power optimization of the captured air bubble surface

226
POWER OPTIMIZATION OF THE CAPTURED AIR BUBBLE SURFACE EFFECTS SHIP Frederick Kenneth Richardson

Upload: others

Post on 16-Mar-2022

5 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

POWER OPTIMIZATION OF THE CAPTUREDAIR BUBBLE SURFACE EFFECTS SHIP

Frederick Kenneth Richardson

Page 2: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

58*>*

Page 3: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

assR*

NAVAL POSTGRADUATE SCHOOL

Monterey, California

THESISPOWER OPTIMIZATION OF THE CAPTUREDAIR BUBBLE SURFACE EFFECTS SHIP

by

Frederick Kenneth Richardson

December, 1976

Thesis Advisor: G. J. Thaler

Approved for public release; distribution unlimited.

117711?

Page 4: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 5: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

IINHT.ASSTFTKnSECURITY CLASSIFICATION OF THIS RAGE f»>>«« Dmtm Entmrmd)

RE7»0*T DOCUMENTATION PAGE READ INSTRUCTIONSBEFORE COMPLETING FORM

1. REPORT NUMIIR 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S CATALOG NUMBER

4. TITLE i«i^SuHir/i)

Power Optimization of the Captured Air BubbleSurface Effects Ship

S. TYPE OF REPORT A PERIOO COVERED

Master's ThesisDpppTTihpr 1Q7A• PERFORMING ORG. REPORT NUMBER

7. AUTMOUfi;

Frederick Kenneth Richardson

• . CONTRACT OR GRANT NLMBERfaj

* PERFORMING ORGANIZATION NAME ANO ADDRESS

Naval Postgraduate SchoolMonterey, Ca. 93940

10. PROGRAM ELEMENT. PROJECT, TASKAREA * WORK UNIT NUMBERS

II. CONTROLLING OFFICE NAME ANO AOORESS

Naval Postgraduate SchoolMonterey, Ca. 93940

12. REPORT DATE

December 197613. NUMBER OF PACES

14. MONITORING AGENCY NAME * AOORESSfl/ dIUmtmnt /ram Controllint Olllem)

Naval Postgraduate SchoolMonterey, Ca. 93940

18. SECURITY CLASS, (ol thlm rdperl)

UNCLASSIFIEDII*. OECLASSIFI CATION/ DOWN GRADING

SCHEDULE

l«. DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT (el thi* Kmpott)

Approved for public release; distribution unlimited

17. DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT (ot tho mmolrmct mntmtmd in Block 20, II dltlmtmnl from Rmporl)

18. SUPPLEMENTARY NOTES

19. KEY WORDS (Cmnttmtm on MWN »>*• II nocoatmrr and idmntlfr or mleak nummor)

Surface Effects ShipCaptured Air Bubble

20. ABSTRACT (Cmnllnum on rmrmrmm aid* It nmcmmmmrr mm* imdmOtr *T mlmmk iwtirj

Through the use of simulation studies of the Surface Effects Ship(SES) XR-3, it is shown that power optimization can be achieved by controllingthe air bubble plenum pressure and the pitch angle of the craft. Studiesindicate a savings of up to forty percent in total power required forcruising speeds in the range of fifteen to thirty knots.

DO ,

wJmTn 1473

(Page 1)

EDITION OF I NOV •• IS OBSOLETES/N 102-0 14- S601 I

UNCLASSIFIEDSECURITY CLASSIFICATION OF TNIS PAOE f9hdM Dmtm Snlmrmd}

Page 6: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 7: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

POWER OPTIMIZATION OF THE CAPTURED AIR BOBBLE SURFACEEFFECTS SHIP

by

Frederick Kenneth RichardsonLieutenant, United States NavyB.S., Purdue University, 1968

Submitted in partial fulfillment of therequirements for the degree of

MASTER OF SCIENCE IN ELECTRICAL ENGINEERING

from the

NAVAL POSTGRADUATE SCHOOL

December, 1976

Page 8: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 9: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

wowmmmHAVAt"

ABSTRACT

Through the use of simulation studies of the

Surface Effects Ship (SES) XR-3, it is shown that

power optimization can be achieved by controlling the

air bubble plenum pressure and the pitch angle of the

craft. Studies indicate a savings of up to forty

percent in total power required for cruising speeds in

the range of fifteen to thirty knots.

Page 10: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

wm m

Page 11: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

TABLE OF CONTENTS

I. INTRODUCTION 9

A. BACKGROUND 9

B. OBJECTIVES 11

II. GENERAL DISCUSSION 12

A. INTRODUCTION 12

B. SIMULATION METHODS 13

III. CALM WATER STUDIES 16

A. OBJECTIVES 16

B. SIMULATION PERFORMANCE 16

C. EXPERIMENTAL VERIFICATION TESTS 26

IV. SEA STATE STUDIES 52

A. OBJECTIVES 52

B. SIMULATION PERFORMANCE 52

V. RESULTS „ « 57

VI. CONCLUSIONS 61

A. SUMMATION 61

B. METHOD OF CONTROL 62

VII. OPERATIONAL CONSIDERATIONS 65

VIII. RECOMMENDATIONS 70

Appendix A: SIMULATION DATA LISTING 71

LIST OF REFERENCES 109

INITIAL DISTRIBUTION LIST 110

Page 12: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 13: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

LIST OF FIGURES

1. Total Power vs Pitch Angle, 15.0 knots , 18

2. Total Power vs Pitch Angle, 15.0 knots 19

3. Total Power vs Pitch Angle, 18.0 knots 20

4. Total Power vs Pitch Angle, 22.0 knots 21

5. Total Power vs Pitch Angle, 25.0 knots 22

6. Total Power vs Pitch Angle, 27.5 knots..* 23

7. Total Power vs Pitch Angle, 30.0 knots 24

8. Total Power vs Plenum Pressure, 0.5 Degrees 28

9. Total Power vs Plenum Pressure, 0.6 Degrees 29

10. Total Power vs Plenum Pressure, 0.7 Degrees 30

11. Total Power vs Plenum Pressure, 0.8 Degrees 31

12. Total Power vs Plenum Pressure, 0.9 Degrees 32

13. Total Power vs Plenum Pressure, 1.0 Degrees 33

14. Total Power vs Plenum Pressure, 1.1 Degrees 34

15. Total Power vs Plenum Pressure, 1.2 Degrees 35

16. Total Power vs Plenum Pressure, 1.3 Degrees 36

17. Total Power vs Plenum Pressure, 1.4 Degrees 37

18. Total Power vs Plenum Pressure, 1.5 Degrees 38

19. Total Power vs Plenum Pressure, 1.6 Degrees 39

20. Total Power vs Plenum Pressure, 1.7 Degrees 40

Page 14: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 15: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

21. Total Power vs Plenum Pressure, 1.8 Degrees 41

22. Total Power vs Plenum Pressure, 1.9 Degrees 42

23. Total Power vs Plenum Pressure, 2.0 Degrees 43

24. Total Power vs Plenum Pressure, 2.1 Degrees 44

25. Total Power vs Plenum Pressure, 2.2 Degrees 45

26. Total Power vs Plenum Pressure, 2.3 Degrees 46

27. Total Power vs Plenum Pressure, 2.4 Degrees 47

28. Total Power vs Plenum Pressure, 2.5 Degrees 48

29. Total Power vs Pitch Angle, Natural Response 49

30. Total Power vs Pitch Angle, Natural Response 50

31. Total Power vs Pitch Angle, Actual Craft 51

32. Total Power vs Pitch Angle, 18 Knots, Sea State 53

33. Total Power vs Pitch Angle, 27.5 Knots, Sea State... 54

34. Sketch of Bubble Pressure vs Pitch Angle 59

35. Bubble Pressure vs Pitch Angle, 15 Knots 60

36. Total Power vs Pitch Angle, 30 Knots.... 64

37. Recommended Operating Profile 68

38. Recommended Operating Profile, 15 Knots 69

Page 16: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 17: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

Only those who have undertaken a project such as this

can fully appreciate the influence that others have on its

successful completion. With this in mind, the author wishes

to first express his most sincere appreciation to Professors

George J. Thaler and Alex Gerba, Jr. of the Naval

Postgraduate School. Their knowledge, dedication and

patience provided the guiding light by which the author

traveled

.

A great deal of the author f s time and effort was

spent in the computer center. Without the continuous

assistance of all the operators, a study like this could not

have been completed. A special "thank you" to E. V.

Donnellan (Ed) , M. Anderson (Andy) and K. Butler (Kris) of

the evening shift whose personal interest in each student's

needs was combined with friendly banter and a job always

well done.

To his wife, Nancy, and his children, Hicky, Sally,

Jimmy and Blake, the author expresses his gratitude but his

apologies for his long periods of absence and concern with

thesis matters when he was home. Without their long

suffering devotion, the educational goals of their husband

and father would not have been realized and this thesis

written.

Page 18: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 19: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

INTRODUCTION

A. BACKGROUND

The conventional displacement vessel exhibits a well

known and documented speed limitation caused by drag

characteristics of the hull-water interface. In an effort

to effect a great increase in surface vessel speed, a

program has been initiated by the United States Navy to

develop various craft whose principal means of support is

other than hydrostatic lift.

One such type of craft currently receiving attention is

the Surface Effect Ship (SES) . There are basically two

types of ships in this category, the Air Cushion Vehicles,

or hovercraft, and the Captured Air Bubble (CAB) craft. The

general nature of these craft and their construction is well

presented by Robert L. Trillo in Reference 1. Either all or

a major portion of the craft support is obtained from a

pressure differential between the atmosphere and a plenum

chamber which is open at the bottom. The great speed

advantages of the SES are from two principal

characteristics: (1) energy is not wasted by displacing a

large volume of water, and (2) the frictional forces at the

hull-water interface are greatly reduced by keeping the

structure actually in water contact to a minumum.

Surface Effects Ships are generally categorized as "Air

Cushion Vehicles" whose weight is entirely supported by the

pressure differential in the plenum chamber or "Captured Air

Page 20: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 21: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

Bubble Craft" whose weight is partially supported by a

sidewall structure which extends into the water. For United

States Navy applications, the Captured Air Bubble (CAB)

craft is being researched.

The term Captured Air Bubble is slightly misleading

since the plenum chamber air does leak out and thus must be

continuously replenished by supply fans. When compared to

the air cushion vehicle, however, this leakage rate is

relatively small. The Air Cushion Vehicle has a continuous

gap around its entire periphery, whereas the Captured Air

Bubble craft has leakage only from the stern seal, thus the

plenum chamber supply fans of the Air Cushion Vehicle must

be much larger and more powerful than those of the CAB of

similar size.

This thesis is concerned with simulation studies of the

Captured Air Bubble craft utilizing a digital computer,

specifically the Loads and Motions Program developed by

Oceanics, Incorporated.

The basic rigid body analysis and spatial relationships

of the Loads and Motions Program are well documented in

Reference 2, and thus will not be duplicated here. The

principal static and dynamic approximations used in

developing the equations of motion for the craft in its six

degrees of freedom are also covered.

The Loads and Motions Program has been converted to

represent the Naval Postgraduate School's SES test craft,

the XR-^3. All simulation studies for this thesis were

accomplished utilizing the XR-3 Loads and Motions simulation

program.

10

Page 22: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 23: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

OBJECTIVES

The purpose of this thesis is to take a detailed look

into the aspects of power minimization at various cruising

speeds in both calm water and sea state conditions. Pitch

angle was utilized to reduce hull drag effects and introduce

planing action, while lift fan speed was varied to control

the air cushion bubble pressure, and thus the draft of the

craft. The results are presented in both tabular and

graphical form. The results are also shown in the form of

recommended operating profiles.

11

Page 24: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 25: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

II. GENERAL DISCUSSION

A. INTRODUCTION

Previous studies indicate that significant performance

benefits can be obtained by controlling the pressure of the

air bubble which supports the craft. It is clear that low

bubble pressures would require large thrust values to

maintain a given speed primarily because of the greater

wetted surface at the hull-water interface causing increased

drag forces. If the bubble pressure is increased, the draft

decreases and it is expected that the thrust required to

maintain that speed to decrease, but at the same time the

fan power required to support the craft will increase.

Intuitively, one expects that the total power (Thrust Power

Fan Power) will reach a minumum at some operating point.

It is the purpose of this thesis to investigate and

determine that operating point.

Additionally, it is found that the thrust power required

varied as a function of the pitch angle of the craft. One

might now ask the following questions:

1. Is there a global minimum to be found?

2. Does a change in fan power have a significant effect on

total power?

3. Is the pitch angle a significant factor in controlling

thrust power?

12

Page 26: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 27: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

All studies were initially conducted for calm water

conditions^ Six different speeds in the cruising range of

fifteen to thirty knots were studied extensively. Nine

plenum bubble pressures were utilized at each speed to

obtain a family of curves for analysis. After the calm

water simulations were complete, the XR-3 craft was operated

in calm water to verify the trends found in the computer

simulation. Additionally, two speeds were chosen, eighteen

and twenty-seven knots, for sea state simulation studies.

Three plenum pressures were utilized to check for

correlation between calm water and sea state operation and

to generate a set of curves for comparison.

B. SIMULATION METHODS

Simulation was achieved by utilizing the existing six

degree of freedom simulation model program for the 100-B

surface effects ship as modified for the XR-3 craft. This

program has undergone exhaustive analysis at the Naval

Postgraduate School to determine its accuracy in predicting

craft behavior and it is felt to be adeguate for this study

(References 3, 4 and 5) . The basic program was modified

slightly to obtain the output of data necessary for the

completion of this study. The constant input parameters

were also changed to reflect recent modifications to the

craft seals and appendages.

The actual weight distribution of the XR-3 craft is not

presently known exactly, so an approximation was determined

by an iterative method. By a simulation program, several

masses were moved about the craft until the same magnitude

of moments about the X, I and Z axes were obtained as had

been utilized in previous studies of the craft. This was

initially accomplished with the craft at the present loaded

13

Page 28: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 29: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

weight of 5900 pounds.

Two additional masses totaling one thousand pounds were

added along the centerline, one fore and one aft of the

center of gravity. These masses constituted the control to

attain a spectrum of pitch angles to be utilized in the

simulation study. This is essentially equivalent to the

method used when verifying the simulation results on the

actual craft test runs. Ballast was shifted (in the form of

warm bodies) to obtain the spectrum of pitch angles for

verification of simulation results.

The bubble pressure in the XR-3 cannot be easily

controlled, indeed it cannot be controlled at all. The

plenum pressure can be reduced slightly by securing one or

more lift supply engines, but a significant range of plenum

pressures cannot be obtained. The lift fans operate at

maximum speed at all times and the pressure obtained is

approximately twenty-four pounds per square foot. Thus,

only the middle pressure, twenty-four pounds per square foot

could be verified. In the simulation, the bubble pressure

was varied by changing the plenum supply fan speed. By this

method, the actual power required to support the craft could

easily be calculated.

On each simulation run, the speed of the craft was held

constant and the thrust was allowed to vary to maintain the

desired speed. The thrust was then utilized to calculate

the thrust power in horsepower delivered. Additionally, for

each run at a specific speed and bubble pressure, the pitch

angle was varied by moving the masses along the longitudinal

centerline and allowing the craft to attain a steady-state

condition. The various data were then recorded for analysis

and a next set of conditions was used to initiate a

subsequent run, repeating the process.

14

Page 30: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 31: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

In all cases, the simulation and actual craft operation

was conducted above the transition speed, that is, the speed

above which the craft acts as a Surface Effect Ship vice a

displacement type vessel.

15

Page 32: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 33: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

III. CALM' WATER STUDIES

A. OBJECTIVES

The purpose of the calm water studies was to determine a

data base to observe the general trends of the craft.

Without sea state, the attainment of a steady-state pitch

angle and operation could easily be obtained. This data is

presented as Appendix A.

At each speed a family of curves was developed, each

curve representing a new bubble pressure. Composites of all

speeds are also presented, each taken at constant pitch

angle and allowed to vary with bubble pressure. In each

case, Total Power is the dependent variable.

B. SIMULATION PERFORMANCE

As can be seen in Figures 1 through 7, the total power

(Thrust Power + Fan Power) reaches a minimum, or approaches

a minimum, at each bubble pressure. The change in total

power is relatively small at the lower cruising speed of

fifteen knots, but is drastically reduced at the higher

cruising speed of thirty knots.

In Figures 1 through 7, the ordinate is the Total Power

expressed in actual horsepower delivered and the abcissa is

Pitch Angle in degrees. At fifteen knots the curves tended

16

Page 34: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 35: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

to overlap, therefore, for clarity, Figures 1 and 2 display

data for this speed. In some cases, also, a minimum power

could not be achieved. This is primarily at the higher

pitch angles where water contact with the top of the plenum

chamber occured, rendering these data inaccurate. At higher

bubble pressures, the draft of the craft was quite small and

relatively large pitch angles resulted in venting of the

plenum to atmosphere. Again, these data were considered to

be non-representative and were not included in the analysis.

The minimum power pitch angle at each speed is seen to

move toward lower values as the bubble pressure is

increased. This is felt to be a reasonable result in that

the planing angle of the craft should be reached with a

smaller angle as the draft decreases.

At the higher plenum chamber pressures an interesting

and, at first glance, a somewhat unexpected phenomenon

occurs. The slopes of the curves reverse and a local

maximum thrust condition appears to exist. This is

accounted for by the shallow draft of the craft and the fact

that so little of the sidewall is actually in the water

(draft is about six inches at twenty-nine pounds per square

foot) . The craft, in this condition of operation, is

approaching the behavior of an Air Cushion Vehicle. If the

seals were large enough and stiff enough, eventually the

craft would be completely above the water. With the

flexible seal construction of the Captured Air Bubble craft,

this condition is not possible. As the craft is pitched

either way, the drag forces are decreased. In other words,

the wetted area decreases on either side of an operating

condition which corresponds to maximum wetted sidewall

surface. This action is noted at all operating speeds.

17

Page 36: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 37: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

X

M

*" iv 3::

Figure 1 - TOTAL POWER VS PITCH ANGLE, 15.0 KNOTS

Curve Index: Plenum Pressure in PSF

X-Scale: 1.0 Deg/inch

T-Scale: 0.5 HP/inch, Add: 20.0 HP to all values

18

Page 38: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 39: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

-rryt\J2

Figure 2 - TOTAL POWER VS PITCH ANGLE, 15.0 KNOTS

Curve Index: Plenum Pressure in PSF

X-Scale: 1.0 Deg/inch

Y-Scale: 0.5 HP/inch, Add: 20.0 HP to all values

19

Page 40: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 41: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

nc; 2:5 gin „: 022 125

Figure 3 - TOTAL POWER VS PITCH ANGLE, 18.0 KNOTS

Curve Index: Plenum Pressure in PSF

X-Scale: 0.5 Deg/inch

Y-Scale: 1.0 HP/inch, Add 23.0 HP to all values

20

Page 42: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 43: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

X

:<

rs no: m aoj

Figure 4 - TOTAL POWER VS PITCH ANGLE, 22.0 KNOTS

Curve Index: Plenum Pressure in PSF

X-Scale: 1.0 Deg/inch

I-Scale: 5.0 HP/inch, Add 25.0 HP to all values

21

Page 44: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 45: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

331 ica y.z 03J

Figure 5 - TOTAL POWER VS PITCH ANGLE, 25.0 KNOTS

Curve Index: Plenum Pressure in PSF

X-Scale: 1.0 Deg/inch

Y-Scale: 5.0 HP/inch, Add 25.0 HP to all values

22

Page 46: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 47: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

Figure 6 - TOTAL POWER VS PITCH ANGLE, 27.5 KNOTS

Curve Index: Plenum Pressure in PSF

X-Scale: 0.5 Deg/inch

Y-Scale: 5.0 HP/inch, Add 45.0 HP to all values

23

Page 48: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 49: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

X•jj_ 0*2 :,z i:-: as:

Figure 7 - TOTAL POWER VS PITCH ANGLE, 30.0 KNOTS

Curve Index: Plenum Pressure in PSF

X-Scale: 1.0 Deg/inch

I-Scale: 10.0 HP/inch, Add 50.0 HP to all values

24

Page 50: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 51: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

Figures 8 through 28 display Total Power as a function

of Plenum Pressure at the various cruising speeds. Each

graph represents a slice at constant pitch angle obtained by

linear interpolation of the existing data. This displays at

each probable operating pitch angle the most efficient air

plenum pressure. At the higher speeds, the most efficient

operating plenum pressures are those in the higher range.

The higher pressures result in lower hydrodynamic drag from

a reduction in the sidewall- water interface contact. Since

each curve is shown at a different pitch angle, planing

action is observed to have a significant effect on total

power above one degree pitch angle at speeds greater than

twenty-two knots. At fifteen knots, the lowest total power

is at approximately twenty-six pounds per square foot plenum

pressure (compare Figures 2 and 12). The slight increase in

total power at fifteen knots and large plenum pressures is

caused by the fan power being approximately fifteen percent

of the total power.

Again, minima can be seen to exist at each speed. The

usefulness of this is explained in a later portion when a

recommended operating profile is presented.

From the calm water studies, it can be seen that as the

speed is increased to the higher cruising range,

optimization is achieved by increasing the bubble pressure

to the highest possible value, particularly with craft pitch

angles above one degree (a very common operating point is

one to two degrees)

.

At fifteen knots and below, the operating bubble

pressure must be chosen very carefully at all pitch angles

considered. Even at this low speed, proper choice of plenum

pressure based on the steady-state pitch angle can result in

a savings in power required of over six percent.

25

Page 52: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 53: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

Once the spectrum of calm water runs over the range of

pitch angles was completed, test runs were simulated for

each speed at each plenum pressure to obtain the natural

steady-state condition of the craft. This was accomplished

by utilizing the moments for the X, Y and Z axes that have

been verified by previous studies of the XR-3 at the Naval

Postgraduate School. The simulations were conducted under

calm water conditions. At each speed, the lift supply fan

speed was changed to yield the pressures utilized in the

previous calm water simulations and the craft allowed to

reach steady-state pitch angle and thrust. These results

are shown graphically as Figure 29 for each bubble pressure.

At the lower plenum pressures, the pitch angle does not vary

significantly (0.4 degree) as the total power, and thus the

speed of the craft, is increased. As the plenum pressure,

however, is increased to the higher portion of the range,

the steady-state pitch angle changes nearly 1.5 degrees as

the total power is increased. Figure 29 also shows that the

pitch angle and plenum pressure are essentially independent,

especially at the lower range of pressures.

Figure 30 displays the same information at each speed.

Note the considerable reduction in total power required to

maintain a given speed as the plenum chamber pressure is

increased from nineteen to twenty-nine pounds per square

foot. From this graph, a one-third reduction in total power

is realized along the thirty knot curve, where increasing

plenum pressure allows total power to decrease from 85.44 to

56.52 horsepower. The power required to increase the

pressure is only 1.61 horsepower.

C. EXPERIMENTAL VERIFICATION TESTS

Verification tests were conducted on the XR-3 craft

26

Page 54: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 55: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

under calm water conditions. The total weight of the craft

and ballast was 6 895 pounds. The ballast was shifted along

the longitudinal centerline to obtain a spectrum of pitch

angles for comparison with the simulation results. The

tests were conducted at fifteen, eighteen and twenty-two

knots, constant speed. With the craft loaded this heavily,

higher speeds could not be obtained. Only one air plenum

pressure could be consistently obtained with the present

configuration of the lift fan system. Figure 31 shows all

three speeds at twenty-four pounds per square foot bubble

pressure for the simulated and actual test runs for

comparison. The same trends exist for both situations at

each speed, thus producing the confidence in the simulation

results to carry out the remainder of this study.

27

Page 56: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 57: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

s

Bo

s3

18

a:: j:i 03« 036 sea ojo

Figure 8 - TOTAL POWER VS PLENUM PRESSURE, 0.5 DEGREES

Curve Index: Speed in Knots

X-Scale: 2.0 PSF/inch, Add 18.0 PSF to all values

Y-Scale: 10.0 HP/inch, Add 20.0 HP to all values

28

Page 58: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 59: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

oa

no

too

a

7.5

os: 2C2 ac<{ 025 013

Figure 9 - TOTAL POWER VS PLENUM PRESSURE, 0.6 DEGREES

Curve Index: Speed in Knots

X-Scale: 2.0 PSF/inca, Add 18.0 PSF to all values

Y-Scale: 10.0 HP/inch, Add 20.0 HP to all values

29

Page 60: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 61: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

I

inD

§

aa

§

7.5

_ J5

30: J32 33-J 306 oca 010

Figure 10 - TOTAL POMES VS PLENUM PRESSURE, 0.7 DEGREES

Curve Index: Speed in Knots

X-Scale: 2.0 PSF/inch, Add 18.0 PSF to all values

I-Scale: 10.0 HP/inch, Add 20.0 HP to all values

30

Page 62: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 63: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

Oo

na

7.5

.15

CC2 024 035 010

Figure 11 - TOTAL POWER VS PLENUM PRESSURE, 0.8 DEGREES

Curve Index: Speed in Knots

X-Scale: 2.0 PSF/inch, Add 18.0 PSF to all values

Y-Scale: 10.0 HP/inch, Add 20.0 HP to all values

31

Page 64: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 65: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

B

Jul 3:.; ?:s ssa 013

Figure 12 - TOTAL POWER VS PLENUM PRESSURE, 0.9 DEGREES

Curve Index: Speed in Knots

X-Scale: 2.0 PSF/inch, Add 18.0 PSF to all values

T-Scale: 10.0 HP/inch, Add 20.0 HP to all values

32

Page 66: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 67: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

oa

3a

IS

a

o

2a

7-5

caoCjC :c2 0G4 DCS OjO

Figure 13 - TOTAL POWER VS PLENUM PRESSURE, 1.0 DEGREES

Curve Index: Speed in Knots

X-Scale: 2.0 PSF/inch r Add 18.0 PSF to all values

Y-Scale: 10.0 HP/inch, Add 20.0 HP to all values

19

15

33

Page 68: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 69: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

s

3

jg

3

15

a:: aci 02.; 336 sea oio

Figure 14 - TOTAL POWER VS PLENUM PRESSURE, 1.1 DEGREES

Curve Index: Speed in Knots

X-Scale: 2.0 PSF/inch, Add 18.0 PSF to all values

Y-Scale: 10.0 HP/inch, Add 20.0 HP to all values

34

Page 70: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 71: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

oa

a

o

7-5

oaa

2Q1 3Q4 0G5 0.1 a

Figure 15 - TOTAL POWER VS PLENUM PRESSURE, 1.2 DEGREES

Curve Index: Speed in Knots

X-Scale: 2.0 PSF/inch, Add 18.0 PSF to all values

Y-Scale: 10.0 HP/inch, Add 20.0 HP to all values

15

35

Page 72: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 73: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

A.

a

a

i

a

3

D

15

asi 3d-, 03€ 013

Figure 16 - TOTAL POWER VS PLENUM PRESSURE, 1.3 DEGREES

Curve Index: Speed in Knots

X-Scale: 2.0 PSF/inch, Add 18.0 PSF to all values

Y-Scale: 10.0 HP/inch, Add 20.0 HP to all values

36

Page 74: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 75: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

oa

IBna

oo

aa

aa

7-5

aa

15

- w <- QG4 QG5 c:3 aia

Figure 17 - TOTAL POHER VS PLENUM PRESSURE, 1.4 DEGREES

Curve Index: Speed in Knots

X-Scale: 2.0 PSF/inch, Add 18.0 PSF to all values

Y-Scale: 10.0 HP/inch, Add 20.0 HP to all values

37

Page 76: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 77: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

a

as

S3

B

y

15

33: 332 334 335 33(1 313

Figure 18 - TOTAL POWER VS PLENUM PRESSURE, 1.5 DEGREES

Curve Index: Speed in Knots

X-Scale: 2.0 PSF/inch, Add 18.0 PSF to all values

Y-Scale: 10.0 HP/inch, Add 20.0 HP to all values

38

Page 78: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 79: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

inaa

ao

a

7.5

.15

QCC JC2 3G^- QQ5 0Q9 8:0

Figure 19 - TOTAL POHER VS PLENUM PRESSURE, 1.6 DEGREES

Curve Index: Speed in Knots

X-Scale: 2.0 PSF/inch, Add 18.0 PSF to all values

Y-Scale: 10.0 HP/inch, Add 20.0 HP to all values

39

Page 80: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 81: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

a

Ba

j:i ::•. ao« oia

Figure 20 - TOTAL POWER VS PLENUM PRESSURE, 1.7 DEGREES

Curve Index: Speed in KnotsX-Scale: 2.0 PSF/inch, Add 18.0 PSF to all valuesT-Scale: 10.0 HP/inch, Add 20.0 HP to all values

15

40

Page 82: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 83: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

Oa

ID

a

oa

ga

7-5

.15

03C JC2 3C4 005 208 fliO

Figure 21 - TOTAL POWER VS PLENUM PRESSURE, 1.8 DEGREES

Curve Index: Speed in Knots

X-Scale: 2.0 PSF/inch, Add 18.0 PSF to all values

Y-Scale: 10.0 HP/inch, Add 20.0 HP to all values

41

Page 84: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 85: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

LD3a

3

i

15

333 J32 034 336 ZZi 3i3

Figure 22 - TOTAL POWER VS PLENUM PRESSURE, 1.9 DEGREES

Curve Index: Speed in Knots

X-Scale: 2.0 PSF/inch, Add 18.0 PSF to all values

Y-Scale: 10.0 HP/inch, Add 20.0 HP to all values

42

Page 86: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 87: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

b

U3

7-3

oc: J£2 004 qob naa €10

Figure 23 - TOTAL POWER VS PLENUM PRESSURE, 2.0 DEGREES

Curve Index: Speed in Knots

X-Scale: 2.0 PSF/inch, Add 18.0 PSF to all values

Y-Scale: 10.0 HP/inch, Add 20.0 HP to all values

43

Page 88: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 89: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

IVo5

13

a

X

15

a2Z 3Z2 024, 036 3C6 313

Figure 24 - TOTAL POWER VS PLENUM PRESSURE, 2.1 DEGREES

Curve Index: Speed in Knots

X-Scale: 2.0 PSF/inch, Add 18.0 PSF to all valuesY-Scale: 10.0 HP/inch, Add 20.0 HP to all values

44

Page 90: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 91: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

IV.

C3

K

15

000 JC2 304 005 303 fl:0

Figure 25 - TOTAL POWER VS PLENUM PRESSURE, 2.2 DEGREES

Curve Index: Speed in Knots

X-Scale: 2.0 PSF/inch, Add 18.0 PSF to all values

Y-Scale: 10.0 HP/inch, Add 20.0 HP to all values

45

Page 92: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 93: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

33 .

X

_ 15

033 J32 034 036 333 310

Figure 26 - TOTAL POWER VS PLENUM PRESSURE, 2.3 DEGREES

Curve Index: Speed in Knots

X-Scale: 2.0 PSF/inch, Add 18.0 PSF to all values

Y-Scale: 10.0 HP/inch, Add 20.0 HP to all values

46

Page 94: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 95: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

Cl

K

15

ZOC 0C2 004 OjS 0C9 010

Figure 27 - TOTAL POWER VS PLENUM PRESSURE, 2.4 DEGREES

Curve Index: Speed in Knots

X-Scale: 2.0 PSF/inch, Add 18.0 PSF to all values

T-Scale: 10.0 HP/inch r Add 20.0 HP to all values

47

Page 96: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 97: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

Kaa

h

a

x

15

QZZ 2Z2 Oa-j 326 3C3 013

Figure 28 - TOTAL POWER VS PLENUM PRESSURE, 2.5 DEGREES

Curve Index: Speed in Knots

X-Scale: 2.0 PSF/inch r Add 18.0 PSF to all values

I-Scale: 10.0 HP/inch, Add 20.0 HP to all values

48

Page 98: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 99: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

g

1

n.JE5

9

d

X

x3C2 221 "32. JZJ 320 003

Figure 29 - TOT PWR VS PITCH ANGLE, NATURAL RESPONSE

Curve Index: Plenum Pressure in PSF

X-Scale: 1.0 Deg/inch.

I-Scale: 10.0 HP/inch, Add 30.0 HP to all values

49

Page 100: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 101: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

aa

22. J

L2-3

15. fl

iJE~

~i :ux TT: 57Z

Figure 30 - TOT PWR 7S PITCH ANGLE, NATURAL RESPONSE

Curve Index: Speed in Knots

X-Scale: 1.0 Deg/inch, Add 1.0 Deg to all values

Y-Scale: 10.0 HP/inch, Add 20.0 HP to all values

50

Page 102: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 103: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

•1na

n24

2-1

21

X

321"~

7Z2 J-J 33J 0:J

Figure 31 - TOT PWR VS PITCH ANG, ACTUAL CRAFT

Curve Index: Speed in Knots

X-Scale: 1.0 Deg/inch

Y-Scale: 10.0 HP/inch

51

Page 104: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 105: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

IV. SEA STATE STUDIES

A. OBJECTIVES

Once the calm water studies were completed, sea state

was introduced into the Loads and Motions Program for the

XR-3 to continue the study. The sea state simulation

studies were conducted at two speeds, one at 27.5 knots, the

other at 18.0 knots. Because of a nearly sixty to one

computation time to real simulation time ratio, an

exhaustive study was prohibitive. General trends with

representative sea state introduced was desirable to be

compared with the calm water simulation runs.

B. SIMULATION PERFORMANCE

The introduction of sea state was accomplished by using

a single wave component with frequency 0.7662 radians per

second and height of one foot peak-to- peak. A single

component sea state such as this is termed a regular sea,

which was chosen to obtain reasonable computational times.

Regular seas were also selected to allow somewhat easier

data reduction. The data was smoothed to obtain an average

value of each parameter and this average value was utilized

as the steady-state value.

52

Page 106: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 107: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

X

2Jii_

3d'. 11* 111 025

Figure 32 - TOTAL PWR VS PITCH ANGLE, 18 KNOTS, SEA STATE

Curve Index: Plenum Pressure in PSF

X-Scale: 0.5 Deg/inch

Y-Scale: 5.0 HP/inch, Add 25.0 HP to all values

53

Page 108: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 109: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

K

cna

3-u :. 1L2 121 125

Figure 33 - TOTAL PWR 7S PITCH ANGLE, 27.5 KNOTS, SEA STATE

Curve Index: Plenum Pressure in PSF

X-Scale: 0.5 Deg/inch

T-Scale: 5.0 HP/inch, Add 45.0 HP to all values

54

Page 110: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 111: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

To obtain a spectrum of pitch angles, the same procedure

of shifting masses along the longitudinal centerline was

used as in the calm water study. The total weight of the

craft in the simulation remained unchanged.

Although not as detailed, Figures 32 and 33 display the

same general trends as found in the calm water studies. As

plenum pressure is increased, the resultant total power

required to maintain the desired speed decreases. The total

power at each bubble pressure is seen to increase over the

same calm water condition. The plenum pressures for the sea

state data are shown on the left side of each curve and

marked with SS and the calm water plenum pressures are at

the right side designated with CW. In all cases, the total

power is slightly greater (4 to 6 percent) for the sea state

tests. This is an expected and reasonable phenomenon. The

wetted sidewall surface is now irregular causing an increase

in average thrust power required to maintain the specified

speed. The average fan power is also seen to increase in an

attempt to maintain the bubble pressure constant.

The operational pitch angles are much more restricted

than in the calm water simulations. With one foot waves,

venting of the plenum or water contact with the plenum top

occurs much more readily at the plenum pressure extremes.

Bubble Pressures below twenty-one pounds per square foot

allowed frequent contact with the air plenum top surface and

at the higher bubble pressure (above twenty-seven pounds per

square foot) excessive venting occurred at Pitch Angles

above 2.5 degrees and below 0.3 degrees.

For the purposes of this study, three plenum pressures

were utilized: 23, 26 and 27 pounds per square foot. This

choice of pressures allowed representative trends to be

observed without plenum chamber water contact or excessive

55

Page 112: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 113: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

plenum venting. A comparison is made of the calm water and

sea state simulations. Figures 32 and 33 display the

slightly higher total power necessary to operate the craft

in a sea state condition, the increase in power being

approximately six percent over the total range of pitch

angles used. From this comparison, it is concluded that the

craft, in sea state conditions, operates in much the same

manner as in calm water, therefore, all further analysis is

conducted for calm water conditions. All conclusions and

recommendations will be equally applicable to sea state

operation.

56

Page 114: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 115: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

7. RESULTS

Most data has been presented in the sections devoted to

each specific type of simulation condition conducted. To

test for a global minimum, air plenum pressure was plotted

against pitch angle with total power held constant. If a

global minimum is to exist as a function of the two control

variables, one would expect somewhat concentric circles or

concentric contours at each constant total power point.

The sketches presented as Figure 34 represent the global

minimum expected at each speed. The contours of sketch A

represent lines of constant total power on a plot of Plenum

Pressure versus Pitch Angle. As the optimum operating point

is approached (movement toward the central contour) , the

range of plenum chamber pressures and pitch angles become

more restricted. Sketch B of Figure 34 is a view

perpendicular to the dashed line shown on sketch A. It

represents the profile of total power based on chosen values

of plenum pressure and pitch angle along that dashed line

and displays the actual minimum power point.

From the data produced in the simulations, only fifteen

knots speed can be analyzed in this fashion. At all other

speeds, the bubble pressures chosen for analysis were too

far apart and did not produce a sufficient number of points

at each constant power level to produce a graph. Figure 35

represents the graph of Air Plenum Pressure versus Pitch

Angle for fifteen knots. Curves A through I indicate plenum

pressures of 19, 20, 21, 23, 24, 26, 27, 28 and 29

respectively. As shown by the flatness of these curves,

bubble pressure is nearly independent of pitch angle over

57

Page 116: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 117: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

the operational range of pitch angles chosen for this study.

This is, of course, a desirable feature as these are the two

control variables. Also shown are contours of constant

total power. These are in the range of 21.2 to 21.8

horsepower. The solid portion of the contours represent the

actual data while the dotted portion is extrapolated. The

data for the contours was obtained by linear interpolation

of the calm water data at constant total power. From Figures

1 and 2 we would expect two different pitch angles to yield

the same total power at several of the plenum pressures,

which produces the contours shown. For fifteen knots.

Figure 35 displays a global minimum at 1.7 degrees pitch

angle and 24.1 pounds per square foot plenum pressure, as

determined from Figures 1 and 2. The minimum power point,

and thus the point of greatest efficiency, is determined

graphically to be approximately 20.9 horsepower.

Based on the similarity of results between the calm

water simulations and the simulations after the introduction

of sea state, a similiar global minimum should be obtained

under sea state conditions. It is expected that the global

minimum would occur at a slightly higher total power than

that of similar operation in calm water, however it would

occur at essentially the same pitch angle and plenum

pressure

.

58

Page 118: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 119: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

Figure 34 - SKETCHES OF THE GLOBAL MINIMUM CONDITIONA - Sketch of Bubble Pressure vs Pitch Angle

B - Section Along Dashed Line in (A)

59

Page 120: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 121: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

13Z 3SE 013 213 '*23 D25

Figure 35 - BOBBLE PRESSURE VS PITCH ANGLE, 15 KNOTS

Contours: Total Power in HP

X-Scale: 0.5 Deg/inch, Add 0.5 Deg to all values

I-Scale: 2.0 PSF/inch, Add 18.0 PSF to all values

60

Page 122: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 123: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

71. CONCLUSIONS

A. SUMMATION

At each speed an optimum operating point exists where

efficiency can be maximized. This increase in efficiency

(up to forty percent is possible) can result in a

considerable savings in operating costs, or, possibly more

importantly in a military application, extend tha operating

range of the craft. For example, at thirty knots and a

craft pitch angle of 1.5 degrees, simply increasing the

plenum pressure from nineteen to twenty-nine pounds per

square foot results in the indicated savings of forty

percent in total power required for operation of the XR-3.

This is shown in Figure 36. The high speed capabilities of

this type of craft have been previously demonstrated, and it

is concluded from this study that optimization can be

achieved over the full range of cruising speeds, but most

significantly at the higher speeds.

In general, the power required to support the craft is

relatively independent of the forward speed thrust power at

all speeds. The data of Appendix A demonstrates this very

well. Under the columa heading FAN PWR, the actual power

required to supply the necessary lift pressure is seen to be

nearly constant over the entire speed range at each bubble

pressure. Note also that the fan power does not change as

the craft speed or pitch angle changes, only when the plenum

pressure is altered. Therefore, it is prudent to increase

the lift fan power supplying the plenum pressure at higher

61

Page 124: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 125: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

speeds to effect a decrease in dra^j forces. At the lower

cruising speeds, lift fan power becomes a significant factor

(approximately fifteen percent) of total power, and thus the

bubble pressure must be chosen carefully based on the pitch

angle to obtain optimal operation and power efficiency. The

pitch angle and bubble pressure must be utilized in harmony

to achieve this optimization.

The pitch angle of the craft is also seen to be a

significant factor in power optimization. From Figure 36,

for example, operation of the craft at twenty-four pounds

per square foot pressure and 1.1 degrees pitch angle

requires only 70.1 horsepower. At all other pitch angles,

the required power increases. A savings of six percent,

under these conditions, can be realized if the optimal pitch

angle is utilized.

B. METHOD OF CONTROL

Operator control of both pitch angle and plenum pressure

is certainly a realizable method of obtaining optimal

operation of the craft. It would, however, require a

complete set of information on every possible combination of

operational attitudes of the craft. Although it could be

stored as a set of operational profiles in a digital

computer to be recalled at the will of the operator, this is

prohibitive because of the computational time required to

obtain such a wide range of data. Additionally, no two

craft operate exactly the same, each having its own

peculiarities. It is concievable that a separate set of

profiles would have to be produced for each ship in the

class.

Automatic control of both pitch angle and air plenum

62

Page 126: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 127: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

pressure is also a possibility. The physical method of

controlling these two variables will not be considered here,

but the demonstrated optimization could be achieved with a

minimum power seeking control system. It is envisioned to be

a system with input parameters, in addition to the attitude

of the craft, of thrust power and fan power. At a given

total power level, the pitch angle of the craft could be

perturbed slightly by the control system. If this

disturbance resulted in a reduction in total power, the

perturbation would continue until a further disturbance

resulted in a power increase. A similar set of perturbations

would then be introduced into the plenum pressure system

and, again, power minimization sought. Once the minimum

power point, and thus the optimal operating point, is

attained, this two parameter control system would maintain

optimization throughout craft operation.

63

Page 128: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 129: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

3QC 002

«30* OCi

Figure 36 - TOTAL POWER VS PITCH ANGLE, 30 KNOTSCurve Index: Plenum Pressure in PSF

X-Scale: 1.0 Deg/inchY-Scale: 10.0 HP/inch, Add 50.0 HP to all values

64

Page 130: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 131: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

VII. OPERATIONAL CONSIDERATIONS

At the present time, pitch control is not incorporated

into any of the Captured Air Bubble Test Vehicles. This

includes both the three ton and the one hundred ton models.

Until such time as pitch control is made available, it is

recommended that the plenum pressure be adjusted once the

steady-state pitch angle is achieved at the desired cruising

speed.

Figure 37 is presented as the Optimum Operating Profile.

Again, Total Power is plotted aginst Pitch Angle and two

speeds, eighteen and twenty-seven knots are shown for

comparison. Only calm water data are presented since they

are representative of the sea state conditions as well.

Several cases are considered and the use of this information

is presented below:

1. Consider the case of non-optimal initial conditions.

The craft is operating at 27.5 knots, 26 PSF air plenum

pressure. The natural pitch angle of the craft is 2.25

degrees (Point A) . To optimize under these comditions,

the pitch angle should be changed to 0.7 degrees

requiring 3. 75 horsepower less than the original

condition. This is shown as Point B. To optimize

still further, the air plenum pressure should be

increased to 29 PSF (Point C) reducing the power

required to maintain 27.5 knots by an additional 6.9

horsepower. If optimization is continued, the pitch

angle should be altered to arrive at Point D, resulting

in a total reduction in required power of 13.5

horsepower, or twenty-five percent.

65

Page 132: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 133: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

2. While operating at Point D, it is desired to change

speed to eighteen knots. Thrust power is reduced to

allow the craft speed to decrease to eighteen knots

while maintaining 2.0 degrees pitch angle, and the

craft is at an optimal power level (Point E) . Note,

however, that the craft could also operate at Point F,

with a pitch angle of 0.4 degrees and still remain at

the optimal power level. This would be operator

choice, and might be considered for reasons of crew

preference or equipment operation.

3. Assuming pitch control is not available (as is the

present situation), at 18.0 knots and 29 PSF plenum

pressure, the natural pitch angle is 1.9 degrees, or

essentially the optimal pitch angle (Point E) . If the

speed were increased to 27.5 knots with the plenum

pressure unchanged, the craft would naturally assume a

1.0 degree attitude (Point G) which is very near the

maximum power level for this plenum pressure. It has

been noted in both simulation and actual craft

operation that the craft does not necessarily assume

the optimal attitude. In actual operation, for the

given power level, the craft could have just as easily

settled at Point C. The perturbations during the

transition control this phenomonon and it is mentioned

purely because it does exist in craft operation.

Two specific speeds were utilized for these examples,

but any combination of speed and/or air plenum pressure

changes can be studied in similar fashion by use of Figures

1 through 7 in the same manner as Figure 37. Since pitch

control is not available, one must use whatever pitch angle

is assumed by the craft and optimize operation by altering

the plenum chamber pressure accordingly.

If pitch angle and plenum chamber pressure control were

66

Page 134: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 135: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

both available, the constant power contours of Figure 38

could be used to determine the point of optimal operation.

Figure 38 is for fifteen knots, but, as explained earlier,

similar results exist at all speeds. At fifteen knots, the

operating profile (Figure 38) would require choices of

bubble pressure and pitch angle to reach the center contour.

This could be accomplished either by operator (manual)

control or an automatic controller. For this speed, the

pitch angle would be adjusted to 1.7 degrees and the air

plenum pressure to 24.1 PSF to operate the craft at minimum

total power, 20.9 horsepower. This is the optimal point of

operation at fifteen knots. The broadness of this minimum

could not be determined from the existing data, but the

trend indicates it is relatively small. Based on the

similarity of calm water and sea state studies, this minima

is not expected to broaden nor change significantly.

67

Page 136: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 137: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

Figure 37 - TOT PWR VS PTCH ANG, 18 AND 27 KNOTS

Curve Index: Plenum Pressure in PSF

X-Scale: 1.0 Deg/inch

Y-Scale: 10.0 HP/inch, Add 20.0 HP to all values

68

Page 138: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 139: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

Figure 38 - RECOMMENDED OPERATING PROFILE, 15 KNOTS

Contours: Constant Total Power in Horsepower

X-Scale: 0.5 Deg/inch, Add 0.5 Deg to all values

Y-Scale: 2.0 PSF/inch, Add 18.0 PSF to all values

69

Page 140: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 141: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

VIII. RECOMMENDATIONS

As demonstrated, control of both plenum pressure and

pitch angle are necessary to achieve power optimization.

Air plenum pressure control is incorporated into the larger,

one hundred ton models by use of variable speed lift fans.

Pitch angle control, although not presently available, could

be achieved by a ballast shifting system, possibly using

water and/or fuel tanks distributed along the sidewall

length. An alternate method would be to use additional

controllable surfaces placed below the waterline to effect

pitch control.

A major consideration which is beyond the scope of this

study is the determination of whether pitch control

introduced should be automatic or simply a set of

recommended pitch angles controlled by an averaging system

by the operator. This is left as a possible future thesis

subject.

Optimization of power can be achieved only through

judicious choice of both pitch angle and plenum chamber

pressure. The method of control may be either manual or

automatic, but the results display a considerable savings if

the Captured Air Bubble Surface Effect Ship is operated

toward this optimal goal.

70

Page 142: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 143: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

APPENDIX A

SIMULATION DATA LISTING

Appendix A is presented as the calm water data produced

by the Loads and Motions Program for the XR-3 Surface

Effects Ship. This is done to allow the reader to obtain

specific parameter values used to present the graphical

information included in the body of the text. It is also

presented because it represents considerable computation

time (nearly one hundred hours of computer time) . The data

can therefore be utilized in subsequent analysis work if

desired.

The column headings are presented at the top of each

page. Pitch angle (THETA) is in degrees, THRUST is

expressed in pounds, BUBBLE PRESSURE in pounds per square

foot, and FAN POWER, THRUST POWER and TOTAL POWER in

horsepower.

The graph titles remain in the listing to allow ease in

separation of the data as are the graphical set-up cards

separating each bubble pressure at each speed. The four

rightmost digits are for rapid identification based on speed

(the first two digits) and bubble pressure (the last two)

.

71

Page 144: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 145: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

mo On O* O* 0> On On OnO On o> On On OOOOOOOOOOOO r-*^-»r* r-*~*—t'-4r-i~*T-4-4*-<(\jf\j r-4»-<^-(i-i-j^-<^-<^«r-i^4i—ir-i cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm oj c\i cm cm f\j rvi cm cm cm r\j cminin in in in in in in in in in in in ir\ in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in

Q.

O

r-co r^-NjTvjr^^vOONf-^mcoLnphct> m>rFHo\vONrfMCT>vOf*-comcjncm (\i<>j"»*-r«-(^-a3 0NOrvjin'-*0N

C7^ r-ineni-400Ncocors-vO incn

p* cm p» vo -4- cr>o p» co <-* o»op-cn>o-4-co>rco»rp-cocoNUrom vo a>o cm >r I

s-o roo so<fcMOcocor»vOinin>j-cn.-i

oooNcnaocnininocnco^ao coom >r «r rnm r* in >r cmr*-oinocnv0cor-<cnr-p».-*o o^ p-^ in >i- ro en cm r-to—

OCMp-ICM

CM CM CM CM CM »H <—I -^ •-" i-t—i >-*

CM CMCM CM CMCM CM CM CM CM CM CMCM CM CM^ -H .-« —I —i r-l r-t ~l *-l

CM CM CMCM CM CM <NJ CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM C\J CM CM fM CM CM CM

(-0

a00X

p*-co cr--rcMvou^>T NOcnocorncj>r-»(7> a%comcnocoocnoocMcocjncm o^^-iNrin>j"m>ocoocno>NOsfin o>coNO-rcncMi-tooo>r*-vo

f*-o^CM

enco<J»<Jincnr»o—«>Tmc\i^> q\ rn »-<in cm in cm in in vO cmcm en in co o> *-* en *o on cm s inin en—• a* co co r- vO in in en cm

r-eno>r-TO^*r*rcr>mcMvOo on cm r- >om >4" -4" r- >o -4" cmvf r^ cm r-o en in coo >r in o^o* r- -o -J" -4- en cm ~*—•o cm>

OOOOOOOOOOMJ*^CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM^-H^ CMCMCMrHfH'^-^^-Hi-l^^

0nCJN0nON0nOnOnOnO*OnCOcO

oin

LU

oz.<

to oo o> ,-,ocMCM>^cM»^m\0»oco ^^f-tfMt-tr-^evj—<cMCMCMeno en cm en ^•'n en !-<»*»-* cm on-*uj oo r— cm^OnO^oO'OconOcm^ ^o ,h«-i*-*on'-ipt-itninm—«en (M-oocoooooOsTin^occ oo aooo^cMcneninmNO^op*- ^^^^fininininmtnvoen c\jr-<cMCMeMCM>-«*-^'-*i-<aooNo_ om o—•—•—ii-4.-,f*«-4^^-tr^^ co en en rn en en en en en en en en oo coco coco coco coco cor-r-

CO mO On On On On On QN On s On On On On OOOOOOOOOOOO —*i—i^—*,—ir-tr^,—i*-*r-(i—<—

i

3 CMCM ^r-l^i^^^^H-4^r-lr^^ CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CMCO /

X

OOUJ

OfloOLUUO

Oa:O-Q-

I— COacoH-3

co

_JUJCO

Oct:•~.<r

Q.

<

00

ocX

LUX

oo cooo^eMCMcn>3'>tinin>o ^N.t-*ooNvOONr-e-e— >*oo enr->*'a»-4">i-'^'^^co>oooo inxo-o^OvOvO^o^o^o^o^o^o en en en en cm cm cm cm cm cm cm en cooocor—cocoonononcoooOO CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM r-t «-* —* «^ «—I <-» »-Ii-i,h.—I —l _t CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CMmoN r^p—P—e^r—p—r-f-p-r-e'-e— &<?>& s OnonOnOnOn &(?•<?> ,-i,-4 r-i«-«i-4.^i-ii»4«-«t-»t-«i-i

eMf-H r-.»-l»^f-4»-^—4»-H^f-tp-)f-HrH .-i,-*^,-*.-*^,-),-*,-*.-*.-^,-* CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM

oo >r co -^ cm co co —too cm com .-h

OO enONP— >0^<n.—iOcmP"-Oncooo —<voOvi-oN0'-*oo>cor-ax

oo cMCMinenOr^r-KnvtONONeM

>t'C0Nj-v0CMN0eneMv0>1'0>v0o en coo r-t en on co -j- -*OMncor*cMONcvi—j^^ONcor-^j-co co coo cm .4- r- <-* vo >-< en cm

cm rn en cMr~o cmo—• vO inOon vQ -h co in -4- vj- cm '-* r— <—i vOONONONenoNvoONr«--jp-r-oen >o cm —< ino cm h- <-* r- p» <o

OvO N0CMC0vfCMOC0v0'4'CM0Nlv-

ao-4" inin-4">t>4">l"enenenencMeMin r-^ r» vt cmo co r- in vf -^ co>t >r en en en en cm cm cm cm cmh«* -nT >t -4- >j-* -J- >r -r -4- >t *4-

enONvOenF-tocovOineni—icmen CM CM CM f\l CM »-t i-( -J i-l »-< >-4

>t >r -4- sr <r vj- -*• ^- 4- <r >* <t-

~*o cmco>3" oo en cjn en en en p^ enr^ en cmin on r^ ^o en sor^ on in^ cm in cmvOrn co en en cm in r^ in >^ en^o r-if-^-4- oNoooNON->Tor*>f >—i tninenoooo'-<ONi—nn<-toNO ooNCM^jenvoeMinvooinoN

-*o -^voooor^cNjoo>Tr^coinen'^'^cM'^ooNin'-i<»^in>Tr^r^'-*cjNoo<j>rMoa30OTrgo eMinr*oeMenmr-coo»rco cMincoonj>rinp*oN-^Nrco eMinaocM»nnaooN'-^envor~

en »enrnO OOO'

CM CM

in in

> • • »en t • •

<C\|C\JCM OOO'CMf-t

in

• en<rge\jeM OOO'

>rt-i

in

(CNJCMCMCM

72

Page 146: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 147: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

^^ roromrornmrrirrim^mmrom >*• «4" >t >t >4- >*">! >i- >f «d"<4"^>t -4-

cmcm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cmmm in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in inin in in in in in in in in in in

3 coo co-O'toorvi^vO^OflCimr^fria. ocm o-oc\jvoofM(Ni>rvoao^>ror\j

mm h-in-4-cMCMr-t-^^i—i-^cmcmn**^

ao <\i o^ nto o> co -oom <j>o r* m.cMO>cMr-cMCMr— vocM>rm>rinoCM P*O O"1 CM •>? ^o s cm «* com co c*

cmcm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm

cc mr» —«in>rcM>ocor"-fMmm>of>-cr*in3 mm -o>i"c\jr,»OsOir\mo<\i.-t<\j<r)ma. cocj* "-ir-mp»«-Hmminr-ocMinocM

»-h^ m-^ocooor-r-f-r-r-cocooo

>r co r- r* rr« rvj vo >r -^ ^r in co co o^nO—• in c\j cocmam ooo cm —* *o P*^Orsl^^r^Oco^ofNO^^naotNrOcor^mLnirMno^OvO^or-r-o^o^

COX̂-

r^O O OQn CO CO CO CO 00 CO CO co co a><T> CO CO 00 00 CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO

00LU

Q.

COZ>co

e\jm ooF4HH0>rJO'-<HO'^v0if\r-*r- r-o^mmmomoNcninc^m^^—1<7> OO^—i»-«OcmOc\4'^OCM>0nJ-r^>o r-r— r»-r«-r>-r-p-r»r-r-r»r-Navo

!*»r-»oc^a^c>cooooa>'in«tf'

(Njs^vO^O^vi-vOaorocomNOCNj^o co ooo -i^ cm .-* r-t «-•m cmr—^r- r* r- co co co co oo oo oo oo oo p» r*-

cm<mmmmmmmmmmmcnmmmCM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM

>t -4" <t- -4- <T vr -t ^f 4" >4" >t sJ" <t^CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM

cc >i-m >j-cMr-r-r»'-^>rcM«4, *tcM>i-in(^"s m>o fMfM^^-trHroocMo—tcMor-a>Cl (MCM CJn 0^ s CJ> O* sO s O^ sO C> 0^ CJ*

.^—4 mmmmmmmmmmmmmm

<4" >t CM r- P- r*» CM CM&o >fr CMo »tvOP-c->tmmcMmmmr-icMoocMin in in in in in in in in in in in ininin in in in in in in in inm in inmm

<LL

CMCM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CMCM CM

IS)

3CCX

cmvO -ocMn>j--t, <3is-cn>j->j"as cM-oomm cMP-ocj^i-tcominvOinOvOO^rnp- mmr-CMn-4-cMor«-in^voinf«-p-on soin^OvOOo-tf-cMcoincocM

m^mmp-mcomcMm-^omomm p»^ co cmmoo —* inm «o cosO cm onm oo^ <^ cm in >f in cm P-—

<

oo r- ao oo en oo -4"o ino o>o^ >f

vOvo c^NOfnooop^r-r-f-oooocxMcn_i_i ^,-l,-^^oOOOOOOO>-^'-,

o>o cm cm rom >rin in vo >o co ~h —tOOOOOOOOOOOO^t-i<f *r st >*- -4* -4- nt <j- >r sr <* -4- >t >cf

o>^cMr^ooin>rin>rcninininr,»^cocMrnoaN inONOO'00>'^^HCMNOinvO<t is\^u mif|rncocM>crcoaOf-Hinr^r^o<J o^cnf^aoroNOvOOfnininr-oofnh- -4"Nf-^o>omocoNoco>rcnc7>>3- ocMcjN^^rrnnininm'-<<-rinf,n<—ir*>-i>rom r-co >i"p»-^in>oco(7>0'-»'^cr)incMCM ino>rnin>oP-r*-cocjNO—*rncr>oX »m . * . i • • (fT) • • i i • i • i •h men oo^^'H • CM CM CM CM CM"! en O0< 4 CM CM CM CM rn

in in

73

Page 148: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 149: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

csjcm cm fM fM cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm fM cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm CMCMCMCMCMcMfMCMfMCMfMfMmm mmmminminininininintnintninininininininininin in in in in in in in in in in in in

cc r*»oo cMO^»o«3'OcocMr,-inoO'-*eocM'-«cMrooHOr^'^r»o3. —«o >rco>rr*-rvj>4-inao»ro<7>a^o>3"ro>ro—<r""vi-—"CDrorriina. OfM c\jnO—'inocvicNOir»a3i-<^-ifr)ir\co—tmir\r-a*'^iir\ooocM

O-T (\j^^OOOOOOOf-*^r4r^^(\jf\|(MtM(^rrirOff|^^

Or^OinvOOCOOvOvOrOfMino ro <\i 00 p~ ao <-* <nj in r- -vo in 00o (M rnom r- on i-» >j-

sooooo .—» »-* «-• —^ cm cm

ONCNJcm cm c\i cmcm cm cm cm cm c\i cm cmcm cm cm <\j cm cm cm cm cm cm cm rj cm

OOO f-t "> 1—I .H "* «-* .-4—4 —*INI CM CM CM CM <\J CM CM CM f\l CM CM

00t—a

cc

a.

00X

r-00 Nominrn<»r*^^^c<icointni^fn>or-rq<jcoa>^r*'Cr'r-o,-<o oocncOfHO>o^vj-coooooincnrnocMooinrooro^r*-ocm ^cM>o^^in®ao^o^^rnr,-r*"QO<-t>i'r*-ON>-<cninoN '-t>)

->jyco

^m >r>rmcocMCMCMCMcncororn^>r^r>rNrinininin>OvOvO>o

HCM

m—<o <tcm >r <-r>00 it. >rmm cm f-t ^o r^o »-< -o r-o —«

o

oocM^^r— incr>»-^->rvocjNOOOOOO^—<CMCMCMCM

03a3a3(ncoaocO(X)aocDcoa3ooa3a3COoooocoaocoaocooooo cococooocoooaocooococoao

oin

111

—ioz.<Xo

00LUCCa.

CD

X03

Q.

00 ininin>i-f*-r<-sor»-f>»cor— r*-r»-oor»-ooHi-«'-HOOOO00 ooommcninrncno»H<--iH-4"r'-'-«ininooo^cM>$-fM00 oooocMHO^cnm«4->i->nn>r>*" >t in nOvO^o miningom 0000000000000000000000000

i

s-otnor^O'-4«-*'—icm^^<—1

r-r»-tnor- 1—3- cm ^- 00 cm cminoinOvOOO«-,H'—•—•<—

t

ino ininininvO^c^OvO^o^o^D^oovO^OvCOO^OsO^o-o^o 0^0CMCM CM CM <N CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CMCM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM

00 vo-o^ocovOONcoc^^p-^r^^ror^Nj-or-cMCMCMOCMoo00 inmir\sOcMrOvf mr-io000000 ooococoooooo co00 <4-«4->t>*" -tf'^-^^Nf >^>t>^^mm>trnmmmrncnroroco

r- r—

I

s-

I

s- r* r*- r* r— r*- r- r- r—

CM CM fM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM fM

cmp^cmnO—"h-vomminmin>oinvOirivOininininininLn000000000000

OOLU

Oil/)

UJOO3UJ(3cCQ.Q.

_ILU<-)1-00OODt-X

CO••

CMUJ-J

LUOO0£<XX~Oa£-<LL>

<

00Xorx

X

CM. CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM fM CM CM fM CM fM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM fMfM CM CM CMCMCMCMfMfMCMCMCMfMfNjfM

OO OOOrcicMOO<)I^OOCO>^>J-vOincMOO>a-r»rO>OrO>i-fOCMO00 ooocx)^vOOr^ror^cnf^r^r^cococMc<iooP,-(>(,oinOcMr^00 cncri<rocx)>^>toov^cMoocx5o>or^cnor->tr-<fOOcnaovOOO J-rMOCOvO'-^—^r^-CO^CMCMinOvOrn'O'^^-HOinO-^-O

CO^OOOcMOOfXIvOvOO^-OrOa0a0-^'-i(s-—HO.nin-^33—• cjoo inoo -4-om -o cm >$•

^0>roinr—cncMf-fMr^m

OnO —400^*0^ f-o^ao000 oo^h.-« cm cMroco^inin inco«r 0000000000000000000000000cOn^ •J'vJ' roc^rOc^c<lrOfOi-nrr|fOfn>J-v}-vf^"«4"-4'vl-Ni-Nj-^'^"^"

r-i _i ft cm cm cm >*m in vO <o f-000000000000coc^cnrnfnrocncorriroorirn

ho cMc^oinoounr^o>OH>o>oco^ooroocM'4- cMinofMH'4- rM><oovOcoHOOfnfMo--<o>oincnNOcovO ~OvOincM>j'>TinooincMO'Hcx)'-Hr*-OfMinfM (Moini^op->tr*Hai'TNho -Hir\ou^o^oo™OTOaoininrn"Ha3i^cncMO>rr^'HCDino).H^HOUNvOO<)>^vOfnco>TfO

fMO min>ur>»ooooH'HCMf^ff>'«J"^in»or»r«-coooo^-tfM -r^^rinin'Oooooo —«cmrn >mmo 00000000-

cm inCM

in in

TMCMCMCM 00000000<—lfH»-*f-J

CMin

74

Page 150: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 151: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

|^f«».f»»|^.|>N.|s_f««.(*»f»»fs.^,|^f»_f»_f*. CO CO CO 00 00 00 00 CO 00 CO CO CO CO 00 CO CO CO 00 CO 00 00 00 O 0> O^ <7> 0> CJ*

cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm c\!c\jr\Jc\jr\jr\i

mmininmmmtnininmininmin inminmminmmininmminmininminmminin inmininmin

is ^c>or*-cM vO<—toomr-tmr—a>omo. r~o^t-mo>^>r^oa3fsi(Mcor^o»-'

cm co co co co>r-r >*•->*• inm>4-co^co

r\jooNr^-tr«.voo^^Hm>}"vON}-oomrs-in'4"in(NJO,>vOO,

> r— cocMincovOcncooor-^inrnooooovroogooc^a^cNjaoornrocn o>rror*-focor-t->ra3—<voo3c-»>f -oocM^r-o^cM^p-r-ONrovro coo^o^'"r>»4-^_i^cvjc\jc\jmc<*ifoco^->}">r^"min^rc\j^^-t^to cMCMcoeoi-cico

cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm fM cm <N cm cm cm cm cm cmcmcmcmcmcm

ex >r%omr^>roocNjrr)C7^cr'-<omc\j3 r»in>o»-<>0'-<^o>J'^^5fr>"^coo'-Ha. --unocom^Jcor-K'nor-cni-Mmm

rncocn-4->t>r*ttfM*Mnmin<rvi"co

(,nc7»c\)f*»cjN<j>oomr-a3NOfr>c\jr«-rriNOcj*vO'^OvOO ir\ <j in or> c\i cr>

r-ir^-cof-cMvomcNjooocNjmocMCMrnr^p-OvOco i*-coincocor-cvjincT'CNir-cT^rvimoo—<fnmoO'-^»r^ooococr>'v>-TO >ocoo>"-*com(>a>C7>ooo^.^^cMeMCMCMcocococMOCjHC><3>oo aoaocoooo

00X

oo oo ao oo co co co ao ao ao oo co cd ao co r*» r*~ Is- co co oo oo co ao oo cd oo oo oo ao co co co r- C- r*- r*- p"-r"— f^f'-r^-r*-

00UJccQ.

CO

CO

r\jc\iro,—i"-!—<^^^^mi—i»ot\jm>oinco co «o -4- >r >t «4- -j- oo >r -o oo co -* enc\j cm c\j «-^ -* <-• f-i cm >$ c\j vo cm no r*» >*

4- >s- >4- -4-^ -t ^f <f >* >* «t <irn rom

ooo—^cMrncomr*>or^>4"mr*invOco>4"Oinoinc7> cno>r*-NOin>ooin^OM^iTif^-<if\H-<c^'-*r>-if\h>Hif>(MONin ocoascoino—tminvocoooc^i-fOr-tocTx-tOr-tcM^rncovj-co—* cMaovOr— -oo-OvO-OvOO'-o^or— r^-c^-r— vor"-r*r*r^vONomm>j-m oo-^cMrom

r«- r— r— r- r- r— i*" r— r- r— r— Is- r>» r— r-

CM CM CM CM fM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM (M CM CMcooooococoooooaococoooaoaocococococococococoCM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM <N CM CM CM CM CM

2 (ocn^-mininm^t—^om^©^a. ininininmminmmm^mvOvOvO

> (>0>> <T>0>, CT>O,| CT'CJv >v N C>0<| O,, O^

C7>O CM -vf CO r«- f-* nO CO vOO »H vO CO >j- cj»in (3> "-*&O s

^OOcjNCOcooor-r^r-cocor-r—r«->Oooocn^-r~mOO^CT'COcocoaocococoaococooocococoo^O^c^O'^

cM^-r*-vOfMr-coor-coooh-hOOOO*

CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CO CO rO rO COm rn CO CO CO COm CO rO rO CO CO CO COm CO CO CO CO CO CO rO CO

00

OCX

in >i- vO oo o> 4" r-t *h v^ no in co co cm i»»

r— O^Orvjr— f-tcoOcoONroco-OOcoOco>ocMmo—iininOcMtMcor*-o f*» sr I

s* ino ^o cm >o como .—i in vo

invj-f^-cocMC^vOoOvOOinroococM^ooin^-ivO ocmcm^coo'-<r~-coromr«-invOcO'^cMCMr^cMcooomor^cMO cMcocMCMOr*COCMONJ-CMvtIs-invDCMCOCMCOON r~-CM-J >4-rx--HCOr^- vO—r-r— OOCMcOi—<Ov0^o^-»r,-coc7>^0'^mcMr,--4- cj^cMcjNg>r,-coco rHinr*-—ttn^-t

l»-C0c>0>O^-<'-"CMCMc0c0CMOOC0o^o^oo^oooooaoooocr*CO CO CO rO^ >t ^" <<*• ^" >*•^ ^"^ ^" CO

o>0'-i^cMcoco^"-4-m^ONor,*r*-ooa3r*-cMOO^o^vO ooaococj'C^ooocj^O^O> 0^0> C>0> c^c^cjNO><7>C7»(3>o^CJN CJ>cj>aoaooo co oo oo as 03 C7>

CO CO CO CO CO CO PO rOfOCO CO rOCOcO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO COcOcOfOfOCn

co 0"» cm -o vo co oo i-*m^r- cm r^ co r— cm •-• cr> »-< coo o>o coooo co ^<r> co coa>r*ooo inm co >tcoof»"(Nji-i< o<3^rcMin<-<cMinincococMcoc7^cr> >oeoa>eMr>»>rmr^cMmcMinmmrooa3»-iO'^cM-o —icmosOOco

uj fo>^-mmvO^-coooc^o<-'CM>4- >r^o N4-inv0^or—coo>oo--^cMCMco>rinLnr-cMNf^ ,>ur«- ^r^sj-mmr*-x •••••••••••• t • •en t • • • # •••••••• • •• *co •«••••t— —t ^-t <-* -H r-t r-» ^h-h-h CM CM CM CM CM CM OOOOOOOHF-lr^HHH^HH»4Cg(\JC\JIN(\J OOOOOO

CM C7*

CM i-t

in in

75

Page 152: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 153: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

f\l (\l nj t\j eg rg rg c\j c\j rg eg rg t\j

in in in in in in inin in in in in in

cc o^Ovoor->rinoO'-<ooinrHvos rH(NjrgcorHr>->ror*-o,>ooi>->4-

q. NOcocvjinocgrgr-tf-iinvOincof^»ro>r>3"vrinin>rrnfMtN"-HCT>

t— •••••••••••••l— (NicgfMrgrgrvjrgrgrgrgrgcNjrg

cc rrirg*-*—* in eg ^r>r cmsoO'TH

a. r-oxmr»o>t<4Tgc\jr-ao>oc^o^ o*oo >—i <—i <->o c> ao co f*m

i— #••••#•••••••i/> r- rococo ao co ao cor*- h-h-t^-P*

to Hsof^voo^o^gj'oo-'ONuu rg>f0<t—"in-4-o^OoofMxOrgcc r--Hrgromr«inosOin»n%rc\i

CO <T> <7* <J> C*C1 CT* 0* s CJ^ C* 0"» (J>o3 c\j(M(\if\irgrgr\jcgognjcgc\irg

CO

cc vOcoino^ogr\jr-)>j-ocginr^in3 r«-ininv3->4-m>tvOr-cococoinQ. co co co co co co co co co co co co co

z. »••••••••••••LL

vO rg^tvooomo (mcnjcoooI— rno coo r- in rg margin.-* egtn covO^cNjp— r*<7*r*oinrn.^m"D >ra^oo>orn'^oininrg^orricc • ••••• t •

X 00—<rgro-4">d"'-i0^cocOvO(MI— (T>0N0^O(Tt0>(^0>00C0C0C0C0

co <J> rg in .-» in^ >* -^- c\j vo c^ <?»

< ooo>oc^inc\i>rf-*ocO'-^cN

i— r-rvjo>v£/>rrg>rinr*-cocoomuu r-cocoo^o—^Minr^-cooOrHrox ...•••

76

Page 154: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 155: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

inCT> O CJ> Q* <J\ Cf>&& C7* <>O <X <7> s 0^& 0> 0*> C?> CJn CT* (X1 (7> C7> CT>^ OOOOOOOOOOOOfM,-4 —<—(H^^^^Hf-*^^,Hr^^HH^-»,—i.

i^^^_i ,—<_4^-» cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cmooco 00 00 00 00 CO 0000 CO CO 00 00 00 CO CO 00 CO CO 00 CO 00 00 00 00 00 oo 00 00 00 00 CO CO CO CO CO CO 00 CO

cc o^vO >or*-mm»oco^m'-*ocNr^aoc>a"C^ojco<ricom<\itn*roo3c rnm o>mir\vo<M<Noo«oommooo>rmo>or\jro«4"cr>-«rOvOO>*a. —«o ocT'r-ioh-^Hsj-covOOcMroomr^-^-^cno^ino^r^-m^"

m© a>oococop-r-NOin-4"rnf^rg^oo^O>oO'«0 >£'Ln>J"(N»rHoa^

i-i r- (Mo© <-r r- co c\i a> >r cmom>ooc7>cMc<-)CMinr-oor<*)>rf\joo^<7>cn>ooco(\ivOOO'O'^cor-r^vO^^^mrn

cmcoOOOOOOOOOOOOOO^^C'CP^a^CM^^OOcornmcomrnrncocornmcOrnrncMiMCMCMCMCMCMCMCMCMCM (\l r\j c\j cm (\j <M cm cm cm cm c\j cm

oo

o•z.

cc

3a

00x

cr>vO ^ooovOtrN rgmvom(\jrncro-^0'^rno>rr)ao>Trvjmrnr*mm rnoo(7<o^)r,-mo>j"r*»r*<\jLno\OMno-or^aornco>^om—ir- co %o >tm >3" co (\j >om >o o*1—<r-o^cocM>or,-t-troso>rro(Np-cm rH^-i»-^^oc^ocop*'^mmrom(\i^'-<o> aocor^inNj-(T)r\i

CM CM

r-( omt\ rnm r**o >—• ^omco ooO <7> CVJ rr) to coo cr* -H -4" >*" <7*

cmo o^ r- co^ in oo r- —i in ooo oo>o coco p- *omin^ rr>

ctn o> 0> ct> o co co co oo co co co co co oo oo co f- Is- f*» p» p* I

s- p- p-<N CM CM (M (M CM CM CNJ C\J CM CVJ (NJ (\J f\| CM CM <M CM CM <M C\J CM r\JCMCM

co co p» r— p» p- h- r— r- 1*- r*- Is-

CM (M CM <M CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM

O00

LU

z<

00LUCCa.

co

X>co

oo cor»r-oocois>'vor*-o^coocooc^a>oocM'-«-*ocM'^-^oo ^inrricj>c^mc>fnr»-c^>t'C>>j"inr*-incMNj-oocMcM>ococMCMoo i^or^>o-oomr^oof— <7»f*- co aor"- co <7><^oo<-*©o *-*»-«

OO OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOi-i^-4^—i^-i-^i—i

moCM-*

C^OOOOOOO^O^hcom in roin in in roo in no <-•

cMrommfnrommrrifnrn^m rn rom ro <r»m rnmmmm

(><7>CN ON <>CJ^^0> C>C7N O>C^O^(J>CT>C>CT<(J>C,«0> O^0^CJ\CJ>0> OOOOOOOOOOOOCM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM

x cc oo r-»i^-r*-is-r-sO'Of,^cocoo^oooooooococT>o^oO'-^oo^r-i

o 3 oo in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in OnOvO^o^oOvOI— O- 00") f\J CM CM CM CM CNI CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CNJ (M CM CM— sOf* r"»P"- ^p»r~P*-p^p*p~P~p^Pw P*»P"-p>-p"-p'-r"-P,-P*-P,*'P-P~, p'-P"-

o oo Is- co r—r— I

s- oo vO r- so >4-

>fm ro vOmm rom ro rom rr>

—1 1—I i—1 1—1 1—1 1—1 1—4 ft •-* i—1 1-4 i—

(

CM-*00 LU

a: ooLUOO3LU<DcCa. a.

_ILU<-Jh-COOont— x>

CO

rr)LU

_JLUCUQC-q.

LL>

003ccX

<LUX

oo r-icocMco>j-r-(>o>oin^ocMcors.co^o>r'-40r-)-oo>OsOoo O—<c\4rncoao^inON i.nO'^inc\jinr*invOin<)Ocr*coc\ii-tOO ^incMi^-inr-vMcoO^aocMa^O^ocMinaoococMOOCOvtcoinoo rrior— cooor—o^—*&?*"—i*Qir\-f ego co^OnO©©oop~co

-4- rgO CT^ <-tco >^ 0"> a> CO >f CT>

cr>in«-t'-io>rncT>"OocM:noop- co r- cm cm cm p- I

s- in >-*m inrnOP*>^C0v0r0CM^Jf-<OC0

ino cocor^f*-in>J-rocMOoor,--orr>cM'-tOCJ>>>0>l"frtCM!7N vO>J"CMP*m CMCMCMCMCMCMCMCMCMi-H'-^^'H^'-^»-<OOOOO0N C7Nax C^mm in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in ^sj-^-nJ-

r— r- vo >o^m cm ih o> oo p- inoooooooooa>o^c>in in in in in in in in^^ vj* >i"

-^o cMcj>c\i>^in<omcocMvOcovt>oin^>rpn'-'>t*rrir,*cM<-t'-<coi-(<McO'-<r*»rrirn^--i^oo^hoo infHooNOrooininp-^TO—^aocMoo^coop-r^-c^rnp*—a o^^cr»vO>-ir«.>rsO'-'<-*oocM

^^O HO>ft<M>TfMCOmc^ONOCMCOtr>vOCMOMn—(C\|COOOvr>TC\|f-tfHOOO<—irnrHvOCMOOi-fr^-CMCT1

cr«o ^mininv0^p-p-ONo>oO'-4CM<,nrn>}-sO(>-p*-cO'Hroinp~ ^ininin>o^OP-P^CT«c7>oom • tro ••• t ••••••••••••••••••• tro • t •• t ••••• t •

(MO OOOOOOCJOOO-<HHHHHHH^i-lHriJfMP>)(\J oooooooooo—*<-*

'M in inCM CM

00 00 CO

77

Page 156: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 157: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

OOOOOOOOOOOOO --«.-«—i~4~4r*^i~-l**T-lr-*~4TMT-f-l~*r-ti-i~4w4~4r-4 CO CT\m CT| CO CO (T| enCM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CMCM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM00 00 00 CO 00 CO 00 00 00 00 00 CO 00 00 00 00 CO CO CO CO CO CO CO 00 CO CO 00 00 00 CO 00 CO 00 CO 00 CO 00 CO CO 00 CO 00 CO

cc ao^!-i>rrocovo^H^r-mr--d-3: irvm-a"vococsif-*mmr»co(\ir-

f^^oo(?oor-r»vO>tmrvjo

o o» -o r— cmcm cm o* p» in >r cm p» en —< onm -<o --i si-or^oo f-tm r^m p- <-*oo p* vO r- *o r*- cr> rn ir»oo r*^-to co r-o >f on en •<>" on "4" co co en co en coo en in r-ococop-f-p-vOifMn-jrrifntNj^^ooo^cor-o-t^

(\j p~ (\i co o> ino coco f-i ino *Q on <* inrj^coNomooma^-4-

in in in in sr sfm en

o^O'O^a^cocooooocococoooooc\J cm cm cm r\j r\j cm cm cm (M cm (\J cvj

ao co co co ao co co co co co co co co co co co r- r- r»- r*- p- f^-

cm (\i cm c\j cm cm c\j c\j cm cm cm <\j cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cmr- p-p~ p- p-p» p* p*CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM

ct ^cncooo^comNOr-^-t-H^cvjs. cMOOcn^a«co^-i»-4^-mo>cna. inf-nno«>3-.-i>roc<">mro-*co

cMCM^ooONcoooP-in^cn^

p— r->r>o^" ,^»-icr> OP*cr)ini/Mny>coincr'»T<rm>rp-^r*cMvfo^corri.-i.-»cop*-co-ocoominoo -o

cr> oo vO in co co r— r-t c\i r- cm «o >o—'o -* r— >j* ~* en in covOo >o -om in -j- -<r ro cm cmhoo on <r> co p- -o in en cm

inoo vO p- en ao >r-oomco>fp—^cnocjNp»ma*»rom

Xp*^»r*-r»P^vOvOvOvO-OvO ,>OvOCM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM f\l CM CM

vOv0^o^O vO vO>0'0'0^oo>OvO»0'ninmmmmmmCM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM

inmmmmm in^CM CMCM CM CM CM CM CM

00HiQCo_

CO

CO

—t CMOHHi-(O O* —* On <—• CJ>O_< r» en .-* f-t on en >o •-»o <-*o ensr <*• -4- vf <t -4* <f en <r en >* en cm

m rn en en en en rn en en en en en en

r\) r-> >-* <-4 cvj <-< r-t »-• e\j cm ~* cm CM cm <-•^ cm <-•oO On CP*

vOcoooo^ooo>r^ONO>r>rcoo>rcocMoenmooo i—t <—• >-i <—• •—» *-» «—i »—••—!•—i »-<o i—i i—»ooo cjn aococooococococooococococooococooococococop-p*

i-t—'OOOOOOeneno>(J>o>cr»cP'p«-_<_*oooooop~ r— p* r*- r- r» p- r-

oooooooooooooCM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM

enenmenencnencnCM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM

OC <4"—ien«4-^OrnvON*">0>J"Ocn rnCMCMrHCO—•»-•»-» 0OCO'-*P«- COCO CM^CO CM n0P»"-<>O P^P^CMCMCMCMCMn}'3 cnrnenencnenenmenrncncn^ o^^o^o^coo^c^o^aDcoQNoooococ^o^cofjNO^ONOo h«»^cmcmcmcmcmcmo_ ^4^i^^^-i^-t^t^-(^—*.—t r—i.—i-^ ^i^^i^^^^i^^i^i^^p-i^^t^^H^-i^^^cMCM cj» c^ (j> a> cj^o on a>

qn on onoooo ono on cjn o^ o^ ' '» i» *i Mi ii i i ii ii in ii ii ii ii ii ii ir—> ir -ii j i 1 1 1 1 rn en en en en en en rn

2 •.... » ...t..t • ........< ^^^^^^If-l^lr-t^i^^r-l^t CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CMIX.

CO

X

^ONOoOvO^ooomcMsO^"cm s envOmOsOOmoN g^m^p-omcD^ininr^stcNjp-p-f-*rnNom>^vOenocMONp~m^o

O com cm «-ionom cm cm <-* rc\o r- —*oo co ao nQ co en enono <—>'n com cm i-hm oom co co eno p- en <-* *oo ^o oncm >*• oo -• p— on oo co <f —<o -4* cm eno cmm som on en p»eno p--m cm cm cm cmm vO p*- p- ono •—i cm eno p^ r-» o^ p—

iriMvO'-tHr-ooCn^J-OsOO'-^P,-^en en cm no i-im cmmenor— vj-envi" op*

en cm >—•o on p*-om eno coo ><•

on on on on co co co co oo oo r- P- r—>*• -4- <r -^ -i- >t <t >r «* -r st >r >*•

en en cm cm >-•o o» co -om^ rn <-* **o on co vo en cm co r-co co co oo oo co p- p* p* p- r- p* p- r* r- -o vOo vO nomm<r >j- >3- vj- «4- 4- >t ^- >r -4- sj- Nf vj- >4- >i- si- -4- vt >r vt >t -t

vO-omm>tencM--immmmmmmm

u^^r^sOcMco>^<-tsomooc><x)CMcncMCMONC^^mcncMNOcooocM'^en-4'Or^mvoenmcM^cMr^< cm on en vO on >o co cm -^mp*» enm mcMONmmcocMNOCMmmoNcocMmvocMCMr*-ooo> p*- .-tOvOcococMP^cni— cm com —* cor"- co -o I—Tcmo >-* i-hcm <rmr^m^^co >3*com cm on >r cm oNv0>r^r cm •4"On>t >-'cn <owoooomenuj cMcMcn>r>4"-OP-cooNCMsrNOco mmmmor-p^cooNo^H^en-^-^mvOcoo^cnm OvOOP-cococjnoX •••• • ten • t • •••»• en ,

f— ^rHr-l^r-(F-4r-4^^CMCMrgCM 0OOOO0000<-»Hi-tHHHrt^H(MM(NPJ OOOOOOO^cm mCM CMoo 00

78

Page 158: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 159: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

encncnencnmenmencncnenmenenenen ^^^t^^^^sf sfsi-st^^^»^>t^>t^»fr>f >f >fr>f ^•4-'4"

cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm00 CO 00 00 00 CO CO CO 00 CO 00 00 CO 00 00 CO oo oooococooooooooococococococooocooooooococooocococococo

cc. ocj»vocr»incncor"-r*-inenenincooocj>3 r-<\ioo«3-f*-mcoino^>ooa>'^r»«ooo_ cncocMP~>o—<incj*ooi-<cM>4"incr*i-i.4-r—

cnj i-i -*o o> <j> oo r- r- oo co oo co oo o^ a* cr*

ir>o<Nim^T^o>o>r<Mf*-op*a>fnr*--4,vroi^romcoNOoovomc^om in cj> —< <\i r-jm cm —« cr* cm «oo en cmmmo co in inoo -o <3oo en r—o en cm rnm !* cm ct* t—o •* en —• soo >f oo -^ <o vo r- co oo coen en cm cm rH r-*OO co oo vO vO *0 ^o >0 vOm in *fmm cm cm cm cm cm cnj

ai-

r^^<*»^NO>o»o »o >o <o *o \o >o vo^o «o«oCM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CMCM CM

f*. f«- r— t— h» f» Is- 1*» vO «0 vO <0O *C <-0 »0 <0OO nO >0 *0 "O »0^ *0O

CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CMCM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM

or cor->rcMmvONOvoO'-»tr>r*-coi-*-HmcM2 ^o-ocr>m,-««ocMO>>o>3'oois-ONomoa. >rornoor-cM»ooco^ro>rvOOCMinoo

ao r- r» vO in in <• -<r rn -^ >j- -r >*•m in inm

—* >o -T vO cm in >o cmo co co ^u eno >r cooo co en cm >4* tr> ej> -4- cr> aomm»oox >4"0'0'Oi,*in^cM >oomvOincoinm<-4coco^NOcMCMm f- t-t «^ co so i*" r— fh vO en cmo fJ^ f*~mo »r co cm >ooo cm cmmmao !•> r— >o inm *4- >r en cm r-i -^ <-*ooooo co oo r- r» r*» r»» r- r- r—

X CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM>*^^ >*• >* -4- >t >4" «*^^ -4" -4" vt >4" -4*^ en en en en en en enm en enCM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM fMCM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM

UJ

or:

o_

CO

CO

OOO —*O —*O CT> —*O iH <-< -4 *-> CM CM CMcjn a> cjn en CT> en 0>o en r«- in en en en on >H *-*

OOO^OHOO^OHrH^^Hegegr- r» r*- r*- r— r- r^ r- r- r*-r— h- r— t-- r*»r— r-

r— r- -o oo I*- r*» ao ao r- r- >o r- r-ooo i*- r» vO r— noo^ ej^ co cjn <t>

CM CM CO CO CM CMOO CM CM CO CM CM CO CO CO -4" -4 -O <tO CO COO CO >T >T(7>C>C0C>OOOOC^CT>C0(>0NC0C0C0C0C0C0C0C0C0C0OO'-<i--<p«- r^ r* r- oo co co co r* r* p*- r^r— r- r<- r- r^ r*- r>- r* r— r«- r- co oo ao oo

enenenenenrnrnenenrnenenencnenenenCM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM <N CM<N CM CM CM CM CM CM

-4- >* <r -* -t <} >t >r -i- >t >t 4-^ ^- <t- -4" -4- >i- v4- >t ^- >* ^- >^ vj- xt -^j-

CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM (Nl CM CM

Q.

<U.

cm cm cm r- cm r— cm—i r- >^ ->*• r*- f* p-o r»» r*cm cm cm •—

' e\i ^-t cm en —* cm—* <—••—

• <-*OOO0^c^o*ej,>cj»ej^cJs c^ONCjs cj^cj>CT>c»0

>

*<j>C7*

enenenenenenenmenmencnenenenenen

sj- >i- <7> r- cm cm >* >3" >j- >J- <r> >t vto tr> ej> -^ >f cm »4- e\i cr> cr> r*- >t r- r-vO vO ^o inm in in in >oo o ^o ^o -o *o -o e»~ f*> f- I

s* e*» vO >o «* >J" en enininininininininininmininmininminmininininminininin in tn in in in in in tn in un in in in in in in in in in in inminmmm

CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM

00

a:X

cm cm co >d- enOo en cm e^ en en h- r— Ntm >j-

mm—io sO >ro <?> <t co <4* eno -4-m enmcoo cm *oo en en f^ en r— vO -•o >t ** >j- c^p«- ao oo ooo <y> o> r*mo eno a^mom ej*

OsOP— cm-J" en >j-comm vj> cmoo c^ vO ao co^-^oo >i-mco ^ao ^henmo <-*t- r^ o* cm^ cm_i —i vj-& <j\ co —• cjn en cmr— cmo %o oom enN<j*inin^O>4- H^eNiOfei'-<'^Ht-iHCOvte\j(T>OH(Njineeiifiir\m ^- -4- cmo r«- —^ f-< cm en cj« r«- >j- r-i aommm *j- cm^ cm cm ^-mo so

o^ co r- vO -^ en cm -^ «-* cm cm cm cm en >*• >t >t>t nT >r >t^^ >r >r >r* ^j- >j- «*• >t >t <4* -rvf >t >t -t -^ "•* >4- >t if s*- «t •*• -4- >t^ ^r sf

o co r— nom >*• en eno c> vO v0 <5 -omm -4- en cm f-too <T>o cj^o cjn

^ >t n*" -4- >r >t -4" -t -st en en en en en en en en en en en on cm cm cm cm cm cm>T >f >T vt -4- >t -4" >t >4- -4- -4" >4- >4- vt -f -1" -4" »* -t -f >t >f "4* -1" >t nJ" >f

mo\OcncMC>>rs4'Ocnr^s4-P^vo»reMs4"CMcnoOvOmcnmmOs4-ej>aoeMa3mmr^a3envO>i-tT>cMmcMen>Or^< oco>4"crej>enej>cj>o ,TmcMCMr,<"0-^cr> r*» in >o in -r in en >*"•-«in r*- encom cmcor— srmaoocMCMr-mcoccI— ONvO>r'-i>o>j-i-»»-4vOCMr*- 0>4"s4"C\.'0<)'^aov>OOaO'^mmoejoooocMmaoocOvO>J"CM<-<aocoocMenenlu -4CMen>i"mvor—coooocr«oO'HCMenen cM^i-too ,-, cMcMmmr*-cocococoo>cT«o<-<cMencnen>4">r>j"s4'X ••• t •• *en • t t •••••••••••••••• •

f_ ^_<^H^^-«^-t^^^_,^, fv4CMCMCMCMCM OOO0O0O0O0O0OOOOO'^>-H»-t^'-4'-<'^'^'-^-HCM

I I I I

<r00

79

Page 160: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 161: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

* vf <4* >J- vf -4- >J" «0f >t -4" <t" -4- <f 4» vfC\J CM CM CM <\l CM CM CM (\) CM CM CM C\| (\J (\l

COCOCOCOCOCOOOOOCOCOCOCOOOOOCO

vO in v0 ^o ^o ^o -oo ^o *o *o ~o *o *o *o *o -o ^o *o r*»f>« r*~"f>~ f*"~c**- r*~r*~"f*~

CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CMCO CO CO CO CO CO 00 CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO 00 CO 00 CO CO 00 00 00 GO CO CO 00

or >4"coinp-co>rtncor-rooro>rr-o3 rri >o 10m ^r*-o co co -ooo>r- in >oo. Oi-troroinincoocor-incM^vOoo

rococorororococo>r»4-ino>cr>ONcr<

mm cm «4-co cm I-" <4-o o>m r^-<t> cm vO cmm cm >o

o ino r- >r ir>m inOMn cm >r >-•o r*- o^ o> o^ aoinoro-oo^cocMvOOminr-vOcrCTx^r-ina* co r»r*- 00 co coo o> o>00o -^o ^cmcm^

-4" >ro nt ro -* co r- cmoo >4-com cm r*» o> o>^vOO-^o^^tcocm^cMCMrnrnroNj->S"inin

CMCMCMCMCMCMCMCMCMCMCMCMCMCMCMinmm in in in in in in in >o vO vO vO ^o vo nO ^O >0CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM

in in in inm in inm inCM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM

cc o»ycoovj,inooocoi-«*^>ointncM3 ocO'-*cMP*-rop*in>frro>rNO-4'0,>oQ. •4'vOCOCOO>>OCM>J'OOCMOr-C>Om

r— p.. (*- p- p- ao 00 00 co 0^o re\ co -4" -4-

4* 00 coo v» if*o vr >r Is- co r- u-

*m <-•omm vu

mop^vO^m^vOON-o-TNOro^oooooomoocMvoo>rcocMma><-HrncMvONOO«4"CMcMOO>oo-jF-4rHCMCMCMroro>f rONi-ininp-

coinvrror-ONrcovro^r-roo^r^-cMNfmvoo^^^ooomr-ocMrororo^^ininin

001

rorororororororOfOro>i">4-Nf -4">fCMCMCMCMCMCMCMCMCMCMCMCMCMCMCM

pOrOCMfOrOrOcOrOrocOcOrorOcOrocOrocOcOCM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM <M

CMCMCMCMCMCMCMCMCMCMCMCMCMCMCMCMCMCM

COLUCCCL

CO

CD

coo o> o>ooo coo 00 -<oo r-p*

CO t-4 "4" >T CO CO CO CO fO 00 CT> fO 1—I-4" CM

O CM _4h .-» -^ CM i-t *-*—« CM CM CM CT> <T>

co co co 00 00 00 co co co co co co co r- r-

>t>0>0P*C>0NOO0N O'-,OO(>fvJOO(JiOro r*-m rom r*- <m >j- r«- cmo cm cmm vO cm cmm cmoo cm ro >t •>!mm >rm vo no vOm >ommm >o0000000000000000000

r-^OCMt-tCMCMCMfMmcM-ooo^cooocoCO r-tO •-• -H r-4 CM CM CM

-t -4- >j- .4- -4- vf >$- xf >f 4- st sj- .4- <f sj-

CM CM CM CM CM CM fM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM\Oinvo*o*o ,>o^O vO>ONO^Ox0^o ,-O vO vO vO»O vOCM CM CM CM CM CM^ CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM

p- r» r- r- r» r* r- p- r-CMCMCMCMCMCMCMCMCM

CC

a

<u_

•4" r— p- <j* o> r- cmo cm o> p» (T> <m >*<4" CM CO ro CO CO CM CO fO CO •-• CM CM <0 vOmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

r^ CO >4- -4"O r» CMO f~ <M CMOO P- in CM CM P»OmmcM-^(^c>CT< o^o>i <^cooococor*-o>ooooo>4--4">J"<4"rororocorororo<"OrorocorororocoIs- p» r- I

s- p- r^ p- p* p» r- p» r* p» r— r- r— r* Is- r*

iH C7^ ^O <-h *o <-< Q> <r> a>omsommm<j">^commmmmmmm

m

CMCMCMCMCMCMCMCMCMCMCMCMCMCMCM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CMCM CM CM CM CM CMCMCMCMCMCMCMCMCM

l/>

a:X

CO CO CO cmo CT> CO nO fO cr>m *H r-t CO r-l

r— r*-O >t CO CM vf ino co >t o> ro «t <T>

4"0^>tCMror-000>>OOcoOP^cj^ cmmm co o> ro vo -4"om ro vO cr cm

>j-o ro r^m^mm roo co^o co r~ co r-4 —1 ^«v0 o> ^o r~ —hp—o i-^ on -4-mo cm co ^om >^ ro cmooom oo cm so ro co i-icM co—jo .-4 ^" r» co•^4'r-iC0inr\jOr-iriOls"H4O^N4"-< 4'

^^ -<m co cm .-«^ a»msOOrM^TOOrMONi—

ONO^f—O«4-OCMC0v0CJNp*m>J-CM—«CT>s0O

CT1 OOOO »-l 1-1 r\| cO -41 »H—<—' CMCMCOcororororOrorOroro^vf^^l">i- -t ^t >r >*• >4- >4" vj« >r ^- >4- >r >^ >t >!

o p«- »o «o p» coo a>o *h r-i cm cm >t cm >l"mooCMH i-<«H «-• f-I »H i-l CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CMvj-* >r >4- >f >r vj- vj- >r 4- >i- vi- >r -t >t <r ^* «4-^

cm co -4"m so r* f- co o>000000000>t-4->r>rNfvt>t<f<r

LUx

aocMcooNor^o>4-ocoocMr^^a*cMOfO>4"mc^^coaNCMvrop^^or^mo<r>rmcMCMcof>-vOooooop^'-< mor^-oo-o^mo^cMcovOvOsOcop^cMOco o>oovOCM>ocovor«-NOOCMCMmr^cM^^a^rMao^r^^mmor^mc^or^^ococMmcjNo^4, ifMf\inioin«CvOM>"^r»r»cooo mp*o>o>0'-«cMCM<,

o>j"-fmmvomp»aoo>cM mmvor— cooocr>oo. . • . «CO • • • •

»CMC\JCMCM OOOO-rj\

•CM CjOOOOOOr-H'-*

CM00

80

Page 162: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 163: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

r- r- r- p- r- p-^ p- r*- p- p» p- Is- r- p-

cm cm cm cm cmcm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cmCOOOCOOOOOOOCOCOOOCOCOCOOOOOOO

00 00 CO 00 00 00 CO CO CO 00 00 CD 00 00 00 00 CO 00 CO 00 CO 00 CO CO CO ocyocm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cmcmcmCO CO CO CO 00 CO CO 00 CO CO CO CO CO 00 00 CO CO CO CO CO CO 00 00 CO CO cococo

3Q.

I—

o

r^>o in >j-m co co cr>— o> r» co co p-oi*- co I

s- *o —* <T>o co -*o oo ro co p» >os3O rO in GO CO I** .- inp- CNJ t>O CM CMm >o -o >o "O p- p» oo oooo co oo p- >o

<-"coOi-tOi^->or*"0>j-^-»o^cMCjOr<i-«rNO'r>iMC7>ir.>i-rgm o^o^cmo^cMOc^c7>u^i^cMinrn'-tinf*-«4-incooooc^p,-OvOfOOrn nOOp-coo>o-^p-fOsOCT>>rp-o>^vOO>3-oo>rsOooNOoocMincMco o^mcMcoa^o,<oo^.-H'^cMCMCMrorn>4"^-NttninininNroc7>cop- m-op-

inminininmmminNO>ominmmCM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM

^^^tninininininmmminmtnmininmmmm^st^CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CMCMCM

cc >oco«-«cncMcr>>J"u ,\ocooocMP"«TP-3 ^-vO>TcMe->4, m'^o^r-'r>in-r-4>fo_ i-iincoocMcocM«oocMr*-fn>i"vom

sO\0>OP-p-p~aocoooi—ioo^cop-^

or^orncorri^r-vocMinr«-NO'T)oo^oocnc\jcMinO'-t>o»-< -t-TnOco^OO*C7>P-»*"inr»-sOrOCOOCOC^CM>tCM>4"'-<rOrnP-cO>3" o>4-r-i>r^P*cMoo>rp-oincoocMco.-iinoincoococT> roincMco —tr->i"

so^r-cocoo>o,»ooo^-i—i—'CMCMrncnm-^-rocMQor^vOin cmcmoo

COX

CMCMCMCMCMCMfMCMCMmrncMCMCMCMCM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM

,-<,—l,-*r^,-*^f^CMCMCMCMCMCMCMC\JCMCMCM<'\|CMCM—*—*<-><-*CM CM CM CM CM CM <M CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM fMCMCM

OOLUOCa.

co

OCO

CO CM <-* CO ~* CM »H CM^ nOCnI cjn >o ^- C7>

vtCOCM^O>tOCMOCM>OOOC7>r-vOrorOfncMCMCMrn>f>J'OCMoO'>rcMco>i- >t >4- >d- >i- >J" ^- >4" ^f vf nJ- rO en rr) cm

ONO>ocMro>t'-^covor»»is*(*-ooooo>>'^o^O'-0'na\cocM mp-moo in o* en ro p- in in a*r^Orinoco en vO>—icocoin<Minp-cr> cooojcnrnininp*-c>cocM'-^i-i^r,"CMin>j-inin>j-vO^'-<'*~oo>cM ct>cm-^\0^o^o>o*o o cmp-p-p-p--^p-p-p-r'-p-p-n-p-p- inm >$•>*• or-p-

p* p- p- p« P- p- p» l*- r» p» Is- p- p- I

s- p-CM CM CM CM CM CMCM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM

oocococococococooocooooocooococococococococooococoCM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM

3 mcMro-^^^rncMiNO^corOvO^a. inininmmmmmm^ininvO^OP-

0"n O>1 >1 ,,00>, CT, CT>CJ>000,>OC7nO>

^^OcocMvtmo-4-cMvOCMOOOr—vOro^o>f tno"^-^-h .-•o o^o oo p- I

s- r*» Is- I

s- p» Is- inomm >om so p- "0 »oo o>

0>c>o^cooooooococococococococoaococooooooocT>c>a»cJ>

mmvO<5ininco co co•nmm

CM cm cm cm cm cm<MCM cm cm cm cm cm cm cm rncncnrncncoencnrncncncnrnrncncn'Oenenrocn'-ocncnrn menm

OO

a:X

CM CO P- CO 00 P- CM f-4 >© CM0>0 CM ^" CMo^r-r— r—fooocoororovOr— no^vOvOOvtoocoinocM^r-^oro•4* -^ no ct> «j- >tf- -h com p- i*- cmmo —*

0^in^>t^^inor*-r*-oooo^-<roOco<T«corocMcorofs-r>» inocoOc0^rocOO^^-r>»(n>3-cOCMrO>Of*-CM<)rOO^^OC>inCT>rri 0>r—

m

^^»o^^o^cocM<-<cocM»fm—^inrocovooooooo^mco^om co^t^o<7NO--^f-icMrooOrorooo--H<)incMCT>r«-r*-CMgDr-^incMC0 4'P- 0><-"ro

oooo-^cMmcn^cop-mcncMO

<4- >* s»* <j- >r sf >4" >* <r^^ >j- vj- sf -4-

^HcONi-mvOf^r—coc^O^oo^cMCMro^minmminrOr-io romNO0%C7>C7v CJ>0>0>>C7no>0>CT>OOOOOOOOOOOO^C7>CT»0> COCOOOrococOcornrOcnrOrOrO>tNf ^">4->J">*'>f^-v}-vj--r rocoro<"0 rocoro

oinu^NOocovoor^^coino<fvOCMOni^inosO^cM^^inNi-ro^cxjvo^fHcoin^coo^^rooo^aj< p»cr>^HON^cM^o^o>>r-f-4om'^ oco^p-msoroo^r-oomoooocMmoo^—ir^vOooo^f^ cr>cop-t— >^cofninoocoNO^cMCMcMinvOCM<^vOco^covo>roor^cocMinc^^c^voco^r*cooc^uu ^r-*cMiMm-*'*4-m»oO'^ni>3-mp- ro>rlnln^o^^^^coooo^c^o>^^'-^cM^o^}^ln^o^-roln^o^,- m^mX ••••!•••••••••• co •••• • rn . . .

>_ ^.^.^^H^^r-t^^fvjcvjfvjcMCMCN OOOOOOOOOOOOHHHHHHH^HrgiNNog OOOin co

CM COao oo

Page 164: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 165: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

(\J cm c\j cm cm c\j c\j rg c\i r\j cm cm cm eg cm r\j cm cm cm c\j cm cm cm c\j cm cm cm c\j cm cm cm cm cm cm cma3(i>coooco<»coaDcoooooooooaocooocococDcoa3cocoaDcoco<ri(»coa3a3coca

m »r r-* i-»en cm oo -o -T r- <n «h-^ «o —* «om -j- c* —*r- r»o ino >xxo «$ r* cdo in o> -4- cou^vo*OvOooaoc^^^%oo^oo-Hc^oc\jf-<cMCM<-4ro<^cMc^covO>o»ointr>ocor*'CMCMCMincD00CM>1">r^C0l^a3v0^U^cncMCMCMCM>000CDQ0^<^(^v0OC0Oinf^CJ<Nly-r»Nf^NC000C0C0C0C0C0(^CJi(?0>OOOOOOOOO'-i—4.-t.-(C7>Or->0^

4" •>* «t >t v*" >t >4" -4" >* «j- -4" >4- >fr >t^ -4" «4- in in in in in in in in in in in in in -4* >*• >j- >*• •<}

CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM <M CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM

cl aornminu^f-<0'^cM»-4i—i—*-^or^in<-*v0^cnr"-ina>NrONr-f—»r,-cj^cMinr*-vocn"-c>

3 c^ooocMCMco-4^-«r-(inv}-inr*»r*-^or»<^ONONo>o>oaNor^r-Na- roi-no^mcMinooa. c^>r>*'i^ooc^>o>o^oc^cj^c^r^r^r^o^c^rnmc^r-oo>cj^^u^incx)CM<7«cM>ocoo

enm enm >r >r -4- -4- -4" -4" >r «4* -4*m in inmoo vo >o vo r»oo r» c- r*. I

s- r» *n inm cm—

i— ••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••#••••X CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM

oo f^inininvOu^sOr^a3inoor^r^(>o^ocMCMCM^^cocOvrinrnrncMa»f*-vOOCMr*lu ooocx)QONra3^oco(X)aDCNCM<r^r^^c<)ro(oc>i^^^r^moN<^<r)v^cMvj'vOOincc cMO^^^o—^cMCM^cMrnco>or^r^r^<x)cx)co^a^c>a>(>oooaOvocM'-^invCfri

a. i^r^r^r^^p^r^r^r^i^f^r^r^r^r^r^p^^r^r^r^r^r^r^r^aDa3cor^f*-rv-(s~-OvONO

3 CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM (M CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CMCO

cc in^>Ovoa3^coincM>ocMOOvO^^>3w c»oocaocM<^^cMc^r*f^oosOincorn'-»cM3 u^ vO in in in so in in in in in un in rn en en in cm cm cm en cm cm cm cm^^i^ cm en in in coaorj*Q- O3oooocooocoa3ooaoaoooa3cooocococoaooooooocoooa3oooococx)aoa3coa3cocoao

enm <n rn^ rom rnm enmm romm rn en enm enm rnmm mmrnrocorncnenencnmz #'••••••••••• •••••••••••< cncOrnrncnrnrncnrncOrOcOrOrn<nrOcncnrncncnrnrncncncnrnrncnrnrncncncnrn

oo aom cm aom .4- o>m ~* -oo ooo r- cm ao coo ct» i*- r*» <m co a^ «j-om >$ in cm cm -t r- coI— OCJ> v+-p^>OC>^>OC>P^CMinrOvOCX)I^Q3COOCMO^CO^C^CMvOrnOcMC\10r<Nvd-in(/) cocn^co^inOcMCMCM^cM^fMcn-^cciriininvOcij^Ntvj-^coNtf^r^-cOvO^"^^z> rncnrnco^^^ininin^^--4^>o>oc>r^r^f^r^>^QOooco^<x3ci)fncMOvor*-ro^oc •••• ••••••••••••••••••••••••X v0^vOvOr^r-<3303CScOCJ»^<J'0000'^^^^CMCMcMCMC<)cncO>trr»f-tC^'<OinCMh" ajcoaoroaoaocoao^cacoOToocjv^cjNej^cj^c^cj^cjNcj^cj^^c^c^

co ro rrj ,-n rnm rnm rn en en com rn rn enmm rn ro en cnrncnencneococornmmrocncn

cj%o<^cMvOr^-H>tc»c7Ncninvor^cx3cj^oocn^NOcMO^cMCMin^r^f^cM>oc»cr><-<t r^cacacnc^cr>f^o>cjNCj>ooorncnrnf^r^r^r^r^^c^r- cMCMcM<>cr, r/>>Tr^r^f^cncnroNr>r>TvO'^'^'^'HvorooooocM<jr^cM>rcncnr^lu inininintnin>ovO^>or*r^r^oo<»oococ7>c>c^CTx a^(j>oNcj>ooo>^cM>4'inr^cx)c^X • ••••••••• •••••••••••r- OOOOOOOOOOUOOOOOOOOOOOOOOHHHHHHH-4H(\J

82

Page 166: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 167: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

or*- on on on on on ocr- on on on on on on on ono oooooooooooooooooooooCvJCM —«,—^^-t^-i.—

i—t,—i.—i^-t,—i.—t,—i,—i.^,—i^-t CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM <M CM CM CM CM CM CM

cmcm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm <N nj cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm <m cm cm cm cm cm cmCMCM CM CM CMCM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM C\J <\l CM CM CM CM CM (M (M CM CM CM CM f\J CM CM CM CM CM (\J CM

a: oo o»-»inm.-tON»tf"Oinor»ocopTOco3 p-a* r— ONCMCMO>r->*"i^c\jinor<">mcocMcoa. cmcm cor--oincn^*, vnnp-cMOP»cMcoocM

^o oo p* >t^ co in cmo^p- in cmop- in co

•4"o **o cmo <jo—* co oo co r- r-4 r*» o< »-«a> cr r*-o -4-

cm cm >r «-• cm vt on o>o >4- >r >$o incooo on o> coin^ooincMOcoop-NrrocM^cop-^cooocooinrnooocor*--o--rcM^o<7*somcncMor*-incoo

loco4" CM

vO <omm ir> >i- >r -4" co roro fi co cm cm cm>* -4- -4" -4" -4" «4* -4" -4- -4* 4" >t «* «4" 4" -t 4"

in inm in >j- >f >4- vf^ 4* ^" co co co^ co ro cm cm cm cm•4- -4- -4- «J" >t "4- -4- -4" -4- 4" *t 4- 4- vf -*• ^- vf ^- st -4" ^f

00

a

o•

CMCM

•>

LU_

z<Xo

OOLU

X>Oil/)LUOO3UJOcaQ.O.

_|LU<-J

OCT)

CO

^uu-J

luco

Oct:

00X

ooLUaca.

co

3CO

a:

a.

<U_

00

X

LUX

-oo cocvioocMO^romor-ocop-roinr—o* «r*o<T>cjN>oinr-»cMQ>cMr—oomcMnocm oinmcMi-^cMCMro^rop-tnoocoocMro cocmonocoop-^^ono^cmonp^lo

or*CMCM

or»»ovor-(N»roo!3-oo>T>Tiri'Hoa>^oif\ocop*ONOP-ominoooocM^oooLoooN.-Ha> vo coo -4- cm on -o cm cm—<o r-o co i-i co in cm co >f_i _<^ _i q\ coOm ro CM —*O P—O >4" COO COO fO t-4

COO vt-4- CO COCOcOCM CM CM-^^-^-^OOO•4-CM 4"-4-4-^4-»*-4-vf>r>4-.4->t4"^4'4-

OO O CM CM CM *-*CM <"0 CO CO CO CO CO CO CM CM i-*

oo inoN-^CTrooMnr-r— r*-inp-r>-»-t-Hco

oo p- coco co coco o^ on 0*0* on on s on o^r—•4"in o-o>o»0'0>oo>o>o-o vO>O vO-o ,o ,o

rOcOCOrOCMCMCMCMCMCMCMcM'-*'^'^—<'-<000<f >i- >!• 4" >t -4- vt >4- >t -4" -4- -4" -4- -4- 4- >* 4" -4" -4- -4- 4-

COOCOeocococOONONOOOOOOONONONOaNCOOrOCOOCOOOOOrOcOrocOcOCOOOOCOCOOOCM CM —> CM —< CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CO CM CO CM CM CM CO CM CM<^> CO CO rO CO rO fO CO rO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO

ONCJNCJNONfJXQNCjNONONONCJ^ONONONONON OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOCM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CMCM CM

OO C0 0N0\f^rj\(jvOOOOOOOOQ00 ^rOin>4"in<4-4"i-i^-tcOCOrocOcOCO^-tOOCO'-t-4-OO CM CM CM CM CM CM CO CO CO rOCOCO CO COrO CM ^-^^^^^^^^^^Nj-rO^CO^^^CONtvJ-CMO CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM ^^^~4r->r*r-*~*^r*~ir*~4~*^~4^T-»~*~4r-40*0 CO CO CO COCO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO 0* On On 0> O* On 0* On ON CJN s On On On 0> O On <J> On On On

—tCVJ ^4—«r-H—4,Hf-li-4t-4*-ltHi-<l-J^.^,-|.-« ^|_4i-t-H Hr^p4^H^-* ,_| ,_« .^^ ,_*_|_1,-t^lrH

OO 4- Ococm4"CMOCO-4"CM4-OOnOcM'-iOO \0CM^OC0inc00^r*O0*in^CM0»\0oo vffO^mooNO^—4c\jr— coop- o> cor—oo in in co cm *o cm p** in co no co on cm i

to

h-CMCM^r-OsOO-4- -i'incMinON>4- OcMinOrr»fMp-ONCM^ON^rOi-^cMON—tcoor— <—«.—ip-mor-omooNO-4-v0^comr>->4-—4-4-ONp*-cocovOsOinr—co -4" o*> in i—t r4 >4" <^ on rn p* ,-4 p-O vO sm r-ip- cm in

oo -4-tno>o-<p-cMco>tOP-coOvOcogN4»cj> vomin>j"'4"cococMCMcM^^'^oooNsQrO OOOOOOOOOO v0 »ooOO in

On On CO CO vO nJ- CMOO in CO CM CO P~ CO rH CO in ^h co -4-

cOCOcOrOCOCOCOCOCMCMCMCM"-"'-!—if-tOOOONQNoooooooooNOooooooooomm

f^oocMcoococMr*>frP-m'^mo^coooONCMP~^oooNCMvi-omp-^mo>oocMOOiHP"-ino>taNOO C\JcOP«»COrocOvOCMCMOOOONsO'-^<' 4"COOin^HOOONCM>TCO^HCOvOCM»-i^—»COCOp-t

^oO'^cOi-tNO^ino^ocooco»om>r>rcocM<^^mr^coNOCMcncoocMcx)mco>rcou>(Yi(\(oon —• ^r in r» a>o~^ como co ocm >$•>*} oo rococoro^minvOP^cocooNO'-^cMcoinp^ONOco

co • »co ••••••••••••••• »C0 •••••••••••••••••••••-"•cm OOOOOH^H<HH^c\i(Njrgcgcg OOOOOOOOOOOOH^rtH^HHNtNi

cm I O cm~* CM

CM fM CMCM CM CM

83

Page 168: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 169: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

<M cm cm cm cm cm cm <M <M cm cm cm cm <M cm (M cm cm cm <M cm cm^ cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm <^ cmcmcmcmcmcm cm cm cm cm cm cm <n cm cm rvj cm cm cm cm^ cm cmrM cm cm cm cm cm c\j cm cm cm cm cvjcm™ cmcmcmcmcmcm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm (M cmcmcmcmcm cm cm cm cmcmcmcmcm cmcmcmcmcm

00 OX m

in aoLU oor CMQ. ro

CO o3 CMCD

cc r- co(^Nor^fnrn^u^o^o^rr(<t, oor\io^'covf'a3f-<--^o(Nif\i»-'<\jO(\icooactf««.inf^vo omooo—

3e ao oo^ocMu^>o^^c^oor^cMr^<>o>Of^o^>frr^mr^oininr^incocMincocMinor^ o—toc\ioa. o in.^co>rooocooaD*or^oocMOOOrH^in.^^or^r^vtcooa3CM'^cB^NOoino p-coocmo

co >OvOinmin>f cMCM<-tocj*oor"-r-vOvO»r-t^cmcm.—lOr-f—mmcMCMOor-coaoooo mOvo^co:— • .•.•....«».*.....•.•.•.•...•.•.•...*« • • • • •

O f* CMCMCMcMCMCM<MCMCMCM'-<^^-H'-*^^'-<'-^'^-h^—«OOoOOOOOOOOOOO 000*003

cc ro oovoi^ovor^vroovr^r^^~ <»i^>rNO^^ ,^o^oju^inorgc\j^^crorsivoo'cocntPNr vro».>rooo3 -t o>o^ocMU^>o^^r^or*cMr^NOO>ocM^^tf^r^cor^oininr>->^cocM<^r^.-*>$'Ofs- r-cor»or—a. o> rno>orncooor^'^r,-vO>TinvOOh-coi^<jNOrooocoir*u^rvj^^r*Nooo>oo>-4'00(\ir*- r-coocMO

oo in>i->r-rcocM^^oocot^>o^oin<frocM^^oocov0^o^^^<^o*cov0^r^r,-coco ^vorsjr*^t— • •••••••••• • •••.••«•..•••«.•••••• » • • • •

oooooooooooooooo>oooooaooocooococococor*-i»-f-is~(^-r^r>~-r- cor-h-OvO<f>4-vt^>f^>frNtNfrorn^cn<v>rncnrnrnrorOrncOcn(^^r^ enmrnmm

'-iO^OOOOOOOOOO(MOOO(M(\IO(500^^^0(J1C,Ot?0>00(?00 ,««_l,-i(j>Q\

NOO^oocMOOCMOOCMCM^cMCMcMNO^ocMCMCMCMvO^ONOOfOrocMinrncMCMincMCM in in inooOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOCOP-COOOCOOO ooooor^oor^aDooaaascocoaacococDajajcococoascocoajGor^r^f^OTr-r^ r*-r~f— r—^»

CM CM CM CNJ CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CMCMCMCMCM CM CM CM CM CM CM CMCMCMCMCM CMCMCMCMCM CMCMCMCMCM

cc >f o(^or^r^vorw ^~<)is*r^vOvOrn^^ONOrorn>o^o>o>oooot*--H>--i(NjvO-4-oo^(\ic\i sOvO^o-*^3 -4" OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO^OOOOO CMCMCMCOrnO. i-i (m^cm^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^cmcmcM'-'cmcmcmcmcmcmcmcmcmcm 0*O*ONO, a>

z ••••••.... .....< >-> rg cm cmcmcmcmcm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cmcmcmcmcmcm™ cmcmimcmcm

MOOcMCMOinNomr—4-^r^cMr^>tu^ocMCMor,-cMr>-r--^^covOCMCMGO^v*-coocoNO m^ro^o^oo>^vor^<)OO^ir>u^incorop^cncocsj(\ifnoov0 0a*Ni-<frgvOsO-o^<)oooocornP*- .-nnsfrco-^m-4-(\jinmf\iOvf >d-omoor»f-<coino—<c\jcom>toOvO-4oooo>ococornp-*i-^- otncM^orocO(^CO-^l^-^^^inOrgc0^vO^OrgOU^NOOvOOin<f'-^0>frnLnc\|COroO^Orr|0 <tN^o-o

. ...........».*..•»................... .....o ooooocoNOu^^ro^ooor*^o^^<^njooof,-in(NifsjooN 'ninf-tf-^f*-cooy OO<--t mco"^>i-og\ ooooo*ooo,, o>oo>aococoooaooococor^r^r*r*f»-f^vONOvO v0^o voininincnNO>o -oinm>i->rm vOu^u^ininininininLnu^in^u^ininininu^ininu^inu^LninininLnu^ininu^ininLn^ mmmmin

incMO^or^o^^^^^covor^^c^vococo^incoo^ooc^co^o-^cMi^cof^sO-^ invO^cMO^ooo^cMr^^ocMo^oaj^^^cMOOT^rnin^oooinr^cocMr^-incMr- <-»in>*"'-tmcj\ —< ,—im in r» cr> in «-• *o oo in cm com a* cm o> co inm r-o r- >o in inm >*• c\j <r> .-* cmo °u in cfif-tco-^rncoin^rm•4- (rirr»mrr>ro^u>inu^^^r^cocoOOOi^CNjcMfnrn>r<>^<DCOOOcNj<\j>r>rin^ c\io>rcoo

CM 0000O0000O000 000<^^-^'-t'--l«-''--''-<»H»--''-, CMC\IC\lCMCMCMCMCMC\JCM OOUO-^r«- -o I

CM <MCM <M

vOt- CMlS) CM3 O

84

Page 170: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 171: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

mrnmmmmmmmrnm •4'^>i->i-«d->4'^'>t>t>J">t-4'«4'>t>i"^-4"-4,'«i->t>4-<t

, ^t>t^>i"-4->4-<J- ^Ovoocm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm c\i cm cm cm cm cm cm cmcm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cmcmcmcm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm (\j cm cm cm cmcmcm cm cmcmcmcm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm rM cm cm cmcmcm cm cmcmcm

cc ONincMmop-sainosO-^3 OsocMoooinoomON»-»inQ. -•m so COOCMm^sf 00 -h

somocro^cMNO^Osor—

r*-co>r>--t---4(Nr^-oo>c>o^rw rnr>-inr,»voo, t\iinaocMno>i-vOtNJQom cr-cgoooocNjc\(mr*aoa3cr>vj-co^-<a»NO%or*r^crcovi-or-o>o—t>riAO>roo inr^in>tr^oomcMC>vONO^msfmsf cmvoo cm vOcr>r-isfr*-momi--<sOi-*sf >osf p—mo>o*OsommstmcM^ocjNcor^p*>OvO*OP*p-p'»co<T»or,»p*-oooo ^oom

cocoooP-cococococoaocommmmmmmmmmm ao oo r» r* r» r— f*« p» r*- p- p» p- >oo >o <o «o vo >o >oo vO^ >o p- p- p» p- i**

mmm rnmmmm rn rn rnmmmmmmmmmm rnmmmmm rnm mmm

cc co»-H>-»cMooocMCMaosf r»3 p-mcoinp-sfp-cMvOcrrMo_ t-»sf >osfomsf cm in co cm

cmoo in "G r—oo cm cm cm rn

in soo a> u>m <7» —«o in r-» in »-* ao cm co cr>o in ooo r— oo mp*p- inh<t in^orn sO sO COO^ iM CM OO^ st rM CX> COO (7« sf in OsOsfp-CM P*r^CMCM>--i sf CMm.—

I

Q"'-*iM<7*r<»sf f-4,-<oOC0O00sQ.—tsfp—^sf in CT-^aosfco sO^^OCT> CM©mc^m^oooooNoor-minrncMCM^o^M^^^cMcMf^^r^tMCMCM sf ,-ico

00X

sOininininininxOOvOvOrnmmmrnmmmmmm mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm^crNcnmmmmmmm mmcMmmm

oo

a.

(70(7»0*OH^HOOOoocMOOminmov cy>r*00»^00^>^hOOOp* >o «o p*- p- p» r- r* r- r- p«-

p*p-p- r*-p-- so vO >o -op** NOvO^omp- in a> o<7» <^o oo <tiooo<t>o>o vOir\\0rMsfCMsfsfcOcococosfsOvO^OsfOsamsfsfmcospsfm'-^sfsfrn P-—<inoo^o^c^axoocoOTcocaaDcoooooooooO'-^'--| '-4r-<i-i^^f-(CMCM-^^-«r-t fjhoas r^P*P-P»P--P-P*P~r^r^P^P*P^r^p*cocooo coco coco coco coco coco OOO

CQ

CO

mmmmmmmmmmmCM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM <M CM CM

sf sf >t ^- sf >i- <f >*• sf >d- si- vi- -4- st vt^ -J- sf st st >t -4- si- sf st >t <J" «* stCM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM^ CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM <M CM CM fM CM CM CM

CC ~4 si- ~4 w* CM P» sf sfCM CM sf2 mmsfm cm —•—''-» cm cm cmQ. CJ» g\ g\ CT> 0> <?* C7> fj> CJn CT> <7>

mmmmrnmmmmmm

CMCMsfCMCMCJ*CT»<7«CT>sf CMCMCMCJisf (J»r^(T«P*P^<7«CMP*P*P*^P--r^0N sJ-^00u^vO^^^OOvOO^P*P*P*P^^r^P^strnmrn(^cnrnrncMCMrnrrirn rOsfs)-in in in in in in inmm in in in in in in in in in in in in inm in in in in in in sfstsfin in u-> in in in in in in in in in inm in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in p*-p-p-

< CM CM CM CM CM CM CM oj CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CMCMCM

OO

QCX

^4O 00 CM CM -^ -O COO si-OO

so p- cmmo o>ino ro inoo o> CMo rn <J. f^ cm <r cm *-*

sfrnrninsfcMa^moino

OvOOvOcnvOcoocn^^sf.^p»cMcoincy><7>ooinaovOCMooop-'CMCM<£> m-oaornoNrncMP--oocMincn~oinoooof«-p~sf mp~inp^p*<7«sfONOvOininco —iocosfp^c>c^P*cnocMroop-inp*cT«cMrncMf^^rncx3rnoinincnP*<> vOcoo—iocmoo sf o^^inocMOrninp~GOP~rn^cjNsj-oocop»p*-coincMP*" omcM

>0 CM 00 sO P- <7>O >0 P- 1*- 00mm cm cmcmcmmenmm rnin in in in in in in in in in in

m^0OCT><T>(7»00r>*insf CM^iONP-vOinsf ifilTitn>0'OP-COOOf-*(\J<M inOvOfnrg(\jH^-iHH^^H^OOOOOOOOOOOOHCMrMMC\J (TO 00inin in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in sf sf sf

mcMOcjtvOsf p- p^com —4 cm sfoinmocMo cMmoop- cm cm ^oosf coin a> in mcr» >oooO'-^ sfo r-4CMP-aosf<t voo>mcomcf<msOP~ocM p-sf ocMvO^P-<T»-^mNomsooo—(vomsrcocMm--«p-cM<T'cop»rn p-r»int— mcMCMmmp*-cMmcosro,''-HCMP*cT«'^m>ooovommoooNomcr>rncosf r—aomvomo i*» ,-, 0'-tO'-*sQ^<cMuj cMsfsOP~ooo>-^p,-p*cooo cM^-»sfmmmmvOP*co<T'0>>o<-''-HCM<Mmmmsrsfm-op-mmvOvO ommx ..,m. ,.,.. #••••••••••»••• #m • • .

(— ^^4^4^H^l ^f\n\4C\jCMCM OOOOOOOOOOOOH^HH^HHHH^HH^CMMrMCN OOO<T> I sfcm mCM CMCM CM

85

Page 172: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 173: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

tnNOinir>vO*OvONO>ONO>o vO >o>Ovc*o«o ,OvO'0*o*o»oo*ONO>ONO vOvO N r—p— p*-p^p"-p»p^p~p»-p~-rs-p,»p—cmcm cm cm cm <m cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cmcm cm cm cm cm cm cmcm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cmcm cm cmcm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm

cc cMincnp^>ocoococovOCT>>ocMNOOcoaocoincM'-*cocMincMONf--ieocMOO3 tr»mr«-m(\icoo>omooN vOsrao(Ni<^>rf-<-4-cocN(\jcomvO'-tOf\j^ooo_ cm cy> >o rnO co in in r^ <7* *h >4* r^ ooO cm in coo~* enoca in «^0>vO cm Q^vOrn

>rcnenrnrncMCMCMCMCMcnrnrnrn>4"^^^rinininininvOP,-''Ocoa,>c\o*-4

mooom cmp*- in *o cm co *oo>4" c\j r» cx> p»c r- nJ- >r p^o vr c\i

r-p^r-r-cocococoaooocoo>o^

m inm in in inm inm in in inm in inin in in in in in in in in inmm in in >ooen en enm co com rom eo co ro com ro ro co ro rom rn en rn en en en en rn encom

mmmmmmmmmmmmmm rnmmm rn rnmmm rnmm

cc ^<^in-H^^vn>r>rcrc\jr\jcoinr-o»o^^-^rnrn>r ,oinininc\j rH^-(in'-'co

3 0*^»-iOP^mP*in»-^OO^NO>fcjom0^minc^mcMO^>4"P'-mi-«*4"rMCMCMa. r^inc\ja»incjNO'^rninr*0(^^>ocr^>^vOr^c^^>l"^r«-in(\icoinr\ia>

^o vO >o in in -4" in in in in in -o ^o »o •& >o r- P» P- r— r» co coo t*o ~h >-• <N rn rn

cm^ rg u a i-4^ _to in vo cr> ao >rm>ro>oo(Mf\!a«o^^rnooonO r*o rn r» r* r- p* coom in cor-p-cocoaocococoaoo>>o>o>Q>

00X

cm cm cm rg <\j rsi cm cm c\i r\j CM cm cm c\j cm cm c\j rvi cm <ni (\j cm cm egcMCMcnmmmmmmmm enm rnmm rnmmmmmmm rnmmmm rnm en rnmmmmen

ooooooooooooocnmcnrnmrnrnmmrnmmm

00IDcca.

CO

z>CO

in in >©m in -o r— co p- r*» co cj* a> o>oo o* o>oo cy> o^ e/>o o^ o%o *-« ono »-<

o> o> r- o> onm rn r*»m ~h o>m p-m <4" (M in in cm «$ in r— in >tmm^o in cmcoo^o& o^ o>o cm en en -4"m >t >4"^in in in in in in in >*• inm inm in -c in >oo(?O(J>0*^OOOOOOOOOOOOOooooooooooooo

sOO^OO^O^Oi—li-4CM>-Hi—!»-•»-•C7>r— vOOCT'vO^^J'CO^vtCM^•OO^O^COO^Ot—• >—»«-i«^0«—'«—

I

m rnm rn en *4- >t >fr -4" -4- >t >t -4"

in«oinmvOvO*0 N >ONO vO^O vOvO vO v0^o ,o >o*OvO sO vO ,o*OvO v0^o*OvO>oCM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM

r- Is- p» P- r- I

s- r— p- r» p- P- r* p-CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM

cC3a.

<

vO-t<D^^co>oc^Na--tr^o>r*c^ocMr^p^cMor^r^r*-or*r-ocMr--ocMin >^- in inm >f cmo -"oo &> a> <> a* on co coco co q\ co s co co cj> co co co r—•4" 4" «4" >4* vf >4- >4" >4" >J" >3" ^" CO co ro ro eo co ro CO eo CO CO rnm en rn en ro co co ror^ r- r* r- r* r»- r— r- r~ r- r* r* p- r* r- r«- r- r- r- r- r- r*r-r-r-r^r-r-r*-r-r-••••••• •••••CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM

—^nOO^vO>^'O vOvO'-*'>00>>0<>vO^ r^ f*. ao r*- >om in in in -o in insomininmintninminininin0>CJN > OCJs >>CN0> 0^0^CJ^0> >

'

CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM

00Z>CCX

vOOO^r-ooHO<ta*vOcrj(?vOOor«jvOc,oa*uMn-"0'^r-inoo«o>omo r-t ~* q\ vO ino a> o^ r* co co f-*o r*. p«-o en cm inmooo *o o> en en phm rn cr*m 4-oo cm no rn >o I

s- coo r-* cm o> o> cmco -4- r— r— eno -h <t> cm «t f* cmo ^o —Ir— cm egm no co <-*m o> co in co cm in <?> ro in r-—tin in >*• ^^ inm in in -o

>jTMOOC^C0CMmOmCMvj-rno p- -h r* -4*o -4* in -ho cr> r- r»r«- rnm >o in a^ ao co ^- cm o> >o p*-

•o co en nO cm cm cm enm Is- <-• in s

4- rnm cm cm -^^ *-* —> cm cm cm en en rn >t 4" <4*m in in >oo p* ao ooo <-• cm en >tcocsoocococococoooooGooooococooocoaocococoaocooocoaooNO^ONONON>t <t >4" <f -4" -4- -4- >t >fr -^ 4" <4" >T »t >t vf >4" <f -t -"4* -4- >t >4" >f >t -4" >t <f «4" 4" >1"

mm -o ^o p*- p— r*. r- p— p»- co co oominminininminminminin

LU

X

>4* r** *-*>oo co fH -^ —*mco o^ ^cmo in co >r oeoo eo srmp»oo^oovO>o cm >o cmo cm p* eop- cmmc^eomocnro<)or^rororo^^ONp^r,-cM'>o>i" >4"^4"0«4'aop*r*rncMin»ro"--»inoo ONf-to^-^OLnen—^mo^m«4*o co —* en o> cm >r inooo en <o co ct> cm in oo i-hcmm >o ct> r- >3* oo oo *o eno r* i-h ct> <tm p- r-»cnen>rmincO'-'>j'sOvO>or^r*p^oDooooa30>ONONO> o^ooo^'^^'^'-icMrnrn>4'invOP>-p>- cMrnmm^r^-r«4, >4'^>4"min

OOOOOOOOOOOOOOO' .ml c

vO>4"

CMCM

ooooooooooooo

86

Page 174: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 175: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

r^-r— r^r— r— r^-r*-f— f*~r— r— r— r— r— r— r— r—p— r— r— r— »— r— r— i— i— r*— r*- r*- r~- r— r— r— oooooocococococococococm cm cmcm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cmcm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cvj cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cmcm cm cmcmememcmcmcmcmcmcmcmcm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cmcm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm

cl co^mor^incoinr-«.-^ocM»-*invOOO>4-oo>r»nm<MmsomvO'-iin>4"OCM3: cMin>f vommmoinr^>ror^i^cMin>oin'-<ocMCM^>j-r--oinmminoincoa. r^m vOo cmoo ^cm -4-r^r^ ajin00 vomor*->4-NO<>co00 cm cm ^in^or*-—<o

oooo —1 »-t cm cm c\j cm c\im >4*m in -o f-* 00 aooooooooooooo—* 1-4

ooommsoco*o^mmm^r—covocoo^'-'coooO (T) 03 -J f-H f-i r-( CM C\J rO f\)

-HCMenor—cooO'-^cMm

fH >t >r -4- nJ- >f^^ >r <4- >r <4" <4- 4" -4- "fr4 «4- «4- >t >t4 «4- »*" in in in in in in in in inrn f*lm (*1 rOmm rnmm en rnmmmmmmm en rnm en rn rnmmmmmmmm CMCMCMCMCMCMCMmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

a. omcj>^mNTO^c\jcMinrMCM>oo\00«^co^m^<M^r-cor»»or-crcnm>T'2 r

>»00*-«OOOin.-*cn'-Jr"»mr^Of-im>4'Or"-00»4'<-tinincMCMOmr,-«3- r-a. f^coo>^r^cMini^o^<MCMCMO^>r^ooin'-*ooo^rON}-inr*-r--a»o^-icMvOin

oo^«-^t-»tMr\jcMCMrnrn<rinin'or*-r*-ooo^cT>oooooooo^^«-ti-H^

m>rc/*covocr>Ni-coinmin«o —4 in r»m aoo cmo cm »*•

o^ocMCMCMmmm-rmoo^^m-or-cooo^-i

00 ^^-i^^.-l^^^^^*^^^^-^^^^—•^CM'MCMCMfMCMCMCMCMCMCMCMCMrnm rn rnmm rn rn rom rn rn enm rnm rn rom rnmmmmmmmmmmmmm COOOOOOOOOOO

(M CM CM CM CM CM CM <M CMm rn

</> pncM«^cgi^cncMCMCMCM-^«^cMCMCMF^>^invrcMrn>r^fnrn>rcMrncMcn<rcn<rUJ 03vrOCM>OOOOOOOOOCM^COOOa3CMCMC»CMO^CMCMvrvOCMCO^OO>OCM-OCMcl cM>^<MCMrncMCMCMCMCMcnrncMCMcncn>^^^>trn>^vrrn^Lnrn-r>d->r^*rinCL -4-Nt>fr444>rvr<^>t44>t>fr>4-44>f >4•^r>t4>t>t44^f-4•^4-«4•<^>4•

>4m^ooo•-^cMmmmmrncMcoaomrnommr»r-r^r^omcnvOvOcocooo^ir»vOoO^OvO>OvO-OvONO

co

DCO

r- r» r- r— r- r— r— r*- f*» r«- r— r- r— r«- r— r— r- r— r- r- r— r«- r- r*- I

s-f-rT- r^r-r-N-r*CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM <M CM CM CM CM CM CM CM<MCM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM

cocoaoaocococoaocococoCM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM

CL3Q.

<u_

o I-* >t"o <4" •—1oooo <4" r-4oo *-o 4* •—1en •—•-4" »—

•»-« •-* .—t %o 00 -o >o -4*o •—* «o 00

N^u^>r>trn>tcnrnfncncnrncnrncMrncM<^cMcM(ncMCMcn^ocMr^cM<^cM^oin inm in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in tn in in in in in in in inm in in in to inoooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooCM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM

vO inor-o r- «t ao r- cmor^rncMOOOOaococOvO0000>O^COCOC003cOCO

rn enmmmmmm enmm

3ctX

COCM^vOO (MNOminm>4-^r-(Ov*-OOOOr»-OCMCOv£)fHr1-QOOCO<MeMr«-mmrn 03 vO COO >0 COO <-H inO in CMO COOOO CM vO CS vt <3O in CM r*-m CM P^ nO vf CM>4-vOO>COr*c\iOO->0>i"OmOin^OCMOOCM^OO»-4'^»OincOr«-r»-(MCM>tm co cm f*- ino cm -^oo in vO cm ^o r»- r*> co 00 co r-<^ >j- in co •"-• m >j" vO co >^m

m in »-t —* *t Is-m vj- cm j- -o

>0 f-ooo co cmoo evjeo

vONomomvor-covOOm^^^rcomcomco>rom

oooHHtMroefifCircifOin>oNco^o^(\jffi>i"t+^^ in in in in in in vO-0in *o >o >o ^o^ >o *0^ >o >o vO >0 >0^ -o r—r^r^-r-r*- r*-r^r«. fs. r«»r*. r».r«. r^rwr— r*»

4"^ "4" ^- <T »* •* -J- 4" >t >*• >r -J- -T <J" vl" >*• <f >t >*• -4- "4* >t* "4" 4" <t >* >t >t >d- <r >j-

coo cm in f- coo <-*m -4-ofMmmmmm-^^^^^•4- >t 4" >* <r >t 4- -4- ^" 4- <r

r^cMOmm^or^incx)0>ooo4"cor^cMOu^O'^cMmooincocM»-imomcMm'-tOLnr>-L*\cO"--t>t'mr-moocor^>tmcommmcMminocMr^coin>i">^omr^r»-'-^'-'»4"ino^rcooosom>rcMo-4"OinvOoinr^cM>oca^Hf^O'^m^o»o>omr^coincMO<)minincocx)<JmcMininooo3CMm^ocMcMr^<"mso o^r^r^cocococccooooi^c^jmm>i-inininininvO>o>ONO^^^r^r^o^o ,^cMm^u^in-or>-r*-

<LUX •••p- uooooooouooo<

>m«<->oo000000000m 1 1

mCMCM

87

Page 176: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 177: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 ^Ox^OSO^O^G^O^O^^O^C^O^^O^G^cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cmcmcm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cmcm cm cm cm cm cm cm cmcm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cmcm cm cm cm cm cm cm cmcm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cmcm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm

ad oor-or-inoococM>i-ONcovor-coo>rcoaOr^inino>ON2 co-^m>©<^r-\ooocM^gNONm«oa>oc\jc\joo(T>is-ir\in

-r >*• nT >}• in inm >o ^o r~ r* r- r^ ao coo a* <r> r»- >i- (\joo co

OslC0>J-C0C0NrvONO—<^<30^00COC\|\s\ cm r-t r-t vo c\i r- r—o co ro r- >a- vu in enIs- <n c\j -^ c\j rnm >4" in in in voo co r* egco O^ co —i -4" in «o r— co O^ t-*m sf cm cm —i

ro com co CO rn rO ro ro co co ro rn ro CO rn rom ro co CO ro ro cmrococncocornrncornrocorocororororororocorocococo

QQ _| f-* _| —4 _| _4 r-l r-4 CM CM r-4—4 r-l r-4

ro ro rn ro co rom ro ro co ro co co co ro rn

ac -^oA o«rrooc\j<jir\oomsorooc^tr, >rrorgr-cocou>vO3 —t*000*TCMr^>$->rvO>Oro-4-OOrOinOvOr-r-CMrHO>o. mc\i'^i-tcococominrv4CNjCT>c^NO^ocM20<-«0'-trsir-t.^<\j

rvj c\i ro ro ro ro ro nJ- vj- in in in in vo <3 f* r- r- no «no oo oo vO

>rir\fHsOO<J>r-orn-*cj>r—ONOir\r—ao cm »* roo in -* cmo oo a* ro >* -o >*or- rom cm >r<m >o r- ^oo co r-t o> oo ro>t in a> r«-o •-» cm co >r in r- cr>o oo co r-

xooooooooooooooooooooooa>ofO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO i^> CO CO ro COCO CO CO CO CO CO fO CO CM CM CM

r>" r— r— r— oo co ao co co co co co oo r— h- Is*

CM CM CM CM CM CM <M CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM <M

to COri-(T>^00<-«<J>ON'-400NCMOO'-*rOOC>Or->OCM<J>lu r-r-4ro.ooo^ocorOvOCMco>rrocMaoococoinvr>tcvimcc (MCMmmvOvOinmmin«omNOmsOvOr»-vtco>rf-i>}-moa. r-.r^r^r— r^r-'r— r— r^r^r-r^r^r^r^r*-r-p-f*-vOvOininin

cMvOcMO^inNomvoocroma^NrcMo a*o coo oo cm oo >*• -c cm »hmcrmmino co in on o> «-^ <-»—^ cm vO in cy cm ao in^* vO vO %o vO >o r- r- r— r— r- h-m -omm

co

CO

coaooococooocococoaocooocococococococococoGOcocoCM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM<M CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM (M CM CM CM CM CM

or: ONCMr^-vOinin^P-r-vO^I-r-rnr-^r^oOvO^r-r-^ro3 v0r"-inmmmmmmmmininininininv0>0O'-<*4">3"^0a. co oo oo co co coco coco co co oo oo oo co coco co oo <J\&&&&

co co ro cm oo in <j> sO co ro r— cm <r> -4" ro insO Or- oo OnO inmmmro^c o» —icmcr- cjn co ao co co co co co oo oo co o» coO &rOrOrocOrOfOrOfOromrocOcorororo

<_

rOrorOfOCOrOromrOfOcOrncncOCOco.-ocOcOrorOcororO forornrncocococnrommromcororo

1/7

X

CO COO >* o> >-* <T> i—1 0> CM CO CNJm vO 00 -O 00 ^OO rooom <-•

o<ocomr-mcMocoaNmcococMNj-coa»mmoaoco<j-occcMm>om(M'-<ooNOvCm'0^mcocjNr«-sj-0N r-as r-cor-r»O^OOO^OHH^r^^^OCM?r<iinNUMr\cO

r-t -* a>o r~- »-• r— cm co co cooQ cmO ^tvOr»vj-r»rnmos Ntr>-inincM<7*0'-*co>—•—<>0^rri0«000lfi^i-ivfr-tcomo oo r- vo ro cj^ ^- —• r»» -^ -^m o^ cmo r*-

r«- r- oo cooo© rn r-t cm cm ro co >3" >tmm >t" ro r-^ —• iH co>f>r<">rmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm>r-T>t>rco>t >i" «4- ^-^ -^ >t >r <r -J- <r^^ >*• ^- -t -^ >f <fr^ «^- 4* 4* -j-

r-r—room voco o-^rOvOo >f focooO O -^ r-t r-i r-t i-4 CM CM CM CM CM i-* <-* i—t f-*

oo >-< co ao cjn o^r ocj* on -r f-t r* co r-moo r^ror-*>oorHco«d-NO co cm co co r-mco co cm co cor- oo %*•

< r^cM>4"^Oi-(CMmoror-—<r-Ovov, cocMm>rco ,TcooN co cMor-vOONfOcMNOOO^vrNjT-cocMr-ii_ r-r— >T^r-ir^^Hooco>rmrHCMc»ao>urocncM>ror^r-rOrHc^mrnoocOrHON<)^r-ii^r^LU 00C0 fJ>0\oOOOOr^r-tCMC\JCMCMCO-4-mN00N '-'CMCM^ >f rOOr^Or-tr-^CMcO-^mr-OOrHCMx • tfO

H^HH^Hr4r^rJ-H^H-JH(\f\JMrvl OOOOOOOOOOO OCM CMCM CMo i i i r

oooo>

CMCM

Page 178: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 179: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

fjxtn N N N N N 0^<T>0^00 0>a^O^O^Cr>(T>0N Ox ON CTs (T'O^ONa' ooooooooooooo_4og —i—rf^,-*^^,-^,-*,-!,^,^,-^^—j^-h^-j-*—4^.-*—4-4 cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cmmm mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm mmmmmmmmmmmmmcmcm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm rg cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm

ct >-*f0 -4*o o> co <T> «4- cr» f-i r*- o>mo r» vj-o^o -^^ ooMamNjro3 coo orsjmo>>rp*vorsiONOooocoNOC7>'0(Ma^(Nimr^crirna. coo —<mo>rncnmi>.omr^cnooo—4eo>rcMr-o^o^o>.^.-4e<'i

>i"co -4Tnfvjf\jocovom(7>r-m^-40covo>for-mmcomovf

>$• CT>O cj>Om egm cmm& -j-mooor*-mro(\j>Or^ornm^oo0>^0>-4"^CMCM>r—4tnr—.^0f-*ocr>0N r—inro—4CONO^rnaN

cor- mmrnrnmrvjcMcg^^-^^-^oooooo^o^cocooor*vO vO »o >o vO >o >o -o no vOoo -o >o so ^o vOmmmmmmm oo& a* ct^ cj\ <?> r/> co co co oo r»

sO^ommmmmmmmmmm

oo

a-z.

o

CC

3Q.

00X

—4cn cNcocouAxo^ofNjvoc^^^Jor-^roNOvOi—io>rmrnr-cr>COO m-OO^OCNf-tr-romF^m^rri^^vj-Or^^r^OtNJ^-vOmc/> coc\ir,-t-tOromr*>m'4-*omr*-fj\^-t(\40>j-is->or,-ocoor— cm so^inmm^-tcj^ri«(NOco>^c\ioa>r^moooNO'-^r»-cviP-

—4m

>o c*m >r eg co co co >ro eg r-omm c\i—< co (*- -4 >om ct^ -^ vO rncomcomo>o^f\jo^rng3CMr»—4 .-ioo r- no >r egco r*-mmo

^ FH^^^i t^OOOO^0v C*OC000c0C0r»NNv0v0^vOvO^vOOvOvO^oo-o^inmmmmmmmmmmmm

cocoaocor— p^r—r—vOvOvO-OvOmmmmiAmmmmmmmm

mCM

LU

o<

ooUJ

o.

CO

3CO

oo .-*cM—4CMCMCMoe>>rm(N<NmNr>f sOu^^i^vOvirnmr-moo m—^m i-i r^r^r-mr- -^ •-'•—'rnmo^>-4m i-4o>m s '^rnsfOO —i—4^cmcmcm-^cm—4 eg eg ro cm cm on rn en corn en cm on I

s- inoo ooooooooooooooooooooooo<-4oin-HCM

r«-cococor'»cococor— coo^c^O"^eg co oo co c\i co co co rg co >J- >t -4-

HOHl-<t—

4

l 4i 1—4—I—4—4.—>^Hcncncnenonenencnoncncncnen

OJ\ O^O^O"* O^O^O^ s eJ>Os 0^CJ^C7^0^O> 0^<X, CT, O>, A CJ^Q^0>, OOOOOOOOOOOOOegcMCMegoMCMOMCMCMCMegcMeg

Xo

00 UJ>cc3

a: ooLUOO3UJOctQ-O.

i— ooOco1-3

CO»>

muu—i

uuoo

3"-ioa:

LL>

a:

Q.

<

003a:x

<UJX

oo eg eg eg en on en eg en cm on en on en on >*• on >4" en -4-^ en on r—«4- ooom in coin in in oo in p—p-p*-oo mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm-o ^in^^^^^^^sr^^!-^eno eg cm eg eg eg cmcm eg cm eg eg cm eg eg eg eg cm eg eg eg eg cm eg eg —4^4»^^-ir-4^-*—4^^—4^-4—4,—i—^r— sO e^P^r^P^r^P^P^P^e^p^P~P^P^P^P--P"-r--P'-r*-P-

»P"-r*"-P',-P'- 0> c* O CP* CP1 Cr> C* CT> 0">OO 0*1O

OO ooco>oc\ioorgr--m—taocoo>i-vOO>OvOrsivOcgmo—*mOO OOcom^T-fMOmmO—4OgDOO(r)00rvJ0>Orgm>l-OO moomeMin^cocMonr^ooa3en>ocOsOenegr"~p"-o> p<-cr'<\i

00 Ofsimco—^QO-^Tgr^sorvJO^vOcNjco-ro^^rnvO—4cgo—

4

sOm >o —4 00—4 egm rg vto somoo >^ ro eg r>- >o r* co—1 vO rnen >o o> <n 00o -^ en—4 r-o—1 vf^p-OvfrenCP-cno^vOinrg—4vO

mo -4-rnrsj»-io> >0^'f\imrgo>tegOf»«moN -o^''-4mOrnvoOvO ooooaN 0>C7N o,'cococor>-r^r«->O vutr\mmm>j">jT*,>eg

co>t oocooooOr^P*r^r^P^l^r^P^P^P^r^r^P^P^r*-r"»r*-r*-r*r-in in in in in in «4-vr Penmen enp— p— r- p- p- I

s- Is- r* I

s- r- P- p» P*-

—400 cmen vf in on inrn—4 >^om >^om rn c\j -^ >o od 1^ -^r- r^mmc\j 00r>-o eg rno^ -4" 00 ^-4rg^o>J"00 >r cf en cj* 00o en^*o oco eg q>>q eno^-<r en ine^ in «4-co op-^o^inr-rj*—4cor»en>r

-*oin'^c^oegcnor*-enQ>p«-cnco—4r*->3"—4aommc\jrn<j^a»o> cof^mvocoois"rn'«r>maN >J"'-4coiNropw ro-j-^^mm^^cocTxj*—•—4cgr4immvOf*"Coo(Ni^vO mmmNf>rmmvor*-coo>cr>—

4

m • roorg oooooooooow-

m mc\j CM

>rn4f\irgrgrg ooooooooOOOO-

rg

mCM

89

Page 180: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 181: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

ooooooooo HHH-JHH^H-HH^-i^H^HHHH-<r-( mmmmmmmmm rnmmmcm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm tM cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cmin in in in in in in in in in in in in in in tn in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in incm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm

CC >T(N0>C0v0<T'vOC0«O

p»-»rmoNincoNfoo

*omcMininvo«j-o^ONooincMr— »i-m^op*-mp>-com r*» cmo r- <o >t nom o>m -0o—• -o o> >o cm cmmoo «^ o> -4- >-* in o>m cm com •—io in -4- cm inm >o—•r—>rmcMCMOoovOincMO<T>o3incoom^o>mrMCM

>J- sO vO r- ON 00 <o Is"o <-• CM CM CM

v£> rt) Q\ rr> >r ro CM CM On <m^^ -J-

vo cmr-m rn oo en oo oo vj- ooo tnp-p—vONO-^cM—iONOinmcMoo

r- p*» r*»oo inmm -4"

minminmininminv0^o>oo>ommmtnin>i-^>t«4*^"cnmcMCMCMcMin in in in in in in in inm in in in in in in in in inmm

,-4,^_i»^.—t_4-^ooooooin in in in in inm in inmining

cc r-p-cMr-f'-^<-^^rcocr>

3 CO CO CO CO CM >0 00 CM COo_ p^^o-a-oo^vr-oco

oom >ro vo CMn—i r*

vomovrtninmoooNr^inf-tNocMCMo—^Nr^op*•mp*-cMOP*-^o-f ,>olnoNm^o>o•-^ >ooN^ocMI—icmonoo cm r— cm o>m r** <-•o vom o> com cmom—< >r cr> >fcm cm^^ oo r^»m -^ ^-i on co vOm cm on >ro oo cmo r^

ominr^oo>rmcovt}mmm'-i»ro -J3 —* —•o on oom oo I

s-oor*-mco»r^ONmcooN>rcoi-ivOmmcMCMOco^-mcM»-^ONco>i-

Xmininm^mmmcMinminininmintnin

^- <J* >^- vtmmmmm cm cm cm cm cm^ i-i—•ooooininmmmmmmminminuMnmmminminm

ONONONONONQOaooococor*-r,»r*-

>t <4" >fr "<t -4" <f -t -4" ^" -J" -4* sj- sj-

(/) oNcooNONoor^i^>o^-lu -rco^-vtcocM^sOrg

a. mmmmmmmmcM

ON —<O ON ^-* ON ON f-^ ON -^ ON »—•ON ONO ON s ONO CO COmNOcMmvommNom*om\ommcMminincMP*-p'-ONONONONONONONONONONONONONONONONcococor*-r«-p- p«- (s. (*. (*- r^ r*» p»f— p- r- r» h- r— r- p- r* i«* r- r- p-

o on on —• <r>oo ooooo oo coonl*»OOinO(TiO*\tCT>vt^>1"C\JOOOOOOnOnOnOnOnOnOnOnp^ p— r*» p» h- vQ >o no vO & >o ^o ^o

CO

CQ

oooooooooCM CM CM CM CM CMCM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CMCM

mmmmmmmmmmmmmCM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM

cc iN-mc-r-incocMf-ico •—»o cmhOi-i-»ohohoh^cm^nOnO on •—••-• v^-^.—iso^^4">4-on>$-ononon*-43 «4->4"<J->j->4-^inmm ooooooooooooooooooo^h cMmmcMmmmmmmmm^tQ_ -ihh^-h^HHH CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM Q-O 0> On On On 0> O* On On s On O

on o> on on on on on on on ,-1^,—t^^,-i,-i r-H,^«-j,-4f—i—>i •—4 >—*^^ —* *.* r-* w* mmmmmmmmmmmmm-z. • • t ..... .

< ^^^-l^^^^^_l_4-4 CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM <N CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM

00

X

mo oo cm so no in >i- r-4"mm cm som on cm rosOvO-OfN-sOrN-cOsOCMmo—-»>f r*-<-<onqno

C0»tCM«-<C0r^vtCMOOv0c0>0CMOOO0000>i'O*-*oo com on r-« r— cc\o o>m -4- onm >* -o <-t cnjmm oor-m —4 vtm >j- cm >o --* ^" r*- oom cm >to >t cm ao vt coin co r-4 vj-m -4"m cm cm >4" vo co oo co oo rH cmm co on vo

>i- como no r*-m coo onoo si-

r—ONsomr*-mmr-4i—iON<N>top-om nj- >t r-o -j- cmono on mmo^cocMCMmmininm^vO

oo -4- cm p— cmm i*- cm coCM CM CM —•—4O ON ON COr*-p— p» r» r*» r- %o ^O >0

P*- vO nO lA CMO 00 vO CMO CO vO CMo ^oom CM <i- cmmoooooo on on cjn on oo co oo co r*- r* vO no in in inh«.p"-P

,-p"-p«»p''»v0>>0 NOv0 v0NO vOs0 ,OvOv0vOv0NOvQ

mmcM—^ONp*-mmoNp«»mmco^^^^mmmmcMCMCMCM-^>0>0'OnO vOn0^ vO vO xO vO^OnO

LU

X

oincMONaoooooNmcM^(OvocM^oincMo>m^incMON^ou^vONOooinmoocM<)o>rp*>rcMoo>rcomoN>4"mcomomoor-co^T ON-4CMmoooovO>r>roNm-«f ^ooocMOP—oom^o ONCMmoN>rocor~mo*or^ONon cm ocjn p«.mm >j- >r —• <j> cm ^t so «4*»-i «j u*\ tr> so >r ~*p* in onp^if^somm cm t-*m ,ocoO'-HONso -rooomm on

^m^inp—-Hmmp— cMmmm-^inmNor^cooNO'-icMmNoaNONCMm^ mmm-^-vniAvOp^ONONO-^cM• ••••••• «m .................... »m. ••..••••.•••^^^H^j^(M(\jrMf\| OOOOOOOOOOOH^HHHH^o«J(\J(\j OOOOOOOOOO--*^—

I

CMinCM

CMinCM

90

Page 182: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 183: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

m crimenmmmm >tsf >*">4">t^ >t>frvf>t>^ ^>4">t^vfr >t >$•>* -4* >r>a- >$•<} >4-^"<l-^>t v00>0>oinincm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm CnJ cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cmcmcmcmcmcmin in in in in in in in mmmmmmmmmmminmtninininininininininintninininin inininininincm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cmcmcmcmcmcm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cmcmcmcmcmcm

3 mm>rmcooincoo_ comrs-rs->4'mcMcr>

sOm—'•"-< cm -4" in in

f-i^^o>mcMni-tCN(T><NJ'—iocM«oinommej»<—toin^co>o^cMOin mr—cMin.—tr-opinmcom>^oo-*ho mao-ocMr—m^i-nn^coo ooomcoo o^^cornr-oo^ir\^omr-t^3f-nna^rr»r»-.^c\jrn>}"omvOO—^>oo^os cor^> >f s p— (\jOvOfnoo<t(^<MvO\Oinmsi- ror-i^ooso^mrvj^^-i—<^-ic\jcNjrsic\im-4"mvO>or,~ cio^onHH

Q^O^OcjncTiOno^O^ o^ cj\ co co co oo co co co p— Is- I

s- p-r- r- Is* p- p— I

s- p- p- Is- I

s- r— p- co co oo co>4- >4- -4- -4- -4-^ <f -4- <f -4- >d- -4- vj- -4- vj- -4- >3- vj- ~d-^ >* -4- <f -t >t >4- <i- >t *4"

vOOinminm^ >t <*->*• -4- <J-

cc o«-»co-*>rincMin3 a^O^'-t^OaOfONOa. comoocoinmmo

cMC^r-p-coo^cM

mg>iooo^O(\jcoir\m(>»tr>m!^vO'-<rvj»TO-ro,«cof\jvOi

rcna*'-• cmcj».-iu>u\«-«

mcjNCjNp->cM>ors-mmmmcMmoco^cMO^.-tr**.^p*-inP-'r,-»oo-4'NO *o*omp— -ninrna^co>toinoino>ror--»-Hmr-r*-coinp^-^>i-vOO-<rfncMrvj(^^-^ coincMco>ro^•^^ooo^^f-^^MHO^r-^ininin^-ooh-roco^ooHCM tncMCMnvrm

OOX

p—'O^-O^OvOP'-P^-P*"<* «* «4" <4- -4- -4- vt -4- >t 4* «* >4" >T >* <f >t <4" -4" sf >t <J- >4-* >t <4" -J" -*• -4- -4-

mmcMcMCMcM

OO (JM>^^Qp^OOlu cMCMintncr»moNcj*ct o^^ooo^ooo_ vO^p-p-p-p-p-p*-

osr-.^rs-OvOv0^ot*-mr->oir\mmmr*-oo<7>c7>oN ocooo^oo^co vO-o^inininOvt(M(\l00C0C0v0<4-ONrN0OOOO(Nrr)rr)^-vfvf^cOr-tNO-^Nj-cO r-inmO^O*O0^O0N C0C0C0C0C0C0C0C0C0C0C0C0O--i'Hr-i<-«<-tCMi-4CNiC\JC\J^-tO .-(0000s-

s

oop-r-r-p-p^p-p- r^r-f-r^r-r^p-r-oo coco coco coco coco coco coco oooo^ocr>

co

CO

mmmmmmmmCMCMCMCMCMCMCMCM

>4- >4- >t >J- -i- -4" >3- >J-^ <f <f^^ <f >t -4- -t >t -4- >4- -J" >t >t <1- ^- >!• >J" -4- vfCM C\J (NJ CM CMCM CM CM C\| CNJ (\| <M (M <M CM <\| eg C\| CM C\J (M CM CM CM CM <M CM CM CM

vO^o^o^oininCM CM CM CM CM CM

a:

a.

<LL

-H fl vO >0 CM P»- CM CM4* -4" CM CM CM i-l CM CMo^o^o^o^o^o^o^c^mmmmmmmm

r^cM>t>4"^<^o^cM^cjN>^cMc>(^<^<^cMa>aNr^r^r,-o>>cMO^cMc>(^-^ -j-co.-ivO'O^o^^vOvO^^OvOr^r^r^r^i^r^f^r^p^inmrnmrococMfncMCMcMcn^' mvi-tninininm in in in in in in in in in in in in ir\ in in in in in inm in in in in in in in in Nj-vf^-^^Nfinintninininmmmmmmmmminmmmininmmmmmmmin P-r-p-p-r-r—

CM CM CM CM CM <M CM CM CM CM CM CM CM (M CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CMCMCMCMCMCM

00Z>CCI

cM*4-«ocomco>a-oOcoooOOvf^vfo^rnaor-vQcoocMmCOP—p— P— -^rnm

>0CMC7>Or0inCMCM^0CM>-tCMOtnmv0s0cnCMC0ins*-CMC0s0P~-Nj->0C0 OCOOvO^l-vOco^^o^cMaocoONrH-^^-^^-m-Hmp-tmr^vO^cMvOO^mNO^- <t~t~t~**tcoocMNO^CMmco<»c>^mmcop^p-->tcMaocjN-otnin«4">j-cM^-

tv-oo^-t mvi'0>>cM.-*O

m(^P^CMsOOmmcMCM-^OONinrO'-<r*-0>4'ON'-*r,-CM>t, vOCJ^r--«t^- ^cOvf^-ifMvO

i—It—lOOi-li li IfH

vO»O sO vO'>O vO vO xO

cocooocjNO>cov0^cMocomrncM^Or-t^-i^-icMcMcn-4"inc^o<-i<M cocriOMnmcMr^oooa»c^<>c^cj>c^cj\cococococococococooococococoo>iocjo vo^uininmin>o-o^OvOininininininmmininmminmmininininmLnm>o^oo inmmmm in

coommr^>rcomcMCMO^ocM>oomcavocMOcocovO>^Or^covor^covom>roo^mmcMm^^m'^fO< cocM>rv3->r^f-io mmmmoomo<rmvo*o>or^r^m>ocom>TCM*ocor*»comis-vo tup*- m<"cOvfcoot— r^ma>u>vo-^com'Hrs-mmr—cr-cMincMcjco^^ '-•Ovj, coH>Tr,-0'^ir\coinmrMp»r-i>oHor-mors'0lu ^iin-o>or»o>c^o rs)^^>r>f^ir(mvor^f*-coc^o-^»--t'^cMCMCMrr>cnmcn>4"m>r^"inm o—immmsox ••••••• «m • •••••••##••## iiti

h ^^^_4^^,-4rM OOOOOOOOOOOO^HH^HHHr^^HH^t-i(MMNCg oooooo<J> I

Is-

CM CMm mCM fM

91

Page 184: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 185: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

mir\>o>OvO»o*0>oo>o>OvO*o*o»o>o>OsO\O*OvO r-«.r«»r-r«»p— p»p«-p»-p*-p— p—p^p-p-p-p-p^-p-p— p»-p«-p*- p-CM CM CM CM CM CM <M CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CMCM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CMininmmminminmtninmininmmminminm ininininininininininininininininininininminmcm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cmcm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm

cc CNj«-*coro»-< ,o*'"*»,,*'^'f'»*0'^'"Ht-»com»-4omf«?'""3 rnsO>3"<Jcocom—<vo^ocomrooooa*r»--^vocoa. cr>>j-o^om>o>ra3p-tinrr)NOO'4T^-vomrofO(M^(

oo oo <^ c^ C7>oo rH r-< <\j t\j rn rnm nJ- in r^ co cro

r-t r*-oo -rm <f ^o a^m o> >4" f\j <r>o ^- cm co o> *f in -o rnoom^ co p-m r«- co o> -J

- r- r- co r-o in -4 rvin en vo o>m -omm in in -o coo r*- >r co »* r—r» r»- ^o >o o^ cm p»m tr>

-4- in vO p- co o^o •-• <nim >*" >4"m vO r- co o>oo <-< —< f\j eg

in in^^^^ in in in in in in in inmm inmining-4" >i-^ «4- -4* »4- >4- <i- -4- -4- <* -4- 4" >t >4" >*• -t -4- >4- vt >4-

cm (\i cm cm cm rsi enm enm re) on en rn en en en •>*• ^- <4* >* >* -4-

•4" >t -4* "4" «* >4*^ >1" >fr >4" "4" «4- -4- >4" <f -4" *t >4" >f >4" «T -t sf

cc i-< in >r cm cm cm >r cm p*o mop-nt^^o en *TnT en ~h cm3 cooo>i'is»comi-4r—cM'^o>vO>3'Oc\iocomco^cl ^om^vcMO^-r-^v^cMvoo-j-cMCMO^cTicoco

rOm i-<*HtH cm ro en rr) >j- >j-mm >o vO p— co eno—• CM

cj> -^o cr>o no >ro co cr>oo co co v*j <-•co (M in oo »-< cmr-un cmo co >} en (7>m in in r-t >fmm -^ o^ cm o>o f-< I

s- >f vOv0OO(J>OOOm^-tCMCJ<m0>CM0sJ^^-tO^TI*-CMC0>l"^- no r—r* eno "H cm en^ >rm in p- co a»o »h »h .-i cm cm en

00x

CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CMm rT|m>4" 4" ^" »t >4" vf vf >4" vt >j- vf <t >t -4- >* >*• *t «4" >t »* «4"

O0N(MM3*OOOOOOOOOOOH^^^-4^^nm en rnm >r ^t >i" -^ >t >f »t >t vt >t >t >t^^ >t ^" -^ >t

ooUJcca.

co

x>CO

>4"inincocor^o,, cr'0,, oN OcjNO> o>'--, '-^cj»oN '-,ocMrn fj> o^ i*» r— i-i r- in in p» >r in in inoo in ino cm >ooo^ocMm^^vi-m^mmininvOvOinmNO^OvOOOnOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

m a* cm cm -j cm en cm en <-* cm <-• «-* en cm in cm cm cm en cm cm cmmo^coco>rco>oco>t'CMcocMCM>focoocoovoooconJ- oo »-i -^ cm cm cm en en en cm en en ro -4" >r >j- en >t -4" >J" ^r enen en^^ >t >f >f "T vf -4" 4" -4" >4" ~4" >t >t <f -4" -4" «4" >4" <f -t

mm^O vO ,o>o ,o>0 N > KO vO vO vO vO ,o ,>0'>O vO ><0'«o

CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM e^ CM CM CM CM CM CM fM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM

cC ^>0>4"^^<fr*-<>r>-r--OP--r*-r*-CMeMf*-f>-'CMOin3 mm>4-cMOOrjNrj»cocrrj>cocoaocococooococop"-Q. N$->4">f ^^^encnencnmcncncnencnroencnmcn

p* r>» r* p«- r«- r- r*» Is- r- f» r* p* r—r* r~ r^ r^ r- r- r- r-

rn <3 r-< r-i <fO r-t sO i-l -4" <J> *? >t *-* >tm »4- ^O ^4"O <t -t vO>t oomm >j- rn <! cm en enm en en en cm—* cm cm cm i-t cm cm cmvO in in in in in in in inin in in in in in in in in in in in in ino^o>e>o>> c>ej»o> o^a>o^o> os c>c>cj>o> o> (7NO> o^o>| (>o^

< CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM

00

ccX

vOO cm •-• co co >oO -O r-im coO vO vO in en cm cm vO -4"

>o vO <jso o* en en p- cmoo rn cm p- co rn cm cmo inoo r*- -* C7> cm en -*O oo cm no nC ^J" enO p-m p>-—* >tm0^rn-4*mO>4-N4'(7>enoocOrnaoenooco~4v4-P,-eji^-i

o >4"m oo >4*m en >4* rn cj" co >o •>» som vi-m —< en <oo c> >4"

p*m co r» co vO >4* cmoooo a>o p- ct> ^-ico >omm co encMOp-NOencn'-^vno^comcMinenvOONd-m^coeM^>4" cm -4" P* t-i 4" co nj« in (T> p^ en^ co -h en in co cm «o en ^-i en

r-4 i-i cj> cj«oO r~i ^-1 cm CM en nJ- %tinm vO aoO <-< cm n4"

mm«4->4-mminmm!n"nmininmininvO>o>o>oininmmmmtninmininmmu-Mnminintnmm

>4-o p- coo —» cm >4"m >o p* co eno cm en -4-m ^o^ p*co co,h ,-i —^ i-4 cm cm cm cm cm cm cmcm cmm en enm en en en en rn eninin in in in in >n in in in un in in in in in in ir> in in in in in

UJx

cj> cm %o ef| cm cm P-en «-< cj> oo ej> f*" en P* o> cm >j- en^ oo cmO en P*coo co -* cj> co cm en en P*cop->4"eMr«-vOCMr»-m^OeMincMr-<P*oocMF-icoNj-'-H<7'Oor*»^oin>t)>rp,-oo >r&m p- vO p-CMnao cmo en cmm *r cm& en p- cm oo>ocM>re\iinp~o^e^^^>rocMinoO'-iooino^vO^'^'^Ocj>p*vr'^coin>4, Or^-^>rooaoincMc^inaoou^f^vONOP*p*»p~'Ooooooavo>oooo—t»-4CMen>4,insO cMCMen-4"inin>or*-aoooo>o>>ONO>—leMCMenenNd"^^"^

oooooooooo .eni <

oeninCM

ooooooooooooo.

92

Page 186: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 187: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

r^-r*-i^— r— r— r— r*— oococccococooooooooococococoeDoococoooco coco coco coco coco coco o> a* o^ o> c> s

CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM (\l CM CM <M CM CM CM C\J (\l CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM (\J CM CM CM CM CM C\J CM CM CM CM CMCMCMCMCMCMminminmmin minminmininininmminminininu^inminu^ininininininininm mmminininCM CMCMCMCMCMCM CM CM CM CM fM CM <M CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CMCMCMCMCMCM CM CM CMCMCMCMCMCM

a.

cMCMvOv$-ir\ir\(T>

»r tr» t—io—i co u^incMr^r^om^cocoor^^mr^^a*NOO^^CNa^r^NO<N^r^incoino> r-comvocr*ocMO^u^p^t^vor^'^vOcMr*-'-HcncMCMcnino>ririr«»^HCM'-^>rr,-<-t>3'OCM cm co corner >j-

r^>J-vOcjOCMrO>^^COrn^OU^NO>3"P*-OCMvOCJ^CMir»(^CM^in^-trriP*-«4"^ flr»HOOOO^O^HU^^vOr^(7>OCMcO«3"^OvOr*-CJ»--<-^>-tCMCMCMCOir\>t'CMO>vO^<-« O^oO-^vOO

JNOOOOOOO-i_^_«.-<_«^_*_*CM (\jCMCMCMCMCMCM CM CM 1-4 <-*—< «-*

cn -4- <f >t >t -4- >*• -j* «t >t >fr •j-^ >r >*• -4- >;*• >*• vf >t >t -J- <f vf sr <i- -4" -d- ^t <i-

0^ Q"* Q^ <7» 0*> Q*CO cOcOrci en rO

a.

3a

<j* *r try co «-* >o ooCMQOOP*-0>-HCOcm *o eno «o in o^

>or^u*cnc*ico^^cno^u^vorncu^incM^mu^rou^oeMcj>oo^or-' a>oaoo^r— cx>

r^vocMoa>inr^cMr^<no>cncninmr^oincoocMv0^r^<>ocMcncor»- vO<nmcoocT»r^mr^c^ cm^u^m cj^ >^r^or^ moo ^>tr^o>4-^ocninvo en »roo >$-,-< 4-o^en—<cM*Hr^ooc7*mcM^u^i^coo^cM>r^ir>r*a><j'OoO'H^-tcncMOP^>J"CM<T« -or-crocMCM

00X -i-vt-4->d-<f>r-j-

vO -o vO r— i*- r- f*- r»- r- ao co co co co co co ao co a> o>ooooo o> co CO car-men <n en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en CO en en

mmLn^OvOvOmmmmmm

00UJa:o.

co

3CO

m»^meMCM-*<o or*>ocor-o>o>4"CM>tin^fM>or,»r*'-<o>0'^oo^co<T>r^rnor>-o 'O^or-r-ooco cm co co O**"^ o>oco<%J>tcom^r-o^r—mr— incj>o^comovOCMCMcooomo*ininvOCM ^nOOO-^h>rir»>rcn>roNO ^o^coeM^mmr— r-r— oo^m^eMcMNomvoinvO^OvOcomcMcomo^en r-4CM>j"^"inin4- <4" >t >*" >1" -4" ro ininmv0<>>O>0v0>OvON0vO^r— r— r— r— f—f^^r— r— r--r—r—r—vO^Oinin r-r—r'-r—r— r-

rx-f-e-r-r-r— r-

CM CM CM CM CM CM CMcocjococococococococooocococococoaocococococooocococococococoCM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM

Cj> 0> 0>& (J> o*CMCMCMCMCMCM

a:3Q.

m 00m vO >4" (J1 iH—•0*HCMCM>0'-'mininininmsOo> s ej> o> oo cj>o

crm co >r r- r—o co »-io vO «4- o^^ co oo i-t r—m vO >t >t —• cm r-co i*- a* in cm^cMCM^^ooo>c>^cocoo^r— vONOininininininin>a-tnNOcoocMinO^O^o^c^CT^o^cj^cocooocooooooooococococoaooocoooaococococTNCT*^

COeOr— r-CMCM

00 CO CO 00 CO 00mmmmmmCM CM CM CM CM CM CM rOCOCOcO COfOCOCOfOcOCOCO CO rT) CO fO rT| cO CO CO CO fO CO CO CO CO CO COmm COcOCOcOCOCO

oO

X

oajr-tvor-O'H oo y0^ooN r^vO»-^0'-H<--'>i--^*r-icnr*-rocooOi--<vOunocooOi--(^-^ooco oomcooiaOcmooo^lo r^cocMCMcoinr^co^o^s^cou^vOsO^^-<<30 0>or,,-coirioocMf-icof>~ r>-moovOr— vo<f co vf in >t —< -* ao^m r^r*- 0^-4' co oo oo in in on in in no r*- ro >o oo o^<f<fo-omccMin^ %Mnooa^rMfHcMco>o^o<foo rn>^o^cocMoinoo^covOr^>^rMC>-«oinov}-cocMr-'^ocor*OsOincM vOinco^—t«-i

f-*--tcMco-i-r-ir~- o>o^r^inooON cMminr^QO^-4^-tcM>tr«-oococoO,>cj>oco^coin'--ico>l- >t>OooaNCMCM<4- Nj->r^">r>i-co i^cocooococococm^^^oooooooooooh^hooocixj1 vONO^^Or-r-inmm in in in in >t-4"^^>l"^*'>;,"'4" ,4" -4" vt >i

" inminmininminmmminmininm>r>d- ><t>rvf>r^vi-

>i-vOOc>mcMCMCMoocj^<M>ro>^m^o^cMcr-4-cr'aNincMvOCMoo^c>o>rr^>rvomcMu^m< tncocM^mcoo ino ao >r co >r>rr»~o cm <)^mmco<--ico co cm ino>cMr»- oo rH co vO^T'-^cr) cMoootMcorot— r^cMr^»^^joovo«^moocoO'^muNCT>r^>r ,^<3oovocoomtncoocMinf^m>oao>rocnf^.^incMuj sor*»r^cocDo>-H ^oocM»-tcMCMco>rm<3»0'Or-ooo^ooop-i^-ii-i>-^co>rmp-o>, ocM -^cMcr>co«T>tx • co . . ent— _*^,h -*_»,_< CM OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO^i-h--''^'H—<^^^^-i^^HCMCM OOOOOO

O | I | vT

CO CMin incm cm

93

Page 188: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 189: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

cm (\j c\j cm cm eg cm cm cm cm c\j r\j cm cm cm <\j cm cminminmmmmmtnmminmmmmmtn^M CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM

cc NOr-»r-cocoQ>»-*o»oincT>>3-^.-HvOinm»-t3 o^j-CMOM*->rcMmvOcoo>or*-oo«ocr<^oa. incjsrovo—'^Hinor-^MONNo^Nm

p-aoo^cMCMfOcONj-cnmoo^O^-mmcMi— •••••••••••••a o>cjNoooooooooo^a^a^coooooco\— mm^^^^^-^^-^^cnmrricncncncn

a. incM'-^v0^^inminc^ao<—<r-ocM<—t^mcM3 vOOO^^^a^cMromc^aocor^srcococoa. ^o^-4«4"ao(r)cocMj*-cMO^>rm^-ia3a3ooorn

roinor'Qoooo><^oa>^vj-o >orriocj>cx)i— •••••••••••••»••••co vO^o^o^o^^o^oor^-vor^-vO^minmN^^I co (O^ co co rn en co<oco^<ocorncoco coco

co ocoo^^^^ocMrncMCM^CMcomcMin^-r-ilu ^vO^ininrHm^mininommminr-r^ex inmsor-r*-r>-cDc>cocoor*-cMomoNcovOa. r-r*-^-r-p*-r—r^r*-r—r-coNO^OinminmLn

CO CJ>& CJ> CT> CJ» O^ CT> CT>O G^ CT> Cjs CT> CT> C7^ s CT> C"3 CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CMCO

cc ^o>ocMCM>j-coinr*i^cor,-(^-OMno^cMo2 ^vt' rOCOCOrOCMCMCMCM'^r— CT>OCMO—ICMO- O3a3COCOCOCOC0a3COCOcOCOCOC>C^0>>CTN CT>

cOfOcocOcOroeOcOCOoOrocOcOrooOrocOcO2 • • • •

< coco rococo rococo coco rococo rococo cocoLL

^O >* CM CT» CO CM CO CO CMO COO nO 03 0> -< CM CMt— r^-Or-irncM^ro>or^^coo>t'^>cMcornvOCO CMOf-lOCMvl-NOCMOrOCMOCOr—CMCMNOO3 oo^r-m—«r^ cochin cm cm o^^i-hcncoo —h

QC ••••# ••x ^-mr»c>oo^^cMCM>fr>frCMn^>o>o»tI— r—i^-r-r^-oococoaocococor-^oo^oinmm

>t vt -4- >r >t <$ >* -j- >f ^- vr >* >*• >4- >d- >t^ >*

•4"OO —* CM 0> CM CO >J- r-t r-i <o —I -tf" CMoom< CO^^OO^CO^r-COCOCTx-<OOCM>rcOCMOh- cMtr>vo>4"^oco>-icnincoror^r*-^r-incMnlu inmNor-r-r-cocococoo>>coinr*-cocr>o,,ox •••••• ••••t— OOOOOOOOOOOH^h-ihin

94

Page 190: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 191: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

mo o oooo coooooooooo ooooooooooooooooooooooo(\i_i ^.-(^^^^j^^^^i^,^,^^ cm cm cm cm cm cm cm c\]f\j cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cmp-p- r*-r*-r^r— r— r— p-p- p-p- p-p- p-p- NNNi»-NNr*r«'f,-r"r»r-r-Nf>-r»^(vr«-(»»r*r,»r-cmcm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm

cC op- cot-iocoinp-oco—tcMt-tp-coin3 inco aocop-Oi-<—«o--<coNOcooao«4-a. o*o ocMinocooin>roo>OLnocM

p-co cMCM.-<OvOrooincMOP-cMOin

o -<oo (Moo roo r— co *-< oo co ro >o <i r*»o v0 r**o -4-

^ cnj p-t cm oocma rnm »4- cr« >r o^mo vi" vO r~—• so ** u^mvO oo »-tm <J»m rvjo eg eg oo v*- vo -o vo in vj- ^-m^ ^o^ a^ao p- p- so cmo co in —*oo <to p- ro *- >o ro >—i ooomo

oooo coco cop-p-p-vo»o>oinr» p» I

s- r* r- p- p- p-p- p» p- p-p- p->t -4- sj- »tf- «4- <f ro co ro cm cm c\j -*—t^ r-*oOOoo ao p»p- r- r- p- r»- p- p- r- r- I

s- p- p-r- p- p- p- p- p- p-o ^o -o -o

\-

az

in

en

a.

OOX

op- cor\jocair>>ocr><\i0i-iov0'""<roinco foroc\iinvOso>fvoro»-too<rroo^u>ro p-orOvOOP-cM'-tp-cororOGOO-h>o inin-rrooinrnooincMOincMP-

cmp->fp~

so orooor- co c\j oo inr—o p- cm cr> >r <• roomo cooin\Oscr-ro^ocooo«Nr"0>3"ON}'0'-^cMin.-ioo-o-4" -OO —•co -4- r^p- .-io p- c\iin in sj- ro ro ro ro ro >4"o p-

o oo p- r- ro r->o vo cmo p- ino co <4- r\i p- >t cmo —*mop-r-r»p-vOvOv0mmmm->t>aTOp- p- p- p- p- I

s- p- p- r- p- p- p- r*- p-CM (M CM CM CM CM.-!—MHOOOOOO 00 CO CO P-P- ^O -Op» p- p- p- f- r— p- p* p- p- p- p- p-o so vO soo >o so »ooo

p»CM

LU-J

o<Xo

C/)LU

>QiD

ID 003LUact:Q.CL

<-lI- COOcai-z>

ao

-OIXJ

_lLJJCOct:<;i

Oar:

O0LU

C£a.

co

CO

cc3Q.

<LL

00

or:

X

LU

X

OO CMi-lCMCM<-iCMCMCM'-i>-*rO'-*CMCMoo cor-coror— ro—<cop-p-op-—><-*

oo oo»oooooooooo^hoo oooooooooooooomoCM^

CO P- <3 <3 P- P» sOOO P*OO -J3 00P»P- CO 00 P-P- ^OsOO x}"O »0 s4" xj-O vO vO -iP vO vO »0 <3O sf >j-OO sj" »4" ^0 COOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOCOP-rocOrorOcOfOrocOrorO',OrorOfOrororOrOfOfOCMCMCM

OC0OOC0OOOOOOOOO OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOCM CM CM (M CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM

OO OOOOO^Hr4-JH^^c\j(\l >f f\ji—it—•CMCM'^'—•<—iCM'-<«-^»-'—ivJ-r\jCM>J'Nj- CMP-^-tinoo in in in in in in inmm in in in inm in in in in in inm in in in in in in in in in in in in in in so^oOfO CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CMCM CM CM CMCM CM ,-!,-*.-*.-*—< _< -w ,-< -^ ^H ,-< ,H .^ ,-^ _i ,-* _«^ ,_« _< ,- .^ ,-*

vOP- p-p-p-p-p-p-p-p-p^p-p-p-p-r*" ooooooooooooooooooooooo

oo o-ocos^m^oO'-'Oooao^H-st-OO r^cOOvOi-OrO^^CMrO^xOP-vi-OO rOOinvOCMi-irOOCMvOCO^^coOOO CMrOinp-'0>s'"xr>4- inO<-iCMCMin

tMvOinomoOvtTOcOsoOvOrocomcMcocMCMincMvOoo ^xj-oop- -oa>^ in rocm—< oo vj-oom in-^o-^inaoin—tcocMOcM>ocOxt»oinrooop-inop-p-ooocOsfx0v0P-c0r-<r000Ntv0P--^P-O>4'xj- OinOv0f-HO

oo ocoP-*0-Hp-vj-comcMOroOv}-OCM HH^-tHOOO^C^^COCOCOr*mo ooooo>OococococoaoaOao

vtrorM^p-<f(MOrOr-<ooinOP-CMONtOcOvi-inocM»o vo ^o xO in in in «4- xt xr ro ro co cm cm cm <-• »-•ooo co aoco co co co co wj co co co oo oo co co co oo ao ao co co ao P» P- p-

i-tO CM^O CM COCMO x^"CM OP- coOO CO CM CM>OvO'-iCOO>OOOP-CMP-xOvJ'sO COCO'-<\0 >0<-iC0in»-4

O ^oaovOOrocMNj-^P-mooo ^ooP-moco^coo>-txTCMONj-cOvOsj'cOf^aocMrot-to i-to*<-<cMsTP--4"OCM00xr—<inr-4in—»>TsOP-op->j'<->p-cjp->r'-^vorop-'Nrro>sp'-<rooooooo >i-mmin-op-ooooO'-*cMcOvt >t>j"4'>i"invor-p-ooo^cMro>4-inp-ooooroinso

ro »roCMO OOUUOOOOCJ.

CM >T

p-CM

p-CM

• CO4 <

«rCMp-CM

OOOOOOOOOO' t CM CM CM CM

95

Page 192: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 193: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

O ^—«.-*,H^,Hi-i.-J,-*t-*-j^^^^.-<fH^f**-«f-*.-<.-i encnmenenrnmcnencncncncnmcnmcnmenc\i cm cm cm cm cm cm cmcm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cmr— r— r— r— f— r— i— f^-f^-p~-f— r*-r— r»-r*-r^r— r— r*-r^-r*-r^i— r*- i^-i— r*-r-r— r— p^-i— p— i— r— f*-^-r*-p— r^-r-r-r*cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm <m cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm

CC o>3C rnQ. ^r

on1— t

o p~t— o

CC o3 p-Q_ CM

o^- •

00 oX oI—

oo inULI oCC r-Q. cm

t

CO OX> CMCO

CC 0>

3 vOQ. 1-4

<y>

z. •

< —(

LL

os vo cmt\om »j- vj- c\imoo—•m co r-i %j-o r^ co as vo p-coo rg >t- ^-r- in rn rr» r\jr- rn in rn co in coo^ c\i ct> -^ (\j

>fco-*^*mt\ioorsipn-^o^ommmooMAco^vomo> co co p» «j- f\jo co^ cmo com >-* p-mo >f —• r» oo co cr-

com cvjm f-wo r* eno -o en o> .-4 <j> <r *-* co in cornmoo p-oo co p- oo <ro in cmm coo co eno •4" co r-H en cm—io co en on -4- in —* en in v0 p- covOm >j- >^ —< cr* p-mo com ro ao no >f <i- in so co

o^ o^ o> ct> on o^ g> oo co co co p.. p- p* vo so >o in in •<*• >*• -f >tvO vO vO*0>O vO<0>O^O vO vO >O vO NO vO-O vO v0^3'%0»O vO >'0

co >} oo rnm --^ cm cmp- ^-t co >r ^oo cmin co >rm >rom vo

coocM^mP-mrocMCMvOcM^roco^f-o^o^coo—

*

cm so o> cm enO co ooo —• cr- co nJ- en i-i .-4 co >om -o on -4" •-•

co r— -o <om -^ co vO en r-4 coo cmo ^o >t como >oo r- oo

en c^t rn rnm cm cm cm cm >-• <-* ^-«ooooooo\O^OvO^O\O vO'^3^0 vO>O vO >OvO nO^)^O vO nO'>

>r>rco>j'CM'-<'-4CM^^op-f^icM^rfr>in«T'-<'^o (?<^ cmm -o cm >j- rn vf o> cmo coo in >r -o cmih »f oo cm -r cm cm -( s <• on in vo -^ >r no p- co o»c\jr-*oop-inrn-Hvo^'-'0^vt'CMOO<-<cM>r

p~ p- p>- p» p» p~ vo vO vOom tr\ in in *t >tmmm cm cm cm cm\0'>0 >0*0>0 >0>©vO'>O^O vO*OvO»O sO<5 > >0*0 %0-O vOvO

C7» OO^O 00OOO 00OO ON 00 CO s On ON 0> C7» CJ> On CO 00rn cmm cm r» cm cm cmp» cm cm in p- p» in in in in enmm r- r—Os O> Os O>coo>oONooos ON coooaococoaocoP~P*"vOP**P—p- p- p«- p- p» p- p- p» p- p- p- p- p- p- p» p« p- p*- p- p* p* p- p-

—< i-i -^ -^oooo o> o> on co co co co co co oo oo>oo -o vOoo -o <3 in inm inm in inm in in in

o cjn oco co ooo o>coooo cooon—*oo-<ON^oN^-vj-vfONCMvfONONONNOONomp-p-monooononon(3nooononcocooocooooooo—^

sQsOvOso--o»O vO>o vO vO N^ sO^O vory~f^p,"iN,"f*"

CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM

1-4 cm r^ cmm cm cm cmin cm cm vO inm so ^o *o >o -f -4" on «-< <-<

OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO^^^r^-^CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CMCM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM

rncnrnfncnrnrncncncnrnrnf'N.rncnrnrnrnrn(M CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CMCM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM

rfON^fONONON^i^ONvOvO'OCjNvOl—tvO»f>fP~mm rn rnmm >f vfm >f >f vj- >f <j-m cm cm cm—

4

OnonOnOnOnOnCJnonOnOnOnOnOnOnO^OnOnonOnrnrnrnrnrni^rnrnrnrnrnrnrnrnrnrnrnrnrn

^ CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM

CO3acx

O>f -OCOCOO>fOCM-4-aNvO-0^00>f fMOrfiQ<OOcoin%fcn'^^Ocnrno—4-^^4ornmOvOincM-f cMinOi~4in »f -f rn ooo p- oo p-—»o cm en cm —4 onm i—• on cmm soor—ONi—trnoocMmf-tv0^tcorn'-< NOf»-cMOONoomoN >j-rn

>to co vOoom <*• onoo >o aom cmm rn oo cmco >omo cmo (mco cop- cmo co enm cmcMm p-cmooo on cmo en -to>o p-mp-vC ^o mp- r-4

m no co —4 p~ cm co enm enmm p~ co p»o en no >—

cm encMCMf-4p-incMOinenocomomenp-o or\jcMen»tco oooooNONO^ONcococop-p-p-ooinm^^^r^^rP- oooococoP-P-P-P*r—p-.p*p-p-p>-r—p~p-p-p*p-p-p-p»

m >f enm <J> p- >f cm p* >t -h co cm on p~ co o^o enCM CM CM CM iH i-4 1-< <—IOOO ON UN CO 00 00 CO On On

r» p» r—r>» p- p~> p* r* p-p* p«» >o »o *oo nooo ^o

luX

<^ cmr-mo v0 p-mmm >r >o en cm i-i cm «o on cMrn <Hi-h oo cm cm cm >-i in enp* p- on -oon on en en 1-4 p-rn 1-1 p-mp-<—

•f e\j-r vOoo'-icMom^"ONONeMooNF-4muN,soorn<jenin ejNi-i>j*p«-o-*>fcMP-om>uovOcjN>f op-voONrH(/>i-4minincMONO-^oo*o>rop~mou^r^ONoo>ri^curH>rr^cj>-H<MOr^incjON^orooop- en>r>f ^mvo^OP^ONONO^menw^vor-ONOCMen^^ >f >f>fmvOP-p-cooo-nrM-f ^m-o^op-oo• en

cm 0000000000.mCMP»CM

•CMCMCMCMCM OOOOOOOO'CM

CMr»CM

96

Page 194: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 195: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

CMCMCM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CMCM CM CM CMr**h-r- r^r— r—i^-r^-r—-r— r— r—-r^-r— r— r— r— r— r^r— r—r*»r— t— r— r— r— r— r— p— r— r-— r— r— p-p«-r»r»p--p-p-r-is-

cmcmcm cm cm cmcm cm cm <NfM cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm

cc —ir«-CT> -^oomcMCMCMC^mmc»^^op*->rc^cMmcMC^cn>rrncMOeM^cooe«"i3 coa>o OLnor^r-coomc^ror«-rovOrnoo^cN4r-oc30foooN ^(*->r'-*>ooo(Njo_ c7»ofj> ^«-t<MCMcn"4-OP--orgmc^oooo^>ro>™m>^OM^cMrommoGOC^cT>

a*.—4^ a^r-inm-^^^LnNrrorvj^^Ovo^ cMr—>or>»f,--oocoo*-—^co^inop-ao

inoino>cr>vo«4"-4"0,>

r*r— «oor»inoino\ocooin-4-^aop— -orf| p- I

s- CO 0>O —t CM f"t

OHi-( ooooo o> cr* o*. cr> cj\ qn <j\ co co oo oo p- r- p- p— p- p— r- co co co co oo oo co coo oooo inmm in in in inm in inm in in in inm inm in in inm in in in in

in vf -4- «4- »fmm inmmmmmmmmm

m

cc crmco o^-r^cncncor^r^.^sor^o^comcMmcorocM.^cn^ror^cocMCM'-rvO3 inr-co «4•co>^»^0'^^o^Of^l^oomcomf^|^^<4(^Jm>>ro^*^oco>l^^co^^cocoo,

*

o. o^-trjN mmvOf^co^o^msOOrn^rvjo<Dco-4"<>o<T>rnr\jsOooOfjN^c\irnrovO^n rn^c^r^mrn<N/ocor^r^NOrn'^a>»o^^^(N<NfnsrmvOcocooi--ifNirn

cr* r>a *i> en cm cr> r— cm cm*-4r-IvO'^COvO'—tP"-«—

*

f\j«4-CM^OO>jTOrovOOOH(\m>tift<o

xco co commm cooop^r*-iN,-^r»-r*-vOvOvOvOvOvommmmmmmmmmmmm^nvOvOvOmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cmmmmmmmmmm

to ooo r*-r-r-r*»vo^or-Noor-vor»-mr»mmp-o^a>oo>cococooooooooUJ Ono\cj» c\jrg>4-rvjcocorgsOco>^'<3NtO>tOO>}- vO ,«Ofn-4"COcoco^-tf-t--*^rn^Ornoc OOO <^o^0^o^cocoo>coa3cocococococoa3l^oo<^^^<^^ovjrgc\jf\ir\jf\irga. r*»r-r— p»p*p--p*p^p*r»r^p--p*p~p«-p*p--p--f^p»-cocoa3oococococoa3oo coco coco

msOCs O^0> C7v 0^'^CT%

op-inr—p*-ininoinCT^o-j-^vj-mmsomCT-CT-OOOOOOO

CO

rOrorOcm cm cm

^ -4- «4- -t -I" *4" -J--4" -4- «t -4- -4- -4- -4- <4" ^- <4" -4" vJ- <f «4" si- 4- 4- <f sf ^- >f ^- vf ^f

<\i c\j cm cm cm cm cm cm (M eg c\i c\i c\j cm cmcm c\i f\i cm cm eg CMCMCMCMCMCMCMCMCMCMinooooOsOONOCM CM CM CM CM «M CM CM CM

CC

a.

<

CMCMCM ^d-^CM^^C^^CMO^s^CM^O^^O^^I^r^r^C^I^CMCMCMO^ONCJ^a^h-CMP-cmcmcm ooooooop*oP^^r^r^r--r^p*co^^rncnencncocMCMCMCMCMCMCMO^oo** mmmmmmmm.mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmen corn mmmmmmmm.mmmmmmmmmminmmmmmmmmmmmm

o coo p- p»p» r- cm r-mmo>ocjsooooooco-t^-mrnmcncncn'rir- p- p» p» p- r- f- p- r-

CM<NCM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM

00

CCX

-4<00 CMc000O^C0^0OCMC0CMC>00CMv0mcM00C7>OC0O>0Of,--r0<r)CMO»^-«t<Ooo—» r^mcnmcMCM-H^o^cocovom^fMom^+comr-jr-ONm-O-^rt-im^ovocom covOvor*-«-Hr-mroC7^voco^^-i(^co^-<-^cMomr^rocosO-4"coco-4'0^^4-p-p- Nt^comcnooo^^OvOcO'-^r^'0-i"aoc>vi"f*-r-<r-(f<«.p*-^'cocMfor*'-t'4- vO

>* 00 cm no 00 r- -4-r-or^m cmm -4" -4"^ cm r-mp^oomcMCMmvOm-ommNOco>tmvO

•d-tno ^o^>ONtcMor^mrocM^<-tr--mcMO^rocorn>4-mm^cooo>«t--icMrr(mvor*-ct>qt>c3> ONOoaooococor^-r^p-r^p-r-^ovO^ommmmmmmmmmvOvO^vo^OvOvO^O^ vO>0-O vO\O vOOOO'0>0 > >-OO vO\0 ,OOOO sO nOnO-0>O vO ,00'0>00

COvO^OP~-COQs-HCMfOrM f-t r-1 ft 1—t -^ CM CM CM

<I—LUX

cosfocMmcricoNO^>o^OP--a^orr)mp^>rc^r^omcM>rp^p^r^cocnnmo>«r*-cMCMmmcM>tmomoo-*-

vOcom m^oo^»^'--i<Hcr>o>rr--'m>r'4"CMO^«TcoNOCM^(s->4'mmt-^cMiTiroo cj>>Tf-t>i"ONOm^-i<j>m cm cp< -h .-4m eno r— >r »h oo >rr» cr> ^-t ^-t cj« r-m •-• >r >o cr> in 00 romo p~ >r >-* com cm <-"—• cm crico>j*cr, r*-c*"ioo000 oo^cMCMco>r^mmmvOP-r>-cofj«'^^'H'^cMCMcn>i-mmvOp>-p*-cocj> >rsor--r-coa3o>oo

•mt- ^CMCVJ OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO.

y

cop-CM

* <

CMP^CM

OOOOOOO^-I^

97

Page 196: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 197: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

nOsO>o^oOvOvOnOnQvOvO f*-f*-f-r-r*-f*-r*.i,-f»-r,-r-r~-f^-r~-^-h-r>-is-(>*-r>-^r*-r*-r-f*-f^'fs- cococooococm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cmcmcmcm<m

cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm (\j <nj (nj cm cm cm (m (\l cm cm cm <\j cm cm cm cm cm cm cm c\j cm (\j cm c\j cm cmcmcmcmcm

c£ OP-p-in-^eMr-^'-^fM^jC o>oc^o>tcmo^coon(^o. 00LncoNOCMrn>rsO^rr^co

^minvOcjoc^Of-JCMmcn

o co vO>l"CM»OP-cMin>0'-<P*-ao inrovoor— >r oomm cmcncM^o OMnincnen^cocncM^cx>vOOcncM^cjxrncMmmmcM>rocp>r^o>©p^cT>in cm cm so -finc^co^«4-oovoa>cMOvoao^rn<^r^infncn^-^-invOco^oir\r--4 coinoocMsO•^coo^cn>r>rir\r-cooNOCMrnrn-j-ir\vO^-coo>oO'^cocMvO —^inr-co

ininininininoo^o^o^Oininininininininininin

^^ cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm en en en enm en en rn en en ^vfrvt en en cmin inm in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in inm in in in in in inm

ao oo co co co>r <f -4- >!->*•

ct cor-oaooM*---HNr-^cM-T3 O cm »-•«-•in^ cm enm^*^a. in^incMcocj>ocMOoom

r*- co co a*o^en ^j- tnm vo

<)coc\iincoocnoo%TOO^o^"^rcMino^>Of-tinor»->ocMcor*«-in cj>*Tcocr>vo

cMNtocof^r^cn^ooocMr^^ocncncMOrno>covOC7»crio>in<N o—iincninrococr>co>j*ini^cnr^in'-<co>ocoNj-cMOaocoao(7ioocciocr>>r oNsocr>cnp-inc^o»^ro>TinvO^-coo^^cMrn^inNO^Or*-coo^'-<r-icMo>cNjNO o%cMcnmsO

cm cm cm cm en en encom menmmmmmmmminmm co coooo o> on cr> on o*ooooo oooooo r-*^—*ooo* -4- >t >< >t ^t vt >j- >t >4" in in in in in in inm in in in in inm in in >!s4-inminm

oo -hOO>CJn^CMOOOOOLU OCMinmOvOCMCMCMCMCMcc vo >om in vO <o *o >o -o >o >oQ. ooooooooooo

oom-HCM-^cM—i -* en cm >r -r cm >r >r -TnT -4" in in inmen en onoo> ooonocm^>OCM00CMCJ0CMCM>4"<»CMCMOCNCNCMCMCMC0C000N}->l->i-CT>f--tv0 COCOOOmCJNocMcncMcnmcnmmcnNt^>S"^>jr>t>t>f >r>^^mmcnaMnr«- ocMm>rincn>t^J->t-«J->t^-^>t>i"^>j"-t>i"si-^"^-4'^^'^-t'^-4'cncncM -g-gooo

CD

oCO

CM CM fM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CMr^ p- p* r- p* r- r>- p- r*- p~ p- p- r*» p»r- p- r- I

s- r— p- p- Is- p» p- p- r* p-

CM CMCM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM C\l CM CM CM CM CM CM CMCO CO CO CO COCM <M CM CM CM

Q.

<Li.

cMOr*»r*cMinooooocococooocor~cococococoenmenmenmmmmmmp- p* r- p- p* I

s- p- p» p» p- r—

co^fncncncMcncncncMCMCMCMcMCMCMcMCM^^-t^oocnp--cncM cm^oooin in in in in in in in inin in in in Ln in in in in in in inin in in in sor- a> 00^000

CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM mmmmm

OO

X

OvOCM>OCMOcMCMCMrn>0vf h-^o in -j- p- sf cm -4" inco >-* p»—*m <j- i-i in cm cmmooocM*-<om>oooaM*»

^ocoaoor—p^NOooo^ocMo^p^^vOp-co^ocooco-ONj-cM cnocM<f—*

c^in^Oi-tOrno-^^oc^coinino^^cMCMP^oOvj-^-oococMCM —• soo* in <*

c^NOOP*>oincMcoo^cMr-^cocjNrno>fnin>ocM»-iornOvOCT>in rnmcMvO^ocar^cop^op^^^p^p^NO>^inc>p^>ONOtnh-ocn^o<)i^cMC>cM —imONincM

in in so p- 0">o i-i en^ >!• incm cm cm cm cm enm en en rn en

inoN^cM>i- v0^cocT>ocM4'invOr*-coa>0'-<en>4'intnp--f,ninco m^p-Or-ir^p^coa3cococoa3ajoN(>cj%cj>cj<ONCT>oNOoooooooc7>cjo mencncn-4"inininininininininininininLninininvO-o^O^o^ONONOvOinin mmmm in

LU

x

a,, NO-TincMco>}'CMoo>3" vrcM^-tcjsr-oen &—<*Gt-icococo ONmmen^tcjvmen •O'-*—'coco ct*<m cmmen >r>i-cj«coc7Nmmmm«-|^Hcomo mencoenr^cMO>OP^c>in>rcMo\cMcj>vocMCT>vj">^>j'>3"CM>ooNso ocmcm^^coingNCM^ONOcnor^^vO^^ooyo^ocovrP^mo^^^uj^o^mc^^^eMCM^n^}-mmvo>OP,- cM^mvOvor^p^coo^cj>o>--t^4CMCMcn'*n>i">*'mvor«-p*-p*-cr'--icn oo<-»—^cm

»m« <

p-

CMP^CM

OOOOOOOOOO-»en

ICMCM OOOOOo \

enp-CM

98

Page 198: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 199: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

COCOCOCOOOcocOOOCOCOOOCOCOCOaOCOCOCOOOOOOOCOCOOOCO (7*C^<^C^O^e>CJiO>l <Tv C^Ol>CJ*CJ^C>CNCJ>CJ,iCJ\CT*

cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cmr-~ f*— p*— r-^ r— r— ^— p— r— r— r— r-- r— r— r~- r*- r^- r— r*— r~- r~- r*-r*-p-p» r-p-p-p-p-r-p-r^p-p-p-p-p-p-p-p-p-p-p-cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm <M cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm

cc p»vOinrn^o-^>r-4-tncnocnincpvO'-«c*p-cpop-rncPcn3 ininininocococoo>cM«4-cM>rin>rocMoor"-incocn<7>vOcMQ. P-e^vO-^fMvOmOMni—«sOi-«mcj*>i"OcnvONONOO> 0> -000

ocMcnmp-ocMcninp-r"-cocococ7to>>oocMOvOCM<y>»ocM

<T> oo^ in >o >*• r- -4- r-t o^ cmoo co on 4-p- cm o>a^ cm o''o on r*»m^ co •j- >r ^o vo <7^o^ vo cm cj^

en cm cmoo vO ^o -1" «4" cm cm o> cj> vO -4- r-t r— inomrs-coa>ocMCM>f>*">oof*-p>-oN^mocovO

C| OnOnOnOnOOOOOOOOOO (-Ih^^^oOO,^Ov

<r>t^"^>J-mmmmminmmmmmminmmmmvj»^->4-sO ^o ^o vO P* p~ p- p» p- p- P» p~ p» p- co co co r- p»>*• -4- >t 4* >*^ <*- -4- "4* <r >t <t -4- <t <t <t <t >t -4-

cc »-^->r>T^or->T<J, in^ocMNr'-«o>u,>in<t)—40 0cmco«tcop-c7>3 vO^vOvO^oo-HCMvOcovOcoocpmr^-^enoOvi-p-cnma. coor-mmcoin^-ir^cMr^cMNOrHinovrcococOf-top-i-to

co^-i^rnmcoocMminmvO-or-r^-cococooaoin^r-^o

-4*o>m cm >rm cr> «o •-» co so «r in \o p»m «rm<4* p- «4- vOm en o> p-^—*omm >o co o> -^ in cmin en^—t cm co p»m vO >T >$ -• -* 00 in cm </<o cm^m >f <n >o 00 qooo cm cm >r <f in r- cjn vO ^t cm

00 in <0 •O ^O >0 *0 I** P- p* P- P- r>- P» P» p» P- p*> P- ao P» P- p» -O -OO<r >t «fr -4- ^- -4" -4" >*• ^-^ -f vt -4- >j- <4- -J- -4- >t -4" -4" -4- vj- >t .4- -4-

("aencncnrnmcn^4'N}->4-^Nt>J-*t-4"4--t«d-•4- >*- <* >t^ >t <j- 4- 4- >*••>* -4- ^- <f <r -4" >r -4- si-

00LU

ccQ.

CO

3CO

m >r cm en -4" p* p- co p-&ooo enom en cm cm o> p- .4- co vO p»m r-ir- in en ^-t cr> p- ct^ r-ioo cmo cmoo -4" cmm c^ »-^oom-o p- p- co o^ r-t >-4 cm cm >^*m in so p-o p- p» p- o> in *-t p- cm 00o^o »o >o vO -o r— p- p- p- p» r- p- p- p- p- p» r*- p-p- p» p- >o ^o in in

p- vO p- cooooo 00& cr> *-t ih ^-t ^r rn <3 en encm >*o co r-t -t -4 r-to >r >rm p- in p- a*o <? «4-

cm en >j- >4* tn in \0 nCm no sO p- P- p- cj> o^ cm o> p-p- p- p- p- p- p- p» P-p- r^ r* p- p- p- p- p- p- >o vO

oocooocococococococococococococococoaoaoaocooocoooCM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM

0>0><J>ejv cj>o>, >, ejN(>cj^o,,, C7% ,> cJN C^ej>oC^(7^CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM

cc Oen—ir^«4'vOcMO>cofncj>o^o>j-ooej«T-4r»-cMenmcM>*-2 o^c^c^oocor^-p-NOvOvOLnininminininNj-vi-inr-o^f-tenNOo. 00 co 00 co 00 00 co 00 ao aoao co 00 co 00 00 00 co co co co 00 CT'O^ej*

in rj> p- en cm i-^ 00 coo *oo cm r-t cm cm —4 en p» inm<fvj-<f>j->3-enrn>fenenenrnencMCMinvor-cocococooooooococococooocococoooooaooomenmenmeneneneneneneneoenenenenenen

<u.

enrnenenenmrnenenenenenenenrnenenfnencnenenfnenen enenenenenenenenmmrnenencncnrnenroen

003CCX

co r-t *t eM <4"Om en cm ^O cm e\io -4-O >i- -O 00—1—t ino cm in -J-

coo> o>d-o>cM'Hin-4'-4"CMP-incoo>s >^^ocno^o> <—•>o^o—«coen>fP-—4oocM>i-^'mp-<MnsomcncoP-—4P-vOO>p-o<y'mp- rn r-t en enm in >$• en —t P- en co en cj> >}c -4* P» en CT^ iH en o> 1-*

^ ej% >i-P- si- en en rn cm 00 r** vO co en vO «d-mo fJ^

O^ensOsOOONOCMC^COOP-O^OO^-^CMvO-*>o «4"o inmoo P- >f >t >t co co vfr p-o coo cmen in 00 ^0Oo cj^o r-4 <m cm cm cm en en >tm <jnO

m vO p-o^m r^ <r« —4 rn en >*• <j* in in no vO p- <x> p- cm co^ (7* in>}• >3" >r >*mmm in *ooo >o >o ^o »o -o >o -o *o «o ^o inm >r >rinininmmmmmmmmininmmininmmmmmmmin

-< en >* in sooo cm <nj -4* <f vO o 00o cm cp no >i"

^^ -^ ^^-* <—" CM 1—t CM CM CM CM CM CM CM en en CM CM CM

ininurMnmminmminmminminm"'>min

inc^cn^cTiin^voin^oNenocMNOOo^inr^c^c^vococMOrn^cjNinvONOu^r^NOP-invOO^< v^^^mp-o^r— incM»-ienp"i-<*Ten>ococMcnt-^min<-4<M>3' <—tvOCMi-i>}'enen'^«-tenrnvOP-P-aoooen>f ^r

I— ^oenor^»HooineMO>^en^cocj>cM>rr^o^in(MvOf^r^^^cornvOOOor^r^^^^^ooinr\iin>f r^

uj rri>4--4-ininp»p-oocr>c^oooo—t^^—••-•cn^Tmr— aoo-^ -•»-<cMCMen^<i"^>4"mm>o^OvOr^coo—kmx • .m

-fr-tr^r-tr-t-^r-lr-(^^4^<\jeM OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO 1-1—IHinCM

OOOOOOOO00 •

CM

99

Page 200: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 201: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

X

(J* CJ* Q\ Q\ Q> Q\f\JC\J<\IC\IC\4(\J

a: -fr^corgor-is —tr—or-i-<mo. c\j-oc\j.-toao

I— ••••••

(X. ^-*vOr—COCO

a. rcir-rorvjocor*-o*mor-Ln

i- •

X >1- «4- >*-<! vt>i-

00 (Dm—t(Mi-4(NJ

a. >oiAif\inm^• • • • • •

CD V> Q> 0> C* C7* 0*1

3 c\jc\|(\jom<\j<\j

CQ

rqmc\Jir>(N«4-

CO Q*O C^ s 0^mmmmmro• • • • t •

rfi ("0 rO ro rO CO

nj-O>*0c\JC0OI— 4"in<\lrOf*-CO(/) F-nn>f corgcM3 {\|C\|vO^<NCOCC ••••••x aoo^-'r- >*•<%]

h- p-tOOCT^O^O*

en co QO cr\<}—*< nO(MCT><NJi-I0>j— oir\c\ioocr>

• c\k\j

100

Page 202: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 203: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

QNIO CO CO 00 00 CO CO CO CO 00 CO CO 0>O OOOOOOOOOOOOO p-4^^^^^h^,_(^^.-hcm ^i^^H>-ip4Hr-tr-i^HH^ cm CM cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cmOO OOOOOOOOOOOOO OOOOOOOOOOOOO oooooooooomm mmmmmmmmmmmmm mmmmmmmmmmmmm mmmmmmmmmm

a: +t>t .-tincMincr>s$-Nr-4-m.-i—iinm3 ocnj o^o> >oa>r-<-*oo>T>m<Njao^o_ cm >rm.-icMcop-p-co^o^^com

>oo> c\j>f co^-((M^*sOomir\i—«OvO

vfom^vf-omoalmoin cm^ «o ^o <-• oom <\i >f oom r- srmm <-itr\ fHm cm >rm in »-•.^cm-4" p-om r-omo o> 04p» >*• 00

m 00 <r •-*p» o> r-o >o —•4- 00o -«roo cm r- >-> inoin>j-c^vomr-iooina*m co >s-p~omocm

00omo co >om -4-m <m —1 f-<oo r*> vfo cr« o> o> o* a*ooc o> co 00 co

^- r\j >—1& 00 co p- >o inmmmmo^oooocococococooocococo

r«- >o >j"m cm c\j r-io <y>ccocococooooococop-p-

00>-

o*i

O•

om•»

LU_Joz.<

00X

00LUa.Q.

CO

CO

>r»r m«om>ooininin>r>rmp-p->0(\j ^->3-f-i>4-m>om^>J"oor— (njlo

cm fMmoovO^^oo^ocovOOa>m mP-o>*-mp-o>cMinoommo>

coco

^<m

r\i 00—» voo c\j somo cm rg >r r-*

v0o <-•mm co so com o>o p-o^ONtccvjocsjrH^-cror-fMm co ih in co —t >* p-o cm com <t*

comaor\jr*c7>>o>ocMsum coom <?> a* i-iinomr-m i-tr-mo o> 00 00mco cm r*m voo —1 >f 1** cm

oovommcNj^ooocor^tncMOM^O^G^O^OOOOOcOOOCOCO

OO Q>OO0> <?, CT>O0,N ,, C00> 0NP-OO ^o^rNKMrgo^CNjcNjvO^T^-O00 p-p-oocococop-cooonOP-cop-OO CT* tT> Q* CT1C CT»O 0*

1C CT1 C*O

O

rsioc r*» -o vo in -J* >*m r^ r-^—

(

<7> a> 00 00 co 00 co co co co 00 co co

Is- I

s-o -o co 00 p- r* <n vo in >rp->r>toocooo<M>rovoc\i>or~oo o> cr>oo o> o^c 00 r- vo (\j

mmc\ic\jmmcMtN(c\jr\jc\i(M^'

'n-fM—<oo>c?>coP-p-co co co co co I

s- r- r» p~ p-

COOOC^OCOCOCOO^O^P"p-p-mcMOo^p-mm^00 co 00 00 p- r- r*» r» I

s- p»p- p- I

s- p- p- p» p- r- p» p-

cocococococoaococococoo^o^ OOOOOOOOOOOOOC\J CM CM CM CM <\l CM (M CM CM (M CM CM CMCMCMCMCMCNJCMCMCMCM

Xo

00 LU>C£O

C£00-U«/)2LUOct:0.0.

^ILU<-Jt— COocaH-O

CO

LUCOCC<3.

o»-Oct-.<LU>

a:3Q.

<LL

00OC£.

X

LUX

00 aoo> a^a*o>c*<7'C><7sP-cocov0 c\icMinin>4-vtcop-o^'-4 co»-ti-i ininvOo^oo-^"4-<Mn00 ^•^^^->^4'>4, >4">i->i'>tmin inmLfMnminminLO^vOP-o oooo^-^-^^^»-<mo CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM <M CM <M CM h-^i-(^^4^^H^^^^O CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CMp»vO r-P-l— P-P-P-P-t'-P-P-r-P-P- OO CT* CJ> <T> CT>

O

<T* <y> (?> O* CT> C> f~-li—1 * i p.j»«ii i, ii i i i

_K\j ^^^^-ir-i^i^^^^^^i,^^ r-i^,^,-,^^^^^^^,^^ CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM

00 Ovomp-ocMOcomoa^cM00 oop-p-\0^inmp-corn>J"mv}-00 cjNmoco>j-p-p-i*-cr^cMm-vt00 r-^p-o>LO«i-ooooNt'-4mcMCMin

co in r- 00 Lnm co <4* p- -4-oo >oom *tf— in <-*om 00 co in vOmmop-ooo>mcNjmo>^m—ico^mcM^omo^cMcocom^-itTi

CMC0vJ-CMC\JP-<MO>r>tmo in td m^cm t> egco—<cMo^moomvomp-Oincoo> ocMincoo>

inm oocM>i-inv0^omincT»p-op-cm r-mm^OCr>aocop»NO^<NOoin ooooooo^o^u^o^oo^o

4-o co^m in p-o cm ^- co »o a*O co >0 in vrm cm rg f-io co co co

00>*CT'0,>tPQ^O>0>0A OCOCOCO

cMincomincoocMvj-com—io>cop-NONOm>i-mo>c co co co co co co co CO

^oocM^co^vOP-co>ro^cM>oo^cMP-^oo>'^^^cMOOO^mcovOfMminp»inoinmo>'^cM00 aomoMn^rcMOoomaoocovr cr>cop-p-MJo^ucMcri>rcorHO —*cMm—»cMaj»-<cop-in

'^oo'^mmNrNom—<o^r^««tninrgr^^>rp~ainmmi/>cocinm^'^''-<cMCMco^oir\sr >T,

'--'o<j—4co r-t-^p-ocM^mp-oNi-iino^NO omp-ofM^"tnp-o>>'-^inp-in om-oocM>j-\Qooo-H

m >mom 000.cm t mom

om

•m«CMCMCMm ooo<

mr-t

om

•micNjcMCMm ooo<

in i

r-t

om

<CMCM

101

Page 204: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 205: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

^,_»_i_*,_» rncnrnrnrnrnrncnrnrnrnrncnrnrncn <4*>4-^*>t>t s*">3"^"^"^">1"-4"^"4'^"»J'*i"^>3->fr*1-»tf"cmcmcmcmcm cm cm cm cm cm cm fM cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cmcm cm cm fM cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cmooooo oooooooooooooooo oooooooooooooooooooooocncnenrnen rnmmrnrnmrnrnrnmcncncnromcn cncncncnrncncnrnrnrnrnrnrncncnrnrncnrncnrnrn

cc >ocncMr^-^ (\j>^-aoocom>o«OvOf*- ,orocMnr-in:2 c\jo>-tr-«-^ cMONOS|

C7i cMP"»fs-r-Oen>o»rcnrs-incna. r-r-oo^'-* (NjofMao-j-^oc^ocncoom^-ir^vf

srmcMrnm »rc^*Tao©invOp--os ocMN*-inininvO

vOcMr^coincnrs-^p-incoeMinrs-aoP"-os cocop«.rncnmo <7* cm —i commm in >o <->coo r*» t\io vj- rn «$ in cmcm on co -4- cm (7> in <7» p- en r— cm coo —* cm vo ct> cm -4" >->ocm *o s cr> r*-o vi- ^-t^ s

- sO -4- coo <\j rn -4- in p» co »^ma^<7>ooo^-r*» co coco

cj>p-vO>a->j-rnmm en >*>$• >*>*• inmmp» r- r- p- I

s- h- p- r*- p- p- Is- r- p» p» p*» p-

*t^TOfOfnror*T,nmcNjc\ic\joooooooo^^p«- p~ I

s- p- p- p- p- p- r- r* r- p» r- p» Is- r- p» r- p» p~ p- p-

Q.

00X

—<>T'—ir-in .—iincMC7>r».-4oeMCMmcM»or-co^u>^-tcoo^sfp— o> ininmPs«'4'ininco*-iincMr-ivomom^t^o^-co c\j^rnoN^rinp».oo>ra»^-*>rf\icoinm-4- —*cMro oino^^O'-'fsJ^mvOcoO'-^—«r-(C\i

•r co on u* *•+o co cm in^o co crm »-4 in cm >r cm in >r <op-m cmmm cm co qoo coom <j> cm -4"o I

s-^ >-« -h cm cr>

vOCOc<^co>0>}-Os cnf-^rs-r-(vOCNJ»4"'>0^30>4"fs-C7>vOOsO i-i >rm <-> f^ oo -o <om «-• co rn in >o I

s- cr>o^ cm in ao

p-

I

s- co co cop-p-p-p-p-

p>-m>^rM<—••-*»-1—4—4^-4^^c\icvjrncnmp- r*. p- p- p- p- p» P- P- P» I

s- Is- P- I

s- P» P»^(\J^h^hOOOOO(?c0P-NNP-00 00C0C0C0P»P-P— P— P"»P,-fs»P*P>»fs-P»->O vO'<0^'0''O sO -o>o^o>o

co rs-os

is->otn o^c^oo^ooO'-'OOO'^homfhh

uj p-nncnrs-p- o >* o> -4* >*• cr* in Is- p-p>- in mQN.-* in in

OC p-vOvOmm OCOOOOOOOC^OOOO-^i-tOCMOOq. f»-f»»p«.f«.f«, P-sOnOnOvOOP-P-P-P-P-P^P-P-P-P-

P- P- vO >o P- Is- -O «0 vO P*»O I

s- P*» 00 tT> 00 sOO 00oo>4- c\j oo oo cm c\j oo voo >r o >r ^- co -^ co >r >-* rr\ oo^mO^ <7> 00 00 s CJ^ CO 00 00 CO CO 00 P*O »-l—I <~* C\J CNJ r-t (M CMp- p- p- p- p* p- p- r- p- r- p- p«> p- oo oo ao co oo oo oo oo co

co

3CO

CNJ CNJ CM CM CNJ

m en^ rn ro ro rom romm ro rnm rnmCM CM CM CM CM CM fM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM

>1- -^ >t -4" <+^ «t <f -4" •* >f >t >t^^ »f -^ -t nJ-^ ^- >fCM CM CM CM CM <M CM CM CM CM CM <M CM CM CM CM CM fM fM CM fM fM

CL incj>'-i<fPs» —•0s-^0'-^i—i^^D^^nJ-^P-CMP^-vOvO2 ^P^CMCMcn rom>3-minmCMCMfMCM'-<'-*rMOCMCMQ. CMCMfMCMCM (7sO <J>O C71

tT> CT>O C^O CT> CJ>OOO <7—4—i—i^hi-i rn^cnrorncncnmrncnfnrornrnrnpn

CM -^ CM7> «4" >J- C7 cm CM <T CM nJ- P- vt- p- CM P-O P- CM sIs-

o >o >o voo vo vo f*" Is- I

s- Is- p- co >d-m rnm cm cmm cm cm

in in in inm in in in in inmmm in in in in in in in in inin in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in

<u_

CMCMCMCMCM CM fM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM fM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM fM CM CM CM CM

UOZ>OCX(-

oooo^ p-cop-in—4movOcMin^OcMmm^o>toinvj-—*o <-tc^ocofs-inos cMCMP-m'Hcnm>^i-tO^O^^^O f-ixOCTl >*'inOs-OCM^'00-4-fMCMCMmP»'CMCMOCM^ r

s-CM-^>J'fMCO(MOP-<-^Cr>CM vOcnCT«sO

CMvOrn^O-^vj-cOOCMmO>4-COvO<-t'^fMOOCOO(M^p-m en inm cmcm >o -o ao or*- cm so >^p- <r room o^p-m cm^ <—

' >o cmom vO in p- -^o oom cm oo so -j- <m•4" in <7» >4-O P- fH CMO nj- vO 00 CM ^0 C7^ —•OO -4" CO P- >i-

Oho>oh vOO^tf-aocM^invOaoccMcnvt^-inNf>}"^mm ^nfMOCOP»P»>P-P-^s•P-•aOOOCOO^O^CJ^cococooooo oococoPs-p*P-P*rs"P— p-p^p-p--p-p^p—

comm in en cmo t*- p- >j-^ oo cm rn vj- vo p-oo —< -41

Is-

p* co r*- r- p- p» r*-oo ^oo in -d-mmmmm -4- >d- >r -^r

r- p..p- r- p*. p- p.. p* p» p- p- p- p~ p- p- p-r- p- r» p- p- p-

UJx

mON^^cncMCM^ rs-vOOT^is*^Of^O(MOcocoincMLnrs-

<^«oinooin-4"^OrH^inP--^incnrnrn—i^oocoor**!*- ct'nocoo^cmo—4vop*co—(CM^rinm p*rnoorncjNvoO'-<oocM'HcoincM^^*oin^o-4"Ocjx rnorMvorn—4rHrrivoin>r>^<»incMcoinc^<ocncMNO^^'Hcor^cM>TC^OP^^>t"'^OTm>ro—4cm offiP-HrOvfiA^vOP-oof/OvO^p- OHoooH^rg<\imfn>j, co'Hi-4(Njrr1 rn>rin>oP'

cMCMcnmm ooo-o I

i—

t

om

tCMCMCMCM OOOOOOOOOOOOO'•& I I

CMom

102

Page 206: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 207: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

>^^>i">4" »o vo in inin in go ga %o *oo *o >o »o go go go*vo goNO-ogogogogo^ogogogogogogo^o^ogogogogogo^ocmcmcmcm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cmcmcmcmoooo ooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooromcoco c^cOfOcocOcOrOcOc^cOcOrncOcocOcO^cocOr^coc^

3 (^<y>o>m ir\f^ma3coog>r<Nogmfs»cgtr*inr^co>^<>r^ir\oa3ro<\j<\J^(T)rnu^N^

CMCMCMCMr-r-f-r-

cjnooc—r—\Ovo>o>o>or>- ,o>0 NONOo^o ,o >o , NO vO>o»Ovo^o <o ,o>o >or— c-r— r—r-r-f—f-f-coco^OvO*O vOvO vOvOvO*OsOvO >0*0 %0'0>O^O^OvO vO vO*O^OvO'sO vO vO vO^O s© vO>0',O vO vO vO sO vO^O^O

cc oao^^ >orgvrcoc\jrnro>T^(7>u> '^r-rn^^cp^i)vOini—tao^oa3r>»'^a30<^ioocr>'-^fncr>p*' cj>r<igocM.—»co

aoQNO^ lhmo in a>m >rmm >f vr^r>t^ inininirun m>or*-r>-coc^ono i-HCMCMrncn in >or- o^o^ro>r

X<T>a>oogogor»r-

gom in >*m co ro co co >*• co ro co co ro co co co co rn com ro com co »4- «*• -$• >t Ni-^>*"Nt>tf, 4, intninin>0v0O ,>0^0^0 v0v0 > ,>0^0 v s v0>0 v v s v s s0*0 v y0^0 >0v0 s0>0 N v0^0 v v v x N N v0'O

i/) ocor-go in^voin>or— >^p*-aooocor*-r*-cr>p-<ji(7Ncr'U^c^ooocr>CT»(7>o>'^(\j>-^ooo,, 0'--t'--iO'^<\iouj f-tco(Nj>o ^ror-air-rOf^irnr-r-ai^-ii-iin^-ir-'r-ininp*-^^^ tninininogoocMCMincMOOCMOgocMac cmooco ^oo^o^o>^<>^c\ic\jc^>r^>f ^^>i-^v4"^-inininininininvOvO vO*o^oinvOvOvOvor-NOvOa. oocoaop- ooo^o^o^oooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooCOZ>CO

CM CM CM CMvo <ommininvOvO > N ,OvO vOvO^O'O^OvO ,o ,o>o yO>ONO vO vO ,O sO HO yO'0^o sO vO vO sO >o^o>OvoC\J (NJ <\J CM (M f\J CM (\l <NJ CM CNl CM (\| CM rg CM CM CM Cvi CSJ C\| CM CM CM CM (M CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM

cc a>-d-fMcM ^^co^coinroc^^^f^v}-^c^<ff^r^<>(>r-ooois-t*»r,-r-<MincMoor*«'OcMCMOOino2 cM^mr- >^mmmm.^gococMCMOOo^o^<o>o^c3>co^co^c^c>cocoa3cocor— ojcocoota. inininin >t>fr>^>fr^cj>>r>t^^>f >^*4"ro>^ coco <r»co coco coco cocococo coco coco c^

inmm in r--f— r~-r—- r*— o>r— j*— r— r— r— r— r-— r— r— r— r—- r»- r*~ r— r— p-- c»— r^ r— i—r— r— r— r^- r*- r— r^- r— r— **— r*— r^ r*- r—

<u.

CMCMfMCM eg CM CM CM (M CM CM eg CM CM <M CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM^ CM CM CM C^

00Z>enXr-

cmcocoo *tcoc^^a}<r>c2C)&^(X)r^<)^^co<D<Dr^cr\-&or4c^r^>t<3<)^t^<)r*<va}\jria**G<J*c^<Zir<iOvO^ cMncorriogocMCMinr>-^ >^ co cooo cm »^co co co ^cm <o o>o co o^ co^mmo^ coco cm co^mo"* <?*»-»

cMm>t^ ^^cof^o»to>^vOmm>^a30NomcMOi^o>OrncM^vO>^cocomc^o*t^cx>o>^(7'cnmcMOr-a>m -^^tcocr^-ir-rrimmr-oofomp-r-coocMcor^^omco^.-^r-Ogoop"-cococogO'-^gocr>>j-o

a^a^ocM rncM>oomoc>aDooo^cooNONC^cjNcj>oooo^cMCMcn^mmr^r^a3cac^ocMc^in in go go cM^OO^o^OTCococo^cocococDcoajc^cj^o^O^c^co^co^c^r*>r—^-p» r».f>»r*"r— v0^0s0v0v0*0^0 v0>0*0v0>0>0 v , v0O >0v0 v v s N >O vOO*OOr"^'N P—f*" f-r-r*—

LU

X

fOCMgOOCMCMCMO>T

rci«4">Tin

• . • »coCM CM CM CM

co>*oCO

nO cm co cm -4- coooO n*"—im i—t co cm co r—o com ro p- en go go co gocoin^o^^cogOG^-^^fcoin^ocMgor^go>ror—m rococo co^coror^m r^aoa>r—c*i r- cm cj» go >3- 0"*goor-incocMinin>rco->J"CMr^r^mcT> cocor^OTO^cM>rm>or^i^wc^.^^^r^c^uir^o<^OTr\jo^c\i^uiinin^^>0'0^^vO^<3^^^^r»i^cocDc^c^(^oooo^c\i(\jrog"<,in<)

OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO'

103

Page 208: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 209: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

eg (\i <\j c\j cm eg eg <\jOOOOOOOOmenenmcncncn<n

p* Is- p- p» r— p«» r*- p* p* p-p»- p- p- e- p- r*- p- h- h- p- P- p- p*- P- r— I

s- h- f*» p- r— r>- p- r— r*— r— r—rg eg eg rg eg eg eg cm r\j eg eg eg c\j eg rg c\j r\j eg eg rg cm eg eg eg eg eg eg eg cm cm cm cm eg eg cm egooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooen en en co ro ro re, en enm en en en enm en en rn en co en en rnmcnrncncncncnrncocnencncn

cl ^rgogoegiMcoegp-^ ^^%©r-oinegmo. cnr^cjs-4-cr«cnooc\j

en en <n -4- ^" ifMT>o

eg©r^^Ocncor^^^(^oa3ooor^>roN sOina3CMO^aO'^egen^c\jor^r^cn^a30N cjsen

cm «o p* eg en (^ in (7> en r- vo in 1-1 en—* coo >-t P*»o >r <-4& inoo co eg 1-100 r— in eg cro vOvO en eg r*oo cm p~ oj- vf -4" >4* inp- qo -4" r-i *-« %o in ,—i •< —i cm in cp- en ej* >yco en oo en g3 en vOLnininin<o>OP^P*ODOeMNt, NOe^cj»r^cnen^ing3r^cocj»o^cn>4"ining3vOr^cO<>e^

aooocoaococococjo ^^^^^^^^^cvJ cgcMCMegegcncnenencnrncncncn>t>i->4-^^'>j'>tvr>t^>t ,«tvOvO ,>0'-o^Ovog3 vOvO^NO sO^O vO vO vOO vO >o^O vOvOvOvOsO vO vO vO^OvogO'-og3 vOvO vO

ac o^^gje-egrnr-m3 en>faoo>CMaoNi-QOo. cj> en ino in ct>>1"CO

m^gar—p^p-coco

oo eno tr> cr> soo >r —«p» r*» —io en ino rj* r— -a in p- co *o eg oo .-« r*» eno cmo cmo *-*o^0^>tej^cMoou^Oin<^oOvOOcx)u^cocoinr^cM^r^ena3>4"vOOO^vOincn^ooo^a^ >o >0o >$•o vO cm co co <^c^ cm eg a^ in in^ c^ so u^ g? r^ <j*>r roin in in gp so I

s- p- co ooo cm -J" vOoo «-• en en in in go Is- co cx>o eg en in in go go r- p~ ejv rjso

00 mmmmminmm cooocooo(DoococDco^(?ONo,'OOOOooooooo^^^^H-)^(^^HHegLninLnmmmLnmminiriinm«ogo>OgDvo^ vO sOg3 ,,O vO vO vog3 sOg3 vOgo^og3 NOg3g3

a.a.

en

CO

CMCMOCMOegeg—*go go eg >0 eg -o >o cogOgjvO^O^vOvOOOOOOOOOO

O eg soO r- vO p» r» fj>O a> eg eg en en »-h cm eg >t eg eg *r **> en >}• -4- -4-in cm >4"-tf" >fr en in >$• in

minr-4 0^ini-<r*-incr>g3CT>c0Osl- ^cMcococM030egco>oegegegcooegrMCM-OcocMco(7»^in>rr^r^p*oo<i)<^o^cMen(ncncnen>tcn^<r>rNt>^v^>r>r>r^--4'-4">r>tin^cm en en en fn en en en en en^ >j- ^- vj- ^- st >t >4- >*• >i" >*• »t >t >i- vt -^ -4- >t -t -4- vt >t^ -t >t vf

g^gDvo^^ogDgDvOeg eg eg eg eg eg eg eg

p- p-p» p- r-r— p-r* e* r- r- e* r- p— e* r- r— r— r» p«- r»^^^^f^^^r^^,*^-^^^«-r«-r-•^-r>-^*p,-

eg eg eg eg cm cm eg eg eg eg eg eg eg eg eg eg cm eg eg cm egcm eg eg eg eg egeg eg eg eg eg eg eg eg eg

cc ininoinoinmegjc r-p»cop*cop-p*-p-ex en en en en en eo en en

P* p- P- h- Is- P^ P- P»

goao^gO"^^'^'^^^'—, -^o>>'—*'-*^"g3vO"—ig3->^'Hcn>Oi-H»-<>—•cn>^'—t—41—<vo.^ncomO P- en enooO <?> co P- >om >^ en en en eg eg eg eg eg eg —1 r-t eg eg cm —* eg cm cm cm i-h—<O <-•

p* gD -o g3 >o >o g3m inm inm in in in in inin in in in in in inm in in in in in in in in in in inc^O^O^^c^^e^^Cj^^e^^c^^e^cj^o^c^c^ONCj*^

< cm eg eg eg eg eg eg eg eg eg eg eg eg egeg eg eg eg rg, eg cm cm eg eg eg eg cm cm cm cm cm cm eg eg eg cm cm cm eg cm eg eg eg eg

a:X

m co >r rn 00 r» *-*r-o>in i-»p- co& en coomoin-^—<cmo*4" 0> eg r— cm P~ cm *0

0>^ejoo-^CM>^eMC^<X)r^vOcoocM^oco>tinf^o<^ininsOeMegin«^Oooo^<l-a33cM^r^incMcoONa3^»^>^ino>tOin>^coP*enc>en^inP*-egegc^cnegO>l-<)iricncnr^vteMO^i^egi^eg^enoroga^gacMcnencMencjOvO^vOinasr^o^^^^rop^^eg>j-^f^NOON P~enc/>vocoocM^<T>ocogD»ocncM<7v <7>—4engoege-%j-cMnomoincM^o

eg eg en en^ vt in in

is.r- f>» r^. f^. («- («»f«-

vO>og3>oor^cocoaN^vt^OQO<^egcnininr^Qoaja>^cMcninvocoooa*oo^HCMcnenen en en en en en en en en^^ >^ »^ ininmm in in in inm ga go ^o \0 g? «o >o >o r* p*-p~ p* p*> e-g3g3>o^g3^og3>C vO vO«og3>O vO N NO v^ NOvO ,o > NOg3^0 vO vO>o»o^og3g3^g5 vt'g3 vO

LUX

co^vrvOOinc^u^cMvOcocMcMenco<>ingDO>cor*>r^cnco<>ocMin(n^P^cocM<^cj>egr-H-4-ejo.^^Tco -4" 000^-4* '-*NrcMNOcnin>j">^^OP-mo>r cmOi-ictn vooMncMcoc^cMmcoi—icooou^cM>rgjco^cninr^ing3coornu^r^ocMO>vOcnor^>ror*r^^co^incn>J"Or^>reM>rr^u>r^>rvOp-r—p*p~aococo ooo^^<^^egegegen>f intng3r^p*P~cocoa>o>i OO'H'-^egcneoencn>r^ininin

0000000000000000000000.eg

O<n

104

Page 210: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 211: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

r-r— r*-r»r-r*- oo oo oo co co as oo oo oo co oo oo as co as coooooco as co asasasasas coco o>cr>0>ocr*0N <s>0> <T>

cmcmcmcmcmcm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cm cmcmcmcmcmcmoooooo oooooooooooooooooooooooooooo ooooooooo

cc oj—tooo^r*- ina3r-4 <-ic\iir\fn^r»<\jir\ir\ONooooinLn(s-Ofn^a^in^-tr~o^3 (nj>oo(\iop* mrs-(**orr»(\iromcoo>fvj-oo>, r*o>r^oa3mor\jox f

,*-4-'^'^a3o_ moc^a^o^m >^>j'inf^asin(MC*ini^as^ooocjNin*-ir«-rnoinino^oro>3-o

o^^—<>^nO ^soaD^-tcNj^rvOasrjmmr-orvjvj-r-aso^o^o^^-irvj^aD-HmvO

vommcs>cMasa*NO«4"ro a* >o ihm tro as romr-ocnr^^r^oMmO <y>OOO—* CM eg rr\

inininm-4-m N(s,P"OOCOQOCOCOON (7l <^Ov OOOOOOO'-<-^i-<^'-*OOC7v COin in in in in lh in in in in iri in sOo vOoo^ ^o >o so nO vO ^o vOo inm mminininmmmm

cc >o as >ro> in .-* c\jincg(s>^ascr>rr^ininr*^N0 03i>«.^mi^<^r^vOr^»T<x, rr>orr)

3 ^-i>i-asascgr<"i rr»vo>0(^rof\iroinc»»-<vOvOrnc\ia»roa3 0<\jaN>l-vO>*"rnvO'-^r*'0a. astncomrocj' mmvO^crvomONoaDo^na^cg^-tOvOfrio^Nrr-^yor-njr^^r^f-t

Or-^<\Jc\imsO cgvrvOo>o(N>3-r*o>^HminooonjvOv0^r*-a30Ncro<MvOOx ^>^

mcr, tncj>.^oasrgc\i-o »h o>^ vom >rnj r-vO a> -^ >^ ao so in r-i >r

X n0*O >OvO >o >o-t >4" >4" >tmmm in in vo >0 >o vO r- r— f*- 1** r*» r— r— r- r* as as r- as ^omin in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in

ooooooooomminmir^inmmm

<•>

CCa.

asOCO

mm cocoasm Noajo^-«(Ni-tc\i^^«4'roininsor*-r^ooo*oo^^ooj(Njr*-oroin^aa<o>i"^<'-i o^in^c^rno> cno,>irio*r^inoN ^ooroa3rn>oo>f cNj>-tino<7>

in^>4"coo>-4- oc\irnininvCvOO(s-a3a>oo—tf\i>T^>^-<}"tninNOsO^(Ni^"^o>o«4-^-4->fmco NO>o^^ONO^>o>o>o>o>Or--r*r--r»-r-r«-is-r--f«-fs-r--r*-r,*r^NOinvj-

cMCM>rmco^rin>rNO

cor-a»coa30>000vO ,-0 >O^ONO >Or^r*, r,~

p-r-r-r-r-r-CMCMCMCMCMCM

asasasasasasasasasasasasasasasasasasasasasasasasasasascoCM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM

C^O^OOXS^C^CS^OCM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM CM

cc

a.

2:<

O^^coas>rin in in in in no0* O*O 0^ 0"> CJ>

m roo cm as P» >*• p"»O r» »-i as as cm cm sf -4- cmO r-O in ro^ cm -4"O ascm *-<oo a* a* o> cr> o* as as p- r*- p- p- >o so >o vom in in in -4" r-o -4- r—a^O^OO^asasasasasasasasasasasasasasasasasasasasasooCT'

(T)>J"asO'-<as^>4-c\ip—r—gDp—p->o>o>o<oasasasasasasasasasrocommcoromrom

cmcmcmcmcmcm mmmmmmmmmcococommcommcommcommco romcoco mm com coco rococo

CCX

^coascMm^ OO^O^CMOCM^SroasaSO^invOasoaSasinocMOCMOOOOP»(\joomin m^0^mOoasr^ascomO^ON mp~vOP~c\i<^>tmC*maS(\jc\i«4- '-*

*4--4"intnasgs ^cMO^mvt asm asinine o»Ma^mooasinP*as>t, cMmO'-",asasm-^oomcN roinr*in>^rNjr^ocj»cMinOi^rntnp--'4'Or--roOvoasvi-inincoas

^•cMO>j-cr>-ooNCMmLnmmcjMni-«asc\jcM

(MlOCO^lfivtrflCvt

•4- in «o vO as cjn <3>^^m^asocMinr^ocMvj"f>»c>^in>oP-r*-as(>o^ocM'>oascj>--<h-r-P"-r»«OLn ascjNg>cr><^oooo^^^t-H»-ic\icMCMCMCMc\icMCMoorncM^-«ooo^o^o^o^O ininininm^o^o^o^o^oo^OvO^o-o^ONO^o^O'OvO^^go^vO^^o

r^oooo^egmm4" -4* -4*in in in in in inininininminininin

fs.f^^corocMcgcMf^cMO>tCN^cj^in^cNcOvOcj>'^in<^inor^^r^vO^<t >fas—4(MvO^" incMincM^iArovom^^asop'-NOOCNjinascMCMiiAasCN^-ir-asgs o cm .4- in -4" r— as .-4ot— o(v»p^<\joc\jf^ro>«ocj>v^oNO>rrn«r-'-H<-ti>-^asocM«4"r-cr—-uncMrvjcor-cr*!—iin«4-rocM'-»asin«Tmuj -o^o^or^<T"-* r-»ooO'HC\jcMfnNrininvor>»r*-as(^ooooO'-''-<<M^voaso mmmmmcMCMCNjcgx m • m • • . •

l_ .-i.-i.-i^.-KVj oOOOOOOOOOOOOCJOOf-H—*»H'-H'H—4—t^Hf-H^-t^CM OOOOUOOOOas i I o i I l I i I I I I

CM >*-

o oro

' m

105

Page 212: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 213: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

X

rg rvj rg eg eg eg eg (\i <\i f\i cm eg cm <nj eg rg rg eg (M rg rg rg rg cm rg eg eg rg cm rgrgoooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooro ro enm en on rn en en en en ro on ro ro en on on ro ro ro ro ro ro rororororoeorn

c£ >©>*, co>*-r^r*r^cor^oocr>0^^o^egcoa^o^>^rorginaDOr^rgvrr\jr-o>3 r*oonr^inu^rn<^tnr^^in>r^ogr^>rrgvr>f -^c^O^rgr^srsrsfOsi-gsQ. f\JfOi^OvO^<>O^OOr^^vOU^vOOO(^^>J'vOr*-O^O^Of-tcO^-tinc\j>J-f\l"*

>rin so r- r* r- co o*o—» eg rg ro <j- vo co ~* ro inf— c* <-h <r >*• eg co co co i*- inoh- • •#•••••••»••••••••••#• •••O >i*vt^>^^>^>^Nj-^u>u^^u^inininvO>og3>og3f^r^r*-r--Noin>3"rnroroH- m in in in in inmm in in in in inmm in in in inin inm inmm in in inm in in

ct (^vOONi^a3^^invou^»^fOfNjrgr^ir\r-«rgrr)i^-Tvrcr>o>r>rornr-incDinjC —i<f r-i—io><fco<fOog>o.—lOO^ooro^o^^^cogDr-o^ogcosf >-*r«-.-^og

a. ^srrgrgr^^Of^OQ>^cor*r^o^^oninooc^o,^rgrgOog>oensf enino—i ogm rn vfmo r~ r» cd co <t>oegm r>- <j> <-*m ^o cooo <j> <!• >*• >rm .-•so

H- • ••••••••••• ••••••••••••(/) ^^^^^,^^,^^^^,^^ rgrg rgrg rgrorOroro>i-<j-rO'-o eg.-iqoo*X in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in u"i in in in in in in in in in in in in >*^-

uo so >onOvO gam 03 coco r-r—r-r-r- coc^o^o-^ i-iogroOQ>rop-oo^r—lu og>^rg^vococoaocorgoooovO<f sf ^cj><y»ONin-*«-iog<f-r-^»-tr«»oot ^-«^-i^-i—4cgi-4CMc\irgrn->l"-4">f sfvl-in^vO^or-o-o^r-sfo^-^ininvf ^-i

CO C^0> C^<^O> O> 0^O', C^C^<7s O> O> O> > O^C> 0^O^CJ^C>O> > N O> O^0N > (7*0^C7>

^ rg rg c\j rg rg rg rg rg eg eg eg rg rg rg rg eg eg eg egeg eg egcNrg eg eg rgrg eg eg egCO

cC 0> co 0^ co en vO eg rgrgo r^r^ r^r*<f ^vOsO>frOO on in <fvOr^O>r^r^O^ <!•

2 inininininininintninsf>^>r<f«^^onrnroonenrgrgon>f* voo^rgrgrgvj-o. co co co 00 co co 00 co co co co 00 co oo co co co co co co co co co co co co co o^o>0>cr

roroononcornroroenro^roonrorornonroenenrororotoenrofoenrnror^z ....#.. •••••< rOroenrnrnrnrornrnrnenrnrnrororOroroonrnrorOro<^rorororoeoonr^li-

ra vi- si-o >0 -4- *n >o eg >c rgo —1 1-1 vO -4-O ro <$ -OO r»O -O rgo on in -d- rs| »0

h- o>vO'^Oi^«^o>'^ino> ^r^in>tO'^^^corg<\jcorr»NOrgrgc>''-<incoino>>

oo rg<j-inr*Or-CMncop-^o<j- ^-iOco^-tcoinp-inor-inooOsi-cosOco<j-m3 ^ in <f vt -^ <r^^ in in --tin in r^o >t r^ eg no (^ ro in coco in rocovo 00 in ona: ••••• •

X «^insOr*<DcoO^O--^rgrnro<rincoOcvjinr^o^rg<fgDNOinoO>'CO^ONro>h- ininininmininvo>Ov0^^^^o>or^r^r^r^r^oocococoooo3\Oin>^>rrri

inmm in in in inm in in ininm in in in in in inin in in in in in in in in in inm

o* co on o^ ro —1mo ga ct> co <ro en co in o^ r-o co rn co rg vo co r-t ro _i >o -o <r< '^o>ininoor^o^^Oeo<rro>r ro>d'r^«-4'HOCOvOr*-vOrO<--<>rrgcoegrOi-tOt— OsO<r^o>coinegoegsru^cO'MCO>ueno^i^cjr*>reni/»inu<r>ro^cr>lu (\jHi-i^ooooooooOH^f\jrfig,g, if\vOvOr»coooOfninr»r-oo

000000000000000000000000 o-V I I I I V t » \

106

Page 214: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 215: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

Ooo onono^OCT^O OOOOOO ^-ir-t^*<-*f-4r-t corocococOco -4-»*"^n^ -*•>!- OnO^O0D^ r-l^-t*—1^4>—4^-4 CMCMCMCMCMCM CMCMCMCMCMCM CMCMCMCMCMCM CMCMCMCMCMCM CMCMCMmm mmmmmm mmmmmm mmmmmm mmmmmm mmmmmm mmmC\J<N CMCMCMCMCMCM CMCMCMCMCMCM CMCMCMCMCMCM C\J CM CM CM CM CNJ CMCMCMCMCMCM CMCMCM

CC3Q.

H-O

mcnCO CM

CO 00

mr*co>roc\jCMsOCM>l"OC\JvOi-ic^omo^omcOvQCM^"

r-f—cocnr^'-^OCMf-f^OCMo»or*-tnoo—*<T>CMr"-r*-i-<CM

>r-^^cocov0

^r-'-'mm^c^sj-cvjm-^-cjN

cM-rmcnr-tcocuro-Or^m>-*

CJ>>OCOCJ*CMCJ*

OOCOCTOCMCM<-* 0"» —* -* CM >—

i

om>rr*-mcMOCMCMCMO^"

CM 00 COIT\—«C0ooco»-«

COOr-co

>tcor^mcO'-<COCO «*ir\vO r^-

COCO >0<i"CMOcoco«d-mvor^

cor»-mcMcr>vococo>d-mm^

CO vO CO0**0 CMcoro-4-^mvO

^sOCMCO-J-OCOCO^^^O

comococo^-

cc

3Q.

f-00X

mcj»CO CM^mOO'-*

aocr*cno>mr-cor—cm^ocvjcooovor-cMsOcor—vooomr-

r^">r>rmovo-oaocMmomr»co>ocor- cr*

OCMOOCOOJCM

^moM^-asr*-cMmo^^Ocomcm in co co CO cmoocoo^coco

m»-4<—t>r>rcr»r*-cMm-Ococj»>J•Gor•• vO^ <J,,

mcMC^moom

vOvOOcoojino>oo^ocomo«7>cMOvONd-r^-vor-inco

rToo<-CJvCOCMoo^

vOCMcvivOmco^-toCOro>J-mNO>0

CM*O>t<^JOa0coco-^movO foro^-mm>o

-^vj-or-coococo^^in-o

--» coa*ir\.-4 ro-

coco ro>t in in~*CMC0co co CO

LU_lo<uu

IDO00>—OOi—•LUa. a:

o_OO>LU

_fI— CD00 CO33a; coXl-QZ

<H-QOlul-UJ

00

LUCQ

OoC-.<!LL>

00LUOCa.

3CO

3a.

<LL

003C£X

LUX

ooooooooOC0COr-t

ooooooinr-

cO^h

m vO cr> -^cm tr>

p-inoocorjNOCO «-h CO ^o ^o ^o

cjiooomvo-ooocooo^ococMCMOfJNcor-CO CO CO CNJ CM CM

CMO00 0^0000-4"CMr~mocr>-<ococor*-r^aocor-r— p—p*-

CM»—»r-»C\J^^f-t

p-p-p-p-p-p*

CMO—»CJ>CJnOmcocT>>o^fOCO CM CM CM CM CMCO 00 CO CO CO 00

0*O 0> 0* 0* c*

r^cosi-mmmco oo CT» 0^ <T> cj>

CMCMCMCMCMCM

ooooooCM CM CM CM CM <N CMCMCMCMCMCM

oco>}"oo^m oosomvooo

.—t.—'.

i^_,__i_^ ^ ,-4CM CM CM CM(J\ Q\ CJ» CXJN 0> H^i-lHf-l'^

CO cO CO CO fO COCMCMCMCMCMCM

r-vf-4-ONf—

t

OhhOhHCJ»0> 0*0>CJ*C7»cOrOCOcOrOcO

CMCMCMCMCMCM

CMf"-C7>CMOr>-i-tCMrHCMCMCMmmmmmmmmmmmm

OO CMCM-0>l"COvOoo cM^-tvfmcoooOO sOCMOvfOcOOO >J-mcMCMC^CO• • •••••»OO ^cj»mcM—*&f-tCO CMf-CJNOOOcjnco ^^u^r*-co(7\

OOOcOCOvOvO

f-Ii-4<O0s '-'i—

I

^OP-sO-OCM

oo com -j- cm-*cr«oino*oino* in >o cm cr> cof**covO*cO<^

cor-o^mro-j-

CMOOOO^O*

ooco>r°omo^-HP» cocoooo*4->4"mvor*-co

vj-o-4f*-r«->t—tvo^om^*4--j-ir\Nor--ao

<—inO>j-o<-*cjx

^>r co cmooo>t>J-ms0is~fs-

CM-^CMsOOOs0v0>OOOO

CM CM CM

mcMmr»oor>-COfOCO

CMCMCMCMCMCM CMCMCMCMCMCM CMCMCMCMCMCM CMCMCM

O-t^oo cMaocMOP^On^CM^-4 lf\0>Niniri^N^o omr^-CJ^cOCOOncmco ror^-o

cjx^r^-m^vl- p^aor-OCO'-'OT—m OCMCT>

»-toocMP*-cMvOO>r*-cMCM<-"CMr-OvO'-»cMNOoOf-4cjicMmcMr*-o->j- cocor*-cMO> oomcMOCMCMO*r«-moooo^ohooon ^r— nOvqcmit* o>o—it— vOcr> ooor>»»rcMCM <HcocofMoo p*»mcM<^om'^mm^vOOO^'Hr^cocoNomr^-^u, cM<?cj>r^r^'^r^>ocjO'--| coco<--tcr>vo <Jr*-cocM'-*^o<—icj*omcMOo>o>rcococo «o»tcm—i-^<-« cMOaor—r-p*- ao>o>j">rcoco ^o^ cm —«<-••-< ^tcmo>co • «co • t • • • »fO • • • • • »co • • • • • »co • • t • • »co * t • • • »co • • •

CJO^OvrcOCOcOCOcO COCOfOCOcOCO cncOCMCMCMCM CMCMCMCMCMCM CM CVJ CM CM CM CM CMCMr-tCM >0 O vO >o -O "OO Omm m m m m mCM CM CM CM CM CM CM

107

Page 216: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 217: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

«oo*o h-h-h-h-r1*!*- cocooocococo o>om3>oo^o^CMCMCM CMCMCMCMCMCM CMCMCMCMCMCM CMCMCMCMCMCMminrn mminmmin tnmintninm ininminminCMCMCM <M(\|(\JCMCMA4 CMCMCMCMCMCM CMCMCMCMCMCM

3Q.

Oaoo

mr-m

mco^o —tornmcovtcMmmr-o^m^m

mmoooaoo>rir»t-*inrricMm^oc^m-^—4—i —i en r- ^0

OOm^mOOCMvO>Tt-«>TCMmoor- cmo

ro^o^cj^mmm^-^m

m -4- co cm sO >-*

mmm^^tncM(M*oo>rr»mmm ->f^ .4-

OOvOin

•4T^vOvOCJNCO

r»a>cov<j»-*>rr^ -4"m ao qo -$cj*mcj*\Or»-oo

oinino>ro*-4r-inr-4a\r-»TCM—<<-t»5"CMa>OCT»cMm>r

vyvOmmcoornr*-cj>ooo>-crvoo^oomr-mm.-ior-cM

Xrooo^^f^tn

OCM^-^vO—

1

mmm^-4-moo -i" <j>m cocMmmm>t<j-

0J>CJ>mr,-O>3"cMCMmm^>t

LU

a.

^.-•CM

ooo

—imrOCM^mCM^vl-OCMCO-^mm^^^l-

m-o —<—«cMmcMir»vO>o>rop-comr" coff-

in r^r»r--r- r--

P-OvO'-^COCM

m>tmr»mvO

Z>co

CM CM CM CMCMCMCMCMCMCO CO 00 CO 00 COCMCMCMCMCMCM

CJN fjv <J\ Q\ QN CJ>

CMCMCMCMCMCM

CX3

CMCMIT*cocor-mmm

CJ>^-l-^Nj-r-4minmmcMCM^inininminm

s CT" CJn 0> fj> fj>

mcovoco<fomr,-m^'sMno> co co co co 00

<Mr*»O^-"4C0'-«jNco-4-m^aooo co ao co co comm commm

cMCMCM cmcmcmcmcmcm mmmmmm mmmmmm

00

atX

cmOco Lnp-cococMvi-cor^->—

<

<T>>OvO cocoonmc*c> mvOoocM<-iooomo >4"ir»NOCMC7,m

^ooaor-coNOm^mm^mr-m--ioinmf\J.-H*-*i-l>OCM

coomcor— >$vO^Nt^CMON4-cMommoNr->or*--4-oo

aooom —ir-mo^^cM•omn OHl^fOOr"irvsor- »r^ -4- in <o -o

omir»»-'r— 1-4

aNom«-*vomm^vfmmvO

oocomcomh-mm^^mm

cm^cm cm r-< ir\o cm vj- oo cm cjn r- cmo r*-mm cminm rj* co oo< C7>ooir\ r-vomoNcrio —<o>o^cocm co^mm-*mh- co«rm<—icMi-if*-vOi-t'-^'-<omomc'>co<-'r~oinoc7NCMlu cococo mosommm mr*»mcM^r-t roc/iNOO*^x • t »m • • • • • »m • • • • • «m ••••••(— r-lf-li—t rMiHi-i-^HH cMf—I^ •—•.—•<—4 CM^i—MQp-I

vO <o *o

inCM

inCM

inCM

108

Page 218: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 219: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

LIST OF REFERENCES

1. Robert L. Trillo, Marine Hovercraft Technology, Leonard

Hill, 1975

2. Oceanics, Incorporated, Report No. 71, Technical

Industrial Park, Plainview, N. Y. , 11803, August 1971

3. Boncal, R. and Leo, D. G., XR-3 Surface Effects Ship

Test Craft ; a Mathematical Model and S imulation Program

with Verificat ion, M.S. Thesis, Naval Postgraduate

School, December 1973

4. Forbes, G. T. , Validation of the Non linear

Six-Degree-Qf -Freedom M ath ematical Model of the XR-3

Captured Air Bubble Surface Effect Ship in Calm Water,

M.S. Thesis, Naval Postgraduate School, December 1974

5. Menzel, R. F. , A Study of the Roll and Pitch Tran sients

in Cal m Water tJsing_ the Simulated Per formance of the

XR-3 S urfa ce Effect Ship Loads and Motions Computer

Program, M.S. Thesis, Naval Postgraduate School,

December 1975

109

Page 220: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 221: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

INITIAL DISTRIBUTION LIST

No. Copies

1. Defense Documentation Center 2

Cameron Station

Alexandria, Virginia 22314

2. Library, Code 0212 2

Naval Postgraduate School

Monterey, California 93940

3. Department Chairman, Code 62 2

Electrical Engineering Department

Naval Postgraduate School

Monterey, California 93940/

4. Professor George J. Thaler, Code 62Tr 5

Department of Electircal Engineering

Naval Postgraduate School

Monterey, California 93940

5. Professor Alex Gerba, Jr., Code 62Gz 1

Department of Electrical Engineering

Naval Postgraduate School

Monterey, California 93940

6. Mr. A. W. Anderson 6

PMS 304-31A-1

Surface Effect Ships Project Office

P.O. Box 34401

Bethesda, Maryland 20034

110

Page 222: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 223: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

7. Lt. Frederick K. Richardson, OSN

Strategic Systems Project Office, SP-273

Department of the Navy

Washington, D.C. 10091

111

Page 224: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface
Page 225: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

20FCB7925210

;8882lbThesis

H3f ^er"optimization ofPoWer

°~d"air bubble

Surface

20FEB7925210

3

ThesisR386/

c.l

163682Richardson

Power optimization ofthe captured air bubbleSurface Effects Ship.

Page 226: Power optimization of the captured air bubble Surface

thesR3867

Power optimization of the captured air b

3 2768 000 99051 9_, DUDLEY KNOX LIBRARY