pgti data gathering report1
TRANSCRIPT
102 Weatherby Court Savannah, GA 31405
912-777-6007 or 954-554-5370
Description of Company and Products or Services:
PGT, Inc. is a Delaware corporation formed on December 16, 2003, and on June 27, 2006, PGT
became a publicly listed company on the NASDAQ Global Market under the symbol “PGTI”. PGT, Inc.
manufactures and supplies residential impact-resistant windows and doors in the Southeastern United
States, the Gulf Coast, Coastal mid-Atlantic, the Caribbean, and Canada. PGT, Inc. focuses their efforts
on marketing their products to a highly diversified customer base that is comprised of approximately
1,200 window distributors, building supply distributors, window replacement dealers, and enclosure
contractors. PGT’s diverse product line is broken up into two components, impact windows and doors and
other windows and door products. The company has seven different impact-resistant product lines and
four high quality window and door product lines. Approximately 22% of net sales are attributed from
PGT’s top 11 customer accounts. Other business is generated through new construction, home repair, and
remodeling end markets. This organization does not distribute their products directly to homebuilders, but
believes a majority of their demand for their products is a function of the relationships they have with
national homebuilders. PGT Industries will continue to grow with the help of hurricane impact-resistant
building codes that have the potential of being passed into law by the hurricane-prone southern coast
states. The company also has potential growth by expanding sales through contracts for the higher end
store front window market, the high rise condominium window market, and the electricity efficient
homeowner market.
Culture:
PGT’s business is order-based with a strong sales strategy that primarily focuses on attracting and
retaining distributors and dealers. They do this by consistently providing exceptional customer service,
leading product design and quality, and competitive pricing all using their advanced knowledge of
building code requirements and technical expertise.
PGT Industries (PGTI) 1070 Technology Drive North
Venice, FL 34275
Prepared by Ryan Emmons
May 19, 2016
102 Weatherby Court Savannah, GA 31405
912-777-6007 or 954-554-5370
Management Team
Manager Position/Background Start Date
Rodney Hershberger
(CEO and Chairman)
Mr. Hershberger, co-founder of PGT Industries, Inc., has served the
Company since its founding in 1980. Appointed in 2005 as Chief Executive
Officer, Mr. Hershberger led the company's IPO in 2006 and was elected as
Chairman of the Board in 2014. Previously, he served as President,
Executive Vice President and Chief Operating Officer. Throughout his
tenure, Mr. Hershberger has led all aspects of PGT, including Engineering,
Marketing, Sales, Manufacturing, Transportation, Logistics and Customer
Service
1980
Jeffery T. Jackson
(CPA/ President and
COO)
Mr. Jackson joined PGT in November 2005 as Vice President and Chief
Financial Officer. The following year, he helped lead the Company's IPO,
and was later named Executive Vice President. In 2014, Mr. Jackson was
named President and Chief Operating Officer with responsibilities of
overseeing the Company’s strategic plan, as well as all aspects of operations
in 2016 Mr. Jackson was appointed Director. Prior to joining PGT, he served
in various Executive Management roles, including Division Chief Financial
Officer, Vice President Corporate Controller, and Senior Vice President of
Operations. Mr. Jackson earned a B.B.A. from the University of West
Georgia and is a Certified Public Accountant in both Georgia and
California. The Board recognizes Mr. Jackson’s experience with the
Company and within the Building Products Industry as driving the
Company’s business strategy and creating value to its stockholders.
November 2005
Bradley West
(Senior Vice President-
CFO)
Mr. West joined PGT in 2006, and has held increasing responsibilities
during his career in Finance and Accounting, currently serving as Chief
Financial Officer, serving as Director of Financial Planning and Analysis,
Director of Accounting and Finance, and Vice President and Controller
through 2014. With his most recent appointment as Chief Financial Officer,
Mr. West is responsible for PGT’s Accounting and Finance Departments, as
well as its Investor Relations, Treasury, and Risk Management functions.
Mr. West has over 18 years of management experience in manufacturing
organizations, earned a B.B.A. degree from the University of Michigan, and
is a Certified Public Accountant in Georgia.
2006
Mario Ferrucci III
(Vice President and
General Counsel)
Mr. Ferrucci joined PGT in April 2006 and is responsible for PGT's
Corporate Governance and Compliance, our Strategic Purchasing and
Material Handling functions, and our acquisition and integration activities.
At various times since joining PGT, Mr. Ferrucci led the Company’s Design
Engineering, Code Compliance, IT and Field Service departments.
Previously an M&A Attorney at Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom
LLP. Mr. Ferrucci graduated magna cum laude from the Widener University
School of Law, earning an M.A.A.B.T. from the University of Connecticut
and B.A. from Colby College. A member of the Delaware Bar Association.
April 2006
102 Weatherby Court Savannah, GA 31405
912-777-6007 or 954-554-5370
Martin Bracamonte
(Vice President and GM
of PGT Glass
Opperations)
Mr. Bracamonte joined PGT in 2015, and as a seasoned operations
professional since 1990, Martin brings to PGT extensive experience and
leadership in glass, international operations, and innovation. Martin has a
University Degree in Industrial Engineering which he received in Buenos
Aries, Argentina. He also has completed numerous post-graduate programs
such as Business Marketing with Tuck School of Business at Dartmouth
(2012), Business Marketing with Kellogg School of Business (2011),
Strategic Marketing Management with Harvard Business School (2007),
Manufacturing with Cranfield University in London (2003) and holds a
Quality Assurance Degree from ITBA Arg (1995).
2015
Debbie L. Lapinska
(Vice President, Human
Resources)
Mrs. LaPinska joined PGT in 1991 and has held increasing responsibilities
during her career, currently serving as Vice President of Human Resources.
She has led Human Resources, Workforce and Dealer Development,
Customer Service and Field Service, Transportation, and Sales and
Marketing departments. Mrs. LaPinska earned a B.A. in Business
Management from Eckerd College.
1991
David McCutcheon
(Vice President,
Manufacturing and
Logistics)
Mr. McCutcheon joined PGT in 1997. He directs Manufacturing
Engineering, Quality, Production, Scheduling, Transportation, and Logistics.
Mr. McCutcheon has over twenty years of management experience in
Manufacturing Operations and Engineering. Mr. McCutcheon earned a B.S.
in Electrical Engineering from Purdue University and an M.B.A. from The
Ohio State University.
1997
Danielle Mikesell
(Vice President,
Marketing, R&D and
Customer Service)
Mrs. Mikesell joined PGT in 2014, serving as Director of Marketing. Within
a few months, she was also given the responsibility of Design Engineering.
With her most recent appointment, she is responsible for brand and product
management, market research and analytics, customer and field service,
design engineering, and code compliance. Mrs. Mikesell has been in the
building industry for over 20 years. Her extensive and diverse experience
includes leading nationally recognized brands, complex configurable
product lines and working with various channels of distribution to include
Independent Dealer Networks, Architects and Designers, National Builders,
and Big Box Retailers.
2014
Who is the typical shareholder? Institutional
Institutional Holdings: 93.72%
Total Number of Holders: 154
Total Shares Held: 45,624,665
Total Value of Holdings: 437,996,784
Net Activity (3,067,461)
Market capitalization of company:
$471.74 Million
102 Weatherby Court Savannah, GA 31405
912-777-6007 or 954-554-5370
Historical Financials
Income Statement
Year Ended Percent Change
January 2,
2016
January 3,
2015
December 28,
2013
Increase / (Decrease)
(in thousands, except per share amounts)
2015-
2014
2014-
2013
Net sales $ 389,810 $ 306,388 $ 239,303 27.2 % 28.0 %
Cost of sales 270,678 213,596 159,169 26.7 % 34.2 %
Gross profit 119,132 92,792 80,134 28.4 % 15.8 %
Gross margin 30.6 % 30.3 % 33.5 %
Gain on sale of assets held — — (2,195 )
SG&A expenses 68,190 56,377 54,594 21.0 % 3.3 %
SG&A expenses as a percentage of sales 17.5 % 18.4 % 22.8 %
Income from operations 50,942 36,415 27,735
Interest expense, net 11,705 5,960 3,520
Debt extinguishment costs — 2,625 333
Other expenses, net 388 1,750 437
Income tax expense (benefit) 15,297 9,675 (3,374 )
Net income $ 23,552 $ 16,405 $ 26,819
Net income per common share:
Basic $ 0.49 $ 0.35 $ 0.55
Diluted $ 0.47 $ 0.33 $ 0.51
102 Weatherby Court Savannah, GA 31405
912-777-6007 or 954-554-5370
Balance Sheet
Period Ending Jan 2, 2016 Jan 3, 2015 Dec 28, 2013
Assets
Current Assets
Cash And Cash Equivalents 61,493 42,469 30,204
Short Term Investments - - -
Net Receivables 31,783 25,374 23,584
Inventory 23,053 19,970 12,908
Other Current Assets 10,660 6,464 4,704
Total Current Assets 126,989 94,277 71,400
Long Term Investments - - -
Property Plant and Equipment 71,503 60,898 44,123
Goodwill 65,635 66,580 -
Intangible Assets 79,311 82,724 38,869
Accumulated Amortization - - -
Other Assets 2,291 2,110 2,240
Deferred Long Term Asset
Charges - - -
Total Assets 345,729 306,589 156,632
102 Weatherby Court Savannah, GA 31405
912-777-6007 or 954-554-5370
Liabilities
Period Ending Jan 2, 2016 Jan 3, 2015 Dec 28, 2013
Accounts Payable 19,578 17,328 15,522
Short/Current Long Term Debt 1,966 1,962 4,890
Other Current Liabilities - - -
Total Current Liabilities 21,544 19,290 20,412
Long Term Debt 190,502 191,792 72,365
Other Liabilities 828 735 1,400
Deferred Long Term Liability
Charges 25,894 20,796 13,380
Minority Interest - - -
Negative Goodwill - - -
Total Liabilities 238,768 232,613 107,557
Stockholders' Equity
Misc Stocks Options Warrants - - -
Redeemable Preferred Stock - - -
Preferred Stock - - -
Common Stock 511 498 489
Retained Earnings (128,457) (152,009) (168,414)
Treasury Stock (10,037) (11,071) (10,046)
Capital Surplus 244,944 238,229 229,269
Other Stockholder Equity - (1,671) (2,223)
Total Stockholder Equity 106,961 73,976 49,075
Net Tangible Assets (37,985) (75,328) 10,206
102 Weatherby Court Savannah, GA 31405
912-777-6007 or 954-554-5370
Cash Flows
Direct cash flows from operations for 2015, 2014, and 2013 are presented below:
Direct Operating Cash Flows
(in millions) 2015 2014 2013
Collections from customers $ 390.8 $ 313.4 $ 238.5
Other collections of cash 3.6 3.0 5.3
Disbursements to vendors (231.4 ) (191.1 ) (147.0 )
Personnel related disbursements (111.9 ) (97.9 ) (68.2 )
Debt service costs (11.5 ) (4.5 ) (2.8 )
Income tax payments (6.8 ) (1.2 ) —
Other cash activity, net (0.3 ) 0.6 (0.1 )
Cash from operations $ 32.5 $ 22.3 $ 25.7
102 Weatherby Court Savannah, GA 31405
912-777-6007 or 954-554-5370
How much personal investment does management have in the company?
Name and Address of Beneficial Owner (1)
Number of Shares
of Common Stock
Beneficially
Owned
Percentage of
Voting Shares
Beneficial Owners of More Than 5%:
BlackRock, Inc. 5,514,191 (2) 11.2%
Columbia Wanger Asset Management, LLC 3,789,069 (3) 7.7%
Renaissance Technologies Holdings Corporation 3,103,329 (4) 6.3%
Non-Employee Directors and Nominees:
Sheree L. Bargabos 1,736 *
Alexander R. Castaldi 114,320 *
Richard D. Feintuch 186,933 (5) *
M. Joseph McHugh 134,213 (6) *
Brett N. Milgrim 62,447 *
William J. Morgan 81,540 (7) *
Floyd F. Sherman 72,538 (8) *
Named Executive Officers:
Rodney Hershberger 1,971,888 (9) 4.0%
Jeffrey T. Jackson 389,018 (10) *
Bradley West 110,116 (11) *
Mario Ferrucci III 62,313 (12) *
Directors and executive officers as a group 3,187,062 (13) 6.5%
* Percentage does not exceed one percent of the total shares eligible to vote.
102 Weatherby Court Savannah, GA 31405
912-777-6007 or 954-554-5370
Valuation:
Company Ticker ROE P/E EPS BETA
TREX 19.32 24.06 1.73 2.44
AAON 20.43 31.73 0.89 1.05
ROCK 6.03 36.58 0.76 1.97
PGEM n/a 17.92 0.78 2.57
EXP 15.85 23.97 3.19 1.14
AMWD 22.48 21.14 3.45 1.48
SSD 8.63 24.97 1.52 1.67
ATRBF(International competition) 0.23 n/a n/a n/a
PGTI 19.53 26.03 0.37 0.95
Mean of Valuation Parameters 14.0625 25.8 1.58625 1.65875
Building Materials Industry Statistics 4.2 80.1 n/a n/a
(Data from Yahoo Finance)
PGT’s Valuation Summary
PGT, Inc. has a strong valuation in comparison to the Industry averages and is also performing
strong relative to a selected group of companies that are currently publicly traded companies
within the building materials industry. These companies, included in the table above, are relevant
to PGT because of their revenue size, investor comparisons, and competition factors.
The P/E for PGT is higher than the average of its closely related companies but it is significantly
lower than that of the industry P/E statistic. The five-year average for PGT’s P/E is approximately
21.5. This average is good when compared to the P/E five-year average of the S+P 500. In
Reference to Russel’s Small Cap Completeness Index, PGT’s P/E ratio is slightly above this
index’s P/E ratio.
ROE and ROA are strong relative to the direct industry comparison. Management is strong and
effectively increased ROE in 2015 by reaching positive net income levels.
Board of directors approved a $20 Million share buyback program that started in January 2016.
Buy back could be a representation that PGT is somewhat undervalued in the eyes of
management.
102 Weatherby Court Savannah, GA 31405
912-777-6007 or 954-554-5370
Which analysts follow the stock?
The stock is currently being followed by the following research companies.
Jaywalk ConvergEx Group
ResearchTeam (Market on Demand , Inc)
Standard and Poor’s Rating Services (Capital IG)
Zacks Research
What are the analyst recommendations?
Research Company Date research was conducted Reccomendation
Jaywalk ConvergEx Group 5/11/16 Consensus: Positive outlook on
the stock with a buy rating of
2.58 considered by an average
of 12 Independent Research
Providers.
Rank in industry(Building
Materials): 60.5%
39.5% of the industry has a
better Jaywalk Consensus.
Rank in Sector: 79.1%
20.9% of the sector has a better
Jaywalk Consensus.
ResearchTeam 5/12/16 Research Rating: Hold
Based off of a past rating to
hold 7/31/15.
Total return since this consensus
has dropped 40%.
S+P Capital IQ 5/05/16 Quantitative model drivers:
Hold
Zacks Research 5/13/16 Zacks Rank: 4-Sell
Position in industry: 22 of 26
102 Weatherby Court Savannah, GA 31405
912-777-6007 or 954-554-5370
Financial ratios:
Financial Ratios PGT 2012 2013 2014 2015 1Q 2016
Operating Margin 7.2% 10.7% 12.4% 13.1% 9.9%
Net Margin 5.1% 11.2% 5.4% 6.0% 1.5%
Cash Flow to Sales 13% 10.80% 7.30% 8.30% 5.90%
Debt Ratio 12.13% 54.58% 22.16% 22.10% 60.70%
SG&A Margin (As
Percentage Of Sales) - 22.8% 18.4% 17.5% 20.01%
Competition
102 Weatherby Court Savannah, GA 31405
912-777-6007 or 954-554-5370
Financial Ratio Analysis
PGT has increased their profit margins over the last 4 years. However, the first quarter profit
margin is actually below that of the four year average which is 10.85%. The company has
concluded that the decrease in margins for the first quarter are a result of acquiring new labor
to meet the demand of WinDoor product lines that were part of the business acquisition back
in February. New transportation costs associated with the acquisition were another reason
that contributed to a decrease in profit margins. The Net margin for the first quarter of 2016
is also is lower as a result the company says is due to acquisition costs.
Cash flows to sales ration has diminished over the last 4 years. This is not a draw for
concern, as long as the company has made essential purchases, acquisitions, and
improvements that will lead to potential growth. After analyzing the sales from the first
quarter of the recently acquired WinDoor product line it is important to note that sales for
this specific line exceeded the companies expected sales for the first quarter. From the date of
acquisition in February, PGT management projected sales of $3.5 million, and actual sales
came in at $4.1 million just from WinDoor. The decrease in the ratio is obviously a result of
the use of cash flows for the WinDoor purchase that cost PGT $100.3 million. $57.3 million
was financed under PGT’s new credit facility and the remaining $43.0 million was cash on
hand. A reason why the debt ratio is much higher this first quarter of 2016.
Selling, general and administrative expenses were a bigger part of sales in 2013 than in 2014
or 2015. That leverage was expected to maintain until the new expenses from property and
equipment added with the WinDoor in February 2016. The expense of WinDoor is expected
to increase SG&A by $4.0 million annually. That’s why this value is significantly higher in
the 1Q of 2016
Concerns and challenges the company faces.
PGT, Inc. hires contract workers as the business grows. They are subject to the availability of
labor and labor costs in Southwest Florida. They are also dependent on the availability of
credit. Most of PGT’s business is associated with homebuilding construction. As we reach
the end of the business cycle there is downside risk the slowdown in housing. This could
impact the demand for PGT products. Transportation costs are a big portion of PGT’s cost
structure. With the recent acquisition of WinDoor, there is an increase in costs between both
manufacturing in Venice and Orlando. An increase in gasoline prices could have a negative
effect on PGT’s business.
There are also risks associated with the integration of WinDoor. Amortizable intangibles,
property, and equipment acquired from WinDoor will become inventoried, and are expected
to increase the cost of SG&A. Incorporating the new WinDoor line could present short-run
draw backs regarding marginal product of labor due to integration of PGT standards at the
Orlando facility.
102 Weatherby Court Savannah, GA 31405
912-777-6007 or 954-554-5370
Positive developments in the company: growth prospects for the stock and
the company.
Acquisition of WinDoor allows for continued growth of sales. PGT has potential to
increase revenue if there is future home builder growth. PGT’s impact resistant lines are
Hurricane code certified. This means that if new counties pass new housing code laws in Florida,
and neighboring states, there might be an increase in demand for the required hurricane impact
resistant windows and doors to be installed on the house.
Industry concerns
Raw materials that are used to make some portion of PGT’s product lines are bought
through third party suppliers. This creates a concern because the quality in which PGT materials
are acquired is important to compete with other companies within the industry. Building
Materials is an economic driven industry and as we come to the end of a strong business cycle
there is potential that the market for new homebuilding will decrease substantially. An increase
in interest rates could also slow the demand of PGT products.
Contingent Liabilities (eg. Outstanding lawsuits)
PGT is involved in various claims and lawsuits incidental to the conduct of their business
in the ordinary course. The Company carries insurance coverage in such amounts in excess of
their self-insured retention as they believe that they have the potential to cover all liabilities in
respect to claims and lawsuits. These law suits should not have an impact on their financial
position, cash flows or results of operation.
102 Weatherby Court Savannah, GA 31405
912-777-6007 or 954-554-5370
Performance analysis of the stock
Performance history
Stock Performance (%) 1M 3M 6M YTD 1YR 5YR 10Yr
Price change (PGTI) -1.5% 0.58% -7.61% -9.39% -15.55% 339.15% -34.68%
Price change (S+P500) -2.89% 6.37% -1.99% -0.20% -3.89% 52.49% 116.92%
Price change (Nasdaq) -4.62% 4.59% -7.12% -5.90% -6.67% 66.57% 116.92%
Price Change
(Russel 3000 Index) -2.56% 7.50% -2.39% -0.04% -5.08% 51.22% 65.25%
*Data From Google finance
Performance vs benchmark
The S+P 500 index has performed better than PGT’s price YTD. The stock’s price change shows
higher volatility than this index.
Performance vs universe
The last three months the NASDAQ price change has been slightly higher than that of PGT.
YTD data shows that PGT’s price is performing below all benchmarks.
102 Weatherby Court Savannah, GA 31405
912-777-6007 or 954-554-5370
Performance vs industry and Cratus Capital benchmark
PGT has underperformed relative to the Russel 3000 over a 10 year time horizon. The only time
frame PGT beat the indices in the above table is the last 5 year period.
PGT has underperformed this month, 6 months, and year to date compared to the Russell 3000
index.