part 2 - great lakes phragmites collaborative...seasonal prescriptions and risk – part 2 march 12,...

61
Phragmites and Prescribed Fire: Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan Department of Natural Resources The webinar is listen only. You can listen by phone or through your computer’s speakers.

Upload: others

Post on 07-Jul-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

Phragmites and Prescribed Fire: Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2

March 12, 2015

Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist,

Forest Resource Division, Michigan Department of Natural Resources

The webinar is listen only. You can listen by phone or through your computer’s speakers.

Page 2: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

Lee Osterland, Fire Management Specialist

Page 3: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

3

Can Phragmites, people and fire co-exist? Yes, BUT you better do your homework!

Page 4: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

4

At the last presentation I mentioned there are a few fuel and weather dynamics we’ve found that affect how readily Phragmites will burn, Let’s discuss these briefly: RH below 60% Wind speeds 10 mph or greater Clear sky conditions – sunny Stem moisture below 19% Try to burn Phragmites within a year after

being sprayed Altering fuel arrangement can aid you in

getting the job done To have a successful Phragmites

prescribed burn program you may need access to some specialized equipment

Take advantage of unusual weather patterns

Page 5: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

5

Check stem moisture with a moisture meter

Page 6: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

6

Text Text Text Text

Page 7: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

7

Burning within a short time after the spraying program allows you to take advantage of the fine fuels on the plant, ie. leaves, etc., which aids in the spread of the fire.

Page 8: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

8

Text here and here and here Text Text Text Text

Lets discuss some of these other points while reviewing some past prescribed burns we’ve conducted here in Michigan

Page 9: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

9

Conditions were ideal to conduct the prescribed burn on an island in Lake St. Clair in a very populated area

Page 10: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

10

Dickinson Isle. 012.mpg

Page 11: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

11

Smoke column as viewed from a “sky cam” which is located on the roof of the Renaissance Center in downtown Detroit: Public reaction was….ah….”interesting”

Page 12: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

12

Several hundred acre Phragmites prescribed burn that was conducted under “perfect” weather conditions. Too perfect!! Ash particulates dropped out of the smoke column 20+ miles away onto a populated area.

• Vent. Index • 20 Ft Winds • Transport Winds • Humidity • Sky Condition • Temperature

Page 13: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

13

Text Text Text

Historically, this is the way Phragmites prescribed burns have been conducted and there still is a place for this technique. Experience, and the need for a better way, have taught us there are various tactics that can be utilized to minimize smoke and heat output.

Page 14: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

14

Altering the fuel arrangement allows you to control the fire’s flame lengths, intensity and generally allow for a less complex prescribed burn. There are other benefits to this tactic as well and we’ll discuss those shortly.

Page 15: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

15

Manipulating Fuel

Arrangement

Page 16: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

16

Utilizing existing features for control lines is always a good practice, however they aren’t always in the most ideal locations.

Page 17: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

17

Page 18: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

18

Page 19: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

19

Page 20: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

20

Page 21: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

21

Page 22: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

22

What’s the big deal? Juuust Buuurn It Already!!

Page 23: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

23

Page 24: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

24

Page 25: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

25

7-11-12 Time: 0900 Fuel Moisture: 2% - 22% Temp. 85 R.H. 50% Wind W@ 5mph Clear Sky Precipitation: 2/100 previous night

Page 26: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

26

Page 27: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

27

Page 28: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

28

One side benefit of rolling Phragmites for burning is that the burned off stems, which make walking difficult or injure dogs pads,

are minimized.

Page 29: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

29

Page 30: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

30

By manipulating the Phragmites fuel loading on this prescribed burn we were able to successfully conduct operations adjacent to I-75

Page 31: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

31

Page 32: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

32

Let’s continue in shifting gears and explore other tactical options to burning Phragmites in populated areas

Page 33: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

33

The prescribed burn location was a river running through a very populated area. Originally the proposal was to potentially burn the entire island, but due to the proximity to high value areas that wasn’t feasible. What we did was use fire behavior and fuel moistures to guide us in developing a sound fire management plan.

Page 34: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

34

Remember the: “Do your homework” statement!!

Page 35: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

35

Page 36: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

36

Page 37: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

37

Page 38: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

38

Page 39: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

39

Page 40: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

40

Page 41: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

41

Page 42: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

42

What about equipment used? We’ve definitely learned a few things over the years and having the “right” tools to do the job is invaluable.

Page 43: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

43

Prescribed burn operations were routinely conducted over ice as this was the only way to “get the job done”. Thankfully, today there are more options for doing business which makes the job less complex and risky.

Page 44: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

44

Page 45: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

45

Conducting prescribed burns during the winter months challenges traditional equipment, clothing, and techniques

Page 46: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

46

Wheeled vehicles and soft ground conditions of a wetland environment aren’t always compatible!!

Page 47: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

47

Flare gun being utilized to ignite a remote patch of phragmites

Page 48: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

48

Conducting operations with specialized equipment demands additional training for some personnel and attention towards safety attributes at briefings

Page 49: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

49

Page 50: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

50

Page 51: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

51

Flamethrower operations being conducted. These are great tools to get an extremely high amount of heat into a small area to get ignition.

Page 52: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

52

Utilizing watercraft as a mode of transportation is effective, but adherence to personnel safety is a must and everyone wears a life jacket.

Page 53: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

53

Page 54: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

54

Page 55: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

55

Utilize weather “abnormalities” to conduct prescribed burn operations during periods that normally wouldn’t be conductive to burning

Page 56: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

56

Page 57: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

57

8-31-12 Fuel Moisture: 2% - 17% Temp. 104 R.H. 38% Wind: W @ 10mph Clear Sky Area was under drought conditions

Page 58: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

58

Meet objectives, utilize a variety of tactics and equipment

but above all, firefighter safety is foremost. Everyone should go home at the end of the day!

Page 59: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

Thank you! Questions? [email protected]

Page 60: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

Lee Osterland

Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan Department of Natural Resources

989-275-5151 ext. 2042

[email protected]

Page 61: Part 2 - Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative...Seasonal Prescriptions and Risk – Part 2 March 12, 2015 Lee Osterland- Fire Management Specialist, Forest Resource Division, Michigan

Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative:

greatlakesphragmites.net

[email protected]

GLPhragCollaborative (@GLPhrag)

Great Lakes Phragmites Collaborative

Lake States Fire Science Consortium:

lakestatesfiresci.net

[email protected]

LakeStatesFireSci (@LSFireScience)