powerpoint presentation polish immigrants in ireland accent and the dynamics of social mobility
TRANSCRIPT
1
Ewa Malczuk
Polish immigrants in Ireland: Accent and the dynamics of social mobility
Postgraduate Research Seminars 2016 Ewa Malczuk
Postgraduate Research Seminars 2016 Ewa Malczuk 2
Background of the Research
Proposed Research Study
Methodology
Content
Postgraduate Research Seminars 2016 Ewa Malczuk 3
Standard language Non-standard language
correct incorrect
superior inferior
having power and prestige lower status and lower socioeconomic perspectives
promoted stigmatized
speakers viewed as competent, intelligent and successive
speakers often discriminated against and viewed as less competent and less intelligent
positive judgments / stereotypes negative judgments / stereotypes
Social ideology of standard language (of any language)
Background of the Research
Postgraduate Research Seminars 2016 Ewa Malczuk 4
An accent - phonology or a way of pronunciation of a language.
An accent is an indicator of social identity. It can be an identifier of a different nation or different cultural group.
For many people, different accent becomes the first silent marker to identify social outsiders (Lippi-Green 1994).
Speaking a language with a different accent can be a reason for discrimination.
Accent - Social Creation
Background of the Research
Postgraduate Research Seminars 2016 Ewa Malczuk 5
Accents of English
British English (Received Pronunciation)
Foreign-accented English
New Englishes (with reference to British
and American English)
Regional accents/dialects
General American English
Standard Irish English
Standard-accented English
Non-standard-accented English
Accents of English
Background of the Research
Postgraduate Research Seminars 2016 Ewa Malczuk 6
Irish-English-accented speech, if compared to the British and American accent capital, is perceived as less valuable capital and an inferior variety of English.
Irish-English was stigmatised and treated as a peripheral rather a legitimate language (Nestor et al 2012).
The Celtic Tiger period which led to immigration influx into Ireland, frequently from Central and Eastern Europe, turned Irish-English into a more attractive accent.
The possession of competence in dominant Irish-English has begun to be seen for many as a valuable accent capital.
British and American accents The British and American accents are considered as the most powerful accents
(Nestor et al 2012; Waniek-Klimczak et al 2015).
The accent capital of British and American accents is constantly strengthened by those controlling powerful media outlets (CNN, BBC World, etc.), wealthy Hollywood movie productions, business and advertising (Phillipson 2001).
Irish-English accent
Accents of English - Accent Capital
Background of the Research
Postgraduate Research Seminars 2016 Ewa Malczuk 7
Proposed Research Study
The proponents of accent globalization are mostly the people who belong to the accent dominant group or those striving to join said group.
The ability to speak standard English, more precisely the use of the British or American accent which is considered as the dominant and most prestigious and valuable English language variant worldwide, is an indicator of identification with the dominant group.
An ability to speak standard English, in terms of the accent out-group, can be both the prerequisite and also a licence to join the accent dominant group.
The ability to speak standard Irish-English can be considered as a dominant and valuable English accent in Ireland. It is an indicator of identification with the dominant group. This refers not only to native-accented English speakers but also, and particularly for, non-native accented English speakers.
Lack of ability to speak standard English can be a factor contributing to exclusion and discrimination.
Postgraduate Research Seminars 2016 Ewa Malczuk 8
Proposed Research Study
Areas for exploration
Do Polish-accented English speakers strive for a standard English accent as a means to join the dominant group.
Referring to social ideology of standard language, does the lack of ability to speak standard Irish-English by
Polish immigrants in Ireland contribute to discrimination.
The proposed research study will gauge the attitudes, opinions and experiences of Polish immigrants in Ireland in relation to standard accented English speech and their non-standard foreign-accented English speech.
Limitations of the research study
Further research is necessary to study the attitudes and opinions of standard native-accent English speakers on this topic.
Postgraduate Research Seminars 2016 Ewa Malczuk 9
Methodology
Research Approach/Paradigm
The multi-modal research approach/paradigm will be adopted. This will include:
Semi-structured interviews containing open-ended conversations with the respondents (to record the respondents’ insights, feelings and experiences)
Analysis obtained from secondary sources (articles, policy statements, statistical reports, etc.)
Postgraduate Research Seminars 2016 Ewa Malczuk 10
Methodology
Population of interest
Sampling method Sampling Group
Polish community in Ireland who have immigrated into Ireland after 2004.
Purposive sampling.
Snowballing sampling.
Forty respondents - (half male and half female).
Age 25 years and over - people in this age bracket have acquired proficiency in speaking English but their accent is mostly affected by Polish.
Middle class people who perform work on a professional, managerial, or administrative level.
The 18 to 25 years of age range - most of them acquired the ability in speaking Irish-accented English but their parents or relatives living in Ireland most likely speak Polish- accented English.
Students.
Postgraduate Research Seminars 2016 Ewa Malczuk 11
So what?
Globalisation means that Standard English is becoming even more powerful – if accent is being used as a simple way to differentiate and so discriminate, how can certain populations ever gain access to top levels of social ladder?
Linguistic colonialism – Frantz Fanon
Conclusion
Postgraduate Research Seminars 2016 Ewa Malczuk 12
Lippi-Green, R. (1994) ‘Accent, Standard Language Ideology, and Discriminatory Pretext in the Courts’, Language in Society, 23(2), 163-198.
Nestor, N., Ni Chasaide, C. & Regan, V. (2012) ‘Discourse ‘like’ and social identity – a case study of Poles in Ireland’, [online], available: http://www.academia.edu/4032999/Discourse_like_and_social_identity_-_a_case_study_of_Poles_in_Ireland [accessed 15 Dec 15].
Phillipson, R. (2001) ‘English for Globalisation or for the World's People?’ Globalisation, Language and Education, 47(3-4), pp. 185-20.
Waniek-Klimczak, E., Rojczyk, A. and Porzuczek, (2015) ‘Polglish’ in Polish Eyes: What English Studies Majors Think About Their Pronunciation in English’, Switzerland: Springer International Publishing.
References