open stent design poster
DESCRIPTION
Open Stent Design poster from FDA / NHLBI / NSF Workshop on Computer Methods for Cardiovascular DevicesTRANSCRIPT
Open Stent DesignCraig Bonsignore
NDC. 47533 Westinghouse Drive. Fremont, CA 95466.
© 2010 NDC. Reuse and adaptation permitted with attribution per the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 United States License 64
Stent Calculator Python Script
© 2010 NDC. Reuse and adaptation permitted with attribution per the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 United States License 65
Input Parameter Variation
0.07
0.08
0.09
0.1
100.0%99.5%97.5%90.0%75.0%50.0%25.0%10.0%2.5%0.5%0.0%
maximum
quartilemedianquartile
minimum
0.101880.094780.092240.088770.08571
0.08220.078870.075680.072450.06979
0.0654
Quantiles
MeanStd DevStd Err MeanUpper 95% MeanLower 95% MeanN
0.08227060.00504120.00007130.08241040.0821309
5000
Moments
w_strut
0.1
0.11
0.12
0.13
100.0%99.5%97.5%90.0%75.0%50.0%25.0%10.0%2.5%0.5%0.0%
maximum
quartilemedianquartile
minimum
0.129420.123570.120640.117270.114360.111030.107640.104510.10118
0.09790.09246
Quantiles
MeanStd DevStd Err MeanUpper 95% MeanLower 95% MeanN
0.11098170.00497977.0423e-50.11111970.1108436
5000
Moments
t
26
27
28
29
100.0%99.5%97.5%90.0%75.0%50.0%25.0%10.0%2.5%0.5%0.0%
maximum
quartilemedianquartile
minimum
28.981228.303927.980827.637227.348227.007726.678426.373126.033625.742325.2261
Quantiles
MeanStd DevStd Err MeanUpper 95% MeanLower 95% MeanN
27.0101970.497228
0.007031927.02398326.996412
5000
Moments
Af
5.6
5.8
6
6.2
6.4
6.6
6.8
7
7.2
7.4
100.0%99.5%97.5%90.0%75.0%50.0%25.0%10.0%2.5%0.5%0.0%
maximum
quartilemedianquartile
minimum
7.470987.122316.987446.814386.672216.506466.334046.184136.021625.855845.58439
Quantiles
MeanStd DevStd Err MeanUpper 95% MeanLower 95% MeanN
6.50358340.24627380.00348286.51041136.4967555
5000
Moments
D_ves
Distributions
© 2010 NDC. Reuse and adaptation permitted with attribution per the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 United States License 66
Performance Output Variation
23
25
27
29
31
33
35
37
39
41
43
100.0%99.5%97.5%90.0%75.0%50.0%25.0%10.0%2.5%0.5%0.0%
maximum
quartilemedianquartile
minimum
43.71140.672838.959437.077935.428533.577131.8344
30.24528.5801
27.18923.0055
Quantiles
MeanStd DevStd Err MeanUpper 95% MeanLower 95% MeanN
33.6419532.64853090.037455933.71538333.568523
5000
Moments
mass
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
100.0%99.5%97.5%90.0%75.0%50.0%25.0%10.0%2.5%0.5%0.0%
maximum
quartilemedianquartile
minimum
0.866310.693050.625510.560280.499340.440510.386890.342040.295760.268790.19739
Quantiles
MeanStd DevStd Err MeanUpper 95% MeanLower 95% MeanN
0.4467240.08460350.00119650.44906960.4443784
5000
Moments
RF_hoop
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
180
200
220
240
100.0%99.5%97.5%90.0%75.0%50.0%25.0%10.0%2.5%0.5%0.0%
maximum
quartilemedianquartile
minimum
239.065210.871185.473163.718146.462127.811110.67996.092381.183767.417444.0718
Quantiles
MeanStd DevStd Err MeanUpper 95% MeanLower 95% MeanN
129.2784526.8142490.3792107130.02187128.53503
5000
Moments
P_contact
0.0040.0050.0060.0070.0080.0090.01
0.0110.0120.0130.0140.0150.0160.0170.0180.019
100.0%99.5%97.5%90.0%75.0%50.0%25.0%10.0%2.5%0.5%0.0%
maximum
quartilemedianquartile
minimum
0.019290.017160.015820.014470.013270.011880.010580.009420.008040.006930.00429
Quantiles
MeanStd DevStd Err MeanUpper 95% MeanLower 95% MeanN
0.01192480.00197162.7882e-50.01197940.0118701
5000
Moments
strain_mean
0.0013
0.0014
0.0015
0.0016
0.0017
0.0018
100.0%99.5%97.5%90.0%75.0%50.0%25.0%10.0%2.5%0.5%0.0%
maximum
quartilemedianquartile
minimum
0.001810.001710.001670.001620.001580.001540.001490.00145
0.00140.001370.00131
Quantiles
MeanStd DevStd Err MeanUpper 95% MeanLower 95% MeanN
0.0015390.00006699.4597e-70.00154090.0015372
5000
Moments
strain_amplitude
2.2
2.3
2.4
2.5
2.6
2.7
2.8
2.9
3
100.0%99.5%97.5%90.0%75.0%50.0%25.0%10.0%2.5%0.5%0.0%
maximum
quartilemedianquartile
minimum
3.047662.924132.849172.753682.678072.599382.525022.462352.397312.339632.20963
Quantiles
MeanStd DevStd Err MeanUpper 95% MeanLower 95% MeanN
2.60400630.11379180.00160932.60716112.6008514
5000
Moments
N_sf
Distributions
© 2010 NDC. Reuse and adaptation permitted with attribution per the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 United States License 67
Predicting Relationships: Radial Force vs. Mass
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
RF_h
oop
23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44
mass
Polynomial Fit Degree=2
RF_hoop = -0.55894 + 0.0297866*mass + 0.0005111*(mass-33.642)^2
RSquareRSquare AdjRoot Mean Square ErrorMean of ResponseObservations (or Sum Wgts)
0.880790.8807420.0292170.446724
5000
Summary of Fit
Polynomial Fit Degree=2
Bivariate Fit of RF_hoop By mass
© 2010 NDC. Reuse and adaptation permitted with attribution per the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 United States License 68
Fatigue Performance: Constant Life Diagram
0.0013
0.0014
0.0015
0.0016
0.0017
0.0018
strain_amplitude
0.004 0.006 0.007 0.008 0.009 0.01 0.011 0.012 0.013 0.014 0.015 0.016 0.017 0.018 0.019
strain_mean
Bivariate Fit of strain_amplitude By strain_mean
© 2010 NDC. Reuse and adaptation permitted with attribution per the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 United States License 73
NitinolUniversity.com
© 2010 NDC. Reuse and adaptation permitted with attribution per the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 United States License
Open Stent Design: The Book
70
© 2010 NDC. Reuse and adaptation permitted with attribution per the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 United States License
Open Stent Design: SolidWorks
71
© 2010 NDC. Reuse and adaptation permitted with attribution per the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 United States License
Open Stent Design: Calculator
72
CHAPTER 4. STENT CALCULATOR FORMULAS 53
4.10 Force and Strain Calculations
The relationships between stress, load, deflection, and strain have been thoroughly docu-mented for a variety of beam loading conditions. Force and strain related to a specifiedstrut deflection are based on the formulation for a beam fixed at one end, and free butguided at the other as documented in Machinery’s Handbook [1].
E = modulus of elasticity
I = moment of inertia, beam cross sectionw = strut widthL = strut length
Strain = ! =3wL2 "#
Force = F =12EIL3 !"
FL2
FL2
F
F L
Figure 4.5: Beam fixed at one end, and free but guided at the other.
Fhoop is the hoop component of the force exerted by a single strut when the stent isconstrained from the fully expanded state to the analysis diameter. This is equal to Fin Figure 4.5 by the definition of the ”free but guided” beam as described in Machinery’s
Handbook [1].
Fhoop =12 · E · I(Lstrut)
3 · δd
Fhoop = 1.03 · 10−1 N
(4.78)
Fhoop 1mm is the hoop component of the force exerted by a single strut when the stentis constrained from the fully expanded state to a diameter one millimeter less than theanalysis diameter. This allows for later calculation of stent forces normalized per millimeterdiameter constraint.
Fhoop 1mm =12 · E · I(Lstrut)
3 · δ1mm
Fhoop 1mm = 6.92 · 10−2 N
(4.79)
CHAPTER 4. STENT CALCULATOR FORMULAS 54
�d is the maximum strain experienced within the strut when the stent is constrained fromthe fully expanded state to the analysis diameter. This is equal to epsilon in Figure 4.5by the definition of the ”free but guided” beam as described in Machinery’s Handbook
[1].
�d =3wstrut
(Lstrut)2 · δd
�d = 1.64 %
(4.80)
�1mm is the maximum strain experienced within the strut when the stent is constrainedfrom the fully expanded state to one millimeter less than the analysis diameter.
�1mm =3wstrut
(Lstrut)2 · δ1mm
�1mm = 1.10 %
(4.81)
4.11 Pressure and Stiffness Calculations
In this section, the forces and other calculations derived above are used to estimate radialresistive force in terms that are common for bench testing.
RFhoop is the hoop component of the force exerted when the stent is constrained from thefully expanded state to 1mm less than the expansion diameter, normalized by length incentimeters. This value is consistent with radial resistive force type measurement (RRF)generated from a collar type fixture. By convention, it is expressed in terms of Newtonsper centimeter length, and is thus normalized by length.
RFhoop =Fhoop 1mm
Xcell·�10 · mm
cm
�
RFhoop = 0.44 N/cm
(4.82)
RFtrf is the true radial component of the force exerted when the stent is constrained fromthe fully expanded state to 1mm less than the expanded diameter, normalized by length incentimeters. This value is consistent with radial resistive force type measurement (RRF)generated from a Blockwise or MSI type testing fixture. This is also expressed in terms ofnewtons per centimeter length, and is thus also normalized by length, and evaluated for a1mm diameter constraint.
Cardiovascular stents are widely used to treat a variety of vascular diseases. Hun-dreds of designs have been proposed, devel-oped, and commercialized since the 1990’s when these devices became commonplace in clinical practice. Competitive pressures in the commercial marketplace have been intense, and many battles have been waged relating to stent design intellectual property. Naturally, tools, techniques, and resources for stent design have been closely guarded and proprietary.
For all the differences between the myri-ad stents that have been designed and pro-duced over the years, the fundamental archi-tecture of most expandable stent designs is actually quite universal. Stents can be con-sidered to be an array of structural beams, connected in a series to form a circumfer-entially expandable spring. As such, these structures can be modeled using analytical tools to predict many relevant performance characteristics with reasonable accuracy.
Open Stent Design is a manuscript draft be-ing developed by NDC to provide general guidance for design and development of a simple, generic Nitinol stent. The manuscript and related resources are freely available to the community under a Creative Com-mons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 United States license. Resources provided include a detailed parametrically driven CAD solid
model to create flat and wrapped stent ge-ometry, available for download in its na-tive SolidWorks format. Also available are a spreadsheet based Stent Calculator appli-cation, which can be used to relate input parameters such as tubing diameter, strut length, strut width, and wall thickness to performance predictions including service strains, radial strength, and pulsatile fatigue performance. Additional resources in de-velopment include a Python script to au-tomate the stent calculator application, en-abling statistical interrogation of thousands of possible conditions within expected de-sign limits. Finite Element Analysis tem-plates are also being developed to comple-ment the analytical models.
These resources are provided freely to the community to make stent development eas-ier and more approachable for new entrants in the field, and thus encourage continuing innovation, improvements, and progress. We hope that these tools are especially help-ful for researchers in academia seeking to study stents and related structures, and re-lated biomechanics, fluid flow, or other phe-nomena.
These resources are available for download at NDC’s educational website:
http://NitinolUniversity.com