presentation to the israel democracy institute international conference “what do think tanks...
TRANSCRIPT
Presentation to the Israel Democracy Institute International Conference “What Do Think Tanks Do?”May 15, 2011Donald AbelsonThe University of Western Ontario
Scholars who study think tanks have been unable to reach a consensus on how to define these organizations. There are some identifiable characteristics: Not for profit Tax-exempt Non-partisan (not to be confused with
non-ideological) Research -oriented, with a commitment
to shaping public opinion and policy
In the absence of an agreed-upon definition, scholars in the field have established classifications to account for the diverse nature of the think tank community (McGann and Weaver, Stone, Abelson, etc…)
Universities without students –policy researchGovernment Contractors/SpecialistsAdvocacy Think TanksAlthough it is not always easy to classify think tanks, scholars generally agree that the trend since the early 1970s has been toward the creation of advocacy think tanks that combine policy research with aggressive political advocacy.
Andrew Carnegie Robert Brookings Herbert Hoover
The Brookings Institution
The Carnegie Endowment for International Peace
The Rand Corporation
The Urban Institute
Edwin Feulner
Paul Weyrich
The Heritage Foundation
FromPolicy Research to Political Advocacy:Combining Policy Research with aggressive marketing
Quick Response Policy Research-Timely & Policy Relevant
Emphasis on Media Exposure
It’s all about the numbers
National or Public Interest?
Institutional & Private Interests
Institution Date Founde
d
Location Number of
Staff
Budget($
Millions)
Carnegie Endowment for International Peace
1910 Washington, DC
> 100 > 15-20
The Brookings Institution
1916 Washington, DC
250 > 30
Hoover Institution 1919 Stanford, CA 320 > 30
Council on Foreign Relations
1921 New York, NY > 100 > 30
American Enterprise Institute
1943 Washington, DC
190 > 20
RAND 1946 Santa Monica, CA
1,600 > 200
Hudson Institute 1961 Indianapolis, IN
125 > 10
Center for Strategic & International Studies
1962 Washington, DC
> 220 > 20
Heritage Foundation 1973 Washington, DC
> 150 > 30
Think tanks vary enormously in terms of size, financial resources, areas of specialization, and research programs, but they share in common a desire to influence public opinion and public policy.
Target Audiences/Stakeholders: Policy-Makers (Executive and Legislative Branches);
They also target bureaucratic departments and agencies responsible for foreign and defense policy (State Department, Department of Defense, National Security Council, etc…)
Media Academics Corporations The Public
Publications –Books, policy briefs, opinion magazines
Media commentariesBlogs- websitesCongressional TestimonySeminars; Conferences;
WorkshopsLiaison Offices with Congress
Think Tanks convey ideas to policy-makers at different stages of the policy-making process.
To achieve influence, think tanks often need to present the right ideas to the right people at the right time.