origins what is forensic - ram pages · pdf filepostmortem) material ... facial reconstruction...
TRANSCRIPT
9/23/2014
1
September 14Material copyright 2012 Durham
Material copyright 2012 Durham
FORENSIC ANTHROPOLOGYand ODONTOLOGY
Today we meet the –ologies!
Lyndsay S. Durham
AnthropologyStudy of Humans
Physical Anthropology‐Study Human Biology
Cultural Anthropology‐Study Social Behavior
Forensic AnthropologyApplying skeletal identification to matters
involving the public and the law.
September 14Material copyright 2012 Durham
Material copyright 2012 Durham
Anthropological Origins
Dr. Jeffries Wyman1849
Alphonse Bertillon1879
Mikhail Gerasimov1964
What is forensic anthropology?
•The study of human evolution, as revealed by the skeleton or by evolutionary patterns in DNA
•The use of osteology to assess age, sex, stature, ancestry, trauma or foul play and disease
Osteology (defined):
The scientific study of bones
Building a Biological ProfileSeptember 14Material copyright 2012 Durham
Material copyright 2012 Durham
AGE ASSESSMENT
Material copyright 2012 Durham
9/23/2014
2
September 14Material copyright 2012 Durham
Variation ‐ Age
September 14Material copyright 2012 Durham
Material copyright 2012 Durham
Newborn Juvenile
Variation ‐ Age
September 14Material copyright 2012 Durham
Material copyright 2012 Durham
September 14Material copyright 2012 Durham
Material copyright 2012 DurhamMaterial copyright 2012 Durham
Comparison of 5 yr. old and 60 yr. old
9/23/2014
3
Comparison of 5 yr. old and a fetus
September 14Material copyright 2012 Durham
Material copyright 2012 Durham
SEX ASSESSMENT
Material copyright 2012 Durham
September 14Material copyright 2012 Durham
Material copyright 2012 Durhamfemale male
male female
September 14Material copyright 2012 Durham
Material copyright 2012 Durham
Male & Female Pelvis
September 14Material copyright 2012 Durham
Material copyright 2012 Durham September 14Material copyright 2012 Durham
Material copyright 2012 Durham
9/23/2014
4
September 14Material copyright 2012 Durham
Material copyright 2012 Durham
RACE ASSESSMENT
Material copyright 2012 Durham September 14Material copyright 2012 Durham
Morphological Assessment
Asian White Black
Material copyright 2012 Durham
Asian Ancestry• Includes Native American,
Hispanic
• Round, short vault
• Rounder orbits
• Flared cheek bones, sunken in
• Wide inter‐orbital distances
• Narrow nasal aperture
• Edge‐on‐edge bite
European Ancestry
• Rounder cranial vault
• Taller forehead
• Oblong eye orbits
• Flatter cheekbones
• Narrow nasal aperture
• Pinched in nasal bones
African Ancestry
• Globular Skull
• Rounder Orbits
• Flat cheek bones
• Wider Inter‐orbital distance
• Wider nasal aperture
• Slightly protruding
upper jaw
Ancestry Estimation
African
Asian
European
African
9/23/2014
5
Ancestry Estimation
Asian
EuropeanAfrican
Identification
Gender
Stature
Ancestry
Age
Trauma (Antemortem, Perimortem, Postmortem)
Material copyright 2012 Durham
TRAUMA
Material copyright 2012 Durham September 14Material copyright 2012 Durham
Material copyright 2012 Durham
September 14Material copyright 2012 Durham
9/23/2014
6
September 14Material copyright 2012 Durham
Material copyright 2012 Durham
CULTURAL/PATHOLOGICALTERATIONS
Material copyright 2012 Durham
Dental AlterationsMastication changesTrade relatedChipping or grooves
SquattingKnees, toes, hips
Repetitive movements
Arthritis
Fractures
Infections/Tumors/Disorders
Material copyright 2012 Durham
September 14Material copyright 2012 Durham
Material copyright 2012 Durham
IDENTIFICATION
Material copyright 2012 Durham September 14Material copyright 2012 Durham
Material copyright 2012 DurhamMaterial copyright 2012 Durham
Individual Variations
September 14Material copyright 2012 Durham
Material copyright 2012 Durham
Facial Reconstruction
1. Markers to show depth are applied to the skull based on studies and data
2. Strips of clay are added according to depths to fill around markers
3. Features are rounded4. Lips are shaped based on data5. Smoothing, nose, cheeks,
brow bone, etc. are shaped based on data reflecting information consistent with members of the same ethnic groups
Issues: interpretationLeast accurate features: nasal bridge, ears
9/23/2014
7
September 14Material copyright 2012 Durham
Material copyright 2012 Durham
Three Types of Reconstruction
1. 2D• Collaboration between artist and anthropologist based on skull and
antemortem photographs• Placement of tissue depth markers at anthropologically significant
landmarks• Used when we don’t know the victim’s identity• Results in drawings on paper
• Edited and manipulated in computer program to create 2D facial approximations
2. 3D• Collaboration between artist, forensic anthropologist, and scanned
photographs of actual remains• Utilizes stock photos of facial features to generate model
• Used when we don’t know the victim’s identity• Results in clay or plaster sculpture
3. Superimposition• Requires knowledge of victim’s identity• Involves “lay over” of photo of individual and x‐ray of skull• Anatomical match can result in “match” of victim with bones
September 14Material copyright 2012 Durham
Material copyright 2012 Durham
Two Types of Reconstructive Identification
1. Circumstantial• Deceased individual’s skeletal
remains fit a biological profile2. Positive
• Actual identification of an individual’s remains
Applications• Historical figures• Facial recognition• Identification
September 14Material copyright 2012 Durham
Material copyright 2012 Durham
ODONTOLOGY
Material copyright 2012 Durham September 14Material copyright 2012 Durham
Material copyright 2012 Durham
What is forensic odontology?
• The study of the physiology, anatomy and pathology of teeth
• The application of methods and techniques of dental identification in forensics
• Use of teeth and bite marks for identification
September 14Material copyright 2012 Durham
Material copyright 2012 DurhamMaterial copyright 2012 Durham September 14Material copyright 2012 Durham
Why does it work?
• Teeth and bones are often resistant to:
– Fire
– Severe decomposition
– Exposure to the elements
• Dental records must be available for comparison
– This would be your EXEMPLAR
9/23/2014
8
September 14Material copyright 2012 Durham
Material copyright 2012 Durham
S
I
N
U
S
C
A
V
I
T
I
E
SSeptember 14Material copyright 2012 Durham
BITE MARK ANALYSIS
Material copyright 2012 Durham
September 14Material copyright 2012 Durham
Material copyright 2012 Durham Ted Bundy September 14Material copyright 2012 Durham
Material copyright 2012 Durham
September 14Material copyright 2012 Durham
Material copyright 2012 DurhamMaterial copyright 2012 Durham September 14Material copyright 2012 Durham
Material copyright 2012 Durham
9/23/2014
9
September 14Material copyright 2012 Durham
Material copyright 2012 Durham September 14Material copyright 2012 Durham
Material copyright 2012 Durham
Forensic Odontology
September 14Material copyright 2012 Durham
Material copyright 2012 Durham September 14Material copyright 2012 Durham
Material copyright 2012 Durham
The Body Farm