pŕl̀vements h́patiques : enjeux actuels et aḿliorations ... · pdf filedr niccolo...

38
Prflevements hfpatiques : enjeux actuels et amfliorations futures Dr Niccolo Petrucciani

Upload: builien

Post on 27-Mar-2018

216 views

Category:

Documents


3 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Pŕl̀vements h́patiques : enjeux actuels et aḿliorations ... · PDF fileDr Niccolo Petrucciani . ABM 2015 Prelevement hepatique . ABM 2015 Organ shortage extended criteria donors

Prelevements hepatiques : enjeux actuels

et ameliorations futures

Dr Niccolo Petrucciani

Page 2: Pŕl̀vements h́patiques : enjeux actuels et aḿliorations ... · PDF fileDr Niccolo Petrucciani . ABM 2015 Prelevement hepatique . ABM 2015 Organ shortage extended criteria donors

ABM 2015

Prelevement hepatique

Page 3: Pŕl̀vements h́patiques : enjeux actuels et aḿliorations ... · PDF fileDr Niccolo Petrucciani . ABM 2015 Prelevement hepatique . ABM 2015 Organ shortage extended criteria donors

ABM 2015

Organ shortage extended criteria donors

Page 4: Pŕl̀vements h́patiques : enjeux actuels et aḿliorations ... · PDF fileDr Niccolo Petrucciani . ABM 2015 Prelevement hepatique . ABM 2015 Organ shortage extended criteria donors

- Age

- HBV and HCV

Extended criteria donors

Page 5: Pŕl̀vements h́patiques : enjeux actuels et aḿliorations ... · PDF fileDr Niccolo Petrucciani . ABM 2015 Prelevement hepatique . ABM 2015 Organ shortage extended criteria donors

DONOR RISK INDEX CALCULATOR

Page 6: Pŕl̀vements h́patiques : enjeux actuels et aḿliorations ... · PDF fileDr Niccolo Petrucciani . ABM 2015 Prelevement hepatique . ABM 2015 Organ shortage extended criteria donors

- 5939 liver transplants in Eurotransplant

- DRI was higher in Eurotransplant versus OPNT (USA)

- DRI was strongly correlated with outcomes and the most significant factors influencing outcomes

Page 7: Pŕl̀vements h́patiques : enjeux actuels et aḿliorations ... · PDF fileDr Niccolo Petrucciani . ABM 2015 Prelevement hepatique . ABM 2015 Organ shortage extended criteria donors
Page 8: Pŕl̀vements h́patiques : enjeux actuels et aḿliorations ... · PDF fileDr Niccolo Petrucciani . ABM 2015 Prelevement hepatique . ABM 2015 Organ shortage extended criteria donors
Page 9: Pŕl̀vements h́patiques : enjeux actuels et aḿliorations ... · PDF fileDr Niccolo Petrucciani . ABM 2015 Prelevement hepatique . ABM 2015 Organ shortage extended criteria donors

- 1361 prélèvements hépatiques/1782 donneurs (76.4%)

- Age moyenne de donneur: 56.2 ans

- Donneurs >65 ans = 38%

Page 10: Pŕl̀vements h́patiques : enjeux actuels et aḿliorations ... · PDF fileDr Niccolo Petrucciani . ABM 2015 Prelevement hepatique . ABM 2015 Organ shortage extended criteria donors

- DRI was modified to ET-DRI

- ET-DRI includes all covariates of DRI except race and weight

- GGT and rescue offer were added

- Location was modified (local, regional, extra-regional)

Page 11: Pŕl̀vements h́patiques : enjeux actuels et aḿliorations ... · PDF fileDr Niccolo Petrucciani . ABM 2015 Prelevement hepatique . ABM 2015 Organ shortage extended criteria donors

- ET-DRI had high predictive value for outcomes after LT

Page 12: Pŕl̀vements h́patiques : enjeux actuels et aḿliorations ... · PDF fileDr Niccolo Petrucciani . ABM 2015 Prelevement hepatique . ABM 2015 Organ shortage extended criteria donors

- Neither the DRI nor the ET-DRI were validated against French dataset.

- Important donor and candidates differences

- New adaptation of DRI?

Page 13: Pŕl̀vements h́patiques : enjeux actuels et aḿliorations ... · PDF fileDr Niccolo Petrucciani . ABM 2015 Prelevement hepatique . ABM 2015 Organ shortage extended criteria donors
Page 14: Pŕl̀vements h́patiques : enjeux actuels et aḿliorations ... · PDF fileDr Niccolo Petrucciani . ABM 2015 Prelevement hepatique . ABM 2015 Organ shortage extended criteria donors

- 1361 prélèvements hépatiques/1782 donneurs (76.4%)

- Age moyenne de donneur: 56.2 ans

- Donneurs >65 ans = 38%

ABM 2015

Page 15: Pŕl̀vements h́patiques : enjeux actuels et aḿliorations ... · PDF fileDr Niccolo Petrucciani . ABM 2015 Prelevement hepatique . ABM 2015 Organ shortage extended criteria donors

Age

- The proportion of older donors has continuously increased in France

- Concerns: biliary complications, arterial thrombosis, poor initial function, overall graft survival (especially in HCV+ recipients)

Page 16: Pŕl̀vements h́patiques : enjeux actuels et aḿliorations ... · PDF fileDr Niccolo Petrucciani . ABM 2015 Prelevement hepatique . ABM 2015 Organ shortage extended criteria donors

- 149 LTs, donor age >60 y in 47 and <60 in 102

- In older donors group:

> non anastomotic biliary strictures

< graft survival

Serrano et al.

Page 17: Pŕl̀vements h́patiques : enjeux actuels et aḿliorations ... · PDF fileDr Niccolo Petrucciani . ABM 2015 Prelevement hepatique . ABM 2015 Organ shortage extended criteria donors

Serrano et al.

Page 18: Pŕl̀vements h́patiques : enjeux actuels et aḿliorations ... · PDF fileDr Niccolo Petrucciani . ABM 2015 Prelevement hepatique . ABM 2015 Organ shortage extended criteria donors

- 157 donors >75 y compared with 253 <60y

- Older group: better liver tests, only 3 cardiac arrests

- No differences in complications (biliary, arterial, non-function) and graft survival

Page 19: Pŕl̀vements h́patiques : enjeux actuels et aḿliorations ... · PDF fileDr Niccolo Petrucciani . ABM 2015 Prelevement hepatique . ABM 2015 Organ shortage extended criteria donors

Prelevement hepatique

Page 20: Pŕl̀vements h́patiques : enjeux actuels et aḿliorations ... · PDF fileDr Niccolo Petrucciani . ABM 2015 Prelevement hepatique . ABM 2015 Organ shortage extended criteria donors

Age

- Results highly variables in the different studies

- No cut-off

Page 21: Pŕl̀vements h́patiques : enjeux actuels et aḿliorations ... · PDF fileDr Niccolo Petrucciani . ABM 2015 Prelevement hepatique . ABM 2015 Organ shortage extended criteria donors

- Study on UNOS database

- D-MELD (donor age x recipient MELD) accurately predicts patients and graft survival

- Useful for allocation

Page 22: Pŕl̀vements h́patiques : enjeux actuels et aḿliorations ... · PDF fileDr Niccolo Petrucciani . ABM 2015 Prelevement hepatique . ABM 2015 Organ shortage extended criteria donors

- 120 patients classified according to D-MELD (donor age x recipient MELD)

- D-MELD <1000 = 101

- D-MELD >1000 = 19

Page 23: Pŕl̀vements h́patiques : enjeux actuels et aḿliorations ... · PDF fileDr Niccolo Petrucciani . ABM 2015 Prelevement hepatique . ABM 2015 Organ shortage extended criteria donors
Page 24: Pŕl̀vements h́patiques : enjeux actuels et aḿliorations ... · PDF fileDr Niccolo Petrucciani . ABM 2015 Prelevement hepatique . ABM 2015 Organ shortage extended criteria donors
Page 25: Pŕl̀vements h́patiques : enjeux actuels et aḿliorations ... · PDF fileDr Niccolo Petrucciani . ABM 2015 Prelevement hepatique . ABM 2015 Organ shortage extended criteria donors

- Liver steatosis

- Rescue liver (hors tours)

- Cold ischemia

- DCD donors

Other factors

Interpretation of all donor’s and recipient’s factors to define the risk

Page 26: Pŕl̀vements h́patiques : enjeux actuels et aḿliorations ... · PDF fileDr Niccolo Petrucciani . ABM 2015 Prelevement hepatique . ABM 2015 Organ shortage extended criteria donors

- Risk analysis in 37255 patients of UNOS

- 6 predictors of survival after LT identified: recipient MELD, cold ischemia time, recipient age, donor age, previous OLT, life support dependence

- BAR (Balance of Risk) score stratified patients better than previous scores

Dutkowski et al.

Page 27: Pŕl̀vements h́patiques : enjeux actuels et aḿliorations ... · PDF fileDr Niccolo Petrucciani . ABM 2015 Prelevement hepatique . ABM 2015 Organ shortage extended criteria donors
Page 28: Pŕl̀vements h́patiques : enjeux actuels et aḿliorations ... · PDF fileDr Niccolo Petrucciani . ABM 2015 Prelevement hepatique . ABM 2015 Organ shortage extended criteria donors
Page 29: Pŕl̀vements h́patiques : enjeux actuels et aḿliorations ... · PDF fileDr Niccolo Petrucciani . ABM 2015 Prelevement hepatique . ABM 2015 Organ shortage extended criteria donors
Page 30: Pŕl̀vements h́patiques : enjeux actuels et aḿliorations ... · PDF fileDr Niccolo Petrucciani . ABM 2015 Prelevement hepatique . ABM 2015 Organ shortage extended criteria donors
Page 31: Pŕl̀vements h́patiques : enjeux actuels et aḿliorations ... · PDF fileDr Niccolo Petrucciani . ABM 2015 Prelevement hepatique . ABM 2015 Organ shortage extended criteria donors

- Analysis of quality in organ procurement in Netherlands

- Procurement program: “multi organ procurement training” for surgeons since 2005

- Procurement teams: surgeons, scrub nurses, anesthesiologists, instruments

Page 32: Pŕl̀vements h́patiques : enjeux actuels et aḿliorations ... · PDF fileDr Niccolo Petrucciani . ABM 2015 Prelevement hepatique . ABM 2015 Organ shortage extended criteria donors

PREVIOUS DATA

- Injuries in procured livers = 10-34%

- Clinically relevant = 6.6%-23%

- Pancreas = 8%-13% of procured pancreata were discarded form transplantation for surgical injury

- Kidney injuries = 7-21%

Page 33: Pŕl̀vements h́patiques : enjeux actuels et aḿliorations ... · PDF fileDr Niccolo Petrucciani . ABM 2015 Prelevement hepatique . ABM 2015 Organ shortage extended criteria donors

- 754 organs from 2012 to 2013

- 133 livers, 38 pancreas, 420 kidneys

- Injuries = 25%

Page 34: Pŕl̀vements h́patiques : enjeux actuels et aḿliorations ... · PDF fileDr Niccolo Petrucciani . ABM 2015 Prelevement hepatique . ABM 2015 Organ shortage extended criteria donors

- Organ discarded for injuries = 2%

Page 35: Pŕl̀vements h́patiques : enjeux actuels et aḿliorations ... · PDF fileDr Niccolo Petrucciani . ABM 2015 Prelevement hepatique . ABM 2015 Organ shortage extended criteria donors

- BMI for renal procurement

- DCD donation for livers

Page 36: Pŕl̀vements h́patiques : enjeux actuels et aḿliorations ... · PDF fileDr Niccolo Petrucciani . ABM 2015 Prelevement hepatique . ABM 2015 Organ shortage extended criteria donors

- Center volume = less kidney and pancreas injuries

Page 37: Pŕl̀vements h́patiques : enjeux actuels et aḿliorations ... · PDF fileDr Niccolo Petrucciani . ABM 2015 Prelevement hepatique . ABM 2015 Organ shortage extended criteria donors

Outcomes of transplantation

- Organs with repaired injuries have the same survival that non-injured organs

Page 38: Pŕl̀vements h́patiques : enjeux actuels et aḿliorations ... · PDF fileDr Niccolo Petrucciani . ABM 2015 Prelevement hepatique . ABM 2015 Organ shortage extended criteria donors

DONOR

Age

Steatosis

Infections

Ischemia

RECIPIENT

MELD

Age

BMI

PV Thrombosis

CHC