7/25/2019 Order Case 32306-r

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/order-case-32306-r 1/5

-

5'

.,i*

r*"

7/4//{

riillBEm.JSt#P*,{Fq

FH,| $B t.'lffii r''i"']'ru'

'

Fq'i''

''

i

'

'i'i

t

+rwl&T#*t'g$ryi;

i']i'r"

''t;"

:':'rr+ir''

i'r

:

Irli4'"'i"

.--

.

"",*tfiffT-#ffi€l*t;SH$ffilt:.

r'l:*i$+ri

+

r':,{}:"''r

';

"r'

';:'"''

',,

""ffifiild+f$+tfi+tffiffi,'.sX$tiiq

r''1'r'fi+'[1-

;;'e

]'r:jrr'

i''iil

,

r:r,

.:$.&Ult{tt

,,r

'L,i

.

.-,

1.

,.

:,j.i{,

if

'1:.

:

]"]d

,1

11.,,rr,...;.1

.,.

ii.-.

-r:1j

' ''i

:.r

"i;l:;.1.

'l',,n.

-ldEffir$.

,_r:t.i:

,,.t

-lriil4

r.i+i.qi

i'

ir:,;,.;

.,

f,i;,

i.+i

,';;;1.'.ri+r.1i', .

r:

-;r",,

-;i-';

EffitS${S

t}f'tffi

*+f@*t

L&6$dl*&t

'

ir'::

iuurcr*

*fftdev*t

a{rd

ttw

Fr&*el

uf'f1ttautt*

st

hb

#r*r

t

tut&*E$$'

:1.:r

:,.

:

'

i

'"i

't:

'-

'

.:'',-

1 i.

'':'

'.it"

": c:

i;:i{';'i::;i

u666'{Ifts#*iis*&ib$*l.'}dssart.g-r,glngi @'ffi:Yj

.i

;,

ffi*fE*m*.,*6r;ir

gt

XSi,#t

mffitr

BltrSa**,.1r,rrq*

Mh*,*ffiil-*fugi*t*

s**e*{w*f':ffi6#nu*sffiffisd

i

.

i

,,:r*r*x,.ffi*$ttgffrpt.{o

t*ggs

ths,Ge{ft.$fuffi,*som,s,&l

*ud'm6M'ttts'Bhfl

r*,*$#r*e#*ul,*#

tfruu ffi-e$ld''r#

***,*'******r'*krtu'r

Sfilirygg.Eg'

t

m,;ffiffitil

ewhffiH'ttrisn*ffif

l*qm#

ffiffi;itffi,ffiy,*{

tu*'

ffi$lMt#rttu

r;**,. rl#r..eci:rr*J*** tr':ns*foretuafitrt&,r*oJffi-',h.&

d

s'Sli'Mq,*ffis{

ths

#uh&

tffi1ffiqqd

#+ItEt:h{*H

lhffitrs&aGse+sfyT$ffi'ryt#et"

tffirt**r*'* '*i:sr'eu'Tr*Fnr-

'

*{ffiffifiloti.murou'ffi**mm-***+*'*mgm"

,:=*ut

ut,."'

, "

*

:

li*ffirrl$TE

l'tnl't't8*Et':rw

Er

'FrE

i**

p

Xt

t.al

dpfanw

\idtn&$e$

Sel'r*uM,

cBPY

fr*fit$#

fu qf

--.-

...

.i---r-,

*e='*,,,

Wmor

t9 ttH

Itrffi#-J.,ffi,ii#;;t'#il6s

trsil*r,ffi,*

",ffi*,,'*

tB

n**ffiF.t

66i

,r1s;tsff*,ffi{fofur

flryT51|trffiff.ffi

ffiH",ffi

;;o;;';ffi

*'{ft

wh'hn'i*'rdutisnt"stff

nt€d

#ffi-e,k

m

mm*rs*Ex

e'#lm#S*

d;#t$,*

'

Mi#'l#"w

-.

",i,."..-

rlE;ie

-**r*,***,rffi^r**rr*rr

ffit*r.l',6t*o*qf.*mfuti6grurils,6#'m*

#til @ll*W'@-

ffififfislsffi

*rttmrftqr

ir{rir}fie##

,@*

H**ryHH*-#*

rlr*Erilu'L'ww"tro*r'r'

*ffitu*ry#

ts$ti$$hnd

r{ght

to

htl

ttrBcnt

Mctlon

and

denH

Sre

Prm

cp*edy

*rt6l

i+as [iksr;,t$€

t*e

p.thw*g1sl

€Sn*l*Bfefkon

of

f.bffi

C6{*rt

w}-r*r

It

ralexed

ttg

tsdt1tre]

rul€$

orx

ttg':Bubfyrk3to;

of

pe**f*

aff.idavttr

wrd

gr*nted

h**

$ea

tu

he

allcurd

tP

rffit

ft18

'

l&frrith,rtgn*tg

ttrnioh@m'

*wffiihn

nhMotiBn.*t

ht*

ifnvqr:kffis{r$fl

tnse

nd6e.*d..*ffi;;ffiffir;"g3S-*'5at'ifiH

fipg1'e

ffitg6g11,i##fi4;

#HfffiS

$t

rufirts

ro b*

h*-u+d'acfi:tslifud@ffilr6p'#kiwfi

ffuj

ifits

tsd

tts

* *

ffi

ts

ffi;iffi;ffEr13m@e*tpt*-u6r-.

**l*

M

rw'**

sFs

*r,Brewdtffi

$d&''&ff".s*'r#s d

ffinfi;'ths*}r$trinrg*rf,*iffxJr*urt.

.*Ian&us.r,'sft6r'fi*'Hffififu1;r*rm;*&mflm'r

gf

ttF'mffirilw€fiSsn

*ndi

mffi,.fieffti6,;tft.Brfl*Iid"i$r6,*ffim*

,'#tm*t,'*c."';#H*M

i$sr.lig#

ff

ffi"ffid"'d

cmn*fre*ffirs**sbr*g*#*rilr

rt$*r*m&

G

mryt*sng,

,Ud*ffiil

rY*ft3-ndlfq'*f'H.'SffiSgdq

1ffi.6ggffid*#l*m,mmhf6eni{rthc,Bf,nrffiiu*:@i$nrrcHd,ffilts$$uelftc*d

tsffiil'W*}.:':

"'

r

":i

..',u..,-^..l..,..;..,

n

Ordsr

Act*

g,efienrber

14,

I0t3

Urpa"C

Om*tu*

irtetlfi

dtht.* {

d*t*d

Oel'

L

I$1}

q(}dff.dtffi$rgty",l$i[01*,,r,,.',,,',;.;:'1'

;,

;,:,r

i:,1

7/25/2019 Order Case 32306-r

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/order-case-32306-r 2/5

/

,#

i-;

TJ

;

ffi

ildrd

rry{

*.ryg$

T*'the

accuseo

**

a

sumnplnglFt

unfountu

,,,,,r$i*trrrhr*,ir*,,ffi.r*,ffi;*;*

[c]'**"*oit'ffist'tri**n*eu

:L,1g6qr'${r*i.ffi

{.**i1erditffiiEt,ord*'qrth}hf*-{'ttsilqqt+tltqry*d'ai#a$ilav

d

errtf

rt

,pffi*ffi.rstr

fte.pr

.

nmrfine**t,;'iffi*itt"titdmtufriitm'ftrs

,parffiih$,*m*"v*rf*rmif,+."try#me

tm

*$:pf

is'*r@i*r*l'qib

f*}"*ttt'*

,

:ffi6*sG:*s&ls,,imsq#:uprr

*.ro

,rl's*,

a,wotimr'fiiE

H,h,tHH

ifitffit$h

tb

ru*i'tha

t*rxr&r#rr

gf",'tttE

,$?siqtutilBrffitrfiHel1i,''ffi'ffii;ffi;i:$I*t.gt5'6B1'

grt

'Ys

E

rBlYdBd

.

*ffig,rx,

-41g-d#,sgpEr*i

*ogoa

fur

nf"E *.'tu*18

srtsil-sfrtt*r

@.Yn

&r

tils

sor*r

"*

r**il-

#fo;ill*s

rnorlt

TltG

cffist

trormy

11$T

l?

'Hdd.tW

ttlr

t$?ryelaffi

rn#mffin

*1u1ffiS,,tr-m*

ffi*:

rp#r.ry'ffiptdrrffir

[t,,ffi1t'uft*iiitlre'*tf,$t"u#snted

,

,.,n*g**g61g,t&trpt,**

,g6-S4",fll

,4

q

.*'odd,its6

ra

o#e

sfi.lxrffi&"

l

s#ffixlrits,4.{q*11ryg...,ttrerpr,€Bwfid#t'mrmg"lnem**Jttdn&

ffi

ffi

Usd$sr

mikr*e

i.{&ft_ rd,$mroshn-{ex5trds

*,ffiat&tr,,$spe"

ffi;,et;*;iu*i-+

:'ss'gsii

6

.&a

pg*ffi|&ff:+

m*twr,

*6$"8t*,r,*HffiEs{.-cw'sfl*-e.,}' g1ry

rc

t6:s1

:***sr,

d

*:*fficr*p

to,,ggfdc.Elf,wrmLr-fi#u#r

x*ffiffi'ffir

ffdryfi

t'l*s

;ffigf*

s@dpted.wffira*i'iw;,*orr'ou"rfrffi

iii

@,,

i+ f.*-ffi

ffi;l-il;"ffi"ffi;

il

*lJ

b'

t'..T:ry

g3'*1Ttr.m

ffi;eiiltd;,***

Yd'f15'n{:rf$$ffiffis*tx

.ffi.ms*

,,&*4ffif',m,rsrfr'Irflfuffi,fil''d

i#i

#

.g,trffr:

,ffi

ffiiffiffi;ffi'ilffi;;ffiry;.YgY.gg

''Th*

:

r#{.rsm,h,

ffi

#sl&taffi

*e*uv.

fficss

F*

otty

ffi

w .-,

x'

E.-

tldg

corfr's

tpftstryrt

onsiderailon

of

Mev

r9,

mr*r

fft

$e

@TTlffl*1-L:,ui::iJ,,*e,;;,,**

.ifiii,;;gn,idc',xtr$,rtsiix

;rd;*,tcouiotsttffi'

ry ryry-ffi

rsrt

tu

ryedv

redwsfffi*1**fum

*ftf*ffiit

,

,.

::

€'#edily,

ttc

rwhffin

dH

not

rE.d

wfth

t}'€

YIfl:

wd$'twf

f,md#r**tffi#ffi.c

'#'l**,t*4lH*dasfnFrdc.Try@tm

Hryryffi

ffi

-d;ffi6''ilttmcqpt*anrsrmtg1wrrrttte

ru

ttfr

ItE

Wi

t@

.lt

::

 

,,:(

-

.

166

wrrt.*

of

futtsri,,fi}t$ffift

sf}d$kf

.nd

qry kffik-

efskfl

,torsx,pnrfi*mte*rw

#,1*,*m

fffi"ets's

;$rd*$'ffi'Sffieffi1tuts:,ffi*,

ft$yry

ry

O**r,

of

ctxrfts€k

inwsie4

have

rerneired

untarnished

slrcl

ttre

day

B

Tt

*

lS.Fn.}

n*

hffi

$ot

mgli*.Wrtrffi,wm,rwtrhSs,

i*sikn

'mrytn

'[*

HS*Et

sflth

S&

tottrrt*

,";;

i-d*r.

til

i;";r-".r:,e*

uu* e"r

"

u*r*t**.

*rumn

*fu'tfss'Edurt

ha$

ghown

a

;rf;rr;:,ffi;k

t#"tCiriil,'rn*

dt

B-fir"

B

ffirrr

ffifl,ir

ss

tt

u

rrtmrrv

nlflthor#

fsat*nti.ssrml,tfi*rrikrnld8rd1ftB.ffiifti,#',**fr

wffiitltor:thury,r,r*

,}6

ffi

*

,Sttt

sfi*

fus..ffi'sr\ffgr1sq,,6r16'rffiU*s.* P-.{nd

st

n*rfd*trtt

hi'hk

spadtV

as e

fa#icin;'hnrry*r

orrd

es

ffi

Gh€ted

treF.

servant

terffrgserv*d

T

at*

Chl

Councfl

of

G;'f*.

*.y

brg

t*l?r.

ffuq4h

the

tsar

in $is

fi#C

ald

pdvate

tilb,

ttu

tmtrsiBrn{

hes

.ffi-4164

"6gfi*qp@,aff

x#tddr

d

:tk

t{t&t*iY'*if

Bl$lb.

Ufi.i$tr

ffi

ryftE

n'

${ge

t}

tmt

o+*gtr,,*.pn*u*ri

tt*,,.tW$

g***,trffi,nls,h$.*svsit$rfHh

i*mmt*ffits'm6tfitttf$ty

twim

hsl$t

Env

wr,mr}f|:.lfifiGlisstirtr

ffiffiii$rfi:'sry&

rsqy;;i6rHi

Or

onffi

grt-

ti*"s*'tw

uf

ihg'rtuttt

SnV*s*fl *mm*

AAAfi*,

ln

d+n

BsffiaWs*tFt#fiffi,t#f;ctffifir;

sffG*ffiS

tffi'q**mlrtlonr

or

'

ttrssr* &rrnfrhtt,rl*q&i.*ed

*frruft

1S, m{4

7/25/2019 Order Case 32306-r

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/order-case-32306-r 3/5

*

.7'

-

-',

/ {'r

L,

;

,'

\-,/

tufl

$ffiild

have$ssn'csftalil fo"ca[#d

ln

interesrs

Tr{:::

H:T

#"*H:

ffiffi

i**

"ly

*m'',*n*'

*urt

srnc€

IS*r'

murn*ra$l*

Sftfl-s$.flo

P?|:-iJ';;;,

,rgrffi"th6t'heilHtr#l[reir''iTT;ffi,****

"e+n-f,

gssn$,'

ffiil;r*-Tr-ff;S"m

lnhibit

from

ease

t'r,f*i**tt'*{'IT{Y':YffHfi#

*r*p,,f,*nh*

Htd

other

thtfl

th€

suestion

of

thk

-*#;;iless'ard'intestrty'

The'kgal

cout

:ffiffiT:-

lll

ffiffi'H#'ffi;.il""

;;;#;.d*h-Hffi:;*F***'ffi:;;;;;**

-iii=*-il*tt#r*,

-

'

,

'

-h'

ii--r-J'ili*

**

**

tt*E'ffqlrt

hs*'

for

fsrnrFil

r€E$c

inr.Errsr

rs

**o

*,

i.

this

ce$e;

*#*fr

#;t*-U

-m*J-

#

in

ea*n1t

r1*totlo**

l+u*nu*

h[

3tti6

inhrh*isn,

or,

*ii'o***r11t*.1*ril".*o*-.*]**'basis

-d'-d'ki

tre

s'uld'vd*tv

and

hrsrry

*.u-u.'

*e,srnsrstent

#*.rri

#,'*ul1'ilffi

;

-#

to'

tuumuru*n''atuffi

rt'

h#'

ry

s,**'rytg,mooiJ,ion*ury-11*iil,#Jr*,*u'"*ffi

*:#--n-s"*1ffi

-*spfl

*s*+rffi

&*lr

h{ssilB*fi

*nsrt*crt*uv,rmput*+f,nrs,,,#ffi#;"

#ffi;#;*f.**.po$5*s

mrwraff+'s***'

rrom

thh

o**

r.-

uo

nin*

rrx

acomd

@rrad

ffi

tr1;ffi

;f#rut

etrffi

S

.friJro;

u*r{Eti

thisrs'Bt$t'**

mT;ilT****iW*-*l*m..&1fl'rft'$paeu*vi'

I**m'e+p;n

intsrsrtr*

rtg

*se-t-*,3rY,yim

r**dlH'tlTfl*.:*

'

:

[ff*[-l]ffi,ffl][l

*'il,

i'1.*

*mrnsFfrdencc,'"','

,

__,,;ffi#**m-*"8sEEffi,r*-"rrts{Is*#tffi

f"'"ffffis$E$ndil*l''i'7:tr*.r

*g*#l**urffi*wrrlDa:l

m*l

iffifllffi'I:ffiffi

tm

ffi

nm

nf

*@;il'.[

*1*

".*"ffi'+q@"d*

*m

*e+ss*

ts

*tsffi

r

ffiffi';

:

P*rrutr{ffiG-

*

,

t

'

:;

-

-**-

rxc.writiHi*

**

non

r-t,touondugt

aifdr'

frm.yd

;*--ffi

ffi

'

a

cwrrsffi611ry6

sff+r6ffi,ge**ffro*ffig #

s$u*mq$##[friii-*

tf*e"esss,rr@lf'tfi*r

ec$

lrarf*sxann*Jpn,

m*,ryy

r-s#iii-''**o***o*'ffi##ffi-d

ta

r*rum'up#&n

lHaitfi#

th*.case,,rh*siro$rt

$#srlld,ru**il

ffi*tut**ryy**git"*u*

swrress#s'

uffi-r*'.twlws

arid,F*r.rs*6bnu+#.,ilili**n.*n*rfu*-*tm"'.-*m'I;i;f**;

.wrter*iaf':€

€fi'*tt

Eum&nd$rrils,Bn*trit*.*e**Hff;"ffi

ff:::-llff

*ru

',Thsr$ffire:frplda'tnrgmsd:**u*''AO''i'*ou'ryi9#EtstfiaHsi'ths$'r3ffix

rhir

courrs

66p*ul*.

rh€

*d€"#

;,qif-e

J**rr

m

lTiifr*i'i*tqenun'tr*ntrsn

txktr-ffi

tnts

"**r.rtr61#yr$**i:lini-o

*r-*.*n*J

#[**;

**"*n

uu:t'

y*'*u1umtrrwrsr

ebwirdrffi'

tn

ttrl*

***u.m,tt

nrJ**utgo#'$'M*'B

*rym'

@ee('+e$

*$ di#srd

*ffiffiEt"

rp

haus

,rh{*

igsrgt

ffilHi

:*F

.fi.*r"-fiffi

il;;;.

''t*'-ffif

wso

'ssrtEtssglp''

srslttsii*affifi

'

mc$sd

prwrd,,rrq

,m*J*,.f,,11il',,,

m*s,r*r*t

;

ffii't#ilr

'*f''*l+*'srs#

#

fsrxe;d

hy

t{rer

aceussd

in

hr*fir*tii*#ffi',,mru*-'ffiffi;

il;

k*en*d*:ests&1ffi:

Trs#

$ilna*'w**.*i**eerw

er.u*

tiimmi*e*r**r**.utuw'*wq{tisiq"**fr#qs'n$s.t{*

td':s*

tessr

bsw*;,Ttrey

****

o*m*o.oi',n--G#**.r*;;t#"

rui

i*'initistti$

*rt

diftu,sn*

,rccused

*choed

his-iweeping

--* *r--#,J

dmg*r*nH'#t-dry

oo',*i*

p*r$

af

thi*

{owt'

rrftleh,

m

di*ewsed

eprlter,

was

alt

uut

--e*;;uo

*i*

srveertrw

r'nr*ile@-ueaecusatk*fi'

7/25/2019 Order Case 32306-r

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/order-case-32306-r 4/5

r''

Tf

l/

,/./,

lv

,l''

,1tt,"

,i'

,,r$,fu[q

tdi*BFinsrirEEsc"Lstftlsqh?|w.dM-tTt,&r.ffi'$,q#ur}beint,qrp|FtFdas.aft

Etlon

ln.tftn

Fr0cel

evegion,d'frls'Uu*"6.d$nerue

ju*tbc.w{thi$-

fe#'or

fssor,

ef;ffiT3€i

:tryt

thir

hs

csrEtru€{l

es

tnm"tr****i

io'tt*e

bri*l"i*

"rm6#ons

of the

accustd,

ths

sq{t

r*usd

frorn

hHtrrer

tuarlt{,,ttk,ry,

irapefied

@

tfos

*dtmrdrq

ciretrn*tm*fis,

Fkt},(

thc'q$try$

tr*e

strt*k-BrltlY

fid6$Bi*

an6"iti#wt,'a'hsstls

*pprcsd-r

#1d'sttiltls*

tfi.rf,r*rdk

tfr&

caxrlt-

ffi

r*Hsfh

#tr

tl}*f

f,fl

redutisn*,

evon

tft*ri

f*ttp@bk

to

hkri,

srld

ssusfiqts

€ftt$

sorst

hny'$S,*

*

kltcrpr*ts4

ry

udsro,ut{effiHHt+U*#,tb:S*hh**sa;

&thl*t

fieSffiPt

tfE$

E

ii

**}y

qtsat

trsn

tht

;*d;E-

*d t*oo,

o+In

the

pleadtngq

**tt*r,r,

and

rctuations

oi

the

actrrced

and

hls

couneel

futrnard

tftie

.c#$rt,

At,ru

*utuet,

this

ffifit

6nBe$EtSf

*:rft#S

Hq

P-.fffi,

ttq*erfiHndh*

x*d

eainot but

mton*l#r

ns$

#'rrhftit

ffi$

'ffitsr.

Sqrffi

ar

tslffi#

***r*t*ttygaric

theu*ecused

and f*t

erym*ul

tt*

nuffi

n

thh s*tst

tlt**

hrye oarty

*en*iu**

tht

qe*urd

err*

lrh

wrmasl

f.rr.,*

ffi

s,sr*lHtt**ifi{$

this

court.

wittln#ff

+r

urt*tttjrfify;

fmr

rtf;,+ffqd

to.a

r&tsrft€ntr

S{'v&ld

tfih

COrtrt

ss€s

trt

unarcHabl€

$*eEtffi

udraruby

ary

@

aS:,

sf,f*#r

Coort

sd,cBn$e

or

fuvsrah&

&,:,th*rr*t

srtl|

drrrrye ke

wgft

snd

tnt

"h

@r$ ,ffi'

m{ffi?d.

mumd

andrtlrr,pra**errtkn

Thle

aoHfi

#*nnm

rut

ssB

*t

.,ts

krrlsm*

T.I

'net

ffiffi'ffiH,;ffiffi--edr,'tr;HtU;"

t;*n*}6t'r#il3*

-im

*rycf

tlsr

a*,r.r,* fnffitet{g

$rrrcr',ru

Wrnrt,@s€s

thfi

Sm

dtu*thn

uffi

mt

cq$q

if

tftlq

e.4lt

S{$ks$n

to

hearlthis

casa, cerpequenrtly

rasdtlrq

to

rrore

unreceseyrted

dela**r[,k

dis*sttron

of

ttrb

csss.

$erond,

ths:

of

an u*ftf,tndd-

crlmlrud

r-aqs

a{rd

m'

rye

k*YI

ff

slra&t,dbman:,*fi

,$rul,ffift1c*

e,f

th#:'fiawt

*4mlnt*te$*+ twg*r#velf,

fuy

fte

eq1i4@r.ffid#lff

Hb6

tmd*rrgncd'has

undu{y

*xeretrsted

ttts

dmEdy

hcst*fa

f,sxq8*.ffift

,hf

t[$.requ*sd

ryHlft

tt*s

mrit

st*$H,tg11rtuq

fts{ltt

sw}'#ld

stH firffi*skr

ttx

rstd

rt-Butra$tT''**r4'mnmtt*a#t'rr

l$

th#

dlrps56tsn

ot'ttrlsl:ress

nohuith$$ndlng

tfre

ft[]n*

of

th*

pfiarentefi

Esrfis&tftst'h*rL

etrff

Mortovsr,

tht

lolqt,also

tortram

the

P+sstoilitY

tr*t,*

mff,ffi;;_tm

[[

p6ryt-rq

m

li;,,tn

arU

ess*,

ffi.q$trt

&ffiffi

$,tr

nms56 ,

'*p

511rrnm5{,*r's

ffiffi

6Es*

t6*ry*

SdftS

tl#

&W

t*

ffi1ffi$-

*f

ry

pg

ekt.e#.M4*g

ffirffis4-

}**t*St*t,

+SF.Wsfr:'1**1i$

ffi

,erEt*

ffirmrstencs,

to

hapm*n,

bt$ the

mtnd

of

a

dsfe*tqd

pafiV

h

fertllQ

qround

-f.t

t

-1orb.of

eurp*&n*

rt$

cunffi

s.

lt

6nl

tmr'etfter

M,

ffi$*

qllt

meftE:e&:unf*qr&tq

s**w

4effrntm

rS&r

t*srsdffirc$io*mu*il,trq

fri:fu

@t$te,W$xfl

would

con$trlre

ths

s.enffi

as

retallefion by

tHs

cnlrt

"rr

ffi|Strffi$t$,tffiiffi

re

iudge.

i*

nny,ltrfryi,*his

(rurt

ffi.ht

hrmrnpably

h*

I

anff

***

tl,m.*mr$*d-.cnd

il#

munml

*#

Stsd

r

f@txle

atilhrh.tsffffl$its

cryS,

ff$v f*rym #

monifrafly

kr*

felttr

rthh.fimrfr

abi*tr

to

prpm+d

whlt

this,

f{s+,

ffi

rmi

Ue

cnffi

rmqrrcffil#

**.rffieilt*$i

fi&rffirl.,&hlmq$

Brrh{r$

nu

ffiont

*fiXr,C

lt

**

r**g*ffi

thst

th

accllg*d

suilfi&

'kst

fsm

snd

conffierrce

h

Urt*i't*r*'i

iffty

tu cblgs,t*'*h

Wd

withfirt

fe#

ar

fa$or

prceeod

nfth

tftis

cene,

Tlir

Co{nt

sees

@ff

,a.l

,tln

rmrtral

arhit*r

of

&lst

co'ntravorrha

h*tur**a

the

accussd

en{

t*rs

f w.**Wsn,

not

tm,

$tgF*ry

*f

e*tk

psrty,

ttoyr&Er, rr+tur*v

tfun mqls$d

tnd

hhtqm*$

ffi.&t*d

tnm

$q$*..Errytttt

h

ffieffi*

th$

rw,

but rrt&#un6t+lv

ffiu@

root

ilt&

S+urtmtp*t

sn *sryrmrV

*fld

sry

f@er*tH#t

hv

$e

Cetrt

@iirqrf;@aa#c

to

f*tr**rmot

w$Sel*ryr

hsrt$sfftr

x*rqgrydf

$effi"

I

,

l:'.:

: :,-r.

,

Whk

thls

court

$ro{dd never

evade

or shirt frsrn

its

hah*red

duty

te

porfum

its

sehnrt

oath

ta

#*Fryti$e

il*e$,

qfr&

€std

fientf*W

qffill*ut

fear

er

fanor,

lnqreexm

ttre

EryHes

sil

sotgtt*lt

ln a

c**e

mog[*, underittrp for*fioing r]rmtrfi#ffiqer, rnd

#er

a fifir$ful

t$tt

mnhrthn

md

upmr

c@risHcrdftCIn

of

tl*e ftighsr lnterast

of st&steflttd

jurtks

ard

eryfdf

dtspos{trGfi

of

ttrlit

c:rs,

tlm

ur#ntrned

flndr

k

mone

prudent

to

iflhihit

hkn$elf

from ftfrhsr

honrug

this

case,

lf

only

to

dsabuse

ths

alreadl

preiudiced

mlnd

of

the

accu*ed

arid hts m*rrEnl, atld

ln

srfur

to

#d*a

ury

funrof

Fsfi&e

mdhiar

footn anyof

tlre

pnrtl*u,

,

"

'','"

7/25/2019 Order Case 32306-r

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/order-case-32306-r 5/5

$B4$ry

4c

sq"W

rr$sw

{{W

ffiffiiys*

m

i,l:

:

g

t

j:fii;.;i;jii,FJ

tu

Su0fuoil*HeM

of

ateffi8

@afs&wa*ffi#ffirS@'

:.

'

. -,,:

';l

'::i:

,:

.t

',,

:

,

i

ri::..

tsHr$rsAmr

s,ififinB

fmffi?Ef.

ri. lr:H$+;.

i*t

/:r'r n n

irr

;i.

ii

'.

:--

l'l

,'lt

i:

.:l::rti.,jr:

:,1.

j.t.

..

,,t.