presented by| keith mccullough, sydney hawran & amy lamott vargas complex issues with new...

18
Presented by| Keith McCullough, Sydney Hawran & Amy Lamott Vargas Complex Issues With New Project Delivery Techniques

Upload: helena-lane

Post on 27-Dec-2015

229 views

Category:

Documents


4 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Presented by| Keith McCullough, Sydney Hawran & Amy Lamott Vargas Complex Issues With New Project Delivery Techniques

Presented by| Keith McCullough, Sydney Hawran & Amy Lamott Vargas

Complex Issues With New Project Delivery Techniques

Page 2: Presented by| Keith McCullough, Sydney Hawran & Amy Lamott Vargas Complex Issues With New Project Delivery Techniques

I - 15 Norco – Riverside County

Page 3: Presented by| Keith McCullough, Sydney Hawran & Amy Lamott Vargas Complex Issues With New Project Delivery Techniques

Historic approach to project implementation· Design – Bid – Build

- fixed ROW lines

- consistent with RON descriptions

- inflexible, long lead time, costly

That was then . . .

Page 4: Presented by| Keith McCullough, Sydney Hawran & Amy Lamott Vargas Complex Issues With New Project Delivery Techniques

I-5 at SR55 Orange County – Design Bid Build

Page 5: Presented by| Keith McCullough, Sydney Hawran & Amy Lamott Vargas Complex Issues With New Project Delivery Techniques

Duration and complexity of projects increase- Often dense, urban settings- Duration of Temporary Construction

Easements increase- Investigative entries and the timing of permanent

takings

That was then . . .

Page 6: Presented by| Keith McCullough, Sydney Hawran & Amy Lamott Vargas Complex Issues With New Project Delivery Techniques

City of Livermore v. Baca – Temporary Severance Damages

Page 7: Presented by| Keith McCullough, Sydney Hawran & Amy Lamott Vargas Complex Issues With New Project Delivery Techniques

City of Livermore v. Baca – Temporary Severance Damages

Page 8: Presented by| Keith McCullough, Sydney Hawran & Amy Lamott Vargas Complex Issues With New Project Delivery Techniques

Contemporary techniques for dealing with ever-increasing project complexities- Pros and cons with each technique- Challenges become opportunities- Flexibility in current ROW practices: “Every day counts”

. . . this is now

Page 9: Presented by| Keith McCullough, Sydney Hawran & Amy Lamott Vargas Complex Issues With New Project Delivery Techniques

Design – Build- Shorter lead times- Adjust more easily to field conditions- One stop shop project- Changes to ROW lines create challenges- Potential for increased acquisition costs

. . . this is now

Page 10: Presented by| Keith McCullough, Sydney Hawran & Amy Lamott Vargas Complex Issues With New Project Delivery Techniques

Baseline condition – Lakeview Grade Separation – Design Build

Page 11: Presented by| Keith McCullough, Sydney Hawran & Amy Lamott Vargas Complex Issues With New Project Delivery Techniques
Page 12: Presented by| Keith McCullough, Sydney Hawran & Amy Lamott Vargas Complex Issues With New Project Delivery Techniques

Design Sequencing– advantages / disadvantages– potential legal implications

. . . this is now

Page 13: Presented by| Keith McCullough, Sydney Hawran & Amy Lamott Vargas Complex Issues With New Project Delivery Techniques

OTAY MESA CROSSING – Design Sequencing

Page 14: Presented by| Keith McCullough, Sydney Hawran & Amy Lamott Vargas Complex Issues With New Project Delivery Techniques

OTAY MESA CROSSING – Design Sequencing

Page 15: Presented by| Keith McCullough, Sydney Hawran & Amy Lamott Vargas Complex Issues With New Project Delivery Techniques

Construction Management General Contractor– Pros / Cons– Coordinated team approach – ROW Strategic Team– Business decision: do the project management

flexibility merits outweigh potential delay and cost increases of legal challenges?

. . . this is now

Page 16: Presented by| Keith McCullough, Sydney Hawran & Amy Lamott Vargas Complex Issues With New Project Delivery Techniques
Page 17: Presented by| Keith McCullough, Sydney Hawran & Amy Lamott Vargas Complex Issues With New Project Delivery Techniques

I-5 North Coast– Construction Management General Contractor

Page 18: Presented by| Keith McCullough, Sydney Hawran & Amy Lamott Vargas Complex Issues With New Project Delivery Techniques

Questions?

Keith E. McCullough, Esq.AlvaradoSmith, APC(714) [email protected]

Amy Lamott Vargas Deputy District Director

Right of Way DivisionCaltrans District 11

(619) [email protected]

Sydney H. Hawran, MAIHawran & Malm, LLC

(949) [email protected]