proposall on streamlliiniing assessment framework of ... · assessment framework of assessment...

14
1 22 October 2011 22 October 2011 Proposal on Streamlining Proposal on Streamlining Assessment Framework of Assessment Framework of Independent Enquiry Study of Independent Enquiry Study of Liberal Studies Liberal Studies

Upload: others

Post on 31-Jan-2020

7 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Proposall on Streamlliiniing Assessment Framework of ... · Assessment Framework of Assessment Framework of Independent Enquiry Study of Independent Enquiry Study of ... and assessment

1

22 October 201122 October 2011

Proposal on StreamliningProposal on Streamlining

Assessment Framework ofAssessment Framework of

Independent Enquiry Study ofIndependent Enquiry Study of

Liberal StudiesLiberal Studies

Page 2: Proposall on Streamlliiniing Assessment Framework of ... · Assessment Framework of Assessment Framework of Independent Enquiry Study of Independent Enquiry Study of ... and assessment

PPrriinncciipplleess ooff SSttrreeaammlliinniinngg

Should not change the design principles of the curriculum

and assessment framework

Uphold the spirit of IES – integral part of learning & teaching

and essential component of the public assessment, with due consideration given to the interests and benefit of students

Streamlining through reducing administrative work in conducting the assessments and submitting marks, to make

IES more manageable for students and teachers but not at

the expense of essential learning elements

2

Page 3: Proposall on Streamlliiniing Assessment Framework of ... · Assessment Framework of Assessment Framework of Independent Enquiry Study of Independent Enquiry Study of ... and assessment

WWhhyy SSttrreeaammlliinniinngg??

Feedback from schools through principals, teachers, district coordinators, CDC-HKEAA Committees and

various studies

Major concerns:

Students’ and teachers’ workload

No. of subjects with SBA increases to 21 in 2014 HKDSE

Streamlining proposals with a view to addressing critical

concerns, including workload issues, in a timely manner while upholding the spirit of SBA for the benefit of

students

3

Page 4: Proposall on Streamlliiniing Assessment Framework of ... · Assessment Framework of Assessment Framework of Independent Enquiry Study of Independent Enquiry Study of ... and assessment

WWhhyy SSttrreeaammlliinniinngg??

Workload issue:

administrative and professional

• Student work

collection

• Mark submissions

• Handling of irregularity

cases, etc.

• Marking standardization

• Implementation of

Process assessment

• Mark adjustment, etc.

4

Page 5: Proposall on Streamlliiniing Assessment Framework of ... · Assessment Framework of Assessment Framework of Independent Enquiry Study of Independent Enquiry Study of ... and assessment

130130130130 35.0%35.0%35.0%35.0%5 (Strongly Agree)5 (Strongly Agree)5 (Strongly Agree)5 (Strongly Agree)

5

TeachersTeachers’’ ViewsViews

123123123123

46464646

52525252

20202020

NNNN

33.2%33.2%33.2%33.2%4444

12.4%12.4%12.4%12.4%3333

14.0%14.0%14.0%14.0%2222

5.4%5.4%5.4%5.4%1 (Strongly Disagree)1 (Strongly Disagree)1 (Strongly Disagree)1 (Strongly Disagree)

%%%%Level of AgreementLevel of AgreementLevel of AgreementLevel of Agreement

mean:3.78

Almost 70%70%70%70% of the teachers agreed or strongly agreed that

combination of the Process assessment with Task assessment

can be considered

Q.9: I agree that combinationcombinationcombinationcombination ofofofof the Processthe Processthe Processthe Process assessment withassessment withassessment withassessment with TaskTaskTaskTask

assessmentassessmentassessmentassessment can be considered

Page 6: Proposall on Streamlliiniing Assessment Framework of ... · Assessment Framework of Assessment Framework of Independent Enquiry Study of Independent Enquiry Study of ... and assessment

122122122122 32.8%32.8%32.8%32.8%5 (Strongly Agree)5 (Strongly Agree)5 (Strongly Agree)5 (Strongly Agree)

6

TeachersTeachers’’ ViewsViews

126126126126

68686868

43434343

13131313

NNNN

33.9%33.9%33.9%33.9%4444

18.3%18.3%18.3%18.3%3333

11.6%11.6%11.6%11.6%2222

3.5%3.5%3.5%3.5%1 (Strongly Disagree)1 (Strongly Disagree)1 (Strongly Disagree)1 (Strongly Disagree)

%%%%Level of AgreementLevel of AgreementLevel of AgreementLevel of Agreement

mean:3.81

Nearly 70%70%70%70% of the teachers agreed or strongly agreed that integration of

the work of the three stages of assessment can be considered

Q.10: I agree that integrationintegrationintegrationintegration ofofofof thethethethe work of the three stages ofwork of the three stages ofwork of the three stages ofwork of the three stages of

assessmentassessmentassessmentassessment can be considered

Page 7: Proposall on Streamlliiniing Assessment Framework of ... · Assessment Framework of Assessment Framework of Independent Enquiry Study of Independent Enquiry Study of ... and assessment

WWhhyy 22001144??

Earliest year of implementation of proposed changes to the IES would be 2014 HKDSE

because schools have already started IES for the 2013 cohort

Any streamlining should not affect schools and students for whom IES Task and Process have already started

Experiences gained and review upon the completion of implementation of the 2012 HKDSE

would help inform the way forward

7

Page 8: Proposall on Streamlliiniing Assessment Framework of ... · Assessment Framework of Assessment Framework of Independent Enquiry Study of Independent Enquiry Study of ... and assessment

CuCurrrreenntt AsAssseessssmmeenntt FFrraammeewwoorrkk

1

1

1

No. of

Marks to be

submitted

for Task

(50%)

1

1

1

No. of

Marks to be

submitted

for Process

(50%)

Weighting

(%) ComponentYear

S6

S5

Product

Data

Collection

Project

Proposal

50%

25%

25%

8

Page 9: Proposall on Streamlliiniing Assessment Framework of ... · Assessment Framework of Assessment Framework of Independent Enquiry Study of Independent Enquiry Study of ... and assessment

PPrrooppoosseedd AAsssseessssmmeenntt FFrraammeewwoorrkk

1

1

No. of

Marks to be

submitted

for Task

(80%)

1

No. of

Marks to be

submitted

for Process

(20%)

Task Weighting

(%) ComponentYear

S6

S5

Product

Project

Proposal

55%

25%

9

Page 10: Proposall on Streamlliiniing Assessment Framework of ... · Assessment Framework of Assessment Framework of Independent Enquiry Study of Independent Enquiry Study of ... and assessment

Streamlining ProposalStreamlining Proposal

1 (55%)

1 (25%)

No. of Marks to be

submitted for Task (80%)

1

No. of Marks to be

submitted for

Process (20%)

ComponentYear

S6

S5

Product

Project

Proposal

Work of data collection reflected in the Product

and to be assessed together

Two times of marking and mark

submission for Task

Smaller number of Process activities

designed and assessed

10

Page 11: Proposall on Streamlliiniing Assessment Framework of ... · Assessment Framework of Assessment Framework of Independent Enquiry Study of Independent Enquiry Study of ... and assessment

FFeeaattuurreess ooff tthhee PPrrooppoossaall

The issue of workload related to assessment

is addressed to a certain extent

The principle and original design are

maintained

Three stages of learning and teaching

process remain unchanged

The weightings are commensurate with the

amount of work involved in different parts

Enhance the reliability of the assessment

11

Page 12: Proposall on Streamlliiniing Assessment Framework of ... · Assessment Framework of Assessment Framework of Independent Enquiry Study of Independent Enquiry Study of ... and assessment

TTiimmee FFrraammee

May - Aug 2011: Formulating streamlining proposals by CDI and

HKEAA

Sep – Oct 2011:

Presenting the proposals to Principals’ Liaison Meeting, SBA Advisory Group, CDC-HKEAA

Committees for discussion

14 Oct 2011:

Briefing sessions for school leaders

12

Page 13: Proposall on Streamlliiniing Assessment Framework of ... · Assessment Framework of Assessment Framework of Independent Enquiry Study of Independent Enquiry Study of ... and assessment

TTiimmee FFrraammee

Oct – Nov 2011: Sharing the proposals with teachers at SBA subject conferences

Nov - Dec 2011:

Consulting schools about the proposals

Jan - Feb 2012:

Endorsement sought from the Public Examinations

Board

Feb 2012: Informing schools of the finalised arrangements

13

Page 14: Proposall on Streamlliiniing Assessment Framework of ... · Assessment Framework of Assessment Framework of Independent Enquiry Study of Independent Enquiry Study of ... and assessment

14

~ Thank You ~