Sll'/\'l'L;: OP' Ml Cl 11 l;AN DE:P/\HTMENT Qfi COMHf.[{CI~

[3\lf<l~AU ()(" OCCUl'll'f :ON/\L & PHOlfJ;:s s, ONJ\L llE:GUi,ATTON nut,IW (W Ml::DlC.:li'm

.Ln tile Matter of

PAULA G. DAVf!.Y, M.D. I ----------- ----

CONSP.N1' OHDim ---- ---·-- -------·-

WIIEHl!!J\S, an /\dml.nistraU.ve Comp.I aJnt · ,rnd f'.i.rsl Amt':\ndf~c .,tlmin··

i:,trallve Con1plai11t ~ien~ f.Ued wl.tl1 l,,Js 13oard on Ma:d: ·,, i 9•i,

,rnd September 15, 199 ·1, respectl."Jely .. chargi.r.g Paulo G. D,111ey,

t-1.D. (Ho::,por.dent) wli.h havl.nq vic,tat:ed :-:;e ctior:s lfi22:'.~,) .>1i.i

:i 3 J. l l 1) 1 ~!: se9.; t~S/\ 14. J ~; ( ll t_) :. J ~-t_ 0:.§:9. .: and

'Nl!C:RJ.rns, Hm;punden l: has ?1d1nl t: 1:ed by '.::i t.ipu.1.a tic.""ln s11!:arn1 tbJO

hetaw.lth l.twt R(:,spondcnt ·. f..:1Li.eL! t.o 1o1alnta.Jn a :rnf.f:iclenl ly or~F'·

nl.zed i:-ec:)[d i:c pruv.lde adequate documentation for di.c1,:;,101=:i .5 and

treatment provhled to patients Kfj, :38 cind E:S named l.n thf:: 11:.:ln,ln!-

strat .ive Complaint; and further, Respundent fa.Lled to obtain a

suffi.cient informed consent d:3 to patl.1:rnt RL, named i;: the F'i r.st

Amended Allministrutlve .~:or,1plc.llnt, :·egardl119 le::;ti.ng !'o, blo:;--

kJnesJo .lo9y sl:udi.E:s w!1i.ch c,:mst.itul:(~s :H1gligenc·.:! ut· fc.1i.l.u1:e t.c,

E:xurcise due cnni, ln vlolaL1011 c,t Secti.c•n lf,2:'.1(, .1) oC Lhe Puol.il'

ilea l l:h Coda.: and

WIIEI\E/\S, 1 t Is furt:1101 . s l.Lpulaled and agreud that C\:1.111:: 11

which ,1Jleves v .lu 1 1Llons of: Sectl.on H,1.;,.L(b)( .1) [lr.comr,r ::l.c,nc8J

sllall be dti::;mt ss0d; dlld

\1/H•i:R"' /\· . I.h e iJuard l1as re ,; 10•,md fJa! .<1 ::il!pulal:ion ,:11ki, b,we<!

upon the i,,::itler· ,rnmnted therein, i'.HJLGOs that the ~JubUc in ··

terest l s b<:.. . ·. se1.vt:d lly resoluLJ01; nr Lluc:: outstiJn.1111<, (\::,111-

plaint s ; now. tlwrefore,

L'l' TS l!EHE:BY l"OUND that l:IIH fol luwin<j al.legal.tuns of fe1cl · &l "c.!

true and con:.;lilule violations of Sectlon 1621.l(aJ 0f the P•JblJc

Health Code: llwt :iespondent fui.Jecl to 1111dnta in ii ::;1;fflcl w1!.l',i

organi.zed recunl \:o prov !.de c.1de,1uate d•)c::1mentat l(>n fell · cJ :.il<]1".osJs

and tn ,:at111e11t pro\ · l.di::d t.n p,1tifH1ts KS, ~;sa nd P.:':: nc1111c~d Jn t:i1n

Admlnlsi:rativn Cc:Hpl. c ii1t'; c11,c.': ful'ther, Re s pondent 1'0ilel'I to

ol.1La;n « sufl:tclL,itl i!tfunned cun s enL ::1:~ h; pat.lant !H, . nar.iE::J lri

the F.lrst Amended /\( .1d.n l.stnil:ive tX11oplaini:, r<,!gar.Jlng te~;tJn9 fot·

bioklnesiology studieos.

/\ccordlngly,

TT IS HEREBY OHDlmED that for tile afoi:-esa id violations of

SecUon 16221\cl} of lhe Public lleallh Code, He ;=;pondenl shall bo

and hereby· .is plac e d on £'!~~A'PJOI '( frir · a p e e loci of eit]hteen ( rn)

months, corrnnencinq on th, 3 efrecti.ve d ,:::l.8 cf ,.hi~; Order. The

terms :~nd condlt.lr,11,3 of s 0 Hi pn,l>aLLnn are ,1:;; fol]ows:

- 2.-

/\. Hespondont: slrn.11 1;v.1e l: quart:01:ly wJt:h the cllatr­per:r;on of Lhe Board or a pec :1on de::i i.qnated by the chaic­person t:o revie1v Ht::sponc:"nl:'3 profes s .i.onol pra c tlce. The l.n1Ur)l mrcJeUnq sl!,11] occur at: !:lie end of tile t:hlni month of prnl>allon, and m1b s eq11ent m,')etl.ngs sllal.l. occ11r ovHry llli id 111<;,1Lh lhereaft: e r uni..! I th~J period of p·.·o-­bation ends. 'l'he Co,np.1.J ance Sec Lt on of the [,e0al He­source~ Divislon ot Lhe Bureau of Occupal:lonal and Proresstu,w] !W~Jul .:d . l.on, D,,p,1rt.11h·111t of c ,mcn;e, sh .:1.I] provide Hespond ent wttt1 Lile na,ne of the uoanl•s repn · sentativ e a11d Lltfi t1111e and place of sal.d rneel:Jll'J t~.

i3. AJ I co s Ls and e;q.1enset, Ji1c.urred ln co111plyJng wll:h Lite Lerr11~, o r,d c rntdlt.i o ;,s uf I.ills prullaLlon ;-;hall bt:o borne solely l1y Hespondent. in~.L-~!dlniJ costs ussoclah~d w i L11 i nd e µe11dt:\l1 I: rev hiw.

C. HP.,:1(mdent 1 s profesf..lonal activ:itles ~1,c:1.ll. be revle\..-ed l>y dll lndepe;,dent.. 1r,Lernal !1tl1d?.r:ine phy:,lc1iin seJe,:\:ed by d<:Jre~111e:,c.. ot L11c~ pau:Jes . l 'he indepc•r1du11t pllysici crn shuii , vJew quarterly nesponde .,-,t•s pro ­fessional al : livll1es, which may 1ncl.ude, ria,view of patient: charts tu del:er111111e appni~,rlr.d .eness of care pro-vided. ('l'lle e111phc:1sJs sllal.J be on pal.\ents• dlagnosas w.i.th conditien , : w!Jicl, fail wi .l:hi.11 t:lie area known as e11•1ir0nn1e11lal ,,10<.Hc..i.rw.j Tlw fJrsl review strn.ll . ti,:. 3l the e11d <1f l!ie LhJi:d monl:h of proha t I o n 1d . tt1 each revi.·::!\v up111ox 1111a1.e·1 y qua r terJ.·1 Lliereaft. , , :,i,,Le, time il nd pl acr1 t·o be d1:, te:rml11ed be:Lween tile in<iep :,mdent phys .1cic: .r. ,:!nd Renponclr.rnl:). '!'he inde::,endenl : pliyf..;jc i.a 11 sliall rep, , rt hi.s/her fi .ncljnt;s tu tl10 ciw.irperson c,f the I3oar-d or · cJ

member d e :;ign ,~ted ~,y Lhe ::: hi.'>.1;-i_ier!:mn, who shall m~i eL 4uarl:erly w1 Lh i<es ponclenL l:o •11 scu ~:;:s ::·a.id r:epor.t Lo delernt!ne compUan c e w.lth the ternt3 or th.ls Cc,nsl>nt Or·der and Stipu.l.atiun. ( Ir1 the event the parties ca:.1P-,~1: agr:ee on an independent physician, that p2rs0n sha.1.1 be designated l)y the IJcard chai q1erso!1.)

1'1' IS PUR'l'IIEr; OHDERe!D that any v iolatJon of the Public lleal th

Code by Respondent: ,11~,. ': · g sald prubalion s ha.1.1 lie dt '!e 111ed a vj .ola-

tion of pro.bat lon and ' iC .' st 1.tut:e gcounds f r ;:.: furtJ·,eL· d.i.scipllnary

acUon by Llie Doard.

LT 18 !i'UH1'illm URD8Rt!:D i.hal th ~.: timely f illng or the reportf;

reguirec! he r eln shaLI he ne,Jp '.,1idGn ·t 1 s n,sponsibil1ty , and the

failure l:o fJLe said n,ports wl.t11Jn the tJrne Umi.tal'ions prov5ded

IH:n-ui. n shall be deemed a vJolal:Jon of Ll1i,, onlP,.

1'1' IS l~lHl.'l'lmn Oi<Dt~Hlm Lllat: :.wld report::, :.,l,ali. te mulled to

the Board, c/o the l.'.omp~lancH Secl:io1,, Le<JaJ. Resource:; D.Jv .U;:ion,

i3ureau of OccupaLJorMl and ProfessJ01M.l l<eguluLion, Deparlmenl of

COllllllt":!(Ce, P.O. Box :J0018, Li:lllSllliJ, Ml 118909.

i'r · l!:i L•'UH't'lllm ll!l.DE!!mD tl1ul Count Ir of tl1c af:"or8sc1!d Com ­

plain:.: pc,rl:ainJng to vJolai:Jon[~ of S0 c tJL,ri 1622l(b)(ij :111~.t· 1:.8

and hereby are Q.!_Sl~L~SED.

IT lS VUHTIIEH OHDE!l.ED tltal: should nespondt;;n\- ,_, t ,;.lccite any te~ ·m

or cor.cl1 Uon set to:-t:h het :ein, the Buard may clei:erm.l111,, l.!1ot

Respondent ha::; v ,0Jr1teci 1.1n order- of the rioard arid pn.,ceed :;;u[ -

:c;:1a11L to 1980 /'.ACS, H :,3g_9fl), and Se e l.Inn 152; ~1(91 of 1:l1e Pul>I.Lc

Health Code.

IT IS FUR~~E!l. ORDERED that should Respondent v to l=1te a0v tBrrn

or condition set forth herein, c .,: fail to ,·c.Jmply \'1;, ·.•1 .:11;y or t! :e

provisions contained i.n the st.i.fJUlaU.un submitted 11en~wttn, tt: 1::

aoacd may determJne that Respondent hds vlolHtad an Order of the

Boa1:d and proceed pt1rsuant to 19UO AACS , H JJ8.98J, and secl.ior,

1622l(g) of the Puu.lir. Health Code.

1'1' IS PUHT!Hm CJl"<fJf!:l<l-:D tirnl In tlie ff·hmt Respo : ,dt.•11L violi.!tis·:..;

th~) te nns of this Ord<:ff U1e Bo,v d may r<:?cons .ider th~, ,1.1 :.:;cj ul J.na r y

cwt.ton tak~111 in l.110 pruHent: 111,:tLLor; furl11er, 1f such vl.0 1 ," 1·1.:>1,

corwlllutes 1.t11 Jndependenl vJoldi:iDn u-= t:he Pub.I.le J11.:1:1ltli ,·, 1 ~,

or tli8 rctles pro1111llgatarl pursuant- thei·etu, Lhe Hoard may \.ake

appcopdctle disclpl i1rnry c1clion. (The no.:ird's clrnlq:ierso11 ::,r

des1~1111~a slrnll. l,c1vc-i th, ~·1ght Lo determine If Hec:;i?OncJenl:'s con···

tinued p1:ofess.lonal acl1vJt.1es vlo.l.al.e the ten.is of tli.i.s Or,ec.)

l'l' JS l•'UH'l'l!E!R OIWlmE!D that th.ls Order s11alJ b13 1.;.!l'teclive on

the ddte sJyned by Lite Buc.1ru au ::;el; fut 1.h below.

,t-ftt._, . ::ilgned tllis __ )7 -- day of --- ;vl!'j ---·--·-· .1~95.

''TC:IUGAN GOi\RD Ui;> :,1:_:;r.•l('JNl~

... )-f&JUrtl~, f~ ~

.. ,y ·/!--·--- ·--·---·--_ _J -· - -

S'.1'; P~.!_~,~~ ON

~~J COME the respective parti~s who Stipulate an~ Agree as

frllows:

l. The following allegatJons of fact are true and constitute

violations of Section 16221(<'1) of Lh,:1 f'ubJi,; HoaJ.th Cod~i: t-.hat

Hespondent falled to mtllnl:::dn a suffjc1tJ1:tJ.y organizet] n~cord to

provJde adequal:e Jocumentat.inn for dicitJneis.is ar.d tn,dt:n•..Jnt p10-

vided to pc::Uents 1·;~;, ~l:3 rrn:t l::s nwned in U~E: AdminL,l.i:i:.d.ive

Complaint; and turt.11tn, i{~~:::;)onden': failed to obt.air, a suffi.:ient

·-5-

.Informed consent as to pati.ent HL, named :in UIL', li'.l.rst Amended

AdmJn1slrat 1ve Comp.laJnt, reqard1ng test-1.ng for blokJnesJology

studies.

~ Count. IL of ga\li Cnmplc1.inl , wl1\t.:h alleqe!J v.iolc:d:.l.or:s of

Se:iclion l622l.(l>)( .I) [.l.ncompelence] c,f tlv.;: Pub .Uc llcrn.11.11 Code

shall ~e DlSMIS8SD.

J. Respondent understands and i.nlends that by :;.iynlng th.is

Stipulation Re s pondent is walving the rtght pursuant Lo the Pub-

1 : Ilea _11 CodP, ti1e rules promu I.gated the rounder , and thr , /\drnin­

i s t .:ith, , Pr ,cL·' · i:! , .• Act of 1969, 1969 eA 306, as amended; MCL

24.201 et ~~g; MSt, 3.5GO(l01) ?_I:: ::>.~l, lo require the P<:)OpJ.e to

prov\:! tile charges set f o!-f:h i.n th• .~ ah :.resajd cump]a1.nt by prF.!se.n·­

tatton of evi.dence anu .leua! auti1or 1ty, and to ari:x .iar .,,.,lt.h an dt- ·

to t·ney 0nd such 'lil t ne s:s.:is as HEsponden t mny de:s .l re to pr ~:c;en t a

defens'-:i to said cl1an:;es before tl11~ uoard or its authorized repre­

sentative.

4. 1'he floar.d':., confer.ee .in this matter, Haro .id Sauer, M.D ..

may oartic1pale freely in any de l iberations of the Board regard­

acceptance o f this proposed consent order and stipulation,

a~~ may relate to the Doard any knowledge and views of the case

acct\; ired by ~ a Id conferee.

5. 'l'lle fo reuuJnq Con s eri I: t , n :ie r : s appi·ov13d by th<~ res pee:.. J ve

parties arm may be entered as U1e E' Li1c!}. Or-cler of llte Bo .3rd in

said cause,

-6-

6. '!'he foreuo l ng proposal Is cond l l: toned upon l ts acceptance

by the Board, Lhe parties expressly reserving the ri~ht Lo

further pr0ceedln<Js wJthout pre:judice should the Consent Order be

rejected.

state of ~·lj(~{U) ___ ) . )SS

County of J.:.Ul\'J U.f..!.K~-)

/\GHr:1w ·ro BY:

···--·.1~'.J;_!l_,_1.__.,,__'J.•: d,os...lL/LJ)J__-__ _ Pi'.lu I a G. Davey, M. D. Hespondent

- 'l/ 11, . . /I, \ On the .t.. day ol: . fl I , 1995, before mu, , Noti:iry Public in crnd for said county, appeared Paula G. D.:1vby, M. D., who, upon oath, slate;;; Uiat she ilc1s read t!ie fore9olnq Con­sent Order and Sl:lpttlatlu11, by i11~1· ::;ub~;crlbed, that •.:;he k1:m,s l:h~' contents tliereuf l:o be true, and thcit· the si,Jn.l.ng ol' sa111e J.s Iser

free act and deed.

KIMBERLY G. WELTY Notary Public, Llmgston County, Mldllgan

M Av1Jng In WaehwPaw County, Michigan Y ComrnJ,illon Ekjljrtill: Oeco111bar 4. 19116

I have reviewed and approved the foregoing document both as to form and substance.

Notary Pub.Lie, _ Cou:;ty State of My Cammi ss .ton expires ______ ·--··---

/~?1-?.a:Cthil-J } Max R. IIoff~~2-3T99T Attorney for Respondent

This is tile J ast and f Ina: J•cll.JP of a Consent Order and Stipu·­latlon in the matter uf Paula Davey, M.U., pend.lag before the Michigan Board of MelHcine ,1110 Cl.iilSisl:ing of seven (7) pages, this page Jncluch~d.

PIF95A~/davey.cs/csl

-7-