program: early childhood education bsed & post-baccalaureate€¦ · 2014-2015 annual program...

40
1 1 2014-2015 Annual Program Assessment and Improvement Report Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate Expanded Statement of Institutional Purpose: The B.S.Ed. program in Early Childhood Education supports the Columbus State University (CSU) mission to contribute to the advancement of our local and global communities through an emphasis on excellence in teaching and research, life-long learning, cultural enrichment, partnerships, and service to others. The ECE program engages candidates in the use of inquiry-based teaching and learning, field-based experiences in P-5 early childhood environments, and opportunities to engage in experiences with outstanding faculty members in the discipline. The program provides students with opportunities to participate in practicum and student teaching experiences that provide first-hand experience in understanding and teaching in the early childhood classroom. The ECE program continues to grow at all levels and is currently one of the largest in the university. Program Outcomes Assessment Method Assessment Criteria Assessment Results/Analysis Program Improvements Implemented Based on Assessment Results 1. Prepare individuals seeking initial certification to become effective Early Childhood teachers (B.S.Ed. and Post- Baccalaureate). Model of Appropriate Practice (MAP) and Disposition Evaluation One hundred percent of the teacher candidates must meet or exceed expectations (e.g., ratings of satisfactory or accomplished novice on the MAP AND ratings of proficient or exemplary on the Disposition Evaluation) on all elements for exit from student teaching. The teacher education faculty members aspire to increase students’ performances to consistently demonstrate meeting or exceeding the expectations throughout the program (i.e., Blocks 1-3) by providing more opportunities for teacher candidates to teach and be observed by faculty members. AY 15: 45 student teachers, seeking initial teacher certification successfully completed student teaching in 2014-2015. 100% of the teacher candidates received satisfactory or accomplished novice on all elements of the Model of Appropriate Practice Observation Scoring Rubric (MAP). AY14 data indicates 99% of the BSEd ECE teacher candidates received satisfactory or accomplished novice on the MAP. As compared to the AY15 data of 100% receiving satisfactory or accomplished novice, this indicated an increase over the year. AY15 100% of the teacher candidates received proficient or exemplary on all of the elements for the Disposition Evaluation AY14 data indicates 99% of the BSEd ECE teacher candidates received satisfactory or accomplished novice. As The ECE faculty increased the number of times teacher candidates were being observed in their lab placements (e.g., blocks) prior to student teaching. The purpose of the increase in observations was to provide both the teacher candidates and faculty with data to indicate if the teacher candidates were ready for student teaching. Additionally, in AY15, the ECE faculty developed critical assignments (e.g., Analysis of Teaching Effectiveness) to serve as gateways for teacher candidates being able to move onto the next block and/or student teaching without the need for remedial support. The critical assignments are aligned with the ECE program’s SLO’s and INTASC standards. Future plan: We will continue monitoring teacher candidates' performance data to ensure that teacher candidates are consistently demonstrating proficiency in meeting or

Upload: others

Post on 30-Sep-2020

4 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate€¦ · 2014-2015 Annual Program Assessment and Improvement Report Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate

1

1

2014-2015 Annual Program Assessment and Improvement Report

Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate

Expanded Statement of Institutional Purpose: The B.S.Ed. program in Early Childhood Education supports the Columbus State University (CSU) mission to contribute to the advancement of our local and global communities

through an emphasis on excellence in teaching and research, life-long learning, cultural enrichment, partnerships, and service to others. The ECE program engages candidates in

the use of inquiry-based teaching and learning, field-based experiences in P-5 early childhood environments, and opportunities to engage in experiences with outstanding faculty

members in the discipline. The program provides students with opportunities to participate in practicum and student teaching experiences that provide first-hand experience in

understanding and teaching in the early childhood classroom. The ECE program continues to grow at all levels and is currently one of the largest in the university.

Program Outcomes Assessment Method Assessment Criteria Assessment Results/Analysis Program Improvements

Implemented Based on

Assessment Results

1. Prepare individuals seeking

initial certification to become

effective Early Childhood

teachers (B.S.Ed. and Post-

Baccalaureate).

Model of Appropriate Practice

(MAP) and Disposition

Evaluation

One hundred percent of the

teacher candidates must meet or

exceed expectations (e.g., ratings

of satisfactory or accomplished

novice on the MAP AND ratings

of proficient or exemplary on the

Disposition Evaluation) on all

elements for exit from student

teaching.

The teacher education faculty

members aspire to increase

students’ performances to

consistently demonstrate meeting

or exceeding the expectations

throughout the program (i.e.,

Blocks 1-3) by providing more

opportunities for teacher

candidates to teach and be

observed by faculty members.

AY 15: 45 student teachers,

seeking initial teacher

certification successfully

completed student teaching in

2014-2015. 100% of the teacher

candidates received satisfactory

or accomplished novice on all

elements of the Model of

Appropriate Practice Observation

Scoring Rubric (MAP).

AY14 data indicates 99% of the

BSEd ECE teacher candidates

received satisfactory or

accomplished novice on the

MAP. As compared to the AY15

data of 100% receiving

satisfactory or accomplished

novice, this indicated an increase

over the year.

AY15 100% of the teacher

candidates received proficient or

exemplary on all of the elements

for the Disposition Evaluation

AY14 data indicates 99% of the

BSEd ECE teacher candidates

received satisfactory or

accomplished novice. As

The ECE faculty increased the

number of times teacher

candidates were being observed

in their lab placements (e.g.,

blocks) prior to student teaching.

The purpose of the increase in

observations was to provide both

the teacher candidates and faculty

with data to indicate if the teacher

candidates were ready for student

teaching.

Additionally, in AY15, the ECE

faculty developed critical

assignments (e.g., Analysis of

Teaching Effectiveness) to serve

as gateways for teacher

candidates being able to move

onto the next block and/or student

teaching without the need for

remedial support. The critical

assignments are aligned with the

ECE program’s SLO’s and

INTASC standards.

Future plan: We will continue

monitoring teacher candidates'

performance data to ensure that

teacher candidates are

consistently demonstrating

proficiency in meeting or

Page 2: Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate€¦ · 2014-2015 Annual Program Assessment and Improvement Report Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate

2

2

compared to AY15, there was a

1% increase over the year.

exceeding expectations as they

progress through the program.

The purpose is to ensure teacher

candidates are indeed providing

evidence to be recommended for

initial teacher certification.

2. Increase the number of teacher

candidates enrolled in the

program (B.S.Ed. and Post-

Baccalaureate).

Annual review of number of

teacher candidates admitted each

fall and spring

The ECE program faculty

members aspire to increase the

number of teacher candidates

enrolled in the BSEd & Post Bac

program by 5%. The faculty

members will develop recruiting

efforts early (e.g., high school

teacher cadet programs).

Additionally, the Early

Childhood Organization (ECHO)

begins seeking members early in

potential teacher candidates’

college careers (e.g., freshman

and sophomore years). The

purpose of the early recruitment

is to increase retaining potential

teacher candidates for the field of

Early Childhood Education.

AY 15 data: 44 teacher

candidates were admitted to

Teacher Education Program in

2014-15 and began taking classes

in Early Childhood Education

Block 1

AY14: 59 teacher candidates

were admitted to Teacher

Education Program in 2013-2014

and began taking classes in ECE

Block 1

The national trend for college

students choosing education as

their major indicates a decline.

The ECE program is not an

exception to the decline.

The ECE faculty members for

AY15 were committed to

increasing the number of teacher

candidates enrolling in the

program by:

1. Collaborated with Teacher

Cadet Programs within the

Partner School Network (high

school students identifying early

childhood education as their

majors) for recruiting purposes;

the ECE advisor met with a group

of aspiring educator majors

2. ECE Faculty members

attended the university Discovery

Days that occur throughout the

year. The ECE faculty shared

what potential teacher candidates

can experience while working

within the program (purpose-

recruiting).

3. The ECE faculty recommended

two ECE teacher candidates to

serve as Student Ambassadors.

The purpose of the Student

Ambassador program is to help in

recruiting efforts (e.g., share their

success stories and advice) and to

help in retaining efforts (e.g.,

share success stories and advice).

Future Plan:

The ECE program faculty are re-

developing the online ECE

program orientation and have

Page 3: Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate€¦ · 2014-2015 Annual Program Assessment and Improvement Report Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate

3

3

made it a co-requisite with EDRG

2156, prior to entry into the

program.

3. Admit a diverse group of

teacher candidates into the

program (B.S.Ed. and Post-

Baccalaureate).

Annual review of teacher

candidates' demographics

The ECE program faculty

members aspire to increase the

number of diverse teacher

candidates enrolled in the BSEd

& Post Bac program by 5%. The

faculty members will begin the

recruiting efforts early (e.g., high

school teacher cadet programs).

The school district in which we

partner with for field placements

represents a diverse population.

Additionally, the Early

Childhood Organization (ECHO)

begins seeking members early in

potential teacher candidates’

college careers (e.g., freshman

and sophomore years). The

purpose of the early recruitment

is to increase retaining potential

teacher candidates for the field of

Early Childhood Education.

Furthermore, the university

markets areas surrounding

Atlanta, GA with the campaign,

“My First Choice.” The areas

surrounding ATL represent a

diverse population.

AY 15: teacher candidates

enrolled in initial certification

ECE program (e.g., blocks and

student teaching) included 126

female, 5 male, and

48 minority teacher candidates.

AY 14: teacher candidates

enrolled in initial certification

programs included 156 female,

7 male, and

53 minority students

Although there was a decline in

the number of teacher candidates

enrolled in the ECE program, the

ratio for diverse students to non-

diverse students from AY14 to

AY15 increased (but not by the

program goal for increase of 5%

annually):

AY14- 34% diverse

students

AY15- 38% diverse

students

The ECE faculty members for

AY15 were committed to

increasing the number of diverse

teacher candidates enrolling in

the program by:

1. Collaborated with Teacher

Cadet Programs within the

Partner School Network (high

school students identifying early

childhood education as their

majors) for recruiting purposes;

the ECE advisor met with a group

of aspiring educator majors; the

potential teacher candidates

represented a diverse population

2. ECE Faculty members

attended the university Discovery

Days that occur throughout the

year. The ECE faculty shared

what potential teacher candidates

can experience while working

within the program (purpose-

recruiting). Potential teacher

candidates and their families

represent a diverse population.

3. The ECE faculty recommended

two ECE teacher candidates (one

of which represents a diverse

background) to serve as Student

Ambassadors. The purpose of the

Student Ambassador program is

to help in recruiting efforts (e.g.,

share their success stories and

advice) and to help in retaining

Page 4: Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate€¦ · 2014-2015 Annual Program Assessment and Improvement Report Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate

4

4

efforts (e.g., share success stories

and advice).

Student Learning Outcomes Assessment Method Assessment Criteria Assessment Results/Analysis Program Improvements

Implemented Based on

Assessment Results

1.1 Demonstrate commitment to

the teaching profession and the

teaching field of early childhood

Model of Appropriate Practice

(MAP) elements related to SLO

1.1:

4a. Reflecting on teaching

4b. Maintaining accurate records

4c. Communicating with families

4d. Contributing to school and

district

4e. Growing and develops

professionally

4f. Showing professionalism

One hundred percent of teacher

candidates, at exit of the

program, must meet or exceed

expectations for the following

elements related to the MAP

(e.g., ratings of satisfactory or

accomplished novice on the

MAP):

4a. Reflecting on teaching

4b. Maintaining accurate records

4c. Communicating with families

4d. Contributing to school and

district

4e. Growing and develops

professionally

4f. Showing professionalism

BSEd Early Childhood Teacher

Candidates (N = 126)

n = 81 teacher candidates were

enrolled in Blocks 1, 2, & 3(prior

to student teaching)

n=45 teacher candidates that

were student teaching

Ratings on MAP elements for

Student Learning Outcome 1.1

are as follows:

4a. Reflecting on teaching

Accomplished Novice: 49%

(n=62)

Satisfactory: 41% (n=52)

Emerging: 9% (n=11)

Unsatisfactory: 1% (n=1)

***AY14 data indicates 20% of

the ECE teacher candidates were

rated as accomplished novice

related to 4a (reflecting on

teaching) as compared to 49% of

AY 15 teacher.

4b. Maintaining accurate records

Accomplished Novice: 31%

Satisfactory: 54%

Emerging: 10%

Unsatisfactory: 3%

4c. Communicating with families

Accomplished Novice: 25%

The ECE faculty members are

committed to collecting evidence

for teacher candidates to

demonstrate their commitment to

the teaching profession and the

teaching field of early childhood.

The following procedure was

enacted for AY15:

In regard to the increase in

teacher candidates scoring

accomplished novice for MAP

element 4a, reflection on

teaching, the ECE faculty

members have embedded critical

assignments that provide teacher

candidates with opportunities to

critically reflect on their teaching

as opposed to summarizing their

teaching in their reflections.

Furthermore, the ECE faculty

members revised the reflection

portion of the rubric to indicate

teacher candidates’

responsibilities to support their

analyses of teaching and

students’ learning with research

and/or theory.

Ongoing plan:

An overall plan has been

implemented to identify students

Page 5: Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate€¦ · 2014-2015 Annual Program Assessment and Improvement Report Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate

5

5

Satisfactory: 61% Emerging: 6%

Unsatisfactory: 8%

***AY14 data indicates 1% of

teacher candidates scored at the

unsatisfactory level for 4c,

communicating with families as

compared to the increase of 8%

receiving unsatisfactory.

4d. Contributing to school and

district

Accomplished Novice: 32%

Satisfactory: 56% Emerging: 11%

Unsatisfactory: 1%

4e. Growing and develops

professionally

Accomplished Novice: 28%

Satisfactory: 58%

Emerging: 13%

Unsatisfactory: 1%

4f. Showing professionalism

Accomplished Novice: 34%

Satisfactory: 57 %

Emerging: 8%

Unsatisfactory: 1%

who demonstrate deficiencies in

any area of the MAP evaluations

early in the program. The

program coordinator meets with

the student(s), and faculty are

made aware of students who have

difficulty and work closely with

the student(s) and program

coordinator to address any areas

of deficiency in the following

semester. Monitoring of MAP

continue for these students

throughout the program. Students

who earn ratings below

satisfactory in two consecutive

semesters are recommended for

remediation prior to student

teaching.

Data from the MAP evaluations

are shared at Program Advisory

Council meetings, and

suggestions for improvement are

made by the council.

Future plan: In regard to the increase in

teacher candidates scoring

unsatisfactory for MAP element

4c for AY15, the ECE faculty

members will develop the

expectation for each block of

teacher candidates to construct

some form of communication

with families (e.g., newsletter).

Page 6: Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate€¦ · 2014-2015 Annual Program Assessment and Improvement Report Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate

6

6

1.2 Demonstrate commitment to

the teaching profession and the

teaching field of early childhood

Disposition Evaluation elements

related to SLO 1.2:

1. Legal & Ethical

Conduct

2. Interactions with Others

3. Professional

Appearance & Demeanor

5. Commitment to Student

Learning

6. Commitment to

Improvement

7. Commitment to the

Profession

One hundred percent of teacher

candidates, at exit of the

program, must meet or exceed

the expectations for the

following elements related to the

Disposition Evaluation (e.g.,

ratings of proficient or

exemplary on the Disposition

Evaluation) :

1.Legal & Ethical Conduct

2.Interactions with Others

3.Professional Appearance &

Demeanor

5. Commitment to Student

Learning

6. Commitment to Improvement

7.Commitment to the Profession

BSEd Early Childhood Teacher

Candidates (N = 126)

n = 81 teacher candidates were

enrolled in Blocks 1, 2, & 3

(prior to student teaching)

n = 45 teacher candidates that

were student teaching

Ratings on Disposition

Evaluation elements for Student

Learning Outcome 1.2 are as

follows:

1. Legal & Ethical Conduct

Exemplary: 56%

Proficient: 44%

Needs Improvement: 0%

Unacceptable: 0%

2. Interactions with Others

Exemplary: 59%

Proficient: 36%

Needs Improvement: 5%

Unacceptable: 0%

3. Professional Appearance &

Demeanor

Exemplary: 59 %

Proficient: 31%

Needs Improvement: 9%

Unacceptable: 1%

5. Commitment to Student

Learning

Exemplary: 55%

Proficient: 42%

Needs Improvement: 3%

Unacceptable: 0%

6. Commitment to

Improvement

Exemplary: 58%

Proficient: 37%

Needs Improvement: 5%

The ECE faculty members are

committed to collecting evidence

for teacher candidates to

demonstrate their commitment to

the teaching profession and the

teaching field of early childhood.

The following procedure was

enacted for AY15:

The Teacher Education faculty

members, representing various

teacher preparation programs,

constructed the Disposition

Evaluation to represent clearer

criteria for teaching dispositions

that demonstrate qualities

identified as a commitment to the

profession (to include SLO 1.2).

Ongoing plan:

An overall plan has been

implemented to identify students

who demonstrate deficiencies in

any area of the Disposition

Evaluations early in the program.

The program coordinator meets

with the student(s), and faculty

are made aware of students who

have difficulty and work closely

with the student(s) and program

coordinator to address any areas

of deficiency in the following

semester. Monitoring of

Disposition Evaluations continue

for these students throughout the

program. Students who earn

ratings below proficient in two

consecutive semesters are

recommended for remediation

prior to student teaching.

Data from the Disposition

Evaluations are shared at

Page 7: Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate€¦ · 2014-2015 Annual Program Assessment and Improvement Report Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate

7

7

Unacceptable: 0%

7.Commitment to the

Profession

Exemplary: 53%

Proficient: 43%

Needs Improvement: 4%

Unacceptable: 0%

***Note: The Disposition

Evaluation instrument used for

AY15 was newly created and

vetted by Teacher Education

faculty members; therefore, the

comparison of data is not

possible.

Program Advisory Council

meetings, and suggestions for

improvement are made by the

council.

2.1 Establish effective

communication with students,

teachers, administrators, parents,

and members of the helping

professions.

Model of Appropriate Practice

(MAP) elements related to SLO

2.1:

2a. Creates an environment of

respect and rapport

3a. Communicates clearly and

accurately

3b. Uses questions and

discussion techniques to

enhance student learning

3d. Provides feedback to

students

4c. Communicating with

Families

4f. Shows professionalism

One hundred percent of teacher

candidates, at exit of the

program, must meet or exceed

expectations for the following

elements related to the MAP

(e.g., ratings of satisfactory or

accomplished novice on the

MAP):

2a. Creates an environment of

respect and rapport

3a. Communicates clearly and

accurately

3b. Uses questions and

discussion techniques to

enhance student learning

3d. Provides feedback to

students

4c. Communicating with

Families

4f. Shows professionalism

BSEd Early Childhood Teacher

Candidates (N = 126)

n = 81 teacher candidates were

enrolled in Blocks 1, 2, & 3

(prior to student teaching)

n = 45 teacher candidates that

were student teaching

Ratings on MAP elements for

Student Learning Outcome 2.1

are as follows:

2a. Creates an environment of

respect and rapport

Accomplished Novice: 43%

Satisfactory: 44%

Emerging: 13% Unsatisfactory: 0%

3a. Communicates clearly and

accurately

Accomplished Novice: 27%

Satisfactory: 59%

Emerging: 12%

Unsatisfactory: 1%

The ECE faculty members are

committed to collecting evidence

for teacher candidates to

demonstrate effective

communication with students,

teachers, administrators, parents,

and members of the helping

professions.

The following procedures were

enacted for AY15:

Teacher candidates in Blocks 1 &

2 are intentionally paired with

one another to learn how to co-

plan, co-teach, and co-assess. The

purpose of this enacted plan in

AY15 was to prepare teacher

candidates for today’s

classrooms’ expectations.

Through teacher candidates

intentional co-planning, co-

teaching, and co-assessing, their

confidence has increased in terms

of communicating with

cooperating teachers and

administrators.

Page 8: Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate€¦ · 2014-2015 Annual Program Assessment and Improvement Report Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate

8

8

3b. Uses questions and discussion

techniques to enhance student

learning

Accomplished Novice: 23%

Satisfactory: 48%

Emerging: 24%

Unsatisfactory: 5%

***AY14 data indicates 16% of

teacher candidates were rated

accomplished novice for using

question and discussion

techniques as compared to the

increase for 23% of the AY15

teacher candidates being rated as

accomplished novice.

3d. Provides feedback to students

Accomplished Novice: 31%

Satisfactory: 43%

Emerging: 24% Unsatisfactory: 2%

***AY14 data indicates 16% of

teacher candidates were rated

accomplished novice for

providing feedback to students as

compared to the increase for

AY15 of 31%.

4c. Communicating with

Families

Accomplished Novice: 25%

Satisfactory: 61%

Emerging: 6%

Unsatisfactory: 8%

4f. Shows professionalism

Accomplished Novice: 34%

Satisfactory: 57 %

Emerging: 8%

Unsatisfactory: 1%

In regard to the increase for

AY15’s teacher candidates

scoring accomplished novice for

MAP element 3b (using questions

and discussion techniques to

enhance student learning), the

ECE faculty members have

integrated more

opportunities/activities for

teacher candidates to practice

asking children questions that

promote critical thinking and

responding to children’s

responses to deepen their

thinking (e.g., development of

learning segment).

In regard to the increase for

AY15’s teacher candidates

scoring accomplished novice for

MAP element 3d (provides

feedback to students), the ECE

faculty members developed a

new assignment for Block 3

teacher candidates that focuses

solely on providing content-

specific feedback to students

related to their areas of strength

and areas for improvement.

Furthermore, teacher candidates

must explain how their students

will use the teacher candidates’

feedback to strengthen their

learning (e.g., re-engagement

lesson).

Ongoing plan: An overall plan has been

implemented to identify students

who demonstrate deficiencies in

any area of the MAP evaluations

early in the program. The

program coordinator meets with

the student(s), and faculty are

Page 9: Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate€¦ · 2014-2015 Annual Program Assessment and Improvement Report Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate

9

9

made aware of students who have

difficulty and work closely with

the student(s) and program

coordinator to address any areas

of deficiency in the following

semester. Monitoring of MAP

continue for these students

throughout the program. Students

who earn ratings below

satisfactory in two consecutive

semesters are recommended for

remediation prior to student

teaching.

Data from the MAP evaluations

are shared at Program Advisory

Council meetings, and

suggestions for improvement are

made by the council.

2.2 Establish effective

communication with students,

teachers, administrators, parents,

and members of the helping

professions.

Disposition Evaluation elements

related to SLO 2.2:

2. Interactions with Others

6. Commitment to

Improvement

7. Commitment to the Profession

One hundred percent of teacher

candidates, at exit of the

program, must meet or exceed

the expectations for the

following elements related to the

Disposition Evaluation (e.g.,

ratings of proficient or

exemplary on the Disposition

Evaluation) :

2.Interactions with Others

6.Commitment to Improvement

7. Commitment to the Profession

BSEd Early Childhood Teacher

Candidates (N = 126)

n = 81 teacher candidates were

enrolled in Blocks 1, 2, & 3

(prior to student teaching)

n = 45 teacher candidates that

were student teaching

Ratings on Disposition

Evaluation elements for Student

Learning Outcome 2.2 are as

follows:

2.Interactions with Others

Exemplary: 59%

Proficient: 36%

Needs Improvement: 5%

Unacceptable: 0%

6.Commitment to

Improvement

Exemplary: 58%

Proficient: 37%

Needs Improvement: 5%

The ECE faculty members are

committed to collecting evidence

for teacher candidates to

demonstrate effective

communication with students,

teachers, administrators, parents,

and members of the helping

professions.

The following procedures were

enacted for AY15:

The Teacher Education faculty

members, representing various

teacher preparation programs,

constructed the Disposition

Evaluation to represent clearer

criteria for teaching dispositions

that demonstrate qualities

identified as a commitment to the

profession (to include SLO 2.2).

Teacher candidates in Blocks 1 &

2 are intentionally paired with

Page 10: Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate€¦ · 2014-2015 Annual Program Assessment and Improvement Report Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate

1

1

Unacceptable: 0%

7.Commitment to the

Profession

Exemplary: 53%

Proficient: 43%

Needs Improvement: 4%

Unacceptable: 0%

***Note: The Disposition

Evaluation instrument was

modified and vetted by Teacher

Education faculty members;

therefore, the comparison of data

is not possible.

one another to learn how to co-

plan, co-teach, and co-assess. The

purpose of this enacted plan in

AY15 was to prepare teacher

candidates for today’s

classrooms’ expectations.

Through teacher candidates

intentional co-planning, co-

teaching, and co-assessing, their

confidence has increased in terms

of interacting with others (e.g.,

communicating with cooperating

teachers and administrators.

Future Plan:

The ECE faculty members will

develop the expectation for each

block of teacher candidates to

construct forms of

communication with

administrators, parents, and

members of the helping

profession (e.g., mock panel

interview).

Ongoing plan: An overall plan has been

implemented to identify students

who demonstrate deficiencies in

any area of the Disposition

Evaluations early in the program.

The program coordinator meets

with the student(s), and faculty

are made aware of students who

have difficulty and work closely

with the student(s) and program

coordinator to address any areas

of deficiency in the following

semester. Monitoring of

Disposition Evaluations continue

for these students throughout the

program. Students who earn

ratings below proficient in two

consecutive semesters are

Page 11: Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate€¦ · 2014-2015 Annual Program Assessment and Improvement Report Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate

1

1

recommended for remediation

prior to student teaching.

Data from the Disposition

Evaluations are shared at

Program Advisory Council

meetings, and suggestions for

improvement are made by the

council.

3.1 Organize and implement

developmentally appropriate

practice in the teaching field of

early childhood.

Georgia Assessment for the

Certification of Educators

(GACE) ECE Test I and ECE

Test II related to SLO 3.1:

Understanding and

pedagogically

applying content

related to English

language arts

Understanding and

pedagogically

applying content

related to

mathematics

Understanding and

pedagogically

applying content

related to science

Understanding and

pedagogically

applying content

related to social

studies

One hundred percent of teacher

candidates must pass the GACE

ECE tests I & II to be

recommended for certification.

The program goal is to

maintain a passing rate of 80%

or better.

BSEd Early Childhood Teacher

Candidates (n = 45 student

teachers)

GACE results reflect teacher

candidates enrolled in student

teaching and/or satisfactory exit

from the program:

Overall GACE Data: Results for AY 15 ECE Test 1

(ELA & Social Studies) were

98% passing; of the 98%

passing, 87% passed at the

professional level, and 11%

passed at the induction level.

The state’s passing rate for the

professional level for AY15 was

67% and for the induction level

was 20%.

Results for AY14 ECE Test

1were 100% passing; of the

100% passing, 81% passed at

the professional level and 19%

at the induction level. The

state’s passing rate for AY14

was 62% at the professional

level and 27% at the induction

level.

GACE results for AY15 ECE

Test 2 (Math & Science) were

The ECE faculty members are

committed to collecting evidence

for teacher candidates to organize

and implement developmentally

appropriate practice in the

teaching field of early childhood.

The following procedures were

enacted for AY15:

In regard to the construct,

understands and applies

knowledge of government, civics,

economics, and their processes,

the ECE faculty member changed

the textbook to reflect a stronger

emphasis of social studies content

through the lens of literacy.

In regard to the construct,

understands how to incorporate

appropriate teaching approaches

into classroom instruction for

English Language Arts, the ECE

faculty member began

collaborating with the secondary

English faculty member on a

research project (focus on

teaching writing in today’s

classroom).

Future plan:

Page 12: Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate€¦ · 2014-2015 Annual Program Assessment and Improvement Report Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate

1

1

96% passing; of the 95%

passing, 78% passed at the

professional level and 18%

passed at the induction level.

The state’s passing rate for the

AY15 at the professional level

was 59% and for the induction

level was 28%.

Results for AY14 ECE Test 2

were 96% passing; of the 96%

passing, 79% passed at the

professional level and 17%

passed at the induction level.

The state’s passing rate for

AY15 professional level was

56% and for the induction level

was 32%.

For both GACE tests (1 & 2),

there was a decline in the pass

rate from AY14 to AY15;

however, the passing rate for

AY15 exceeds the program’s

expectations of 80% or better

for passing.

Increase in specific GACE ECE

constructs for AY15:

Construct ‘understands and

applies knowledge of

government, civics, economics,

and their processes’ increased

from 66.07% in AY14 to 91.67

in AY15.

Construct ‘understands how to

incorporate appropriate

teaching approaches into

classroom instruction for

English Language Arts’

increased from 73.26% in AY14

to 81.56% in AY15.

Regarding the Test 2

mathematics constructs, the ECE

faculty members met with the

math department and discussed

the areas of concerns. The ECE

faculty members are working

with the math department (i.e.,

reviewing their syllabi) to help

align what is being taught in the

math methods course within

Teacher Education/ECE program.

Page 13: Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate€¦ · 2014-2015 Annual Program Assessment and Improvement Report Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate

1

1

Decrease in specific GACE ECE

constructs for AY15:

For the majority of the

constructs (e.g., understands

and applies knowledge of

numbers and operation in base

10) for mathematics (Test 2), the

teacher candidates scored lower

in AY15 as opposed to AY14.

3.2 Organize and implement

developmentally appropriate

practice in the teaching field of

early childhood.

Model of Appropriate Practice

(MAP) elements related to SLO

3.2:

1a. Demonstrates Knowledge

of Content

1b. Demonstrates Knowledge

of Pedagogy

1c. Demonstrates Knowledge

of Students and their Learning

1d. Selects Appropriate Learning

Goals

1e. Demonstrates knowledge of

resources

1f. Designs coherent

instruction 1g. Assesses

student learning

2b. Establishes a culture for

learning

2e. Utilizing Classroom

Space

3b. Using Questioning and

Discussion Techniques

3c. Engages students in

One hundred percent of teacher

candidates, at exit of the

program, must meet or exceed

expectations for the following

elements related to the MAP

(e.g., ratings of satisfactory or

accomplished novice on the

MAP):

1a. Demonstrates Knowledge

of Content

1b. Demonstrates Knowledge

of Pedagogy

1c. Demonstrates Knowledge

of Students and their Learning

1d. Selects Appropriate Learning

Goals

1e. Demonstrates knowledge of

resources

1f. Designs coherent

instruction 1g. Assesses

student learning

2b. Establishes a culture for

learning

BSEd Early Childhood Teacher

Candidates (N = 126)

n = 81 teacher candidates were

enrolled in Blocks 1, 2, & 3

(prior to student teaching)

n = 45 teacher candidates that

were student teaching

Ratings on MAP elements for

Student Learning Outcome 3.2

are as follows:

1a. Demonstrates Knowledge

of Content

Accomplished Novice: 36%

Satisfactory: 49%

Emerging: 14%

Unsatisfactory: 1%

1b. Demonstrates Knowledge

of Pedagogy

Accomplished Novice: 25%

Satisfactory: 54%

Emerging: 18%

The ECE faculty members are

committed to collecting evidence

for teacher candidates to organize

and implement developmentally

appropriate practice in the

teaching field of early childhood.

The following procedures were

enacted for AY15:

In terms of the element ‘assessing

students’ learning,’ the ECE

faculty members back-mapped

(beginning in Block 1) analysis of

student learning. In each block,

teacher candidates are learning

how to develop authentic

assessments that yield usable

results to analyze.

In regard to the element

‘engaging students in learning,’

the ECE faculty members revised

the classroom management plan

Page 14: Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate€¦ · 2014-2015 Annual Program Assessment and Improvement Report Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate

1

1

learning 3d. Provides feedback to

students

3e. Demonstrates flexibility and

responsiveness

2e. Utilizing Classroom

Space

3b. Using Questioning and

Discussion Techniques

3c. Engages students in

learning

3d. Provides feedback to

students

3e. Demonstrates flexibility and

responsiveness

Unsatisfactory: 3%

1c. Demonstrates Knowledge

of Students and their Learning

Accomplished Novice: 21%

Satisfactory: 57%

Emerging: 15%

Unsatisfactory: 8%

1d. Selects Appropriate

Learning Goals

Accomplished Novice: 21%

Satisfactory: 55%

Emerging: 20%

Unsatisfactory: 4%

1e. Demonstrates knowledge of

resources

Accomplished Novice: 28%

Satisfactory: 51%

Emerging: 20%

Unsatisfactory: 1%

1f. Designs coherent

instruction

Accomplished Novice: 34%

Satisfactory: 50% Emerging: 14%

Unsatisfactory: 2%

1g. Assesses student learning

Accomplished Novice: 28%

Satisfactory: 51%

Emerging: 18%

Unsatisfactory: 4%

***AY14 data indicates 15%

of teacher candidates were

rated accomplished novice as

compared to 28% of the

teacher candidates being

rated accomplished novice for

assessing students’ learning.

that teacher candidates must

complete to reflect engaging

learners as the primary goal for

managing a classroom.

Future Plan:

In regard to the element

‘demonstrating flexibility and

responsiveness,’ the ECE faculty

members will research ways to

help teacher candidates feel more

comfortable in demonstrating

flexibility and responsiveness

when teaching. The ECE faculty

members recognize this as a

critical component to maintain

engagement of all

children/learners.

Ongoing plan: An overall plan has been

implemented to identify students

who demonstrate deficiencies in

any area of the MAP evaluations

early in the program. The

program coordinator meets with

the student(s), and faculty are

made aware of students who have

difficulty and work closely with

the student(s) and program

coordinator to address any areas

of deficiency in the following

semester. Monitoring of MAP

continue for these students

throughout the program. Students

who earn ratings below

satisfactory in two consecutive

semesters are recommended for

remediation prior to student

teaching.

Data from the MAP evaluations

are shared at Program Advisory

Council meetings, and

Page 15: Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate€¦ · 2014-2015 Annual Program Assessment and Improvement Report Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate

1

1

2b. Establishes a culture for

learning

Accomplished Novice: 38%

Satisfactory: 42% Emerging: 21%

Unsatisfactory: 1%

2e. Utilizing Classroom Space

Accomplished Novice: 37%

Satisfactory: 46%

Emerging: 16%

Unsatisfactory: 1%

3b. Using Questioning and

Discussion Techniques

Accomplished Novice: 23%

Satisfactory: 48%

Emerging: 24%

Unsatisfactory: 5%

3c. Engages students in

learning

Accomplished Novice: 29%

Satisfactory: 47 %

Emerging: 19 %

Unsatisfactory: 5%

***AY14 data indicates 18%

of teacher candidates were

rated accomplished novice as

compared to 29% of the

teacher candidates being

rated accomplished novice.

3d. Provides feedback to

students

Accomplished Novice: 31%

Satisfactory: 43%

Emerging: 24%

Unsatisfactory: 2%

3e. Demonstrates flexibility and

responsiveness

Accomplished Novice: 23%

suggestions for improvement are

made by the council.

Page 16: Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate€¦ · 2014-2015 Annual Program Assessment and Improvement Report Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate

1

1

Satisfactory: 53%

Emerging: 20%

Unsatisfactory: 4%

***AY14 data indicates 1% of

the teacher candidates were

rated as unsatisfactory for

demonstrating flexibility and

responsiveness as opposed to 4%

of the teacher candidates being

rated as unsatisfactory for this

element.

3.3 Organize and implement

developmentally appropriate

practice in the teaching field of

early childhood

Disposition Evaluation elements

related to SLO 3.3:

5. Commitment to Student

Learning

One hundred percent of teacher

candidates, at exit of the

program, must meet or exceed

the expectations for the

following elements related to the

Disposition Evaluation (e.g.,

ratings of proficient or

exemplary on the Disposition

Evaluation) :

5. Commitment to Student

Learning

BSEd Early Childhood Teacher

Candidates (N = 126)

n = 81 teacher candidates were

enrolled in Blocks 1, 2, & 3

(prior to student teaching)

n = 45 teacher candidates that

were student teaching

Ratings on Disposition

Evaluation elements for Student

Learning Outcome 3.3 are as

follows:

5. Commitment to Student

Learning

Exemplary: 55%

Proficient: 42%

Needs Improvement: 3%

Unacceptable: 0%

***Note: The Disposition

Evaluation instrument was

modified and vetted by Teacher

Education faculty members;

therefore, the comparison of data

is not possible.

The ECE faculty members are

committed to collecting evidence

for teacher candidates to organize

and implement developmentally

appropriate practice in the

teaching field of early childhood.

The following procedures were

enacted for AY15:

The Teacher Education faculty

members, representing various

teacher preparation programs,

constructed the Disposition

Evaluation to represent clearer

criteria for teaching dispositions

that demonstrate qualities

identified as a commitment to the

profession (to include SLO 3.3).

The ECE faculty members

developed critical

assignments/assessments that

serve as gateways in terms of

successfully moving onto the

next block/semester. Each of the

critical assignments (e.g.,

analysis of mathematics and re-

Page 17: Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate€¦ · 2014-2015 Annual Program Assessment and Improvement Report Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate

1

1

engagement lesson) are aligned

with SLO 3.3. The expectation is

for teacher candidates to provide

evidence through multiple

demonstrations they can develop

and teach appropriate lessons for

children in early childhood

classrooms.

Ongoing plan:

An overall plan has been

implemented to identify students

who demonstrate deficiencies in

any area of the Disposition

Evaluations early in the program.

The program coordinator meets

with the student(s), and faculty

are made aware of students who

have difficulty and work closely

with the student(s) and program

coordinator to address any areas

of deficiency in the following

semester. Monitoring of

Disposition Evaluations continue

for these students throughout the

program. Students who earn

ratings below proficient in two

consecutive semesters are

recommended for remediation

prior to student teaching.

Data from the Disposition

Evaluations are shared at

Program Advisory Council

meetings, and suggestions for

improvement are made by the

council.

Page 18: Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate€¦ · 2014-2015 Annual Program Assessment and Improvement Report Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate

1

1

4.1 Differentiate instruction to

support students’ performance

commensurate with their abilities

Model of Appropriate Practice

(MAP) elements related to SLO

4.1:

1a. Demonstrates knowledge of

content

1b. Demonstrates knowledge of

pedagogy

1c. Demonstrates Knowledge

of Students and their Learning

1d. Selects Appropriate

Learning Goals

1e. Demonstrates Knowledge

of Resources

1f. Designs Coherent

Instruction

1g. Assesses Student Learning

for Planning

2a. Creating an Environment of

Respect and Rapport

2b. Establishing a Culture for

Learning

2c. Managing the Learning

Environment

3b. Using Questioning and

Discussion Techniques

One hundred percent of teacher

candidates, at exit of the

program, must meet or exceed

expectations for the following

elements related to the MAP

(e.g., ratings of satisfactory or

accomplished novice on the

MAP):

1a. Demonstrates knowledge of

content

1b. Demonstrates knowledge of

pedagogy

1c. Demonstrates Knowledge

of Students and their Learning

1d. Selects Appropriate

Learning Goals

1e. Demonstrates Knowledge

of Resources

1f. Designs Coherent

Instruction

1g. Assesses Student Learning

for Planning

2a. Creating an Environment

of Respect and Rapport

2b. Establishing a Culture for

Learning

2c. Managing the Learning

Environment

3b. Using Questioning and

Discussion Techniques

BSEd Early Childhood Teacher

Candidates (N = 126)

n = 81 teacher candidates were

enrolled in Blocks 1, 2, & 3

(prior to student teaching)

n = 45 teacher candidates that

were student teaching

Ratings on MAP elements for

Student Learning Outcome 4.1

are as follows:

1a. Demonstrates knowledge of

content

Accomplished Novice: 36%

Satisfactory: 49%

Emerging: 14%

Unsatisfactory: 1%

1b. Demonstrates knowledge of

pedagogy

Accomplished Novice: 25%

Satisfactory: 54%

Emerging: 18%

Unsatisfactory: 3%

***AY14 data indicates 17% of

the teacher candidates were

rated as accomplished novice

as compared to 25% of the

teacher candidates being rated

as accomplished novice for

demonstrating knowledge of

pedagogy.

1c. Demonstrates Knowledge

of Students and their Learning

Accomplished Novice: 21%

Satisfactory: 57%

Emerging: 15%

Unsatisfactory: 8%

***AY14 data indicates 13%

of the teacher candidates were

The ECE faculty members are

committed to collecting evidence

that demonstrate teacher

candidates’ abilities to

differentiate instruction that

support students’ performance

commensurating with their

abilities.

The following procedures were

enacted for AY15:

In regard to the element

‘demonstrating knowledge of

students and their learning,’ the

ECE faculty members began

using the form Context for

Learning for teacher candidates

to learn and document their class

of students (e.g., students with

learning needs).

In regard to the element

‘demonstrating knowledge of

pedagogy,’ the ECE faculty

members require teacher

candidates to develop and teach

multiple learning segments

throughout the program (3-5,

sequentially planned lessons).

Prior to teaching the learning

segments, the teacher candidates

receive a ‘Learning Segment

Workshop.’ After going through

the workshop, the teacher

candidates revise their learning

segments to ensure successful

pedagogy.

The previously mentioned

Learning Segment Workshop has

also shown to increase teacher

candidates’ abilities to select

appropriate learning goals.

Page 19: Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate€¦ · 2014-2015 Annual Program Assessment and Improvement Report Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate

1

1

rated as accomplished novice

as compared to 21% of the

AY15 teacher candidates being

rated as accomplished novice

for demonstrating knowledge

of students and their learning.

1d. Selects Appropriate

Learning Goals

Accomplished Novice: 21%

Satisfactory: 55%

Emerging: 20%

Unsatisfactory: 4%

***AY14 data indicates 13% of

the teacher candidates were

rated as accomplished novice as

compared to 21% of the AY15

teacher candidates for selecting

appropriate learning goals.

1e. Demonstrates Knowledge

of Resources

Accomplished Novice: 28%

Satisfactory: 51%

Emerging: 20%

Unsatisfactory: 1%

1f. Designs Coherent

Instruction

Accomplished Novice: 34%

Satisfactory: 50% Emerging: 14%

Unsatisfactory: 2%

1g. Assesses Student Learning

for Planning

Accomplished Novice: 28%

Satisfactory: 51%

Emerging: 18%

Unsatisfactory: 4%

2a. Creating an Environment of

Respect and Rapport

Ongoing plan:

An overall plan has been

implemented to identify students

who demonstrate deficiencies in

any area of the MAP evaluations

early in the program. The

program coordinator meets with

the student(s), and faculty are

made aware of students who have

difficulty and work closely with

the student(s) and program

coordinator to address any areas

of deficiency in the following

semester. Monitoring of MAP

continue for these students

throughout the program. Students

who earn ratings below

satisfactory in two consecutive

semesters are recommended for

remediation prior to student

teaching.

Data from the MAP evaluations

are shared at Program Advisory

Council meetings, and

suggestions for improvement are

made by the council.

Page 20: Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate€¦ · 2014-2015 Annual Program Assessment and Improvement Report Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate

2

2

Accomplished Novice: 43% Satisfactory: 44%

Emerging: 13%

Unsatisfactory: 0%

2b. Establishing a Culture for

Learning

Accomplished Novice: 38%

Satisfactory: 42%

Emerging: 21%

Unsatisfactory: 1%

2c. Managing the Learning

Environment

Accomplished Novice: 31%

Satisfactory: 47%

Emerging: 18%

Unsatisfactory: 4%

3b. Using Questioning and Discussion Techniques Accomplished Novice: 23% Satisfactory: 48% Emerging: 24% Unsatisfactory: 5%

3c. Engages students in

learning

Accomplished Novice: 29%

Satisfactory: 47 %

Emerging: 19 %

Unsatisfactory: 5%

3d. Provides feedback to

students

Accomplished Novice: 31%

Satisfactory: 43%

Emerging: 24%

Unsatisfactory: 2%

3e. Demonstrating Flexibility

and Responsiveness

Accomplished Novice: 23%

Satisfactory: 53%

Emerging: 20%

Page 21: Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate€¦ · 2014-2015 Annual Program Assessment and Improvement Report Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate

2

2

Unsatisfactory: 4%

4.2 Differentiate instruction to

support students’ performance

commensurate with their abilities

Disposition Evaluation elements

related to SLO 4.2:

5. Commitment to Student

Learning

6. Commitment to Improvement

One hundred percent of teacher

candidates, at exit of the

program, must meet or exceed

the expectations for the

following elements related to the

Disposition Evaluation (e.g.,

ratings of proficient or

exemplary on the Disposition

Evaluation) :

5. Commitment to Student

Learning

6. Commitment to Improvement

BSEd Early Childhood Teacher

Candidates (N = 126)

n = 81 teacher candidates were

enrolled in Blocks 1, 2, & 3

(prior to student teaching)

n = 45 teacher candidates that

were student teaching

Ratings on Disposition

Evaluation elements for Student

Learning Outcome 4.2 are as

follows:

5. Commitment to Student

Learning

Exemplary: 55%

Proficient: 42%

Needs Improvement: 3%

Unacceptable: 0%

6. Commitment to Improvement

Exemplary: 58%

Proficient: 37%

Needs Improvement: 5%

Unacceptable: 0%

***Note: The Disposition

Evaluation instrument was

modified and vetted by Teacher

Education faculty members;

therefore, the comparison of data

is not possible.

The ECE faculty members are

committed to collecting evidence

that demonstrate teacher

candidates’ abilities to

differentiate instruction that

support students’ performance

commensurating with their

abilities.

The following procedures were

enacted for AY15:

The Teacher Education faculty

members, representing various

teacher preparation programs,

constructed the Disposition

Evaluation to represent clearer

criteria for teaching dispositions

that demonstrate qualities

identified as a commitment to the

profession (to include SLO 4.2).

The ECE faculty members

developed critical

assignments/assessments that

serve as gateways in terms of

successfully moving onto the

next block/semester. Each of the

critical assignments (e.g.,

analysis of students’ learning and

developing next steps for

instruction to meet students’

various learning needs) are

aligned with SLO 4.2. The

expectation is for teacher

candidates to provide evidence

Page 22: Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate€¦ · 2014-2015 Annual Program Assessment and Improvement Report Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate

2

2

through multiple demonstrations

they can develop and teach

appropriate lessons for various

learning needs.

Ongoing plan:

An overall plan has been

implemented to identify students

who demonstrate deficiencies in

any area of the Disposition

Evaluations early in the program.

The program coordinator meets

with the student(s), and faculty

are made aware of students who

have difficulty and work closely

with the student(s) and program

coordinator to address any areas

of deficiency in the following

semester. Monitoring of

Disposition Evaluations continue

for these students throughout the

program. Students who earn

ratings below proficient in two

consecutive semesters are

recommended for remediation

prior to student teaching.

Data from the Disposition

Evaluations are shared at

Program Advisory Council

meetings, and suggestions for

improvement are made by the

council.

5.1 Evaluate, select, and

implement appropriate practices

related to technology and

instructional media, to include

online teaching

Model of Appropriate Practice

(MAP) elements related to SLO

5.1:

1e. Demonstrates Knowledge of

Resources

1g. Assesses Student Learning

for Planning

One hundred percent of teacher

candidates, at exit of the

program, must meet or exceed

expectations for the following

elements related to the MAP

(e.g., ratings of satisfactory or

accomplished novice on the

MAP):

1e. Demonstrates Knowledge

BSEd Early Childhood Teacher

Candidates (N = 126)

n = 81 teacher candidates were

enrolled in Blocks 1, 2, & 3

(prior to student teaching)

n = 45 teacher candidates that

were student teaching

The ECE faculty members are

committed to collecting evidence

that demonstrate teacher

candidates’ abilities to evaluate,

select, and implement appropriate

practices related to technology

and instructional media, to

include online teaching.

Page 23: Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate€¦ · 2014-2015 Annual Program Assessment and Improvement Report Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate

2

2

3c. Engaging Students in

Learning

of Resources 1g. Assesses Student Learning

for Planning

3c. Engaging Students in

Learning

Ratings on MAP elements for

Student Learning Outcome 5.1

are as follows:

1e. Demonstrates Knowledge of

Resources

Accomplished Novice: 28%

Satisfactory: 51%

Emerging: 20%

Unsatisfactory: 1%

***AY14 data indicates 13% of

the teacher candidates were

rated as accomplished novice as

compared to 28% of the AY15

teacher candidates being rated

as accomplished novice for

demonstrating knowledge of

resources.

1g. Assesses Student Learning

for Planning

Accomplished Novice: 28%

Satisfactory: 51%

Emerging: 18%

Unsatisfactory: 4%

3c. Engaging Students in

Learning

Accomplished Novice: 29%

Satisfactory: 47 %

Emerging: 19 %

Unsatisfactory: 5%

The following procedure was

enacted for AY15:

The ECE faculty member that has

taught the Technology for the 21st

Century course for ECE teacher

candidates has increased the

various technological resources

teacher candidates learn how to

use and must provide evidence of

using with students during their

lab experiences.

Ongoing plan: An overall plan has been

implemented to identify students

who demonstrate deficiencies in

any area of the MAP evaluations

early in the program. The

program coordinator meets with

the student(s), and faculty are

made aware of students who have

difficulty and work closely with

the student(s) and program

coordinator to address any areas

of deficiency in the following

semester. Monitoring of MAP

continue for these students

throughout the program. Students

who earn ratings below

satisfactory in two consecutive

semesters are recommended for

remediation prior to student

teaching.

Data from the MAP evaluations

are shared at Program Advisory

Council meetings, and

suggestions for improvement are

made by the council.

Page 24: Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate€¦ · 2014-2015 Annual Program Assessment and Improvement Report Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate

2

2

5.2 Evaluate, select, and

implement appropriate practices

related to technology and

instructional media, to include

online teaching

Disposition Evaluation elements

related to SLO 5.2:

5. Commitment to Student

Learning

6. Commitment to Improvement

One hundred percent of teacher

candidates, at exit of the

program, must meet or exceed

the expectations for the

following elements related to the

Disposition Evaluation (e.g.,

ratings of proficient or

exemplary on the Disposition

Evaluation) :

5. Commitment to Student

Learning

6. Commitment to Improvement

BSEd Early Childhood Teacher

Candidates (N = 126)

n = 81 teacher candidates were

enrolled in Blocks 1, 2, & 3

(prior to student teaching)

n = 45 teacher candidates that

were student teaching

Ratings on Disposition

Evaluation elements for Student

Learning Outcome 5.2 are as

follows:

5. Commitment to Student

Learning

Exemplary: 55%

Proficient: 42%

Needs Improvement: 3%

Unacceptable: 0%

6. Commitment to

Improvement

Exemplary: 58%

Proficient: 37%

Needs Improvement: 5%

Unacceptable: 0%

***Note: The Disposition

Evaluation instrument was

modified and vetted by Teacher

Education faculty members;

therefore, the comparison of data

is not possible.

The ECE faculty members are

committed to collecting evidence

that demonstrate teacher

candidates’ abilities to evaluate,

select, and implement appropriate

practices related to technology

and instructional media, to

include online teaching.

The following procedures were

enacted for AY15:

The ECE faculty member that has

taught the Technology for the 21st

Century course for ECE teacher

candidates has increased the

various technological resources

teacher candidates learn how to

use and must provide evidence of

using with students during their

lab experiences.

The Teacher Education faculty

members, representing various

teacher preparation programs,

constructed the Disposition

Evaluation to represent clearer

criteria for teaching dispositions

that demonstrate qualities

identified as a commitment to the

profession (to include SLO 5.2).

Ongoing plan:

An overall plan has been

implemented to identify students

who demonstrate deficiencies in

any area of the Disposition

Evaluations early in the program.

The program coordinator meets

with the student(s), and faculty

are made aware of students who

have difficulty and work closely

with the student(s) and program

coordinator to address any areas

of deficiency in the following

Page 25: Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate€¦ · 2014-2015 Annual Program Assessment and Improvement Report Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate

2

2

semester. Monitoring of

Disposition Evaluations continue

for these students throughout the

program. Students who earn

ratings below proficient in two

consecutive semesters are

recommended for remediation

prior to student teaching.

Data from the Disposition

Evaluations are shared at

Program Advisory Council

meetings, and suggestions for

improvement are made by the

council.

6.1 Effectively evaluate student

progress and instruction

Model of Appropriate Practice

(MAP) elements related to SLO

6.1:

1g. Assesses Student Learning

for Planning

3b. Using Questioning and

Discussion Techniques

3c. Engaging Students in

Learning

3d. Providing Feedback to

Students

One hundred percent of teacher

candidates, at exit of the

program, must meet or exceed

expectations for the following

elements related to the MAP

(e.g., ratings of satisfactory or

accomplished novice on the

MAP):

1g. Assesses Student Learning

for Planning

3b. Using Questioning and

Discussion Techniques

3c. Engaging Students in

Learning

3d. Providing Feedback to

Students

BSEd Early Childhood Teacher

Candidates (N = 126)

n = 81 teacher candidates were

enrolled in Blocks 1, 2, & 3

(prior to student teaching)

n = 45 teacher candidates that

were student teaching

Ratings on MAP elements for

Student Learning Outcome 6.1

are as follows:

1g. Assesses Student Learning

for Planning

Accomplished Novice: 28%

Satisfactory: 51% Emerging: 18%

Unsatisfactory: 4%

***AY14 data indicates 15% of

teacher candidates were rated

accomplished novice as

compared to 28% of the

teacher candidates being rated

accomplished novice for

assessing students’ learning.

The ECE faculty members are

committed to collecting evidence

that demonstrate teacher

candidates’ abilities to effectively

evaluate student progress and

instruction.

The following procedure was

enacted for AY15:

The ECE faculty members

developed critical

assignments/assessments that

serve as gateways in terms of

successfully moving onto the

next block/semester. Each of the

critical assignments (e.g.,

analysis of students’ learning and

developing next steps for

instruction to meet students’

various learning needs) are

aligned with SLO 6.1. The

expectation is for teacher

candidates to provide evidence

through multiple demonstrations

they can effectively evaluate

student progress and instruction.

Page 26: Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate€¦ · 2014-2015 Annual Program Assessment and Improvement Report Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate

2

2

3b. Using Questioning and

Discussion Techniques

Accomplished Novice: 23%

Satisfactory: 48%

Emerging: 24%

Unsatisfactory: 5%

3c. Engaging Students in

Learning

Accomplished Novice: 29%

Satisfactory: 47 %

Emerging: 19 %

Unsatisfactory: 5%

3d. Providing Feedback to

Students

Accomplished Novice:

31%

Satisfactory: 43%

Emerging: 24%

Unsatisfactory: 2%

Ongoing plan:

An overall plan has been

implemented to identify students

who demonstrate deficiencies in

any area of the MAP evaluations

early in the program. The

program coordinator meets with

the student(s), and faculty are

made aware of students who have

difficulty and work closely with

the student(s) and program

coordinator to address any areas

of deficiency in the following

semester. Monitoring of MAP

continue for these students

throughout the program. Students

who earn ratings below

satisfactory in two consecutive

semesters are recommended for

remediation prior to student

teaching.

Data from the MAP evaluations

are shared at Program Advisory

Council meetings, and

suggestions for improvement are

made by the council.

6.2 Effectively evaluate student

progress and instruction

Disposition Evaluation elements

related to SLO 6.2:

5. Commitment to Student

Learning

One hundred percent of teacher

candidates, at exit of the

program, must meet or exceed

the expectations for the

following elements related to the

Disposition Evaluation (e.g.,

ratings of proficient or

exemplary on the Disposition

Evaluation) :

5. Commitment to Student

Learning

BSEd Early Childhood Teacher

Candidates (N = 126)

n = 81 teacher candidates were

enrolled in Blocks 1, 2, & 3

(prior to student teaching)

n = 45 teacher candidates that

were student teaching

Ratings on Disposition

Evaluation elements for Student

Learning Outcome 6.2 are as

follows:

5. Commitment to Student

Learning

The ECE faculty members are

committed to collecting evidence

that demonstrate teacher

candidates’ abilities to effectively

evaluate student progress and

instruction.

The following procedure was

enacted for AY15:

The Teacher Education faculty

members, representing various

teacher preparation programs,

constructed the Disposition

Evaluation to represent clearer

Page 27: Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate€¦ · 2014-2015 Annual Program Assessment and Improvement Report Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate

2

2

Exemplary: 55% Proficient: 42%

Needs Improvement: 3%

Unacceptable: 0%

***Note: The Disposition

Evaluation instrument was

modified and vetted by Teacher

Education faculty members;

therefore, the comparison of data

is not possible.

criteria for teaching dispositions

that demonstrate qualities

identified as a commitment to the

profession (to include SLO 6.2).

Ongoing plan:

An overall plan has been

implemented to identify students

who demonstrate deficiencies in

any area of the Disposition

Evaluations early in the program.

The program coordinator meets

with the student(s), and faculty

are made aware of students who

have difficulty and work closely

with the student(s) and program

coordinator to address any areas

of deficiency in the following

semester. Monitoring of

Disposition Evaluations continue

for these students throughout the

program. Students who earn

ratings below proficient in two

consecutive semesters are

recommended for remediation

prior to student teaching.

Data from the Disposition

Evaluations are shared at

Program Advisory Council

meetings, and suggestions for

improvement are made by the

council.

7.1 Effectively analyze and use

assessment data for future

planning

Model of Appropriate Practice

(MAP) elements related to SLO

7.1:

1c. Demonstrates Knowledge

of Students and their

Learning

1d. Selects Appropriate

Learning Goals

1f. Designs Coherent

One hundred percent of teacher

candidates, at exit of the

program, must meet or exceed

expectations for the following

elements related to the MAP

(e.g., ratings of satisfactory or

accomplished novice on the

MAP):

1c. Demonstrates Knowledge

BSEd Early Childhood Teacher

Candidates (N = 126)

n = 81 teacher candidates were

enrolled in Blocks 1, 2, & 3

(prior to student teaching)

n = 45 teacher candidates that

were student teaching

The ECE faculty members are

committed to collecting evidence

that demonstrate teacher

candidates’ abilities to effectively

analyze and use assessment data

for future planning.

The following procedure was

enacted for AY15:

Page 28: Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate€¦ · 2014-2015 Annual Program Assessment and Improvement Report Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate

2

2

Instruction 1g. Assesses Student Learning

for Planning

of Students and their

Learning

1d. Selects Appropriate

Learning Goals

1f. Designs Coherent

Instruction

1g. Assesses Student Learning

for Planning

Ratings on MAP elements for

Student Learning Outcome 7.1

are as follows:

1c. Demonstrates Knowledge

of Students and their Learning

Accomplished Novice: 21%

Satisfactory: 57%

Emerging: 15%

Unsatisfactory: 8%

1d. Selects Appropriate

Learning Goals

Accomplished Novice: 21%

Satisfactory: 55%

Emerging: 20%

Unsatisfactory: 4%

1f. Designs Coherent

Instruction

Accomplished Novice: 34%

Satisfactory: 50%

Emerging: 14%

Unsatisfactory: 2%

***AY14 data indicates 27%

of the teacher candidates

were rated as accomplished

novice as compared to 34% of

the AY15 teacher candidates

being rated as accomplished

novice for designing coherent

instruction.

1g. Assesses Student

Learning for Planning

Accomplished Novice:

28%

Satisfactory: 51%

Emerging: 18%

Unsatisfactory: 4%

The ECE faculty members

developed critical

assignments/assessments that

serve as gateways in terms of

successfully moving onto the

next block/semester. Each of the

critical assignments (e.g.,

analysis of students’ learning and

developing next steps for

instruction to meet students’

various learning needs &

analyzing students’ mathematical

learning and develop a re-

engagement lesson) are aligned

with SLO 7.1. The expectation is

for teacher candidates to provide

evidence through multiple

demonstrations they can

effectively analyze and use

assessment data for future

planning.

Ongoing plan:

An overall plan has been

implemented to identify students

who demonstrate deficiencies in

any area of the MAP evaluations

early in the program. The

program coordinator meets with

the student(s), and faculty are

made aware of students who have

difficulty and work closely with

the student(s) and program

coordinator to address any areas

of deficiency in the following

semester. Monitoring of MAP

continue for these students

throughout the program. Students

who earn ratings below

satisfactory in two consecutive

semesters are recommended for

remediation prior to student

teaching.

Page 29: Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate€¦ · 2014-2015 Annual Program Assessment and Improvement Report Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate

2

2

Data from the MAP evaluations

are shared at Program Advisory

Council meetings, and

suggestions for improvement are

made by the council.

7.2 Effectively analyze and use

assessment data for future

planning

Disposition Evaluation elements

related to SLO 7.2:

5. Commitment to Student

Learning

One hundred percent of teacher

candidates, at exit of the

program, must meet or exceed

the expectations for the

following elements related to the

Disposition Evaluation (e.g.,

ratings of proficient or

exemplary on the Disposition

Evaluation) :

5. Commitment to Student

Learning

BSEd Early Childhood Teacher

Candidates (N = 126)

n = 81 teacher candidates were

enrolled in Blocks 1, 2, & 3

(prior to student teaching)

n = 45 teacher candidates that

were student teaching

Ratings on Disposition

Evaluation elements for Student

Learning Outcome7.2 are as

follows:

5. Commitment to Student

Learning

Exemplary: 55%

Proficient: 42%

Needs Improvement: 3% Unacceptable: 0%

***Note: The Disposition

Evaluation instrument was

modified and vetted by Teacher

Education faculty members;

therefore, the comparison of data

is not possible.

The ECE faculty members are

committed to collecting evidence

that demonstrate teacher

candidates’ abilities to effectively

analyze and use assessment data

for future planning.

The following procedure was

enacted for AY15:

The Teacher Education faculty

members, representing various

teacher preparation programs,

constructed the Disposition

Evaluation to represent clearer

criteria for teaching dispositions

that demonstrate qualities

identified as a commitment to the

profession (to include SLO 7.2).

Ongoing plan:

An overall plan has been

implemented to identify students

who demonstrate deficiencies in

any area of the Disposition

Evaluations early in the program.

The program coordinator meets

with the student(s), and faculty

are made aware of students who

have difficulty and work closely

with the student(s) and program

coordinator to address any areas

of deficiency in the following

semester. Monitoring of

Disposition Evaluations continue

for these students throughout the

Page 30: Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate€¦ · 2014-2015 Annual Program Assessment and Improvement Report Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate

3

3

program. Students who earn

ratings below proficient in two

consecutive semesters are

recommended for remediation

prior to student teaching.

Data from the Disposition

Evaluations are shared at

Program Advisory Council

meetings, and suggestions for

improvement are made by the

council.

8.1 Evaluate and support

implementation of a variety of

theories, methodologies, and

materials

Model of Appropriate Practice

(MAP) elements related to SLO

8.1:

1a. Demonstrates Knowledge

of Content

1b. Demonstrates Knowledge

of Pedagogy

1e. Demonstrates Knowledge

of Resources

1f. Designs Coherent

Instruction

2a. Creating an Environment

of Respect and Rapport

2b. Establishing a Culture for

Learning

2c. Managing the Learning

Environment

2d. Managing Student

Behaviors (attitude, conduct,

and academic)

2e. Utilizing Classroom Space

3b. Using Questioning and

Discussion Techniques 3c. Engaging Students in Learning 3d. Providing Feedback to Students 4a. Reflecting on Teaching

One hundred percent of teacher

candidates, at exit of the

program, must meet or exceed

expectations for the following

elements related to the MAP

(e.g., ratings of satisfactory or

accomplished novice on the

MAP):

1a. Demonstrates Knowledge

of Content

1b. Demonstrates Knowledge

of Pedagogy

1e. Demonstrates Knowledge

of Resources

1f. Designs Coherent

Instruction

2a. Creating an Environment

of Respect and Rapport

2b. Establishing a Culture for

Learning

2c. Managing the Learning

Environment

2d. Managing Student

Behaviors (attitude, conduct,

and academic)

2e. Utilizing Classroom Space

3b. Using Questioning and

Discussion Techniques 3c. Engaging Students in Learning

BSEd Early Childhood Teacher

Candidates (N = 126)

n = 81 teacher candidates were

enrolled in Blocks 1, 2, & 3

(prior to student teaching)

n = 45 teacher candidates that

were student teaching

Ratings on MAP elements for

Student Learning Outcome 8.1

are as follows:

1a. Demonstrates Knowledge

of Content

Accomplished Novice: 36%

Satisfactory: 49%

Emerging: 14%

Unsatisfactory: 1%

1b. Demonstrates Knowledge

of Pedagogy

Accomplished Novice: 25%

Satisfactory: 54%

Emerging: 18%

Unsatisfactory: 3%

1e. Demonstrates Knowledge

of Resources

Accomplished Novice: 28%

Satisfactory: 51%

Emerging: 20%

The ECE faculty members are

committed to collecting evidence

that demonstrate teacher

candidates’ abilities to evaluate

and support implementation of a

variety of theories,

methodologies, and materials.

The following procedure was

enacted for AY15:

In regard to the construct

‘demonstrates knowledge of

resources,’ teacher candidates in

Blocks 1 & 2 are intentionally

paired with one another to learn

how to co-plan, co-teach, and co-

assess. The purpose of this

enacted plan in AY15 was to

prepare teacher candidates for

today’s classrooms’ expectations

(co-teaching/inclusion). Through

teacher candidates intentional co-

planning, co-teaching, and co-

assessing, their abilities to work

with their co-teachers to research

various materials (e.g.,

instructional materials and

assessments) to determine if they

are supported with theory (e.g.,

Page 31: Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate€¦ · 2014-2015 Annual Program Assessment and Improvement Report Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate

3

3

3d. Providing Feedback to Students 4a. Reflecting on Teaching

Unsatisfactory: 1%

***AY14 data indicates 13%

of the teacher candidates

were rated as accomplished

novice as compared to 28% of

the AY15 teacher candidates

for demonstrating knowledge

of resources.

1f. Designs Coherent Instruction Accomplished Novice: 34% Satisfactory: 50% Emerging: 14% Unsatisfactory: 2%

2a. Creating an Environment of Respect and Rapport Accomplished Novice: 43% Satisfactory: 44% Emerging: 13% Unsatisfactory: 0%

2b. Establishing a Culture for Learning Accomplished Novice: 38% Satisfactory: 42% Emerging: 21% Unsatisfactory: 1%

2c. Managing the Learning Environment Accomplished Novice: 31% Satisfactory: 47% Emerging: 18% Unsatisfactory: 4%

2d. Managing Student Behaviors (attitude, conduct, and academic) Accomplished Novice: 23% Satisfactory: 47% Emerging: 19% Unsatisfactory: 5%

2e: Utilizing Classroom Space Accomplished Novice: 37% Satisfactory: 46% Emerging: 16% Unsatisfactory: 1%

constructivism) prior to

implementing the materials.

Future Plan:

In regard to the construct

‘demonstrates knowledge of

resources,’ the ECE faculty

member teaching the Cognitive

and Language Development

course will require teacher

candidates to develop a

theoretical framework. As a result

of the framework, teacher

candidates will provide

justifications for instructional

strategies and supports that align

with research and/or theory.

Ongoing plan:

An overall plan has been

implemented to identify students

who demonstrate deficiencies in

any area of the MAP evaluations

early in the program. The

program coordinator meets with

the student(s), and faculty are

made aware of students who have

difficulty and work closely with

the student(s) and program

coordinator to address any areas

of deficiency in the following

semester. Monitoring of MAP

continue for these students

throughout the program. Students

who earn ratings below

satisfactory in two consecutive

semesters are recommended for

remediation prior to student

teaching.

Data from the MAP evaluations

are shared at Program Advisory

Council meetings, and

Page 32: Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate€¦ · 2014-2015 Annual Program Assessment and Improvement Report Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate

3

3

3b. Using Questioning and Discussion Techniques Accomplished Novice: 23% Satisfactory: 48% Emerging: 24% Unsatisfactory: 5%

3c. Engaging Students in Learning Accomplished Novice: 29% Satisfactory: 47 % Emerging: 19 % Unsatisfactory: 5%

3d. Providing Feedback to Students Accomplished Novice: 31% Satisfactory: 43% Emerging: 24% Unsatisfactory: 2%

4a. Reflecting on Teaching Accomplished Novice: 49% Satisfactory: 41% Emerging: 9% Unsatisfactory: 1%

suggestions for improvement are

made by the council.

8.2 Evaluate and support

implementation of a variety of

theories, methodologies, and

materials

Disposition Evaluation elements

related to SLO 8.2:

5. Commitment to Student

Learning

One hundred percent of teacher

candidates, at exit of the

program, must meet or exceed

the expectations for the

following elements related to the

Disposition Evaluation (e.g.,

ratings of proficient or

exemplary on the Disposition

Evaluation) :

5. Commitment to Student

Learning

BSEd Early Childhood Teacher

Candidates (N = 126)

n = 81 teacher candidates were

enrolled in Blocks 1, 2, & 3

(prior to student teaching)

n = 45 teacher candidates that

were student teaching

Ratings on Disposition

Evaluation elements for Student

Learning Outcome 8.2 are as

follows:

5. Commitment to Student

Learning

Exemplary: 55%

Proficient: 42%

The ECE faculty members are

committed to collecting evidence

that demonstrate teacher

candidates’ abilities to evaluate

and support implementation of a

variety of theories,

methodologies, and materials.

The following procedures were

enacted for AY15:

The Teacher Education faculty

members, representing various

teacher preparation programs,

constructed the Disposition

Evaluation to represent clearer

criteria for teaching dispositions

Page 33: Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate€¦ · 2014-2015 Annual Program Assessment and Improvement Report Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate

3

3

Needs Improvement: 3% Unacceptable: 0%

***Note: The Disposition

Evaluation instrument was

modified and vetted by Teacher

Education faculty members;

therefore, the comparison of data

is not possible.

that demonstrate qualities

identified as a commitment to the

profession (to include SLO 8.2).

In regard to the construct

‘commitment to student

learning,’ teacher candidates in

Blocks 1 & 2 are intentionally

paired with one another to learn

how to co-plan, co-teach, and co-

assess. The purpose of this

enacted plan in AY15 was to

prepare teacher candidates for

today’s classrooms’ expectations

(co-teaching/inclusion). Through

teacher candidates intentional co-

planning, co-teaching, and co-

assessing, their abilities to work

with their co-teachers to research

various materials (e.g.,

instructional materials and

assessments) to determine if they

are supported with theory (e.g.,

constructivism) prior to

implementing the materials.

Ongoing plan:

An overall plan has been

implemented to identify students

who demonstrate deficiencies in

any area of the Disposition

Evaluations early in the program.

The program coordinator meets

with the student(s), and faculty

are made aware of students who

have difficulty and work closely

with the student(s) and program

coordinator to address any areas

of deficiency in the following

semester. Monitoring of

Disposition Evaluations continue

for these students throughout the

program. Students who earn

Page 34: Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate€¦ · 2014-2015 Annual Program Assessment and Improvement Report Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate

3

3

ratings below proficient in two

consecutive semesters are

recommended for remediation

prior to student teaching.

Data from the Disposition

Evaluations are shared at

Program Advisory Council

meetings, and suggestions for

improvement are made by the

council.

9.1 Effectively manage a

classroom to include behavioral

and organizational management

Model of Appropriate Practice

(MAP) elements related to SLO

9.1:

1c. Demonstrates Knowledge

of Students and their

Learning

1d. Selects Appropriate

Learning Goals

1f. Designs Coherent

Instruction

1g. Assesses Student

Learning for Planning

2a. Creating an Environment

of Respect and Rapport

2b. Establishing a Culture for

Learning

2c. Managing the Learning

Environment

2d. Managing Student

Behaviors (attitude, conduct,

and academic)

One hundred percent of teacher

candidates, at exit of the

program, must meet or exceed

expectations for the following

elements related to the MAP

(e.g., ratings of satisfactory or

accomplished novice on the

MAP):

1c. Demonstrates Knowledge

of Students and their

Learning

1d. Selects Appropriate

Learning Goals

1f. Designs Coherent

Instruction

1g. Assesses Student

Learning for Planning

2a. Creating an Environment

of Respect and Rapport

2b. Establishing a Culture for

Learning

2c. Managing the Learning

Environment

2d. Managing Student

Behaviors (attitude, conduct,

and academic)

BSEd Early Childhood Teacher

Candidates (N = 126)

n = 81 teacher candidates were

enrolled in Blocks 1, 2, & 3

(prior to student teaching)

n = 45 teacher candidates that

were student teaching

Ratings on MAP elements for

Student Learning Outcome 9.1

are as follows:

1c. Demonstrates Knowledge

of Students and their Learning

Accomplished Novice: 21%

Satisfactory: 57%

Emerging: 15%

Unsatisfactory: 8%

1d. Selects Appropriate

Learning Goals

Accomplished Novice: 21%

Satisfactory: 55%

Emerging: 20%

Unsatisfactory: 4%

1f. Designs Coherent

Instruction

Accomplished Novice: 34%

Satisfactory: 50%

Emerging: 14%

Unsatisfactory: 2%

The ECE faculty members are

committed to collecting evidence

that demonstrate teacher

candidates’ abilities to effectively

manage a classroom to include

behavioral and organizational

management.

The following procedure was

enacted for AY15:

In regard to the constructs

‘establishing a culture for

learning and managing student

behaviors,’ the ECE faculty

members revised the classroom

management plan that teacher

candidates must complete to

reflect engaging learners as the

primary goal for managing a

classroom. The intentional focus

for developing instructional

strategies to engage students has

increased teacher candidates’

abilities effectively manage a

classroom.

Ongoing plan:

An overall plan has been

implemented to identify students

who demonstrate deficiencies in

any area of the MAP evaluations

Page 35: Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate€¦ · 2014-2015 Annual Program Assessment and Improvement Report Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate

3

3

1g. Assesses Student Learning

for Planning

Accomplished Novice: 28%

Satisfactory: 51%

Emerging: 18%

Unsatisfactory: 4%

2a. Creating an Environment of

Respect and Rapport

Accomplished Novice: 43%

Satisfactory: 44%

Emerging: 13%

Unsatisfactory: 0%

2b. Establishing a Culture for

Learning

Accomplished Novice: 38%

Satisfactory: 42%

Emerging: 21%

Unsatisfactory: 1%

***AY14 data indicates 19% of

the teacher candidates were

rated as accomplished novice

as compared to 38% of the

AY15 teacher candidates for

establishing a culture for

learning.

2c. Managing the Learning

Environment

Accomplished Novice: 31%

Satisfactory: 47%

Emerging: 18%

Unsatisfactory: 4%

***AY14 data indicates 16% of

the teacher candidates were

rated as accomplished novice

as compared to 31% of the

AY15 teacher candidates for

managing the learning

environment.

early in the program. The

program coordinator meets with

the student(s), and faculty are

made aware of students who have

difficulty and work closely with

the student(s) and program

coordinator to address any areas

of deficiency in the following

semester. Monitoring of MAP

continue for these students

throughout the program. Students

who earn ratings below

satisfactory in two consecutive

semesters are recommended for

remediation prior to student

teaching.

Data from the MAP evaluations

are shared at Program Advisory

Council meetings, and

suggestions for improvement are

made by the council.

Page 36: Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate€¦ · 2014-2015 Annual Program Assessment and Improvement Report Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate

3

3

2d. Managing Student

Behaviors (attitude, conduct,

and academic)

Accomplished Novice: 23%

Satisfactory: 47%

Emerging: 19%

Unsatisfactory: 5%

9.2 Effectively manage a

classroom to include behavioral

and organizational management

Disposition Evaluation elements

related to SLO 9.2:

2. Interactions with Others

5. Commitment to Student

Learning

One hundred percent of teacher

candidates, at exit of the

program, must meet or exceed

the expectations for the

following elements related to the

Disposition Evaluation (e.g.,

ratings of proficient or

exemplary on the Disposition

Evaluation) :

2. Interactions with Others

5. Commitment to Student

Learning

BSEd Early Childhood Teacher

Candidates (N = 126)

n = 81 teacher candidates were

enrolled in Blocks 1, 2, & 3

(prior to student teaching)

n = 45 teacher candidates that

were student teaching

Ratings on Disposition

Evaluation elements for Student

Learning Outcome 9.2 are as

follows:

2. Interactions with Others

Exemplary: 59%

Proficient: 36%

Needs Improvement: 5%

Unacceptable: 0%

5. Commitment to Student

Learning

Exemplary: 55%

Proficient: 42% Needs Improvement: 3%

Unacceptable: 0%

***Note: The Disposition

Evaluation instrument was

modified and vetted by Teacher

Education faculty members;

therefore, the comparison of data

is not possible.

The ECE faculty members are

committed to collecting evidence

that demonstrate teacher

candidates’ abilities to evaluate

and support implementation of a

variety of theories,

methodologies, and materials.

The following procedures were

enacted for AY15:

The Teacher Education faculty

members, representing various

teacher preparation programs,

constructed the Disposition

Evaluation to represent clearer

criteria for teaching dispositions

that demonstrate qualities

identified as a commitment to the

profession (to include SLO 9.2).

In regard to the construct

‘interaction with others,’ teacher

candidates in Blocks 1 & 2 are

intentionally paired with one

another to learn how to co-plan,

co-teach, and co-assess. The

purpose of this enacted plan in

AY15 was to prepare teacher

candidates for today’s

classrooms’ expectations (co-

teaching/inclusion). Through

teacher candidates intentional co-

planning, co-teaching, and co-

Page 37: Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate€¦ · 2014-2015 Annual Program Assessment and Improvement Report Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate

3

3

assessing, their abilities to

develop strategies to positively

interact with others (e.g.,

colleagues).

Ongoing plan:

An overall plan has been

implemented to identify students

who demonstrate deficiencies in

any area of the Disposition

Evaluations early in the program.

The program coordinator meets

with the student(s), and faculty

are made aware of students who

have difficulty and work closely

with the student(s) and program

coordinator to address any areas

of deficiency in the following

semester. Monitoring of

Disposition Evaluations continue

for these students throughout the

program. Students who earn

ratings below proficient in two

consecutive semesters are

recommended for remediation

prior to student teaching.

Data from the Disposition

Evaluations are shared at

Program Advisory Council

meetings, and suggestions for

improvement are made by the

council.

10.1 Maintain high levels of

professionalism and ethical

standards

Model of Appropriate Practice

(MAP) elements related to SLO

10.1:

4b. Maintaining Accurate

Records

4e: Growing and Developing

Professionally

4f. Showing Professionalism

One hundred percent of teacher

candidates, at exit of the

program, must meet or exceed

expectations for the following

elements related to the MAP

(e.g., ratings of satisfactory or

accomplished novice on the

MAP):

4b. Maintaining Accurate

BSEd Early Childhood Teacher

Candidates (N = 126)

n = 81 teacher candidates were

enrolled in Blocks 1, 2, & 3

(prior to student teaching)

n = 45 teacher candidates that

were student teaching

The ECE faculty members are

committed to collecting evidence

that demonstrate teacher

candidates’ abilities to maintain

high levels of professionalism

and ethical standards.

The following procedure was

enacted for AY15:

Page 38: Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate€¦ · 2014-2015 Annual Program Assessment and Improvement Report Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate

3

3

Records 4e: Growing and Developing

Professionally

4f. Showing Professionalism

Ratings on MAP elements for

Student Learning Outcome 10.1

are as follows:

4b. Maintaining Accurate

Records

Accomplished Novice: 31%

Satisfactory: 54%

Emerging: 10%

Unsatisfactory: 3%

4e: Growing and Developing

Professionally

Accomplished Novice: 28%

Satisfactory: 58%

Emerging: 13%

Unsatisfactory: 1%

4f. Showing Professionalism

Accomplished Novice: 34%

Satisfactory: 57 %

Emerging: 8%

Unsatisfactory: 1%

***AY14 data indicates 24%

of the teacher candidates

were rated as accomplished

novice as compared to 34% of

the AY15 teacher candidates

being rated as accomplished

novice for showing

professionalism.

In regard to the construct

‘showing professionalism,’ prior

to entering the Teacher Education

program, all potential teacher

candidates, representing all

Teacher Education programs,

must take the Georgia Ethics

Exam, a new state requirement.

As part of taking the exam, the

potential teacher candidates

receive a pre-service certificate.

The pre-service certificate

provides eligibility to begin lab

placements in schools and holds

them accountable for Georgia’s

Code of Ethics for in-service

teachers.

Ongoing plan:

An overall plan has been

implemented to identify students

who demonstrate deficiencies in

any area of the MAP evaluations

early in the program. The

program coordinator meets with

the student(s), and faculty are

made aware of students who have

difficulty and work closely with

the student(s) and program

coordinator to address any areas

of deficiency in the following

semester. Monitoring of MAP

continue for these students

throughout the program. Students

who earn ratings below

satisfactory in two consecutive

semesters are recommended for

remediation prior to student

teaching.

Data from the MAP evaluations

are shared at Program Advisory

Council meetings, and

Page 39: Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate€¦ · 2014-2015 Annual Program Assessment and Improvement Report Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate

3

3

suggestions for improvement are

made by the council.

10.2 Maintain high levels of

professionalism and ethical

standards

Disposition Evaluation elements

related to SLO 10.2:

1. Legal & Ethical Conduct

3. Reliability

6. Commitment to

Improvement

One hundred percent of teacher

candidates, at exit of the

program, must meet or exceed

the expectations for the

following elements related to the

Disposition Evaluation (e.g.,

ratings of proficient or

exemplary on the Disposition

Evaluation) :

1. Legal & Ethical Conduct

3. Reliability 6. Commitment to

Improvement

BSEd Early Childhood Teacher

Candidates (N = 126)

n = 81 teacher candidates were

enrolled in Blocks 1, 2, & 3

(prior to student teaching)

n = 45 teacher candidates that

were student teaching

Ratings on Disposition

Evaluation elements for Student

Learning Outcome 10.2 are as

follows:

1. Legal & Ethical Conduct

Exemplary: 56%

Proficient: 44%

Needs Improvement: 0%

Unacceptable: 0%

3. Reliability

Exemplary: 59 %

Proficient: 31%

Needs Improvement: 9%

Unacceptable: 1%

6. Commitment to

Improvement

Exemplary: 58%

Proficient: 37%

Needs Improvement: 5%

Unacceptable: 0%

***Note: The Disposition

Evaluation instrument was

The ECE faculty members are

committed to collecting evidence

that demonstrate teacher

candidates’ abilities to maintain

high levels of professionalism

and ethical standards.

The following procedure was

enacted for AY15:

In regard to SLO 10.2,

maintaining high levels of

professionalism and ethical

standards, all potential teacher

candidates prior to entering

Teacher Education must take the

Georgia Ethics Exam, a new state

requirement. As part of taking the

exam, the potential teacher

candidates receive a pre-service

certificate. The pre-service

certificate provides eligibility to

begin lab placements in schools

and holds them accountable for

Georgia’s Code of Ethics for in-

service teachers.

The Teacher Education faculty

members, representing various

teacher preparation programs,

constructed the Disposition

Evaluation to represent clearer

criteria for teaching dispositions

that demonstrate qualities

identified as a commitment to the

profession (to include SLO 10.2).

Page 40: Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate€¦ · 2014-2015 Annual Program Assessment and Improvement Report Program: Early Childhood Education BSEd & Post-Baccalaureate

4

4

modified and vetted by Teacher

Education faculty members;

therefore, the comparison of data

is not possible.

Ongoing plan:

An overall plan has been

implemented to identify students

who demonstrate deficiencies in

any area of the Disposition

Evaluations early in the program.

The program coordinator meets

with the student(s), and faculty

are made aware of students who

have difficulty and work closely

with the student(s) and program

coordinator to address any areas

of deficiency in the following

semester. Monitoring of

Disposition Evaluations continue

for these students throughout the

program. Students who earn

ratings below proficient in two

consecutive semesters are

recommended for remediation

prior to student teaching.

Data from the Disposition

Evaluations are shared at

Program Advisory Council

meetings, and suggestions for

improvement are made by the

council.