ppm comparison
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/10/2019 PPM Comparison
1/43
Comparison of Project Management Software
Rudolf Muhlbauer, Thomas KlambauerWalter Ruprechtsberger, Josef Schaitl
2007-12-10
Institut fur Bioinformatik, Mag. Dr. Elisabeth Kapsammer
-
8/10/2019 PPM Comparison
2/43
Comparison of Project Management Software
Introduction
Overview
Motivation Criteria
Products
Summary
Closing
Muhlbauer, Klambauer, Ruprechtsberger, Schaitl Comparison of Project Management Software 2
-
8/10/2019 PPM Comparison
3/43
Comparison of Project Management Software
Introduction
Motivation
Licensing & Costs
Migration
Collaborative
Platform Independence
Usability Maintainability
Muhlbauer, Klambauer, Ruprechtsberger, Schaitl Comparison of Project Management Software 3
-
8/10/2019 PPM Comparison
4/43
Comparison of Project Management Software
Introduction
Presented Products
Microsoft Project
dotproject Planner
Trac
Gantt Project
Merlin FastTrack Schedule
Omni Plan
Muhlbauer, Klambauer, Ruprechtsberger, Schaitl Comparison of Project Management Software 4
-
8/10/2019 PPM Comparison
5/43
Comparison of Project Management Software
Introduction
Evaluation Focus
Graphical User interface
Economical
Interoperability
Data Handling
Project Management Miscellaneous
Muhlbauer, Klambauer, Ruprechtsberger, Schaitl Comparison of Project Management Software 5
-
8/10/2019 PPM Comparison
6/43
Comparison of Project Management Software
Evaluated Products
Microsoft Project
Microsoft Project
Microsoft Project Professional 2007
Microsoft Project Server 2007
Microsoft Corporation
http://office.microsoft.com/project
Proprietary license: 999$ / 599$ (Standard Edition)
Muhlbauer, Klambauer, Ruprechtsberger, Schaitl Comparison of Project Management Software 6
http://office.microsoft.com/projecthttp://office.microsoft.com/project -
8/10/2019 PPM Comparison
7/43
Comparison of Project Management Software
Evaluated Products
Microsoft Project
Project Professional 2007
Muhlbauer, Klambauer, Ruprechtsberger, Schaitl Comparison of Project Management Software 7
-
8/10/2019 PPM Comparison
8/43
Comparison of Project Management Software
Evaluated Products
Microsoft Project
Basic Information
Over 20 million licenses sold
Biggest market share
Windows/Office Network effect
Muhlbauer, Klambauer, Ruprechtsberger, Schaitl Comparison of Project Management Software 8
-
8/10/2019 PPM Comparison
9/43
Comparison of Project Management Software
Evaluated Products
Microsoft Project
Evaluation
Graphical interface Designed, but flawed
Economical Pricey, Platform fixed
Interoperability with Microsoft products
Muhlbauer, Klambauer, Ruprechtsberger, Schaitl Comparison of Project Management Software 9
C i f P j M S f
-
8/10/2019 PPM Comparison
10/43
Comparison of Project Management Software
Evaluated Products
Microsoft Project
Web Access
Muhlbauer, Klambauer, Ruprechtsberger, Schaitl Comparison of Project Management Software 10
C i f P j t M t S ft
-
8/10/2019 PPM Comparison
11/43
Comparison of Project Management Software
Evaluated Products
Microsoft Project
Not for everybody..
Muhlbauer, Klambauer, Ruprechtsberger, Schaitl Comparison of Project Management Software 11
Comparison of Project Management Soft are
-
8/10/2019 PPM Comparison
12/43
Comparison of Project Management Software
Evaluated Products
Microsoft Project
Evaluation (2)
Data handling Analysis Services, OLAP Cube
Project ManagementProject Portfolio Server
Miscellaneous Documentation
Muhlbauer, Klambauer, Ruprechtsberger, Schaitl Comparison of Project Management Software 12
Comparison of Project Management Software
-
8/10/2019 PPM Comparison
13/43
Comparison of Project Management Software
Evaluated Products
Microsoft Project
Enterprise Project Management
Muhlbauer, Klambauer, Ruprechtsberger, Schaitl Comparison of Project Management Software 13
Comparison of Project Management Software
-
8/10/2019 PPM Comparison
14/43
Comparison of Project Management Software
Evaluated Products
Microsoft Project
Server Systems
Project Server
Centralizes data
Company environment integration
Project Portfolio Server
Even higher viewpoint
Manage collections of project
Muhlbauer, Klambauer, Ruprechtsberger, Schaitl Comparison of Project Management Software 14
Comparison of Project Management Software
-
8/10/2019 PPM Comparison
15/43
Comparison of Project Management Software
Evaluated Products
Microsoft Project
Summary
ProfessionalityComes for a cost
Microsoft Comes for a lock-in
Enterprise solution Comes for those in need
Clarity & Usability Will hopefully come in next Version
Muhlbauer, Klambauer, Ruprechtsberger, Schaitl Comparison of Project Management Software 15
Comparison of Project Management Software
-
8/10/2019 PPM Comparison
16/43
C p j g S
Evaluated Products
Trac
Trac
Trac v0.10.4
edgewall software
http://trac.edgewall.org/
modified BSD licence: free
Muhlbauer, Klambauer, Ruprechtsberger, Schaitl Comparison of Project Management Software 16
Comparison of Project Management Software
http://trac.edgewall.org/http://trac.edgewall.org/ -
8/10/2019 PPM Comparison
17/43
p j g
Evaluated Products
Trac
User Interface
Administration via config files / console
Web-Interface as module available
SVN
Wiki
Muhlbauer, Klambauer, Ruprechtsberger, Schaitl Comparison of Project Management Software 17
Comparison of Project Management Software
-
8/10/2019 PPM Comparison
18/43
Evaluated Products
Trac
Wiki - Roadmap
Muhlbauer, Klambauer, Ruprechtsberger, Schaitl Comparison of Project Management Software 18
Comparison of Project Management Software
-
8/10/2019 PPM Comparison
19/43
Evaluated Products
Trac
Wiki - Milestone
Muhlbauer, Klambauer, Ruprechtsberger, Schaitl Comparison of Project Management Software 19
Comparison of Project Management Software
-
8/10/2019 PPM Comparison
20/43
Evaluated Products
Trac
Economical
open source
uses python SVN SQLite/PostreSQL web-server Genshi
Muhlbauer, Klambauer, Ruprechtsberger, Schaitl Comparison of Project Management Software 20
Comparison of Project Management Software
-
8/10/2019 PPM Comparison
21/43
Evaluated Products
Trac
Interoperability
integrated SVN
can use SMTP server
integrated RSS feed
iCalendar files from tickets
lots of modules for interoperation
Muhlbauer, Klambauer, Ruprechtsberger, Schaitl Comparison of Project Management Software 21
Comparison of Project Management Software
-
8/10/2019 PPM Comparison
22/43
Evaluated Products
Trac
Data Handling
SVN repository
SQL database
reports through plugins
Muhlbauer, Klambauer, Ruprechtsberger, Schaitl Comparison of Project Management Software 22
Comparison of Project Management Software
-
8/10/2019 PPM Comparison
23/43
Evaluated Products
Trac
Summary
Tickets SVN -> Wiki
Communication Wiki, email etc.
Configurability fine-tuning
Modularity extra features
Open Source user created content
Muhlbauer, Klambauer, Ruprechtsberger, Schaitl Comparison of Project Management Software 23
Comparison of Project Management Software
E l d P d
-
8/10/2019 PPM Comparison
24/43
Evaluated Products
dotproject
Overview
dotproject
http://dotproject.net
Open Source: GPL
Muhlbauer, Klambauer, Ruprechtsberger, Schaitl Comparison of Project Management Software 24
Comparison of Project Management Software
E l t d P d t
-
8/10/2019 PPM Comparison
25/43
Evaluated Products
dotproject
dotproject
Muhlbauer, Klambauer, Ruprechtsberger, Schaitl Comparison of Project Management Software 25
Comparison of Project Management Software
E al ated Prod cts
-
8/10/2019 PPM Comparison
26/43
Evaluated Products
dotproject
Basic Information
Web based (Apache, MySQL, PHP)
Platform Independent
Multiuser System
Muhlbauer, Klambauer, Ruprechtsberger, Schaitl Comparison of Project Management Software 26
Comparison of Project Management Software
Evaluated Products
-
8/10/2019 PPM Comparison
27/43
Evaluated Products
dotproject
Evaluation
Graphical Interface Easy to understand, clean
Economical Free License, Maintenance, Support
Interoperability Raw Database access
Muhlbauer, Klambauer, Ruprechtsberger, Schaitl Comparison of Project Management Software 27
Comparison of Project Management Software
Evaluated Products
-
8/10/2019 PPM Comparison
28/43
Evaluated Products
dotproject
Evaluation (2)
Data handling History, Servercentric
Project ManagementLimited, but easy
Documentation Public Wiki, Forum
Muhlbauer, Klambauer, Ruprechtsberger, Schaitl Comparison of Project Management Software 28
Comparison of Project Management Software
Evaluated Products
-
8/10/2019 PPM Comparison
29/43
Evaluated Products
dotproject
View Project
Muhlbauer, Klambauer, Ruprechtsberger, Schaitl Comparison of Project Management Software 29
Comparison of Project Management Software
Evaluated Products
-
8/10/2019 PPM Comparison
30/43
a uated oducts
dotproject
Extensible
Addon Modules
Open Source
Community Effort
Muhlbauer, Klambauer, Ruprechtsberger, Schaitl Comparison of Project Management Software 30
Comparison of Project Management Software
Evaluated Products
-
8/10/2019 PPM Comparison
31/43
dotproject
Collaboration
User account maps to Human resource
Access from everywhere
Runs in Webbrowser
Muhlbauer, Klambauer, Ruprechtsberger, Schaitl Comparison of Project Management Software 31
Comparison of Project Management Software
Evaluated Products
-
8/10/2019 PPM Comparison
32/43
dotproject
Summary
Cheap
Server-Client only
Needs professional administration
Minimal functionality
Open by all meanings
Muhlbauer, Klambauer, Ruprechtsberger, Schaitl Comparison of Project Management Software 32
Comparison of Project Management Software
Evaluated Products
-
8/10/2019 PPM Comparison
33/43
Omni Plan
OmniPlan
OmniPlan 1.5 beta 2 (v135)
The Omni Group
http://www.omnigroup.com/applications/omniplan
proprietary licence - $ 149.95
Muhlbauer, Klambauer, Ruprechtsberger, Schaitl Comparison of Project Management Software 33
Comparison of Project Management Software
Evaluated Products
http://www.omnigroup.com/applications/omniplanhttp://www.omnigroup.com/applications/omniplan -
8/10/2019 PPM Comparison
34/43
Omni Plan
OmniPlan
Muhlbauer, Klambauer, Ruprechtsberger, Schaitl Comparison of Project Management Software 34
Comparison of Project Management Software
Evaluated Products
-
8/10/2019 PPM Comparison
35/43
Omni Plan
Basic Information
Special solution for MacOS X
Small program for small projects
Assumed low market share
Muhlbauer, Klambauer, Ruprechtsberger, Schaitl Comparison of Project Management Software 35
Comparison of Project Management Software
Evaluated Products
-
8/10/2019 PPM Comparison
36/43
Omni Plan
Evaluation
Graphical interface Neat and clean interface
Economical Low priced but closed-source
Interoperability With MS Project, iCal, HTML
Muhlbauer, Klambauer, Ruprechtsberger, Schaitl Comparison of Project Management Software 36
Comparison of Project Management Software
Evaluated Products
-
8/10/2019 PPM Comparison
37/43
Omni Plan
HTML Report (1)
Muhlbauer, Klambauer, Ruprechtsberger, Schaitl Comparison of Project Management Software 37
Comparison of Project Management Software
Evaluated Products
O i Pl
-
8/10/2019 PPM Comparison
38/43
Omni Plan
HTML Report (2)
Muhlbauer, Klambauer, Ruprechtsberger, Schaitl Comparison of Project Management Software 38
Comparison of Project Management Software
Evaluated Products
O i Pl
-
8/10/2019 PPM Comparison
39/43
Omni Plan
Evaluation (2)
Data handling No features implemented
Project ManagementResources from Addressbook
Miscellaneous Documentation
Muhlbauer, Klambauer, Ruprechtsberger, Schaitl Comparison of Project Management Software 39
Comparison of Project Management Software
Evaluated Products
Omni Plan
-
8/10/2019 PPM Comparison
40/43
Omni Plan
Summary
Addresses users who want simple PM
Not intended for huge projects
Lack in sharing features
Outstanding HTML Reports
Muhlbauer, Klambauer, Ruprechtsberger, Schaitl Comparison of Project Management Software 40
Comparison of Project Management Software
Closing
-
8/10/2019 PPM Comparison
41/43
Closing
Huge Market
Broad spectrum of available products
Big differences in functionality
A lot to do for the Community
Muhlbauer, Klambauer, Ruprechtsberger, Schaitl Comparison of Project Management Software 41
Comparison of Project Management Software
Closing
-
8/10/2019 PPM Comparison
42/43
Thank you!
Thank you for your attention!
We would be pleased to answer any upcoming
questions!
Muhlbauer, Klambauer, Ruprechtsberger, Schaitl Comparison of Project Management Software 42
Comparison of Project Management Software
References
-
8/10/2019 PPM Comparison
43/43
References
Muhlbauer, Klambauer, Ruprechtsberger, Schaitl Comparison of Project Management Software 43