positive behavioral interventions and supportscce.astate.edu/pbis/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/... ·...
TRANSCRIPT
A Multi-tiered Framework for Improving School Climate and Student Outcomes
Positive Behavioral Interventions and Supports
AcknowledgementsWe would like to thank the following for sharing resources that were used in the development of this presentation:
OSEP Center for PBISIllinois PBIS NetworkMidwest PBIS NetworkPBIS MarylandMissouri Schoolwide Positive Behavior SupportPBIS.org
Objectives
Understand how Academic & Behavior RTI support each other Gain a general understanding of PBIS Learn the roles & responsibilities of the PBIS Team Understand the need for Tier 1 Behavior Instruction
LRSDBehavior Needs Assessments
LRSD Behavior Needs AssessmentFebruary & March 2016
Tiered Fidelity Inventory (TFI) 6 teams
Self Assessment Survey (SAS) 229 participants
School Climate Survey (SCS) 220 participants
5
Team Assessment of core features (TFI)
6
47%
28%
64%
0
20
40
60
80
100
Tier I Tier II Tier III
Perc
enta
ge Im
plem
ente
d
School-Wide PBIS (SWPBIS) Tiered Fidelity InventoryAverage of Little Rock School District Leadership Teams
March, 2016
Benchmark Criterion – 70%
Team Assessment of core features
7
Expectations for behavior are identified but are not organized for teaching.
Teaching expected behaviors is informal and inconsistent.
Rewards for positive behavior are inconsistent.
All schools need an easier way to access & share data.
Behavior Systems in Place (SAS)
8
40% 37%45%
26%
0
20
40
60
80
100
School-Wide Non-Classroom Classroom Individual
% O
f Res
pond
ents
System
Percent Of Systems In PlaceAverage of Little Rock School District (n=229)
March, 2016
Benchmark Criterion
40% of School-wide discipline systems are in place (staff perception)
9
What’s in place?
• Classroom routines • Schools know what to do to in emergency/dangerous situations
What’s not in place?• Consistent ways to define and handle problem behaviors• Consistent ways to reward students for expected behaviors
Priority to improve behavior systems (SAS)
10
62%57%
64% 67%
0
20
40
60
80
100
School-Wide Non-Classroom Classroom Individual
% O
f Res
pond
ents
System
Percent Of Systems High PriorityAverage of Little Rock School District (n=229)
March, 2016
Priority to improve behavior systems
11
Top priorities (in rank order from your staff point of views):
1. Directly teaching student behaviors2. Defining positively stated student expectations3. Having options for classroom instruction to continue
when problem behavior occurs4. Collecting and using behavior data5. Defining problem behaviors consistently
School Climate: Engagement Student Respect (SCS)
12
25%
75%
0
20
40
60
80
100
Perc
ent o
f res
pond
ents
Students respect the teachers. (n=219)Average of Little Rock School District
March, 2016
Agree Do not Agree
School Climate: Safety Student Safety (SCS)
13
74%
26%
0
20
40
60
80
100
Perc
ent o
f res
pond
ents
Students feel safe at school. (n=221)Average of Little Rock School District
March, 2016
Agree Do not Agree
School Climate: Environment Code of Conduct (SCS)
14
37%
63%
0
20
40
60
80
100
Perc
ent o
f res
pond
ents
The code of student conduct is consistently enforced. (n=220)Average of Little Rock School District
March, 2016
Agree Do not Agree
School Climate: Environment Student Behavior (SCS)
15
17%
83%
0
20
40
60
80
100
Perc
ent o
f res
pond
ents
Students are well-behaved. (n=220)Average of Little Rock School District
March, 2016
Agree Do not Agree
Behavior and Academic Supports
Academic Behavior Effective Instruction
engages students, and is central to reduction in problem behavior
Behavior Academic Effective Classroom
Management improves student engagement and is central to increased academic success.
(adapted from Horner, undated, pbis.org)
(Based on research from Lee, Sugai & Horner (1999), Allday & Pakurar, 2007; McIntosh, Horner, Chard & Braun, (2008), Preiado, Horner, & Baker (2009), Sanford & Horner (2013), undated, PBIS.org)
Something needs to be done (from SAS)
17
20%In Place
75%Priority
0
20
40
60
80
100
% o
f Res
pond
ents
Classroom System
Students experience high rates of academic success.Average of Little Rock School District (n=229)
March, 2016
PBIS & Literacy/Academics: RTIHow do they fit together?
• They are Symbiotic• They share Philosophy• They focus on Systems
Symbiotic Relations Symbiosis
• sym·bi·o·sis \ˌsim-bē-ˈō-səs, -ˌbī-\• biology : the relationship between two different kinds of living things that live
together and depend on each other (Merriam Webster Dictionary)
Components Depend on Each Other(Adapted From Horner, undated, PBIS.org)
Academic Supports
Academic Gains
Behavior Supports
Behavior Gains
But what comes first?(Adapted from Horner, undated, PBIS.org)
Academic Supports
Academic Gains
Behavior Supports
Behavior Gains
Shared Philosophy Philosophy
• noun phi·los·o·phy \fə-ˈlä-s(ə-)fē\• : a set of ideas about how to do something or how to live (Merriam Webster Dictionary)
Examples of Shared Philosophy• High quality instruction• Prevention• Problem-solving model• Progress monitoring• Data-based decision making
Systems-based system
• noun sys·tem \ˈsis-təm\• : a group of related parts that move or work together (Merriam Webster Dictionary)
Academic Systems Behavioral Systems
1-5% 1-5%
5-10% 5-10%
Intensive, Individual Interventions•Individual Students•Assessment-based•High Intensity•Of longer duration
Intensive, Individual Interventions•Individual Students•Assessment-based•Intense, durable procedures
Targeted Group Interventions•Some students (at-risk)•High efficiency•Rapid response
Targeted Group Interventions•Some students (at-risk)•High efficiency•Rapid response
80-90% 80-90%Universal Interventions•All students•Preventive, proactive
Universal Interventions•All settings, all students•Preventive, proactive
Systems in Multi-tier Model(from Horner, undated, PBIS.org)
Is RTI exactly the same for academics and behavior?
• Specific academic assessments and interventions
• Use of published curricula selected by school or district
• Use of direct assessment of skills
• Periodic assessment through benchmarking periods
• Focus on grade-level teaming
• Described in IDEA as SPED eligibility determination approach
• Specific social behavior assessments and interventions
• Use of free materials that are adapted to fit the school’s context
• Use of indirect assessment of behavior
• Continuous assessment of social behavior with existing data sources
• Focus on school-wide teaming
• Described in IDEA as school-wide prevention and individual intervention approach
• Scientifically-based interventions
• Instruction as prevention• Tiered continuum of
supports with increasing intensity based on need
• Use of a problem-solving model and data-based decision rules
• Focus on teaming• Emphasis on improving
quality of implementation• Embedded into school
improvement plan• Regular screening for
early intervention
Academic PBIS
Features of RTI (originally from McIntosh & Goodman; adapted from Horner, undated, PBIS.org)
Academic PBIS
Why integrate? Because some things work better together
Working together“Academic and behavioral challenges are of utmost concern to schools… …they are too closely linked to approach independently and intervene separately.”
McIntosh, Chard, Boland, Horner (2006)
28
What will RTI look like in your school?
District overview of Literacy & PBIS (January 2016)Needs Assessments of Literacy & Behavior (Feb & March)Literacy Action Plans Developed (March 2016)Behavior Action Plans Developed (March 2016)RTI Overview – today!PBIS Preparation Training (April 2016)RTI Leadership Training (May 2016)PBIS Development Training (May 2016)PBIS Implementation Training (August 2016)PBIS Roll out to staff! (August 2016)
The journey has begun!
Examples of PBIS training timelines
Wisconsin Tier I/Universal TrainingTraining/Workshop Who
Administrative Training District & Building Administrators
New Coaches Orientation Administrators & Coaches
Tier I/Universal Training School PBIS Team
Coaches Networking Meeting Coaches
Time
1/2 day
1 day
3 days
2-4 days/year
32
Arkansas
(Adapted from Horner, undated, PBIS.org)
Now what?
Where do you begin?
How do we implement PBIS?
33
Understanding PBISPositive Behavior Interventions & Supports
A New PhilosophyPBIS is more than just adding interventions it is a change in philosophy.
PBIS is a proactive and positive approach to discipline rather than punitive discipline.
PBIS teaches, models, and encourages positive student behavior instead of waiting for students to make a mistake.
A Good Point… “If a child doesn’t know how to read, we teach.” “If a child doesn’t know how to swim, we teach.” “If a child doesn’t know how to multiply, we teach.” “If a child doesn’t know how to drive, we teach.” “If a child doesn’t know how to behave, we…
…teach? …punish?” “Why can’t we finish the last sentence as
automatically as we do the others?” -John Herner, Former President NASDSE, 1998
Organizing Your Environment
PBIS: What do we need to support ALL students?
Some guiding questions: What outcomes do we want for our students? What supports will help them reach those outcomes? How will we deliver those supports? How will we know if they are working?
4 Basic Elements of PBIS Supports
Supporting Data-based
Decision Making
Supporting Staff
Behavior
Supporting Student Behavior
Systems Data
Practices
Outcomes
Supporting Social Competence and Academic Achievement
1. Systems: Plans for Support- How you support staff so that they can support students
Plan for how and when you teach students behavior Plan for acknowledging appropriate behavior Plan for addressing inappropriate behavior Problem solving team to make decisions
2. Practices: What to do- How you reduce problem behaviors across the entire student body
Teach appropriate behavior Model appropriate behavior Recognize appropriate behavior Discourage inappropriate behavior
3. Measurable Outcomes How you will know if you are succeeding?
Monitor data (e.g., Office Discipline Referrals)
4. Data-based Decision MakingHow will you make informed decisions and measure success?
Answer the following:
Who What When Where Why
Tiers of Intervention
Levels, Or Tiers Of InterventionsLet’s go back to Practices – what you do to support students.
PBIS is for all students! Everyone receives general education in behavior Some students may need more
Tier 1: Core instruction (general education) for all students.
Tier II: Targeted supports for students with non-serious repetitive behaviors.
Tier III: Individualized supports for students engaging in dangerous or threatening behaviors
A continuum of practices: 3 levels of Prevention
Universal Tier 1 is Core Instruction - Why teach all students behavior?
Prevent problem behaviors Reduce time spent on reactive management Improve school climate Maximize student achievement
Tier II is Supplemental InstructionTier II interventions:
• Continuously available• Easily/quickly accessible• Require little effort from teachers• Assessment based• Progress monitored• Led by Tier II team
Types of Tier II Interventions Check-in Check-out:
• More frequent feedback to students• Prevent future & escalating behavior
Social Skills Groups• For students with social skills issues• To acquire & build fluency in appropriate behaviors
Check and Connect (Mentoring)• For students not engaged with school, with academics, or socially• For students motivated by adult attention• To promote student engagement and competence
Tier III is Intensive InstructionTier III Interventions: Individualized to match the needs of the student Based on functional behavior assessment May require long periods of time & intensive interventions Led by Tier III team
Example of Tier III InterventionWraparound: Intensive, person-centered process for planning &
managing care Community-based support to keep student at home/school Engages family of student Helps build social support network
Administrator Support
Tier I for behavior in LRSD
68% of the LRSD school staff say “the administrator is an active part of the behavior team”
53
The administrator’s role
1. Maintain standards
2. Publicly show support
3. Establish a representative team
4. Support team members
5. Guide, rather than dictate
7. Be a leader in problem solving
8. Regularly participate in team meetings
9. Provide recognition to team & faculty
10.Serve as a community spokesperson
11.Monitor & provide feedback to all staff
Colvin, G. (2007). 7 Steps for developing a proactive schoolwide discipline plan, 17
Tier I
Where will LRSD start?First step: create your plan for Tier 1 for Core Behavior Instruction
Essential Components Of Tier 11. Develop common
philosophy 2. Define expected
behavior 3. Teach expected
behavior 4. Encourage appropriate
behavior
5. Discourage inappropriate behavior
6. Progress monitor7. Develop classroom
component
1. Common Philosophy Align with your mission/vision Commit to proactive/preventive discipline Create common language Create a predictable environment Ensure support from administration
2. Define Expected BehaviorSome guiding questions: What have been the 3-5 biggest behavioral issues in your
district/school?
Combined survey responses from students from 2 Arkansas Middle Schools - 2015
How do you know?
Coming soon to your school!
Defiance
ExampleThis graph shows all referrals, sorted by problem behavior.
The most reported is Inappropriate Language. Next is Defiance.
Problem Behavior
Referrals by Problem Behavior
Num
ber o
f Ref
erra
ls
Defiance
Inappropriate Language
Physical Aggression
2. Define Expected Behavior (cont.)What behaviors would you like to see instead?
Common Examples of expectations: Be respectful Be responsible Be safe
Defining Expectations Describe what the behavior ‘looks like’ in each school
setting
State in a positive way (say ‘what to do’)
Display expectations in all settings across the school
Be a Blazer!Classroom & Everywhere
Hallway Playground
BeRespectful
1 – Listen and follow directions.
2-Know the listening position (Keep hands still and eyes on the speaker)
1 – Walk in the
traveling position
(Hands to the side or
behind. Mouth closed).
1-Take turns.
2-Use kind words and
actions.
3. Line up quickly and
quietly.
Valley View Elementary School-Wide Matrix
3. Teaching Expected BehaviorDefine Simply
ModelAdjust for
Efficiency Practic
e in Settin
g
Just like academics:
Monitor and Acknowledge Continuously
Define Simply
ModelAdjust for Efficiency
Practice in Setting
4. Encouraging Appropriate Behavior- Acknowledge students that use appropriate behavior
Turns the behavior into a habit! Competes with problem behaviors Students may encourage other students Prompts adults to recognize good behavior
WHY? Don’t you like being acknowledged?
Strengthen sense of Community Set goals Celebrate your success Build a positive school culture
5. Discouraging Inappropriate Behavior- Create a predictable environment for staff and students
Create consistency across staff• Differentiate office managed & classroom managed behaviors • Develop T-Chart for behavior
T-Chart ExampleTeacher managed behaviors (minor)
Office managed behaviors (major)
TardyInappropriate language (minor)
Chewing gum; food/drinksNot having materials/supplies
Missing homeworkTattling
Teasing/bullyingLying
CheatingMinor dress code violation
Minor disruptionDefiance/disrespect/non-
compliance
Chronic/severe bullyingStealing
VandalismIllegal substance
Chronic non-compliancePossession of weapons
Profanity directed at personRepeated disruptions
Fighting/assaultThreat
Chronic class skippingGang-related behaviors
Sexual harassmentFalse fire alarm/bomb threat
6. Progress Monitoring
Use data to set goals & create action plans
Use data to make decisions on action plans
7. The Classroom Component- Students spend most of their time in the classroom…
Create a classroom environment that • Encourages learning • Minimizes distraction & inappropriate behavior
Establish consistency for transition times
PBIS in LRSD by August (it can be done!)
PBIS will take work and buy-in
(unfortunately it doesn’t just magically happen!)
Concentrated effort
PBIS Teams & Coaches
Do you need a team focused on school-wide prevention systems for behavior?
Leadership Teams, SBIT Teams…why add another team?
So many teams…so little time
Working Smarter-Systems/Staff Support
77Adapted from OSEP Center on PBIS; Effective Schoolwide Interventions
The PBIS Team
Create A Dream TeamWhat you need for school-wide implementation:
An Administrator – decision making power Representative from each grade – voice back to PLCs Represent demographics of school Represent various types of staff
• Music• Library• SPED
Team responsibilities Develop school-wide PBIS action plan Monitor & evaluate behavior data Hold regular team meetings Maintain communication with staff & coach Monitor & evaluate progress Report outcomes to school & district stakeholders
Team Roles Administrator – implements decisions Internal Coach - Guide team development & implementation Facilitator – keeps meetings on task Data Manager – provides on-going data to team Recorder – keeps and distributes minutes Communicator – shares information with others Active team members – participate in problem solving
Who leads the team?
82
What is a Coach?
A COACH helps people develop the skills they need to get from where they are…to where they want to be.
83
Functions of the PBIS building coach Create positive, supportive,
structured environment for team Attend PBIS meetings, trainings Guide team coordination &
problem-solving Guide team action plan
development & implementation
Provide tools for training, evaluation, monitoring
Liaise with District Coordinator & District Coach
Submit data to district coach / district coordinator
2016-2017: PBIS in LRSD • A-state provides coaching
2017 and beyond: PBIS in LRSD• Building coaching is established• District coaching is established
LRSD plan for coaching
85
`
Sustainability
PBIS becomes a part of your school’s DNA
Components work together to form a larger structure in school
• A = Actions• C = Culture• G = Guidance• T = Teamwork
PBIS Will Work and Sustain If… You make PBIS a priority!
• Visibility• Written policy• Connection to other initiatives
You do it effectively• Evaluate fidelity• Share data
You do it efficiently• Repetition builds fluency – it
will get easier with time• Over time, less resources
needed
You adapt to change• Use data• Change culture
PBIS in LRSD
90
Develop PBIS Team
PBIS Team Preparation
Training
PBIS Implementation
Training(all staff)
PBIS
Kick- Off!
March April May August
PBIS Team
PBIS Overview
Coaching and Technical Assistance from Arkansas State University
Invest in prevention Create a PBIS team Teach, model, & reinforce
expected behaviors Use & share data
SUMMARY
References Research literature on PBIShttps://www.pbis.org/research
Research on Discipline, PBIS, and RTIhttp://www.nhcebis.seresc.net/research_and_literature
Article on benefits of implementing behavior and literacy RTI togetherhttp://www.nhcebis.seresc.net/document/filename/373/PBIS_and_Reading.pdf
92
CCE.astate.edu/pbis PBIS.org Midwestpbis.org Wisconsinpbisnetwork.org Pbismaryland.org