oo investigation of turbulent £ heat transfer at … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 ›...

233
AFFDL-TR-67-144 Volume III oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT HYPERSONIC SPEEDS to ^f< Volume in. The Laminar-Turbulent p T n r Momentum Integral and Turbulent Nonsimilar Boundary Layer Computer Programs R. T. Savage V^ » ±jm JäGCK J. R. Mitchell THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December 1967 This document has been approved for public release and sale; its distribution is unlimited. Air Force Flight Dynamics Laboratory Air Force Systems Command Wright-Patterson Air Force Base, Ohio Roproduced by fho CLEARINGHOUSE for Fodorjil Scientific & Technical !"'ormstion Spnngfioid V<i 22551 r D D C [ii Wl 1968 (ijl C 23-2.

Upload: others

Post on 07-Jul-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

AFFDL-TR-67-144 Volume III

oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT

£ HEAT TRANSFER AT HYPERSONIC SPEEDS to

^f< Volume in. The Laminar-Turbulent pTnr Momentum Integral and Turbulent Nonsimilar Boundary Layer Computer Programs

R. T. Savage V^ » ±jm JäGCK

J. R. Mitchell

THE BOEING COMPANY

TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III

December 1967

This document has been approved for public release and sale; its distribution is unlimited.

Air Force Flight Dynamics Laboratory Air Force Systems Command

Wright-Patterson Air Force Base, Ohio

Roproduced by fho CLEARINGHOUSE

for Fodorjil Scientific & Technical !"'ormstion Spnngfioid V<i 22551

r D D C

[ii Wl 1968 (ijl

C

23-2.

Page 2: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

...

THIS DOCUMENT IS BEST QUALITY AVAILABLE. THE COPY

FURNISHED TO DTIC CONTAINED

A SIGNIFICANT NUMBER OF

PAGES WHICH DO NOT

REPRODUCE LEGIBLYo

Page 3: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT

HEAT TRANSFER AT HYPERSONIC SPEEDS

Volume III. The Laminar-Turbulent PrPr Momentum Integral and Turbulent Nonsimilar Boundary Layer Computer Programs

R. T. Savage C. L. Jaeck J. R. Mitchell

This document has been approved for public release and sale; its distribution is unlimited.

Page 4: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

NOTICES

When Government drawings, specifications, or other data are used for any purpose other than in connection with a definitely related Government procurement operation, the United States Government thereby incurs no responsibility nor any obligation whatsoever; and the fact that the Government may have formulated, furnished, or in any way supplied the said drawings, specifications, or other data, is not to be regarded by implication or otherwise as in any manner licensing the holder or any other person or corporation, or conveying any rights or permission to manufacture, use, or sell any patented invention that may in any way be related thereto.

MCESUMftr

tmt nm «im s ' NC mvama ntrnwa a jutTmnw

wsniMTioii/iwiuiiiin eooB

m. 1 AVAIL Ut/m VECMLj

/

Copies of this report should not be returned to the Air Force Flight Dynamics Laboratory unless return is required by security considerations, contractual obliga- tion, or notice on a specific document.

Page 5: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

AFFDL-TR-67-i44 D2-113531-3 Volume 111

; FOREWORD

This report was prepared by the Space Division, Aerospace Group of The I Boeing Company, Seattle, Washington, under direction of Messrs. A. L. Nagel j and V. Deriugln, program managers. The contract was initiated under BPSN

5(611366-62405334), Project 1366 Hypersonic Gas Dynamic Heating. Task 136607 Aerodynamics and Flight Mechanics. USAF Contract AF33(615)-2372, Investiga- tion of Turbulent Heat Transfer at Hypersonic Speeds. The work was adminis- tered by the Air Force Flight Dynamics Laboratory, Air Force Systems Command, Wright-Pattersoi. Air Force Base, Ohio. Mr. Richard D. Neumann (FDMG) was the Air Force project engineer.

Results obtained during this program are published in three volumes. Volume I, Analytical Methods; Volume II, Analysis of Heat Transfer and Pres- sure Data on a Flat Plate, Cone, Ogive, Cylindrical Leading Edge, Blunt Delta Wing, and X-15 Aircraft; and Volume III, The Laminar-Turbulent pivr Momentum Integral and Turbulent Nonslmllar Boundary Layer Computer Programs. Boeing document numbers assigned to these volumes are D2-113531-1, -2, and -3, re- spectively.

| This report covers work conducted between March 1963 and March 1967. The | report was submitted by the authors in May 1967.

I The authors acknowledge Barbara J. Safley for her exceptional effort in generating and editing the figures contained in this report.

This technical report has been reviewed and is approved.

PM» ffat^rfr. V. PHILIP^P. ANT0NAT0S Chief, Flight Mechanics Division Air Force Flight Dynamics Laboratory

11

Page 6: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

ABSTRACT

This report presents a combined analytical and experimental investigation of turbulent heat transfer on basic and composite configurations at hypersonic speeds. The analytical results are presented in Volume I, the experimental results, including data-theory comparisons, are presented in Volume II, and computer programs incor- porating the analytical methods described herein are presented in Volume in.

The two heat-transfer prediction methods programmed are the laminar-turbulent Pr^r momentum integral method and the turbulent nonsimilar boundary layer method. This volume of the report describes the numerical method and presents flow charts, program listings, input forms, and a description of the output lor each program. The programs are written in Fortran IV language for operation or. the IBM 7094.

iii

Page 7: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Page

I INTRODUCTION 1

II THE LAMINAR-TURBULENT MOMENTUM INTEGRAL COMPUTER PROGRAM (Pr»ir) 3

1. DISCUSSION 3

3 9 9

2. PrPr PROGRAM DESCRIPTION 11

12 13

13 13 17 19 21 22 26

26 28 29 31 32 36 37 39 40 42 43 53 56 58 59 60 60 63 65 66 66 66

a. Method of Solution b. PrM r Program Schematic c. Nomenclature

pr Pr PROGRAM DESCRIPTION

a. PrM r Flow Chart b. Subroutines

1) ATMOS 2) AXI2D (Option D-l) 3) BEQI 4) CYLIND (Option D-3) 5) DBTP 6) DELTA (Option D-4) 7) DERV

8) DIVERG

9) DSIRCH 10) EBAR

H) FIND 12) FLOW (Program B) 13) HEMI (Option D-2) 14) INTIAL 15) IWALL 16) JAYELL 17) MUZERO 18) QTRANS (Program A) 19) REF 20) RORMUR 21) SIRCH 22) SOMEGA 23) SONENT 24) STACON 25) STREAM (Program C) 26) TABLE2 27) TABLE6 28) TABLE7 29) TABL14

Page 8: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

s

TABLE OF CONTENTS (Continued)

Paiie e1

30) TABI18 67 31) TABJ.-19 67 32) TAEL20 68 33) TBLP 68

3. INPUT-OUTPUT DESCRIPTION 69

a. Data Input Preparation 69

1) Axisymmetric or two-dimensional bodies (Option D-l) 69

2) Hemisphere (Option D-2) 74 3) Swept infinite cylinder (Option D-3) 77 4) Sharp delta wing (Option D-4) 81 5) Streamline calculations (Program C) 87 6) Reference calculations (Program REF) 93 7) Boundary layer calculations (Program B) 95 8) Heat transfer calculations (Program A) 99

b. Output Description 104 c. Error Statements 108

4, PROGRAMMING INFORMATION 110

a. p ^ Program Listing 110 b. prLir Deck Setup 182

HI THE TURBULENT NONSIMILAR BOUNDARY LAYER PROGRAM (MSBL) 186

1. NOMENCLATURE 186

2. METHOD OF SOLUTION 189

a. Forward Integration 189 b. Numerical Method of Solution 191

1) Calc.ilation of tabular values 192 2) Values obtained from tables 192 3) Computation at initial x = x 192 4) Calculation of ÖT) J 193 5) Calculation of y-derivatives and v-profile 193 6) Cf.lculation of x derivatives 196 7) Calculation of 6*. 0, Q^, TW L, and Tw T at x 196 8) Calculation of u and I-profiles at x + Ax 196

Stagnation Region Calculation 197

VI

Page 9: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

3.

TABLE OF CONTENTS (Concluded)

INPUT-OUTPUT DESCRIPTION

a. Data Input Preparation

1) Data card formats 2) Case dependence

b. Output Description c. NSBL Input Form

4. PROGRAMMING INFORMATION

a. b.

REFERENCES

NSBL Flow Chart NSBL Program Listing

Page

19H

19H

19H 203

204 205

206

206 207

222

Figure

1.

2,

3.

4,

LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS

Pressure distributions on a hemisphere and unswept infinite cylinder

Boeing modified Newtonian hypersonic pressure coefficients

Streamline correlation for sharp delta wings

Correction factor for the velov ity gradient at a hemisphere stagnation point or cylinder stagnation line

Streamlines near the apex of a sharp delta wing

24

62

H2

VI i

Page 10: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

SECTION I

INTRODUCTION

Two methods for the calculation of turbulent heating rates are discussed in Volume I of this report, the laminar-turbulent momentum integral method (prMr) and the nonsimilar method for turbulent boundary layers (NSBL).

This volume describes the computer program for each method. A description of the numerical method is given as well as flow charts, program listings, input preparation, and output description.

The first computer program was written incorporating the Pr^r heat transfer prediction method developed by R. A. Hanks of The Boeing Company. The method was developed in the course of the X-20 program and finalized under NASA Research Contract No. NAS 8-11321 (Reference 1). In addition to the PrHr method calculations, the program also contains subprograms for calculating pressures, gas properties, and streamline patterns for several special cases. The SRU 1108 version of the pro- gram was written during Boeing Company-funded research and converted to the IBM 7094 during this Air Force Flight Dynamics-funded study.

The program has four major sections. Program A contains the method per se. Given the external flow properties and wall condition, this section of the program computes laminar or turbulent heating rates. All required gas properties are com- puted by the program from the given pressure and edge velocity. The effect of tran- sition is estimated by matching laminar and turbulent boundary layer momentum thicknesses at the transition point. The point of transition is determined by the pro- gram on the basis of a transition Reynolds number selected by the user. Program A can be applied to any geometry for which the external flow properties including nonisothermal wall effects can be defined by the user.

The second section, Program B, computes the local velocities and static tempera- tures along a streamline from a given pressure distribution.

If the streamline divergence is not known. Program C can be used to obtain this information. Program C calculates the path of two streamlines, the streamline of interest and one below, given a two-dimensional array of streamline angles. With two streamline paths known, the divergence parameter can be computed. This calcu- lation, however, assumes zero divergence due to body geometry.

The fourth section of the computer program, called D, calculates or provides information for the three previous subprograms for four special cases; the axisym- metric and two-dimensional body, the hemisphere, the swept cylinder, and the sharp delta wing.

Page 11: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

The second computer program, the turbulent nonsimilar boundary layer, inte- grates the boundary layer partial differential equations (described in Appendix C of Volume I) using finite difference methods. The program can calculate the turbulent boundary layer on unyawed sharp or blunt axisymmetric or two-dimensional bodies. Three-dimensional flow effects are calculated using the zero crossflow pressure gradient approximation which implies no rotation of the velocity vectors within the boundary layer. Tl.e program is also limited to attached flow in air. which is con- sidered as ideal gas.

The program is capable of initiating its own boundary layer solutions, given only external flow properties, for the stagnation point of either sharp or blunt tip cones and plates.

Special inputs required are: pressure, wall enthalpy, a three-dimensional flow parameter and its derivative, the velocity gradient at the boundary layer edge and the normal velocity at the surface, all functions of the streamwise distance x. The user must also specify an initial and final value of x, the value of the x increments, and printout Information.

Output includes streamwise and normal velocity, temperature, total and static enthalpy, shear, heat transfer rate, a similarity parameter, and x derivatives of velocity and total enthalpy. These values are tabulated as functions of y (normal to surface) at each output position. Also printed In the output are the shear and heat transfer rate at the wall, and the boundary layer displacement and momentum thickness.

The Pr l^r progi'am requires about 0.5 to 1 minute of computer time per case, while the nonsimilar program requires 2 to 3 minutes for a flat plate case. The time estimate can vary and depends largely on the type of case.

Page 12: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

SFCTIOX II

THE LAMINAR-TURBULENT MOMENTUM INTEGRAL COMPUTER PROGRAM (PrMr)

1. DISCUSSION

The computer pi-ogram described in this report is based on the Hanks PrHT

method of solution to the boundary layer momentum integral equation; and, as such, contains all of the assumptions pertaining to the method as discussed in References 1, 2, 3, and Volume I. The program calculates aerodynnmic heating on arbitrary bodies, with or without streamwise pressure gradients in laminar or turbulent flow. Three-dimensional flow effects are included in the form of streamlinf divergence due to body geometry (r) and crossflow or transverse pressure gradients (f)- The effect of a nonisothermal wall on aerodynamic heating is also calculated with modified methods of Ligbthill and Seban. This is discussed in further detail in Reference 1. The program described herein is applicable only to air in chemical equilibrium (References 4-7).

a. Method of Solution

The Pr^r integral program is actually four programs, any of which can be oper- ated separately. The first program, Program A, calculates heating rates for any body shape at any flight or ground-facility test condition given the external flow proper- ties, gas properties at the wall, gas properties at the stagnation condition, total streamline divergence and the streamline divergence due to body geometry alone.

Program A has an additional capability of calculating transition effects based on a transition Reynolds number selected by the user. The program matches laminar and turbulent boundary layer momentum thicknesses at the transition point.

In addition, the program calculates reference bent transfer coefficients which are used to normalize the calculated local heat transfer coefficients. The laminar heat transfer coefficients are all normalized by the value of the hemisphere stagnation- point heat transfer coefficient evaluated at the same free stream conditions as the body of interest. The heat transfer coefficient on the stagnation line of a GO0 swept infinite cylinder is used to normalize all turbulent heat transfer coefficients. The hemisphere and cylinder radius are items of input.

Program B calculates the boundary edge velocity and temperature given the pressure distribution along the streamline or body.

Page 13: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

Program C computes streamwise pressure and divergence parameters given a two-dimensional field of pressures and streamline angles. Since pressure data and streamline angles are often most easily available as spanwise plots at various stations, considerable crossplotting is required to provide specific values along the streamline passing over any specified point on the body. This work is performed by Program C, which begins at the point for which the user desires to calculate the heating rate, and traces out the streamline, proceedmg upstream to a specified boundary (e.g., the boundary layer origin). The streamline angle is determined by double interpolation of a two-dimensional array of angles which is input. The streamline angle is then used to determine the coordinates of a point on the streamline a distance dx upstream. This procedure is repeated until the upstream boundary is reached.

|,feet

It also interpolates as required to obtain initial values at the upstream boundary of the input array (4, 1) thus providing all information required for Program B.

Program D provides the pressure aad streamline arrays and initial values required by Programs A, B, and C for several specific bodies. These optional configurations are:

D-l Arbitrary two-dimensional bodies at an angle of attack and arbitrary axi- symmetric bodies at zero angle of attack. The bodies may be sharp or blunt and composed of wedges and plates or cones and cylinders.

D-2 Hemisphere

D-3 Swept infinite cylinder (0 < A < 90°)

D-4 Sharp delta wing (60° < A < 80' and o > 0)

Page 14: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

For options D-l and D-2. the user provides a table of body width or radius at various locations along the axis. For options D-2 and D-3. the cylinder or hemis- phere diameter must be input and for options D-3 and D-4. the cylinder or delta wing sweep angle must be provided. For option D-4 the angle of attack must be stated. In all options, the user provides the free stream conditions.

Options D-2 and D-3 (hemisphere and swept infinite cylinder) use pressure distri- butions stored within the program. These distributions are shown in Figure 1. Options D-l and D-4 calculate pressures from the local flow deflection angle and a modified Newtonian pressure expression. For Ö > 0

2 sin" 6

1. or, 1.1025 (•"W sinö)'

1/2 , 0.. . 2^ 1.2<s sin ^

M 0.6

(1)

and for 6 « 0

sin" 6 (2)

This approximate analytical method was devised for predicting pressures from the Newtonian relationship in which K is allowed to vary.

C, P

K sin o (3)

The relationship for K was chosen to obtain the best agreement with the exact solutions for a wedge, cone, and blunt body stagnation point. A plot of the modified pressure coefficients is shown in Figure 2.

The D options also provide velocity and streamline angle distributions along a streamline. In option D-l, the velocity is computed from

1/2 if P

initial 328 P (4)

and

u = a' — e x

sonic point if P. .L. , > .528 P

iiutial o X < X

(5)

sonic point

Page 15: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

1.0

.9

.8

.7

.6

.5

.4

.1

.09

.08

.07

.06

.05

.04 0

l^-"1 "^ 1 ___ J ^"""N

\ N, V

1 ■ II

I j I

-V i 1

1

1

^ \k 1 : ' \ A^T ^ 1 i

i j

1 ! \ V§ '

j , \ \ ^ i i i

i 1 \ V

1 1 L \ "* I 1 I 1

1 i ' \ \^

• 1 i

i \^ \ I \ w \ 1

i h - [ - i \ " \ L ..____

i ! y \l\ 1 \M i i -A ȊJ

■ ■

1 10 20 30 40 50

6, degrees

60 70 80 90

Figure 1: PRESSURE DISTRIBUTION ON A HEMISPHERE AND UNSWtPT INFINITE CYLINDER (REF. 3)

Page 16: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

o CM

00

's c

« JC

i 0 8 8: o

8 II '*

!

5

1

/ CM

/ o

I \

CO

iv / V

i, A 'O

> 1^ ,bxi

A CM

o

——

CO I—

UJ

o

O O UJ OH

on to UJ

a. o

O CO

c Q- •?. >-

«I O

o o

o

o CO

o ■

n oo

CN

o CM CN CN

O

CN

CO

Q. U CN

Page 17: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

and

u = a* i e

6 1 ■ (kf .1/2

X > X sonic point

(6)

where a* is the velocity at the sonic point

Program options D-2 and D-3 obtain the edge velocity by integration of the pres- sure gradient ?long the streamline, while D-4 calculates ue from

u = u e «o

1 - 5600 (7)

The development of Equation (7) is presented in detail in Reference 3.

In addition, options D-3 and D-4 for the swept cylinder and delta wing also provide a two-dimensional array of streamline angles. The streamlines angles on the swept cylinder are obtained from

tan 0 = :—- e u_ sin A (8)

where the spanwise velocity ve is obtained by integration of the pressure gradient normal to the leading edge. Delta wing streamline angles are obtained from a corre- lation curve and

/d0\ R +

CL LE

(90 -A) m B9

CL (9)

where

tan R = (I)

tan /90 - A\ ' 57.3 /

PcL is the gradient of the streamline angle with

respect to the ray angle e

The streamline angle distribution across the wlug span is a curve fit obtained by matching the boundary conditions given by the angle and the gradient at the centerline and the angle at the leading edge. The calculations of program D are necessarily some' what approximate since exact flow field calculations are possible for only a few simple geometries. The approximations used in program D are those discussed in Reference 1 and are simple yet reasonably accurate.

8

Page 18: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

Program D is easily modified and extended as more information becomes available, or as certain specific shapes become important.

b. Pr^r Prosra"1 Schematic

The relation of the four programs is illustrated on the following page: however, it should be understood that all four programs are coupled and function together as a single program when desired. The symbol OR indicates that the required data can come from either of the indicated sources.

c. Nomenclature

a* sonic velocity

Cp pressure coefficient

f streamline divergence due to crossflow pressure gradients

AI free stream Mach number 00

P local pressure

P stagnation point pressure o

P stagnation point or stagnation line pressure 2

streamline divergence due to body geometry

u boundary layer edge velocity

u free stream velocity

v spamvise velocity at the boundary layer edge

x distance along a streamline

6 local flow deflection angle measured from the free stream velocity vector

A total streamline divergence, includes body geometry and crossflow pres- sure gradients (rf)

e ray angle on a delta wing

9 angular location

Page 19: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

INPUT

• Geometry • Test condition • Wall temperature • Transition Reynolds

number • Printout information

4 f PROGRAM D\

♦ D-l Axisymmetric or two-

dimensional D-2 Hemisphere D-3 Swept infinite cylinder D-4 Sharp d el to wing

<

1 Output from Pr ogram D OR I input to Program C

• Test condition • V/all temperature • Pressure • Streamline angle • Streamline divergence

due to body geometry • Transition Reynolds

number

i '

f PROGRAM C^)

i ' Output from Program C OR

input to Program B • Test condition • Wall temperature • Pressure • Streamline angle • Streamline divergence

due to body geometry « Streamline divergence

due to crossflow pressure gradients

• Transition Reynolds \ number

f PROGRAM B^)

\ Output from Program B OR

input to Program A • Wall temperature • Pressure • Streamline angle • Streamline divergence

due to body geometry • Streamline divergence

due to crossflow pressure gradients

• Transition Reynolds number

• _dge velocity • Edge enthalpy

| • Edge temperature • Edge viscosity

(^PROGRAM A^

Output from Program A • Heat transfer coefficient • Skin-friction coefficient • Heating rate • Shear stress

10

Page 20: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

0 local streamline angle

A leading edge sweep angle

(|,T)) coordinate system

pr^r density-viscosity product evaluated at a reference condition

2. PrMr PROGRAM DESCRIPTION

Presented in the following section is a description of the program and subroutines. Equations, nomenclature input, and output from each subroutine are presented in alphabetical order by the subroutine title.

Before proceeding, a description of the program coordinate system is required. The program operates in a two-dimensional curvilinear coordinate system where the coordinate axes are designated as TJ and |. Restrictions on this coordinate svstem are:

lc t) and ^ are orthogonal.

2. Both T} and ^ must be parallel to the surface over which the boundary layer flow is being considered, and

3. i is taken to be in the general direction of the fluid flow.

Thus, no coordinate axis projects outward or normal from the surface area. In the case of a flat surface, T? and ^ will lie in the same plane.

CYLINDER

x, streamline distance

FLAT PL^"E

II

Page 21: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

a. P w Program Flow Chart

INTIAL 1 r-SONENT * L-ATMOS

L-STAnON i

REF

-RORMUR

-SOMEGA—rTABLE 2 LTABL18

-TABLES IWALL- -SOMEGA—I-TABLE2

LTABL 18

T TABL 14 TABL 19 TABL20

-JAYELL

MUZERO—TABLE?

STACON SOMEGA

SOMEGA-r TABLE 2 LTABL 18

—r TABLE 2 LTABL 18

•-EBAR- -SOMEGA—T-TABLE2 LTABL18

DELTA K TBLP DBTP- -TBLP

CYLIND TBLP -FLOW i: SOMEGA—r TABLE 2

Li •TABL18 DERV

dsTREAMf—rFIND 1 J '-TBLP

•DSTP-

HEMI h-

Ü-r- Li

TBLP OIVERG

HAXI2D f i-TBLP c

h TBLP DBTP STREAM

"TBLP

TBLP -FIND -TBLP

DBTP TBLP

FLOW

SOMEGA-rTABLE 2 TABL IS T

h DERV SOMEGA-rTABLE 2

LTABL 18

^j BEOI [—pDERV

[OTRANS —pDERV -I WALL- -TABLE 6

-SOMEGA-T-TABLE 2 LTABL 18

-RORMURxTABL 14 kTABL 19 l-TABL 20

-iWALL TABLE 6 -SOMEGA-r-TABLE 2

•-TABL 18

-RORMUR-i-TABL 14 hTABL 19 l~TABL 20

EBAR —SOMEGA-rTABLE 2 LTABL 18

-EBAR- -SOMEGA—i-TABLE 2 L'

JAYELL-

'-MUZERO-

-SOMEGA-r-TABLE 2 L'

-TABLE?

TABL 18

TABLE 2 TABL18

12

Page 22: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

b. Subroutines

The main program of the laminar-turbulent Pr^r momentum integral computer program —II (AS2419) —controls the input and the logic flow to the required mathe- matical subroutines. The input logic is arranged to minimize the modification required to change the input formats or the source of inputs (e. g., tape input or direct coupling to another program).

1) ATMOS(ALT, SONIC, PINF, RHO, TEMP)

Given the altitude, ATMOS calculates the free stream conditions. This subroutine is program AS1772, "Standard Atmosphere Properties, 1962".

t Input

ALT altitude, ft

Output

SONIC aÄ

PINF P«

RHO P«

TEMP T

free-stream velocity of sound, ft/sec

free-stream pressure, lb/ft

free-stream density, slug/ft^

free-stream temperature, "R

2) AXI2D (Option D-l)

AXI2D calculates the flow conditions for arbitrary axisymmetric and two- dimensional geometries using the following procedure:

(a) With the geometry specified by the coordinates (^j, yj), the slopes and pres- sures are assumed to occur midway between the input geometry points.

yi+l " yi

i+i M

i;;

Page 23: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

Where y is the local body coordinate:

and

r O r

Xi+l/2 = Xi-l/2 + [(yi+l/2 " yi-l/2) + (5i+l/2 " ti-l/2)

1y 2 i 2 4-M sin 6 + 1

äin 0

where

C,

. 2X sm 6 = 0 for Ö £ 0

. 2. sm 6

= 1.05 + 1.1025 + 2 2

M^ sin 6 .

1/2 1.278 sin 6

M .6

for 6 > 0

The end points Xv and Xf and the pressures at the end points are found by linear extrapolation.

(b) If P at either end point is less than P^, set the respective P = ?„. If P at either end point is greater than P0, set the respective P = P0.

(c) Initialize x* = Xj and calculate the flow conditions at each increment dx along the streamline

x* = x* + dx i > 2 1 i-l

14

Page 24: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

Linear interpolation is performed to find P/PSL(X*) at each x* using the tables of P and x calculated previously.

If P(x,) < . 528 P0

^»'"-['-(i-1)^ ll/2

If P(xi) > .528 P0 find the sonic location X* where P = .528 P0 from interpolation of the x and P tables. Then

a*x u (x*) = —— when x < X* e X*

-U-^ri! ue(x*) a i m\ 1/2

when x > X*

1/2 a* = (H/3) Sonic velocity

The remaining flow conditions are calculated from

A. i

(x*) =1.0

(x*) =1.0

Two-dimensional body

A(X*) = y(x*)

(x*) = y{x*)

Axisymmetric body

ie(x*)

w (x*) e

ZT (x*) e

H - I UeV)

f(P/PSL(x*). ie(x*)) j

f(p/?SL(x*), yx*)) [SOMEGA]

15

Page 25: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

(d) Step (c) is repeated until the flow properties have been calculated for all points on the streamline.

Input

H H

XSI 4

Y yU)

XI xi

DX dx

POPSL Po/pSL

ACH M«

PINF P«

Output

II

XSTAR

POPSLX

UE

AIEE

ZTEX

OMEGAE

RORI

DODI

P/PSL(x^)

ue

(ZT)e(x*)

We(x*)

(r/rjHx*)

(A/Aj) (x*)

total enthalpy. ft2/sec2

coordinate in free-stream flow directic n, ft

geometry coordinate orthogonal to ^, ft

streamline coordinate at which calculations are to begin, ft

streamline coordinate increment, ft

stagnation pressure, atm

free-stream Mach number

free-stream pressure, lb/ft"

number of points calculated along streamline

streamline coordinate, ft

local pressure along streamline, atm

edge velocity, ft/sec

edge enthalpy, ft /sec

edge compressibility-temperature product, 0R

edge vircosity parameter, slug/ft-sec-cR

divergence parameter due to body-shock layer geometry

distance between streamlines, or total streamline divergence

16

Page 26: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

3) BEQI

BEQI calculates the equivalent distance parameters at the initial streamline coordinate x». Following is the sequence of operations:

b b (a) Initialize -^^ = -^^ =1.0

(b) Divide the first streamline increment dx into 10 intervals, dx/10. Inter- polate to find the flow properties at each interval.

(c) Interpolate for i = f(T , P/POT) [IWALL] w w SL

ZT,

CJ,

= f(H, P/PSL) [SOMEGA]

ZT w

u w = f(iw. P/PSL) [SOMEGA]

(d) Calculate the reference terms

u; , o u , ZT , i , a [RORMUR] r frfr r r r

(e) Calculate d(A/A.)

dx [DERV]

(f) Calculate ie SL and EXPK from

N = x* d(A/£0 i_

(A/A.) dx

If N < .05; .99 < N < 1.01; EXPK = 0, ie SL = Je

--N(N-l) .05 < N < .99; EXPK = -.194e ' ^SL^N-^Ö,

-|(N-1) N.J

N > 1.01; EXPK = .194 e ' SL = ( N/

17

Page 27: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

vP=UeCOSÖSL: VSL^'T

(g) Obtain EL and ET (EBAR)

(h) Calculate the equivalent distance parameter

b _eq

x 1

X* x* G(x*)

^ 'X, X,

where

and

GLMf^''r^(r/••l)2(f/t1)

2ELX,

A/A. f/f. = i r/r.

The integration is performed by applying Simpson's rule to the integrands GL and G-p to finu b L/X and b f/x, respectively.

(i) bg- /x is calculated for 10 inter/als. The 10th bg- /x is used as the new (b „ /x)v , the first interval is divided into 100 intervals, and the above eq AJ

calculations are repeated for the first 10 Intervals.

(j) The calculations are repeated for 5 iterations (1) where

dx i

dx. = —r and 1 101 (%) ] " [(%)

XI i ^ i-1

The final (b^/x)v is then used as the (bö /x)v for the general l CM

AII ii=5 ecl XI

calculation (.QTRANS).

18

Page 28: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

Input

XSTAR x*

POPSLX P/PSL(x*)

TW Tw(x*)

UE ue(x*)

THETAS Öe(x*)

OMEGA E ü;e(x*)

DODI A/AjCx*)

RORI r/r^x*)

DX

Output

dx

BEQXLI (b r/x) XI

BEQXTI (b /x) eq, 1 x I

streamline coordinate at dx intervals, ft

local pressure along streamline, atm

vail temperature, 'R

edge velocity, ft/sec

streamline (edge) angle, degrees

edge viscosity parameter, slug/ft-sec-'R

dimensionless distance between streamlines

divergence parameter due to body-shock layer geometry

streamline coordinate increment, ft

laminar equivalent distance paraneter at Xj

turbulent equivalent distance parameter at xj

4) CYLIND (Option D-3)

CYLIND calculates the coordinates 4 and TJ and the two-dimensional parameters Öe(l. ^)• p/po(^ > ^) and Tw^ ^• ^) for an infinite swept cylinder. The properties are calculated as a function of TJ at ^ - 0 and are assumed to be constant in the ^ direction.

Pressure:

where

p 0

P(0) pT

X

l"PT ' P

. o .

e = 57.3- T)

R CYL

P/PT (0) is found by linear interpolation on a built-in table (Figure 1).

19

Page 29: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

T2

\7MN "'

2.5 Stagnation Line Pressure

M„, = M cos A

V'all temperature is found by linear interpolation on the input array.

Streamline angle:

9 (7?) - tan ;—j- e u^smÄ

where V(TJ) is the tangential velocity calculated in subroutine FLOW.

Then

P/P fM) = P/P (T?) for all | o' o

Input

RADIUS

SWEEP

ACH

VEL

ETAF

XSIF

TW

■yi.Tj) = Tw(i7) foralU

9 (M) = fl (T?) for all i e e

(u ) =u sin A e'xj

R, CYL

M„

w

cylinder radius, ft

sweep angle, degrees

free-stream Mach number

free-stream velocity, ft/sec

final T} coordinate for which streamline is to be calculated, ft

final ^ coordinate for which streamline is to be calculated, ft

wall temperature, "R

20

Page 30: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

free stream pressure, lb/ft"

stagnation pressure, atm

coordinate along axis of cylinder, ft

coordinate tangential to cylinder, ft

number of 4 values

number of TJ values

maximum 17 value, ft

streamline angle at Imax, degrees

pressure ratio array

wall temperature array, 0R

streamline angle array, degrees

DBTP is a linear double interpolation routine. Search time is reduced by starting the current search at the search result for the previous entry to this routine. DBTP uses TBLP to perform the interpolation.

Input

XX

YY

7.7.

X

Y

NX

PINT P«

POPSI. fVPSL

Output

XSI i

ETA V

M

N

ETA MAX w^) TH8MX %ax(0

PRESSR P/iy^n)

TWALL TwU,n)

THETAE eea,Ti)

5) DBTP

independent variable table

independent variable table

dependent variable table

independent variable

independent variable

number of values in X table

NY number of values in Y table

Page 31: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

NXS location in X table at which search is begun

NYS location in Y table at which search is begun

Output

Z dependent variable

6) DELTA (Option D-4)

DELTA calculates the body geometry, the streamline angles, and the two- dimensional pressure array P/P0(|, TJ) for a sharp delta wing. The following procedure is used:

{&) If R < 0 a sharp delta wing case is indicated and 6 = a (degrees) for all |.

(b) The pressure is calculated from

y 2 / CP \ 2 Pa,-n)=j P^M^ —2-) «in Ö + P«

\sin 6/

where

sin 6 = 1. 05 +

,1/2 1.1025 +

2 2 M„ sin 6 00

1. 278 sin 6

(c) The initial velocity is calculated from

<ue)xT = "ocl1" ö2/560o|

M .6

(d) The equations used to calculate 6e(4,J?) are:

6 + 1 ■"&mr am ■1 _1_

M.

1/2

MXT = M^ sin £.

* ** 1 90 -A

tan I 6

'M 1 + N

M, M N (u/u«)

1 + - ü 6

1/2

22

Page 32: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

y = 5($**)4

5(i**)4+ 1

e* = (90 - A)(i^***)r

N is found by linear interpolation on a built-in table (Figure 3).

If *** < 1.2 N = f(#**)

If ♦** > 1.2 N = f(A,***)

1 + ♦** _ NCL=—2 NCL LL M„+l CL

N

M 2

N

V = ^ tan (90 - A) max

6= (90-A)NCLR+ |Ö*-(90-A)NCL|R ^9

where

= _ tan^/g) tan (90 -A)

Then

0 =6* max

^W" T) = T). + A»;

i i-l

(e) The delta wing option D-4 assumes zero streamline divergence due to body geometry

— = 1.0 r.

i

Page 33: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

CM

o

LU Q Q. cc: < »fcfcs

to 1^*1

< Or: o LX.

_ o o z o> o \ ^—

H- 00 * <

• ■Q' _J LU G£ Qi

«o o o LU z ■MM>

_-J

S -^■ <

LU Q: »— CO

■ •

CO a> k- =5 a»

CN

m

U |Z

24

Page 34: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

Input

ACH M«

PINF P«

POPSL Po/PSL

VEL u«

ALPHA a

SWEEP A

RADIUS R

XSII «j

ETAI n,

XSIF lf

ETAF i7f

DELXSI A|

DELETA ATJ

Output

M

N

XSI

ETA

ETAMAX

TH8MX

THETAE

PRESSR

URATIO

max

max

e

P/Pc

uAu

free stream Mach number

free stream pressure, lb/ft'

stagnation pressure, atm

free stream velocity, ft/sec

angle of attack, degrees

sweep angle, degrees

leading edge radius, ft

initial streamline 4 coordinate, ft

initial streamline ») coordinate, ft

final streamline ^ coordinate, ft

final streamline TJ coordinate, ft

increment used to calculate ^ coordinate, ft

increment used to calculate TJ coordinate, ft

number of { values

number of TJ values

geometry coordinate, ft

geometry coordinate, ft

leading edge coordinate, ft

streamline angle at leading edge, degrees

streamline angle, degrees

pressure ratio

velocity i*atio

Page 35: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

7) DERV (V, W, X, Y. Z. DBYDX, DX. ITYPE)

DERV calculates the derivative of a tabulated function f by Langrangian five-point formulas. Given a sequence of points x_2. x_2, x0, Xj, X2 separated by a common increment h, the corresponding derivative of f at each point is given by:

'^i'-Vi^'i^'-vy f2 = Ä(-fl + (2'

Input

V f-2 1

w f-l

X fo

Y fl

Z f2

ITYPE

DX h

Output

functional values

determines which derivative formula is to be used

function increment

DBYDX f function derivative

8) DIVERG

DIVERG calculates P/PQ. TW, 0e, r/r^ and A/Aj along a given streamline by the following method:

(a) Store the original streamline (1) data and calculate an auxiliary streamline 12) such that

n = T) ± An r p ^i max

26

Page 36: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

(b) Calculate the following at each dx location on the streamline of interest

ß (x*) linear interpolation on 9 (x) e e

T (x*) double linear interpolation on T .(|,1)

P/P (x*) double linear interpolation on P/PJi.ri)

—{\*) =1.0 r.

i

cos fl (X*) A ^(x*) - n2(x*) e^

AT0*** _ V^lx*) - r,i2(x*) cos 0e (x*) i I

Where the subscripts 1, 2, and i indicate the original and auxiliary stream- lines and the point at which calculations are begun, respectively. If the streamlines cross at any point, the above calculations are begun a distance dx downstream from the intersection point.

Input

XI XI

DX dx

FTAF "f

XSIF «f

M

X

XSI i

ETA »1

PRESSR P/PoU-

TWALL V^.T,)

XSIX 4(x>

ETAX rj(x)

initial streamline distance, ft

streamline coordinate increment, ft

final streamline coordinate, ft

final streamline coordinate, ft

number of ^ input values

number of rj input values

streamline coordinate array, ft

streamline coordinate array, ft

pressure ratio array

wall temperature array, "P.

streamline coordinate, it

streamline coordinate, ft

Page 37: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

streamline coordiiwte, ft

n coordinate for geometry leading edge, ft

streamline angle, degreei

streamline coordinate, ft

pressure ratio along streamline

streamline angle, degrees

dimensionless distance between streamlines

divergence parameter

wall temperature, 'R

final streamline x-coordinate, ft

number of points on streamline

9) DSIRCH(Z, X, Y, ZA, XA, YA, NZ, NX, NY, IX, IY)

DSIRCH uses DTAB to perform double interpolation on a table of the form

Z = f(x,y)

Input

ETAMAX max

THETAX *e(x)

Output

XSTAR X*

PRESRX P/P0(x*)

THETAS 0e(x*)

DODI (A/AjHx*)

RORI (r/rjHx*)

TW T

XF xf

II

X

Y

XA

YA

ZA

NX

NY

NZ

independent variables

table of X values

table of Y values

table of Z values

number of values in X table

number of values in Y table

number of values in Z table

28

Page 38: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

IX order ot intenxjlacion in X direction

FV order of interpolation in Y direction

Output

/. dependent variable

10) KBAR (AVEW, AYESL. 11, SIGR. EXPK, POPSLX, OMEGE. OMEGS, GAMC, GAMO. EBARL, EBART)

K3AR calculates the crossflow pressure gradient parameters Ej^ and E-p and the pressure gradient correlation parameters rc and r using the following method:

(a) Interpolate to find

e, SL oL e, SL

(b) Calculate the local pressure in lb/ft^ and the Pß terms

P p =

r p i

SL (ps. ,

VT =

p.

R ^s

pc^e =

P

ir-e

(c) Calculate the mean enthalpies

'avg 2 (l\v ^ 'e. SL)

i = i + .2 (H - i or) a m,c avg e, SI, r

VT\JA

pe^e"/

(d) Interpolate to find

ZT = f(P/^T. ' ) [SOMEGA) m,c SL m,c

ZT = f(P/POTl i ) (SOMEGA) m.o SL avg

2i)

Page 39: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

(e) Compute:

and

where

(I^-.294)«rr-355

FZC .4018

(£0-.294)<rr-355

FI0 = .4018

\ - ('*rpK

F _ ln„ \EXPK K

o = ("0)'

ZT 2 = m'c

c ZT e,SL

ZT 2 = m'0

0 ZTe,SL

(f) The pressure gradient correlation parameters are calculated from:

rc = -7m4FKc(\P\-1)

r0--71764FKo(VrT\-1)

(g) Compute the crossflow pressure gradient parameters:

ET = 1+ r L c

i+r \4

ET = (1+.76519 ro)_

30

Page 40: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

Input

.WKW Ky

AYKSI. ^.SL

II H

SIGR ^r

POPSLX p/ps]

OMEGK "e

O.MEGS ws

Output

GAMC rc

GAMO r0

EBARL EL

EBART ET

Jl) FIND (ZA. Z. NTZ. XZS)

2 2 wall enthalpy, ft /sec

edge enthalpy at flow line of symmetry, ft /sec

total enthalpy, ffVsec

Prandtl number

local pressure along streamline, atm

edge viscosity parameter, slug/ft-sec-0R

stagnation viscosity parameter, slug/ft-sec-'R

pressure gradient correlation parameter

pressure gradient correlation parameter

laminar crossflow pressure gradient parameter

turbulent crossflow pressure gradient parameter

FIND looks up Z in an array ZA, dimensioned NZ, and stores the location of Z relative to ZA(1) in NZS. If Z is not in the range of ZA, the message "VARIABLE NOT IN RANGE OF TABLE" is printed, followed by the input values of Z, ZA(]), and ZA(NZ), respectively. NZS is then set to 1 if Z - ZA(1) and to NZ if Z ZA(NZ). Upon subsequent entries to FIND the search is begun at ZA(NZS) where NZS is now the location of Z from the previous entrv to FIND. For a normal exit NZS = i where ZAjiZ<ZA.+ 1.

input

ZA

Z

array to be searched

variable for which location is desired

."■1

Page 41: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

NZ

NZS

Output

NZS

number of values in ZA

location of Z in ZA from previous call to FIND

location of Z in ZA

12) FLOW (Program B)

FLOW calculates the external flow parameters at the boundary layer edge as a function of streamline distance given the pressure and the stagnation conditions.

At the starting point, on the streamline, edge enthalpy is obtained from:

v2

("e)

Cel = « I

For the special case of the swept cylinder tangential velocity calculation

\ /x KsmAJ (0 = H - "I 2

Then

Let

and define

ZT = f(i , P/POT) (SOMEGA] e e öL

w - f(i , P/POT) (SOMEGA] e e oL

u - \**

K

2\u.

2 \u„

.21

X*,K

as the Kth iteration for u at the point x*.

32

Page 42: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

Simüarly define |(ZTe) ^ i as the Kth iteration for ZTe at x*.

The iterative equation to be satisfied at each point x* on the streamline is

, , dxR x* „ x*-dx 2

K u„ (ZTeL

r_d_ /p dx ft I

avg

K \ o avg

where

d<p/IV _ i dx 2 lr<p/p°,i,.*ä1

<p/po'L. x*-dx

and

(P/Po) avg 2

P P — (x*) + —(x*-clx)

o o

The derivatives are calculated numerically using subroutine DERV.

For each iteration:

(i ) = !l-u 2\u >

K

For the swept cylinder tangential velocity

(U H - u " u 00 v* - 2 (u«si11 A

Then

x*

(-,

K

K

f Ce) P

' P. (X*)

K SL

SOMEGA]

;i:!

Page 43: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

This va'ue of ZTe is then used in the above iterative equation to yield a new ux* These calculations are repeated at every x* until

K 'K-l

K

< €

where e = 10 . A maximum of ten iterations (K = 10) is fixed by the program. If the relative error criteria has not been satisfied after ten iterations at any point x*, an appropriate error comment will be printed. If convergence at x* has been estab- lished in the Ith step, then set u^ = {ux«} and

(Ue)x. - U-(2V)

(ZTe)x.= lK)x.!

KL-IKL

1/2

A special cass results when /ue) = 0. This corresponds to a stagnation point

where x, = 0 and d/dx(P/P0) = 0. The iterative equation for ue becomes

ue(x*) = ue(x* - dx) or due/dx = 0. Because this result is incorrect, the first step is calculated using the following:

The velocity gradient at the stagnation point xj is calculated from:

1/2

4fe) =f -*K) 4(f) \ «v J Xj »I Xj dx \ o /x

where the pressure derivative is obtained from the numerical derivative equation

2 £■(«!. i1)-2|-({2,T)) + |H|3,tj) d/P\o o 'o

A 2 \p dX \ Oy A«'

34

Page 44: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

The use of this equation requires that the first three i input points be equidistant. Then

(Ual = u

I+dx

i /u d / e dx \ u

1 / 2

dx Jx,

I'M =H-^(U ) \ e' 2 \ e / I-dx Pdx

(ZTe) I-dx

K) I+dx

> = f Cel I+dx

SL I+dx

[SOMEGA]

The calculations continue, using the previously described procedure where the starting point is now Xj + dx.

Input

PR ESUX P/P0(x*)

II

ratio of local to stagnation pressure along streamline

number of values in pressure array

L"RATIO (ue/u«) velocity ratio at x

II H

VEL "*

DX dx

POPSL P0/

PSL

Output

total enthalpy, ft^/sec"

free stream velocity, it/sec

streamline coordinate increment, ft

stagnation pressure, atm

The following outputs are a function of streamline distance:

UE u,- edge velocity, ft/sec

POPSLX P/Pgjjx*) local pressure along streamline, atm

Page 45: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

AIEE 'e

ZT EX ZT

OMEGAE we

XSTAR X*

13) HEMI (Option D-2)

edge enthalpy, ft"/sec

edge compressibility-temperature product, " R

edge viscosity temperature ratio, slug/ft-sec-'R

streamline coordinate, ft

HEMI calculates the streamline and the pressure and divergence parameters along the streamline for a hemisphere geometry.

(a) Set x? = Xj

(b) Calculate x*, P/P^x*), r/r^x*), and A/A^x*) for all dx increments along the streamline until fl = 90°

e = 57.3 x* R HEMI

Interpolate to find P/PJx*) = f(e)

r/r.(x*) = sinj — HEMI

(c) URATIO - Up /u

Input

XI

A/A.(x*) = sinf —

RHEM RHEMI

XI XI

DX dx

Output

XSTAR X*

PRESRX P/P0(x*)

HEMI

hemisphere radius, ft

x-value at which calculations are to begin, ft

streamline increment, ft

streamline coordinate, ft

ratio of local to stagnation pressure along streamline

Page 46: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

UORI r/rj(x*) divergence parameter due to tody-shock layer geometry

DOD1 A/Aj(x*) distance between streamlines, total streamline divergence

14) INTIAl. (LI, NTYPE)

INTIAL calculates the free stream conditions for wind tunnel and flight type inputs.

(a) Wind Tunnel Class i

2 u

H = 6000 T 2

Q« = 0.7 P^H.,2

P« - 1^/(1716 T^)

(b) Wind Tunnel Class II

2

i^= IT —r-

aao = Mi«) when 5.93 x 10(,< i«« 20.3 x 10° ffVsec2 [SONENT,

a^ = .6325 s/ i^ when !«< 5.93 x 10° It" sec"

u a

M. a«

,2 u„ \

T E \49M,

P« = P«,/(nif. T„)

Page 47: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

P /P from [STACONl o oc

P-fe) SL\ P

o^

00 CC

q«> 2RT 00

(c) Flight

a^ = f (altitude)

P., = f (altitude)

T,, = f (altitude)

«« H = 6000 T,, + —-

u

00 a«,

q, = 0.7 P^M^2

UTMOSl

For wind tunnel I and flight

P /P = f(M , H, P^, u ) (STACONl

VPRT = U2- SL

Input

Wind Tunnel Class I, NTYPE = WTl

ACH M„ free stream Mach number

TEMP T.,. free stream temperature, "R

PiXF free stream pressure, Ib/ft^

38

Page 48: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

Wind Tunnel Class 11, NTYPE - \VT2

VKL

II

POPSL

PINT

H

rJo/PSL

Flight, NTYPE = FLIGHT

ALT

VEL u.

Output

free stream velocity, ft/sec

total enthalpy, ft /sec

stagnation pressure, atm

free stream pressure, Ib/ft"

flight altitude, U

free stream velocity, ft/sec

ACH M,

H H

PINT P„

POPiNF PQ/P^

POPSL Fo/pSL

QINF q,,

SONIC ^

V EL u

15) IWALL (T\V, POPSLX, AYEW)

free stream Mach number

total enthalpy, ft /sec^

free stream pressure, lb/ft

stagnation to free stream pressure ratio

stagnation pressure, atm

free stream dynamic pressure, Ib/ft2

speed of sound, ft/sec

free stream velocity, ft/sec

IWALL calculates the enthalpy at the wall as a function of the waii temperature and the local pressure.

(a) Set Tu ~ Tw/l.8 (conversion to 6K)

;;<)

Page 49: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

(b) Calculate wal! enthalpy

i =- .432 T.. when. T . < .JOO'K

i -.432T.. ^ 3.82x 10 r>/T . -SOOT when 300 < T < l-iOO'K

iw = f(log.,0 p/psl. Tw ); |TABLE 6| when Tw > ISOO^K

2/c^2 (c) Convert iw to ft^/sec

Input

i /_iL\ . 2.,031 i (m wl 2 } w\ lb /

\ sec /

TW T 1w wall temperature, 0R

POPSLX P/PgL(x*) local pressure along streamline, atm

Output

wall enthalpy, ft^/sec Hv AYEW

16) JAYELL (AYEW, H, AYEE, ZTE, ZTS, SIGR, BETAS, POPSLX, XJL)

JAYELL calculates the laminar pressure gradient effect correlation parameter JL

from the following:

(a) Calculate the mean enthalpy

i = -(i + H) m.s 2 w

(b) Interpolate to find:

(c) Calculate

ZT = f(P/POT, i ) [SOMEGA] m,s SL m, s

(Z - .294) /i

Z .4018 s

( aw\ 355

40

Page 50: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

where

ZT Z =

s m, s

ZT

i = H aw

i e — + a

H r 1/2 M)

(d) If /3 < 0 set j = -1

It ß > 0 set j = 1 s

See subroutine QTRÄNS *"or ß calculation.

(e) Calculate the streamwise pressure gradient function:

(1+2 CPES) \ß

where

(f) Calculate J,

Input

J. =

AYEW \v

H H

AYEE äe

ZTE ZT

ZTS ZT

s 2 CPES+ (■~-)/J

CPES = ZT /ZT

e s i /H e

1 + .7176 //T+ F. F 0 Z s s nf

wall enthalpy, ft2/sec

2 O total enthalpy, ft /sec

2 y 9 edge enthalpy, ft /sec'1

edge compressibility-temperature product, 0 R

stagnation compressibility-temperature product, "R

41

Page 51: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

SIGK a Prandtl number r

BETAS H,. streamwise pressure gradient parameter

POPSLX P/Pgj (x*) local pressure along streamline, atm

Output

XJL JT laminar pressure gradient effect correlation parameter

17) MUZERO(OMEGR, ZTR, AVER, AYEE, H, POPSLX. XMUO, XL)

MUZERO computes the reference stagnation viscositj7 ix0 and the diffusion effect parameter £.

(a) Interpolate to find:

-p - f (log10 P/PSL, ie) (TABLE 71

If

/i < 0, set L/i = 0 iD/ie<o. set^

(b) Calculate fi0 and Z

v3/2 H = u (ZT ) ^

o r r'' (t)

e

ZT •*• 200 r

(f)zv 200

I = 1 ■m'i Input

OMEGR ^r

ZTR ZTr

AVER h

reference viscosity-temperature ifatio, slug/ ft-sec-8R

reference compressibility-temperature product, "R

reference enthalpy, ft /sec^

42

Page 52: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

AYEE 'e

H H

POPSLX Py

Output

XMVO ^c

XL £

edge enthalpy, ft2/sec2

total enthalpy, ft2/sec2

P/Pgi (x*) local pressure along streamline, atm

reference stagnation viscosity, slug/ft-sec

parameter indicating diffusion effect on heat transfer

18) QTRANS (Program A)

QTRANS calculates heat transfer data for any body shape given the external flow properties, gas properties at the wall, gas properties at the stagnation conditions, and the streamline divergence parameters. The sequence of calculations is as follows (names in brackets are subroutines):

(a) Set up x-printout array

(b) Initialize 0 = 0.5

(c) Interpolate for

i = f(T , P/PCT) w w SL

[IWALL]

(d) Interpolate to find

ZT

w.

= f(H, P/PSL) [SOMEGA]

ZT w

u. w

= f(iw, P/PSL) (SOMEGA]

(e) Calculate

u , p u , ZT , i , a [RORMUR] r rrKr r r r

43

Page 53: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

(f) Calculate

du d(Ä/A.) e i

dx ' dx [DERV]

(g) Calculate i and EXPK from

x* ^^^i) A dx

If NS.Ü5; ,99<N<1.01; EXPK=0, i e, SL 'e

.05<N<.99: EXPK= -.194e0 , fl = (N _ n ö SL e

T^'1) - /N-l\ N > 1.01; EXPK= .194e • 0OT = -vT— Ö

oL v N ' e

(h) Obtain EL and ET [EBAR]

(i) Calculate the equivalent distance parameters defined by:

1 x x* G(x*)

1

/b \ x* x. G(x.) i-^-j + I G(x)dx

\ / Y V X. X.

x* G(x*) x.G(x.)

eq .x*-2dx

i i \ x x. ^x.

i i

i G(x)dx+ f G(x)dx+ / G(x)dx x*-2dx

where the integrand G is calculated from

and

GL^pr^Ue T

/ \2E r V / f \ L

e 'i Vfi

G,, / r \5/4 / f \(5/4>ET

f A/Ai f. r/r. i \

44

Page 54: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

Thus, for x* = Xj + (2K)dx (INTEGER x > 1) the integration is performed by applying Simpson's rule using Gj^ or G-j as the integrand to find (bg^/x), an^ (b^/x) , respectively. eq -p

eq _ i x /x* x*G(x*) XiG^-~

X; c x*-2dx G(x)dx

dx G(x* - 2dx) + 4G(x* - dx) + G(x*)

where

/ x. i

x*-2dx K-l G(x)dx = f D G [xj + (2j - 2)dx I + 4 [x. + (2j - l)dx j

G(x. + 2jdx)

This last sum is the result of successive application of the three point inte- gration as the calculations move along the streamline. When x* - x, -t- (2K+ l)dx an extra point is required to compute (b^/x). The calculation is made by repeating the above sequence of operations (c) through (i) with x* incremented by dx.

(j) Calculate the streamwise pressure gradient parameter /3S from the following:

ZU**) = /Hx*-2dx) + F (dS - 0 ) s s dx\ s *'/x*-2dx

where

F = 71/(70+ l/cx)

G eq

L\ x

c = 1 x

x*-dx

. / eq 'ihr.

Page 55: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

and

K) x*-2dx

H \/ ea

L J x*-2dx

u = 0 e

mu x* e dx'

Jx*-2dx u ^ 0 e

(k) Calculate the reference Reynolds number R „: calculate JT [JAYELL] and u £ (MUZEROl rM

then

eq (V*)L ; F

x,Q

■Li7/2ofe!

eq

'L

1/3

eq (b /x) y eg /.

- ; R x / .9/16 ' r.Q L

('

eq X ;

(b /x) V eq /.

4/10

p ^1 u (x /x ) r ^r e \ eq /

2 2 ^ F o o x.Q

11 Rr,Q a transition <input) a new value of (beq/x / is calculated using the following equations:

R p u u S T ^rrr e eq, L

L, S

R, 0 M u S ,„ MrKr e eq, T

T. S

46

Page 56: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

e .664

(RL,S) 1/2 e e L

R .0(.2135R )

e e T B.T

^eKo^.S--407) 2.64

transition

fr) =(H-

./4

transition /

transition GTdx

TR GTx*

^ ^r Q < ^transition ^nPut)' a check is made at this point for x-printout values. If a printout point does not lie in the open interval (x* - 2dx, x* + 2dx), where x* is the current value of x, the sequence (c) through (k) is repeated until one is encountered.

(1) When a printout point lies in the above Interval and when the transition point is found the desired heat transfer data is calculated using the following equations:

Calculate JL and n0£ (JAYELL] and [MUZERO]

Then

eq M, L

c \

X/L

(b /x) \ eq /I

' 4/10"

-17

Page 57: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

x.S

(b /x) T 17/4 \ «1 /-,

1/3

L /b /x\

x,Q

(h /x)

17/20 i^__TL /b /x\ [ eq JL

1/3

Reference Reynolds numbers:

p M u fx /x\ x* r r e \ eq /.

li r,Q

eci

~2~ 2" ^ F ^ o x,Q

p u u /S /x\ x r r e \ eq L

R r.S 2^ 2

M F 0 x.S

TT_ %Fx,SJL 3/2

/S 7x1 x* ' eq 'L

185 R r,S

!loS10(Rr,S+S000) 12.534

J.3/2 . F In \i/2 o x, S\ r, S/

— - . 332 -.——7—■ - u /S /x \ x* /SQ /x\ >

Skin friction coefficients:

L 1 C, =2

1, e, L u p u e e e

T 1 i, 0, T ' u p u

e e e

where P/P

Pe=1-232-ZT SL

48

Page 58: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

Heat transfer coefficients based on enthalpy:

3/10 „ in \l/2

HL = L o x,Q\ r.Q/

.645 Tx /x\ x*

H, g-ej 3/1% F fe L Mo x.Q

T .645/ , t . a /x /x \ x* r ( eq L

.185 R r.Q

|1Og10(Rr,Q+3000) |2.584

H. H. =

L H

H„ H

T H ,. _ ref, T

Nonisothermal wall parameters:

n V-

local \ w, , w / ^ \ w. w. I S. ♦. , = (i - i + E f * - * F

local o/ i=l \ i

where

Fs; - ^ (SL). 1 L

Fs. = 1

5*\9/10

-(^T):

1/3

1-1/9

laminar

turbulent

and

L. 3 ;* _

(SL. " 3L. , ) ' 1 1-1/

local

Örp

G dx

N ; sn dx

local i 0

49

Page 59: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

Adiahatic wall enthalpy:

i -iff (H - i ) aw, 1. e roe'

W^e^X-e) Nonisothermal heat transfer rates:

q-'Hii , - i + * \ L LI aw, L w L, . ;

> local/

"T'

Isothermal heat transfer rates:

q JL., lOU

(in) Print out heat transfer data.

L, iso L \ aw, L w/

T.iso ""Ti'aw.T ' w)

hi order for the sequence of calculations to reach this point, at least one printout point XpQ mutt lie in the interval (x* - 2clx), (x* + 2dx) where x* - K. + (2k)dx (INTKGKK k 2 0) is the current value of x. Answers of interest are now printed using linear interpolation for those printout points satisfying x* - 2<!'x < Xpn" x*. If a printout point satisfies the criterion x*< x <fx* + 2dx) ther, all quantities are saved for the current value of x to use for the interpolation scheme at x+ dx. Steps (a) through (m) are repeated until all printout points have been exhausted.

Input

Streamline Functions

XSTAR X*

POPSLX P/PSI(x*)

TW Tw(x*)

A IKK ie(x*)

streamline coordinate at dx intervals, ft

local pressure along streamline, atm

wall temperature^ 0 R

2/„'2 edge enthalpy, ft /sec

50

Page 60: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

THETAS ee(x*)

DODI A/A^x*)

RORI r/r^x*)

UE ue(x*)

ZTEX ZTe(x*)

OMEGA E we(x*)

Initial and Reference Cond

H H

XI XI

RTRANS transition

SIGR <Tr

DX dx

XPO xPO

KF KPO

AYEvVO ^o

BEQXLI M BEQXTI UAI Output

XSTAR X*

POPSLX P/PSL(x*)

UE ue(x*)

A/Aj A/A^x*)

streamline edge angle, radians

divergence parameters

edge velocity, ft/sec

edge compressibility-temperature product, "R

edge viscosity temperature ratio, slug/ft-sec-'R

is

total enthalpy, ft2/sec2

initial streamline value, ft

transition Reynolds number

partial Prandtl evaluated at ZTr

streamline coordinate increment, ft

printout array, ft

number of values in printout array

reference wall enthalpy, ft2/sec2 (needed only if Tw ^ constant)

initial value of b /x (laminar and turbulent)

streamline coordinate, ft

local pressure along streamline, atm

edge velocity, ft/sec

distance between streamlines

Page 61: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

ROM r/rj(x*)

TW Tvv(x*)

ZTEX ZTe(x*)

OMEGAE we(x*)

AIEE ie(x*)

AYEW iw(x*)

BEQXL beq, L/x(x*)

BEQXT beq/r/x(x*)

AYEAWL

AYEAWT

HL

HT

QL1SO

QTISO

QDOTL

QDOTT

CFEL

CFET

RRQ

RRS

HL(x*)/H0

HT(x*)/Href i T

4iso,T<x*)

qL(x*)

qT(x*)

Cf)C>T<x*)

R r,Q

R r.S

divergence parameter due to body-shock layer geometry

wall temperature, "R

edge compressibility-temperature product, 0R

edge viscosity temperaturs ratio, slug/ft-sec-0R

edge enthalpy, ft2/sec2

wall enthalpy, f^/sec"

ratio of laminar equivalent distance parameter to distance x along streamline

ratio of turbulent equivalent distance parameter to distance x along streamline

2 / 9 laminar adiabatic wall enthalpy, ft /sec*

2 2 turbulent adiabatic wall enthalpy, ft /sec

laminar heat transfer coefficient ratio, lbm/ft2/sec

turbulent heat transfer coefficient ratio, lbm/ft2/sec

laminar isothermal heat transfer rate, Btu/ft2-sec

turbulent isothermal heat transfer rate, Btu/ft2-sec

laminar heat transfer rate, Btu/ft2-s8C

turbulent heat transfer rate, Btu/ft -sec

laminar skin friction coefficient

turbulent skin friction coefficient

heat transfer reference Reynolds number

skin friction reference Reynolds number

Page 62: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

19) REF

REF cucut&tes the stagnation heat transfer coefficient based on a reference hemisphere of radius R*, and the reference heat transfer coefficient based on a 60° infinite swept cylinder given the reference cylinder radius. The following procedure is used to calculate the stagnation conditions:

(a) Initialize ie = H

(b) Obtain ^he following from the indicated subroutines:

iw [IWALL] o

ZT , ZT , ZT , o , a; . u) (SOMEGA) w e s w e s

w . p u , ZT i , <T (RORMUR] r r r r r r

J [JAYELL]

ti0, £. [MUZERO]

(c) Calculate the stagnation heat transfer coefficient and heat transfer rate:

1/2 _ .664g^

o .645 a r

■ RHEMI, ref .

\-\V-^ ) a

The reference conditions are calculated from the following:

(d) Reinitialize MN = 1/2 M^

(e) Obtain the following from the indicated subroutine:

P^T/P«' W' U^V, [STACON] ST " ST MN

Hv.ref tlWALLl

ZT , ZT , ZT , w , a) , w [SOMEGA] w e s w e s

,").')

Page 63: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

UJ , p n , ZT . i , a r r r r r r

IROUMUR]

rC'ro

IF. BAH]

v^ (MUZEROl

(f) Calculate the following:

•86tiRCYL.rof

«I.L~ (i+ rc)u^N

x,Q

i+ r 1.6

1 + .7625 r O' -i

1/3 i+ r

i+ r

R r. Q, ref

.866 p u u x r r <*> eq, L

Mo x,Q

H .332gJ£ ''o x,Q

ref, L . 64o x a eq, L r

, " {Rr,Q,ref) 1/2

H 185 gX 'io x,Q

R r,Q, ref

ref.T .645 x a\ eq,L log10(Hr,Q,ref+3000)l

2.584

aw, ref, L = H

1/2 (■-^("-'e)

1/3' aw, ref, T

= >,-(!-,-)(„-g

ref, L ref, L aw, L w, ref

Vf, T Href, T (law. T " w, re^

Page 64: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

.866 u a .645

ref, L

ref.T

z£ H ref.'

.866 u a oo r

.645

g^ ref.T

ref "f.C ref q^

Input

PINF P«

ACH Moo

VEL Uoo

VELP UMN

H H

POPSL Po/PSL

TWREF T w, ref

RHMREF RHEMI.ref

RCLREF RCYL, ref

Output

AYEWO Hv 0

HO Ho

QDOTO %

HREFL

HREFT

H ref, L

K ref.T

free stream pressure, lb/ft2

free stream Mach number

free stream velocity, ft/sec

modified Newtonian velocity gradient, 1/sec

total enthalpy, ft2/sec2

stagnation pressure, atm

reference wall temperature, *R

reference hemisphere radius, ft

reference cylinder radius, ft

2 / 2 stagnation wall enthalpy, ft /sec

stagnation heat transfer coefficient, lbni/ft

2-sec

stagnation heat transfer rate, Rtu/ft -sec

laminar z'eference heat transfer coefficient, lbm/ft2-sec

turbulent reference heat transfer coefficient, lhm/ff-sec

Page 65: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

AYAWUI. iaVv,reif,,

AYAW,lT W.ref/F

TAl'ilL Tref ^

TAURT Tref/r

QRKFL flref. L

QRKFT qret.T

CFREFL

CPREFT

%e, ref, 1,

^f, (:%ref,T

AYKREF iW(re{

laminnr reference adiariatic wall enthal|)y, ll-/sec~

turlnilent reference adiabatic wall enthalpy, ft2/sec2

laminar reference shear stress, lb/ft

turbulent reference shear stress, lb/ft

laminar reference heat transfer rate, lbm/ft -sec

turbulent reference heat transfer rate, lbm/ft -sec

laminar reference skin friction coefficient

turbulent reference skin friction coefficient

reference wall enthalpy, ft /sec

20) RollMUH

UOltMUR calculates the following reference properties:

(a) Viscosity parameter

ws K* =

1/14 1,005

W. .005+--

0J

K - (K¥)

13 3 ,_ -i

10 Ifi

U). F. - K

u).

a; -

vv

p7/8

ww F 1 1.2

1/10

.2-* F,

ÖC,

Page 66: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

(b) DensHy-viscotity product

^ - fc ^

^r r r r R P„M_ = P

(c) Compressibility-temperature product ZTr

Change units of (jjr to slug/ft-sec-'K

u) - 1.8 w r,'K r,'R

For3.585 x 10"10 < w <8.03xl0'10

r

23213.13 x 10"20 T /, Ä„0„^ 1A18 2 \l/2"|2 ZTr,-K= 2 [l+(l -.478656x10 W ) J

Otherwise ZT »LT is obtained from interpolation

ZVK = f(lOg10P'Wrx) fTABL19]

ZTr "K is converted to "R by ZTr ,R = 1.8 ZTr .K

(d) Enthalpy ir

i r

RT o

f(log10P. ZT^^) [TABL201

/ I

i = 847559.8 ' r

r IRT \ 0)

(e) Prandtl number a.

a = f(ZT ) (TABL 14) r r

Page 67: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

Input

POPSIX p/psi

OMKGS ws

OMEGE we

OMEGW ^w

Output

OMEGR ^r

ROMUR P M

ZTR ZTr

AYER V

SIGR ^^

local pressure along streamline, atm

stagnation viscosity-temperature ratio, slug-ft-sec-'R

edge viscosity-temperature ratio, slug/ft-sec-"R

wall viscosity-temperature ratio, slug/ft-sec-'R

reference viscosity-temperature ratio, slug/ft-sec-0R

2 M 4 reference density-viscosity product, slug /ft4-sec

reference compressibility-temperature product, "R

9 9 reference enthalpy, ft /sec

reference Prandtl number

21) SiRCH (Y, X, YA, XA, N, IO)

SIRCH uses TAB to perform single interpolation on a table of y = f (x).

Input

X

YA

XA

N

IO

Output

independent variable

dependent array

independent array

number of values in XA and YA arrays

order of interpolation

dependent variable

Page 68: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

22) 30MEGA (ENTH, 0OPSLX, ZT, OMEGA)

SOMEGA calculates the viscosity-temperature ratio u; and the compressibility- temperature product ZT as functions of enthalpy and pressure.

(a) Convert enthalpy to Btu/lb m

i(Btu/lb ) = 25301 rf/sec2) x m'

(b) Calculate ZT

For i < 180

For i > 180

ZT = i/.432

ZT = f(log10 P/PSL, i) [TABLE2]

Calculate u

ZT < 111 CD = 14.454 x 10 ■10

m<ZTs20„„ w=(i-T)^(_i|«4__)M.45x 10 -10

ZT > 2000 w - f(log10 P/PSL, ZT) (TABL18]

(c) Convert ZT and w to "R

ZTtR = 1.8 ZT.K

u slug w ft-sec-'R 1.8

Input

ENTH

POPSLX P/P SL

enthalpy

local pressure along streamline, atm

.)!.•

Page 69: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

( )UtiJUt

ZT ZT

OMEGA w

23) SONKN'T (EXTH, SONIC)

compressibility-temperature product, 'R

viscosity-temperature ratio, slug/ft-sec- "R

SOXENT calculates the speed of sound as a function of free stream enthalpy. The result is obtained by linear interpolation on tabular arrays constructed from the equation:

f>RT„ ,1/2

where

T« = f(U/RTrt)

T«, = MT«,)

Input

ENTH

Output

2 / 2 free stream enthalpy, ft /sec

SONIC a^ speed of sound, ft/sec

24) STACON (PSTPNF, AYEST, VELP, ACH, ACHN, H, PINE, VEL)

STACON calculates the stagnation-free stream pressure ratio, the stagnation enthalpy, and the modified Newtonian pressure gradient.

(a) Stagnation enthalpy

iorr = H - -— ST 2

'M 1 -

N M

(b) Pressure ratio P0/P

P

(H^1-2^3'5^- 2.5

MN21

no

Page 70: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

3.5

("ST)

M. 1 +

X

o SL MN < 1

P2 GMN P 2

1 -MN ' 5

Interpolate for

(ZTST) - f(PST ' W) ^ 'o v o /

fSOMEGA]

(psT)r^:+K ^ \ \pi PSL/L

6006 (ZTST)

ST 2(P2/P1)- 1

Interpolate for

Krj/^srW [SOMECAl

(p-)2=fej k - ^ 2(P2/P1)

6006 ZTST

'ST 2(P2/P1) - 1

p (PST) o _ ' 'o P (P /P )

(c) Modified Newtonian pressure gradient

MN "?'- ' P

"KVC'V

6006 IZT (ZTST

ST

1/2

Interpolate to find the empirical correction factor to the modified Newtonian velocity gradientas a function of M^cos A (Swept cylinder) or M«, (Hemisphere).

UMN

= KIN) ' (CORRECTION FACTOR)^

For the correction factor jee Figure 4.

61

Page 71: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

c v E

I x 0)

X

1.14

1.12

1.10

c

I 1 -08 v Z

'x ^ 1.06

1.04

1.02

1.00

!

\ ! \ !

0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5

M^ or M^, cos A

Figure 4: CORRECTION FACTOR FOR THE VELOCITY GRADIENT AT A HEMISPHERE STAGNATION POINT OR CYLINDER STAGNATION LINE

(i2

Page 72: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

Input

ACH M«,

ACHN MN

H H

PINT PcC

VEL U=o

Output

PSTPNF PoK AYEST 'ST

VELP ui«v

free stream Mach number

normal Mach number

total enthalpy

free stream pressure, Ib/ft^

free stream velocity, ft/sec

stagnation to free stream pressure ratio

stagnation enthalpy, ft /sec4'

modified Newtonian velocity gradient, l/sec

25) STREAM (Program C)

STREAM calculates the streamline coordinate x as a function of the geometry coordinates ^ and TJ . A complete description of the geometry and streamline pattern are provided by the coordinates ^ and TJ, 0e(£,»)), ^maxd) and ^max^*

Öe(^,Tj) must be provided for the grid of ^ and TJ that lies within the geometry boundaries. With ömax(4) known along the upper TJ geometry boundary the complete streamline pattern on the body is defined. V^^^) specifies the upper n boundary thus defining the geometry.

The coordinates (^f, Tf) determine a point on a particular streamline. The streamline calculation begins at (If, Hf) and proceeds upstream until the geometry boundary is reached. The calculation of the streamline is done by the following procedure:

Let (4X)1 - Ij, (Hx) - l^ and (x)] = 0. Linear interpolation is performed on 6e{i,V) and ömax(4) if necessary, to determine (ox).. Then

(d\)1 = dxsin{ex)1

(^K)1 = dxcos(9x}1

G3

Page 73: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

Then the coordinates of the new point are:

Continuing this procedure, the general equations are.

H.rf[MK»Kj /d 4 \ = dx sin /eJ \ ^ Xk-1 [ Xk-1

(dr) ] = dxcos (9 ) \ X/K-I \ X/K-I

and

K-l

(^)K = v - s {^ K-l

(\)K ' "F - S (<■.,). v 'K i=l 'i

K-l (X)K= Z d(Xx).

1=1 1

The streamline calculation is completed by rearranging the 4Xi ^x and x arrays such that 4 x' Iv and x are measured from the upstream end of the streamline.

The subroutine STREAM assumes zero streamline divergence due to body geometry

I- =1.0 r.

1

64

Page 74: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

Input

M

N

XSIF «f

ETAF "f

DX dx

XSI 1

ETA T

ETA MAX :'r

TH8MX «r

THETAE 9e

Output

II

XS1X

ET AX

X

THETAX

XF

max

max

^x

ex

numl)er of 4 coordinates

number of r? coordinates

final streamline ^ coordinate, ft

final streamline of n coordinate, ft

incremental streamline distance, ft

geometry coordinate, ft

geometry coordinate, ft

body edge coordinate, ft

streamline angle at body edge, degrees

streamline angle, degrees

number of points calculated along streamline

streamline coordinate, ft

streamline coordinate, ft

streamline coordinate, ft

streamline angle, degrees

final x-coordinate on streamline, ft

26) TABLE2 (AYES, PEDGFL, TS, CHECK)

TABLE2 obtains by table interpolation the compressibility-temperature product as a function of pressure and enthalpy.

Input

AYES i

PPLOG log10 P/PSL

enthalpy, Btu/lb m

log of ratio of pressure to sea level pressure, pressure in atm

Page 75: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

Output

TS ZT

CHECK

compressibility-temperature product, 'R

program check to determine success of interpolation (if the interpolation is not successful, sn error statement is printed)

27) TABLE« (TVV, PPLOG. AYEW)

TABLE6 interpolates to find wall enthalpy as a function of pressure and wall temperature tables.

Input

TW

PPLOG log10 P/PSL

wall temperature, 'K

log of ratio of pressure to sea level pressure, pressure in atm

Output

AYEW Aw wall enthalpy, Btu/lb m

28) TABLE? (AYEE; PPLOG, AYEAYE)

TABLET interpolates on a table of pressure and edge enthalpy to find the dissocia- tion on reaction enthalpy ratio io/ig.

Input

AYEE

PPLOG log10 P/PSL

Output

AYEAYE iD/i

edge enthalpy, ft2/sec2

log of ratio of pressure to sea level pressure, pressure in atm

dissociation reaction enthalpy ratio

29) TABL14 (ZTW, SIGT)

TABL14 obtains by table interpolation the partial Prandtl number as a function of the compressibility-temperature product.

fifi

Page 76: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

Input

ZTW ZT compressibility-temperature product. °\l

Output

SIGT Prandtl number

30) TABL18

TABLls determines by table interpolation the viscosity-temperature ratio as a function of the pressure and compressibility-temperature product.

Input

ZT ZT

PPLOG logJ0 P/PSI

compressibility-temperature product. 'K

loi? of ratio of pressure to sea level pressure, pressure in atm

Output

OMKGA

CHECK

viscosity-temperature ratio, slug/ft-sec-'K

program check to determine success of interpolation (if interpolation is unsuccessful, an error comment is printed)

31) TABL19

TARU9 performs table interpolation to determine the compressibilitv-temperature product as a function of pressure and viscosity-temperature ratio. The table is com- posed of data in TABLED and TABUS.

Input

OMEGA u)

fPLOG log10 P/PsL

viscosity-temperature ratio, siun/ft-sec - "K

log of ratio of pressure to sea love! pressure, pressure in atm

Output

ZT ZT compressibility-temperature product, "K

(IT

Page 77: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

32) TABL20

TABL20 performs table interpolation to find i/RT0 as a function of pressure and compressibility-temperature product.

Input

ZT ZT

PPLOG log10 P/PSL

compressibility-temperature product, 0 K

log of ratio of pressure to sea level pressure, pressure in atm

Output

dimensionless enthalpy AYERTO i/RT0

33) TBLP (XT, YT, X, NTAB, N)

TBLP is a linear single interpolation routine. To save search time in finding the location of the independent x value in the x table, the search is begun at the previously loca.ed x value.

Input

XT

YT

X

NTAB

N

independent variable table

dependent variable table

independent variable

number of values in the x table

location in x table at which the search is begun. This value should be set = 1 upon the first entry to this routine. Thereafter, it stores the location of the previous search.

08

Page 78: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

s

3. INPUT-OUTPUT DESCRIPTION

a. Data Input Preparation

Data are input to this program via punched cards. The purpose of this section is to define the required input and the form it takes on the cards. Input sheets for each option or section of the program are shown. Use of this type of form greatly reduces the amount of effort recjuired to obtain results from the program. Data may be key punched directly from the forms.

1) AXISYMMETRIC OR TWO-DIMENSIONAL BODIES (Option D-l)

Card Columns Format Description

| i 1-6 A6 Type of case: FLIGHT, WTl. or \VT2. I This card indicates the type of free-stream | condi'ions to be input.

f 1 7-10 Leave blank.

1 11-72 10AG Title or some description of case.

Cai'd -2 will consist of only one of the following types oi input: Flight. Wind Tunnel 1 (WTl), or Wind Tunnel 2 (WT2). Wind Tunnel 1 case should be used for tunnels operating in the ideal gas region, while Wind Tunnel 2 case should be used tin- high energy tunnels such as shock tubes.

FLIGHT

2 1-10 F10 Flight altitude, ft.

2 11-20 CIO Flight velocity, ft/see.

WTl

2 1-10 F10 Free-stream M;ich number.

2 11-20 F10 Free-stream static temperature. H.

2 21-;50 F10 Free-stream static pressure. lb/!'t-.

WT2

2 1-10 F10 Free-stream velocity. It/see.

2 11-20 F10 Total enthalpy, ir,.secJ.

(I!)

Page 79: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

Card Columns Format Description

2

3

3

4

21-30

41-50

1-10

11-20

21-30

1-14

F10 Ratio of stagnation pressure to sea level pressure.

2 F10 Free-stream d^amic pressure, lb/ft .

« F10 Radius of 60° swept infinite cylinder for

the turbulent reference heating rate, ft.

F10 Radius of hemisphere for the laminar reference heating rate, ft.

F10 Reference wall temperature, " R.

A6 Contains the word AXISYMMETRIC or TWODIMENSIONAL.

1-5

6

7

15 M is the number of values in the geometry tables y(4) and § . 3 < M < 50.

8F10 This table contains M values of ^ , ft.

8F10 This table contains M values of y(^) corresponding to 5 in the preceding table, ft.

Note: A minimum of three points must be input into the preceding two tables. If the body is very slender, more points should be used.

1-10 F10

8 11-20 F10

8 21-30 F10

9 1-5 15

Initial x location, point at which calculation begins, ft.

Increment in x, ft.dx > (x. - x )/750, i o

Edge velocity at x., ft/sec.

ITC is the number of values in the wall temperature versus surface distance tables. 2^ITC ^50. If ITC 2*3 then the wall temperature must be nonisothermal.

70

Page 80: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

Card Columns Format Description

10 8F10 This table contains ITC values of surface distance, ft.

11 8F10 This table contains ITC values of wall or surface temperature corresponding to the preceding distance table, R. If T = constant then enter two values, w

12 1-5 15 KpQ is the number of printout locations desired. KpQ < 500.

12 11-20 F10 Transition Reynolds number, see definition of Rr)Q in Program A, labeled QTRANS in section 2. b, 18.

13 8F10 This table contains KpQ locations at which printout is desired.

71

Page 81: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

s

n (/) Z o H

z. o

o 7

1- o o

8 z

K Ul (O U.

£ _, _.

L LU 0. > I-

8 UJ a: a. U P < ft

a.'

u

d z i u < 5

8 HI o: 0. o i < z >- □

8 Ul

0. o

<

_l

a.0

>

UJ

>- t-

Ö O -J

>

1

I

ü u.

s H

5 ai X

ir

_i

> u

UJ z O h O

i oc u

<0

-I

< o

Z o

c y- M 0. UJ Z z ? Ul

S S > n CO

X < 1

u—— -.„■■,.- _«

72

Page 82: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

o 00

oT

x V

-

in Ul D -i < > O

UJ _i CD

< t-

ä

< > o o.

I

Page 83: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

2) HEMISPHERE CALCULATION (Option D-2)

Card Columns Format

2

3

4

10

Same as Option D-l

1-10

1-10

1-5

1-5

11-20

A6

F10

15

Description

Contains title of program - HEMISPHERE.

Hemisphere radius, ft.

ITC is the number of points in the Tw

versus x tables. 2<ITC£50.

If ITC > 3 then the wall temperature must be nonisothermal.

8F10 This is a table of ITC values of x where T... are input, ft.

8F10 This is a table of ITC values of Tw

which correspond to locations given in the preceding x table, or if Tw = constant, enter two values of Tw-

15 KpQ is the number of printout locations desired. KpQ < 500.

F10 Transition Reynolds number, see definition of Rr,Q in Program A, labeled QTRANS in section 2. b. 18.

8F10 This table contains Kpg surface distance locations around the hemisphere at which printout is desired.

74

Page 84: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

§

c

f-

5

81

^s

.1 UJ D K

<

to 2 5 <r a

i a.

UJ I

5 a o

u h-

-j L '■ 5

tu I

rrt~i

j i

L_ L

Page 85: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

s

to UJ

-I < > 2

in -i ca <

J o a.

y

76

Page 86: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

3) SWEPT INFINITE CYLINDER (Option D-3)

Card Cuiumns Format Description

Same as Option 0-1

1-8 A6 This card contains the word CYLINDER to allow the program to select the D-;5 options.

1-10 F10 Cylinder radius, ft.

11-20 F10 Cylinder sweep angle, measured Irom a line normal to the flow, 0 < A < 90 .

1-10 F10 |r is the abscissa at which the streamline calculation begins, ft. £j- must be large enough so that the streamline has very nearly zero slope at the sta^naticn line. Cases have been run by the authors using ^f ^ 10 and 20 ft for A 10D and GO .

11-20 F10 Tjj- is the ordi ate at which the streamline calculation begins, ft.

21-30 F10 dx is the increment in distance along the streamline used in the boundary layer calculations (Program A), ft.

o ■> 1 ''2 dx>(|f- t nf) 'f;oo

1-5 15 ITC is the number of values in Tv, and ij tables. 2 < ITC < 50. 11 ITC > .'! the wail temperature is nonisolhcrmal.

8F10 This table contains ITC values of 77. where T) is the distance around the cylinder, ft.

8F10 This table contains ITC values of Tw

corresponding to the -q table/H.

Page 87: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

Card Columns Format Description

10 1-5 15 Kpo is the number of x printouts desired along the streamline. KpQ < 500.

10 11-20 F10 Transition Reynolds number, see definition of Rr,Q in Program A, labeled QTRANS in section 2. b. 18.

10 21-30 F10 Arjf is an increment used in Program C to locate the starting location of second streamline, ft.

If Arjf is small, in some cases the resolution between streamlines near the streamlines origin or apex may be very poor. The poor resolution leads to heat transfer distributions that are not smooth. In the event this occurs Arif should be increased, ft.

11 8F10 XpQ is a table containing locations along the streamline at which printout is desired.

78

Page 88: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

Hi

5

J i-

s 5

8 cr

o a

0 I

8

j

I a

,8

Ui O

P <

5

1 I

a:

-) >- o

a: za

u

H

<c P*

Page 89: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

g

i

Ul

-I < > O

ul -I o < 1- i

t-

<

I1 3 CD <

I1

I il

80

Page 90: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

4) SHARP DELTA WING (Option D-4)

Cards Columns Format Description

Same as Option D-l

4 1-6 A-6 Contains the word DELTA.

5 1-5 15 ITC is an indicator for wall temperature gradient. If the wall is at constant temperature input a 1 and one value of wall temperature in table.

6 1-10 FIG Angle of attack, degrees.

6 11-20 F10 Wing sweep angle measured from a line normal to the flow, degrees.

6 21-30 F10 4 f is the final or end coordinate along the streamline at which heating data is desired, ft.

6 31-40 F10 T]J is the final or end coordinate along the streamline at which heating data is desired, ft.

6 41-50 F10 xj is the point along the streamline at which the calculations begin and may have to be greater than zero as indicated in Figure 5. The resulting change in streamline curva- ture, due to interpolation, near the apex produces a discontinuity in the heating calculations, ft.

7 1-10 F10 A^ is the increment in | which the pro- gram uses to setup an (£.i?) array of streamline angles, velocity, and pressures, ft.

^f

si

Page 91: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

■Region of interest

.0125

Tj, feet

■Points in o two-dimensional array of streamline angles

090

^ , feet

Centerline - Streamline I

.135

Figure 5: STREAMLINES NEAR THE APEX OF A SHARP DELTA WING

82

Page 92: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

Card Columns Format Description

7 11-20 F10 ATJ is the increment in n the program uses to setup an (£,T)) array of streamline angles, velocity and pressures, ft.

Ari > - 50

7 21-30 F10 dx is the increment in distance along the streamline at which calculations will be performed, ft. dx > (Xj- - xj)/750.

Note: If l\v is a constant value, enter ope value into card 11, and delete cards S, 9, and 10.

8 1-5 15 M is the number of points in the 4 array. 2 < M < CO.

8 6-10 15 N is the number of points in the n array. 2 < N < 50.

9 8F10 This is a table of M values of i where wall temperature will be input, if ITC > 1.

10 8F10 This is a table of X values of TJ where wall temperature will be input if ITC > 1.

11 8F10 This is a table containing (X) • (M) values of wall temperature, input so i varies with each T) .

12 1-5 15 KpQ is the number of x printouts desired along the streamline. Kp()< 500.

12 11-20 F10 Transition Reynolds number, svv definition of Rr.Q In Program A, labeled QTRANS in section 2. b. IS.

12 21-30 F10 See card 10, svept infinite cylinder. option D-o.

13 8F10 Xpo is a table of Kpo locations along the streamline where printout is desired.

Page 93: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

o as

I UJ a. >

8 a.

s 5

8 a

8 a.

eT o a.

0 I

8 3

i

I o -I

8 3

IU Q 3 H H _l <

tu i

o GC

u in 1

< H -1 UI O D K

84

Page 94: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

t3

^

My 0

1 ! 1 j

i ! i |

! | |

—i—i

! i

1

- to UJ 3

5

I

{

i -1 EC

UJ 1

> |

UJ!

CD !

< 1

:l I

Page 95: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

o to

0)

< > O a.

UJ _l a) <

PJ

<1

I O a.

86

Page 96: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

5) STREAMUNE CALCULATIONS (PROGRAM C)

Card Columns Format Description

Same as Option D-l

1-6

1-5

A6

15

Must contain the word STREAM.

M is the number of points in the array £. 2 < M < 50.

6

6

6

6-10

11-1;

1-10

11-20

21-30

31-40

41-50

15

15

F10

F10

F10

F10

F10

8F10

N is the number of points in the array n 2< X <50.

ITC is an indicator used to test whether the wall temperature is a constant or a variable. If T^. is a constant ITC = 1 and enter one value of T into card 16 and delete cards 13. 14. and 15.

4f is 5 at the final or end point, ft.

n£ is T) at the final or end point, ft.

dx is the increment in distance along the streamline, ft.

1/2

dx >

/. 2 'i iv ^ V2)

750

Xr is the point along the streamline at which the calculations will begin, ft,

ue xT is the edge velocity at the initial or start of calculations, ft/sec.

This is a table of M values of 4 2 < M < 50. 9e, P/P0 and T^, ui input as functions of ^ and r\ . ft.

87

Page 97: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

Card Columns Format Description

8 8F10 This is a table of N values of TJ

2 < M < 50. Ge, P/P0 and Tw will be input as functions of | and TJ , ft.

9 8F10 This is a table of M values of Tlmax as a function of {. rtmSül defines the upper or outer boundary of the body, ft.

10 8F10 This is a table of M values of the stream- line angle 0max along the boundary as a function of ^, deg.

11 8F10 This is a table of (M) . (N) values of the local streamline angle 6e and should be input along lines of constant TJ and { . deg.

12 8F10 This is a table of (M) • (N) values the local pressure divided by the stagnation pressure and should be input along lines of constant TJ and varying {•

13 1-5 15 MT is the number of | values entered into the table Tw = f(4,Tj). Also see ITC above.

13 6-10 15 NT is the number of TJ values entered into the table Tw = f({ ,TJ). Also see ITC above.

14 8F10 This is a table of MT values of £ at which Tw will be input. Also see ITC above.

15 8F10 This is a table of NT values of n at which Tw will be input. Also see ITC above.

16 8F10 This is a table of (MT) • (NT) values of Tw as a function £ and TJ , 0 R. Tw

should be input as a function of 4 at constant TJ .

17 1-5 15 KpQ is the number of x locations along the streamline at which printout is desired. Kp0 < 500.

88

Page 98: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

Card Columns Format Description

17 11-20 F10 Transition Reynolds numbfr. see defini- tion of Hr.Q in Program A. labeled QTHANS in section 2. b. 18.

17 21-;i0 F10 Sec card 10. Swept infinite cylimler. option D-;}.

18 1-10 F10 xpo is a table of Kpo locations along the streamline at which printout is desired.

M)

Page 99: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

I <o g

0-

8 a

8 a.

-J

■— o a.

o I

8

I o -I u.

6

LU Q D h- h-

<

_J

>- ()

(C 5

oc o

< LU

a: a. z

in

2

in

5

• >

•-• X

X ■D

tr

«/>

in ut 3

< >

-I

<

90

Page 100: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

o oo

Ü3

< >

OJ

< >

«5 UJ

-I < >

3 < >

<

Ei

< I I

CD

< CO

< H a.0

a.

2

!»I

Page 101: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

s

•Si UJ 3 < > 5 j -i CO

<

05 Ui D -I < > Z UJ _l OQ

< P

I o Q.

r

j

in LU

< > o

o

X

Page 102: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

6) REFERENCE CALCULATIONS (PROGRAM REF)

Card Columns Format Descriptor.

Same as Option D-l

1-10 A6 Must contain the word REFERENCE.

Page 103: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

o CD

I

8 a.

8 5

8

a?

o 0.

I

8 3

I- I ?

1-

i UJ I

a:

_i >- u

K

N LU () a 7

ü UJ cc (T a. UJ 2 u.

Ul tr

!)-l

Page 104: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

7) BOUNDARY LAYER CALCULATIONS (PROGRAM B)

Card Columns Format Description

Same as Option D-l

I 4 1-6 A6 Must contain the word FLOW.

; 5 1-5 15 IS is the number of values in the P/PQ,

f ee, &/&\ and r/rj tables as a function of | streamline distance. 2 < IS < 50.

6 8F10 This is a table containing IS number of x locations, ft, along the streamline at which P/P0, öe, A/Aj and r/rj will be input.

7 8F10 This is a table containing IS values of local pressure each normalized by the model or vehicle stagnation pressure. Tho P/P0 correspond to the above x table.

8 8F10 This table contains IS values of the local streamline angle relative to the axis of symmetry, degrees. The values of 9e

correspond to the above x table, degrees.

9 8F10 This table contains IS values of the stream- line divergence parameter A/A^. The values of A/A^ correspond to the above x table.

10 — 8F10 This table contains IS values of the body shock geometry parameter r/q . The values of r/r^ correspond to the above x table.

11 1-10 F10 xj is point at which the calculation will begin, ft.

tjf)

Page 105: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

Card Column Format Description

11 11-20 F10 dx is the increment in distance alon^ the streamline, ft

XF!NAL"XI dx > -

750

11 21-.10 F10 uex is the edge velocity a ft sec.

12 1-5 15 ITC is the number of values in the Tw

versus x table. 2 < ITC < 50.

If Tw = constant then ITC = 2.

13 8F10 This is a table of xlocations (ITC) along the streamline where Tw will be input.

14 8F10 This is a table of ITC values of Tw along the streamline corresponding to the x table. If ITC = 2 enter only two values of TW, 'R.

lo 1-5 15 Kpy is the number of x locations along the streamline at which printout is desired. Kp() < 500.

15 11-20 F10 Transition Reynolds number, see definition of Rr Q in Program A. labeled QTRANS in section 2. b. 18.

16 8F1Ü This is a table of KpC) locations along the streamline where printout is desired.

Of)

Page 106: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

g

I UJ a.

s 5

1—

8 a

8 a.

_i

0 a.

I

8 3

1

I i

i UJ I

_1 >- o

a: !D

* if) r~i 0 o rr 1 0. -1

u. CO

V) UJ D -I < > CO

UJ -1 m <

< a. OL

Page 107: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

s

<]

X ■o

in Ul D -1 < >

Ul J to <

c

JJ

< > O a.

I .°l

98

Page 108: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

8) HEAT TRANSFER CALCULATIONS (PROGRAM A)

Card Columns Format Description

Same as Option D-l

1-6 A6 Must contain the word QTRAXS.

1-5 15 IS is the number of values in each of the following tables: x. P/PgL' ue- "c A/Aj and r/rj. 2 < IS < 50.

1-10 F10 Xj is the initial x location a^ong the stream- line at which the calculations will start, ft.

6 11-20 FlO dx is the increment in distance along the streamline, (ft.)

XFINAL'

XI

dx> — IOO

6 21-30 F10 ue.xT is the boundary layer edge velocity

atxj, ft/sec.

7 8F10 This is a table containing x locations (IS) along the streamline at which P/Pg^. ue . 8e , A/A, and r/q will be specified, ft.

8 8F10 This is a table containing IS values of the local pressure normalized with the sea level pressure, and at locations correspond- ing to the x table.

9 8F10 This is a table containing IS values of the boundary layer edge velocity correspond- ing to locations specifiec in the x table, ft/sec.

10 8F10 This is a table containing IS values of the local streamline angle 6C relative to the axis of symmetry. The angles correspond to x locations specified in the x table, deg.

99

Page 109: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

Card Columns Format Description

11 8F10 This is a table containing IS values of the streamline divergence parameter A/A.- and correspond to x locations specified in the x table.

12 8F10 This is a table containing IS values of the body-shock parameter r/r. and correspond to x locations specified in the x table.

13 1-5 15 ITC is the number of values in the T... versus x table.

2 < ITC < 50 If T is a constant, ITC =• 2. Input two values of Tw into card 15.

14 8F10 This is a table containing ITC values of x along the streamline, ft.

15 8F10 This is a table of ITC values of Tw along the streamline and corresponding to the x locations in the preceding table. (° R)

16

16

1-5

11-20

15 ^po ^s ^e num^er 0f x printout locations desired along the streamline. KpQ < 500.

F10 Transition Reynolds number, see defini- tion of Rr,Q in Program A, labeled QTRANS in section 2. b. 18.

16 21-30 F10 BEQL is the ratio of the laminar equivalent distance parameter to the distance along the streamline. If xj > 0 then a value of BEQL is required. If xj = 0 input BEQL=0,

16 31-40 F10 BEQT is the turbulent equivalent distance parameter. See BEQL above.

17 8F10 This is a table of Kpo locations along the streamline where printout is desired.

100

Page 110: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

8

J ID 0. > (- u

I O

s 3

UJ C D

_1 <

2 tu X

a:

-j >- u (0 v> v. o < o X

tr H o. o £

101

Page 111: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

o CO

—_

102

Page 112: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

o 00

o I-

< >

to 111 D _) < > o

tu _J CO <

W -1 CD <

K

—T~~\—

I

J

>

c 0 M c

!■

1 in

o Q.

103

Page 113: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

b. Output Description

INITIAL CONDITIONS

VELOCITY

MACH

ENTHALPY

TINF

PINF

QINF

PO/PSL

PO/PINF

free stream velocity, ft/sec

free stream Mach number

2 , 2 free stream enthalpy, ft /sec

free stream static temperature, 0R

2 free stream static pressure, lb/ft

free stream dynamic pressure, lb/ft

(model total pressure)/(sea level static pressure)

(model total pressure)/(free stream static prepsure)

REFERENCE CONDITIONS

HO

.24HO

QDOTO

HREF.L

RHEM,REF

RCYL, REF

SWEEP

.24HREF,L

QDOT.REF.I,

^k/^aw'Sv) = ^c/cp where ^o is the hemisphere stagnation point heat transfer coefficient, lbm/fr-sec

. 24 ho/Cp , Btu/ft2-sec-0 F.

2 hemisphere stagnation point heating rate, Btu/ft -sec

^REF.l/^avv.L" Hv,REF) = hREF,L/CP where hREFsL is the laminar heat transfer coefficient based on enthalpy at the stagnation line of a GO" swept infinite cylinder, lbm/ fr-sec

hemisphere radius, ft

cylinder radius, ft

sweep angle of the swept cylinder used for the turbulent reference condition, degrees

•24 bREF,l/CP

laminar heating rate at the stagnation line of a 60° swept infinite cylinder, Btu/fr-sec

104

Page 114: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

HREF.T

.24HREF.T

QDOT.REF.T

LAW, REF, L

IAW,REF,T

I\V, REF

TAUREF, L

CFINF.REF.L

IW.O

TAUREF, T

CFINF,REF,T

TW.REF

^REF.TAiaw.T " V.REF) = hREF,T/cP where hREF, T is

the turbulent heat transfer coefficient at the stagnation line of a 60° swept infinite cylinder based on enthalpy, lbm/fr-sec

.24 hREF)T/Cp

turbulent heating rate at the stagnation line of a 60; swept infinite cylinder, Btu/fr-sec-c R

laminar adiabatic wall enthalpy on a 60° swept infinite cylinder, ft^/sec^

turbulent adiabatic wall enthalpy on a 60° swept infinite cylinder, ft^/sec2

reference wall enthalpy, fr/sec

laminar shear stress on a 60c swept infinite cylinder, Ibj/ft2

2Tref l/(P'ou'*)' laininar skin friction coefficient based on free stream conditions

stagnation wall enthalpy, fr/sec2

turbulent shear stress on a 60° swept infinite cylinder. Ibj/ft2

2Tref T^^«11«'" k^bulent skin friction coefficient based on free stream conditions

wall temperature for 60" swept infinite cylinder heating calculations, 0R

GEOMETRIC PARAMETERS

SWEEP CYL cylinder sweep angle, degrees

SWEEP DELTA WING delta wing sweep angle, degrees

ALPHA angle of attack, degrees

RCYL cylinder radius, ft

RHEIvII hemisphere radius, ft

10.1

Page 115: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

STREAM UXE

XSI

ETA

THETAE

coordinate, ft

coordinate, ft

streamline angle, degrees

BOUNDARY LAYER CALCULATIONS

X

ETA

XSI

BEQXL

BEQX~

POPSL

AYEAWL

A YE AWT

UE

HL

HT

DODI

N

QLISO

QTISO

RORI

?treamline distance, ft

ordinate of coordinate system, ft

abscissa of coordinate system, ft

(b /x)^. laminar equivalent distance parameter

(beq/x)^ turbulent equivalent distance parameter

local pressure in atmospheres

2 2 iaw L, adiabatic wall enthalpy in laminar flow, ft /sec

2 9

law j, adiabatic wall enthalpy in turbulent flow, ft /sec"

edge velocity, ft/sec

laminar heat transfer coefficient divided by the reference hemisphere stagnation point heat transfer coefficient

turbulent heat transfer coefficient divided by the reference turbulent heat transfer coefficient at the stagnation line of a 60° swept infinite cylinder

A/A^, total streamline divergence

x/^A/Ai) (d(A/Ai)/dx), streamline divergence parameter

laminar isothermal heat transfer rate, Btu/ftr-sec-0R

turbulent isothermal heat transfer rate, Btu/ftr-sec-" R

r/r., streamline divergence due to body-shock geometry

10()

Page 116: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

QDOTL

QDOTT

TW

CFEL

CFET

ZTEX

RRQ

RRS

OMEGAE

AIEE

AYEW

THETA

iMUO

ZTR

EBARL

EBART

JL

XEQL

FXQ

FXS

OMEGAR

laminar heating rate, Btu/ft^-sec- R

9 turbulent heating rate, Btu/ff-sec-^ R

wall temperature. R

laminar skin friction coefficient \ based on dynamic > pressure at boundary

turbulent skin friction coefficient ; layer edge

ZT , compressibility factor times the edge temperature, "R

heat transfer reference Reynolds number

skin friction reference Reynolds number

2 edge viscosity divided by ZT . lbf-sec/ft -' R

2 2 i . edge enthalpy, it"/sec

0 2 1, wall enthalpy, ff/sec" w

Q . local streamline angle, degrees

ß , absolute viscosity at the stagnation reference condition. lbf-sec/fr

compressibility factor-temperature product evaluated at the reference enthalpy, l H

laminar erossflow pressure gradient parameter

turbulent erossflow pressure gradient parameter

laminar strcamwisc pressure gradient profile parameter

laminar heat transfer equivalent distance divided by the local distance along the streamline

see definition of F ^ in QTRANS

see definition of F in QTRANS

reference \iscosity divided by reference tcmperatiire. lbrsee/ft2- H

107

Page 117: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

THETAL laminar momentum thickness, ft

THETAT turbulent momentum thickness, ft

c. Error Statements

ERROR IN CONTROL CARD (NTYPE - name)

ERROR IN CONTR il, CARD (NPROG - name)

The above errors are caused by ari input error of the code words NTYPE or NPROG. "Name" is the control word that was input. This error will terminate the run.

ALTITUDE INPUT TO ATMOS EXCEEDED RANGE - ASSIGN VALUE OF 2,300.000 FT.

ALTITUDE INPUT TO ATMOS BELOW ROUTINE RANGE - ASSIGN VALUE OF 0 FT.

Input altitude out of range of ATMOS subroutine. FLIGHT case only.

STREAMLINE COORDINATE DIMENSION (750) EXCEEDED IN SUBROUTINE AXI2D

The input value of dx is too small for an axisymmetric or two-dimensional ease. Also printed with this comment is the x-value at which the array dimension was exceeded, the maximum x defined by the geometry input, and the iiiput dx. The run is terminated by this error.

DBTP ERROR

The independent variable is outside the range of the program tables. The independent variable and the table limits are printed. The program will use the table limit and proceed.

STREAMLINE CROSS AT XSI =

When the twe divergence calculation streamlines cross, the above comment is printed with the value of the i coordinate at that point. The program moves down- stream, by dx increments, until the streamlines are not crossed and begins calculations at that point.

10«

Page 118: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

CONVERGENCE NOT ESTABUSHED IN VELOCITY CALCULATION

The velocity iteration routine in subroutine FLOW failed to converge on a solution in 10 iterations. The program proceeds using the final calculated velocity.

SIRCH ERROR

Table interpolation error in the general interpolation routine SIRCH-

ERROR IN TABLE2 LOOK-UP

ERROR IN TABLI>5 LOOK-UP

An error occurred during table interpolation in subroutine TABLE2 or TABL18.

FREE STREAM ENTHALPY EXCEEDS TABLE VALUES IN SONENT

The enthalpy value used for table interpolation in subroutine SONENT is outside the table l>mits.

ERROR IN STREAMLINE CALCULATION

This comment is printed when a calculated streamline point lies outside the (9e(£ .T)) grid in subroutine STREAM.

109

Page 119: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

4. PROGRAMMING INFORMATION

a, PrPr Program listing

-•(Ncn-t)A>ot^<ao«o>-i<Mcn^mmr-co(hO'-4<Mcri^inoi>.(oo«o^{>4fn4,m<or<-0(>o-i

§OOOOOOOOOooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo OOOO000000000000000000000000000000000000

^0»0*0»0>0v0«<?'0»0»0»^0»0*0»O0»0»0»O0»0>0»0»0»0k0>0*9»0»0'0>0»0»0>0>0»0>0»0>0k

♦ ♦•♦•♦♦■»•♦"••-♦^^■♦^^^♦♦^^■-«•■»•«••»♦■«'^•■♦■«•^■'«■'»•«•■«••♦«»^'»♦•♦•♦^ («(M(>iMoir4c>ir«ir4fMr4<vriiriiNc«f4(>i<>irar4r4i>t(M^r^r«c>|c>ii>iciir<iri<i>iNNrii<>4i>ii>«i>i

o -^ * «o -* r* UN o

• ••>••••••••«>•«>«•• • • «»r- in

u. O ui uj _i« «» a. *- UJ a-• < < (K ^>o » «/) x< u. u. a tu»- •-• ►-•»«o < a o *~ -•

•-o»-a zzx.ui< -> üJ oc ui K- u»oo • s -J UJ LÜ K •-• <-« X X OC U. U) x o X tO Ui u. *-. -»a • — UJ < 00 o xa. o a 1/):? x x >»-of o x x 3a v£^o»-~ o x • «••••.•••••«,•*••• • • ••m^o «ft x -«..-.-. — -»«, ^ÄÄ*» Ä ^. ^,Ä —~ „-. w © ^ — >. «o <<\^)0»ojinoo«-<*f^o««»iOh-r,-f*»*''s>r- f-f- cn9»x»nr- 1/) »-•

•-(•Mr-irijrgojmfncnoo^mAmtn OOOD X^— OC XX «v r* * *v r* o» «n «0'-«/> o o «•

^«o«^ o» t-i xx< or »-• o "^ ^ _ w. H-er »- • j O */»

^ — w w w w w ^, — ^ ^, w ~~ w — — — *-— <<»^>UJ — u. » as O» <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<< << .-.-. — IUX o X»-< »4 « v «. w . ^ w — w w w . — — — -, ww —WOQ;^ — m ■« X OC <♦ «na •-. o— • <o ►- CM •••••••*•••••••••• • • •»— •—.QmtO • O «« x — o«nr-a xx < ^, — ^. ^.^^, ^.^ ^,«. — Ä ^ ^ ^ ^, ^ ^ Ä.^. .~_<oin«>~* >-« — •-• u.«/> w? Xinf*-OX-~ rat/)»

<-ivo »--luJZU. x J < <r»-»«n»«n >--• X XXX -• U. t/) « < UJ Q. U. X'-'UJ-JX t- H- —UJ — »x < a o _J! < UJ 0. «1 a: et _J — < « o UJ < < ui o o:uia:<_iouj x<* oc _i uiuj x>-o: o u >-at UJ tn •-x o« at»- xa a*<»9-J«nQ. <o x o o < coo au» x a a a: h-> xuj >-o < »-ui »-x z« —»-uj<r->- »«J O •••••••••••••••••• • * ••OiOX3i'-»- »Ut nt «.^^«.^^ » A M«. «.«. A ^ ^, ^ «. ^ *.*« —.tnxo^-x» ujx Ou fNiina)^-#i».o«o<oo»nj«nr»-r-r»f«»h<'h- t^r- Ma>— ••••-«• oc -o

t-ii-ii-tnjMojcijenwooooaotntntn mo» >. Ä *»-•»/) —. -» rtui» D t-i o» r» rg r- ex ^ »oooxo o ►-ü. x

tviri ■*> & >-* —-mino»— in»Ly< ^ -. — o*r-'-« — o—— xoruj

o ~«-.w.^w.^w^^-,wwww — —.-. <<ino — — ooot- voxce I^ <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<< << «• « — m x O m ac in< v ^> »- oc — ~. ~-~ «. w w ~. ~ w ~. — ^. w — ~-*, •,»► «.«.<«. UJ a. r> o. — H- -> >. t/)

< K o: ►-x «-'« in ui m —x acM •••••••••••••••»»• » • ••UJCON»X*»-»~*O»>O

1 O* •i/)»—<'~UJ—o»-«»* f u. — —-. — *.*»*.««*»«. ÄÄÄÄ«,Ä«.*. -. — -~-«—.UJ —o»-o x 0^4 « ^o I O < ULf) xxo: X oa Otnuj »n H-tn —— w z

XO 0»-to XD <-j u> oc intLinh* XO o»-t/) X3 < _i 10 a ino-nnr*»— • — UJ»*-'« < <o »UJ<U. —m a. xtntoxx *n *» • r»-"-ui — H-_i — •-j

w oe »4 xuj-tK< o. 0 o x-1 «-• < a UJ I*J «-• UJ «-.«.»,« o o-• H-"«-. >- u o «H u >-uiUJ t-o o < ZUJ UJ M«^»-o ae H tn ae s ■-« «A oiu »->«-o muj>-• — Mu ^ UJO — w<«caoujxa.oc«K->xxwaa(MxuJo.»-ujx«xinuJ*aQ-'X>-uj>-xtn

avx — -»« x--x—-XO< oxxxsczvo «m OUJrH4-r-o<nvoo«rsim«o^)<*r-r>r^r>-h-r«-ujr^r<-UJ'~i-#Oin • *\ O O •OOt-ac I-H

a> z N, _i >-••-• pi I^N (VM tn m m m it m m a> _)• m j ^ « «.^« « Ä« »^ « o, < w »m-i z < «H »M KOJ o» < *r-< 10 UJ o «-in 10 ©to tn ~-.»~ K «<C> «x ♦ m > A o > Z<0—ZZmzz ~ -j < ni x X « -■^« — — uj»~r~ocuJuJ—üJUJ<<UJX W) l3--.-«-w^^-.--.-.«».-.-.«.-D-.-.3<<XUJ-OXXi«XXi-»-OlK < oo<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<o<<o<-'-'^iujoe«"«uj«-<<<xo

(JUJ«''»'<-''VWWW«..«W«.W«»WWW~~UJV««UJ«««.O»~3 0030000<OU. u •-• N m •«■ m <o r» 00 o« ^ oj m ^ m <o r« • o> ^N •-• «O I-IM tn <H r

110

Page 120: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

C00003000000000000000000000000000000000000 oooooooooooooooooooooooocooooooooooooooooo

rs>rgr>jr4r4r^ni<>ir4rNirj(^nj^r4r4r>jf>jr^r4r«ir>ir^rg(N4r404rvirtjr4rgrgrvr4Nr^r^r«iriJ(>irgr\i

X

Q. >-

-• O

a or <

o a:

UJ

>-• .-t 2 t-^ • o — II O u. a u. vO .u — U z * i< • _l • ^H «—i _j cc o f- — » •tT a lA 2 iO •—i »-• ro i—* • a. X r*. •

—• 1— — •■ a o a UJ o o — — UJ i-H a r-« z a Jt * a •o — • in • _l UJ O _l UJ * UJ u. o > ~* o vO o —• UJ »- ^-■ a Q: *■ i— X > UJ O O t- tf« o < ^-t O a -• — ►—* >- a: * * • a: o a z l^ a: O U- ^H >- f- <o ~- ►- UJ o X -j H- _J a: a • M a.

^ r-t m * i < UJ z X d w UJ _J u a z —'H o z o • • O z — o Q. **• \j\ • < > < oc z — O -1 o » • XX« <"■ r-l ^ >- O rj o ~ m < ~- Q: o o -t m o o o • l— ^H •> f\j o o o o O »-i • _l o^ a CM

■-I * * r-l (\i o -< rr( *~4 o o * i-H f-H 1-1 ^H (M O O < * M o U. vO (TV U. O O X •> t ^ X o o o o o o >o X -• ^ 1 o 03 < -H CM xi o in • •-« ^H UJ LU • rH UJ •-< ixi id Oujinoujinujin m • rH »- u. II u? OUJ * — — — — 3 II .. ,0 - li a D O - 3 %» Z3 • 4- 3 • •* 3 • 3 - • >o — z UJ -«o r- D «o !- K- h- 1- Z oc iH m «-■ t— »—< V Z — t- Z Z m z m z in z .n m ~. i- ►-. ü: a z M

< < < < •—* o II — tu < i- »-* UJ < •—< o •—1 '— O — -' o •—* »^ •—4 *-* — UJ < oa. »—* o -■ UJ z x x z t- a > Q e- X ■-H k—• z »- t- X a. 1- 1- l-OH-f-QH-^-0>-0 Q K- Z _J _J •J3 z n »- »- ►- cc a: a: a: Z (X lO < — a U '^ z — a: o z Z < z < z < z < < •-« (ü -J _i Qi z •—1

o o O O O UJ X tu cc o o i-H u. o o: o H- o OOUJOOUJOOUJOUJ Lu o: o < < o u. a o o ct u. u. u. u. u »—J z a: 3 u. Q -J •—* VJ 36 U. (/) U ejuctouaejuaua a: at u. u u o — z a u 3

o o o o o H f-H o (^1 o o o o m o o •-t rsi tn <o o O r-l .H nj d ^t 1-4 in vO oo o o o o o o m in m »r> i-< « >o «o

u u

111

Page 121: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

<4-in>o^-«o(>Or-<rMm4'ift<or^coo»0'4(>j(n^t'in<or-a>o>Ot-irM(n<^m<or<-«o»0'-ioi(<%4' 0OOaoooaoO9>O«O«(|tO<^O«OO«OOOOOOOOOO<-t>-i>Hi-«tH>-4«H<-«r.«f-ioi<M(Mr4rM

ooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo

r4(>|C4C4r4Nf>i(>ir>iojr«fVira(><NNriiNNc\i(>ir<l<>i(>i<>4NrMr>ir<ic^cii(>i<>iri|c>i(sirg(>4N(>l<>i X 00

X X

a UJ Ul

vO I

E a •-• a X • z <o o • • < —• IO • o o «1 o *^ iD co xo O m Q < a: O • Q: Q. o u. x 2 t- -1 < <o "*" •

o < z UJ X

Q o o • c*> a 'O *-4 Ü. V < • t0 •-■ "N u o

o z UJ ^^ 10

X cc u-~ -j <n X — u ~ • UJ ►- U (O ~ o • ^ <~ U f- u. a Q •-•►-< u. at o Cl X »- •-■ V ui z • -«>- i^ •- o i * »-4 * * a x UJ -> ^ r-l •> Ul • z Ift rH X • i-i iH UJ o 3: _j m H •-« O iH o • 3 H » ^-i ii II UJ • (O >- • »• a • n VJ o ►- •-• r-l n — w »-Nf XU. • u r>J «••XU}»

o • B « • r • »0 < l/) d -. • z • z ♦ Q — <-* ♦ — < «C <-. • >- 3 t- UJ »4 •» 4 •>. *M • z *H * -.« a ~. i0 10 ui «am »«■* »-4 Q^ ^-<

o < — -» X M w K ■~ 31 OC Z3 • Q UJ -s 1- — »~ — a: c t-< H^ Q — io a: O*- UJ •-« U. < 2 "s < (O (K O o <v u V) •a» • u CO x • Q. • O Q« a: «o x H- » • a a: • "^ X > »-4 t- x »- u. X CO Z < iO X Q UJ 1- Ü. X a: o a X — ■"" X « u - X « Q£ X — * I z «« w ^ •» UJ o t- ■*^ *» ^k Ä .<««>%««««. «-* «^ _j -« ^ Od rj — #% M« 4M ^^ o (SI Ul S2 o o o o o o o^ > o o o • • o OO O OO X I • o i l-t fH O O r^ r-« If» <HH- Z o u >-i r-t <n o X O •H r-i m «H Z < o o o OOOOlMOOOOO-i "-< o O OO Z CO o O O O O-i UJ (n ui o Ul o UJ> m m m m Mmmtniniojoao üj H- m m • ,_<•. m m m m m _i a: ** D <* 3 r-t Dt/) * • • •> x • • • • • < UJ 1- I-* 3a • * <( w a. • »•*•>. t- »- z — z z « u->»ninin<if\tf»iniAtf\3ta30 Z UJ m m — i- < m m mm m u io < ■>• o ►-< o « X «■* •■* *^ -«^ •-» ««* «« «^ «M* o •-4 * — — m < H- — z — — xa »- »- (- t- t-<QQOQ_/QQOOQ-J-l-i H- H-coao»-zujo 11 Q O O Q _J _J 5° z z z <<<<_|<<<<<_J-J-J z < < «acl<u<<<<_j_j OK o o oo o UJUJliJtlJ<UJUJUJUJUJ<<<0 o uuiae04>uji-ujujujuj<< u.«o u o uo u acirafleuaaceacruuuo u K o: 3i u. • tr •-« a a a: a: u u o o o o o o rsi J^ o o o o o r4 fM tn en <o •o u u u u

112

Page 122: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

ooooo ooooooooooooooo o o o o o o o ooooooooooooooo

^ * ■* ■♦ ■* ■* >*• r>4 «M (M «M fM PM rj rsirsif>4(Mr\4r>jr>4(Mrgr>j(M(M(V(Mrsj

Z

X • 33 rg

2

IP

>o o u.

< <

X < UJ

3

■-> UJ

-< Q. Z M _J «<

'-« CD O QC H- Ul K

O II CD O m —. en P-I _j _j

— _j _i X << o

o

fNJ

3

<

UJ oc UJ I a

to O) to D « 3 ~ r « Q UJ Q < X < o: x

•jj (ü ^* Q* (K •~ O »-4 UJ o o »

O X <-" .* o o a o >o x O UJ to if» • <-i i-i ^ ►-« • «o —<

2 X m — i- O •-■ UJ — UJ < H- »- i a H- £

r < « QE: o o UJ o: c o u a: 3; u-

X -J

Q *

U. <

— X X •

<

LU

«a

UJ

II •-

— to U 10 2 I- X I-

u.

H to *■* z • < . ce •- to f- - 3: a: o »- « a. •

U. X to i^ — X

o o o o »-• <-•

— 3 ooo Z O üJ in in in uj -j r> • • • X ü- z m m m

_J _j H- Q O O _J _i z < < < < < O UJ LU uJ c; u u o: at a

O O r^ m f-<»- z O O O _l ►- < O m ir. _i o o: O '• • < uj i— •-»

m m 2 CD O O O Q _J _J _J >- < < -1 _J «I UJ UJ < < < O a: a u u u o

o m

o o

o o

yj KJ U

i- o "* z — « o 3 O

O uj < in 3 l- • • z -j in o •-• UJ — II I- o o -« z < -< a uj to u ai x

o o m

u

UL x « *-• i_i tO I/) » X x< • • ^ a a LU UJ uJ -I UJ UJaJ 3 3 Q to «/) • • • »-«<; < i^i I X X OL a _I _I -Jixl < <Q — O OOO -i --i m ooo in m •

• • • <o O m m — it — ^ UJ

»-< QO t- < << « i- üJUJ a: UJ cr ex 3

-^ jj

tO ^ X v. I X •* o » X X rsi i^ •*

• X a -o UJ • ui ■-; 3 ^-

r -i m uj • O X X

< x I o c^ • _1 — < tO I X m _i • uJ x a co x

x IP 00 Z • —• u. 3 <

l- < UJ t- X _J -* UJ • a x O ao X •

; -H u.

< H- H- < UJ £ -i a UJ O Q U. rH i

o o m *o

o r-«

m

O

o z o • — I-

< < o o t- UJ UJ O _j a: • in UJ »- • Q i/5 u m

i -J -J — Q -J -J w < < < u. ui u u •-• a:

113

Page 123: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

,0*«f.r.r>.ror-r-ror»r*r><B«o««o«)cooeo«o«O'Oto«o»oio>o>Ok»o>oooooooo ooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooocooooooooo

z z

9 H

• •M • • * ^* t- -»— M

f- < z s »- X oc • • X « 3 _ rH ,4 •

— — •-• *«* • X -> « ■ -~. *» ^4 »-•- ■ «o— t- M • X -• •-• ►-»- « xz« < u. «c K ■— ~ -< • • • X z •« • * • »- w: ►- • X Z M F*~«. •> • • ^4<-» — ui « m UJ K • •->«-> T <H i-4 «^ ■ in O^ o • Q rt ^ • "1 • • o ■ ■ -» Ml-« • • • tft h* • ■ « ■". • »« i» •H •^ M • • AM UJ •-» « U. M 1 -) -><-«' « • • tM a* M w Z • O w> < • • — -i UJO: «»«>«» •«« a < — H- M U*--—— X-»<«/) o •M »« _J w- J oe« • ^-UM-)<K»-IO »- -.- _J Ht- < K- O »- M •«-~.xZlUUi_J »->-»-< •-•< 9 a O o z • i».-><<cDXtt:uJOz«< x

u • a. • z «« w) i- ^ x Ka > o • (ÄH» K u X U. K —»- •UJXUiUil-«- — %. ^^ H- XW - » «••»•» ►- »« ^- -*x UIX K«-«--"-'-^0 »-« X --' *• »-

4m, 0m ^^ •* •* «^«« ** z 4M«.

oeo O • OO O • <M »m oooeeooo? • «oo o Q i-l ■-• 1-4 o oo oo

o r-f »N «-« •-• r* IA »-• OC O ►- z

§ i A >-l^^^4^(r4r4< 0 •-4 oo oo O ■ U OOW W Jl » ~< e oooooooa: ui o m IA IA N uj m »• xumjinA> • _i wo ooc Uul<iAlAlAlAlAiAiAlA3 • iniAlAlAAIUJtftUI • •••AD ft »- 3 3 • • *• < 3 J W>- •HI 3UJ • • » »-« 3 • 3 mm m Ztntni zziAi«ou»«äi,«oc» ZQClAlAtAlAlAlAlAlAOUlAlAlAlA ZiA£ «.» « o Mt — »■« — ^i ■-■ — ^ »_ I-« o •X *~ K %* «i^ *^ 'w^ Ö fe-« w >>■ OQOt- »- ot

« z z<3 -j —i » O OUJUJ < n. <

K_l -1 -J t- »- «^o o o a aoa a i- ►-• o OO o »-»- 3* UI o 5 < El JI_J 5 <<<<<<<<< **• <<<< i ULi o < < o UiUJUIUJUJilJuJUJ0£U.UJLÜUJUJO

«Kocoufleai-uuaedeuMuuuuuo u acaeocaeacaeacoes »^ aeaasaeouacu o «A O lA S o o »•* •M N O r-l Ol m •A «ft ■A <« « «o

114

Page 124: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

r>jrsjrycs!f^(Nrvir>irgry|r\jrsjrs«f^rsirgrari4rg(\irvjr\ir\irsir^r>jrsjr^r^rjr^fgrsirvrv4rvjrgf\i(^ oooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo

r4r4ra(>ir4c\irgr>ir\irNir^c>ir^A4(>i(>ir4rsirsio4rgr4r4r4r4r4Nrsjr\<rNi(\jr\jryir4cvryir>irsir^fvr4r^

U-) ~ ^- < u. < ►- >£ t— iu » in üJ a ^4 rg • • H •O ►- Ifl « *-« z • O U) < •-« >- X a. -• • K- — O t- ac o o z • a m

u. X ~ H J^ V- •H S •-4

■m* *~* «M- •^ ooxo • rg * If» r-« <a: a h- ^-i z o O OüJ UJ LÜ _J O II U JS — < O m «n o: > • _i to -< 3:UJ O O Qi O * • K-t < ^5 l- 3 JÜJ K f-t m m wo u X in It Z U. (D O *^ *** t- O ,-1 _ M Q

ao -J -j « _J 1- <o-• t- -J _J -J f- < < _J -i — -1 wZ _J J J ujuj<<u.<ooa!0<<<o a: a u u •-•uc»o»-uuuuo

m m o m-H «n \0 O <Q

■y) X

— Z — ,» > • > > 10 i/y OT CO X — X X z • z z ♦ ^» • * (/)-• f) uQ »—* •—■ *-e •—•

• a: • • —i* — < MW <-<.

(^ -< f- ►-• »-*

•-• tO (/) — LO ~~ ~^ « ^* * »-• ft-4 or x cr a: I/) 1/5 ^M • « < • < < i— — It t-t r-l O »- t- t- • «. M || || ^

X X »- i^ to X X »« — ••< Q • Hi • •

•^-' -• ot + WX 1/5 cO «-* • . w _ „ rs — a »- Q a -«

CO —. —. i/) • *-• • • o o rH Z -• — 1- W </) X X %^ Wio a a: — _J o — — uiQüiao ÜC X X • • i^ UJ -< ^) i/) X o o • N. < M> >— CO u? X > ►-coxa, I-OQ:« •~ K a a X X 1 v •-•MWVV«.VX •-* *«< tO ^ _i_i w ««» -~ o o .— . X «41 X •-« CD iO a CL en ** zoooocoo 1 »-4 « H >»> H- t- _j _i — i- O O r* r* i-4 r4 r* r-i X r 1 *- o: • • N It CO CQ ^^ •« •*> iO < U OOOOOCOiO II II f-l < o o f- ►- ?H fM r^ X (X.

UJ m in in m u^ m in *~* —» *—< + »- It 1! —i •-■ 11 II IÜ w w w - z> ^^••»•••» •— f-( «H i-^ irt *-. » •» w >-> *m 3 *rt (^ «0 ♦ II ZOininininiTiininio ♦ Srf o — X •^ •"• X Ifl ft-4 »-4 z a a a m O ►^j^- . X l-t ££ (M QC it w w (X < w ~> —i ti II II • •->• »-u-QOOOOOO —> »»4 < f- < -» X X <S)h- »—1 H^ >- ^» — -» « »- Z <<<<<<< u N H- K- *■* »-• < UJ UJ o ac z rH rvi to Q. < O UlLüUJLÜUJlLlUJ w t~t w o w Ne* w t- ax oo o — •w ■— x a: u accaacaact •-• »-4 XQ K X xiDai-OQ:uaa.aQD

o o o fM r^ C-

u

113

Page 125: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

o<-icM(*\«in<or<>oo^o-(r^!*i4'iA<or^(oo>o^4(M(n>tin<or>co(hO'ioj(<>4'in>ora'(0(hO

ooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo

Ui

— VJ — ! U 1- U. »-« *

M •> *

• t-« p-t

-i 11 N i M lO"-» Ml • Z • • «.«.<«.

— «IO a:« 1 M ^ j H-^. 1 - OH» CCO

u «o x • * a h-X 1- CO Ü. K •-— « x ^ —

! QOOrH OO 0«H <-•>- m IH z o eoo-i oox -< ( i ininm-itnmooac di • ••<«»_JUJ»-^» mtn m 3B m m u. (0 a — — ^ —.«. o OQ 0_JQa_l_IJ>- << < -1 < < -I _l _J UJUi UJ< UilU < < < o acaeixuKaeuuuo

y) ■~ « O «/)

*-» -^ i/) • »M« ^« i/i {/} — r-t * •

O >-< 1-4 • || .H l-l M • • r4 »I M II

< N | M «. • • a: «•-. •« — -.x 3 * • »^ ■»•»-«•-• o

Q^ — ioujQa:-«

to«-xa3t-Qa: — «H— — — «- — — (/>

UiQOOOOOOO I voooeoooooio ujZirtmtninmmifkinM

3 < • • • • • • ••«« ZCKtnmtAinmininmiA N^ ^— *w« «^ ** ^M» «^ «^ «^ ** X

t-OQQQOOQOQ- X <<<<<<<<« O lijUJlUUJUJüJUJUJ« u a a: a a: a: a o: a « o o

X 11

-«< ■ »- -«to »■* X

z o

x Ui

X _' v/) a. o • a.

CM • X <-« »>*rH --

♦ UJ — — —UJ »/) I-« ,-1 ■• ^» .H »-« ~ -.< uj — — «/» — Ui — I VO «/) O. r^ 3< h- Q QJ

••H-lJlOO oo — voiuj-^oa: H N^UiNX«-4n M

»HrlX ■ f-»U)»/)«-»f-« *--.J-- < XXl/)f-«UJ_JH-'-«—« ►-<Q.-'UiJUJQQt ««»-OUiw<XOO xui(L3<L;»-oa:

X o ♦

a:

• «/) (M X II H

> X — z > • o

«A X

< — t- — i/) a: x < • i-

a. x io ^ X Ui - D a. • -I W) 03 X

a • • • a. < oo ~ _( M -~ H « II ■-■ CO

o— x »-<<-« x a <V0£ M — -. _! — CO < — X X U) «-I

I— ■»<■-( ^ g^ w O (/)"«/> H> O UI Q X X K Ui a D

u u

116

Page 126: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

•Hr<jrr»^in^is-oo(7>o.-<(\i««»^in>of~aoi>o>-<<Ni<*>-*iAv6r~<o<>Oi-*rs(-o4'in<Oi^ao(>0»-»f>i 0»0>CO»0>0^'J>^0000000000<^<-«<-^'^'-«'-««-«<-«>-*<^'Nir,4rg''Mrgo|fMrMOjr^m<Ot*»

OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

c^f^i>irsjr>*rvjrafNjo^ryjf^r\jr»i«>ir«j<>jrgr>jr^^jfMr«r\j«>jf4ojfgr<r4P4Mrsir\jo*rvir^r^<>|<>|rgf^

Z o

o (X.

ct <

z aJ —a

< _l

UJ — tU -~ X > -1 v/) o «^ ai v • x ~ -» Z) z - z > > o -• •-• • LO U) Cl tO — ^/l >I X X X >-« .2 Z s: z UJ • • • i- a • — K -» tfl '0 X o >- o FSj ■-< *■* ^4 o u. z m • ««••. UJ oc • • — a ^ ., CO UJ X o «.<»-■ — — * a z m .*»_-. «^ — u _! '- * w x ifl a o; u K X li. O V M _J x < < ►- *1 O ^ ►- • ISI cO • >~ i- *~4 * UJ • x • Q. tO !/) i/) • ■-« tQ r-l Q. • — O »- X X —" N • n -I r>« >- o

• a, LU • • !t -• </) >-« CD M Z <M fvj • I tO vO •-« * z • O »- • — o »-• >s — »- O CK * .*» ->< « tn V >- a 4- * rg—i • O O —• *-* i/5 a •-• !D <Si •>- >- to •• o ♦ — to o a: _i •-• —>• xi—• n UJ • •> * o r- ♦ UJ X • • UJ — W >- CC O in ^ X -~ o m * — UJ — lO iO > u «^ 31 • • a (Ni 3 X X N • o — »- a x x V K X 1- i/) Ü. X oo - z * o CD

ujw co a. a 3< 1 1 _J

O-i »-* *-» x *: - * :*: a. a. — U t- h- X UJ CO CD X

o o — t- o oo i-4 O O rg ^* ■^

1 V9 K CQ CO 2§ iH <-» 1- üT» ^1 00 z O Q a o •». X X X UJ — >- »- OO_J oo -^ •-^ < o z •H o z — o z H Z •-< II II ai D in trim_imin_iuJOUJoiO z z o «^ — r»- uj — uj x r«- UJ — ** O ** *^ '^ 3 n • • • < • • X 3 UJ D \- l-l o o -« X r-» rl DX D Z »H 3 K •-• i/) 10 •"• >-• ZO^oMnsminozaizo M M (/} X ~' ZX Z X — Z X w < — w *^ ft-4 «>* **• -w «^ -*■ UJ •-* N-* o a. ►- »- z 1 rH X • O ►-• 1 •-> z X • O — 1 U _J K — -« f-l-QQOJQQ0Ü»-_J ►- _) H- H- U U UJ O X -I H X O 1- H- X -< 1- II X O 1- 1- X IU_IUIOO:2:<<<<J<< « Z -I Z -I oai z z r II — H i^ tt N Z ~ II Z (/) U H Z — "-<XOOOQ:UJUJUJ<üJUJU.O<O<OZQ3D-' _J U. -1 X ft <N O OU, _l O X •^ <N o o u. <u»-aau3ü:QiQ:uo£a: •-« U U U U O UJ a. u. Q

1 1 X »-• X z X X O U •-• X U Z X X o u •-■

O m O o o O O o o fX OJ «^ u. rH CJ fn >t in * «» co OD OD

M U U

117

Page 127: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

ooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo

c«if\l(>lfsiMf\ir^cNjf^r4r^r^o«iNiC4rg«Hr«c<r*lc<r«*oir<<>«r^r«<^i>»r«if«i»>*p>jr<fv<Ni<vc>if>i«Ni«>4

• r-« UJ

X oo

• fM »-• UJ

II

r in

X -*- z u ^ — z -~ >- X uj z X X >- • • IA z > X >s • z z a > • ~ • o z > ^

o o — a: — • • X r-l * -t K ir\ > — 1 I-« l-l — UJ • • rl C\J • • X rg — ♦ X o o x a <-• 10 U) -' o <£ OJ • K UJ X OX "v r-l fH r« x m • Z eo Z - • » ^ »a • i-l • x o o • Z I M ^ • l-l 1 o m M — O •>* O — ra ^ iH •H p» o -^ — isj 0> ISI K

N ^ N • u

«« tf« «-»M • I UJ » .«. «w «» --* • o o ♦ • • • * o U) o z PH O z o rH o l>*<«I • >• o>. - s K r- tu — O— + P-IU UJ — «» — 1 r^ •»» UJ r* •r-i<nuj>"^>x Z ^^ O X O Z Z »-ID 3X -•z z f* r-i z 3 ^ 4» - - 3-^-1 rg <- 1 Z X — z Z X ^# •_• 1 —• z *. ^ K • z a -a. ac M Z x »o «s)*-) i f-i O X X z o -• W)~ 1 r^ O X X Z O X • z »t JUJ < -

Xl~-Z X »-I J fM .J — o N a a.

X ON- K ►- K i ►- X X B H t- X ♦- X + H- X X i h- X o 11 H- »- 00 X CO 1 »- X Q. 3 -i H a z z ~ z ■ ■ U) Z

O >^ <M X oo z z- z N ■ '/) u N (/> i -«ot Z K — »•"■ Ot II 1- t- Q CD

^* «V O H Ott. H M Ott. 1 0*M fi K O rH CNJ X u.aoxo«u.H n o CD UJ Z h- X X o z u« ZÖXXZOUZVJ-i ZOKXZOKXZU •••xu.<nux~>a:rgoNiaaeujK —j ■ i

o o o s o o o o o o o rx o tf> o oo r- oo o> •H M «n -«• lA vO r- r- •-• p. oo 9, O u.

r-i •X l-t <-l •■4 fH IT« r-l r* o «

|H I-» fH OJ (O

118

Page 128: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

k

I oooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo

f>ir>4r4r4^^(>4r>irg(Nr>)f>irs«fN4r^r>ir«ii>jrvir4r^r4r\|r4rs|^r4CNNr\jr4r>*N(>ir«jrgrsjrgivrgrsi<>i

UJ Z

O a:

<

Z

u I

z u. 00 (O < < z >- t— o z z-> • <-» t— X ►- < • > ij

>- —Ü. • CD ■-< I- < Q X f-O - zac a — j t- < (O x t- ui

z ^^ z o O ►- «/) >-• I/) « t-ZI U UJ l- Z X

u- a

x i X

* m » • *

a:

* *

X X •■0 < Z to X t-

Q- •-• oo in < tu Ul X UL >^ I o:»- I »- o X X t-a LU h- Z 111

* «• * * m • *

z rg m r- t- h- r- r^ • aJ ^M tn f^ 00 (^ (t\ (T, ~ a: -i h- r- <M u rg ■« ^

z »—* *M« "W ■«# ■«^ ■K^ «MT *— —■ •—«

< < < < < < < » X — «— — V- w. _*_>«•. a <*■

•- < — -~ — -~ — >— ^.

o X x — < »^^ < Q: < ^- t— u. z — X l/) "— UJ < »— < o: ►-• UJ — I X cc iS) t- O tO oc • H- Q 3 x uj a: x a. —

<n

fM

• »- O X H I >- K _l O — UJ II U.

X I • •*£*••»

<-• * -«oini^-r-f-r*- •f a. «-^^fofn^oofloz »-• • rH |^ ^ ^ • — >-« •-< i/\ a) •— i- a — cv K -vO •-

<D •"• I/) < w ^ • — UJUJ"-« •••••••>< • 0»»HO»^ *— Z* •-<

in »rH^H — 0<'-'— -»——■'-— -» — — • o*»»- a _J _) o ••

<<> OfM-H >-V UJDXOiO a—.-~ ~ r^ -^ t-l |_| >U<<0<U. -"< ä •••» — uj i/«_«ujr^>-<<Qh-a: co r*- r- •-» r-t Q uQ<aC'**xti-<-**-ov)(L < — — ri + 4- UJ U»- — UJOUJXUiOXXXZ t- «• —■ + »-• ««■ QUJ i/)<U»»»» -'*•••

OZ O Z •-• « O— Z ZO N> Z-~ ~ . o«" o «* •- — OH- — ►-'OiOOLiJO(,'>-<"r*r--h-r>-'-<oD r-tt- >-* t~ >- H- --IV K O»-UJZv._)f-4f-(<«>00«0crW

xcD xxx «->-za:D>OZ< o^ CM t- Ol <0 l^l^j^o« Mat UJO'-'-IO> «nr-»

»H H-x h-1- XIX4-K+»-V a. 3 >a:Ci<x-" lr-i —•IHZ zwi-.»,«.-.!-! jMjt-O'-ia) xrs*-" —»-w~<< II IIOUuH HOHU.HU.IILLllOüJllflDUJZQD 0O<<<<<<<->» XZO'-»XZO'-''-'-«>-«>-«'-'ZOOZt-0CUJ iO uui— — >----' — — »,w

r-l f-4 1-4 O U. r-t CO

u u t« u u

119

Page 129: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

<or^<oo«o«-«(M(n4'in<or>-(o<>0'4rsi(n4-in^>r~«oo»o>H(Mm-^m^r^a><hO'4rM<«\-#m<o

ooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo

O «n

iO X • ^* <v • o lt\ r- W

O < .— t- o uj »m I or »- m— m • wo: —

— «< a eg </> >- • • XU> — O • X o u> »m fw »»t«

^— w oo- Q o m m to < X - •< W-*

»- • < Ot~ z UJ -~ t-iAUJ • I rg u —X »■* < »- m • CCt~ it H- • o ->«) • -> <

«M m o«/) — • Q r- r> m tu o <« «n — w r- o: m z UI h-»/) o —a f* Z M< < x - fH »>4

K t- < -• N -1 w ÜJ UJ f- ae M4 z <I • UJ o • < — K- - I a: ••» UJ

• <M H- • -« "I a •X • • —. O • i-

< o -> o m »^ cO — ♦- mo m — «^ ««

Ui f- «r f» X QC -1 •M

I - h> - < tO < ^ t- O - «X 10 z X w «x a < UJ »Ml >-«

U) • • O H- Q£ V9 nj U) Q.UJ X » — Q UI a. »« « X • u oo ** g • ■ -.« «^ r* «• r*ui en — N <M tt-i »Ml «^ «>» 1^ »^ <n UI »4 •

tn< «0 X X i0 CO O- > *>4

»4> z <Q:Z z ZUI <- O- »«•-• UJ (~ IOUI ui M K- O(0M •«o -3 z uüuiz z »•- ■ ■ l-f

<o ■i • a: M i^ UJOf X «MO V) — IU Q '-O.Q o o: »z - a x CO »H nj

tn

x — < — UJ x z < K H- •* ■ UJ «^ —. ■ — m -•x • tv n — u. • -»—x

•-• «VO »i — •< OJ o •-•»- to <~ui~ KOI 10 UJX »- X

UI

< UJ ac »o

UJ o Z -I

z o u

> X z

•I o lO x o X < — z — < rH I- «^ UJ < • lO ►- (O

•-• < Ui < tO ►- »- X Ui • UI — O H- o z a I o ♦ <

U. _J Nl • IM UJ < OD < < UiCE h- H-I^U. K Dl- UJ^ II UI<UI ZU) II H X N H- ■ « (M>ZU.UiU.^»-_l <tO < < «-< ■ Z -i H-X»-»-U,KXO< UIZUiUiMUJZUU

m

X < »- UJ I X X

-«< «o X UI II II — ^ -.— X •

nj CM

o o

fM lO

to X

^ (O I- «> N

• I-l rt I-f • * •—»

« o H« CM i ^o tOK

X Ui

•-i u. ui i-t m - X 3 «O 4- O H Z M < »Hl-I iOO H tO >- K I- Ul »- Z — I u)0 U. O »- X u « o

o

u

120

Page 130: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

f^flBOOr^tMr^4-inof^fl(>o>Of-i<Mco4,iA>or^a)o>o»^tMro^»,ii><OP-aijovo«-««M<«>'*in«i-oo

oooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo

C4r* r* rst tv r* C4 <v <v r* rv t* tv C4 r* ry et <v fv r* (v C4 r<4 (V r* et r<t f* C4 fit r* e* r* c<4 c* (-4 *l IH 04 r* t>4 r* X —

>- X '-"

< • H,

s: x - o: • —< D. < I/)

»- X X ai • <> I «

■N X — rj

O" ^ * UJ • < »-* ~ _l« t- «^ rg O U) Ul Q <S) Z X X < z < I f- »- •

<0 X UJ <NJ i • m X —• — OX» 1- tO • -» rg -1 0 X * »- — rg to u. -< —< ~ z —• -0 Z — —.

N. r-4 (M — Ui —. Z •^-1 rg Q ->. • » s\ X X. * pg iO -r) Z ui X »-^ • UJ < rg « 2 2 < 2 X w (M tK 1- #-« « • *

•— «-< 0 i^t ^ tO • — rH CJ

1/) J " X UJ Z X .-**——, ^-. UJ X X • ■* •-< • 1-^ -w. Ä • 1- < o^ ~ * ~ — ^ tO tO < UJ • fNJ X X «M cc < — •-« 2. a < * Oi Q * < H- tO tO — t~ >- »-• • rH »-«OX X O tO UJ —• — in 1- — tO X • * a: x a f~* •-<• < Q X • —' »> O >- «n < * * < • ~ f-l OJ O a: • t- — X »-« 1- — rg • • rg u < X UJ — 0 a UJ f\< • -1 r-* 4

« o> * O r-< ■N X • l»l w w

UJ _J • —• < • a 1- -H - O Q O z - - fM h- m • • - Q < < t- ►-« X to * UJ • < --» X Q< h- t~ r-t

»n U 3 X i~* X rg »— <MQ « 1— UJ UJ ■♦ O f-l r-l «\ Z < I —. »- r-« u • + 75 UJ • • O • • •-. -«. < X rn Q • UJ 1 I-« X • -» -~ O •^ i-iO «V r* tu 0 • 1^4 — •» ^- «^ »"^ • '- 1-4 f>g 1

1 1 t- » • o: 04 CO f-< •> • X 0 —> rg • • rg *~i »—1 r-« CM H • X X • X ►- a X IX. rg • r^ -» O < w w O .— «• to X f-- • —t rg * * •M> < • fH — -Oi- 000 0 a I * rg >~t » • a. • a 1- rH — Q O UJ -• < — < ~ |s. -n • »» O m <*\ _j •O 0« - a « »■^ **

tO H- — V/) K- O cr» • < (VOX« UJ i (M CD X ■* O X 1/) to O • X [liCM X UJ O • H « 0 • • t- p-< *-• •-" H- u t«- X — X X t- N II II II -• OUI UJ • rg — < x eg • II **^ . — Q. — " • _J ^ ^-* • «« ** «01 z x --" «0 rH x _i II • T-g — p-t ^«a -J Q. a H- •

UJ U r-) f-« UJ OUJ -> ^ UJ • ^ _, >_ II • • .HUJ rs *% rg UJ 11 -• + II -J CD -1 -J 0 D-H 3 • • _l co D • • D*-_J X « « •-•«-DU r-l >-• D I—« <W w^ — 00 H- CO CD • <-• Z -f Z M •-• • Z »-«rH Z — 1- X m «• — H- z -J w »» Z to w 1- 1- h- < >-• fH ■-. w w ^» O ^ ^ ^ *-l UJ < < » rg UJ Q < •-* < r-l I-* —< r-l o: a »-4 -H < ÜC r^ O H It II B X 1- KM <-( 1- 3 o« 1 H»-00»-l-XUJX M(-< X i-u H H 11 H < X 1- m i- < 11 0 m to to •-• rg z uj Z H »-• ST -« < — ►-• z -« < Z « a oe -^ »—« i- ac z tO »0 AJ •H 1- n Z UJ ^ rg R — < < < — w O-H II O to K U. II ootot-oaoi-'^ 0 a UJ 0 O x >- to m tO UL 0 0 X tO to -■otfli-1-i-ü.u. U« «■• 'vJ X lü •-• «-• OUXUJU»lt.O • Q 31 • Ü. u Z Z Z Z X X O Q K XZ Z Q X tu UJ UJ •-• •-•

rM nj r-t ri 0 (A in O O rvi 4- 1-«

N fO tn ^ 0 OrH eg «0

-«• in

121

Page 131: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

OkOOOOoooooo>'4rN'4»4>^'**'<4v«v4*«i^f<4c4<^ctc4<^(M(^(MO*tmfOfrtmi*mmA •*m«\intfMr\K\inintf>iA>n<ninmiA«ntfi<f\tAtniAiAm«A«AiAiAirkiniAinm«nmintniAiAiniA ooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo

CM >- Z

10

o ae

«n UJ

-I X X <a Ui ♦

io a -> ♦-• ^- *-<

«^ «o — xi a:

eox •OI R

UJ • »^o

ooco to U % li. K

l~»

o

< UJ

w ♦

o

o

a 4- uj o^ujp <<>

I- z< z o W>0**^"0,,^'^Z Xl-l-UJt-HZM • z« z — s

— OOU. OO UL UJ XOUXOVJMK

4r •*

i -»

5/

to «o IU Of o. — «n «to

Ui UJ an ec

ui z

Ui

o 00

o »H

oo o

8 «0< <« •- O »- KO Z U UJ UI u

o o < -~ z -.— o • M oj IM O Q

•4 «4 Ml •» • Qf CM <- ~ -O (- O •-< Q Q — O

• •^ < M • • ui «-«iO K • a ae a XUJM UJ o

uj o — ■ » — UJ ••-• 3H- — — OO I- z to O"» M x zge < t-tUJOv«« ■ »-i Q. QC l-OJiHXX—t-Z3 Z M. < ►* » — -» O O W K — O u. u. U QXUIKUMM

4■ oo «A <e s

122

Page 132: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

oooooooo- oooooooocoooooooooooooooooooo

m « r- a o< o r-i r» r* r- • oo ir\ m m m«n

_ o o o o o

< is»

I

UJ

X in

UJ -I CO <

u. o UJ m O • z «M < r-< tX UJ

fH «M m

x x a: ac UJ UJ Of oc a a N II

IH OJ

a a.

UJ UJ K D Q. X Z ^ M Q « QC «- H t- 3 O O. Z t~ «-HOW a. o u a:

o «D

10 M Z » M Z *

Nl

N

O N z z

^ M ~ U UL < UJ (si O UJ

z z «o s» *■«

a o z z a ut o

o M a) x n z u. 3— j uj too x:

t~ u. CO

«ft

o

o fM

c

o

o

o P«J

o

o

o

o

o o

o

o

o in

MZ z •-• K

<»- — MO X • z .*

M • Z UJ M

— — W) — — M ^ —• "* ez oz z < I-« < «-« < r-l < Q> rsl Nl Nl N I N l^-^OI ZOIWI^O

Nl I Ht-Nj^Rt-NNlNl I K -«U) —HO) - Z • Z li.-JNIOU.-JrgOU.HU.HO — XZO-«XZO-'Z«ZO

oo <-* P>J

o oo <n <•« O O O G <o co o« o

< M

«J) I M N z — It u. z«

oo

o

I

in

O «•

m UJf» UJ

rHOZOZ>~>_jM 41-HKHh-X»- Z W «A Z — Z H ONIONIOU.O zozozu^u

— co -<<

<o:

* > NT.

o«n I-* » oo «X • c«

«O -' — H" UJ < t-Z

a o 5 U.

< Nl

X

■A •

«-4 UJ

U u

o o o o m o 4- »n «or- r» r4 r* r4 ^H iH «H O

Ul 3 Z z z < HI ae ui t- 3 QC Z ►- Q K- O UJZ (O u ae ui

O H- 00 u. i-t to

123

Page 133: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

coao<scatscoooao(7>a«<7>o o* 9> 0* o> & o* oooooooooo f-4»-ir^»-«r-«-<»^rH^r-«cjfW(M if\in>Ainininir\>AirtininiAti%iAiniAifitr><o«o>o>OiO<oo4><4)<o<o<OiO,00«o<o<o<04>iO<o>o ooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo

♦ ^♦♦•#4-4--*4'4-4-***<^ 4- 4- •f'f-t-*'**-**,**-*'*'*-*-*-**-*'*-*-*

o .A "v

UJ r- *-• U ». » i/)

z O X X UJ m • X o *-* * -^^ tn ac ■-* o o • UJ K tO m n X > £ X X — f* 0» — — oo — _i UJ — r-l

a u. i/) x </) uj co XX H- K Q X MM«

< X t- —

a • * * » * * * UJ U) »» z >M X X < < co r- r^ r>- ao r-

tT\tr\ CO ao CO -r

Ul UJ f-( o» ^ — o • a: tn » o m ■-•

D *-- tn r^ •^ 10 < «tf w X 10 <<<<<< *■* X X » UJ *— z < UJ «« <M X 03 t- < ON z a • I UJ

UJ

• * .-1 • «% —». «•■» «-» *«• ^-. *-» • ««> I H «-* x

iO K WO -~ o »- <o II wj < < O iT» » < t- U.U. Z t- tO m r» ~ X «_ 00 • < «t« < UJ« ~ ~ o •O 1 rt M

z »-iO f- I tO x to m r-t a #^ a • -) •-• UJX UJ X H- X Z < x r^ v. «S. •-• m • X a Q • • • • <k tk •> Z • - ♦ Q >. <-' • — >0 ►l

a: •n < -» X * * Ul <N CM i-l ,^

8 cnm r^ t>- r~- f- rvi f- o < * — (O < ^ z ^ UJ r-« <0 C^ ^ C% (*% »» UJ iTl ►- ♦ ON UJ t- Ul • in <

u rH (M fM f* tO • f~ UJ * • _1 UJ & p-i -* ►- in o O < X * -HO X • Z (M UJ

aJ ~ -H •^ t- O ^ t- X II z K * 11 r-4 I Z O < UJ lA •-« • « -i < -t UJ 1- t—* f-i <<<<<< »-4 X - i/) -> * o • • I o • ON -I >— ^^ »- < X o oo o> — UJ -~ IM 00 — • • z < •»- • m .-« — z -) • -« X M

< •MI * XUJ — r^ v o -« — >♦ o w « -> Ul

ZQC » < • o-

Ul o f- »- CD

1- « J

o x< « < • 1- -4 UJ r-l

»- •-4 r-«

X -•

*^ o UJ o

< 1—

UJtO o < yf) X m — ui — * a — uj < UJ o — •/) UJ oc <o t- X i^h- 1 OX CO »1 00 Of 00 •"« • X »-I/) 1/) f-t < UJ < < l'i — ►-«<>- rt n «r» — — ►- .-• o< — — X <m,

tOUJ X eH x»-> t- I ►- K x iO I- • — -4 ON •HO«/)» •^ ►- eg o en o *~ UJ — UJQXUJI-UJUJI- X ul x ui •-> o » PlJ ooxz out z fM «Z ^

UJ< K- < U Z_IUJ>s Z. ~*T>X O UJ

• u o z £ 3 " 3 uJ O O r- O

** • If»

• OX «0 O <0 0» 'H Ul • iH N.

• «o ox • «oo» ^ • -H II

c ^ *■ r» r- r- f» t- r-i ^^ i-» • x

II « * UJ Ul Ul >o • UJ m

t-KJ < vjfHfnaoomaoo .J M4 1^ ^ N-l a H • « — «m — — -j -j_IO>Ov»0 — ->,fl-3rt D-JOC Z < rur* ■♦ r* < 10 VO */) (/) ««^ z —»- • t- z z • -f + - »- •~ z o< < ^i «o oo r» > z z < z < l-UJ<<MOUJ<w< Ml l-f pg UJ < O UJ -• O KU a *-^ «-> UJ UJ >- Ul < •M -t-T-* rHj- X »- .H O» h- Z Z Z I- Z N 1- »- 1-

CO li OXZUJZi-O w MI ac uj ►-• Q£ Z II H Z - H a •-• oe »i z 3 << < < < < < l-< O "■<•-• I •■* < < u.(rOo>oixoo ^ «M O Ü. iH CMQ: oooi O o U) U UJ **. w w w v w w w ÜJ Q Q t- Q Q a « 31 U. O X U. u z z u *»zxxu.oxuo

fH <NJ cn ^ in ^o r* «o ^-l

8 oo m o o •H ft •^ CM CNJ

o o o «p ^J »0 u u u

124

Page 134: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

oooooooooooooooocooooooooooooooooooooooooo

•*'■**■* 4 **** + * + j* ***** * *•*•*** 4 4 * 4 <t *•*•*•* 4 •*■**■*•**•* *

X z

>-

cO

ÖUJ

z z »-• o •-• h- »-• t- »- O Z H Z N O»- OOt-

Z t/) »H X UJ • *« XllflH>Hr4 O

z « a ■>u)<<coio^'H

U-^ZZKZXK-ZZ — K

H ■ ft IS) < t-l

t- tO Ul < • 1-

.*> •« UJ ~ ^ X • UJ X >- < z z o o H z z — »- < < ■ II r\i • « r-4 UI « « « < i/) XZ-+- X Q Cl (O »- < • ••-•>->- H- < < x uj 1-

r^ ^ + Z Z ~ • ae a o a Ul !/)»/)>- • •>••-• V 'S « < Z ^^« Z U) »-< rH ~ — m U) t- • -f -f • X «/>«/)••< • •-• X UJ X K X X • CO CO O Ol- O v/> • •ZZZZ<'H XI UI X M<*.wv«.h-l/) H- K • ♦ O o Q l/)l_UJUJUJUJUJCOU.U. «-' — UI UU 1 UJ 1 XUi<<<<«'Z M* < i/) Z _i -i -« _l ^

u. u. — «-t-H-h-t-at- *rt 1- O « • • </) • </) X (M «- < o a ui a» ui uj >- K X UI u »^ < — O 10 »/> >- zzzxiiao« N N • UI * * -t r-H~ rt *0 ♦ « K UJ •-'•-'»-»-t-l-OiH «■* -■*. O 3 X X «O O UJ tO X r-l tO N i U.U.N ■«■«<- t-« ft N ZO O a « N « II Jl X •H t-« •H OJ m # fH »/) *^ « ««• '-««IXMXOJXH (^ «/) -l_Jt-h-Kt-tOKO<^ -< *-<- < t- *~ w i~ </) n o M < -i_IUJU/UJUJ«»UI "-• < ^» zo ►- < — •-• OJ < tfl K <<riixxxio ►- (/) O X UI U. U. 1- U. I/) «/) >- X HI UUK>-h-l-»-t-XUJXUQÖ-«'-'UJ »-• X X UJ

o eo

o s m

u u

Page 135: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

inor-<»(>o-<(Mm-*-in>Of>-coo»o ^ 'O ^ ^ 'O *o ^o o »o *o ^ ^ *o ^o ^o *o oooooooooooooooo

'♦-»♦♦'♦'»*'*>*>*'»-# *•»♦■*

^ft OQ CB CO CO OO GO ^O

o o o o o «:> o o ^«r^y^f^i^ ^4 P4 r-l

OIMNCMCMtMOirM

OOO^CKC^O^OOi^O^^OOOOOO

ooooooooooooooooo

z <

z <

< z a: <

a — < z a: <

«/5 < oo or X >. ►- ^

O — U) m Z eo ^i < I

►- — z

< — — »- —. — \U r-t r* I — — r^ < < <n *-

I- I UJ r-l

• —(/> UJ- I < O»-* <■"* H- • — U> Ui < « —

C4K in + (/)UJ X r-l < N ■ (/) UJiO i/) it — < « Oi

«UJ K X

UJ

r-t Q V) < 00 ct 1 V

Ift — wO •* Z co r^ < X

O * *• I- ~ l^

- o o ^ u o — ^

ä X «-• ^ I —

> > > vn irt </> x x x z z z • • »s

m muj ^ z> z o •-•

»^»- ►- N Z X O O "H O U

t-< I/) I/) l-l

X i0 X

• UJ - I \3 r* >-* • ^ \n -•<

UJ (M «/) 3 «O X UJ z ►-. « ■

Ot- XU) VO « Z —« < X O U. »/) t~ •-• u •-■ x uj

CO X I

•» tO

lO X

>- +

o o o <NJ

o o o •

UJ I-

z • •x X

to X H -H I- -< rg II Z — tO X O u. X « u •-•

X z

<o

tO X • >~ .» ** rH •-» 10-»+ + X X X X — z z z Q w - *, Z •"* »"^ <■■< •-• to o to U. X X X

N N II _J iH cv <*\ . J »^ •-• »M < to to to U X X X

z z (M lO < UJ

< »H ~r-i I- ♦ ><•-• UJ >- z «o - z — XQ — « I z < tO rj •-' K X »- U. UJ H (O N ♦ X _l »H >-■ I» _l < 10 U < K X O U UJ

+ —.-..♦ >->->-<: Z Z Z I- ■^ ~. «- tu < < < I K >- H- .H UJ UJ UJ < H H • »- W <*> •♦ UJ < < < ■ H K t- UJ UJ UJ UJ O

~ + ~ + z z >- • • Z !-• •-• • + ♦ XXX z z z UJ UJ UJ < < < I- I- K UJ UJ UJ III »- f- »- M H N

i-< eg <n h- >- h- UJ UJ UJ III

—i r«J >-^ i-^

tO tO X X • • X X < <

— < < >- I- H- Z UJ UJ • • • X •-• •-» Z tO to — X X Ul — w < a. a ►- _J _J UJCO CD I ►-1- I- II II II •-• (M

■»XX t-X X UJ < < I H- (- H- UJ UJ

rvi lO

to X

X < X < »H I- X UJ X • <

— »- tO UJ X I — «M a. x -I X CD < K I- II UJ

tO II X UJ x a < O

o o cr«

O in

o o o

— (M tO lA X rH X • < oj h- If» IÜ ^4

(NJ UJ UJ tO DO. < Z O

UJ K tO - z - u. O u.

UJ tO ►-< u «

o If» o m

u u

12()

Page 136: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

<OI'-o>0>0^r>j«*>.*tn«OP- _,..,,,..., ,. ^ . <o o» o -• fM <n ^ m <o r* co o o t^ fs'! en ^ in <o f». in o» o •-• <M <n <# a> «o r-

ooooooooooooooooooocooooooooooo _ooooooooooo

W«Mf«ioiPiifMr4rgoj«Mc\jrMoirM<M«M<M«>ir>j«M<M<Moj«Mi>loifM«MrgrMfM«Mr<j rMoicMoioioioioir*«

rg tO X ^^ ^^

to z r-l fO < • X eo »- >- X X UJ z • »-

1 1-

1 ft X rg r-<

CNJ * UJ ~ i- 03

tO z a ^ Ul X •—« • O »- X — h- in eg -1 UI H- <n «0

X to </) X — 00 * I

►- tO Ul I > ~ t- •~ <^ < X * > «»> t^

—•I- X *-* >

X 1 1— r-t

— > < > tO f-

UI rg t~ UJ oz 1/) <S) 00 sfl X UJ < to « x •-• • X X X X z 1

o 0 0 0 f- < to H- pgx z 1 H- z • z: >t c 0 0 0 0 U) »- O — <-• • » cg — • x < in r» 00 rH O m I UI Q. ♦ rg Z -• ♦ r • »- ■H CU rH 0< i-< CM O <H <> r-t »- • u o< • tO Ul • rg uj • »r> • o* • • ff\ • ON • UI 1 a»- •- rg X 0 rg to — o <-• o {> 0 0 (V 0 O O UI < ■«v UJ < — X. to ^ ^v 0*0« 0 0 • 0 •k 0 t— t- >- - O • ►- s. -. ~t tO ~ r-< \0 NO O 4- ^ O <NJ O >!■ < Ul Q ^t a x ui — <r\ to X r> f-i lA P4 «0 I-» rH N •-< -* rH _J V X 0— a • Si < X • < • f« ♦ <■* « • CJ • rg • D Q»- (£ U) •*■ 00 •-H —• »- • XI- 0 • 0 • O O • O » O u O • X^X to u) ui X < Ul 0^00 O OOO 0 O _J CD « Z 1 < t- X X 1 X X 1 IH m <o >c •* ^ «NJ (N -t * < Ul O eg I- • • 1 fM 00 < rg |H i-t f^ i-l <-t iH rg ^ rg i-l u Z X

0 • to UJ X X

< rg to tO <

X t- tO K Ul <

CsJ rM (M tH rsi rn eg FH (M <-« 0 < 1 to • z X ►I ♦- • • 1- X X X X X XXX X X H \S) t~ t^ X UJ < < tO Ul •-<•-< UJ X X X X X XXX ?■ s: h- UJ 1 -.Jt- t- X — lO tO — < < < < < < < < < < i>',' z — (M + • UJ UJ — + X X + h- (- t- !- t- 1— K (- t- 1- UI -• Q. 0 4^ - ~~ + tn O — — ro UJ UJ 111 u UJ UJ UJ LU Ul Ul z 0 t- 0 1/)»- »/5 a. a ^ 00 rg a a 00

tU 1 UJ K Ui 1 LU 1 !U 1 UI • UJ 1 UI I UI 1 UJ 1 *-< uj a as 0 UI K Ul X -1 -J X X rg ui -J _J X 3fMDr-«D^D^3 <n D^OfNJD^-DPOD* 1- ""> 0 r\j DZXXODCDIH- r-t Z5 CD CD 1- z<z<z<z<z< z<z<z<z< z < 3 z .J M Z !-.»_<(_ t~ f- H z >- f- 11 «I-«!-«»-«!-« (— •-• (~ *-• K t-i ►- •—* 1— •-• 1- O ►-4 .J CJ O •-• O M h- II n H <M O »—< 11 11 rg H-lUKUJH-U»(-UJt- Ui K UJ f- UJ 1- UI »- UI t- UJ ac 1- < tO h- H- Q. <»n ul —1 X -g t^ 1- 1- r-« X tO Z^Z-Z-Z-Z — z ~- z - z - z •^ z M z «0 Z ao - s; »—• oo 00 z CO < CO 011.0U.0U.0Ü.0 UL Oü.OU.Oü.Oü.0 u 0 X O O X U. X m T X 0 0 X H- X ^jM^t-^I^I^UMU ►^ u -• c» « u -• u ** u ♦-4 u h- 0 u !—•-••— K t- \- t9 W H- UJ f-

eg .* <£ ao 0 000 0 0 0 0 0 ■n ITI m in «0 O r-t (M (f\ -* 0 0 ^1

u <M rg rg og eg

u U «J

r-(

u U

eg r-t

u

og

12'

Page 137: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

«00» O •-• rtj + 4 m in IA

oo o o o

(«\.4-in<or»a>oto>-«(Mfn'fm.o^aoo>Or<«(M«i<4'iA<ar>eoo*Of«(M(n'*'

oooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo

MM (N M M ■♦ * * <♦* CM og CM <M Ol

^^ *«*. «n oo

en oo

Z X X X I X »- h- 1- »- 1 1 1 1 *-> i-H

(*\ 04 a) — ao •- 1- I ^ r

UJ Ui UJ ~ >- UJ t- H- Q. I X <n a uj — OT> O t- »- oo * O I * «• — -J - w x _i >- —. > (M —— (^ -, 4t ~ * |_ •~ m u) | — tn tO tO > >

> > 1 ^ > < <n -» > < X _ M CO (/) iiiv/)>X iO>X^ > ^ r- ui t- > co •- Z > to X X >Xi^»-»OXlO»-«00 tO X UJ > U» «O X UJ • (O X z z «ZX«/)^«ZX^I XZ 1 »-• x; x z l «-« X X 1 • • »-•rx«n»zx(- z • 2: ♦- 1- Z • X tn • z tns: x -• X • 1 rHJE • 1 — • s < -« — • X < IM • *• • • i/)»2<n »ZfX* £ • t- W * X • »- i- tO X tO «Nl (\j 0(n «»«Qr-« • »_ LJ • CM UJ O U • rvj Ul z < • X iO to a<<-«i/)i-<i-tv/)Q (M I/) —• Q. O fM to >- »-* »- «M «- -< < *-•

1- < X f- < X -v LO '-1 N. -V t/) "-l N. o UJ tO >> to »- _i 1 UJ 1- — O I'J !- --■ — « CO — | — -. to -. a. • «- — X UI UI

• liJ>v.O »UJ-vtO O x n <t to x <n — x to tn • • o V X • - X» — < X • < >- M X • < X X < X -* X - QX"ix:-~5:-«s:t~ • X »- Q U) • X f- V 00 • K < to < z OaOLO>-«iHaoini-tuJ X < UJ O X X < UJ Q X X UJX X o - iIlXXi^<IXvfl 1 X X 1 (D I 2: X 1 O t- Z 1 < •> 1 tO

»- »Xh-t- »xrg oo < rj (NJ oo < rg 03 UJ • OO (M t- X < v Z •> X 1 U • x 1 i^ X t- i^ Z to X W- tO a x x to ui < X Q OX<rg X<(M< •- UJ < O « ►- UJ < z o < ►- < »X '-Q. U

<ZiO •<rtOK- • • H- tO • • •- O -I X * h- — < X fM O _J * mX<-'UJZ<i-*üJ i—i ^ LU 4- X -« •- UJ a) < « UJ to >- X vO u < —

1 <t-tO_J<H-U)w I/) I/) — 1 — (0 to ^- t- t- tO «- x UI ** < \ 1 < rg^uJX •►-UJX + X X + «n + x x + z ui UJ x ■ — tO h- O O» X

o UJ ^ UJ — w (T» o ^ «- e« o 4- — „ ro o •-1 > z a. a. x ui co IT« a o i« — a + io—CL+oo ra a a. co o to»- a a. oo o O- a a < -j _i i 1 -^ _l

ujo ijj»-a-Js:xQ._is:x f» IU _l _1 X UJ o UJ KUI _l _) X OÜJa.l~-i-JH-CDCD fM X Z 4< Z>C4 3Z_ltDXS:_iCQX»-r-t3(OcOI-D fM 3 Z X CD 03 K M D M ajoj<i-i-tox<«-tw z Z»-iC0H->-<a3^»- H Z 1- ^ H z Z •-• ►- 1- »- M Z UJ to 1- H- II II II •—• < 1- • z '-O «Of- II Ml-h-ll MMO ►-• II M M •-• O •-•OM N »MO1-» Z O M H < X X to ^ < tn ►-< »-►- »-a HZtniuiiXr-ii/) h- •- «-^X tO (- 1- (- 0. m »^ X to i- h- o a rHCMIXXXUJII lltO z z s:->oo — z»-«oooo Z 00 < oo Z Z OO OO < 00 z co oo a. < •-I n u x -J n oo O xioiu.iinxx O O X J- X O O O X X 1- X o o XX_JI-tOQQ<UJUJ ua <j H-xt--it-xi-^e»uK-uj>-ua U 1- 1- UJ »- 13 L» l-»-<UJXUCDOOU

o o o o o o <M o •-• M o o fM en «n «O 4- in

u u u u u

128

Page 138: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

«00»0»0«0»ChO»0»0»0»0»0000000000»-«^»-l^«>-«'^r^r-l^l^fMnjM«>|(M<viM(M04iM««> f«-r>-r>r«-r>r«r<-r«t^r«-r«aoocoeoooa}aoioaofloeoana»a>ooaooeoi0cooooDoo<oo(Oaoio«iflOoo oooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo

44** * -t -***** 4 ■**** 4* **'**■*•* 4 * * * -t ■**■**■**■* 4 ** * 4 *

CO r-i X 00 »- X

1 CD «M X oo

— ^- — X ^ w •* y- H- « -**. s—. *^ UJ — <C UJ ~ ♦ «•* X «n X > — -» —. H- < O H- iO ~4- > 4

1 i- Z 1 X >« o ». > > m — UJ < .H Z «OlO X -» W lO 10 1- > 1 1- • X X Z > X X X UJ l/) «/) -• UJ X Z 1 • «/» 1 z z XXX X • • X — X X fM • • >- Z X «^ h- U) X X -» • Z </) X X —* - •< 1 X • -• IM • « • •

•~ m ♦ XI- Z * X csj tO H 10 X v/) rg rsi •ai

IH ~ <o U •> UJ — üJ < wi x Z < • X ^ to rH —. <o < X Q cv — O Q t- < — _ >_ rg — •-• < a oo < I I (- >K (/) x. Q. ^ UJ K- >. O UJ «) V oT f- U X X 1- Q Q. 1 ä i-t ~ •-■ *-* * uj «•« Q. • •-. — x Ul * t- O Q.

1 U -J >t -t tfl tn •* X • •* w x UJ 4- • • — 1 U -J (M ♦ < 00 -« x < >- < x —■ •-< X X < X — X _l rg * <

— 00 -> >- — X </>•!- O i— oo vo */) >- CO • 1— < lO < — UJ 00 — — «MI -J tO >-t- X X UJ O UJ X X X Q X XUJ X X O fM Q X -1 tO « )- LÜ O z — 1 X i CO 1 »- ♦ 1 O 1- X 1 < • I * w »- UJ O — ♦ — Q U • * (N 00 ISJ UJ rsi • x cg CD • oo rg f- x < * z — a u >- Q ♦ - ^ rH < tO X J) Q. Z ^ X < tO X I tO Ul < X Q -« ♦ «- "v Z CDU r — + Ul — *- < OO < < X ->« z< t- < • X -»Q-UtOUZ—• • ■f CD "■• CM X "v (/)•!- _l 1- X < iO O X • »-H-, < fMCMO-J + vcD«-.-* X OJ V. l/) ü) zo X M UJ 10 i/) UJ < 1- X < •-• Ul l/) 1- tOtOU<fM-.\tO— Z * UJ V « «, ÜJ — 10 *- 1 ■ K UJ — »- 1- 10 w X Ul <-"<<,>»i*<UJNstO — ♦ U -0} UJ ♦ + X ♦ UIZ + UJ ~- ■♦• Z Ul x — — — w) t- o t» * x u — x ui Q + X X < m o * — .H O >-« 4- -a ^ o •-< — —za.Q.xujoD!noQ. + xi < <-»-•< 1 h- 00 o »- a oo o «o »- a _i oo o o a a < -i -i 1 i — <-« CD _l rH < <N ►- ~ eo o «^ Q üJ I o UJ Ul _JX o ui)-auj_icoxo UJ Q. -i _l 1- CQ £0 XXZ4--<e0Ot0QUJ K I «» •- < 11- fM O X CD 1- OJ 3 < X OD 1- »- OJ rj [na)<»-t-xx<^HK~-x*'-'<x Ütl- Z tO + »- II Z f- K M Z O O »- 1- 11 M z uj»- »- ii ii « -•<l- »CCZl-ZtO+l- 0«-«XQM(MO •"• H II «MO •-• UJ 3E II II X rg o w z M a < x x irtf-<«no-««"^xoii -/) CO i/) -'■ UJ sT co H- 1- ^ <M ^ 1- t- Z ►- »H rg X t^ »- 1- O ^ fM I X X XUJH N t0iOfnt0wUJ4- II CO H II M 00 00 Z 00 (0 CO z 00 GO •-) CD z oo oo a < •-• II II X -1 11 11 00 11 11 11 00 UXQQ<XIO O X I X O o I X (/) X o o XX-Jt-tOQQ<UJUaJXQQ<I aDt-uj<ujt-i-o U >- H- »- V3 u 1- »— X H- O u l-f-<UJXU(nOQ(DU»-UJ<UJf-

o o o o o o >0 r>- CO

u uu u

129

Page 139: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

r-tfM (o4,iA«r~(OoOi-ir\j<n-riA4>f^ooo>Oi-if>ifn4-<n«or«-a>o>o«H(M<«>-*m<or-cooOi-t mm (t\ m <*\ t* <<\ &\ m •* -t j' ■# *t -t -t * -t -t u\ & >t\ *\ u\ tn in ir\ it\ *\ >o *o IO IO *0 >o 'O o >o *o t^ r* CO GO 00 00 00 00 ^0 CO GO CO GO 00 00 GO 00 GO GO CO 00 00 GO CO CO CD CO GO GO 00 00 00 GO GO flO GO 00 GO CO 00 00 GO 00 oo ooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo

cttH r^rMr^tMO<<vr*ir^r^c«ifa(>ir^r^wi>iM«>i<vc>ir\jivr^t\icaoiir»j<\|cvcv*Mfsi«Voir«*i>ir«i<%i«>i

z < o #» -« rg z Q 1- < < -H M

Q: • «a, Q >v o > <

~ rH tf» tO cc > ^ t>- X ^v 10 CO ^ z r-l

XX* * tO Z 1- o X 00 • — tA • X z z r- X »- •~ • < t-i X •»

n OJ f- — < z oo i^ * »O 1— •-« X > < ~ o UJ to 1— a t- 0>J I • X

1 o LU lO i-U X ~ * CO • •-• • X fNJ CO -«</).-« GO tr. X u. ^ X 1 X < y- o K « ~ h- l~ **r • X (M * Ui * ti. x x ui X 1 < u. < «-• < < •H 111 o X LO 1- X to v. < X LU < < Q Ij) t- — 1 1- t- UJ 1-4 UJ + X Ul UJ + — 04 z X X X X — — «^O \- a 10 < X X 0 x x a + COO z _i< t- !-• < »-t >4 < _J i-t

xo LU *-« UJOOl-LÜUJvOi-r^ÜJtOKtD »fl t-rsi D O ^ >- HI -' 3 X LU r-« D X ÜJ t- X II z a i. n n w) z H n z M li II II (MO •-^ — X X CO »—i OJ I\J 0 ►■4 «V (M «M rH <» cOt- i - * 1- X X < f- t/) i/> t- t— (/) v/) tO + -« oo z z-^ < - z »-I < z »-* < OO •-• «— XO o O 0 f- u. O to 1-- O O tO t- X II V) KO u U X LU •-• u X UJ O U X LU K- -• X

o 0 0 0 o r-l (M m o> r^ r- f>- 1-1 i~t <-■< <-*

• • 0 0 H 11 «■* —fc

*^ ■-■ -— «^ tO to -• < tO K X UJ *^ «^ I-« r-<

0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 • • + +

tO co X I- II

o o

< < I— h-

■-• LU LU <M (M I/) i/) tO OO • • •-• < X LU UJ tT (- 1- _J _J O X LU II • • O II II — 1-1 — —•-• Q Q IN «-• — << w ^. U) I- I- O 10 i/) I- LU LU I- — < UJ — ^- «^ t~X u. u. o X UJ t- -« -■ t3

UJ

z H + z - O II u — o o o

fM to

to x eg 11 «/)

« H

tO«

to to X X

eg rgto tO co < X I- H- •

tO O f- I- UJ X o »- to

o o

UJ II II —

•»» t/) (Ol- < UJ H- X

o o

X X

U. u.

rg eg rg rg »/) t/7 tO tO 1-1 < •-« 00 m vO I- tO X o X eg UJ X •- 1-1 II tO H H 11 r-l X rH iH iH O CO II tO tO tO h- ►-. r^ < -e CO t/) tO I- 10 X O X X UJ K •- O

u

130

Page 140: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

r-r-^r^f-r-r-p-ÄOOwoocotooowcowo^oi?. aocoapaocoooooaocoaoaoaoooaoaoaJcocooOcaco ooooooooooooooooooooo

0>0»0»(hO>0«CKOOOOOOOOOO<H'^<»i'-<

ooooooooooooooooooooo

< <«

< PM »- 1-4

r '-• n

tu »- < z o a: o o u Ui z

< UJ a: i- irt

of Ui

UJ Q D a: z o ►i Ui i- a z o u o o l-i CM

— — U)

« < X UJ II II

Ui X

X X «-■ < 10 I- X Ui

ox II < *» I- <-t Ui -I X I-

— -~ * I/) v: x — K

(X w w (/) UJ • «7 v/> X X

<M *-• < I I- II «/) H- -* II t* ~t X Ui •-• — ■-•

« M — -) Ui UJ —

0 + "1-)XXZZ<-i rg-)ww a < '— —i in eg I XX^I-I-I-X»-«

t-t •-'«<~)UJZZIIH II O II «>l-—XOOUL« ->Q^XUiXI-UUX»-«

oo oo rj O Psl (r\

Z < o »- •-« Ui

< I _l OO z> • U «n -I •

-t < <M < U -H •- LL.<

Ui Ui • • z

m •-■ M < -I h- Z «n ui < < • Ul »-

fM ce ui X I- z iO I < oo I- z * ui •-< tf> • •

t-i o: M x O «-< £ (T Ui < ae • ►- Ui ui x II •~ rH 0> (*> fM O» • X

o o> o < O <0 X £ O UI • «H < ift 3 «O — I-

Z — »- UI O -• ui < ^ H i- s: X Q.

z <-■ o: fi o o o a o ^ i- o u 3C u. • iO

< — — o

< to x

►- o • lA

r- —

— o • to -> i-t •>-> » o — o H- i-< < m

> «o

u Ui a

ui

z z •- «a: _i I- D _i z Ka< O UJ Z 31 u a: ui

u

to X — -' X

-I I- -I < «) 3 Ui

Ui < Z _i -• D »- U

O < a: u CD

to

«o

a: <

x • to 3

a» a«

o o o tA

u. CO

O '- O Of o <o < in *-t I- u — i-i U) t- (/> — UI X "■♦ X < u • • N. Z -'— Z O ui c- o» o v _i <n i-i Z < r>- to 0>f^ z^«o—«-»Q: £>-• — Uillr-|i-<H-D ZD'-<X> — Zl-Q oo<^->oo»ouiz uui ozoi-uorui

<-i rsi o

•-I X •^ '^ • a.

»^ _l H en ui -' •- 3

n z z

u

131

Page 141: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

ooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo

«k «k «» »

• rg

• •o • ♦

X

fSI * • OO fi

«n oo «-i *

r-l »

X z ■^^ m «n o ^ • (M — u • •- ao rg m f-i o> o 10 1- ^ < * * * * »-I • X •-• >- o r- r-f* r«- * oo • m z UJ r- rg

#-». *-fc ■> X » • • • • t- ON ►- o • 00 CO X • • • o • * O^ • ••« • rg.» o •* rg m 1— «o m m * o »H o

— z rg «n rg sr O * • — < • * m (M 4- r-« r- co < — •-» r* * * ♦ ♦ • rg w «^ t-M

i— r» r-r- f- o

• m m X

t— a

N. • • » •

-H (M «Mb «^

X #* i-l

o • • •

• <r a- o> * o

^*» • CM < iO o •4- ^ 00 OO • ^co •— X o •~ •-I * a o ■* O« 00 CO O —M t- < m •-* II •M> Ul o •t r4<r\ CO "S r-l OO < t- «r~ mm NO •> o * * ♦ ♦ —» • ^H t- IU •-• w X U njZ • r~ r- r- r- ON r*- • • ÜJ • • » < •- * < * v. • * Org • ä *»!- ~ 1- MI l>- •-« co «*•>»* a. r-t 1^ cH o •- f*- * • o ai — a r» <o 11 • II • •-• i*« — m * • ^- < ■^ in rg • • • -> oo -> 00 VO r- o r- -J rg 1- CL 10 o» • • m co oo • NO • rg X •~ <o »n — _l y- isi » a rg V -* <r\ <t tf\t* -^ • — * < -*-^ X < _i * a UJ • • ii w <o <n f*- r~ in r- »-»- o -<»--. o 3 -J »» u • r- rg T <n IH <n r^ • * * • Z UJ 1-4 < «< vrt rg >- < r^ u Z m •s. * • ♦ * ♦ ♦ r-« r~ rH rg • * •x — —h- X • 3 w < < • *m • -« r» r-r- r- M • II o t- *~t < UJ • O 1- i— •• NM o> r^- r^r>- •—• \0 *—< • X LO t— •>••—. t- *«< z u> _l Q n * • • • • • • Nt • rg » co — X * — o vO •-• 10 10 < r- , • ■-4 • ~ • -^rg CM <M> ^* .- ~ O in O X uj a a i-«< o 11 •••!>-->*-) H- » o in r- o » ex oc * • • •-» • — • t*- TO t*- O • * • -J K O _j — - h- o a. a: a CM » • » «n co m <o <o ►i r- >-• • -J vO _l t~ X •« < o: v. N. u (^ <-> ^H ~ rg en o kO «o — • — «n

^< U) «-• < — < fM t— — a u H- Z u • t-t 1 ->C\4rH«n>0>-tl-4l-l>- U 3 UJ i-H 3 SO) h- <-« UJ OUJ u < o < .M «* • ****** O as O • Ul ►- —' UJH- K X ^J • ft m* r-4 O UJ Q u • • t- • "-ir-i-r-f-r-i- «t-oo OUJ < < u • • ►- •0. OX O < i^ 5/ -i «o «/) rg *■* CC <M a: rg

z _l »sZ z z _J rH t- ■O t^ t-_J -J CO ^ 10 1 !-••••■• >- ♦ > *■<• DO ujr- r^ o O • 11 CD UJ O UJ • rg ul < 00 CD a. iH Ul • h- • < r- <

fXKU's-Kncf»"- — «Q Z> <n D g>— 3 < Q ^ X • CM a • rg • • • ON V « w ft

h-3_jz<<Mr-u>io u M Z z -l~ z z h- z z tx. •> a CO «» • O 00 >0 oo ■«- rg *- 4- -IO<0>lf»OZZr-f r-l (- o — •-< o « UJ < -< a a ^ o o • 1 w ^ ^ r» m oo 4- o -JO; u 3C •-» f-4 LU UJ II II •—t r-l KH ►- t- K t- X 1- D ^ ux X < g> < * <r-ifHr»inn< •< • <(D gr D x r w 10 *-f •a^ Z z — az^-o-jox X H- r-l i- • H- fH rH rg m -H 1- .H (- o at 3 oo<<'-«x>u.03tOoOQ:ooiijz(n_ioo <r»<<*<»**** < * < n *- U) UUJ«- —OQZZ •-# Q 1- U O O 3U.UK •JJ (D U U o l-t Q 1 Qh-r-i^f-r-Qf-Q u i-f rg u r-l iH i-i rg m vt- m r-l r-l »- o o o o i- u. l-t rg tH rr> u. co O CD »■* >0 rt w u

132

Page 142: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO oooooooooooooooooooooooooo

m-t a\ «tt- o o >-*

• •••••••

«*>«'»•$■ ^ ><% W) oo o>

• •••••••

ooin«Mmm»HrHrH • •••••••

fMP-cn0»OO^>PH • •••••••

oo«nooo-<'0'-» • •••••••

cgooinrMof^t**» • •••••••

rv O en c\j o O O

*

o

o ♦

O dt O (D «O O «O r»- r» •-< •tf' oo >o o «O -4- (n fM o o> o* • ••••••

«n in in •* ^ «n co

o o%ooo >r -o j- CO O tf> if» t-« o <n ■A 4- ry| O O O« 00 • ••••••

m m m IT ^ en en

ooo«3-ooo-»Ofvj (nr-iaoin-oencooo ^cn«-(OW>cor~iA • ••••••• «ommmmentnen

eo o o o o o o^ Is- ao f"« r»- o • • • • r^ CM rg ru

<0 oo oo rM en i-« FH c> r» r* r- «n • • • • (M CM (M CM

O ^ -S- vO cn «A <o in en >o vo in • • » • <n CM (M CM

CO <M 4- 4- OO00 o moovoooooOr-i •"•eMooor-r-m • •••••••

•Oininin.$-«n<ntn

«o ^ >i -t o r^ f*" o» oo en CM <n in -a- 4^ • • • • • en CM fM CM CM

enm^in^ot-O^O—■'MiAO><nfl0en4-en

JM

ininoo>H'-40v.'no«o^r-*r-i>ncO'4'(no 00>0«0'-«''<0'-»»-<<-«(n4">*4"4*en4' • ••«••••ii ••••••••

(nor^vOOvOr-t-t-^co^cnOinoo oin en4-4-in>oooO'H «(MOiHr^cMr-ONin

•-«r-i'«f-*i-ieMCM(nrn4'in

>* in -~ • o-»

~«0<M<O4-O»0-*00—"»ffMOONO ocnenoo^oofMinen^o oentMenr^ fMi-«oo^^>or--%6'*cMrgf-tin*co

• ♦ •-•«o«n4'-*4'«n{n<nf-t<nenrMCMCM ■-tr-' «-« CM II || •••••••.• M •«•••> -> •X-)C0<M>0'*OOO-*")fMOC0004- • vO-* •enenocMO^'-iOco »envO-a-ino

—-^en — •-<<nfl0flDin4''X!<n-»>-HO^ten(n

o r- CM CM o «-• • • •

-a- eM CM en ■* m

en oc> rH rH O • • • «n m en ^> r- o\

(J\ f~ rH O <-« M

m » — m oo •> o <-« -• r-l r-l ->

in o m m o» vO <n CM sf •* ■» 4- «n <n • •••••• I- 4- P- O <0 O O «n oo •* <-• «ö «M •-• ■H ^ (M en en -t m

r~o en in m <o • • • «O tO (h en 4 m

f-4 oo O IH m o • • • <M CM -O f-OO O*

en o*

• • r-l O» •-« <M »-< r-l

4 4 0^ O* in CO o en 4 4 4 4 eM 4

• • • • • O CM eM OO O O in rH oo m r-t xo en •H <M CM en 4 4 in

O • •

O rH CM rH <0 iH • • • Ocn <> 4 m «o

O» «O (M O O »-• a • • Ooo o» 00 CO o

• • xQ 00 iH en

en r^ tH 4 4 m

eMtn4insor~aoo^

if» r- ^ en 4 eM eM ^)

• •••••• oo oo en 4 o O m vO 4 fM O» m co 4 •-* CM en en 4 4 m f-« (M en 4 m o f-

O • CM 4 r4 rH • M *

»n —• f~-

m ~ • -) oo

• «, ,0 o> •-< • 4 — en • I- r-l o < ♦ <-i 'J r- vO UJ

S • • Or-

f 4 r- — • • <4

O ►- rH f^ <♦ -o Q r- ■O rH

in4"444(nen »enencMfMrii • • «U •••••••«It f->-<0OCM44 CMOOvO O«

• «nin4cnfloen4en * • -^rHsomp- ^enu^en — O") ••••••••") oo •^tnin444:nen • 0^ r^ *««

CO <0 OvO OO r- o r- oo vO o o l> (M CM • • # • •

en <n rsi (M (M

♦ < UJ

oo ^) *. m — • <

r- t- * < CM

fMeM44CMOO'Ol- oen440»cn4r»-< rHCOlAOcnCMr-ICMC) • •••••••UJ OiAin4444enX

o

4 <M vO 4 4 <M in "H rH rH O 0> O CM (M • • • • • en CM CM CM CM

OO4OOa00D>0 — en)o4rH{MinvO0O< or^menenrHOrHt- ••••••••< >Oininin444eno rHCMen4iAvOr~oo

4 o 4 4 CM en oo 4 4 4 C?» CO CO CO i-H • • • • • fj CM eM CM CM rH CM m •» m

UJ a

x o

o >- CD UJ O Q. • >-

rg >- • ■-• V ♦

X O • m ^ • • O > 4

OX en O

> 4^ UJ • "v U Q O-« UJ CM jK Q UJ • +

z o> ft 1-1 I O

<o 3

> O cc oc

O UJ CO Z Q =)

II O X h- Q

>- o ra

UJ i/J o a u y~ o

o

o

u 03

(A

133

Page 143: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

0»0»0>0000000000«-<^»^«-li-«.Hr-l»H»^«-<fMPijr<(M«MMCMfMPgfM«>(n«0<ncO<<»«n(*l a>o»ooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo

(>lciirjr4<>i(vrsi(NiNrvjcaNNr<4tv(\|Ciirgc>i«>i(>jrsif\i(>£r4<M(Vrii<>l(>i<>irN|(vr4rti<>i<>l(>lC|4ri<(Ni O

<

o

X

*

eg

x o * eg

Q

rg x Q

X ■f > I o — «o II xo > COO QO

O

+ + 3: X I O i

— .O — II N X O X a y- a >- >- CD O (D Q O Q

+ >-

O

o CO

o

II X

> CO o

o Ifl

ui o

o

a o a.

a x Ui

o ►-•

LO

I/} Lul

< • 3 UJ >- <

< >/ CD U UJ UJ Q UI

Z

10 -I 0. 10 UJ UJ • 2: z o < •

Q >/) < UJ cr 1-

a •

u 10 < a • O

_i a w « CL _J • 10

a: uj

-«Z <

Z 3 cc a o D < a K Q CD OD UI Z UI D a UJ 1/)

o ►- «O u.

CO

1-0 oc u < i^ CD-I UI CO • X -I z CKO < X CD X UI O

(X on ■s. \ »0 UI

UJ UI

• u u

— a * o mo. • * > <o <a ui II >-Q: < a.

3

O

3

o

at — O u i02 * X * o oc • o u JO t- * fsl «^ » _J _J »O lO UJ a >- o < a I • x u -s * UJ -I rg V «O • < UI + — H- >< isj < ^ V UI UI u

< O 1- II iO IM

U II X -JU UI _l O

< u «o

2 X o

o X »- rM

lO a. o a. > < UI >- <

< N O V UJ O X X o ►- «O Nl

II -J o

< — U 10

co co

00

• • %. >s m m >£\»%

• • * ♦ * * oe a: ►1 **

U) IO ♦ *

fVfM • • I i uo

to to

II II uo to to U.U.

I t

u o 10 CO u. u. + +

a. a. X X UI UI * * * * uo O ^)

o1) 10

* • (st rsi

11 II U O

u. u

a: a: o o u) iO

O

u. ♦ 4- «

• • 11 H U O 5: X < <

i <

u X <

+

o X <

m U <6 x r- < • o + •f •

MHZ _J 1- Q: OCX Z) < < H- CO CD UI UI UJ (T

z -• UI

<

_) to a. o a • 3 — i- _i — 10 -I Q. -I o < a

^3 - u — o UJ a ui

z *■« UJ I- z>

-J 3 Z _l O -» < at 1-

oo z DO to u

O 00 o •

< il o o

u u

u. CO

o

134

Page 144: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

a>ptOi-i(Ni(<t<f>n'Ot''-a>otOr-<oi<<t-*4n«r*-''uo»0'4(Mflt<f<A<o^-cooto<-4<M«*i<*iA>or'~

OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOC^OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

_J • o

X o •> — m _l -J ♦ 10 X oc a • »- o on 0. •» 3 ♦ • z z -

i/) Q- xoc < U. «UI »- * _J >- UJ v) -) .o< CO < * Q. >. • •- * I- X

tr UJ —. ^) - o ao 4- a — —> + o • N» l/> 09 «or- I - • »H UI fH • •

10 o a. r- UI o (NJ »- — 4- u • ui O * M I • * i >- (NJ * • OT. V "S. • —• < + — UJ «/) UJ ,J m w) • 0£ • f- UJ X ~iO o: »- o f4 J >■ a: >. u. UJ isl o * o < UI ~ * >- — <*> UJ • l >- CO iO < ♦

1 UJ 10 • < < < • m m * ^^ >- z 'H * 1- t- a: •

m M X 5 < »- — m Ui UJ (— fH >H (H (- UJ • NJ ♦ in 03 CD iM * H iH «— > X * -~ <n — U. • ♦ 0) ^i * ♦ < • _l a • ~ CO + cc — m • o nj • y lO O * I ca • o cc • O eg oo o ' j a. -• • ^ < ^ UJ UJ PN r-( fH «o o >- o to cr UJ ♦ -^ Z >- «'i — <-< fH O -J < a. — O UJ •M H- O < V _l <H • O a * 1- -H >• co a ~ V «o to • o o a 3 _J ~ c0 at to < o ui o O X • Q. o rsi o » UJ -i i z: o ♦ - (NJ a to a: — -»»- rH fH • v: V UI + UJ tO — V • u * UJ ♦ n to rH iH + 3 < >- x .■- + <* — o ♦ 4 rsl JT OQ. rH ^ •~> V K * ^ < UJ< 40 I <> tO fM • <« * D K m — •» 3 • 2 — «n u -) >- - »- x rg t- » c\jr- U Z »Nl «M o • h- o t- «O • UI < < Nl UI • Nl «—- + fH Ui * V. r-( o ♦ o o * o u fH a UJ ~. o "S. UJ 1 N, -H • r- Q ui a UJ o o (NJ rf> 00 nj <n -1 r» z * UJ I/) >- 1/V.U ..-« fH • z o UI o tr UJ r» ^ UJ fH UJ «n 1-t UJ co ui o ►H m T. Z < O >- */) UJ O UJ UJ- + ^ UJ >- _l

1 Z) '»rH => 1 D -» fH D < Dm -1 ►- • O 1- It -• N < D • tn z> DM» o »- z < < ^ z • z ^ z • Z K Z CJ Z -J 3 H I« M _J «J — >- z ^ z • Z 10 <H z a: D O ii it x« N O •-• » >-• N O •H •»na; ui o 10 N X — M UJ « 1 o 1-^ ^ »- < w a. Ui o i< u o »- »- 3S (- •- h- h- 3 »- t- -it-*0 >- tt Z -J ifl S II tO CD H • fH K 1- n H- K n D Ni QC O UJ o ~ Z Ui z - Z LU Z-JZlUI-Qrfrn UJ -J IO UJ in UJ «. z z 1 z z fHZUJ_(»-QOCD3UJ_l U.O>-OOU.O>-OO<O>-UJZ -) 3 >- < »-< >- oo Q. u. o a. n o o a M OtO -) aJ ZX. ZDT >- O. -< u < o u « U < ou u u< a: ui W < u tO < u. u 1—• u u. -> o u u. -> UÜ. X a: ui io x < a

U \J o in o m o K o o o H- fH <H

•H fH fH

fH fH fH

fH fH

u. CO

fH (NJ n u. CO

u *«

Page 145: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

0'-tr4(n4'm<or^aoo«o<-<(Mm4'<n^^co(>0'Hoicn<4'ift^i>-aeokO'404m<«'>n,o^*(SO«o OOfiOeOOOCOaoeOCOa>cOO^O^O«9>OkO«9><hOO«OOOOOOOOOOi-4<-l'H'^i-<'^<-l«-t'-l'^Cil

Nrii<\iN(>4r4<>lN(>iNr4Nr4r«if\i(>ir4rgry|rgr4NC4rg(>ii>iNr4«>iN<>l(>l(>iriirvi(vr>i(>i(vi(>i(>i

a: •-* fM <S) * * *

a: *>» UJ —» V cu < • • *

a: u i- a tO rj z Ul • O a:

ac * Ui D 00 X z rH a o Ui tO o: -o o * m z

a: <o t- o <o < UJ «^ f»- Z • ■* z o 4- — • •H

• »H a l -r^

3t ■sO • UJ < O • UJ .H a: o UJ '/) ^Z «• Z) Ul za -o rH »- tO z O Ui ♦ V • a tO o • * ♦ Ul 4i 3 UJ •

•— UJ Z -o * to QJ 1- UJ 13 < -» UJ ■^ + •«~ H- Q, N »^ UJ •« r- z ^* • o tg • Q s: Q ♦ o m rH «ft •- O tO IU o< « ♦ ♦ •■r w oc Q Z tO > • a: UJ lO * o * CC Ul Z < Ul < to . tO w rH rH o rg h- >- < CC * o o Z X u. * <n * »SJ < eg a o r UJ U o « + o • ♦ * • < ♦ • o N. ZU + — IM rH o W O o a ♦ x -J Ui o < tn a • » CM oc o o o. UJ U f- a UJ * • o X •** o • z _l -I o a Z UJ z a. >- a. -i OLU V tn O O a a h- o O ui ui • o < — cO fc ♦ fNj —m eg ^ a. a. a •H v —

U*M * os a — in 3t • O — o • • UJ 10 Z eg < UJ • UJ 3 • UJ N, S1* O <-t 3 CC rH O OJ w * >- • -« * O UIO •m s a - O m oo Ul •tf o a. 1 ■-H 1 o: QC < ce < ♦ 'JJ >- f\J Q a: >» a. UJ Oft Z * UJ I|I a Ul 1 UJ z •- * »- »-»- z < • Ul wo z - Z o • a o m Z cr o «n UJ en o M «0 N W CO U. O -o V u a: o oo • + X vx r- O "s ui oo en |H — • 00 w U O to f«.rH < UJ u ^ v fH if« Ul UJ 00 ♦ a Z m o • o» OO» • * UJ z UJ ~ * O UJ w O iO - rg w >3 • » O O e • «n »H CM m #-• fH Q O •-• UJ -IUJ • Oh z _i o a * -H X UJ * ac UJ ♦ «n <x> rH _) _» m ♦ _J »- z £D ft UJ O Ul rH -• OQ -1 UJ UJ 00 * Z * J Z Z oo 1 ÜJ 1 ui eg oui amicar- u a >- •- <0 D II D • tt K- N. < z to • * o i-H to o O • U Z) *. Dm * D < D< <» CK < < uia. i- t-uj z uj z + z D D Z M O Z 'i tO * u.a II II i-< a Z K Z rg Z»-Zl-oot-h-Z O Z _J D

>- 1-4 »-• H-« • ae. z OO ^ H O a v: V II * a a II z >-. z ►H h o •H •H ll rg Q£ ui «< O X t-xec _j< h- d »- 1-t 3 QC a: Z o ui

oocol _i to II X X X XQ. O D W O 1— O t- w i- 1- J t- -J a: II -13

_J — Z UJ z II >- to Ul ii 11 (X. 11 ui z at — z w ZQC Z-JZ_)UJ0£_iH-OOr>l-£D <U.0V0_JUJZü£30aZ w w w rH ZCt:ZOZli.OU.OKOO<C<>-l-<UJZ«OOZD u — «J < u K a: UJ io u a o xxxii-oaoao •■H u •H O NJ OU .' u u < pg u a: ui a ui t/)

u u o o h- o O o o i- r-t CM U.

CD ►-i

.H rg <n * u. CD

136

Page 146: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

tO UJ IN CC cg a • "»r-»

• O • r-t _J »H

o* - If».* • fM rgo* O «*\ N.rg eo ^ X4- 'H • t-<A I v Z •* U U O uj • x J: -d-

uo z z o X O UJ UJ I- »- _J - II ZCL U. ►- O UJQ. -' IM O

O ^ M 04

u UJ X u

N

o a o • •

«o u o eo i ^■

<n Z O «^ üJ m Nk ~ «r.

X I

in •

fM PH

UJ

X IA

a i

o o

fM t- UJ IM _» • 00 U< X I- I— z z Ul •-•

o o: oo -ja a Qc a uj

x — n O «M O • OO «x

«NJ

Z CQ V: UJ • rH UJ l. UJ z X _J U f- H- J ~ Z z < u. o UJ u « u

• o «H t-t * I —' Ui •H *

• * *-* •

»O — i-t c«

UJ

in

■*

o o

(NJ

+ rsl * oo

o 4-

• O

* O •♦ «M • V

«n t-

• * «n oo

<J UJ X KJ

< a UJ

c

o -J a. a.

in •

CM rl

UJ

»

in ft a Z5

8 €0

< rH O -J UJ CD X < O f-

N

-l- I UJ < I- X -• K a: o 3 u.

< IM O w uj U. X

• • so OK- rH Ott _l

O OO OCQ «O nj io ^) <

I H H- o ►-< o •- N O »- _l

•-UJ _J o u. x o « o o<

N O • in o •. o O -I

• a o •n — — o • o

r-t r-l

UJ w X UJ U I-

u. a « 3

a: o er a: AJ x ri

* O X 03 ■-I • •■' rH K * < H- X N a ii O H- U. IM

< UJ

s0 pg

rg CM

O o -^ O 04 04

CM n 4- ^

o o o in o vo

-o ^f- ua: Ui> X < wi u • a • r« Ui

i/) «o • 1— CM Z • ft < _ir- « UJ — Q C •- < a*- oc UJiM ft OL • O • ~ U

to r- u UJ ~ < „ >-1- • ^4 < t0 J », .-H - 10 tO ... • cMLu a rH rH UJQ: • _ia ce -« o ►- 1- CD N. V ro rH •~ 4/) o

u < K Z rH ft A t0 H u — »-< o - —1 rHÜJ — tr UJ >, O U _J V ft ^» a: o > a » UJ ^ ^ rH rH _l Q. — <

»- Z -J _J z V -> «- w iD — a: >- Oü CQ O (M rH UJ U u < U

m -s ►- v v. •-• to 1 Z)0 O »- o UJ — 3 Z Z oO V <M Z _J _J rH f«- CM CM K _j _i — o o o z (/> t-^ M II a II II II II 11 co u. a x X ui < ^ >- «. r>

Q < 11 ODX X X 1- w z rH (M «t ■♦ m <o h- a Z 1- l- D O O — < u. o w* _ — Ul IM 10 U U O Ct »-4 u _» _l _J _J -J _i _i _J

U H- rH

ID

i:r,

Page 147: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

'•<A<A<#<A<o<or-t,>h-r'>r*r»r*F>r<>r*aoa>coco<scooo«ov4BO»o»oo»<h9>o>otOtotoooo

(>i(>lfy(>i(N(>ir<ie;r>ir4<>i(>i<>ir>i«NirNirsirs|(>irilNC4(>ir4<Ni(MC>«r4r4i^<>4<V«^r>iN(>ir4(\l(M(>4<^

• o ■*OSMOOO(7>'OiA r-<H^(n^frv«nf*- o -*O00tf\fM0>iAO njininoo><ti^tn o o ao 0» ^ P- <:> ^i <# h-Oinoo>*<«>4-flO

• • o o

<nfMoj«OfMiAoi4- »H-i-rHtniHjn^PSI

• • <n o

• ••••• O O tM OC0 O -i-o^omo-oo

00 o^ o <n m OO« CO (M *0>aocoinc«>-#in rg «o >o r- ■-• n4 9« <0 Oi •♦O(n<o««\niinr- • • OX O a

^CnrHtnrHOrHni

• • • • • • • • «O O co o rn in o»^ oa> r~r-p-rgm<o^i^ rj O «OOOOOCtO^^O >O*cn00fM»O(Mm •«t « O r-ICV yO >0 C\ O CMOOCMtACMOrM^O • ■* (M O CM vO 'H •* r-t 4- ■-•(<>i-«(nrH<nrHr«J

m ^

O • o •

r*

• • • • • • • • •>• CM O I^OOOfMmOW oaioo'ninofMiO -J *c\ <0 m rH ^ * Oin CM <M in o oj o oo o «> • • -* O CO tf\ o* CM r-l ■-• CO -H'O^fO'Hr-rH^

•-» o •> pg p»- -• * ^ -» fH pr» «-HfTliHn^rsJrHfM ao o •

N O (MO — «/) • • • • • • • • • •••••••

x to •OJ o<Of>-<ö<MO>cor- ^r-cvjnjorMoom UJ UJ • •* rg r» cr> r- eg r^ o <VJ ©»«OO^OO^i-tCO-* v oc O • \ rt e<\ Of-«or>-o*>.o<ro\o<>inoi\i < a. O • ^ mm ^•m "* •♦ rH (O rH <n ^« «> «n (M nj • •

UJ 0^

OO <\J o • o

• fVJ

* oo

r** • • • • • • • • m *» o ^ • 4- • II 0(<\ om o m o <o ii ooomooooo '■^ Q • o • >-4 •-< f- lA f- CO r- m r- in 9—t h-Mi^OOI^iT. P-NO -i ui ao o • » * 00 CM no r^ ao in oo 4- » oofMco-OoorgcoO *■* a — CO o • •M* •* ra «i en m* c^ (Nj CM rg -j • UJ rH O ■', O 0* m * * * o» » * «* « • as > "V •00 -** •-« • * • • • • • • rH «~ -i •- < •-* • <n 00 * O • o • o • o • • o«o*o«o»

•* UJ <** • o> o • * f-t r-l o o O 00 om o o <-l OinO^ OcOOfO iH S « — i-I o • l-t H f- CO r- "O r- co r- r- II r>-c>r"-mr--fMf"-o • O UJ ON • m o 11 -) <o ■* o t\j "> ao fo O C« .-< UJ — _l r-t f-4 r* O ►^ * » m • CO • m • (^ * • rg «(NJ »CM • rH o »* a a eo — II • >o • fNJ *^ • • • • -^ • • • • rH o.

h- • ^ • < H- -) • en ^ ~) o • o • o • o • -> o«o »O «O • «k •« h- i/) u >-►- at • o • •-• * m • in • m • in • • in • in «in • x» • rH rH M UJ UJ " ►- ■N. ~ o • » M •* •* •» m ■«!• r- -* o I—* <tyO-f'0-*(V-*'-* * «« — >- •~ Q U. UJ rH -) OO {/) m ^. r- oo CM cn w 0> rg eg !A rH J U < 00 11 z z ^ w «H O l/) 1 UJ • f\ • AJ • (M » O UJ •k^* * o * co • r*« -— o »o ** "W — — o «o 1- • ■* UJ * V • «o < en • on • m >- • Ckj »rg »^H »rH rH UJ U _j p» r«- fM 03 -J <o »- •-• »« X • cyoc • < o o O o < O O O O 5 r) o H H H « o< II Z UJ <o 3 </) w ►- o • a -t ^^ •* •> <t • >J- • 4- • 4-»^- » # »^ • <o Z _l

-«» *ä ^>* ** AJ H ►- i^ Qt -IUJ o z «# o • ^ 1 «« fNJ • <M • (M • (M • «» rg*rg*rg*rg« ^ »-« It O r^ (NJ CO H —Q U D cü JQ£UJ<<ino< * < o O 4- m < O -* h- r»- ^ H *^i

r-) »-I rH fH fNj CO H UJ 1- Q < CD tn X H 1- • o •— • h- • 00 • «*■ • J- • m H- «kCO *k>0 * ^ * o ^* z rH —• «» — «* ^ — CO I UJ Z »-< D « < < • fNJ <£ tf\ < • f* • i-4 • o • vo <r • o «r» »vo • >o u. o -i_i-j_i3/-it-ua:uj •- «0 O Q Q om Q f Q o ca O «n O «n O rvj Q 0«MOrHOrHO«H r-e U -J

'^J ^H (NJ r-4 -t rg >-i <\i rH nj M (M rHrgrHogrHrgrHCM o t- rH r-i U.

CD

IA U

138

Page 148: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

■if lA -Ol- OOOO OJ Ol (M rtj M #4 pi r« O* O* Ch &> »H »1 t-« »►.

CMM N Ol Nr4Nrti(>ir4(>if4«>ir4cMAii>i<>i(V(>iriiri|oi(>j«>ir>lf4r4c>ir4(\irij(>ir>irijriJ(>f^i(>i<>in«r<j

< UJ z o CO

o o

in >- >- < < • UJ — >- •«

-J UJ —

O ^ UJ w

UJ

a

o

-J

UJ

UJ Q.

UJ — UJ « >- rj < •

—»~ >- je

CD — U 00 < v.* o a* < H- G J tH oo »H »-

•HICOfHrHX-JHHMN OOZ H II H H N M -~ ~ -~ -~ r-l H II 01 ~ — —.~ — — Oi-HOJO It ->3ID <*\«tin<or-o«r-i^^r>«y[)eoujt-Q ^.ww — w. ■«-tO-'VUJZ _J-J_I_I_J_J_»_IJ_JW:_I<Q:UJ

u. id N U UJ

a % D

UJ r»- -I UJ CO -J < CD I- <

t- u I- u. CD •-•

UJ UJ _l >• CO < < Q I- >-

< UJ Z Z — o I- ■-■

O Z ac uj CD X D-«

♦ OOOOOOO^* i-tr-jtV(>4f\c\(f\^it\ ^•••«•••* •••••••••

•~ooj(n4'm<oeoi-i«inmoc4tnch«naocoo^

• r- H •<j-vC(7>s»4-!Ooo«nMa3»ninorNi«ooo -«•'-• ") 0(M(«>«*»f»oor>jr-flO~)<^<or>»0'Orsj<D<M»0 • ♦ OOOOO^fHtM <»m(nrPi*4-iAin<0^ '«^••••••••— •••••••••

■->! ♦ 000>-*<HCMr>j(OM(n4'4'4-intO<0<0<0 • ^-••••••••••••••a •••

-) »••••»•«•-)«.••«••.••

►-<0'-<rs(0<n»H>OO^rr>>-«>r>>tin.a-vOOP><»T><N

ujr><«««**«*«uj« •••••••• > >-

r~<* oo•-•r»^«n^<J■-*<ct■*ln>o^•^■r-^-r,'

139

Page 149: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

<0r»«»Oi-4(M(n4-tn<oh-cooo<-«(M<n-«'in«or>coo»Oi-4rM«>^iA<or>(Oo»Or-io<(n-tiA4> •#<C^'#>nmiAiniAmiAininiA<04>iA4><o«O4)<i><o<i>r«-i^h-h>{^r>r>>r<>f«fte(OeoaoflOcoo>co ^rgr4i>i(>irgr4cgr4N^^N<NirM(VCNi(vir>j(v(Ni(>i(>j(M(Nicii<>l(M(>4(>i(>|(^(>i<>l(N|(>j(>i(>ii>i(V(>l

♦ ♦♦♦'♦***'»'*****^***^J*5******3*4?5*3*7 r4«vci<>40«^«(>ir4r4(>tr4r«r4rsirvir«fvi<>ir4N(Nir4r>i(vrii(>ir«<^r4ri4r^<vo4<>ir>4rNir«Ai(Ni<>iN

vO en o* IH en oo

• • • • f*r- «o • • • • • • • o o o o o o o o * • • * eg O O <o (M m ft 4 f* (Ji o -* 00

rH T-* r^ r» vo • • •

• • • • • • • • » • * o o o o in o <r o o o o 0» m a) fM O O O «h- >o iH ^- O 00 • • •

rH i-l • » •>

m m m m f- rH m • • • • CO «0 ao o o o o <o r- <o o o o o • • • O iA O O >-i no* r- * * •>

*s. fH CM o r- ^ oo r«. as »n • » » * <o r> <o «n • • • • • • • • o o o o

o o o o • « » • 00 O o o 04- o

(O CO 00 sO oo h- 0* •"4 I-l «or- »o v» • • • •

00 • • • • • • • • » • «

•> #* w o o o o 4 r- m <|- *^ -1 o o o o oo r» o* «J i-i -» • <o in o o vO r- <o v> ■w h- -«. (M r- in • 0 •

>s • -J O m |H *"* • ■-I m * » * r- « J CO — a> «o ■-• • «<» »• IU • 1- o» r- o IHW •~ ••• o 2 K ooooo^-oi^r- ■ <Ci ^ r-« a H- N N. o o o o o » • • • t-4 •' •■• r^ • UJ IM • o« -* OO O 0«n * "• * iH a ^* *^ m tvo-trvm»*» ^* • fH i-l "«» • •♦ »TV ^ f* rg • 00 O CO

rj « O ^> L- UJ UJ

UJ >•

-* iH «O 1- -J — N CD X

• * IH r>j r- o H h- r- r» T • • •

a — • h- r-« ~ U) o <

^4

H • • • • • • *• rH i-< • w — tO H O < ^ - < O ■X o o o o o * V rH -> «ff — iH rHUJ — a: >- —• U UL 1» M N. • O O O OO o» •• * • • rH f- UJ n • w 0£ O V < CO UJ H (/) iH 0m ojaoOOOiooom * .-4 «-' t- >- m <-* -i a — < •• < a o uj v. »4 ^ in co ^ — r- m <-• o — ~i N < P«J -^ *-• •— OD — u « z z * ^ f« rg 2 I«- r- h- 1-iH %# «•» Ol» fH UJ U U < VJ O O «/)■-« O iH K o • • • • 1 Ul u u >- • 1 D O O t- O -i r«- r»- rj 4- 1- -HO K —■i 4 30 0 < f^ z _l -J -H r- CNJ fM K _i n ii H a OUJ z •H •4- :> tf) W N (/)••>•> • rH Z _J ^' s* * I/) *"t B II H II II H N H «« *» — — <M II >- a: _i »H o r *»^ o o o o o — o o 4 4 to •M« II II < CO ^ t- *** ** ^ O r-4 rj cn II -"■ o CD _l (£ UJ < < O0OO<r-4-(M(>*: 1- r^ <**

^^■Wli /^ ^^ fc— — ^- -^ ^ . i-l r-t rHf-ir>-»ujKa<eoisZKi- «<ooot-r^r^f*->o — Z rH OJ

o • 1-4 u-j _J _i _J-j _j _j-j j _i _j j ^ j < a: u t-io a a a « u. u — —

-• U -1 -1 l-l

^-i o r-l

U

U. CO

■-I «M m 4- in I-I rj fo 4" <-4

IÄ u

140

Page 150: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

0000<O0><y>0tQt9'OtOk0t0t0iOOOOOOOOOO'4iH'-l>-4r4<-4p4»l'4'-«(MOJDJ(M(Mri(O4«>l04 04MN(MOir<l<>JcgN

r4r>ic>|(MNrgr4(>irviNNC\iNCiir40lNCNiriir4C4rsi(>jr4r\iN(>i(>iC4(>ir<loi<>«f>t(Nj(>i(>ic>iA4(>i<>ti>i

o

to

o -J ^ <-( II II H

d .* in

_i _J _J

<

o

UJ <X X >- u < »o • • a. < -» UJ o «c • UJ <V 2 X • < Or*'-* • _ Q _l H- < ü> i- a

UJ • O a: ~ u a r^ u • w <

-. H- K • a N io _! —> • ««■ m U) « i- oo uj a r-i tsi r-tCC • O «- — -J Q. ai — IH ►-

^ll<l-Z«-« r-t —lO U<l-<0~->v» f-*UJ UJ e) QU.J-«-« •'(r OUJUI^^ v«> _j a

x z _J _J ;: oci .H w«. O^COCOOf-t l üjyu

eo H-vv-tioooDOO

.JrHOOOZ 10 -« N II II II II ^—r-_» tD-JOCXXUK^t--. — -»— — >er>-<Haoa^-o<cocoxxxi- — zrHcsj^^-m wwio — '-«UJZH-<300-»< u.o — — ~- — »- _i _i ^ _j to a UJ i-10 u o Q Q «u j _i _J _l-J

u

I UJ

< a UJ X o

OH >■

< IS) *** • Q^ I- — UJ N >0 •

. • <

»4

(Q m <

pg <n CM OH- Z n n M ti ii a:

4- —H O

at <

11 N

<o r»

_J -J

• < w UJ H X HO N — — U u o o -J i- -i II II M — — •■>■ o •-• a> r-» <-«

n II

-J _l

UJ

a.

N «Ml

ca < i-- Q

fsl O M II 11 < oo —o •-4 eoui i/> — X ^ -J o

UJ ct a. *

UJ — x a. o * «^ < o»

UJ -J X CD

* o < U — I- Ul u. o II ui

i- z M -•

o* I- Z r-l O* D oi _J <-• o 3 co -i cr »- o < en CD ui z i- < 3 o: ui >- io

u

— o f- <

isl • • o

— u

— <

lO _J '0 i^ UI D. cr • a. o: ~ ^ "v (^ I- r r-« < o - Q U -I

-I _l ÜD CO v. v Z Z o o z X X ui XXX o o — u u o

z o

to

u. CD

u.

w» u w u

141

Page 151: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

& &* iy* Ct* &* &* Q* Q* &* Q* O* & &* O* & O* & O* O* O* &* Ch O* ^ O* &* 9* 9* O* O* &* &* &* &* 9* O* O* Q* Q* &* &*

< O Ui

o

o_i

I »/) UiUJ • cr:

>- — < tT o • a »- — UJ a vo • UJ rsi Z >- • < < r- -• -i »- < vo t- a ifl M •

ui ~ u a. r- u • — <

• — O) < - ^ • rH — tO Ot- <<

N. • r-« HI — Ult- oo ^^ — a: O Z N WUi N.« JO. - O - XX (y, rH »^ ~- CD — U O O r-< 1 UJ U U < u o <o -■ to o> 3 o o K-O-Jr^-r-«^ »DO i^r^Z _J -J r^ r* i-i r-t x _i a ii « a fv o <

10 -• M II U » ii II II II -~ — 11 H < 1- <i<: h- — — — .»» ■~ -~'»-«O>-f(M«n0^'~OCi !-—Zr-»rg««^i«>cr^o>'^<-«fH^4rHcoiu u

Q«-i U -J -J _! _i _j -J-J_l-J-l-l-i^_JÖNl

u a

— N a — ♦ o

►~ (\ N -I — CO u.< II I- I- OC UJ N. z

to a. • o

a: ~ ^

O K Z rsl OD Qi _J rgo 3 oo -J CC »-o < ajoD UJ Z K O a IU »- i- i0

u u

en lH —• V.

z o O eg

(/) ^ z UJ< X h- ■-«<

— tO — to •HUJ

*-* — « — _J Q.

I ui u u OD O O CMZJJ^ir-i-«r-« to ■»• II H II tl II II ^1 ^^.^^ — Z'-i^coJ'in* U.O- <- MU-I-I-I-I-J-J

* o — (a

— i- >- OH < w M w 00 ~» <J < u o K O -J K _l II II II — — -. O r«- o> <-4

H II

iH (N|

_J _J _l -J _l

U. CD

^ U

142

Page 152: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

Or4oi(n-9in>or-<oo«0'-i(M(n'*m<or'<-ao<hO«-ir>j(n.*tf\<ar-a>o>o«-io4(«t,^in'Or>-<ooo<-i ^f>.r>.r>i«>r>-f>r-r>»r-«oa)«»aco<o4oa>a>OkOkO»(h»o«o>o«Ok9ioooooooooOf^»4

♦ ♦♦^♦^^♦'»■•■'♦♦•♦♦■♦•«•♦■♦♦♦♦••■-«■♦■♦•♦♦♦♦•♦■♦♦■♦♦♦♦••■♦-♦•♦♦^

•»- en o pg tn -» m ^ <o in • • • • -o

• w og en ■* m o • — rg o Oi- •>••>• • • m •-• • • • • I rg or- oa. tvm <o

• <n PH rg «n •* • • • • ••* «n < UI

•- JQ. < in • oj.» ■» ■* pg «n ^ «n ■» • UJM (/) UJ U. 1- -• -« • • • • _I<Q. UI — < UJ UJ o • » • • • • Ulh- O X tflf- I < m • • • • o pg o IU a. >/) x LU i- A. •

TH

ET

(5

• 30

.5

5

• 60

f-4

• c-l

o •-! pg en • • • •

pg en ■» -x«

o 4" • in

r-«» o h- ui r^ r- (NJ t-^ •

f« r>j pg en eo <n • fV • • • • • * «M — i- • • • * o oo

o o z t-> oo in o o> o ^ pg o o z •— m x oo a» r- «n • • • • r- .* •-» < w • i-i «n ^ •* ^< en * in • • 3 <<<<<<< •^ < - • • •

*- o uj in « •> ■>

• < * ^ * * A

in o »- * • — «mom o <Xi o-. o -* • 4- • « -1 LU Q

—.,— t-i <-g m r- Oa. rg • • • muj

• « • • • • •-• pg -* m o

• «O • 4" o • m • -o gj

< x lO — UJ in • • • • * » a: I u. u. x a x x v • • • * * v. ^ O N. «O O a < z o _!•-• a> ui s: io -~ tn r- o> o« m r- a> o* o 4> -« in -« pg u. _i ♦- « I ui co r • oo • ^ <■ rg r- tn • • • • • O m o 4-

< UJ a üC >xt-xzx — cMr-«^* ■4- •vi-tpgmin'Oin «in •

< UJ

* < H- m • • • •

Q -. — II • • •

• o • • « «

* • CM en «o m .i r- r- «-I * m n o II o

«M, oc rH ^t rj n en 00 < Or-«MOinotn • vo r- oo c» 4 ") CO -j o *» t- • r-« xmz »rg^-r-o •-<•••• • • 4- • 4 •-• V) o • — x — • • • • » »H pg m -* vO ■—••-«.•

* -J

CO UJ

o ►- o

o — o X • -■ *•< 1 1 *< ~~

~) -) -) C5 00

IU -1

<<<<<<< «—• uxmrt»»*» -> in so r- JO w • • • •

CM r-t pg tn 4" •

» * » * »H •-» pg o w pg », oo pg 4' e\» en 10

1- fM ^ < • »- — X CM O« 00

_J UJ •-« • i-t (M 4- ^ »H- — • • •

■3

• < m Z Z a a UJ »- ** *-* Q_ »« 1-1 ►«, *—**»** » X • X • a < z a -1 »- O M i/> O x a: • OI — • • • • X >- m —' r- * K -• CO Ul < O cO 3 « < namcL^mOin o a ^ m >o r- o « o» • h- t- _i z ui i «o X •■*»-•-• X »o >. — • H- rH <* vO o^ — • • • • • — en — m N w!liil^03UU.i-i I _l Q < « «; UJZ»-''»»-« • • • • • .-< pg p-i -* o rH • C\! •

U Q UJ •-• to < o l-t UUJ <(r>/)i-o:oiooi -) — «• m UJ H H- X «-• uj<oxQ:3xujauKina >s i— • • • • * »-•»-• < OUJ<UUJ UJ<U •> ^ • w * • • *

tn

z oo • en >}■ m >o 0^ -^ • • • •

a. oa. r- — oa:

\s o o a LU >-4ooirtcMO<oh-r-cDOin>-io>mr^

UU UJ CP LU UÜ • UJ en UJ en

X 11 1- u»- o z >. _J rH <M »n m «n en ^ !-• — K o pg ■* ■4- en »— rH rg en 4- m 36 • 3 • M rgoo Z < O_J«0-«'0<Z< •-•r>-zcoa:z • • • • • z I/) m

— ii ii H- a: H- O < UJ o > e>JO Z LO •>*»■> * «» • m o — oc 3 _J a: u a: X »-H X UJ to < • * • * • < < oo < oo fi (NtCOUJ^OUJCO X o —• X X ui »- o in o m pg t— pg ;i 4- m vO 1- C> f- ^ — U) w >. UJ za z) oo<<<<<<<<o-«Q:<'Hfr>^} CD • <•••• • < en < en -J i^ _l <(K Ul V) U UJ ^ -,_»-... «^ w «** u Q a o • • • • >-« Q ^i oj in <♦ in Q • o •

u i-nrgto-* inof~-co i-i r-i pg tn 4" tn r-i pg «n -J in rH r-H o t- r-t u.

CO •-* w i.; u u u u

143

Page 153: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

C\i*\.*Si*V(*V.fMrg«Vf\.rgrurjfVifN,»vr\.«V(l>i«M#N.*Si*N(CN.IM«V(fS.«lf,y^^.«V«SJ*N.fV:f^»\,«N.»Ni«,i.lMIM

CD GO O O-^ o o ©• ^ t-l .-« •v. CO O t^ tP <* * >o m ♦ m r- • O • • c • • • •

o o

o-« in ir •-• in c^i o o r^ * OflC * f^ *\ <c n « o .* (T O» f*) -3 m r^ • f\ • • «-■ • • • •

» • » » r> • • • • in o « r o (M in <o O < o a * «r r- 4 ^ •-• ■♦ • <n in o* «^ 4 r< r- • r-l • • • • • • • • • • • •

«f> IT O • » » •

<C CD « 4- rg <0 «> « oc o ^ ir ©>

• •

• •

«r «r «c • • • • • •

m « ir> « • • • •

• • • • «DO öD « »r ^O«^

O • ■ IT •• • O • • • >

• • ••• • • • •

■ «VJ ^r ■«irin ■ ir (N <f> »^ «r

O— •«»•••'-<•••• o -> -> -»

•-*noo ••©«eor^oi^t'r^ao

Ofvir<o<Ni«n«r>- »vi^ ♦ ♦ * «j •^•-••»-••••-•••••0

Z X z z • K« •»«•••»(••••••»

o • f~ «) • f- * o« • r- ^ • *-• IT

t-tfrt« • 4 •• • ifv • • • r «»-

*0 N.

* z <

IM IV O *

z < c < « v a lu UJ X

z <

v

IM

I u <

I l«g z X

*

X

oa out

• o IM

^ a

IT <

« < m <M a i<>

• •

O CL K M » • il> «O UJ« •> ^ ^ o « uin M « r» io • jt • • • • •

• •••»•> tfv < as « o m « mK o> « ^ «> «

• o • • • • • IO v-i IM m 4 «^

o a ft « I

o ♦ o • H o «A a

e — IM • • o

< c z ♦ a. • -JO _i •< H Ul « oo

IsJ Q. U.

UJ O

• * oo • tr, * a z *J c * « r- "^ • «M ♦ IM * Z • * V* — < J _J • UJ UJ f- c o • • Z -"C »- * • V) U. «n * z • «D— I f- a • «M » •-< • IM « — a o

UJ < o UJ z o » Ul

N. Q. UJ «M •»- • UJM

— « • UJ «^

m iu — rj _J3 ZN. ■ m'— OiM c a • «o a *• v x <• »~ IM N «iroi < ft. UJ JO ft > »• < X DO.« Uft

< —

* IM ft ft * IM

Ui IM (D O- z - ft *- V ft oo z m ft ii « « fvi»- X UJ

o «o

ISJ « • z • IM« — • »- X • «

« —«- • »-a

•IUJUJ »MUJ

*-z«o «to • • ♦ o f*iZ«» • »J- • «x —»» • « • •-• «IM — ^Z ■ • I- • oz • «ft

z < *

z — -a z ra -f ft

z • • • « ■♦■ .-«o •-• — 4 — «M Z O * ♦ • K « * — o • ft Mft _■ ri • Z UJ • t- — a ui o »» -- » ^ z • N. w — a « <* • IM " >. • • • a — ♦ o »-«u/ jo UJ • "- a I D CD m 3 ^Z «- » Z ►- Z I a n Z » HO» rs(«»-a»-f-t_i»-»- • X UJ --z « y z • «Zu. ozzo o 30^»»UZXOU

c o r-i IM

VU

IM

Page 154: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

r4r<oiriic>i<yirgi>ir4r4r4rar4r4NC>iMrvir<iNr«r4riioic>ioir«raf>tf>ir4<MC4r<<r4r4<>i<>ir>ir«ri|(>i

• oc Mi a z

a o -i Q QC >

ca cj »t •H fM CO

-> 1- o

u < < <t z m >- * Q. • • • a. O UJ UJ ^* h- i J-^ _,-L ^x

UJ rg o tO o 3 Z O r~ to _i -< to X a> o a: a to 1- • u * o O ui a. < f^ < * «** »- u. • X O QC X ^ z < z a a o a. ^^ < 1- o X < • • • • • o Ui o < M f\j <-4 ■~ Q < -1 ui a •-too t~ + z z ♦ UJ -» oc < •-• fM «O z *XJ < < z a « 1— (K X z r<« »- Q •f (O tO * • X Q V X -I X — o h- u < — 1- iO •« -1 O O U ^« «# ««• a < a -» ♦ OL < — •-• UI H- f^ VJ < < < UJ — _J \ o -x o »- X rt o — < tu — u *^ z — < Q. UJ < X ♦ to < •> X V z M < w O "v -JX -1 U. h- •-• J * •> » tO -1 x UJ KZ tO < -J UJ < UJ ^4 D • to • u * UJ * 9 X * o Q H- Q »0 o a. -» a. «*.-.»* OJ z —■ 3 — s VX Q. •f UI f X z z o • h- x a i0 •• >- — J V Mk J^ •-t »M o a: Q. M ♦ LU Z 1 - + -> UJ (NJ f-H • i-t • _J »O -s U. UJ X a

— Ui _J • M 2 UJ O

«z «0 -J

- Q Q. < H ■

1 UJ ->_l

1 i^ >- to ^ z U U ÜJ i-l o

X Z UJ U M X

Q. x to a o« a i i w

• OUJZ

»4 k-4

X UJ -• N 0<

»_ ~ «> UJ -j -> < *^

• uj i uuj<a.to Q UI < < ^ U • • »

CO liJ X UJ «» II ►» ** * » •-» — UJ UJ Z "- -«

5- -» 10 X UI -« out UI

Z_IV_JZ — — -^ >-»30«nuJr-iai^ a D »-• a X < n U — -• « 3< H *- H 3 - <* D Z) O »- tj "S N. _J l-l f\J IJ z — ^. ^_ K *• z X — — Z H- UJ OC — < •» z >-♦ z z z Z 3 _l Z Z <

■'«* H H II H •-« *>4 <x -> « « < 1/) I-« -) 1- 'H »4 #"«■* «0 o •—• r-« rt — ac •-« o < O O > »^ iH J »- -J Z ZQ <■• 1- XX - »- X H- ^ + -ÜJ + «> 1- X K K 1 1 1- 3 _l Of LJ T X M n HU2V^_JOZ i-4 *-* ZiH<«o<aE<ujuj->< — -« »"* z <» z •^4 ~)Z^-Qvco arsr-j ^, w X>-ZOZUJI< H U)0 M KXKOOXO: H >- U. M tO O U. o o II MOUJZO^ nooirf<*-«r ZZXUXQ»-»- •-•XU">UJ»-UIU<l-Q.-)UJ-i-t X u — OU X Z u cc u 1 to tj U UJ ■» w w

U I-H rg ffi o o O o o o h- «n >*• in «o r- o u. so

145

Page 155: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

m«erte«o<hO>-«<M(n-4-m<ori»«(>o>Hoi(«)<#in%o*>><oo>Or4(vci<#tft<oi>«flOO«0'-«(M(fi<«'m Ok»Ok<><hoooooooooOf-i<H>4«4r4r4«-«^<-4>^MCV(>j(MrMM<M(^c«(vm««tm(n<«\cn

raMr4iN^<>iniAir>ii>ir\(Nr4<>l<>lciiNrti(>iNr<irsi<>i<>i(>|(vri|(>iCiiA<Mi^f^M(>iriir«cii(>i<M(>i

~o • * O if» -t * •

* • • • o om

en o 0»

eg o <n «o

K <-J «n -> CO • • * X_l — _J 9\ • • »r^ » m • o << UJ J 0> O <0 >0 Ov rsi r-t • h- u. »-B ^ •-< << »^Mt-imoooitn z Uil- t- > *>4 •- X • ovr^mmen^m • «-• • • • u * Ulh- o> o> so «o en c« • v a. •-•«««« ^ I • • Ov Ov CT> o» o^ «0 • • m * r-r* r* ^t *- -* «••••• • m NO o m en i*^ <*\

m o

• o • <> m •

• • •

4 o • • • • nj

I-« >» iC\ — • • • r» •-• m 0» • O o * ww w uj < -5 <0 »H (O r-l f« I-« • eg o << < 3 •-^ x »-

z • co -^ X o t~ m • r-

eg »4 m •>•>••> •> o« <o co r^ m co

• o» m p» o co -* 4- o Ok eo o 0> •-•

CO 4 rH rg •

• • -»

•> •

1 rg

* Ä • • IM • » Ifl m o tM r- 4 4 m r- ♦

uj a: ^» «^ 4" O» 0» 0> 00 v0 -J1 OOO o * < i0 o X • 0^ 0> O O^ 9> o • • • Z »» »• »- i/5 ma: *v • • • • • • • m * X ^ >

<UJ UJ XUJ 4 ^ • • • • •»

• oo • < *

x u) Z X • —z

fl— .k «*« u. UJ t- o Q. r ^ • rg o • • • • rg • 0> • • » • « To. • • • «O O 4- 00 * • h- J • ««•««««« *% < • ■*~ rH rH M r-l r-l r-< •> • » f^ Z 10 z r»r^ r«- r^ fSJ (_ — ~ o II • • r~ oo 4- »0 • Q. • oo en oo ^ UJ o o m M rg • • • • r- * 00 4 (SI >» D a ♦ ~

rj O« h- • «Am r- • « o rg o» <n o> •-I 00 r-l —, *m. • i»4 •- j « 0» eg -^f- — w •~ h- c~ O (n m en m • •■ • z z g» O Ul i0 —

~» o— t- X « co ^ o rg m 0> 4 » o •> < < < I a (r < w w w w < m > rg » — 0» ^i ^ o> P~ 4 i-t • * • •^ ►-« ♦ OC H- o < i- << < < •™4 -' • »-

< — a t- oo. UJ m •>

»— 0> 0> 0* o* o> <?» rg o^ • • • • •

a • • • • • • a o ao • • •

o> om o CM • 00

* < < OC oc

m X o • 0. 1- UJ »- — wo rg >w x ♦

o m

9 • »^

»■I •

9

• • • 4 1- a. a

* cc «n a ►- »•- «>« ^ ^« •» <-* «. ^ o t~ * • • • m o< rn t» 4 O UJ UJ «^ < * a a H- '-

X out m —■ — eg M ^t ^« l-< rg Ul UJ rg ¥- O • ♦ • CK xa m o w oc »«• • • • 3 3C «^ ♦ 10 i-H 1- CM < < X «0 ~- » ^ — < >* « • ifl «fl D« X *—• 00 ►- K- »-

H00 UJ ►t — oo m H- H- •••.••> • o • %•■«»« Z o * • I a ui i/) W1I cc «o O I — in co • o rg og «n r- rg «o o Z i/)Q I mz o KO-X xt-a. a z: xm K a X I P (O 04 rH «o r- O • r> « O < u • r-< o -o. a. « • •>••> • * H o o« o> m o «o 4 » W U 0£ < o • *m rH a » _i — ^ <M» ^ <^ *^ z oz z z »- p o» 0s ^ co m rg • * * * « * u MQ 1 _l —OQ r-» h-r«- i»-f- rH O n O O O * o ^ c^ ^ ^ 0* a Oao -J I »-*rg M <QeUJUJ— f-* «noo «o co 1—4 «-•■—• »-H 1-4 t- O * • 9 • • • 4 m UJ O O • ■H »-ia*-D>-'-«'-«

^i ♦ m v» a: tf) IO w z • rg t-t X > < • tH ^^ N U Z M X ~ ~- CO ^ —> 2 ^ z z z rH **•••> «• • * • r^ N Q « II 11 a: oo: T ■-. rg a: -> a:

•H < UJ uO UJ Ul UJ Z UJ X X £

< •> CO <0 • • • »- • • • 4 eo fsi

• vO

o • II > II Z Z < U < cgt- t— 1- »- W) — < ■"— -^ ^^ -^ "^ v< u/ ^ »-i i f— r^ ►•• tu *^ Z 0. UJ X K << < < •^ «4 Q£ IM >-< »-4 < O M ft r-l <o m xxioiouuiKujoiu-ooaaio w *»* w w • a a Q Q o a • o z z x r) < a a. XQ >- (-< u a. a. >- x 4-in <o r» co i-4 fH «-« ^t rg en 4 m ■H rg en

u u u u

146

Page 156: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

1

«or»«io>o^irMca4,in'Ot^flOO»Or-tr>jrt^in«oh-«joo»HfMi«i-*«nvor^ooovo<-i<Mi«>-»«n^)r>-

iniA^iA^iniAin^u>iAiniAiAininiOiAininin>rtintnii\ininiAinirkinininininininininininin

Nm rM CM n

10 tu

z < — z Q s: a ui ui u z X o Ui cc

"• x o >o m (M

ry|(Nir\icjry|r4r4r4rgrsiriic«irgrgrNjc\irtirsir«jcMr4<\ic>J(>ii>irgoi(>irttrNirti(>i'>t(\i(>iN(>i

z • O «M •-• r-l k/) LÜ Z <M UJ • X X — m Q •

uj —.

< -• z — «1 < Q I- a u o I o a

>u <

< UJ

UJ X

o o i-H «o

UJ •

z — ►i UJ

<->(-»- n z ->

o

UJ UJ z r

< m UJ rH a -^

X z

<o -I • >- ou X rH UJ — z

UJ Q — + rt "■ I

I « ■; X —

«- (K »H Q: to I < ui — >- Qi •-« 10 Q. — K II X It —5

co (vi

£ x ii x oo m < 11—3 os »> o^ QJ ^«>H • o\o«<r2 o UJ »MM II ooo>o»<no O 3 rH «1 w ä .' |1 •a>0>'0-J a z+ — x — KOi-t^-ou. a. ►-. « cc o: -. u/ •-• n n ii •

x a: UJ — a ->

za - • n x

■H -> S

<t-Q. '~»-*ccaC'*ui—nuti» v m XD Q.K'-*<i/) — Q»-«.-.*.||_| M m aO>-OZ nt-UJX ii<rHrgfnQ._l(M«<-H Oa:cDh-0'-'i/)a:axa: — ~«-'X<ii II no u-co i/)u«-'xa.H-Qr>aa.aQuzz->o

■H rg o o o <n

— n x — ^ »H to — UJ X CE X Q. »-

< —10 -> X «- n > — II !-•

>-■ < — h- > UJ

o H

z -~ • ->

2 <

< *

VO D N.

-> -)

> X — or 2 ui < Ui ►- ce < Q. K 11

«z ^^ *■* • -> -)

UJ

Z * •-• -»■ I- ->z II o -> u

m

o n

+ UJ

• • O rH II It

o

o a

r-1 r-• rH (>J

II •-■ UJ II II ►-•«-• ÜJ UJ "> <- Z) »H -) D3

UJ Z UJ K Z 2 O < •-• O O -4. «.7 ■* t— i— >o in '-- to

UIZ UJUJZZ»-',-< OXOOCXQCOOtOtO QI-UQCII-Q.UUXX

o o o

147

Page 157: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

COO Or-ttMrr»-t«f«'O^-C0<>O^rs|C0 4-ift>0r-00OO<-«rj{n*iA»0r>-C0OO^fN|fr»^-iA^>r-C0 r«-h- «oaiao(oaaco«oaa<pcoo«ovo^o«oo>o>oo>o«oooooooooO'-*<-<<f-««H>Hr4i>-tiHr4

«MW WC4^wc4rafsi<\ic4PMrsjrsir>ie>ir»ir*i(><rarj<M«>if>ii>i«Ni«>lPiir>ifsi<>(NP«4«>jtiic14«\ir»j(>i«>i«>i

UJ < -i tu •> ai M (/) •

r IXXQ.— io O • • « • • o >- M « — — ~ ~ m < ►- lOr-tr^f-r^r- ce — < .-•<n«n(^oo— a: — 2 r- r- «n UJ < i-i o «N r~ 'H uj — < r^ ►-• »- UJ *- — < M <

. ~ Q UJ a o z x z • • • • • m < —O < r- oo •

^.•-«». • in ~ X O K UJ >- O r-l o<fl'->_j3 a f\j~ -JO. t- W) X • -J »x u. UJ a. < a. ui o:-^ < r- ui

• x a: o ►-UJ a. o-« i »n i- -J Z QDOLMDZinO »- '*M < < ••••••r-in Z o.»

— z — -..«.«.*» ^.—-. i- ui UJ -- o Q:Q«Mor>r-r-eox~ uir-i in uj<r-irri<^tnoD_ja: ui 3: — a. »-a r^c\4(>io< O iOx <M x» ^-aat- — a — _i • m o " —01/5 -JUJ ZI/J

I». (jo— — *- ■<ax — «-«a. ui UJ KJf* <<<<<-'»» X* l/lO v 1 <w-,^.w— a:>- * a.

-. ». Q. (- •< OO Ifl K _j • zziu _|i-i»«.»»«»inin ui»-« ui—• • •ui 1/) u) • r-h- a: u «Ni > <NJ r-i r-l rH 5 UJ Q.— *-.«*«— -~*.ww. aO * 11*^

-~ ■«/> ►- •© UJXXUI «-I ♦_I2»UJ ZZUJUI — 2< ceo _i a < o: a: < _j ui o UJ 3UJ — —<<Z O-l "«.«O lOuJOiOtOO'* »/>> «>—•♦» << H-t- •« ^ _i D z «H a uj UJ ui ui UJ m <-» a. t-* -Oit\< K-I-UIUI LO. U U. U o "-• x o JC x a •-« a: x — MO UJ <O •— UIUJ xx ui _i u — uiQai^oa.»-iaoa •o. H a:'- ••< «MH-t- OUJ<(/) 3^<U»»»»»» • »-«II < D»- OXO — — II II ZUUI -JVZ — -»— — — — Z-~Z II -> _J *< U UI ,-ICNJ •*« •-• »-i cD0UJi-ior^f^r~-*0O0 "i-)UJDui moc »iiX «.~ MfM II »-3t>- N.V.-Jr-trj(M0O«O I-IIA»-« —DUD •3'- -*0 XX — — >OZ DOOi ZZ< •*'♦ i^r-tO OXZ-JZ MMi-lCKrHirt << x x i/) -■ a: 30-JUJ 00> o« z — z «_!•-'<•-• u.— — Q.— JEXSZXI-D o a u. Q. XX»-' — UJ x UJ r* to H> u t-fM z »H ui z UJ j << eo oo II < »-Q _l£Q O XX3 — -'<XUJX aZ Zllt-t — D—UJ_l i-H I x xa UJ z u. D a ooa<<<< <*-***-<- OOO O^UJUJIIU.»-'< UIUJ t-l-ODCKUJ 10 a UUUI«- — — — — — QMQ QQ.U U^D3D«-«<VJ

u »-«(Mm-tin'niH

u. o o CD 00 O

wuuu uuuu so

148

Page 158: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

(>o<-«rgra-4'tn«or>ooo>o<-<(vjm4'tA<oi%-<aoO'-4ryirrt4'io<or^coo«0'H(Mm4'tn>or>a}Oto

r\irN4cv(^r4r^rsir^r\iojrvirsirNjr\ioj(%ir^(\ir\irNir4r<jrkjr4N<Mr^r\iC4rNjN(\irM

04 * — * > a on x o O KJ V UJ — <S) -" * P} UJ >■» H- a M

o + ♦ 00 (M I

O 00 •

o -.00 r-( — -o X — UJ I- f- < NJ Qi II 3

UJ —

a

rg I

CC * O * {/) «-i

* D _( O UJ UJ > D

o

(M * *

CO >n 0^ OJ

m v — a — UJ cj UJ — 2 UJ I/) < — O Z UJ - z i/> o ♦ •

UJ ro > — — X * UJ m K- • »I I • —* —» nj rg

Ul X Ul -1 —• 1/5 < a II o — a rg •

Ul «M ru UJ * « * < * »O m • • I O I UJ II •

rg M U (/>

3 O UJ Ul

Ul > « -* II rj rg o:

. —a. rg UJ Ul Z -. 3 UJ - UJ 11 ►-• ü.

Ul

< «* O rg UJ —

m rg oo

— o »- nj • 00

*! • ^ m II r-*

Ul — CO

•t- z m (o ^ -• -o l i^ 1- «D « HZ — ^ O OIL. !^ U O >-

(M rg ♦ + **rt •-• 1—' «■#

X X CÜ a; 10 i/i u> UJ or. CC a. Q.

X X a 0: Ul LO UJ UJ a o: a a

X X cc cc <J) if) ui uJ ce — a; a. -«Q. • * * — x — i-t o •-« I " I

X CC to Ul CC a. >

UJ QC 3UJ Z Q

I- _) Z _J o< u u

x — Q X > QC Qi >/) Ci uJ •■ CC -•a p» •*• •••■ >

»-• Oi — UJ X o a: i/) _i Ul -I QC < a. u

rg * x a

rg X Q

CO a

rg + *~*

* «» — X l-l CC + 10 t-^ UJ — QC X a. oc «» lO —. UJ r-l

CC + a •—• m ■^

<— X »—1 CC •— iO X UJ CC on 01 CL Ul • QC • a 0

* rg —* + »—1 •-« + <_r

^! X •-« CC X ^ CC UJ l^ CC UJ a Q: * a —

— ■♦-

X X a: Q: io I^ OJ UJ o: oc a a. * 0

• • 0 0

X CC I/) UJ cr a.

fM I

X QC 10 UJ CC a. >

Ul CC => Ul

Q

X QL <S) Ul

— OC rg a » * x ~ O nj • I

X ~ Q X >- a CD to Q Ul • OC

** a rg —

O

00

rg

X a: UJ cc a

I

X OC <S) UJ oc a

rg I

ro

»n ••• "-' fO X X CO CC oc • lO lO O Ul UJ ro a: -~Q: -» co a. cna. 'fn

x oc lO UJ CC a

x Q: tO UJ CC a

o

eg I

I

x CC S) UJ CC a

X CC 'A Ul oc a

X or 10 UJ CC a

rg I

X X CC cc to lO Ul Ul QC CC — a a. vf

— X «n o I •

—• (M ~ X X o CC V i/) DO Ul Q

-> CC • <n a —

o —

> CC Ul o

I- _J Z _J o <

x ^n i-4 > o 4- uj 4 ui o: • «O 3 « D Ul

rg Z •-, Z Q X o -" I •-• O t- »- »-• H- _J >- Z — Z -I m o o ü. o <

x>xin >x> + in OCCQ^-UJQ:QCC-«4- • UI »OODUI »ui — oo

•■HQrg zOr-^QX X x o —• x cc O 0_JQKI-_IQ_JiO»- >-_l>- Z_J>-_IUJ cc<cooo<oD<tt:o

X oc lO Ul CC < VJ V, . , ^ w -^ ^ -., ^, v. ,... -., UJ ■-. «-, v..

Q.UOOU'-'UUOUOOUUQUG.O

in o 00

o CO

m (D

o rg 00

m rg

o co

in m 00

149

Page 159: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

<o<0'A<0'0<o<o«<or»r~r»roh>r'^^r-r>>r>>co(0(D<8c9ai>(seocoeoovo>otOio>o«oo»o»o*oo

0f(^NNr4(>iiNifMc>i<>ir>«r4f>ir«rNi<>iNf^(yNrii(vi(>iriiNr>i(Nr4Ai(Nj<v(^(>J<>i(>i<M(>l(>iNi>l(>i

• rg

z o

V. N-«

«« H- — < •x rg _I >— * D * * X ♦ u *~ •~ ac _l

»H I-« «o «« < 1 1 UJ 00 u •-• •-• a in w **• a o» > Q X X ♦ CSJ t- z a: ae • M < io o r^ /- u lü UJ 1 m o -1 ae ac •—1 V -1 < a a *»-• a UJ z • * X Ul > o •» *« oc UJ •-• f\i <N *n X m z tO l i UJ irt m *-« z

i«-* ü^ oc «UP co Ul w •» CL z • Q X K X 'w t-t —. »n aJ t—*

ac oc •V i0< m I Q «/) tO « ♦ o 00 l/) 1 UJ UJ fNJ -I UJ • f-4 ^* o ÜC K * UJ £ o _l m 2 & Q. ♦ >o « CD • l- m • «k _J w •> 00 < rvj a *•> ^ UJ ♦ UJ <*«■» »- i-i oc Ul

«o tn > mf- U) Ifl UJ o • 1 • <w • N a UJ • u. z «-• K4 •s. 1 • UJ < «» W X l t- H z *4

K X Q *-• —i w-i o < Q cc ae ♦ •i^ •■*♦ u. z IM o: < W) WO X Ul X z fNJ U. I- a: UJ UJ O UJ _1 U. Ul z o • Q£ (X • >- — in Ul z u p-* *» O -~ a. a. rg cn rv! < Q. 3 « z UI u. o u o • «» »«^ >v Q ♦ H O V UJ UJ D z o 1- tOU r-l —* ^ - m —« * * - a -« 3 o •^ o Ul < — ■«• • 4- • rsl UJ -1 »4 * <M • Q: X UJ •H t0 — • < 1 X 1 X X ►- Ul ^* «^ U. .-«UJ O 3 ■ »- Q J M ** Q -« O o tsl > UJ •-• z u. > IH * er 3 o «^ • ** • ^. • V * * UJ w r>- *H zz * • a. a. to a -» >< •-< K r>4 aa OC f-< M UJ ■* Ul -t o m JN z Q Z • o a xa x o 1 U. < UJ 00 D UJ u • < (M •-< u o: o tO Q to Q •f o u. z *■* »^ •> J D I rg h- o •» •-« M «s, \0 UJ >-iu > f» ^l .-• z »X <o< o .-t — N fH OC UJ «o x x m a z <-i ae doa (0 X «U. M Ul rf> u. m 4> ui r4 a T U < Ul K O <-• a Q a o o rH Z UJ D • < CO z o • • U. ul Ul O • Ul 1- UJ u — *>• • •« • >- 11 -« D 1 o a • tat o o z * »- n o O UJ < X X < > -.> - CQ OUJ X UJ UJ f«- m ui «ox II •- -J rsl >- Ul Z _J X -1 v

UJQC «a « uj a Z 3 II M • X 4- Ul m Ul D Ul • rH UIUI Ul II — Ul • « 3 V(D O DUJ w UJ *» 3- H «« O 00 D CO D- DO- l-l D D > J«k ta» Z3 •- U t0 's 'X ZO KO X Z • <H m (M IH •^ a: v) «• z z in z — J- u. z ii n M UJ z a z Q 3 -1 «Z Z •-« ae ae -• X mu. u. •«• a. "> ►x o •- 00 — UJ< z ^^ u. — — < *-< a oc <M O < XO O t-J O J «fl »-Q II 00 Z Z UJ Z_i-)>-o»-t-<»-KX »•4 t- z- X o»- z z> •-« a: u < x x Z -1 UJ _! lü Z >■ •^ ►-• UJ — _J «« z ■ z - z» ae UJ i »4 «» Ul UJ Z •^ K Q X tC X X o< ac < « ooa -> OUJüJ •-« u.<u.O">oou.Ott:OD UJUI h- X O u. UJ Z< D o o uuQ.ua uo -»ODD ~< M U ** u -> o u •-■ u XU. U D 3 M O U ** OC U t0 u u

«-• rH H r- m

1^ u o m ■* o m o O m u. 't' ♦ 00 sn m o <o « CD 00 00 «0 co <o co « —

u *rt u u

150

Page 160: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

rgrrk-4'tnNor-co(>o>-«(\jrrt4'un<or^GO(/>Or-«r\i(<>4'tn<or-(oo«0'H(>i(n^'ir><or-<o(h0^rsjm OOOOOOOO^rHrtr-t^i^r-lf-tfHi-trg.MCMfMfMCiUMOIC^tMmmminrtm«;;»«»«»»**^-*

r>jNf>i<>i(>irsiNC4rgc>ir4r4Nr«nir*r4t>ir\jr<jr>ir<4r4f\ir«cM('<<<>i(y(>iN(>i(*(>i(>ic«rj(*N<V(\iN

o in

UJ • ••**•••• UJ ^* KM» «P* *•* «^ *-* --* «MM -^ *—<

o <

X »- •-• X X ~ o < •-« a u < o iiJOa:i/)0>-»-üj-« in ajX3x(r:MUJ3~. r-

~ . ~ UJ >Ovoor-r-r-r~-f^<r o *«

r- CJ r- a> ~ «n rH 4' >o o> o (*-

N» in •» . . . — _< r- x

. x— t- _J O UJ

• *••••••«. ^m x a r- H.

«, o ~- • UJ x a.« —

-j-j << •a:~ o x io •-.ejxi- ^-00 m 0 Q. auj'-'ü,- o a m t» UJ o»-«o^wix m»— — CDXQ.XQOX»-Z r»-~^ X • •••••••• —ox < ^^^^^^.^.^^ am* •- mino-tr^i^r-f"-«-« <r-~ UJ

O»4-O><M LO—moo — fnin(> xQr^mino

w » O — w — in — — — w ~ — < —Qi/)i/)»-r- <<<<<<<<*- o»irt'-ico«- ww^-w www in~üJi/)iiJx

— OCX x cc -< *«•••••«• vina»a.vo

• i«- • «~ • x ^ ~, w-^o— •

X O LU O T» o — Q:_J in<in — ino

üL UJ <</) —of^io—»n 1 z _J UJ f-a. cc •-• UJ — _J ►-r- UXMüJ <-I tOOCLtOXtOUJl/J«-

uj<OQ.>>-<xxa.zxo>-oxx

z „„ — ^.-^«^z^zzzz UJr-t^lOOr-ir^l*-f^f»-^(DOOOOOO

< r-iMr~r«j ioh-towi/)to > cvmr- z — zzzz <-• ~ UJ K UJ UJ UJ UJ 3 w- — <S:UJXXXZ

Ujwwww .. «-QrslOOQO rHJNJC^^finvOf^-OOOrH f-l

CM

tO

u> X

1 ^«k

M-t «»» -6. --»

«o -~ -« i-i n iO 1 >0 X — O^ r. ♦ — o rg i/) f<- ♦ x m * 1 • *« —. r-< — « M ^« — — | »*« >—■

l-< (/) —

» — X to «K »^ ~- _» •-• V v,u 1 1 —o

M« —. #-* •Mi •-• «-H —*

•^ «« >» 1 «^ iO — tO — <-! K -H > ~ I

O ♦ | - >- « <-4 «<k « w | w o •H ■MT — »- ~ — fM ■> ** >- cc — «o • o •-• + O -^ X o CM tO — «/>>- t-t

— iH X « + — • • ^ • w ~ wO o - o »» »« X* v »H z ui l-t « M (M o o f^ ^ • «n — 1 < • ■»•. ••• l^ ■~ X iH • • w w» <M • * « »- •-• ^» X •-« II <~ r-l ►-« o >• >- n ou^ — < - w M4 II ~- ►-• ~ <V UJ N (1 d UJ II N UJ ►-• N • tO M -• to w UJ — V X ^ 1 D «« •<"• f-t D ~s. ** 3 A O X « — -J tO D •

■-• r^ M H — 0t Z >H ■>4 Z <-» r* Z o« «»—•-• UJ _) z o it -,,— a; a. >■.: •** w o 4-< «- •• »-4 o- \n a UJ — ■ > (O ^1 rH < Z ►- ** •-« ♦- t- k« »-« ♦- r^U) « »- tfl X N Q J- Q U) -> >» w 1- «. Z O g z Q« Z *■• -I >- z « Xi/)l0(0*0li.00 CO O O O O iO iotouju.uju.oa Z X >- X X •-« uoaouoauQx >- x o ►-• o -< u «->

o o o o <-» M m r^

151

Page 161: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

r-f>'r'»*'r»f»'r-r-f~r~r»r,»r»r-p-r*h-^f^t~r-f^f»-f*r»f*r,-h-t«-r~^rr>-f*t*-f*r>-i,*r*f^i«- r4i^<H^>Hf^r4lH>^r^r^<^«>4f>4<^f-l>-4r4l-tp>tr-t«Hl-«r-lr4«Hr4«-4fHi-4r4r-l>-<i>tf-tr>4i-ffHi^i^i^

v.

UJ O

10 * oo

iNJ

* * -J UJ a

LO ■V

+ z *

♦ ♦ X

<

+ in rg O

o +

OUJ O

z ^ O -< H h- t- Q

Z vO o oa o u u

o rsi

UJ

* O

Q.

* rg

* — X -J u io * V

• a. o — — ii

>o UJ ♦ '- • D Ü. >-' oz z — 4, M i-i i/) * t- Q. l/> X Z ■ UJ u O wo: < u a a r-l

o

•—• C\J-~ c^ * z: X ♦ — -r — U> V. *«► »—•

<M z^ — -* X r-t tO 1 — w •—• -^ (\J IS) ■-'? -1 * •—• X + * ^ 1 X I X U

1 i^iO < —. + « V r\ ZiO ■*

«-* «- X _l -J ■ ■-0 I/) — c0 co «H ►—* — * a. a. \ iO c0 — V s. —. X X - u_ u. — • — — (-1 z z ^* > 1-«

* + 1 -• _l •-. > CO 1 —. oox CL c0 Q. — ifl X _1 «Mb * — « Q. II > X z lO 04 * </) — o ~ »/) — z * Q. •^»» -co xa. -* X > • X * CO — UJ -' M — z u) x * M U. I/) see i0 — 10 • X • - > z UJ ~-a to X w X z — o « CO o ■-■

a iO I UJ — UJ *.«>,_• r-l — x tn a a. >- — a: o a: — X — fM a: z * "V

• 1 £ a. coa — • a: «. < • o — M UJ w — < — o i— 1<L ■* »^ CO .-ico «cc — o: M h_ « »-I Cl • • «, «>< + c0 .j a _i < — co — rg X — o X Ul ZLÜ O cO X »-a: x x • • »— •* -J 10 — Q£ a —a o CO < • < o i/) - --* W7 Ui i^a X -J N. + x •- co »- r»- coo: _J a. <£. >• — U- CO U. — • CO _l UJ r-l UJ < iO o oo a >- + Z CL z c0 X UJ I ■— a i- a a m — -—• —«• «-« « o •-< •-• • Q ►- -^ a. co o «^ i t-x — a. a. a »-« CO CO • * X • x a I O

9M a: '- rH ■w X >• CO 00 •»• cO • * • i- ». <n «Mt a co 1 • • • a: • • x m cO X CO O) p-i -> •» X coco s: ►-»-»- < i/) cO — 0« X — _i rsj w O *«*• <y) + UJ *-• J O _J o» t- X X Q. N 1 Q. u m K o c0 c0 *«i -QC «rt • • • •♦ co J • — J Q • ac CO UJ CO — XQ. Ml r- x — a. a. tat* r* CD • 1 o "* _l UJ — o: X X — M CO ^% <» «« • H — _J -j i- m + 1-vO — CO <-) iO X Q: ~) a. 11 w W — X X X ^ ^ -• a: co aa n u IM M X ■H * a. - a — II *« > X-H 1 M w *• II r* <»->- — — >rf •■* *-* ^* _l • o •-< II U)

UJ „ -** rH H H + —* cO »/) ifl « + (-U II M M ct ui^acoujujoujH-Q. ii — X ^ «H *^ + X s: 10 O V) *^ i/)»~ •— •— •» < 3 -_l to 3 > -O DC? ♦ ^ r-t ^ II z- CsJ £ «-I >Hw ^* UJ UJ UI o» X •-< M x X K Z X CD UJ Z H z • 00 + — — «lO ^»^ *^ + +t/)»/)<-ia:«o£ ocx II •— < < CO « _; f-oe M« —* o >- OliA ^ H- ^ t- ^ cO «/) Z Z i/) N>l + a a a «NJ< — X X t- H- X H- CO II Q. ►- •-< 1- »- >-• tn m 1 CO «- ZUJ •-* »-« — —UJCOX >- •-•-•< UJ UJ ^ z a -J w z — z •— • X UJ K OQJtovomt/xrx II u. u. u. o co ^w>l-Ilu.OOUJü.OuJOO u. II O ii a co uc x x >- xa «^ X *^ **"* *'^ Q X X X UJ 1- 1- •-4 U Q. Q l-< U Z) o u >" a Q -> Q. X

rH r-l

o O o o o r» 4- ir\

152

Page 162: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

0CD<DCD<OO>O>O>O'9,O>O>C'9>^OOOOOOOOOO«-<<«-<>H'-<>->'-<'-<r-<f-<>-«rvlVfM(VilVfVi(V

&Q'O*O*O*&O'Q*O>,&'&'O*1T*&Ot'O'Q'O'O*&K&0'&&'tt'&&'&' &&&■{?'&*&& & & & &• & & fr

D

ac - »■■a |^

• O rg Ui ** O UI Ui rg UJ • O K K «M UI »

a

UJ 10 ■r x & - I a « n a:

lua O 3 ■ «0 XKJ • •n M (J

zoz UK «A

o OD

o

o

o *) K

I

ct

K *

z o CO

K

ir>

CD

a c

o ft I *

o •>

— <J

a o (A * U

UI < o Ui X o

K UI

rg

to a o

• a. CM • O >» — ^ «\i »1 «H * ~ • * u< o ~UJ in

Ui«

«>-

OH-

DU) Z «

JE- oui

o

Ui— o D< «T.

X Ui **• »H #P« O OUJOkuUitJIfyi»;» « « * 3«« Da**© 13--«

Z • Z »««i) «z •-*- O«'-««- ft —--o »-»-•«»~»_UJ.JZ*-»~*~»~ Ä S*" «f Ui j~«ca OOUiOO*-< uoooo 003 C/U«8U»-C/CttO

> X z

ft < »- V) X • >-

K

a ID

z o

z X

UJ »- <

x z o — • o »o — o t/i U X • Ui 3.Z

UJ

X IT

o I

*0 X I z I

Ui « D~

CO oo wo

o o o ■ UI

•• z

Si ft u

rv ft iu - <ft X ►- I- « «/) U) »- K X

zo« P o • ■ PtQ * «X

UJ «M • f^

D- *- ZK «■*>

•-u»- »u

ft

*0 X

I e

ft o o a a. >■

OD

D UJ

z ft UJ

a »-

o

ft

X X >-

rg Z • X v O j * <

ft UJ rsj X O X > »Sj o> fV — «> V » •» f-^ »■> — O «M fl» ♦ o • o X <Ni • •*• *M rio «o < «-«o %^ »\J •■* I t-i

<0 X UI —. « •-• r> « UJ • v ur? rg UJ • «- e^ uj • z « •> D » 1 i «»- f-D «c •-• — »- r o ft -« Z - *- Ui < ft uj x o •- ui 3*- S ft»-»- Z*r »►ft »► »- K

Sftl oz< «» ^

-o « — »-©ft U. ft U OOft

« »u. v) c»D "• U X o u » « o o

CD c o a «

o o CO o « c o •-«IM »4

o o o « ♦ «% M tH m* tV

U

1 T),')

Page 163: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

(OOaoococoaQaoaocDcocooaoaoOaocoaccoaoaocoooaocoajaoaocoaoaooooooaoaocDooaoco

(4rgr4r4C4r>jr\i4>irg<>ic«i(\ir4rsjc>jr^rsir4Nr4r\irsicviry<r\irsir4r\ir4<>jr^rMfMcvir4rsjrgr«irsiri4rt|

>- I

• * * * » K

X ««i «^ •M #<^ —* -^ O o- t/) m • D ao *

•-1 *—• — X O * » •f. • * IO a Q a < CA o vO ^ O» <N» rH

K X < O H- —. -^ O* -» cM^-iinoo • • • I 0(X or UJ Q. — o • o* r^ m tn «^ 4 o o o (^ * * • •> * • in o ONCOiOtnONrgino » M> «« *~. *m. —' ~ t>- * Ov ONO>ONONCor~4-fM X rg rg r- r- (- ^ «- ■o • • • • • • • • • t\J r-t (M tr> en 00

lA o

— • V

o m

«k * ^ *

o • • • a • • • -v »H ^ a: r^- * • • r--<-4<AO^rgooin in UJ «v <■» •~ — — < • •o t-J O —1 rH r-t tn <4- vO • DC < < < < < •—• •*• X CM

(NJ UJ w ~- ■ w — — o < i-t

•-I X m t- S\ «k • •>••> * tu a • * * * • c. |^ UJ o vO CO r- IT CD rg • >/> ~- X • CA vn f» O oo -* in • • •

— 1-4 -m ~~ _ ^. -- -~ i-< ►- ^ (> ON 00 ON ON iH ,* .r. p- og »- II X X X O » rf (?. o> ON 00 ^ J- O co <-) >0 z> UJ L0 -I < a: o *~ • O» ON ON O* ON ON 1*- m fM a. X X a iO -< X >- ifl Q o •v • • • • • • • • •

O

o

O

UJ a. x o

o- UJ -T-

UJ • m •k 4» • *

X Z V«' w; j. ufc — Q x t- a o

r^ • • * • • o • • • • • • •

-o u. < • • * » * • m X * • • >0 O 4" OO CO <t O _J •» •■* •«, — <_ ^~ ~ — r- < rH rH rg rH ^i «H m ^ <o < in 3E o ^-i o r- r- r^ r — >- II • * z • O < r-l og oo oo ro 00 X o UJ •-i (M •k » * «r» * o (NJ _J eg o o (v -t a: tn * • 00 o (M ON m ON rH »—« r-t u. * in o> CO to «— «■«. ~ r- r- o m in tn Ul • • « oO UJ «-> o - UJ i- o — oo o- O» fSI in ON -t oo in o z * -^ — O u o v w — w — — cc (M tn — o* ON o« ON r- •* rH tn oo rg UJ — i^i t~ u ^ < < < < < «t a t- r- (- (A ON ON ON ON ON O oo in <n 5: It V s < — w ». —. M. *-» •» a. «. fgo> • • • • • • • • • r^ «> ff W • < «~ a. X 1- (A Q »—• #^ r-4 t- -J « • * » • * • o * *•* a • * • • • •> * «i * «

1 X X t-* UJ o tO • in .-. in a O 00 • • • • • • • o Q X — rg a Q. ~ « --. «~ —. —. — r- o X * * • • in ON tn r- 4- o NO 3 • m •—« r-t z • o O - iA » — rg .-H r-l f* rn rg 4- «n »- •-« • ui •• •^ ^-* a: o a: « a: •v » >-« • I X X X X X vo u. < \- < t- -~ o •~ (M — o •~ o ^ UJ 10 Z r-l X z >- < i— oo «n m h- * • • • • 4» •

tM O ~4 X O l-t U X ÜJ O -4 (J — 1-4 to o: io x ~- r- a> •■ o rg rg <n f" rg rg • o • • o «1 UJ H U •'UJ <a. X X X ^ X t-Q. w X O 00 (N* rH >o f^ OO • •> o <M O ■-I ro Q U < U< ■J • * •t * * • X fc-oa'O^tnOvO-Tfn^-a-

X -« X II «O X Z _J _J vZ »» ••» _ ~. »^ ^Z z z z — ©<> ON o> CO lA (Ni 00 -n oo -t UJ • r-t ►-• • r-IUJ •» D m o UJ rH 00 •* f- r- oo o o o • O O <J< CT- iJ> 0^ ON 00 NO <n ■»IB- D <0 — <o -^ 3 »-U ^ N, _l l-l m (^ m «n l-t •-• I-« H-» 1- o • • • • • • • • • <

z »—4 LU <

rj -' t- r-ir^UJ <

1 rg>- x z Z

3

D _J z z < */) to lO l^ z • • •» •> •» «k «k «k •>

>- i- + -^ v-r "^ X Of u UJ UJ Ul UJ < • 00 vQ • • • • • • •

a Z - or X « o: z x <_ o UJ CD X X D •W *^ >^ *-- —■ - X X X X »- • • • * oo rg NO C <0 rg o oa o ii o o: o o ii uj z x D o o o < < < < < < -• t-4 fcH ►^ < o rH l-t rH rg tn m u. U 3t U. xo 3 u. vj x o: UJ U) U U UJ ^, _ w «^ w ~ Q Q Q Q o

u r-< rg ro -* m -O 1-4 r-l rHtMtn^mNor'-oo O CO o o <v H- o W o o rg u. l-t n pg o rg CO «o -o «o *-*

»« U KJ U

154

Page 164: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

^>^>r^r^r^r-r^r-r~r>-r>-r-a)ooa)oooooooocoa>ooo>o*o>o»o>o>o»o»a>Ovoooooooooo »-I rH r-l o o o»

•-• r-l ft r-l r-* r* r* <h Qy O* O ^ ^ ^ o* o^ c^* o* ^ O* (7* 0^ 0^ 0* 0^ (7*

.-1 r-< 0*

^ ?>

r-« r-l Os 0^ O O^ CT* O^ Ch

«-t

■*

r-1 * * -* ■^-t-t-t-t-t-t-t-t-t-t-t^t-t-t-t^^r-t-t-t-t^t^^-t^^^^-*-*-*

«MJ>i r>l CM eg oj <M «X o« «>lrgfM«MrgcMr«|fMr>jrurMr^(M<Mr«4«M(Mrsj(>4(M 3

Z •-•

Q UJ

<M IM fM fM ru CM CM CM CM CM CM «M CM

x

UJ UJ u X UJ

o

>t p- • -^ UJ

X • z ~ t- • O in O •-• • z o 10 (M UJ 1-1 Z r-t

aJ aJ - >

• »-« » < If» Q X K < -t in O 1— o ** UJ • O < • > »—

< X a: Q

* X Z Q ct • • z >— 1 >- UJ o o •> Q a: CD u. (J.

3

R

•-• !— z

t0 3 )

»OX

C

00R

X

ST

A

Q Ul 1—

tO z <

* »-« X UJ •—« -. i < 1- <o Q < X O w UJ < Z r- < r— H- < CÜ Z h- •—• 1— o o CC UJ o » a: X < -. aJ x < i—i • ^v X

r-l \

+ f- -J X to s i- UJ

UJ X to < • •-• • i— »-^ -* x < 1- z i—i

• — h- —. o a —' ^-4 • UJ x to O • o a UJ • m a a: «^ ►- o: m z UJ — «^ co

3 < t—

X >—

O • o i— rg

< a: ÜJ ►- —< X to ^

3 a:

Z <

1— h- < U

O o

OJ >o >-« O 10 I • in 00 l- (/) >-• H- ♦- X X or _1 z vO CO fNJ O »n x »» • 1- ». x a x — (/) — n -• -» m ^ ►- 3 3 ^ r- M < t» ♦ *-* o _i • t— O *-• *-* X o<ox O (M U O U Ü. r-<

• CD lA a: •-^ • z w- 0* • o «^ a z a 11 O »UJ fM •> UJ _) ^. f- o> O O * X ^H < ae. • • II o Q. ii - o —. ^ ox r-t o Q UJ < UJ < ^t ^ (> <t o II II « < o o~ X r-( _l «Nta (Oa <~i «O X O X • z u z ^ rH oer o (n o — -■ Q M II II —. < 1 UJ CD 1-4 n II + Ul * rH UJ * #-H UJ o i—i •-« o • • O (> o «^ l-t < W) •>"•■ *•* ««( »- t- 3 ►- — » » i-i 3 <© «- Z «o — 3 II 1- Z _J •^

i-> r-t • • o o — oa- X •-« «-• X UJ UJ Z II X HH t—l V z w »- « •»• H- Z O z z 3 IT X z ^ II • it n 1) • o Q£ O H II -» - < X I >-< OJ a: ^. Su- a: •-I UJ < ►- UJ < »—« *-4 a: < o >- < o • > o «■^ *■> ■~ II • < -^ i- -» K X f- b- h- l- »- to t-4 »-< < ■-• 1- «- X 3 H- X a 1- ►- 3 Q: cc O UJ X o tO II i-l (N CO a. II 1- tu M4 •-4 < UJ w ~. z a uj o: a i- II z — (X o »-• en. o z < 1- Q 1- m QC X r- X *—• — —' "-" X X iS) O T ^» </> ►- I U. U. o o o: O o io •-• O a: o Q: CL o >— O cc UJ z o 3 *— o

z x a a a Q Q X Q >- X X UJ 1- »-• CH ua a a o X «u XÜ. CD Jt u. tO U 3 (X ÜJ tO tO u CT> o m

o o

t-H

o o r-l

o r.j r-4

o l-t

1-1

u i— u. CD

u u tf> u u

IK

Page 165: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

O»HrMfr«-*»f>>Of^00O»O<-«CM<n-*«ft>Or^c00»O'^r>4Cr>4,tA4»r^fl0(>O>-ir<jt'>-*if»'O^000*O

fMf>ic<r»i<Mr\jrM«\i<MfNi«M«MiMojr>4iMO«<MP«j * 4- 4- -»

o o • •«.***••*•■ ^o ^^ ^-«~ r^i-«

i- Z D X O X<-<XX-« tUQ. o oc cruj< oa: i-x lUO»-,-,0»-t-uJ<CLI- f>i» tnxaxcK'MUJDaz^ • —

■-•rgmr^mmcorg eo r~~ r»- (\*»»- o* o* — 3i r-t -J >0 O» lit >—

w UJ »

<<<<<<<<<^< <o . «. ^ww — »in

~ r- *********** o "^

in •-• ~ r-QC

uj to — O to _i < < -^UJ a: a x u-OLi—oxt- oo» LU O Z-JQUi«ÜJO lA* — » UJ -«iuos;^XCi.-^-i r-->o

Z cDXO>QOX»-X-«^ —om < *•*•*•**•>•• ,_ 1ft f^

< r^iMmooootowoo m —xQ o: CT>-*<>?M<r <>J o_io • C\ il\ O* r-t vOlOQ

ij >H «« f- ^ •• U www w .w<w w O — U <<<<<<<<<«< _IQ.O < wwwwwwwwwww I/) • in • • — I*-

_l ••••••••••• -~o — i/) o in </> (X ^ •»*.-.«-. ^«. ~ — int>-< • x r^ w H-

oi o (- -J a: —auj -^3 U. vOlJJ < 3 3<I z UJ uj-iauj H- ujuujt-i- o >-XQ:üJO»-> u)3iü.>-t->-40» UUJ<QZ:>QL<XX>-^<»-'<X —

_ie zziri cDüJ>*''-tr-»-<f"-f^f^-f-r"-ff>oo»OOP-

Z< fMh-rsir^f^ t» coiouj 0> (Minr^o <M z z < Vl-I ^wwllJLLlt9 J^j^ <-'<XXlU

UUJ— — — — »■' — *--'—''■»"— — OQO r-irvjro-^in^Jf^coo^-^tMf'i r-«

-t -*•»'♦ •4- rxi oj oi oi (M

3: • t~ X x r- <M » • _i X cc 00 < • 31

—. Hi a I O in cc • X X -* o

•* -* * •» CM r>j «M csi

* 4" •» 4- -* ■»• -* rg (M rsi (M <M m (M

44

< UJ X in

x o

o in r-

x <

w >-• HJ

o m

irt x — < o< m • p. UJ — > X <

z o o -' tu IO Ul z o UJ UJ

« z

<? I

_J u. 4 O

O n

_i u. 4 O

ti. !*% o ~ • -J

_J u. u. o <M O O I • _J

-J u.

o — • *

_l — U. -J Ou. o o w (J a I ac -J i- u. z ^ — o

x co

o o X 4 'v • 3e x UJ o> •-* < • X

UJ 4 3 • X X

r m

x *

O X. X X

r

x

X UJ

< UJ >- N. < _J X Ul yO U. • U x x

Z X x o^ CM •

• iO X X vO u. • X t- m

a ■s. Q. X in

— x o <^ o • rvj r-4 «ox 4) w w H- ÜJ <

-i oc 0C O 3 U.

o o f\J

« -I X < x r- X o • 4 UJ _J • X t- x x o «o in Q • • O

ui x x < r^ m o •> • UJ J X X xr~ O O • X UJ O >o co i/) • X -• x m _j Oi • O • x x

tu o> m H- • • N -« X x in o «^ X rH •X • X (^ _i o »x <-• XX • 4 cj

rH (Vl fO

< LU >- ^ < ►- X Ul ■o tu - u x I h- 4 « •

t- X X 1^ o • UJ t~ X *- X o in Q • O x x • •

H- X x r- O • tu o to iO X — m t— • O x X o m

x

* o X u. X en

X

» o X X

m

X

< UJ X t- X

X

* _J < I— Ui X

o

X a ♦

< X l- © UJ r* X • <n H- • X X X 4 fsj 4 m

Nl X X «o ro • • X X «o r- • • Q: < < Ul UJ I X h-O X X m so • •> X X 4 O» «o r-

ii

o o r-t 1^

M O X

<

x

— o ^ LU fM UJ - 3 ^ D O Z Z Q. —i O •"' X ►- »- »- - z z U. o o o

O X •-• U O vJ

o o O r-l

z o

< ISJ

< Ul —• D »- z -• -' z z o

o

u

156

Page 166: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

rsirgfNirg(>ir4c\i(\ir>i<>i<vc4r*if^f\iryjrJ«>l«>jr^r^rsir4r\lrjrgr^r^r^irvirgf>if\jt>irgrj^r\jfgr^r\j(Ni o o

D Z ^ -H — II II

> >

OO • • K •-■ C O II II O O • • O O «- II n h- a ti 11 o o it • v 'f 10 zozaiüi-ii iiioo-ia-z < 11 «-• tu > z _i ^ < 11 x •- <

zw<s>o-*a:a:a:h-<'2 — <~i-x. n 11 a nxxii iit-»-Q.ztooxxuJh-aai- UZX,-,^,-«,-«,-',-,OUQ.Q.(DU>->*-»X

o o

X X * .0 0

X. _l -I t— UJ UJ ■S! O Q » O — a —

a: • ^H * <''! 3 *■•, » ^-^ * ■Z <r X r"i X

X 0 + Q + a 3 a: * —• •

X »-^ *

X V as •-• 3 —< a 31

0 3 0

UJ 3

1 O

UJ a

Q UJ 0 a 3 ^ -U «r^ * ^ * * 1- D -. -~ *~ — 2 •> n"i 4 fM c-i jj * ■1- ■i- + + X < —• ►-4 —• •—< UJ O — — — — a: UJ t—« i^J ^-« -iJ vJ ~x 3 3 3 a T 3 D O #■ O • M < •

,n 3 * r>.

l^ UJ —. — + — + -^

„^ .^ X - O -J +

»—< +

—'

X *-* <

• < —" UJ 3

•—• a

I/) *- IT 1- UJ UJ —t * ^-4 * < ^ uj »M >: > C — O —

UJ x * O •—• O ;M O •-> 0 >- 0 *— * t— a + Q + z < * •-« \S) < #^ —• * — •*• • ■A — < > — <^ -* — a '- h- X 0 •—• 1—t iu ^^ J 0 ►-• Nl _l UJ QC + 3 ^^ a 0 — » 10 X UJ ^-. » —t #< .j X

-J •-« 0. O O •

0 •—« r-1

a 0 l_m^

Q <A — a — < O 0 + a UJ a. X * *-« 1— t»1 0 ^-. * xi 1- 0 _J <-> w _J fVJ Q — a < a i/; •-• X UJ rH •> UJ r-< •» UJ » a — _i Q » «. -> 1 a. —- O B '-0 O —< * •-■ r-i u: —! a UJ Q. O fNJ — — ~- 1 r.< w- • - V O z fNJ >-< ►-< ►—#

2 1 < a < r-4 Q — a ■—

ce ►- *-.■ ■W ^rf m O UJ 0 UJ O — -t < X >- O Q 3 a a u. -J 3 O D -» f— i-H w *~ 0 — —

_J UJ uj x a: *-^ (M > > r- > > h- UJ UJ < x x ac <J u UJ 1—< UJ tX ac tSi Jj Lt U£ Z Zi D JC OOO »-^ 0 D — Z) UJ UJ rH O UJ UJ 1—• z Z »—< 10 co a: L0 -1 Z (M Z D Q Z a a O •-• t-l B-* * UJ »—< 1 1—I O »—« a ►- + t— -J _) _J _J a > h- *—4 1- _i — _J t- »— _) — _i

z - Z _l -J _) -J UJ z w Z -I -I -J z _J OJ _l 0 II 0 < << < >- O u. 0 < • < OO < • < u — u u U VJ (J < u ►1 U (J X u U3 u u X U

rH »—1 r-«

rH 0 0 0 0 O 0 0 r-t !N O —1 r\! r-j f\J t-l rH rH rH i-<

u u u yj u

Page 167: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

0*oo^o*t>>{>OCOOOOOOOO>-«»-«<-«'^'^«-«'-«<-«'^'H'Nioj(\jf>4«MrM^r>jrsifMf<%cncnm 0,OvOvOvC>0»(>0000000000000000 0 00000000000000000

en X X * 3 Q X _J _J Q UJ UJ

«k O o X Q — D ^ £5 • •^ » m

r -» * *** • ü) -. .-t X M« X Q (^ + Q *- Q O • —4 • »-i • • X ^ X 3 X

— Q «—1 a O 3 t M • o -xJ 3 UJ + X o 3 • 3 « Ci a 3 *«. 3 ■— LU * * *—t * - 3 -— -^ 1 *•» Q a •—« ^-« ►-« »: o • *- + — i^ — »-« »-^ i-^ UJ • f>J Q w O 3 — + O jj O •-

l-t •-• O 3 3 »- + — * • * r-«

M LU ** —• «^. 1 - D rH >—< pg »-• * 1 1-» 1 ^ o — t—• UJ I-« ID O rH ^ 3 •^ 3 Q + k-« #* ■_> * o z * *-* a ~ Q M rg < • «- o r-» O fNj <n M

O uj o 1 Q 1 o ^< Z Q • •-* • t-4

<n <

o - <

—i • (M UJ (^ UJ r-( 1- 3 s 1 C 1 3 1 3 < ^»

»--i «* »—* A *-4 * X o o o Q: •-« — — w — ■^ — 3 O t- 4 O -x ■-

o « ft »-M iN l-H ro O _J CM en *-• a^ vO O 1 o 1 Q 1 rg UJ cn O ^-« -* »-• < f\J o - o t—< O •—• tn Q r-( O r-« — i- r-t Q - Q ~» Q w r-l Q O O 10 UJ • • LU • UJ • UJ ♦ o *-*. i— • < X '~ o — 3 — 3 »« 3 o t- m f- —. —• H- -I m rg • «\ • 4 * s- M4 oo • UJ • V ♦

Ä <st

rsj 1 — 1 '» 1 -. »--- o • O UJ x ft X «» ^ »- r-l — (\j t-4 m t-4 -t o *-« «3 _l >- » 1 Z -^■ X UJ og • — 1 w 1 » 1 i3 a • »» • * z X • 1 X ♦ o *—4 •—« *-H l—t »-H ►—t — o —« Lu 0> M X a ^s r-i «— *- * •t Q ~ Q «v 3 ^. -» Q • _J (> <-• >-> • —. X • I CL — Q. tM O UJ O UJ O UJ V O • • • M r-l ♦ UJ r-4 "* X to > i-t O 3 Q 3 o 3 • *» ^ « | z ♦ 1 X uJ o *

O — o — »^ o «^ UJ •—« • rfK • 1 O UJ o z X 4 o • • M» * u in r- H > >r- > > r- > > 3 — t- Zi-zin ujr»- x* o *o iH ♦ 4 * • (MUJ + UJ a: o: eg UJ ce at eg UJ a: QC UJ • a UJ _J x _l X CO UJ w <n UJ — • -* en UJ ^- • 0* UJ -~ I r^rD >-« 3 UJ UJ .H 3UJ UJ .-« 3 UJ UJ 3 < 3 » «^ • — fH3 •<r-l3N en • r-l 3 II cn rH 3 •- X

z — Z Q Q Z Q o Z Q Q z o: K z 01 tO Z O « Z 3 >v J Z 3 "v • z — n O-« 1 >- O •—« o 1—4 1—» a to »-• ZCQZCQO-« II -IO-IW) • tl o !-• tO • H « UJ 3 (-!--• *- -J _iK- H- -1 — -1 H- t- 3 — 3 t-Z XI-X<X<h-t-^iOh-»-»- cv *£ h- h- h- rvl i^ y- z><J)

z - Z -1 -J Z -I 4 -J Z -J n _i z w II Z *» •» w -' z a UJ ZUJ H a ZUJ II Q. Z H UJ oou.o<<oo< • < o o < • < OU-ZOU-U-U-U-OOXVOOX^XO ox ^ X O a. v ou -• u u u o u u xu o u u X u u 1—« X u •-• «—« •-• •-«<5UUJ<OUf-XU.IC» u t- X UJ u > <

i-H r-i

o o O o o o o o o c <n >t m <o r- o <M 4 m <o rg rg pg eg f>j ««^ m c*> to cn

158

Page 168: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

oooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo

2: <

<

o

<

o

_! <

a 0 1 j

Q. — * r~

lO * _i m — D Q: ^ OC rg x a UJ a < • < D t- X (D f-t _i 1- UJ UJ U) ~ u e? z » * * + + < Q; • * rg r^ — « oa 0 rg •-> 0 _l t- ^ 10 < t—» — ü. cn O 0 >_< < a * * O

* ü. IT» *

• * ■ ~ et

_l O X

UJ X — * * <t 4- ce < -~ -0 gj a u * ü. m 0 + + < h- • 1 iTi UJ z _i — O <N IN rH rH t- ^0 rH LO rH [Q < w — u. • in t- _J 1- -0 K + OJ • * 1— UJ ~ * <-t rH _I X O O X * X 0 0 -~ tO >- — ■-' rw * • x 0 ^ * CD u ~ iA — •—• < t- QC * * O O UJ * * 2; a _i * * in «-« Q

» < O ♦ - Qi —-•

rH

in UJ CD OQ *

• • ox -J K 3

• X dl » aJ

H- uj ca — ■N. -» ~- rH * « v v. 0 0 in r- u. O UJ Z >- UJ •-H -^ •** »-^ — ►-• X X X ^ ~ + >0 KH UJ < • -' « — o: X * Q O "v »V -J ^ 10 in < _J — _i UJ ~ tr 0 rH ♦ (S -1 >- _i O rH + + _) 1- _J >- UJ X < _l r-H V,

< o: CC D — 0 o: 1 x a: x TX <t CO O _J (- z Z XX > u »- £ -r UJ > UJ < < * Q cc * UJ UJ < D 3 z> D m üJ 2: cc O Lu 2 £ 3 D D D< ♦ UJ 3 UJ -~ UJ — D t-^ Z> (Oajao* o>o -H _i t- U) tO kO rH D rg< D rH 3 rH D O l/) 1^ </)»/) 00 • CD in 3 ^ 3 * Z D Z UJ UJ D O O 11 < Z H O O u u M Z II _J i- z (1 l/> 00 II II 11 11 1 rH M 11 Z — Z • 1—* O »-^ * Z H N 03 l/) 1-1 UJ n M ^ — -J O rH UJ O O O --* UJ M II 0 _l h- • f~ LO _J uJ —• r\j ►- UJ h- -i 0 O « r a: 0 ^- > _) j- ,-H t-4 UJ 1- ^- > II 11 1- 1- > _l t- *^ •M X X rH II < UJ i~ 3 1- 11 Z Z -J 2: a ü. < D —' Z <3. X. — ^* > z< rg rg Z < 2 X «> M O O II X h- > z - z in O O < < 11 0_l^üLOi0 1>3_li-<OOto_i ►- O O ^ D 3 _J >- UJ UJ X O UJ < 0 U. O (O u u u 0 O ü. O O ** u 13 l/> --O i-O tOtOOVJOOOOUOiA 'S) lO i/) (K CO 'v^ Ü- CD in u — vj Qi

0 0 £1 0 O 0 0 r- 0 i^ rg vn t m ff* »n IT «n m m •n t-« »H .'■* r-> IHI rH rH

u u u

15<)

Page 169: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

^>r>-oo(7>0'H'Mfri-*-(n<oi*-coo>0'-«ivi«o4-iA<or-QOOOiHrvi(»>4'<f>,ö'^<ooOr-i(M<n4-«n>o r*r-f^r^coa>coeo'noo(Ooo<ocoo><>o>^a>o*o^o<><>oooooooooo»-trHr-«»^^^-< OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOr^^ir-t^r^i-«Mr.|r-tr-«i-«i~lf-«»-lHi-i^ r4rgrjf\jr4rM<s<Njr>jrg<>«rgfsiCNjrjr4«Njrgr»i(Nir*j<N»fNj(>irarg<>ic>ir^f>jr\4r»irgrafgr>irgrg«g(>jrg

X O Ji CD * X o

1^ o < 3 t- s: LU X 35 *

*. ^» a ■-•

o <- »-• X to _i * tO tO 0. t- o ^j CL

— X

u •— -» fM * 3 *c X •— ♦ * Q u UJ -~ * « * UJ »- UJ O rv «^ X ^g UJ X ♦ — ■■4 u * >^* — u. * in w ->. < _J ^ #^ X f^ LÜ z «-^ * X f\J o i^ UJ • r) o — o: o * CT> _J O -i N. *-• UJ ÜJ UJ « m PO (T < ♦ -> H* UJ >- 00 O •-* a» •_• N. «I *m «-^ cn »-• < >v D m in 1- to — T iO oo o < m> l- Z o rH l-t rvj ce f- »- oc z in o * u. in X X <7> o« • * -o <f o: I < < i-« -o X 1- <NJ c? ^ in m o * •-<(// r^ o« * 1- h- Q: * r-f • rNl >0 UJ _J ^-« •H o O — * O m m a: i/> »- «*> * *■» • m » ^. 4- ~ a3 a • • * :J x ■♦ •* ^ «n v X oo in l-H 0C (V • — — • « * U) O O r* s: ÜJ >0 » • -• _i * a. in 03 M < ♦ * w ^ * — m x O O • X t- «0 i m nj X —. ÜJ r-t in 3S e>**Q:a:*a:a3* «o <o o 'v fsl • — 0> • i— »-« >- • r-l UJ ÜJ «J _J < < _l< • — f-l ^ o «^ * ♦ to m ♦ a: — < o * >- ~X">~>»->-T»-* -• •— • * »-M -~UJ f- «H UJ —' Hl _l O in < _»OXXl0t0Xt0* ~ t0 Or-I w •-' 3 ÜC • ZJ 1 tu •O 00 ~^ ~) — V X X X »v X «J UJ z o — ÜJ _J ►- - y w fr, X • »^ >- r-« in _i X O _l 1- ♦ * _l ♦ T 3 < ^o — r> o o uj x oo« X r-l

o < a: -^ <-« -J • crxx_ji-x_jx* a: 1-4 « ♦ uj uj < N, IH m m v >- r>~ v to < in ••» U '-UJ OOXXOXWQ: »- — w CK m m o o a ^ *o * m üj i OJ x a LL! O Z üJ z LÜ >- — fMUJüJOCJUJOKDcrUJ — Q£ D ♦ * UJ 3 O ~ mDi- -HD * 3 < ^ D aw -i 3 < D< — Dcpffiujujmiüccx l 3 -• < rH z: x z: z x -J z: • •HX X

ü • Z _l »-Z D o: z cc z -> X Z II II to tO ii x coo o z — »- II 0300X<UJO • X 3 O«-" f^ -* o o »■* o »- «-• ►- »*4 _J -1 K- It tt -J a ua oc H« U h0 Z CC (K CC II M H Q « O O B t0 »-»- ii 1- II II h- 03 CC i- « t- _) t0 _l X X J 1- X _J 11 1! tr »- => X < It N II UJ _l X < H- 11 »-»■- n

Z iO z ^ ■I Z «- z - z-ia-ioooooooo w z — -"orxtotODxuj — IQ: x a: O O CD O -1 >- o ü_ O U- o < O < UJ ÜJ UJ ID UJ UJ X ÖL II.OU.IJ.I-O_I»-2:>-OU. (-»- OH- 1- 19 U Q U O O U ►-« u — u u a »-■ w </> to vo x x u. a •M u N^ IM« IM« ac oc oc x a < — a u 15 « U

o o o m in o f-l N «n * « r- 00 co 00 o» cr> o> o <> lt. m m in in m m m m m

u u

160

Page 170: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

<v«v»v(\i»vi\i»vf\j«v<v<\(\.rg«\/*M»Vf\,r\.«\iv.»Si«>j«v»Si^«vrvfs.t'\f\,*\.*v»v«v.r. «\.rg»v»\jrvfvj»N.

o

O

o o

I/) o < D •- X Ui X 00 * • ~~.

or »-• vD — •*>• X i/) _i • in in a t- o »Ni c — I

X •-• w —

CD

« *

• o o o m ■♦■

tt fsj IU

or < tn K V (C a i~ o

»- < X »- o «n UJ X cc n N ui

»- X X «t o a UJ ►- 00 X

«n o

> O

O

a a o

o a x

I

c c

o a x

l X o

+

in x UJ at IK «-'*J 3 < D

UJ 7 ^- Z •x O I •-•«/) •- • »- VJ »- X ►- « x - z »-- o ou. o

,"* O U *' SJ

a UJ < Z)

«/> « X t-

.-4 •

— a UJ UJ UJ v

< • • et X t- • <M

^» * M at en — « * X o * UJ Ui J >- -1 -> «« _) O x — -)- V J X O _J -j • a: x UJ — UJ o

•-4 Ul >- »• isj Ui ■ D -*. — 3 «D »- X -> K X ■ Z •- -J _i •- ►- J «n J X a z-j a -i o a o< O < UJ

* —

«r rvi <C

^ ITS —

- ♦ — a * a « _J < >--)♦- «r x in X >» x ♦ »- * _iX »- x O x C UJ o Ul CD UJ X • *0 •i t- N -JX ♦- oo o UJ UJ UJ X */) */)

CD

-J B X * O *> UJ <\j cc •

♦- ♦ X * O _J UJ -) e x

-i e CD VO •- X « u.

• o -J i CD X »- V

• — ^ — to UJ

• * • er -J z> ->» x C

■ » o s: X D U ft

• * sn a X X u u

-I -J o o u u tr (Sj x • • • -" XI* D D • » « -J • • -> w o x a S « ft ft a

c S X *

m * ♦ «A • K -J u -> ■ x X ■ a o u

_»o o o Ul -J «o < N. N.. — tO tO ft ft ft ft * w in t- co ft »-< O • 1/5 — * * X -J ft o u. UJ • *n

• u ■ ■

UIUJ 3 I?

_' ft

Nl —

— X — UJ X »- _J Kl lO • a - c — a - • UJ

r>. UJ

• S — c • M

UJ UJ 0 3 1 X tt x

a O to * ■*•

<0 «0 •

UJ o

C C x U. U -N u w O * ♦ D sax 3 r x ft ft M N B _J

«^ «r 1

r- (T

or-

c • ►- I

O to o ►-

a. •w O

• c o o UJ _J

- x — u.

ft ft ft •• «

— « ? • ^• UJ o OnO < ¥- ¥- — I u »- O — ft o

IT

O O o ^

o m

u

itil

Page 171: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

* 4- -♦ * * ^ 4- -* V •» •♦ 4 4 * it •» 4 4 4" •* 4 4 4 -» 4 4 4: ^r (M04(>j(M(M(MiM0iirgr\jrMojoic«rMri4(MojcMiM(ViiMr«iCMr«iM<MrM

4 4 4 4 4 oj «M oj

< ~ a

44444444 <M(M(M(MO|04(Mrg

4

*

Ui Q_l < I VH-

t- * QC -' * -• m — rHD (M «N • UJ

* O LliX 3 a: s: v

os: 3K Z ii X_l II < t- >- XUJ l-X a i-

Q: * —

UJ UJ Z> "s, UJ UJ O 0 I 1 a:

UJ UJ

i2 X * n • < « K- _l UJ UJ X u. »- u

o UJ X

a 3

* o X u. * o

— z — ♦ UJ in

^ « U) • O * X * a o: N. O -I H- -ii Ul i^ *

»~o X * * * rg (»Mj H cou I- •< UJ H H U. _J _l U XI

+ 3 oe. .x

o

o a: Q:

* in (0

O LU X

iT.

0 • 11 * -I * 1 a.

o

Ui UJ UJ UJ

z * < O tr 3 H X <-* X ~ II 14. I- -« X

© X m * • _l

rg x * * — u « u o< O H Oi- »n x

oo N ►-• t~ 10 x - — Ct 03

lO • |

UJ • _l»-« • —

I Z X < II a _J t- x •- < w ui u. >- « <

< x ♦ O — 'O >« V. ~ o *> — ~ OC * r* o <o ••■* '-* « f« O •!■ + tO t- -i -) w O i~ t- O _,i t- OC O u! i/) to o I\J ^ + u o — • — ~ I rg ►-• r« »H • - • II I

^i r^ • rg -') -> — UJ M — — I • _J -> _l H.

X UJ • (/) s/) UJ II _) ift — — 3 »- • U W ■ II Z x ►_ * — -.« < « « ^ -> -> K UJ z V U. U. O _J K o < »-• « Q (/) I/) VJ

in

»fl w

-' -* ir> r-l r-( f». I I •

~) -t * ■ *

_l I- LO t0 10 CD I i -J ~ — tO -»-) I — -^ • -i y~ •-* W) »/> w

• I I oc rg . ^00 H -> "> U U)

"> «- •* N. I • • _l H- • • O O O I/) «/) r-t rH IIN 4^ N n

-IK >o • w _j a. i/)t0O»Hi0i/)i/)</) •-•«II CO CD CD CO II<O-J»-t0H> Q.a<Cii/)i/)u.i/)

>o • m

• m

Cn r-l <o • rt ON

\n ** as — i- <

u. u.

_J _J <

_l <

to CO

to

I/? Si < X

UI (M X *

X o l/!

z o z UI X

• Q UJ oc UJ

z 3 O

o z UJ

z O to « < I- X < -J UJ 3 3 U _l -J < < > u

UJ UJ > X -> t— t—

< z o ►-. UJ

z T K < o>

-' X to <o in to «n • K- <? OtO ~ X • rH

«o —« — K UJ UJ < K K X UI «a: x a o < x u. a:

to to

X X a. a. + + _j »- tO 10 CO CO t0 lO

— U.U. • * ♦

rH I I I 33

** »^ X X a a. i i

* *

o» tO

— 03

X3 UI UJ >- >- << I i

»- 3 -)

10

<

vO f- CO CO !*> <*> <o <o «o

• Q UJ X 3 «/) t0 N < H-

•H 10 iO ■ CD < < »O 3t < U. rg

O» en

3! X UJ UI >- >- < < I I

UJ UJ «• w w at x < < UJ UJ UJ 3 >. >. n « z « < -j i- -< ii n tOlO I- _J H-

II OI I aa u a Q.

o 4 <6

162

Page 172: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

OOOOOOOOOO^»-i»-«»H^^^ii-i^«<M<\ir1(<MfM0ifgr. <Mrgcf»fHf<^crim<nfn(nfnft\4-4-

^fg«>jrjrgr»jc>/{Ni(>jcaPa«Nl«>irgr*iMc^(>jAi<N^carMCJCjfMi><r^r^rarvir^rjr>irs»r^r^r^(\i<>j<>i<>i

r4r4rgc4<>i(><NrgrsjrgriiC4r4rgrMr4rgr4<>ir>l(>l^Ni>irilNf^oj(>j(>ir4r4ct4(>jr>ir\icsirsif>4r\4rsioj

fo cn

0 o if» «f» t*» ci nl (Nl • • v. "s. ^ ^ *» *» Ci o *» — o o »-••-• m if« «- -» eg f\j X 3e -^ 'v UJ UJ > >- < < _ >- II _i >- at a -m >— iii UJ 1 X >- >- a a < < + + l i _» ►- _i t- » J« » 3C < < < < UJ UJ UJ UJ

o

o oo

< *

UJ -J D I Z I)

z o o o u o o >f

< < < * * _J H- X X H II o o

I- o u. co UJ ^)

O CK »H UJ 11 - D ^ "v a z

o o <o UJ rl O

Z ►-* O O '^

I- W *S) X T. >- t- H I-»- o-'-'HH-za: z Cl-JK- -Jt-U-Ol-OO OOOII-iU'-'OU

z UJ

UJ u. X u. »- UJ

o o u z •-• z z o < 1- t- u

O oc u. a: x o z o Ü. -« _•

V u.

z •- O Q Z -■ Z UJ >- < _J < 3 -I I- H D z Q: U üJ D _l « H- < "-• \j ** a

U. Z UJ u. < X u H- o a

u < to z ui a: *-• H- UJ x UJ u. < _i ^ _i

üx o a: »- u »- o & t- -• < oe X UJ o t- X ÜL

to UJ D O UJ cc

UJ X

— / UJ

z <

> o co to < K

z UJ >-< I o ►-OL

iD K Z D ►-. O z >-• K < Z ►- •-• 03 ÜC o a

o o CO

— UJ - < ~- — UJ

_ „ 2; _»l c. -~ — ~ O 33_Jt- O-JH-uJ • <<xx a x ac ui ~ lUUJOC3i—~»<<-<OiO -~ «">J >>_UJUJ_J»- — (iiaj<XK — -»-J i <<(IlCDUJUJfMUJUJ «U.U--lt— T-" — • • * • U. ix. I •••—•••XXXZ — lOtOtOJluU—•t0t0rsl>> • • »XuJ _lh-_J»- • • — _l»-| <<^JuJ> •< »3c>cxiOto-«a:at->i/)^o> > si >o <<3 0-J»-O<<—C3t0<<_Ji0uJ >->-uJUJUJujO(Da3ujxx^to->zs <<CQCQU.Ü.auJUJUJXÜ It-XXO • •••(j^J ••••-1 ••XX • • ♦ • , < • • ^^v^~-~^^:i<: » *c v ■ ^ ^ ^

oooo ooo^oo — 000 aaaaooaaa—Q.Q.ooa.aa xxxxaaxxxoxxaaxxx

«/) ••••xx»»»a.»»xx»»» »_ •• x ».

O M, « « »- cEQiaor — — Q:cca:>->a:a: — —0:0:0: z <<<<Q:QC<<< — <<Q:a:<<<

ac totototo»->-ioi/)</)<i/)to>—t-tototo a xxxxio^xxxt-xxio^5<xx

• •• • x X • ••v/)»«XX» •• ^o: — ••« x ••• OO oj<Nf>J(>J—• — (MiNrg •<Mfs(—.—ojrgrvi I^U. I I I I CM rvi I 1 1 ~ 1 | (M rg I I I ,-t >X|_<I-|>-I| j « »^ _ fvj _ _ j I ^« ^_ _ • o «„« 1 «« miu Q:oca:Q:>- — ocarQ:"-Q:a:~ — oitrct WQ <<<<a:a:<<<—<<aro:<<< r-uj ►-►-»-►-<<K>-i-a:H-h-<<t-t-t~ r-iUJ i/)t0t0t0»-'»-i/)i/)t0<</)tOl-H-i0tOt0 •Z XXXX^iOXXKKXXintOXXX

,H —-' KX-— — tO XX oz aao-a. — —aaaxaa aaa r-O ocoiQcoiCLa.acocQi'^acoca.u.oca.o: i-»«-» h-K I— I— QCClth->-i~a*— I— QJOil— H-H- -~K zzzz(->-zzzae:zz»-»-zzz Q.«t 1—«MH^-^^-^ZZ,,,-,►^l-'^■-'-,^"«ZZ>-,l—«•-•

UJCtJUJU.U.U.U.'-'-iULlLU.ZU.U--' — U.U.U. 3 LÜ O D M N M M U. UL M « B — « IIU.U.N II n zi-a.z»-i-i->-ttii>-(-h-u.i-KMH »- -•zo: — ji-zzt-t-z_j»-iizzH-i~»-i-z I- — UJ»-»»«-«_lh--'üCQiX^ — zzzzo Z — I-Z<<-J»-UJUJQ<<K-Ot0—-'J—Ul Ou.zo>-vooü.u.oooa)zxx-ji-">zx U««(j<<CQCD«JUQUJUJUJU.U.IXXXO

o •-• o o

UUUUUUUU«J u

1 iVA

Page 173: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

OK»» ^•ift<0l*-(5>OOi-<(N!r>4,iA>Ofs-00OO.-<<Mt'>«*'»n>Or-00OO«H<M<n-4-<Av0f*-00OOt-lf>l

«>I(M «>|racijr^f>jpgf>jr^(>jrsj(\jrgf>jr>|(\irsir^f^f\irai>lMf>4r<lry|rsjr>irjr*ir>irjc^c»i(NirNir>ic>j(Ni<Ni

z _l t- '3 ijj UJ UJ u. u. X u o o * » * h- *- t- _J (- r h- t- i—t o o UJ -> a H- a o r>l • •> * i- t-

»- o o Z <S) CO

J w LU «-^ «# ~v0 « I — X Q£CL — Q£ _»►-•- X—^ UJ <0-JH-000 <i<»*.-.uJ_lt-~H- OQ-t-t-LOifla: — -^»-i ••-••-■VXKO N — UJ»00'-«'-' •OiOUJliJfM^^^tOO^ «QC

OfMCSOOOf^Q:o:t->-'-«H-3 — xxxrMM « -•-< • |**<k»|«»*«>>^*»(\j***|» 3J _J (— t—

to—• io^)'^io>-«>>i/)toio — —ii/)in>-.> »- ooz a:—_J^OO — <<_i»-<rs4f\j—_jf--^~< • ••-< OXh-l-OliT;— ^lOf-t-K-ll— XXOX^J t- ^-K-^ iij_ioo->'-'CCO^LuuJUJ-<-«3:ocjauja; z zzac ZiooQ_j»-OQ:Q:xxi>'~ujioiiJXt-t- -■ « — o: OCL o300Q:Q:Q:>~(-i-3üj>-xxxiNjt>i o: -IH-* • O ••••••••». •h-3<«»-»»«. O XIi-

-»r^ ^« — —,»»-»—.^.^»^.—.»••.^.^H»»—.—. 3J «eZ

.^»«.•^~»>-.« —»-—.-, — ^^^-j^w — w.»,—. i— -JKO O^OOOOOOOOOO OOOOO Z Q£ a a a~-acLCLacLQ.Q.aaQ.oooaQ.a.a.Q. « < < x. xo xxxxxxxxxxaaaxxxxx o coaa» •a ••••••• »••xxx»*»»» o üJLüt—

— X •—"*'- — — ->•-» — •••ä.-»«.»^. -«— Q »»Z -< «•_-<.*.-.t-i1-.^_. ■_■_•—..~.~,™,_.-<.-.~. > > • t— H- >-• O

Q£I-I a:a:Q:a:Q£Q:oiQ:Qca: — -''-'a:Q:a:QtQi xxo -J»-« x •-4

<—<<<<<<<<<<Q:a:a:<<<<< sza ->zu. • KÜi *-»-l— l-t-h->-»-»-K<<<f-»~l-t-t- •»UJ xx» o i/x i/)»/)v/)i/)iOL0ioiy)i/)u)i—t-i—»/)</>i/)t/)i/') QL a 3 • • K ■* X»- XXXXXXXXXXiO(/5iOXXXXX «^ »«•«-«• »-»-z f^ • io •»••••»«»»xxx»»»»» o »»_i -j t- «^ H —x ■"> »»» —^«^-.— r^ irt 3:3CJ • CM»fM«\i(MfMfM(M(Nfsirgfvj— -""—■ojrvjfvjfNioj r^ i^^Q. <<>; "• O l<->llilllllll<MrsjrM|l||l • a. J-Vü. — O -O

w.|w — ~.~.~^ «1-!«—.www«. 04 Q-Q.^ ••^H--* O >-« □:•-• ocaocceQiacKQicsia: — ac tx. ae. oe. oc r- xx^ t-n-zt-« •-• — <—<<<<<<<<<<a:Q:a:<<<<< •-« ••— JKOUJM • — Küi »-»-»-►-f-t-f-t-t-t-<<<H-K-t->-t- • XXO XXZJXrH o ^

XH- XXXXXXXXXXi^(/)i/)XXXXX <N l/)f-X UJaJX^O t*- O ^ifl — «.«- — — w — ^-^^xxx^^- — — »'•h- XlU xx»t-<-< -* Q- aXQLCLa.a.aacLQ.aa — aaao. o.'-t^ — ••— ••!»_!_ • x a—Qjococüfacaaacaaaa.aocQccKafK'f— o xxo t~^zt->* o i ►-a s-H-t-»-h->-(-f-H-»-(xaa:»"h-^-^-KH-« o —«•©•zz—'uj^ «^ — za z z z z z z z z z r »-t-»-z z z z z z o* M Q-Q. * X-«»-'a: X O P* -• •-i^—•^►-•►-•►-«•-«»-(•-•■^«-II^ZZZ"^'"«»^»-«-'Ol "O Jj'Oh-J^ ^H~X ""^ "^ U.Zii. U-U-U-U-U-U-U-U-U.« "-►^U.ii.U.li.U.O'-t-l • «llJCDcD »ZOONI •■-' O'-'UJQ: «•-i« N H It H n It II • HU.U.U.H H M H •UZ3«O»-«3»->-«OUJCQC0 »I l11k.D< t-U. »-t- »->-*-t-K>-l-l-K MHK-f-KKHIlDZ— »ZBH—X»»»-«^»- Ü-^ZK a:« _J»-OOZZZ_IH.ZH-UJXJ»-ZZZK'0-'UJh-«OOUi •OOZO<'-<a l—W) o_j>-»-u)i^»-«'-t>-«»-H-i/)Z(3i-xxo-«,-,zu(-KZH-aa »-ia.a.^üjx + UJV:K-X uj«/)OO'-,,-'QiO>/)UiUJa0'-iOzoc33ujQ:D — z•-•^Z•-'<^=<^-•^<so^:a:^^-"Z^ J:a QQ_iH-oaa:xxxxujujujujxt-H-ou.oacoo*ot-ürztot-xoo M ZU.OU. O0. ooc5Oa:Q:0£^-^-^-^-^»xxxMNlu•-'U»uuxuJxuJXllJ^-*u-^-•>-, «^•-

r-l (M CO •* lA rg o O O o M O tn r- ^- 4- r- •-< t-i ^) •-•

U

164

Page 174: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

00eO00e0a0e000O^O>a>0»ai0>0«0»0»0>OOCOOOOOOOi-lr-4»^«-«^41-«r-«r-lr-«rH'>4fS|{>J<\l<\J

^>i^v|r>J^4f4(^J{^J<^|rgf^J^f^fgr^JNrJ^^^(^lrlJ^^f^Jf^^^4^gf^|pgf^JCJ^JpJf^^r^J^^^g^a<^|(\|^|f^J<^|r^J

isl

3: at UJ 1— U. U. * U U

*•*» * * ** J »- •^ h- t- »-• O O c: O Q 0 3 O cc •M «

•• O O *-* 10 (/) l-m •■^ *-« _i ^ -J ►- < t—• O O > Q * * ac O _J 1- «n UJ Q X I >o h- * * • t" z

<t «•«, _l 1- rH —• 0 »-4

»-< < < I/) -1 U.

t- ÜJ 00 CO OC 00 < D uj uj a: 0 -1 * m m m -t Q O .•• -1 O • Z a 1-4 T z o: r-1 UI (X «-> X X fK O ÜJ X * * * * O H- K fM _l — _| ►- to r-l U. z >f l^ -• 3 3E X — UJ •-> 0 to r- a — < < u. — _l

<f UJ <-< 0 ": tu uj • Ü OC r- u * a UJ >- > 0 0 ~- 1- O r-« -1 0 * >- < < X t- 0 0 < u. * < in .*••» < • • u. < 0 a

in > r^ ^ • _J >- • »- rH X tO UJ O f^ *». ^- X X O UJ •> 1 UJ > f~ H- » 0 -« O O D X O x >- < t-i Z 0 a - ui UJ 2: »- O 0 ►- i/) * UJ m X UJ X X X • h- ♦ —

O OC • f- UI • • • _1 rH • h- Q ■* at. r-t rH -~ *** -• _J »- a: < * rg Z _i K Z r» D + — 0 0 < X X t- h- O + < 3t S _l 1- J 1- < t-> u t- • 0 0 • G 3 rsi Ul <o -> 3 < < X X (X. OC —• Z 0^ eg 4" — U! U) • X c* <-« 3 UJUJOO _l»-<<3tO (- h- ^- D 1 0 >o -' CD 3Q '- t- r-l <w >->-UJUJujuJa3coxx D LÜ Z D aj O H- (jj • • UJ • w * » j—# •. 0 »» ujQ:_juj<<a3cou.u.uJujULU. O 3-« O ^U Z D «O I-«3<OUJ — '~ — n: 11 a. 3 < -J 3 II II 11 II U W II II U II

z a: Z M D Z •w M Z- < ^, « to < l-^ZI-<ZlOlOlOi/)M Ml/)lO>> t- -•Q. »— •-< 1- O «—« UJ l—>-iüJO — — <0 rH Z 1 — <A >-« _J»-_ll-tOi/).J»-<< Z t- — i:! f-ZUH-t-ZKt-UJXXKUJ ■>- 1-^ ^i-xuii-33:xx_j»-Q:a:toto ** Z — •-• Z D - Z I-* D Z — J: -• < tu 2 ^ a — Z — >Z<<3OUJUJ<<3t0 OC 0 u. a OOU.OQJOOO'OlOt-XO II au.ou.<o>-vujuJu.u.cDaDxx a U M a U U •"" U S U U 3 • x ui (- • i«; ►-• •^4 U^lOU<<a3cQUUUIUJü.U.

r-i IM m ■* in m O rg O 0 m «*\ •* 4 m •0 <o 1- r~ r~ f- r- f»

OC < _l

_J 01- x ui o

i- _i xa 11 x -> 00

11 x z 11 II LÜ ui 11 x to lO to > > > 11 a; -J t- < < 1/) > o I- •- tO ifl _l tO UJ o -I h- T Z XQ X X X X 03

O a 3 H

O O 3

U U U

16i

Page 175: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

r\ir4NNrvim(*tm(^mm(nrtmfn<?.«'4>^*4''t'<*'4''4,,niA<niniftintninii\«<><o<o<0'0'a<o

rstrsir4r4r4r>4r\|ogf\i)>joir\irsirtiNrijrvrsi(>i<\i(>irv(>i(V<>i(>i(>ioir-r<ir>j(>ir\joi(>ir>ir«(>4(M(>|(><

X 10 "**

_l < ^o UJ ♦- a Ui UJ at: *

x o "• 2: a. — a a < t- z * — r-< * • m m * «^ 0 -H ». ^. *» M, •~ O »n w

^i r- r- r^ ao in •s- X ^ «n w «> f~ «^ *

r>j r* rg — X —. «v 0 UJ >- t-H

00 10 in

ri n 11 i/> v/) > o o< I/) i-O m

_ii-a: OOQ:

< < (/j Ui LU ail o: t- >-

11 11 11 > 10 1/) < _i 1- 1/) 1— ►- ^ UJ u air o: H- 1-

_i 1- X X o o UJ UJ X X II II

_l t- X X o o UJ UJ X X

o rxr z. t- X Nl II II > > 10 < O 1/) Da 2: >- X rj

UJ *

II

X

a UJ a a: D U u o

10 <n z z < < oc at I- H X I — ^ O fM o •

o >o I O UJ •> rH ^ Z> vO —

Z w ►- z o •-> LU < a I- H- K S D

z -• a H- o o a o uj o u 3 u. cc

o o o o O r*

lA •-• •»»

~ o -« >- a uj a: — x •-« < o • o o en >- • -~ o UJ—iOiOS — OQ aDxa:x>-oin • • ••»•inr- —

«noroenxo — r-< t^ r- r» _i o O — ■-< r~ o 1/» Q uj ui

— -na • 2; < Q O — O • <-« <<<<<ao*'~ ^, w»- — » ^n „ <-( < « h- •-< -H

• m 10 — u. ~ r-<aO o ui — »- »> u.

— O -J < KuJ'-» 00 x «o <l^-.

ÜUJr-i O OUJ l-h-^tt-» UtOrH UJ OXUJtO»«-»-« UJ — UJflQlQOI5X~»- — CiuJ<tJ«**»» O D

Z>.Z — -"^Zinz » «OUJininr^r-r^or~o~ J-V_J r-ieooooo»--««-!-!,-! DZ< ON4-O>l0UJl0rH

-•oo> moz<z~' oas-" ujioujto

QUJCD23— — ~ XUJXcO ZCD300<<<<<«-<Z-.x UJ lOUUJ»''^ OOQl-

U. 03

en • O

r- • in r*

11 11 z « < _J •- x Q 3 < UJ CC OJ

r-« — II 2

—I h- H- II X — O "* UJ — CD »-

— UJ — — to •-I < r-< i-l — < «. O " " •-< »- X UJ "-••-• — UJ

X o a o: 1 O < 1- 0£ I- M Ml/)'» -» X f-« t-4 II —

10 O O a 11 o 0 ~ 11 Q. r-« -. 11 " iH .-. ^) w w .« (/) r-t uj o a: »-i ao — s: o o - 1 01 o o o: x >~

166

Page 176: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

^o^-so(^o^^^^f,^■*>A^^-coo>o-*<^J<*^■*■in^)^-oo!>o•^t^^(«>4■^f»4>^-oo<y■• D-^INC»^ ^•or^-

r-tUi W l--#

LU < D « II -~

o<

UJ I/) < <

— O t~

■— f-t -~ J" r-l r-l X ~0 y-

— _j — — Q a: -~ a: iO UJ rg o o <N < a uj — Ci oe — (_ O •- OJ I I cO i/;a-~ — <<•«-«•< X I r-i M I O rvj f\» i—

— tMSUJ'Mjr.ii-iX CM — »-^«OQirf- — K I I UJ — O O — ct-i^ — ujiOQo:*

f-Q. <+*♦ + m o: L0O3UJ — —-jiai-« • UJ XQ.»-3*^-t++i-!

i-t t- r-l ww — — CD—-»** —

oc *• CDOQlOtn — UJ t) uj »eg +♦•»» + '-*£ Qa;x »-••n '~-~ — — — oooi— t-lOO'-' ^Hl-Hr-lr-tUJIIOQill

rH^-t wwww<—.1(11 — ON,XO irixQ.t-3ii»-« — — « OX •0'-<# II M « II ^«w raQi-ii-H I X~ — — —— O' i/)

ii ii ~4to-«'-«-«>-> — ujQa:oo oxxoii II— — ujsrooi CiOa30a3ajxaH-D<ocia:(-

X X X • o Q —. o

a: * * <n * u X K •• X > Q n X 3 < _l _i a _! • UJ uj * UJ

a: Q Q V 3 •— Q Q o 3 rsl «■ * _< • * j-k «■» UJ IT*.

(£ 4- .^ 3 ■-I

Z3 + + 3 + X •—1 •—• at ►-*

O *_r -— —^ «■»

x O 3 OJ 3 A o O + O

a: Q o •—■ 3 < * * <^ • o —. -^ a _ -U CO OJ o «—■

X + ■t- 3 — o ~i -^ * 3 • •^ ■u- .M O 1 d 3 r-l

< O O + * J O ^v -^ —^ aJ * • ■ ^H

5' » — 3 1 •~ O fNJ rH O ►-.

i * + + 3 — < -* »-■ k-« m 3

— O •-• — — • O bT UJ ~- Q o o 3 < Z o O o » • O O UJ a 3 — —

~ UJ • l-L * * •-I rg 3: s: i O — 1 1 LU O t- «• *-* M O —• >- •• NJ in + JJ — ■M

< tO • < •-• a rsj 3 O • (— —. 15 o o ■-t O o ~ rg ~. aJ m Q o • 3 3 1-4 * ^« X UJ (■■j O • O • • a. o > r-l i-j -~ »n ~ M.

Q. »-^ * •> •-^ ♦ * l-i !M <\j en • — 3 -* h- o -^ 1 r-H 1 1

-~Q. U »—< < (M *-H »-4 * »—• *-••>- — > rg »- — o ^ w

rH — X < a N^ ■-< Q 3 ■* 3 3 ^H (— — — — o: • O O <M O O • — < < X UJ o o Q f-l 3 3 ^ _j o a D Q r-( w o — O ^» — o — II _J UJ IU >" <M > r^ > r- > r- >

UJ « < z: 5: a: < UJ i-t UJ oc fNJ LUD: f^j -U iu cr r^ UJ a: D 3B o o o t— 3 •<• 3 LU r-l 3UJ r-l 3 O 3 LU r-l 3 -U z O ►-• i/) CO cc _l Z (NJ Z 3 ZQ Z r-t z a *— 3 —4 o -•-. UJ —< 1 »-4 o ^H O —• 1 —4 o •—i

r- 0«\J -I _J _l -j Q: Q h- i—< K _l t- t- _l (— 1— —• »- -I t~ »— _J z II _J _I _l _J o z — Z _J Z -1 Z — z -J z _J o 15 O < < < < 1—4 o U. o < o o< o o U- o < o o < u Z Q U U U u to u •-• u u o uu e) u IX V.' u o u 'O

.-< o o o o o o o o o r-l (N tn 4- m r-i

1-4

(NJ ft

fM r-i

rsi r-i

IN i-i r-i

u

167

Page 177: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

rgoir\jr4r^r4r4(>l<>iNNNr4r4ry|i>iNr>i(Ni<^rgf>irsir4(>i^^if>j(>j(siry(>i(>iNtNriJNr\IN(>iN

rvioic\4r4NrMr4r>if>ir>tr4NC>iNr4r4i>ic4rvi^NCiirvir><r4i>jr4NivryfrNiNr4riifvi(>J(>JC>iri|Cij(>i

X Q * X Q _J UJ a

o < *

<

o

<

t—1 0 UJ

3 i: 0 0 *^ Q 4« (— * «M ce — f—• <

CM «« -~a3 1 0 a _l ÜJ

►-• rg IS) » oc * — <n cc u < fVJ

G O »H UI a CO • O r«J »— X UJ --i Q «O O UJ UI ♦ — • rH t— 5: * • *

— ■— < cc fM*

n O

OOO OI-^O ^. 1 a:

< 0 •—• * '-

«—• rg rg rf\ •-< »^ a 0 * — — Tl m 0 »-< ~ -' Q * — u. O rH ■-« C3 •-« -~ l^ < UJ X « 0 O X O O >-• a> ce U • — u. a OQ O- •- • — X ^v z _l »■• u. * m i- -J ►- m tO V*. *** t- _1 < ^ «-^ O CM f^ — U) OO • ao • ^ * -« cO H- UJ — u. • tn

■* OQ O • O Ul X r* X — i/. H- m >- a ♦ ^-« »H | OQ O -» H J i Z — X Ul fNJ •-■ < O (M ♦ • »—• * • -^ • * 2 - X • 1 I ♦ Q • a: * * (\J *- — .» —. IÜ O '— x a. N. r-l — •- ♦ 3 \ * ~ in Q ^« • _i a» -~ • — X • 1 a — a l- UJ r~ ^ •-« r-«

O 0 • • • •-* * UJ f» z x m > Z > -» »-. •-• »-^ *- • Q • Q f-« <-> 1 z ♦ 1 X U4 0 * UI < »- -" w w ft rH

O — LÜ O • ~ • l O t-t 0 z X .* O • — » U m _J a: — Q a O m r- > -IQ (- Z (- z tf> w r- X * & -O rH* J" * • < IT < Q 0 0 a ^t fMUJ OC UJ • v. Ul _J X -J X CMU UI «n ui — • r-i O UJ — • OS Ui — 1 UJ > < OQ * Q ct ♦ --> Ui <-<^ Ul 3 «• D • «- • w f-( 3 • < fH o 11 (f) • r-l 3 II fO r-l n - I D h-4 03 ui a: n * O r-l u

z 0 ZQ: — r U) SI 2 O II Z _J >. 1 Z J -^ • z — 11 Z 3 U) • 3 —» O H 1 Z 0« N-* Q. — »—• Z 03 Z CQ O -^ 11 -1 0 •—t 10 • II O M« fcO • II »—1 O -1 MH O -IX >-. 11 cß O •-• t- 1- -J »- Z X >- X < X < 1- t- *i IS) *- ►- »- (M ^ ►- ►- i- r<4 ^ 1- <A 1- UJ _l Oi O w. x a: z •- rn

Z -1 z — M z «,«.■_ w Z a ui Z uJ II Q. z uj 11 a. z tt Ui Z -i < a: u. < D — Z 1: 0 0 < OU,ZOU.Ü. U.U. OO X > O O X ^XOOIWXOQ.>-0 < CO 11 O _J K U. O O ou u w -• X u •-« 1—t «-^ »-^ a u UJ < 0 U f- XUJOUH-XUJU><U u Ul O U. O O >-• i_; z

0 0 0 O O 0 0 0 rH

<o r- 0 tM >t m 0 r- tn fNJ CvJ t^ tn m <n to <n r-t

r-« r-t f-l r-4 1-« r-t r-l rH

u u u

168

Page 178: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

4'inAu>tninin«ntntn«n«««<o«4«4>4><or~r>r^f>-r>-r-r>»r>-r<>r^(nao3>a>eo<»»a}co(not

X O

X o

i^ a Q. J: O UJ

I a »- » • •

-*. «-« o« .n OJO »—i rg ^M

X — — w

UJ

X!

» * *

X U. o ^ z

■— 1-) a *-* a ~flD ^ UJ K- a o -j

xa to LO m _j a X aJ < D LJ Z Z < a a: > -I 1- o o < * » * • OO _i ••-« •-^ «^ ^^. ^^ ^^ + + < K- Q CO c^ in rg (\i OJ > -h •—• < r-* ^ n -J H- »-• uJ O QC tD CJ 1- o Cl_ z • * ♦ X UJ >- o a ~ • • *• 3 IE i— J U o w •^— -— —

<t -t -~ —■ UJ «. u <-( < < < < + + ~ *« m -i * -J <f «_ ^ ^ ^^ — *-^ t-i 0-* »-• -' • < 1-4 < * <

•-• 1— _l f- ■»^ X •-• ^^ _J _i •-t • • *■ • _J X o o X * _J H- 1— 1/) * X o -^ -■* ♦ CO X — _l »—1 Q. ^. ^. « ^» ^» O uJ * * x a: O Z < z • o aJ (O • • < D UJ -< _ „ CE o 00 * <n n _l 1- 03 X »- V vO L^ LL ♦ — X N. o e> ~ co ^ z LO ~ •-I I rfT «cT _J -• X X X — ~ -J h- ♦-• •-^ o -. U t-4 UJ O r—* ^ *-< »—« UJ X ♦ Q O v» •s. X X _J t— r-« •> X LU t— u — aJ < a o > * OD + + _J K- o o X X o o o Q UJ < ■u. < u «t •>> * * X IX o CD o _J t- X X IE UJ UJ o o >o x *m, * z _1 "v z « „, ^^ ^^ < D vO UJ T oc O UJ X X D U Ui X a: uj ID CD uj UJ UJ UJ • 1-1 •v m *-• CD 3 UJ rH OD rM r^

-J K 1-1 D < D (NJ D ID D i/) CO 13 < D 3 II N D 03 CO OO" 'S. + _l »- u N, ■«s _J rH fv/ f-l

O O 2 -J i- z lO Wl II II z -J K- Z •-• —4 z II II z — t- in UJ z < -) i Z z < il M o •—• ooo <-• II II -J H- •-f o o •-« -J t- •— _J h- •-• UJ < • • a *-* r> «r o o > _J »- i— *- pg H H t- 1- •^ -J h- X X 1- II II t- X X ♦- X X H- h- X (M l-t 3 1- c^ u X X 3: x Z. H fNi IN z H Z X o o z 1-4 •H z o o z o o z «-• oc <-» It 1- Q Z D X X J3 —■ W* ^, — 3 3 0 00_/l-000D3iiJUJ0 -J 1- O UJ UJ O UJ UJ o a: o LU X UJ z D o o O < < <T < v^ lO O U zooauzto^cnmu O O U CD CD U CD QD yj 3 U. * Q a: UJ ID u u UJ

.-) W .—i rw ri <f fM r<> o o o o o *- m m vO o o »-« 1-1 Ü. ^» H 1-1 rg CO tn o

o OD 1—•

u VJ (ft u

l(j!>

Page 179: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

0»C7>O0><7>0>0>0»OOOOOOOOOOO'^«^'H'^'^»-«»^»-««^'^«MIMr^rM<VfM<Mri<r4<venc»l

rgrvjrgrgrsirgrsirjrsitNirs:.. jrj{V(Nirs»eNiPgr\»f\joi(\jrviPgr>jfjfsiNr>if^f^r>jrsic^r^(Nj^ O^ ^ ^ C^ ^* ^ O ^ ^ O^ O* ^o^O^O^^O^^O^ 0^0*^0*0*0^0^0* O* 0*(^0*0*0*0*(^-0*0*0*0*0*0'

r*lNr^rarsir4r^r4rsirir4r*trsir*iN^rsir*ir\|r>j(MCMN<>Jr*ir*ti\ir4r*tr>ic\4Nr4CNjNr\t(Nirgr*j(>iri|

-I

>

z X

•» < a * X I UJ yj I— < «* • 0 a. X _i cc UJ

> (NJ u. » r\j z ►- •> -* M oi

— (M (N «~ u a rg LU O. * — r\( « 1—« r*j -~ • * >- _i s: ♦ ü. * UJ z * a u ♦ < iO ai _i 5: rH >- 0 * 2: ►- _J eg * Q.

^t »- UJ UJ rg < I/) ^. LU Z UJ * u. I-« V _i - > ►- 1-4 '-> — * X h- 0 > * z -1 U.

—• • K- ♦ ♦ *-4 (NJ » t- ►-i U * I/) * X Ü. * z -~ at m • * O cc UJ < • • m u (- ^ —1

JO 0 • >o -I ♦ O 0 > •^ -O t- • < U) 0 Q. lU <*\ I/) + ^H UJ _l O iS) < U • rl -1 + u * Q. >0 U. * z • ♦ a 1- z UJ 0 * ~» -• o> r- < a. 1—< u — * z u. Z O I S: 'H z > m ir> 1— z ■* ^ - s: z z z 0 Q. Z 3 rg u Lü >- 3 * o* <\t z 0 v ~ l/) UJ O •-■ 0 r- »- « t- • < ^ -s. H- m m rr\ UJ 10 _i ^ i~ 0 1- W7 a u * 10 a

O UJ * * Ü. O UJ • 1 UJ 0) m UJ Z UJ V.UJ Ü. O X UJ s * VUJ * UJ X < 0 UJ a. O Q r-« D • • Z <f Q r> 1 -• 3 • r*J D O D -J > Z in 0 3 f- • -J D r- 3 u i- «0 D 11 a. Z >- z 0* 0 •-• z zx uj z II Z tO Z UJ — -< M Z < OUJ Z • Z < »^ »- Z U. II «- O — •♦ O 0- O •—« •-« 11 >■ 1—• ^ O « •—1 > n a O _J M O > — 11 »-* II 0 »-4 Z -J 38 »- 1- II O II t— s h- — < H- —1 »- t- _J K- 1; Q. II 1— u. 1- _) O 11 h- u l— Z _J 1- h- -• m

z _J>O 0 z UJ — z z Z -J z z s: 0 Z -I *0 X z z z I -1 z a a. O O ÜJ H IO OVU.OOOO< 0 O Ul X O 0 < II UO »^ 0 u < 0 000 0 L> > i cc e? u <t •-• U */) 0 u u u < t- a: 0 U U X < u 0 u < u 0 u a. a.

0 0 l-< (M f^ 0 0 0 0 r-l rvj CM rg rg n ■4- m gj

uu u u u u u

170

Page 180: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

fM«'i-»ift>or-a>(7>o-«r*j<«>'*iA>ot*-ooa»o«-«'M<T»^<n>cr-ajoO'Hr«*t*>-»invor~tooi»0'-«iMO (timmmt^nmrt-t-f-t-t-f* •t-t4t't>f\it\u\it\ix\<t\a\ie\ie\it\-o •o«o^)-o>o^>^o>o<»r~r~r~-r-

r4r4rg^r4^r^rgr4ryir4r4NNf>ir4r>i(>ir4r4rgrsjr\jc>it>t^ir>ir>ir4<>if>i(>irsjr4rsj(>ir>j(VP>jrijr>jrii X X

a

z • •-• (M Q. ^ O fNi a. *

-i -I i/iUJ

u-a > z ■* * a. -ia K m a. wio. 2:

o UJ a O ■-• oo D M a. a

z u. ii u o — za a. I- H- .-• UL u.

z a z z o O O '^ *** o u a a o

o r-

CL a

Z Z UJ

a o z H —• U. I- z z

« « o a o u

o oo

z

>- _l

-«a i- u >^ -J oo x _ia. • UJX

U. >^) Z I - -• a> x a. «co OX» a -s-u. • N^Z -I >V« iO uiO Q. tOX o < -t 0. u » • X

u. X ao Z «n • « »u. 3 &Z • <« —

u. »a >. z XV — a: -* x a o • »n • u. x •

a. co (M 2 tO • r-l JJ Z U. UJ »- oz o»

•> >^ •-• • X I-*- X • •-• X ^

o -*■ V Z » v O x UJ u <r o

• 3 -IV»- <a —

U- UJ

u. ac z -1 -J *-i KJ UJ

x a a > m » * *

*-» «—^ ^^ ■-«»

iTl ao m i-«

r-» r-t f\J CO

a: o

< ~

a: -> f- x

• _J -~

x u < *

UJ >

to a UJ

z <

<

< < < <

OH- U. 3 U. Ü. UJ UJ UJ z a v o: — 3 < x o l-

4- !>- »H (> ^i rg pg

a:

X. O

o txj >. o

o — wo — V -I < < < < < w «www • <

UJ I- < a —x >■ Zi- »- «z Z XUI ~ (OX O fM CO (N • • o OX vO X 00 » r-« •

>o ~-I i — t- u UJ << •- XX — ax cc o ■* at UL •

o rg o

< X oo * X

* u. z

o a x *

eg

to a

OS

v; UJ z u a o UJ u o UJ^

z -I

I- V oz oo

u. a X O UJ oa x z a: D o .u to u

u t- u. CQ »-•

o o

w UJ < < u • v z - O UJ r-t V, _l z < o > X - X o - o o < U UJ —

u. _l UJ vo a a. a x -i

O O I UJ x a. a >

-O O -4 (SI -^ rg rg to

< < < < rg to ■♦ m

O n to < UJ no

3 UJ 5- «f * -J ;/) a o a. * u. UJ a: 3

3 O UJ X o

isj

UJ

UJ —

X */) o o • UJ

UJ X y-O ^g « • to

_i I- t0 r>| a « O _i a v/) • a

UJ o UJQ. >- • < X

• ac 3 O '3 — UJ tO X • o -■:

lil ^g 0

X * • -J

o ~> D X X * X _J • ^J -J > -5 * a x O D a. 5: • o x a

ui a -

UJ cc

< o to *

a: m O ^g LLI • • >-

■3

3 O

>- X < o

-J <

< < oo UJ UJ X X oo tO tO

-1 -J -J _l < <

X ♦ o — VJ u. U UJ < QC

m

o

3 u V <

_J _1 .J

< <

I i a:

II _J O UJ X >

O iu

a <

X

< * • a II

IT X

<

o u u

171

Page 181: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

r>r>i^r>r*-r>-aooo0a9eocoao<Da>9oo«»o«o>o«ok(>O'OO>oooooooooO'H'4r4^^

0«0i9i0kOO<7'O9>9«OO0^(^0>9>OO(^Ch^0'9>Ch0^9><T'C7>9>9>0>O0k(^9>l^^^^9*(?k

*-*4***-t*-*-*-**-#*4***4**4*<t**<t***4*4-*<t***4** r4r4(>iriin<ri|f>iN(>irvir>jr4rNir>ir>ioiriir<«(>l<>i(NI<>irNi(^N(>ir<4ryriir<iN<>4r4r4(>i(y|(>ir<l<>i<>|c^

Ui •

3 <

z

o -« X u X u ■33 X < X «» r-t

o < X i-t * o m * u ■♦• —. * X X • a. * -1 m < •H UJ u. * *

* o «^ oc Ui u. H- tr * >v O CC UI • »- tO <» a s. X at U.

•~ fsl o o QCUL X m UJ -i • al — X — UJ oc 2 (X. UJ a: X -J < ►-a: * < ♦

> D o x O Q: O h- «-« 2 * X • • + ooc CC X <

u. o UI o • i/j a: D • o« •-« z a: o 3 rH * * < u. «k X urn # UJ X - j j t— UJ X o> a. a: X X ♦ oo • a: •O * • •j o • <r\ UJuJ _i -J • X

X LÜ * _l <«% (N X X a: u K- tn * X -I tO «\ * >•. >v D Of • m z o tO a • * oo < • u. t— I «t a H- * — X X t- ►- UI » u 3E H tO * O Uu u. • u. u. cc u. >. < O lO Q. ~ X * 4i -j UI UI X UI u. * UJ a. • — U. O O o: a: ^ X ac UJ X 3 UI X • I O ♦ D 3 — ^ <n <n Sli. »>o I ac u a o o i£ • XOXX UJUJ»» < u t- * •t - < UJ UJ — • a ui a < D XX UJUJ«-<^I_J»- > • • X ^ fM _J * X X tO UI X UJ _l o X *♦ >-v^«nu.u. < J O «o u. • >- a — O O O O UI >- ui ♦ xinin^<<oouJUJ • u. » • UJ X u ~i 3 • • UJ UI * < ><NJ — j- 4- co I I in m ac a 1- UJ UI .J 01 o a: ID UJ 3 UJ X X a • v m v. 'O'Omxx^P'Jll u, o: >- • * * > > (- l- o O o a: — « _i • • • V,>v* * UlUu < u. X X X * < M isl * • «i uJur-3** rvj* * _i_» OCKJ » UJ aJ m (>

H- * • • v/3 i/) tO >- X • ui «« * 23XX X • U. a: cc * «• lO -J -I _l ►- O * <r < + x (XüC* — f^UIUJ-V'«* • H- UI X X _i ►- UJ _l 1^ tO t0 rg IAJ X • o • ♦ t3 0~Q:tn>->oeJ -io: a: x r- * • >-(r/ a a Q. • x * a + ^ _l ««-,i3fn<<uu-n- u. » UI o • u. a. <a h- •- K- _J O _J 1- • ~ UJ (/) </>••-•• | I VJ u u. u. UJ < >- • X UJ UI • ^. oO J) {/) 'S) » •Si fs|t-i>»>vv.oi0* _JI-<<UJüJ OCX x 4- cr o:

u. u. Q. a a. a -j UJ • — — * _I_IO—* tror^ vaa: X < • o • X • z z * ♦ •> »- to >- a^ocKxxoi-QisXtfvinD^ij. u. » • >- r-l t~ -t ÜJ a « u. 2 LU ^ a. < O U.X D ♦ * (nQ:o<<-**i-»-z z O •* U. • • OJ Z »-a UJ uj ui a >- * UJ UJ < X 00 + 0«>>-«04i<i« ** _l l-X <MUi O U. • ►■•

i/>* ct >- >- • to j» xaoouuii.iOto<< • «JJOO U. U- H- CC X UJ x u. Q.U. 3 < < I Q. UI O -I + a UUUJI 1 ♦♦UJUIV "N UJ UJ -* CC O X CC o u ~z »- ««>«»«>•« > —■ u • * << cc • •****>>_l 1- a ae ox • fM O • X za. -^ l-< < < cc < i-ooi^«*)* ♦ Or^^ji-ora« ♦ aaaorxo •_! • < X "-< Ot- _J h- tOO O O D »», — o: cc * — .0 Oiina — — ti.ü.OO«0<ODDUJX* * O-i-ü. oi- r- -i U 00 _j CO UlUJ UJ u x a: oi < ui >o* eo m co cc i I UJ ui — •-< vo vo < <>.* ^■•#vOf\jüJXX * •» <a <uJ>-xxs:ce:o<cQNjvOO • <*»r-t — xxQ:cct^^o•(»^- H- < ^ (V f>J • -J cc •-> eo o x

• Hu a >- <o o o o —• CD UI D CO • II • • o II 11 X X 11 11 • • 11 )l H «VJ • • »o cc o *» * X ^H OiO_J -•< » to m io a: l/)UJ •X •'-tu. II II r-« _l »- II II _l K N H _J K- U. • M II *» X • t- X -t • ii i/) n _i » -J 11 >- UI _I»-OQ:Q:_JI-U.U._IK-U. U. UJ N * 4- UI -O < -t CJ _J ^-ja _IUJ to -I -J _l J a: j a j _j II a u.Lu055:u.uLUJUiQia:uJUJa:-»r«jf^!--t(-X • • • a_Ji-_nuiij_i-j_i_iiu_j<jeooujuj_j<<uJüja:a:33a:o;Lü(v-jH--'rgo CE _I u. ><<i>i<>->-<<<< V < £0<ujxa:a:Qi<>->-Q:Q:D3<<u.u.>-OQiQ:a:ooo • x UJ LUUO- U < <U VJ u u < u UJ u x u. a xx>-«f<oo»-i-i-H-uu<xxxxxou.u.^)Q:

r-t r-« .-i -I (\J o o o

CM en

172

Page 182: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

in>or>a>oOf-«.^rrt4'<A<4>roa>o«0'-4r4cri4'in<or^<s(hOr^c>i(«>4'in<cr>-oo«0'-«<sg(ri4'in>o ,^,4r4*4r4(MrM(M04(>Jojoi(Mrv'Vcnct(nf<i(n(rk(n(<<«(*)c«t*<*4-'*'*'-i''*-t'<*'#tnintnintAinin

rxfMpgrii(Moij>**M<McM«MfM (MNrMrMrMrsioiNfMNMOioiriliMiMoirarMrMdjiMtvoioiNrtirMOirsi m ao

O

T

*

u.

r

z o in

o Q o r o

a. UJ

o Q 3 r o

X >. X r- u. ^ • UJ v o a: ■*

vO ^v u Ui • lii m o> t0 o> o ■V • <0 >- <o rg

o z

o

O

z O

— o O UJ a uj oc a. UJ LO

K. UJ Q

U < >-• UJ z a: O h- to I/) * X UJ t- UJ z a Ui u.

t- z z — UI < z o

Q — UJ CO UJ — a < i/) _i

Q — Z O < ^ <\i U) * > * < u • UJ ~ to o

(\J ~- * *-

NO lA (Ni OJ t *

m • rH -• • OJ

O ^J- UJ rg -o * in • ■ «o

«o ^i ^« (^ * f\j

<o • UJ • O <o O f> DO o • Ci O ft AJ t- r-t * * • o

>o V * o UJ — r- -^ r- O CO

031 O

a) O

O o C5

X

i ^g Z »- r-i Q: x UI 3 vO f^- ►-

•> — UJ x m a m >o

z UJ z

QO Z to

U K-

CO

(- UJ 3 Z o - CD D SO t0 Qi

Z o LO

z o lO z UJ r.

z — UJ a

V I-« •> OJ ui •»-■ • rH • ^ o» o ii • n • «-» x ►* •-< • i/)

-^ • «O * ^ O 10 II >o UJ >— a* rvj v<: •-• UJ j- •-« •-• •

u •mc^— •• — 0">>'->r- • i- «h-o

X"S— »(NJ»-!^ • • tOUJDO »Zh- OUJ_

Qico>- •VOO^I^DXX UJ^<«OUJlO »K" a —ui*— «zo uj<<fn>o<OüJii-

z<< •oo<inu.o •-•OQin>-iQiHi-«(j>

— ^ U ^-4 ^-» »^

— uj Z < V O _J < to

u u u o o o

X i-l i-l »H tH Z II II D n N H H

Zww to 0<<<<<<<W U_I-J_I_I_IJ_J^

in

— O _J • ill M

> • • in

< u. • > z -< aJ -. 0. r\i _j • « CD • X r-i < >o » •• t— UJ

•* z o X •

tO (r\ •J "* o • < ixl o • -o UJ fM X • J V- *■

X II t r- UJ

UJ * • a

>- D _j ~ tn a -J UJ »-• • _J < > -• • < > • >- ri

I H- »— • t- X iSl oc • z Z) ui OC C\i UJ > o •

< u - z X » » --< < < u. ~ • UJ 5 Z rH ^ a: a »-i —

.— »- I 1— ^ rH » to m t,') h- <-< r-l (M a io • <** UJ X - o •-« < X UI ir. z U "I -I h- oc. • o < — * z u. r<i u • • X UJ x •-« < ~ ^. h- — m ui i/ »- CO -< Z o >o * u vO — — UJ o • UJ -1 1- •-# r-« O ll Q UJ to OD «O X z z o < OUJ • 1-1 >- U.i —• C U

o >~ 4" D «O - Q. D Z ^ M <

II N Z ^ h- -1 z z o D to - — <J o - Ul < < •-^ a: u o z eo »-« y- t- *- X X K- 3 o < a: UJ < — Z Z — oc t— z »- Z H- CD X ^~ < o o o a o z O UJ UJ tO D — < -J vO o U TR U. UJ V.J cr

u tO O O

o c o o 1— fNJ m o ■* u.

u u

Page 183: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

r^a>o»0'-«(Mrrt-4'in<oi>-a>oO'^oi(<t4-m<or^(Oo«o-«rM(rt4'in«r«oo(>0'4oj<<><^in<or>- «nm iA<o<o«o<o<o>o<4><o<o«or>-h-r>r>r>r>r>'roi«>r^co<oaDa>aoooa>(Oco<99>o^^^o(>(ho

Nrsir4<><r^rsiro^r4ra<>ir4r«icg^ictir«c4r4car\iNr4(Ni^c4i>tr\iri<rijrNirii<>ic>irsi(>iNr<i(>irtirii

•A o

aa

o

* LÜ

<

>/>

UJ

I/)

o o

ifl »A

o

ir\

oo a -• UJ

X

< • V z

• o —

(M • < ^ Z r-tf-t 0£ 'H I • • • » \J

^-l(NJ (J f^ < VO u • — — o u -• I ■-1 • < • •

it r» — o • o

a: o o • m

<<^ i-o < • Q-i

a ~

a: •

z « o« u • 3^ — _J — CO — ">. _l z - O X <

o<

— o ♦ «M r\i • * O * <\» _J • UJ o >^ ♦ — m • * r-l I l I Z

M I >- U lO < UJ ~. >- u. < -

41

lA -^

* * Z X u < +

CM * * Z I

<

r-

* lA

* *

* Z X

< * rg

in a •s. u.

UJ z

z a. — 11 1- o Z K o m u a

a.

OUJ z m Z) -•

Z Q. O- II ►- h- o

Z h- o o m o u a

o rg

• o o o -o

lA +

<NJ * z X u

a:

* — • O AJ UJ w

o ♦ - m -— o -l 1- 00 to a N u. • z o - t- a. m 1

< a o 1-

>. 1- m f\j ma * u» — * >- + Z < _J X — »n U < QL < O ^ * LU U.

UJ • 2: Z 3 vO O -• z • m a « O a *~ ** ^ •-* z a: _i 1- O <N < 01 u a: u a

o to

*

o o <« I o r-t OH tvj a: *

—• • O AJ UJ — X - o ♦ • **

t- in LO a >- ■«> rvl U. • Z

H- a m 1 a o • 1— ^ in m a UJ —

~ >- + ~ < _j • — m

rH < Q. » O N.

O ÜJ u. -HZ Z o: o -- CM m a a n * _l AJ • _l (-

t\i < m — u a.

z a. »~ in a. •

1

* z X u <

lA +

z .-• a. * >>. •

— m

• *

I l- o m ^ a. a 11 AJ IL. a: z * a. • K

AJ LO — a

o lA * O

o — 4-

AJ -» in

m • UJ rg >- I < Z >. X •-I u I- < m — 1- u. M —

m o u <

ac o

z I u <

UJ u

r j « N K — Z rH O - U _J

o 4-

u o

OD O < «o

II M O QC »- Aj en «0 0£ OO -I _J _» u o

N n

»A * * a a: o u ♦ o a.

UJ OUJ -J D • D UJ Z •-• Z > « M -• M I- a t- Q. Z ST Z -I O O O UJ U L' u >

u UJ Q

m o z

o ir

o

z or 3 I- Q t- UJ z < a: uj

u

CO

in z Ui Q

<n u

< m »- O I z o I— « < _)

UJ ui z m -« z I- UJ D m O QC UJ 03 > Z)< m m

« u

174

Page 184: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

cootO'-4(M(rt.*'in<or>~coQ«o>-4f>4(*)'*trv<or,,-aoo«OiHoji*)4'trt>oi*-aootO'^rgm4'in<or-4>Ct

'0*r»-r~f^r^-r-f«-r--f-r-r^»*-^r~r-r-r,»r~r*r»-f,-f«-f«'h-f»r»h»r,"f*r,»r-r,-^r*r-^f-r-f,»f*r«'

4•■»•»4■•♦4•-*•!t■*4■<■4•■*■•♦*4•♦'♦•»*4•4■4■*••■♦4■«r■•■•♦^■-*4■4•■#■«■•«•4•♦-♦4••»

lO o; UJ i— UJ X

o z <

O \f) oz>

tu oo — Q rs» x 's! O H- + »- • O »-* o >- • r^ o m r-

X f- Oi- -o p* r* <•* r*

u. _J O LU vO o < ^ z r~ 4^ t*~ 0\ • • • •

— o « «o «■< en m f^ X o -1 • z «n * U. \C cc < o <n 4- r- o> o • o M o z <o • A * * o — h- <S) ►- o< w * • • O tNJ •» »O o o < oc z rH X V 4- m <0 00 r-l t-l r-4 r-i ^ o u ÜJ UJ h- ^4 -t CO r-t

• h- IH4 »- «0 h- — * vO *^ (M ^^ ^^ —* «^ <-^ ««k |

r^ * o UJ -» o o u> o c> * o 1 OOOOOO UJ w * z z o a • I/) • • fNJ • m oiu • •••••m Oo >n H- o « tr\ o O LU vO 00 rA oo • r«- oooooo<oo«o -< in üJ o o o o o • UJ O _) >0 fM o • OOf-OOOOOOO • «ooo • • h- >o • o • a h- o o O f- * o o • OmOOOOOOOfM^fO^Ooo^O — •* r-< oo OüJ O * O LU vO II f-H tNJ O CO 0000r-0»-4^rgrgm I oooooo I O _J •- -* 3a ¥- »- UJ a> o m O »-i r~ #•* o- • W4,nj<0'-<ff\4n<M i-4 »{nrg • LO O It ii z a: DC _l K 1 3 (^ -i -~ r-» • 1 II f» iH 1 1 1 S 1 1 II <£ «H || o

►- o i-* UJ O UJ < 15 N 1- «O O ^sl 1 oo Nl it OfsIfMisJ^isiMII CM _) LU f- LU »- > a ^» •-• ■x. ^^ »- 'W a II n 1 . Ollllt- Q II -JO> > Zh- II z II £ »- II •■H It J! CO < Ci < m < < o< O < O UJ o O U. _J UJ u. Ou-zamajou. ü.ii.u.üLU.5:ctcDa30 3£ct CD u iO O cO U i^ — u M VJ « < IM 3 >~4 ►-• N O i—< •- o tsj a ^►-.««.««^.f-^rg^^^-^Kj

o o o O r-t (NJ fO «* inoh-coa»©--! rg o o o o rH fH <-« o t» « o

■* 4- •* «-( u u u u u u u

I i)

Page 185: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

r>4rsir^fg(Nr^c>»(>jrN4<\jrsir\jf\(pg(Nic4rg(>lf>j*vir>jr^r^r>i<>4rg«>jr4r^c4Mrarvirjr^rsi<>irsir^ojf>j

CO (M 4- «O 00 O (M J- •-i CM <M f^ CSJ O Cl «^

* tg -* vO oo o IN j-

rg m m fM nj rri tn cr»

• o ri m m r- O« ri m CM rg (si m <M CM tn m

rH ^ ,*. **, ~, *~. *~. ~. ~. ^| m OJ --I 1 O OOOOOOO O UJ UJ UJ UJ • • •«•••• co \t\ in O O in Ol- in o 4- m o m in o m o oooooooomnor* fM >o • nj <0 • <o O • rH o • o -o o • O o • OOOOOOO<0O • r^ oo • o o w o • 0 0 4- o • ao O o o • ooa» o • • o OO o OOOOOOOO •0 04 -to vO • o «o o <o • O f- O 00 • O oo o o c O O O Org O OOO OOOOOOOOO »oo OO r* O O rsi O -H ^H O •* O fNJ oj o vo o r- o o r-t or- l O 9« O O Or~'-«OOinc<%OooOO'-i • m rg ** • <f\ ( •> o • m CM (M • (^1 fNJ l- • (o rj f>J • »o r- o»-''-<-*<-<^''Mini-i o«

»-4 II ^ fvj u CM m ii (^1 00 Ii •* r-t ii in m 1 O 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 » & o O N O H o ll o II o It O IN! •-^^-»^J^>I^J^J^J^4^J II

ii i- Q M II »- O Ii U h~ Q II 11 1— o ll IS i— Q n n 1- — ^w OHM £0 < CD < co < cr < CD < II It CO <

cao 2: a: CD coo 5: CX CO CD o S oc en CD O 5. cc ID CO o s a: 03 CO o li. u-u-u-u-u-u-u-SQCtua) ao ►- c» M ao »- c? M a o t- O tvj a a ►— o M a o i— O isi Q. O -< ••* rJ^««_>-,w^,f_^3|SJQL

cr, -t m s0 i- O oo O'-'nin^invOi^ >-< ^-i ■-< rH i-i O

o CM

•H mni(NjrMnj<*4<MfM

17G

Page 186: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

rH ra to

-O <0 O (V •*■

«1 en -t •» 4"

• * « • • >0 ® O eg ■t PO «o -t .t * • * * • •

r-t if» r- ^ ^< in O rg eg ro (»i to o tn <n (^ ^" o •* O OOOO J 1 i ilia

UJ — ■ UJ "ÜJ UJ UJ UJ UJ co o o o o o o m m •4" (M o*

o^ • • • • m o f-» >o • OvO Oi-* OfHtnoo^'AOf'-in lA «A • *0 O O O O >0 • >« fvj o m • r-4 m »m min«o >o »eo <or-»ov %o <C O O-t oooo »o^o o <<> o 4 .-i <0(M04 »o r-« o f^ • -* o IM • o o in •

O «OOf-OOOOOOOOOOO • O ■* O O •OOi-iO •00'-äOOOO<fOOOOC»400 OO »OOOOOOOvOOrr) • OOOOm^OO^Or^OO^OoO^'OOO^ »OO^Om Ot^OOOOfMvOI^O»HOOOOO>00«riOOvOOOtAO<00000»MOO^)CiMOOKOfr> ^- rg o f^ J-^-lr^rHrrirvlO* ■♦«onii-tr^ -*<o rgrg*^ mm-ti-« >o to -* r-t r^rvj^-t-t

II rH • 1 1 1 1 4- • ii 1 r-tail II «-< * K -> • Hi-«« II ^9 O II O Nl M N) M 11 O .>l II O II O II O II OH O H •- a n ii t . II II Q •- — 11 II Q 1- O II II i- O 11 II »- Q II II 1- Q 11 II l-

CD < CD < CD <tn< CD< CO < CD« CD o s. oc caca ou.u.u.iJLSmmiKOu.xcD.DaoxiaDaiO^atDcoozacD'DOzoitQcDO1- o »- o Ni a ^5M««w^-ls|Q.OO>-«H-^g0LOO^-^^f'JQ.O^-l^'vlaOl-l0^sJü. di-ONjaoi-

w ^ o <-t rsj <n -»■ m vo r~ co a o rg eg co m f*"* m fO t<> o to to c"» 4

Page 187: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

cn4'>n>or-co(>0'^csi(n^in<or>-oooOf-irMm^in<or-ooo>Or-4oim''>n<or>(oo«o>HrMm (Moir^rgrtiojojmort tntncf»<nc«\m<*»<*»-*-* -♦-*■-» -3- ~* <|- •4-<4'iniAtft>niAinintoininyO<o<i<o tSflOtDootocoooooaocoaocooocococoaOGOcoÄcocococöoOflOcoaodaaDaDCOfiOcotoaoaoocoto rsiNr>tr4<Nj<>i(viNrjc\i<vi(>i(>ir\irsir4r4i\if>iry|ci4rgc4rvinJ(>i(^Nr^<>4r4N<siNNC4C4rkiN

r*r*r4Nrvc4C4r\ir4C4N™r*itvriirtiri4r4r^rwrsjrg<Nir4r>iftj<>irtiCNr4NrgiMNr4r4r4r4rHcr\irg

isl * •o r-l

I OJ vO

m o* •a

+

*

o 1

Ul

O -4 in • (M OO og OOrfN • OflO OO o

o»»-» tt -* •

a ii u

OCiXi CC

■»0 4" •O

O OO O sn • o m o 4 -i

O B t-

O £

a »

UJ

o a a CM

O-* o o o OO o o^ o <«> <o 4-

o II ii t-

co aa O M a. o

<o <*» • o OO m • CD o «-)

H II

Q cn <

o I

UJ o

o o • -t o 00 O fO oa> ooo O-H <^ • II II

CO GO M a.

• o o O (M o* •* fM

o I—

o o

in o I

UJ

f*- o ^ rH • r- OO « O O in • oa» OOO

O r-l II m •

< o: to cG O M Q.

in

• o o o o o m

o II

to o 3: O I-

r-l a •-< • o o oo • o OO

O H <0

O M < a CD

4" 4" 4

o o • o ♦

CO tNl I

fsl

< on

ooo m o + ■* O CO (^ 4- s: • i—

o II H- II

a o i-

o o o

00 \0

00 -a-

o o

o I

UJ in 4 <-t

X

* 4

o o m 4

O o in

— o OD O NJ 4 I 4

< oc

OO o + am

o

o O o o h- fl I

M

UJ H- 3 Q- 51 O

» s: •

o o o o f-

z <

o o o o a« z

111 UJ DUJ Z 3

It I- 11 — H

tS) z: u.

o o o 4

UJ Z CD O U INl

o o 4 4

U

o <~* n» O o- t in uj <r\ vO • in

o tsl O * m

IM • I i

UJ

4 * co —. GO O in o 4 1 f) UJ f-t en ^ <o • r-«

I in I-«

M rg * in r- -O CM in I •

UJ + o

O ♦ in «o — 00 r-t i-t r-1

* ! .H UJ • o

w r-( II

— m _» — <0 <N O II <o UJ z:

o "-i •-• s: »o o UJ ui • IH 3:

pH fM

• CO

•3-

CO

* UJ

UJ i—

Cu

o

o o o a r-

I U.' — om rg r-t vO I rH UJ O 4- CM m 4- O • !M

tn o I 4

O

z. < X

O m a: out UJ •» z> K

z < O -• UJ i- i- o:

z o o o O U rs|

c o m 4

* CO C^l I NJ

UJ ♦ o-> 4 »M m CM in i o UJ co o -i >o • <0

t-t O» w ^ <■• I-l

— 00 — • fl +

ts)

178

Page 188: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

^iA<or~a>o»Oi-«rg(n-*iA»o^«oo»0'^'>»',»'*>f><0'>-oooO'^fMcn^tn^>»^ao^o«-*fN«m^-in <o,<}<O4)^)<or>-r*-r«h-r,-r''>^^^^co<x>aocoaoao0oo<o<DO>o>o>ot9kO>o>OkO*(^OOOOOC aoooflOootOÄ<o«o<0<8®co«>«)eo«ocooo<oco(OcooooO(Ooo©coo(jco<OoOcoaotoeoCiO»(^Oi^o

i UJ (> oo •* o o O •

^« 1

h- o

rvl CO 10 o ♦ CM •t z •

^ ■to o O <f UJ'O <J * r-l -* a: a* —

1 r-« <o 3 • i0 eo O D UJ UJ 0» »- CO — UJ <ö < < 30 r-i m • < rg QC fO (K iA a isi ■* o> CO QC >v O 3 00 O rg <o ft fO ^ >t Q l3-~ rgmto-*-*-* <-t & (M !U _i Z tO •# ^ ßOQOQOOX — «vr-lO'-» CJQQQOOQ U fN» O» * a O O t/> <n SO CJX£X*XXXU CD a — z o oaaaaaaaua (M rg s Xro-tUJOXeo XUUUUUUW* 0.0 — O a.lMrslr^l^4lSlM^gQLr^l 4- >0 UJ UJ>-<I^«<-Q:O>-O U **♦♦*♦ *ln — XUJtOO ^♦♦♦♦♦«♦fvj« >ö in (- UJ • Q. • + P- ♦ eviiMfMtn-i'-^inQ (JUJKIDO •rgfvjrgmw^initirg • « II LU JE u. <y* o en in ooaoaaaox O — O Q U Q Q Q Q QO Q Q VJ U in tn DU*O^>U Mh-oxxxrxrxsu u >JII_IUJ • + +aaaaaaaQ.aa + + -1 Z »- X eg »- ll I ^ 1 UUUUUUUU II u * 0< t0»-*>O»Oislrs|rs|fsl!S(isJMMMiS(

o '«UH-O O — m U il B it II Jl M H H O ♦ pg • n 4- 3 CD rsj NJ ti H n ii n tt n ii ii is x y Q. UJ tt iX ac • iir>j<*\4-in'öf>-aoo>rHuuQZ<-<_jQ.N4 A u (v<<\4tr\-or*-co&cvrr\ •—1 ZXIIUI ZOH^)OQOOOQQQQQll ii II _JX_iX U QUQQQQQQQQUU

(S/MUJOO awos: n xxxxxxxxxxrgro(MüOUj<o -DaaaaaQ.aa.aü.a.a ♦ * 3EUU»-i^VJUUJUauUUV-'UUUUUUUUQa.t-UUr>JrvlMfslfsltsiMMiMMtsJrJM

o O m o o rH

<!• -♦ u u u u

179

Page 189: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

riii>i«>j*yriiCMrxi>jr>4r>jr<j>jr>i»>i<vi«MfMMr>irsifM<Mr<f^«MdjfMpj CMiMrgnirgfMfMegcMfMfMcMCM ««, in • ui (t\ ■» ^ »-

d 0 + ♦ a in r^ ^> ISI «nx m * r- tu in Q -t •- 0 2: • * »o u -H O O * 1 1 O • UJ (M

e«^ (O sO • -w ^* —* tx r-a + >» in as X 0 • —. O O UJ ^t rH

I-« <n a a h- I"-- rH 1 O *~ rsj (Vl ♦ O X

—. 21 ^J- — Ol * * OOO UJ -~ fNJ U — Q PW O »n tNi ~ O • >- —». a * O 2: O Q. O O rsi rg rg ♦ O a o 2: u s: !M X X o in CA + 00 < «si a. u >v ^ \j * O iJ Q. O <> Ui a: * rsj * O tNJ ♦ O «0 * * isi X ^3 ■O f> 0 eg — <V< O Q —• -» CM O Q • • ♦ U ^X » * Q ■v O _l X Q O O _J X m 00 tn ^ 4- UJ ^ rg x: QQ. O <J X 2.0. u VJ <- — 0 0 0 t- 00 m u + M r-J ♦ U U ^sl M * >v ^ X O • * oo 4 * <n* *~(\j*>s* * • • • U _J 1 (N» <TV r-.

• O • -*■ rg t*> O «n O • (O CM fH ^-t * U fV O 4" C^l

fNJ ZrgQQOaoOrg U ~ 1 ♦ • rsl a I • • w 0 — -z 1 s:tNia_i — 1 ^ r^g I X aJ rH T>

"S ^»»IJ^VJ* ISJO>. VJ • 4- r- UJ t^ + — • O'^Q* • * rg • a. r-t 0 0 N. ^ 1- <t 's

M. «-. r* 0»-«CJZOf>J •*■-• Ni + a a • Q * r- O -* • • + -11 OUQ. — f>tM + ♦ ~ isl r«J ^ a ■* >o 0 ~ -*

O O rg -» O'^-i'v'M^.—U — oa 0 * ♦ 1 M «o 00 _| -^ vO fH fH OO rgcMUO — ."M"^*© 0 u a -o (^1 — * rH in u m 0 •^ w 5.0. + OrslCl.>^Qrg^a O* fsiQoooor-giM rH • o o <J N ^■2:*Mr>j+QCiivj -J • * X X »—• 0. X IM rg * X 00 oo v. * OUU*Q— is:* Uf^O^UUOrsiurg »m UJ CM

-1 -1 O «^ X * 1 Q 1 04 — U CO rg + O * * S * * • 1 CM t- 0 * < < — oo utM^-* mrjQN.o * • X • • 'J -*■ • O in rH t O m ♦ ♦ ~ _J 2: ^00 »oxxur CM f\j u 4 r» ■s o -t ma m X (^ O <o • «O Q U oa S(MSUUQ.U u -^ -^ — — O X - 1 X ^ u. rH vO »o

«o >oa u -' O-NIO + U* * M — + rg->>->.v.ou>«.'-<xJo O 0 X 0 + + ivl fsj -^ ISI* v.-.\Q{M* v. uu • • • _l w • a. 1— fv. O «. 0 UJ * CO *-. -^"V •f • 1 •u-s-oaou» QL Q. ^ »-< ■-< U \ rH 21 * ^1 _J X 0 h- 0 • — ^>u — f-i ^■r«jQ.QOMQ.* f« •SIN 1 + 1 M • 1 UJ rg 0 UÜ. *: 'imm O Ov o ua. a i Q — iMSI-J — isI «1 * * O — — + rH -~ t- ^ • fsj 0 * * 0 ~- a. a IM a >* Z^ + UQ's — rgjr 0. U U •"< t^l vO m + CO * 00 | * 0 -* -t r- * r>l r^ — N O uo~* NON. 1 000* *ooo(>inoor~co moo rH * w — 10 ♦ 2: ^I0«**0-»£ZO • »xaa-QoaJ-MX 1 V 0 r-t X • <"» 10 '/) CD O U O—'2:r\)0 • + <t u KJ _l «VJ CO U CSJ M a. X is| O (O UJ UJ • CO fsl O LJ 0 X CQ ÜD< X V. OOJU«-* fN4-~Os» ♦ U l l v * * fvj U * ^ • »- a» rH <r O 1- CD 0 1- < <- u 0 _Jo*'v«iQ2:a C^ rsl • • e? r- <r * s, rg CM >0 * <T> « • O O 1 X 0 's o 1 0-tQZt^cgr\irgXuOO* rgcnOOOOoO^OCMCM 4- h- OCO Z O z 0 tXi ooo — -JOMUOQ 1 OU*_JQ. U V v. _J X X X O X • + rH CO UJ O-H •—• 0 o_i 0 ^ 0 X oo_JVQ2:**aaros:* «org | CM en O U VJ U -I U 00 •* 1 r~ 1- fMX ft • 003 1- O O —- ►- _i _J< • NjUOONllV/OUOfNJVJ* U U U M * ♦ * 0 * 0 a. UJ >o *~4 <!■ UJ 3 * ^HQ. • O Q «- < < ii ^ 1 V Q.*IX-s.ü.—Nl • a a. a 1 • • • M • CO X .H ■* -1 s^ i- 4- -, 1— O CO < * H II O II II O M M • 11 U O M X II rf\islMfsl II !^«00> II CO II UJ -t a m O 11 h- a sr ♦ oc CO o oo r-irvjO«^ — ^-* vO — cNjin _ t! II II rH « — — eg —■ co >- CM rH h-m < O K UJ a 0 0 a. o o -j a. a. _JQ-V-'Q.Q_J'>vUa V 0 r~ 00 ^1 N. N. ^ rH V. rH * ^ + _) rH U IS) H- UJ > h- ~- _i -ici 3: z ux »VXCLO »ax • X X X X • • • x • x r- CO CM -I O X a II n z II II QUUlUUJislUJf-lGUJrvlis) r-trvJUJ 1-4 UJ U UJ UJ •-* f) <-i ui rH uj 1 ro iH < (J UJ UJ >o 0 0 O u- NJ MM »- 1- + t-++f-+ 1 1 +(- 1 1- t- 1- f- 1 + 1 1- + t- UJ 0» X u ^- a: rsi O a. u ü. 0 *-# CL

r-t r-t rg rH rsi f^» 4- rH rH (\J cn rH rH CM CO

O 0 0 0 O 0 0 0 eg en 0 0 -* 4- m O

180

Page 190: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

r~«a»o-«(Mf>'*in«or,»»<7*Or^oj(n-*-in^>t'-a><T»o^r>4('»4'in>or'-eo<7>o^r\j

^ * -* ^ 4- 4" 4- 4'<#4'4'4'<<9-4-4-4-<«'«4-«-4-4'<#<r<r4-4«4 ■***■*•** «M *M m »V .-M CM IV f>ifxrM»>*<M«xr«i*MiM«Mr«jrMr««njrnf«irM«Moi<Mf^r<ojf«/<Mr>#<Mf>j«\i rg

J l oo z O» < UJ rg

a: z

O O

UJ < 2 a:

»- UJ 3 z O •-•

—' QC »- ** 3 so ü O X UJ ££ *~ O * UJ » rg UJ O «n u _J J- K UJ ~t .J CO m • <^ L0

ep O o —• X X "•>> h- h- -• < < a

INI o ■vO i f- ^ t—

Nl "v *— t- V. t- * r*- 3 •- r> r-t *-* m — a u- a o • f<\ ,-NJ INJ z z o O t— O» ro U o — • * U- m t- UJ o o •— -N to Ü- LO UJ OUJ * 5: 03 in >» ^ o • o ^* -t i- _i ^ - H- D O 3 ■N •* * • <fl u. o »- o >- ~v >o r\j o o i0 m* o n —■ s. c* m h- \ < 10 (V X i— • t— N, • ^ r» £ u 00 u. _J (Ni -J !

aj r-t — * ^ o < < u. r»4 n m * OQ o • •» o o r U. X * • s: -~ _i o f-i K- — o X o o o O aa o <r> oo N. 00 r-i ^* o o o: H- o u. ^ (M i^ <o «0 — i^) -♦ o 4 o + 1 — X <n o * UJ * u. vD 'N V o >- r- X ui UJ fM tNJ ^ »- U5 00 o ^* * X Z) X o O a — C1! -H rg o r- t— u o »-« o o o in _; m CO * V • > • i' oo X CO u. UJ (O o -J m ■u o o >. < v UJ • <t 1- o »- rg Z v0 r» v 1/) 00 t- o — ♦ ■* o \ > V Z) O^ <t l-l «-^ •-• ffi — M z OdQ O» \ O UJ o i-i i-H oo o — ~ ^v V _/

1 yO lO * 10 ■va sO t-i 0_l «A Z oo -» tO OJ ■^ — • o o ^ O "v < *•* O Z U) z UO o r>- <M *-* rg v Z a> K o • o o • UJ • > oa • ÜJ z tu z o oo eo O r- </) • <— UJ UJ OUJ o 04 O lO a z o ox 00 o uj a UJ t- in 1- Ch }- • u en i— OO lO *-s h- ot- 4- o «> O * i D X 'J OUI UJ OJ Q Q r- en O * • UJ »-4 <* — 00 LU rO >o O ^) UJ <-( —• f-( •LU oo * 3 (- K- (- • t- • i- N K- 10 t- 1-4 UJ > -J 00 _J •w D *— <7> _* o ^. (/) w z

CD Z 11 ce (i Q: tl a: * cz ♦ (X. ♦ a o a: * o: < I/) 1/5 o z _ z. Z H- S-O 1- o O a. -' LU UJ UJ Q. ÜJ a uj a uj UJ K O to O »- t«4 >-• UJ o UJ *-* o: < < < *-* »- t- OO > irt > i/} > > > > ii > ►- — _l t~ J 1- w »— (- 1- \- DX z tO

u z z z z z z z H z ii z li z z 11 10 _J _J o z •-< •-• z t- a; i ce </) Q O O U O LU O UJ o o o O to o UJ UL < O < ^ OU. cc o a o UJ o Q < z o a u Q U Q U o u a. u a <J a u u u t- a: t-4 u o u u •-< s o s KJ or u. UJ u. UJ

r-l i-H oo o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o oo r-i (M CO 4 tM (A o ■t l/> r~ as co OO CO «0 a. u u u u u u

181

Page 191: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

b, PrMr Deck Setup

The following diagrams indicate the deck setup and the core storage requirements for the Pr^r program. Each link is composed of the subroutine decks (symbolic or object) listed in the allocation diagram. All control cards are indicated by a $ in column 1 and must be punched exactly as shown in the deck setup diagram. All items in parenthesis indicate subroutine or data card decks.

182

Page 192: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

OOöOö

LP1

LP2

LP3

Notes:

1. Storage locations are on actual numbers.

2. Load points (LP) are indicated as follows:

LP1 - 04076

LP2 - 60005

LP3 - 65623

SCHEMATIC DIAGRAM OF COMPUTER STORAGE ALLOCATION

183

Page 193: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

{ a. 1

i CD

1 = | a. P K

Hi

sec!

r- n

r- |

■C J

^H

,C'*I

-ccl

^3

*■■*%

»n «

"* — ***

-rC^ «»"^

^ —

»ige

-^^

r^ao

rNt^

^<

f*^

r*^

i*NO

—SI —«

— <-i

— cj

— O

oo- oS o~

p~ pv

P5 p-

J

c 1 "

1 UJ'

[*" 1 h'

U

<*

- - -

- -^

ru i- <

\i 1 K

V

1 h

1 '

• 1 **

r-*

^*

o' " o"

r • i o;

-> a"

UJ

►-'

1 3 rw

**-

**

-

-*

vi u Q

u.'

0."

<"

at

r° •I as

w

■ -|

- —

-

r * i a. J

L <

Z

1 ^ c d

-

L "^ i • •

1 o M

C

J

< >- Ui

L ■

z

« q

- —

-

1 J«_

1 u' •

ji

e]

t-' III*

r <* K Q •»

>- -

M

U

• •o.

e

S

- • -

- - -

' < T *: <

z]

'«a K Q m

r- -

.

3 J

q M

u m'

. *] u'

i

*

af

q

u •

IB

5

- - -

- - -

< a"

<

z;

q

^»_ u •'

J«"

c"

J"

-<

\ <

.«4

Q *•

* -

• ■

- -< -*

-

"*j •i

cl

)- -

H

«1 •1

- '-) •1 •*! ■1 o|

Ui]

. -

">1

«aj

h -

-j

<

> < <

z z

* lo 1 X

1 "*J 1 »J Jl-

1 ^ lo

184

Page 194: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

The '•ontpnts of each link are:

Link 0 AS2419 (main program) TAB DTAB DBTP TBLP XTAB LOC XLOC

Link 1 DIVERG UND STREAM

Link 3 DELTA

Link 4 CYUXD FLOW

Link 5 AXI2D HEMI

Link 6 QTRAN BEQI

Link 2 WALLT 1 WALLT 2 BLKDTA DERV EBAR IWALL JAYELL MUZERO RORMUR SOMEGA TABLE 2 TABLE 6 TABLE 7 TABLE 14 TABLE 18 TABLE 19 TABLE 20

Link? INTIAL REF SONENT STACON ATMOS

tn;

Page 195: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

SECTION ni

THE TURBULENT NONSIMILAR BOUNDARY LAYER PROGRAM (NSBL)

1. NOMENCLATURE

Program Symbol

CP

Math Symbol

* DET.FTA 6(rj /p)

DELSTR 6*

* DHDX 3I/8X

♦ DHDY ai/ay

' DMUDY öti/dy

DQ dq/dy

DRDX 'di/bx

DS AS

* DUDX 3u/ax

* DUDY 9u/9y

* DUDYL (au/a.y)

* DVDY dv/dy

DX Ax

Description

sj^cific heat of air at constant pressure, 60Ö6

boundary layer thickness

increment in boundary layer parameter

boundary layer displacement thickness

derivative of total enthalpy

derivative of total enthalpy

derivative of viscosity

derivative of the heating rate

derivative of three-dimensional flow parameter

increment for stagnation region problems

derivative of velocity

derivative of velocity

velocity derivative at boundary layer edge

derivative of velocity normal to surface

incre^rnt in x-direction

Units

2 2 ft /sec -0R

ft

ft3/slug

ft

ft/sec

ft/sec

lb-sec/ft

3 Btu/ft' -sec

ft

1/sec

1/sec

1/sec

1/sec

ft

* Those symbols marked with an asterisk are arrays (tables) in the program. Throughout this document, a subscript i on either the program symbol or the equivalent math symbol indicates that reference is being made to the i^1 position within the array.

1%

Page 196: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

Program Math symbol symbol

DY Ay

* D2HDY a2i/ay2

* D2UDY a u/ay

ENDX xf

* ENTH i

EPS e

EPSY a«:/ay

* ETA n

* H i

* PR a

* PRESSURE P

* QP q

QW %

QQW QQW

R r

E

* RHO P

SI

STARTX

* T

*TAU

TAULP

Description

increment in y-direction

second derivative of total enthalpy

second derivative of velocity

final value of x

static enthalpy

eddy viscosity

derivative of eddy viscosity

similarity parameter

total enthalpy

Prandtl number

pressure

heating rate

heating rate at the wall

heating rate at the wall

thiee-diroensional flow parameter

universal gas constant, 1716

density

initial value of S for the calcuiation of 17

initial value of x

temperature

shear force

local laminar shear force

Units

ft

2

1/sec

i /sec-ft

ft

,2. 2 ft /sec

lb-sec/ft

lb-sec/ft"

u2/ 2 ft /sec

lb/ft"

/ 2 Btu/ft -sec

2 Btu/ft -sec

2 Btu/ft -sec

ft

ft7sec2-0R

2 4 lb-sec /ft

ft

ft

0R

lb/ft2

lb/ft2

187

Page 197: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

Program Math symbol symbol

TAULW Tw.L

TAULY 3Tl/ay

TAUTP rT

TAUTW TK.T

TAUTY dTT/dy

TAÜW \

THETA e

TURBS 3TT/3y

arL/ay

* U u

* V

X

XI

*XMU

*!

M

Description Units

2 laminar shear force at the wall lb/ft

3 derivative of the laminar shear force lb/ft

2 local turbulent shear force lb/ft

2 turhuient shear force at the wall lb/ft

3 derivative of the turbulent shear force lb/ft

2 shear force at the wall lb/ft

boundary layer momentum thickness ft

ratio of the turbulent to the laminar shear force derivative

velocity in the x-direction ft/sec

velocity, v" in Volume I (Appendix C) ft/sec

coordinate tangent to the surface ft

initial value of x for the calculation of 17 ft

2 absolute viscosity uf air lb-sec/ft

coordinate normal to the surface ft

Subscript notation:

Subscript

e

i

I

L

o

T

w

evaluated at the boundary layer edge

evaluated at the i^ position within an array

initial value

laminar

initial value

turbulent

evaluated at the surface

188

Page 198: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

2. METHOD OF SOLUTION

a. Forward Integration

In the following discussion, the equation numbers in parenthesis refer to an appropriate equation in Appendix C of Volume I. The equations solved by this com- puter program are the equation of state (C-3),

p - P/(RT)

Continuity (C-17),

1

au. 2u. 1 1^

ITy ' Ay

2 /I ap 1 dri iu i +

i \p ax r axi ap^ _a_ / au i

" ax ^ ay v ay;

aTn

a>

ip ay (a ayj

dih du { du \ dp + IM * T + U —- ay ay \M8y Tj dx

1 2"i vi-i /av\

x-momentum (C-6),

au = _1_ ax pu

ap a / au \ 1 ^H. u av

and Energy (C-7):

9I = -L A dx pu ay

M ai • / 8u v ai_ u av

In addition, the relationship for turbulent shear stress, Equation (C-39), is required for the computation.

9y I P. 1 ^mi^u^ w 1 m

e di S =ä äy

s!l

Page 199: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

Since v is expressed as a function of input data it can be determined explicitly at each point in the boundary layer at the initial or start position.

The y derivatives in the above expressions are calculated using three-point central differences at all positions except at y = Ay, Since the turbulent velocity and enthalpy profiles change very rapidly near the wall, an off-center method of calculation of derivatives is used at y = Ay.

au\ aV2

1 6 Ay (9u3 -2U4

-6u2)

8 2/ 1

2<V -3u3. -9u2) GAy

With v defined and with u, I and y derivatives, da/dx and dl/dx can now be determined. With the 9u/3x and 8l/8x derivatives determined the u and I profiles at the next station (x + Ax) can be obtained by forward intt ation using:

u = u + x+Ax x

1 ^A =! + x+Ax x

The y derivatives, v, du/dx, and 8I/9x calculations move out from the wall along a line normal to the wall until a specified limit is reached. The profiles are then stepped forward and the calculations repeated.

At each point in the boundary layer, a similarity parameter TJ is calculated as indicated below in subsection b., item (4). A value of V max is an item of input used to limit the calculation in the y-directions, which are to be printed out.

Also calculated at each station x are the displacement and momentum thickness, heating rate, and the laminar and turbulent shear stress at the wall using:

6,

Ü >■■ i i'-Ä»

/ o - i6 L£L./i-iL

0 KUel V dy

1 The notation x0 will be used throughout this section to denote the initial value of x.

190

Page 200: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

i fö\ ai si \ =-778 y [pU87+PV37-UT dy

6' _?J1 üü ^L M a 2 + "57 3y ■X dy

The heating rate and shear at the wall are calculated by an integration over the boundary layer rather than from the definitions because of the greater accuracy which can be obtained with the equation.

b. Numerical Method of Solution

The purpose of this section is to give the procedure used in solving the partial differential equations defined previously including the required numerical approximations.

The following variables and tables are input. Tables are indicated as functions of some independent variable, e.g. P = f(x) indicates the table of pressure as a function of x.

u = f(y) at x

I - f(y) at x^

ar ax

au 9y

P - f(x)

r = f(x) w

= f(x)

= f(x) e

In addition, the following quantities must be specified:

Ax Ay T) max f

191

Page 201: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

(1) Calculation of tabular values

x. - x. , x. , - x.

l+l l X. . - X, l l-l X. - X. i+1 i i i-U x. , - x. ,

i+1 i-l

i = 2, 3 (NP-1)

= 0 ap ax

i=l

(2) Values obtained from tables (linear interpolation)

P = f(x) (|^) =f(x)

9P 3x

f(x)

r - f(x)

v^f.:)

i =f(x) w

_ar ax -f(x)

(3) Computation at initial x = x

y. = (i - 1) Ay i = 1, 2, 3, .... 200

u. = u._1 + (-|ü) Ay i = (LIST + 1), .... 200

I ^IST

LIST = number of input values in u and I tables.

T. = (I " u /2)/Cp

-8 1/2 Ji. - (2.272 x 10 T. )/(T. + 198. 6)

p. = P./(1716T.) ii r

C = 6006 ft2/sec-0R

i -2, 3 200.

192

Page 202: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

(4) CalcUi. tion cl 6^

S fl\ , A 3/5.4/5 [p) ~- <ue r Ay "e )/S

S = SL^pu ur x- initially. At x + Ax

= o u u r Ax x+Ax e e^e

(5) Calculation of y-derivatives and v-profile

3v

9y

•m Ay

3^

9y

Mi+i - Vi 2 Ay

du i 1 T- =7T-(9uo -2u^ " 6uo) oy 6Ay v 3 4 2'

A ay

il 9y

ay

6Ay 2("4-3u3-9u2)

6Ay <9I3-2I4-6I2-Il)

2 6Ay' 2^4-3I3-SI2 + 5V

j =2

8u Vi - ui-i 2Ay

ai 'S?

^1 - ^-l 2Ay

a2 o u u. + u. , - 2u.

i+l i-l i

v 2

^y

193

Page 203: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

82I

I. +1. -21. i+l i-l i

ay = M.

32U

'»y2

IE 9y

3u

: 9y

.833 . 12

= .054

L 'L

?) ©ft)©, Ay 2

T' = T T T 2

^rVi^^i^i-i)«^)-?

i = 2, 3; . . ., MIN (j, 199)

The edge of the boundary layer is defined by j = i at which the following criteria is satisfied:

Ay 9u aui

9y" 9y| eJ < .00001 —%?- < .00005 I 9y

The following are calculated for the range - < i < j

T = r - r T. T . T . i ii lj

T =7' - T' L. L. L.

i 'i lj

T - T - T i L. T.

i i

T = - T' - T' 1 T . L .

'J 'J

194

t. - TT /(9U/9y).

Page 204: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

v.833 , 12 "#)(Mm-'0 (3u/ay).

dy a2i

9y ay ^y i

2Ay (Ui+l Vl " "i-l Vl'

• • /dq qi = ^-l + W

i-l dy ) 2

T,.™ , 2/I d- 1 dP\ PART 1. ="- u. (- ^- + r=r -T-)

i \ r dx P dx /

= _1_/^L| + ^T _9P| \ i p.u I 3v 3y . OX . J

PART 2

1 dq I 1 PART 3. = hr1 + (u- , T. - u. , T. ,)hTT-

i P.u. dy . v i+1 i+l i-l i-l' 2Ay

PART 6. = u. i i

2v- i A i-l 9v

i-U

v. = i 3u 2ui

^y

PART 1. + u. PART 2. i t i

(I - "j /2)

-— (PART 3.

- u. PART 2.) - PART 6. i i i

9y = 7^^ -v^J -

3v Av v i i-l' #)

i-l

195

Page 205: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

(6) Calculation of x derivatives

ax „. „ i 3u

= PART 2. ä- 1 U. oy

l I J

31 ax = PART 3. —i^-

i u. ay i i

(7) Calculation of ö*. fl, Qw, TW L, TWJT at x

J 6* = Ay ^

2 1 -

p.u. + P. , u ri i i-l i-l 2 p.u.

J J

A J P.". / "A P- , u- i / u- i\

2 ^ p.u. ^ u./ p.u. V "j /

% 778 ^ « 9I

i i ax ai

+ pi-i Vi T* i-i

ai + P.V. -5- ri i ay

ai + ^i-i vi-i ^

i-i - (U.T. -U. , T. )-r— v i i i-l i-l' Ay

QQ = ^Sv 778 '

1 Ay

ova

M1 2

Tw, L " TLj

T = - T' w,T TTj

(8) Calculation of u and I-proflles at x + Ax

ai Wx-Vax Ax

d"\ A U A = U + -r— Ax x+Ax x 9x

'x

} i = 1,2 j

196

Page 206: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

ui =UJ

1.1 = I, ■x+Ax 'x+Ax

i = j+ 1, j + 2 200

c. Stagnation Region Calculation

A slight modification to the previous discussed procedure is used to obtain stagnation point profiles. Input profiles are corrected by integrating the u and I profiles, but x (not equal to zero) is not increased during the integration. The profiles are assumed correct when

W. x < •1 "LIST for a11 i

This convergence criteria is obtained with the velocity similarity stated below.

/au\ u a / e \ _ _e 9u \ dx)~ u ax

91 e

8x = 0

Experience has indicated that an enthalpy profile convergence criterion is not necessary.

For the stagnation region, the equations for the velocity and enthalpy profiles are changed to

I =1 +^ i,S i,S-AS ax

AS

i,S au

u + i,S-AS ax

AS x + AS

o

If ![ or uj become negative for some i, AS is halved and the case is restarted. This may be repeated a maximum of two times for any combination of Ij or uj < 0.

Additional input quantities are AS and MITR.

MITR is the maximum number of iterations that the program will make in trying to converge on a solution to the stagnation problem.

197

Page 207: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

AS is a pseudo length similar to Ax. The program also uses AS as a test to determine whether the stagnation point calculati i is to be performed or bypassed. For a flat plate case AS = 0,

Calculations for a hemisphere may be performed near the stagnation point and also along the surface. This is accomplished by the input of AS > 0 and Ax > 0.

3. INPUT-OUTPUT DESCRIPTION

a. Data Input Preparation

Data are input through the medium of IBM cards. The purpose of this section is to define the required inputs and the form they take on the cards.

A sample data sheet may be found at the end of this section. Use of this type of form greatly reduces the amount of effort required to obtain results from the non- similar boundary layer program. The data may be keypunched directly from the form.

All cards except cards 1 and 4 must be keypunched with decimal points and power of ten indicators as follows: if only a decimal point is needed, the number may be punched anywhere within the respective ten column field; however, if the power of ten indicator E is used, the exponent must be right-adjusted in the field.

The information on card 1 is alphanumeric and may be keypunched as desired.

The data on card 4 are all integers and are keypunched as fixed point numbers (i. e., no decimal or power of ten indicator E is to be used). Each number on card 4 must be right-adjusted in its respective five column field. For example, if JOT1 = 1 then a one must be keypunched in column five.

1) Data Card Formats

Card Columns Format Description

1 1-48 8A6 Any information may be given on this card. It is used to identify the case.

2 1-10 7F10 Ax, the increment in the x direction. See the discussion on numerical stability in Appendix C (Volume I) for the criteria to be used in choosing a value.

2 11-20 7F10 Ay, the increment in the y direction. Should be chosen to provide at least ten points in the boundary layer for accurate results.

198

Page 208: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

2 31-40 7F10

2 41-50 7F10

2 51-60 7F10

Card Columns Format Description

2 21-30 7F10 ^max' the limiting value on the number of calculations in the y direction.

XQ, the inicial value of x. x0 > 0.

xf, the final value of x.

a, the turbulent Prandtl number.

2 61-70 7F10 CHECK, case dependence criteria. If CHECK = 0 then the current case is not dependent on previous calculations. If CHECK = 1 then the current case is dependent on the previous cade.

3 1-10 4F10 AS, Calculations may be made for a bluLt body. This involves calculating profiles near the stagnation point as well as along the body. This type of problem is indicated by AS > 0 and MITR > 0 (card 4). For nonstagnation point calculations, AS = 0.

3 11-20 4F10 Turbulent Prandtl number - must be equal to Prandtl number on card 2.

3 21-30 4F10 Sj, value of S used to initialize

S = ST + p u v^ x lee I

3 41-50 4F10 Xj, value of x used to initialize

2 S ^ S, + p u r xT lee I

The data on card 4 control the number of values to be input to each of the iuc- ceeding tables. The values must be greater than zero. There is an upper limit on the number of values that may be input to each table. This limit is given with the description of the table. The limit may be changed by altering DIMENSION statements in the program.

4 1-5 1415 JOT1, the number of tabular values in the DJOT and XJOTT tables. 0 < JOTl < 10.

4 6-10 1415 LIST, the number of tabular values in the u and I profile tables. 2 < LIST < 50.

199

Page 209: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

Card Columns Format Description

11-15 1415 NR, the number of tabular values in the three- dimensional flow parameter table (r), the table of its x-derivatives, and the tables of their corresponding values of x. 2 < NR < 50.

16-20 1415 NP, the number of tabular values in the pres- sure table and the table of corresponding values of x. 2 < NP < 50.

21-25 1415 NW, the number of tabular values in the wall enthalpy table and the table of corresponding values of x. 2 < NW < CO.

26-30 1415 NDU, the number of tabular values in the (9u/9y)e table and the table of corresponding values of x. 2 < NDU < 50.

31-35 1415 NV1, the number of tabular values of velocity normal to the surface and the table of corre- sponding values of x. 2 < NV1 < 50.

36-40 1^15 MITR, the maximum number of iterations allowed to calculate the profiles for the stagnation region.

Cards 5 and 6 are used to specify different frequencies of output and the corresponding ranges. The maximum number of values in these tables is 10.

7F10 Table DJOT, assigns value to first, second, and successive printout intervals,

7F10 Table XJOTT, assigns value of x up to which each interval of table DJOT is used.

2 In the case of tables with more than seven input values, the card number refers tJ a set of caris (e. g., if ten entries are made in the DJOT table, then card 5 actually refers to two cards).

200

Page 210: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

Example: XQ = 0.5 and Xf = 1.0, Printout is desired every . 05 (value of x) until x = .25, every .01 until x = .3, and every . 1 until x = Xf. The required input would be:

Card Column Value

m 1-5

5 I

1-10 11-20 21-30

.05

.01

.1

6 1-10 11-20 21-30

.25

.3 1.0

(right-adjusted)

Columns Format

7F10

7

7

7

8

1-10

11-20

21-30

7F10

;FIO

7F10

7F10

Description

Table u-profile = f(y). The purpose of this table is to provide the program with an initial velocity profile at x = x0. Normally, this table must be input and contain at least three values. Exception is made when a case is dependent on a previous case (see Section 2).

This table contains LIST tabular values. The maximum number of values in this table is 50.

Velocity at wall.

Velocity at Ay from wall.

Velocity at 2Ay from wall.

Table I-profile = f(y). The purpose of this table is to provide the program with an initial total enthalpy profile at x = x0. Normally, this table must be input and contain at least three values. Exception is made when a case is dependent on a previous case (see Section 2).

This table must contain the same number of values (LIST) as the u-profile table. The maximum number of values in this table is 50, Entries are assumed to be consistent with Ay.

1-10 7F10 Total enthalpy at the wall.

201

Page 211: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

Card Columns Format

8 li-20 7F10

8 21-30 7F10

9 7F10

Description

Total enthalpy at ay from the wall.

Total enthalpy at 2Ay from the wall.

Table r = f(x). This table contains NR tabular values of r, the three-dimensional flow param- eter (streamline divergence due to body geometry). The maximum number of values in this table is 50,

10 7F10 Table (ar/ax) = f(x). This table contains NR tabular values of {dr/dx). The maximum number of values in this table is 50,

11 7F10 Table x. This table contains NR tabular values of x corresponding to entries made in the r and (dr/dx) tables (cards 9 and 10),

12 7F10 Table pressure = f(x). This table contains NP tabular values of pressure. This table is numerically differentiated for (9P/ax). The first value of (dP/dx) is set to zero. The maximum number of values in this table is 50.

13 7F10 Table x. This table contains NP tabular values of x corresponding to the entries made in the P table (card 12).

14 7F10 Table wall enthalpy = f(x). This table f ntains NW tabular values of the total enthalpy ^ i.he wall. This table is used for nonisothermal wall problems. The maximum number of values in this table is 50,

15 . 7FIO Table x. This table contains NW tabular values of x corresponding to the entries made in the wall enthalpy table (card 14).

16 7F10 Table (9u/ay)e = f(x). This table contains NDU tabular values of (du/dx) evaluated at the edge of the boundary layer. For all problems not involving vorticity (9u/ax) - 0, The maximum number of values in this table is 50,

202

Page 212: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

Card Columns Format Description

17 7F10 Table x. This table contains NDl tabular values of x corresponding to the entries made in the (au/3y)e table (card l(i).

IS 7F10 Table Vw = f(x). This table contains NV1 tab- ular values of the velocity normal to the wall. This table is used for mass injection or leakage problems. The maximum number of values in this table is 50.

19 7F:o Table x. This table contains NT 1 tabular values of x corresponding to the entries made in the Vw table (card 18).

20 NOTE: In all cases where the values in the above tables are zero, a ?ero must be entered on the input sheet.

E>ample: the normal velocity at the wall is zero:

V table (card 14) 0,0 0.0 0.0

x table (card 15) 0.0 1.0 2.0

2) Case Dependence

The NSBL program has a criterion which allows a case to be c'ependent on the success or failure of the previous case. This involves the input CHECK and LIST and the test for ERROR.

If: Then:

LIST CHECK ERROR

0 0 — Not dependent on the previous case, program continues.

0 1 0 Dependent on the previous case which worked, program continues, using final profile from previous case.

0 1 1 Dependent on the previous case which tailed, so present case stops and program continues to next case,

0 — 0 Dependent on the previous case which worked, program continues, using final profile from previous case.

0 — 1 Dependent on the previous case which failed, so present case stops and program continues to next case,

20;'.

Page 213: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

b. Output Description

The printed output consists of the input data and at each printout interval the following are printed as a function of y:

y u q dv/dy v 9u/9x

T T I T) ai/ax e

The following are printed as a function of the x at the end of each printout interval:

K Tw,L

Tw,T

Ö*

9

P 1

ap/ax

QQW

S

204

Page 214: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

c. NSBL Input Form

CARD TITLE CARD FORMAT 8A6 ALPHANUMERIC ANY SPACE 1-48 1

Ax Ay Vma* *o xf Prandtl no. CHECK

AS Prandtl no. «I XI 50 60 70

JOT1 LIST NR NP NW NDU NV1 MITR

mnr 5 10 IS io 25 30 & 40

XJOTT

1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 7 u-profile

8 I'Protil6

9 L

10

11

x

I I I I I I 1 x table

12 Pfwsure

13 x table

14 Wall anthalpy

,K xtabte

1 1 1 1 1 1« Wu/dy)e

! 1 1 I 1 1 17 x table

i 1 ! ^ 1 1 v

Ifi w

1 1 1 1 1 1 iq x table

1 1 1 1 I 11 21 31 41 51 61 71

20Ü

Page 215: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

PROGRAMMING INFORMATION

a. Program Flow Chart

INPUT

X PRINT INPUT j

LOOK UP p 9? cfc 3ul P 5x,r'8x,8y|e

,vw

AS FUNCTIONS OF x

CALCULATE

. dH du 31 d2u a2l aTL 9TT T. T. „

FOR ALL POINTS IN THE PROFILE (»I < TJ^x)

I CALCULATE

de \, TT. T. C.-p-, AO, Q", PART 1, PART 2, PA.TT 3

PART 6, v, |^ , li FOR ALL POINTS IN PROFILE 9v 8x

CALCULATE qw, Tw, 6*, 9

X PRINT OUTPUT

| INCREASE x tYAx j

Pi* 'ax'

LOOK L"?

ox ' w ' 9vl AS FUNCTION OF x+Ax

——" 1 -L

CALCULATE u AND 1 PROFILE ji.T, p AT x+Ax

206

Page 216: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

b. NSBL Program Listing

22022222Pooo:}:>::>:>00<:>000000oooooooooooooooo

»« (O«®«oo(0«oaoaooocoaao»oo<oooooa)ooooa5oooooo<0(aoo<o«ooooocoflac0(0<o<aco

>--J Q^ ox «3 ~~2 z

.^O - lO O - I _J 5< • j -,-(N DO CM > 4" < OUX -

. ~0X^'*UJ a 0 & ^ x x a: x» oo UJ ce 3 ^ tu n « j< IA

OOQ-m-^OV- L0X_l ^-IliArH.ouJUJUJ»- Dxi Q^m^^.n^

^n CM-WX- .<NDD oa:a< a < o a> x < ooo o S « ^ g o -x<^^^T

^9««~^^9 '^<r00000000<0^00000-0000<00irortr,

WU

L'O?

Page 217: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

fM(n-tm'Or-a><>Or-«(M(04-iAor-ooo«o^r^tn^if\«or-{o^O'-«(\i<n-tm^>r-eoo>.o-«fM«*>

ooooooooooooocoooooooooooooooooooooooooooo

co<o<o<X)aooocooooocooocO(OJßcO(tido<0(OcoGOcoo9cocott(DflO(OGoe9<ooocoaocO(OaoeQoo(0<o

M uj a u. X o •- r a: o a x

f- UJ UJ 4- U — z X -Ui I- iOQ

UJ Z (£ -ilü o «a U. N, U. UJ

m o a — • a t- rg 0. O Z ^ »- UJUJ X _j o» u» ^iO • D «-. en -• «no >- o: >-• Q «^ 3UJ • z ^v •* 1- -J D D R-<

— « cc a: O «^ U. UJ X >

JO H-»- m -» — 1 _J DC U. O • Q: a ^i- <a < z x o O • a v m QC a x 1 u) m o ^ rH Q: a: <o 3 ►-« • UJ < • UJ UJ »-I < I oj« 3; X • »- H- rH li. x a a x

ÜJ (/) UJ rH 3 D X i o: «- *0 • I •H rH O *0 1- < X i«J ^ • ^ u. •-• < u Os o o x >. 10 rHO O Ov u>a: to co V _J J r-l • < *0 i/) <-• UJ -x

f\J »- UJ < X -1 UJ UJ UJ rH U) Z 3 »- 03 _1 _J _J UJ ^ < 03 CO GO

< U 2 * t- < < < CO •- •-• O ♦ H- ►- t-

<-• _l X -• * >- ui H- o: i ~ Q >- —. MI

uj O uj m ♦ >. O »H r^ CO _J Z K »o ♦ 3 3 *-- «^ i— -< X 3 •- • * Q O > > Z u. rg t- o: x ^^ X X X X < O " ^ z u vo UJ m r-l ^■ * o t- CK ^v UJ Ovl 10 • rH OJ CM r-l co O a m Z ui • < a • * — • • z o •

• O VJ O U OJ o o o O • o co <N 2: z x u. X X < X I u o II ~ >-> UJ fH o tn r* r* CO 1-1 1-1 it ** I u UJ o — z — «#«•«• W <Bi X ^^ 1-1

f- X cz *~ — t~ >- f- 1- h- H- < r-i «# CO ►- UJ < Q < < < < < < on a« H-

at -• > z UJ z x x z z r o t- H o izaoaocaoraci: O o o ILUJ>DOOUJOOOOOO o: ~J -)

_j<Muu.(x:u.u.u.u.t/.u. a Q X r-« f\j oj rg !-•

r- oo ^ O '-' <o r- o o O iH f4 p-4 f-4 INI r\j r\J eg (M CM CM

UJ

z UJ 3 o UJ to

o e> • Z UJ

• o «-a: >0 II • _l 3 O— O _J W) OIH II < tf) « «• "• U UJ

>• ^ Q: no— u. a

3 < aa * a x H- < * u a UJ »- *

a K H- -i xa u u u o oo -J -J J o XXXi-lf-4f-«if\ X « H H n II II II o MM«.«.» «. M a

« « a a a. a a a a * -i j _i -j _j -j j ♦

a - K ot-a -JXQ «^ *w« *-•

ooo j j _i a X X X iH •-« rl m it n it it it ii )i

■-• CM <n ^ ift «o »»•

a a. a aa. a. a ooo oo o o _i -j J -JJ _i -J

u u u u u u u u u u u

208

Page 218: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

^ift<or-oo<>o«^rsi<n*in<o^eoo»0'-«fM<o-»mi4»f~«oo*Oi-i<Ntn'*«n<or-ooo'>Oi-tr^«n^ ooeocoaooococ*0>(r>OkO»o»0«0»&0«0000000000>-<i-i*<i'>4MMr>«i-4p4^4r4rM(vr>jot

CO<OaOCOOOCO(O<O(OCQOOOO«OCOCO4OflO<O<OCO<OflOCOCOOOflO<8a>aoaOaOOOCOflO<O0OOtf>(OOOCO i,»f«'p-^r-r»i,»r»h"f«»r-r,-r»f,"i*r»r*^f>»r»^r>-h-f»f«r»r»f,«r*f,»r»r"t-h-r,-r«'r»r»f»r»f*

z o

OZQCh-

>-« *■*•<** -»rf

u z 3 U.

u u u OO O _J J J o X X X >H r-l r-l in il II 11 II II II 11

a: * * *

»H rg <n >» m >o r-

a: cc QC QC oc oc oc j j _j _J _i -i j

a: H K- a ae a: -j x a

u u u o o o -I -J _l o x x x i-t f-t -# m

x II II II II II II II

a — * ac o: on oc oc a: ac * OOOOQOO

V — ^ I a. i-t — _j -I -x -I < i»< z JX x z uu u uj OOO

-l-l -J o -J XXXr^>H>-iin X -i II N II N H II II O < «-. 3

* IIIXixi * * _i j _i _i _i _j _i ♦

3 3 1- O O 3 _l X Q

<J u u OOO -1 -1 -1 X X X -• II II II II

r-l II

o M «ft II M

r-« r*i «*» .* IT» <o P~

3 3 3 3 3 3 3 Q O O O Q Q Q _l -J _l _l _l _l _J

u u u uu u U U VJ u u u c;

L'O!»

Page 219: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

m-or-o30«Or^fM<n4,'n^r-ooo»Or-if\j«n4-m>or-coo»Oi-«<^<n^iA^>^ooo>0'Ht><cn>t«A'0

aocooococoaoaococoooaoooooaooocoeoVfioaocococococoaocoiOoocOfiOflOaocococBCOVcooocDQ} r-f-t»r-t*r«»r>-r»r»f-t»r»f>»'-r»r*r>«r»r*r*r*r»r-r*t*»*r»r,»r,»h'^r»^r*r*i*f*r»h»h-^'K

x

a

> -I

o J X II

> -* X >

uu o o _J _J x x n ii

> > -i -i

— »-»«MM > www

* -• « > * -J

u u

u I

cc a

•> X o z UJ •

— X ao t- • oc

II h-

• • — X <- <

UJ < _J I- • f- UJ r-« <-* • + »- >• X — Q Q .—. • "s r-« X X r-IQ Q

OtM ~ z f-lf-trHtn • rH K UJ II II II H lO • H- II max 4- «n >o f- «- < H- wwwwQQHO ^|fHt-«<-«<<«/)Z > > > > UJ UJ 11 UJ -j-i-i-nraex-i

> z

Q Z

a z

to o 00

CO

— CO — »- « H- o ^ O -) M

• eg • <v « ~ ■ MM f- -« M • w UJ —

-« l-H _J

a — • •- xo Q -> z • UJ (M • N X« H •

< •-« H «-

» I— X o < -) X X < •

a: z

v) t0

o X "1

a o r- < • • t- o m «o a f-4 w •i co n

•-«»- ui vo u o z ac< x -> -■ HUJ _J x i- zoc

to m M «

>- (- m M M «- ^- I-- •-}•»• »-»-H XQfM~ — O O "■' Q <-• in »i i-« O ->-)——-. — rjww«o OX<HrM<^4- • 3 I ♦ — — OOOOOJ-» — t-t — -'fNjrijMojtrt'~-»oo

4|'H'4-H-miA*»«-» — «»t-if>trieo

o ■«■•-< (^ -> Ul UJ Ul Itl M oc rMK-i>-i n aat-KH-H-JOOz M «/)*--JH-<<i-«MMI-»w<<w ^MU. H oujujaocor. üCLLUIUJü.

a

— a: o: — u) a: z z t- _| z • • oc (Q • M »-i • < fH H • <- I— B <—• ►-• ♦-•

M • • «* X • — — >- Q «« i-t ■_< Of v© V M w w X <> CC «*»-►- "- • Q H a cc — —•-*

Q£ Q x m 00 o» O w o o * Z -. — ~. CM fM ♦

« » • ^ tO If» Ifii «f» >"• — UJ

-I CO <

o m 00 00

uj uj a. Q Q O H H Z < < < M M w UJ UJ UJ a: o: u. a: cc a at 3 «••

o >-< 00 CO

L» UU

210

Page 220: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

r»<oo»o>-«cM(n4-i<>>or-ao»Or-ir>ji<t*mtor-aoto>HrM<*t^mtor>a>o\0>-ir>jcn*M«ot» ««0«or<-p»r*r>i<*r»r*r>-r»r»a>cocoaeoa9»cow«oo>otOkOvo>o>o»OkO>OkOOOOOOoo

OO(OOflBCOIOncooOCOO'O4PCOCOaOCOCBCBCOOO(OCO<DCO9OOcOOBflD<BttCBCOCO0O9<Btf9CO

Ui a >.

_i UJ a

UJ o

a. 1

a 3 Q Z

a. z r-« N

a. a -» z z ^ • • i-

>-i •-• a. H n •

tii *»* *^

CD <

u a:

to UJ a: a.

o. x — «. «. > r>- *» — OD fH pH r-l • • • • »o »o

in m — — IH

UJUI a o O »-I- z < < ►-• -i it ui tu o: a a ac ct ?2Z

ÜJ a (NJ _i LLt a ♦

UI «-> -I h- CÜ ^ -. a

< «^, I H- *, | -

X K — tvi + f- Q Q. | K _|M os a z — x IU w • o • --( i o t— oo

O«M ♦ — + a o> UI * || M >4 c* «* «1

< ii »- »~ uj M D e» -I —OK X Q— Z -> 3 MOM«»**»-«» U —iHtHNW— H-Z -J H- _I_I_IH-Z — < aoujuiuiCLOu.

3! — Z ~ X • 3 -I ^Z J « • <

• • • UJ «* M »»

-3 DO oz z • » 1-4

3 O

03 <

< X I- z UJ

<

04- o o

I »-• I -1 - JC -J X X < 3 — XX — ** MP *^ ^w

*» •» o* »^ r-l »-« * •

IT» If» >-• «»

UIUI Q Q K I- <<■-■« ui ui o: a: a a » 3

o •■« • •-« eo • — <• 0* —.- K • •-« w 3

m — ^- CJ eo K3 X ^ SO — — • O X O» —

ui m — — o r~ _J 00 —. * . iNj »-4 CQ 0> r-l f« • *

t- — trv m — >-

>- a ui IU o z a o i- ►- — X w < < •-« •-• t-t o u. UIUJ cc a — o »- a a x 3 >

CO o Os OO

ON

-H > > Z Z • • i-i

•^ H ■ »-«

«O )-4 %M*

00 — H. O» H •-• • »-«> —

o* > x r^ ^ - — •-• • «. ^ Cg

<h rH iH • Os * • <0 — lf> If» «- rH w. — > Ui Z Q Q »- - < <« u. ui ui Q: •-• a oc » m vo eo oo Os Os

<JU u u u u u u u u u u u u u

211

Page 221: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

eSüa0cocococDcocO(O(ODeo<o09<ocO4)co<eo(BflOoeB<oMcocB(O9ncococo<soo<oco(sao r>»j*fh.r<.r-f«»r.t>-i«'^r»r>-r«'r>'r««^i«-i*r*r^t«-r'f*r*-r».r*r*i^r»f*r«-^r*r-f*r>.»*r*r»h.^

CM

u. o« •v I I r-* • &

X

Ui

10 UJ

— u. O •HO a > a a. r a. — • *->■

f* >■ ma. N a. -• _i — -i -i< • < »T

— I •-* ►- <->»- « Z — z •« ai rH •> O > Q -• Z • z «-<

— < I

_i *-• u. o ac a.

<

UJ

> ><

u o

— UJ r- >

— o UJ Ui

2 3

DO — -I — UJ CO > r-t O

• fH «0 o

Ui < t-r oc o »u.

oo

OJ

o < Q Z < to UJ

UJ ac

<

_l < (Q U. <

< < UJ oc

to o a to

t^

* * o Q: a: UJ

Q z < v u UJ I

in in r>i (M • • o o ni rg • • o o nj rg

o O H H a: auj

ÜJ OH-

(X o a: o: ÜJ

io L. U.

0* »H

ni

O a: UJ

tO

tO

* o oc cc UJ

UJ

CO >n CM

m

en r- m o 0« eg

O

tn

CM O

-.o —

a o _J Ch

i-i tn — o» a. o o _i ~ • r-i

X I

rsi

ON

O CO a:«o «oo • < — oOD<o

a K K ii » — — H a ojujaoa-^toQ-oo NO UJt-O»-Oc0t0_l — X-i — »-"oc a — u — OL o— u.a:Q£OQCQ.a:ii.oau. MXujoui-ia.<->_jo>->

oj en m m nj nj

o CM

OC -J

O X II —

— 00 00 <

OC II -I oc

rg o

0C O" o -I — • <-* X I

-« O CO 00 CO II < •- — '-»-a: ac co N o J— X_i -oc o« (i. o a: u. <-• _j o ►-«

fM CM rl

D O _J n X

CO o< n i- — ii CO -I — >- O D -JO

Ov CO

co

Ox ^• • O»

f- OK

co • • »«

CO — CO 0« iH • 0» — •*

r-t Ok > <>

I X I

00 O 03 00 — II < — D — I- >-• O CO H > .J — -' -J — »-4 rH — U. > — UU « _i > l-l

oo

uu u u u u uu u u u

212

Page 222: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

o>^rij«n4'>n<or^a}0«o^cM<n4-m<or>-a>o«o<-4(Mm'«'in<or-«ao>0'-><^«^^>AiOt>i-<oo«o inminmiAin)nin>nm>o<o<o<o^)<o<o<o«<or<-r>r<-r<-r<-r>r>.r<-ro.r>co«ofloaoao<oao«o(0«oo>

^f«»r»r«i»-t^t*f^f,^r-t«'f»-r»r>-i»-f«f*f*^r*f*f-r»r-»»K^r»r»r»r-r*'i,»r-r»- 40 CO W 4> «B (0

CO

Q >

UJ

»^ •-• UL * *i^ X O * >- »- ♦ 10 a tO Q »-* «M UJ a V X >. ♦ _J «o m IO * M > • •

a f — a: u. ♦ r-i U rH — U. « o • * 1 V ♦ « o «•» a (O

o — ♦ — T a UI -) r-t o» • —.f- UJ M> > 'W

00 >- fM M * D D _i •-* D 1— •Q V, — • -J Z < »- X V.

^ ♦ CM •- o < X M < X ON _J * * r-l > * >- > * rg oo >- * ooi>» »-4 -* -^ >- ■•«

• Q — OrH -I -) z !-• »^ QC a i- •H 3 M | - < »» ■-< o UJ *

O O» O w UJ V M D O DO Q 0£ * O 00 > -•» U rjul •- * Ui to -i CM — — — X X * (NJ — h- 1 I-LO M ä > m x X >- ••-••-■-• X DC > *^ r-l

• >•■•*' r* IS) ~ fMLiJ z -> < ui o Q Q .-> l-4~> w «. u N X -) •** -H Q ►- | »-< - .(K MM w to on a. Ü£ D i-( li D I >- UJ < > It * U) —! _l «- rgo. uj O a. a O Q w — n n ii »-« -i UJ h- z: o D II ft MM.* N^ X II II D UJ X o n it II R > D < O < Q II _

"•v- -i D x w Ä— a; H- oc t- UJ > oc > > «n a ^ M M M UJ UJ Z _l n H- Z < •-I

m i N i u tl U i—t t—* »-^ 3 * > to II t0 to M UJlA > > •—§ D a ÜJ 11 l— w ^ 1-^ ^« M« «^ *■*> <"» w — t— a. M (^ t/)XUIX>-UJ>(MUUJUJ«/)l/> »- U 8 II •-< UI O O V

n M <» H I-» « DO Z X W) § UJ a > a cs > to > > > DO Z -I O O -1 n n c> o« — Ü. — %* — ZI O o H CK a to o: D vn r-l O to to 10 T X O < _) o o ui I»« -> > Q>- v<->3x»-xa:u VJ 10 _J Q.oa:OQ(n>ODXt-xa:u u z Z Z Q z z a 00 o •H kA f\ 4- o 00 o» o> o» m (fl fM

«0 00 Ch <> U U U «J u u uu u

213

Page 223: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

0'»<M>0v0»(hO0«OOOOOOOOOO>-i-4r-lf-l^t-l>>«»4r4iH(MC«r«<>«(M(M<MrM<M(M(n<nm

<DCSCDS<OOB<DCOCOCOOO<OCOCOCS<OCOCO0aO(DQ<O(OCBCOCDCO<OCD<OCO<p(OIO to <& <D ao co <0 oo

CM r-l *

3

w * • • « ♦ CM CM en >- N. >«» «n >- Q >• >- CO O «v a a • N. • * * ♦ • -O mm *«"• -»* * vO CM «^ >-* -. -,< •> >- -^ * — •mm «.-•»_ «w a — * — CM CM > w w ui KM V.—• >-r^ * « Q >- V _J w —. B »^ Q — * * D -J ►- UJ D >- >0 — N.I >>• a D D Q X Q v X • * OQ • < < ♦ X ♦ — 1 a> • V.'v »- ►- — >s. • — —. vin »• mm. 1-4 ♦ + — *» (M <M fM —> +• *********. «■V -« — fH n« <—• ********* >■■>-—*•* > •-• «H | «• ^ D X CM CM a a o 1 1 — > •• * * —— * ♦ DX D *-i •—» ■^#

* »-• • • DX • • * * X o *M —1 « <o * « CM CM • • o — >- >- X •I I 1 1 • • >-'<-» CJ IM "f « _! i- o: «•^ •■* ~ o O Ov ■V >» 1 1 ^ *•«' 3 D + D — <t -t 1 1 <««>»«>, *^ >- < < — ♦ D •^r -^^ -^ ^^ *» — »-» »H — J 1- 1- •- r» «n ^» Z <-« D X cncn ^«-«11 V D en en

o ►^ X o ♦ * — 1 1 <->« Q < + + o • •*• l-t «^ 1 o • • DX ^4 •>« «^ «M» D 1- 1 r- • tn O •* in eg <M ♦ ♦ • DX fM * r-« 1-4 Q£ en vn • I rH * 1 1 • • D I t + Q — 1 1 - • f-i en en o oc + o —» »-. CO f-» 1 1 --<. ♦ "-> « « + en 4- <* 4- •» rg — •♦ o en en -f + — -» ,-t r^ •-* «^ IMf <M^ *-* 4> • • 4- • tn * * •» o «»*««««» •H ^ + + •-'«/> Q. Q. •-• < 4 in * O

x • o •* ♦ D tr> D X >* •* + ♦ -«• «- ID -J »- 1 •-• ~ <A<0 O <* o o Oift - X * ♦ * ww »»• M «#* «^ D OC D D -< a: «• • • en 0, • • • <M z o — X o • ^ DX DX X D << - UJ -> 4- m 4- — o o o o <n • • w <^ o Ot Ot ~_ CM D X —— X 1- 1- H- < \~ «- <<> <4> • -* H II H N ~ CM 11 — n o — — (1 II O -» -* 11 II II H 11 II H- •-4 D OH •«•««««« • » Q. UJ IÜ N -»»- »» m tu ii ii — — OLU II II — — UJ -» — «~ -«■ UJ Q: + — — en u) fHr^^lr^OOODO*^ ^4 N^ Nfc >-« *■» 3 — — CM CM ^ 3^ ^.«„ 3«« « >-< H u ^* ** «^ ^ •-*

^1— *.ww|| IIOZO*Z «^ *■* ^» CM Z «M CM —-' 2! *-* »M *-» »»• Z ~ - «^ w <^. MMM _| ii>->-ü.a-* — -i *H rH ** o«^ -> > 1 w «* V >- >. o <-——>- >- •-<>->- a. a. •-• a: «• v w .« | a-JH_iKfHfHZt- II 1-4-CQ«- a *** 1- >• >• QO l-^->->-QQ^-_l^-_^^-— o « D X »- X « ODD D D z o z o: H-D •» ZQ O DX ZO ODI Z D D D D < oc 0<<<<Oau.OQOOD- XU.ODXcM<MOODXCMfMO<<<<»- a: ^ U. U. U. li. u. »JI-l-H-t-OO« u zuo»- ♦ o Ml UQ a Qo ouacoou»-K •- h- UJ Ul ^ « —««<-l

o o o t-t CM •-* m i«» rH en o 1-« CM o O o en <n en 4- ■* en tr\ m o o

m o »n

< JU u

4

214

Page 224: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

<n'*,iA>or'~<DOkOr4r4t«i<*m«or-cootOr-ir<jm<t'iA<or>aaoto>-4cM(n'tf'm<af~<ootO'-iri4(^

<0 40 CO <D IO SO aococoaococDcooocosDocoio ><DCOO9(OflO0flOIOfiO0CO<OCO<OflOa><OMflO(O •r*f«-r*r»r*f«*r«f-^»».r-r>-f-r»r«-r«r-»^»,»r-

4"

o lA

o o o o • I

o

>fl v) O -J-J n II o

m

u. o a

ÜJ

z

o 3

m o 4- I • •* — O 4«

»o m 3 O ft ^ 4- -*^ ~ <0 I 1-4 * •-•

a <r 3 8^

1-2 Z ^

in o o o o • I

m -^ 4--< 0 — mi

♦ * • —*

C4 — 4-1 -» • 1 >-•

4 4 <o

o 4 *

-> O Z 4in * -« + «M <-•">•-• a z»- ii a

z o

4 4

u. u. u. »HZ — •-• II Z<^0 M -) w OO

4

»

4

o 4

OUJ o iu 43 Q3

z zz (Mü 43

Z o »^

H il-)wOO Z-Z-"- z <-<U.U.-)«ü.O-JOOU.OII »oo Z»-»-«ZZ»-»ZZOf-»»-iU^->OU

o o a o z z N II "> w

10 Ui >

< > •Ml

a

UI

3

u

uu u

o»-» r<-4 04 «n m 4 m <o o 4444444 4 4 4 4 >0<0«00«0<00 "Ä <ö

in m

UJ 3 -> Z N

^8 O _J u z

4

a »- 3

-> a • »-

(M 3 « <

•-• K- 11

Ov *"■» 4 ►-•

4 »- 3

O < Q »-

a — _i — 3 — •«f l~ ►- 3 I <

— »- >- +

a -• _i — 3 _) < 3 t- < K t- Ui ^ II 3 K «^ Z

u u u

3 3 Z < < o »- ►- u

4 o 4

0. — _l <-i 3 — < >- t~ Q I 3 - Q -> V

a. -> ■-

3 (Si I- < M 3 i- M <

J H- M O B ^ 4- —

»-4 O i"^ ^» ft^ %^ 3 10 < o a i- o ui

215

Page 225: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

r»h>r^roror-«ooofl»oooocQa:<Dcosok<h<ho«OkO«(>(h(hOkOOoooooooo>H^l-ir4*4<-i

co<Q««)oi><Q(»<o«a>«e«a>«oa>o««fl9<OA(O<oao<scofloa»flOco<o<o<o«o9flOo>co0tta>co

a: oc UJ Ul *~ t- z z. 3 3

«» o o ■-» yj u rH z z 1 bl UJ

* 1-4

*» «tf «o UJ *• D ■^ < < •^ < «^ s X «# t- * >- * * X 3

->• CO ^* -»^ «Q. tH tm ÜJ Ul — Ui 1 «• > > >- + - M< 3 ►t

QÄ>- •-» 1 1- 1- 3«Q D r«a m < < o — >. "» 1 f- fVI * 13 o "V^ • X — a: * UJ Ul -~>0 rj O ^i < — • ^^ i Z z -3 "% a ♦ a «o 4- »■.

«Z — Q « ♦ K- ra to * < < «.Q - • - -a: Q * >--"-• - D « < • + * I I Q + 1 M < — a -» X * u u 3-.« ■^ h- D 1 — f\* 1- * a: — a: — CM«-» — >- * + — rH oc * < <o ♦ < <<> Q - 3 • H- — — -< «NJ I m < UJ • Ul • ♦ >< rsi 3 r-i — 1- 1- •-• «» 1- oc CO CO K toeo — O K >v -~< + r-»a: a ^ 1- o o li. O b. -X ♦ >• i0>- •- 1 << >- tO «* a z QC Z ^ rg — O IO * *- ^•Q, a. o »« »— •"• N. ae O II K O II ü>0 ^ ♦ UJ — D — -' * > ►«• l-< -1 X LU -• m Ul I-I to a * i <» (£ M v >• * —o ^ ^ ^* f- t- a l-Q UJ •» M — a — + o — « 1 >- > 3 o: z < z <c

1 —' "*%.> — > v OQ * < »-I z a •-4 z a — ►-13 •^ X_l *-• o o :D — 3 X rH »- o z oz M - | O Q 3 - + V I ^ QQ • to V) < « to < « — «) — oa < o >■ — tn I ♦ * 1 %* ta4 1- CO •-• »- VO >-a ^ •f OH- Q O •^ h- — «• Mi * tO 3 «03 -IÜJ + ~ + — « v. ~ a — »--« »^ O X 2 3 D + « ^o:* ♦ -. 3 < > *-» «a^ tn X U) O UJ Z o UJ z < - w 1 N.— — ^ * a. i 33 * «* o «O Q r*- J I <- r- _i I - »-- 3 ft X •■* »4 I • v 'v o K« IA O ♦ out 1- < OUJ 1- < • w < ^# Q *^ •«* _ INJ >* >-< «>* «>* o W * -» •H oca o ODD O — D »- o a: 3 3 w | •-^ f* o 3 • ■•» •-» h- r-t o < (H o < «X ♦ Q Q >s V > - • > •» <M • 1 ■* ►4 «» • • H- CO Z t-« •1- lO z — X — •— — »^ •-. « M C<J W > > o *» — X O m z a« z rg ^)Z o«z «0 — <-« + ♦-«■--« • — ^v ♦ 1 1 o »^ * I- X Q f* f- LU — a: 3 a» r* uj — QJ 3 03 — + -. (M ~ — f^ >- r»j > CJ m o m ** -* OQ 3 • • X m 3 a rH • X «30: oc» « r-l ♦ O O ~ a * a t-i- • •• X »H X o o in U! MO rg <OUJ rHO DO: - 1*11 * 3 * v. a oc ox o -^ -IQ -f r- r-lh- 1- O -J » rHt* »- O -J i-a o i-i —ü: Q: •» o •« • < < mi- 3 1- * + -* ♦ —«•Hl-imrg + ~< »HX -J «n w *x w — •-• v. N. ►i — _«<vi a a. • a Q tO ^ «^ P4 #>. a. rg K • 00 •-• Of^ ü. rg t- • 00 ►-• O II • 1 a ~- • • «- V — H II II LU 0< »4 II 1-» «* «« • 3 1 JO «O 03 i o ~* • 3 1 iO «O CO 3 O -» r-t « 0 3^-« - 3 • 3 '- ~ —3 m»- 10 -J <-i - 3 M rg oa — — f-4 —. eg o a •» >» l-t <-• B i-t ft II H (1 >- II •-• 1 «-• ^^ ♦-* 2J ~«o CD 1 X - Mi >»-J3 ♦ >- UJ I-I v -J3 * KUJ w, -• ^. — fH(\J<nQ«0 H -> •- ** <«- »NH (^ « < ^ i^ iH H II I to n o ♦ UJ < X O ■a. to no* WOO >-«-•>■ «-• I-K i- N.I ^-»y-XKH-QX — -f ««• M ** *^ •» oa. j ♦ I- X i- 3 Q 0. »1 ♦ 1- X >- W- Q — oco; Q: • ac« — QQOZ ^ <«* r-l •-• i-l r4 HS"« l-l £V • w u 3— * «oc • Q.Oia<<<r»i<wi>3ioii.U. II li. II u. o w •« a. (/> o u. « Q:OQOü.IOOU.* £ o o o ujQQOaaa\CL>-QOQu I-« >^ •-« M «-4 ►4 QI3 !■« D J« * » Ü. Ul o i^ Q _) •-■ * 3 U. UJ C9

»H r-t I-« 4i iH * r-l O» <f\ O <t 't IT» O * 4n in iH (M * <ä <0 ■4- O (M N r- ♦ 1» r* r-r^ * r- ft O CO ♦ o * o en <-• .HI

u

216

Page 226: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

4>f> ao<?>Oi-*oj(<\'#in<o^'0O«Oi-iN<n<^in<Oh-cootOt-«rgpt<*in<or<-oo(>o>-<cj(n<*miO

COS00O*0fl0<O<O<Ofl0«0*ÖC8<6<O<0<O<O€0«C>a)fl0SO«0fl0flDWCOW<J099<O«O0500<O<O0OcO(CWCO rk.r<.r»h>r»r>>r»r»r»f«r»r«>^>h>r>f«>r»r»>^ro|«>r»-h>r>-r»i^r^r»r»r<'r«-ro^r«ror«r«>r«>h>r»^

UJ i- < ft — o -> IO 3

-'^ -) K *^ v + o 3 X

1 ~ ■-4 Q£ X — 1 * — Q H- »-« 1 • «* 3 «O w m CM-) Q « X • w *-» — .J cc o * X 3

«» a I - -» v. -» V 3 * o -~ ä -»-> t- ä ♦ .H r^ « w -• U. •H — 1 1 - 3 H-O a* rH •-• «D-s z > 1 ~ < f- * -» >- 3 »3 3 z ^* -Q ♦ •-< — a uj a: rH D X — o

u < «^ * O ^* X UJ QC X UJ

H o

o I rH -«

a h- a. oc | PH — •-• ^* o • < + - 1 >- o — oc m UJ H- • w « Q x - on UJ z -1 rH o - v. o: 3 UJ -1 O

»-4 UJ o >s

X > ~ a ♦ — - 3

z U. Z «•* + — ^» -« >. ** o< rH a • — ^ i «^ **.

CO oc x m z CM M | « D <-< fM O a t~ • rH < V ^. ►» »- * 1 •-* co m •^ X - 3 M «■» taH • x UJ o • _j CM • O O < 1—• »«4 ^» m

CO X ^ Q »H (M -i «• oo XXI- 3 ^ 09 O o> D • M < 3 l- o ce ♦ O 3 1

-1 • »- 00 * X < I» ♦ ♦ ~ I * • o. • Ul en »-• OOI 1 »- • •v — •» rH a —.H _J

eo ai a -« z <-*c* D * 00 «» r-i ■«« t v to* a* 3 oo •- • O Q < —. h- «« «^ «^ •-« 1 -♦ • <

H- -• < UJ •■* «% »- CM K -) D >- - • o -« 00 f- >- — z I a: z (- • « • >— N. ♦ Q O iH £. fH f- 1 — — Q OC UJ — UJ UJ <M <M ^ 3 »* ÜL -I 1 x T o; i r- — ^ ^ ♦

rH »- s m »- Ui -J "SV Jl ♦ • -) ? - Q - o J: ~- -« «V ^ w w QC + « UJ OH. K a. X X < CM • W - * « Ot- + - >- — a. a K o: z i- oo X QO 31 -) V <v -« • o a m < 3 Q a -i H- io UJ 1 < rH _J o + + 1 ^^ > H l-l »M i»- :D 1 _!»- ♦ ■^^ ♦ h- 3 3 _l H- a; t- • TOO u h- X O • Ofc o i-a •^ II ü: - < a UJ UJ -~ r-l X 3 < < UJ

ujf- in ^ »o r- io o> OO Ul • o • <? * O. Ul «—>KOOX«-» UJ -—■ X O < »- f- Q o— »- w w (Q 0\ UJ -)Z Ul oo» a T »• OO D * * O u i- i 3 O »- O H. 1 1 H z ■ H « 1- < _l X UJ H z a: N <-• ^i m «^ ro n - - at « « Z m o l N n o: «ü; *-•« Ul < o ** 1 1 D 1—1 H ►-< N w «H H »« m •-••-• H >- < - »■« X o « « » XH HÜJ — * »- X Z K u. X X 0. H tS> 1- «> o «n •>. »- ^H » vO 1- o K 1- o X J 1- 10 ZK ♦ •-I Q; i-i o *■* *—► 1 Z X -IUJ «■H X •^ z OOOX-JUJXZO II X 3 .5 3 _l o»- u.« a: O o a: U.U. o OUJ x >^ X o «» O o ox - O UJ X cr: o o at o < < < UJ u»-» <-• * :» u. o: c? a « t-l U UOQKON.QOUQQO:-' OQ»- + UOOOl-r-k-Q

* r-i tH rH f\J r^

^ * <n m O 00 fH o o «M * IM O m c m m m

* O rH rH rH

u uu u vJ u u

217

Page 227: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

h-ooo*o>-«cM(ri^u\<or-<oo>0'Hoj(f)^iA<or»aDo*Or-<ni(n^in<or>«o*Oi-i(M(n-«iA<or>a> ■nintft«0'0«o<o<0'0<04»4><or~r>r»f>r>»f>ror»r'»r»eo<Oflooo«coaa<DiDeootOkO«Ok»o>o*Ok9k

<O<OOCOCO<pCOO)<OeC<O<OOO(OCB90CO(O<OaO<OCOCOCO9(OO0OflD<OflOCOWCB<)9CDaOaOCBflO f>»r»-f»r»r»f»r«-r*r^i,-r»r-r*r-r»»*r»r»r-»,»'r-f»r^f»r*i-»»r-rfcr»r»'r*r-f>'r"t"r-f"r*r^t»rfc

3 < OH I- ÜJ

* UJ — X t-« K- «^ • X a Q i- 10 3 W5 UJ Ü _J _J • UJ —* CO •-* Q — m < »^ * CO • •>« w 3 • nj Q: > 1- ■♦ w4 < «k 3 rH UJ > •» < UJ »-« l- to t- ^« • H •-« z

>- 3 UJ a _J X UJ o

X > — 3 Q -J m z • Q ^ < a —t m UJ o. • • 1- X Q u. • Q. co «• r-l * Q I o <M UJ • »* it JB a i- Q: m a f-l *^ M <3 Q • a. * oo I II O * • X fNJ iH X m >-« * »• -~ m to m * o 0» «o r- tn «k 4-« 1-4 ►- • *-« (M 3t 0« 0» 0* o* 0*

~m *-* w co «o i ». .» fNJ UJ 0* 0* o* 0* —* 1* «0 ►-< • t- m « * z • o » • • •»• 3 a. _J * • N fM * f* moo* Mi • UJ «- r^ ae OJ >» — "04 a *^ o — ^ M —o> a

• _l —, * O UJ xo •-4 X X X < X *■* ^1 -• •> i-i -» • —. P"« M »- —» •■» ou. uj O J _J — UJ o f-t • <H «n • r-t r* — * ^ tO •-« *— I^I a: ii o • -f ~- w • a: * w o - 0* <i) — o* •-* m >• UJ t- > «» *«• — 3 tO — »- t- (M • »^ a o> a o» ■—o* oc o» — 0» Q _l « ■» K — 'OO oo — II X o 0>s Q MUJ -10» o -0* Q 10* * (O *» •» » Q «O OI <00 ^ _l-) -»x z + z • _i — ^ -J — _J < < O »-4 tNj I o oct o «OtO — o CO < tn •M X •- • i-t «- — • iH • — t- ** >H <H i-l a C4 Csl NX O K + 4 + (J h- 'i X 1 QC^ XI X -l Ui QC • •> •> * • • I • »n fviX H h- K-X X z + (D -J 1 — - 1 X < -Ö «0 vO -> <o «o r-- >o CM •m O O <*■ OQ 1—• X < •>* O CD CO • —OCDOO ai «-> O K > •» v «~ ^H ^* — «0 •«* >' «o— T ~) m r-l '•»r a. »-H-Ot-OD II <- OXCOH <wO<00 II N «» h- H — 1- X X + ;< Ui D M oc II H — -~»- a H—.-.*»>_oc)||_w-. < (- UJüJUi<liJUJ<üJ<UJ< 1 HO X * 1 u>< — (/)a OO H Q — CQQ: oo II Q -« II i co t- z t- t- H- ►-»-KZi-s:»-xx»->»-«jk-K a ujK«D«/)-J~x-ioo<-) — x_ia> — -j — UJ >-• N« M *-< UJ •-• «o: -• o: «es — O II o- UJ X </) « Ui «- a o ^ wj-^otO — — f-»«-3 X a: ae a: a: • a:a:Oo:OQ:ou.->ox TÜL •- •-« II a. K u. o a. u. QC rtU.Q0:u.X«-U.O K a. 31 ji 36

l-l leu. 3ru. 3U. •-• X O _l X«' to »- X -JO. « _J o •-• ja^-iQ-t-Ji«-«-!

m >o o rH eg <n ■* CM «* o «n o o* m o

o IM

o CM

o (M

m •A C4 o ^« N O* O •H M (-4

u u u u uu

218

Page 228: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

0»o<-<(vm<riA<or«'eDOkO»H(M(n4'm4>r»«eOkO>4C4(n'#iA<or»cQ9>0'-«<V(n<tf'in<or«-flBO» 0>OOOOOOOOOO'Hr4i^i>4^>4«4r4f-|p4M4MN(^(M<MM4MMCMl«>««tfn(nmmm!«)|f|<n

UJ -I

u. o tt a 3E UJ Z

«0

00 Ov ^

• 0> o> • I» o

—.O CO

l-l • ■*» »H «•• l-l • DO» -■* Q0> r-10» J ><> • — -J — Xfi • <-• — I X J 03-* -- < CO O 00 00 K» M < — ■ 3 —»- ^ _JO «O N > >-_l — "_! Q -• i»l •-• «» DU. >-U- O«-« _i > <-•

o« ^- o

a O o -^

O

<

UJ

uj a -i ♦ DO OJ < ♦ a: at < ♦ > —

2 D Ul * Q — Z -> UJ w CL D UJ z Q X I * K «•

-J UJ — >o O X z Q:

o H V)

CO 00 o o

CO o

o • MOO • o

oo * o —

NO

oS

a

TV —

it — I z

a ♦ 4- X «. CO w -. OI

a

>- <M Ox DOI O* '

« i

^«D I I

D » li O

D- Z

N — M -

•f»

■A

• <»

♦ -I ♦ -

«• •

♦ •-• oo r- o^ l -

UJ v OJ tO f» I/) ra UJ • oc

rg a H II

OU. o«

o CO o

u. -

o oo oo

•*■■• o *»• D OI

<*> «0 o

-.*. u. DH •«

D O X X

UJ o> D M z - o I- t- z o a

ae o »- — < ~ — « ,0 U^tncn-*—.^ — "• IHOIHO^OM tn fM <o O •>o*kO*p*>o«*>o«*ot*o» z ^ o <o o^> o <0 ch <o o« <o (h o (h

a ui o UJ OUJ o UJ o UJ OUJ o UJ o QC l-4*4MM 1-4 M« (^

o:oo:OQ:oa.'OQ:oo:oQ:o xo»aso»oxu)3toaia UJ

CO o

<n 4 oo r4 O »H

in o «n ^ m w> Ch o* o» »» ©>

uuu u uu u

21^

Page 229: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

Ortoi«n4'in«roao(hOrirMm-4>tf\<or»aoo»OF4N<t^iA<or«ooOkO>-iM<n4'in<or»a»(AOf-i

tniÄiAiAiAiniAinmintnmiAinu>ininiAinti\i(\ininmmi(\iniAiAtAiAtAmininiAminmii>iAin »-l-l-»-»-»-»-»-»-»-l-H-»->-l-«-l-»-l->-»-»-»-t-l-»-l-l-»-»-l-K»->-»-l-»-l-l-l-l-»-

CQaOCO8><D(0cOOOCOCOCOCp(OaO<D(O<OCOlO0COflOCOCOCOncO<DtQ<O<O4OCO<PCOO<OflO4O8><O<D

3 < <

X a Q

X Q

O

>-

X > — • cm

— • *

ti o »<

UJ * a

•» UJ — -I > «-• • UL - O -. a

>- a -j

x > -^ < • Q ^ •-•

— • 5^ K 00 -»••-.

II l-t

— 11

- 3 »O ÜJ • Q. _J —UJ

O

UJ a:

I—< W M Q

— O O— — —X 0« O r-lO^tMO OrH

<-■ II UJOUJOUJUJUJUJ — (XOUJ K.|-HH-h-l-HI-<0»-t- •-* *4 i-^ I-* *«••-« J— QC •—« Qfoaiooicifuiaujaoa: XOat03t3t3E3 • UJ o at

w < X a i Q

>-

(M 1-4 iH •> •

UJ UJ — (— t- <

a: a: UJ 32 •

X Q

Ul

< UJ a: u ui o

o o

o o

o o — -f en >- I QC

>- I- OC Z I- H z >- — oc u. *-

UJ

u. o o: a.

r«J o o

X i-« o • • m > o ac o

z

X <

o o

ui

o

UJ a:

OC W UN. 10 »- < II (/) X • UJ -•

a »- t-'H UJO OK _J a OCOONZUHM» p >-ll",)X'-«X«0QtU. O w>XX_Sh-QQ3lM _J

UJ > > »0 «/) UI X DC

4-a.

.-e U) _1 UJ « a

a.

> X o

OUJO n > H Xü)X aocQ ü. it a

o o «M

9» r- oo <>

O 0* o» o o

o o o

o o

f\j «n o o oo

UI > iH

UJ> > H V) — 10 tH 11 '» to >

N -' >—i UJ

> 4-40 03 O II

o - 03

u u o u u u

220

Page 230: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

oj <n ■» IT, <o r* «o «o <o CD oo o « CO in «ft «f» in «n IA in I-1- i- ►•»- h- t- ^ ^4 rH r-l >-l fH >-• Ofl» CO (OCB « O r» r* ^ t" r* !»• t-

CO co us o o o

— > >

3 O UJLU Z X >> K o: Ui 9> W tfl M n D eg XI- z H H M, » IM O — -"- — »-•- «—3 OZ Q XIO o z XK X OCU O UJ

•♦ o o

221

Page 231: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

REFERENCES

1. Hanks, R. A.: and Savage, R. T,: Thermal Design Methods for Recoverable Launch Vehicles with Consideration of Arbitrary Wall Temperature and Surface Conditions. NASA CR-74714, August 1965.

2. Nagel, A. L.: Fit/simmons, H. D.; and Doyle, L. B.: Analysis of Hypersonic Pressure and Heat Transfer Tests on Delta Wings with Laminar and Turbulent Boundary Layers, NASA CR-535, August 1966.

3. Thomas, A. C.: Perlbachs, A.; and Nagel, A. L.: Advanced Reentry Systems Heat Transfer Manual for Hypersonic Flight, AFFDL-TR-65-195, Air Force Flight Dynamics Laboratory, Wright-Patterson Air Force Base, Ohio, January 1966.

4. Hansen, C. F.: Approximations for the Thermodynamic and Transport Properties of High Temperature Air, NACA TN-4150, March 1958.

5. Hilsenrath, J.: and Beckett, C. W.: Thermodynamic Properties of Argon-Free Air (0.78S47 N^ 0-21153 O2) to 15,000 °K, NBS Report No. 3991, July 1955.

6. Feldman, S.: Hypersonic Gas Dynamic Charts for Equilibrium Air, AVCO Research Report No. 40, January 1957.

7. Logan, J.; and Treanor, C: Tables of Thermodynamic Properties of Air from 3,000 to 10,000 "K. Cornell Aeronautical Laboratory, Inc., January 1957.

8. Ames Research Staff: Equations, Tables, and Charts for Compressible Flow, NACA Report 1135, 1953. " ~

222

Page 232: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

JJNCTASRIFTF.n riU ( 1.. vsij i, .ili-'H

DOCUMENT CONTROL DATA - R&D tirttv l.i-.-ilu .,tv.n -I ml.-, U.tiv .'! .ihslrHt t .«n.J phliJunK .n.ij.taüon muvt *>«■ rnlrr-d vvlu-n t!i>- i>v<*r.Jl rf^ort is < lusst(i»,'i>.

1. ORIGIN*! IMG ACTIVITY l(\,rIN.r.Hi- ..ulii.irP

The Boeing Company P. O. Box SF^S Aerospace Group Seattle, Washington Space Division—Kent Facility 98124

2.i REPOIT SECURITY CLASSIFICATION

UNCLASSIFIED 2h. GROUP

3. REPC- : riTLE

INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT HEAT TRANSFER AT HYPERSONIC SPEEDS Volume III. The Luminar-Turbulent prMr Momentum Integral and Turbulent Ncnsimilar Boundary Layer Computer Programs

4. DESCRIPTIVE NOTES iTvr'-> "' '<T"'t ami imlusivc dm.-M

Final Report. March 1965 to March 1967 5. AUTHORS iKirsr ram-. raiH.ll.- inilial, I.1-.1 nann-

Savage. Ricru rd T. Jaeck, Carl L. Mitchell. James R.

8. REPORT DATE

December 1967 7 i TOTAL NO. OF PAGES

222 71.. NO. OF REFS

8a. CONTRACT OR GRANT NO.

AF33(615)-2372

Project No. 1366

Task No. 136607 ^BPSN 5(61136-62405334)

9^.. OR1 JINATOR'S REPORT NUMBERS

D2-113531-3

9li. OTHER REPORT NO(Sl (Am othrr numbers iVuit may hi- assign.-.I

AFFDL-TR-67-i44! Volume III 10. DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT

This document has been approved for public release and sale; its distribution is unlimited.

11. SUPPLEMENTARY NOTES 12. SPONSORING MILITARY ACTI "T-

Air Force Flight Dynamics Laboratory A;r Force Systems Command Wright-Pattp.rsnn Air Fornp. foifiP, Ohin 4fi4a?

13. ABSTRACT

This report presents a combined analytical and experimental investigation of turbulent heat transfer on basic and composite configurations at hypersonic speeds. The analytical results are presented in Volume I, the experimental results, including data-theory comparisons, are presented in Volume II, and computer programs incorporating the analytical methods described herein are presented in Volume III of this report.

The two heat-transfer prediction methods programmed are the laminar-turbulept Pj.^,. momentum integral method and the turbulent nonsimilar method. This volume of the report describes the numerical method and presents flow charts, program listings, input forms, and a description of the output for each program. The programs are written in Fortran IV language for operation on the IBM 7094.

FORM DD 1 NOV es 1473

U3 4802 1030 REV 7/66

UNCLASSIFIED S. . urit-, fUissili

Page 233: oo INVESTIGATION OF TURBULENT £ HEAT TRANSFER AT … › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 667804.pdf · THE BOEING COMPANY TECHNICAL REPORT AFFDL-TR-67-144, VOLUME III December

UNCLASSIFIED

*£> *CSDS L'^r £

N'onsimilar Boundary Layer

Momentun Integral

Aerodynamic Heating

Laminar Flow

Turbulent Flow

DDINOV651473 U 3 4802 1030 REV 1 ftft

P A R T 2 O F i

JINCLASSIZIEIL SecunlA Cliissifu .ill