problem skin disorders - amazon s3 · 2 davidovici bb, wolf r. clin dermatol 2010; 28(1): 12-16 28...
TRANSCRIPT
Problem Skin Disorders
© Kerry Bone 2012 MH232 1
Problem Skin Disorders
Kerry Bone Co-Founder and Director Research & Development MediHerb Adjunct Associate Professor, University of New England Australia
Our Co-Presenters This Evening
2
Val Allen
David McLeod
Monica Cocchiara
Problem Skin Disorders
Atopic dermatitis (eczema)
Acne
Rosacea
3
Problem Skin Disorders
© Kerry Bone 2012 MH232 2
Problem Skin Disorders: Traditional Considerations Elimination of waste through skin resulting from
poor lymphatic, liver, bowel and kidney clearance “Stagnant heat” apparent in all hot, red, itch
rash conditions Liver, blood cleansing, lymphatic support and
frequently immune support necessary to return skin to good health
I generally find patients experiencing dermatitis, rosacea or acne present with a white, coated tongue indicating congestion and sluggish lymphatic clearance
Lymphatic congestion from iris indications frequently confirms the above findings Thanks to Val Allen 4
Atopic Dermatitis
5
What Causes Atopic Dermatitis (AD)? AD arises as a result of an interaction between
our makeup and our environment It is now recognised that certain genetic defects
in the epidermal barrier occur in many AD sufferers
Specifically, loss-of-function mutations in the structural protein filaggrin, with resultant enhanced transepidermal water loss, are consistent with a new unifying hypothesis1
The resultant diminished epidermal defence to allergens and microbes is followed by polarised Th2 lymphocyte responses with resultant chronic inflammation
1 O'Regan GM et al. J Allergy Clin Immunol 2009; 124(3 Suppl 2): R2-6 6
Problem Skin Disorders
© Kerry Bone 2012 MH232 3
What Causes Atopic Dermatitis?
7
Pathophysiology of Atopic Dermatitis Innate immune responses are also defective in
AD, leading to increased susceptibility to viral, bacterial and fungal infections1
An example of this is the almost 90% rate of colonisation of the skin with Staphylococcus aureus in AD patients, compared with only 5% colonisation in healthy people
Circulating NK cells are significantly reduced in AD patients and are functionally defective, as observed by the reduced release of interferon-gamma
1 Dokmeci E, Herrick CA. Semin Cutan Med Surg 2008; 27(2): 138-143 8
Atopic Dermatitis and Dysbiosis The authors of a comprehensive study suggested
that their experience shows that correction of the intestinal and dermal dysbiosis, along with appropriate nutritional support and immune modulating therapy are essential steps in the management of AD1
However, a Cochrane review failed to find evidence that conventional therapy against S. aureus was clinically helpful in people with AD that is not clinically infected2
1 Ionescu G et al. J Advance Med 1990; 3(1): 47-58 2 Bath-Hextall FJ et al. Br J Dermatol 2010; 163(1): 12-26 9
Problem Skin Disorders
© Kerry Bone 2012 MH232 4
Atopic Dermatitis and Dysbiosis A meta-analysis of 21 studies found that current
intestinal parasite infection was protective against allergic sensitisation1
This supports the “old friends” hypothesis, a modification of the hygiene hypothesis, where exposure to certain relatively harmless micro-organisms (including helminths) supports immunological regulation via gut-associated T regulatory and regulatory dendritic cells2
A less diverse gut microbiota, with high counts of Bacteroides, Clostridium, Enterobacteriaceae and Staphylococcus early in life has been associated with an increased risk for AD3
1 Feary J et al. Allergy 2011; 66(4): 569-578 2 Rook GA, Brunet LR. Gut 2005; 54(3): 317-320 3 Vael C, Desager K. Curr Opin Pediatr 2009; 21(6):794-800 10
AD: Lifestyle and Diet
Based on the preceding discussion, the following lifestyle and dietary changes can be recommended: Measures to eliminate exposure to house dust
mite antigen should be instituted Harsh soaps and detergents should be avoided,
including those used for washing clothes Simple or multiple exclusion diets should be
considered, based on the clinical information. Elimination of cow’s milk (and related dairy products) is a good starting diet
Care should be taken to substitute protein and calcium in young children
11
AD: Lifestyle and Diet If there is no symptom improvement in about
4 to 6 weeks, different foods in turn could be eliminated such as eggs, peanuts or seafood1
Various multiple exclusion diets are available1 These typically involve avoidance of dairy products, eggs, nuts, pork, bacon, shellfish, yeast and fruit. (Such diets can be severe and should not be instituted as a first resort)
The diet should otherwise be well balanced with plenty of plant fibre and should not contain excessive amounts of junk food, sugar and refined carbohydrate
1 Ursell A. Practitioner 1994; 238: 284-288 12
Problem Skin Disorders
© Kerry Bone 2012 MH232 5
AD: Herbal Treatment Goals
Echinacea root will help to balance the immune response. Experience shows that it does not aggravate AD
Boosting the innate immune response with Echinacea, Andrographis and other immune herbs may help to control Staph. aureus infection
Antiallergic herbs (such as Albizia, Baical Skullcap and nettles) and anti-inflammatory herbs (such as Licorice and Bupleurum) can help to control symptoms
Bitter herbs and Ginger will improve digestion (if indicated)
13
AD: Herbal Treatment Goals
Long-term treatment with depuratives such as Burdock, Clivers, Yellow Dock and Sarsaparilla
Evening Primrose Oil as a source of gamma linolenic acid can correct an essential fatty acid imbalance, confer anti-inflammatory effects and support the epidermal barrier (but omega-3 fatty acids should also be co-prescribed)
Topical treatment with anti-inflammatory and antiseptic herbs. The antiseptic herbs will help to control skin microflora imbalance and infection with Staph. aureus
14
AD: Herbal Treatment Goals Topical Calendula, Myrrh, Tea Tree oil, Golden
Seal and Echinacea will help to control microbial levels
Licorice, Chamomile and St John’s Wort oil have topical anti-inflammatory activity
Hemidesmus and Rehmannia can be used to modulate the Th-2 cell response
Gut dysbiosis and deficient Tregs should be addressed using the bowel flora protocol (BFP)
15
Problem Skin Disorders
© Kerry Bone 2012 MH232 6
Bowel Flora Protocol (BFP)
This novel protocol is based on a weed, feed and seed approach
It is based on a weekend/week day cycle For best results 6 to 10 cycles should be carried
out The weeding phase uses key antimicrobial herbs
(weekends) The feeding phase is week days
16
Bowel Flora Protocol
The key antimicrobial herbs such as Oregano and Anise oils, Phellodendron and (optionally) Garlic provide the weeding
Ulmus rubra (Slippery Elm) provides the feeding treatment, but this is done in conjunction with Vitis vinifera (Grape Seed) and Camellia sinensis (Green Tea) to depress pathogenic bacteria
Combine with the appropriate diet depending on the pattern of dysbiosis and optionally use an evidence-based probiotic to enhance clinical results
17
Eczema - Atopic Dermatitis Diet Family history often reveals links to asthma and
hayfever in rotation with eczema, in these cases consider food sensitivities to dairy, oranges, tomatoes, wheat
Favourite Herbs Calendula, Golden Seal, Helichrysum and Rosehip
Oil Nutritional Support Potassium chloride (white tongue, sluggish
lymphatics) Iron phosphate (hot, dry, itchy rash) Evening Primrose Oil Fish oil (older skin)
Thanks to Val Allen 18
Problem Skin Disorders
© Kerry Bone 2012 MH232 7
Very Successful Tonic for Eczema
Red Clover 1:2 30 mL Yellow Dock 1:2 20 mL Burdock 1:2 20 mL Dong Quai 1:2 20 mL Sarsaparilla 1:2 10 mL 100 mL
Thanks to Val Allen 19
Childhood Eczema Although we see many adults with eczema, babies are probably the most common and more severe cases I see. As communication is an issue LOOKING and OBSERVING the child is crucial in selecting the correct herbs for Rx Digestion: signs of lactose, fructose or wheat intolerance; parasites; leaky gut syndrome etc. • What do nappies look like • Colic, reflux, vomiting • Is baby crying after feeding • If breastfed, what is mum eating or drinking
Thanks to Monica Cocchiara 20
Childhood Eczema Proposed causes: Iatrogenic: medication, vaccines Allergies: foods (dairy, wheat, yeast etc.);
contact allergens (pets, plants, grasses etc); additives & preservatives
Toxins: chemical exposure, heavy metals, alcohol
Immunological: what is general immune response to common colds? Does eczema present after a cold/flu?
Stress
Thanks to Monica Cocchiara 21
Problem Skin Disorders
© Kerry Bone 2012 MH232 8
Case History from Monica
4 month old baby Presented with chronic eczema from 4 weeks old. Fully breast fed. Vaccinated. Mother was non-smoker and had a balanced diet. Baby did not respond to first basic skin treatment I prescribed. Next treatment we looked at mum. • Mum was put on a lactose free diet as she was
drinking 3 glasses of cow’s milk daily. • Hair analysis showed that mum was high in lead
22
Case History from Monica Mum Rx Galium 30 (for lymphatic cleansing) Silybum 50 (heavy metals, galactogogue, detox) Echinacea 20 (immune, cleansing) Sig 5ml bd
Slippery elm 2 caps bd Essential fatty acids 1bd
23
Case History from Monica Baby Rx Lappa root 20 Galium 30 Trifolium 30 Echinacea 20 Sig 2 drops bd Evening primrose oil 1drop bd Next visit in 6 weeks baby’s skin was clear. I suggested that the lactose should be avoided when food was later introduced. As baby’s skin only aggravated when mother had lactose in high amounts in her diet. Otherwise, 2 years later her skin was still eczema free 24
Problem Skin Disorders
© Kerry Bone 2012 MH232 9
Panel Discussion and Questions
25
Acne
26
Seborrhoea
Comedones
Papules
Pustules
Pathogenesis of Acne Acne is a disorder of the sebaceous follicles
(sebaceous glands associated with hair follicles), which are located on the face, chest and back. Several factors play a pivotal role in the pathogenesis of acne: • androgen dependence • excessive sebum production (lipogenesis) • abnormal follicular differentiation (retention
hyperkeratosis) • increased colonisation with Propionibacterium
acnes • inflammatory processes
27
Problem Skin Disorders
© Kerry Bone 2012 MH232 10
Diet and Acne Despite the popular conventional view that
diet is not related to acne, several experts in the field are encouraging a reassessment of this position, partly because the data refuting any association are weak1
For example, one review pointed out that acne is virtually unknown in traditional hunter-gatherers2
The review goes on to suggest an association between dairy products (from the protein, not the fat) and dietary fat (especially in terms of increased sebum production)
1 Costa A, Lage D, Moisés TA. An Bras Dermatol 2010; 85(3): 346-353 2 Davidovici BB, Wolf R. Clin Dermatol 2010; 28(1): 12-16 28
Diet and Acne
Another review considered that there was compelling evidence that high glycaemic load diets may exacerbate acne1
The view is growing that acne can be regarded as an indicator disease of the exaggerated insulinotropic effects of modern western diets2
Especially milk- and whey protein-based products contribute to elevations of postprandial insulin and basal IGF-1 plasma levels
1 Bowe WP, Joshi SS, Shalita AR. J Am Acad Dermatol 2010; 63(1): 124-141 2 Melnik BC. Nestle Nutr Workshop Ser Pediatr Program 2011; 67: 131-145 29
Acne and Dietary Strategy
Appropriate dietary strategies for acne, as supported by the above evidence, stress the avoidance of high glycaemic index foods and dairy products
The diet should also not contain excessive levels of fat and be rich in plant fibre
30
Problem Skin Disorders
© Kerry Bone 2012 MH232 11
Acne: Herbal Treatment Goals Depurative herbs are again the mainstay of
treatment. In particular Calendula and Burdock may reduce excess sebum production, but other important depuratives for acne include Yellow Dock, Poke Root and Oregon Grape
A more effective immune response will help to control levels of P. acnes. Echinacea has been traditionally used in acne, possibly for this reason, Andrographis is also useful
Chaste tree given to men and women has shown benefit in acne in early clinical trials, possibly due to its hormonal effects
31
Acne: Herbal Treatment Goals Linseeds contain lignans that may raise SHBG Studies have found that consumption of Licorice
can lower testosterone levels, but high doses may be necessary, especially in men
Other internal herbs used to treat acne include Garlic and Golden Seal
Case observations and even clinical studies have shown that insulin and antidiabetic drugs appear to cause clinical improvement in acne.1 It has even been suggested that acne is "skin diabetes“
Hence herbs that control blood sugar should be considered
1 McCarty M. Med Hypotheses 1984; 14: 307-310 32
Acne: Herbal Treatment Goals Topical treatments can be of benefit, especially
as resistance is growing to antibiotics used in acne1
A single blind clinical trial found that topical treatment with fresh Basil juice (Ocimum basilicum) was as effective as conventional treatment2
Topical Tea Tree oil was found to be effective. Calendula and Comfrey are also popular topical treatments
1 Smith EV, Grindlay DJ, Williams HC. Clin Exp Dermatol 2011; 36(2): 119-122 2 Balambal R et al. J Assoc Physicians India 1985; 33(8): 507-508 33
Problem Skin Disorders
© Kerry Bone 2012 MH232 12
Acne Example liquid formula
Chaste Tree 1:2 15 mL Calendula 1:2 20 mL Burdock 1:2 20 mL Baical Skullcap 1:2 20 mL Poke Root 1:5 5 mL Echinacea root 1:2 30 mL 110 mL
Dosage: 8 mL with water twice a day 34
Acne Diet & Lifestyle Reduce sugars and yeast Increase water intake Encourage regular exercise
Favourite Herbs Chaste Tree (always male or female), Barberry,
Burdock, Yellow Dock, Blue Flag, Horsetail (scarring, pustular), Andrographis or Echinacea (subcutaneous, cystic), Clivers
Topical Herbs Golden Seal
Thanks to Val Allen 35
Case History from Monica Case 2: Acne 23 year old male Luke presented with severe cystic acne on face chest and back. It first appeared around 14 yrs but has since become more inflamed and painful. I also noted that his sclera was yellow and that his hair was receding more than it should be for some one his age. He did not consume alcohol. And had a fantastic organic diet since he was a child. So there was no room to move with his diet. He was highly anxious and a very light sleeper
36
Problem Skin Disorders
© Kerry Bone 2012 MH232 13
Case History from Monica Rx Smilax 30 Trifolium 20 Serenoa 20 Scutellaria 10 Vitex 10 Sig 7ml bd 6 weeks later his skin was not as painful or as inflamed. Even though he had a good diet he still required cleansing. His yellow sclera was indicative of this for me
37
Case History from Monica Rx Smilax 30 Trifolium 30 Serenoa 20 Scutellaria 10 Vitex 20 Sig 7ml bd Zinc 1 tablet hs
7 weeks the inflammation had reduced and his chest and back starting clearing, but still experiencing some breakouts. He was less anxious and sleep had improved
38
Case History from Monica Rx Smilax 20 Tribulus 30 Scutellaria 10 Vitex 20 Echinacea 20 Sig 7.5ml bd Zinc 1 tab hs
When I saw him 2 months later his skin was clear. Not one pimple! It took about 7 months of treatment
39
Problem Skin Disorders
© Kerry Bone 2012 MH232 14
Panel Discussion and Questions
40
Rosacea Types
41
Rosacea Epidemiology Rosacea prevalence is highest (between 2.7
and 10%) in adults of northern European or Celtic heritage
People with fair skin are mainly affected Incidence peaks between 30 and 50 years and
may be more common in women Microbial agents such as Helicobacter pylori are
associated, but controversial There is a clear association with higher
infestation with the Demodex mite (up to 20 times higher mite counts with rosacea) Steinhoff M et al. J Investig Dermatol Symp Proc 2011; 15(1): 2-11 Chosidow O, Cribier B. Ann Dermatol Venereol 2012; 138(Suppl 3); S179-S183 Alvarez F et al. J Appl Microbiol 2012; 112(1): 159-174 42
Problem Skin Disorders
© Kerry Bone 2012 MH232 15
Rosacea Pathophysiology
Yamasaki K, Gallo RL. J Dermatol Sci 2009; 55(2): 77-81 43
Rosacea and Digestion
Gastrointestinal problems are often reported Dyspepsia, bloating, flatulence, abdominal pain,
and alteration of intestinal habits have been described
Many case reports associate rosacea with ulcerative colitis, Crohn's disease, coeliac disease, hypochlorhydria, Helicobacter pylori (Hp) gastritis, alteration of intestinal mucosa and lipase deficiency
Parodi A, Paolino S, Greco A et al. Clin Gastroenterol Hepatol 2008; 6(7): 759-764 44
Rosacea and Constipation A single-patient case study was described
of a young male rosacea patient with a slow gut transit time (GTT) of >70 hours who suffered from periodic constipation
30 g wheat bran after each meal was prescribed, reducing GTT to 28 hours after 7 days
After 14 days his rosacea went into remission
Kendall SN. Clin Exp Dermatol 2004; 29(3): 297-299 45
Problem Skin Disorders
© Kerry Bone 2012 MH232 16
Rosacea: Diet and Lifestyle
Foods or drinks that cause flushing such as coffee and other hot drinks, alcohol and spicy foods should be avoided
The diet should be high in plant fibre Stress levels should be reduced,
since in some patients periods of stress are linked to a worsening of their skin
46
Rosacea: Herbal Treatment Goals The hygiene of the whole gastrointestinal tract
(mouth to anus) is important and any noted problems or defects should be treated
Attention should be paid to oral hygiene (for example with a mouth rinse containing herbs such as Sage, Echinacea, Propolis and Thyme)
If H. pylori tests are positive, then appropriate treatment should be instituted (see later)
If there are symptoms of digestive insufficiency, bitters (but not Ginger because of its potential flushing effect), Coleus and choleretic herbs can be judiciously prescribed
47
Rosacea: Herbal Treatment Goals Constipation needs to be addressed if present
(choleresis will help here) The bowel flora protocol should be considered Depurative and immune system herbs are still
an essential aspect of long-term treatment Herbs which tone the microvasculature such as
Gotu Kola, Grape Seed extract and Bilberry can be of value, particularly in the early stages of the disease, since they may help to combat flushing and correct dilated capillaries
48
Problem Skin Disorders
© Kerry Bone 2012 MH232 17
Rosacea: Herbal Treatment Goals Topical application of acaricidal herbs which
include Echinacea root, Myrrh and Quassia Bark could be helpful, especially in papulopustular rosacea. Clinical trials now support this
Care should be taken that the vehicle used to apply these herbs does not irritate the skin
49
Herbs and Helicobacter Current research suggests that herbs can
have only a supportive role in the management of Helicobacter and they are most suitable for cases where antibiotic therapy is not fully successful
Activity has been demonstrated in vitro for Allium sativum (Garlic), Thymus vulgaris (Thyme), Salvia species (Sage), Cinnamomum species (Cinnamon), Hydrastis (Golden Seal), Arctostaphylos (Bearberry) and Camellia sinensis (Green Tea), among others
Moderate benefits have been shown in clinical trials for raw garlic, Rheum species (Rhubarb Root), Vaccinium macrocarpon (Cranberry), Nigella sativa (Black Cumin), Broccoli sprouts Bone K. Helicobacter: A Hidden Factor in Cardiovascular, Digestive, Autoimmune and Skin Disorders. Townsend Letter for Doctors 2006; 271/272: 48-50 50
Rosacea Diet & General Observation I find 75% of cases improve once wheat is
eliminated Sympathetic nervous system is sensitive Underlying infection exists in blood stream
Favourite Herbs Barberry, Astragalus, Echinacea, Golden Seal,
Burdock, Yellow Dock, Chamomile, Sarsaparilla, Clivers.
In past Chaparral great results
Thanks to Val Allen 51
Problem Skin Disorders
© Kerry Bone 2012 MH232 18
Rosacea
Topical Herbs Golden Seal, Manuka honey
Nutritional Support Calcium Phosphate Potassium Chloride or Sulphate Zinc B Vitamin Complex
Thanks to Val Allen 52
Case History from Monica Case 3: Male aged 72 yrs rosacea for 20 yrs LFT showed high GGT and ALT Ultrasound showed a fatty liver His testosterone was low Osteoporosis was also detected Rx Rheum 40 Silybum 40 Vitex 20 Sig 7ml bd
Dandelion tea I cup bd, to replace and reduce his coffee intake 53
Case History from Monica
8 weeks later his LFTs had reduced and his skin appeared less red and inflamed. He had a very sensitive stomach and he was taking the mix with no problem so I kept the same Rx for a further 8 weeks
There was no sign of the rosacea so I continued with the Silybum for another 8 weeks until all his LFTs were back in the normal range
This was a simple but very effective treatment
54