origin and development of pāramitā in theravāda buddhism.pdf
TRANSCRIPT
1
Origin and Development of Pāramitā in Theravāda Buddhism
By
Khemawati Bhikkhuni
An independent Study submittedin partial fulfillment of requirements for the Degree of Master of Arts at the International Buddhist Collage, Thailand.
(October) 2013
2
Declaration
I declare that this Independent Studies entitled Origin and development of Pāramitā-s in
Thervāda Buddhism and the research work has been done under the supervision of Professor
Tilak Kariyawasam, Dean of Graduate School and thereof represents my own work, except
where due acknowledgement is made, and that it has not been previously included in a thesis,
dissertation or report submitted to this University or to any other institution for a degree, diploma
or other qualifications.
Signed________________________________________________
Khemawati Bhikkhuni
Signed__________________________________________________
Professor Tilak Kariyawasam
3
Abstract
This Independent Study highlights the pragmatic and holistic aspects of Pāramitā has
been very much a point of a discussion when talk about the Concept of the Bodhisattva. The
Concept of the Bodhisattva also has been divided in to two when taken to consider two Buddhist
traditions: Theravāda and Mahāyāna. Some of the Western writers thought the Concept of the
Bodhisattva has been developed by Mahāyānists and they did not see Theravādin-s also have
developed it according to their point of view.After reading Pali Commentaries were so many
scholars realized Pāāāāli Commentaries have developed Pāramita-s along with the Concept of the
Bodhisattva. When they developed Pāramitā-s they developed the number of Pāramitā-s into ten
to include all the virtues qualities of the Bodhisattva. When they realized the attaining to the
Buddhahood is a matter with great difficulty they thought to increase the ten Pāramitā-s to thirty
with the degrees of intension of fulfilling. Further they wanted to give a meaning of difficult path
and any difficult matter to complete it is needed a long time, therefore length of fulfilling
Pāramita-s also have been extended to form the categories of Buddha’s who would be able to
fulfill certain amount of time also have been worked out by Theravadins. And they try to
develop further the benefit of Pāramita-s which could have achieved by the virtuous persons like
the Mother and the Father of the Buddha,Buddha’s Chief Attendant and the Son of the Buddha.
4
Acknowledgements
I completed this independence study for the submission to international Buddhist
College (IBC) in partial fulfillment of the requirement for the degree of Mater of Arts in
Buddhist studies.
First of all, I am deeply grateful to my thesis Supervisor, Prof. Tilak Kariyavasam, Dean
of graduate School of IBC. He has given me an invaluable Advice and gentle guidance on how
to proceed with the Topic. I would also like to record a note of thanks to Dr. Krishna Ghosh,
who advised me to write this independence study.
I also wish to express my thanks to the member of the Faculty Office of IBC for
providing me with the facility to carry out the present study, and also as take this opportunity to
express my sincere thanks to my friends and well- wishers who have been constantly giving
encouragement and care.
5
ABBREVIATION OF SCRIPTURE
A or AN : Anguttara-Nikaya
CP-A :Cariyapiţaka-Atthakatha
D or DN : Digha-Nikaya
DHP : Dhammapada
JA :Jataka
M or MN : Majjima-Niakaya
S or SN : Samyutta-Nikaya
VBH : Vibhanga
6
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Titles Page No
Abstract i
Acknowledgements ii
Abbreviations of Scriptures iii
1. Introduction 1
2. Origin of the Concept of Pāramitā 2
3. Criteria of Forming Perfections 2
4. The Development of Ten Pāramitā 5
5. Theravāda Pāramitā English Term Mahāyāna Pāramitā 6
5.1. Dāna Pāramita – Sasa Jātaka 9
5.2. Sỉla Pāramita -Samkhpāla Jātaka 10
5.3.Nekkamma Paramita-Culla-Sutasoma 10
5.4.Paññā Pāramitā- Ummagga Jātaka 11
5.5.Viriya Pāramita- Mahajanaka Jātaka 12
5.6.Khanti Pāramita- Khantivādi Jātaka 13
5.7.Sacc Pāramita – MahaSutasoma Jātaka 13
5.8.Adhitthana Pāramita – Mugapakkha Jātaka 14
5.9.Mettā Pāramita- Ekarāja Jātaka 15
5.10.Upekkhā Pāramita- Lomahamsa Jātaka 15
6.Pāramita-s in Cariyāpitaka and Atthakathās 16
7.Purpose and the Length of fulfilling Pāramitā 17
8. Conclusion
Bibliography
7
1. Introduction
In Buddhism Pāramitā becomes a major teaching to advance the spirituality to
attain to the highest position. According to the given meaning to the word Pāramitā, it
directly applies to the Bodhisattva in Theravāda Buddhism. The reason for directly
attaching the word ‘Pārami’ to the Bodhisattva is his determination to fulfill certain
qualities in himself to become a completely Enlightened One. The story mentioned in the
Buddhawamsa is the ascetic Sumedha met the Dipankara Buddha and had the
prediction (vyākaraņa) to declare that he will be the Buddha in future. Then the ascetic
Sumedha searched for the qualities to develop to become the Buddha (Buddha kāraka
Dhamma). Then he realized the ten perfections (Dasa Pāramitā) as necessary qualities
one has to develop to become a Buddha. This word Pāramitā indicates the mechanism of
the Bodhisattva’s ability to become a Buddha. His ability to fulfill each perfection to the
uppermost extent will lead him to the Buddhahood.
The word Pārami means ‘going to the end.’ Pāramitā means ‘has gone to the
end’. This word cannot trace in the early scriptures such as DN, MN, SN, AN. But we
come across this word Pāramitā in the later works Buddhawaṁsa and Cariyā. Those
works are belonged to Khuddakanikāya. Khuddakanikāya was recognized as later
compiled Nikāya. Therefore the word Pāramitā also recognized as a word used later
time. Later than the early scriptures of Pali Nikāya-s.If it is used in later time, that create
some problems with regard to the concept of Bodhisattva. That because of when we
mentioned the word Pāramitā, it directly applies to the concept of the Bodhisattva.
The Concept of the Bodhisattva is a part of the Biography of the Buddha.
Buddha’s biography is different from any other human being’s biography. Buddha’s
biography is the story of a long journey with very pure intention to become a Buddha to
help enormous beings in the world. According to Buddhist teachings every other being
8
also has a long journey in the Saṁsāra. In order to differentiate the journey of the human
being who aspires to become a Buddha the word “Bodhisattva” has introduced. In that
case the word Pāramitā also must have introduced much later time.
If the word Pāramita has introduced much later period then there will be some
problems to explain the Siddhārtha Gautama Buddha’s life in this world and his
intensions to become a Buddha. All these problems and possible answers given for those
problemsand will be discussed in this study. Then it will be much easier to find out the
proper answers for those matters to clarify the real story of Pāramitā-s.
2. Origin of the Concept of Pāramitā
We can think of the origins of the concept of Pāramitā-s in relation to the writing
of the biography of the Buddha. This writing the biography must have started during the
time of the Buddha, but at the last stage of the Buddha’s life. During the life time was the
collection of materials necessary to compile the Biography were searched. After the
Parinibbāna necessity of a biography was felt very hard way. Then the faithful Sāvaka-s
started to write the biography. This writing biography soon after the parinibbāna has
created a tradition in Theravāda Buddhism up to the present time. Even now days the
important first activity upon the death of a abbot of a Buddhist temple is a writing
biography. In that manner when the faithful disciples started to write the biography of the
Buddha soon after the Mahā Parinibbāna they compelled to write Bodhisattva’s certain
kind of behavior towards achieving the goal of Buddhahood. This kind of inspiration
emerged with certain kind of terms used with the connection of the Bharmā. Brahma
cariyaand Four Brahma Vihāra-s1 were the some words inspired Buddhist disciples to
search what kind of practice could have developed in to the life of the Bodhisattva. In the
Buddhavaṁsa this has been mentioned as Buddhakaredhamme (Buddha
1. prof. P. v. Barat. 2500 Years of Buddhism. Chapter. IV. p. 33
9
kārakadhamma)(Practices bringing about Buddhahood)2. In the Theravāda this
particular practice has been categorized with ten components.
3. Criteria of Forming Perfections
The aim of Bodhisattva practice is also cannot be different from the path of
Nibbāna. Path of Nibbāna is the path to end of suffering. This end of suffering should be
achieved through cultivation of one’s physical part and the mental part. That has been
shown in the Nikāya-sveryoften. In the Saṁyuttanikāyamentions “The intelligent person
having established in the morality (Sila) and cultivate mind (Citta) and improve wisdom
(Paññā), one such monk who is ardent in subduing the passions, disentangles the tangles
like klesa-s.” Here it is mentioned that one who cultivate Sila, Citta (Samadhi) and
Paññāis capable of eliminating klesa-s. This is the path one has to follow in order to
attain the enlightenment. These three has named as TividhaSikkhā, because one has to
cultivate these three in order to get release. When one fulfills these three he has followed
the Noble eight fold path3 (Ariyoaṁṁhaṁgikomaggo). Therefore Pāramitā-s also has
developed on the basis of three kinds of discipline- Sila, Samādhi and Paññā. These
three kinds of discipline serves for any individual to end of suffering through elimination
of klesa-s, but for the Bodhisattva it is not only end his own suffering but also to end the
suffering of many other beings around him. This altruistic attitude had to be addressed
properly with the cultivation of Bodhisattva career. The answer for this dilemma has
created the concept of Pāramitā.
Therefore Pāramitā-sare nothing but the Bodhisattva’s career towards the helping
other beings to fulfill their aspirations with whatever the aims would be. By doing so the
Bodhisattva automatically fulfills his aspirations towards becoming the Buddha. This is
2.Buddhavaṁsa. 3. Bhikkhu Bodhi, The all-embracing net of views, Kandy: Buddhist Society publication, Sec, 2007.p. 41.
10
the one action with double benefit. One example may comprehend this double benefit
easily.
The Bodhisattva practices Dāna Pāramita. The double benefit is The Bodhisattva
fulfills his practicing of Pāramitā when he is engaged in offering things to somebody.
Then the recipient also fulfills his aspiration of receiving what he wants. This is the
double benefit and this of course is a benefit the Buddha has expressed by observing
precepts. Buddha expressed “When one protects himself, protect others and when one
protect others protects himself”4. This double sided effect has been explained very often
in Early Buddhist Scriptures as well as used as a criteria to define what is wholesome
(Kusala) and what is unwholesome (Akusala).In the AmbalaṁṁhikāRāhulovādaSutta5
“If any action is harmful to himself and harmful to others, harmful to both sides, that
brings suffering, that brings results of suffering, therefore that action is unwholesome”6
“If any action, which is not harmful to himself, not harmful to others, not harmful
to both the sides, that action is wholesome”.7 On the basis of this theory wholesome
action and unwholesome action has been analyzed in Buddhism. Pāramitā-s also have
been built on the same ground. In short whole Buddhist moral background has been
designed on the same basis.
Therefore categorization of Pāramitā-s have done taking into consideration one’s
spiritual advancement and what kind of way the society will be influenced with his
spiritual advancement.Sila (Morality), Samādhi (Concentration) and Paññā (Wisdom)
these three kinds of discipline will not show very much the benefit to the society. In
order to clarify the Bodhisattva’s social relevance some of the Pāramitā-shavebeen
4.S.V. 169.Attānambhikkhaverakkhantoparaṁrakkhati.paraṁrakkhantoattānaṁrakkhati. 5.M. i.415-419 6.M.i.415, “attabyādhāya pi saṁvatteyyaparavyābādhāya pi saṁvatteyyaubhayavyābādhāyapi saṁvatteyyaakusalaṁidaṁ…..dukkhudrayaṁdukkhavipakaṁ”. 7.M.i.416 ,” n’ ev’attabyābādhāyasaṁvatteyyanaparavyābādhāyasaṁvatteyyanaubhayavyābādhāyasaṁvatteyya, akusalaṁidaṁ …..skhudrayaṁsukhavipākaṁ”.
11
introduced.DānaPāramitā, (Perfection of generosity), KhantiPāramitā (perfection of
Patience), Sacca Pāramitā, (perfection of Truthfulness) were the suchPāramitā-s
especially attached to the list of Pāramitā-s to show the Bodhisattva’s social relevance.
Generosity (Dāna) is very important as most of the people are selfish and not
ready to offer something to somebody free. The things are not readily available and
difficult to search things. Therefore offers are very important. Generosity trains towards
sacrificing. If someone has not trained to sacrifice he cannot practice Sila (Morality).
Morality needs a lot of sacrificing; exampleone may really like to engage in sexual
misconduct. If he does not engage in considering moral behavior that is the time he
sacrifices his wish. This is the way Dāna helps Sila.
Patience (Khanti) is very important for someone to live in the society.One has to
be patience to live with others. Live alone is also one has to be patience.Life is not as
easy as one has problems from the people around and from the situation as well as from
himself. In order to live, one has to bear up hunger and thirsty. Everybody has hopes and
wishes whichare not going to be fulfilled. At that time one needs to have patience. In this
manner patience is an important character for a pious one has to build up. Truthfulness
(Sacca)8 is essentially one has to have to live in the society with dignity. If one is not
truthful then he will be look down upon by others as well as truthful person will be
honored and respected.Therefore Bodhisattva has to develop this truthfulness to be
truthful for himself and others.These new components of s have been added to the list of
Pāramitā to form the Bodhisattva’s long patience to fulfill his aspiration.
8. Arunasiri. K. Encyclopaedia of Buddhism Volume- V. Government of SrilanlaPublising, 1971. P. 312.
12
4. The Development of Ten Pāramitā-s
It is not possible to reject some views with regard to the influence of other
Buddhist sects for the development of the Theravada Concept of Pāramitā. B. Keith9
mentioned the Mahayanists should be given full credit for the development of the
Bodhisattva ideal. E.J. Thomas10 mentioned that Theravada and Mahayana both were
influenced by early texts which do not exist anymore.
Keith’s view cannot accept because not only Mahayanists developed the
Bodhisattva Ideal but Theravadins also has developed the Bodhisattva ideal to the upper
most extent according to Theravada point of view. E.J.Thomas has not left Theravadins
to talk about the development of Bodhisattva ideal, but mentioned Theravada and
Mahayana both the traditions were influenced by some unknown texts existed earlier.
There is no evidence to prove that there have been some unknown texts earlier to
influence present development of Bodhisattva Ideal. But on the other hand these two
views give some insight into the development of the Bodhisattva ideal, Theravada and
Mahayana both must have been influenced each other in reciprocate way is the insight
we can gather through this argument.
We can have the picture of development of Theravāda Pāramitā-swhen compared it with
Mahāyāna Pāramitā-s. In Mahāyāna there are six Pāramitā-s mentioned in early
Mahāyāna scriptures11. These six Pāramitā-s are Dāna (Generosity), Šỉla (Morality),
Kṁānti (Patience) Vỉrya (Effort), Dhyāna (Meditation) and Prajñā (Wisdom). When
Mahāyānists have these six Pāramitā-s Thervādins have ten Pāramitā-s12. Those are
Dāna (Generosity), Sỉla (Morality), Nekkhamma (Renunciation), Paññā (Wisdom),
9.Keith.B, “Buddhist Philosophy” 10.Thomas.E.J. 11.AṁṁasāhasrikāPrajñāpāramitā, ed. 12.Buddhavaṁsa, RatanacaṁkramaņKāņṁa, 76 Gāthā, BuddhajayantiTripiṁaka Publication Series No.38.
13
Viriya (Effort), Khanti (Patience), Sacca (Truthfulness), Adhiṁṁhāna (Determination),
Mettā (Loving Kindness), and Upekkhā (Equanimity).
If these lists of Pāramitā-s in both the traditions display as a chart similarities and
difference can easily view to understand the possible influence of each other tradition to
develop these Pāramitā-s.
5. Theravāda Pāramitā English Term Mahāyāna Pāramitā
Dāna Generosity, Giving, Donating Dāna
Sỉla Morality, Good Character Šỉla
Nekkhamma Renunciation Nekkhamma
Paññā Wisdom Prajñā
Viriya Effort, Exertion Vỉrya
Khanti Patience, Forbearance Kṁānti
Sacca Truthfulness Sacca
Adhiṁṁhāna Determination, Decision, Resolution Adhiṁṁhāna
Mettā Loving Kindness, Amity Dhyāna
Upekkhā Equanimity, Indifference, Neutrality
This chart of Pāramitā-s in both the traditions clarifythe similarities of Pāramitā-
s.Here it can see one section hassix Pāramitā-s and the other section has ten Pāramitā-s.
What we can understand is this, whoever the tradition has ten, must have been the
developed forms of Pāramitā-s than that of the tradition whoever may have six
Pāramitā-s. If it is the case Mahāyāna list of Pāramitā-s would be the earliest than that
of Thervāda list. It also not logical to think as long as Mahāyāna tradition is a later
developed tradition those Pāramitā-s cannot accept as earlier than that of Theravāda. But
we have the records of how Mahāyānists have been influenced regarding the
development of Pāramitā-s.
14
Akira Hirakāwa writes13Sarvāstivādins declared four perfections as conventional
perfections andMahāvibhāsā maintained four and six Pāramitā-s. With this information
we can decide first Sarvāstivādins accepted For Pāramitā-s:-Dāna, Šỉla, Vỉrya and
Prajñā and Kṁānti and Dhyāna were added as necessary components of Šỉlaand Prajñā.
In that manner Sarvāstivādins incorporated six Pāramiā-swerein to the Biography of the
Buddha. Sarvastivadins were derived from Theravada. Therefore these six Pāramitā-s
must have influenced the Theravadins to develop to the ten Pāramiā-s. Normally
number 10 was the set number in a certain period for the categorization of any matters.
In Theravada Buddhism number ten is somewhat popular and most of the matters have
been grouped in ten numbers:-Dasa Dharma, DasaBala, DasaSenā, DasaSaññojana, and
the four main Scriptures divide into chapters with Vagga-s. Every vagga has ten suttas.
In this manner when Theravadins developed Pāramiā-s they grouped it as ten, Dasa
Pāramitā. Therefore when Theravādins developed these Pāramiā-stheywere influenced
not by Mahayanists, but by Sarvastivadins. Mahayanists also were influenced by
Sarvastivada view through Mahāsanghikas. These six Pāramiā-s category has been used
by Mahāsanghikas also. That shows even Mahāsanghika’s were also influenced by
Sarvāstivādins.
Bhattacharyya is on the opinion that “Whether the concept of the Bodhisattva and
thepracticeof six Pāramitā-s were introduced forthe first time by the Mahasanghika’s or
by the Sarvastivadins is uncertain.”14 It seems that he is confused with regard to the
nature of Mahasanghika’s. Though the Mahasanghikas originated much earlier to
Sarvastivadin’s, they composed their literature much later time. We can find about it
through “Mahāvastu”. Mahavastu belong to the ĀryaMahāsanghika group. That group
13. A. Hirakawa. History of Indian Buddhism (Delhi: Motilal, 1993).P.266, 299. 14.Bhattacharyya,N.N. Buddhism in the History of Indian Ideas, ManoharaPunlishes, New Delhi,1993. p.204.
15
also originated sometime later and Mahavastu talk about Four Caryās of the
Bodhisattvaindicating much developed form of Bodhisattva practice. Even
Bhattacharyya also admits the Mahasanghika-s developed nature of Bodhisattva practice
by explaining the four Caryās15.
If it is the development of Bodhisattva concept in Mahāsanghika’s that proves their
development is later than that of Sarvāstivadin’s. Then it is justifiable to think
Mahāyānists were influenced by the Sarvāstivāda through Mahāsanghikas to develop
Mahāyāna.
It is evident that the Theravadins developed these Pāramiā-s into ten looking at
the Jātaka stories and made it as rule for anyone who aspires to become a Buddha has to
fulfill these Pāramiā-s.When the Bodhisattva fulfills Pāramiā-seach Pāramiās has to
fulfill in three degrees:- Pārami (Ordinary way), UpaPārami (Better way), Paramattha
Pārami (Superior way). These three ways have been explained in the commentaries in
this manner. Take for example Dāna Pāramitā, Giving away one’s external possessions.
DānaUpa-pāramita, giving away one’s own limbs similar to blood, kidney, Eyes ect,
Paramattha Paramita, Giving away one’s life. When each Pāramiā fulfills in three
degrees at the end it will be thirty. Therefore it mentions the Bodhisattvahas to fulfill
thirty Paramiata-s16. Commentary of Jātakaand the Commentary of Buddhawaṁsa
mentions certain Jātaka stories to represent ten perfections.
Jātaka stories are supposed to be the previous birth stories of the Gotama
Bodhisattva and 547 birth stories are written in the Birth Story book called ‘Jātaka’.
There are a lot of controversies with regard to the stories contained in the Jātaka story
Book. Some of the births of the Bodhisattva as an animal such as Monkey, deer,
Elephant, Rabbit have been explained even in the animal forms the Bodhisattva has not
15.Ibid. P.205. 16.BuddhavaṁsaAṁṁhakathā
16
separated from the Dharma.Commentators have selected ten Jātaka stories to present the
Bodhisattva’s performance to fulfill the Pāramiā-s. The followings are the Jātaka
stories:-
1. Dâna Pâramitâ - Sasa JâtakaNo.316
2. Sila Paramiatâ- Samkhapâla JâtakaNo.524
3. NekkhammaPâramitâ - CûlaSutasoma JâtakaNo.525
4. Paññâ Pâramitâ- Ummagga Jâtaka No. 546
5. Viriya Pâramitâ- MahâJanaka JâtakaNo.539
6. Khanti Pâramitâ- Khntivâdi Jâtaka No.313
7. Sacca Pâramitâ- MahâSutasoma JâtakaNo. 537
8. AdhiṁṁhânaPâramitâ- Mugapakkha JâtakaNo.538
9. Mettâ Pâramitâ- Ekarâja Jâtaka No. 303
10. Upekkhâ Pâramitâ- Lomahaṁsa JâtakaNo. 94
Among these Jātaka stories only three Jātaka stories Sasa Jātaka, Ummagga Jātaka,
Khantivādi Jātaka are very popular among faithful listeners. Therefore reading the
summery of other jātaka stories will give the understanding the Bodhisattva’s effort to
fulfill the Pāramiā-s.
5. 1.Dāna Pāramita – Sasa Jātaka - Jātaka No.316
jātaka story related by the Buddha when he was at Jetavana. One landowner
offered for and other requisites to the Buddha and Sangha for seven days. At the end of
the seventh days The Buddha said to that landowner you are offering things to any
beggar in the same way probably you are ready to offer even your flesh also. Then the
landowner asked the Buddha to relate those stories. Then Buddha uttered the Sasa
Jātaka.
17
Once upon a time there were four animal friends in the wood. Hare had three
friends, monkey, Jackal and Otter. Hare used to advice other three friends during the
night of everyday. One day when the hare looked at the sky he notice tomorrow is the
uposatha day and advised to the friends “Tomorrow is the fasting day and you must
observe morals and be ready to offer for any beggar comes to you”.
Then the hare also having kept nearby him some grass bundles observing the fast
and stayed. Then the Sakka, the king of Devas saw what the hare was determined to do
and came to check the hare and asked for some food. Then hare said to lit up a fire.
When the beggar did that he jumped into the fire telling that when I am roasted you can
eat my flesh.
But the Sakka deva performed a miracle for not to get burned. The fire felt for the
hare as cooled. Then the hare asked why he was not burned and that felt like cool. Then
the Sakka mentioned who he was and said that came to check him. Then hare said in
time to come so many will come to check me. Then the Sakka said not that will happen
he will draw the picture of the hare on the moon to know the hare’s determination17.
This story was related at the time the land owner of Sravasthi made extensive
offerings to the Buddha and the Sangha for seven days. Ven. Ananada is identified with
the Otter, Moggallana with the Jackal and the Sariputta with the monkey.
This story is included in the Cariyāpiṁaka and in the Jātakamālā
5. 2. Sỉla Pāramita –Samkhpāla Jātaka – JātakaNo. 524
The Bodhisattva was born as Duyyodhana, the son of the king of Rājagaha.
When the Bodhisattva Duyyodhana came to the age the father king handed over the
Kingdom to him and became an ascetic. He lived sometime in the royal park and later
went to Himālaya and lived there. When he was in the Himālayas he was visited by
17. Cowell.E. B.The Jātaka or Stories of the Buddha’s former Births. At the University press. 1897. P. 34-37.
18
Nāga King Saṁkhapāla, to whom the ascetic preached the Dharma. Later Duyyodhana
discovered where was the father and visited him, and saw the Nāga king and impressed
by his magnificence, desired to visit the Nāga world. On his return to the capital he was
engaged in works of merits and after the death was born in the Nāga world and became
king in the name of Saṁkhapāla. Later he was weary of his magnificence came to the
near Kannpenna River, where the ascetic also was and fasting on an ant- hill there. Some
sixteen men roaming in the wood saw Saṁkhapāla and caught him and made holes on
his body droving stakes put ropes into those holes and draw him along. ButSaṁkhapāla
did not show any resentment over their harming to his body. But one land owner in
Mithila, called Ālāra saw him being ill treated had him released. Then the Saṁkhapālaa
invited the land owner to the Naga world. Ālāra lived therefore one year. When he came
back to this world he became an ascetic18.
In this Jātaka the Bodhisattva’s father is identified with Mahakasspa Thera, the
King of Banareas with Ananda, and Ālāra with Sariputta. This story also given in the
Cariyāpiṁaka .
5. 3. Nekkamma Pāramita-Culla-Sutasoma Jataka No. 525
Once, the Bodhisattva was born as the son of the King of Sudassona(Banaras),
under the name of Soma. He was fond of Soma juice especially to offer it at the time of
Pujas. Therefore he was named as Sutasoma. When he came of age his father gave up
the throne to him. As he had sixteen thousand wives his family became very great, and
he wished to become an ascetic as soon as a grey hair appeared on his head. Everyone in
the palace tried to turn him from this resolve; rich merchants, like Kulavaddhana, offered
him their immense wealth, but all in vain. Having handed over the kingdom to his
brother, Somadatta was wearing the garb of an ascetic and left the city unknown to
18. J.i.45, MA.ii.613, Bu.A.50.
19
anyone. When people discovered his departure they followed him19. Sakka also sent
Visskamma to build for them a hermitage thirty leagues in extent.
5. 4. Paññā Pāramitā- Ummagga Jātaka – No.546
The Bodhisattva once was born in Mithila as the son of Sirivaṁṁaka and
Sumanādevỉ. The child was born with a medicinal plant in hishand, and was therefore
called Mahosadha. He talked immediately after birth and tolled the mother the
importance of the medicine he was carrying. Mahosadha showed his extreme
intelligence since his childhood and the King Videha of Mithilā wanted to have him in
his court though he was only seven years old. The King had four council of ministers but
Mahosadha was appointed as the fifth councilor.
King’s four councilors were unhappy with Mahosadha, because they could not overcome
his extreme intelligence and plotted to embroil Mahosadhapanditha with the king. Most
of the plots were discovered by the MahosadhaPanditha’s wife, Amarādevỉ. Finally they
had unsuccessful attempt to kill MahosadhaPandita.
Because of MahosadhaPandita’s extreme loyal to the king he discovered the
plot of CulaniBrahmadatta , the King of Kampilla, and his PurohitaKewaṁṁa to
capture the whole of Jambudvipa and Mahosadha Pandita made it complete futile
attempt and finally Mahosadha Pandita went to Uttara Pañcāla country because his
king Videha wanted to marry King Brahmadatta’s daughter, Pañcālacaṁṁi. This was
the plot of Kewatta of King Brahmadatta to capture King Videhaand the Mahosadha to
get the Mithila country to his rule.
Mahosadha Pandita used the same plot and went to Uttarapancala country and
became a friend of King Brahmadatta and with his permission in the guise of making a
city for King Videhaconstructed a tunnel. Mahosadha Pandita brought Queens
19. ibid, p. 91.
20
MotherTalata, the queen Nanda and Pancalacandi and brought the King also and did the
marriage Pancalacandi with the King and took them to Mithila safely. When the King
Brhmadatta came to know about the marriage of his daughter to King
Brahmadattahewnted to capture them and rounded up the palace newly constructed for
the King Videha, at that time only Mahosadha was there. He revealed everything to King
Brahmadatta and took King Brahmadatta to see the tunnel (Ummagga20). In the Tunnel
they became friends. Lived as friends arethroughout the time.
5. 5. Viriya Pāramita- Mahajanaka Jātaka- Jātaka No.539.
Mahajanaka, King of Mithila in Videha had two sons; Ariṁṁhajanka and
Polajanaka. When he died elder came to the throne and made his brother viceroy, but
later suspecting innocent brother as him of treachery, had him put in chains.
Polajanakaescaped from the chain and having gone far had his preparation completed he
came to the city and sent messages to the brother “Earlier I was not enemy of you now I
am enemy. Give me the throne or come to fight.” Arittajanakawent to the battle with his
brother but he was killed. Aritthajanaka’s wife after hearing her husband’s death left the
palace taking a lot of treasures and disguising herself. She was pregnant; the Bodhisattva
was born in her womb. Because of the power of the BodhisattvaSakka, the king of Devas
came for her help as a charioteer took her to Kalacampa. There a Brahmin helped her
making her as his sister. The child was born and had the name as MahaJanaka. When
grew to the age of sixteen mothers revealed the story and gave wealth also to him to get
the throne back. He went on a trade in a ship and ship wrecked in the middle of the sea,
people died. Mahajanaka however swam about a week. On the seventh day, a sea
goddess, Manimekkhala helped him brought him to the shore place him in a mango-
grove. While he was sleeping there Polajankas chariot came and stopped and asked him
20. J.iv.329-478.
21
to get up and take the throne. As he went to the palace Polajanaka’s daughter, Sivali
liked him so much. The Mahajanaka married to her had a son, Dighavukumara, made
him viceroy.
After long time he was disgusted with everything in the life became ascetic
stayed so many years in his room. Later he decided to leave and go. When he was going
though the queen saw him on the staircase she did not recognized him because of his
ascetic garb. But later when she discovered he has gone she ran after him and try to
persuade him to return to the palace but he did not listen21. One sage also helped him to
follow his plight. Ultimately with the cry of Sivali he went to the wood and queen Sivali
also lived ascetic life in the royal garden of Mithila.
5. 6. Khanti Pāramita- Khantivādi Jātaka– No.313
The Bodhisattva, under the name of Kuņṁaka, was once born in a very rich
family of Kāsỉ. After the death of his parents he gave away his immense wealth in
charity and became an ascetic in Himālaya. Returning later to Kāsỉ, he dwelt in the royal
park, being tended by the commander in chief. One day Kalābu, king of Banaras, visited
park with his harem and, falling into a drunken sleep, women were disperse their own
ways; while they wandering about they met the ascetic, asked him to preach to them.
When the king woke up he was searching where the women were, he saw them with the
ascetic and being told that he had been preaching on patience (khanti), he gave orders
that the ascetic’s own patience he tested. The ascetic was subjected to various forms of
ill treatment until, becoming more and angrier at the ascetic composure; the king gave
orders to cut his limbs. When the king left the park the earth was open and swallowed the
king to Avici. The commander in chief hurried to the ascetic, after seen what had
21. ibid,p. 19-38.
22
happened, asked the ascetic for forgiveness. Ascetic told he had no malice over the king,
and died because of injuries22.
This story had revealed because of the wrathful monk. King Klabu was the
Devadatta. Commander in chief was Sariputta.
5. 7. Sacca Pāramita – Maha Sutasoma Jātaka No. 537
The King Brahmadatta was much addicted to eat meat. One Uposatha day the
meat prepared for him was eaten by dogs. The cook was unable to buy any meat because
of uposatha day. Ultimately he took some human flesh from the cemetery and cooked for
the king. The king ate it and found very delicious and thereafter he used to murder his
subjects for his food and when the people discovered he was driven out of the Kingdom.
He dwelt in the forest with his cook and used eat the travelers through the wood. The day
came he ate his cook also. After that when he was following a Brahmin who came with a
large followers, they gave chase after the king. As he ran an acacia splinter pierced his
foot, causing him a great pain. There was a banyan tree and he made a wow to bath the
tree with the blood of one hundred of one prince if the wound would heal with seven
days. Some or other within seven days the wound healed. Then he captured one hundred
prince and they were hanged passing a rope through their hands.
The deity of the tree was worried and on the instruction of the Sakka he appeared
before the man eater (Parisada) and demanded that he should bring Sutasoma, the Prince
of Kuru to complete the number. However the Prince of Kuru was his friend, but
Parisada brought him to please the deity of the tree. Sutasoma explained the virtues of
the truth. Parisada was pleased and offered to Sutasoma four boons. Sutasoma chose as
his first benefit that Parisada should live one hundred years, as a second one captive
Kings should release immediately, as a third their kingdoms should be restored, as a
22. J. III. P. 26-29.
23
fourth that Parisada should give up his cannibalism. With many difficulties Parisadahe
agreed with the fourth one. Sutasoma then took Parisada to his kingdom. Where here
stored to him his kingdom, having first assured the people that Parisadanever return to
former vicious habits23. A village was built on the spot where the Parisada was
converted, that was called Kammasadamma. This story was related in reference to the
Buddha’s conversion of Angulimala. Sutasoma was the Bodhisattva.
5.8. Adhitthana Pāramita – Mugapakkha Jātaka No.538. (Temiya Jātaka)
Candadevi, wife of the King Kasi did not have son. She was grieved and Sakka
knew that with the heat of his seat. Sakka persuaded the Bodhisattva to be born as her
son. He was called Temiya because on the day he was born there was a great shower
throughout the Kingdom.
When he was one month he was brought to the king and when he was on the lap
he heard punishment were imposed for some robbers brought to the king. When he was
lay in bed Temiya recollected his previous life. Once he had been the King of Banaras for
20 years. As a result he suffered in Ussadaniraya for twenty thousand years. Having
seen all these troubles his suffering seized him at the thought of having to be king once
more. The goddess of parasol, who had once been the his mother, advised him to pretend
to be a dumb and incapable of any action. He took this advice, for sixteen years the king
and queen tried every conceivable means to break his resolve, knowing his physical body
is normal. Finally asked the charioteer to take him to the charnel ground, where he was
to be clubbed to death and buried. At the Queen’s urgent request Temiya was appointed
to rule Kasi for one week before being put to death. But the enjoyment of royal power
did not weaken his resolution.
23. J. V. P. 246.
24
The charioteer under the influence of Sakka took Temiya to what he considered to
be the channel ground. There the charioteer was digging the ground to be berried the
dead body of Temiya. At that time Temiya stole himself behind Sunandaand confided to
him his purpose and his resolve to lead an ascetic life. Sunanda was so impressed and he
wanted him to become an ascetic immediately. But Temiya wanted him to tell his parents
what had happened. The King and Queen when heard the what happened they
immediately came with large retinue to Temiya’s hermitage, after hearing Temiya’s
sermon they all became ascetics. Following their example all the inhabitance of three
kingdoms adjacent to Banaras became ascetics24. There was a large crowd of ascetics
Sakka and the Vissakamma provided protection for them. The crowed flocked together
were called Mūgapakkha-samāgama.
Temiya’s parents are identified with the Buddha’s parents, Sunanada with
Sāriputta, the goddess of the parasol with Uppalavannā. This story was told in reference
to the Buddha’s renunciation.
5. 9. Mettā Pāramita- Ekarāja Jātaka No. 303
Once upon time the Bodhisattva was born as the King of Banaras. When the king
was sitting in the meeting with his ministers one rebel prince called Dabbasena captured
him fastening him by a cord hung him on the lintel of the door suspended him head
downwards. But the king of Banaras cultivated Mettā towards the rebel prince and
meditated and attained into jhānas. By the power of jhānas bursting his bonds sat cross
legged in the air. The rebel prince was attacked with a burning pain in the body, and with
cry of “I am burn, I am burn” He rolled over and over on the ground. When he asked for
the reason, he was told by inmates of the court “that because of what you have done for
the holy King you had this pain. Then he said “ Go quickly and release him” when they
24. J.vi.1-30, Cyp.iii.6.
25
went there, they found the King was in the air sitting cross legged, came and informed
the rebel prince then he went and bow down and asked for pardon and confessed his
wrongdoings and send the King to his kingdom. The Bodhisattva also offered his
kingdom to his ministers and became an ascetic and after the death born in the brahma
world25. At that time Ananda was Dabbasena. Buddha was the King of Banaras.
Ekarajamena King of Banaras who escaped with power of Mettā.
5. 10. Upekkhā Pāramita- Lomahamsa Jātaka No. 94
The Bodhisattva once became aĀjỉvikaand practiced all manner of austerities in
order to test the efficiency of asceticism, enduring extremes of heat and cold. He realized
his mistake as he lay dying, and was reborn in the deva world.
The story was told in reference to Sunakkhatta, who, having left the Order and
joined Korakkhattiya, went about Vesāli, vilifying the Buddha and declaring that his
doctrines did not lead to the destruction of suffering. When Sāriputta reported this to the
Buddha, the Buddha declared that he had tested the efficacy of asceticism ninety kappa’s
ago and had found it wanting. As Mahālomahaṁsacariyā, where it exemplifies the
practice of Upekkhā26.
6. Pāramitā-s in Cariyāpiṭaka and Aṭṭhakathās
These ten Jātaka stories were selected to represent the Pāramitā-s purely on the
responsible of Atthakathācariyās. It is evident this selection is not very authentic when
anyone look at them carefully. It seems that they have selected these Jātaka stories
without proper investigation. For Dāna Pāramitās Sasa Jātaka is not very enthusiastic
story to mention at first. It is very difficult to decide why they have not mention
Vessantara Jātaka. Vessantara Jātaka is the ideal Jātaka story for Dāna, Pāramitā. It
25. J. 303. IV. P. 9. 26. J. 94. II. P. 229.
26
has given in the Cariyapitaka under the Pāramitā, but also at the last Jātaka story. In
similar manner some given Jātaka stories were not served the purpose properly. There
are some Jātaka stories could have selected much better for the purpose. The
Cariyāpitaka is the volume belongs to the Khuddaka Nikaya, gives many Jātaka stories
to represent each Pāramitā. In that for Dāna Pāramitā ten Jātaka stories are given. For
Sila Pāramitā also ten Jātaka stories are given. For Nekkhamma Pāramitāan only five
Jātaka stories are given. For Adhitthanaparamita one Jātaka story is given. That is the
Temiyapandita story and this is the same story in the Jātaka Book it has mend as
Mugapakkha Jātaka. For Sacca Pāramitā six Jātakaastories are given and that Jātaka
stories are different from the Jātaka story given in the Jātaka Book. For Metta Pāramitā
two Jātaka stories are given and for Upekkha Pāramitā one Jātaka story isgiven.
It is very much interesting to read only seven Pāramitā-s in the Cariyāpiṁaka.
That shows the development nature of Pāramitā-s whether it has some influence or not.
In any other places ten Pāramitās mentioned. In this text the seven Pāramitā-s are Dāna,
Sỉla, Nekkhamma, Sacca, Adhiṁṁhāna, Mettā, Upekkhā. Three other Pāramitā-s Paññā,
Viriya, Khanti, have not mentioned. It is not known why Cariyapitaka mentioned only
seven Pāramitā-s leaving even the very important Paññā Pāramitā-s. According to the
CariyapitakaAtthakatha the explanation is given the whole Pāramitā-s can included in
the six Pāramitā-s Dāna, Sỉla, Khanti, Viriya, Dhyana and Paññā. These six mentioned
there is not the relevance with Theravada but more exactly similar manner mentions in
Sarvastivada and Mahayana. This shows that when forming Pāramitā-s in Theravada
Buddhism they may had the influence of stories of Pāramitā-s in Sarvastivada or
Mahayana as the Mahayana came into the front later than Sarvastivada, it is better to say
Theravada had the Sarvastivada influence.
7. Purpose and the Length of fulfilling Pāramitā-s
27
According to Theravada Pāramitā serves very important way in the career of
Bodhisattva. Bodhisattva is the highest being according to Theravada or Mahayana
Buddhism. This being if wishes in the correct manner he can become a Bodhisattva. By
becoming a Bodhisattva he is achieving the highest position. Then from there he has to
start the journey to become a Buddha. The Bodhisattva’s journey in the form of fulfilling
Pāramitā-s. Length of Pāramitā-s has been decided according to the length of fulfilling
Pāramitā-s. This has been clearly explained in the Suttanipāta Atthakatha27. Where it
explains to become (1) Full enlightened one (Sammāsambuddha) one has to fulfill
Pāramitā-s Four incalculable and one hundred thousand eons (Caturāsaṁkheyya kappa
satasahassāni). To become a (2) SolitaryBuddha
(Pacceka Buddha) Two incalculable and one hundred thousand eons
(Dveasaṁkheyya kappa satasahassāni).To becomeaSāvaka One Inclaculable one
hundred thousand eons (Ekāsamkheyyakappasatasahassāni). There are two kinds of
Sāvakas. 1. Aggassāvka (Main disciple) Similar to Sariputta and Moggallana.
2.Mahāsāvaka (Great deisciples) they are eighty. (AsỉtiMahāsāvaka).To become one of
eighty Mahāsāvaka one has to fulfill Pāramitā-s only one hundred thousand eons.
According to this explanation in Theravada there are three kinds of Bodhisattvas28.
Those are Sāvaka Bodhisattva, Pacceka Bodhisatta and MahāBodhisatta29. In Theravada
Pāramitā-s extended so many ways to say that it serves for the Bodhisattva and the
Buddha. In Suttanipata Atthakatha mentioned that the mother of the Buddha, and the
Father, the Chief attendant of the Buddha, and the son of the Buddha
All have to fulfill Pāramitā-sone hundred thousand eons (Buddhassamātā,
buddhassapitā, buddhassaagguppṁṁhāyakabuddhaputta).
27SN.A. 28 Dictionary of Pali Proper Names,Vol.ii.P.322 29Th.A.
28
This indicates how the Theravada Pāramitā concept differs from Mahayana
Pāramitā-s concept. In Mahayana serves only for the Bodhisattva to become a Buddha.
In Theravada it functions in a wider sense to the Bodhisattva and the Buddha as well as
even some others also to get the benefit from Pāramitā-s.
8. Conclusion
In the early Pali scriptures it is very difficult trace the word Pāramitā, but similar
terms can find rarely. The concept of Pāramitā must have influenced to Theravada from
other Nikayas in later time. Once the influence had occurred Theravadins developed it in
the way they wanted. Thervadins had this influence from Sarvastivadins when they try to
develop the concept of Bodhisattva and the Concept of Bodhisattva was in the early
scriptures and Sarvastivadins developed it by starting with four Pāramitā-s and later
developed up to six Pāramitā-s which even given the influence to Mahasanghikas also.
Theravadins with this influence inspired to develop full Bodhisattva career with Dasa
Pāramitā. This development has done in the Pali commentaries. Pāramitā-s divided into
three categories such as Pāramitā-s, Upa-Pāramitā-s and Paramattha Pāramitā-s
ultimately became early ten Pāramitā-sinto thirty Pāramitā-s. Further explain the
purpose of Pāramitā not only to become Buddha but other categories of the Buddhahood
such as to become a Pacceka Buddha and a Savaka also with the benefit of Pāramitā-s.
Not only that but also to become Buddha’s parents, Buddha’s chief attendant and to
become the Buddha’s son also Pāramitā-s help are needed.
29
Bibliography
1. Primary Sources
Aṁguttaranikāyaa.Ed. Richard Morris, second edition revised by A.K. Warder, 1 Vols. London:PTS, 1989.
Cariyāāāāpiṁaka aṁṁhakathāāāā, Chaṁṁha Saṁgāāāānāāāā, CD-Rom version 3, Igatpuri:Vipassanāāāā Research Institute, 1999.
Dhammapada aṁṁhakathāāāā, ChaṁṁhaSaṁgāāāānāāāā, CD-Rom version 3, Igatpuri:
Vipassanāāāā Research Institute, 1999. DīghaNikāāāāya. Ed. J. E. Carpenter, 3 Vols. London:PTS, 1992. Jātaka.E.B.Cowell, 2 Vols.London: PTS, 1897. Jātaka.E.B.Cowell, 3 Vols.London: PTS, 1897. Jātaka.E.B.Cowell, 4 Vols.London: PTS, 1897. Jātaka.E.B.Cowell, 5 Vols.London: PTS, 1897. Jātaka.E.B.Cowell, 6 Vols.London: PTS, 1897. KathāāāāvatthuppakaraṁaAṁṁhakathāāāā. Ed.RhysDavids. Delhi: Caxton for PTS, 1985;
Trans. B. C. Law, the Debates Commentary, London: PTS, 1999. Mahāāāāvaṁsa. Chaṁṁha Saṁgāāāānāāāā, CD-Rom version 3, Igatpuri: Vipassanāāāā Research
Institute, 1999. Majjhima Nikāāāāyāāāā. Ed. Robert Calmers, 3 Vols. London: PTS, 1994.
2. Secondary Sources Barat. P. V. 2500 Years of Buddhism. Delhi: Government of India publication, 1996. Bhattacharyya, N.N. Buddhism in the History of Indian Ideas, New Delhi: Manohara
Punlishes, 1993. Bhikkhu, Bodhi. The all-embracing net of views, Kandy: Buddhist Society publication,
2007. Buddhadatta, A. P .Enlish-Papi Dictionary. London: PTS, 2002. Hirakawa. A. History of Indian Buddhism, Delhi: Motilal, 1998.
30
Keith. B. Philosophy of the Buddha, London: Routledge, 2003. Nyinatiloka, Buddhist dictionary, manual of Buddhist term & doctrine, Kandy: Fourth
Revised Edition, Buddhist Society publication, 1980. Thera, Nārada. The Buddha and His Teachings, Taipei: The Buddha Educational
Foundation, 1998.