Other ‘truth tests’

AuthorityConsensusPragmatic

…and there are more

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criteria_of_truthhttp://www.brentcunningham.org/?p=584

What are we going to talk about today?

Knower(s)

Natural Sciences

Language

SensePerception

Emotion

Reason

Mathematics

Human Sciences

History

Arts

Ethics

Ways of Knowing

Areas of Knowledge

Theory of Knowledge Diagram

TaK - Perception

ToK Prescribed Essay Title: 2008

“When should we trust our senses to give us truth?”

Knower(s)

Natural Sciences

Language

SensePerception

Emotion Reason

Mathematics

Human Sciences

History

Arts

Ethics

Ways of Knowing

Areas of Knowledge

Theory of Knowledge Diagram

What role do the different senses playin the different Areas of Knowledge?

TaK - Perception

TaK - Perception

TaK - Perception

Empiricismstarting point for all knowledge is experience

Rationalismstarting point for all knowledge is reason

TaK - Perception

Sense Perception and Knowledge

Our senses connect us with the world around us …

… but how connected are we?

TaK - Perception

Cosmic RaysX Rays

UV LightInfra Red

RadarTV & Radio

Frequency (Hz)

Visual Window

1022 1020 1018 1016 1014 1012 1010 108 106 104 102 100

Our senses are limited: Light Waves

Common Buzzard

Can spot a meal (rodent) from 15,000ft (4,500m)

Fields - taken at 10,000ft

Brasilia - taken from 15,000ft

TaK - Perception

Highest Voice

Frequency (Hz)

Audio Window

1022 1020 1018 1016 1014 1012 1010 108 106 104 102 100

Lowest Voice

Our senses are limited: Sound Waves

McGurk Effect – Videohttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G-lN8vWm3m0

TaK - Perception

Bloodhound: “A nose with a dog attached”

• 230 million olfactory cells compared to 5 million in humans

• 1000 times better sense of smell than humans

• Have been known to be able to track a scent for over 100 miles

Our senses are limited: Smell

So perhaps we don’t see, hear, smell, taste and touch everything…

… but what we do sense, we sense accurately – don’t we?

TaK - Perception

What is in the mind and what is in the world?

TaK - Perception

TaK - Perception

Esref Armagan – born blind

TaK - Perception

Sensation which is provided by the world

Interpretation which is provided by the mind

(external stimuli + mental processes)

TaK - Perception

In our everyday life, we are not usually aware of our minds

interpreting the sensations that flood into our senses ....

Awareness test – Videohttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oSQJP40PcGI

TaK - Perception

TaK - Perception

“It’s not what you look at that matters, it’s what you see.”

H.D. Thoreau

Sensory Perception is selective: What the eye saw….

TaK - Perception

TaK - Perception

Sensory Perception is selective: What the camera saw….

TaK - Perception

Interpretation: Understanding what we see - Coherence

TaK - Perception

Interpretation

TaK - Perception

TaK - Perception

Interpretation – finding meaning in what we see

TaK - Perception

TaK - Perception

Expectation

TaK - Perception

What is this?

Organising Principles – the Law of Simplicity

TaK - Perception

TaK - Perception

What is this?

Imagination, Context,

Expectation andSense Perception

affect the way we interpret sense data

TaK - Perception

TaK - Perception

You are walking down a dark alley ... there are footsteps behind you …

TaK - Perception

Context

TaK - Perception

The mental construction of reality

TaK - Perception

TaK - Perception

TaK - Perception

TaK - Perception

TaK - Perception

“The eyes see only what the mind is prepared to

comprehend”Bergson

Who are you?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dgbs2ZP_qSk @52.21

TaK - Perception

“Who you are decides what you see”

TaK - Perception

Take the following and explain how education and training can affect what we perceive:

• A biologist looking down a microscope• A professional wine taster• A lifeguard• An artist

TaK - Perception

Think about the following and describe how they might be seen through the eyes of the

different people:

1. A child dying in poverty as seen by a doctor, an economist, a social worker, the child’s father

2. A sunset as seen by a religious figure, a physicist, a painter, a farmer

3. A tree as seen by a biologist, a logger, an environmentalist, a carpenter

TaK - Perception

Sense Perception is an important source of knowledge but there are reasons for treating it with caution:

TaK - Perception

• We may misinterpret what we perceive• We may fail to notice something• We may misremember what we have

perceived• Sensory perception is selective• Our senses have limitations• Experience creates expectations• Subjective factors – interests, moods –

affect sensory perception

TaK - Perception

Eye-witness testimony

TaK - Perception

TaK - Perception

TaK - Perception

Person Swap – Videohttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vBPG_OBgTWg

TaK - Perception

Some key points:

• Sense perception consists of Sensation and Interpretation

• If we accept that pain and taste are subjective, we might conclude that color and sound are also subjective

• Senses are an important source of knowledge but rather than passively reflect reality, they actively structure it

TaK - Perception

Some more key points:

• Sense perception is selective

• Sense perception has limitations

• Although sense perception cannot give us certainty, if the evidence of our senses is consistent with what reason and intuition tell us, it can still provide a good foundation for reliable knowledge

Some safeguards:

• Confirmation by another sense

• Coherence

• Independent testimony

ToK - Perception

TaK - Perception

Perception

LanguageHow does the

way we describe something affect the way we see

it?

ReligionWhat role does

perception play in religious

experience?

EthicsDo good people

see the world differently from bad people?

ArtsTo what extent do the arts help us to see the world with

new eyes?History

Should we trust eyewitness testimony?

Human Sciences

Does observation influence what is

observed?

MathsDoes perception play any role in Mathematics?

Natural Sciences

Do expectations influence

observations?

TaK - Perception

Some Knowledge Questions

• What factors affect our ability to gain knowledge through the senses?

• How do our senses hinder us in our attempts to gain knowledge?

• How is sensory perception affected by emotion/reason/faith/language?

• How do context and culture affect our perceptions?

• When you are told that ‘you should be more objective’ – what does that mean?

TaK - Perception

Extras

TaK - Perception

Common sense realism: the way we perceive the world mirrors the way the world is

Scientific realism: the world exists as an independent reality but it is different from the way we perceive it

Phenomenalism: it makes no sense to say that the world exists independent of our experience of it. “To be is to be perceived” (Are the chairs in the classroom when you aren’t there?)

See ‘Theory of Knowledge for the IB Diploma’ Richard van der Lagemaat, p 99-101

TaK - Perception

Think about physical sensation (Touch)….

• You plunge your hand into a bucket of hot water – is the pain in your hand, or in your mind?

• You plunge your hand into a bucket of ice cold water – for a moment you aren’t sure if it is hot or cold …

TaK - Perception