plenary session 3. dr parisak paper

8/9/2019 Plenary Session 3. Dr Parisak Paper

1/28

Glum{~bml~ Ecp}bGlum{~bml~ Ecp}b

ecp Eccn [mk}pg~wecp Eccn [mk}pg~wgl F{gf fln ~jm Tfkgegk ?gl F{gf fln ~jm Tfkgegk ?

Hfc TNP Kf{mHfc TNP Kf{mBglg{~pw ce Fipgk}h~}pm fln Ecpm{~pw( Hfc TNP

F{gfl Nmumhctbml~ @flaBflghf( Tjghgttglm{ 88


2/28

Hfln"hglamn

fnufl~fim{


3/28

^jm [g~}f~gcl

Hfc{ jf{ fkjgmumn `f{gk {mhe"{}eegkgmlkw gl Wmfp 0444 *;=4ai{#kft#wp' `}~ tpcn}k~gug~w g{ {~ghh hcy fln nmegkgmlkw g{kjpclgk gl ~jm ]thfln{ * 0#; ce Hfc{ ' Jcymump epcb fl}~pg~gclfh {~flntcgl~ umpw b}kj nmegkgml~

F~ ~jm lf~gclfh hmumh( fttpczgbf~mhw 094(444 cp ;9- ce kjghnpml}lnmp = *K]=' pmbfgl }lnmpymgij~ fln cump ~jm tf{~ ~ml wmfp{(~jg{ pf~m jf{ lc~ nmkhglmn, Kjpclgk bfhl}~pg~gcl pmbfgl{ ~jm

`giim{~ tpc`hmb yg~j lmfphw ;44(444 cp >4- ce K]= {~}l~mn,^jmpm g{ f {jfpt glkpmf{m gl {~}l~gli fln }lnmpymgij~ `m~ymml5 fln 0> bcl~j{,

Eccn {mk}pg~w fln ngump{gegkf~gcl ? 0;- ce ~jm tct}hf~gcl g{}lnmplc}pg{jmn, ^jm bc{~ {gilgegkfl~ kcl{~pfgl~ ~c ~jmfufghf`ghg~w ce eccn gl Hfc{ g{ ~jm hcy hmumh ce ncbm{~gktpcn}k~gcl ce eccn g~mb{, ^jm hcy hmumh tpcn}k~gcl g{ bfglhw ~jmpm{}h~ ce hcy hmumh{ ce tpcn}k~gug~w fln jgij pg{a{ gl ~jmfipgk}h~}pfh {mk~cp,


4/28

FLP [mk~cp ? E}~}pm C}~hcca

Thfl UGG ? 0466"046= FLP {mk~cp yghh tmpecpb cump >- cefll}fh ipcy~j *cumpfh INT ipcy~j < :-'

6" Eccn {mk}pg~w fln pgkm pm{mpum t}~ f~ ;=4 ai{#kft#wp ecp

pgkm fln =4"54 ai#kft# wp ecp tpc~mgl ecpm{mm mzkm{{ }t ~c6 bghhgcl ~cl{ bgllc bcpm {gilgegkfl~ pgkm fln eccn

nmegkg~ gl Hfc{ gl 046=pgkm pm{mpum 54 ~c 604,444 ~cl{ fln

pgkm {mmn pm{mpum cump 64,444 ~cl{* lcy ycpagli cl fpgkm pm{mpum ce ;4,444 ~cl{ '

0" Tpcbc~m ufh}m kjfgl{( glkh, gl }thfln{ * ~fam fnufl~fim ce

Lmy F{mfl Kjfp~mp % Mkclcbgk"[ckgfh Tghhfp{1 PmigclfhMkclcbgk Gl~mipf~gcl1 Nwlfbgk Mf{~ F{gf Mkclcbw m{t,

f`c}~ TT%TT' pmfkj p}pfh tccp fpmf{glkpmf{m glkcbm

;" Lmy mbthcwbml~ cttcp~}lg~gm{ ecp ~jm }thfln fln pmbc~mp}pfh tccp lc bcpm [jge~gli K}h~guf~gcl

>" Ecpm{~ kcump }t ~c 5=- ? PMNN! % khgbf~m kjflim


5/28

Kjfhhmlim{ flncttcp~}lg~gm{ ~c fkjgmugli

eccn {mk}pg~w


6/28

B}h~gthm tf~j mzg{~ ecp fkjgmugli eccn {mk}pg~w

Jgij ngump{g~w ce mzg{~gli p}pfhhfln }{m {w{~mb{

Fgb ecp efbghw"`f{mn eccn{mk}pg~w

Fgb ecp kcbb}lg~w"`f{mn eccn{mk}pg~w

Lf~gclfh eccn {mk}pg~w nmpgumn

epcb fl gl~mipf~mn eccn {}tthwkjfgl flfhw{g{

Flfhw{g{ 2< fyfpmlm{{ ce{~pmli~j{ fln cttcp~}lg~gm{

Flfhw{g{ 2< glum{~bml~{ ~ccumpkcbm ymfalm{{m{ fln~jpmf~{

Eccn {mk}pg~w g{ bcpm ~jfl pgkm ?glkpmf{mn kcbbcng~w % ~pfnm 2glkpmf{mn glkcbm % {fem~w lm~{

Fipcecpm{~pw

[jge~gli

k}h~guf~gcl

Bgzmnefpbgli


7/28

Mlf`hgli Mlugpclbml~ ecp [mk~cp

Nmumhctbml~( Kcctmpf~gcl % Fipg`}{glm{{6"Mlncybml~ gl Lf~}pfh Pm{c}pkm{ * hfln( yf~mp pm{c}pkm{ "

ecpm{~{ ' Khmfl mlugpclbml~ ? Icumplbml~ tchgkgm{ ecp Eccn

[mk}pg~w( Khmfl Fipgk}h~}pm % Kcbbmpkgfhgf~gcl ce@gcngump{g~w[~pmli~j &

0"Tfp~ ce F{mfl,,F{mfl ! ;,, Nwlfbgk Pmigclfh MkclcbgkGl~mipf~gcl,, Ngeempml~ ecpb{ ce mkclcbgk kcctmpf~gcl ?Tpcugnm Gbtm~}{ ~c kcctmpf~gcl( glum{~bml~ % Fipg`}{glm{{

;"Ymhh m{~f`hg{jmn Pc}ln ^f`hm Bmm~gli Tpckm{{m{ ? : YcpagliIpc}t{,,Jfpbclgf~gcl gl kcctmpf~gcl % glum{~bml~{

>"Hmifh {}ttcp~ fln Glum{~bml~ Glkml~gum{ ? Mbmpigli HfcTpguf~m Fipg"@}{glm{{m{ % Glkpmf{mn ENG gl Fipg"`}{glm{{m{ ?[}kkm{{ [~cpgm{

="Hfln"hglamn % Glkpmf{mn Kcllmk~gug~wPm{tcln ~c pmigclfheccn % kcbbcng~w lmmn{


8/28

Mzg{~gli cttcp~}lg~gm{

Pmigclfh *IB[' kcbtfpf~gum fnufl~fim efk~cp{?

F`ghg~w ~c tpcn}km lf~}pfh fln cpiflgk tpcn}k~{

Hfln fufghf`hm ecp {bfhhjchnmp efpbmp{ fln gl~ml{gum # thfl~f~gcl"{~whm

bmif"tpcomk~{

Fufghf`ghg~w ce L^ET{ fln c~jmp lgkjm tpcn}k~{ ecp lgkjm bfpam~{ *lf~}pfh% ncbm{~gkf~mn {tmkgm{( glngimlmc}{ {tmkgm{', Hfc TNP jf{ bcpm ~jfl;444 Ufpgm~gm{ ce pgkm &

Hfc kcbbcng~gm{ fpm gl jgij nmbfln gl pmigclfh bfpam~{?

Egmhn kpct{? bfgm( kf{{fuf( tmfl}~{( {cw`mfl{( {m{fbm( m~k,

^pmm kpct{? p}``mp( M}kfhwt~}{( ~mfa( fifp yccn( m~k,

Jcp~gk}h~}pm kpct{? kceemm( ~mf( umim~f`hm{( ep}g~

Gln}{~pgfh kpct{? Of~pctjf( {}ifp kflm

[tmkgfh~w kpct{? L^ET{

Hgum{~cka? kf~~hm ecp bmf~1 `}eefhc ecp jgnm{1 tgi{ # kjgkaml{ f{ lf~}pfh #yghn tpcn}k~{,

F[MFL nmumhctbml~ ift?

KHBU u{, fnuflkmn F[MFL *@p}lmg( Glnclm{gf( Bfhfw{gf( Tjghgttglm{([gliftcpm( ^jfghfln' fhhcy ecp kcbthmbml~fpg~gm{


9/28

7

Pgkm

P}``mp

Umim~f`hm{

Bfgm

L^ET

PmigclfhPmigclfhMkclcbgkMkclcbgk

Gl~mipf~gcl ?Gl~mipf~gcl ?Cttcp~}lg~w ecp ~jmCttcp~}lg~w ecp ~jm

Hfc TNP ?Hfc TNP ?^}pl hfln^}pl hfln""hglamnhglamn

~pfl{tcp~ kcppgncp{ gl~c~pfl{tcp~ kcppgncp{ gl~c

mkclcbgk kcppgncp{ ?mkclcbgk kcppgncp{ ?

glkpmf{m gl hflnglkpmf{m gl hfln""`f{mn`f{mn

glum{~bml~{glum{~bml~{*kclkm{{gcl{( kcl~pfk~*kclkm{{gcl{( kcl~pfk~

efpbgli,, ' ~c tpcn}km %efpbgli,, ' ~c tpcn}km %

{}tthw eccn % FLP{}tthw eccn % FLPiccn{ ~c ~jm Pmigcl %iccn{ ~c ~jm Pmigcl %

YcphnYcphn


10/28

Tfp~lmp{jgt{ ecpEccn [mk}pg~w fln

FLP {mk~cp nmumhctbml~


11/28

Gbtmpf~gum{ ce Pmigclfh Gl~mipf~gcl6" Kcl~gl}mn glum{~bml~{ ? TGT( CNF `}~ eck}{ cl ENG lmmn lmy

tchgkgm{( pmi}hf~gcl{ fln glkml~gum{ ( m,i, hfln hmf{m tchgkgm{ hgam

hmf{gli gppgif~mn fipgk}h~}pm hfln( l}khm}{ m{~f~m{

0" Gl{~g~}~m lmy kpc{{ `cpnmp hgla{( `}ghngli f lmy F{mfl Mkclcbgk %[ckgfh Kcbb}lg~w ~pfl{tcp~ kcppgncp{ % mkclcbgk

kcppgncp{glkpmf{mn kcllmk~gug~w % gl~mipf~gcl

;" Kchhmk~gum meecp~ gl tpmuml~gli cp bg~gif~gli cl lmy pg{a{ {}ttcp~~c [T[

>" [}{~fgl ^mkjlchciw Nmumhctbml~ ~jpc}ij glkpmf{mn gl~pf"F{mfl1

F{mfl Th}{ ^jpmm % Kcctmpf~gcl yg~j fhh NT{hm{{cl{ hmfplmn epcb

~jm tf{~ ? ufpgm~fh gbtpcumbml~( {}tthw kjfgl nut~( kf~~hm nut~( L^ET{nut~* TT % TT '

=" Meemk~gum mlifimbml~ yg~j {bfhh jchnmp{ fln hfpimp jchnmp{ lmmn ~c

pmfhgm Nmkpmm{ cl F{{ckgf~gcl{ % Kcctmpf~gum{~c tpcbc~m [BM{% tpcn}kmp{ ~c tpguf~m `}{glm{{m{ tfp~lmp{jgt{ * amw ~c tcump~w

mpfngkf~gcl'


12/28

E}~}pm Lmmn{ ecp T}`hgk Glum{~bml~ fln

Ecpmgil Ngpmk~ Glum{~bml~ gl Fipgk}h~}pm

Eglflkgfh glum{~bml~{ pmv}gpmn ~c {}ttcp~ ~jm9~j L[MNT * 0466"046= ' ?T}`hgk glum{~bml~? 64-

Kcbb}lg~w"`f{mn # bgkpc"eglflkm? 64-CNF? 04-

ENG? 54-

Fttpczgbf~mhw 6 @ghhgcl ][N lmmnmn glfipgk}h~}pm fln ecpm{~pw {mk~cp ecp ~jm kcbgli= wmfp{

60


13/28

Y^C bmb`mp{jgt 2 fhh F[MFL u{, lcl"Y^C 2 Hfc

TNP

Hfc fipgk}h~}pm fln ecpm{~pw lmmn ~c }tipfnm g~{kftfkg~w ~c bmm~ ?

IFT {~flnfpn{

[T[ {~flnfpn{

Cpiflgk Fipgk}h~}pm {~flnfpn{

Efgp ~pfnm {~flnfpn{

Hgum{~cka jmfh~j {~flnfpn{( m~k,,

T}`hgk fln tpguf~m glum{~bml~{ lmmn{ ~c

`m {wlmpigmn ecp {}kkm{{e}h pmigclfh fln

ihc`fh gl~mipf~gcl


14/28

Tf~j ~c Eccn [mk}pg~w

fln [}pth}{

Mzg{~gli cttcp~}lg~gm{ ecp Tfp~lmp{jgt{

gl Eccn fln Kcbbcng~wUfh}m Kjfgl{ ecp ipcy~j( eccn {mk}pg~w

fln tcump~w mpfngkf~gcl


15/28

6=

Eccn {mk}pg~w `f{mn {w{~mb{

Eccn {mk}pg~w `f{mn gl~mipf~mn yg~j

kcbbmpkgfh fipgk}h~}pm

yf~mp

Hcy hfln PGKM *6

kpct#w'

jc}{gli

]t hfln pgkm egmhn

lf~}pfh ecpm{~flgbfh ipfgli

egmhn

yf~mp

Hcy hfln PGKM

*0 kpct # w'

jc}{gli Jcp~gk}h~}pm

Lf~}pfh

Ecpm{~p

w

Fipc"" ecpm{~pw

*umi, ep}g~ ~pmm'

]thfln

pgkmKpct

Pc~f~gcl

Flgbfh

ipfgli

Hfc[bfhhjchnmpfipgk}h~}pmg{gl~pfl{g~gcl


16/28

Fipg"`}{glm{{ ? Lcp~j

Cpiflgk ~mf ~c Kjglf

P}``mp ~c Kjglf

Bfgm ~c Kjglf( ^jfghfln(

Ugm~ Lfb

[cw`mfl{ ~c ^jfghfln

Yjg~m {m{fbm ~c ^jfghfln

L^ET{ ~c Kjglf( Oftfl(Acpmf@migllgli ce {}tthw

kjfgl{ bc{~hw}ltpckm{{mn tpcn}k~{ cp

mfphw {~fim ce tpckm{{gli

" Kpc{{"`cpnmp ~pfnm " bfocpglkml~gum


17/28

Fipg"`}{glm{{ ? Kml~pfh

Bfgm ~c ^jfghfln

[}ifp Kflm kcbthm~m {}tthw

kjfgl{ {jftgli

[ymm~ kcpl ~c M}pctm

Umim~f`hm{ ~c M}pctm

Tmfl}~{ ~c ^jfghfln

Kf{{fuf ~c ^jfghfln

@hfka ih}~glc}{ pgkm ~c M}pctm(

{cbm cpiflgk


18/28

Fipg"`}{glm{{ ? [c}~j

[BM {}tthw kjfgl{

Capf ~c Oftfl {}tthw kjfgl

Kceemm ~c Jcliacli( M}pctm(^jfghfln {}tthw kjfgl

Kf``fim{ ~c ^jfghfln(

Ugm~ Lfb

@flflf{ ~c ^jfghfln(

Ugm~ Lfb

Kc~~cl glngic tpcn}k~{ ~cOftfl

Tmfl}~{ ~c ^jfghfln(

Ugm~ Lfb

Kf{{fuf ~c Ugm~ Lfb

P}``mp ~c Ugm~ Lfb {}tthw

kjfgl

[cw`mfl{ ~c ^jfghfln(

Ugm~ Lfb

^j K ~ e Kj ~


19/28

^jm Kf{~ ce Kjfpfk~mp{ ?

[}kkm{{ {~cpgm{

Kceemm

Nfc Jm}fli *Kjfbtf{fa'

[glc}a *Kjfbtf{fa'

Hfc Bc}l~fgl Kceemm

C}~{tfl Kceemm *[gliftcpm'

Umim~f`hm{

Hfc Fipc Gln}{~pw *Ugml~gflm

Tpcuglkm'

Bbm, Gltmli *Kjfbtf{fa'

^flgwfbf"[gfb *[macli'

^mz~ghm{

Hfjf *kc~~cl glngic'*[fufllfajm~'

Hfc [mpgk}h~}pm *B}h`mppgm{'*Zgmli Ajc}fli'

@mlcgl Fipcecpmz *Epflkm' gl J}ftjfl

[}ifp kflm

Bg~p Hfc *^jfghfln' gl [fufllfajm~

[fufl *^jfghfln' gl[fufllfajm~

Of~pctjf

Achfc *Acpmf' gl Ugml~gflmTpcuglkm

^pmm thfl~f~gcl{

Cog *Oftfl' gl @cpgajfbzfw(ajfbbc}flm'

@gphf *Glngf' gl [fufllfajm~

[}l Tftmp *Kjglf' [fufllfajm~

Kf{{fuf

Wm~fc *Kjglf' gl [fufllfajm~

Jmlfl *Kjglf' gl[fuflllfajm~

^mlij}g *Kjglf'gl [fufllfajm~

J} Tj} *Ugm~ Lfb' gl [fhfufl

Mbmpigli % Ipcygli [}tthwKjfgl{


20/28

T"T % T"T * ~gij~ml Ufh}m kjfgl{'

T}`hgk % T}`hgk? Icumplbml~ ~c Icumplbml~

BC]? Hfc Icumplbml~ fln Tfp~lmp Icumplbml~

T}`hgk % Tpguf~m? Icumplbml~ ~c tpguf~m kcbtflw?

BC]? Hfc Icumplbml~ fln Tpguf~m kcbtflw

Tpguf~m % Tpcn}kmp{ ? Tpguf~m kcbtflw ~c tpcn}kmp{

*Kcl~pfk~ efpbgli'Mzfbthm ? Kf{m ce pgkm cp flw kcbbcng~w tpcn}k~gcl gl f

iguml Tpcuglkm,

Tfp~lmp Icu~ ? ufpgm~gm{ % `pmmn{1 ~mkjlchciw1 kftfkg~w `}ghngli

Tfp~lmp kc}l~pw Tpguf~m [mk~cp ? kftg~fh1 bfpam~1 kmp~gegkf~gcl

Hfc Icu~ % Tpguf~m [mk~cp kcbthmbml~ ? hfln hmf{m1 tchgkw %c~jmp glum{~bml~ glkml~gum{1 ^F1 kftg~fh % gl~mplfh bfpam~1hgfg{gli % `}{glm{{ {}ttcp~


21/28

Eccn fln

kcbbcng~wtpcn}k~gcl ~jpc}ij

TT % TT{

F~~pfk~ V]FHG^W ENG

@pgli gl % Ftthw fnuflkmn efpbbflfimbml~ ~c fpmf{ ce jgijufh}m tpcn}k~gcl? m,i,(

Gppgif~gcl kcbbfln fpmf{

L}khm}{ thfl~f~gcl{

Fipc"mkc{w{~mb{ }lgv}m ~c~jm IB[

Imcipftjgk fpmf{ mlncymnyg~j bcnmpl glepf{~p}k~}pm

Kpmf~m fipc"gln}{~pgfh kh}{~mp{ @chcuml

{

Thf~mf}z

Thfgl ce Ofp{(

ZgmliAjc}fli

Lfb ^jfl

Gppgif~gcl(Zfwf`c}pg


22/28

T"T % T"T

Bflfimbml~ kcl~pfk~

ecp 6 cp bcpm gppgif~mn

fpmf{

Bglgb}b {gm 2 =(444 jf

Mztmpgmlkmn tpcn}kmp

ipc}t{ fpm gl thfkm ?

{aghhmn hf`cp `}~ lmmn

}t{kfhm cl {aghh{

Kcl~pfk~ efpbgli fpmyg~j tpcn}kmp{ cp

tpcn}kmp ipc}t{

Kf{m [~}nw?

Lcp~j ^cljm Gl [m`fliefgThfgl( Ajfbbc}flmTpcuglkm


23/28

T"T % T"T

@fppml hfln fufghf`hm f{

f hfln kclkm{{gcl

;4 wmfp pmlmyf`hm hmf{m

;4 jf 6(444 jf

Ctmpf~m f{ f l}khm}{

m{~f~m

Kcl~pfk~ efpbgli c}~pmfkj

tpcipfb yg~j hckfh efpbmp{

Hmf{m hfln epcb efpbmp{

]{m efpbmp{ f{ ycpamp{

yjghm ~pfl{emppgli

~mkjlchciw glkpmf{m

glkcbm % eccn {mk}pg~w

Kf{m [~}nw?

^flgwfbf"[gfb( ^jf~mli

Ng{~pgk~( [macli Tpcuglkm

Capf?

[macli

~c Oftflgl 90

jc}p{


24/28

Ugml~gflm

Kftg~fh

Kjfbtf{faTpc

Glum{~bml~ Tc~ml~gfh gl Hfc TNP gl FLP [mk~cp

Ugml~gflm

Tpc

Hgum{~cka( Pgkm

fln Gln}{~pw

Bfgzm

P}``mp ~pmm(

[}ifp kflm

fln Pgkm

Bmacli Eg{j

glngiml}c{(

Kcemm flnUmim~f`hm

[fuflfajm~

Tpc


25/28

Fipgk}h~}pm fln Ecpm{~pw Hfln

gl tmp{tmk~gumFipgk}h~}pm fln Ecpm{~pw Hfln fpmf ecp tpcbc~gcl

fln f~~pfk~gcl glum{~bml~?

^c~fh hfln fpmf? 0,;5 bgh jf

6' Fipgk}h~}pm hfln? 6,: bgh jf( glkh,?

" Egmhn kpct{ hfln? 4,9: bgh jf

" Ep}g~ ~pmm kpct{ hfln? 4,9: bgh jf

" Tf{~}pm hfln? 4,0; bgh jf0' Gln}{~pgfh ~pmm{ thfl~f~gcl? 4,=5 bgh

jf

;' @fppml hfln ? 9 bghhgcl jf * Lcp~j( Mf{~ '


26/28

Kclkh}{gcl{

Eccn {mk}pg~w pmbfgl{ gl Hfc TNP fl gbtcp~fl~ kjfhhmlim fln HfcTNP

Ipmf~mp glum{~bml~ gl eccn fln fipgk}h~}pm f{ ymhh f{ gl lf~}pfh

pm{c}pkm bflfimbml~ g{ e}lnfbml~fh ~c bmm~gli ~jm BNI{( gltfp~gk}hfp ~jm icfh{ kclkmplgli tcump~w( j}limp( fln jmfh~j,

Eccn {mk}pg~w kfl clhw `m fkjgmumn gl Hfc TNP ge f `pcfn pflim ce{~famjchnmp{ fpm tfp~lmpgli fln fhgilgli ~c f kcbbcl c`omk~gum,

LIC{ lmmn ~c `m bcpm tpm{ml~( ycpagli meegkgml~hw f~ kcbb}lg~whmumh( fln glkpmf{gli hckfh f}~jcpg~gm{ kftfkg~gm{

ENG fln Ncbm{~gk glum{~bml~ kfl thfw fl gbtcp~fl~ pchm gl `cc{~glifipgk}h~}pfh tpcn}k~gcl( gbtcp~gli eccn {fem~w {~flnfpn{( ,,

Glkpmf{m eck}{ cl eccn {mk}pg~w gl mlugpclbml~fh gbtfk~f{{m{{bml~{ *MGF' ecp glum{~bml~{ gl fipc"`f{mn gln}{~pgm{ flnthfl~f~gcl{( `gc"e}mh gln}{~pgm{( bglgli( jwnpc"tcymp fln c~jmp{

Hfc TNP lmmn ~c mljflkm g~{ pm{tcl{m{ ~c pmigclfh kjfhhmlim{ *m,i,

FGE[( [TT"E['

Hfc TNP Lf~gclfh {~pf~miw lmmn{ ~c `m e}p~jmp fp~gk}hf~mn yg~j ~jmpmigclfh eccn {mk}pg~w {~pf~miw


27/28

Hfc Fipgk}h~}pm g{ Ctml

~c Kcctmpf~gcl % Glum{~bml~


28/28

^jfla wc}^jfla wc}

plenary session 3. dr parisak paper

Documents