paul robbendutch health care inspectorate research & innovation department [email protected]...
TRANSCRIPT
Paul Robben Dutch Health Care Inspectorate Research & Innovation Department
Evaluation of supervision and the
Academic Collaborative Centre
Evaluation programme 2005-2011• Suicide notifications• Disciplinary court • Quality of reports • Inter-rater variability
Reflective and science practitioner • Professionalize inspectors, methods and instruments• Accountability
IGZ-effect chain
Measures and sanctions
Punitive sanctions
Report for (criminal) prosecution Prosecution by disciplinary law
Measures under administrative law
Order closure License withdrawal Seizure of stock Ministerial directive Administrative fine Cease and desist order
Corrective measures
Intensified supervision Naming and shaming Plan of action
Advice and stimulating measures (compliance assistance)
Circular letter Publications Making reports public Campaigns
Background
March 2011 Dutch Health Council – Towards evidence based supervision. Research into the effects of supervision by the Dutch Health Care Inspectorate.
Recommendations: • A culture of accountability in the Health Inspectorate• A long-term research programme • focus and mass (3 million euro’s for four years)• An Academic Collaborative Centre in which the Inspectorate
cooperates with external researchers
CQC | 23 April 20126
Academic Collaborative Centre
CQC | 23 April 20127
Academic Collaborative Centre
Health Care Inspectorate
iBMG
NIVEL
IQ-Healthcare
EMGO+
IQ-Healthcare - Scientific Institute for Quality of Healthcare, Radboud University Nijmegen Medical CentreNIVEL - Netherlands institute for health services research, Utrecht iBMG - Institute of Health Policy & Management, Erasmus University RotterdamEMGO+ - Institute for Health and Care Research, VU Medical Centre Amsterdam
CQC | 23 April 20128
Academic Collaborative Centre
Contribution to university education
IGZ: evidence based inspection
Academic partners: practice based
research
Contribution to
inspectorate staff
training
Practice based
research themes
Research of
inspection related themes
Strategies• Department Research and Innovation• University chair in evaluation of supervision • Knowledge transfer: colloquium (researchers and inspectors) • A joint research agenda• Participation of inspectors in the research
Research advisory committeeParticipation as junior researcherPhD research project
CQC | 23 April 20129
Academic Collaborative Centre
4 Major Research Themes 2012 - 20151. Supervision and individual complaints 2. Supervising quality and safety systems of health care
institutes 3. Supervision of health care networks4. Malfunctioning health care professionals
Additional themes in 2012•Supervision of clinical trials•Polypharmacy•The use of social media in supervision •Assessment frameworks for interventions
CQC | 23 April 201210
Academic Collaborative Centre