operations management - iivkteaching.weebly.com/uploads/1/4/3/9/14393508/om_s02e15.pdf ·...
TRANSCRIPT
03-03-2016
1
Session 15
Vinay Kumar Kalakbandi
Assistant Professor
Operations & Systems Area
3/3/2016 Vinay Kalakbandi 1
Operations Management - II Post Graduate Program 2015-17
Agenda
• Up next
• Project presentations
• Recap
• Quality Analytics Simulation - debrief
• Six Sigma essentials
• Lean Management
3/3/2016 Vinay Kalakbandi 2
03-03-2016
2
Rest of the course
• 8th March – Toyota Production system
• 10th March – Esterline technologies
• 11th March – Federal Express + group activity
• 17th March – Cincinnati Children’s Hospital
• 23rd March : Project Presentations
3/3/2016 Vinay Kalakbandi 3
Team project guidelines
• T <= 15 minutes
• Grounded in OM-2 course concepts
• Demonstrated team effort
– You are allowed to disown a team member if he/she
has not contributed
• Not Boring: Role plays, videos, crowd
interaction
• Will be Peer evaluated
3/3/2016 Vinay Kalakbandi 4
03-03-2016
3
Type I Error: False Positive
• Concluding that a process is in control, when it
actually is not
• Caused by control limits that are wider than they
should be
Type II Error: False Negative
• Concluding that a process is out of control
when, in fact, it is in control
• Caused by control limits that are narrower than
they should be
03-03-2016
4
3/3/2016 Vinay Kalakbandi 7
Internal Defect Costs
• The cost of defects discovered before the
product is in the hands of the customers
• Cost of scrapping defective items
– Material
– Labor
• Cost of reworking defective items
03-03-2016
5
External Defect Costs
• The cost of defects discovered after the product
is in the hands of the customers
• Can be very substantial
– Warranty costs
– Recall costs
– Lawsuits
– Negative word of mouth
Appraisal Costs
• The cost of running an internal inspection
operation
• Labor costs for QC inspectors
• Equipment costs, such as gages and
measurement devices
• Destructive testing costs, where applicable
03-03-2016
6
Prevention Costs
• The cost of preventing defects from occurring
• Training costs
• Cost of changing to a more reliable supplier
• Cost of changing to better raw materials
• Investments in equipment
Relationship Between Costs of Quality
• Investments in appraisal
– More defects found before product is in the hands of the customers
– Increases internal defect costs
– Reduces external defect costs
– Reduces the total cost of quality
• Internal defect costs
• External defect costs
• Appraisal costs
• Prevention costs
03-03-2016
7
Relationship Between Costs of Quality
• Investments in prevention
– Produces fewer defects, in the first place
– Reduces internal defect costs
– Reduces the need for investments in appraisal
– Reduces the total cost of quality
• Internal defect costs
• External defect costs
• Appraisal costs
• Prevention costs
Cost of quality
03-03-2016
8
SIX SIGMA
The giant leap approach to quality
3/3/2016 Vinay Kalakbandi 15
Six Sigma Approach to Quality
• Six sigma is an approach to process control first practiced by companies such as General Electric and Motorola to achieve near zero defects in processes
• Elements of six-sigma
– Understanding customer needs well
– Appropriate and disciplined use of data and statistical tools
– Statistical analysis and a closer attention to managing and improving business processes using a set of tools
03-03-2016
9
How is it different from traditional
approach?
• A new metric, Defects Per Million Opportunities, to
predict/assess the quality of a business process
• A new methodology, DMAIC (Define-Measure-
Analyze-Improve-Control), to ensure that very high
levels of quality could be assured in the chosen
business processes thereby generating favourable
outcomes to both the business and the customers
• An organizational framework for ensuring the above
outcomes are generated on a sustained basis
Defects Per Million Opportunities (DPMO)
• It indicates how many defects a process generates in a million opportunities
– While service industries find it convenient to use DPMO, manufacturing organizations use Parts Per Million (PPM). Both are conceptually same.
• If in a process
– “k” Denotes the number of opportunities for making a defect per unit of execution of that process
– “n” Number of units of observation of the process
– “d” Number of defects that occurred in that process during the observation
– The defects per opportunity =
000,000,1*
*
nk
d
03-03-2016
10
DMAIC Methodology
DMAIC Methodology • Define
– Define the problem, the requirements, project scope, project charter
– Set goals for improvement
• Measure
– Identify variables to be measured, the type of measurement
– Data collection and synthesis
• Analyze
– Develop a set of tools for analysis
– Apply graphical tools of analysis
– Identify possible sources of variation and “vital” few root causes
– Explore means of eliminating them
03-03-2016
11
DMAIC Methodology
• Improve
– Generating and validating improvement alternatives
– Creating new process maps for the process
• Control
– Develop control plan
– Establish revised standard measures to maintain performance
– Develop relevant raining plans to maintain standards
Organization for six sigma
• Process Owner
– Supervisor or a manager who takes responsibility for various
steps of a process that is responsible for delivering some
output to the customer. It could be the in a particular work
area where the improvement project has been identified
• Team Leader & Members
– Team leader (the project leader) and the members will
comprise of the employees in the chosen work area
– They will have day-to-day operational control of activities
In six sigma, three terminologies are used to indicate these organizational entities. This includes Master Black Belt, Black Belt and Green Belt.
The depth of training and experience differentiates these three.
03-03-2016
12
Organization for six sigma • Six sigma coach
– A consultant or a senior person in the organization who offers expert knowledge on various aspects of six sigma.
– This includes statistical tools, process design & analysis, change management, small group improvement, use of QC tools for improvement etc.
• Sponsor
– A member of the senior management who oversees the overall progress and implementation
– Helps the team refine the project scope, sorts out issues cutting across other parts of the organization, approves projects and provides the necessary support in terms of resources
Achieving breakthrough improvement
• Six sigma is a project based approach
• Teams embark on six sigma projects only if
breakthrough improvement can be achieved
3/3/2016 Vinay Kalakbandi 24
03-03-2016
13
JIT AND LEAN OPERATIONS
3/3/2016 Vinay Kalakbandi 25
Muda - Waste
3/3/2016 Vinay Kalakbandi 26
03-03-2016
14
Antidote to Muda : Lean thinking
Accurately specify Value
Identify the entire Value stream
Making the value creating steps Flow continuously
Let customer Pull value from the enterprise
Constantly endeavour Perfection
3/3/2016 Vinay Kalakbandi 27
Accurately specify Value
• Defined by the ultimate customer
• Developing products and services from the
perspective of the customer
• Providing wrong good and service the right way
is muda
3/3/2016 Vinay Kalakbandi 28
03-03-2016
15
Identify the entire Value stream
• Value added (VA): Activities are classified as value added as long as the customer is willing to pay for that activity
• Non-value added (NVA): All those activities for which the customer may not want to pay are classified as non-value added activities
• Necessary but non-value added (NNVA): the set of activities that are to be eventually eliminated as and when better systems are developed in an organization
• Value stream: All activities that need to be performed (VA and NNVA) from the time the customer order is received to the time the order is fulfilled will make up the value stream
3/3/2016 Vinay Kalakbandi 29
Making the value creating steps Flow
continuously
• Make the value-creating steps flow evenly
• Three important flows
– Design; Order taking; Production
• Moving away from Batch and queue
– Single piece flow; Takt, quality at source
• Minimizes WIP, process interruptions, lead and
waiting times
• Increases quality and flexibility
3/3/2016 Vinay Kalakbandi 30
03-03-2016
16
Let customer Pull value from the
enterprise
• Customer pulls the product from the production
system rather than pushing products
• Minimizes overproduction, inventory, working
capital
• Use of kanban systems to indicate downstream
demand
• https://youtu.be/ZIv2e61SH1A
3/3/2016 Vinay Kalakbandi 31
Constantly endeavour Perfection
• Achieving zero defects through quality at the source - jidoka
• Continuous incremental improvement of processes
• Previous principles interact with each other in a virtuous circle
• Harder you pull, more the impediments to flow are revealed
• Percolate best practices to the rest of the supply chain
3/3/2016 Vinay Kalakbandi 32
03-03-2016
17
Manufacturing Architectural Changes
Function based structure Product focused structure
grinding milling turning quality
stores materials planning
Marketing
Finance
Sea of waste!
3/3/2016 Vinay Kalakbandi 34