pc2kc2rdzond5: sketches and guesses while i generally agree with the uses ofthe zond 5 class...

5
The Packard Model 7101 Liquid Chroma- tography Detector System enables you to make quantitative analyses of high molecular weight compounds without the need for time-consuming preparation of derivatives. "Pre-flame" Pyrolysis, a unique feature of this new, patented sys- tem, transforms liquid chromatography solutes into a gaseous state in a controlled atmosphere furnace before they reach the hydrogen flame detector. Because the conveyor does not pass through the hydrogen flame, noise levels are ex- tremely low ... sensitivity unusually high. Your Packard Sales Engineer can give you complete information. Call him, or write for Bulletin 1086U to Packard In- strument Company, Inc., 2200 Warren- ville Road, Downers Grove, Illinois 60515, or Packard Instrument International S.A., Talstrasse 39, 8001 Zurich, Switzerland. 1 Pc2kc2rd 1 2 22 atmosphere clean. In the late 40's 1 ran some large turbo-compound engines of this kind at Cornell as well as at Pratt & Whitney Aircraft and found sturpris- ingly low levels of carbon monoxide in the exhauist during operation below 80 percent of fuLll load at all speeds. In the early 50's, I witnessed the "Texaco CombuLstion Process" engine, which seemed uinusuLLally indifferent to octane rating. The engine ran on almost any- thing. My recollection is that I wasn't particuLlarly impressed with the combUs- tion chamber design and privately pre- dicted nothing would come of it. Never- theless, I recall that the design permitted a form of air-fuel mixing that promoted detonation resistance and might be worth another look from the standpoint of lowering atmospheric contamination from fuLel additives, but I doubt whether the CO level would be reduced. This kind of engine design might be an example of the performance com- promise that Fay and Keck so correctlIx anticipate. I agree with them that virtuLally every method for redLtcing pollution woULld introduLce seriouLs per- formance penalties. I do not think that the atutonmotive steam engine (even if somehow run condensing) woUld be especially attrac- tive either in terms of economy or the instant response requlired of character- istic stop-and-go driving as well as of sudden accelerations as in high speed passing. Therefore I douLbt whether there is a truLly practical soltution to the pollution problem withouLt inordinate costs to the car operator. ISRA,Ei K ATZ N orthe eastern JUniiersilv, Bost.i, Alassachlusetts 02115 Cultura Italiana Some of Nicola Di Ferrante's coIml- ments (Letters, 20 Sept.) on the Italian academic situation bear some truth, but I ca;nnot help feeling that he suffers from "Italophobia." It is not uncom- nion among Italianis, especially those who emigrate to other lands to criticize excessively that very country and those institutions which prepared them, dur- ing the "green years," to attain success in life. Most remarkable, are not the shortcomings of the Italians, but the abilities of Italians to denounce their own shortcomings, without ultimllatelV doing anything to resolve them. It is not unusual that they would even de- nouLnce themselves for sins which are either nonexistent or common to the entire human race, as Barzini (1) has involuntarily demonstrated by writing his book. Everybody agrees that the university ssystem in Italy needs complete over- hauling, but for Di Ferrante to say that the new generation learns precious little and is well versed in the art of intrigue and academic politics goes beyond a fair and constructive criticism and creates the general impression that Italian students are ignoranit lads whose primary pursuit is deception. Di Fer- rante reassures us that he did not in- tend it as an accusation against Italian students and graduates. but in the meantime, for all practical purposes, the accusation has been made. Regardless of how impractical the programs and system of teaching in Italian universities may be, most Italian students who reach the university have perhaps the highest general culture training among their couLnterparts in any couLntry. The American ptublic, even in the academic world, is not aware that the university in Italy, as in other coun- tries in Eturope, is in essence a grad- uiate school. Before entering the univer- sity, the Italian student goes through 3 grUeling years of Licco, during whichi he practically "recapituLlates" 3000 years of knowledge of the western world. He hais to digest an impressive number of Latin and Greek authors in the original language. including translation, inter- pretation, and comment. The same is true for an endless list of Italian poets and writers, Dante's entire Divine Conmevy, the philosophical work of German, English, or French authors, and works of art: painting, sculpture, aind architecture, from Phidias to Frank Lloyd Wright. To this, one has to add the chronolog- ical histories of each subject: history of Greek literature, history of Latin literature, history of Italian literature, history of philosophy, and so forth. The hunianities represent the major load. but the natural sciences are also part of the course of study. Division of ssubjects is conventional, with no frag- mentation into a variety of courses with different exotic titles. A single word "L-atin" defines a subject which mnay comprise everything that was written in Roman times. The value of such training has been seldom pointed out or sufficiently em- phasized. Rather, it has been minimized by the Italians themselves, at a time when many in America are crying for m(ore hulmalnistic training for scientists SCIFNCE. VOL. 162

Upload: others

Post on 23-Mar-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Pc2kc2rdZond5: Sketches and Guesses While I generally agree with the uses ofthe Zond 5 class (Soviet) space-craft proposed by Davies and Murray (11 Oct., p. 243), their description

The Packard Model 7101 Liquid Chroma-tography Detector System enables you to

make quantitative analyses of highmolecular weight compounds withoutthe need for time-consuming preparationof derivatives. "Pre-flame" Pyrolysis, a

unique feature of this new, patented sys-tem, transforms liquid chromatographysolutes into a gaseous state in a controlledatmosphere furnace before they reach thehydrogen flame detector. Because theconveyor does not pass through thehydrogen flame, noise levels are ex-

tremely low ... sensitivity unusually high.Your Packard Sales Engineer can giveyou complete information. Call him, or

write for Bulletin 1086U to Packard In-strument Company, Inc., 2200 Warren-ville Road, Downers Grove, Illinois 60515,or Packard Instrument International S.A.,Talstrasse 39, 8001 Zurich, Switzerland.

1 Pc2kc2rd1 2 22

atmosphere clean. In the late 40's 1 ransome large turbo-compound engines ofthis kind at Cornell as well as at Pratt& Whitney Aircraft and found sturpris-ingly low levels of carbon monoxide inthe exhauist during operation below 80percent of fuLll load at all speeds. Inthe early 50's, I witnessed the "TexacoCombuLstion Process" engine, whichseemed uinusuLLally indifferent to octanerating. The engine ran on almost any-thing. My recollection is that I wasn'tparticuLlarly impressed with the combUs-tion chamber design and privately pre-dicted nothing would come of it. Never-theless, I recall that the design permitteda form of air-fuel mixing that promoteddetonation resistance and might beworth another look from the standpointof lowering atmospheric contaminationfrom fuLel additives, but I doubt whetherthe CO level would be reduced. Thiskind of engine design might be anexample of the performance com-promise that Fay and Keck so correctlIxanticipate. I agree with them thatvirtuLally every method for redLtcingpollution woULld introduLce seriouLs per-formance penalties.

I do not think that the atutonmotivesteam engine (even if somehow runcondensing) woUld be especially attrac-tive either in terms of economy or theinstant response requlired of character-istic stop-and-go driving as well as ofsudden accelerations as in high speedpassing. Therefore I douLbt whetherthere is a truLly practical soltution to thepollution problem withouLt inordinatecosts to the car operator.

ISRA,Ei KATZN ortheeastern JUniiersilv,Bost.i, Alassachlusetts 02115

Cultura Italiana

Some of Nicola Di Ferrante's coIml-ments (Letters, 20 Sept.) on the Italianacademic situation bear some truth, butI ca;nnot help feeling that he suffersfrom "Italophobia." It is not uncom-nion among Italianis, especially thosewho emigrate to other lands to criticizeexcessively that very country and thoseinstitutions which prepared them, dur-ing the "green years," to attain successin life. Most remarkable, are not theshortcomings of the Italians, but theabilities of Italians to denounce theirown shortcomings, without ultimllatelVdoing anything to resolve them. It isnot unusual that they would even de-nouLnce themselves for sins which are

either nonexistent or common to theentire human race, as Barzini (1) hasinvoluntarily demonstrated by writinghis book.

Everybody agrees that the universityssystem in Italy needs complete over-hauling, but for Di Ferrante to say thatthe new generation learns precious littleand is well versed in the art of intrigueand academic politics goes beyond afair and constructive criticism andcreates the general impression thatItalian students are ignoranit lads whoseprimary pursuit is deception. Di Fer-rante reassures us that he did not in-tend it as an accusation against Italianstudents and graduates. but in themeantime, for all practical purposes, theaccusation has been made.

Regardless of how impractical theprograms and system of teaching inItalian universities may be, most Italianstudents who reach the university haveperhaps the highest general culturetraining among their couLnterparts in anycouLntry. The American ptublic, even inthe academic world, is not aware thatthe university in Italy, as in other coun-tries in Eturope, is in essence a grad-uiate school. Before entering the univer-sity, the Italian student goes through 3grUeling years of Licco, during whichihe practically "recapituLlates" 3000 yearsof knowledge of the western world. Hehais to digest an impressive number ofLatin and Greek authors in the originallanguage. including translation, inter-pretation, and comment. The same istrue for an endless list of Italian poetsand writers, Dante's entire DivineConmevy, the philosophical work ofGerman, English, or French authors,and works of art: painting, sculpture,aind architecture, from Phidias to FrankLloyd Wright.To this, one has to add the chronolog-

ical histories of each subject: historyof Greek literature, history of Latinliterature, history of Italian literature,history of philosophy, and so forth.

The hunianities represent the majorload. but the natural sciences are alsopart of the course of study. Division ofssubjects is conventional, with no frag-mentation into a variety of courses withdifferent exotic titles. A single word"L-atin" defines a subject which mnaycomprise everything that was written inRoman times.The value of such training has been

seldom pointed out or sufficiently em-

phasized. Rather, it has been minimizedby the Italians themselves, at a timewhen many in America are crying form(ore hulmalnistic training for scientists

SCIFNCE. VOL. 162

Page 2: Pc2kc2rdZond5: Sketches and Guesses While I generally agree with the uses ofthe Zond 5 class (Soviet) space-craft proposed by Davies and Murray (11 Oct., p. 243), their description

SweetHigh Specific ActivityLow PricesUnexcelled Quality Control

Sugar NucleotidesNEC-513ADP Glucose-C'4 (D-Glucose-C'4 (U))228mc/mM* $85/1Ouc $320/5OucNEC-536GDP Mannose-C'4 (D-Mannose-C'4 (U))151mc/mM $110/louc $400/50ucNEC-557UDP Arabinose-C'4 (L-Arabinose-C'4 (U))183mc/mM* $90/5uc $350/25ucNEC-429UDP Galactose-C"4 (D-Galactose-C'4 (U))280mc/mM* $100/lOuc $350/50ucNEC-213UDP Galactose-H3 (D-Galactose-1-H3 (N))65.2mc/mM* $80/50uc $300/250ucNEC-403UDP Glucose-C'4 (D-Glucose-C'4 (U))237mc/mM* $60/lOuc $200/50ucNEC-414UDP Glucuronic-C'4 Acid(D-Glucuronic-C'4 (U) )233.Omc/mM* $60/10uc $260/50ucNEC-543UDP Xylose-C'4 (D-Xylos.-C'4 (U))198mc/mM* $90/5uc $350/25uc* Sp. Act. In Stock

Write for complete radio-chemical specifications.FREE wall chart of NucleotideDerivatives available uponrequest.

and engineers -in order to producemore "complete, universal men." Uni-versity reform and elimination of obso-lete methods and practices is imperativein Italy, but international vilification ofthe Mater universitatis and her studentsand graduates is not.

GIORGIO SOLI41-885 Laumilo Street,Waimanalo, Hawaii 96795

Reference

1. L. Barzini, The Italians (Atheneum, NewYork, 1964).

Zond 5: Sketches and Guesses

While I generally agree with the usesof the Zond 5 class of (Soviet) space-craft proposed by Davies and Murray(11 Oct., p. 243), their description ofZond 5 as being comparable in designto the Soviet Mars and Venus probesis, I think, wide of the mark.The sketch in Dmitriyev's article

(Pravda, 25 Sept.) does show threesections for the spacecraft in its park-ing orbit. However, it is easily seenthat the section described by Daviesand Murray as containing a midcourserocket motor (that is, a rocket engine)is not that at all. It is, in fact, theupper stage of the booster rocket andits purpose is to inject the Zond 5 intoits translunar trajectory. That upperstage adds some 10,400 feet per second(3120 meters per second) to the Zond5 which at that point already has anEarth satellite velocity of perhaps 25,-400 feet per second. Midcourse enginesadd only corrections of the order ofhundreds of feet per second and oftenless AV. The stage was ignited 67 min-utes after the initial launching and dis-carded after burn-out, leaving only twocompartments. All this is described byDmitriyev and is shown in his sketches.He describes a sphere-the "descentvehicle"-and an instrument compart-ment as leaving the parking orbit.

Despite Dmitriyev's relatively de-tailed article, both Davies and Murrayand myself will have to await photo-graphs of the Zond 5 spacecraft com-parable to those of the Venus 4 releasedby the Soviet Union. The latter weresufficiently detailed so as to permitcounting of threads in the "plumbing,"whereas the crude sketches of Zond 5give rise to an extended guessing game,no less.

SAUNDERS B. KRAMER1241 Eureka Avenue,Los Altos, California 94022

13 DECEMBER 1968

Precision molded and precisioncalibrated, the Nalgene' Volu-metric Flask is in a class by itself.It won't etch, contaminate orbreak. Repeated autoclavingwon't affect its accuracy. Eachflask is individually calibrated tobetter than ±+- of 10/0.

100 ml size now in stock, 250,500, and 1000 ml sizes comingsoon. Order from your lab supplydealer . . . and specify NalgeneLabware. Ask for our 1968 Cata-log or write Dept. 2124, NalgeneLabware Division, Rochester, N.Y.14602. NALGENE LABWARE DVIS

N12231223-

Page 3: Pc2kc2rdZond5: Sketches and Guesses While I generally agree with the uses ofthe Zond 5 class (Soviet) space-craft proposed by Davies and Murray (11 Oct., p. 243), their description

precisely exPosed Ptomicrographs .. automatically.ma it for hours for a pomicrograph opporttunity. Why risk

),fn:It by a wrong meter rea6ding? Or why take a chance on missingre completely while you're busy with camera controls?

Itz0 @THOMAT Microscope Camera leaves your hands and youre more important things. All you do for a perfect photo-h is select your field a push a button. Attachable to most

:roscopes, this automatic 35mm camera trips the shutter, calculatestosure and advances the film. Even automatically compensates forges during exposures! Exposures range from 1/100 second withonic flash to over 1/2 hour with fluorescent.

shu"tter of the Leitz ORTHOMAT is specially dampened againstrion. You can switch from black and white to color film, or vicesaV in the middle of a roll. Use any system of microscope illu-3tilny want. And, of course, the ORTHOMAT is built with the~ousL ~recison

TH*MAT Microscope Camera automate your clinicalonpcrography. Write for an ORTHOMAT catalog.

NIC., 468 Park Avenue South, New York, N. Y. 100166 9 6 a

Page 4: Pc2kc2rdZond5: Sketches and Guesses While I generally agree with the uses ofthe Zond 5 class (Soviet) space-craft proposed by Davies and Murray (11 Oct., p. 243), their description

WILKS SCIENTIFICANNOUNCES...

INSTANTINFRARED

I m , ~

INFRAREDACCESSORY DEPOTSFisher Scientific Offices:Atlanta, Georgia: 690 MiamiTelephone: (404) 261-4120King of Prussia, Pennsylvania:Gulph Road- Route 23Telephone: (215) 265-0300Springfield, N.J.: 52 Fadem RoadTelephone: (201) 379-1400Silver Spring, Maryland: 7722Fenton StreetTelehone: (301) 587-7000

Chicauc.Il11inoIs: 1458 North

I

IINSTANT SERVIC

Demountable Cells and Windows

CUT ALONG DOTTED LINE--------------------------------------------------

WA ILKS SC I EN T IFCCORPORATIONV

O Please send complete Wilks Scientific Infrared Ac-cessory Catalog.

0 Put us on your Mailing List.

We have the following l.R. spectrophotometers

Name

Organization

uept.Address_ __ Zip

rnoenlx, Arizona:fl u vvestOsborn RoadTelephone: (602)24-111Fisher Scientific Co'pa.y LimitedOffices:Montreal, Quebec, Canada: 855fDevonshire RoadTelephone: (514) 735-2621Toronto, Ontario, Canada: 184Railside (Don Mills)Telephone: (416) 445-2121Edmonton, Alberta, Canada: Box3840 Stat. D.Telephone: (403) 455-3151Vancouver 3, B.C., Canada: Box2149Telephone: (604) 872-7641

Analytical Consultants Offices:Dallas, Texas: 5622 Dyer StreetTelephone: (214) 368-7755

Wilks Scientific Corporation Offices:South Norwalk, Conn., Box 441Telephone: (203) 838-4537

TEL E PHONE * (203) 838-4537

SCIENCE, VOL. 1621226

mmmma

IIIIIIIIIII

Page 5: Pc2kc2rdZond5: Sketches and Guesses While I generally agree with the uses ofthe Zond 5 class (Soviet) space-craft proposed by Davies and Murray (11 Oct., p. 243), their description

Just $325* buys the 1Fwrrtm "Foci-Flex")

A low-cost, qualityinstrument ideally suited

for systems operation,education and

experimental uses.*14,440 lines per inch - $325.; 28,800 lines per inch - $385.

A product ofFarrand Optical Co., Inc., New York, N. Y.

Direct

to: iFeirra1i OPTICAL CO., INC.Commercial Products Division535-SC So. 5th Avenue, Mt. Vernon, N. Y. 10550(914) 668-9393/Cable Address: FOCIUS NY

For more information, write

lF-AB RI11=T 1E KSItnstruments, Inc.

Dept. S-128, 5225 Verona Rd., Madison, Wis. 53711 Phone:

The newly designedModel 1010 digital computer uses

true signal averaging rather than straight summationor weighted average methods. Sweep speeds rangefrom 20 microseconds per address to 200 seconds

for a complete 256 address sweep.It's easier to operate; even the oscillo-

I. scope and X-Y recorder outputsare calibrated by pushbutton.

iO8/238-8476 * U.S.A. and Canada

13 DECEMBER 1968

&.15V 19-

GRATING MONOCHROMATOR

A

1311