fee of the juror shall be double of the minimum wage and shall be shared equally

by the parties to the case and its total cost shall be estimated and deposited in court when a civil jury

trial becomes unavoidable in the case. In case of a pauper claimant, the defendant shall be required

to make the deposit in court in advance of the estimated total jury fee.

(10) In civil jury trial involving tort cases, the jury shall have the discretion to grant an award

for punitive damages in favor of the prevailing plaintiff in such amount as it may deem reasonable

taking into consideration the aggravating circumstance or circumstances that added to the hardship

of the victim-plaintiff. Use Form TJ-110B, the Charge Sheet, as your guide in formulating a tort

complaint claim for submission to the Jury similar to Form TJ-110D.

(11) The civil trial jury shall reach its verdict by the secret votes of the jurors. No juror is

permitted to force his fellow juror to vote either way. No opinion of the juror during deliberation shall

count as vote until written secretly in his ballot. Before voting to arrive at the jury verdict, the jurors

shall, and must, hold a discussion or deliberation among themselves. They may use the local dialect

of their community in combination with commonly spoken English words if necessary for the jurors

to understand to accomplish their jury job.

(12) Either party may appeal from the verdict in a civil jury trial on the issue of law. The

finding of facts by a trial jury cannot be changed on appeal.

Page 263: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

230

(13) Civil jury trials shall be conducted in English and simultaneously interpreted by a trained

or expert interpreter from English to the common local dialect of the jurors. Jury instruction shall

be interpreted in the same manner.

Section 37. No person, judge, justice, or any public official, shall order, interfere, instruct,

dictate, or indicate in any manner to any juror or to the jury, in or out of court, which way the jury

shall decide a case at hand. Violation of this law shall render the violator liable for obstruction of

justice with punishment and fine as provided in Article IV, Section 24, of the National Jury Law.

Section 38. No prosecutor, Counsel for the Plaintiff, or Counsel for the defendant shall order,

instruct, interfere, dictate, or indicate in any manner to any juror or to the jury, outside of court or jury

trial, after he has rested his case for decision by the jury. Violation of this law shall render the

offender liable for obstruction of justice with punishment and fine as provided in Article IV, Section

23, of the National Jury Law.

Section 39. Other than the jurors chosen to hear, try and decide by jury a case at hand, no

judge, justice, or any member of his staff in court shall participate in the deliberation of the jury in

arriving at its verdict. Violation of this law shall render the violator liable for obstruction of justice with

reference to Article IV, Section 24, of the National Jury Law.

Section 40. Filing Fee - No civil litigant shall be required to pay a filing fee for his pleading in

court if it shows that he is indigent considering his income from, and security of, his job, and the size

of his family or dependents as shown in the old or customary form of his statement of assets and

liability which must be filed together with his pleadings and his request for waiver of filing fees. In the

event of an award in his favor after trial or appeal, and the award is one hundred thousand pesos

(P100,000.00) or more, he shall be required to pay the required court filing fees which shall not be

more than two (2) thousand pesos (P2,000.), upon filing a request for execution of his favorable

award.

Section 41. Pauper Litigants and Contingent Attorney’s Fee - Notwithstanding any law or rule

to the contrary, any party to a civil case may retain the services of a lawyer whose fees shall be

contingent upon the successful outcome on the matter under litigation. The contingency fee for

attorney’s services shall be no more than one-third (1/3) of the money value of the gross award plus

reimbursement of all expenses paid in advance by the attorney in behalf of his client without interest

charges. Payment of the contingent fee to the attorney shall be tendered and delivered only if the

award has actually been paid and recovered by the winning litigant.

Page 264: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

231

ARTICLE V

DEFINITION OF TERMS AND COMPLIANCE

Definitions of Obstruction of Justice

Section 1. The acts described in the following sections in this Article, Article V, shall be

deemed acts of “Obstruction of Justice” and shall not exclude other acts of obstruction of justice as

defined elsewhere in the other Articles of the National Jury Law. The duration of penalty of

imprisonment for obstruction of justice shall be four (4) years to seven (7) years unless a specific

length of time of imprisonment in jail has been stated and defined in a particular provision found

elsewhere of the National Jury Law.

Section 2. Preventing witnesses from testifying in any criminal or disciplinary proceeding

or from reporting the commission of any offense or the identity of any of its offender/s by means of

bribery, misrepresentation, deceit, intimidation, force or threats, demotion in rank, title or position in,

undue influence, or termination or dismissal from his customary occupation or employment in the

government;

Section 3. Altering, destroying, suppressing or concealing any paper, record, document,

or object, with intent to impair its verity, authenticity, legibility, availability, or admissibility as evidence

in any investigation of or official proceedings in, criminal cases, or to be used in the investigation of,

or official proceedings in, criminal cases;

Section 4. Harboring or concealing, or facilitating the escape of, any person he knows,

or has reasonable ground to believe or suspect, has committed any offense under existing penal

laws in order to prevent his arrest, prosecution and conviction;

Section 5. Publicly using a fictitious name for the purpose of concealing a crime, evading

prosecution or the execution of a judgment, or concealing his true name and other personal

circumstances for the same purpose or purposes;

Section 6. Delaying the prosecution of criminal cases by obstructing the service of

process or court orders or disturbing proceedings in the prosecutor or fiscal's offices, in the

Ombudsman office, in the National Bureau of Investigation’s office, or in the courts;

Section 7. Making or presenting an oral statement or testimony under oath or using any

record, document, paper or object with knowledge of its falsity and with intent to affect the course

or outcome of the investigation of, or official proceedings in, a criminal case before a grand jury or

a crime investigating body or a trial court.

Page 265: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

232

Section 8. Soliciting, accepting, or agreeing to accept any benefit in consideration of

abstaining from, discontinuing, or impeding the prosecution of, a criminal offender;

Section 9. Threatening directly or indirectly another with the infliction of any wrong upon

his person, honor or property or that of any immediate member or members of his family in order to

prevent such person from appearing in the investigation of, or official proceedings in, criminal cases,

or imposing a condition, whether lawful or unlawful, in order to prevent a person from appearing in

the investigation of or in official proceedings in, criminal cases;

Section 10. Giving of false or fabricated information to mislead or prevent the law

enforcement agencies from apprehending the offender or from protecting the life or property of the

victim; or fabricating information from the data gathered in confidence by investigating authorities

for purposes of background information and not for publication and publishing or disseminating the

same to mislead the investigator or the court.

Section 11. Contacting by a lawyer or an associate or friend of such lawyer with a public

official for the purpose of securing the influence of such public official to communicate with a judge,

or presiding judge in a bench or jury trial or a juror to obtain a judgment or verdict in favor of his

case.

Section 12. Active or passive co-operation of an employer, job supervisor or co-employee

with any person or public official to influence the decision of its employee, subordinate or

co-employee who is serving as a juror on a matter being tried in a jury trial.

Section 13. Failure of a juror to comply with his mandatory duty to report within thirty (30)

days to a grand jury from the date of his receipt of any direct solicitation or request from any person,

public official, his employer or job supervisor or co-employee asking such juror to make a decision

over a case he is sitting as juror in favour of the soliciting person, public official, his employer or job

supervisor or co-employee.

Section 14. Failure of an employer, job supervisor, or co-employee of a juror to comply

with his mandatory obligation within thirty (30) days from the receipt by such employer, job

supervisor, or co-employee to report to a grand jury of any solicitation from any person or public

official with the view of influencing such juror, or a judge, in making his decision over a case he is

sitting in a jury trial or a bench trial.

Section 15. A decision by a juror in a jury trial based on a solicited decision by any

person, public official, employer, job supervisor or co-employee regardless of whether such juror has

received a bribe or not, or intentional failure or refusal to write in his vote in the jury ballot for a jury

verdict.

Page 266: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

233

Section 16. Failure of a presiding judge in a bench trial or jury trial of his mandatory

obligation to report to a grand jury within thirty (30) days of his receipt of a solicitation or request from

any person or public official with the view of influencing the decision of a case in his court or of the

jury over whom he is presiding.

Section 17. Failure of a government prosecutor to comply with his mandatory duty to

commence within three (3) days from the date he received notice of the filing of a government

criminal accusation of the act of securing the grand jury indictment by submitting to the grand jury

all documentary proof of court filing and every prima facie evidence of a crime with the information

whether the accused is in the custody of the government or not arising from a criminal accusation

that has been originally filed in court by the government.

Section 18. Disobedience by any public official or person of a writ of amparo, writ of

habeas corpus, or writ of habeas data issued by the Supreme Court, Court of Appeals,

Sandiganbayan, Regional Trial Courts, Metropolitan or Municipal Trial or Circuit Courts and Shari’a

District or Circuit Courts, or Justice of the Peace Court.

Section 19. Disobedience by any public official or person of a subpoena, subpoena

duces tecum or summons issued by the Ombudsman, Commission on Audit, Commission on

Elections, Civil Service Commission, Commission on Human Rights, through their deputies, in

matters within their respective jurisdictions to investigate.

Section 20. Intentional failure of a person or witness of his obligation to tell the truth in his

testimony before a grand jury.

Section 21. Disclosure to another person or public official, or failure by a witness, also

known as “invitee”, to comply with his legal obligation to strictly keep in secrecy of his receipt and

possession of a subpoena, subpoena duces tecum, or summons, issued by a grand jury to appear

as a witness before such grand jury. Disclosure by the witness to his personal attorney specifically

for confidential legal consultation shall not be a violation of this prohibition and the attorney under

no condition, and with pain for disciplinary action by disbarment, shall disclose to anyone such

confidential consultation.

Section 22. Disobedience or refusal by any person or public official to testify before a

grand jury by disregarding his receipt of a subpoena, subpoena duces tecum, or summons issued

by such grand jury.

Section 23. Preventing by any person or public official of a witness from testifying before

a grand jury who has received a summons, subpoena or subpoena duces tecum from the grand jury

by any means of aiding such witness to leave the country or by detaining such witness for any

purpose.

Page 267: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

234

Section 24. Termination, demotion in rank or position or relocation of employment of a

witness who has received a subpoena, subpoena duces tecum, or summons from a grand jury or

who testifies or has testified before such grand jury and such termination, demotion in rank or

position or relocation of employment has been initiated by an employer, or superior public official,

member of a board of directors or trustees of a corporate entity, quasi-government entity or

government owned or controlled corporation.

Section 25. Refusal by a witness who is a giver or an offer or in the crime of bribery to

testify before the grand jury against the recipient of his bribe in which such witness has been granted

full immunity from prosecution when such grant of immunity has been stated in the subpoena,

subpoena duces tecum or summons issued by such grand jury upon the witness.

Section 26. Interference or participation in court or from elsewhere by telephone, email

communication, or by any electronic device by any person or public official in the impaneling of jury

members for a jury trial other than the presiding judge, government prosecutor, and the defense

attorney.

Section 27. Failure of a trial presiding judge in a jury trial to comply with his mandatory

duty to report to the grand jury within thirty (30) days of the act of interference or participation of any

person or public official in the impaneling of the jury members on a case for jury trial before his court

room.

Section 28. Failure of a subordinate officer or employee in the public service to perform

his mandatory duty within thirty (30) days of his knowledge to secretly report said knowledge to a

grand jury for investigation of an act or omission defined as obstruction of justice by his superior

officer or co-employee.

Section 29. Failure or neglect of a police or military officer to comply with his personal

mandatory obligation to provide preference of protection to a citizen who is serving as a juror in a

grand jury or trial jury proceeding over and above the safety of any public official from physical injury

or psychological harm or death from an imminent peril within the jurisdiction of command of said

police or military officer. Said officer need not be in his official uniform at the time the perilous

situation was taking, or about to take, place.

Section 30. Omission, deviation or alteration by the presiding judge in the reading or

issuance of the statutory basic jury instruction of the National Jury Law with the intention of giving

undue favor or disfavor, or advantage or disadvantage, to a party or witness in a jury trial.

Section 31. Failure or refusal by a presiding judge to comply with his mandatory duty to

report to the grand jury within thirty (30) days of the dismissal of a criminal case before his court for

the reason that the prosecutor failed to prepare in the presentation of his evidence or for presenting

a procured affidavit of desistance from the complaining witness or victim at the scheduled firm

Page 268: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

235

commencement date of the jury trial of his case.

Section 32. Surreptitious attendance or intrusion in the formation proceedings of a grand

jury by any person or public official or government employee or permission by a clerk of court or

presiding judge to allow such person or public official or government employee to observe the said

grand jury formation proceedings.

Section 33. The arrest or detention of a person with or without cause who is a juror in a

grand jury or trial jury while reporting to and from between his place of jury duty and his residence

by any police agent or by any other person including his instigator whether public official or not in

violation of this provision of the National Jury Law shall be liable for indictment of obstruction of

justice by the grand jury.

Section 34. Purposely delaying by a vehicle driver or operator in delivering a juror whom

he has provided a ride, whether paid or as a courtesy passenger, to a juror in delivering such juror

to, or by deviating from, the general direction of his intended travel to the court, such driver or

operator shall be liable for indictment for obstruction of justice by a grand jury.

Section 35. An open announcement by a driver or transportation operator by means of

a visible placard in his vehicle to the effect that he is a provider for a courtesy ride for a juror or jurors

along the way to their destination courts is hereby prohibited. Violation of this provision shall be

punishable as an act of obstruction of justice. The driver or operator of such vehicle and its

passenger juror are hereby forbidden to talk with each other on any subject matter that may be

related to the case for jury trial and for which such passenger has been summoned to serve for jury

duty. Violation of this rule shall subject such vehicle driver or operator and such passenger in his

vehicle liable for indictment by the grand jury for obstruction of justice.

Section 36. Failure of a person to appear to testify as a witness in a civil or criminal trial

before a court of law who has been properly served and has received, upon proof of his receipt of

a summons or subpoena or subpoena duces tecum at the instance of the complaint of a requesting

party for the appearance of such witness in the referenced scheduled trial.

Section 37. Willful refusal or failure of a person, public official, or an official of a

responsible party by the use of an illegal or dilatory act or acts or act of defalcation of funds or

property by such person, public official, or official of a responsible party to prevent the

implementation of a civil or criminal duty to perform, or settle, upon a court order or jury verdict that

has become final and executory.

Section 38. Departure from the Philippines by a person or public official for a foreign

jurisdiction or country for any purpose knowing that he has committed a criminal offense that is

punishable by imprisonment in jail for a period of one year or more regardless of whether such

departure has been authorized or ordered, or not, by any official of the government. Any person or

Page 269: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

236

public official who shall issue such authorization or order for the departure of such crime offender

under investigation, knowing or having been informed of the crime or possible crime he has

committed, shall be similarly liable for the commission of, and imprisonment for, the crime of

obstruction of justice.

Section 39. Suppression by, or failure of, a government or private prosecutor or fiscal,

or by a presiding judge in conspiracy with such government or private prosecutor or fiscal, to disclose

to the accused or his defense counsel, if represented, any exculpatory evidence in his possession

in favour of the accused prior to, or during, the jury trial.

Section 40. Public display or parading of a crime suspect as a publicity exhibit prior to

conviction in any manner by any person or public officer in custody of the crime suspect shall

constitute obstruction of justice and a violation of his right to constitutional innocence and human

rights. He shall be entitled to claim moral damages in the sum of two hundred thousand pesos

(P200,000.00) jointly and severally against such person or officer and the government entity such

person or officer represents in addition to fine and imprisonment for obstruction of justice.

Subsequent conviction or acquittal of the crime suspect shall not extinguish the civil and criminal

liabilities of said person or public officer and the public entity he represents prior to the conviction

or acquittal of the crime suspect. In the event of death of the crime suspect, his heirs shall have the

power to pursue his claim.

Section 41. Forcing a crime suspect to confess his alleged crime by any person or public

officer through torture or any forceful means in which case the penalty for such obstruction of justice

shall be seven years and one day to ten years and one day. Such crime suspect shall be entitled

to claim moral damages in the sum of two hundred thousand pesos (P200,000.00) jointly and

severally against such person or officer and the government entity such person or officer represents

in addition to fine and imprisonment for obstruction of justice. Subsequent conviction or acquittal of

the crime suspect shall not extinguish the civil and criminal liabilities of said person or public officer

and the public entity he represents prior to the conviction or acquittal of the crime suspect. In the

event of death of the crime suspect, his heirs shall have the power to pursue his claim.

Section 42. Failure of a lawyer or lawyers of the president in attending at the scheduled

firm trial date of the president who has been criminally indicted by the Grand Jury. In addition for

conviction of obstruction of justice, such a lawyer or lawyers shall be disbarred from the Roll of

Attorneys.

Section 43. Disclosure or publicity of additionally discovered evidence or names of

witnesses to any person or member of the media by a government prosecutor, or his successor, in

pursuing to trial in his charge a matter relating to a grand jury indictment.

Section 44. Preparation by, or dictation of, an attorney in making an affidavit of desistance

contrary to the intended will of the affiant victim or witness.

Page 270: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

237

Section 45. Conversation by an attorney with a trial juror on duty on any matter outside

the jury trial proceedings while a case at hand is still in progress prior to the reading of the jury

verdict in said case. If the attorney is a counsel to any party to the case at hand, such attorney shall

be liable for disbarment in addition to the penalty for obstruction of justice.

Section 46. Failure of the lead attorney or counsel of the president to attend a firm date

of trial when the president is on trial before a trial jury upon the indictment by a grand jury shall be

liable for the crime of obstruction of justice on complaint by any citizen or any member of the media

before such grand jury.

Section 47. The act of filing by any person of a preemptive impeachment complaint in

Congress against the convicted president with the view of protecting such president from being

impeached or any public official who is removable by impeachment as a result of his conviction in

accordance with the National Jury Law shall be deemed an act of, and shall render such person

criminally punishable for, obstruction of justice.

Section 48. The act of preventing or discouraging, in any manner, a citizen who has

receive a summons for jury duty from serving as a juror in a jury trial or the confiscation of the

summons to such citizen for jury duty to prevent said citizen from fulfilling his duty to serve as a trial

juror shall be criminally punishable as an act of obstruction of justice.

Section 49. The act of disclosing or gossiping about a grand jury investigation by any

witness who has received a grand jury summons or who has testified before said Body shall be liable

for the crime of obstruction of justice.

Section 50. The act of knowingly participating in any sham or mock judicial trial, hearing

or proceedings for the purpose of harassment shall be criminally punishable as an act of obstruction

of justice. This provision shall not apply to classroom or televised drama proceedings for educational

purposes.

Section 51. Filing a complaint before a prosecutor's office or before a grand jury or before

a court of law knowing that such act is based on a completely false allegation of facts for the purpose

of harassing, or intimidating, or threatening, or punishing, to prevent or discourage another from

performing a lawful activity shall be criminally punishable as an act of obstruction of justice.

Section 52. Any lawyer who shall provide legal assistance in committing the act or acts

described in the immediate preceding Section 50, or Section 51, knowing that the action of his client

is a total falsity, shall likewise be held liable for the crime of obstruction of justice and penalty of

imprisonment.

Page 271: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

238

Section 53. Any member of a grand jury who shall be criminally liable for committing the

crime of bribery shall be deemed a public officer as defined in Article 210 of the Revised Penal Code

of the Philippines. However, no indictment against such member of the grand jury shall be filed in

court, until his term of grand jury service shall have already expired.

Section 54. The act of any indicted government official referred to in Article III, Section

74 in refusing to be taken into government custody by an arresting officer after such arresting officer

has announced the execution of an arrest warrant upon such indicted government official shall be

criminally punishable as an act of obstruction of justice and penalty of imprisonment in addition to

such other crimes he may have committed.

Section 55. Violation of the prohibited acts in Article I of this Law shall subject the violator

liable for the crime of obstruction of justice and penalty of imprisonment as the context of the

provision in said Article demands imperative obedience.

Section 56. Any surreptitious act of giving a false testimony or official report by an

investigator, or by the supervisor of such investigator, of a crime to prevent or suppress further

investigation of the crime, or to prevent the prosecution of a person believed to be the probable

responsible offender of a crime, or to cover-up the commission of a crime, punishable by

imprisonment in jail regardless of the prescribed period of incarceration of such crime shall be

punishable by imprisonment and fine as an act of obstruction of justice.

Section 57. Interference and intrusion in any manner by a jury presiding judge, or by a

member of his office staff, or by either the prosecuting attorney or the defense attorney, after the

case at hand has submitted to the jury for jury deliberation and decision upon the trial jury or upon

a jury member or members during the process of jury deliberation in reaching its jury verdict shall

be punishable by imprisonment and fine as an act of obstruction of justice.

Other Definition of Terms In the National Jury Law.

Section 58. “Employer” shall mean any natural person who hired the juror to perform a

certain job with, or without, pay for the former’s personal affairs or business regardless of

permanence or length of time of employment for such person;

Section 59. “Job supervisor” shall mean any person towards whom the juror receives

instructions in executing his job at any given time or location. It likewise includes a member of a

board of directors or trustees of a corporation, government owned or controlled corporation or

quasi-public corporation as well as a public official who may be a supervisor over a juror who is an

Page 272: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

239

undisclosed subordinate employee in the organization of such supervisor.

Section 60. “Co-employee” shall mean any person with whom the juror is employed in the

same employer or organization of any nature or purpose.

Section 61. “Public official” or “public officer” as used in the context of the National Jury

Law means any person who holds an employment or activity, mentally or manually, in the public

service or any instrumentality or branches of the Republic of the Philippines including government

owned and controlled corporation or quasi- government corporation, by election, written or verbal

appointment from another public officer or from a private citizen or usurpation of office by an

impostor, regardless of position, title, rank, amount of compensation or intended length or

permanence of service.

Section 62. “Public service” is any function or activity, mental or physical labor, by any

person for the operation of any instrumentality or branches and level of the government of the

Republic of the Philippines including service in government owned or controlled corporations and

quasi-government corporations.

Section 63. Debarment -

(a) Any person with a professional license in the Philippines when found guilty of

obstruction of justice, or of crimes in violation of the Anti-Graft Law, the Anti-Money Laundering Act,

or Crime of Plunder in a jury or bench trial shall lose his right or privilege to engage or practice his

profession. If he is an unlicensed professional, he shall further be barred from aspiring to hold a

public or government position or office including but not limited to government owned or controlled,

or government-quasi, corporation.

(b) Any government authority or commission in charged of evaluating the qualification of

any person aspiring to hold a public office by election or by appointment or by promotion shall

require such aspirant to submit his Statement of Assets, Liabilities and Network, or SALN, to such

government authority or commission for publication, at the personal expense of such aspirant, in

a newspaper with general circulation in the geographical jurisdiction such person shall serve office

when elected, appointed, or promoted.

(c) If it is shown in his SALN that such aspirant owes the government for taxes or

unliquidated money or property allowances or advances for any reason, or if it appears that any of

the information in his SALN is found untruthful, or falsified, upon due notice and hearing before, and

found such fact of untruthfulness and falsification by, such government authority or commission, said

Page 273: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

240

government authority or commission shall issue an order to disqualify such aspirant from proceeding

with his election, appointment, or promotion to a public office or position.

(d) Failure of the government authority or commission to obtain the SALN of the aspirant

to a public office shall cause the Grand Jury to initiate action to investigate violation of the Code of

Conduct by the officers and employees of said government authority or commission as established

by Republic Act 6713.

Section 64. Right of subrogation and monetary reimbursement of criminal and civil liability

in favor of the government over, and from, acts of public official - Notwithstanding any existing law,

statute, decree, or rule to the contrary, any monetary award or judgment in favor of a plaintiff in a

criminal or civil case against a public official or employee arising from the unlawful act or acts of such

official or employee in the course of the performance of his official duties, shall be satisfied as

follows:

(a) Such monetary award or judgment shall be charged and paid in advance within thirty

(30) days from the finality of award or judgment to the prevailing litigant against any public funds

budgeted or allotted to the office, bureau, commission, government branch or department or

government instrumentality, government owned or controlled corporation or quasi-government

corporation of which the losing party is employed or has the authority to supervise provided that the

said related government instrumentality or entity is likewise sued as a co-defendant of the losing

party in the same criminal or civil action.

(b) Any public official or employee who shall delay the payment of the monetary award or

judgment to the prevailing party as required in the foregoing subsection (a) above shall be liable for

the crime and punishment of obstruction of justice upon the instance of such prevailing party or his

conservator, or estate in case of death.

(c) The paying government entity shall have the absolute right of reimbursement from the

private funds of such public official or employee including from his salary, retirement benefits, and

his other emoluments by reason of his official position by election or by appointment, directly or

indirectly, and from his private business or enterprise, or of his estate in the event of his death, until

fully paid regardless of the location of his assets and funds in the Philippines or in other countries

with the assistance of the Philippine Consulate office in such other countries.

(d) The monetary liability of such public official or employee herein shall not prescribe and

shall not be extinguished by his act, or act of his heirs, of filing a petition for insolvency or bankruptcy

Page 274: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

241

before any court of law.

Section 65. Obstruction of Justice after the fact - Reckless negligence or intentional failure

of a person, government employee, officer, or official, by reason of his position, title, or rank by

appointment or by election to a public office in the national or local government unit or

instrumentality, armed or police services, including government owned or controlled, or

quasi-government corporation under the control or supervision of his position, title, or rank to report,

or to continue to report, to the grand jury the commission of a serious crime that occurred prior to

his assumption of his position, title or rank shall be punishable as an act of "Obstruction of Justice

after the fact". If the failure to act is the result of his grossly reckless neglect, the penalty shall be

imprisonment in jail for 3 to 5 years, and if the failure to act is intentional, the penalty shall be

imprisonment in jail for 5 to 7 years, plus forfeiture of all benefits from public service and perpetual

disqualification from holding any public office in either degree of such failure to act.

(Continued to Article VI)

Page 275: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

242

ARTICLE VI

NATIONAL JURY MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY

Section 1. A unified judicial entity is hereby created by this Law with authority to establish

the Rules and Management of the National Jury Law.

Section 2. This Entity shall be named as the “National Jury Management Authority ” and

may be known in brief as the “NJMA”. Its complete attributes, powers and prerogatives are further

defined in Article XI of the National Jury Law.

Section 3. Procedures on How to Start and Conduct The Jury Trial -

To enable the courts around the country to start trial by jury, a Statutory Basic Jury Trial

Instruction has been set up on prescribed form, Form TJ-108, as an integral part of the National Jury

Law and Procedures, and ready for use upon the passage and approval by the people through the

people’s initiative process under Republic Act 6735. The NJMA may update said Form TJ-108 for

further improvements.

(a) This Jury Instruction shall be extemporaneously interpreted into the local dialect by a

trained jury trial court interpreter in the course of a jury trial.

(b) A translation of this Jury Instruction in the common local dialect shall be posted in a

bulletin board in the Jury Assembly Room for optional pre-reading by incoming jurors and shall be

published, once every five (5) years by the Jury Commissioner or Clerk of Court, in a newspaper

with general circulation in each province and city around the country for the education of the people

of their rights and obligations in justice.

(c) Upon completion of the impaneling of the jury and swearing in of the jurors, the

Presiding Judge of the Jury shall promptly issue and read the Statutory Basic Jury Trial Instruction

on Form TJ-108.

(d) No presiding judge shall be allowed to omit, deviate, or alter the text in issuing the said

instructions to prevent giving undue favor or disfavor, or advantage or disadvantage to any party or

Page 276: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

243

witness to a case. A violation of this rule shall hold such judge criminally liable for obstruction of

justice upon investigation and indictment by a grand jury in addition to administrative disciplinary

action for removal from the bench and disbarment for such omission, deviation or alteration of this

rule upon complaint by an aggrieved party or any person for such deviation against the violator.

(e) Oath of Impaneled Jurors - Upon completion of the reading and issuance of the SBJTI,

the Jury Presiding Judge shall stand and require the jurors to do the same and ask to raise their right

hand. He shall then administer their oath by the following statement:

"Members of the jury: Do each of you swear by Almighty God, or affirm

solemnly, faithfully, and truly declare that you will try the case before you to

the best of your ability and give your verdict according to the evidence?"

And each juror shall respond: “I do.”

(f) After the impaneled jurors have taken their oath, the Jury Presiding Judge shall

thereupon announce the sequence of the presentation of the evidence in the Jury Trial. Generally,

the format of presenting the evidence in the jury trial shall be similar to the presentation of the

evidence in a bench, or solo judge, trial. Each witness shall be instructed to face the jury in the

course of giving his testimony.

(g) The Jury Presiding Judge shall then call on the Prosecutor to state his opening

statement for the trial of the accused with the reminder to the jury that the opening statement is not

an evidence and that it is only intended as an outline of the case that the jurors are about to hear.

In his opening statement, the prosecutor is not allowed to show any exhibits. Any exhibit shall be

shown in the course of the giving of the testimony of a witness in the witness stand.

(h) No opening statement of the Defense attorney shall be required.

(I) After the prosecutor’s opening statement is done, he shall, thereupon, announce to

the Presiding Judge and to the Jury that he is now calling is first witness to sit in the witness chair.

The witness shall be sworn in and to whom he shall thereafter begin to ask his direct examination

or questions. During this process, the prosecutor shall present his exhibits for identification by his

witness and he may further ask questions on items or statements on each exhibit for needed

clarification on such items or statements.

Page 277: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

244

(j) Cross examination on the witness of the prosecution by the attorney of the accused

shall promptly follow after the direct examination by the prosecutor is completed.

(k) After all the witnesses of the prosecution have been examined by direct and cross

examination by the respective counsels in the case at hand, the attorney for the prosecution shall

then announce to the Presiding Judge and to the Jury that he has no further questions to ask, and

no other witnesses or exhibits to present.

(l) The accused shall thereafter be entitled to present his evidence for his defense

through his attorney. If the accused strongly feels that he may be found guilty and communicates

to his defense attorney of his desire to enter a “guilty plea”, his wish shall be respected. This process

shall be held confidentially in chamber with the presiding judge and strictly away from the

knowledge and hearing of the jury. If it appears that the accused is positively determined to enter

a guilty plea, a recess for the jury shall be ordered by the presiding judge with the further order for

the jury to come back on the third day. The jury or any juror shall absolutely not be informed

anything about the plea bargaining efforts. If the accused pleaded guilty to the crime or crimes

charged against him, the presiding judge shall inform the jury about such guilty plea and he shall

give thanks and discharge the jurors for their attendance in court. A court sheriff shall then lead the

jurors to the Jury Commissioner who shall attend in making the payment for their jury fees and given

their noon time meal at the Jury Assembly Area before final discharge. The Jury Commissioner shall

likewise provide the jurors with their Transport Ticket, Form TJ-131, in going back home.

(1) The attorney for the accused shall then negotiate with the prosecutor for a minimum

penalty of imprisonment for his client. If the accused is charged with two or more criminal offenses,

the minimum penalty for the most serious crime charge against him shall be granted. The presiding

judge shall have no authority to order reduction or increase on the penalty of imprisonment that has

been agreed upon between the prosecuting attorney and the accused through his defense attorney.

(2) The Plea Bargaining process shall be governed by the provisions of Article VII,

Sections 2 through Section 11 of the National Jury Law and the accused shall be required to prepare

and execute Form GJ-51 in Article III, Section 99, and Form TJ-134, Article X, Section 2, of the

National Jury Law.

Page 278: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

245

(3) If it appears that the accused is liable to pay for probable compensatory damages

suffered by the victim or victims and monetary penalty fines, in addition to the penalty of

imprisonment as shown by the evidence so far as presented by the prosecution, the judge shall have

no power to approve or accept the guilty plea unless the funds for the compensatory damage to

indemnify the victim or victims and monetary penalty finds shall have been paid with a bank

manager’s certified check payable and delivered to the victim or victims within three (3) days

counted from the first day that the accused offered to enter a guilty plea in accordance with the

requirements of Article VII, Section 6(a) and 6(b) of the National Jury Law.

(m) If within three (3) days, excluding Saturday, Sunday, and Holiday, the accused fails

to come up with his funds to pay in full of the amount due from him to comply with the condition of

his guilty plea, the jury trial shall absolutely proceed promptly as if no attempt of guilty plea has been

proposed. The Presiding Judge shall have no power to grant continuance of the jury trial beyond

the three (3)-day recess period granted under this sub-section.

(n) Thereupon, the accused through his attorney shall be compelled to present his

evidence for his defence by calling upon his first witness and presentation of his exhibits, if any,

subject to the cross examination by the prosecutor. Such witness shall be sworn before starting to

give his testimony

(o) The defense attorney shall call other witnesses and present his exhibits and likewise

shall be subject to cross examination by the prosecuting attorney. After presenting his last witness

and duly cross examined by the prosecutor, the defense attorney shall inform the presiding judge

and the jury that he has no further witness or exhibits to present and he has no further questions

to ask.

(p) Thereupon, the prosecutor shall state his closing arguments to support the accusation

against the criminal defendant. Thereafter, the defense attorney shall likewise state his closing

arguments for the acquittal of the accused stating his strongest evidence to support his position.

Both parties shall be allowed to revisit their exhibits and show to the jury.

(q) Each of the opposing attorneys should endeavour to present their closing arguments

in a chronological sequence of events leading to the indictment of the accused for the easy

understanding of the jury on their respective positions.

(r) The Jury Presiding Judge shall thereby advise both counsels to refrain from personal

Page 279: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

246

attacks against each other. Their arguments must solely be concentrated on the merits of their

respective evidence on the case.

Section 4. Submitting the case to the Jury for deliberation and decision - Upon

completion of the closing arguments of both the Prosecution and Defense attorneys, the Presiding

Judge shall promptly submit the case at hand to the Jury. For this purpose, Form TJ-111 shall be

used as a guide by the Jury Presiding Judge, and by the Prosecution and Defense Counsels in

submitting the case to the Jury.

(Continue on Article VII in the next page)

Page 280: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

247

ARTICLE VII

MANDATORY TRIAL BY JURY

AND EXCEPTIONS

Section 1. Trial By Jury shall become mandatory upon the effective date after the

passage of this Jury Law on all crimes punishable with imprisonment in jail by one (1) year or more,

referred to herein as “Serious Crimes”, provided that the requirements in sub-sections (a), (b) and

(c) below are complied with. Crimes punishable by less than one (1) year of imprisonment in jail may

be tried by bench trial before a trial judge if preferred by the crime suspect which he shall have

chosen immediately after he entered his “Not Guilty” plea.

(a) The criminal charge against the accused has been approved by the grand jury in the

form of an indictment;

(b) No arraignment of an accused shall be administered unless the accusation against

him has been approved by the grand jury in the form of an indictment;

(c) No accused shall be compelled to stand trial by jury unless the accusation against him

has been approved by the grand jury in the form of an indictment.

(d) Any judge, or a prosecutor, or a defense attorney, shall be liable for the crime of

obstruction of justice who shall conspire to administer the arraignment of the accused in violation

of the forgoing rule wherein the accused shall have been allowed to plead guilty to a criminal charge

without prior grand jury approval of his indictment to obtain an extremely undeserved lesser penalty

for his atrocious criminal act or acts to the victim or society.

(e) If the accused shall enter a guilty plea on his arraignment, the requirements in Sections

2 through 11 of this Article, Article VII, shall be strictly complied with.

Section 2. In the event of a plea bargaining for the purpose of securing a lesser penalty

of imprisonment for the accused, no presiding judge or any public official or any other person or

persons shall be involved in the plea bargaining process, except the prosecution and defense

Page 281: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

248

counsels. Regardless of the atrocity of the accused in committing his crime, no penalty of death

shall be imposed upon him upon pleading guilty to the crime or crimes charged against him.

Section 3. Any person, public official, or judge, except the prosecution and defense

counsels, who shall interfere, directly or indirectly, in the plea bargaining process shall be guilty of

the crime of obstruction of justice.

Section 4. The role of the presiding judge shall be ministerial for the purpose of recording

the guilty plea of the criminal defendant upon full compliance of all requirements under this Article.

Section 5. Conditions for acceptance by the presiding judge of a guilty plea of the

accused -

(a) Before an accused, or criminal defendant, is allowed to enter into a plea bargaining

agreement, he must, under penalty of perjury, be required to file:

(1) A verified statement of his assets, liabilities and networth (SALN) regarding his financial

standing in accordance with the prescribed Form GJ-51 in the Table of Grand Jury Forms in Section

99, Article III, of this Jury Law ; and

(2) A list of name or names of the person or persons to whom he may have given or

consigned to, which actually is, or are, a part or portion of the listed assets with its, or their,

corresponding monetary values. Such statement shall include all assets he received from the date

he entered public service, minus the total value of his regular salary and legal money allowances in

the entire period of time he has serve in the government, if he is an official or employee of any

government instrumentality, up to the date he enters his plea.

(3) A statement of a life-time waiver to his anti-disclosure rights on his bank account

deposits to, withdrawals and payments from, any existing opened, and/or future created, bank

accounts in the Philippines and/or in any other country. The form of the waiver shall comply with

the prescribed Form TJ-134 for this Jury Law. This waiver shall expire upon full payment of all

moneys owed by the convicted offender as a condition for the acceptance and approval of his guilty

plea by the presiding judge of his case under this Article. Partial payment by the criminal defendant

in this matter shall not change the effectivity and terms and conditions of said waiver.

Page 282: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

249

(b) If upon investigation, it is shown that he, the accused, falsified his statement of

assets, liabilities and net worth, including distribution of assets, and name or names of recipient or

recipients thereof, as well as unjustified amount or amounts of banking activities in reference to his

bank accounts in the immediately preceding sub-paragraph (3), his plea for reduced penalty of

imprisonment shall be disapproved, or revoked if the falsity is discovered after his plea and he shall

further incur criminal liability of imprisonment for the crime for obstruction of justice.

Section 6. No presiding judge has the power to approved a plea bargaining agreement

unless the accused, or criminal defendant, shall have fully paid with a certified bank manager’s

check, and actually delivered to, and received by, their respective payees, the following items:

(a) To the victim or victims of his crime for compensatory indemnity damages suffered

by the victim or victims; and

(b) To the National Government Treasury for penalty fines imposed upon the accused

for the cost of administering justice arising from the criminal act or acts of the accused.

Section 7. The civil liability of, including monetary penalty fines imposed upon, the criminal

defendant in the event of his conviction in a jury trial, as determined by the court, or adjudged

against him in a separate civil action, shall not be extinguished by his action for insolvency or

bankruptcy and shall not be subject to any prescriptive period of collection from him or his estate in

the event of his early demise.

Section 8. If the accusation against the criminal defendant consists of two or more crimes,

he shall be required to serve no less than the minimum penalty of imprisonment imposed on the

most serious crime charged or the maximum penalty of the lesser serious crime charged against

him, whichever imposes the longer period of penalty of imprisonment, as part of the condition in the

plea bargaining agreement with the criminal defendant.

Section 9. If a criminal defendant is allowed to plead guilty to a lesser offense and allowed

to post bail, he shall be required to surrender his passport to the court. Failure of the prosecutor or

presiding judge in requiring compliance of this provision wittingly or negligently shall render such

prosecutor or judge criminally liable for obstruction of justice upon investigation and indictment by

a grand jury.

Page 283: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

250

Section 10. A criminal defendant, or the accused, in a crime punishable with a maximum

penalty of less than one (1) year of imprisonment may be tried without a jury unless the accused

demands for such trial by jury and, if so demanded, no increase in penalty of imprisonment or fine

shall be imposed upon him if found guilty by the jury. The foregoing sections 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8 and

9, shall likewise apply to the civil liability and imprisonment penalty of the criminal defendant under

this section.

Section 11. If the accused is found guilty of any of the crime or crimes he has been

charged with and the total amount assessed against him in Sub-Sections (a) and (b) in Section 6

of this Article, Article VII, shall have amounted to one hundred thousand pesos (P100,000.00), or

more, in Philippine currency, his preparation and execution of Form GJ-51 in Article 99, Section 2,

and Form TJ-134 in Article X, Section 2, of the National Jury Law shall become mandatory. If he

fails or refuses to comply with this requirement, he shall be liable for the crime of obstruction of

justice and the penalty of imprisonment of fifteen (15) years in jail shall be imposed upon the

accused without the possibility of parole.

(Continued to Article VIII)

Page 284: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

251

ARTICLE VIII

QUALIFICATION FOR

TRIAL JURY MEMBERSHIP

Section 1. Requirement for Trial Jury Membership:

(a) No person shall be chosen to serve as a juror in a trial jury unless such person is acitizen of the Philippines and resident of the congressional district in which he shall be chosen asa juror. He must be at least 21 years of age, possesses an average intelligence, high schoolgraduate or its equivalent of an informal education or training. In civil jury trial, the parties maystipulate to require that the educational qualification of the jurors be a college graduate consideringthe degree of complexity of the case and in such event, the jury fees to the jurors shall be doublethe rate of the minimum wage.

(b) No person shall be rejected to serve as a juror in trial jury on the basis of his ethnicity,creed, color, gender, marital or financial status in the community.

(c) A person who is obviously suffering from insanity, imbecility or mental incapacity shallnot be permitted to serve as a juror.

(d) Unless specifically disqualified in this law to serve as a juror, lack of any legaleducation or knowledge of law shall not excuse any citizen for disobedience to a summons for juryduty and shall be subject to contempt of court for refusing to serve his jury duty.

Section 2. No public official or any person serving in any government entity or branch ofgovernment service, office, or commission, police or armed services, or government ownedcorporation or quasi-government entity or a relative by blood or affinity within the first and seconddegree or household servant of such public official or person shall qualify as a juror in trial jury. Nolawyer or a person with comparable knowledge of law shall be seated in a trial jury and no suchlawyer shall be allowed to claim ignorance of this rule.

Section 3. No public official or any person shall have the right to demand upon a jury orany of its members for an explanation, written or verbally, from its verdict or judgment pursuant tothe concept that “a servant has no power to demand for any reason from the decision in good faithof his master.”

Section 4. No person who has been separated or retired from public service in thegovernment shall be seated as a juror in either juries until the lapse of twenty four (24) months fromthe date of his separation or retirement from public service.

Page 285: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

252

Section 5. No person who has been convicted in court for a crime involving moral turpitudeincluding any other crime punishable by imprisonment of one (1) year or more in jail shall be seatedas a juror.

Section 6. No person who is a datu, bai, or a sultan or a member of a royal clan or rulingfamily, or any person who claims to be a datu, bai, or sultan or member of such royal clan or rulingfamily shall qualify to serve as a juror in a trial jury.

Section 7. No citizen shall be served with summons for jury duty more than once eachyear regardless of whether such juror is seated or not in a jury trial.

Section 8. Regardless of whether the juror who reported for jury duty has been seated ornot in a jury trial, he shall be entitled a full day juror's fee.

Section 9. The rate of the trial juror's fee shall be equivalent to the minimum wage ofgovernment employees in the locality where the citizen shall be serving his jury duty.

(Continued to Article IX)

Page 286: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

253

ARTICLE IX

FUNDING THE JURY SYSTEM,SECURITY, AND RELATED MATTERS

Funding The Jury System

Section 1. Congress shall appropriate funds in such amount recommended by the National

Jury Management Authority for the operation of the jury system. The term “Government” or phrases

“responsibility of the government” or “shall be paid for by the government” shall refer to the Republic

of the Philippines, unless clearly used in a different context.

Section 2. Additional Funding for the Jury System-

(a) In addition to the appropriation of jury funds in the preceding Section 1 in this Article

IX, an amount equal to one-half of the combined total budget for the discretionary or intelligence

fund or any alias named fund of similar nature or any allowance of money for the president and the

total of all pork barrel funds or alias named fund of similar nature or allowance of money for all

members of the Senate and House of Representatives of the Philippine Congress, also known as

the Priority Development Assistance Fund, directly or indirectly by channelling the same through

other public officials or private entity or person, shall be budgeted for the operation of the National

Jury Law.

(b) Any allotment in the national general or special budget for an appropriation of funds

for discretionary spending by members of Congress or the President beyond the amount of their

regular salaries regardless of whatever name, title, or label attached to it in the law creating it,

temporarily or permanently, shall be deemed as a pork barrel fund for lawmakers or as a secret

presidential allowance.

(c) No such funds or moneys for the President or Members of Congress shall be released

by the Treasurer of the Philippines unless the funds in the preceding section and in this section for

the jury system shall have been similarly provided and simultaneously released to the jury funds in

the judiciary. For this purpose, the National Jury Management Authority shall create a Special

“Account” under its care in its financial records which shall be known as “The Jury Fund”. This

allocation of funds shall take effect immediately upon approval of this jury law and a readjustment

of the balance of the existing pork barrel funds and presidential allowance fund shall likewise be

made in such a way that one-third of the total of such funds shall be credited to the jury funds.

Page 287: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

254

(d) The Treasurer of the Philippines shall be personally and criminally liable for

malversation of public funds as defined in Article 217 of the Revised Penal Code of the Philippines

upon investigation and indictment by a Grand Jury for failure to simultaneously release the money

to the judiciary corresponding to the funds referred to in sub-paragraphs (a), (b), and (c) of this

section at the time he shall have released the money earmarked for presidential allowances and

congressional pork barrels to the members of congress.

(e) To facilitate and speed up in paying the compensation of citizens who shall serve in

the Grand Juries and Trial Juries, and other creditors who have a claim for services rendered relating

to the implementation or operation of the National Jury Law, a payment voucher device, an

accountable form, is hereby created which shall be known as the “Unconditional Non-Transferable

Redeemable Judicial Voucher”, and otherwise known as the Form GJ-27 under the control of the

National Treasurer of the Philippines. The National Treasurer shall distribute blank forms of said

form to the respective Clerk of Courts around the country, subject to unannounced audit by the

Commission On Audit representative around the country for use as a medium of payment of all

government obligation relating to the operation of the National Jury Law.

(f) Any bank or public treasury, National or Local, to whom Form GJ-27 is presented for

payment shall be obligated to pay the named payee, or his SIDN, is stated therein. Thereafter, such

bank or public treasury shall be entitled to seek reimbursement from the National Treasurer. The

National Treasurer shall thereupon submit to the Department of Budget and Management for the

final accounting of the funds so disbursed in accordance with Section 16, Article XI, of this Jury Law.

SECURITY MATTERS

Section 3. Paramount obligation of men in uniform to protect citizens on jury duty - Far

above their duty to protect public officials, the police and military officers in the armed forces of the

Philippines shall have the absolute duty to provide safety preference and protection to every citizen

who serves in the grand jury or in the trial jury from any physical injury or psychological harm or

death from any imminent peril.

Section 4. Police and military commanding officers who have jurisdiction of command over

the location of activity of a grand jury or trial jury shall have the mandatory personal obligation to

comply with this provision of the National Jury Law. Violation of, or negligence in complying with, this

rule shall subject a police or military officer for investigation and indictment by a grand jury for

Page 288: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

255

obstruction of justice or for neglect of duty.

Section 5. No person serving as a juror in the grand jury or trial jury shall be subject to a

civil lawsuit for acts relating to his jury duties and no such person shall be subject to arrest or

detention with or without cause, except for the commission of a grave offense, while reporting to and

from his jury duty appearance in court or grand jury office. Any arresting officer including his

instigator or mastermind whether public official or not in violation of this rule shall be liable for

indictment for obstruction of justice by the grand jury.

TRANSPORTATIONFOR JURORS

Section 6. Transportation assistance from vehicle drivers and operators in keeping

efficiency of justice and juror transportation entitlement -

(a) Any vehicle driver or operator shall share a citizenship burden in maintaining the

efficiency of the justice system whose services shall be paid via the Form GJ-27 payment system.

Upon serving a juror with summons for jury duty by the clerk of court or jury commissioner, he must

include with the summons a Juror's Rider Transport Ticket, known as the Form TJ-131. The juror

shall then present said ticket to the driver of the transport provider. The driver of the transport service

provider shall take said ticket and he shall present the same to the clerk of court from whom it

originated to ask for payment according to the terms of the ticket.

(b) Any vehicle driver or operator who shall unreasonably refuse to accept or ignore or

delay the request of the juror for a ride in his vehicle shall be subject to indirect contempt of court

with such punishment the presiding judge may impose upon complaint of the subject juror. If such

driver or operator shall purposely delay, or deviate from the proper route, in delivering the juror to

the general direction of his intended travel to the court, such driver or operator shall be liable for

indictment for obstruction of justice by a grand jury.

(c) For the foregoing purpose, the clerk of court shall issue a transportation ticket of Form

TJ-131 for his return trip home regardless of whether the juror has been seated in a jury trial or not.

If the juror is seated to serve on a jury trial for the following day, the clerk of court shall provide him

another rider's transport ticket to come to court the next day and also with the same ticket in going

back home.

Page 289: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

256

(d) A grand juror is likewise hereby entitled to a rider's transport ticket Form TJ-131 which

he shall secure from, and issued by the Clerk of Court to, him. The rider transport provider shall then

get paid via the use of Form GJ-27.

Section 7. No vehicle driver or operator shall announce by placard sign or in any other

manner that he is providing a courtesy ride for jurors for security reasons.

NOON TIME MEAL FOR JURORS

OF THE TRIAL JURY

Section 8. Trial Jurors’ Noon Time Meal - Jurors who come to court in obedience to their

summons for jury duty shall be entitled to have a noon time meal regardless of whether they are

seated or not on a case for jury trial.

Section 9. Responsibility of the Jury Commissioner or the Clerk of Court - It shall be the

duty of the Jury Commissioner or the Clerk of Court, as the case may be, to enter into a contract with

a food caterer to serve the meals for the jurors. A bidding shall be held for this purpose and the

bidder with the lowest price bid shall be awarded with said contract.

Section 10. Eatery Location - The food caterer shall deliver the food along with a clean

and empty trash can at exactly 12:15 PM and shall remove all food trashes therefrom at 12:45 PM

in two locations as follows:

(a) For jurors who are seated for a jury trial, the food caterer shall deliver their food at the

court jury deliberation room which will serve as their lunch room. At all times, said jurors or food

server shall be prohibited during their lunch time to discuss about the case they are trying or any

other court case. The court room clerk shall supervise the food delivery to the said jurors and they

should finish their meal at exactly 12:45 PM;

(b) For jurors who are not seated for a particular jury trial, the food caterer shall deliver

their food at the Jury Assembly Room which shall serve as their lunch room under the supervision

of the Clerk of Court or Jury Commissioner and they should finish their meal at 12:45 PM. At all

times, said jurors shall be prohibited from carrying on any private conversation therein and they shall

be required to devote their time in reading educational materials which the Clerk of Court or Jury

Commissioner shall provide. If, at 3:00 PM, no court room judge has ordered for jurors from said

clerk or commissioner for jury impaneling, said clerk or commissioner shall then issue to said jurors

Page 290: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

257

their Voucher Form-27 for their juror’s fee for the entire day and shall then discharge said jurors from

further jury service for twelve (12) months.

(c) Food Ticket Payment Redemption - The food caterer shall be entitled to the payment

of its services via the use of the Unconditional Non-Transferable Redeemable Judicial Voucher,

otherwise known as the “Voucher Form-27". As soon as the food caterer has accumulated a number

of food tickets with an aggregate value of at least fifty thousand pesos, or more, he shall then

present the said food tickets to the clerk of court from whom the food tickets originated in exchange

for Form-27 from the clerk of court. The food caterer shall, in turn, present said Form-27 to any

government cashier or treasurer or at any bank doing business in his locality for cashing.

NOON TIME MEAL FOR THE

MEMBERS OF THE GRAND JURY

Section 11. Noon Time Meal For the Members of the Grand Jury - The members of the

grand jury shall likewise be entitled to noon time meal at government expense and shall be paid out

of the jury funds of the National Jury Law.

Section 12. It shall be the duty of the Clerk of Court to enter into a contract with a food

caterer to serve the meals for the grand jurors. A bidding shall be held for this purpose and the

bidder with the lowest bid price shall be awarded with said contract.

Section 13. The grand jurors’ food shall be rationed and delivered to the Clerk of Court

with the aid of his deputy who shall, in turn, forward the food to the secret grand jury investigating

room which shall serve as their lunch room. Each grand juror shall sign with his grand juror’s Security

ID Code Number (SIDN).

Section 14. Form TJ-129 shall similarly be used for the food ticket for the members of the

Grand Jury which shall be paid via the Form GJ-27.

Page 291: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

258

ARTICLE X

TRIAL JURY TABLE OF FORMS AND PRINTABLE FORMS

TRIAL JURY TABLE OF FORMS(Also known as “Index of Forms”

Section 1. The following shall comprise the Table of the Trial Jury Forms and Indexed tothe Printable Forms in Section 2 of this Article X of the National Jury Law- FORM NAME DESCRIPTION PAGE NO.

Form TJ-101, Request for Names of Citizens for JuryService With Local Election Registrar . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 262

Form TJ-102(A), Pattern List of Citizens To Be Filled in by Local Election Registrar. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 263

Form TJ-102(B), Sample Pattern List of Names of Citizens . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 264

Form TJ-103, Summons for Jury Duty . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 265

Form TJ-104, Jurors’ Summons Logbook . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 267

Form TJ-105, Order to Show Cause for Disobedience to Jury Summons. . . . . . . 268

Form TJ-106, Jurors' Appearance Log Book . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 270

Form TJ-107, News Paper Advertisement Inviting Applicants for Pro Temp Jury Presiding Judge Pool . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 271

Form TJ-107A, Application to Participate in the Pool Pro Temp Jury Presiding Judge . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 272

Form TJ-107B, Notice to Applicant for Pro Temp jury Presiding Judge Accepting His Application With Requirement to Start Service within 3 Calendar Days of Receipt of Notice. . . . . . . . . . . 274

Form TJ-108, The Statutory Basic Jury Trial Instruction. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 275

Form TJ-109, Duty of Jury Commissioner or Clerk of Court to Incoming Jurors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 291

Page 292: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

259

Form TJ-109A, Information Questioner Sheet - For Jurors to fill up . . . . . . . . . . 293

Form TJ-110, Lead Trial Index Form . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 296

Form TJ-110A, Confidential In Chamber Conference Guide . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 297

Form TJ-110B, The Charge Sheet - For Submission to the Jury . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 298

Form TJ-110C, The “Law & Fact Sheet” Pattern - Not to be submitted to the Jury . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 299

Form TJ-110D-1, The Law & Fact Sheet, Case 1, Refer Back to . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 296

Form TJ-110D-2, The Law & Fact Sheet, Case 2, Refer Back to . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 296

Form TJ-110D-3, The Law & Fact Sheet, Case 3, Refer Back to . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 296

Form TJ-110D-4, The Law & Fact Sheet, Case 4, Refer Back to . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 296

Form TJ-111, Instruction in submitting Criminal Case to the jury For Deliberation and Decision. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 302

Form TJ-112, Jury Ballot (Master Form); Must be cut apart For Submission to the Jury . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 308

Form TJ-113, "Guilty" Verdict Form - For Submission to the Jury. . . . . . . . . . . . . 309

Form TJ-114, "Not Guilty" Verdict Form - For Submission to the Jury . . . . . . . . . 311

Form TJ-115, Summons Disobedience Register . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 312

Form TJ-116, Petition & Order for Contempt . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 313

Form TJ-117, Docket for Contempt Citation. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 316

Form TJ-118, Application For Execution of Warrant of Arrest . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 317

Form TJ-119, Arrest Warrant for Court Contempt . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 319

Form TJ-120, Record of Assigned Arrest Warrant . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 320

Form TJ-121, Resource Table for Criminal Jury Instruction. (Reserved for Development by the Supreme Court) . . . . . . . . . . . 321

Page 293: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

260

Form TJ-122, Instruction for Civil Jury Trial Proceedings. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 322

Form TJ-123, Submitting a Civil Case for Jury Deliberation and Decision.. . . . . . 335

Form TJ-124P, Plaintiff's Ballots. Plaintiff's duty to provide the jury . . . . . . . . . . . . 343

Form TJ-124D, Defendant's Ballots on Cross or Counter-Claim. Defendant's duty to provide the jury . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 344

Form TJ-125, Civil Jury Verdict Form. Presiding Judge's duty to provide the Jury . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 345

Form TJ-126, Resource Table for Civil Jury Instruction.(Reserved for Development by the Supreme Court) . . . . . . . . . . . 347

Form TJ-127, Plaintiff’s Bill of Particulars . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 348

Form TJ-128, Defendant’s Counter-Bill of Particulars. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 349

Form TJ-129, Noon Meal Ticket for Trial Juror . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 350

Form TJ-130, Noon Meal Ticket Log Book . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 351

Form TJ-131, Juror's Rider Transport Ticket. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 352

Form TJ-132, Jurors' Transport Ticket Log Book. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 353

Form TJ-133, Courtroom Jury Trial Seating Plan . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 354

Form TJ-134, Waiver of Banking Anti-Disclosure Rights. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 355

Form TJ-135, List of Exhibits in Criminal Cases . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 356

Form TJ-136, Delivery Envelope for Forms to the Jury (Size #10, 4.1 x 9.5 Inches.) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 357

Form TJ-137, Verdict Envelope (To contain the written Verdict of the Jury.) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 357

Form TJ-138, Large Envelope, Size: 9 x 12 inches. To contain all criminal files of the accused. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 358

Form TJ-139, List of Exhibits in Civil Cases . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 359

Page 294: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

261

Section 2. Trial Jury Printable Forms -

Find the page number of the printable forms in the foregoing Section 1, beginning on page261. Use the page reference above on the right column to locate the form.

Page 295: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

262

Form TJ-101, Request for Names of Citizens for Jury Service With Local Election Registrar

The ________________ Trial Court

______ Judicial District of _________________Street Address ____________________________________

Municipality/City/Province __________________________________Date today- ____________________

(Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type)

Attach the Pattern List on the back. Fold this letter into 3 equal parts and paste the needed mailing labels on outside fold, then staple, stamp and mail. No need for envelope.

The Election RegistrarStreet Address ____________________________________________Municipality/City/Province ____________________________________

Subject: Form TJ-101, Procurement Order of Names of Citizens To Serve in the Trial Jury

Greetings:

You are hereby required to serve this Court a list of all the names with voter registration numbers andaddresses of the citizens residing within the Judicial Jurisdiction of this court. The judicial jurisdiction of thiscourt is comprised by the [(_)-district (_)-barangays (_)-towns (_)-municipalities (_)-cities (_)-province of (ifthis space is insufficient, write names in a separate sheet) _____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Please type or print the information which shall be laid out similar to the patterns shown in the attached "FormTJ-102(A)&(B)" in a white 8-1/2 by 13 inch bond paper and each page list shall contain exactly 12 names.Upon receipt in this court of the sheets containing the names of citizens, the corresponding names will be cutapart to serve two purposes: the cut apart sheets of the names of citizens will be entered in a raffle bin inthis court. When drawn from the raffle bin, each cut apart piece of names shall then serve as mailing labelfor pasting on the summons sent to each citizen called for jury service in this court.

You are required to bring the accomplished document to this Court definitely no later than (date)_________________.

For the Presiding Judge of this Court, by:

(Printed Name)______________________________ (Signature)______________________________

(Title/Position) Jury Commissioner, Telephone #_________________ Faxphone # _________________

- End of Form -

Page 296: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

263

Form TJ-102(A), Pattern List of Citizens To Be Filled in by Local Election Registrar from Voters’ Listin his Congressional District No. ________________________________. No namein this list has been previously submitted to Court in the past 12 months.

Date Submitted- _________________

Submitted by: Print- ________________________ Sign _______________________ Election Registrar.

(The information must be centered similar to the sample “Form TJ-102(B) below)

End of Form

Page 297: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

264

Form TJ-102(B), Sample Pattern List of Names of Citizens - 12 Names must be written on a white 8-1/2" X 13" Bond Paper. List in the boxes below. After cut out apart, each piece

to serve as a mailing label of the summons to be served on the named citizen.

Juror Summons - Free Postage Mail FirstName M. LastName Voter # 987654321 Number and Name of Street Address Zip/Barrio/Muni/City/Prov

Juror Summons - Free Postage Mail FirstName M. LastName Voter # 987654321 Number and Name of Street Address Zip/Barrio/Muni/City/Prov

Juror Summons - Free Postage Mail FirstName M. LastName Voter # 987654321 Number and Name of Street Address Zip/Barrio/Muni/City/Prov

Juror Summons - Free Postage Mail FirstName M. LastName Voter # 987654321 Number and Name of Street Address Zip/Barrio/Muni/City/Prov

Juror Summons - Free Postage Mail FirstName M. LastName Voter # 987654321 Number and Name of Street Address Zip/Barrio/Muni/City/Prov

Juror Summons - Free Postage Mail FirstName M. LastName Voter # 987654321 Number and Name of Street Address Zip/Barrio/Muni/City/Prov

Juror Summons - Free Postage Mail FirstName M. LastName Voter # 987654321 Number and Name of Street Address Zip/Barrio/Muni/City/Prov

Juror Summons - Free Postage Mail FirstName M. LastName Voter # 987654321 Number and Name of Street Address Zip/Barrio/Muni/City/Prov

Juror Summons - Free Postage Mail FirstName M. LastName Voter # 987654321 Number and Name of Street Address Zip/Barrio/Muni/City/Prov

Juror Summons - Free Postage Mail FirstName M. LastName Voter # 987654321 Number and Name of Street Address Zip/Barrio/Muni/City/Prov

Juror Summons - Free Postage Mail FirstName M. LastName Voter # 987654321 Number and Name of Street Address Zip/Barrio/Muni/City/Prov

Juror Summons - Free Postage Mail FirstName M. LastName Voter # 987654321 Number and Name of Street Address Zip/Barrio/Muni/City/Prov

End of Form

Page 298: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

265

Form TJ-103, Summons for Jury Duty.

Important: Any person who shall prevent or discourage you in any manner from serving as a juror, orany citizen when qualified disobeys his summons to serve, for jury trial, he shall be liable for the crimeof obstruction of justice. You must Report such person to the Grand Jury for investigation andindictment for the crime of Obstruction of Justice.

Republic of the Philippines______________ COURT OF __________

Branch _________Street Address __________________________________

Mun/City/Prov Address ______________________________________(Telephone Number - ____________________)

SUMMONS FOR JURY DUTYThis summons must be translated into the local dialect of the jurors.

(Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type)

Staple both pages together and fold this letter into 3 equal parts. Paste the mailing labelson outside fold, then staple and mail. No need for envelope or stamp. Attach but do not staple 2

(round trip tickets of Form TJ-131. Check amount of prevailing fare with Transport Providers.

TO THE REGISTERED VOTER WHOSE NAME APPEARS ON THE MAILING LABEL ON THE OPPOSITE SIDE OF THIS SUMMONS:

Number ____________GREETINGS: (Obtain # from Form TJ-104)

This Court and by its Summons, you are commanded to appear on the date, time, and place, shown belowand be ready when called by the court to fulfill your civic duty to serve as a juror and render justice in a jurytrial of a case in said court. You are not allowed to have anybody accompany you. This is a whole day duty.You will be given a free noon time meal regardless of whether you will be seated or not in a jury trial.Enclosed is your round trip ticket, Form TJ-131. Submit the proper ticket for each route, There is no excusefor being late, even for one (1) minute or else you can be held in contempt of court for a violation of thisinstruction.

Date: ___________________________ Time: Exactly 8:00 o'clock in the Morning

Place: The Jury Assembly Room and Report to:

(_)-Mr.(_)-Mrs.(_)-Ms. _________________________________________________________ Building: ___________________________________________________________________ Address: __________________________________________________________________ THIS IS AN IMPORTANT DOCUMENT. Bring this summons for presentation when you report to the person named above.Without this summons you will not be seated as a juror and you may find great difficulty getting paid of your jury fee for comingto court. YOU DO NOT NEED TO KNOW ANY LAW IN ORDER FOR YOU TO COMPLY WITH YOUR JURY DUTY. You

will be instructed on the law of a case and interpreted into your local dialect so that you will understandwhat the law is. This summons shall be entered in Raffle Bin "B" after you sign in the Juror Registry Bookupon appearing in the Jury Assembly Room or JAR. You may wear a pair of dark eye glasses to hide youridentity while serving in a jury trial and you must not reveal your name to a fellow juror or anybody exceptto the Jury Commissioner or Clerk.

You are entitled to collect a jury fee at the rate of the minimum wage per day of a government employeein the locality where you will serve as a juror for your appearance at the place and the date you sign in theSummons Registry Book. If you are not seated as a juror on the day you reported for jury duty, you will bepaid for one day you appeared and you will not be called again until after 12 months from the date of thissummons. If you are seated as a juror, you will collect jury fee for each day you serve at the trial. Alwaysask permission from the Jury Commissioner or Clerk of Court before leaving the court. If you leave the courtwithout permission, you will not be paid with your jury fee.

Page 299: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

266

FAIL NOT UNDER PENALTY OF LAW. Your failure to appear as commanded above, will subject you forcontempt of court citation with an order to render community service for two days without pay, unless youare exempted or disqualified to serve as a juror. The issue date of this Summons is _____/_____/_____(write Month/Date/Year).

__________________________________ _________________________________(Printed Name of jury commissioner) (Signature of jury commissioner)

IMPORTANT: Your lack of education in law is not a v alid excuse to disobey this Summons For JuryDuty. DISQUALIFICATION AND EXEMPTIONS : You will not be required to report for jury duty, IF youadmit or profess and check any of the brackets as follow: "I am disqualified or exempt from jury dutybecause: [_]-I am not a citizen of the Philippines; [_]-I am below 21 years of age;[_]-I have beenconvicted in a court of law of a criminal offense; [_]-I cannot read, understand, or speak thelanguage of the community within the geographic jurisdiction of the court where I am being calledto serve as a juror; [_]-I have taken drug or alcoholic substance in the past 5 days; [_]-I have beenserving, or have served, in the Grand Jury within the last 12 months; [_]-I hold a public orquasi-public office or I am a member of the military or police organization or deputy civil militia ofsuch military or police organizations or I am an immediate member of the family of such person;[_]-I have served as a trial juror within the last 12 months; [_]-I am actually serving as an employeeor official, elected, appointed, or I am acting as a special or secret deputy or agent or body guardof such employee or official, of a municipal, city, provincial, regional autonomous, or nationalgovernment; [_]-I am not a registered voter of the municipality or city or judicial district over whichthe court has jurisdiction; [_]-I am a person who is declared, or obviously known, as mentallyincompetent; [_]-I am an attorney at law or member of the Integrated Bar of the Philippines. [_]-Iam not a graduate from high school and I do not possess a certificate equivalent to a high schooldiploma; and [_]-I am a woman in my eighth to ninth month of pregnancy or I am a mother of anine-year old child or less under my personal care.

I DECLARE UNDER PENALTY OF PERJURY that the bracket I have marked describing my

personal status is true and correct this ______ day of the month of ________________ and year

____________ in the City or Municipality of _____________ Province of ________________."

Sign and mail back to this court this summons. (NOTE: If you are qualified to serve for jury duty,

bring this summons PERSONALLY with you and report to court as directed and sign it only in the

presence of the Jury Commissioner or Clerk.)

(Your signature)- (X)_____________________________

(Printed Name) _________________________________ Voter ID #________________

- End of Form -

Page 300: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

267

Form TJ-104, Jurors’ Summons Logbook.

__________________ TRIAL COURT OF __________________Street Address ________________________________________Municipality/City/Province________________________________

Page _________ JURORS SUMMONS LOGBOOK (JAL) (Perpetual Numbering) (Paper Size: 8-1/2 by 13" - Temporarily Keep in a 3-Ring Binder - Book bind upon reaching 2-inches thick)

IMPORTANT: A citizen who fails to appear shall be issued an Order to Show Cause (OSC) the next day after his failedAppearance Date shall be conclusive proof that a summons has been properly served.

Summons #For FormTJ-103

Date ofIssue of

Summons

Name of Citizento whom

Summons was Issued

Voter IDRegistration

Number

Date ofScheduled

Appearance

(Check Mark)APPEARED?

YES NO

Address

Mun/City/Province

Address

Mun/City/Province

Address

Mun/City/Province

Address

Mun/City/Province

Address

Mun/City/Province

Address

Mun/City/Province

Address

Mun/City/Province

- End of Form -

Page 301: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

268

Form TJ105, Order to Show Cause for Failure to Appear for Jury Duty

Republic of the Philippines__________ TRIAL COURT OF _____________

Street Address ________________________________________________________

Mun/City/Provincial Address _____________________________________________

(Telephone Number _______________________)

From: THE PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES

To: _______________________ Address: _____________________________________________

________________________________________________________________________________

ORDER TO SHOW CAUSEOSC Number _____________

(Obtain Number from Form TJ-115) GREETINGS:

YOU ARE HEREBY COMMANDED to appear before this Court on or before (date) _____________

at 8:30 o'clock in the morning at (location/address) __________________________________________

__________________________________________________________________________________

TO SHOW CAUSE why you should not be held in contempt of court for FAILURE TO APPEAR FOR JURYDUTY on the Summons Number ____________ issued on (date) ________________ for which you werescheduled to appear before this Court last (date) ________________ at 8:00 o'clock in the morning.

Should you ignore and fail to appear to show cause in this Order, this Court will find no recourse. This Courtshall cite you for contempt of court with issuance of an order for your arrest.

FAIL NOT under penalty of law. Such penalty shall be in the form of community service for two (2) dayswithout pay and under such other terms this Court will deem proper.

ISSUED at (place) _______________________________ on (date) _________________________.

Signature _____________________________ Print Name _____________________________

Title Presiding Judge

PROOF OF SERVICE BY MAIL(On the Next Page)

Book entry on Form TJ- 115Verified by: __________________(Judge shall not sign, if not verified.)

Page 302: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

269

PROOF OF SERVICE BY MAIL The undersigned, Jury Commissioner, hereby certifies that, on the date of this certification, he served the

foregoing ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE by placing a true copy thereof enclosed in a sealed envelope with

postage prepaid, addressed to the party to this case named below and deposited the same in the Postal

Mail Box at the nearest Post Office to this Court.

Name of Citizen - __________________________ Voter ID Number ___________________

Number and name of street address _____________________________________________

Barrio/Mun/City/Prov address __________________________________________________

I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing information is true and correct.

Issued at (place) _____________________________________ on (date) ___________________.

Signature - ____________________________________

Print Name- ____________________________________

Title Jury Commissioner

- End of Form -

Page 303: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

270

Form TJ-106, Jurors' Appearance Log Book

_____________ TRIAL COURT OF __________________Street Address ___________________________________Municipality/City/Province___________________________

Page __________ (Continuous Numbering)

JURORS' APPEARANCE LOG BOOK(Paper Size: 8-1/2 by 11" - Temporarily Keep in a 3-Ring Binder - Book bind upon reaching 2-inch thickness)

Trial Jury Commissioner shall strictly monitor this Record

Date Today :_____/____/____

Notice To Jurors: READ THIS INSTRUCTION and follow the sequence below. Also, this Instruction must be posted at the entrance door to the Jury Assembly Room:

Number 1: Upon arrival enter your information in the JURORS' APPEARANCE LOG BOOK below;Number 2: MEMORIZE, Write and REMEMBER your Summons Number; then Number 3: Submit your summons to the Jury Commissioner or Clerk of Court;Number 4: The Jury Commissioner shall drop your Summons in his Raffle Bin "B";Number 5: Be seated, keep quiet, no talking and wait for instruction from the Jury Commissioner.

Enter YourArrival Time

Print Your NameIn This Column

Sign Your NameIn This Column

Write YourSummons #

ICNAsk

Clerk

- End of Form -

Page 304: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

271

Form TJ-107, News Paper Advertisement Inviting Applicants for Pro Temp Jury Presiding Judge.

THE REGIONAL TRIAL COURT

______ Jury (Legislative) District of _________________

Street Address ___________________________________________

Municipality/City/Province __________________________________

Date today- ____________________

(Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type)

GREETINGS:

The members of the Integrated Bar of the Philippines in good standing who have been

engaged in the private practice of law for three (3) years or more within the ______________

Judicial Court District of _________________________________ are hereby invited to participate

in the Pool for Pro Temp Jury Presiding Judges. A participant in this pool may be called upon on

a random basis to serve as a Jury Presiding Judge who shall willingly promise and be ready within

seventy-two (72) hours, including Saturday, Sunday and Holiday, upon receiving his call, to sit as

a presiding judge in a jury trial for criminal cases in the event of unavailability or sudden incapacity

of a regular presiding judge.

A Pro Temp Jury Presiding Judge shall be compensated on a per diem basis starting with

one (1) non-trial day per diem to prepare for trial

The qualification and terms of participation in the Pool are written in the durable official

application form on Form TJ-107A as prescribed in Article X, Section 2, of the National Jury Law.

The application form is available in the Office of the Clerk of this Court. The form shall not be

substituted with any personally devised form.

This advertisement has been issued upon the order of the Executive Judge of this Court.

Issuance Date ____/____/____ Signature ___________________________

Printed Name ________________________

The Clerk of Court

- End of Form -

Page 305: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

272

Form TJ-107A, Application to Participate in the Poolfor Pro Temp Jury Presiding Judge .

(Print Name) ___________________________________

Attorney at Law - Bar Number _____________

Street Address ____________________________________

Zip/Mun/City/Province _______________________________________

Office Telephone _________________ Fax __________________ Email

__________________

Date today __________________

INSTRUCTION: 1. Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. Noneed to type; 2. Read carefully as you will be strictly bound by its terms and attach to it therequired accomplished forms as called for and personally submit the same with the Clerk ofCourt. 3. After review by the Clerk of Court, staple together the entire batch and fold the sameinward into 3 equal parts. Staple the folded application at the center of the upper edge and dropit in the raffle bin in the Office of the Clerk of Court; 4. This application shall be void if alteredin any manner.

The Honorable Executive Judge

[_]-Regional [_]-Metropolitan [_]-Sharia [_]-City [_]-Municipal, Trial Court of ________________

The _______ Jury (Legislative) District of _________________________________________

Address ___________________________________________________________________

___________________________________________________________________

GREETINGS:

I wish to apply and participate in the Pool for Pro Temp Presiding Judge in this Jury District andI respectfully request that my application be entered in the Raffle Bin Pool in the office of theclerk of court for the participants in the Pool.

A: I CERTIFY that:

1. I am a bonafide member of the Philippine Bar. My Bar Number is ____________.

2. I have been engaged in the private practice of law for over three (3) years. I haveactually practiced law for _____ years.

3. As of the date of the filing of my application, I certify that I have completely devoteda total of at least 24 hours of self-study of the National Jury Law. I have read and I amthoroughly familiar both with the Statutory Grand Jury Instruction in Section 24 and Form GJ-41of Section 99 in Article III, and the Statutory Basic Trial Jury Instruction on Form TJ-108 inSection 2, Article X of the National Jury Law. I have actually accomplished a “dry run”preparation in my own handwriting with the following forms by assuming the roles of those whoare concerned in preparing or filling up those forms, most particularly the following: Form TJ-

Page 306: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

273

103, Form TJ-109, Form TJ-109A, Forms TJ-110A-B-C-D, Form TJ-111, Form TJ-112, FormTJ-113, Form TJ-114, Form TJ-135, Form TJ-136, Form TJ-137 and Form TJ-138. I furtherstate that I am expertly cognizant of the rudiments in the impaneling of a trial jury and theperemptory challenges of jurors.

B: I PROMISE and WILFULLY AGREE that:

1. I shall serve as a Pro Temp Jury Presiding Judge within 3 Calendar days, Saturday,Sunday and Holiday included, from my receipt of an assignment notice within the jury districtin which the Trial Court is located;

2 I shall accept compensation on per diem basis starting with one non-trial day per diemto prepare for trial under the Unconditional Redeemable Judicial Voucher prescribed on FormGJ-27, at the rate of pay equivalent to the computed hourly compensation of the last appointedregular presiding judge of the province, city or municipality where I shall serve.

3. The assignment notice served upon me on a particular case shall be subject to arandom drawing with five (5) competing participants in the Pool of the Pro Temp Jury PresidingJudge from the raffle bin.

4. Should I accept the assignment and another or more drawn participants likewisesignify his or their willingness to accept the assignment, our names will be raffled further fromamong us and whoever whose name is picked on the first pull and who is present at the raffledrawing shall get the assignment to serve.

5. If my application and/or name is drawn and I fail to get an assignment on a case asoriginally set for trial, I shall be available for assignment on another case set for trial the sameday, and if I am not given an immediate assignment, my application shall be automaticallyredeposited into the raffle bin pool for my availability to serve in another case set by this courtin the future.

Very truly yours,

Signature _____________________________ Attorney at Law

NOTE: The next following form, Form TJ-107B, with court heading pre-filled by Applicant toguide the court branch where the Applicant wishes to serve, except the other information calledfor to be left in blank, should be attached to this Application, Form TJ-107A, when depositingthe same in the Raffle Bin in the Office of the Clerk of Court of this Judicial District.

Page 307: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

274

Form TJ-107B, Notice of Acceptance of, with Order for Assignment to Serve As, Pro Temp Jury Presiding Judge within 3 Calendar Days from receipt of this Notice.

INSTRUCTION TO THE CLERK OF COURT : Send a photocopy of the Notice Form below to theParticipant in the Pool for Pro Temp Jury Presiding Judge not later than three (3) calendar days by faxAND by email transmission before the Trial Date stated in this Notice. Fill in by hand print with theinformation called for therein and promptly transmit to the named pool participants.

The Regional Trial Court of _______________________

_______ Jury (Legislative) District of __________________________

Address _________________________________________________

________________________________________________________

Telephone: _______________ Fax: _______________

(Note: The above heading blanks should be pre-filled in by Applicant in submitting his Application)

Dear Participant in the Pool for Pro Temp Jury Presiding Judge:

You are one of the five (5) participants in the Pro Temp Jury Presiding Judge Pool whose name is randomly drawn

from the Raffle Bin Pool for assignment to preside in the jury trial of the accused in the criminal case identified below;

Name of Crime: ______________ Case Number ____________ Name of Accused _________________________

______________ Trial Court of ________________ Branch _____________ Telephone __________________

For further details Contact (Name) ____________________________________ Telephone __________________

in the Office of the Undersigned. Trial Date: _____|_____|_________________ Starting time: 8:30 A.M.

If two or more of you will appear to signify to accept the assignment to preside in the jury trial of this case, a lottery

shall be conducted to finally choose one (1) from among those of you who appears at (time) __________ ____.M.

on (date) ___________________ in the Office of the Undersigned located at _________________________

_________________________________________________________________________________________.

I CERTIFY under penalty of perjury at (mun/city) _____________________ that on this date __________

_____________, I have transmitted to the attorneys named below a copy of this notice to their respective fax number

AND by email attachment on (date) _____________________ at approximately _____________ o’clock ____ M.

[_]- Atty. _____________________ Fax No. _____________________ Email _________________________

[_]- Atty. _____________________ Fax No. _____________________ Email _________________________

[_]- Atty. _____________________ Fax No. _____________________ Email _________________________

[_]- Atty. _____________________ Fax No. _____________________ Email _________________________

[_]- Atty. _____________________ Fax No. _____________________ Email _________________________

NOTE: If "Atty. Box" is unmarked, it is presumed that "no notice" was sent to such attorney addressee unless the

attorney calls in to acknowledge receipt of the letter and signifies his willingness to preside the jury trial.

Very truly yours,

Signature _______________________Printed Name __________________ ____, Clerk of Court

- End of Form -

Page 308: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

275

Form TJ-108, The Statutory Basic Jury Trial Instruction.

(This instruction must be contemporaneously interpreted during the jury trial by a trained

court trial interpreter from English to the local dialect of the jurors, and vice versa. The Jury

Presiding Judge is mandatorily required to issue this instruction without deviation. A presiding

judge who shall deviate from this instruction to favor any party or person shall be liable for

indictment of the crime of Obstruction of Justice by a Grand Jury upon complaint by the

aggrieved party.)

"Ladies and Gentlemen of the Jury:

Pursuant to Article II, Section 1, of the Philippine Constitution, you have been randomly

chosen to sit and serve in this jury to solemnly exercise your sovereign power, the same people’s

power you used when you elect your public officials, in our government to give and serve justice

for our community. We welcome and thank you for waiting patiently and for your eagerness to

serve in this jury. The case you are about to hear is a Criminal matter wherein the People is the

accusing party against the crime suspect called the Accused who is alleged to have committed

a serious crime.

First of all, there are:

Benefits For Serving in the Jury

Please know that you will be compensated for your jury service. For each day of your

service, you will be paid with the prevailing minimum wage set by law. In addition, you will

likewise be entitled to a noon time meal.

You will take your meal at the Jury Room in this courtroom where your food will be

delivered by the food server. Inform the Clerk of Court the kind of food that you cannot take

because of your religious belief. My clerk of court will guide you in going to that room. You will

not be allowed to bring in your cell phone into that room. You must deposit your cell phone with

my clerk, wrap it in an envelope, and make sure to label it with proper identification. You must

finish taking your meal within 30 minutes between 12:15 PM to 12:45 PM. Jury service requires

promptness at all times.

During your meal time, you and my clerk of court, or among yourselves, must not talk

about the case at hand or any law about any legal matter. You cannot talk to any other person

except among yourselves only on some social matters or to my clerk for any question but not

Page 309: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

276

relating to the case you are hearing about. If you have an urgent call, you must seek permission

from my clerk of court who will supervise you during your meal.

"In your trip in coming to and from this court, your fare will be paid by our government. For

this purpose, you will be given a transportation ticket which you will obtain from the clerk of this

court and you will, in turn, present it to the operator, or driver, of the vehicle who shall provide

you with transportation.

And now, here is your:

Instruction for the Jury Trial

In order to achieve your mission, you are required to strictly observe and obey the

following Jury Trial Instruction.

For your personal and family protection or safety and to keep absolute fairness and

integrity in our jury trial proceedings, I hereby instruct you which you must obey as follows:

(1) To carefully listen, remain absolutely silent, and follow my instructions. You are

required to wear a pair of goggle dark eyeglasses during your jury service to minimize

exposure of your identity to the public. Your most difficult job is to avoid talking about this

case with anybody else, not even with your fellow jurors, or members of your family, until I

order you to do so only in your private jury discussion room. To avoid problems to yourself as

a juror, you must absolutely never talk about this case or any legal matter at all until your

decision in this case has been read in this court.

(2) (a) You must remain seated throughout the proceedings in court except when I, or

the sheriff on duty, ask you to stand. You must avoid informing anyone outside this

courtroom that you are a juror in this case. From this moment on, you shall have the right to

refuse to disclose or reveal your name to anyone in this court room and you shall not disclose

your name to your fellow jurors. At all times, you must wear your dark goggles to protect your

identity.

(b) If you are employed with a private employer or company, you likewise have the

right to refuse to disclose or reveal the name or description of your employer.

(c) However, if you are employed in any department of the government, government

instrumentality, local government unit, or armed or police services, or government owned or

Page 310: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

277

controlled or quasi-government corporation, or as a body guard of a government official even

if you are a private citizen, you are required to disclose or reveal the name of the government

entity you are employed with or the name of your supervisor or the public official for whom

you are serving or acting as his body guard.

(3) Each and all of you must be present in this court from the beginning to the end of this

jury trial-

(a) It is absolutely important that you arrive on time when each further proceedings begins

from your recess or continuance of the proceedings from the previous day.

(b) You must bear in mind that this jury cannot proceed to perform its job in the absence

of any one of you. The presence of each of you is as important as the presence of both the

attorneys in this case.

(c) Merely calling in that you are sick is not an acceptable excuse. If you are truly seriously

sick, you must ask your doctor to appear before this court to explain in your behalf the

seriousness of your illness. This instruction likewise applies absolutely with the alternate jurors.

(d) This proceeding is not like an ordinary meeting where a quorum is enough to proceed

with the majority of its members present. Do not think that because a majority of your fellow

jurors is present, you can leisurely spend your sweet time with someone or something outside.

It is imperative that each word or statement said in this proceeding must be heard by each and

all of you at the same time.

(e) I must emphasize that the trial cannot proceed if one of you is not seated. You cannot

simply go away from this proceeding just because you do not like to hear what is being said by

anyone in this court. You must be warned that this court will not hesitate to order your instant

imprisonment in jail for direct contempt of court if you violate this instruction.

(4) You must dress up with ordinary attire without fanciness to avoid distracting attention

in the proceedings.

(5) You must not discuss or talk about this case privately among yourselves as jurors.

Yes, that is right. You are not allowed to talk with your fellow jurors about this case, anytime,

anywhere, or by telephone or email until I permit you to do so in your private jury room. If you

know of any of your fellow jurors speak or attempt to speak anything about this case, it is your

duty to report such juror to me, your presiding judge, through the sheriff. Do not speak to me

directly. Talk to the sheriff and he will tell me your report. You are likewise strictly prohibited to

Page 311: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

278

discuss with your family members even if he is a lawyer, or friends about the evidence,

witnesses, or any aspect of this case. Lawyers are admonished that they should never speak

to a juror and it is a violation of the jury system rules for which he can face a disciplinary action

before the Supreme Court.

(6) Alternatively, if you have personally observed your co-juror or anyone in this court of

having violated any of the jury instructions I have read or issued to you, you must confidentially

report without seeking permission from me for such violation to the Grand Jury for its secret

investigation by placing your report at the "Citizens' Secret Crime Reports Drop Box" somewhere

in the hallway of this court, or of the clerk of court of the Executive Judge, of this Jury District.

(7) It is equally important that you avoid calling on a cell phone with anyone about this

case. Regarding any matter, this case or any other thing whatsoever, you must absolutely, with

no exception, and as a reminder again, avoid speaking, or consulting, with any lawyer,

government official, police, army or military personnel, officer, or co-employee or supervisor or

employer, or to any person whomsoever. You must not write any article or letter, or

communication, or email in the Internet about this case. This means that you must not start a

gossip about anything while this case is still going on for trial.

(8) Bear in mind that if anyone hears you talk about this matter, you could start a gossip

without knowing it and you may find yourself unexpectedly inviting at your doorsteps a crowd of

media people, the interested parties and their relatives or friends in this case and all other

investigators that may even prevent or delay you in coming back to this trial. With your

negligence in mentioning about this case with anybody, the case that you are working on could

end up in a mistrial for which you will be held in contempt of court and promptly I will order your

imprisonment and further be responsible to pay the expenses of the parties and jurors fees in this

case.

(9) You will be given the opportunity to hear and see the evidence of both the parties to

the case at hand. You will be required to listen to the testimony of witnesses and you must keep

close attention to every word the witness says. You must also watch the demeanor of the

witness such as his facial expression, eye movement, and body language to determine the

truthfulness of his statement. Sometime later, I will explain to you what is an evidence and what

is not evidence. A natural human reaction or statement resulting from a sudden or surprising

event can be considered an evidence.

(10) After you have seen and heard the evidence in this case, you will then be ordered

to go and enter in the secret jury room to talk and discuss among yourselves alone and to make

your decision. Once all of you have gathered in that room, you must lock yourself in at all times

Page 312: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

279

to prevent anyone from disturbing you until you have finally decided the case. Once you have

reached your decision, you must knock at your door to indicate to the sheriff that you have

already done your work but you must not tell the sheriff which way you decide or shall decide.

Did you understand what I said? Repeat: You must never tell the sheriff, or anybody else, which

way you decide or shall decide the case.

(11) While you are still inside that jury room, I will order the Sheriff to guard your door.

I will also order the opposing attorneys as well as the members of the media to keep an eye to

ensure that no one else can contact or disturb you inside.

(12) Before you enter the deliberation room, I will require you to deposit your cell phones

and tape recorders with my clerk of court. Make sure you mark your cell phones with appropriate

identification. Request and ask my clerk for a plain envelope, label it with your name and wrap

in it your cell phone and then entrust it to my clerk or secretary. Your cell phones shall then be

returned to you after your foreman shall have read your decision in this court room. If any of your

fellow jurors shall surreptitiously bring in a cell phone in the jury room, each and any of you shall

have the responsibility to report such matter to this court through the sheriff or you may drop your

report at the “drop box” which you may find in the hall way of this court.

(13) Should you violate any of my instructions, I will hold you liable for payment of the

expenses of this proceedings and declare you in contempt of court for which I will order your

instant imprisonment in jail for the duration of this trial until it is finally decided by another jury.

I will further order non-payment of your jury attendance or allowance fee;

(14) If you are unable to hear or see the evidence presented during the trial, it is your duty

to inform me, through the sheriff, not with anybody else, so that appropriate arrangements can

be made for you. If anyone of you may notice a fellow juror immediate to your side who may be

getting sleepy or bored, you must do a little shaking by your elbow to wake him or her up but do

not overdo it. I will not tolerate any teasing or horseplay while the trial is going on. I am

addressing this particular instruction to counsels likewise. If you think your presiding judge is also

getting sleepy or bored, you may move for a five-to-ten-minute break to stretch up for all of us

and I would be glad to grant your motion.

(15) You must not take notes or draw pictures, diagrams or other memoranda to remind

you of the facts, and you must rely entirely upon your memory. The purpose of this rule is to

avoid over-emphasizing some facts and de-emphasizing others. You should not worry in

forgetting what you have heard from the witness because you will eventually recall their

statements, or through the exhibits presented during the giving of the testimony of witnesses,

once you go into the deliberation room as you embark in discussing the various events as

Page 313: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

280

narrated by the witnesses.

(16) You must not pay attention to news accounts of the trial or gossips, whether they be

on radio or television or in the newspaper or in the Internet or other publications. You must not

comment on anything you have seen on television or heard over the radio or from any person

about this case. You must not purposely watch on television or hear over the radio any news

about this case. You must not search the Internet for evidence or news reports about this case.

Sometime later, I will instruct you about what is an evidence and what is not.

(17) You are not allowed to inspect or take pictures of the scene of the crime which is the

subject of the trial. This is important because the place where the incident occurred may be

entirely changed from what it was at the time of the occurrence. You are not allowed make a

tape recording during the trial or during your discussion or deliberation in the jury room.

(18) In some rare cases, you may be kept away from your home continuously during the

trial. You may be allowed to go home at night, but you cannot discuss the case with anyone, and

again, not even with a member of your family, even if he is a lawyer. Remember, that you are

not allowed to speak with any attorney or a judge or public official or employee about this case.

(19) While this jury trial is still in progress, you must not make or express your opinion or

decision. You must remain neutral at all times. It is only in your assigned jury room where you

will be able to talk about this case independently among yourselves and absolutely without

interference or presence on my part or of any other person. In your deliberation, get more

reminders for information from your fellow jurors. Do not impose your will on them. If they ask

your opinion, inform them with all honesty and or simply state your reason for your opinion. The

first and the last time you make your decision is when you secretly and actually write your vote

in your jury ballot.

(20) You must remove from your minds or vocabulary any law you have learned or heard

in school or from anywhere in the past or from any law school. You must not discuss among your

fellow jurors about those laws. You must not read a law book or news story about the case at

hand. You must not consult a dictionary or encyclopaedia. If you have previously served as a

juror, whether as a member of a grand jury or trial jury, you must not mention or remember any

law or legal instruction you have learned from such prior jury duty during your deliberation to

arrive at your verdict regardless of whether such law or legal instruction is similar or identical in

the present case. Your prior education in law, officially or unofficially, is not a requirement in order

for you to sit as a juror in the present case. The only law or laws you shall keep in your minds is,

or are, the laws I instruct you in the course of this trial. You must submit through the sheriff a

written note to me to ask for the definition of a word if it is essential in making your decision. I

Page 314: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

281

will make a proper response to you with the agreement of the counsels of both parties to this

case.

(21) During our court recess, or at any time, you must not talk to me, your presiding judge.

Make sure you come back to this room without a minute of being late. You must all be in the door

and be ready to get in when told to come in. I instruct the Sheriff to prevent anybody or non-jury

member to mingle with you during your recess or when getting ready to come back to this court

room.

(22) You must not enter the deliberation room until I order you to do so. I will give you the

proper instruction at a proper time after we are done with certain court procedures;

(23) You are absolutely prohibited from asking money or favor of any kind or in accepting

a bribe from any body on account of your having been called to serve as a juror in this case

currently or in the future on account of the information you had discussed during your deliberation

about this case;

(24) You must not consider any other evidence except those presented at the trial in this

court room. In other words, you must not give probative value on anything you have seen or

heard from any source or person outside this court room about this case.

(25) When you have been ordered to gather in your jury deliberation room at the proper

time, you must not allow anyone - not even me, your presiding judge - to enter your deliberation

room. Your deliberation room is your exclusive territory and domain. At any moment, while you

are discussing about the case at hand, I may knock at your door. In that event, you must politely

decline to speak with me or with anyone else for that matter otherwise I will declare you in

violation of this instruction.

(26) When you need for a clarification on any matter that prevents you to proceed with

your discussion or judgment, you must submit a hand written note through the sheriff in uniform

and on duty in this court to me, your presiding judge, and write what you may ask. I will

accordingly make a ruling or response to your query in consultation or conference with the

prosecuting attorney and the defense attorney in this case.

(27) I cannot order you which way you will decide this matter but I have the summary

authority to order the sheriff in uniform at this court room to send to jail for contempt of court any

juror who violates the legal instructions that I have just read and issued to you. If in the course

of my talks to you that may sound as if I am making my opinion about the case, you must not

take that as a guide in arriving at your decision or in expressing your opinion. You must decide

Page 315: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

282

on what is right from your own independent conclusion.

(28) The evidence presented at the trial may consist of documents, things, or objects and

testimony of the witnesses. If a question is objected to and I sustain or uphold the objection, you

must disregard any answer to such question as if it has not been stated. The opening and closing

statements, and the arguments of the lawyers do not constitute as evidence because they are

not witnesses.

(29) You must consider the accused your co-equal or a common person. You must not

give any special importance or significance to the fact that [the accused] [or any party] may be,

or is claiming to be, a celebrity actor or actress, or a person with great fame, or title of nobility,

or for being a datu, bai, sultan or sultana, or wealth, or high rank or title or position or power in

any government or government instrumentality in our society or a relative, or the spouse, or a

compadre, a comadre, a querida or querido, or close friend of such person. While being seated

as a juror in this matter, your authority to decide justice in this case based on facts according to

the evidence is absolute and more superior than any such person of nobility, royalty, great fame,

or public official, in our society. Keep this in mind at all times until you finally decide this case that

you are acting as a Master of our society while serving as a juror in this matter today.

(30) You shall not take into evidence any description of the accused or of a witness in

reference to his being a Christian, a Muslim, or with any religious affiliation, or creed, or ethnicity,

or tribal feature, or regional lingual accent, in the course of this trial or during your jury discussion.

(31) After this instruction that I am now issuing to you, you will soon hear the

presentation of the evidence in this case. There are two opposing parties in this trial. The

accuser and the accused.

(32) The people are the accuser and they are represented by the government

attorney. He is called the Prosecutor. The People or Prosecutor may be referred to as the

"Prosecution."

(33) The accused is the suspected crime offender. He is defended by his defense

attorney. The Accused and the defense attorney may be referred to as the "Defense."

(34) At this point, I want you to learn about the word "Witness." A "witness" is the

person who is sworn to testify to tell the truth about the facts that lead to the indictment

against the accused.

Page 316: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

283

(35) The witness is required to sit in a witness chair on my left in this court room to

state the information he is asked for the purpose of this trial that you are about to hear by

way of answering questions from the Prosecution, the Defense, or by this Presiding Judge.

(36) Therefore, if you hear that same person speaking outside this court and it

happens that you were riding together with him in the same vehicle with him and you

heard him talking about the same case he testified to whether the same or different from

what he said in court, you must not give any credible value to whatever he said at the bus.

Important reminder : You must not talk or argue with him and you do not need to listen

to him. And so, at the time this case reaches the stage wherein you are asked to

deliberate on it, you must not tell your fellow jurors about the story the witness said that

you heard from him at the bus. Why? Because he was not sworn at the bus and he was

not sitting on the witness chair. The bus has no witness chair in the first place.

(37) At this time, I want you to know two important words. They are very different

from each other. They are not the same. You cannot substitute one for the other.

"The first word is “Opinion” and the second is the word “Evidence.”

(38) The “opinion” is what you hear from the mouth of the government prosecutor

or of the defense attorney saying about his case or his opponent’s case. An opinion is not

evidence. You are not allowed to use an opinion to make your decision. From time to

time, by way of an instruction, I will tell you which is an evidence and which is not.

Exception: You may consider an opinion like an evidence if:

(a) It is an "Expert Opinion" of the witness,

(b) The person stating his opinion must have been sworn in to tell the truth, etc.

and must have been seated in the witness chair and has answered questions

from the Prosecution or from the Defense attorney;

(c) It is shown that the person making the opinion had sufficient training or

experience on the subject he testifies to; AND

(d) It was admitted into evidence by the presiding judge of the court and subject

to your scrutiny or analysis whether it represents the truth or not.

Page 317: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

284

(39) The “evidence” is what you hear from the mouth of the witness who was sworn

in and he is required to talk in the witness chair. The evidence is your basis to make your

decision in this case.

(40) Another thing you must learn about "evidence" is that it consists of several

things: The statement or word of mouth by a witness is evidence. An object or thing

related to a case in court to prove a fact is evidence. Objects are usually marked or

referenced with exhibit identification, such as Exhibit "A", Exhibit "B", Exhibit "1", and

others. Evidence, therefore, is a combination of what the witness said, an object and

identified as an exhibit to prove or disprove the existence of a fact. An exhibit may be part

of evidence and it is up to your discretion to believe or not of its existence specially when

you are in doubt of the source of such exhibit.

(41) The words and statements of attorneys are not evidence. Attorneys only act

as guides to help you find and understand the evidence. If there is variance or difference

between what the attorney says over what the witness says, you must rely on what the

witness said - not what the attorney said.

(42) Before the attorneys will present their witness or evidence, each of them will

make an opening statement in favor of their side of the case.

(43) The prosecutor usually or always delivers his opening statement. However,

the attorney for the accused may, or many not, make an opening statement.

(44) At this point, I will ask you a question. You must not be afraid to give me a

wrong answer. This is a part of your instruction and education about this case and it is

imperative that you learn it now. My question is this:

When the lawyer delivers or speaks of his opening statement, did you hear an

evidence or did you hear an opinion? Right or wrong, I would like to hear from anyone of

you.

(Presiding judge should emphasize that the words coming from

the mouth of the lawyer is only an opinion and it is not an evidence).

(45) Again, the thing you should remember is that an evidence can be accepted

Page 318: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

285

only when it is stated by the witness while testifying in the witness chair. The subsequent

statement, therefore, of the witness who speaks at another location after he testified in

court such as when he speaks over the radio or television show or anywhere with another

version than what he testified to in court is not the evidence. What the witness said over

the radio or television station is a matter of opinion and of no evidentiary value because

he was not sworn to tell the truth of what he said at the radio station or at the television

show or anywhere else.

(46) Another evidence you must know is "Circumstantial evidence." Circumstantial

evidence is a fact or event that can be used to infer or presume another fact or another

event. It is an indirect evidence, an evidence the witness did not see, but it implies

something occurred but does not directly prove it. It is a proof of one or more facts from

which one can find another fact. It is also a proof of a chain or connection of facts and

circumstances indicating that the person is either guilty or not guilty.

(47) You may also hear an objection to an evidence by an opposing attorney

saying that the evidence is a "hearsay evidence." In ordinary meaning, a hearsay

evidence is like a second hand evidence where the witness is stating a fact or event based

on what he heard from another person or witness. The person in the witness chair have

not personally seen the existence of the fact or event but is simply restating what the

actual eyewitness had said to him. On the other hand a hearsay evidence may be

credible or believable in the following instances:

(a) An excited utterances as a natural or spontaneous reaction to a startling event;

(b) It is a present sense impression that expresses the declarant’s spontaneous

impression of a condition existing at the time it was said;

(c) A declaration of the present state of mind where the statement reflects the

declarant’s mental condition is in question;

(d) A business record which was created during the ordinary course of business;

(e) Prior inconsistent statement that was written and signed by the declarant;

(f) Dying declaration and other statements under the belief of an impending death

Page 319: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

286

and the declarant is unavailable to testify in court; and

(g) A statement against the declarant’s own interest which would incriminate or

expose the declarant to liability who would not have made the statement unless the

statement was true.

(48) In the course of the trial, an expert witness may be called to demonstrate or

describe a "Scientific Evidence." He is more of a teacher about the underlying scientific

theory and instrument implementing theory. He is called in to bring out opinions that a

theory is valid and the instruments involved are reliable. The witness must be accredited

as an expert witness, which may require academic qualifications or specific training or

actual experience on the matter he is talking about. You may or you may not accept his

explanation as viewed from the logic or natural result of his statements.

(49) Remember the rule. Evidence may be acceptable only if allowed by the judge

to be admitted into the record and while the witness speaks on the witness stand. So, if

you hear any body talking about the case or crime, not sworn and not seated in a witness

chair or stand, regardless of how prestigious or powerful he is, even if he may be the

highest somebody of your community or who said "I am Chief of Police So and So, and

I actually saw the happening of the crime or event," what you hear is not evidence. What

you hear is an unsworn declaration from someone who cannot be prosecuted if his or her

statement is a lie or a statement of falsehood outside of the court trial.

(50) There is an exception wherein an evidence will be admitted without the need

of a testimony by a witness. It is called “Stipulated Evidence”. Its other name is “Agreed

Evidence” wherein both the prosecutor and the defense attorney will agree with the

approval of the judge that the evidence be admitted without being testified to by a sworn

witness. If such an evidence will come up, you will be told that it is a "stipulated evidence".

Nonetheless, It is up to you to believe or not depending on what you think of how credible

the source of such evidence is.

(51) Now, here is another word I want you to know at heart. The word is the “law”

of the case you are going to hear. You must disregard any law you have learned outside

this court even if you studied law in college or university.

(52) The law that will govern the case is the statement of the law that I have

Page 320: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

287

instructed you to use. The definition of the law will be issued to you in a “Law and Fact

Sheet”. You are therefore forbidden to read a law book, legal dictionary or any dictionary

whatsoever. You are not allowed to learn more of the law than what I have stated to you.

Your prior knowledge of the law is irrelevant and you must not use that prior knowledge

in making a decision in this case.

(53) While the trial is still in progress, you must presume that the accused is innocent.

During this entire trial, it is the right of the accused to remain silent and he may choose not to

testify. Therefore, you must not presume or you must not guess that he is guilty because he did

not testify or he has remained silent in this trial. Our constitution forbids to force the accused

to testify or say something against him/herself. You may hear this instruction on “presumption

of innocence” of the accused several times in the course of the trial for the protection of his/her

constitutional right of innocence.

(54) Submission of exhibits to the jury for review and analysis by the jurors:

(a) After both parties or their lawyers have presented their respective witnesses for

questioning and have submitted their exhibits, or arguments, to prove their case, I, your presiding

judge, shall submit those exhibits in this case to you for your inspection, analysis, discussion and

decision. Exhibits that were produced and shown during the trial will be submitted to you for your

review and recollection of what you heard or saw in the course of the witness testimony.

(b) In that room, you will absolutely be forbidden to bring in any type of weapon and

should you notice anyone of your fellow members in violation of this rule, each of you shall have

the authority to secretly report the matter to the Grand Jury for secret investigation and criminal

indictment in court by dropping your report in the "Citizen's Secret Crime Reports Drop Box"

located in the lobby of this court house.

(c) You are absolutely forbidden to smoke or drink any alcoholic substance, except water

or eat the food we provide you. If you feel hungry or thirsty, your foreman may ask the sheriff to

bring in some crackers, cookies, or pan de sal, or bottle of water and the sheriff shall forthwith

inform me of your request and for which I will gladly order to provide you.

(55) In your verdict, you shall not declare the accused guilty as charged unless you have

found proof or evidence of guilt beyond reasonable doubt of the alleged unlawful act of the

accused. This means that you declare the accused guilty only if you cannot find in the evidence

a believable reason that the accused could not have committed the offense charged against him.

Page 321: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

288

You will again be reminded of this instruction, from time to time, as we proceed with this trial.

(56) In making your collective judgment, called the “verdict”, you must not force upon any

of your fellow jurors to vote against his or her conscience. You must write your vote secretly and

your ballot folded when submitting for counting. No ballot shall be opened or read until all twelve

ballots are gathered. Upon submission of all twelve (12) ballots, all “guilty” votes shall be sorted

separately from the “not guilty” votes. The “not guilty” votes shall likewise be sorted separately.

You decide by the majority rule.

(57) The “GUILTY VERDICT” - If you arrive at seven (7) or more “guilty votes, the

accused shall be declared guilty as charged. You shall then promptly record the number of the

“Guilty Votes” on Form TJ-113, the “Guilty Verdict” form and sign the same with your ICN. After

completing this form, put it in the “Verdict Envelope”, known as “Form TJ-137".

(58) The “NOT GUILTY VERDICT” - If you arrive at six (6) or more “not guilty votes”, the

accused shall be declared innocent, or NOT GUILTY, of the crime charged against him. You

shall then promptly record the number of the “Not Guilty Votes” on Form TJ-114, the “Not Guilty

Verdict” form and sign the same with your ICN. After completing this form, put it in the “Verdict

Envelope”, known as “Form TJ-137".

(59) Disposition of Documents-

(A) VERY IMPORTANT: The only document to be put in the “Verdict Envelope”,

Form TJ-137, shall either be Form TJ-113, or Form TJ-114. The only Envelope you will bring out

from the Jury Room to the open court, or Jury Trial Court Room, shall be Form TJ-137 containing

either Form TJ-113 or Form TJ-114 for reading by the Jury Foreman of the Jury Verdict in open

court. Your jury ballots should NOT be inserted in Form TJ-137.

(B) IMPORTANT: All the rest of the other documents such as the Jury Ballots, Law

& Fact Sheets, the Charge Sheet and Exhibits shall be put back into the Envelope Form TJ-136

which you will leave behind in the Jury Room for the Clerk of Court to gather and for safekeeping

in the custody of the court. Care must be observed by the Clerk of Court that said documents

shall be collated correspondingly to the Criminal Case Number and Name of the Accused inside

a larger and Master File Envelope, size 9 x 12 inches, known as Form TJ-138, to accommodate

the exhibits for safekeeping.

Page 322: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

289

[Note: The presiding judge shall re-issue this instruction upon submitting the case to the

jury for its deliberation and decision.]

(60) In the course of this proceedings, I will further issue other instructions as their need

may arise. I will also instruct you on the definition of the law of the criminal offense that the

accused is charged with. In the mean time, you must not speculate or try to guess as to the

definition of the alleged criminal offense. You are required to know the facts of this case because

you are the principal judge of the existence or non-existence of the facts to this case. Your

finding of facts cannot be reviewed on appeal. Among those facts are the demeanor of

witnesses such as their eye or lip movements and body language that reflect facial expression

for truth in their testimony. Such facts cannot be recorded by the court reporter for review.

(61) If you received any solicitation or request from any person, or any lawyer, or public

official, job supervisor, or co-employee, with the purpose of influencing your decision, regardless

of whether you were influenced or not by such solicitation or request, you have the mandatory

duty and obligation to secretly report in writing within thirty (30) days from the date you received

such solicitation or request to a grand jury for investigation. You shall be liable for the crime of

obstruction of justice and indictment by a grand jury if you ignore or fail to comply with this duty

or obligation.”

(62) Any statement given by your fellow juror whether favouring a guilty or not guilty

verdict, during your discussion, you must take such statement as his or her opinion only and shall

not necessarily bind you in making your personal actual and final secret vote in your jury ballot.

(63) If you find in good faith and in your conscience that the accused cannot be convicted

under the law that I have instructed to you for application in this case because you think that the

law itself is unconstitutional, or unfair, or by the weakness of the evidence you have seen or

heard during the trial, you must give the benefit of your doubt to the accused by granting him your

vote of “Not Guilty”.

(64) By virtue of the sovereign power of the people in Article II, Section 1, of the

Constitution, as conferred upon you as a jury and direct representative of the sovereign people,

you will not be held liable, civilly or criminally, individually or as a jury, in writing your vote in good

faith and without malice in your jury ballot to reach your verdict to find the accused either guilty

or not guilty.

(65) You are the exclusive judges of this case. Ask not anyone else, not even your fellow

Page 323: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

290

jurors, once you have arrived at your personal opinion, which way you, as a group, shall decide.

It is your collective jury votes that makes up the decision of the jury.

(a) Each of you, the regular 12 jurors, must vote and none of you shall abstain from

voting. If you will refuse to vote either way, "guilty" or "not guilty", I have the power and authority

to charge you with the crime of obstruction of justice. I strongly urged you to cast your vote, one

way or the other, in order to reach your collective decision or verdict. I repeat: Each of you must

vote and none of you shall abstain from voting to avoid being criminally charged for obstruction

of justice.

(b) If any one among you, the 12 regular jurors, is overcome by fear to write your vote

in your jury ballot for any reason, inform your Foreman who shall call for the Sheriff and shall

inform me about your condition about your fear of voting as a juror. I shall then order your

replacement with one of the alternate reserve jurors who shall become a regular juror in your

instead who shall then vote with the remaining 11 jurors. I will order the replaced juror to refrain

from telling or announcing to anyone which way he wanted or wished to vote. Choosing the

alternate reserve juror shall be done by lottery.

(66) In your discussion, you may speak the local dialect that all of you understand and

speak. If you feel it necessary to speak in Tagalog, you may do so to emphasize your point. What

is important is that you must understand each other very well and understand your decision.

(67) After you have declared your verdict in open court, you have the power and the right

to refuse to explain your verdict. I strongly advise you to exercise that power and right to refuse

to explain your verdict for your personal protection and the protection of the members of your

family. By making your verdict, you have exercised your sovereign authority as judicial masters

of our society in accordance with Article II, Section 1, of the Constitution. Keep your sovereign

power and authority by remaining silent about your collective jury verdict.

- End of Form -

Page 324: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

291

Form TJ-109, Duties of the Jury Commissioner or Clerk of Court And Instructions to the Incoming Jurors for Jury Duty

(This Form must be translated into the common local dialect)

NO CONVERSATION SHALL BE ALLOWED IN THIS JURY ASSE MBLY

ROOM. WAIT AND LISTEN TO INSTRUCTIONS AND REMAIN SI LENT.

INSTRUCTIONS:

1. To the Jury Commissioner : Provide every juror the following items:

a. A blank copy of Form TJ-109A and pre-write in it a unique 5-digit ICN (Identity Code

Number) differently from each other jurors to be used as his Identification Code name while he is

on jury duty. Attach to it a Tag Form with the same ICN for the juror to keep for his Court ID at all

times. The rules herein applies to women jurors as well.

b. A pair of Dark Goggles which you shall instruct the juror to wear at all times upon receiving

it from you and with the further instruction to return it back to you when he picks up from you his

juror’s fee on Form GJ-27. You shall procure this item at government expense and have them in

stock at all times for ready use. Require each juror to return the dark goggle before delivering to the

juror his voucher fee, Form GJ-27.

At exactly at 8:30 AM, pick 29 names of jurors from Raffle Bin "B" and instruct each and all

jurors to read and have each juror answer the questions in the Form TJ-109A below. Read

Instruction number 2 below "To ALL Jurors ". Instruct all other jurors whose name were not drawn

to wait for the next raffle. Upon receiving a call from the clerk of the jury trial court room for jury

impaneling, lead and usher the 29 jurors in going to JTCR (Jury Trial Court Room).

2. To ALL Jurors: “This room in which you are in is called the “JAR” ( "Jury Assembly

Room"). This room is a legal extension of the actual Jury Trial Court Room called the JTCR. Upon

your signing of the JAL (Jurors Attendance Logbook), the court thereby acquires jurisdiction over

you and over your acts in this room. Any violation of the Instruction I have read to you is punishable

with contempt of court or Obstruction of Justice for which penalty of imprisonment for a number of

days may be imposed by Order of the Court.

Page 325: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

292

So, you are mandatorily required to follow my instruction.

In this room you are NOT ALLOWED :

(1) To bring in anybody with you; to talk with anybody, not even with your fellow jurors or a

close relative by cell phone by any chance.

(2) You must not call by cell phone any person outside this room. If it is necessary to call

someone because of an emergency, you must ask my permission before doing so.

From these room, I will take you to the JTCR (Jury Trial Court Room) and you must be

ready to answer truthfully the questions in this form, your Form TJ-109A. The attorneys at the JTCR

will be asking you again the same questions. It is important that you answer their questions

truthfully.

VERY IMPORTANT: For your protection, from now on, you must not give or mention your

real name to anyone. You will notice that in Form TJ-109A, there is a 5-digit ICN (Identity Code

Name). That Code Number shall be your name in the court room. Your real name should not be

known to any of the lawyers or persons in this courthouse. Bring with you your Tag Receipt Number.

The one I gave you with your ICN (Identity Code Number) in it.

At 8:30 A.M., I will pick 29 sheets of Form TJ-109A from the Raffle Bin #2 and I will announce

the number. When your number is called, you must get ready and follow me to the JTCR.

Whenever your ICN is called or announced, you must acknowledge the call by raising your right

hand at the level of your right eye and look towards the caller. DO NOT stand .

Note that when you are serving as jurors, bear in mind that you are acting as a master to

decide a case in court, not as a servant, pursuant to your status as a sovereign people under Article

II, Section 1, of the constitution. Our role in court is to guide you, by instructions, on how to perform

your jury service but not to control which way you will decide in making your decision in the Jury

Trial. I ask you, therefore, to follow court instructions as those questions are issued to you for your

education and guidance as we progress along the way to accomplish your mission.

Page 326: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

293

Form TJ-109A, IQS and Form for Accomplishment by the Juror.

(NOTE: If you have a question, ask the Jury Commissioner. Do not ask your fellow juror)

This document will be presented to the Presiding Judge in the Jury Trial Court Room

and a photocopy of it will be furnished to both opposing lawyers for their information.

Instruction to Juror: Answer truthfully the questions below otherwise you will be charged forPerjury by a Grand Jury for lying in your answer. Your truthful answer to any of the questions will notbe used to charge you criminally or for any other purpose. After you are done, keep it ready forsubmission to the trial presiding judge at his court room but keep the tag ID with you. You mayanswer the questions in your local dialect, not necessarily in English, even if the question is inEnglish.

DO NOT WRITE YOUR NAME IN THIS PAPER

(Huwag Isulat Ang Pangalan Mo Sa Papel Na Ito)

1. This number ________ is your ICN (Identity Code Number). (This will be your “name”

as a Juror ). Your actual name will not be disclosed to anyone in this case.

2. Name of City or Municipality where you reside: __________________________________

3. Are you a high school graduate? Answer: [_]-Yes [_]-No

4. If “Yes”, in what school? Name of school: ______________________________________

5. If “No”, what work experience do you have? Answer: _____________________________

_______________________________________________________________________

6. What type of work do you have today? Answer: ______________________ [_]-None.

7. While working did you supervise a number of workers? [_]-No [_]-Yes, how many: ____

8. How long have you been doing this job approximately? ________________________________

9. Marital status: [_]-Married [_]-Single [_]-Widowed [_]-Common law spouse.

10. If Married, how long ago? ________________________________________________

11. Do you have children? [_]-No [_]-Yes How many? _____________________________

Their ages. Do not write their name. _________________________________________

Page 327: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

294

12. Have you spoken with any attorney or a police about your having been called for jury

Service relating to any crime? Answer: [_]-Yes [_]-No

13. Have you been accused or convicted of, or pleaded guilty to, a crime punishable for

one year or more? Answer [_]-Yes [_]-No.

If so, what kind of crime? Answer: ________________________________________

14. Are you, or any of your close relatives, working, or have worked,

in the government? Answer [_]-Yes [_]-No.

15. Is your spouse, common law spouse, or fiancee,

working in the government? Answer [_]-Yes [_]-No.

16. Is your son or daughter, or is your father or mother, working in the government?

Answer [_]-Yes [_]-No. If so, name and locality of government office:

_______________________________________________________________

17. Are you, or have been, a member of a fraternity, or sorority, in any college,

university or school? Answer: (_)-Yes or (_)-No. If so, what college and what

fraternity

_____________________________________________________________

18. Are you or any of your closest relatives a member of the Police

or the Philippine National Police? Answer [_]-Yes [_]-No.

If “Yes”, in what location:

_____________________________________________________________

19. Have you or any member of your family been a victim of police abuse?

Answer: [_]-Yes [_]-No.

20. Are you or any of your closest relatives a member of the Army, Navy, or

Air Force of the Philippines? Answer [_]-Yes [_]-No.

21. Are you, or have you been, an official or employee, in the government once

upon a time? Answer [_]-No [_]-Yes. How long ago? ___________ Year

_______

Page 328: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

295

22. If you have previously served as a juror, describe your prior jury

experience: [_]-Criminal case [_]- Civil case [_]-Not yet.

23. Have you or any member of your family, or any close friend, ever worked

for the Police or any law enforcement agency?

Answer [_]-Yes [_]-No.

24. The case that you will hear as a juror is a criminal case. Under our law, the

accused is considered innocent until all evidence against him are shown to

you. Are you willing to wait first to hear all those evidence before you

decide whether he is guilty? Answer: (_)-Yes or (_)-No.

25. During the course of hearing the case, you will be given instructions by the

presiding judge to help you and let you know how to serve as a juror. Do

you have any reason why you cannot follow the instructions?

Answer: (_)-Yes or (_)-No. If “Yes”, why?

__________________________________________________________

26. Do you have any interest in the outcome of this case or will you be

receiving from any party to any case you will be serving as a juror?

Answer: (_)-Yes or (_)-No. If “Yes”, what is it? ______________________

27. Have you taken any drug or alcoholic substance in the past 5 days or are you

Suffering from any mental illness? Answer: (_)-Yes or (_)-No.

28. As a juror, you will be given maximum protection from any harm.

Is there any reason why you cannot serve as a juror in this case?

Answer: (_)-Yes or (_)-No.

29. Are you, or is your spouse, or a close friend or relative of yours, an

attorney? Answer: (_)-Yes or (_)-No.

30. Jury Service is an honor and sacred duty. Your duty to attend is as

important in attending the funeral of your most beloved relative who dies

while living with you. Is there any reason why you will not be able to

complete your jury service? Answer: (_)-Yes or (_)-No.

- End Form -

Page 329: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

296

Form TJ-110, Lead Trial Index Form :

FORM NAME FORM DESCRIPTION PAGE NO.

Form TJ-110A - Confidential “In Chamber Conference.” Instruction to the Presiding Judge, . . . . . . . . . . .

Form TJ-110B- The Charge Sheet . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

Form TJ-110C- The “LAW & FACT SHEET” PATTERN . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

Form TJ-110D-1 Law & Fact Sheet - 1st Case # vs Accused. . . . . .

Form TJ-110D-2 Law & Fact Sheet - 2nd Case # vs Accused. . . . . .

Form TJ-110D-3 Law & Fact Sheet - 3rd Case # vs Accused . . . . .

Form TJ-110D-4 Law & Fact Sheet - 4th Case # vs Accused. . . . . .

Form TJ-110D-5 Law & Fact, etc. - For additional case . . . . . . . .

Page 330: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

297

Form TJ-110A CONFIDENTIAL “IN CHAMBER CONFERENCE.” INSTRUCTION TO THE PRESIDING JUDGE,The PROSECUTOR AND DEFENSE COUNSEL/S.(THIS PART SHALL NOT BE SUBMITTED TO THE JURY )

“Confidential In Chamber Conference ” and preparation of the Joint Supplemental Instruction to the Jury .

1. “This conference is mandatory. It shall precede at least one day ahead of the actual jury

trial. It shall be held strictly confidential and its schedule shall not be announced to the public.

Except for the Prosecution Attorney and the Defense Counsels, as well as the Presiding Judge,

no other person or any public official or any member of the media or public shall be invited to this

conference. The attendance of the accused and witnesses shall not be required.” Article XI,

Section 4, Sub-paragraph (1)(a), of the National Jury Law.

2. The main purpose of this Confidential Conference is to prepare and to set up a Joint

Supplemental Jury Instruction for the jury trial. It will serve as a guide in presenting the respective

evidence of the opposing parties during the trial and in submitting the case to the jury for

deliberation and in securing its jury verdict.

3. The other purpose of this proceeding is to avoid waste of time of the jurors in requiring

them to wait at the court room lobby for the judge, the prosecution attorney and the defense

attorneys in planning out how to proceed with the jury trial. The personal time of the jurors is just

as precious as the time of the judicial professionals who are charged with the disposition of this

matter.

4. “Failure of the Presiding Judge, or of the Prosecution Attorney, or the Defense Attorneys

in showing up for this conference, resulting to the postponement of a Firm Trial Date shall be

liable for disciplinary action before the Supreme Court or for criminal liability for obstruction of

justice upon complaint by any party to the case through the Grand Jury.” Art. XI, Sec. 4,

Subparagraph (3) of the National Jury Law.

Page 331: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

298

Form TJ-110B, The “CHARGE SHEET” The Clerk of Court shall fill in the information called for in the blanks

below. This Charge Sheet SHALL BE SUBMITTED TO THE JURY.

INSTRUCTION TO THE JURY:

THIS DOCUMENT IS NOT EVIDENCE. Read this document as your introductory visual aid inunderstanding the case or cases charged against the accused. In some occasions, there maybe more than one criminal charges. In this situation (Clerk of Court should mark the appropriatebox) [_]-there is only one criminal charge [_]-there are ____ criminal charges, against theaccused.

Title of Case: The People vs

(To the Clerk of Court: Mark “NONE” on blanks for extra case numbers. If there are

more than 3 case numbers, expand the form by adding more blanks to it. If there are

more than one (1) accused in the same Criminal Case Number, a separate Charge

Sheet should be prepared for that other co-accused.)

1. Criminal Case Number:

Offense Charged:

2. Criminal Case Number:

Offense Charged:

3. Criminal Case Number:

Offense Charged:

Name/Location of Court: Br/Sala:

Name of Judge:

Pretrial Conference date held last:

In Chamber Conference Date:

Firm Trial Date (FTD):

NOTE: The information called for in the blanks above

shall be filled in by the Clerk of Court.

Page 332: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

299

Form TJ-110C. The “LAW & FACT SHEET” PATTERN. DO NOT SUBMIT this form to the Jury. Instead, submit Form TJ-110D as approved in the “In Chamber Conference.”

For each Case Number under which the accused is cha rged, type on a separate Law Sheet onForm TJ-110D (Example: Form TJ-110D-1, Form TJ-110D -2, Form TJ-110D3, etc) the simplifieddefinition of the crime, the associated aggravating and/or mitigating circumstance in the allegedcommission of the crime as well as allegation of se lf-defense by the accused, if any. At the “InChamber Conference”, both prosecution and defense a ttorneys must submit a draft of theirrespective simplified definitions in their case to the presiding judge for reconciliation and for hisguidance in preparing the final Joint Supplemental Instruction to the Jury. The counsels’ draftsshall be submitted to the Judge only BUT NOT TO THE JURY. Prepare as many Form TJ-110D’sas there are a number of cases in which the accused is charged.

Both the Prosecution and Defense Attorneys shall a lso bring in their respective EXHIBIT LISTSto weed-out inadmissible evidence or exhibits. The admitted exhibits shall then be presented atthe trial and shall be submitted eventually to the jury in the jury room.

PATTERN TO SIMPLIFY LEGAL DEFINITIONS OF TERMS OR PHRASES

Case Number: - People vs

Short name for the alleged crime committed by the accused

[_]- The Indictment: “On or about, etc” [state here the date, time, location and court

jurisdiction and all elements in simple terms of the crime charged against the accused. [In

this bracket, cite Article or Section number, and Definition of Law violated by accused,

then followed by the alleged criminal act or acts of the accused.]

[_]- Aggravating Circumstance: State below in simple terms. Alleged acts of the accused that

add to his guilt and enormity or injurious consequence or suffering upon his victim which

were unnecessary in attaining the objective in the commission of his crime [Authority:

Write in bracket case citation such as “People vs _______ Case #_______ SCRA]

1.

2.

3.

[_]- Mitigating Circumstance: If convicted of the accusation against him, the accused claims

a reduction of the penalty imposed on him for the following meritorious acts he performed

during or immediately after the commission of the crime charged against him [Authority:

Write in bracket case citation such as “People vs _______ Case #_______ SCRA]

1.

2.

3.

[_]- Self-Defense: Accused pleads for acquittal of the crime against him. He only acted in

defense from imminent forceful threat of serious harm or death to himself that the victim

tried to inflict upon his person or well being and that the acts of the accused in defending

himself was no more than necessary to stop the aggression of the victim [Authority:

Write in bracket case citation such as “People vs _______ Case #_______ SCRA]

NOTE: Use same pattern above in simplifying definitions of NON-VIOLENT crimes.

Page 333: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

300

Form TJ-110D, Refer back to Form TJ-110 for Guidance:

The “LAW & FACT SHEET ” For Criminal Case No.

Name of the Accused:

Instructions in accomplishing this Form:

1. This Form SHALL BE SUBMITTED TO THE JURY .

2. A separate Law & Fact Sheet shall be prepared for every other criminal case that theaccused is charged with. The first Law & Fact Sheet shall be designated as Form TJ-110D-1. The additional Law & Fact Sheet shall be consecutively designated as TJ-110D-2, TJ-110D-3, TJ-110D-4, and so forth as the case may be.

3. A separate Law & Fact Sheet shall be prepared for a co-accused who may be chargedwith the accused in the same criminal case number above. The first Law & Fact Sheet for the co-accused shall be designated as Form TJ-110D-1. The additional Law & Fact Sheet shall beconsecutively designated as TJ-110D-2, TJ-110D-3, TJ-110D-4, and so forth as the case may be. 4. In retyping/reprinting to finalize this form, an unmarked or blank box ([_]) and its relatingparagraph/s must be omitted or stricken off.

INSTRUCTION TO THE JURYANY STATEMENT IN THIS DOCUMENT IS NOT EVIDENCE

(It is only your guide to understand the case)

Ladies and Gentlemen of the Jury:

Earlier during the trial of this criminal matter, you heard from the testimony of witnesses and also

saw certain exhibits shown to you to prove an alleged unlawful acts committed by a certain

person by the name of (state the full name of the accused including alias name by which he is

commonly known), the accused person in this case. For such alleged acts, the People of the

Philippines has filed a criminal indictment for (state the name of the crime) against the said

accused for the alleged violation of (state Section or Article and name of law violated).

The criminal Act: The indictment specifically stated that on or about (state date) in the (state

the barrio, municipal, city, or provincial location of the crime), and within the jurisdiction of this

Court, with full malicious intent, willingly, and without hesitation, the said accused committed the

crime of (state the name of the crime) in the manner described as follows:

(State in this paragraph in simple and commonly known terms and phrases of

the unlawful act/s of the accused. All elements of the crime must be stated

[In this bracket, write case citation]

The law allegedly violated by the accused is punishable by imprisonment in jail ranging from

____ years and one day to ____ years and one day which shall be imposed against the accused

if found guilty of the crime of (state the name and definition of the crime committed by accused).

Page 334: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

301

[_]- The Aggravating Circumstance : The indictment further states that the said accused, (state

full name and alias name), additionally committed the act or acts described below which was or

were not necessary in the course of, or immediately after, committing the crime stated above,

thereby increasing the sufferings, humiliation or insult upon the well-being or dignity, of the victim,

as follows:

(State in this paragraph in simple and commonly known

terms and phrases of the aggravating act/s of the accused.)

[In this bracket, write case citation]

If you find proof or evidence that the aggravating circumstance stated above was performed by

the accused in the course of committing the crime of (state name of the crime) or immediately

after committing the said crime, an additional penalty of imprisonment shall be imposed on the

accused if found guilty of the crime charged against him/her.

[_]- The Mitigating Circumstance : The indictment further states that the said accused, (state

full name and alias name), performed the act or acts described below in the course of, or

immediately after, committing the crime stated above, thereby decreasing the sufferings of the

victim, as follows:

(State in this paragraph in simple and commonly known terms

and phrases of the mitigating act/s of the accused in committing his crime.)

[In this bracket, write case citation]

If you find proof or evidence that the mitigating circumstance stated above was performed by the

accused in the course of committing the crime of (state name of the crime) or immediately after

committing the said crime, a lower penalty of imprisonment shall be imposed on the accused if

found guilty of the crime charged against him/her.

[_]- The Self Defense: The said accused, (state full name and alias name), claims that he is

innocent of the crime he/she is charged with that resulted to the injury or death of the victim for

the reason that he/she was purely acting in self-defense to prevent harm from the violent

aggression of the complaining victim.

(State in this paragraph in simple and commonly known terms and

phrases to describe the act or acts of self-defense by the accused.)

[In this bracket, write case citation]

On the basis of the evidence presented to you, it is now your duty to find in your discussion

whether the accused is guilty, or not, of the crime charged against him.

This instruction as finalized has been concurred in by:

______________________ ______________________ ____________________

Prosecuting Attorney Defense Attorney Jury Presiding Judge

(Instruction: Strike out any box [_] not used above)

Page 335: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

302

Form TJ-111, The Master Joint Supplemental Jury Instruction. This form shall be read by the Presiding Judge and thereafter its copy shall be submitted to the Jury.The Secretary and the Sheriff on duty should closely pay attention also to thisinstruction. This instruction shall be extemporaneously interpreted while beingread by the presiding judge to the Jury.

JURY INSTRUCTION IN SUBMITTING THE CASETO THE JURY FOR DISCUSSION AND DECISION

Honorable Members of the Jury:

Previously, you have heard the evidence in this matter pertaining to the alleged criminal

act or acts of the accused (and his co-accused) while the witnesses gave their testimonies. As

a reminder, EVIDENCE consists, or is a combination, of the sworn testimony of the witnesses

while being seated in the witness chair in this court and the exhibits presented and identified by

the witnesses during their testimony. Evidence also includes statements agreed upon by the

parties through their attorneys and admitted into the records by the judge in this case. The

demeanor of the witnesses such as body language, eye and lip movements that reflect

truthfulness or falsity of his statement are part of the evidence. It is within your power and

authority to determine the existence and truth of the fact of the act or acts of the accused by

applying the evidence in this case whether he has committed, or has not committed, the criminal

act or acts being charged against him (or them).

In a few minutes from now, we will go through the steps below in their chronological

sequence. You do not need to memorize or write them now. A copy of this Instruction shall be

furnished to you through your chosen leader for your review:

First: I will instruct you to go to your private jury room. My Secretary shall lead all fifteen

(15) of you in going there. The first twelve (12) of you that we have chosen and impaneled earlier

shall compose the Regular Jurors , and the last three (3) of you shall be your Reserve Alternate

Jurors . As soon as my secretary leaves you behind that room, the first thing you will do is to lock

your door and no one else, except the 15 of you, shall be admitted inside the jury room. You

should not ask me to sit with you in that room. The National Jury Law forbids me or anybody else

to partake with you in performing your work inside the jury room. You are required to perform

your function to discuss and decide independently with no interference from any person or

anyone. You must not call by cell phone anybody outside or anywhere for help. You are also

not allowed to make a tape recording of your discussion in your jury room. I will definitely hold

you in contempt of court for any violation of my instruction to you.

Second: The next thing you will do after you are locked in and have seated inside the jury

room is to choose your leader. He will be your foreman. You shall also choose his two

assistants. The foreman and his two assistants shall be chosen from among you who are the

12 regular members. None of your alternate jurors can be chosen for those positions. However,

all 15 of you shall vote to choose your leaders. After you have chosen them, you will rearrange

your seating locations. Your foreman shall be seated at the head-end of your jury table. On his

right shall be his First assistant and on the left shall be his Second assistant . The 3 alternative

Page 336: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

303

reserve shall be seated at the opposite end of the jury table facing your Jury Foreman.

Third: After you have organized yourselves by choosing your leaders, you shall call the

Sherif who will be standing by the door outside your jury room. Simply knock at your door and

the Sherif will see you. Then let him know that you already have chosen your leaders. Do not

mention their names or ICN (ID number) to the Sheriff and then close your door. The Sherif shall

then inform me, your Presiding Judge, that you already have chosen your leaders.

Fourth: After learning from the Sheriff that you have already chosen your leaders, I will

instruct my Secretary to bring in to you all the exhibits presented at the trial. With the exhibits,

my Secretary shall also bring in a blank note pad paper and a pen. All the exhibits shall be

handed to the Foreman. In turn, the Foreman shall lead all your members in reading and

analysing the exhibits. If you have a question, write to me in the note pad your question. Do not

send back to me any exhibit. You must keep them with you inside the jury room at all times. Do

not mention any name of any person in your question. You may use Tagalog or your local dialect

to write me and I will answer your question privately together with the prosecution and the

defense attorney in my chamber and sent to you promptly which will be delivered to you by the

Sheriff. I will answer you in the dialect your question was written.

Fifth: The exhibits are intended to refresh your memory of the events narrated by the

witnesses during the jury trial. After you have all read or examined the exhibits, knock your door

and call the Sheriff to inform me, your presiding judge, to inform me that you already have read,

examined and understood all the exhibits.

Sixth: In this sixth step, I will submit to you, through my Secretary, a document called the

Form TJ-110B. This document is not evidence. It will inform you only on how many alleged

criminal acts have been charged against the accused. If there is only one Criminal Case Number

written on it, this means that the accused has been charged with only one criminal act. If there

are more than one criminal case number, it means that there are other case or cases charged

against the accused and that they are identified with another separate Criminal Case Number

or Numbers. If more than one case is charged against the accused, each cased will be

submitted to you one at a time for your discussion and decision. To understand more about this

instruction, discuss it with all your fellow jurors. If you don’t understand it, let the Sheriff know

who will inform me accordingly, and I will answer your question properly and delivered to you by

the same Sheriff. After understanding how many criminal cases have been charged against the

accused, please let me know through the Sheriff that you understood this instruction.

Seventh: In this seventh step, I will deliver to you, through my Secretary, a “Delivery

Page 337: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

304

Envelope”, known as Form TJ-136 . Its size is #10, 4.1 x 9.5 inches. [Assisted by Secretary,

closely show to the jury an exact size of the envelope.] Outside the envelope, it will show the

information about the Criminal Case Number and the Name of the Accused. Inside the envelope,

you will find the following items and their description [Assisted by Secretary, standing closely to

show to the jury exactly the items in the envelope, one a time, in chronological sequence and

explain each item.] :

[_]- Form TJ-110D-____, “Law and Fact Sheet ” (Secretary to pre-fill in the blank).

[_]- Form TJ-112, Jury Ballot form in 12 pre-cut pieces (Secretary to precut the ballots). [_]- Form TJ-113, The “Guilty Verdict” form (Secretary to pre-fill accused name & case#).[_]- Form TJ-114, The “Not Guilty Verdict” form (Sec to pre-fill accused name & case#).[_]- Form TJ-137, Empty Verdict Envelope (To contain only the written Verdict of the Jury)

Eight: The discussion and decision process -

(1) Read and reread carefully the “Law and Fact Sheet” in the envelope. The criminal

case number and the name of the accused in Form TJ-110B shall be the same as written in the

“Law and Fact Sheet”. [Assisted by Secretary, point out closely to the Jury, the case numbers

between the two documents]. Review the Exhibits submitted to you.

(2) Your work inside the jury room is to discuss or deliberate among yourselves and to

collectively decide whether the accused is guilty or not in the light of the evidence you heard and

saw. Review again the exhibits, if you need to. Try to recall everything you heard from the

testimony of the witnesses. Ask questions with your fellow members to get a good understanding

in making your decision.

(3) If you find the accused guilty of the crime he is accused of, it must be without any

doubt in your mind. Mere suspicion is not sufficient for conviction. Your guilty vote must be

supported by a proof beyond reasonable doubt. It is a degree of proof that proves the certainty

of the truth of the act or acts and criminal intent of the accused. If you entertain some doubt, you

must acquit the accused. If the accused has remained silent, did not testify by himself in his

favor, you cannot base your guilty vote on his silence because the constitution does not require

him to testify to prove his innocence. At all times, he is presumed innocent until you find him

guilty with proof beyond reasonable doubt.

(4) All the 15 of you, the members of the jury, shall participate in the discussion or

deliberation.

(5) However, only your 12 regular members shall vote to make your decision. As you will

note, only 12 ballots are inside the envelope. No jury ballot shall be given to your alternate

reserves. Your 3 alternate reserve members shall not vote to make your decision.

Page 338: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

305

(6) When you write your jury vote, do it secretly. Let no one of your fellow jurors know

which way you voted and you must vote according to your own conscience in the light of the

evidence. Then fold your ballot. Wait until everyone has filled in his ballot before submitting it

for counting.

(7) When the foreman sees that everyone has already completed his jury ballot, the

foreman shall call for submission of all ballots to the assistant on his right. All in all, there should

only be 12 ballots to count, nothing more or nothing less. The assistant shall collate the “Guilty”

votes and separate the “Not Guilty” votes. He shall then announce the total of the “Guilty votes”

and the total of the “Not Guilty” votes. Thereafter he will submit it to the second assistant to the

left side of the Foreman to verify the counting of votes and to confirm if correctly counted or call

for correction if not correctly counted.

(8) The Verdict: Once the number of votes is counted and confirmed, the Foreman shall

order the preparation of the Verdict Sheet. A number of seven (7) “Guilty votes”, or more, shall

convict the accused and in such event, the Foreman shall ask his assistant on his left to fill in

Form TJ-113, the “Guilty” Verdict sheet. A number of six (6) “Not Guilty Votes”, or more, shall

acquit the accuse and in such event, he shall ask his assistant on his left to fill in the Form TJ-

114, the “Not Guilty” Verdict sheet.

(9) Thereafter, the Foreman shall formally announce to your fellow members that the

“Jury has [_]-Convicted the accused, or has [_]-Acquitted the accused, as the case may be.

After announcing the verdict by the Foreman, he shall ask you if the number of the majority

verdict is correctly written. If confirm, the Foreman shall put the Majority Verdict Sheet in the

Verdict Envelope, which is Form TJ-137. All other documents such as the Jury Ballots, Charge

Sheets, Law and Fact Sheets, the Exhibits and everything else shall be put back in, or attached

to, the first Envelope, Form TJ-136 and laid on the table for the Court Secretary or Clerk to

gather for safekeeping by the court and collated according to their corresponding case numbers.

(10) After the majority verdict has been placed in the Verdict Envelope, Form TJ-137, the

Foreman shall knock at the door to call the Sheriff to inform the presiding judge that “The Jury

has decided the case .” Once the Sheriff appears, the Foreman shall say to him “The Jury has

decided the case.” The Foreman MUST NOT say which way the jury decided the case. He

should simply say “The Jury has decided the case.” He should not yet give the Verdict

Envelope TJ-137 to the Sheriff, until further order is given by the Presiding Judge for the Jury to

get back to the court. At all times, the Foreman shall take hold of the Verdict Envelope Form TJ-

137.

(11) If the accused has been charged with another act as indicated in Form TJ-110B,

another set of a “Delivery Envelope” Form TJ-136 will be submitted to you, the Jury. Thereafter,

you shall go through the process of analysing the evidence from (1) to (10) listed above in

discussing and in deciding the next case at hand in the same way you did with the first case that

Page 339: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

306

you have already decided.

Ninth: Separate Verdict Envelope for each Criminal Defendants: After all cases against

the same accused, or of all co-accused, have been decided by the Jury, the Presiding Judge

shall then instruct the Sherif to call on the Jury to get back to the court with all its verdicts in the

corresponding Verdict Envelopes as follows:

(1) If the Jury has two (2) or more verdicts for the same accused for two (2) or more cases

against such accused, put all his Verdict Sheets in one (1) Verdict Envelope, Form TJ-137;

(2) If the Jury has two (2) or more verdicts for 2 or more co-accused or criminal

defendants, place the Verdict Sheet or Sheets in a different and separate Verdict Envelope,

Form TJ-137 corresponding to the name of each of such co-accused or criminal defendants.

Each accused shall have separate and different Verdict Form TJ-137 for the cases attributed to

him.

Tenth: Upon returning of the Jurors from their Jury Room to the Jury Trial Court Room,

the Foreman shall then submit the Verdict Envelope or Envelopes to the Jury Presiding Judge.

The Presiding Judge shall not yet announce which way the jury decided and he will simply state

the applicable comment below:

[_]- “The Jury has reach its verdict(s) in the criminal charge(s) for the Accused,

(by reading his name in the Verdict Envelope, Form TJ-137.)

[_]- “The Jury has likewise reached its verdict(s) for the co-accused (Read his name in the

Verdict Envelope, Form TJ-137), if there is, or are, co-accused in the commission of

the crime.

In turn, the Jury Presiding Judge shall order his Secretary or Clerk to read the Jury Verdict or

Verdicts Sheets, one at a time for the accused and for each co-accused as the case may be. It

is imperative that this proceeding should be recorded accurately by the court stenographer or

court reporter.

Page 340: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

307

After the verdict or verdicts are all read, the Presiding Judge shall issue the following orders:

(1) To order one of his Clerk of Court AND ALL the jurors to go to the Jury Room for:

(A) Issuance of their Redeemable Voucher, Form GJ-27, to pay their jury fee;

(B) Issuance of their Transport Ticket, Form TJ-131, for their trip back home;

(C) Return to the Clerk of the Juror’s goggles;

(D) Giving back of the cell phones to the jurors;

(E) Removal of the ICN tags from the shirts of the jurors; and

(F) The Clerk, in behalf of the Court, shall thank the jurors for their jury service.

(2) To order the Sheriff to take the accused into custody, if convicted; or

(3) To order the immediate release of the accused, if acquitted; and

(4) To order the Sheriff to provide security to the jurors while departing from the court.

(5) The Sheriff should thank the jurors for their jury service.

Page 341: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

308

Form TJ-112, JUROR'S BALLOT FORM (Print on a white 8-1/2 by 11" bond paper and cut apart )

(Must be pre-cut into separate ballots forms by Clerk of Court before distributing to the Jury)

I vote _____________ in Case # _________

Choose one of the words in parenthesis below:

(GUILTY) (NOT GUILTY) - Date _____________

Write Your ID Code Number here: _______

“Guilty” means the accused shall be punished.

“Not Guilty ”means no punishment for the accused.

I vote _____________ in Case # _________

Choose one of the words in parenthesis below:

(GUILTY) (NOT GUILTY) - Date _____________

Write Your ID Code Number here: _______

“Guilty” means the accused shall be punished.

“Not Guilty ”means no punishment for the accused.

I vote _____________ in Case # _________

Choose one of the words in parenthesis below:

(GUILTY) (NOT GUILTY) - Date _____________

Write Your ID Code Number here: _______

“Guilty” means the accused shall be punished.

“Not Guilty ”means no punishment for the accused.

I vote _____________ in Case # _________

Choose one of the words in parenthesis below:

(GUILTY) (NOT GUILTY) - Date _____________

Write Your ID Code Number here: _______

“Guilty” means the accused shall be punished.

“Not Guilty ”means no punishment for the accused.

I vote _____________ in Case # _________

Choose one of the words in parenthesis below:

(GUILTY) (NOT GUILTY) - Date _____________

Write Your ID Code Number here: _______

“Guilty” means the accused shall be punished.

“Not Guilty ”means no punishment for the accused.

I vote _____________ in Case # _________

Choose one of the words in parenthesis below:

(GUILTY) (NOT GUILTY) - Date _____________

Write Your ID Code Number here: _______

“Guilty” means the accused shall be punished.

“Not Guilty ”means no punishment for the accused.

I vote _____________ in Case # _________

Choose one of the words in parenthesis below:

(GUILTY) (NOT GUILTY) - Date _____________

Write Your ID Code Number here: _______

“Guilty” means the accused shall be punished.

“Not Guilty ”means no punishment for the accused.

I vote _____________ in Case # _________

Choose one of the words in parenthesis below:

(GUILTY) (NOT GUILTY) - Date _____________

Write Your ID Code Number here: _______

“Guilty” means the accused shall be punished.

“Not Guilty ”means no punishment for the accused.

I vote _____________ in Case # _________

Choose one of the words in parenthesis below:

(GUILTY) (NOT GUILTY) - Date _____________

Write Your ID Code Number here: _______

“Guilty” means the accused shall be punished.

“Not Guilty ”means no punishment for the accused.

I vote _____________ in Case # _________

Choose one of the words in parenthesis below:

(GUILTY) (NOT GUILTY) - Date _____________

Write Your ID Code Number here: _______

“Guilty” means the accused shall be punished.

“Not Guilty ”means no punishment for the accused.

I vote _____________ in Case # _________

Choose one of the words in parenthesis below:

(GUILTY) (NOT GUILTY) - Date _____________

Write Your ID Code Number here: _______

“Guilty” means the accused shall be punished.

“Not Guilty ”means no punishment for the accused.

I vote _____________ in Case # _________

Choose one of the words in parenthesis below:

(GUILTY) (NOT GUILTY) - Date _____________

Write Your ID Code Number here: _______

“Guilty” means the accused shall be punished.

“Not Guilty ”means no punishment for the accused.

Page 342: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

309

Form TJ-113, "GUILTY" VERDICT FORM .

(NOTE: Staple together Page 1 and 2 of this Form when inserting on Form TJ-136)

This part (Part “A” ) shall be pre-filled in by the Clerk of the Trial Court

“REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES

BEFORE THE ___________TRIAL COURT OF ________________

Branch _____________

Municipality/City/Province__________________________________

CRIMINAL CASE NUMBER _________________________

The People of the Philippines, Plaintiff versus _____________________, the Accused,

FOR THE CRIME OF ____________________________________________________

This part (Part “B” ) shall be filled in by the Jury Foreman with help of fellow Jurors. This will then be

submitted by the Jury Foreman to the Jury Presiding Judge for Reading of the Verdict by his Clerk of Court.

Date Today: ____________________

Instruction: Use this form if the number of “Guilty” votes is seven (7), or more than the “Not Guilty” votes.

The JURY finds the accused, (name) _______________________________________, of the crime of (name ofcrime) _______________________, GUILTY as charged by the total of _____ GUILTY VOTES against ______NOT GUILTY VOTES, after a thorough and careful deliberation of the members of the Jury.

A. The Jury has found and considered the following AGGRAVATING CIRCUMSTANCES which the Jury

considered not necessary for the accused in attaining the desired result of his crime: (Mark “None” on the blank

line, if none.)

1. _______________________________________________________________________________________

2. _______________________________________________________________________________________

3. _______________________________________________________________________________________(Cross out unused blanks above)

Page One

(Continue on Page 2)

Page 343: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

310

B. The Jury found the following MITIGATING CIRCUMSTANCES which the Jury considered to have caused

less sever suffering of the victim in committing his crime. (Mark “None” on the blank line, if none.)

1. _______________________________________________________________________________________

2. _______________________________________________________________________________________

3. _______________________________________________________________________________________(Cross out unused blanks above)

Respectfully submitted by: Reviewed for count correctness by two jurors:

Foreman (x)_________________ x________ & x_________

(Sign only with ICN) (Sign only with ICN)

NOTE: JURORS NEED NOT, OR SHOULD NOT

BE FORCED TO, EXPLAIN THEIR DECISION OR VERDICT.

Jurors are Sovereign. Jury Instruction No. (67), Form TJ-108, similar in concept

that they cannot be required to explain when they voted to elect a public official.

- End of Form -

Page 344: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

311

Form TJ-114, "NOT GUILTY" VERDICT FORM .

This part (Part “A” ) shall be prefilled in by the Clerk of the Trial Court

“REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES

BEFORE THE ___________TRIAL COURT OF ________________

Branch _____________

Municipality/City/Province__________________________________

CRIMINAL CASE NUMBER _________________________

The People of the Philippines, Plaintiff versus _____________________, the Accused,

FOR THE CRIME OF ___________________________________________

This part (Part “B” ) shall be filled in by the Jury Foreman with help of fellow Jurors. This will then be

submitted by the Jury Foreman to the Jury Presiding Judge for Reading of the Verdict by his Clerk of Court.

Date Today: ____________________

Instruction: Use this form if the number of “Not Guilty” votes is six (6), or more than the “Guilty” Votes.

The JURY finds the accused (name), _______________________________ for (name of crime) ________________

NOT GUILTY of the crime charged by the total of _____ NOT GUILTY VOTES against ______ GUILTY VOTES after

a thorough and careful deliberation of the members of the Jury.

Respectfully submitted by: Reviewed for count correctness by two jurors:

Foreman (x)_________________ x________ & x_________

(Sign only with ICN) (Sign only with ICN)

NOTE: JURORS NEED NOT, OR SHOULD NOT

BE FORCED TO, EXPLAIN THEIR DECISION OR VERDICT.

Jurors are Sovereign. Jury Instruction No. (67), Form TJ-108, similar in concept

that they cannot be required to explain when they voted to elect a public official.

- End of Form -

Page 345: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

312

Form TJ-115, SUMMONS DISOBEDIENCE REGISTRY

_____________ TRIAL COURT OF __________________

Address ________________________________________

Mun/City/Province________________________________

Page ________

SUMMONS DISOBEDIENCE REGISTRY (SDR)

(Paper Size: 8-1/2 by 11" - Temporarily Keep in a 3-Ring Binder - Book bind upon reaching 2-inch thickness)

Entry in this Registry shall be conclusive proof that the OSC has been properly served.

OSC# for

Form

TJ-105

Original

Summons

Number

Name of Citizen

Summons was Issued to

Date of

Failed

Appearance

Date O S C

Was Issued

O S C

Appearance

Date

How O S C

Was Resolved

Address

Mun/City/Province

Address

Mun/City/Province

Address

Mun/City/Province

Address

Mun/City/Province

Address

Mun/City/Province

Address

Mun/City/Province

Address

Mun/City/Province

Page 346: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

313

Form TJ-116, PETITION & ORDER FORM FOR CONTEMPT OF COURT WITH

NOTICE OF INTENT TO EXECUTE WARRANT OF ARREST

Republic of the Philippines

_________ TRIAL COURT OF __________________

Address: ______________________________________

Mun/City/Province: _________________________________

(Telephone _______________ Fax _______________)

PETITION FOR CONTEMPT OF COURT

WITH NOTICE OF INTENT TO EXECUTE WARRANT OF ARREST

Contempt Citation No. ______________

(Obtain the number from Form TJ-117)

THE HONORABLE PRESIDING JUDGE:

ON MY OATH, I declare under penalty of perjury that the information given in the following paragraphs 1, 2, and3, of this Petition are true and correct. I request that the Respondent, named below, a resident of the Jury District overwhich this Court has jurisdiction, be cited for contempt with notice of intent to serve warrant of arrest if Respondentfails to voluntarily surrender within five (5) days from date of receipt of its citation for contempt of court for disobedienceto a summons to serve for jury duty and for disregarding an order to show cause for [_]-his [_]-her failure to appearfor jury duty:

Name of Respondent: _______________________ Voter Registration# ______________

Address: _________________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________

1. On (date) _____________________ Summons Number ______________, on Form TJ-103, I mailed to the

Respondent requiring [_]-him [_]-her to appear at the office of the undersigned as Jury Commissioner of this Court for

consideration to be chosen to serve as a juror in a jury trial on a criminal case on (date) __________________. The

Respondent failed to appear and neither did [_]-he [_]-she call the herein Commissioner the reason for Respondent's

failure to fulfill [_]-his [_]-her obligation to serve for jury duty. The summons was duly registered in Form TJ-104, Page

_____, of the Summons Registry Book.

2. On (date) ____________________ an ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE requiring the Respondent to appear before

this court on (date) ____________________ to explain the reason for [_]-his [_]-her failure to appear for [_]-his [_]-her

summons to serve as a juror. Respondent was warned in the Order To Show Cause that should [_]-he [_]-she fail or

ignore to appear, [_]-he [_]-she will be cited for contempt of court and that the penalty imposed for the citation shall be

a compulsory community service for two (2) days without pay. The Order to Show Cause was served upon said citizen

in person by a process server of this Court on (date) ____________, with Proof of Service indicated in said Order. The

Order to Show Cause was duly recorded on Form TJ-115, Page ______, of the OSC Register for Summons

Disobedience Book.

Page 347: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

314

3. The issuance of the summons and the order to show cause, all served upon the Respondent, were fully

documented in the regular course of business in this Court in our Form TJ-104, the Summons Registry Book; and Form

TJ115, the OSC Register for Summons Disobedience.

I respectfully pray before this Honorable Court that this Petition be granted.

Date of this Petition: ______________ Issued at ______________________.

Signature __________________________ Telephone: __________________

Print Name ___________________________ Title: Jury Commissioner

ORDER

This Court finds in the Petition that the Summons for Jury Duty and Order to Show Cause were issued in the

normal course of business by the Jury Commissioner and that the Respondent has shown complete disregard and

without justification for failing to obey summons for jury duty and response to the order to show cause, this Court

hereby Orders that: The Respondent be held in contempt of Court and shall suffer the penalty of performing

community service for two (2) days without pay. The Respondent is given reprieve for five (5) days to voluntarily

surrender from the date of his receipt of a copy of this Order. If Respondent fails or refuses to surrender, this Court

will issue a Warrant of Arrest upon application by the Petitioner to take the Respondent into custody.

ISSUED at (place) _____________________________ on (date) _______________, BY:

Signature ________________ Print Name __________________ Title: Presiding Judge

SERVICE OF THIS ORDER

From: The Office of the Jury Commissioner - Telephone: _______________

Name of Court: _____________ Trial Court of ____________ Branch _________

Address of Court: __________________________________________________

Mun/City/Province: _________________________________________________

To: ______________________________________, Process Server

Name of Office: _________________________________ Telephone _________________

Address: _______________________________________________________________

_______________________________________________________________

GREETINGS:

You are hereby ordered to serve the foregoing CONTEMPT CITATION AND NOTICE OF INTENT TO SERVE

Page 348: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

315

ARREST WARRANT to the Respondent named in the above Petition and Order. Thereafter, accomplish the proofof service of this document by filling in the needed information as called for below and promptly return when

completed to the undersigned:

Signature _______________________ Print Name_________________ Title: JURY COMMISSIONER

PROOF OF SERVICE

[_]- I CERTIFY under penalty of perjury that I have personally served the foregoing citation to the person at theaddress and time indicated below. I am an authorized process server in the organization or office as indicated

below my signature in this certification.

Name of Person Served- ________________________________ Telephone _________________________

If received by another person, name of such person _______________________________________________

Relationship of such person receiving the citation __________________________________________________

Address of the person receiving the citation ______________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________

Date the citation was served ________________ Time served ______________ ___. M.

[_]- I personally attempted to serve the above citation to the person named therein twice: The first attempt was

made on (date) _____________ at __________ __ M. and the second attempt was made on (date)

________________ at __________ __ M. On both attempts, I failed to effect the required service for the reason

that

_________________________________________________________________________________________

_________________________________________________________________________________________.

_________________________________________________________________________________________

_________________________________________________________________________________________

I DECLARE under penalty of perjury with liability for obstruction of justice that this information is true and correct

and that this failure to serve the herein citation has not been caused by any conspiracy between the person to be

served or with any third party and the undersigned.

Date of this certification: _________________________. Issued at ___________________________________

Signature of Process Server (X) _______________________________ Telephone ______________________

Printed Name _________________________________ Rank or Title ________________________________

Name of Organization or Office ________________________________________________________________

Address __________________________________________________________________________________

_________________________________________________________________________________________

- End of Form -

Page 349: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

316

Form TJ-117, DOCKET FOR CONTEMPT CITATION AND NOTICE

OF INTENT TO EXECUTE WARRANT OF ARREST.

"Republic of the Philippines

______________ COURT OF __________________

Branch _________ - Telephone _________________

Address ____________________________________

Mun/City/Province ____________________________

Page _________

(Paper Size: 8-1/2 by 11" - Temporarily Keep in a 3-Ring Binder - Book bind upon reaching 2-inch thickness)

Contempt

Citation #

for use in

Form TJ-116

Date

Citation

Was Issued

NAME OF RESPONDENT

ID # Of

Disobeyed

SUMMONS

Date of

Failed OSC

Appearance

Name of

Process

Server

Date

Citation

Was Served

(Ask Server)

- End of Form -

Page 350: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

317

Form TJ-118, APPLICATION FOR ISSUANCE, AND

EXECUTION OF WARRANT OF ARREST,

"Republic of the Philippines

_____________ TRIAL COURT OF ___________

Branch __________ Telephone _______________

Address __________________________________________

Mun/City/Province __________________________________

APPLICATION FOR ISSUANCE, AND

EXECUTION, OF WARRANT OF ARREST

Warrant of Arrest No.

(Obtain the number from Form TJ-120 )

THE HONORABLE PRESIDING JUDGE:

ON MY OATH, I declare under penalty of perjury that the information given in the following

paragraphs 1, 2, 3, and 4, of this Petition are true and correct. I respectfully apply for the issuance and

execution of a warrant of arrest for contempt of court against the Respondent, a resident of the Jury

District over which this Honorable Court has jurisdiction, for disobedience to a summons to serve for jury

duty and for disregarding an order to show cause for [_]-his [_]-her failure to appear for jury duty:

1. The personal information about the Respondent is as follows:

Name _________________________________ Voter ID Registration # ____________________

Number and name of street address ____________-____________________________________

Zip/Barrio/Municipality/City/Provincial address _________________________________________

2. On (date) _______________, this Court had issued a citation for contempt of court with notice

of intention to execute a warrant of arrest against the respondent under Contempt Citation Number

________________. The said Citation was recorded on Page No. _____ of the Docket for Contempt

Citation and Notice of Intent to Execute Warrant of Arrest pursuant to Section 13(m), Rule 3, of the Rules

of the Jury System.

3. In the Citation, the Respondent was given a reprieve of five (5) days to voluntarily surrender and

to commence service of [_]-his [_]-her penalty as imposed in the contempt citation.

4. The citation with notice of intent to arrest was served upon the Respondent on (date)

___________ by _____________________, a Process Server. The proof of service is herewith attached

and marked as Exhibit “1" and made part of this Application. More than five (5) days, excluding

Saturdays, Sundays and Holidays, have now elapsed since the Respondent received the said citation and

Page 351: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

318

notice and the Respondent has failed and still continue to fail to voluntarily surrender in defiance to the

lawful order of this Court requiring [_]-him [_]-her to serve the penalty imposed on said Respondent.

Wherefore, it is respectfully prayed that this Application for issuance and execution of the warrant

of arrest against the Respondent be granted.

Date of this Application ________________ at (place) _______________________

Signature __________________________Printed Name _______________________________

Title: JURY COMMISSIONER Telephone ___________________________

COURT ORDER TO EXECUTE WARRANT OF ARREST

PREMISES CONSIDERED, the Court finds the Application meritorious, and said Application is

hereby approved. Let a Warrant of Arrest be issued and promptly executed to take the Respondent into

custody.

Date of this Order _______________ issued at (place) ______________________

Signature ____________________________ Printed Name ______________________________

Title: Presiding Judge

- End of Form -

Book entry on Form TJ- 120Verified by: ______________

(Judge shall not sign, if not verified.)

Page 352: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

319

Form TJ-119, WARRANT OF ARREST FOR CONTEMPT OF COURT

"Republic of the Philippines_____________ TRIAL COURT OF ___________

Branch __________ Telephone _______________Address __________________________________________

Mun/City/Province __________________________________

Warrant of Arrest No. _______ Contempt Citation No. _______

(Obtain new number in Form TJ-120) (Find previous number in Form) TJ-117)

WARRANT OF ARREST FOR CONTEMPT OF COURT

To: ______________________________________, Arrest Warrant Officer

Name of Unit: ______________________________________ Telephone ____________________

Address: ________________________________________________________________________

________________________________________________________________________

GREETINGS:

YOU ARE COMMANDED to serve the herein Warrant of Arrest to seize and take into custody the

accused person named below:

Name of Subject of Arrest - ______________________________ Voter's ID __________________

Home Address - ___________________________________________________________________

___________________________________________________________________

And bring forth said person before this court the next business day following his arrest. A RETURN of this

warrant shall be promptly made to the Court identifying the individual seized and arrested.

Issued at (place) ________________________________ on (date) ______________________.

Signature __________________________

Print Name _________________________

Title Presiding Judge

- End of Form -

Book entry on Form TJ- 120Verified by: ______________

(Judge shall not sign, if not verified.)

Page 353: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

320

Form TJ-120, RECORD OF ASSIGNED WARRANT OF ARREST AGAINST

DISOBEDIENT CITIZENS ON SUMMONS FOR JURY DUTY

"Republic of the Philippines

_____________ TRIAL COURT OF ___________

Branch __________ Telephone _______________

Address __________________________________________

Mun/City/Province __________________________________

Page _______

Number for

Warrant of

Arrest in

Form TJ-119

Date

Warrant

Was Issued

Name of

Respondent

Contempt

Citation #

from

Form TJ-117

Date Assigned

to Arresting

Officer

Result or Status

of Warrant

of Arrest

Name of

Arresting Officer - > Telephone - >

Name of

Arresting Officer - > Telephone - >

Name of

Arresting Officer - > Telephone - >

Name of

Arresting Officer - > Telephone - >

Name of

Arresting Officer - > Telephone - >

Name of

Arresting Officer - > Telephone - >

Name of

Arresting Officer - > Telephone - >

Name of

Arresting Officer - > Telephone - >

Name of

Arresting Officer - > Telephone - >

- End of Form -

Page 354: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

321

Form TJ-121. (Reserved for Future Use by the Supreme Court in Creating the

The Resource for CRIMINAL JURY INSTRUCTION)

This Table will be expansive as each new decisions of the Supreme Court

comes up, similar to the SCRA citations.

You may refer to the California Criminal Jury Instruction as a study material how to

set up the Philippine Resources of Decisions at:

http://www.courts.ca.gov/partners/documents/calcrim_juryins.pdf

Page 355: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

322

Form TJ-122, Instruction For Civil Jury Trial Proceedings. This form consists of 3

important parts and designated as Part “A”, Part “B” and Part “C”. All three

parts shall be visited by the Presiding Judge, the Plaintiff’s Counsel, and the

Defendant’s Counsel, in preparing for the Jury Trial.

"Republic of the Philippines

_________ Court ________________

Address_____________________________________

Mun/City/Province _______________________________________

CIVIL CASE NO. __________

PART "A"

INSTRUCTION FOR THE COURT AND

FOR THE PARTIES OR THEIR COUNSELS

Civil jury trials may be more complex than criminal trials. In view of this circumstance, the parties or

their lawyers may stipulate before the Presiding Judge to redefine or limit the qualifications of jurors they

would mutually agree to sit as jurors. Example of these civil cases are, including but not limited to, medical

malpractice, Commercial Claims, Aviation, among others. They may target a certain educated group of

knowledgeable citizens or at least college graduates who would be more familiar with the intricacies and

terms related to the type of the civil case at hand and to whom application for jury service will be announce.

The names of those who have applied shall then be entered in a raffle bin from which the name of each

juror shall be picked and be subject to challenge at the impaneling of the juryg. The stipulation shall further

state the sharing of the payment of the jurors fee and other possible expenses relating to the trial and the

parties shall be both required to deposit the estimated cost of the civil jury trial. In simple tort claims as

may be determined by the Presiding Judge and the opposing counsels, jurors may be chosen from

potential jurors in criminal cases.

One or two days the actual Civil Jury Trial Proceedings begins, the Presiding Judge (or “PJ”), the

parties or their respective attorneys shall schedule an “in chamber conference” to frame a Joint Jury

Instruction for issuance to the jury to guide the members of the jury on how to follow the sequence, to

understand the proceedings and the evidence presented by each party during the jury trial. If a party is

represented by an attorney, his attorney shall be required in his behalf, not the party himself, to participate

in the In Chamber Conference with the Judge. The conference shall be held confidentially and no other

person or public official shall be permitted to partake in this proceeding. Presence of represented parties

and witness are not required. The actual civil jury trial proceedings begins with the impaneling of the jury.

One of the important purposes of this conference is to avoid the requiring of jurors from waiting the

formulation of the Joint Jury Instruction. The time of the jurors are just as precious as the time of the

professionals in disposing of this matter.

In preparing the Joint Jury Instruction, consult Form TJ-126 for local jurisprudence.

The format of the Joint Jury Instruction:

Page 356: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

323

The Joint Jury Instruction

Role of the Judge at the “In Chamber Conference”:

1. In conference with both parties or their attorneys, plaintiff and defendant, the judge shall require

each party to state his objective about his case, the law and evidence to be relied by the party to prove

his case one at a time with each party starting with the plaintiff and followed by the defendant.

2. The presiding judge shall consolidate the proposed jury instructions as presented by the

respective parties for issuance and reading before the jury. A jury instruction is a set of simplified definition

of a legal or non-legal but unfamiliar term, law, rule, legal dictum, phrase, sentence, provision of law or the

constitution and followed in parenthesis “(__)” the legal or original reference or citation of the term, law,

rule, etc. .

3. The plaintiff and defendant shall submit to the PJ their respective proposed Jury Instructions.

The Plaintiff’s instructions shall be titled: “Plaintiff’s Proposed Jury Instruction”. The Plaintiff must

attach Form TJ-127, its Bill of Particulars for its claim. Each plaintiff’s instruction shall be numbered

consecutively from “100" through “499" with prefix letter “P”. Example if his first instruction is the word

“award” and his first number is “100". Assume further that the legal source of the word “award” is Article

2232 of the Philippine Civil Code. This Instruction shall be identified and written as:

“P-100, Award - If you find in the evidence that the defendant acted fraudulently, you must issue a

judgment of award in favor of the plaintiff against the defendant (Article 2232, Civil Code of the

Philippines).

If plaintiff’s second instruction is about “Fraud”, this instruction shall be written as:

“P-101, Fraud - Plaintiff is entitled to an award of exemplary damages against the defendant if

plaintiff’s evidence show that the defendant acted fraudulently in performing his obligation to the plaintiff

(G.R. No. 114791. May 29, 1997, Go & Go, vs Ong & Ong).

The Defendant’s instruction shall be titled: “Defendant’s Proposed Jury Instruction”. If the Defendant

has a counter-claim, he/she/it must attach Form TJ-128, indicating his Counter-Bill of Particulars, against

the Plaintiff. The defendant shall use the prefex letter “D” followed by his instruction number. Each

instruction by the defendant shall be numbered consecutively beginning with “500" through “999" with

prefix letter “D” - Example: D-500; D-501; Etc. His instruction shall be written in similar fashion as the

plaintiff’s. He should review carefully the plaintiff’s complaint and his own answer thereto. From there he

shall formulate his instruction based on the defenses in his answer and each of his instruction must be

accompanied (in parenthesis) the citations of points and authorities to support his instruction.

Advisory Note (Not mandatory): READ BUT DO NOT COPY to prevent copyright violation. It may be

helpful to peruse the newly up-dated California Civil Jury Instruction which is found in the following web

site: http://www.courts.ca.gov/partners/documents/caci_2015_edition.pdf (copy/paste to ensure in

targeting the correct URL) in preparing the Joint Civil Jury Trial Instructions.

Page 357: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

324

Role of the Plaintiff at the “In Chamber Conference:

The plaintiff shall submit to the presiding judge his prepared written proposals as his instructions

using Form TJ-127 for submission to th jury as a guide to indicate the following items to prove his claim

or case:

1. Objective (meaning what does he want from the defendant?) based on his

pleading complaint he has filed earlier in court);

2. The evidence and number of witnesses he will present; and

3. Instruction in simplified terms that defines the law, leading decision,

jurisprudence, or contract, relied by plaintiff for his or her claim.

Role of the Defendant at the “In Chamber Conference:

Likewise, the defendant shall submit to the presiding judge a written outline of his defense/s also

showing the following items:

1. Objective (meaning why the plaintiff has no right to collect or seek redress from

the defendant) usually based on his response pleadings he as filed earlier in

court;

2. The evidence and number of witnesses he will present; and

3. Instruction in simplified terms that defines the law, leading decision,

jurisprudence, or contract, relied by defendant to defeat plaintiff’ claim.

If the defendant has a counter-claim or cross-claim, the defendant shall likewise formulate his or

her Instruction by submitting Form TJ-128 in simplified terms that defines the law, leading decision,

jurisprudence, or contract, relied by plaintiff for his or her claim.

If there are other adverse parties, the same pattern shown above shall be used by that party in

outlining his objective/s about his case which he must submit to the presiding judge. The PJ shall assign

to each additional parties their jury instruction numbers from 1000 through 1449; 1500 through 1599; etc.,

and their respective letter prefixes.

If a counter-claim or a cross claim is presenting by the defendant or any third party, the Presiding

Judge shall explain to the Jury the meaning and nature of a “Counter-Claim” or a “Cross-Claim”.

Upon completion and approval by the PJ of the foregoing Joint Jury Instruction (which must include

the proposed instruction by both parties), the Plaintiff’s, and Defendant’s Counsels, and before

proceeding to Part “B” below , the Presiding Judge shall then issue an order to call the Jury

Commissioner to bring in 29 jurors for empaneling.

Page 358: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

325

PART "B"

INSTRUCTION FOR THE CIVIL JURY TRIAL PROCEEDINGS

(Must be translated contemporaneously during the trial

from English to the local dialect of the jurors, if necessary)

This instruction shall be read to the jury prior to the presentation of the evidence at the trial.

At the trial, a simultaneous translator may be employed to translate the Instruction as it is being

delivered. Part of the training of a court translator is to read this instruction in advance so that he will be

ready with terms to translate unfamiliar words. It may be delivered in a combination of both English and

the local dialect by the judge to make the proceedings substantially understood by the jurors as follows:

"Ladies and Gentlemen of the Jury:

"You are now about to hear the presentation of the evidence in this case. There are two opposingparties in this trial. The Plaintiff and the Defendant.

“The Plaintiff is the party who is seeking an award (or restitution) from the defendant. “The Defendant is the party who is resisting or denying the complaint or claim of the plaintiff.” (If

there are other contending parties such as a counter-claimant or cross-claimant, the Presiding Judgeshould state that fact and instruct the jury accordingly.)

“It is a common practice that a plaintiff or a defendant is represented by an attorney or counsel.The word counsel has the same meaning as attorney. When I mention of plaintiff’s counsel, it is the sameas plaintiff’s attorney. And so with defense counsel is the same as defense attorney.

“I understand that you have no special training in law and it is for this reason that you qualified tosit as a juror. The jury system has been specially instituted for the general public to participate in ourjustice system in accordance with our democratic form of government. Juries are not necessarily madefor lawyers. In order for you to learn your job as jurors in this case, I instruct you to listen carefully on whatI read or say to you. By the rules of the jury system, legal terms have been redefined into simple terms,words and phrases. To make those legal terms even easier to understand, we have employed a trialtranslator who will translate my words, and the words of the attorneys, into your common local dialect.

"First, I would want you to learn about the word "Witness." A "witness" is the person who is swornto testify to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth in this court. Normally, he/she is requiredto sit in a witness chair or stand to state the information he/she is asked for the purpose of this trial thatyou are about to hear by way of answering questions from the Plaintiff’s Counsel, the Defense Counsel,or by this Presiding Judge.

"Therefore, if you hear that same witness speaking outside this court and it happens that you wereriding together in the same bus with him and you heard him talking about the same case he testified to butwith a different story than what he said in court, you must not give any value (or you should not mind) towhat he said at the bus. Important reminder : This is my instruction to you. You must not talk or arguewith him and you do not need to listen to him. And so, at the time this case reaches the stage wherein youare asked to deliberate on it, you must not tell your fellow jurors about the different story the witness saidthat you heard at the bus. Why? Because he was not sworn at the bus and he was not sitting on thewitness chair. The bus has no witness chair in the first place.

Page 359: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

326

"At this time, I want you to know two important words. Their meaning are very different from eachother. They are not the same. You cannot substitute one for the other.

"The first word is “Opinion” and the second is the word “Evidence.”

"The “opinion” is what you hear from the mouth of the Plaintiff’s counsel or of what the defensecounsel says about his case or his opponent’s case or from the mouth of some else who is not a witness.An opinion is not evidence. You are not allowed to use an opinion to make your decision in this case. From time to time, by way of instructions, I will tell you which one is an evidence and which is not.Exception: You may consider an opinion like an evidence if:

(a) It is an "Expert Opinion",

(b) The person stating his opinion must have been sworn in to tell the truth, etc. and must havebeen seated in the witness chair and has answered questions from the Plaintiff’s Counsel orfrom the Defense;

(c) It is shown that the person making the opinion had sufficient training or experience on thesubject he testifies to; AND

(d) It was admitted into evidence by the presiding judge of the court; and, again,

"The “evidence” is what you hear from the mouth of the witness who was sworn in and he isrequired to talk in the witness chair during a court session. The evidence is your basis to make yourdecision in this case.

"Another thing you must learn about "evidence" is that it consists of several things: The statementor word of mouth by a witness is evidence. An object or thing related to a case in court to prove a factwhen identified by a witness is evidence. Objects are usually marked or referenced with exhibitidentification, such as Exhibit "A", Exhibit "B", Exhibit "1", and others. Evidence, therefore, is a combinationof what the witness said, an object and identified as an exhibit to prove or disprove a fact.

"The words and statements of attorneys are not evidence. Attorneys only act as guides to help youfind and understand the evidence. If there is variance or difference between what the attorney says overwhat the witness says, you must rely on what the witness said - not what the attorney said.

"Before the attorneys will present their witness or evidence, each of them will make an openingstatement in favor of their side of the case.

"The plaintiff’s attorney usually delivers his opening statement, and the lawyer of the accused may,or many not, make an opening statement.

"At this point, I will ask you a question. You must not be afraid to give me a wrong answer. Thisis a part of your instruction and it is imperative that you learn it now. My question is this:

"When the lawyer delivers or speaks of his opening statement, did you hear an evidence or did youhear an opinion? Right or wrong, I would like to hear from."

(Presiding judge should emphasize that the words coming from the mouth of the lawyer is only an opinion and it is not an evidence).

"Again, the thing you should remember is that an evidence can be accepted only when it is statedby the witness while testifying in the witness chair during a court hearing or trial. The subsequentstatement, therefore, of the witness who speaks at another location after he testified in court such as whenhe speaks over the radio or television show or anywhere with another version than what he testified to in

Page 360: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

327

court is not the evidence. What the witness said over the radio or television station is a matter of opinionand of no evidentiary value because he was not sworn to tell the truth of what he said at the radio stationor at the television show or anywhere else even if such person is the most powerful government officialof the land.

"Another evidence you must know is "Circumstantial evidence." Circumstantial evidence is a factor event that can be used to infer or presume another fact or another event. It is an indirect evidence, anevidence the witness did not see, but it implies that something occurred or exists but does not directlyprove it. It is a proof of one or more facts from which one can find another fact. An example of that factis while you were sleeping during the night it rain very hard. When you walk up and looked over thewindow the ground was very wet and a neighbor of yours said “it rain very hard last night”. You believedyour neighbor’s statement because you saw the effect of what he stated.

"You may also hear an objection to an evidence by an opposing attorney saying that the evidenceis a "hearsay evidence." In ordinary meaning, a hearsay evidence is like a second hand evidence wherethe witness is stating a fact or event based on what he heard from another person or witness and not onwhat the witness himself has directly and actually seen, heard, or felt of the occurrence or existence of afact or event he is testifying to. You must not believe a hearsay evidence and I confirm it is if it is objectedto by an opposing party.

"In the course of the trial, an expert witness may be called to demonstrate or describe a "ScientificEvidence." He is more of a teacher about the underlying scientific theory and instrument implementingtheory. He is called in to bring out opinions that a theory is valid and the instruments involved are reliable.The witness must be accredited as an expert witness, which may require academic qualifications orspecific training. You may or you may not accept his explanation as viewed from the logic or natural resultof his statements.

"Remember the rule. Evidence may be acceptable only if allowed by the judge to be admitted intothe record and while the witness speaks on the witness stand. So, if you hear any body talking about afact, not sworn and not seated in a witness chair or stand, regardless of how prestigious or powerful heis, even if he may be the highest somebody of your community or who said "I am Chief of Police So andSo, and I actually saw the happening of the crime or event," what you hear is not evidence. What youheard is an unsworn declaration from someone who cannot be prosecuted if his or her statement is a lieor a statement of falsehood outside of the court trial.

“There is an exception wherein an evidence will be admitted without the need of a testimony by awitness. It is called “Stipulated Evidence”. Its other name is “Agreed Evidence” wherein both the plaintiff’sattorney and the defense attorney will agree with the approval of the judge that the evidence be admittedwithout being testified to by a sworn witness. If such an evidence will come up, you will be told that it isa "stipulated evidence" upon which you believe to prove or disprove the existence or not of a thing, fact,or event.

“Now, here is another word I want you to know at heart. The word is the “law” of the case you aregoing to hear. In a civil case such as this present case, the law of the case is the law according to whatI state to you or the contract between the parties. However, a contract entered into by two or more partiescontrary to law or public policy is not a contract and cannot be made the “law” between the parties. It isan invalid contract.

“You must remain neutral and you must not make a final mental decision in this case until up to thelast minute when the time comes for you to cast your secret vote to make a jury verdict or judgment.Before making your decision you must first carefully and thoroughly deliberate or discuss with each otherthis matter with your fellow jurors in your jury room. If we are not able to finish this trial at the end of thisday, you must not think anything about this case, and have a good night sleep. You are not allowed to talkto each other among yourselves for your private deliberation. It is never allowed and if I will learn that youviolated this rule, I will hold you in direct contempt of court and I will order the Sheriff, the person in uniform

Page 361: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

328

in this court, to keep you in jail in the duration of this trial.

“The next phrase you must learn is “preponderance of evidence .” In civil trials generally, the proofrequired to prove a fact is by “preponderance of evidence” or the greater balance between twoprobabilities. Think of our common estimation of 50-50. Whoever provides additional proof of 1 to raisehis point to 51 has achieved his “preponderance of evidence”.

“Another phrase I instruct you to learn is “Clear and convincing evidence” . This is a higherdegree of proof compared to preponderance of evidence. It is required in proving a fact in civil tort cases.Tort cases refers to injury or property damage claims arising from the recklessness or gross negligenceof the responsible party that led to an accident. To prove something by "clear and convincing evidence",the party with the burden of proof must convince the trier of fact that it is substantially more likely than notthat the thing is in fact true. As a jury in this case, you are the trier of fact. If this were a solo judge trial,the judge would be the trier of fact. In the 50-50 scale of probabilities, Clear and convincing evidencewould be somewhere around 60 and/or higher probability.

“The other phrase I am instructing you to learn is the “Proof beyond reasonable doubt” .[For criminal case only: This is the standard required by the prosecution in criminal cases within anadversarial system. This means that the proposition being presented by the government must be provento the extent that there is no "reasonable doubt" in the mind of a reasonable person that the defendant isguilty. Usually, reasonable doubt is defined as "any doubt which would make a reasonable person hesitatein the most important of his or her affairs." A balance in the scale of 50-50, where the probability of 90 maynot satisfy the standard for proof beyond reasonable doubt. It should be much more than 90.]

[For civil case only: In the present case, proof beyond reasonable doubt is not required for you in orderfor the plaintiff to prevail in his/her/its claim.]

Both of the parties will present or show to you their respective evidence. Stated in another way, theevidence consists of the testimony of the witness and the exhibits that each party will introduce throughthe identification by their witnesses. The exhibits come in different forms such as a document or a simplepiece of paper or anything you hear and see or shown to you by the witness who is testifying in answerto the questions in the course of this trial. Once an exhibit is identified by the witness, it is promptlydesignated as an, example “Exhibit 1 or Exhibit 2, and others.

Sometimes the exhibits were already marked earlier with such identifications. Remember thatexhibits are not evidence if they are not identified by the witness at the witness stand. Example: If you hadseen the exhibits with the markings and being carried into the court room and the attorney told the jury,“this is Exhibit 1", but it was not identified by a witness on the witness stand, that “Exhibit 1" even if it wasmarked is not evidence. It is only made as an evidence when it is actually identified by the witness or whenit is admitted as a "Stipulated Evidence."

The presentation of the evidence will be shown in the following sequence:

The party who has the first right to present his evidence is the Plaintiff through his/her/its attorneyor counsel.

He will call his first witness to the witness stand and have his witness sworn to tell the truth, thewhole truth and nothing but the truth and required to sit in the witness chair. The Plaintiff’s attorney willthen ask all questions to the witness to obtain his statements or testimony. Along the way, he will showdocuments or things or items to the witness which are marked with Exhibit identifications to prove his case.The act of the Plaintiff’s attorney to ask questions to his own witness is called “Direct Examination.”

In "direct examination," the witness that is being asked to answer questions is the witness whois in favor of the party or his attorney who is asking the questions. In direct examination, the attorney orthe party asking questions is not allowed to ask a leading question to his own witness.

Page 362: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

329

A "leading question" usually calls for an answer that is either "Yes" or "No". The question itselfalready contains the answer. It is like putting the answer in the mouth of the witness. Often times, aleading question is objected to by the opposing attorney. If there is an objection to a leading question, youmust listen to the instruction of the judge who will tell you either to accept or forget about the answer asif it is not an answer at all.

After the plaintiffs attorney’s’s direct examination is finished, the attorney for the defendant willlikewise have the right to ask questions to the witness of the plaintiff’s attorney. This act by the defenseattorney is known as “Cross-Examination.” The purpose of the cross-examination is to find anything in thedirect examination that may not be true or to find inconsistencies on what the witness said. Incross-examination "leading question" is allowed. It is a question from the opposing counsel to verify howtruthful the witness was in answering questions during his direct examination by his own friendly attorneyor party.

When the cross-examination by the attorney for the defendant is done, the plaintiff’s attorney maycontinue asking questions to the same witness on matters that were brought out during the crossexamination. This process is called “Redirect Examination”, to fix or rehabilitate the testimony of his ownwitness if needed.

When all the witnesses of the plaintiff’s attorney had already testified with direct examination, crossexamination, and re-direct examination, then, it becomes the turn of the defendant with his lawyer to callhis own witness for his own defense. This is the time when the attorney for the defendant will conduct hisown “Direct Examination” upon his own witness.

After the lawyer for the defendant is through or finished with his direct examination, the plaintiff’sattorney will in turn have the right to “Cross-Examine” the witness of the defendant. And when he is donewith his cross-examination, the attorney for the defendant may likewise do a “re-direct examination” on hiswitness to clarify new matters that came about during the cross-examination.

In the course of the direct examination, or cross-examination, of a witness, the opposing attorneymay object to the question of the other counsel. In such event, you must pay attention of what I will sayas presiding judge. I will either sustain the objection or I will deny the objection.

When I sustain the objection, it means that I do not want to allow the question to be answered. Ifthe witness had already answered, I will order to strike out the answer and you must therefore disregardthe answer.

When I deny the objection, it means that I will allow the question to be answered. The answer tothe question will stand or that I will say, “witness may answer.”

Another instruction I want you to remember.

There are some few instances in a civil jury trial that a member of the police or military force maybe called to testify as a witness. Very often a civilian witness is called in to testify. You are required to giveequal weight of credibility to the testimony of either witness. As to whom you will believe better than theother will depend on the logic and truthfulness of the statement of the witness as you may observebetween the testimony of such witnesses.

It is likewise usual that a witness may not be an eyewitness to the crime but he is called in to testifybecause he is considered an expert witness. He is considered to have a better education and experienceon the subject that he is testifying to. When you are confronted in believing the testimony between theexpert witness and an ordinary witness in the subject that is being talked about, you may give morecredence to the testimony of the expert witness.

If you are confronted in weighing the correctness of the testimony of an expert against the

Page 363: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

330

testimony of an eyewitness or the witness who actually saw the happening of an event on the subject beingtalked about, you may give more credence to the testimony of the eyewitness.

"To start the presentation of the evidence in this case, I ask plaintiff’s counsel to introduce himself

and the name of his client. Defendant’s counsel, please do the same.

(PJ continues the issuance of Instruction) "The plaintiff has presented a complaint to this court

seeking (payment for a sum of money) or (for some redress claiming violation of his well-being or right)

from the defendant;

“On the other hand the defendant has denied any responsibility against the plaintiff’s claim. (If

counter-claim or cross-claim is presented by the defendant, also read the appropriate instruction in the

following box/es.)

Instruction on the Counter-ClaimAdditionally, the Defendant has filed a COUNTER-CLAIM against the plaintiff. A counter-claim is a

lawsuit in which the defendant is requesting for payment of a sum of money or for damages against theplaintiff. The defendant, then, shall be required by the rules to prove his claim with his/her evidence.

Instruction on the Cross-ClaimFurthermore, the Defendant has also filed a CROSS-CLAIM. This is a situation wherein there are twoor more defendants in a case and one of the defendants files a lawsuit on the same subject lawsuit

against his own co-defendant. Sometimes, it can also happen when there are two or more plaintiffs inthe same case and one plaintiff files a coss-claim against his/her/its co-plaintiff.

“The plaintiff and the defendant now are asking your wisdom to resolve their conflictingclaims. Before you may do so, I want you to listen and understand carefully every word in thefollowing instructions I am about to issue to you:

(All INSTRUCTIONS MUST BE FORMULATED BEFORE ADDRESS ING THE JURY)

"Counsel for the plaintiff may now make his/her opening statement for the plaintiff’scase and followed by the defense counsel to do so for the defendant. You may recall in theearlier instruction that the statements of the respective counsels or attorneys are not evidenceand they are merely your guides in understanding the case.

Attorney for the Plaintiff: "Good morning/afternoon, Ladies and Gentlemen of the Jury.

(Plaintiff’s attorney to deliver his opening statem ent at this stage and promptly calls in his first witness to te stify)

“My first witness is ______________________.

The Court Clerk swears in the witness: "Do you swear to tell the truth, the whole truth and

nothing but the truth at this trial?"

Page 364: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

331

Witness answers: "I do."

Attorney for the Plaintiff shall now proceed with his questions to the witness.

1. Witness _________________ <- (Fill in blank when witness is sworn)

Witness to answer Attorney for the Plaintiff's questions.

Plaintiff’s attorney asks witness to identify Exhibit "__"; asks questions about it;

Plaintiff’s attorney asks witness to identify Exhibit "__"; asks questions about it;

Defense attorney cross-examines (asks question) on same witness;

Plaintiff Attorney’s redirect examination (asks question) on the same witness

Attorney for the Plaintiff continues with his next witness:

"My next witness is _________________ .

2. Witness_________________ <- (Fill in blank when witness is sworn)

Witness to answer Attorney for the Plaintiff's questions.

Plaintiff’s attorney asks witness to identify Exhibit "__"; asks questions about it;

Plaintiff’s attorney asks witness to identify Exhibit "__"; asks questions about it;

Defense attorney cross-examines (asks question) on same witness;

Plaintiff Attorney’s redirect examination (asks question) on the same witness

Attorney for the Plaintiff continues with his next witness:

"My last witness is _________________

3. Witness _________________ <- (Fill in blank when witness is sworn)

Witness to answer Attorney for the Plaintiff's questions.

Plaintiff’s attorney asks witness to identify Exhibit "__"; asks questions about it;

Plaintiff’s attorney asks witness to identify Exhibit "__"; asks questions about it;

Defense attorney cross-examines (asks question) on same witness;

Plaintiff Attorney’s redirect examination (asks question) on the same witness

The Judge:

Page 365: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

332

"Ladies and Gentlemen of the Jury, it is now the turn of the defense to present its

evidence. I must remind you that you must not yet make any conclusion in your mind about this

case at the present time.

"There are two things to consider before you can conclude this case and that: One, you

must first hear the evidence of the defendant, and second, you must discuss about the case only

when you are told to do so at the proper time. I must remind you again, that you must not discuss

or talk about this case with anyone, not even among with your fellow jurors at this time.

“The defense attorney may now deliver his opening statement or he may proceed to call

his witness to the stand without making an opening statement.

"Defense counsel, you may now proceed."

Defense counsel:

"Thank you, your Honor.

"Ladies and Gentlemen of the Jury, good morning/afternoon, to you all.

(Defense counsel to deliver his opening statement or directly call in his witness to testif y)

My first witness is ______________________

The Court Clerk swears in the witness: "Do you swear to tell the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth at this trial?"

Witness answers: "I do."

Defense attorney shall proceed now with his questions to the witness.

1. Witness ________________________ <- (Fill in blank when witness is sworn) Witness to answer defense attorney's questions.Defense attorney asks witness to identify Exhibit "__"; asks questions about it;

Defense attorney asks witness to identify Exhibit "__"; asks questions about it; Plaintiff’s attorney cross-examines (asks question) on same witness;Defense attorney redirect examination (asks question) on the same witness

Defense attorney continues and says: “My next witness is:”

Page 366: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

333

2. Witness ________________________ <- (Fill in blank when witness is sworn) Witness to answer defense attorney's questions.Defense attorney asks witness to identify Exhibit "__"; asks questions about it;

Defense attorney asks witness to identify Exhibit "__"; asks questions about it; Plaintiff’s attorney cross-examines (asks question) on same witness;Defense attorney redirect examination (asks question) on the same witness

Defense attorney continues and says: “My last witness is” (and sworn in):

3. Witness ________________________ <- (Fill in blank when witness is sworn) Witness to answer defense attorney's questions.Defense attorney asks witness to identify Exhibit "__"; asks questions about it;

Defense attorney asks witness to identify Exhibit "__"; asks questions about it; Plaintiff’s attorney cross-examines (asks question) on same witness;Defense attorney redirect examination (asks question) on the same witness

After the attorney for the defendant is done in presenting his witness and his exhibits, headdresses or tells the jury and the judge: "Your Honor, I have no more witness to present orexhibits to be identified."

The judge now shall ask the Attorney for the Plaintiff: "Counsel, are you presenting arebuttal witness?"

If, there is, or there is none, the judge will inform the jury accordingly.

If no more rebuttal witness is presented by the Attorney for the Plaintiff, he will thenproceed with his Closing Arguments which he must address to the Jury. He will again state hisposition regarding his side of the case.

After the delivery of the Attorney for the Plaintiff's Closing Argument, he gives his thanksto the jury and the judge.

When the Closing Arguments by the Attorney for the Plaintiff is done, the attorney for thedefendant will likewise state his Closing Arguments to overcome the allegations of the Attorneyfor the Plaintiff.

Finally, following Closing Arguments of the attorney for the defendant, the Attorney for thePlaintiff will make his sur-rebuttal against the closing arguments of the attorney for the defendant.A sur-rebuttal argument is a statement intended to overcome what was said by the defenseattorney in his closing arguments.

Page 367: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

334

The Judge now addresses the Jury:

"We still have another instruction coming up. In the mean time, I order you to have a briefrecess. While you are in recess, I will be presiding the offer of exhibits by the respective partiesto this case. Exhibits admitted into evidence will be submitted to you once you get your order fromthis court to proceed to the private deliberating room. Remember that up to this time, your mindshould remain neutral. You are reminded that you must not talk with any person even amongyourselves about this case while you are on recess. Do not stay too far from this court. You willbe called back any moment soon for further instruction.

PART "C"OFFER OF EXHIBITS

As soon as all the jurors have step out of the room for recess, the Presiding Judge shall order the

parties or their attorneys to offer their respective exhibits as well as each other's objection. The presiding

judge will then formally rule on the admissibility of the exhibits being offered. The judge shall instruct the

respective attorneys to the case, the following:

"First, let me ask the plaintiff for its exhibits. One at a time, I will identify all the exhibits as marked

and I will show them briefly, one at a time, to the defense and to which the defense counsel must state

his objection for its admission and the basis for his objections. After this process is completed, I will then

rule on the admissibility or not on the exhibits objected to by the defense;"

"The defense counsel shall act by the same process. The plaintiff has the obligation to offer its

objection specifically for each exhibits and the basis for his objection. I will then rule on the admissibility

or not on the exhibits objected to by the plaintiff;"

The Plaintiff and the Defense lawyers with the PJ will now finalize their joint instruction which they

prepared before the Jury Trial began. This final instruction in written form will then be submitted to the

Jury. It will be in the following form. It looks almost exactly the same Joint Instruction before the trial

began, except this time, there may be changes and some lines are already filled in very briefly. Upon

completion, the presiding judge shall order his clerk of court to compile in one large brown envelope, 10"

X 13" in size, the following Items:

[_] - Form TJ-123, This Final Joint Instruction to the Civil Jury;

[_] - Form TJ-124P, Plaintiff’s ballot forms (pre-cut and kept in a separate small envelope);

[_] - Form TJ-124D, Defendant’s ballot forms (pre-cut and kept in a separate small envelope);

[_] - Form TJ-125, Civil Jury Verdict’

[_] - Form TJ-139, List of Exhibits for the Plaintiff with the exhibits attached to it.

[_] - Form TJ-139, List of Exhibits for the Defendant with the exhibits attached to it.

- End of Form -

Page 368: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

335

Form TJ-123. Instruction for Submitting a Civil Case to the Civil Jury for Deliberation and Verdict.

There are 5 Stages to follow in this Form and designated as Stage “A”, “B”, “C”, “D” and

“E” which all shall be studied in days before the actual jury trial begins. The actual jury

trial begins with the impaneling of the members of the jury.

This form, and all other forms to be submitted to the jury must be translated into the common local

dialect that the jurors can speak, write, and understand. The Executive Judge of the Regional Trial

Court shall form a Committee composed of 5 citizens who are proficient both in English and the local

dialect of the district to perform the translation. The blanks in the forms shall then be filled in English

or the local dialect of the jurors or a hybrid of the two whichever is convenient for them.

The Presiding Judge will now recall the jurors

CIVIL CASE NO. _______________

"Ladies and Gentlemen of the Jury:

"Here is your Written Final Instruction in dealing with this matter. This written Instruction

is NOT EVIDENCE. It is given to you as a GUIDE ONLY on where to begin with your analysis of

the evidence for your discussion and in deciding the case. I order the Sheriff to stand by near

your deliberating room door and if you need something very important for this court to know, you

simply knock at your door and the Sheriff will knock to answer your call.

All alternate jurors in this matter shall be present in your discussion but shall not be allowed

to make comment during your deliberation and shall not be allowed to vote and to whom no ballot

shall be furnished. If, for any reason, one or any of your regular members is unable to finish with

your deliberation or is unable to write his or her ballot, you must call the Sheriff and tell him you

are unable to finish the deliberation and you want to see the judge and all parties in court. Once

back in court, shall you then inform the Presiding Judge who shall formally make an order for the

record to replace your incapacitated regular juror with the senior alternate. You will be ordered

back to continue deliberation until you make your secret voting.

Page 369: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

336

"FINAL JOINT INSTRUCTION TO THE CIVIL TRIAL JURY

The Presiding Judge shall hand this instruction with the order to contain in a brown envelope, size 10" by

13" all of the following forms for delivery to the Jury in the Jury deliberating room:

[_] - Form TJ-123, This Final Joint Instruction to the Civil Jury;

[_] - Form TJ-124P, Plaintiff’s ballot forms (pre-cut and kept in a separate small envelope);

[_] - Form TJ-124D, Defendant’s ballot forms (pre-cut and kept in a separate small envelope);

[_] - Form TJ-125, Civil Jury Verdict’

[_] - Form TJ-139, List of Exhibits for the Plaintiff with the exhibits attached to it.

[_] - Form TJ-139, List of Exhibits for the Defendant with the exhibits attached to it.

(Follow the Sequence in this Instruction)

REMINDER: THESE DOCUMENTS ARE NOT EVIDENCE THEY

ARE GUIDES ONLY FOR YOUR DISCUSSION

Ladies and Gentlemen of the Jury:

I instruct you to follow exactly all the steps below in their proper sequence in your discussion and in arriving

at your verdict.

First: DO THIS FIRST BEFORE STARTING YOUR DISCUSSION:

CHOOSE YOUR Foreman before proceeding.

Second: Special instruction for the Foreman. Stay neutral when you preside so that you will not violate

your certification which you must sign in the verdict form, Form TJ-125. Exception: You vote either way

but secretly according to your conscience tells you in the light of the evidence you have heard and saw.

No tape recording shall be allowed during your deliberation. Alternate jurors shall participate in choosing

your Foreman. Your Foreman shall be chosen only from among the regular members of the jury.

Absolute rule: An alternate juror has no power to vote to decide to reach a jury verdict and no alternate

juror shall have the power to request, demand, or force to exercise the vote of a regular juror.

Third: Your Foreman MUST read aloud this entire instruction for all of you to hear including the enclosed

Ballot forms (which must be all in blanks), the Civil Jury Verdict Form, TJ-125. DO NOT DO ANYTHING

ELSE but just read this Instruction. After reading, go back to Stage "A" and start your work: Also

absolutely important: No one else but only you, the members of this jury, must enter in the deliberation

room. You must not call by phone anyone. You are absolutely forbidden to contact any outsider for

anything you need for information. You must contact the Sheriff of this court, if someone tries to interfere

in your proceeding.

Page 370: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

337

The role of the Foreman: He/She will preside your discussion. He/She should stay neutral all

through out your proceeding, except when finally voting for the verdict which he/she do so likewise secretly

with other members; Arrange the sequence in which each one who wish to speak or to ask a question

among you. When a question is asked whether the defendant is responsible to pay the plaintiff or not, the

Foreman must call any member to answer the question and let such member speak to express his opinion.

Regardless of the conflicting or agreeing opinions expressed in the oral discussion, no one should dictate

or force his fellow jurors to follow his opinion. It is enough that other jurors have heard his opinion. What

will count are your secret votes when summed up which will become your jury verdict.

It is now your duty to carefully examine the evidence presented to you by going over them in the

order and sequence in the stages below:

STAGE "A" THE INSTRUCTION BY THE JUDGE ON THE LAWS GOVERNING THE CASE ARE

AS FOLLOWS (Spaces in Nos. 1, 2, 3, and 4 must be pre-filled prior to submission to

the Jury):

1. The law and/or the contract relied by the plaintiff for its entitlement on his/her claim against the

defendant is as follows (adopted from the plaintiff’s proposed jury instructions):

____________________________________________________________________________________

_____________________________________________________________________________________

_____________________________________________________________________________________

2. The law on punitive damages, if applicable (adopted from the plaintiff’s proposed jury

instructions) _______________________________________________________________________

____________________________________________________________________________________

_____________________________________________________________________________________

2. The law on punitive damages, if applicable (adopted from the plaintiff’s proposed jury

instructions. Must be proven with clear and convincing evidence) _______________________________

_________________________________________________________________ __________________

_____________________________________________________________________________________

4. Other laws, jurisprudence, or contract relied by the defendant for its denial to defeat the

plaintiff’s claim. ______________________________________________________________________

___________________________________________________________________________________

___________________________________________________________________________________

___________________________________________________________________________________

___________________________________________________________________________________

___________________________________________________________________________________

Page 371: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

338

___________________________________________________________________________________

STAGE "B" - PRESENTATION AND OFFER OF EVIDENCE BY THE

PLAINTIFF (Blanks below must have been filled in while

each witness was testifying during the trial):

1. Witness (Write name of witness) ______________________________________________

Testified that: (one brief sentence by plaintiff) ____________________________________

_________________________________________________________________________

Foreman should ask: "Are you convinced by the testimony of this witness? Why?

Any or more juror may answer, one at a time.

Exhibit " " showed that: (one brief sentence by plaintiff) __________________________

_________________________________________________________________________

Foreman should ask: "What can you say about this exhibit?"

Any or more juror may answer, one at a time.

Exhibit " " showed that: (one brief sentence by plaintiff) __________________________

_________________________________________________________________________

Foreman should ask: "What can you say about this exhibit?"

Any or more juror may answer, one at a time.

2. Witness (Write name of witness) _______________________________________________

Testified that: (one brief sentence by plaintiff) ____________________________________

_________________________________________________________________________

Foreman should ask: "Are you convinced by the testimony of this witness? Why?

Any or more juror may answer, one at a time.

Exhibit " " showed that: (one brief sentence by plaintiff) _________________________

_________________________________________________________________________

Foreman should ask: "What can you say about this exhibit?"

Any or more juror may answer, one at a time.

Exhibit " " showed that: (one brief sentence by plaintiff) _________________________

_________________________________________________________________________

Foreman should ask: "What can you say about this exhibit?"

Any or more juror may answer, one at a time.

3. Witness (Write name of witness) ______________________________________________

Testified that: (one brief sentence by plaintiff) ____________________________________

__________________________________________________________________ Foreman

should ask: "Are you convinced by the testimony of this witness? Why? Any or more juror

may answer, one at a time.

Exhibit " " showed that: (one brief sentence by plaintiff) __________________________

_________________________________________________________________________

Page 372: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

339

Foreman should ask: "What can you say about this exhibit?"

Any or more juror may answer, one at a time.

STAGE "C" PRESENTATION AND OFFER OF EVIDENCE BY THE ATTORNEY

OF THE DEFENDANT (Blanks below must have been filled in whileeach witness was testifying during the trial):

1. Witness (Write name of witness) ______________________________________________

Testified that: (one brief sentence by defense attorney) ____________________________

____________________________________________________________________

Foreman should ask: "Are you convinced by the testimony of this witness? Why? Any or

more juror may answer, one at a time.

Exhibit " " showed that: (one brief sentence by defense attorney) _________________

_________________________________________________________________________

Foreman should ask: "What can you say about this exhibit?"

Any or more juror may answer, one at a time.

Exhibit " " showed that: (one brief sentence by defense attorney) __________________

_________________________________________________________________________

Foreman should ask: "What can you say about this exhibit?"

Any or more juror may answer, one at a time.

2. Witness (Write name of witness) _______________________________________________

Testified that: (one brief sentence by defense attorney) ____________________________

________________________________________________________________Foreman

should ask: "Are you convinced by the testimony of this witness? Why? Any or more juror

may answer, one at a time.

Exhibit " " showed that: (one brief sentence by defense attorney) __________________

_________________________________________________________________________

Foreman should ask: "What can you say about this exhibit?"

Any or more juror may answer, one at a time.

Exhibit " " showed that: (one brief sentence by defense attorney)__________________

_________________________________________________________________________

Foreman should ask: "What can you say about this exhibit?"

Any or more juror may answer, one at a time.

Page 373: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

340

STAGE "D" - Deliberation Stage

IN THIS STAGE, YOU WILL NOW ENGAGE IN AN OVER ALL DISCUSSION OR DELIBERATION

ON THE MATTER AMONG YOURSELVES. No recording by a stenographer or by electronic

recording will be allowed. It is illegal to make a recording of any kind in your deliberation. If this

is a case wherein there is a counter-claim by the defendant, you must DISCUSS FIRST THE

CLAIM OF THE PLAINTIFF:

(1) You MUST NEVER ASK from any one who is not a

member of your group to help in your discussion.

(2) If there is a question or anything that is preventing you to proceed with your discussion, you

must send to the Presiding Judge - to no one else - a written note about your situation but

YOU MUST NOT INDICATE what your decision is going to be. You must knock at your door

to call the Sheriff to pick up your note who will bring it to the Presiding Judge. The Presiding

Judge will then confer with the Plaintiff and the Attorney for the defendant before giving out

his instruction about your note or question.

(3) Reread the instruction on the law, the aggravating, mitigating, and alternative circumstances

attending the case;

(4) Your Foreman shall at all times remain neutral and he shall schedule everyone to speak. He

must give at least 5 minutes for every speaker to make his comment. After everyone has

spoken, The Foreman will then say: "Everyone has spoken, let us now end our deliberation

and come to vote by secret ballot. Let us make no further comment on the matter and go on

with our secret voting." The Foreman shall then vote whichever way he decides.

(5) An alternate shall make NO comment in the discussion and he shall have no power to vote

to decide in reaching your jury verdict.

Page 374: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

341

STAGE "E" - Decision Stage.

THIS IS THE TIME FOR YOU AS A JURY TO DECIDE THIS CASE whether the defendant is

responsible to pay the plaintiff or not. If this is a case wherein there is a counter-claim by the defendant,

you must DECIDE FIRST THE CLAIM OF THE PLAINTIFF:

To reach your decision, you shall vote BY SECRET BALLOT using the "Civil Jury Secret Ballot

Form." Your ballot has been prescribed as Form TJ-124P, and Form TJ-124D, Section 14, Rule 3 of the

Rules of the Jury System. Your ballot should be folded when you submit it to your Foreman for counting.

The Foreman shall not open a ballot until all your ballots are submitted. Each of you has one (1) vote to

cast. Your collective or total votes will represent the jury decision, called the "Verdict." You write your vote

either “YES” or “NO” . The Foreman shall be responsible that each ballot is properly initialed.

You must be reminded that when you start writing your ballot, no one of you must speak, force or

harass any of your fellow jurors as to who would you want to win in this case. Violation of this rule will

result in the mistrial or “no trial” and the violator will be personally responsible to pay for the expenses of

this trial equal to, but not more than, the total of all the jurors’ pay for one day of the trial. If you were

threatened or forced to vote one way or the other, you must secretly report the matter to the grand jury for

secret investigation and you must ask the clerk of court to help you how to submit your report. The clerk

of court is hereby instructed to keep the matter confidential.

You vote and write “YES” in your ballot, if you decide that the plaintiff has the right to collect his

claim from the defendant.

You vote and write “NO” in your ballot, if you decide that the defendant is not responsible to pay

the plaintiff.

Your Foreman should instruct to hold on to your filled ballot until every one has finished writing his

vote. When every one has written his vote, only then shall the Foreman gather the votes all at one time.

The total of all ballots shall neither be less nor be more than 12. Once all your votes are submitted to the

Foreman, the Foreman shall open each ballot and he shall separate the ballots into two (2) groups. On

his right will be the "YES" votes and on his left the “NO” votes. Your majority “Yes” vote is your jury

decision requiring the Dependant to pay the claim of the Plaintiff. Your majority “No” vote is your jury

decision to prevent the Plaintiff from collecting payment of its claim from the Defendant.

Before the Foreman announces the result of the balloting he shall ask two jurors to review the

reading of the ballots one on his right to count the “YES” votes and one on his left to count the “NO”

votes. Only then shall the Foreman announce to his members the total number of the "YES" votes and

followed by the total of the "NO" votes.

Page 375: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

342

1. If the total of the “YES” votes is seven (7) or more, this jury has found the defendant

responsible to pay the plaintiff. If the total “NO” votes is six (6) or more, this jury has found the defendant

not responsible to pay the plaintiff. You will then proceed as follows:

(a) Pull out your Jury Verdict form, Form TJ-125, and write your verdict in this form and have

at least two of your jurors verify and ensure that your verdict is correctly entered in it. After your

verification, your Foreman and your two members who verified the verdict must sign the verdict form TJ-

125.

(b) Your Foreman shall then call the Sheriff stating that the jury is now ready to declare

its verdict. You MUST NOT GIVE THE VERDICT SHEET AND YOU MUST NOT TELL the Sheriff what

your verdict is. Simply say, the jury is now ready to declare its verdict.

(c) The Sheriff shall then inform the Presiding Judge that you are ready to declare the jury

verdict in court.

(d) In the mean time, you must wait in your deliberation room until the Sheriff ask you to report

back to your seats at the court room regardless of how long will it take for him to get back to you to report

to the court.

(e) The Foreman shall hand in the Verdict Sheet to the Presiding Judge and the judge must

inform that no clapping of hands is allowed upon reading the verdict. The Presiding Judge shall then order

the Clerk of the Court to read the Verdict in open court in the presence of all parties concerned as well as

any of the interested members of the public.

2. This Instruction has been JOINTLY APPROVED this _____ day of ____________, year _____

(this part to be signed by Plaintiff’s Attorney, Defense Attorney, and by the Presiding Judge before handing

to the Clerk for delivery to the jury in the jury room. BY:

_______________________ ____________________ ____________________

(Plaintiff’s Attorney) (Defense Attorney) (Presiding Judge)

- End of Form -

Page 376: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

343

FORM TJ-124P, Plaintiff’s Civil Jury Secret Ballot Forms (Must be cut apart before submitting to the Jury with the Civil Jury Verdict Form, TJ-125, andplace in a separate envelope, marked “PLAINTIFF’S BALLOT” ).

I vote _____ on Plaintiff’s Claim vs ______________. Choose one of the quoted words below:

“YES” “NO”Write your Juror Code Number here: _______

“Yes” means defendant shall pay plaintiff. “No” means defendant shall not pay plaintiff.

I vote _____ on Plaintiff’s Claim vs ______________. Choose one of the quoted words below:

“YES” “NO”Write your Juror Code Number here: _______

“Yes” means defendant shall pay plaintiff. “No” means defendant shall not pay plaintiff.

I vote _____ on Plaintiff’s Claim vs ______________. Choose one of the quoted words below:

“YES” “NO”Write your Juror Code Number here: _______

“Yes” means defendant shall pay plaintiff. “No” means defendant shall not pay plaintiff.

I vote _____ on Plaintiff’s Claim vs ______________. Choose one of the quoted words below:

“YES” “NO”Write your Juror Code Number here: _______

“Yes” means defendant shall pay plaintiff. “No” means defendant shall not pay plaintiff.

I vote _____ on Plaintiff’s Claim vs ______________. Choose one of the quoted words below:

“YES” “NO”Write your Juror Code Number here: _______

“Yes” means defendant shall pay plaintiff. “No” means defendant shall not pay plaintiff.

I vote _____ on Plaintiff’s Claim vs ______________. Choose one of the quoted words below:

“YES” “NO”Write your Juror Code Number here: _______

“Yes” means defendant shall pay plaintiff. “No” means defendant shall not pay plaintiff.

I vote _____ on Plaintiff’s Claim vs ______________. Choose one of the quoted words below:

“YES” “NO”Write your Juror Code Number here: _______

“Yes” means defendant shall pay plaintiff. “No” means defendant shall not pay plaintiff.

I vote _____ on Plaintiff’s Claim vs ______________. Choose one of the quoted words below:

“YES” “NO”Write your Juror Code Number here: _______

“Yes” means defendant shall pay plaintiff. “No” means defendant shall not pay plaintiff.

I vote _____ on Plaintiff’s Claim vs ______________. Choose one of the quoted words below:

“YES” “NO”Write your Juror Code Number here: _______

“Yes” means defendant shall pay plaintiff. “No” means defendant shall not pay plaintiff.

I vote _____ on Plaintiff’s Claim vs ______________. Choose one of the quoted words below:

“YES” “NO”Write your Juror Code Number here: _______

“Yes” means defendant shall pay plaintiff. “No” means defendant shall not pay plaintiff.

I vote _____ on Plaintiff’s Claim vs ______________. Choose one of the quoted words below:

“YES” “NO”Write your Juror Code Number here: _______

“Yes” means defendant shall pay plaintiff. “No” means defendant shall not pay plaintiff.

I vote _____ on Plaintiff’s Claim vs ______________. Choose one of the quoted words below:

“YES” “NO”Write your Juror Code Number here: _______

“Yes” means defendant shall pay plaintiff. “No” means defendant shall not pay plaintiff.

Page 377: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

344

FORM TJ-124D, Defendant’s Civil Jury Secret Ballot Forms (Must be cut apart before submitting to the Jurywith the Civil Jury Verdict Form, TJ-125 and place in separate envelope, marked“DEFENDANT’S COUNTER-CLAIM BALLOTS” ). Do not provide this ballot form to theJury if the defendant has no counter-claim against the plaintiff. If the defendant has across-claim against a third party defendant, then the defendant-cross-claimant must beprovided with the Plaintiff’s Ballot Form TJ-124P.

I vote _____ on Defendant’s Claim vs ____________ Choose one of the quoted words below:

“YES” “NO”Write your Juror Code Number here: _______

“Yes” means plaintiff shall pay defendant. “No” means plaintiff shall not pay defendant.

I vote _____ on Defendant’s Claim vs ____________ Choose one of the quoted words below:

“YES” “NO”Write your Juror Code Number here: _______

“Yes” means plaintiff shall pay defendant. “No” means plaintiff shall not pay defendant.

I vote _____ on Defendant’s Claim vs ____________ Choose one of the quoted words below:

“YES” “NO”Write your Juror Code Number here: _______

“Yes” means plaintiff shall pay defendant. “No” means plaintiff shall not pay defendant.

I vote _____ on Defendant’s Claim vs ____________ Choose one of the quoted words below:

“YES” “NO”Write your Juror Code Number here: _______

“Yes” means plaintiff shall pay defendant. “No” means plaintiff shall not pay defendant.

I vote _____ on Defendant’s Claim vs ____________ Choose one of the quoted words below:

“YES” “NO”Write your Juror Code Number here: _______

“Yes” means plaintiff shall pay defendant. “No” means plaintiff shall not pay defendant.

I vote _____ on Defendant’s Claim vs ____________ Choose one of the quoted words below:

“YES” “NO”Write your Juror Code Number here: _______

“Yes” means plaintiff shall pay defendant. “No” means plaintiff shall not pay defendant.

I vote _____ on Defendant’s Claim vs ____________ Choose one of the quoted words below:

“YES” “NO”Write your Juror Code Number here: _______

“Yes” means plaintiff shall pay defendant. “No” means plaintiff shall not pay defendant.

I vote _____ on Defendant’s Claim vs ____________ Choose one of the quoted words below:

“YES” “NO”Write your Juror Code Number here: _______

“Yes” means plaintiff shall pay defendant. “No” means plaintiff shall not pay defendant.

I vote _____ on Defendant’s Claim vs ____________ Choose one of the quoted words below:

“YES” “NO”Write your Juror Code Number here: _______

“Yes” means plaintiff shall pay defendant. “No” means plaintiff shall not pay defendant.

I vote _____ on Defendant’s Claim vs ____________ Choose one of the quoted words below:

“YES” “NO”Write your Juror Code Number here: _______

“Yes” means plaintiff shall pay defendant. “No” means plaintiff shall not pay defendant.

I vote _____ on Defendant’s Claim vs ____________ Choose one of the quoted words below:

“YES” “NO”Write your Juror Code Number here: _______

“Yes” means plaintiff shall pay defendant. “No” means plaintiff shall not pay defendant.

I vote _____ on Defendant’s Claim vs ____________ Choose one of the quoted words below:

“YES” “NO”Write your Juror Code Number here: _______

“Yes” means plaintiff shall pay defendant. “No” means plaintiff shall not pay defendant.

Page 378: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

345

FORM TJ-125. Civil Jury Verdict Form

Republic of the Philippines

BEFORE THE ___________TRIAL COURT OF ________________

Branch _____________

Municipality/City/Province__________________________________

CIVIL CASE NUMBER _________________________

______________________, Plaintiff versus _____________________, Defendant

FOR ______________________________________

Date Today: ____________________

NOTE: The “P” below stands for “Pesos” money sign.

The JURY voted on the claim of the plaintiff _________________________ <insert name of plaintiff< against the

defendant ___________________ <insert name of the defendant< AS FOLLOWS :

____ “Yes” Votes to Approve the claim of the Plaintiff against the defendant; and

____ “No” Votes to Disapprove the claim of the Plaintiff against the defendant.

The JURY approves the award of P_______________ PESOS for the Plaintiff on its claim against the defendant.

Write “NONE” in the PESO blank space, if the total “NO” votes is six (6) or more over the claim of the plaintiff against

the defendant. This total award consists of the items below:

1. On Plaintiff’s principal claim and interest earned, P_________________ PESOS.

If award is denied enter “NONE”

2. Punitive Damages, P___________________. If award is denied enter “NONE”.

The JURY voted on the [_]-counter-claim [_]-cross-complaint of the defendant ________________________ <insert

Page 379: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

346

name of the defendant< against the plaintiff ______________________ <insert name of the plaintiff< AS FOLLOWS :

_____ “Yes” Votes to Approve the counter-claim of the defendant against the plaintiff.

_____ “No” Votes to Disapprove the counter-claim of the defendant against the plaintiff.

_____ “Yes ” Votes to Approve defendant’s cross-complaint versus ______ _________________

_____ “No” Votes to Disapprove defendant’s cross-complaint versus _________________________

The JURY approves the award of P_______________ PESOS for the Defendant on its counter-claim against the

plaintiff. <Write “NONE” in the blank if the votes “NO” are six (6) or more votes on the counter-claim of the defendant

against . This total award consists of the items below:

1. On Defendant’s principal counter-claim and interest earned, P_____________ PESOS.

If award is denied on defendant’s counter-claim, enter “NONE” in the PESO blank space.

2. Punitive Damages, P______________. If award is disapproved, enter “NONE”.

The JURY approves the award of P_______________ PESOS for the Defendant on its cross-cclaim against

_________________________, cross-defendant. <Write “NONE” in the blank if the votes “NO” are six (6) or more

votes on the cross-claim of the defendant against _____________________________________________. This total

award consists of the items below:

1. On Defendant’s principal cross-claim and interest earned, P_____________ PESOS.

If award is denied on defendant’s cross-claim, enter “NONE” in the PESO blank space.

2. Punitive Damages, P______________. If award is denied enter “NONE”.

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - The statements below need not be read in open court - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

I CERTIFY that I have kept myself neutral all throughout the deliberation, except by voting secretly in the same

manner that all members of the jury were required to vote secretly as instructed by the rules. I have not influenced any

member of the jury to cast his or her vote either way. I further certify that each ballot was correspondingly voted on

and initialed personally by the juror in this jury.

Respectfully submitted by: Reviewed for initials and count correctness by two jurors:

(Signature) Foreman Juror’s SIDN#-_________ SIDN# _______ SIDN# _________

- End of Form -

Page 380: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

347

Form TJ-126. (Reserved for Future Use by the Supreme Court in Creating the

The Resource for Philippine CIVIL JURY INSTRUCTION.

This Table will be expansive as each new decisions of the Supreme

Court comes up, similar to the SCRA.

You may refer to the California Civil Jury Instruction as a pattern and study

material, but not to copy it, to get the idea how to set up the Philippine

Resource of its Civil Jury Instruction. The web site is at:

http://www.courts.ca.gov/partners/documents/caci_2015_edition.pdf

Page 381: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

348

Form TJ-127. Plaintiff’s Bill of Particulars - This document is not an evidence of Plaintiff’s Claim.

It is only a guide for the analyzes of the Jury of Plaintiff’s Claim. <This caption

must be copied entirely<Your Honor:

Herein Plaintiff ___________________ <insert name of plaintiff< respectfully submits the following Bill of Particulars

on its claim for the consideration of the Jury against the defendant __________________________ <insert name

of defendant<:

1. On Plaintiff’s claim in-chief briefly described below:

_______________________________________________________

_______________________________________________________

_______________________________________________________

Supported by Exhibits ID No. _____, _____, _____, _____, ______,

______, ______,_____, _____ and ______ in the amount of . . . . . . . . . . . . P

2. Accrued Interest due on Claim No. 1 above for the

Period form _________ until ___________ <insert dates< . . . . . . . . . . . .

3. Punitive Damages (Applicable only to damage or injury

Tort and Fraud Claims) supported by Exhibits ID No. _____,

_____, _____, _____, _____, ______, and _____ in the amount of . . . . . .

GRAND TOTAL CLAIM OF THE PLAINTIFF . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . P

Respectfully submitted by:

Signed ____________________________

Printed ____________________________

Attorney for the Plaintiff _______________

__________________________________

Trial Date: _________________________

REMINDER: THIS DOCUMENT IS NOT AN EVIDENCE. ITIS A GUIDE ONLY FOR DISCUSSION BY THE JURY. Ifthe Defendant has a cross claim or counter-claim he may usethis form as a pattern for his own Bill of Particulars.

Page 382: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

349

Form TJ-128. Defendant’s Counter-Bill of Particulars - This document is not an evidence of Defendant’s Counter-

Claim against the Plaintiff. It is only a guide for the analyzes of the Jury of Defendant’s Counter-

Claim. Defendant shall submit this form only if he has a c ounter-claim or a cross

claim <This caption must be copied entirely<

Your Honor:

Herein Defendant _________________________ <insert name of defendant< respectfully submits the following

Counter-Bill of Particulars on its claim for the consideration of the Jury against the Plaintiff ________

____________________________________________ <insert name of the plaintiff<:

1. On Defendant’s claim in-chief briefly described below:

______________________________________________________

______________________________________________________

______________________________________________________

Supported by Exhibits ID No. _____, _____, _____, _____, ______,

______, ______, ______, _______, ______, and ______ in the amount of . . . . . . P

2. Accrued Interest due on Claim No. 1 above for the

Period form _________ until ___________ <insert dates< . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

3. Punitive Damages (Applicable only to damage or injury

Tort and Fraud Claims) supported by Exhibits ID No. _____, _____,

_____, _____, _____, _____, ______, ______, and _____ in the amount of . . . . .

GRAND TOTAL CLAIM OF THE PLAINTIFF . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . P

Respectfully submitted by:

Signed ____________________________

Printed ____________________________

Attorney for the Defendant ____________

__________________________________

Trial Date: _________________________

REMINDER: THIS DOCUMENT IS NOT EVIDENCE.IT IS A GUIDE ONLY FOR DISCUSSION BY THEJURY.

The defendant shall submit this form only if he hascounter claim against the plaintiff or a cross claimagainst a co-defendant or a third party.

Page 383: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

350

Form TJ-129 , Noon Meal Ticket for Trial Juror on Duty or on Call in the Premises issue

this Form only to a Jurors who are not actually seated in a jury trial

NOTE: Legible hand-printed information is sufficie nt to accomplish this form. No need to type.

This is a Confidential Document. Do not let anybody else read this.

Name of Issuing Court _____________________________________________________________________________

Court Branch or Sala ______________________________ Presiding Judge ____________________________

Address of Court ____________________________________________________________________________________

REPORT SECRETLY to the Grand Jury ANYONE asking for “kick back” on this Juror’s Meal Ticket System.Bribe giver will not be prosecuted for bribery if h e testifies against the bribe recipient - GJ Instr uction No.

(194). This is a statutory durable form. This form can be changed only with promulgation by the

Supreme Court. If juror is discriminated to avail o f this ticket, he must secretly report the matter

to the Grand Jury. All used tickets returned to Cle rk of Court in exchange for Form GJ-27 mustbe book bound, archived for five years and destroye d only upon an open court order.

Name of Food Provider __________________________________________ Phone # _______________________

Business Owner of Food Provider ________________________________________________________________

Clerk Issuer of this ticket: (Printed Name only) _____________________________________________________

Declaration: I declare under penalty of perjury that I am not a business partner, openly or

surreptitiously, directly or indirectly, with the f ood provider to whom this ticket is directed.

Customary signature of issuing clerk: _____________________________________ Title _____________________________

Clerk of Court (Printed Name only)___________________________________________ Phone # __________________________

________________________ ____________________________________________________________________________________

Noon Meal Order Number ____________ Dated: / / (Obtain the number from Form TJ-130, Food Ticket Lo g Book)

This ticket is valid only if dated and recorded in the Food Ticket Log Book

Court Case Number __________________ or Summons Number __________________(Enter Summons Number if Juror not seated on a case for Jury Trial)

To The Named Food Provider Above:

Please serve with one (1) full meal today (per date above) to the bearer of this Order with ID No.

_____________ who is reporting or has reported for jury service at the above named court.

Accumulate all tickets of this class until the grand total thereof amounts to an aggregate of P50,000.00 pesosor more and thereafter personally present them back to the Clerk of Court named in this ticket in exchangewith an Unconditional Non-Transferrable Redeemable Judicial Voucher, Form GJ-27. You may then presentthe voucher to a public treasurer or a bank for cashing.

Food menu and cost: Menu Name- ____________________ Total Cost - P___________. Thisinformation shall be written in this ticket before issuing to the Juror by the Clerk of Court.

Please have the bearer affixed his/her initials ONLY with his/her own hand here- _______.

End of Form

Page 384: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

351

Form TJ-130, JURORS’ NOON MEAL TICKET LOG BOOK. Date Today: / /

Page No. ____________

Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type.

Name of Court _______________________________________ Branch or Sala ________________________________

Clerk of Court (Printed Name only) ____________________________________ Phone # ________________________

Ticket SerialNumber

DateIssued

Juror IDNumber

Name of Food Provider

Ticket signedand issued by:

Page 385: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

352

Form TJ-131, JUROR’S RIDER TRANSPORT TICKET FOR JURY SERVICE. Issue to Juror in pairs:

[_]-Ticket from Home to Court on (date) / / ______ Kilometers.

[_]-Ticket from Court to Home on (date) / / ______ Kilometers.

Name of Issuing Court _________________________________________________________________________________________

Court Branch or Sala ________________________________ Presiding Judge ______________________________________

Address of Court ________________________________________________________________________________________________

REPORT SECRETLY to the Grand Jury ANYONE asking for “kick back” on this Juror’s Rider Ticket

System. BRIBE GIVER WILL NOT BE PROSECUTED FOR BRIBERY - Grand Jury Instruction No.

(194). This is a statutory durable form. This form can be changed only by promulgation by the Supreme

Court. If juror is discriminated to avail of this ticket, he must report the matter to the Grand Jury. All used

tickets returned to Clerk of Court in exchange for Form GJ-27 must be book bound, archived for five

years and destroyed only upon an open court order.

Name of Ride Provider ______________________________________________ Phone # _______________________________

Business Owner of Ride Provider ____________________________________________________________________________

Address __________________________________________________________________________________________________________

_____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Clerk Issuer of this ticket: (Printed Name only) _________________________________________________________________

Declaration: I declare under penalty of perjury that I am not a business partner, openly or

surreptitiously, directly or indirectly, with the R ide provider to whom this ticket is directed.

Customary signature of issuing clerk: ________________________________________ Title __________________________________

Clerk of Court (Printed Name only)_______________________________________________ Phone # ______________________________

________________________ _____________________________________________________________________________________________

Ride Order Ticket Number ____________ Date: / / (Obtain the number from Form TJ-132, Rider Transpor t Ticket Log Book)

This ticket is valid only if dated and recorded in the Transport Ticket Log Book

Summons Number ________________ or Voter’s ID Number ___________________

To The Named Transport Ride Provider Above:

Please provide a one-way transportation ride from the home of the bearer in coming to this court (stated

above) OR from this Court to his/her home. You will identify him/her with his/her summons number or Voter’s

ID Number. DO NOT ASK FOR THE NAME OF THE BEARER.

Accumulate all tickets of this class from all your juror riders until the grand total thereof amounts to an

aggregate of P10,000.00 pesos or more and thereafter personally present them back to the clerk issuer of this

ticket in exchange with an Unconditional Non-Transferrable Redeemable Judicial Voucher, Form GJ-27. You

may then present the voucher to any public treasurer or to a bank for cashing. NOTE: Do not place a placard

in your vehicle that you are a transport provider of jurors.

Describe here the date and time and location from where you picked up the bearer and the destination where

you took him/her for the ride:

Pick up date: / / Pick up time: ____.M

Please have the bearer affixed his/her initials ONLY with his/her own hand here- _______.

End of Form

Page 386: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

353

Form TJ-132, JURORS’ TRANSPORT TICKET LOG BOOK. Date Today: / /

Page No. ____________

Note: Legible hand-printed information is sufficient to accomplish this form. No need to type.

Name of Court _______________________________________ Branch or Sala ________________________________

Clerk of Court (Printed Name only) ____________________________________ Phone # ________________________

Ticket SerialNumber

DateIssued

Juror IDNumber

Name of Transport Provider

Ticket signedand issued by:

Page 387: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

354

Form TJ-133, Court Seating Arrangement

(Wall Behind the Presiding Judge)

Entrance Door

LOBBY - HALLWAY

_____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

The foregoing court room lay out should be followed nationally as a symbol of national unity and

uniformity of justice, except on the technical architectural requirement. The left side and back of juror

seats should be walled 10 inches higher above shoulder.

LEGENDS

1 - Presiding Judge (PJ) 7 - Sheriff’s Area D3- Defense Atty 3

2 - PJ Desk/Table 8 - Interpreter’s Area P1- Prosecutor 1

3 - Court Secretary (CS) 9 - Sheriff’s Area P2- Prosecutor 2

4 - CS Desk (facing PJ Desk) A - Accused’s Seat P4- Prosecutor 4

5 - Witness Seat D1- Defense Atty 1 J1, J2 Etc - Jur or Seat #s.

6 - Court Reporter’s Seat D2- Defense Atty 2 AJ- Alt ernate Juror Seats.

Items 1 to 9 should be in the sameplatform and elevated around 6".

1

4 253 8

7 6 9

A D1

D2 D3

P2 P1

P3 P4

J1 J2 J3 J4 J5

J6 J7 J8 J9 J10

J11 J12 AJ1 AJ2 AJ3

Public Seats

Extra Security

Utility Seat

TV Crew &Equipment

Public Seats

Page 388: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

355

Form TJ-134, Waiver of Banking Anti-Disclosure Secrecy Rights.

TYPE HERE THE “TITLE, CAPTION, AND

DOCKET NUMBER OF THE CRIMINAL CASE”

_________________________________________________________

TO ALL WHOM THIS WAIVER MAY CONCERN:

I, the undersigned, hereby waive my anti-disclosure banking rights under any existing law or laws of

the Philippines in reference to my bank accounts with any local or foreign banking institution as listed

in my Statement of Assets, Liabilities and Net Worth in Form GJ-51 in Section 99, Article III, of the

Jury Law as part of the terms and conditions in entering my plea bargaining agreement in this case

with the government prosecutors against me.

I shall offer no objection or resistance, and shall keep the banking institution concern free from harm

in showing or disclosing my bank records.

This Waiver shall include any future bank account I shall, or I may, open after the execution date of

this Waiver.

I understand that this waiver shall expire fully and with no further effect upon my full payment through

the public treasurer and duly receipted by him of all moneys due in favor of the Victim of my crime

for damage indemnity or to the Philippine Government on account of my plea bargaining this case.

Partial payment by me shall not diminish the effectivity of this waiver.

It shall be my responsibility and my attorney, jointly, to serve a copy of this waiver with proof of

service to this Court, to the Prosecutor and to all my bank depository(ries) stated in my SALN Form

GJ-51.

EXECUTED at the [_]-City [_]-Municipality, of _________________________________, Province

of _______________ on this date _________ month of ______________and year _______.

Signature: _____________________________________________________________________

Printed Name: __________________________________________________________________

Street Address: ________________________________________________________________

[_]-City [_]-Municipality __________________________ Province of ________________________

PREPARED and EXECUTED with the presence

and assistance of his/her attorney hereunder:

Signature: _______________________ Date ______________, Bar No. ____________________

Printed Name: __________________________________________________________________

Street Address: _________________________________________________________________

[_]-City [_]-Municipality of ___________________ Province of _____________________

- End of Form -

Page 389: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

356

Form TJ-135, LIST OF EXHIBITS. Mark “X” on the Box the Party You Represent:

If there are several accused persons in the same criminal case, a separate

set of list of exhibits shall be prepared by his attorney and offered at the trial. If

an Exhibit is shared with another party, an authentic photocopy, signed with the

initials of the offering counsel of that same exhibit, shall be listed and remarked

accordingly in behalf of the party offering such exhibit under a separate set of

Exhibit List. THIS LIST BY ITSELF IS NOT EVIDENCE. Each Exhibit is

evidence subject to evaluation for its probative value by the Jury.

[_]- Exhibits for the Prosecutor by Atty _____________________, Case No.

______________

[_]- Exhibits for the Accused (Name) - ____________________, By Atty _______________

EXHIBIT ID Brief Description Author/Maker Purpose: Briefly State the Fact

SUBMITTED BY:

______________________ Atty. For _______________________

Page 390: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

357

Form TJ-136 , Delivery Envelope for Forms to the Jury (Size: #10, 4.1 x 9.5 inches)

READ: VERY IMPORTANT NOTICE to the Jury Foreman: Do not open another envelope until

you have written your decision in either of Form TJ-113 or Form TJ-114 in this case and you have

already inserted it in the JUDGMENT Envelope, Form TJ-137.

Case Number ______________. People vs ______________________________, Accused.

Contents of this Envelope:

[_]- Form TJ-110B, The Charge Sheet

[_]- Form TJ-110D-___, Law & Fact Sheet

[_]- Form TJ-112, Jury Ballot forms in 12 pre-cut pieces.

[_]- Form TJ-113, The “Guilty Verdict” form.

[_]- Form TJ-114, The “Not Guilty Verdict” form.

[_]- Form TJ-137, Verdict Envelope (To contain the written Verdict of the Jury)

Form TJ-137 , The JUDGMENT ENVELOPE (Size: #10, 4.1 x 9.5 inches)

Decided Case/es for: ___________________________, Accused:

Case on Form TJ-110D-1 for the crime of ______________________

Case on Form TJ-110D-2 for the crime of ______________________

Case on Form TJ-110D-3 for the crime of ______________________

Case on Form TJ-110D-4 for the crime of ______________________

Case on Form TJ-110D-5 for the crime of ______________________

Page 391: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

358

Form TJ-138 MASTER CASE FILE ENVELOPE. Size: 10 x 13 Inches -

NAME OF THE ACCUSED: _____________________________________

(A) Form TJ-110B, the CHARGE SHEET [_]-1 [_]-___ Cases

(B) Form TJ-135, Prosecutor’s Exhibit List and Exhibits

(C) Form TJ-135, Accused/Defendant’s Exhibit List and Exhibits

1. Criminal Case No. _________________

[_]- Form TJ-110D-1, Law & Fact Sheet For the Crime of __________________

[_]- Jury Ballots, 12 pieces

[_]- Form TJ-113 (Guilty Verdict) Or Form TJ-114 (Not Guilty Verdict)

2. Criminal Case No. _________________

[_]- Form TJ-110D-2, Law & Fact Sheet For the Crime of __________________

[_]- Jury Ballots, 12 pieces

[_]- Form TJ-113 (Guilty Verdict) Or Form TJ-114 (Not Guilty Verdict)

3. Criminal Case No. _________________

[_]- Form TJ-110D-3, Law & Fact Sheet For the Crime of __________________

[_]- Jury Ballots, 12 pieces

[_]- Form TJ-113 (Guilty Verdict) Or Form TJ-114 (Not Guilty Verdict)

4. Criminal Case No. _________________

[_]- Form TJ-110D-4, Law & Fact Sheet For the Crime of __________________

[_]- Jury Ballots, 12 pieces

[_]- Form TJ-113 (Guilty Verdict) Or Form TJ-114 (Not Guilty Verdict)

Page 392: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

359

Form TJ-139 , LIST OF EXHIBITS in CIVIL CASES. Mark “X” on the Box the Party You Represent.

If there are several contending parties in the same civil case or matter, a separate

set of list of exhibits shall be prepared by his attorney and offered at the trial. If an

Exhibit is shared with another party, an authentic photocopy, signed with the initials of the offering

counsel of that same exhibit, shall be listed and remarked accordingly in behalf of the party offering

such exhibit under a separate set of Exhibit List. THIS LIST BY ITSELF IS NOT EVIDENCE. Each

Exhibit is evidence subject to evaluation for its probative value by the Jury.

[_]- Exhibits for the Plaintiff, Atty _________________________, Case No. _________________

[_]- Exhibits for the Defendant, __________________________, By Atty ___________________

[_]- Exhibits for the ____________________________________, By Atty ___________________

EXHIBIT ID Brief Description Author/Maker Purpose: Briefly State the Fact

SUBMITTED BY:

Atty. ________________________, For ______________________________

Page 393: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

360

ARTICLE XI

IMPLEMENTING AUTHORITY

OF THE NATIONAL JURY LAW

Section 1. The Entity known as the “National Jury Management Authority,” also

briefly named as the “NJMA” as created under Article VI of the National Jury Law shall further

have the additional prerogatives, attributes and powers enumerated below in this Article, Article

XI:

(a) Composition - It shall be composed of eight (8) members as follows:

(1) The Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, as chairman;

(2) One Supreme Court Associate Justice, as vice-chairman;

(3) The Chairman of the Court of Appeals as member;

(4) The Chairman of the Sandiganbayan as member;

(5) The Secretary of Justice as member;

(6) The Ombudsman as member;

(7) The Solicitor General as member; and,

(8) The President of the Integrated Bar of the Philippines, as member.

(b) Secretary - The Clerk of the Supreme Court shall serve as Secretary of the NJMA.

(c) Location of Business - The Supreme Court shall be the seat of all official meetings

of the National Jury Management Authority;

(d) Functions -

(1) To promulgate the implementing rules and regulation of the Grand Jury and Trial Jury

Systems;

(2) To supervise trial court judges in the enforcement of the rules of the Jury Trials;

(3) To designate the Executive Regional Trial Judge in each Judicial Districts around

the country as the sole authority in conducting the bi-annual confidential reorganization of the

Grand Juries in their respective districts. For this purpose, the Clerks of Court of the Executive

Regional Trial Judges shall serve as their assistants in bi-annual reorganization of Grand Juries.

After the Executive Regional Trial Judge has organized the grand jury and sworn in its members,

the said judge shall have no further role in the operation and functioning of the grand jury. The

grand jury shall be completely free and independent from any control or supervision from any

branch of service of the Philippine Government.

Page 394: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

361

(4) To Issue directives to each and all Provincial and City Prosecuting Offices to

implement the general objective and policies of the National Jury Law.

(5) To prepare the annual budget for the operation of the National Jury Law and to

submit the same to Congress for inclusion in the national annual budget of the government.

(6) To establish the additional amount of compensation of the officials and other staff

members of the National Jury Management Authority.

(7) To create the jury forms needed to function the National Jury Law. Unless and until

such time that the National Jury Management Authority shall have devised a more appropriate Jury

Forms, the designated Jury Forms in Article III, Section 99 and in Article X, Sections 1 and 2, shall

be used to operate the Jury Systems upon approval of the National Jury Law.

Section 2. Creation of Reserve pool for pro-temp presiding jury trial judges, community

deputy prosecutors, defense attorneys for indigent persons -

(1) The NJMA shall require each trial court to create separate reserve pools for

volunteer lawyers to serve as pro-temp jury presiding judges , community deputy prosecutors,

and public defenders for indigent accused persons , respectively, with pay, from among private

practicians attorneys to ensure availability at all times for the required service of the Philippine

Justice System, to prevent delay in the administration of justice. Their names shall be drawn by

lottery from among applicants. The NJMA shall set up a standard uniform durable form for this

purpose, separately: One for the application of pro-temp presiding judges, one for community

deputy prosecutors and another form for public defenders. Interested lawyers who wish to serve

in any of those positions shall file their applications on a prescribed durable form. A durable form

is a document in which its terms and conditions shall, and can, not be amended or modified by the

applicant.

(2) Each trial court, prosecutor’s office, and public attorney’s office, respectively, shall

set up separate lottery bins for this purpose wherein an applicant shall drop in his application at

any time and shall be ready for drawing of his name. Once he drops in his application in the lottery

bin, he shall be bound to report for service. If he shall decline to accept his assignment, it must

be based on a life threatening situation or if any party to the case at hand is his client or the

defense attorney is a close relative, friend, business associate of the complaining party or plaintiff

and his written notice to decline to serve shall have been received by the presiding judge, or

prosecutor’s office or his clerk, at which he is called to serve not later than five (5) working days

prior to the date he is required to serve, otherwise he shall be liable for disciplinary action for failure

to honor his commitment to serve.

(3) The community deputy prosecutor shall serve under the supervision of a regular

Provincial or City prosecutor.

Page 395: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

362

(4) The formula to determine the compensation of the pro-temp jury presiding judge, the

community deputy prosecutor, and the public defender, computed on a daily basis, shall be based

on the annualized pay of a newly appointed regular judge or provincial prosecutor in the judicial

jurisdiction he wishes to serve, divided by two hundred fifty days, and then multiplied by the

number of days or fraction thereof, pro temp jury presiding judge, community deputy prosecutor,

or public defender, had worked on a case.

(5) In the event that a public defender who shall appear in court and willing to serve and

defend a criminal defendant on short notice within 3 days before the commencement of a jury trial,

or when ordered by a Jury Presiding Judge to defend the indigent accused, his fee shall likewise

be paid by the Government by means of the Redeemable Voucher GJ-27 at the rate as determined

in the foregoing sub-paragraph (4) of this Section.

(6) The NJMA shall have the duty and power to recommend to Congress the required

budget for the expenditures in the functions and operation of the National Jury Law and

Procedures.

Section 3. The NJMA shall have the power, upon the recommendation of an Executive

Regional Trial Judge, to create positions for jury commissioner in trial courts who shall have the

duty and power to serve summons for jury duty to citizens and to prepare such citizens ready for

empanelling for jury service provided that a cluster of trial courts regardless of hierarchy or

jurisdiction shall be served by the same jury commissioner. Appointments of local interpreters to

serve as such in jury trials shall rest with the Executive Regional Trial Judge upon recommendation

of presiding court judges.

Section 4. Proceeding the case for jury trial:

All jury trials without exception shall be conducted with the aid of an expert interpreter

in the local dialect spoken by the members of the jury and shall proceed under the following rules:

(1) No later than thirty (30) days, excluding Saturdays, Sundays, and Holidays, following

the arraignment of the accused who has entered a no guilty plea on the accusation against him,

the presiding judge before whom the “not guilty” plea was entered into shall promptly order the

setting of two (2) closely related essential dates, namely as follows:

(a) The First Date: The date for an “In Chamber Conference” between and among the

Opposing Counsels and the Jury Presiding Judge in the case at hand. This conference is

mandatory. It shall precede at least one, or two, days ahead of the impaneling of the jury for the

actual jury trial. It shall be held strictly confidential and its schedule shall not be announced to the

public. Except for the Prosecution Attorney and the Defense Counsels, as well as the Presiding

Judge, no other person or any public official or any member of the media or the public shall be

invited to this conference. The attendance of the accused and witnesses shall not be required.

Page 396: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

363

(b) The Second Date: This date shall be the starting day for the opening of the actual

jury trial and shall be called the Firm Trial Date, also briefly known as the FTD. The trial shall begin

with the impaneling of the jury, followed by the issuance of the Statutory Basic Jury Trial

Instruction, and the presentation of the evidence by the prosecution and the defense, in that order,

among others.

(c) Counting from the pretrial conference date, the party requesting for the longest and

farthest estimated period of time to prepare for trial, not exceeding three months if the accused is

detained, or six months if such accused is free on bail, such farthest date shall be chosen as the

FTD of the case at hand. Absolutely, no excuse for postponement of the trial of a case from such

dates shall be granted once the FTD is set and no judge shall have the authority to order further

postponement of the jury trial from the firm trial date.

(d) Failure of the presiding judge to order the setting of the two (2) important dates

above shall be liable for disciplinary action or for the crime of obstruction of justice or for dereliction

of duty.

(2) At the pretrial conference, the presiding judge, the prosecuting attorney and the

defense counsel, shall pre-designate their respective substitutes in the event that any of them may

not be available or capable to proceed to trial at the FTD. The Presiding Judge shall order his clerk

of court to designate his substitute Pro Temp Jury Presiding Judge. The Prosecuting Attorney

shall pre-designate his Community Deputy Prosecutor and the Defense Counsel shall likewise pre-

designate his co-defense counsel or Deputy Public Defender. All pre-designations in this

proceeding shall be entered in the minutes of the pretrial conference.

(3) On the date following the pretrial conference setting the “In Chamber Conference”

date and the FTD, all the attorneys referred to in the preceding subsection (2) shall promptly

commence to prepare their respective Form TJ-110, consisting of Forms TJ-110A, TJ-110B, TJ-

110C, and TJ-110D to help in forming the Joint Supplemental Jury Trial Instruction by the presiding

judge.

(4) At all times, the defense attorney shall be prepared, in the event that the accused shall

change his mind to plead guilty at the end of the presentation of the evidence by the prosecution, to

follow the requirements of the plea bargaining process as governed by the provisions of Article VII,

Section 2 of the National Jury Law wherein the accused shall be required to prepare and execute

Form GJ-51 in Article III, and Form TJ-134, Article X, Section 2, of the National Jury Law. If the jury

trial is delayed for lack of preparation on this process on the part of the defense attorney, he shall be

liable for the crime of obstruction of justice upon complaint of an aggrieved party before a Grand Jury

and/or for disciplinary action before the Supreme Court for failure to adequately prepare for the

possible guilty plea of the accused.

Page 397: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

364

(5) Failure of the Presiding Judge, the Prosecution Attorney, and the Defense Attorneys

in showing up for this conference, resulting to the postponement of a Firm Trial Date shall be liable

for disciplinary action before the Supreme Court or for criminal liability for obstruction of justice

upon complaint by a party to the case through the Grand Jury.

(6) Notwithstanding any rule or law to the contrary, no affidavit shall be required for

execution by either the accused or by the complaining victim or witness to set a case for jury trial.

(7) The jury trial shall be conducted continuously from day to day, excluding Saturday,

Sunday, and Holiday. Absolutely, no postponement of the jury trial for more than three (3) days

shall be allowed. After arraignment, the personal presence in court of the accused suffering from

a life threatening condition or for any other reason shall be excused and his trial shall proceed with

the personal appearance of his defense counsel to defend his rights and interests at the trial.

(8) If the accused without justification fails or refuses to appear in court to attend to his

trial in spite of due notice served on him or on his counsel to attend or participate in the trial after

having been previously arraigned and pleaded not guilty to the charge against him, the jury trial

shall proceed without his presence pursuant to Article 3, Section 14(2) of the Constitution.

(9) If a continuance of the jury trial is sought on the basis of an alleged life threatening

medical emergency and evidenced by the issuance of a spurious or fake medical certificate of

incapacity of any one involved in a jury trial, the act of a medical doctor, orthopedic doctor,

chiropractic doctor, internal medicine doctor, cardiologist, physician, or psychologist, of issuing said

certificate of incapacity without knowing the prior history of the medical, physical, or psychological,

condition of such judge, lawyer, party litigant in said trial for the sole purpose of aiding a judge,

lawyer, or party litigant in a jury trial to delay, or obstruct, said trial, shall be liable of the crime of

obstruction of justice upon complaint by an aggrieved party before, and upon indictment by, a

grand jury.

(10) If the certificate referred to in the preceding subparagraph (8) shall show that it shall

require incapacity for more than three (3) days of the subject of the certificate from attending the

jury trial, the issuing doctor, physician or psychologist shall be required to attend in person before

the court to explain the basis of the issuance of his certificate of incapacity to delay the jury trial.

Should he refuse to attend in person, he shall be charged for obstruction of justice by a grand jury.

Any party requesting for the issuance of such certificate shall explain to, or advice, the issuer of

such certificate of this requirement before obtaining said certificate from the issuer thereof.

(11) In all levels of the trial courts where a jury trial is conducted, a complete

stenographic record shall be taken on any of its proceedings by a court reporter or with an

electronic recorder on every case without exception notwithstanding any rule or law to the contrary.

(12) Affidavit of Desistance - Notwithstanding any rule or law to the contrary, no criminal

indictment shall be dismissed on the basis of the presentation of an affidavit of desistance by any

party, or his attorney, unless said affidavit of desistance has been previously investigated

Page 398: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

365

independently by a grand jury for issuance under undue influence, threat, coercion, intimidation

or any similar circumstance upon the claiming victim by any person or party interested in the

dismissal of the criminal indictment in the case at hand.

(13) In the event that the Grand Jury shall find probable cause that the complaining

victim or witness, through the testimony freely stated by such victim or witness in a secret grand

jury investigation, has been subjected to sign said affidavit of desistance, on account of fraud,

intimidation and undue influence, or pressure, or coercion, upon the complaining victim or witness,

the party or person, or attorney who shall have been responsible in obtaining the signature of such

complaining victim or witness shall be held liable for the crime of obstruction of justice. If the

producer of such signature has been committed by either of the prosecuting or defense counsels

in the case at hand, such counsel shall further suffer liability for disciplinary action for disbarment

before the Supreme Court. If the procurator of the signature in such affidavit is a public official or

government employee, such public official or government employee shall further suffer termination

and perpetual disqualification from holding any public office or position including forfeiture of

pension benefits.

(14) No later than six months from the effective date of the National Jury Law, any and

all pending cases in which the accused offender has been charged with an offense punishable by

one year or more shall be set for jury trial, moto propio, by the presiding judge of the court in which

said case is, or cases are, pending and shall proceed subject to the same provisions from

sub-sections (1) through (12) of this section.

(15) If the accused has already been arraigned and a life threatening situation shall

befell upon the accused at the outset of, or during, the trial, further personal appearance in court

of the accused shall be excused and the jury trial shall proceed in his absence pursuant to Article

3, Section 14(2) of the constitution with the presence of his defense counsel or alternate defense

counsel in court. If the accused is unable to ambulate or walk, not agonizing in pain, non-disruptive

or free from physical discomfort, his illness is not contagious, and he prefers to be present during

the jury trial, said accused shall be comfortably wheeled to the court room in a wheel chair at

government expense.

(16) Every person who is under government custody awaiting for ten (10) days or more,

Saturdays, Sundays, and Holidays, included, for further proceedings of his case in court and who

is not represented by a legal counsel, shall be provided promptly with legal representation from

among the lawyers of the Public Attorney’s Office within the legislative district of the court where

his case is pending for resolution. If there is no lawyer available in his staff to take care of the case

of the detainee, the official in charge of the Public Attorney’s Office shall avail of the remedies of

securing the services of a Public Defender in Article III, Section 107, of the National Jury Law.

(17) The jail keeper or warden over the detained person referred to in the preceding

subparagraph (16) shall have the responsibility to promptly make a report of the name or names

of the unrepresented detained person or persons under his custody to the court that has

jurisdiction over the case of the detainee. Failure of such jail keeper or warden to perform his

reporting duties required in this subsection shall be liable for disciplinary action upon indictment

Page 399: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

366

by a Grand Jury and criminal liability for the crime of obstruction of justice, upon complaint by the

detainee or any close relative or friend of the detainee before the grand jury of his district.

(18) Any accused crime offender who has been detained pending final disposition of the

criminal case against him shall be compensated for the extra time served in prison beyond the

legal period of his incarceration and shall be set free promptly upon promulgation of the judgment

against him. Such compensation shall be paid through the Redeemable Judicial Voucher, Form

GJ-27.

(19) Upon receiving the report of the jail keeper or warden, the presiding judge of the

court to whom the report was submitted shall then order the Public Attorney’s Office to secure the

legal services by a lawyer to assist the detainee referred to above and the bill for his services shall

be borne by, promptly paid for, and charged to, the government by means of the Redeemable

Judicial Voucher, Form GJ-27.

Section 5. The sovereignty of the people serving as jurors -

(1) Any citizen who is summoned to serve as a juror shall be chosen by lottery.

(2) The citizens who are chosen by this process to constitute as a jury shall be deemed

as an official sampling of the sovereign people of their community. The selection of a juror by

appointment directly or indirectly shall be void.

(3) The decision of a trial jury to convict or acquit a crime suspect shall be sovereign

similar to the concept that requires no explanation from a sovereign electorate when it decides to

vote or elect any one whom it chooses to serve as its servant. This concept holds through when

the people decide by the grand jury to indict in court a crime suspect or by the trial jury to hear and

try to convict, or acquit, such suspected crime offender.

Section 6. The “Confidential In Chamber Conference” Before the Actual Jury Trial Begins

-

The “Confidential In Chamber Conference” shall serve as the last and final day in

preparing for the jury trial under the instructions stated below.

(1) In addition to the reading and issuance of the Statutory Basic Trial Jury Instruction

on Form TJ-108, the trial jury shall be guided by a set of a prepared Joint Supplemental Jury

Instruction on Form TJ-111, that will be developed with the use of Form TJ-110 between the

opposing counsels of the parties with supervision by the jury presiding judge in a “Confidential In

Chamber Conference”.

(2) The opposing counsels are advised to show candidness of their respective theories

or positions, pro or con, to the Jury Presiding Judge for the reason that it shall be the jury, not the

Page 400: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

367

Presiding Judge, that will decide the case. The Presiding Judge shall likewise openly state his

opinion to both counsels during the in-chamber conference on an issue to prevent any delay and

confusion in the course of the jury trial.

(3) The prepared Joint Supplemental Jury Instruction, Form TJ-111, shall serve as a

supplement to the Statutory Basic Jury Instruction as structured in Article X, Section 2, Form TJ-

108.

(4) The Joint Supplemental Jury Instruction shall be developed from the theories of the

respective Forms TJ-110A, TJ-110B, TJ-110C, and TJ-110Ds as presented by the opposing

counsels to the jury presiding judge during the “in chamber” conference.

(5) From the Forms TJ-110A-B-C-Ds presented by the opposing counsels, the Jury

Presiding Judge shall then create the master Joint Supplemental Jury Instruction similar in pattern

with Form TJ-110 for reading and issuance to the Jury.

(6) The Master Joint Supplemental Jury Instruction, Form TJ-111, for issuance by the

Jury Presiding Judge shall serve as a guide to the jury on how to follow the sequence of the

presentation of the evidence to help them in their deliberation and in arriving at their jury decision.

(7) In preparing the Master Joint Supplemental Jury Instruction, great care should be

taken to avoid any violation of the Statutory Basic Jury Instruction on Form TJ-108. Violation of

the Statutory Basic Jury Instruction can be a ground on appeal as an issue of law.

(8) Upon completion of the presentation of the evidence by the respective counsels or

parties to the case with their closing arguments before the Jury, the Jury Presiding Judge shall

submit the case at hand to the Jury. The instruction on Form TJ-111 for criminal trials shall serve

as a guide in submitting the case to the Jury for deliberation and decision.

Section 7. No juror shall be permitted to impose by force, or intimidation, his will against

another fellow juror to vote for or against the conscience of the latter in reaching their collective jury

decision. Nonetheless, a juror is mandated to secretly write his vote in his jury ballot one way or

the other, otherwise he shall be subject to contempt of court for his abstention to vote, except on

being overcome with fear in casting his jury ballot. In such event, the fearful juror shall be replaced

by order of the presiding judge with one of the three (3) alternate juror reserves who shall be drawn

by lottery from among said alternate reserves.

Section 8. The jury Deliberation and verdict -

(1) The members of a jury shall arrive at their verdict by secret balloting. The arguments

or comments of the jurors during their deliberation are mere opinions of the jurors. Their secret

votes as written in their jury ballots when summed up collectively shall serve in determining the

Page 401: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

368

verdict of the jury. An accused shall be convicted if the total of the guilty votes is 7 or more.

(2) An accused shall be acquitted outright if the verdict is a tie vote of six for “guilty” and

six for “not guilty.”

(3) No claim for a hung jury shall be entertained in case of a tie vote without prejudice

to the right of the aggrieved party to pursue and to file an appropriate civil action before a proper

court of his claim for damages over the alleged criminal act of the accused.

(4) The acquittal in the criminal case shall not serve as a defense in favor of the accused

in the civil action against him.

(5) Any person who has been convicted and put to prison to serve his jail term and, in

the course of his incarceration, he is subsequently found innocent of the crime he was accused

of, such person shall forthwith be released without any condition. In addition to such right of

release, he shall be entitled to, and the presiding judge shall promptly order payment, of the

compensation for the period of his incarceration in the amount of two/thirds (2/3) of the established

minimum wage law and computed on a daily basis, including Saturdays, Sundays and Holidays

which shall be paid out of the jury funds by means of the “Voucher Form GJ-27".

(6) If the innocence of such incarcerated person in the immediate preceding sub-section

has been established and secured judicially through the jury systems with the assistance of his

self-procured lawyer, such lawyer shall be entitled to a contingency attorney’s fee equal to one-

third (1/3) of the incarceration compensation money and the remaining portion of such money shall

be promptly paid to the imprisoned person PROVIDED that his release shall not be contingent

upon any delay in the delivery of the payment of his compensation and PROVIDED FURTHER that

the contingency attorney’s fee shall not be paid to the attorney until after the said innocent prisoner

has already been actually released from prison as witnessed in writing by the presence of his

spouse, or closest blood relative and his contingency-paid attorney.

(7) If said person referred to in the foregoing two subsections (5) and (6) is found

innocent through his own efforts, no person or attorney shall have the right to share in his

incarceration compensation. Should any person, attorney, or public official as defined in any law,

shall attempt to take any share of such compensation through any form of deceit or illegal

manipulation from the released innocent prisoner, such person, attorney, or public official shall be

liable for the crime of obstruction of justice and appropriate disciplinary action.

Section 9. General penalty guidelines to reach a jury verdict - The unanimity of verdict

of the 12 jurors shall not be required and it shall be the duty of the presiding judge of the court or

the same presiding judge of the trial jury to impose the penalty upon the convicted offender in

accordance with the guidelines below in this section.

(1) A crime offender found guilty by a trial jury shall suffer penalty as imposed by law the

imprisonment and fine in their minimum range if the total of guilty votes is 7 to 8 votes; medium

Page 402: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

369

range if the total of guilty votes is 9 to 10 votes; and maximum range if the total of guilty votes is

11 to 12 votes.

(2) Within each range, the court shall impose the maximum penalty if the jury finds that

the crime was committed with an aggravating circumstance.

(3) Conversely, within each range, the court shall impose the minimum penalty if the jury

finds that the crime was committed with a mitigating circumstance.

(4) If both aggravating and mitigating circumstances are found by the jury, the court shall

impose the penalty prescribed by law committed by the accused as if neither aggravating nor

mitigating circumstance exist in the commission of the crime.

(5) In crimes punishable with imprisonment in jail for one year or more, no party shall

have the prerogative to choose a trial before a solo judge or a division of the Sandiganbayan,

except by pleading guilty or by offering a “no contest plea” by the accused to the offense charged

against him prior to the commencement of the jury trial and, in which case, the penalty in the

minimum range prescribed by law for the commission of the crime shall be imposed upon him.

(6) In a criminal indictment wherein several counts of crimes have been alleged to have

been committed by the accused, the following rules shall apply:

(a) If a maximum penalty calls for the imposition on anyone of the counts of crime of

which the accused is found guilty, the convicted offender shall suffer the maximum penalty in the

maximum range of penalty imposed by law regardless of the number of counts of charges the

accused is convicted with;

(b) If the accused is found guilty of two counts out of the several counts of crimes

charged against him, the convicted offender shall suffer the medium range of the maximum penalty

imposed by law of the crime committed regardless of whether the penalty in either of the count of

crimes the accused has been convicted for is punishable with the lowest penalty in the minimum

range as prescribed by law. If one of the said two counts for which the accused is found guilty is

punishable by law with the maximum penalty, in such case, the said maximum penalty shall be

imposed upon the convicted offender.

(7) If the total of the guilty jury votes is unanimous, or twelve, with finding of, or more,

aggravating circumstance and no, or lesser mitigating circumstance, and the crime committed is

punishable by death or life in prison, the penalty of life in prison at hard labor shall be imposed on

the convicted offender with no benefit of an executive clemency or parol regardless of his age or

gender notwithstanding any existing law, executive order, or rule, to the contrary.

(8) Unless a specific penalty by imprisonment in this law has been prescribed over a

particular act defined as a crime of obstruction of justice, the penalty by imprisonment shall be

three years and one day as minimum to five years and one day as maximum imprisonment

penalty.

Page 403: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

370

(9) Regardless of the duration, or degree, of penalty imposed in the foregoing

sub-section or elsewhere in this Law, the convicted offender shall suffer perpetual disqualification

from holding any position or office of the government or government owned or controlled

corporation and quasi-government corporation or entity.

(10) Any public official, regardless of title, rank or position, who shall violate the

immediately preceding sub-section in appointing, or in recommending to appoint, a public official

or employee to a public office or position shall likewise be liable for obstruction of justice upon

investigation and indictment by a grand jury regardless of whether such appointee has been a

beneficiary of a presidential clemency or parole.

(11) If the convicted felon has been incarcerated while awaiting the outcome of the case

against him, the period of time of his incarceration shall be deducted from the penalty imposed by

law over the crime for which he has been found guilty by the jury. If he is acquitted of the crime

charged against him, he shall be entitled to an indemnity in the form of a compensation equal to

two-thirds of the legal minimum wage as of the date he has been actually released from detention.

If he is convicted and he has served in detention for a period beyond the period of the prescribed

penalty of imprisonment for his crime, he shall be compensated in the same manner for the excess

period of imprisonment.

(12) The convicted offender may receive clemency or pardon from the president in good

faith for humanitarian reason subject to scrutiny by a grand jury upon complaint for obstruction of

justice by any citizen or by the media or member of the media. Clemency or pardon based on

political consideration or bribery or of conviction of offenders of serious crimes punishable by death

or life in prison upon unanimous verdict of a trial jury shall be void and without effect and shall be

ground for investigation and indictment for obstruction of justice against the president.

(13) Clemency or pardon based on political consideration is hereby defined as clemency

or pardon with the expectation that the public official granting such clemency or pardon may obtain

enhancement of his political standing or for that of a family kin or upon solicitation of a political ally

or confederate regardless of whether such grant comes from the recommendation of a parol board,

bureau, or commission.

Section 10. Televising the jury trial -

(1) A jury trial may be televised or video taped at the discretion of the judge upon motion

of the media provided that its camera shall, at no moment, be focused on the face or faces of a

juror or jurors and provided further that the television equipment shall be stationary and no member

of its crew or reporter shall be permitted to move around the court room or to make a comment

while the jury trial is in progress. The television equipment shall be situated in accordance with the

court room layout as prescribed in Form TJ-133. A person in violation of this prohibition shall be

subject to direct contempt of court and the Presiding Judge, on his own motion, may terminate the

video taping of the trial and shall further order the impounding of the film of the video tape and the

banning of any further broadcast on television or on radio.

Page 404: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

371

(2) If there is a necessity that a jury trial shall be televised to accommodate the needs

of the viewing public and there are not enough seats in the court room for use of the viewing public,

the presiding judge may order to televise the jury trial upon his own motion or upon motion by any

party to the case or by the media.

Section 11. No claim for mistrial in a jury trial shall be entertained before any court of

law. If a party is aggrieved by the verdict by reason of fraud, bribery, or illegal interference by any

party, the aggrieved party may file his complaint before a grand jury for secret investigation and

filing of the appropriate indictment against the alleged responsible party as soon as he gains any

knowledge on any of such grounds but not beyond one calendar year from the date the verdict was

read in court.

Section 12. Security for the Jury Trial - A jury trial may be held in another jury district

outside its normal court location or venue if there is danger that the trial may be disrupted in such

location by reason of the poor or deteriorating peace and order condition or due to the possible

strong influence of the accused in mobilizing his followers to interfere with the jury trial or to

threaten witnesses, court personnel, the prosecutor, the judge, as well as the jurors, in attending

the trial.

(1) The jury trial shall be held in a different judicial district or court jurisdiction anywhere

in the country upon motion by either of the parties or their respective counsels or by the court on

its own motion or order where adequate protection for all concerned in the trial can be guaranteed

by police authorities.

(2) To ensure the presence of such police authorities, the prosecutor shall serve with

proof of service to all parties concerned a written request for that purpose to the Philippine National

Police no later than thirty (30) calendar days prior to the commencement date of the trial. If the

location of trial is one hundred fifty (150) kilometers or more away from the regular trial court

jurisdiction, such notice shall be served by the prosecutor no later than sixty (60) calendar days

prior to the commencement date of the trial.

(3) The determination of the trial location shall be decided at the pretrial conference in

setting the firm trial date of the case.

(4) Regardless of the location or venue of the trial and it appears that any party to the

case may be inviting extraordinary concern or interest from his sympathizers who may cause

eminent danger to the safety and well being of the jurors, the presiding judge shall order the

provision of a safe common shelter for the jurors in an appropriate hotel with food whenever the

trial is on recess with police protection for the duration of the trial at government expense.

(5) The seating location and arrangement of the seats of the jurors shall conform to the

set up of the Jury Trial Court Room arrangement as outlined in Form TJ-133.

(6) The foregoing seating arrangements shall be such that all public viewers during the

Page 405: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

372

trial shall all be seated respectively at the back of the jurors and at the back of the defense and

prosecution attorneys.

Section 13. A jury trial shall be absolutely civil in character. Any witness who shall testify

in a jury trial shall be required to wear a civilian attire. A witness who is a member of the military

or police force shall be barred from testifying in a jury trial unless in civilian attire and without any

official insignia.

Section 14. Sealing personal information of the jurors - Promptly after the reading of the

verdict of the jury, the Presiding Judge shall order to securely seal the records pertaining to the

personal information of the jurors. Such records, once sealed, shall not be opened, except by a

grand jury in the event a criminal complaint is filed within one (1) year from the date of the reading

of the verdict at issue in open court by an aggrieved party before said grand jury on grounds of

fraud, bribery, or illegal interference by any party or any third party.

Section 15. Appeal from Jury Verdict.

(1) An accused may appeal a guilty verdict against him to an appellate court on error of

law. The finding of facts by the jury shall not be appealed.

(2) All other aspects of appeal in criminal cases to an appellate court shall follow the

same procedures under the current Rules of Court.

(3) The prosecution has no right to appeal a “not guilty” verdict by the jury.

Section 16. Accelerated implementation of the National Jury Law -

(1) Upon approval of the National Jury Law by the people, the Executive Judge and his

Clerk of Court are hereby mandated to commence the formation of the respective grand jury of

their congressional districts. Expenses incurred for this activity shall be paid by means of the

Redeemable Voucher Form GJ-27.

(2) The paying entity for expenditures incurred and paid via the Redeemable Voucher,

Form GJ-27, shall submit his voucher directly to the National Treasurer for prompt reimbursement.

Thereafter, the National Treasurer shall, in turn, submit to the Department of Budget and

Management for inclusion of such voucher payments in the ensuing fiscal year’s national budget.

(3) The executive regional trial judge and his clerk of court shall post in a newspaper with

general circulation and in their hallway bulletin boards an invitation for grand jury membership

applicants upon the approval of this Law.

Page 406: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

373

GRAND JURY VOLUNTEER SERVICE

(4) Pending the approval of a formal budget expenditure for the National Jury Law, the

executive regional trial judge and his clerk of court shall post in a newspaper with general

circulation and in their hallway bulletin boards an invitation for grand jury volunteer membership

applicants without pay upon the approval of the adoption of this Law. The acts of the volunteers

to secretly investigate and indict in court of suspected crime offenders shall be held officially valid

as if they have applied as a fully compensated grand jury membership applicants.

(5) If during the term of service of volunteer grand jury members, the funds for the jury

budget is approved by Congress, such volunteers shall be paid retroactively from the date such

volunteers started their jury service plus reasonable amount of their expenses for launch and

transportation in reporting for jury service.

(6) The form of the announcement and application for grand jury membership shall

conform to the prescribed forms by the NJMA in the implementing jury rules to this Law. The

executive judge, his clerk of court and staff members of his court is mandatorily required to refrain

from disclosing the names of the applicants for grand jury members regardless of whether he is

a volunteer applicant or not. Except in writing his name in his application for submission to the

clerk of court or his deputy office staff, the applicant for grand jury membership shall not, at any

moment, reveal to any body his true name or about his family members.

TRIAL JURY VOLUNTEER SERVICE

(7) Pending the approval of a formal budget expenditure for the National Jury Law, the

executive regional trial judge and his clerk of court shall post in a newspaper with general

circulation and in their hallway bulletin boards an invitation for Trial Jury volunteers to serve as

jurors, without pay or per diem, to decide cases that are scheduled for jury trial in a certain date

and time. Upon approval of the budget for the National Jury Law by Congress, the jurors shall be

paid retroactively plus reasonable amount of their expenses for launch and transportation for

reporting for jury duty.

(8) Upon appearance of a volunteer juror, he shall be ushered to the JAR (Jury

Assembly Room) to sign the JAL (“Jurors’ Appearance Logbook”) and thereupon he shall be

provided with the IQS (Impaneling Questioner Sheet), Form TJ-109 A for accomplishment. The

same procedure and qualification of jurors to empanel jurors for jury service as promulgated in

Article IV, Section 1(a) through 1(m), inclusive, shall govern the empaneling of volunteer jury

servers.

(9) The executive regional trial judge and his clerk of court shall respectively receive ten

percent (10%) additional compensation over their current salary commencing the date of the

publication of the invitation for grand jury membership until such time that a standard

compensation for their service has been set up.

Page 407: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

374

(10) In clustered courts, the trial judges of such courts shall come to an agreement to

appoint one of the deputy clerk of courts from among the most senior deputy clerk of court to serve

as jury commissioner for all the clustered courts, until they shall have appointed a Jury

Commissioner to serve their courts.

(11) In areas where individual trial courts are far apart by two kilometers, their clerk of

court shall act and perform the duties of a jury commissioner.

(12) In the absence of a Jury Commissioner, the Clerk of Court shall act to perform the

duties of the Jury Commissioner in the National Jury Law.

(13) Clerk of courts and clerk of trial courts acting as jury commissioners shall receive

ten percent (10%) of pay over their current salaries or compensation until such time that a standard

compensation for their service has been set up by law.

(14) Any judge and any clerk of court or deputy clerk of court required to perform the

duties to accelerate the implementation of the National Jury Law shall be liable for malversation

of public funds as defined by law who shall collect his incremental pay without prior compliance

with his duties in this section.

(15) An existing court trial interpreter shall likewise act as a interpreter in the court where

he is currently employed during a trial by jury. If for any reason he shall have been terminated as

an interpreter, he shall not be eligible for rehiring in any court unless he shall have passed the

examination and certification as a jury trial interpreter required by this National Jury Law.

Section 17. Unless the context of any provision of this National Jury Law clearly indicates

otherwise, the plural shall include the singular, the past and present shall include the future, and

the male gender shall include the female gender, and vice versa.

Section 18. The Postal Service Personnel shall be required to handle any jury mail

matter as a registered mail when clearly shown on the face of the mailing envelope thereof as part

of its official activity in contributing to the success in the adoption of the National Jury Law.

Section 19. Any person who has been convicted of a serious crime as defined in this

Law shall absolutely lose his privilege to run for, or occupy by appointment, any public, or quasi

public office including government owned or controlled or quasi-government corporation

notwithstanding executive clemency or presidential pardon granted to him by the President of the

Philippines.

Section 20. Nothing in this Jury Law shall imply the abrogation of the power of judicial,

executive, legislative officials of the government in issuing subpoena, subpoena duces tecum,

summons and other similar processes.

Page 408: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

375

ARTICLE XII

JURY TRIAL INTERPRETERS

Section 1. Court Interpreters for Jury Trials. Each jury trial court shall employ a court

certified interpreter who shall interpret during a jury trial from English and into Tagalog or into the

local dialect commonly spoken and understood by the jurors in their jury court district. The position

of jury trial interpreters shall be professionalized and properly certified. The certification shall be

issued by the executive judge of said jury court district. To qualify for certification, the applicant for

interpreter shall satisfy the following requirements:

(1) A holder of any bachelor’s degree in an accredited college or university and a citizen

of the Philippines. The clerk of court shall invite an unlimited number of applicants to submit their

applications to the position of the jury trial interpreter in the trial courts of his judicial district and in

which he shall state the rate of pay to the position of the trial jury interpreter.

(2) He must be proficient in English, Tagalog, or the local dialect in the judicial district

of the court where he will serve as a jury trial interpreter;

(3) He shall pass a written interpreting examination for which he shall be given at least

30 days to prepare prior to the date of the examination. The examination questions shall be

formulated with emphasis towards learning the commonly used jury instruction words, and legal

terminologies in court proceedings and phrases for interpreting into the local dialect and vice versa

by a committee of five members. The committee shall be composed of the presiding judge of the

court, where the chosen interpreter will serve, a government prosecutor and three private

practicians attorneys as members in the same judicial district.

(4) The applicant-examinee who obtains a grade of 75 or higher in the written

examination shall be interviewed and he must show excellent ability to interpret

contemporaneously before the committee that shall then choose by secret ballot at least ten (10)

of the applicants with the highest grades the committee considers best qualified for

contemporaneous interpreter’s position.

(5) The names of the qualified applicants who have passed the interview for the

interpreter’s position shall be entered in the lottery container from which one applicant’s name shall

promptly be drawn in the presence of all the applicants who passed the interview and who will be

appointed as the regular jury interpreter appointee. The rest of the names shall be kept for three

years for future lottery drawings for appointment in the event the regular appointee is unable to

continue to serve or in the event a vacancy needs to be filled or an additional interpreter will be

needed.

(6) If there are other trial courts within the district that require interpreters, the respective

vacancies for such courts may be filled in by picking the name by lottery from the remaining

Page 409: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

376

qualified interpreters. All future drawing of names shall be conducted in the presence of the

prospective qualified interpreters who shall be informed in writing in advance of at least 30 days

for such purpose. Appointing an interpreter without going through this lottery process shall be null

and void.

Section 2. The interpreter’s rate of pay shall be recommended by the presiding judge

of the court in which the appointee shall serve.

Section 3. An interpreter shall be held to the highest standard of confidentiality and shall

be subject to decertification for violation of this proscription. Unless required by the court in a

proceeding held for the purpose of restating any matter he has interpreted in a court proceeding,

an interpreter shall neither voluntarily reveal nor shall be forced to reveal on any information he

acquired, officially or privately, while being employed as a court interpreter.

Page 410: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

377

ARTICLE XIII

EFFECTIVITY OF THE NATIONAL JURY LAW

Section 1. Any act punishable as a crime of obstruction of justice committed prior to the

enactment of this law which has not yet prescribed for prosecution shall be subject to prosecution

under the rules of this Jury Law upon the date of its effectivity.

Section 2. Any offense punishable by imprisonment for one year or more and its crime

suspect has already been indicted by the Ombudsman or by any government prosecutor and the

trial against the accused has not yet commenced upon the effective date of this Law, or if trial has

already commenced and it is ascertained that it cannot be completed within six (6) months by

bench trial after this law has taken effect, the accused in such indictment shall be tried by jury in

accordance with the provision of the National Jury Law.

Section 3. Any government prosecutor or his deputy who has been officially designated

to prosecute the criminal case under the category defined above who fails or failed to comply with

his duty to commence to prosecute the matter within thirty (30) days, Saturdays, Sundays, and

Holidays, excluded, from the date he was designated to prosecute the matter, shall be liable for

the crime of Obstruction of Justice upon secret investigation and indictment by a grand jury on the

complaint of the accused, or by the crime victim or relative or friend of such victim or by a member

of the public through the media.

Section 4. After the effectivity of the National Jury Law, all existing jury systems, if any,

operating in provinces, cities, municipalities, or barangays, or barrios, shall automatically convert

to, and be governed by, the rules, instructions, and regulations of this Law. This National Jury Law

shall thereupon absorb the expenses of the jury operations in such government instrumentality.

If the jury law of such provinces and cities contain provisions where drawing of allowances and

money advances by political and supervisory officials in said provinces and cities of funds shall

trigger additional jury funding, the same shall remain in effect and the funds generated therefrom

shall be credited and utilized to augment judicial funds in underwriting the expenses to operate the

trial courts of such provinces and cities.

Section 5. Land owners, or their heirs, who may have lost their land ownership as a

result of fake or spurious documentation issued by Registrar of Deeds shall have the right to

reacquire their property by jury trial with the filing of their complaint with the grand jury in their jury

Page 411: Proposed Philippine Jury Law

378

district within seven (7) years, effective from the date of the approval of the National Jury Law.

All controversies relating to land ownership and judicial land registration shall be resolved by a jury

trial after the passage of this jury law.

Section 6. Upon effectivity of this Law, no government treasurer or paymaster shall have

the authority to pay any government obligation and/or expenditures, except regular salaries and

wages of government employees and officials, unless the same shall have been pre-audited by

an authorized auditor of the Commission on Audit. If the total payment of an obligation and/or

expenditure exceeds one hundred thousand pesos, such representative must be a certified public

accountant.

Section 7. This law shall take effect upon election for its approval by the people and

fifteen (15) days after its publication in the official gazette or fifteen (15) days after the publication

of all its provisions in a newspaper with general circulation in the Philippines whichever comes first.

Section 8. Date approved by the Filipino People on: _____________, Year ________.

(End of the Code Provisions)

Copyright 2015 by Atty. Marlowe Camello

Email: [email protected]