privatization presentations

Upload: mellamo-ian

Post on 03-Apr-2018

223 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 7/28/2019 Privatization Presentations

    1/49

    AUCTIONS FOR SALE OF PROPERTY

  • 7/28/2019 Privatization Presentations

    2/49

    2 AHR the first nationwide Russianuniversal auction platform

    Sale of stateproperty Sale of privateproperty

  • 7/28/2019 Privatization Presentations

    3/49

    3

    Real-estate

    Business (shares)

    Rights of real-estate lease

    Art works

    Universal auction platform

  • 7/28/2019 Privatization Presentations

    4/49

    Structure and financial indicators4

    Volume of transactions 1.65 billion

    on the classic platform on the electronic platform

    1.09 billion 0.56 billion

    On-site auctions, in the auction

    hall, with an auctioneer (English

    and Dutch auctions)

    All interested persons from any

    part of the world may take part in

    the Internet auctions

  • 7/28/2019 Privatization Presentations

    5/49

    Geography of sales

    5 Financial network

    6 auction platforms

    Classic auctions:

    presence in over40 regions of the

    Russian Federation

    CIS countries

    Electronic auctions:

    the geographical scope

    of electronic sales isincomparably wider

  • 7/28/2019 Privatization Presentations

    6/49

    6

    Khanty-Mansiisk Bank

    44.2% of sharesKhanty Mansiisk Bank Joint StockompanyPrice of sale - 266.5 million poundssterling

    Major transactions

    The National Hotel in Moscow

    100% of shares in the National HotelPrice of sale 97.6 million poundssterling

    AHR the first private seller ofstate property in Russia

    Total volume of transactions with state property 794 million

  • 7/28/2019 Privatization Presentations

    7/49

    7

    Goal: To acquire property or business in Russia

    Solution: Open AHR auctions

    Receivinginformation On the site

    www.auction-

    house.ru

    On the site

    www.torgi.gov.ru

    Submittingapplication

    Payingdeposit

    Winning AHR

    auctions

    You are theowner of a

    business in theRussian

    Federation

    AHR auctions are the simplest way forforeign investors to become owners ofbusinesses in Russia

    http://www.auction-house.ru/http://www.auction-house.ru/http://www.torgi.gov.ru/http://www.torgi.gov.ru/http://www.auction-house.ru/http://www.auction-house.ru/http://www.auction-house.ru/
  • 7/28/2019 Privatization Presentations

    8/49

    8 AHR services for foreign clients

    Marketing and consulting services

    Legal assistant

    Evaluation of real-estate and business

    Deals structuring

    Wide advertising of objects for sale and media coverage

  • 7/28/2019 Privatization Presentations

    9/49

    9 AHR proposals today

    13.11 % of shares in UAZ

    25.5 % of shares in Murmansk Shipping Company

    20% of shares in Northern Shipping Company

    31.32% of shares in Northern River Shipping

    Company

    25.5% of shares in Amur Shipping Company

    25.5% of shares in Anapa airport

  • 7/28/2019 Privatization Presentations

    10/49

    Welcome to our auctions

  • 7/28/2019 Privatization Presentations

    11/49

    Privatization of Russian companies

  • 7/28/2019 Privatization Presentations

    12/49

    12 Privatization of Russian companies

    Ocean and river transportationMurmansk Shipping CompanyNorthern River Shipping LinesNorthern Shipping Company

    Amur Shipping Company

    Air transportationAnapa Airport

    Automobile manufacturingUAZ

    36 enterprises, including:

  • 7/28/2019 Privatization Presentations

    13/49

    13 Ocean and river transportation

    Murmansk Shipping Company 25,5%

    14.8 million

    Northern Shipping Company 20%

    4.2 million

    Northern River Shipping Lines 31,32%

    1.7 million

  • 7/28/2019 Privatization Presentations

    14/49

    14 Proposal to investors

    Northern Shipping

    Company 56.36%

    Murmansk Shipping Company

    Northern River

    Shipping Lines56.9%

    Leading position on the market of sea and river shippingoperations in the northern and north-western regions of

    Russia

    P l t i t

  • 7/28/2019 Privatization Presentations

    15/49

    15 Proposal to investors

    Northern ShippingCompany

    Northern RiverShipping Lines

    20%56.4%

    56.86%

    11.82%

    Murmansk Sea ShippingCompany

    Other Shareholders Russian Federation

    G h

  • 7/28/2019 Privatization Presentations

    16/49

    16 Geography

    Access to the biggest market Northern trade routeNorth, North-west and South of Russia, Western Europe

    North-Atlantic regionAntarctic region

    Cargo shipping all over the world

    The company has reinforced ice-class shipsUnique fleet: bulk carriers, tankers, icebreakers,

    passenger and auxiliary shipsShips for construction and dredging worksOil and oil products reloading services

    Key features:

    O d i t t ti

  • 7/28/2019 Privatization Presentations

    17/49

    17

    Amur Shipping Company

    The largest shipping company of Siberia and Far-Eastregion of Russia25,5% share

    Domestic shipping: Far East, Khabarovsk TerritoryJapanSouth KoreaNorth KoreaChina

    Geography:

    Ocean and river transportation

    Ocean and ri er transportation

  • 7/28/2019 Privatization Presentations

    18/49

    18 Ocean and river transportation

    Amur Shipping Company

    5.5 million

    Unique fleet - 220 ships of 211,1 thousands of dead-weighttonnage

    Ships of river-sea mixed class

    Bulk carriersTankersHigh capacity vessels

    The company manages the number of river and sea ports, portloading complexes, repair and maintenance bases.

    Key features:

    19 Key advantages of sea shipping business in Russia

  • 7/28/2019 Privatization Presentations

    19/49

    19 Key advantages of sea shipping business in Russia

    - Northern Sea Route (NSR) the shortest way from Europe to Asia(access to markets of Northwestern Europe and Pacific Ocean region);- Expected growth of NSR cargo shipping by the 2030 - 50-80 million tonsper year;- Active development of northern oilfields of Russia.

    growing marketincreasing incomes

    20 Air transportation

  • 7/28/2019 Privatization Presentations

    20/49

    20

    International Airport

    Anapa 25,5% share

    - The airport ranks 5th in terms of increase in the rate ofpassenger thoroughfare 5th result by growth of passengerstraffic;- one of the 20 leading airports of the Russian Federation;- Passengers traffic in 2012 more than 0,5 million;

    Airport serves 24 airlines covering 47 directions

    Key features:

    Air transportation

    21 Air transportation

  • 7/28/2019 Privatization Presentations

    21/49

    21 Air transportation

    International Airport

    Anapa 25,5% share

    - Active development of Southern Russian region;- Sochi Winter Olympic games in 2014;- Soccer world championship in 2018;- Krasnodar territory the best Russian health resort.

    Key advantages:

    2 million

    22 Automobile manufacturing

  • 7/28/2019 Privatization Presentations

    22/49

    22 Automobile manufacturing

    UAZ

    13,2% share

    UAZ is one ofthe largestRussianenterprises inthe sphere ofautomobile

    manufacturing

    FinancialindicatorsIn 2012 thecompanys

    turnover was

    590 million.Profit was 21 million.In 2012 thecompany sold70,517automobiles.

    Company turnover (million GBP)

    23 Automobile manufacturing

  • 7/28/2019 Privatization Presentations

    23/49

    23

    UAZ is an automobile manufacturer of off-road vehicles(SUV) and pick-ups, commercial automobiles, light trucks(LCV) and minibuses (MPV).

    Automobile market share:- minibuses (MPV) - 27%;

    - pick-ups - 12,3%;- commercial automobiles and light trucks (LCV) - 11%;- off-road vehicles (SUV) - 3%.

    Key features:

    Automobile manufacturing

    24 Proposal to investors

  • 7/28/2019 Privatization Presentations

    24/49

    24

    Russian Federation (13%) + Privateshareholders (17%) = blocking stake of UAZ

    Consolidate sale

    Proposal to investors

    20,7 million

    Private Shareholders

    Russian Federation

  • 7/28/2019 Privatization Presentations

    25/49

    Welcome to our auctions

  • 7/28/2019 Privatization Presentations

    26/49

    A Good Time to Take Part in Russian Privatisation ?

    Investm ent Climate and Macro-economic Outlo ok

    28 May 2013

  • 7/28/2019 Privatization Presentations

    27/49

    Contents

    1. Why Russia? 3

    2. Why now? 11

  • 7/28/2019 Privatization Presentations

    28/49

    1. Why Russia?

    Solid Performance Despite Recent Slowdown

  • 7/28/2019 Privatization Presentations

    29/49

    29

    Solid Performance Despite Recent Slowdownand Vast Resources

    Stable and growing economy

    Russia Brazil India China Mexico Turkey South Africa

    Population (2011,m) 142 197 1,241 1,344 115 80 52

    GDP growth (2013E) 2.4% 3.1% 5.2% 8.0% 3.5% 4.0% 2.6%

    CPI (%, 2013E) 6.8% 6.0% 9.0% 3.0% 3.8% 7.0% 5.7%

    Current account balance(% of GDP, 2013E)

    2.3% -2.8% -4.9% 2.5% -1.1% -6.7% -5.8%

    Intl reserves (USD bn) 514 374 290 3,180 168 118 50

    Rating(S&P/Moodys/Fitch)

    BBB/Baa1/BBB BBB/Baa2/BBB BBB-/Baa3/BBB- AA-/Aa3/A+ BBB/Baa1/BBB+ BB+/Baa3/BBB- BBB/Baa1/BBB

    Resource % of global Rank globally

    Oil (production) 13 2

    Oil (reserves) 6 7

    Gas (production) 21 1

    Gas (reserves) 21 1

    Nickel (production) 20 1

    Platinum (production) 13 2

    Timber (reserves) 23 1

    Fresh water 15 2

    Arable land 10 4

    enjoying vast natural resources

    9.0%

    11.9%13.3%

    8.8% 8.8%

    6.1%6.6%

    2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012

    and decreasing inflation

    _____________________________________________________

    Source: Statistical office of the Russian Federation, Gazprombank

    _________________________________________________

    Source: Country statistical offices, Bloomberg, Gazprombank

    __________________________________________

    Source: Global Insight, International Energy Agency

    Strong Financial Position of the Sovereign

  • 7/28/2019 Privatization Presentations

    30/49

    30

    68.0%64.0%

    45.0%41.0% 40.0%

    22.0%

    11.0%

    India Brazil Mexico Turkey SouthAfrica

    China Russia

    g gBut Risk Premium Still High

    but high perception of country credit risk and low P/E compared to peer countries

    Total sovereign debt (2012), as % of GDP

    balanced budget low government leverage

    -5.8%

    -4.5%

    -2.4%-2.1% -2.1%

    -1.8%

    -0.6%

    IndiaSouthAfrica Brazil Mexico Turkey China Russia

    Budget balance (2013E), as % of GDP

    18.1

    12.6 12.311.3 11.0 11.0

    9.1

    5.1

    Mexico SouthAfrica

    India Average Brazil Turkey China Russia

    ____________________________________________

    Source: Country statistical offices, IMF, Gazprombank

    _________________________________________

    1. Weighted average of presented countries

    Source: Bloomberg, Gazprombank

    _____________________________

    Note: Data for India is not available

    Source: Bloomberg,

    __________________________________________________

    Source: Country statistical offices, Bloomberg, Gazprombank

    1

    +122%

    5-year country CDS, as of24.05.2013 Price to earnings ratio based on countries domestic index

    171

    143132

    123

    9079

    South Africa Russia Brazil Turkey Mexico China

    Resilience of Russias Fiscal Policy

  • 7/28/2019 Privatization Presentations

    31/49

    31

    yto Various Oil Price Scenarios

    Oil prices that balance the federal budget

    Source: Finance Ministry, Gazprombank estimates

    The State Duma approved the Federal Budget Law for 2013-15, based on a new fiscal rule for the management of oil &gas revenues: Allows reduction of the non-oil budget balance from 10.5%

    of GDP in 2012 to 8.4% in 2015, as well as to improve theinvestment climate.

    The rule proposes a net borrowing limit of 1% of GDP an additional source to ensure stability.

    Any oil revenues received due to the oil price exceedingthe base price stipulated by law would be used toreplenish the Reserve Fund until it reaches 7% of GDP allows to build buffers against external volatility.

    The Russian government has decent reserves for a badscenario: The Reserve Fund has accumulated RUB 2.65 trln (ca.

    $85 bln) as of May 1, 2013. The fiscal safetymargin covers the annual budget deficit

    in the most probable negative case (average annual Uralsgoes to $85.0/bbl).

    The National Wealth Fund contains RUB 2.7 trln (ca. $89

    bln) an additional source of capital investment.

    0%

    2%

    4%

    6%

    8%

    0

    2

    4

    6

    8

    2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015

    RUB trln

    Well-being Fund, RUB trln

    Reserve Fund, RUB trlnReserve Fund, % GDP (rhs)Well-being Fund, % GDP (rhs)

    0

    20

    40

    6080

    100

    120

    140

    2006

    2007

    2008

    2009

    2010

    2011

    2012

    2013

    2014

    2015

    $/bbl

    zero-defic it price actual/ forecasted pr ice

  • 7/28/2019 Privatization Presentations

    32/49

    2. Why now?

    Why now?

  • 7/28/2019 Privatization Presentations

    33/49

    33

    Russian capital markets are expected to show strong growth in the upcoming years due to attractive macroeconomic indicators andlow valuations

    If anything, recent economic slowdown reinforces Russian governments commitment to structural reforms and improvements of the

    investment climate

    The Russian Government is taking measures to develop local capital markets:

    Regulatory changes will allow pension funds to become active investors in Russian corporate bonds and equities

    Capital market liberalization and infrastructure improvements simplify the access of international money into the Russian market

    State-owned companies have been encouraged to increase dividend payout to 25% when possible

    At the same time the Russian government announced its plans to privatize over 20 large companies through share issue; thecurrent phase of the programme is expected to be completed by 2016 with estimated total proceeds reaching up to $100bn

    Access of Russian companies to the equity markets was restricted for several years due to the crisis which resulted in significantIPO/SPO pipeline of issuers waiting for the market window

    Russia taking actions to broaden the investor base

  • 7/28/2019 Privatization Presentations

    34/49

    34

    Russia taking actions to broaden the investor base

    Domestic investors Foreign investors

    Currently low allocation of pension funds into equity is expected to increase:Removal of the requirement for pension savings account of individuals to show

    positive returns each year for non-state pension funds (NPFs)

    Expansion of the list of securities eligible for investment of pension savings for

    NPFs

    Permission given to pension funds to participate in IPOs/SPOs

    Solid growth of personal income and savings

    together with tax incentives will lead to domestic

    demand increase

    0% tax rate on income from securities held for

    more than 3 years

    Tax incentives for pensions and life insurance

    savings accumulation

    Planned allocation of National Wealth Funds money into domestic equity

    securities

    Currently $88.6 bn of NWF funds are allocated in foreign government debt

    securities (75%) and VEB deposits (25%)

    Shift ofNWFs investment policy towards investing in the Russian securities market

    Realistic opportunities for the NWF funds to participate in privatization

    Upcoming liberalization of the Russian bond and equity

    markets

    NSD has already received the status o f Central Securities Depository

    Euroclear / Clearstream have obtained access to Russian OFZ

    market in Q1 2013

    Access of Euroclear / Clearstream to equity market is expected in 2014

    Further infrastructure build out, including introduction of improved

    market access solutions

    T+2 settlement cycle with partial collateral

    Tariff reform

    Modernization of listing requirements

    Planned introduction of unified trading system for all markets

    Russian equity market

    1

    2

    3

    1

    2

    The above mentioned measures could potentially lead to c. 2x increase in local funds invested in the securities market

    Russian market infrastructure progress to meet

  • 7/28/2019 Privatization Presentations

    35/49

    35

    global standards

    Signing of law

    on CD

    Dec. 2011

    Start of OTC trade

    in OFZs

    Jan. 2012

    Law on CD comes

    into force

    July 2012

    Euroclear /

    Clearstream receive

    approval for account at

    CD

    Sept. 2012

    NSD status as

    ND confirmed

    Nov. 2012

    Euroclear / Clearstream

    open accounts at CD,

    execute first deals

    Introduction of T+2

    New tariff model on

    MICEX

    OTC derivatives platform

    2013

    Jan. 2013

    Centralized

    CCP

    Repository

    2013+

    Basket REPO withcollateral management on

    MICEX

    Fully integrated risk

    management and clearing

    platform

    Access of Euroclear /

    Clearstream to Russian

    equity market

    Jan. 1, 2012 Entry into force of amendments to CBR Regulations On the servicing and circulation of federal state securities issues, which authorizedOTC market transactions. In 2012, secondary placement and primary auctions of OFZs on MICEX were officially withdrawn from the special segment(where only authorized dealers were eligible to trade) and transferred to the main trade platform.

    July 1, 2012 Entry into force of the Law on the Central Depository, signed in December 2011, and also amendments to the law on joint stock companies.

    The Central Depository unifies the system for recording titles to securities in Russia. This is one of the mandatory conditions for a number of conservativeglobal investors. In addition, legislative acts introduce the concept of depo accounts held by a nominee foreign holder (or opened by a foreign organizationthat records and assigns the title to securities on behalf of other parties).

    July 27, 2012 The Federal Financial Markets Service (FFMS) approves a list of organizations eligible to open depo accounts of a nominee holder at theCentral Depository where 84 organizations were shown on the list, including the parent companies of international settlement systems Euroclear andClearstream. The same FFMS Order approves a list of securities that can be credited to such accounts. These include state securities, bonds issued byconstituent entities and municipalities, bonds by other Russian issuers, as well as securities of foreign issuers (until July 1, 2014 ); and securities recorded inthe Central Depository (i.e. shares of Russian issuers, etc) until July 1, 2014.

    Nov. 06, 2012 The National Settlement Depository (NSD) is officially vested with the status of Central Depository

    Feb 07, 2013Launch of OFZ OTC market with Euroclears participation

    Year 2013: OFZ auction with Euroclears participation, liberalization of access of corporate and

    bond markets, Clearstream on Russian bond market, introduction of OTC derivatives platform,implementation of T+2 and new tariff model on MICEX

    Ambitious Privatization Programme Likely to mark astep change for Russian Capital Markets

  • 7/28/2019 Privatization Presentations

    36/49

    36

    step change for Russian Capital Markets

    Company Sector % share

    for sale

    Expected deal

    size, $ m

    Russian Railways Transport 5-25% 1,680-2,700

    Sovcomflot Transport 25% N/A

    Sheremetievo Transport 83.4% 1,000

    Aeroflot Transport

  • 7/28/2019 Privatization Presentations

    37/49

    37

    Domestic pipeline

    1 Privatization

    The current stage of privatization is expectedto complete by 2016

    Potential pipeline comprises 22 companiesspanning across 8 sectors, waiting for themarket window

    Estimated total proceeds are up to $100bn

    3 Secondary equity offerings

    Potential pipeline of 15+ companies on thebasis of previous public announcements andour analysis

    Over 10 sectors

    4 Fixed income

    894 registered fixed incomeissues as of December 2012

    Low yields and ambitiousinvestment programmesmake debt capital marketsattractive source of financingfor Russian issuers

    2 Private sector IPOs

    At least 25 companiesacross 7 sectors thatannounced their plans to go

    public

    Poor market conditions in2009-2012 have led to anumber of private companiespulling their plans to gopublic until the market picksup

  • 7/28/2019 Privatization Presentations

    38/49

    FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONSENERGYINFRASTRUCTURE, MINING AND COMMODITIESTRANSPORTTECHNOLOGY AND INNOVATIONPHARMACEUTICALS AND LIFE SCIENCES

    General overview of privatisation in Russia

    Angelica PhillipsPartner

    28 May 2013

    Legal background

  • 7/28/2019 Privatization Presentations

    39/49

    On the View menu, click Header and Footer to update this text39

    Legal background

    Laws

    Federal Law No.178-FZ dated 21 December 2001 On Privatization of

    State and Municipal Property (as amended) (the Law);Resolution No. 2101-r of the Government of the Russian Federation

    dated 27 November 2010 endorsing the Project Plan (Program) forPrivatization of Federal Property and Guidelines for Privatization ofFederal Property for 2011-2013 (the Plan);

    Russian Civil Code;

    Federal Law No.208-FZ dated 26 December 1995 On Joint StockCompanies (as amended); and

    Federal Law No.14-FZ dated 8 February 1998 On Limited LiabilityCompanies (as amended).

    Purchasers and Privatisation plan

  • 7/28/2019 Privatization Presentations

    40/49

    On the View menu, click Header and Footer to update this text40

    Purchasers and Privatisation plan

    Purchasers

    Any physical person and legal entity. Legal entities in which the RF

    owns more than 25% could not be purchasers under the Law.LLCs and OJSCs could not buy their own participant interests/shares

    which are subject to privatisation under the Law.

    Privatisation plan

    The Russian Government is allowed to set forth a privatisation plan ofthe federal property for a period from 1 till 3 years. The effective Planlists legal entities and assets which a due for privatisation before theend of 2013.

    Determination of price and information support

  • 7/28/2019 Privatization Presentations

    41/49

    On the View menu, click Header and Footer to update this text41

    Determination of price and information support

    Determination of price

    The Law envisages a market mechanism for determining the starting

    price based on an assets evaluation report prepared in compliancewith the Russian legislation on valuation activities.

    For participation in an auction or tender an applicant shall make adeposit in the amount of 10% of the starting price of the appropriatefederal property.

    Information supportThe Law introduces a concept of information support of privatization,

    which includes a complex of measures aimed on creation of a freeaccess of the general public to information concerning privatization ofthe federal property.

    Regulatory approvals and mandatory offer

  • 7/28/2019 Privatization Presentations

    42/49

    42

    Regulatory approvals and mandatory offer

    Regulatory approvals

    Acquisition of the appropriate threshold of shares/participant interests could be

    subject to obtaining approvals from Russian regulatory bodies: Federal Antimonopoly Service

    Governmental Commission in case the target company is of a strategicnature

    Industry regulators for example Central Bank, Federal Service of the

    Financial MarketsMandatory offer

    Acquisition of more than 30% of shares of OJSC will trigger an obligation of thebuyer to make mandatory offer to other shareholders of the target to buy out theremaining shareholding.

    Corporate Structures - 1A i t i t t d i tti R i h h i

  • 7/28/2019 Privatization Presentations

    43/49

    On the View menu, click Header and Footer to update this text43

    An investor interested in setting up a Russian company has a choicebetween: a limited liability company, abbreviated in Russian as OOO (LLC); and

    a joint stock company (JSC) which may be either:

    (a) a closed joint stock company, abbreviated in Russian as ZAO (CJSC); or

    (b) an open joint stock company, abbreviated in Russian as OAO (OJSC).

    Legal Status LLC and JSC may conduct any form of commercial activity. Any Russian and foreign

    companies and individuals may be founders of LLC and JSC. LLC and JSC may beestablished by a single founder which must have at least two shareholders.

    Management Bodies LLC and JSC have a three-tier management structure consisting of (1) General meeting

    of shareholders/participants, (2) Board of directors, and (3) General director. Generalmeeting of shareholders/participants is the highest management body and it must meet

    at least once a year

  • 7/28/2019 Privatization Presentations

    44/49

    The rights of minority shareholders of JSC depending on thesize of their shareholdings - 1

  • 7/28/2019 Privatization Presentations

    45/49

    On the View menu, click Header and Footer to update this text45

    size of their shareholdings- 1

    Regardless of the size of shareholding

    The approval of interested party transactions (together with other non-

    interested shareholders) which, in accordance with Russian legislation, aresubject to approval by a majority of non-interested shareholders at thegeneral shareholders meeting (GSM) of the JSC.

    Pre-emptive right to acquire additional shares or securities convertible intoshares (new issue).

    Shareholding equal to 20%

    All rights specified above. The right to elect one member of the board of directors if the number of

    directors of the board of directors is equal to the minimum amount establishedby the JSC Law (i.e. - 5 members).

    The ability to block the approval of major transactions with a value between25 to 50 percent of the balance sheet value of the JSC's assets, through its

    representative in the board of directors since in accordance with the Russianlegislation requires unanimity of all members of the board of directors of JSC.

    The rights of minority shareholders of JSC depending on thesize of their shareholdings - 2

  • 7/28/2019 Privatization Presentations

    46/49

    On the View menu, click Header and Footer to update this text46

    size of their shareholdings- 2

    Shareholding equal to 25%+1 share

    All rights applicable to Shareholding equal to 20%

    The ability to block decisions of the GSM on matters which require a 3/4 majority ofshareholders present at the GSM, namely:

    1. insertion of amendments and additions to the JSCs charter or approval of anew edition of the JSCs charter;

    2. reorganisation of the JSC;

    3. liquidation of the JSC, appointment of a liquidation commission and approval

    of interim and final liquidation balance sheets;4. determination of the number, nominal value, category of declared shares

    and rights granted by such shares;

    5. acquisition by the JSC of the allotted shares in cases stipulated by the JSC Law;

    6. approval of major transactions with a value exceeding over 50 per cent ofthe balance sheet value of the JSC's assets;

    7. decrease of the charter capital of the JSC by reducing the nominal valueof shares.

    Protection of minority rights in relation to approval of related partyor major transactions

  • 7/28/2019 Privatization Presentations

    47/49

    On the View menu, click Header and Footer to update this text47

    or major transactions

    Major transactions

    Minority shareholder is able to block the approval of major transactions with a valuebetween 25 to 50 percent of the balance sheet value of the JSC's assets, provided ithas a representative in the board of directors as well as other issues within thecompetence of the board of directors, which in accordance with the charter or Russianlegislation requires unanimity of all members of the board of directors of JSC

    Minority shareholder is able to block the approval by the GSM on matters whichrequire a 3/4 majority of shareholders present at the GSM in particular the approval ofmajor transactions with a value exceeding over 50 per cent of the balance sheet value

    of the JSC's assetsInterested party transactions

    Minority shareholder is potentially able to block the approval of interested partytransactions (together with other non-interested shareholders) which, in accordancewith Russian legislation, are subject to approval by a majority of non-interestedshareholders at the GSM of the JSC. This means that if a major shareholder isinterested shareholder than minority shareholder will be the one to approve

  • 7/28/2019 Privatization Presentations

    48/49

    On the View menu, click Header and Footer to update this text48

    Disclaimer

    The purpose of this presentation is to provide information as to developments inthe law. It does not contain a full analysis of the law nor does it constitute anopinion of Norton Rose (Central Europe) LLP on the points of law discussed.

    No individual who is a member, partner, shareholder, director, employee orconsultant of, in or to any constituent part of Norton Rose Group (whether or notsuch individual is described as a partner) accepts or assumes responsibility, orhas any liability, to any person in respect of this presentation. Any reference to a

    partner or director is to a member, employee or consultant with equivalentstanding and qualifications of, as the case may be, Norton Rose LLP or NortonRose Australia or Norton Rose Canada LLP or Norton Rose South Africa(incorporated as Deneys Reitz Inc) or of one of their respective affiliates.

  • 7/28/2019 Privatization Presentations

    49/49