paragas v. heirs of dominador balacano

2
PARAGAS v. HEIRS OF DOMINADOR BALACANO FACTS: Gregorio Balacano, married to Lorenza, owned 2 parcels of land. He was already 81 years old, very weak, could barely talk, and had been battling w/ liver disease for over a month. On his deathbed, barely a week before he died, he allegedly signed a Deed of Absolute Sale over the lots in favor of the Paragas Spouses, accompanied by Atty. De Guzman who proceeded to notarize the same, alleging that it was a mere confirmation of a previous sale and that Gregorio had already paid a P 50,000.00 deposit. The Paragas’ driver was also there to take a picture of Gregorio signing the said deed, w/ a ballpen in his hand. There was nothing to show that the contents of the deed were explained to Gregorio. Paragas then sold a portion of the disputed lot to Catalino. The grandson of Gregorio, Domingo, sought to annul the sale and partition. There was no sufficient e vidence to support any prior agreement or partial execution thereof. ISSUE: W/N Balacano is incapacitated to enter into a contract of sale HELD: A person is not rendered incompetent merely because of old age; however, when such age has impaired the mental faculties as to preve nt a person from protecting his rights, then he is undeniably incapacitated. He is clearly at a disadvantage, and the courts must be vigilant for his protection. In this case, Gregorio’s consent was clearly absent – hence the sale was null and void. The dubious circumstances raise serious doubts on his capacity to render consent. Considering that the Paragas Spouses are not owners of the said properties, it only follows that the subsequent sale thereof to Catalino  who was not in good faith  is likewise void. Further, the lots pertained to the conjugal partnership  having been inherited by Gregorio during his mar riage to Lorenza. It cannot thus be sold w/o the latter’s consent.

Upload: marion-nerisse-kho

Post on 10-Oct-2015

492 views

Category:

Documents


16 download

DESCRIPTION

Paragas v. Heirs of Dominador Balacano digest

TRANSCRIPT

PARAGAS v. HEIRS OF DOMINADOR BALACANOFACTS:Gregorio Balacano, married to Lorenza, owned 2 parcels of land. He was already 81 years old, very weak, could barely talk, and had been battling w/ liver disease for over a month. On his deathbed, barely a week before he died, he allegedly signed a Deed of Absolute Sale over the lots in favor of the Paragas Spouses, accompanied by Atty. De Guzman who proceeded to notarize the same, alleging that it was a mere confirmation of a previous sale and that Gregorio had already paid a P 50,000.00 deposit. The Paragas driver was also there to take a picture of Gregorio signing the said deed, w/ a ballpen in his hand. There was nothing to show that the contents of the deed were explained to Gregorio. Paragas then sold a portion of the disputed lot to Catalino. The grandson of Gregorio, Domingo, sought to annul the sale and partition. There was no sufficient evidence to support any prior agreement or partial execution thereof.

ISSUE:W/N Balacano is incapacitated to enter into a contract of sale

HELD:A person is not rendered incompetent merely because of old age; however, when such age has impaired the mental faculties as to prevent a person from protecting his rights, then he is undeniably incapacitated. He is clearly at a disadvantage, and the courts must be vigilant for his protection. In this case, Gregorios consent was clearly absent hence the sale was null and void. The dubious circumstances raise serious doubts on his capacity to render consent.

Considering that the Paragas Spouses are not owners of the said properties, it only follows that the subsequent sale thereof to Catalino who was not in good faith is likewise void. Further, the lots pertained to the conjugal partnership having been inherited by Gregorio during his marriage to Lorenza. It cannot thus be sold w/o the latters consent.