optical design with mirrors jose sasian · "the world of unobstructed reflecting...

48
Prof. Jose Sasian Short Course Optical Design with Mirrors with emphasis in unobstructed systems Jose Sasian

Upload: others

Post on 20-May-2020

6 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Optical Design with Mirrors Jose Sasian · "The world of unobstructed reflecting telescopes," Journal of the Amateur Telescope Makers 1, Fall 1992. Also in “The best of the amateur

Prof. Jose Sasian Short Course

Optical Design with Mirrors with emphasis in unobstructed

systems

Jose Sasian

Page 2: Optical Design with Mirrors Jose Sasian · "The world of unobstructed reflecting telescopes," Journal of the Amateur Telescope Makers 1, Fall 1992. Also in “The best of the amateur

Prof. Jose Sasian Short Course

Contents

• Introduction• References and papers • On-axis systems• Un-obstructed systems• Examples• Summary

Page 3: Optical Design with Mirrors Jose Sasian · "The world of unobstructed reflecting telescopes," Journal of the Amateur Telescope Makers 1, Fall 1992. Also in “The best of the amateur

Prof. Jose Sasian Short Course

Introduction

• Why this short-course?• Course requirements• How I got experience with mirrors• What you should expect from the course• Mostly aberration control• References

Page 4: Optical Design with Mirrors Jose Sasian · "The world of unobstructed reflecting telescopes," Journal of the Amateur Telescope Makers 1, Fall 1992. Also in “The best of the amateur

Prof. Jose Sasian Short Course

References• Dietrich Korsh, Reflective Optics, Academic Press, 1991.• H. P. Bruegemann, Conic Mirrors, Focal Press 1968.• Reflective and Catadioptric objectives, Lloyd Jones,

Chapter 18, Handbook of Optics, OSA.• Michael Rogers, Un-obscured Mirror Designs, SPIE

4832 Proceedings IODC 2002.• Patent literature• Journal and Proceedings papers

Page 5: Optical Design with Mirrors Jose Sasian · "The world of unobstructed reflecting telescopes," Journal of the Amateur Telescope Makers 1, Fall 1992. Also in “The best of the amateur

Prof. Jose Sasian Short Course

Papers• Sasian, J. M., "Flat-field, anastigmatic, four-mirror optical system for large

telescopes," Opt. Eng. 26 (12), 1197-1199 (1987)• Sasian, J. M., "Four-mirror optical system for large telescopes," Opt. Eng. 29 (10),

1181-1185 (1990).• Sasian, J. M., "Design of a Schwarzschild flat-field, anastigmatic, unobstructed, wide-

field telescope," Opt. Eng. 29 (1), 1-5 (1990).• J. M. Sasian, ‘Annular surfaces in annular field systems,’ Optical Engineering, 36(12),

3401-3403, 1997.• Sasian, J. M. "Review of methods for the design of unsymmetrical optics," SPIE

Proceedings on Optical Engineering Midwest'90 1396, 453-466 (1991).• Sasian, J. M., "How to approach the design of a bilateral symmetrical optical system,"

Opt. Eng. June (1994) • Sasian, J. M., "The world of unobstructed reflecting telescopes," Journal of the

Amateur Telescope Makers 1, Fall 1992. Also in “The best of the amateur telescope making journal, “ William Cook Editor, Willmann-Bell, 2003.

• J. M. Sasian, ‘Double-curvature Surfaces in Mirror System Design.’ Optical Engineering, 36(1), 183-188, (1997)

Page 6: Optical Design with Mirrors Jose Sasian · "The world of unobstructed reflecting telescopes," Journal of the Amateur Telescope Makers 1, Fall 1992. Also in “The best of the amateur

Prof. Jose Sasian Short Course

Mirror virtues/problems

• Large and small apertures• Large bandwidth• No intrinsic chromatic aberations• Support system• Aspheric surfaces• Twice the deflection and no cancellation• Stronger scattering

Page 7: Optical Design with Mirrors Jose Sasian · "The world of unobstructed reflecting telescopes," Journal of the Amateur Telescope Makers 1, Fall 1992. Also in “The best of the amateur

Prof. Jose Sasian Short Course

Wave aberration conceptsreview

Page 8: Optical Design with Mirrors Jose Sasian · "The world of unobstructed reflecting telescopes," Journal of the Amateur Telescope Makers 1, Fall 1992. Also in “The best of the amateur

Prof. Jose Sasian Short Course

...cos

coscos

cos,,

4400

3311

22220

222222

3131

4040

1112

0202

200

HWHWHW

HWHWW

HWWHWHW

nmj

mlkmlk HWHW

,,,, cos,

Wave aberration

Page 9: Optical Design with Mirrors Jose Sasian · "The world of unobstructed reflecting telescopes," Journal of the Amateur Telescope Makers 1, Fall 1992. Also in “The best of the amateur

Prof. Jose Sasian Short Course

Page 10: Optical Design with Mirrors Jose Sasian · "The world of unobstructed reflecting telescopes," Journal of the Amateur Telescope Makers 1, Fall 1992. Also in “The best of the amateur

Prof. Jose Sasian Short Course

Page 11: Optical Design with Mirrors Jose Sasian · "The world of unobstructed reflecting telescopes," Journal of the Amateur Telescope Makers 1, Fall 1992. Also in “The best of the amateur

Prof. Jose Sasian Short Course

Page 12: Optical Design with Mirrors Jose Sasian · "The world of unobstructed reflecting telescopes," Journal of the Amateur Telescope Makers 1, Fall 1992. Also in “The best of the amateur

Prof. Jose Sasian Short Course

B

B

yyL

m1

Page 13: Optical Design with Mirrors Jose Sasian · "The world of unobstructed reflecting telescopes," Journal of the Amateur Telescope Makers 1, Fall 1992. Also in “The best of the amateur

Prof. Jose Sasian Short Course

Design of reflective axially symmetric systems

Page 14: Optical Design with Mirrors Jose Sasian · "The world of unobstructed reflecting telescopes," Journal of the Amateur Telescope Makers 1, Fall 1992. Also in “The best of the amateur

Prof. Jose Sasian Short Course

Flat-field, anastigmatic, four-mirroroptical system for large telescopes

Page 15: Optical Design with Mirrors Jose Sasian · "The world of unobstructed reflecting telescopes," Journal of the Amateur Telescope Makers 1, Fall 1992. Also in “The best of the amateur

Prof. Jose Sasian Short Course

Flat-field, anastigmatic, four-mirroroptical system for large telescopes

Page 16: Optical Design with Mirrors Jose Sasian · "The world of unobstructed reflecting telescopes," Journal of the Amateur Telescope Makers 1, Fall 1992. Also in “The best of the amateur

Prof. Jose Sasian Short Course

Page 17: Optical Design with Mirrors Jose Sasian · "The world of unobstructed reflecting telescopes," Journal of the Amateur Telescope Makers 1, Fall 1992. Also in “The best of the amateur

Prof. Jose Sasian Short Course

Design of un-obstructed reflective systems

Page 18: Optical Design with Mirrors Jose Sasian · "The world of unobstructed reflecting telescopes," Journal of the Amateur Telescope Makers 1, Fall 1992. Also in “The best of the amateur

Prof. Jose Sasian Short Course

Symmetry

• Axially symmetry• Double plane symmetry• Plane symmetry• Monocentric symmetry• Confocal symmetry• Non identiafiable symmetry

Page 19: Optical Design with Mirrors Jose Sasian · "The world of unobstructed reflecting telescopes," Journal of the Amateur Telescope Makers 1, Fall 1992. Also in “The best of the amateur

Prof. Jose Sasian Short Course

Methods of design for NRS

• Eccentric and off-axis sections• Annular or Ring field systems• Concatenation of well corrected

systems• Tilted component theory• Expansion about the Optical Axis Ray• Confocal systems

Page 20: Optical Design with Mirrors Jose Sasian · "The world of unobstructed reflecting telescopes," Journal of the Amateur Telescope Makers 1, Fall 1992. Also in “The best of the amateur

Prof. Jose Sasian Short Course

Eccentric and off-axis systems

Page 21: Optical Design with Mirrors Jose Sasian · "The world of unobstructed reflecting telescopes," Journal of the Amateur Telescope Makers 1, Fall 1992. Also in “The best of the amateur

Prof. Jose Sasian Short Course

Annular or Ring field systems

Perkin-Elmer’sMicralignconcept byA. Offner 1975

Page 22: Optical Design with Mirrors Jose Sasian · "The world of unobstructed reflecting telescopes," Journal of the Amateur Telescope Makers 1, Fall 1992. Also in “The best of the amateur

Prof. Jose Sasian Short Course

Ring-field system for EUV lithography Annular surfaces

Page 23: Optical Design with Mirrors Jose Sasian · "The world of unobstructed reflecting telescopes," Journal of the Amateur Telescope Makers 1, Fall 1992. Also in “The best of the amateur

Prof. Jose Sasian Short Course

Concatenation of systems Example: on axis aspheric

system

Dietrich Korsh

Page 24: Optical Design with Mirrors Jose Sasian · "The world of unobstructed reflecting telescopes," Journal of the Amateur Telescope Makers 1, Fall 1992. Also in “The best of the amateur

Prof. Jose Sasian Short Course

Concatenation of systems Example: Reed and Schwarzschild systems by David Shafer

Page 25: Optical Design with Mirrors Jose Sasian · "The world of unobstructed reflecting telescopes," Journal of the Amateur Telescope Makers 1, Fall 1992. Also in “The best of the amateur

Prof. Jose Sasian Short Course

Tilted component system

Tilted Component Optical Systems, Richard Buchroeder, Ph. D. Dissertation, University of Arizona

Page 26: Optical Design with Mirrors Jose Sasian · "The world of unobstructed reflecting telescopes," Journal of the Amateur Telescope Makers 1, Fall 1992. Also in “The best of the amateur

Prof. Jose Sasian Short Course

Scheimpflug condition

Page 27: Optical Design with Mirrors Jose Sasian · "The world of unobstructed reflecting telescopes," Journal of the Amateur Telescope Makers 1, Fall 1992. Also in “The best of the amateur

Prof. Jose Sasian Short Course

Displacement of the aberration field center

Page 28: Optical Design with Mirrors Jose Sasian · "The world of unobstructed reflecting telescopes," Journal of the Amateur Telescope Makers 1, Fall 1992. Also in “The best of the amateur

Prof. Jose Sasian Short Course

Aberration fields

K. Thompson, "Description of the third-order optical aberrations of near-circular pupil optical systems without symmetry," J. Opt. Soc. Am. A 22, 1389-1401 (2005)

Page 29: Optical Design with Mirrors Jose Sasian · "The world of unobstructed reflecting telescopes," Journal of the Amateur Telescope Makers 1, Fall 1992. Also in “The best of the amateur

Prof. Jose Sasian Short Course

Plane symmetric systems:Expansion about the OAR

Page 30: Optical Design with Mirrors Jose Sasian · "The world of unobstructed reflecting telescopes," Journal of the Amateur Telescope Makers 1, Fall 1992. Also in “The best of the amateur

Prof. Jose Sasian Short Course

Plane symmetric aberration function

Page 31: Optical Design with Mirrors Jose Sasian · "The world of unobstructed reflecting telescopes," Journal of the Amateur Telescope Makers 1, Fall 1992. Also in “The best of the amateur

Prof. Jose Sasian Short Course

Aberrations of aPlane symmetric system

Page 32: Optical Design with Mirrors Jose Sasian · "The world of unobstructed reflecting telescopes," Journal of the Amateur Telescope Makers 1, Fall 1992. Also in “The best of the amateur

Prof. Jose Sasian Short Course

Aberration coefficients

Page 33: Optical Design with Mirrors Jose Sasian · "The world of unobstructed reflecting telescopes," Journal of the Amateur Telescope Makers 1, Fall 1992. Also in “The best of the amateur

Prof. Jose Sasian Short Course

Aberration coefficient calculation

Page 34: Optical Design with Mirrors Jose Sasian · "The world of unobstructed reflecting telescopes," Journal of the Amateur Telescope Makers 1, Fall 1992. Also in “The best of the amateur

Prof. Jose Sasian Short Course

Basic forms of astigmatism

Page 35: Optical Design with Mirrors Jose Sasian · "The world of unobstructed reflecting telescopes," Journal of the Amateur Telescope Makers 1, Fall 1992. Also in “The best of the amateur

Prof. Jose Sasian Short Course

Behavior of coma

Page 36: Optical Design with Mirrors Jose Sasian · "The world of unobstructed reflecting telescopes," Journal of the Amateur Telescope Makers 1, Fall 1992. Also in “The best of the amateur

Prof. Jose Sasian Short Course

Confocal arrangement of mirrors:No aberration along the optical axis ray.

Excellent starting design point

OAR

Use paraboloids, ellipsoids, hyperboloids

Page 37: Optical Design with Mirrors Jose Sasian · "The world of unobstructed reflecting telescopes," Journal of the Amateur Telescope Makers 1, Fall 1992. Also in “The best of the amateur

Prof. Jose Sasian Short Course

Examples

Page 38: Optical Design with Mirrors Jose Sasian · "The world of unobstructed reflecting telescopes," Journal of the Amateur Telescope Makers 1, Fall 1992. Also in “The best of the amateur

Prof. Jose Sasian Short Course

Optical surfaces ....

)11110864

22

2

DhChBhAhhck

chz

Page 39: Optical Design with Mirrors Jose Sasian · "The world of unobstructed reflecting telescopes," Journal of the Amateur Telescope Makers 1, Fall 1992. Also in “The best of the amateur

Prof. Jose Sasian Short Course

Amateur telescopes I

Page 40: Optical Design with Mirrors Jose Sasian · "The world of unobstructed reflecting telescopes," Journal of the Amateur Telescope Makers 1, Fall 1992. Also in “The best of the amateur

Prof. Jose Sasian Short Course

Amateur telescopes II

Page 41: Optical Design with Mirrors Jose Sasian · "The world of unobstructed reflecting telescopes," Journal of the Amateur Telescope Makers 1, Fall 1992. Also in “The best of the amateur

Prof. Jose Sasian Short Course

Double curvature mirrors I

ToroidEllipsoidElliptical paraboloid

Page 42: Optical Design with Mirrors Jose Sasian · "The world of unobstructed reflecting telescopes," Journal of the Amateur Telescope Makers 1, Fall 1992. Also in “The best of the amateur

Prof. Jose Sasian Short Course

Double curvature mirrors II

Page 43: Optical Design with Mirrors Jose Sasian · "The world of unobstructed reflecting telescopes," Journal of the Amateur Telescope Makers 1, Fall 1992. Also in “The best of the amateur

Prof. Jose Sasian Short Course

Double curvature mirrors III

Page 44: Optical Design with Mirrors Jose Sasian · "The world of unobstructed reflecting telescopes," Journal of the Amateur Telescope Makers 1, Fall 1992. Also in “The best of the amateur

Prof. Jose Sasian Short Course

Page 45: Optical Design with Mirrors Jose Sasian · "The world of unobstructed reflecting telescopes," Journal of the Amateur Telescope Makers 1, Fall 1992. Also in “The best of the amateur

Prof. Jose Sasian Short Course

Page 46: Optical Design with Mirrors Jose Sasian · "The world of unobstructed reflecting telescopes," Journal of the Amateur Telescope Makers 1, Fall 1992. Also in “The best of the amateur

Prof. Jose Sasian Short Course

A 1.6 m off-axis paraboloid

R=13 mD=1.6 mE=2.4 m

Page 47: Optical Design with Mirrors Jose Sasian · "The world of unobstructed reflecting telescopes," Journal of the Amateur Telescope Makers 1, Fall 1992. Also in “The best of the amateur

Prof. Jose Sasian Short Course

Confocal system: Cassegrain telescope made unobstructed

Page 48: Optical Design with Mirrors Jose Sasian · "The world of unobstructed reflecting telescopes," Journal of the Amateur Telescope Makers 1, Fall 1992. Also in “The best of the amateur

Prof. Jose Sasian Short Course

Summary

• Comments on several references• Basic review of aberrations• Methods to design un-symmetrical

systems• Examples• Must have a good idea about how the

basics for designing some reflective systems