pathway analysis: projected cost, lifecycle energy use and ...inconsistent data, assumptions &...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Pathway Analysis: Projected Cost, Lifecycle Energy Use and ...Inconsistent data, assumptions & guidelines (C) • Insufficient suite of models and tools (D) Partners • Alliance Technical](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022053107/60744f75ae6a031b8e2748b7/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
NREL is a national laboratory of the U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy, operated by the Alliance for Sustainable Energy, LLC.
Pathway Analysis: Projected Cost, Lifecycle Energy Use and Emissions of Emerging Hydrogen Technologies
2015 U.S. DOE Hydrogen and Fuel Cells Program and Vehicle Technologies Office Annual Merit Review and Peer Evaluation Meeting
Washington, DCTodd Ramsden
June 9, 2015
This presentation does not contain any proprietary, confidential, or otherwise restricted information
SA-036
![Page 2: Pathway Analysis: Projected Cost, Lifecycle Energy Use and ...Inconsistent data, assumptions & guidelines (C) • Insufficient suite of models and tools (D) Partners • Alliance Technical](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022053107/60744f75ae6a031b8e2748b7/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
2
Overview
Timeline• Start: March 2014• Finish: September 2015• 70% Complete
Budget• Total Funding: $130K
• 100% DOE funded
• FY14 Funding: $40K• FY15 Funding: $90K
Barriers Addressed• Stove-piped/siloed analytical
capability (B) • Inconsistent data, assumptions
& guidelines (C)• Insufficient suite of models and
tools (D)
Partners• Alliance Technical Services• U.S. DRIVE Fuel Pathway
Integration Technical Team (FPITT)• Sandia National Laboratory (SNL)
Note: Timeline/completion address only the present pathway analysis; future funding of additional pathway analyses not yet established
Note: Budget addresses only the emerging-technologies pathway analysis; completed future- and current-technologies analyses funded at $310K during FY12-14
![Page 3: Pathway Analysis: Projected Cost, Lifecycle Energy Use and ...Inconsistent data, assumptions & guidelines (C) • Insufficient suite of models and tools (D) Partners • Alliance Technical](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022053107/60744f75ae6a031b8e2748b7/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
3
Project Objectives and RelevanceHydrogen Pathways Analysis Project Objectives
Lifecycle evaluation of complete H2 production, delivery & dispensing pathways
• Determine cost, energy use, and greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions of H2fuel pathways, deployed in a mature market
• Provide detailed reporting of hydrogen cost and capital costs of complete H2 fuel pathways to support fuel cell electric vehicles (FCEVs)
• Lifecycle reporting of energy & feedstock usage and GHG emissions
Relevance
RelevanceEvaluate the potential of various hydrogen fuel pathways
• Evaluate the potential of various hydrogen production, delivery, and dispensing configurations to meet DOE’s $4/kg cost target
• Evaluate pathways to understand associated energy use and GHG emissions
Consistent and transparent analysis of hydrogen technologies
• Common modeling platform and assumptions with detailed reporting ofinput parameters and results allows for cross-pathway comparisons
• Helps DOE overcome stove-piped analysis and inconsistent data by providing a modeling framework using published DOE component models
Assist in R&D decisions • Helps assist DOE’s Fuel Cell Technology Office (FCTO) in goal setting and R&D decisions by providing detailed understanding of technologies
• In-depth analysis of pathways provides insight into cost drivers
Industry review and model improvement
• Industry review of input parameters and results helps validate and improve the MSM and the associated component models
• In-depth reviews help determine modeling gaps, inconsistencies & concerns
![Page 4: Pathway Analysis: Projected Cost, Lifecycle Energy Use and ...Inconsistent data, assumptions & guidelines (C) • Insufficient suite of models and tools (D) Partners • Alliance Technical](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022053107/60744f75ae6a031b8e2748b7/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
4
Project Overview
Analysis Framework
• Macro System Model• Design parameters from
the H2 Delivery Scenario Analysis Model (HDSAM) & H2 Prod. Analysis model (H2A)
• GREET (GHG, Regulated Emissions & Energy in Transportation) data
• Annual Energy Outlook (AEO) 2009 energy & feedstock data
• H2 Analysis Resource Center (HyARC) data
Models & Tools
• Macro-System Model (MSM)
• H2A Production• HDSAM• GREET 1 fuel cycle• GREET 2 vehicle
cycle• Vehicle Cost Per
Mile tool
Studies & Analysis
Cost, Energy Use & Emissions of H2Production & Delivery Pathways
• Hydrogen cost• Lifecycle energy &
emissions analysis• Lifecycle vehicle
cost
Outputs & Deliverables
• Pathway Reports• Pathway input &
output spreadsheets
Detailed understanding of H2 production & delivery pathways
System for documenting assumptions & data for well-to-wheels analysis of hydrogen pathways
National LabsNREL – MSM & H2A
Argonne – GREET/HDSAMSNL - MSM
CollaborationAlliance Technical
ServicesUS DRIVE FPITT
NREL, DOE Fuel Cell Technologies Office & US DRIVE Reviews
Lifecycle Energy Emission, & Cost Analysis of H2 Production, Delivery & Dispensing Pathways
Approach
![Page 5: Pathway Analysis: Projected Cost, Lifecycle Energy Use and ...Inconsistent data, assumptions & guidelines (C) • Insufficient suite of models and tools (D) Partners • Alliance Technical](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022053107/60744f75ae6a031b8e2748b7/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
5
Key Input Parameters & AssumptionsThe Macro-System Model (MSM) is being used to link H2A, HDSAM, GREET1,
GREET2, and the Cost-Per-Mile tool and as the I/O interface
Modeling Assumptions
• Future technologies for H2 production, delivery and dispensing
• Urban demand area, 1.25 million population (nominally Indianapolis)
• 15% FCEV penetration• Station size of 1000 kg/d
for delivered hydrogen• Station size of 1330 kg/d
for distributed hydrogen• 62 mi. delivery distance
Analysis Assumptions
• 2025 start-up year• Mature market assumed• 2007$ cost reporting• 40-year analysis period
for central production• 20-year analysis period
for distributed production
• Feedstock & utility costs from the 2009 annual energy outlook (AEO), reflect national averages
• Consider upstream energy
Vehicle Assumptions
• 2020 FCEV purchase• 15,000 miles/yr VMT;
160,000 mile lifetime• Mid-size FCEV modeled
(chassis comparable to conventional vehicle)
• 58 mpgge (miles per gallon gasoline equivalent) on-road fuel economy; sensitivity at 68 mpgge
• Vehicle cost with five-year ownership period
Approach
![Page 6: Pathway Analysis: Projected Cost, Lifecycle Energy Use and ...Inconsistent data, assumptions & guidelines (C) • Insufficient suite of models and tools (D) Partners • Alliance Technical](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022053107/60744f75ae6a031b8e2748b7/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
6
Pathways Analyzed in 2014/2015
Future technology pathways (analysis completed as of 2014 AMR)
Approach
8 future-technology production, delivery & dispensing pathways completed in FY2014; analysis of 4 emerging technology pathways in FY2015
Emerging technology pathways (results reported below)
[ CCS = Carbon capture and sequestration ]
![Page 7: Pathway Analysis: Projected Cost, Lifecycle Energy Use and ...Inconsistent data, assumptions & guidelines (C) • Insufficient suite of models and tools (D) Partners • Alliance Technical](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022053107/60744f75ae6a031b8e2748b7/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
7
Future Technologies Pathway Evaluation CompletedProgress
• Lifecycle cost, energy use and GHG emissions evaluation of 8 future-technology hydrogen production, delivery and dispensing pathways completed in FY 2014 (results presented at 2014 AMR)
• Future-technologies report completed (under review)
• Lifecycle cost energy use and GHG emissions evaluation of 10 current-technologies hydrogen pathways completed in FY 2013
Report on pathways evaluation of future technologies completed (under DOE review); Current technologies report published in 2014 (available on-line)
• Current pathways report published and available on-line at:
http://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy14osti/60528.pdf
![Page 8: Pathway Analysis: Projected Cost, Lifecycle Energy Use and ...Inconsistent data, assumptions & guidelines (C) • Insufficient suite of models and tools (D) Partners • Alliance Technical](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022053107/60744f75ae6a031b8e2748b7/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
k%
D,+R1)+13'<>'4/+#'K1+G*#+'d'!./3G2M/)'`'D1*,L1.&'A>>+98,&'293)/%
2:++$*3(-/9$'"*,(/#($-$+,"*,C3$%?*/'/,&(>53?@5&.(V*9.(67(%/.3.($W%$$9"*,(3?$(XSMH,(35+,$3T(#:+3?$+(J1<(".(*$$9$90($.>$%"5''&(#/+(+$*$@5G'$(>53?.(
!"#$$%%
!&#$$%%
!'#($%%
)*+,+-.+/+0.12/%3456+078%9%:7/.;764%+<%=2>7+?>%3$%.8%).@7/.87>%
)6+5?1A+8%
:7/.;764%B%CD:%
E+>>7>%
!"#$%&&
!$#""&&
!'#'$&&
()*+,-.&/-+0,-.&1-2&3)45,67*8&97+:&(-,;5*&(-<+0,)&=&>)?0)2+,-@5*&A&B).7C),D&54&
1-2)502&EDF,58)*&7*&G7<).7*)2&
G,5F0H@5*&
B).7C),D&-*F&(>B&
I522)2&
!"#$%&&!"#%%&&
!'#'(&&
)*+,-./&01/.-&23*-4153*465./&7%&8&9*/6:*-;&1<&=.>*1?>&7;@-1A*+&6+&B6C*/6+*>&
B-1@?5D1+&
9*/6:*-;&.+@&)09&
E1>>*>&
!"#$%&&
!'#((&&
!)#)%&&
*+,-./0&123-3450+6-.362+786/0&915*:&1.3;<6=3,&4&>+08?+.@&3A&B/C+3<C&&
D@;.3E+,&8,&18F+08,+C&
1.3;<6=3,&
>+08?+.@&/,;&*G>&
H3CC+C&
41)#."*'<>'!./3G2M/)'4/+#+%
!(/B.(,%W('%6c"%@MCC6L%%PJ5HUMZ:%%
[2+/+F3,3>/.+F>239&>(,L%%PU5fIMZ:%
6+,(.%D23.9+F>239&>(,L%%PH5iJMZ:%
[2+/+F-&+,+:&>(,L%%%Pd5JJMZ:%
!,R1*,)1'D1*,L1.&'")3'4CD'4/+#+%
PH5JJMZ:%
[.3,&9&)(.0%.3'B,/'%'2+@)%
![Page 9: Pathway Analysis: Projected Cost, Lifecycle Energy Use and ...Inconsistent data, assumptions & guidelines (C) • Insufficient suite of models and tools (D) Partners • Alliance Technical](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022053107/60744f75ae6a031b8e2748b7/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
d%
!"#""$$
!%#""$$
!&#""$$
!'#""$$
!(#""$$
!)"#""$$
!)%#""$$
!)&#""$$
!"#"$%"&'"()*+,-*,("
./0102)030%)453"&6(70%,-".70(8490-":)1/".)+,3)-,";,3)<,76"
=7,5$(0:-"0>"&6(70%,-"?,<,3)@,("A0*1*"
?0**,*"
B1590-"C-,7%6"
B1590-"D1/,7"DEF"
B1590-"A5+)153"G";)*+,-*,7"E"H44,**07),*"
B1590-"A5+)153"G"?0:".7,**87,"B1075%,"
B1590-"A5+)153"G"A5*45(,"B1075%,"
B1590-"A5+)153"G"A0I+7,**07"
"""""J5*,08*"K,>8,3)-%"B1590-"
"""""J,030%)4"B1075%,"
""""";)*17)2890-".)+,3)-,"
"""""L75-*I)**)0-".)+,3)-,"
"""""A,-1753"A0I+7,**07"
;,3)<,76"C-,7%6#M8,3""
;,3)<,76"D1/,7"DEF""
;,3)<,76"A5+)153"
;,3)<,76"
.70(8490-"M,,(*104$"
.70(8490-"D1/,7"DEF""
.5((3,:/,,3"F)N,7*"
H3%5,".0-(*"
=535-4,"0>".35-1"
.)+,*O".8I+*O"5-("P53<,*"
A0I+7,**07"5-(".BH"
.70(8490-"A5+)153""
.70(8490-"
D,+R1)+13'<>'4/+#'K1+G*#+'d'V.1"b3/%)''A>>+98,&'293)/%
<$35"'$9(67(%/.3(G+$5H9/@*(>+/="9$.("*.",?3(3/(-5Y/+(%/.3.Z(8?/3/CG"/'/,"%5'(%/.3(9+"=$+.("*%':9$[(X7MH,(#/+(5',5'(>/*9.0(\XSMH,(N1B0(XKZORH,(>">$'"*$.(
!$/#/[S,/*/9,2"*'<>'%\R,R1*,)1'31*,L1.&'+$/%)'"+'1e";R*1'
[.3,&9&)(.0%.3'B,/'%'2+@)%
![Page 10: Pathway Analysis: Projected Cost, Lifecycle Energy Use and ...Inconsistent data, assumptions & guidelines (C) • Insufficient suite of models and tools (D) Partners • Alliance Technical](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022053107/60744f75ae6a031b8e2748b7/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
QG%
!"#""$$
!%#""$$
!&#""$$
!'#""$$
!(#""$$
!)#""$$
!*#""$$
!+#""$$
!,#""$$
!"#"$%"&'"()*+,-*,("
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
D,+R1)+13'<>'4/+#'K1+G*#+'d'V.1"b3/%)''A>>+98,&'293)/%
<$35"'$9(67(%/.3(G+$5H9/@*(/#(./'5+C3?$+-/%?$-"%5'(>53?Z(2/.3(9+"=$+.("*%':9$[(XKZ]RMH,(#/+(?$'"/.353.0(XKZORH,(>">$'"*$.(
C=4<'R./3G2M/)'%\R,R1*,)1'31*,L1.&'+$/%)'"+'1e";R*1'
[.3,&9&)(.0%.3'B,/'%'2+@)%
C/*".[#$1.;/2$1;,2"*'<>'R./3G2M/)'%,#$'R,R1*,)1'31*,L1.&'d'V.1"b3/%)'/7'<>'*1L1*,c13'2/+#+'
![Page 11: Pathway Analysis: Projected Cost, Lifecycle Energy Use and ...Inconsistent data, assumptions & guidelines (C) • Insufficient suite of models and tools (D) Partners • Alliance Technical](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022053107/60744f75ae6a031b8e2748b7/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
11
Total Cost Per Mile Results – Vehicle & FuelAccomplishment
H2 fuel costs represent 15-25% of ownership costs for emerging technologies;FCEV depreciation & financing represent ~50% or more of costs
Similar results available for Photo-Electrochemical & Solar Thermo-Chemical H2 pathways
Photo-biological H2 production, with pipeline delivery
Natural Gas SMR w/CCS, with pipeline delivery
Hydrogen Fuel Cost: $0.10/mileTotal Ownership Cost: $0.72/milePreliminary results shown
Hydrogen Fuel Cost: $0.22/mileTotal Ownership Cost: $0.84/mile
![Page 12: Pathway Analysis: Projected Cost, Lifecycle Energy Use and ...Inconsistent data, assumptions & guidelines (C) • Insufficient suite of models and tools (D) Partners • Alliance Technical](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022053107/60744f75ae6a031b8e2748b7/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
QJ%
N1**[#/[N$11*+'8)1.9&'K1+G*#+'A>>+98,&'293)/%
!/@(>+/9:%;/*($*$+,&(#/+(+$*$@5G'$(>53?@5&.(E./-$(,+"9($'$%3+"%"3&(:.$9F((
@0/0:<*&*)#6:$#&<;<0:<B:)&1"*&@DE&>F!!@&.&@":<*&C=)*/"A7=)/07<:&&23&?<$=><,#&
N1**[#/[N$11*+'=/#"*'8)1.9&'
])/#',)2*G3,)9'.1)1%"S*1'R./3G2M/)'7113+#/2b+^%
!(/B.(,%W('%6c"%@MCC6L%%%
JJf;GGG%OD4M::3%%
[2+/+F3,3>/.+F>239&>(,L%%fJ;GGG%OD4M::3%%
6+,(.%D23.9+F>239&>(,L%%%
Hf;GGG%OD4M::3%%
[2+/+F-&+,+:&>(,L%%%iJ;GGG%OD4M::3%%
!"
#!$!!!"
%!$!!!"
&!$!!!"
'!$!!!"
()*+,-.+.,/"0-123+415"6"7*).8*-/"
9/2-1:*5"0-123+415"
0.;*).5*"<-=5>;1-,"
?1-*+13-,"@,1-=:*"6"7.>;*5>.5:""
A,3BCC("
D<D"(5*-:/"E5;3,"F0G1,1H.1)1:.+=)"9%""I.,G"0.;*).5*"9%"7*).8*-/J"!$/#/[V,/*/9,2"*'<&3./91)'%,#$'!,R1*,)1'D1*,L1.&'
!"#$!!!"%!$!!!"%#$!!!"&!$!!!"&#$!!!"'!$!!!"'#$!!!"
()*+,-.+.,/"0-123+415"6"7*).8*-/"
9/2-1:*5"0-123+415"
0.;*).5*"<-=5>;1-,"
?1-*+13-,"@,1-=:*"6"7.>;*5>.5:""
A,3BCC("
D<D"(5*-:/"E5;3,"F0G1,1*)*+,-1+G*H.+=)"9&""I.,G"0.;*).5*"9&"7*).8*-/J"!$/#/[8*12#./2$1;,2"*'<&3./91)'%,#$'!,R1*,)1'D1*,L1.&'
[.3,&9&)(.0%.3'B,/'%'2+@)%
[.3,&9&)(.0%.3'B,/'%'2+@)%
b)&*(,%.3'B,/'%-('3?%+)%8(/2@(0%3,3>/.&>&/0;%)(/B.(,%:(';%()?%83/.+,3B9%3)3.:0%B'3%e%!+%'83>&E>%W"##D%>('3'%
![Page 13: Pathway Analysis: Projected Cost, Lifecycle Energy Use and ...Inconsistent data, assumptions & guidelines (C) • Insufficient suite of models and tools (D) Partners • Alliance Technical](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022053107/60744f75ae6a031b8e2748b7/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
13
![Page 14: Pathway Analysis: Projected Cost, Lifecycle Energy Use and ...Inconsistent data, assumptions & guidelines (C) • Insufficient suite of models and tools (D) Partners • Alliance Technical](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022053107/60744f75ae6a031b8e2748b7/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
14
![Page 15: Pathway Analysis: Projected Cost, Lifecycle Energy Use and ...Inconsistent data, assumptions & guidelines (C) • Insufficient suite of models and tools (D) Partners • Alliance Technical](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022053107/60744f75ae6a031b8e2748b7/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Qf%
4/;R"."ML1'K1+G*#+'d'<>'4/+#'V.1"b3/%)'A>>+98,&'293)/%
C+9-&)3?%C67%()?%?3,&\3.0%>+'/'%.39(&)%(%>2(,,3):3'
)-$+,"*,0('/@$+(%5+G/*(67(>53?@5&.(?5=$(%/.3.(?",?$+(3?5*(XSMH,(35+,$3(
$0.00
$2.00
$4.00
$6.00
$8.00
$10.00
$12.00
$14.00
!"#$%"&'$()*+,$'%,-*.,#*/(01%2"34*
5(3$%,-*+,$'%,-*.,#*/(01%2"34*6"7(-"3(#*
5(3$%,-*8-(9$%1-:#"#*
;<"3)*.(3(%,=13>*6"7(-"3(#*
5(3$%,-*+,$'%,-*.,#*/(01%2"34*?"$@*55A*6"7(-"3(#*
5(3$%,-*6@1$1B8-(9$%1B*
5@(2"9,-*;C:7(*D>*6"7(-"3(#*
5(3$%,-*6@1$1B*
E"1-14"9,-*6%1)'9=13*6"7(-"3(#*
5(3$%,-*A1-,%BC@(%21B*
5@(2"9,-*;F(%%"$(>*6"7(-"3(#*
Leve
lized
Cos
t ($/
kg)
!"#7(3#()*G:)%14(3*51#$*
5A!*A@,%(*
6,$@?,:*H1##(#*A@,%(*
!(-"I(%:*A@,%(*
6%1)'9=13*A@,%(*
[.3,&9&)(.0%.3'B,/'%'2+@)%
![Page 16: Pathway Analysis: Projected Cost, Lifecycle Energy Use and ...Inconsistent data, assumptions & guidelines (C) • Insufficient suite of models and tools (D) Partners • Alliance Technical](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022053107/60744f75ae6a031b8e2748b7/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
QI%
!"#
!$#
!%#
!&#
!'#
!("#
!($#
!"#$%"&'$()*+,$'%,-*.,#*/(01%2"34*
5(3$%,-*+,$'%,-*.,#*/(01%2"34*6"7(-"3(#*
5(3$%,-*8-(9$%1-:#"#*
;<"3)*.(3(%,=13>*
5(3$%,-*+,$'%,-*.,#*/(01%2"34*?"$@*55A*
5(3$%,-*6@1$1B8-(9$%1B*
5@(2"9,-*;C:7(*D>*
5(3$%,-*6@1$1B*
E"1-14"9,-*6%1)'9=13*
5(3$%,-*A1-,%BC@(%21B*
5@(2"9,-*;F(%%"$(>*
6%1)
'9=13
*G(H
(-"I()
*51#
$#*;J
*K*L4>
*
6%1)'9=13M*NOP*G(H(-"I()*51#$*6%1)'9=13M*5,7"$,-*G(H(-"I()*51#$*6%1)'9=13M*F(()#$19L*G(H(-"I()*51#$*
4/;R"."ML1'K1+G*#+'d'<>'!./3G2M/)'4/+#'A>>+98,&'293)/%
J$*$@5G'$($-$+,"*,(67(>+/9:%;/*(%/.3.(9+"=$*(G&(%5>"35'(5*9(VW$9(N1B(%/.3.(
[.3,&9&)(.0%.3'B,/'%'2+@)%
![Page 17: Pathway Analysis: Projected Cost, Lifecycle Energy Use and ...Inconsistent data, assumptions & guidelines (C) • Insufficient suite of models and tools (D) Partners • Alliance Technical](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022053107/60744f75ae6a031b8e2748b7/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Qi%
PH;JGG%M?(&,0%Z:%
>(8&/(,%>+'/%93()'%
PH5Jc%1+.%(%QGGG%Z:M?%'/(*+)%
!"#
!$%"""#
!&%"""#
!'%"""#
!(%"""#
!)"%"""#
!)$%"""#
!)&%"""#
!)'%"""#
!)(%"""#
!"#$%"&'$()*+,$'%,-*.,#*/(01%2"34*
5(3$%,-*+,$'%,-*.,#*/(01%2"34*6"7(-"3(#*
5(3$%,-*8-(9$%1-:#"#*;<"3)*
.(3(%,=13>*6"7(-"3(#*
5(3$%,-*+,$'%,-*.,#*/(01%2"34*?"$@*55A*6"7(-"3(#*
5(3$%,-*6@1$1B8-(9$%1B*5@(2"9,-*;C:7(*D>*6"7(-"3(#*
5(3$%,-*6@1$1B*
E"1-14"9,-*6%1)'9=13*6"7(-"3(#*
5(3$%,-*A1-,%BC@(%21B*5@(2"9,-*;F(%%"$(>*6"7(-"3(#*
5,7"$,-*51#$*;G*H*),"-:*I4>*
!"#7(3#"34*5,7"$,-*51#$*
!(-"J(%:*5,7"$,-*51#$*
6%1)'9=13*5,7"$,-*51#$*
4/;R"."ML1'K1+G*#+'d'4"R,#"*'4/+#'A>>+98,&'293)/%
)-$+,"*,0(+$*$@5G'$(>53?@5&.(+$`:"+$(.:G.35*;5'(%5>"35'("*=$.3-$*3(G5.$9(/*(%:++$*3('$=$'(/#(3$%?*/'/,&(9$=$'/>-$*3T(-/+$(J1<(".(*$$9$9(
[.3,&9&)(.0%.3'B,/'%'2+@)%
![Page 18: Pathway Analysis: Projected Cost, Lifecycle Energy Use and ...Inconsistent data, assumptions & guidelines (C) • Insufficient suite of models and tools (D) Partners • Alliance Technical](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022053107/60744f75ae6a031b8e2748b7/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
18
Challenges and Barriers
• Cost and lifecycle analysis based on publicly available H2A and HDSAM models, but specific cases for the emerging renewable production pathways are not available in GREET• Preliminary modeling of upstream energy and GHG emissions
conducted, with results based on production electricity usage and GREET factors for these energy types
• Preliminary GHG results for emerging renewable paths shared with DOE and U.S. DRIVE/FPITT
• Recommendation made that Argonne National Lab be funded to develop specific cases for the emerging renewable pathways• Lifecycle assessment of GHG emissions will be revised based on new
GREET cases, once developed
Energy use and GHG emission results are preliminary: No GREET cases.Preliminary GHG results discussed with DOE and U.S. DRIVE
Progress
![Page 19: Pathway Analysis: Projected Cost, Lifecycle Energy Use and ...Inconsistent data, assumptions & guidelines (C) • Insufficient suite of models and tools (D) Partners • Alliance Technical](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022053107/60744f75ae6a031b8e2748b7/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
19
Model Gaps and Concerns Raised
Industry comments on modeling of emerging production technologies:• Contingency costs may be under-estimated considering the low
technology-readiness levels (TRL) of renewable processes analyzed• Need better understanding of the processes modeled and comparison to
similar fuel production processes • e.g., algal processes for non-H2 fuel production
• Total electricity usage and/or necessary grid electricity may be under-estimated (solar-only electricity may be inadequate)
• Land usage may be an important consideration for renewable paths• Overall solar-to-hydrogen efficiency of the process will impact both capital cost and
total land usage requirements
• CCS costs may be underestimated (DOE expected to fund CCS cost review)• Specific cases for the emerging renewable production pathways are not
currently available in GREET
Industry reviewers would like a better understanding of the processes involved for emerging renewable hydrogen production
![Page 20: Pathway Analysis: Projected Cost, Lifecycle Energy Use and ...Inconsistent data, assumptions & guidelines (C) • Insufficient suite of models and tools (D) Partners • Alliance Technical](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022053107/60744f75ae6a031b8e2748b7/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
20
Collaborations & Technology Transfer
Pathway Analysis Collaborators
• U.S. DRIVE Fuel Pathway Integration Technical Team (FPITT)• Review of key assumptions, modeling parameters, analysis
inputs and results• Alliance Technical Services
Core Model Developers (fundedseparately by DOE)
• GREET: Argonne National Laboratory• H2A Production model: NREL• H2A Production case studies: NREL• HDSAM Delivery model: Argonne National Laboratory• MSM: NREL and Sandia National Laboratory• Cost Per Mile tool: Alliance Technical Services
Tech Transfer • Not applicable (analysis activity based on publicly available models, with results made public when finalized)
Collaborations and Acknowledgements:
Technology Transfer Activities:
![Page 21: Pathway Analysis: Projected Cost, Lifecycle Energy Use and ...Inconsistent data, assumptions & guidelines (C) • Insufficient suite of models and tools (D) Partners • Alliance Technical](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022053107/60744f75ae6a031b8e2748b7/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
JQ%
a1e#'C#1R+'")3'FG#G.1'N/.b'ST%JGQf%A>*\&*3'L%•! r+&)/%S[bDD%()?%X0?.+:3)%[.+?B>*+)%D3>2%D3(9%933*):%/+%?&'>B''%393.:&):%XJ%8.+?B>*+)%/3>2)+,+:&3'%()?%8.+>3''3';%9+?3,&):%:(8'%()?%>+)>3.)';%()?%8+/3)*(,%B8?(/3'%/+%/23%393.:&):F/3>2)+,+:&3'%()(,0'&'%
•! C+)?B>/%&)&*(,%()(,0'3'%+1%393.:&):%20?.+:3)%?3,&\3.0%()?%+)F-+(.?%'/+.(:3%/3>2)+,+:&3';%8+/3)*(,,0%&)>,B?&):L%
•! X&:2F8.3''B.3%:('%/.B>Z%?3,&\3.0;%fGG%-(.%?&'83)'&):;%>+,?F%()?%>.0+F>+98.3''3?%+)F-+(.?%'/+.(:3;%'+.-3)/F-('3?%'/+.(:3%'0'/39'%
[+/3)*(,%SB/B.3%s+.Z%V16(50(+&5)?)(5)($JL%•! C+98,3/3%393.:&):%8.+?B>*+)%8(/2@(0%()(,0'&'%-('3?%+)%)3@%W"##D%>('3'%1+.%82+/+F-&+,+:&>(,;%82+/+F3,3>/.+>239&>(,%()?%'+,(.%/23.9+F>239&>(,%XJ%
•! C+98,3/3%3\(,B(*+)%+1%393.:&):%?3,&\3.0%()?%'/+.(:3%/3>2)+,+:&3'%•! C+)?B>/%(''3''93)/'%+1%(??&*+)(,%>B..3)/,0%(\(&,(-,3%/3>2)+,+:&3'%'B>2%('%-&+F93/2()3%6c"%()?%/.&F:3)3.(*+)%VXJ;%23(/;%[email protected]%KLDE++)#8"(M&
•! "3\&'3%STQH%>B..3)/F/3>2)+,+:&3'%8(/2@(0%3\(,B(*+)%-('3?%+)%)3@%?(/(%1.+9%.3>3)/%20?.+:3)%1B3,%&)1.('/.B>/B.3M&)'/(,,(*+)'%KLDE++)#8"(M&
SB/B.3%s+.Z%
![Page 22: Pathway Analysis: Projected Cost, Lifecycle Energy Use and ...Inconsistent data, assumptions & guidelines (C) • Insufficient suite of models and tools (D) Partners • Alliance Technical](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022053107/60744f75ae6a031b8e2748b7/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
22
Project Summary
Project Overview:• Lifecycle assessment of complete hydrogen production, delivery, and
dispensing pathways evaluating cost, energy use & GHG emissions• Assessment conducted with MSM (linking H2A, HDSAM, and GREET)• Evaluation of future-technology pathways completed in FY 2014• FY 2015 analysis focused on emerging-technology pathways: natural gas
reforming with CCS, photo-biological, photo-electrochemical and STCH• Preliminary GHG assessment of renewable paths shared only with DOE & FPITT
Emerging-Technology Pathways:• Current modeling of emerging-technology pathways finds hydrogen costs
exceeding the $4/kg target; further R&D is needed, especially for renewable paths
• H2 fuel costs represent 15-25% of ownership costs for emerging technologies; FCEV purchase costs represent ~50% or more of costs
• Renewable H2 production costs driven by capital and fixed O&M costs
![Page 23: Pathway Analysis: Projected Cost, Lifecycle Energy Use and ...Inconsistent data, assumptions & guidelines (C) • Insufficient suite of models and tools (D) Partners • Alliance Technical](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022053107/60744f75ae6a031b8e2748b7/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
23
THANKS!
Questions & Discussion
Current technologies report available at:http://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy14osti/60528.pdf
![Page 24: Pathway Analysis: Projected Cost, Lifecycle Energy Use and ...Inconsistent data, assumptions & guidelines (C) • Insufficient suite of models and tools (D) Partners • Alliance Technical](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022053107/60744f75ae6a031b8e2748b7/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
24
BACK-UP SLIDES
![Page 25: Pathway Analysis: Projected Cost, Lifecycle Energy Use and ...Inconsistent data, assumptions & guidelines (C) • Insufficient suite of models and tools (D) Partners • Alliance Technical](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022053107/60744f75ae6a031b8e2748b7/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
25
AcronymsAEO DOE Energy Information Agency’s Annual Energy OutlookCCS Carbon Capture and SequestrationCSD Compression, Storage & DispensingDOE U.S. Department of EnergyFCEV Fuel Cell Electric VehicleFCTO DOE’s Fuel Cell Technologies OfficeFPITT U.S. DRIVE Fuel Pathway Integration Technical TeamGHG Greenhouse GasGREET Greenhouse gas, Regulated Emissions & Energy in Transportation modelH2 HydrogenH2A DOE’s H2A (“hydrogen analysis”) Production modelHEV Hybrid Electric VehicleHDSAM DOE’s Hydrogen Delivery Scenario Analysis ModelHyARC Hydrogen Analysis Resource CenterMPGGE Miles per gallon gasoline equivalentNREL National Renewable Energy LaboratorySNL Sandia National LaboratoryU.S. DRIVE U.S. Driving Research and Innovation for Vehicle Efficiency PartnershipVMT Vehicle Miles TraveledWTW Well-to-Wheels (i.e., fuel-cycle)