p.c. lippman1 cefpi 85 th international conference: refp workshop september 29, how does learning...
TRANSCRIPT
P.C. Lippman 1
How Does Learning Occur? Mastering Formal and Informal Skills
CEFPI 85CEFPI 85thth International Conference: REFP Workshop International Conference: REFP Workshop September 29, September 29, 2008
Presented by:
Peter C. Lippman, Assoc. AIA, REFPJCJ Architecture, New York, New York
Robert Nicholson
JCJ Architecture, San Diego. CA
P.C. Lippman 2
PART 1: Normative Theories PART 1: Normative Theories
P.C. Lippman 3
Normative Theories of DesignNormative Theories of Design
•the architect’s position is not accepted nor valued in the marketplace;
•the position was developed before implementation ;
•the intentions of the design are treated as separate from practice;
•the architect did not have the design skills to put into practice their intentions (Lang, 1988).
P.C. Lippman 4
Normative Theories of DesignNormative Theories of Design
•the architect’s position is not accepted nor valued in the
marketplace (L-Shaped CR);
•the position was developed before implementation. Since the position was never implemented, the consequences of having no practical experience were unforeseen (environments that do not assist teachers and teachers are blamed for spaces not working); •the intentions of the design are treated as separate from practice (Space Program & Educational Program);
•the architect did not have the design skills to put into practice their intentions (Integration of Educational Theory).
P.C. Lippman 5
PART 2: Learner-Environment PART 2: Learner-Environment Relationships Relationships
P.C. Lippman 6
Learner-Environment Relationship Learner-Environment Relationship Learner-Environment Relationship Learner-Environment Relationship
Quadrant 4:Quadrant 4:•Learner activeLearner active
•Environment ActiveEnvironment Active
Quadrant 2: Quadrant 2: •Learner passiveLearner passive
•Environment active Environment active
Quadrant 3:Quadrant 3:•Learner active Learner active
•Environment passiveEnvironment passive
Quadrant 1: Quadrant 1: •Learner passiveLearner passive
•Environment passive Environment passive
Environment activeEnvironment active Environment passiveEnvironment passive
Lear
ner
activ
eLe
arne
r ac
tive
Le
arne
r pa
ssiv
eLe
arne
r pa
ssiv
e
P.C. Lippman 7
Learner-Environment Relationship Learner-Environment Relationship Learner-Environment Relationship Learner-Environment Relationship
Quadrant 4:Quadrant 4:• How the learner influences their How the learner influences their environment & how in turn the environment & how in turn the environment influences the learner - environment influences the learner - TransactionsTransactions
Quadrant 2: Quadrant 2: • How environment How environment influences and influences and causes the Leaner causes the Leaner to change behavior to change behavior
Quadrant 3:Quadrant 3:• How Learner chooses to How Learner chooses to behave in the behave in the environmentenvironment
Quadrant 1: Quadrant 1: • How the environment How the environment does not affect learner & does not affect learner & where the learner’s where the learner’s behavior does not behavior does not change change
Environment activeEnvironment active Environment passiveEnvironment passive
Lear
ner
activ
eLe
arne
r ac
tive
Le
arne
r pa
ssiv
eLe
arne
r pa
ssiv
e
P.C. Lippman 8
Learner-Environment Relationship Learner-Environment Relationship Learner-Environment Relationship Learner-Environment Relationship
Quadrant 4:Quadrant 4:•Practice TheoryPractice Theory
Quadrant 2: Quadrant 2: •Behaviorism Behaviorism
Quadrant 3:Quadrant 3:•CognitiveCognitive
•ConstructivistConstructivist
Quadrant 1: Quadrant 1: •Genetic DeterminismGenetic Determinism
Environment activeEnvironment active Environment passiveEnvironment passive
Lear
ner
activ
eLe
arne
r ac
tive
Le
arne
r pa
ssiv
eLe
arne
r pa
ssiv
e
P.C. Lippman 9
Learner-Environment Relationship Learner-Environment Relationship Learner-Environment Relationship Learner-Environment Relationship
Quadrant 4:Quadrant 4:•Practice TheoryPractice Theory
Quadrant 2: Quadrant 2: •Behaviorism Behaviorism
Quadrant 3:Quadrant 3:•CognitiveCognitive
•ConstructivistConstructivist
Quadrant 1: Quadrant 1: •Genetic DeterminismGenetic Determinism
Environment activeEnvironment active Environment passiveEnvironment passive
Lear
ner
activ
eLe
arne
r ac
tive
Le
arne
r pa
ssiv
eLe
arne
r pa
ssiv
e
P.C. Lippman 10
Behaviorist Model Behaviorist Model Behaviorist Model Behaviorist Model
Social Environment• Teacher is the Content Provider
This Environment is Teacher-Centered
Physical Environment• Desks arranged in rows to face
front of Classroom
P.C. Lippman 11
BehaviorismDoes this look familiar?
1920
1960
2000
P.C. Lippman 12
Learner-Environment Relationship Learner-Environment Relationship Learner-Environment Relationship Learner-Environment Relationship
Quadrant 4:Quadrant 4:•Practice TheoryPractice Theory
Quadrant 2: Quadrant 2: •Behaviorism Behaviorism
Quadrant 3:Quadrant 3:•CognitiveCognitive
•MIMI
•ConstructivistConstructivist
Quadrant 1: Quadrant 1: •Genetic DeterminismGenetic Determinism
Environment activeEnvironment active Environment passiveEnvironment passive
Lear
ner
activ
eLe
arne
r ac
tive
Le
arne
r pa
ssiv
eLe
arne
r pa
ssiv
e
P.C. Lippman 13
Cognition: Cognition: Active LearnerActive Learner – Passive EnvironmentPassive Environment
P.C. Lippman 14
Multiple Intelligences: Multiple Intelligences: Active LearnerActive Learner – Passive EnvironmentPassive Environment
•Linguistic intelligence ("word smart")
•Logical-mathematical intelligence ("number/reasoning smart")
•Spatial intelligence ("picture smart")
•Bodily-Kinesthetic intelligence ("body smart")
•Musical intelligence ("music smart")
•Interpersonal intelligence ("people smart")
•Intrapersonal intelligence ("self smart")
•Naturalist intelligence ("nature smart")
•Existential (“real world smart”)
P.C. Lippman 15
Constructivism: Constructivism: Active LearnerActive Learner – Passive Passive Environment Environment
P.C. Lippman 16
Social Patterns of ParticipationSocial Patterns of ParticipationSocial Patterns of ParticipationSocial Patterns of Participation
PERIPHERAL ENGAGEMENT GUIDED ENGAGEMENT FULL ENGAGEMENT
P.C. Lippman 17
Conventional ThinkingConventional Thinking
• Age: 6-18Age: 6-18 • Any ageAny age
• Time: 9-3Time: 9-3 • AnytimeAnytime
• Place: SchoolPlace: School • Any placeAny place
• Resources: Books & TeachersResources: Books & Teachers • Any resource - real time Any resource - real time (newspapers, interviews)(newspapers, interviews)
• Positions: Sitting at a desk or Positions: Sitting at a desk or standingstanding
• Any positionAny position
• Activity: 3 R’s - RoteActivity: 3 R’s - Rote • Any activity that stimulates Any activity that stimulates brain developmentbrain development
Alternative Thinking Alternative Thinking
Learner, Learning, & the Things to be LearnedLearner, Learning, & the Things to be Learned
P.C. Lippman 18
Active Learner & Active Learning Active Learner & Active Learning EnvironmentEnvironment
P.C. Lippman 19
LearnerLearner
Alternative Learning : Authentic and Relevant
P.C. Lippman 20
Learner-Environment Relationship Learner-Environment Relationship Learner-Environment Relationship Learner-Environment Relationship
Quadrant 4:Quadrant 4:• Practice Theory – involves Levels Practice Theory – involves Levels of Participation and grounds of Participation and grounds learning in physical settinglearning in physical setting
•Interplay of acquisitions & Interplay of acquisitions & transformations – Transactionstransformations – Transactions
Quadrant 2: Quadrant 2: • Individual responds / reacts to Individual responds / reacts to environment – Learner is influenced by environment – Learner is influenced by the environment peripherally & is guided the environment peripherally & is guided by social environment. Leaner must by social environment. Leaner must change behavior change behavior
•Acquisition by exposureAcquisition by exposure
Quadrant 3:Quadrant 3:• Cognitive & Cognitive & Constructivist – involves Constructivist – involves Levels of ParticipationLevels of Participation
•Acquisition by Discovery Acquisition by Discovery
Quadrant 1: Quadrant 1: • Learner development is Learner development is direct result of genetic direct result of genetic makeupmakeup
•Acquisition by ChanceAcquisition by Chance
Environment activeEnvironment active Environment passiveEnvironment passive
Lear
ner
activ
eLe
arne
r ac
tive
Le
arne
r pa
ssiv
eLe
arne
r pa
ssiv
e
P.C. Lippman 21
Understanding Place: Understanding Place: Meanings of Constructed Objects (1995)Meanings of Constructed Objects (1995)Understanding Place: Understanding Place: Meanings of Constructed Objects (1995)Meanings of Constructed Objects (1995)
Research Methodology:
• Interviews at three stages of project
• Video Tape
P.C. Lippman 22
Understanding Place: Meanings of Constructed Objects (1995)
Understanding Place: Meanings of Constructed Objects (1995)
Findings: • Use of the Physical
Environment (flexible & Integrated)
• Zones of Activity o Zone 1: Group
Participationo Zone 2: Working
with Otherso Zone
3:Independent with others
o Zone 4: Independent
P.C. Lippman 23
Learner, Learning & the Things to be LearnedLearner, Learning & the Things to be Learned
P.C. Lippman 24
Learner-Environment Relationship Learner-Environment Relationship Learner-Environment Relationship Learner-Environment Relationship
Quadrant 4:Quadrant 4:• Practice Theory – involves Levels Practice Theory – involves Levels of Participation and grounds of Participation and grounds learning in physical settinglearning in physical setting
•Interplay of acquisitions & Interplay of acquisitions & transformations – Transactionstransformations – Transactions
Quadrant 2: Quadrant 2: • Individual responds / reacts to Individual responds / reacts to environment – Learner is influenced by environment – Learner is influenced by the environment peripherally & is guided the environment peripherally & is guided by social environment. Leaner must by social environment. Leaner must change behavior change behavior
•Acquisition by exposureAcquisition by exposure
Quadrant 3:Quadrant 3:• Cognitive & Constructivist Cognitive & Constructivist – involves Levels of – involves Levels of ParticipationParticipation
•Acquisition by Discovery Acquisition by Discovery
Quadrant 1: Quadrant 1: • Learner development is Learner development is direct result of genetic direct result of genetic makeupmakeup
•Acquisition by ChanceAcquisition by Chance
Environment activeEnvironment active Environment passiveEnvironment passive
Lear
ner
activ
eLe
arne
r ac
tive
Le
arne
r pa
ssiv
eLe
arne
r pa
ssiv
e
P.C. Lippman 25
Practice Theory: Practice Theory: Social Patterns of ParticipationSocial Patterns of ParticipationPractice Theory: Practice Theory: Social Patterns of ParticipationSocial Patterns of Participation
PERIPHERAL ENGAGEMENT GUIDED ENGAGEMENT FULL ENGAGEMENT
P.C. Lippman 26
Practice Theory: Practice Theory: Active Learner, Active Social Active Learner, Active Social Environment, & Active Physical EnvironmentEnvironment, & Active Physical Environment
P.C. Lippman 27
Real World Work Settings
Active Learner & Active Learning Active Learner & Active Learning EnvironmentEnvironmentActive Learner & Active Learning Active Learner & Active Learning EnvironmentEnvironment
P.C. Lippman 28
Learner-Environment Relationship Learner-Environment Relationship Learner-Environment Relationship Learner-Environment Relationship
Quadrant 4:Quadrant 4:•Learner Active Learner Active
•Social Environment Active / Physical Social Environment Active / Physical Environment ActiveEnvironment Active
Quadrant 2: Quadrant 2: •Learner Passive Learner Passive
•Social Environment ActiveSocial Environment Active
Quadrant 3:Quadrant 3:•Active LearnerActive Learner
•Social Environment passiveSocial Environment passive
Quadrant 1: Quadrant 1: •Passive Learner Passive Learner
•Social Environment PassiveSocial Environment Passive
Environment activeEnvironment active Environment passiveEnvironment passive
Lear
ner
activ
eLe
arne
r ac
tive
Le
arne
r pa
ssiv
eLe
arne
r pa
ssiv
e
P.C. Lippman 29
PART 3: Active Physical PART 3: Active Physical EnvironmentsEnvironments
P.C. Lippman 30
Active Physical EnvironmentsActive Physical Environments: : Defining Guidelines for Activity Settings Defining Guidelines for Activity Settings Active Physical EnvironmentsActive Physical Environments: : Defining Guidelines for Activity Settings Defining Guidelines for Activity Settings
Guidelines for Individual, One-to-One, Small Group, & Large Group Transactions
• Privacy
• Personalization
• Physical Comfort
• Control
• Access to Resources
• Manage Interactions
• Place Identity
Definition of Activity Settings• access to peers of greater, equal, and
lesser ability;
• transactions between students and teachers, verbal and otherwise, that occur in the daily routine;
• opportunities to investigate an array of activities permitted within the settings;
• opportunities to design, redesign, and react to self-generated changes as they work through their goal-directed activities; and
• low levels of adult guidance, supervision, and considerable freedom for what students accomplish and how they accomplish it (Tharp & Gallimore, 1997).
P.C. Lippman 31
L-Shaped Classroom:L-Shaped Classroom:Activity SettingsActivity SettingsL-Shaped Classroom:L-Shaped Classroom:Activity SettingsActivity Settings
Aspects for Creating an Active Physical Environment
"Contexts in which collaborative interaction, intersubjectivity, and assisted performance occur—in which teaching occurs—are referred to as activity settings" (Tharp & Gallimore, 1997, p. 72)
Flexible: The ways in which the non-fixed elements,
furnishings, in the classroom can be arranged and re-
arranged by the teacher and students for the diverse
activities that occur in the learning environment.
Integrated: The shape allows for the separation of
activities and connects activities. It limits distractions
and encourages activities to collaboration. Ability to
move and through and oversee throughout the space Variable-in-Size: The shape affords different zones to
support the diverse ways in which people acquire
knowledge. Where zones are layered and overlap
P.C. Lippman 32
L-Shaped ClassroomL-Shaped Classroom::Activity Settings Activity Settings L-Shaped ClassroomL-Shaped Classroom::Activity Settings Activity Settings
Integrated:
Variable-in-Size:
Flexible:
P.C. Lippman 33
Neighborhood
Neighborhood
Neighborhood
Neighborhood
Lincoln Elementary Schools, Lincoln Nebraska, USADesigned by TAP, USA
Zones outside the classroomZones outside the classroom::Activity SettingsActivity Settings
Integrated:
Variable-in-Size:
Flexible:
P.C. Lippman 34
Zones outside the classroomZones outside the classroom::Activity SettingsActivity SettingsZones outside the classroomZones outside the classroom::Activity SettingsActivity Settings
Maxi, Cavett, Campbell, & Roper ElementarySchools in Nebraska (1990’s) Designed by The Architectural Partnership,
USA
Guidelines Privacy, Personalization , Physical Comfort, Control , Access to Resources, Manage Interactions, & Place Identity
P.C. Lippman 35
Westwoods Upper Elementary Middle SchoolFarmington, Connecticut, USA (2002)Designed by JCJ Architecture, USA
Zones outside the classroomZones outside the classroom::Activity SettingsActivity SettingsZones outside the classroomZones outside the classroom::Activity SettingsActivity Settings
P.C. Lippman 36
Harvey Milk High SchoolNew York, New York, USA (2002)Designed by Perkins Eastman Architects, USA
Zones outside the classroomZones outside the classroom::Activity SettingsActivity SettingsZones outside the classroomZones outside the classroom::Activity SettingsActivity Settings
Guidelines Privacy, Personalization , Physical Comfort, Control , Access to Resources, Manage Interactions, & Place Identity
P.C. Lippman 37
Main Street: Wilbert Snow Elementary SchoolMiddletown, Connecticut, USA (1996)Designed by JCJ Architecture, USA
Integrated:
Variable-in-Size:
Flexible:
Zones outside the Learning Zones outside the Learning CommunityCommunity: Activity Setttings: Activity Setttings
Zones outside the Learning Zones outside the Learning CommunityCommunity: Activity Setttings: Activity Setttings
P.C. Lippman 38
The Downtown School, Minneapolis, MinnesotaThe Cunningham Group
Zones outside the Learning Zones outside the Learning Community : Community : Activity SettingsActivity Settings
Zones outside the Learning Zones outside the Learning Community : Community : Activity SettingsActivity Settings
P.C. Lippman 39
Peter C. Lippman, JCJ Architecture
Robert Nicholson, JCJ Architecture
Thank YouContact Information