powder metallurgy titanium and titanium alloy components ......uts [ksi] ys [ksi] elon. [%] fracture...
TRANSCRIPT
-
Georg Abakumov, Director Business Development, ADMA Products, Inc.October 7‐10, 2012 • Atlanta, Georgia, USA 1
Powder Metallurgy Titanium and Titanium Alloy Components Manufactured from Hydrogenated
Titanium Powders
Georg I. Abakumov, V.S. Moxson , Vladimir Duz, Mykhailo Matviychuk, Viktor Sukhoplyuyev
-
Georg Abakumov, Director Business Development, ADMA Products, Inc.October 7‐10, 2012 • Atlanta, Georgia, USA 2
• INGOT BASED (WROUGHT) TITANIUM• ENORMOUS ENERGY INPUT• EXTENSIVE PROCESSING and MACHINING• HIGH SCRAP RATE – LOW “BUY to FLY” • LONG LEAD TIME TO FINISHED PRODUCT• HIGH COST = USE LIMITED to “COST IS NO OBJECT” APLLICATIONS!• As the Commercial Aviation industry grows in the “post recession” economic
recovery, strain on the supply of titanium and DRIVE UP THE COST of Titanium and Titanium Components!
• THE FUTURE OF TITANIUM IS TITANIUM POWDER METALLURGY!
-
Georg Abakumov, Director Business Development, ADMA Products, Inc.October 7‐10, 2012 • Atlanta, Georgia, USA 3
• ADMA HYDROGENATED TITANIUM POWDER BASED COMPONENTS • REQUIRE LESS PRECIOUS ENERGY AT EVERY STEP OF PRODUCTION • HAVE “BUY to FLY” APPROACHING 1 TO 1 (LITTLE OR NO SCRAP)• SHORT LEAD TIME TO PRODUCTION OF FINISHED COMPONENTS
• WITH NO SACRIFICE INPERFORMANCE • ADMA TiH2 COMPONENTS MEET AND SURPASS ASTM, MIL
DTL 46077, AND AMS AT A FRACTION OF THE COST
-
Georg Abakumov, Director Business Development, ADMA Products, Inc.October 7‐10, 2012 • Atlanta, Georgia, USA 4
Processing Steps for Blended ElementalTitanium Alloy Parts Production
Powder
RollingFlat (foil, sheet, plate)
Round (bar, rod)
Post-Processing Outside vendorsADMA Titanium P/ M “in house” Processes
Die Press
Direct Powder Rolling
Cold Isostatic Pressing
Vacuum Sintering
Finished product
Rotary Forging
Extrusion
FlowformHIP
Vacuum Sintering
Wire drawing
Forging
-
Georg Abakumov, Director Business Development, ADMA Products, Inc.October 7‐10, 2012 • Atlanta, Georgia, USA 5
Wednesday June 20, 2012 Dr. Sami El‐Soudani, The Boeing CompanyDr. Kuang‐O (Oscar) Yu and Ernie M. Crist, RTI International Metals, Inc.Dr. Vladimir S. Moxson and Dr. Vladimir Duz ADMA Products Inc.
The feasibility of rolling process development has been successfully demonstrated at RTI…using initial rolling preforms of blended‐elemental hydrided titanium powder billets fabricated by ADMA using their titanium hydride (“hydrogenated”) powder blended with master alloy aiming at Ti‐6AL‐4V composition… All elements of the pre‐rolling billet preforms…were within AMS Specification limits…showed equivalent or superior tensile properties as compared to rolling processed wrought ingot‐based Ti‐6AL‐4V billet materials… The Boeing executed text matrix included processing‐microstructure‐property correlations of tensile properties, S‐N fatigue life, fatigue crack growth rate…fracture toughness per ASTM‐E399‐K1C…and stress‐corrosion resistance…
Development and Optimization of Rolled Product Forms Using Blended‐Elemental Powder‐Based Ti‐6AL‐4V Alloy
-
Georg Abakumov, Director Business Development, ADMA Products, Inc.October 7‐10, 2012 • Atlanta, Georgia, USA 6
Wednesday June 20, 2012 Dr. Sami El‐Soudani, The Boeing CompanyJohn Fanning, Megan Harper, Dr. Stephen Fox, Timet, Inc.Dr. Vladimir S. Moxson and Dr. Vladimir Duz ADMA Products Inc.
The feasibility of rolling process development has been successfully demonstrated at RTI…using initial rolling preforms of blended‐elemental hydrided titanium powder billets fabricated by ADMA using their titanium hydride (“hydrogenated”) powder blended with master alloy aiming at Ti‐6AL‐4V composition…
All elements of the pre‐rolling billet preforms…were within AMS Specification limits…showed equivalent or superior tensile properties as compared to rolling processed wrought ingot‐based Ti‐6AL‐4V billet materials… The Boeing executed text matrix included processing‐microstructure‐property correlations of tensile properties, S‐N fatigue life, fatigue crack growth rate…fracture toughness per ASTM‐E399‐K1C…and stress‐corrosion resistance…
Development and Optimization of Rolled Product Forms Using Blended‐Elemental Powder‐Based Ti‐6AL‐4V Alloy
-
Georg Abakumov, Director Business Development, ADMA Products, Inc.October 7‐10, 2012 • Atlanta, Georgia, USA 7
Development and Optimization of Rolled Product Forms Using Blended‐Elemental Powder‐Based Ti‐6AL‐4V Alloy
Ti-6Al-4V rolling billetsBoeing/ADMA/RTI/TIMET Sami M. El‐Soudani,
-
Georg Abakumov, Director Business Development, ADMA Products, Inc.October 7‐10, 2012 • Atlanta, Georgia, USA 8
RTI‐Rolled Blended‐Elemental Ti‐6Al‐4V Billets Met Specification Requirements and Matched Properties of Wrought Ingot Alloy
Initial Rolling Passes Were Performed by Straight Rolling ADMA Billets From 4” Down to 2”, 1”, and 0.5”‐Thick Plates at Niagara Specialty Metals, Inc., Then Followed by Final Cross (or Spread) Rolling at RTI International Metals, Inc.
Sami M. El‐Soudani,
-
Georg Abakumov, Director Business Development, ADMA Products, Inc.October 7‐10, 2012 • Atlanta, Georgia, USA 9
Sami M. El‐Soudani,
RTI‐Rolled Blended‐Elemental Ti‐6Al‐4V Billets Met Specification Requirements and Matched Properties
of Wrought Ingot Alloy Material and
Processing HistoryProduct
Form Sheet / Plate ‐Optimized
Number of Tests Used in Average Values
Statistical Measure: Average *Maximum *Minimum *
UTS[ksi]
YS[ksi]
Elon. [%] Fracture Toughness KIC
or KC[ ksi.inch½ ]
BE Ti‐6Al‐4V Powder CIP/Sintered then Hot
Rolled and Mill Annealed
Plate 10 Average 144 130 15 67
Sheet 34 Average 152 135 9 131
Double‐Arc Remelt Ingot Hot Rolled and
Mill Annealed Standard Grade
Ti‐6Al‐4V
Plate 2 Average 138 126 13 79
Sheet 8Average 132 121 10 147
-
Georg Abakumov, Director Business Development, ADMA Products, Inc.October 7‐10, 2012 • Atlanta, Georgia, USA 10
Our Plate Mill Product Processing Optimization at RTI Demonstrated High Fatigue Endurance Limits Matching Double-Arc-Remelt Wrought Ingot-Based Ti-6Al-4V Standard-Grade Alloy
Similarly Rolled Product FormsPlate Product Form Pedigree: Powder
Versus Ingot
Plate Identification and Rolling
Vendor
Plate GeometryAs-Tested per ASTM E 466
KT = 1 for S/N Fatigue Life[inches]
Original As-Sintered Rolled Billet Thickness[inches]
Fatigue Endurance
Limit [ksi]
Blended-Elemental Powder-BasedTi-6Al-4V Plate Product
RR4-2A (RTI) 27.7 x 7.2 x 0.480 4.0 88.0
RR2A (RTI) 13.1 x 6.9 x 0.970 4.1 72.5
Double Arc-Remelt Ingot-Based Plate W1 (RTI) 16.7 x 16.7 x 0.975 4.0 82.0
Sami M. El‐Soudani et al, Metall. and Mat. Trans. A ‐ Vol.41A, 2010
-
Georg Abakumov, Director Business Development, ADMA Products, Inc.October 7‐10, 2012 • Atlanta, Georgia, USA 11
Our Sheet Mill Product Processing Optimization at RTI Demonstrated High Fatigue Endurance Limits Matching
Double-Arc-Remelt Wrought Ingot-Based Ti-6Al-4V Standard-Grade Alloy Similarly Rolled Product Forms
Sheet Product Form Pedigree: Powder
Versus Ingot
Sheet Identification and Rolling
Vendor
Sheet Geometry as Tested per
ASTM E 466 KT = 1 for S/N Fatigue Life[inches]
Original As-Sintered Rolled
Billet Thickness[inches]
Fatigue Endurance
Limit [ksi]
Blended-Elemental Powder-Based
Ti-6Al-4V Sheet Product
RR1E (RTI) 13.5 x 7.7 x 0.131 4.2 68RR3D (RTI) 17.2 x 7.5 x 0.065 1.0 81
RR4-2C (RTI) 17.4 x 7.5 x 0.073 4.1 77
Double Arc-Remelt Ingot-Based Sheet
W2D (RTI) 16.9 x 8.6 x 0.076 4.0 85.5
W2C (RTI) 14.5 x 8.1 x 0.127 4.0 67
Sami M. El‐Soudani,
-
Georg Abakumov, Director Business Development, ADMA Products, Inc.October 7‐10, 2012 • Atlanta, Georgia, USA 1212
Material and Processing History
Product Form Sheet / Plate -
Optimized
Number of Tests Used in Average
Values
Statistical Measure:
UTS[ksi]
YS[ksi]
El.-[%]
KIC or KC[ ksi.inch½ ]
BE Ti-6Al-4V Powder CIP/Sintered then
Hot Rolled and Mill Annealed
Plate 8 Average 142 130 12 63
Sheet 18 Average 148 139 12 128
Double-Arc Remelt Ingot Hot Rolled
and Mill Annealed Standard Grade
Ti-6Al-4V
Plate 2 Average 138 126 13 79
Sheet 8 Average 132 121 10 147
Timet-Rolled Blended-Elemental Ti-6Al-4V Billets Met SpecificationRequirements and Matched Properties of Wrought Ingot AlloySami M. El‐Soudani,
-
Georg Abakumov, Director Business Development, ADMA Products, Inc.October 7‐10, 2012 • Atlanta, Georgia, USA 1313
The Boeing Company Goal was Near-Net Sheet Rolling Mill Product with the Lowest Overall Rolling Reduction Factor, the Best Property Balance, and Sintered Billets as Thin as 0.75”
The ADMA Hydrogenated Titanium Billet T4-2 (as-Sintered Dimensions 0.709 x 8.5 x 11 inches)
was Rolled Successfully at Timet and Easily Met Tensile, Fracture Toughness and Fatigue S/N Requirements!
Sami M. El‐Soudani
-
Georg Abakumov, Director Business Development, ADMA Products, Inc.October 7‐10, 2012 • Atlanta, Georgia, USA 1414
Our Sheet Mill Product Processing Optimization at Timet Demonstrated High Fatigue Endurance Limits Matching
Double-Arc-Remelt Wrought Ingot-Based Ti-6Al-4V Standard-Grade Alloy Similarly Rolled Product Forms
Sheet Product Form Pedigree: Powder Versus
Ingot
Sheet Identification and Rolling
Vendor
Sheet Geometryas Tested per
ASTM E 466 KT = 1[inches]
Original As-Sintered Rolled Billet Thickness[inches]
Fatigue Endurance
Limit [ksi]
Blended-Elemental Powder-Based
Ti-6Al-4V Sheet Product
T2.2.2 (Timet) 10.2 x 6.2 x 0.114 1.8 78
T4.2A-9 (Timet) 10.2 x 7.1 x 0.067 0.709 82
Double Arc-Remelt Ingot-Based Sheet
W2D (RTI) 16.9 x 8.6 x 0.076 4.0 85.5
W2C (RTI) 14.5 x 8.1 x 0.127 4.0 67
Sami M. El‐Soudani
-
Georg Abakumov, Director Business Development, ADMA Products, Inc.October 7‐10, 2012 • Atlanta, Georgia, USA 15
General Conclusions on Blended–Elemental Ti‐6Al‐4V Rolled Plate and Sheet Mill Product
The blended elemental RTI and TIMET‐hot‐rolled Ti‐6Al‐4V alloy mill products met the AMS Specification mechanical property
requirements for both static loading, as well as damage tolerant fracture toughness and cyclic S/N fatigue endurance limit for
aerospace applications. • Encouraging powder‐based rolled mill product form properties of
Ti‐6Al‐4V using optimized processing pathways shows static tensile, and fatigue S/N, and fracture properties matching similarly‐processed ingot‐based hot‐rolled product forms.
Boeing/ADMA/RTI/TIMET
-
Georg Abakumov, Director Business Development, ADMA Products, Inc.October 7‐10, 2012 • Atlanta, Georgia, USA 16
ADMA-fabricated Ti-6AL-4V blended elemental powder-based billets were extruded successfully by Plymouth Engineered Shapes, Inc.
Extrusions (up to 27 feet length) were fabricated and analyzed at front, mid-length, and back and found to be uniform with respect to oxygen content & microstructure. Longer and larger cross-section fabrication is a non-issue in this process.
AIRFRAME STRUCTURESCanless Extrusion Process Development for B/E Powder-Based Titanium Ti-6AL-4V Alloy
The Boeing Company and Plymouth Engineered Shapes, Inc.
Sami M. El‐Soudani et al, Metall. and Mat. Trans. A ‐ Vol.41A, 2010
-
Georg Abakumov, Director Business Development, ADMA Products, Inc.October 7‐10, 2012 • Atlanta, Georgia, USA 17
ADMA-fabricated Ti-6AL-4V blended elemental powder-based billets were extruded successfully by RTI International Metals, Inc. for The Boeing Company
36’-Long Extrusions Cut-up for Shipping and Laboratory Characterization
Ti-6Al-4V Ultimate Strength, (psi) Yield Strength, (psi) Elongation, % Reduction of Area, %
ADMA P/M 134,000 – 135,000 156,000 – 157,000 12.5 - 12.9 28.2 - 28.3
Ingot Based 125,000 – 127,000 140,000 – 142,000 12.4 - 12.6 26.9 - 27.6
AIRFRAME STRUCTURESCanless Extrusion Process Development for BE Powder-Based Titanium Ti-6AL-4V Alloy
RTI, International Metals, Inc.
-
Georg Abakumov, Director Business Development, ADMA Products, Inc.October 7‐10, 2012 • Atlanta, Georgia, USA 18
ADMA P/M Ti‐6Al‐4V Commander’s Hatch“… passed with flying colors, met the forging spec requirements, as well as the plate spec requirements (MIL‐DTL‐46077)… THIS IS THE BEST RESULT WE HAVE SEEN FROM ANY P/M
BASED, NO MELT, LOW COST MATERIAL.” (BAE 7‐6‐2010)
Al V Fe C N O H Y Ti Other, Each Other, Total
CIP/Sinter 6.16 4.21 0.080 0.009 0.021 0.179 0.0018
-
Georg Abakumov, Director Business Development, ADMA Products, Inc.October 7‐10, 2012 • Atlanta, Georgia, USA 19
Sample 1 Sample 2 SPEC
UTS (PSI) 146,300 152,500 130,000
0.2% YS (PSI) 131,800 138,900 120,000
ELONGATION, % 13.0 13.0 10.0
R. A., % 26.4 25.2 20.0
ASTM E8 ROOM TEMPERATURE TENSILE TEST
P/M Blended Elemental Ti-6Al-4V Commander’s Hatch Pre-Form Produced from Hydrogenated Ti Powder
(These 220 lb ADMA Titanium Powder Metallurgy platescan replace 400 lbs of steel plate on the hatch of the Bradley Fighting Vehicle)
-
Georg Abakumov, Director Business Development, ADMA Products, Inc.October 7‐10, 2012 • Atlanta, Georgia, USA 20
Large Powder Metallurgy ProductsLow-oxygen P/M Ti-6Al-4V Billets from
ADMA Hydrogenated Ti Powder
Ti-6Al-4V billet 8.50” x 12.0” x 52.0” 725 lbs
Chemistry conforms to AMS 4911L
-
Georg Abakumov, Director Business Development, ADMA Products, Inc.October 7‐10, 2012 • Atlanta, Georgia, USA 21
ADMA Direct Powder Rolling Mill- 50 Million Lbs/Year Armor Plate Production
Capacity
0.25” thick plate was successfully rolled at ADMA facility
-
Georg Abakumov, Director Business Development, ADMA Products, Inc.October 7‐10, 2012 • Atlanta, Georgia, USA 22
P/M Ti-6Al-4V (Low Oxygen) Plates- ADMA Hydrogenated Ti powder
0.75” thick 0.50” thickCold Isostatic Pressing
Sintering
Rolling
L – LongitudinalLT – Long transverseST – Short transverse
LLT
ST
-
Georg Abakumov, Director Business Development, ADMA Products, Inc.October 7‐10, 2012 • Atlanta, Georgia, USA 23
ADMA P/M Ti-6Al-4V alloy Barsfor the IBIF Fred Sert Program
Cold Isostatic Pressing
Sintering
Extrusion RollingRotary Forging
ADMA P/M Ti-6Al-4V Extruded bars
Ti-6Al-4V UTS ksi YS, ksi El., % RA, %
ADMA P/M 148 – 152 142 – 145 19.8 - 22.8 28.2 - 28.3Ingot Based 140 - 143 125 – 127 19.4 - 21.1 26.9 - 27.6AMS 4928R 135 Min. 125 Min. 10 Min.
-
Georg Abakumov, Director Business Development, ADMA Products, Inc.October 7‐10, 2012 • Atlanta, Georgia, USA 24
Fracture Mode: Extruded Material, Tensile Tested
Fracture initiation location: center of specimen
Fracture mode: microvoid coalescence or dimple mode
Fatigue Test Results
Maximum Load (lb) Maximum Stress (ksi) Cycles to Failure Diameter (in)
INGOT 5880 119 1,014,725 0.251
ADMA Ti P/M 5880 119 3,716,462 0.250
Blended ElementalADMA P/M Ti-6Al-4V BARS Outperform High Cost Ingot Based Products
-
Georg Abakumov, Director Business Development, ADMA Products, Inc.October 7‐10, 2012 • Atlanta, Georgia, USA 25
P/M Ti and Ti alloy Hollow Cylinders for US NAVY Tubes and Pipes
CIP
VacuumSintering
ADMA Hydrogenated Ti Powder
Flowform
-
Georg Abakumov, Director Business Development, ADMA Products, Inc.October 7‐10, 2012 • Atlanta, Georgia, USA 26
• Piping for LPD (Titanium CP Grade 2), approx. 20,430 feet per ship, weighing approx. 130,000 lbs
DensityCu‐Ni 0.323 lb/in3
CP Ti 0.163 lb/in3
• Titanium pipe saves 178,000 lbs per LPD compared to Cu‐Ni pipe system, improving fuel efficiency and reducing life cycle maintenance cost of the pipe system
USS SAN ANTONIO (LPD 17)
Low Cost Titanium Pipe for Naval Applications
-
Georg Abakumov, Director Business Development, ADMA Products, Inc.October 7‐10, 2012 • Atlanta, Georgia, USA 27
-
Georg Abakumov, Director Business Development, ADMA Products, Inc.October 7‐10, 2012 • Atlanta, Georgia, USA 28
Titanium or Titanium Alloy Components
Die Pressing
Sintering
Near Net Shape
Die Pressing + Sintering
-
Georg Abakumov, Director Business Development, ADMA Products, Inc.October 7‐10, 2012 • Atlanta, Georgia, USA 29
Titanium or Titanium Alloy Components for Aerospace Applications
Near Net ShapeDie Pressing + Sintering
Material Composition, %
N C H Fe O Ti
CP Ti washers 0.015 0.016 0.0014 0.14 0.206 Bal.
ASTM B 348 Grade 2 0.030 0.080 0.015 0.20 0.250 Bal.
CP Ti washers
Material Composition, %
N C H Fe O Al V Ti
Ti-6Al-4V washers 0.019 0.014 0.0014 0.05 0.263 6.32 4.23 Bal
ASTM B 817-98, Type I
0.04 0.10 0.015 0.40 max
0.30 5.50 –6.75
3.50 –4.50
Bal
Ti-6Al-4V washers
-
Georg Abakumov, Director Business Development, ADMA Products, Inc.October 7‐10, 2012 • Atlanta, Georgia, USA 30
Ti-3Al-2.5V Components for Aerospace Applications
Die Pressing
Sintering
30
-
Georg Abakumov, Director Business Development, ADMA Products, Inc.October 7‐10, 2012 • Atlanta, Georgia, USA 31
Metal Porous Membrane Sheets by Direct Powder Rolling Process
Direct Powder RollingMetal
Powder BLEND
FINISHED SHEET
POWDER ROLLING
RE-ROLLSINTER
ANNEAL
Binder Filler
-
Georg Abakumov, Director Business Development, ADMA Products, Inc.October 7‐10, 2012 • Atlanta, Georgia, USA 32
Direct Powder Rolling of Ti Alloy Foil, Sheet, and Plate at ADMA
0.25” thick plate
0.010” thick Ti foil
-
Georg Abakumov, Director Business Development, ADMA Products, Inc.October 7‐10, 2012 • Atlanta, Georgia, USA 33
Porous Titanium Sheets/Plates
“Cracking Oxygen from Water -Life Support Systems for the US NAVY, AIRFORCE, and NASA
-
Georg Abakumov, Director Business Development, ADMA Products, Inc.October 7‐10, 2012 • Atlanta, Georgia, USA 34
Porous ADMA Titanium Electrode - High Capacity Storage of Wind and Solar Energy
• High capacity storage batteries for wind and solar generated energy
• Improved costs and asset utilization• Lower maintenance, longer life span, enhanced reliability• Greater penetration of renewable energy technologies• Reduction in green house gas emissions
-
Georg Abakumov, Director Business Development, ADMA Products, Inc.October 7‐10, 2012 • Atlanta, Georgia, USA 35
Manufacturing Continuously Re-Enforced Ti-6Al-4V Sheet and Plate by Direct Powder Rolling Ti alloy Blend
with Graphite or Alumina Fibers (S&T)Preliminary experiments demonstrated the feasibility to produce continuously re-enforced Ti-6Al-4Vplates with Carbon or Alumina fibers (S&T) by using low cost ADMA direct powder rolling or loosesintering P/M processes.
The fiber loading fraction can be tailored. ADMA can increase the volume % of fibers in compositematerial. In some cases a hot temperature consolidation (HIP or hot pressing) is required toconsolidate to full density.
Direct powder rolling/SinterCold isostatic pressing/Sinter
Loose sintering
-
Georg Abakumov, Director Business Development, ADMA Products, Inc.October 7‐10, 2012 • Atlanta, Georgia, USA 36
Porous Titanium Tube Sleeve/Flange
Cold Isostatic Pressing
Sintering
Cold Isostatic Pressing
-
Georg Abakumov, Director Business Development, ADMA Products, Inc.October 7‐10, 2012 • Atlanta, Georgia, USA 37
Ti‐6Al‐4V Al V Fe C N O H Ti Other, Each Other, Total
ADMA TiH2 5.83 3.72 0.29 0.017 0.029 0.189 0.012 Bal.
-
Georg Abakumov, Director Business Development, ADMA Products, Inc.October 7‐10, 2012 • Atlanta, Georgia, USA 38
TITANIUM FOR THE MOST CRITICAL DEFENSE, AEROSPACE AND INDUSTRIAL APPLICATIONS
HYDROGENATED TITANIUM POWDER METALLURGY CAN MEET THE CURRENT INDUSTRIAL, DEFENSE, AND AEROSPACE APPLICATIONS for
TITANIUM by PROVIDING ANY COMPONENT CURRENTLY MADE.
LOW COST/ HIGHEST PERFORMANCE ADMA HYDROGENATED TITANIUM POWDER WILL BRING the OVERWHELMING BENEFITS OF TITANIUM TO A
BROADER RANGE OF INDUSTRIAL APPLICATIONS.
THE FUTURE OF TITANIUM IS TITANIUM POWDER METALLURGY!
THANK YOU FOR YOUR INTEREST!