Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report...

61
61 ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL INVESTIGATION OF ROTOR HARMONIC AIRLOADS INCLUDING THE EFFECTS OF ROTOR-ROTOR INTERFERENCE AND BLADE FLEXIBILITY By Norman D. Ham Paul A. Madden May 1965 U. S. ARMY AVIATION MATERIEL LABORATORIES FORT EUSTIS. VIRGINIA CONTRACT DA 44-177-AMC-22(T) MASSACHUSETTS INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY ',

Upload: others

Post on 30-Jul-2020

4 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

61 ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13

AN EXPERIMENTAL INVESTIGATION OF ROTOR HARMONIC AIRLOADS INCLUDING THE

EFFECTS OF ROTOR-ROTOR INTERFERENCE AND BLADE FLEXIBILITY

By

Norman D. Ham

Paul A. Madden

May 1965

U. S. ARMY AVIATION MATERIEL LABORATORIES

FORT EUSTIS. VIRGINIA

CONTRACT DA 44-177-AMC-22(T)

MASSACHUSETTS INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY

■',

Page 2: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

...

THIS DOCUMENT IS BEST QUALITY AVAILABLE. THE COPY

FURNISHED TO DTIC CONTAINED

A SIGNIFICANT NUMBER OF

PAGES WHICH DO NOT

REPRODUCE LEGIBLYo

Page 3: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

DDC Availability Notice

Qualified requesters may obtain copies of this report from DDC.

This report has been furnished to the Department of Commerce for sale to the public.

Disclaimer

The findings in this report are not to be construed as an official Department of the Army position, unless so designated by other authorized documents.

When Government drawings, specifications, or other data are used for any purpose other than in connection with a definitely re- lated Government procurement operation, the United States Govern- ment thereby incurs no responsibility nor any obligation what- soever; and the fact that the Government may have formulated, furnished, or in any way supplied the said drawings, specifica- tions, or other data is not to be regarded by implication or otherwise as in any manner licensing the holder or any person or corporation, or conveying any rights or permission, to manu- facture, use,or sell any patented invention that may in any way be related thereto.

Disposition Instructions

Destroy this report when it is no longer needed. Do not return to originator.

Page 4: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

HEAOOUART^NS

U S ARMY TRANSPORTATION RESEARCH COMMAND FORT EJSTIS. VIRGINIA 23604

In this report, the Massachusetts Institute of Technology Aeroelastlc and Structures Research Laboratory investigated harmonic spanwisc airloads for single and tandem model rotor configurations at various rotor angles of attack, tip-speed ratios, and thrust loadings.

The experimental results are used in a discussion of rotor vibration levels at various harmonic airloads.

This Command has reviewed the report and considers it to be technically sound.

NOTE

On 1 March 1965, after this report had been prepared, the name of this command was changed from U.S. Army Transportation Research Command to:

U.S. Ami AVIATION MATERIEL LABORATORIES

Page 5: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

Task IP1215901A14203 Contract DA 44-177-AMC-22(T)

USAAML Technical Report 65-13

MAY 1965

AN EXPERIMENTAL INVESTIGATION OF

ROTOR HARMONIC AIRLOADS INCLUDING THE

EFFECTS OF ROTOR-ROTOR INTERFERENCE AND

BLADE FLEXIBILITY

by

Norman D. Ham

Paul A. Madden

Prepared by

Aeroelastic and Structures Research Laboratory

Massachusetts Institute of Technology

Cambridge, Massachusetts 02139

for

ü. S. ARMY TRANSPORTATION RESEARCH COMMAND

FORT EÜSTI6, VIRGINIA

Page 6: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

SUMMARY

Experimental airload harmonics from the first to the tenth at various blade spanwise stations are presented for single and rear tandem rotor configurations for various rotor angles of attack, tip-speed ratios, and thrust loadings. The results in- clude the effect of blade bending motion on airload harmonics for selected test cases.

Evaluation of the experimental results indicates several general conclusions of importance with regard to vibration levels of compound helicopters, tandem helicopters, and three- and four-bladed rotors.

iii

Page 7: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

PREFACE

This report was prepared by the Aeroelastic and Structures Research Laboratory of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, Massachusetts, on U.S. Army Contract DA44-177-AMC-22(T), The project officers for the U.S. Army Transportation Research Command, Fort Eustis, Virginia were Mr. John E. Yeates and Lt. Francis E. LaCasse. The M.I.T. Project Supervisor was Professor Norman D. Ham, Department of Aeronautics and Astro- nautics; Mr. Paul A. Madden, Research Assistant, was responsible for data reduction and assisted in the test operations.

The contractor's report number is ASRL TR 117-1.

Grateful acknowledgement is made to Professor Rene H. Miller for his comments and suggestions, to Messrs. Oscar Wallin and Carl Fall of the Aeroelastic Model Shop for the construction of the models, to Mr. Fred Merlis, Research Engineer, ASRL, for the design of the electronic circuits, to the M.I.T. Computation Center, which made available the computer time necessary for the harmonic analysis of the test data, and to the Aerophysics Lab- oratory, M.I.T., for the loan of amplifiers.

Page 8: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

I Rotor Characteristics II Test Conditions

III Test Results

V1U

IX

CONTENTS

Page

SUMMARY iii

PREFACE v

LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS

LIST OF SYMBOLS

INTRODUCTION

CONCLUSIONS

EXPERIMENTAL PROGRAM

DISCUSSION OF EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS 8

REFERENCES

DISTRIBUTION

APPENDICES

35

36

37 38 40

vu

Page 9: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

ILLUSTRATIONS

Figure Page

1 Rotor Test Rig H

2 Pressure Calibration Equipment 12

3 Test Section Velocity Profiles 13

4 Circuit Schematic 14

5 Recording System 15

6(a)-(f) Nondimensionai Third Harmonic Airload Amplitudes for the Single Rotor with Rigid Blades 16

7(a)-(c) Nondimensionai Third Harmonic Airload Amplitudes for the Rear Tandem Rotor with Rigid Blades 22

8(a)-(c) Nondimensionai Sixth Harmonic Air- load Amplitudes for the Rear Tandem Rotor with Rigid Blades 25

9(a)-(c) Nondimensionai Third Harmonic Airload Amplitude Comparison — Three- and Four-Bladed Rotors 28

10(a)-(c) Nondimensionai Fourth Harmonic Airload Amplitude Comparison -- Three- and Four-Bladed Rotors 29

11 Nondimensionai Third Harmonic Airload Amplitudes for the Single Rotor with Flexible Blades in Bending Resonance 34

vitl

Page 10: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

SYMBOLS

|l 1 nondimensional magnitude of harmonic airload, |L I , I "I fraction of Lo/R I nl

n harmonic number

x nondimensional blade spanwise station, fraction of rotor radius

CT rotor thrust coefficient, thrust divided b> air density, disk area, tip speed squared

L steady-state thrust of one blade, pourds

L harmonic airload acting at one blade station. n pounds per inch.

L - L cos mr -»- L sin my c s

L cosine component of harmonic airload acting at one nc blade station, pounds per inch

L sine component of harmonic airload acting at one ns blade station, pounds per inch

R rotor radius, feet or inches

a rotor shaft angle, positive aft of vertical, degrees. Since rotor has no cyclic pitch, also no feathering axis angle, degrees

u rotor advance ratio, free-stream velocity divided ' by rotor tip speed

-y blade aximuth angle, zero when instrunented blade downstream, degrees

a rotor solidity, blade area divided by disk area

SR single rotor configuration

TRR rear rotor of tandem configuration

(R) articulated blade, relatively rigid in bending

(F) articulated blade, relatively flexible in bending

:x

Page 11: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

S^b»cri»f

f froet rotor

1 rear rotor

tl valae for purposes of classification

Page 12: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

ISTRODUCTIOII

Rotor-induced vibration is a probles of major significance in current helicopter technology. The difficulty of designing for Minisui vibration levels is largely due to the lack of knowl.. edge of the harmonic airloads acting on the rotor blades them- selves. Considerable extremely valuable flight test data have become available for two- and four-bladed rotors. However, in such flight tests, the necessity of keeping the aircraft in trim prevents a vide variation of such major parameters as rotor angle of attack and blade loading, vhile sanufacturing costs prohibit saajor changes in such parameters as rotor blade flexi- bility and tandem rotor geometry. Also, verv large vibratory loads c«ccur at transition flight speeds that are difficult to achieve in steady free flight. Yet, extensive data at these speeds are urgently required doe to the occurrence of extreme uake distortion which greatly contributes to the large magnitude of ire hanoonic airloads and increases the difficulty of tbeo- rclical prediction of these harmonic airloads. (See leferences 1, 2, 3. and 4).

Tut purpose of the present study is to present and assess extensive harmonic airload data obtained in the wind tnooel for simulated transition flight with three-bladed rotors in both single and tasdeat configurations for wide variations in rotor angle of attack, blade loading, and blade flexibility.

Zr.is stody is a continuation of a maxhcr of investigations that have been conducted over the past several years on rotor -ribratioc and airloao problears. The equipment developed during these past investigations was utilized during the current study.

Page 13: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

CONCLUSIONS

The rotor orientations and blade loadings associated with a coKpound helicopter having auxiliary propulsion units and lifting surfaces lead to harmonic airload amplitudes conparable vith those of pure helicopters at aoderate forward speeds.

The orientation of the rear rotor of a tandea helicopter relative to the front rotor is of fvndarental ioportance in establishing rear rotor haraonic airload amplitudes, particu- larly during transition.

There is no significant difference between the doainant harmonic airload asplitudes of three- and fcur-bladed single rotors operating under identical flight conditions.

Page 14: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

EXPERIMEKTAL PROGRAM

Test Stand

The test stand consists of two pylons mounted on heavy steel beams in such a way that the front pylon can be moved fore and aft to varv the rotor overlap. Both the front and rear pylon can be raised to vary the rotor stagger (Figure 1). For the present tests the rotors were at the same height and overlapped 67 percent of the rotor radius.

The pylons are made of welded steel channels, and pro- vision has been incorporated to tilt the rotor heads from 5° aft to 15° forward by remote control of an electric-motor-driven linkage. The rotor power is supplied by a 10-horsepower hydrau- lic motor, controlled from outside the tunnel. Two right-angle gearboxes and a connecting shaft with constant velocity joints turn the front rotor shaft synchronously with the rear shaft, but in the opposite direction.

In the single rotor configuration, the front rotor pylon and the connecting shaft are removed.

Appendix I lists the principal parameters of the rotors.

Rotors

Both front and rear rotors are 8 feet in diameter and have three fully articulated (flapping and lagging degrees of freedom) blades with no mechanical daspers and no cyclic pitch control. The blades are rigid in torsion.

Thirty-three slip rings are available to transmit pressure signals from the rotating hub to the amplifiers and recording equipment. Three spring strip brushes wired in parallel bear on each slip ring. A timing signal is generated every time the instrumented blade passes through azimuth angle 90°.

The flapping displacement of the blade is measured by means of a spring steel beam between the flapping pin and the hub, with two active arm strain gage bridges mounted on the beam. The angular displacement signal is linear over the %ihole range of measurement. The duamy arms of the strain gage bridges consist of precision resistors mounted on the top surface of the hub, so that the bridges are complete on the rotor side of the slip rings.

Page 15: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

Pressure Measurements

Variable reluctance transducers (Reference 7) with a dif- ferential pressure range of 0 to 2 psi are installed in the instrumented blade against the front face of the spar, oriented so that readings are not affected by centrifugal force or blade flapping accelerations, and connected by .040-inch-diameter hypordermic tubing to the pressure tap locations on the upper and lower surfaces of the blade. Eight such locations were chosen, all at the 10 percent chordwise station and at the 20 percent, 40 percent, 60 percent, 70 percent, 80 percent, 85 percent, 90 percent, and 95 percent spanwise stations.

Each transducer was calibrated statically and dynaaically before installation in the blade (Figure 2). Static calibrations of all pressure transducers were performed frequently during test operations. The transducers had a flat response to sinusoidal pressure oscillations at frequencies from 0 to 70 cycles per second but were not tested beyond this frequency, which corre- sponds to the tenth haraonic of the rotor at 400 rpst.

Model Blades

All blades are of 0012 cross section with uniform chord ■ass and stiffness and incorporate 10 of linear twist. The rigid blades consist of a partially flattened 2024-73 aluminua- tube spar with a hardwood leading edge and a balsa-covered, ribbed, trailing edge. The flexible blades employ a solid rec- tangular section aluminum spar with solid chordwise-grain-balsa leading- and tralling-edge portions. The pressure transducers are attached to the leading edge of the spar of one instrmented blade, and corresponding lead ballast is added to the other blades. The elastic axis and the e.g. are at the quarter chord. Lead tape was applied at the trailing edge to attain the desired e.g. location.

Two strain gages were mounted on the spar of one of the flexible blades at 30 percent of the span to provide a bending signal that was displayed on the oscilloscope to indicats the onset of blade bending resonance.

The blade root attachment fittings include a worm and gear mechanism to permit adjustment of the collective pitch as well as to facilitate tracking of the blades.

Page 16: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

Wind Tunnel

All tests were conducted in Che 9-foot by 12-foot return test section of the Aeroelastic and Structures Research Laboratory Flutter Tunnel at MIT. To provide a uniform velocity distribu- tion over the test section and to nininize the turbulence and swirl created by the upstream fan, the test section was aodified as follows: New walls were built to eliminate tunnel expansion at the test section; a vertical aid-divider from floor to ceiling was placed from the tunnel fan downstream to an existing vertical beam to cut the one large swirl into two smaller swirls and to bring additional velocity into the center section; a trailing edge fairing was placed on the beam to smooth the flow; two coarse damping screens made of stretched steel sheets were placed at the end of the divider to create a back pressure and to even the flow, and a fine mesh damping screen was placed downstream of the coarse screens to minimize turbulence from both the fans and the coarse screens. Velocity profiles across the test section are presented in Figure 3.

The effect of tunnel turbulence on the higher harmonic air- loads was not investigated quantitatively. However, the repeat- ability of the blade pressure test records indicated the effect to be negligible for tip-speed ratios of .05 and .10. At a tip-speed ratio of .20, the increased turbulence due to the higher tunnel speed caused significant random changes in amplitude and phase of pressure harmonics above the sixth order of rotor ro- tational speed. However, these harmonics were of such small magnitude that it was not considered worthwhile to perform a statistical analysis of many test cycles to eliminate the random effect of turbulence.

No corrections were applied to the data to account for the effects of tunnel wall interference. Although such corrections would affect the magnitude of the steady-state airload by five percent or less, it is expected that they would not significantly influence the higher harmonic airloads.

Test Procedure

Tests were run on both tandem and single rotors at various blade loadings, rotor angles of attack, and tip-speed ratios (see Appendix I). A stroboscope was used to monitor rotor ro- tational speed and blade tracking.

Page 17: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

All blades were tracked to the instruaented blade tip at the pitch settings and rotor speed for the given test condition.

Instrunentation

The strain gage bridges were excited with 5-volt DC and the pressure transducers with a 20-kc, 5-volt carrier system.

Because of the number of channels involved, it was found necessary to use two separate four-channel carrier amplifiers, with synchronized excitations. The flapping signal did not re« quire amplification.

All the channels were recorded simultaneously on an oscillograph using galvanometers having a natural frequency of 400 cycles per second. The complete recording system is shown in Figures 4 and 3.

Data Reduction and Accuracy

One typical cycle of each pressure channel trace for a given test condition was subjected to a 40- to 48-point harmonic analysis that yielded all harmonics up to the^tenth. In the course of the analysis, calibration factors vere applied to con- vert inches of pressure trace deflection to pressure in pounds per square inch. A conversion factor of 2.173 was also applied to convert these pressure readings (at 10-percent chord) to the equivalent total loading in pounds per inch at that spanwise station, following the method described in Reference 8. This technique is valid for the moderate blade mean lift coefficient (0.6) and the low advancing blade tip Mach nwber (0.13) of the present tests.

Due to the low ratio of the highest airload frequency of interest (67 cycles per second or tenth harmonic) to the gal- vanometer natural frequency (400 cycles per second), the maxisrua error in amplitude response of the galvanometer (for 64-percent daaping ratio) was less than 1 percent. Similarly, for the above damping ratio, the phase angle error corresponds to a blade asi- muth lag angle of about 1.3° for all airload harmonics. Both these errors were considered negligible. The phase lag is con- stant due tc the linear variation of phase angle with frequency ratio for a second-order dynamic system with 64-percent damping ratio.

Page 18: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

The pressure gage itself has a natural frequency (including inlet tubing) of greater than 2000 cycles per second and a damping ratio of the order of 0.1 (Reference ?); hence, errors due to its dynamic response to frequencies of 67 cycles per second or less «ill be negligible. Errors due to gage hysteresis are less than 1 percent of maximum pressure experienced (Referen- ces 7 and 9).

From the above considerations, errors in the roeastired har- monic airload data can be expected to be less than 5 percent of the measured values.

Data Presentation

Test conditions are specified in Appendix II. Included for convenience is the steady-state lift acting on one blade at each test condition.

Test results are presented in Appendix 111 in terms of airload harmonics up to the tenth at various spanwise stations. Steady-state data are also presented, though dim to instrumenta- tion drift, much of these data had to be corrected by inter- polation and are approximate only. They are believed to be with- in 10 percent of the actual value.

Page 19: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

DISCUSSION OF EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS

Detailed experimental results are presented in Appendix III. In order to evaluate the effect of variation of rotor parameters upon helicopter vertical vibration levels, certain harmonic airload amplitudes were expressed as a ratio of the mean blade airload-L /R and plotted against spanwise station, for various shaft angles, tip-speed ratios, and blade loadings. Note that the values of C~lz shown are nominal only. Actual values for individual test points can be obtained using the values of L given in Appendix II. Since, for a given test condition, these amplitudes have different phasings for different spanwise stations, such values do not represent an actual spanwise loading at a given instant of time. However, it is a useful qualitative indication of the harmonic excitation acting on a rotor blade in a given test condition.

Significant airload harmonics for vertical vibration of a three-bladed rotor are the third, sixth, and ninth. Nondimensional third-harmonic amplitudes for a single rotor with rigid blades are shown in Figure 6. Here, the term "rigid" implies that the blade first mode ber. ' ng frequency was far higher than third har- monic (see Appendix I). Sixth and ninth harmonic amplitudes for this rotor configuration were found in general to be much smaller than the third harmonic (see Appendix III).

Two general characteristics of the higher harmonic airloads are evident in Figure 6: the concentration near the tip, and the rapid spanwise fluctuations. These characteristics necessitate a corresponding concentration of airload transducers near the tip when such airloads are measured.

The well-known increase in harmonic excitation as the rotor angle of attack is increased at very low flight speeds (e.g., during flares) is indicated by Figure 6. This effect is due to the corresponding decrease in rotor inflow that permits the blade tip vortices to remain close to the rotor. The figure indicates that this effect also occurs at moderate flight speeds («i - .20), though the increase here tends to occur at inboard stations. This point may be of significance for helicopters with auxiliary propulsion, since such helicopters operate with low rotor inflows.

The variation of harmonic airloads with blade loading-Cy/a is seen to be most pronounced at -oderate flight speeds (Figures 6(c) and (f)). At lower flight speeds, the reduced in- flow, and consequent close proximity of the trailing vortices to the rotor, is apparently socewhat cffset by the reduced strength of the vortices. The effect of reduction of blade loading is

Page 20: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

most pronounced at moderate flight speeds, since changes in mean downwash, and, hence, vortex spacing, are now directly related to changes in thrust (X^ C_ rather than^Jcl).

The detrimental effect of reducing Cj/a will be of concern in the design of compound helicopters utilizing auxiliary wings to unload the rotor in cruising flight.

The familiar reduction in harmonic airloads with forward speed is illustrated by Figure 6. This reduction is, of course, due to the increase in the rate of passage of rotor vorticity downstream.

Third and sixth harmonic airloads for the rear rotor of a tandem configuration with rigid blades are shown in Figures 7 and 8. The sixth harmonic airloads are included, since they are of a magnitude comparable to the third harmonic for the tandem rotor. It should be notea that in certain cases significant ninth harmonic airloads occur on the rear tandem rotor and that in many cases other higher harmonic airloads are of appreciable magnitude for this configuration (see Appendix 111), apparently due to the proximity of the trailing vorticity from the front rotor. However, detailed discussion of these harsonics is not presented here.

Figure 7 shows that the third harmonic excitation of the rear tandem rotor is comparable to that of the single rotor. Figure 6. Note that the tandem airloads tend to be more dis- tributed over the blade span, with appreciable amplitudes at the inboard stations.

The figures also illustrate the complex variation of har- monic airloads with changes in rear rotor orientation with respect to the front rotor. It would appear to be advantageous to trim the rear rotor to a position as far from the front rotor trailing vorticity as possible for minimum rear rotor outboard harmonic excitation. However, the inboard harmonic airload is increased. This paradox is apparently due to the outboard har- monic airloads being largely due to vorticity trailed from the front rotor; hence, rearward tilt moves the rear rotor away from this vorticity, while on the other hand, the trailing vorticity of the rear rotor now remains close to that rotor and increases the inboard harmonic airload as in the case of the single rotor.

Page 21: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

Shaft angles for Che tandem rotor configuration of this investigation that lead to rotor trim positions typical for a full-scale aircraft in free flight are as follows:

u ^F ^R 05 -5° 0° 10 -5° 0° 20 -10° 0°

The value for u • .10 provides insufficient rotor angular separation for uinimun harmonic excitation according to the present results. However, a_ can be readily decreased (rotor tilted forward)in an accelerating transition and 2^ can be in- creased (rotor tilted aft) in a decelerating transition.

Third and fourth harmonic wind tunnel airloads for the three-bladed model rotor of the present study are prepared with those for the four-bladed full scale free flight rotor of Ref- erence 2 in Figures 9 and 10 for similar test conditions. Of Interest are the similar character and magnitude of identical harmonics even for such wide variations in test envirooaent anc rotor configuration. The data also indicate that there is no significant difference in the predominant harmonic excitation (third harmonic for three-bladed rotors, fourth harmonic for four-bladed rotors) for rotors with three and four blades. This result is apparently due to the fact that thoi^h the trail- ing vortices of a four-bladed rotor are closer to the blades than they would be for a three-bladed rotor producing the same thrust under the same flight condition, the strength of the individual vortices is also reduced and the two effects approximately cancel in terms of airloads induced on the blades. Xote that M.I.T. flexible blade results (Case 43) are almost identical to the results of Reference 2.

The third harmonic airload measured on the flexible blade in bending resonance with the third harmonic airload is shown in Figure 11 for cocparison with the results shown in Figure 6(e) for the rigid blade far from third harmonic resonance.

Page 22: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

'S-F£ ~J* ~£1' *

Page 23: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

LIQUID MANOMETER

.»PRESSURE TRANSDUCER

»Hi

20 kc CARRIER

AMPLIFIER

BELLOWS (REFERENCE PRESSURE)

OSCILLATING BELLOWS

1 DC \ POWER

SUPPLY SHAKER

POWER AMPLIFIER

AUDIO 1 OSCILLATOR

r DYNAMIC SYSTEM

L.

FIGURE 2. PRESSURE CALIBRATION EQUIPMENT.

12

Page 24: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

28'

Q Z o Ü UJ (/)

ÜJ CL

I- UJ LU U-

l

>-

Ü o _J UJ >

20

12

8

0 0

ROTOR

2 FEET ABOVE PLANE OF ROTOR IN PLANE OF ROTOR 2 FEET BELOW PLANE OF ROTOR

I I I L_ 4 6

DISTANCE - FEET

8

FIGURES. TEST SECTION VELOCITY PROFILES

13

Page 25: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

en tu

i 2

to tr Hi

ui U a. o DO tot« (OZ LU < IT (T

O

X I AAH> L-J? ■s«ii

o I Ä7\ if-r i_ii

u. i AA r

UJ I AAr-O r

T.«^

o I Ä7\rO r

i_»i

AAr^> ■i

m i AAr^> r

:*_ij

AAr-O L._*i._*J

Ö- _l z

a. Ui

a. a. <

o CM

(NJ

*

tu

-I a

IT UJ

IT a. < Ü

o (M

♦ UJ

U.

a

<

UJ

o IT O O UJ

a.

i a < tr o o _J -i

o en o

Ü

I- <

UJ X o en

3 o

o

LU cr

14

Page 26: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

FIGURE 5. RECORDING SYSTEM.

15

Page 27: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

o* -

O d ii

b

o

if) o d

o in

0 o 0 m

0 o 0 in

II i 1 ' o **'

0 * D < o

o >0«<-

Ö

GO

d

d

d z o

in w

d ÜJ (A

d

c\J

d

Q < _l CD

O CD in <t ro c\) —

O o o o o O

aanindKiv avoidiv - ^1 16

o

0) ÜJ o D h- -J Q.

<

o < o a: <

en ÜJ o <

Q

a: I < 1- X

$

a or ir O T h- I- u

ir

-^ liJ < _) z o o z en a) z UJ UJ 5 X - I- Q

2 (T O O

CD

ÜJ cc D o

Page 28: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

ö

O*0CD-

O Ö

o

1

0

ii

o

0

o 0

in •

0 o 1

0 in

i

"**"

o * D < o

G *> <3

<J>

o

00

o

N-

o o h- <

CD \-

O w

ÜJ w

in ^ 0I ^<

a. XI

<n CD

^r iiJ ÜJ

^ Q OC O < 3

_i O CD ÜL

ro ' O X

CJ

O

in d 6 O d

Banindwv avotäiv f\

17

Page 29: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

ö

00 o

N- O

o 1-

(D <

O

ÜJ

in $ o Z

< ,_; ü. o W 0)

^r LU Lü

ö <

er.

_l o 00 u.

ro 1

O X

(M O

aaniiidwv avoidiv -

18

Page 30: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

Ö

O

Ö & i. o b d

^ ;

1 0 0 0 0 0

m o in o ID ii i 1 i

o

0 * □ < O

10 Ö Ö 6

CVJ

6 3anindiMV avoidiv -

19

o ocxü *

0) o

00 o

N- o z

o »- <

CD 1- O

ÜJ

m ^ O 2 < ^

Q. "D (^ CD

*■ LÜ UJ

d < -J O CD Ü.

ro 1

O X

(\J

O

o

Page 31: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

CD Ö

* O D <H

o

b o II

o

0 If)

n

Ö •

0

o 0

i

0 0 O ID T i

O * D < o

»C&3-

0> o

GO o

N- o z

o

CD < 1- O cn

ÜJ

in Z o z

< ^ a. a> en (D

^t UJ UJ

o Q a: < _) _l o 00 U-

K) I

o X

Cd

O

IT)

o d d C\J

d o

3anindiMV avonaiv

20

Page 32: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

o

o II

b \- o

o Ö

o in

ö

0 o

0 0 in O

' T

0 * D <

& o

00 o

h- o z

o h-

<P2 O w

til if)

to $ O Z

< <"• CL •»- (/) u?

^ hi UJ Ö 0 cr w < ID

_l O m li.

ro ' O x

Cvl O

CD Ö

in <t to O o O

aanindwv a^

Cd

Ö O

avoidiv - rt\

21

Page 33: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

CO

ö

d s b O

^ ■;

0 0 o 0

(O o if) o n 1 , a.

0

0 * D <

0 in

i n u.

Ö

Ö '3- d Ö d

aanindwv avoiäiv - 22

tl

o u.

(0 UJ o

CL • 5 cn

Q < < d O DO

C Q

< e>

if or < x Q OC.

X

tr o h- o a:

< a

cn z UJ 2 Q Z o 2 ^-;

f^ UJ a: D O

< UJ oc

UJ X

Page 34: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

o II

b \- o

0 0 0 0

in o If) o o ii I 1

Ö 0 ' n

^ 0 * D <

0 If)

I

II

u. b

z o

<

(/)

u CO

Z < Q. CO

ÜJ O <

m i

x

XJ

UJ

O

I

CD

d ID

ö o ro Ö

c\J Ö

o

aamndiNv avonyiv - \*f

23

Page 35: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

o d ti

o OJ

b O \. ii

o i

0 0* 0 0 0 0

lO o in o n i 1 0

^

it

u. 0 * D < 0

0> o

00 o

K o

z o h-

Ä < <D H O «rt

tu </>

to ^

o| ^«

Q. o W N-

^r UJ UJ

öS 13 _J o CD ÜL

ro ' O x

CVI O

(£> to tf ro cvj o o o O O

3anindiNV OVOHdlV - 24

1^

Page 36: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

o II

b

o

if) o o

i 0 0 0 0

1 in o 0 o ii i 1

oc 0

0 * D <

0 m

i n u.

Ö

(D in ^r ro (M O o o O O

aanmdiNv avoidiv - 25

*CV1

$0

O

O U.

CO ÜJ o I-

a. 5 en < LiJ

Q

S <

O OQ -J

z 2f a: < x x i- X

CD < Z o

O X en

UJ

Q Z o z 'S 00

UJ (T D O

cr o \~ o cr

UJ a z < I-

< UJ (£

UJ X

i9rl

Page 37: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

o o 11 —

b Ö II

CD

d in d

0 in

0 o 0 0 in O

H 1 i

(T Ö

0 * □ <

d ro O

3anindwv avoidiv - l9^! 26

XI

CO

ÜJ Q: ID

Page 38: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

o

00

a: o

aanindwv ovoidiv - |9M

27

Page 39: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

«5 in t ro cvi o o O O O

3anindKiv avoiaiv 28

z o m

m < o a. o o

GO Ö Q

3

_J a

K ^ o z <

o a — < 1- o < _J

<D \- o: O co <

LU o (/>

2 </)

tO ^ O CE

Ö 2 2 O

Q. < o (/) i tr

^J" UJ Q Q ÜJ

Ö Q < X

O <

_) »- _) CD CD

rO 1

_j <

o

1 cr 3

Ö X o li.

(/) z O lil z

CVJ 2 < 1

d n Lü

z Li.'

o X z h-

— —t

Ö O

UJ

-) <J

u.

Page 40: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

O) OJ ro CJ O CJ

O f o

i ?o LÜ Ö o

UJ CO d o

o s - ID < ti lO < II /■"V ID

CO

i

8 0

O

1-

b d 1

II

Ö

o 1-

b v.

O

O i

ti

O 0)

5 s

O CD

o 2 o o tO CM

o d d d ö ö d

sarundwv avoidiv - rr

If) d

< Q.

O

.a

UJ

29

Page 41: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

D

^T Of) ^—

o CvJ o »- I O _J LL

d 8

ro O

ÜJ CO <

Ö

b O i o b •\ ll \

CO \- j- I- •^ o ^ 0 o

s

o cü o d i

■I ii

<

IT)

UJ

Oi

UJ Q:

o

a. CO

UJ Q < -J CD

I

X

O

1 O in

C\J O

O o aaruiidiAiv

\o o

o 6 avonaiv - ■r\

in O d

30

Page 42: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

o o avoidiv - M 31

Page 43: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

o m o C\J CVJ

in O in O

O O O o O O aaniiidi^v QV01WV - 1^1

Ö

CD Ö

6 z o

< CD i-

o w

UJ in

2

in $ o 0i ÜJ

QC

_i GD

I ro Ö x

OJ

O

C

o o

32

Page 44: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

o in o co CVJ

in o in o

o o o o Ö aannidwv avoidiv - 1^

ÜJ a:

33

Page 45: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

Ä o-

o lü —

^ ° 2 n ■ X b O UJ \ "i

^ ^ s

in o IT) O

n 1 1

o -

o * D <3

1 1 1 1 o CD

O

O O O in ^ fO

ö d ö aarundKiv avoiäiv

o CM

o

6

Oi o cn

ÜJ Q D i-

00 _) o 0.

Ö

(Si

in

CD

dx

ö

O

tu X I-

a: • o tu

< z o CO ÜJ cc

o z

o

O (/) — Ü z o

< X

-J < z o (/) z ÜJ 2

ÜJ

5 cc z

cn ÜJ Q < -j m ÜJ _i CD

Q x Q: üJ

x

Q: o o er ÜJ

Q -' 2 z o £ z cn

ÜJ er D O

34

Page 46: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

REFERENCES

1. Bell Helicopter Co., Measurement of Dynamic Airloads on a Full-Scale Semirigid Rotor, TCREC Technical Report TR 62-42, U.S. Army Transportation Research Command, Fort Eustis, Virginia.

2. Scheiman, J., A Tabulation of Helicopter Rotor-Blade Differential Pressures, Stresses, and Motions as Measur IrTFlight, NASA Technical Mjmorandum X-952, March 1964.

3. Miller. R.H., "unsteady Air Loads on Helicopter Rotor Blades , Journal of the Royal Aeronautical Society, April 196^

4. Ham, N.D., An Experimental Investigation of the Effect of a Nonrigid Wake on Rotor Blade Airloads in Transition Flight, Cornell Aeronautical Laboratory/TRC Symposium on Dynamic Load Problems Associated with Hel.lcopters and V/STOL Aircraft, Proceedings, Vol. I., June 1963.

5. Miller, R.H., A Discussion of Rotor Blade Harmonic Airloading, same source as Ref. 4.

6. Zvara, J. and Ham, N.D., "Helicopter Rotor Model Research at M.I.T.", Journal of the American Helicopter Society, January 1960.

7. Patterson, J.L., A Miniature Electrical Pressure Gage Utilizing a Stretched Flat Diaphragm, NACA Technical Note 2659, April 1952.

8. Duvivier, J.F., Study of Helicopter Rotor-Rotor Interfer- ence Effects on Hub Vibration, Air Force Systems Conmand Technical Documentary Report ASD-TR-61-601, June 1962.

9. Daigle, L.L., Evaluation of Variable Reluctance Pressure Pickups for Application to Helicopter Rotor Test Rig, Report M-11554-1, United Aircraft Corp., Hartford, Connecticut, February 1954.

^5

Page 47: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

DISTRIBUTION

Ü-S Army Materiel Command Z US Army Mobility Command Z US Army Aviation Materiel Command 5 Ch:ef of R&D. DA 1 US Army Transportation Research Command 38 ÜSATRECOM Liaison Officer, US Army Ä&D Group (EurooeJ 1 US Army Engineer R&D Laboratories Z Army Research Office-Durnam 2 US Army Research Support Group i US Army Avidtion School i US Army Aviation Test activity i US Army General Equipment Test Activity i Air Force Systems Command, Wright -Patterson AFB 3 Air Force Flight Test Center, Edwards AFB J Air Proving Ground Center, Eghn AFB 1 Bureau of Naval Weapons 3

US Naval Postgraduate School 1 US Naval Air Station, Patuxent River i David Taylor Model Easin i Marine Corps Liaison Officer.. US Army Transportation School 1 Ames Research Center, NASA i NASA Representative, Scientific and Technical Information

Facility Z National Aviation Facilities Experimental Center 1 Canadian Liaison Officer, US Army Transportation School 1 Defense Documentation Center ZO

US Government Printing Office 1

Air University Library, Maxwell AFB 1

NASA-LRC, Langley Station 1

36

Page 48: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

APPENDIX I

ROTOR CHARACTERISTICS

Sipgl^ Row. Rigid Flexible

Tandem Front

Rotor Rear

Number of blades 3 3 3 3

Rotor solidity 0.10 0.10 0.10 0.10

Rotor radius, feet 4.00 4.00 4.00 4.00

Blade chord, inches 5.00 5.00 5.00 5.00

Airfoil section 0012 0012 0012 0012

Flapping hinge ©ffset, percent radius 2.60 2.60 2.60 2.60

Lagging hinge offset, percent radius 3.70 3.70 3.70 3.70

Linear twist, degrees -10 -10 0 -10

Blade mass constant 8.40 7.00 8.40 8.40

Blade mass, slugs per foot

Blade e.g., percent chord

First mode bending frequency, cycles per minute, at:

400 rpm 300 rpm

Rotor hut .pacing, feet, vertically horizontally

Rotor operating rpti at H - .05, .10 u - .20

.0128 .0168 .0128 .0128

25 25 25 25

2000 1880

1180 960

2000 1880

2000 1880

--

0 5.33

400 300

400 300

400 300

400 300

37

Page 49: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

APPENDIX II

TEST CONDITIONS

Case (CT/o nom M- o

a 0° L -lb. o Type

1 .05 .05 5 6.8 7.2 SR(R

2 0 6.8 6.8

3 -5 6.5 6.2

4 -10 6.5 6.0

5 | -15 6.8 6.0

6 .10 5 4.8 5.9

7 0 4.8 5.2

8 -5 6.5 6.4

9 -10 6.5 5.7

10 t -15 6.8 5.3

11 .20 5 2.6 3.2

12 0 4.0 3.2

13 -5 5.4 3.2

14 f \ r -10 6.8 3.2

15 .1 0 .0 5 5 11.6 12.5

16 0 11.6 12.1

17 -5 11.4 11.6

18 -10 11.4 11.3

19 ^ f -15 11.6 11.2

20 .1 0 5 10.0 12.0

21 0 10.0 11.3

22 -5 11.4 12.2

23 -10 11.4 11.5

24 i -15 11,6 11.0

25 .2 0 5 7.3 6.9

26 0 7.3 5.8

27 ,

28 / i

-5

-10

10.0

10.0

6.8

5.7 1

SR

f

(R

38

Page 50: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

Case

29

30

31

32

33

34

35

36

37

38

39

40

41

42

43

44

(V0) nom .10 .05 -5

e.

11

10

20

10 10

t

'F ^ e, R 'R

11.7 11.9 5 12.5 9.6 11.7 11.9 0 12.5 9.3 11.7 11.9 -5 12.5 9.0 11.7 11.9 -10 12.5 8.7 10.6 11.3 5 11.0 8.7 10.6 11.3 0 11.0 8.0 10.6 11.3 -5 12.3 8.9 10.6 11.3 -10 12.3 8.1 9.4 6.3 5 8.0 6.4 9.4 6.3 0 9.3 6.2 9.4 6.3 -5 10.7 6.3 9.4 6.3 -10 12.0 6.3

5 10.0 12.0 0 10.0 11.3

-5 11.4 12.2 -10 11.4 11.5

TRR(R)

SR(F)

39

Page 51: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

APPENDIX III

TEST RESULTS

rfo»-*o —•• —e-c oooöoeooco oooooocceo

*• — « * * •- ««CO

w-COTC^«»cc

^•O>woo«v —c — c

oooöoeooco oooöoeooco

• - * -j o * •

t •*• ♦ o • •<. • ,• •. o —o o - *■ —o eo o < o o o eo e s

,. — o*»"»'*!; — = c —oeoeoaooo 0003000000

»*.Ot«w*»".— - — ♦

— 000000-500 oeoo-arcc-^c

;T n ■- 3 -r f-i n- o n ** OGOOOOOOOO

^CöooooO'S'Oe »0^300300 0 3

Oo&ncoooco ocsäaoöeoooc

• oaoooncooo eSoeoroocc-

jocooco&oe'Ci »e-sooooooac -^o&oooöocce

5oeeooooooc oooooosooo

»♦••**»» — »«<■• -ftf«««0«*G«0~0 oooeocosoo ooooooeooo

o ' * T * ' ' * i' * t

ITOv«- *»*■. o**oa jO^^Äcir^^e*»

OfV<"S^OOOOO OOOOOOOOOO

^M.*.>r^O«>r*«"<C «-OOOCiOCiCOO ooeooor»eoo

O i i t ■ i

• 0«««««>*M'W*.*.

O^-^O««***"© ^«»S.*1 ««»»-».IM« w'****—^-oooo OM-'nOOOOOO OOCOOOOOOC

I < < II

«f ?.*()'*•*•»*»-

w* « M * ♦ O w *- * O C ZV«*-«»»«««« .j»-0 — •*''•*< — ". — o — OOOOOOooO OOOOOOOOOO

O . i ( ■

i^o»—•■-Orf'a'w

_i — #*,i«^*.-3 — OOO — 'WOOOOOOOO OOOOOOGOCC

*-«■«« IT1 <«>««>*

ap»««*>r*-««^><r _(«^I*-I/««^ — ooo OOOOOOOOOO OOOOOOOOOO

O .tttiiiii

# «^r « <" * ^. « o *- O*— «.«> — *\_-i^

-lO* — OOO — — OO X "»OOOOOOOOO O OOOOOOOOOO

«

— — * •« c r »■•■»■ f« • • ^o •- ^ r * i - # « # « « ««te"*« j« —— 0«»in«,*-»*i

f«- — ♦«—*.o»*

«-«■»o—o—oo oc COOOO-JCO

^oc«*-«*-—•■*■ •^»♦•'««••^•■#»

^^CO-»»v'^*-»^ * «*»■•« « — O«—*">*

— '.eocooooe ooaoeooooo

o — ♦ — *•*■ — c.» — • r^'V'-'S«*^ — *•• jC-<--««C*r.

«■c*"-» — oo — o-r ocooocoooc

a o««,-*'«'0">o*« J»-*^I^*O«—e*"» — o* — c—coocc ooooee soeo

'»•««rf-O»*"«-© .•«**'*'*3**'*.,^

«■ — «■o-» —— — OC oonoooocoo

y # a.« •* « o * *■ ■• r j — 't—■'•■rfi* « "c C ooo^, oeecoc

JO » *■ -w» «■— "" 5 V — •*. — öer. 30c D'-co^ioosio

I * 3 » — e • o * « «»

„■v — c — ctc-eeo «wvOOOOOOOS OOOOOOOOOO

V « -. «• -■ ro*.*»>-# _,«*--- oeo^ —

ooeo -j o oo ö 6

*^»*M»«'^W>« sJ»«*t«»*-*->~*

-.»—ococcc^o «. —CcOOOCOO OOOOOOCOOO

« * *• « o • - o « » v

^O — CC"'"'*-««*' Z—tf'--«>«V»'C»"**a

" -occooe

U«"fc«««' — -#«¥■ y-*oc—« — — «««s —

• cc —o — CO

• C» « — •'«»• — «■«««0«>#»«i»

^«»^*-M.««««C

» •'• o - - •«••*- *

*••••#«#»*#■« w » e * ** —^•» — - • •••«co—ooo ooooeeoooe

*• » * « «— MtQtf»«'«

w —•♦c — —— •" —^ •«^oeoeeeoo ooe oooeooo

8o«« — c»«*c

,«^o»-*-~*'« «—«-o — CO — oc OOOOOOOOOO

r — «**«••«•-•- ^o»i^--«-«*- •^«oooooooo OOOOOOOOOO

»»«•-^i«" — **-o *'*-»«• — <»• — O

^J■*»«■*■• — #e»^ r«<tfO»**^«MO —

«rf-rf'O-.CCO-o OOOOOOOOOO

^ *■ •

» Q C ( 2 o c «

r «-■ o ^ 9

J V * *■ < • f a £ o - « «. ♦ o * * - o o « e ö o o o e s

O- O i- K *.

**»^«« — *••*■ jr-j—«s ji »**••■ •" _#-fC^* — OC*>.-s.—

•>*»30C;00OOes -~OOPOOC»CO

«•^CO«-».' T**« v e ^ ä ■*.# — *- .fl- ■-

j ^l Ä - *, » ., ^- V »- .- ft*.«« «<*.«», ^»v rf •- U * «•*■»* ~- ^ . .

C # — —OOrtlOO O JS O O i* O .^ O O O

». ***• v* <

•»•A.C.».»»««'»»'

-jae^^ÄO«"*1^". « «OOOCOCC—O OOCOOOOC CiO

«»««•-«C'n'u'VO «

X Mt * ««*-^ —— « — _*«•«.*■-«« — *- ♦*» — «ifA'O — ooo — ocoocoo&oo

O»". — » — O"«"

trt«^«"-«(0«"-»« 20*«*«« — « — -O

«*o—oeocooo SOOOOCOOOO

"•OO«^--»»«*'*» O •*■«■»»»- O #■* •- 2*«OMM«n«« -rr _**>0 — •©"SO-»« — .«w^wont — OOO OOOOOOOOOO

*.0-**»-fc*>««

jO^-fM — » *«■•-« OOOOOOOOOO OOOOOOOOOO

O*1'"*«- Orf*»« «•"©♦«OW^Orf*

O^O»««*-— — w«

— O^OOOOOOO OOCOOOOOOO

«« — rf1— — — 1^1*1 *

J^O^O — «< *«•' O^O^v-ooooo OOOOOOOOOO

o» «—rf»»* ei\# « Wi^ — ■^'S — ««o j ** fc. •• .» O n* ■• (^ ^. im

3»*.»« — *--««» -l rv « ö ff« O " J' * ir*

00«^raN0030 0030000000

* j" *-c!»«e««» S1 *~. * *^«~«Ö««-- ^«w»«o«*vO-r<» ooooo^eoeo OOOOOOOOOO

»«K.«0*>«»rf«>« O —•»0*»*'^0«'

kJ»>'»%#i*»".0«-«. ]» rf. -. *. « — < C * — 9" _(_0»l.«o»»i^o*.„ o# — — oocooo OOOOOOOOOO

n*M»o.*«<'»r>«<

wip-i«»—O*«"'«

_.*« — »*« — — OCO -OOOOOOOC'O OOOOOOOOOO

»^«0O«O«,"''»ff O »s, --. ». C *• • " « «r Jp». — O^ K. « MO »m« _l*«rw*> — wOOOO

-«■OOOOOOOO OOOOOOOOOO

j*— ö« oo — o^.— — OOOOOCOOO OOOOOOOOOO

««M<0««»'W^*' o#*o< — o»*1»» rm^tvff- o * o • *> »

— OOOOOOOOO OOOOOOOOOO

-. -- « C 9- — « »^ * • »--.--i^O^o»'

^^""^«»O^O« —

— ooe©ooooo OOOOOOOOOO

ooo — «-»»o^

0**000— o»o — So-w«*^^-©«*.

— OOOOOOOOO OOOOOOOOOO

♦ — * ••*K-|Oir'f^">F «r » «»'•••«■©«BO

■it*«*w»a»«-«« ö »*■ «««»•#«• — «o -(»fi*- — «•>,••«• — *—ooooooc- OOOOOOOOOO

*«»«»•«»■ — n.* — ^rflfc-M»«^*-©

_v»C'*VJfc-«««*' — — *»<«*. *Ol*» —o — o OOOOOOOOOO

©"■ — *>tf04<*>— — O *•*. ^««»•—■M<M

»«»■• — ot^»-«*«n r — *"«»/»»-*.!"«.« j^*Ma——«« — o*1

3*.«*. -, — ^O — O OOOOOOOOOO

c »«« — « — »o« *.tf>»rf>*.««>«».« w*r'"-'*»"»»»<

^^•«O»-»- « — O'" — ^•«•r,© — — OOO OOOOOOOOOO

II III I

«^*t «m» c—w'1 —

OOOOOOOOOO OOOOOOOOOO

9 —*--H*«^»V»fc«» ^'VfSd-****»'*.

cj'e«**-**»'^—A>

^ — ^-»^ — --00 OOOOOOOOOO

y«o*»»e — '•c*»'s -fi/" — — OivO *o%«

— — ooocoooo ooooooooec

»*«0«**ff*-i»

o — «* — i^«o«* — O »»^»Ofc**» — »o

©«♦O'veoooo OOOOOOOOOO

r--*"« • * *■ c*-«»»n

40

Page 52: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

«>- « o — e -> « —^

» *■« ••••■•»«'-•■ „•.««O — O—*«• — —ae—oeeeoQ ceooooooee

• ••^«»»•^■«^* — <%-. *-«,**•- — »O«— ••W^'Nt — — ••

— oo ©»ooeoo oooooeooeo

«•ooooeoeee ooo oe o ooo o

»)•• — — — «•o-o _ —C — 0".-'#OCO

— eoocoooce cceooöoeoo

• •*-••* -»•••'*C ^a«* — **■•*—«»■ »—•'«■»^•-O — * —

*^ooooecooo oeeoeeooes

u> • "• -c « " ' » » o • y *••*'« O « « n « «

3009000000 ^ocooonooe

•*•••■ *»*«-rf-a<S ^ «» j ♦ ^ ■*■*■■*- o .^««-on&ooooc

*">a s c o o c o o 00003000CO

#■•—•■#— •^■ffCi?* M.A.O«C *■«*■»■ —

f ««» «» o « » » « '

caoeoooÄfie oooooDscoä

?■* — • — • * • »■ ♦

»♦**'»>1»*-^-«Sl*'0* w— «—©«■"•OOC oooooooooo oeoooeoeoo

■» *^■•*«•*■•-»• » • r «»■ « •^■«v «

^»^»oro*-—•*« »«^^'WiO'*»»«»*- j*-.o-'^oooao

*, — ooocccos OOOOCDOOCO

a-f — Äsro^o«»»« _<»•• — p— —«■-•oo oooooooooo eoooeooooc

»««i^fw — ^Oif«^

»«"■s*t» * ^. «. O — ■* ^i _j»w»0—O — C»wOO

•wOOOOOOOOO COOCOOOOOO

9- t\,t* r*m if ** O * * »rt — * »■ —•■•s.tr»"^»-

j^o« —«ooc — e -oooooo^oo oooooooooo

*j^O<B*»-"»**0 — »♦O — Oi^O»»*!© „•»O-nOOoOOOO oooooooooo ooooooooco

n. e ff A»* •- ""^ <- — «»ff»hffSS)««

j — '-tSl — OOOOOO — ooooooooe ooooccoooo

«'s.»- — f--. — »«S'^

j — "O— — — cooo oooooooooo oooooooooo

aoeeoooeoe

*##^-•■©*««* — —

«« ©"•© 9 OO O Ct oooocooee©

:=2s ^ . - # o e M o ^

«•« eo ooeoe c eaooooöooe

ta.*.*:»©»*©-*« •i rti, » — © «« « « rM t

; — »»»»««••♦♦<

*• — «o*»r? — «• —

^ » O 9 r - "•

o»"»- «v —<r « ^ « « *■ »*>♦»©•♦»♦•«•<«

sooooooooo

«0«0 — — ^tf1«»

i^«->««>«0«0© — «^©or-ooep no^oe©©©©©

« • » ^ * o • «*- «

M « o Wö. o e © c© oöo^cteoöoc

f •©'♦*#*'©»•

©oSSoeSsäö eo«©o©o«$o

«•«•»«««•«**•*■«

^^If««"«.«©»!.^-

S eooe oe© o

•»»©•#»— s • •>• * »c • — *# # # • o «• © « »^ «■« •». « ^ © •• «»•*«»»' ■•* — *»

^«0*»0«'"*i —o — ««•O'OOOOOO eoöoooeooo

S« — ••»«»^•■»«

VQ*«««*»©««

^} — O »Ä»M.^ o

«•«*«*e<»^«

— 09 o ©ooe© e ©eooooec*©«

•»a«-« — ©«»* «« « « « «• «•# « o <- ©•.

a oo ooe ts «a o

*»_*«* «M>A) «

r » * "ä •*!.*»# *

»©©•".♦ — ••«'* »«•«»*i «**•»•* ,.5 - •, --"*#*«• e «o — -« — oo©« «»ttooooeooo

•»• — — «» ■>■*■•«

r — ••»•.• *> —^ •* * ♦ o o #*■ —•- o -** •"«•"•©'S«©—«© OOOffiOO^CO©

• «>«*«os«©o »^M. ■» « «tat *, tf> «

• «©"•CO* • - ■» O C - - -

»ooo©©

r«n.».*.#*0©<n*« *«• — ♦mir*.©*

9 oooooeooSe

xp««*«©*1***^

—oooooeppo oooooeoooo

o**».««<^*> «« •• * «« *-«-**'-. XA>#*»C©©©>" — ^««"«'»o — ©e —*■ - *, — «© oe o o© oeceoooooo

^*rf'•»-0^r*,^Pft**>«,* Z «n. » «©O«©"*

sssiissisi "■^-•••»■ — «ft.^« JOO»-*«^«»*

J ~^ « ^ ^ o * © ©- ^ — jV-t-OOOO© ©oooooe©oo

ffft.«ft»ft« ft-*ftt©0 — «»»Q« —*«•»

»»-««•■►•♦©♦•ft- ^ o * ■# «r. * — e— — o—©©OOOOOQ OOOOOOOOOO

U -• « " ^ t^ 9>' 4 * «ft * aro«*D •*•"■*■-» J -• »^i If •tä-afttC O —

««si-«o-c©eoo OOOOOCOOOO

«♦ff*»©*«© — ©«^

OO — -sOÜOOOO OOOOOOOOOO

o»^9'«->0««-av

j « « « ft; ft» * ft» « •■ f* o-o-*ooaooo oooooooooo

tA»AiO«»«ft>««>0 «««««MtfteM*« ^«*ft-»0".*«-«-i^ ÖO©ooooooo ooeoooeooo

^•-ft-C»«© — »-« ••«•o#**—«ft* ■ ftf«©wj»©ft^«M

♦ «©*• r «» « f««ft ^«M«^*»^««©« C«9*4««W*ft^M©

©eo©«©©«:. O© ooo o fe©e 6*©o

r * o < , Us; » *> « v t» - ** ,;■ fi — ^ -.Oft. — **«ft.«l»p —

So©o «©« ooo «ooooo^c CO

©«•»««ft-«©-** m««*^ # tV » o — l*«ftl—*^#1»*#*»

^««««-•w —— o — oc "OODOOOOOO ©oeos^oa©©

^©^«VO^ft-ft.!*«© « <ft **< « « »©<■>«•* -l*"*'***——-.©ftl ©oae©eooeo ooäeceooo©

ooooosoaoo

«-*©©»*♦** ©

u«*O^Cft-«»nt#

^«««OftaÖ^ftt^©

ft«©*©**«^**«« «**•• — —f>*«-«©0

«.-oooceooo oeoeoooeeo

> i i i i

O «ftt»- • ©«> * #o — ö«* «# ©*«ft.

«•^•w<«fttO«*-»* ^

-ff «"'ff «SS00

ooeoSooooo

©*»-©* ©•*• —ft* <««#ft.~ft.«i>it». ©■-Oft,-*»-««*

CM«*>«—*»ftlA(* -•-•##•«<» — o*># m s ©oo © © © e © oeoeo©ec©o

♦ ••• « * —p * ««N r, • ••»#**#^* —« ijft«#i.ft-»*«»»fttft#0 2*o©>ftpM««fti^ ^ • - ♦ »v #. - * -ft, ©

<5 * —ft. © o ©e © c e©©oooo©eo

•*»■ ft. * -o • ^ r < V-*fft « «ft> * ©o«. . ^©♦•i^-ft.ft.-'O*

ft(»ooaaeoop oooeoo©ooo

#OPfi-0—-o« ^ «» tf< »»»•"»• ^ ^■•«^»•©^Aftift««!

* p * ©

o ©?© oc

« —

*

1

•- o ♦ ♦ ft« -*

* — • ** Oft- © » ■»*» — •

* «ft © MO*««© $:: 85

o © o o o o OOP©

« ftift- - "•♦ t'ZZ »s ::? s 0©©©000©© t 1 III

41

Page 53: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

**.* -■#6 ♦ « ** w ••- # —* «OO —«

5ö£ ofc ©«►« e f

« 5 # J « ? 5 re - #• # 3 —— eoe c-a-oa

«**%•**-<>•¥■«*-

.-(••^» — «■• — *, — *«

0 c e s o o a c v> o 3 - ■ > > = . 1

* »*.»■ ♦«*.— «*« —

r •♦**•■• e ->•• •0 ^irc«. — " — oe-'c;

— « ^ »w — «■ r x f- * »•"». — •.*«■• * ->■

_<••*■ *,vci*—•» — —

«ft,fc-w —e -. e* -

w*^-«— — »u<?CJO — f — O C' o o O S » C5 JI

««•■«■"»• — '■ o

^wntO^"« — -•-•-•O ooeocooooe oeeooooooc

o ' t »* t * t i

-.■ —— OCOCOOC ooocooccco

«■r(»»«tfh « « 9-

— OOOvüOOOOC Öi^OC -SC.OOCO

O , . . 1 ; 1 ■c • J O A: •*"•'"* "^ • •

tv «• ^ «■ •! h,*-«»-

£ »■..■.■«•»- fS. * -^ » — *■

-a .•* O e» t? o n c c-

SA *9 ^ ^ r f. ■. ^ -

*oe©ia*coce

«--*»■«—^ — «■ — '

?sgggg

»*e* « •*-•• » <",■

•*•• — — oo «00 =

^ * •■ «4 # -g •« * ö — F »■ - <■ * O ft ■* — V *

«i--«-,*^ ■.* < * «n — « »

* —if -» fc- *<*-'"0O

cococooeso

«-, *= Ä«— ■••>!— *■««

_l — •^» v^O«^*" ^^.^c——-«one

vj»-da-*^—•♦•^ »^.*-~^ — ^*y^ e

-O'VSC—o — —

3» -e *V *#>■.*•'« *^i

Pa'<•■■*««• *>-«« *>•

*■»•- — ♦»w«^«.*-»

oo©oe»e*oooo

00*0 — ««o —p« ooocoooooo

•>. ••> tfl ««»fMISO^1

ar —*» —■•^»otf.*»*

oooooeoooo

• «*» — «** "wO — »«* — »o*»» —

^©'«■♦'•O.-V»»-»

oc*o — 00000 C ^ C' O O V; o o o o

* ^ «, •>■ V *■ * •« "9 *■ -• ir -> s O O '- .•« ^ «r^

i; — « ^ 0 O —t' O O OOrt5 3 0C3000

n /. (» -ü 9- O ■* " " rt „ *, ,^ T ». .- - C „ * O

^J «r »■' V- *■ -^ •- •< *I A

at—^j*»«!? *4j'\>—' ■J — O W -» P ' O -TS i"* O -

- ■.■ Q 01 r». es a ä o rt O -3 tt o c c ^J o c o

*C*.«* NOW'» — — ->fr ♦^-v »■«*'-'

tJ »■.»>*. O » <r w -• "-•

^*Äi<B'o--r>- *-■■*

a o o 3 a 9 c v «i 6-

A — « ^j «f >- • ö »»... •»

■--«■ e B o -& «. ^ a «

LJ — • # 1^ « * ao rf- r- -.-

— cooi-ts'-eo o

-* ; * " •• e O »> fr- » • «ft « *■ ". i »«•--. K, — «.*•.» 5 »#*»«•■•■«

JV — e fi O -*> C C ..-,- «5

■«—««•• — ««• — • ««>•«•<■»»• — «» ^•■^•*<-—^«O^M

rOOO — OOQCtO oeeoooooee

c»-c*o —'«»•* OO«"» —»P. —•

M —— — eooeo o ooooeooooo

« -■ — « — « or Mt p 'tw / - —«■#««

-** », <U i ^«M.^^^*. B 1^ 'S * t # ".*•••«» ^•vCO« *-*•*•* o «>^-.o-*ooooo oooooeoooo

.4 #* Ä. « -3 *v - » «

= ^ «t1^*-—«fei*«. » » >- s- *i e- sr. er» # o • wr**1^ — . o "• --- e o

SC003O0C*0O

«« — — •je*-'** " » — « * * jf **•*■

r *» — D -■ " o — ^ ■ e —

»H- —rseoor »00 oorcoooooe

^ M * *• >( {^ * ^ ^ ^ «,

Eroocaeoooo

»- » ^ •

_fe-r>*-«»<0««*00 * ^„-o OCOOO COOOOOOOOO

^•ooo — ooooe oooooeoooo

w — » V"d*'0-«-«-VO -•oo — cooooo c-occooccoe

4,— »«■"'«««•«O rf'rf' — *•— — jr^t^i»

n*—.v«^ — «. — — O oooonooooo

o«i*«»«9<*> « « n.

-» — »©•«-»♦•irff OOO— — •DO — O 0090000000

III • 1 I

«tf**»**»*»*» — »O

.j *•#■- — — OOftt — —oPoooppoo oeoooooeoo I t t 1111

OTMfVM,»r^l««C ««*1~0*«SA«»»-

r^^r — ow^oo*- _,»«**« «f -.*-*» o — o^-ro — 00000 oooooooooo

II II

»•wO«» — »-*'»--••

— -.MOCOOOOO oooooooooo

O ^rv^-AtvOi^rvH 0fsi^'0^^9'0^»0

j ^ -►- ^, * (M —-. ^© ^O*" —OOOOOO oooooooooo

• «^•oin«»«A«

_i«i*-«0'"'*0'rO — oooooooooo oooooooooo

— "»»-O»»*»-—*■**-■ w«««*«*-* •■■"«-♦

,rf«'Si«i*.00 — "*— ■v — — — —ooaooo OOOOOOOOOO

«»ir <ioo*«r»* *"

MOO—-«0000*< oooooooooo

¥■*■#*►-("*• — »o ^ «•--.* — «(SIVO^ «O^-iOOOOOO OOOOOOOOOO

I I (I

r.df««t*«*«M-«»o

». t, •. •» ^. f> ^ # W> M

a: • • - < «'-•"•O*M ^ ♦ * J« •?■ «» O *u -oc

—occooocoo OQOCOC eooe

O "O ♦ * *ä «rt ^ « •"

LJ •< 1- A an SB ' S e *• * *> »c fr j ♦ o c * •■ c

c — o 00 o OO C O o o

t

a « O *»*•

o ♦ - o o < c o c

rf W Ä .-♦**«> » -•-.< »"

X ■**.£ & **** C **-'»< ■ -< S *5 O O O C- O O ö O O a O «■ Ci ^ • O -i 3

^ £ M. — 5 ■• t: Cf — — o O -I O O « fv O £: O C £ C C" Ö ri O '1 Ci s> r-

J- *» 1- — — J5

* ^ — ̂ « Ai

V) # JV <» * -1 * ■£ •^ « «. c a ,t «u e 0 O O OOO

fk — ■f f n- « r^ ,V

< — - »■^ • 0 e- -s, N ^ ■• - * ■^ «.^ tf* -^ ^

-rs a 0 a O O

0 a oäo^oocie

— .? IT * *- O # ♦ 1* O * ^ 9 ~ -f « « «o »

«nM_oi#>tv_^fMO« ywo — e#***-#* — _*i"*»v*o*«r^-ioo

-. o o o o o e ■ roc OOOOOO €> COO

Z *< ■» O 0" >i9»-*^* ^■"o^ir — Nioa — c o—oooooooo oooc000000

**■«•!? *-ÖO*-«* *-^-*«i**',wOO»

^«♦•(»♦O'Si'v — .»*>* j»0*"*0 0 — OO — "fOOOOCOOCO oooooeoooo

PW O * O. W *- J) •" * i^

y««>>-Oir*-fwo — fti rf*-.«^ — OOOO —

OOOOC-OOOOO OOOOOOOCOo

— — *■» ■<■»•»-»"■»» .■-■^•sjO^flm»^ f ft

v* j «A n 01 * o * *• •* -•

j — -«ofyoo-jOoo "Moooooooao nffloooooooo

t/ 's' - ^ n» 1- «or>fv *.-'«. Jil ™ R* -.*»■ — 0>

*-* *«»^^«**« _(•«« — IM— OO nOO OOOOOOOOOO oooooooooo

42

Page 54: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

— • o • «.* «*<««,«>

■«*• wOO o —o oo OOOOOoOOOO

C l i l I I

■ o——or»oo»* • *»*» o » — * • -«

OOOQOOOOCO

— «■oooooeoo ooooaoeeoo

e • ■!■. 5

OOOOOOOOOO

»•»•*0«*" — -■

« — oooooooo OOOOOOOOOO

O t I t . . t

u^4i«or«'«#>o «<*• « *. B. •« *, ^ D «- ^»■^«««nfOOC Soeooooopo oeooooeoo

rftMiV*»»" *> — o « «

JO*«*«- — «"««•"^ ««•ooonooeoe OOOOOOOOOO

O t i ■ At

*• • O * ♦ rf* *• O — •- oO««»*«*9»9 « X««0*-*W««'*-*'*A ^^^•«« — OOOO

«■ ■* *■ o n o o o o o o C OOOOOOOOOO

■M —

»♦ — *' — ♦****« MAM «MM! ««MO«

X««0«9^«'l">w^O ^•««>Mi«NO«AiO

OOOOOOOOOO OOOOOOOOOO

O 1111)1

O'tftM^o-O««*^» »•*«OMt«*_MM«

8000000000 oooeooooo

I I I I I

• ftt«<n«»-*-o«« •^■rt^^<0O-#»#O9 CWM«»^««»t^#IM ^nt — O'* — — OO-O OOOOOOOOOO OOOOOOOOOO

O i i • i • ) t l ( « f •■ ♦ ^ ff p-O ** *» — ^

^^^^Mf" «troo U — OVP^'O^^M Z»«<n»-<0*»*'»* ^OM^IM^O — OOO »ooooooooe OOOOOOOOOO

III II

B.»»._,rMn«o«tft

^•«««o^^r^'^o Xr»K—•««OMtfOA« J* — o^ — o-—oo •"OOOOOOOOO OOOOOOOOOO

o r i» 1111 • —«»l>**0»»»MM

tj> « •- «r * » ^*.,*^fc. »«••vrtMo«^ — -• _(»mM(0O0 — OOO OOOOOOOOOO OOOOOOOOOO

»«ir^««o«itfiM «<M|f*n<0»9«l»*

JO — — ooooooo — ooooooooo OOOOOOOOOO

O I t t I N

• 0»*#»*"-M*.fW V**-«*0**-*ni«(SO » • * —«O —*■—Mt*1

^MMOOOOOOOO «OOOOOOOOOO

OOOOOOOOOO

:♦♦ —o » * » •*■ •

-•«••O* # # • # M 8 —J*«O OOO —o oeoeoeooo

• I I I f • I

• ««o—o»e*«"

f * « » o ♦ «• # •* ♦ M««>Mooo —— o OOOOOOOOOO

II I *

S« — * —*~ae —

j«0»»-«**#0«. « —MtfOOOO^«» OOOOOOOOOO

e • •■•«».—^*—^-^

^ •«•» M «#«»*' — *•*.•« «— ''*»««M«0»V jOM^««»44«*^ ♦ — ••>».«**<•*•«. o oooocejcooo

j*« *»»«»M<i^M«i *w-*MM.M6eoo OOOOOOOOOO

• -»•*.*- C •♦- O <* o • ".»M « O « - « « «>

^•^•-©"■"♦•♦Otino »■0~«0«0^<*-0 oo—eeeoooo

w — **•■♦•".* 3 O * -••v»so — oeooo noneoeoooo

o • IT ««•«»»• O *■ »M «

»•^o««o«*»-»- — o

»««•OMOOOOO OOOOOOOOOO

I (I «I

^*V^M««^>«OM «•«At —««M—)v

■ 0#»M«^««M«*. jM^*.*^aPOO# — S-*o —oocooo ooooooooo I I I I I I I I I

» «« • « M»» ^. A, M ». «I • W*-■ O # * • » » »w * uo«^-*«^*!««««

W^-«0»-000'>*OM «M — — OOOO —O OOOOOOOOOO

I I I

Of*M*«*.^««>S ««»««f-'O-*« — OM» r«o«o«««Aio^ -«♦•Sf — <**«o — — o MOOOOOOOOO OOOOOOOOOO

o • M«0«0^«««» . NMN —O O O —*■ ■# U»»*lW"*0'«««* VMM«»««M«MO ^«•'•-•OfS'stO«'» M^o—OOOOOO OOOOOOOOOO

I I

^•"•»«•»•«■-•«*

»»■»**♦•«—«»^« J — •• — ««♦•wO*« — «steo ooooooo OOOOOOOOOO I I III III

m ■•Ä»#MM— *^Mfr

U^'W — «N^M^-O*

^^«»»-MO^NMO

oooooooooo « I

«^^•«•«tf«Mno ««tO<*,«»<^vtMn«

iMB.M».oo»MA«a«

., ►-^^-.»MOO— <S. ooc—oooooo OOOOOOOOOO

o • <# *« •* • >* « * N » O

• O M M ~ * «W • M O * u-#«oa»M«tf««« ji«-«rf>o* — *>«■" — a

^^««■OQOOQO 000000>3000

«•«%«««• M«»0'0

«,!•»*•♦— — ««•*».♦ M*oo—eoooo ooeeoooooo

e iii

• Ifc *«(0 # W1 M — o« *##« i##»«*l«l

yj* «^O« » » « « « S » «I M «««««« « ^«*M*>^M«|M»» «O ••oo» — ooooo o—oeeeeoee

* i * • ■

^■«SM#>*b»^«0« r »o»- — v * ♦*•«»*■

"*-.-ooSooopo OOOAOOOOOO

C I l I l t 4

«^©-»♦ — »«•*• *M^.M.O*»0»Vrf'*'

^«•.•SlMWM^««^ »OMViiOVO»«'*^ ^•^••►••»»—♦ «o «M—ooooooo oooccooooo

M»INi«^.».^*».M ♦ •♦ — *c—— • —

»—-.#—*.ö»--*0#' -.-*"-0-000 -o MOOOOOOOOO OOOOOOOOOO

e i • ■ *

• cfTvm ***'»&*•*•

»♦• — *« — — #—o ^—aM#*«o—»v — o MQOOOOOOOO OOOOOOOOOO

■'».««•««««■«Mfk« MCMd^M^M««

^OM«»M».««»*

-«•*«% —ooooo — —oouoöeoop OOOOOOOOOO

O t t t ill

• *»«»-•»#.«» M < ««•^»•MO^O

LfO^^MM«^«^« SM«I9W.»«M0M«0 U-**** #-.0 00 00

» ". —ocoooSco O OOOOOOOOOO

h. X *A. 1 « tf> «•> • » O

ft*«*V>0^O«ihf>-

in«iW*M«o*«« «Or>«*oe-«*>OM JO*O«O——oeo %0 60000000 OOOOOOOOOO

O } t t II I

• »» • fW«V « « O » »♦ •• — *»■ • « M •

OM».k.«00 — » — p

WM«MMM«*n^l««a OOOOOOOOOO ecoooooopo J I I I I I I I I

»«^M^^NSMM vl*iiO*-tt«tf'OMOM »»•♦«•MAO—— ^««r-0-«**PpOp •voooooeooo OOOOOOOOOO

o 11 r 1111 • #«M«»0««>«

--epo oo o c 4 OOOOOOOOOO I I I I If

« —3 «P>•• — fc. « tA-M-M^O«* — «PO« »«♦«♦«^«.ÄO« J *•«# *♦^--* •"OOOOOOOOO OOOOOOOOOO

O l I l I I l i • i ■*

. ^IS>«4— «-«M*!»«

4J«rwro««*-»>00 c«At»Aoee»>AA _«^.^fsen«0«'V-> —

ooe oooSSee I I I I

0»«0*»»*-M»*-

(»•«•now — «M WMtf<MO"« — 0 — «"0 ««oooooeoep OOOOOOOOOO

O • l I i i M

«-•00»*M«M« .« # « ^ « *i N M K *>

ClKIMM»*.»«-.«» ^»«OOMMQOOO

s ssssssisss k> I I ( 4 •• V »fMM « « « k B * O

•S9ZZiSZiSZt ^»•«-••««««0.—

oooeee eeSe

... ^..N »#♦ — — ##*i»-0«

ooeoeo«e&o

«MM ««» « •••• OP o « o • «•■ *-« — l*»«*'0«*-*-*'#*fc

^M«o*o«-S49 ^ iv»- «o-tpooe OOOCOPOPOO

II I I I I I I

•*♦••««•••*« —

CM«M«l-l«ti*«M jO» »*■#•*. — •*»

•>• —— P*»—«n — OP OOOOOOOOOO

#1 • M— «*»Äfc.MM-»

ir—O««*'«»-««© j«**o-r #■■••-#'■#•« «h. —MM^QOOO oo—ooooooo

#»OM*M»MOM ^ k.«MN«U »«•«•>.

M«».e«weooMp ooooooeooo t ii if

o • ««MO»*^ O*-•» **"

».<►«» fc. * Mft,^ »

iM»JIM.«M||«.«M

jn*«u<^*0«»«««« — «»^ •♦ O O- —O OOOOOOOOOO

« «M. ■» <r ^ *•- *» O

« ««MMO^«»««

Sa««iofbt»«ii««««

^I^ tf>oo»oe»e- SööiS?8l8g ill II

w^-**»»«* —♦# a«i«^«f««-«w<"^

''io-oSSSoSs OOOOOOOOOO

I III

O «» •*« O M««M M # » •*• — «*l«0 #

wi>-....o«««v-# »*» — -* — ««#«•♦♦*« J«P»Mi#«MO«MM M.QocPoope ooeeoooeep

• 4 » ^ * •Q — »»» — • r * —pif * »-M« **

I«*«»««tft«totfio«#

M& — d poppp P OOP oo p ooo o

i III

f>.«hr«»«.*IS*5*

SO* oo^v *»***

ooSeeSaSoo iii« i

m ^•••»•"• —•♦•

pSoSeSSSSo I 1 J » t

^«•*-.#-»w^oS- «-fp — —oo«So oooooo eo oo

• M *•♦*«# »»u «*M < **# O *Wi *•**.» *«i

S So»OOPooo

« — S3 « —

43

Page 55: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

s — « 5S

fS2*o —* * » * r

-Iff " f>, — n« ^ " , oo oo O < e ö e e ö s

#«« «o «•# *»■#«#)* w«» •- C- p «• * Ä—«^.ö

^ *w © o } o o e

.« — * fi *■ ^l *• at *•*•■? "^ o — ^« #«.*- «•«

—00000 000 00 o o a

_. * o J *w * CT ■«

O IS O o o Ü c

o c o c o o

^ »^ — « • » • «or?«'

5 O £

«•* w» *«a «a »•%«?■*>.-•-'■« — ■*■,*

5 « e » « — f- 1 - *«

i*fli:0 v— #-•-»«* -» f ^ M .» fk « ». ^ ft,:.., „

•*» t # •■.# * 'W — •» * w «

»*«<■**•**[*« »»

* ö - e o o p o o S o

IM —

w». j^ ^. »■«»«*»• «c »OO»1 — *=> — *«*

o<>ooococoo oooaeooeco

o 1 1 < • - 1 *

<"»- e*c*v^ — •*< ur *■ ». — r. ^ - c * r »

ooeoocjoijoc

K * «-.»«--C ■".-«••

O—OOOCOOOO ooaooooooo

o 0 *» r 1 1. 1' 4 ( ♦ * •» K •* • * if -• ••

• A ^, « ^ ". v »' < ir

^•^ — *coc — — ■ o «•"rsooooeco Oooccoocoo

O If ^ 'v c « #■ *o«

»««»—».->- » K ^ O » -.-.»vo -.-«,» «v*. „C — — — '•"•OOO — *^oc»ooooooo ooooooooco

O . t - .

• ■» *l — * K: iA # » N •• **<»■*«««(? -C"

Jp © » rft 1^« -• #»(. o ■ •* fVi

«.H-QOOOOC. 00 ooocooooSo

01 iT 0 «w S «v 0 t» s; - c !5 c s ^ c e e r

' ^

1 ' !

ft *»»~.*-^*'^. * * *1 « --v « «

9-

^ *; 0 ps-« (5 e 0 »■ is

♦- J # -• » 0"s. * « • * *-» -"P c- r « «:9> *■ * T ^ •-

0 «• oao^acs-»

J«K^»*^ «**»■*■ * r -e f. 0 * & J* & ■»■ * <■ ^ ■* e f. ■*: * *. t* V *~ 9

us # ^ — — » e .» — o

o S »s. rf» —••«.*'-• ■*

*. ~. * o "V r. v o o c- — 5 o c 0 £ o 3 ^

-* O P,.—«* —00 Ö OOOCCOOCCC

«.»■ — —■**»—•«•-

U « « >■ <%K, — •"■*■

_ IT ^ fc. « •"«A'*'»"« »« — — uoooon

mo-r-r-Kftr — ■»'.

^ * « ♦ BS ■» <•* •- - O •- »O — ^W*»— * -*«

^^'vOO — O'vO — ooooooocoo

fVOrf-W^ — Ä^O* o«.» <- ■■ O "^ ff • ""i *■ z >>■ « ■> r « ^ « o «r 0

yp ■* 3 _•—-*«,— -• a OOOODWOOOO

O — O # Ü — !* « "•*

"W^OOJOO — OO

t^ © f« ■■ * f* «» P« ^ ** i^-

w »•*■#*»**»•*« *"

y ff M « «-lrf"<«W*J> — ^1 — -•« Ä-.^— «■«*

r>*.«"Q.«■•'"** « O O O C f! -1 O O o O

^)«-. — ««r.n.^.rf'Ö

^5 -V — * # -v ,» -„ _ _ 0 3 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

^o — ro—■« — ••«>

- * o c o »- c c ^ a t «o o c e ^

o sooooocae

< o 5 e — « o 09 * ^«©ooccoca

_._,*-* 4» •» - 6

e55?Soi»c 00a

". C - Cv - - ^ -■ * ^

' 0»* «e ~ e " —0 — a .«j« 0 a e c c e 0

it «,«■■» ™♦*«»»■—«.^ «■ O • * * — O O * » <P

*-a-—coo-»-'«*-

y« » C •» "* -^. <fc * * «w -

«s — Cr » S1 -<■ C t«*?? P, — — _ ^ -3 c- -; o -1 ä e «s o a» o o o .© e

-«c -'-50 — coots

© -* #. .B». .* .* -^ „ e» &. •*■ ** *• 4to *n W. ■*• •* * tt ar « **• - r. a- # o o — ^ * ^ -r c •" # o c- — ^r1-

c» r e C C « » ft c- o

; * « « « »i. w *• w ■-

N t» «- o o c s> a e ■3-1030000?

SOCOOOOOÖÖ

« "* « O « « ^ • O *

»'OO-''»*^» — « — ^ « * » ^> a •■ » f* i. •-

oco^oooooo

*v*vC»0&'5C 005 oooooeoooo

« j^ — * .*- B, «i # — o n © *i 1/ 1? C*!^!^«!

?*»-OM*WI*W»«

#•$■« — *■&*■*•**■*'

WC'* — 0*V — — OO ooocoocooe

«■«««-eo«»«««« ta»-iv^ «O — «^O-s* X » f- *- i*t**v — »•»*

«-JS.— OOOOOO OOOOOCOOOO

«Ofti — *"-*•—f«»'

u"^*^l'"*« — # «••■ jr«s> —•^-•^» — •■ .j *.-,.*.*. — .*.« cw * .*

^*0'-- — -.0000 OOOOCCOOOS

* « « rw »v «> ^ • w ». O — — O-'^*O^0'iM

wfrf'OOO — "»O*© *%C— — O-'O'-O OOCOCOOOOO

•> O IP "N «•■**'# » -

^«««■«»••roo«

„I»»*' — — •'■'WOO^ O^'-OO-^— 00 ooaooooooo

«•-«•< — — *- — *» (.* — ■#■* « ^ * •" O W V

^fS — *«»{>'*'^»-» K.»M-^— OOOOO orsoooooooo

^-»w.' * *• * — O O !f■

-j'N«^ a « * ao * o is. — — -- — ooocoo 000000000a

o^O^^^^^QWO »^ n^o^ofvÄe-i

o«oooooooo 0000000000

r 0 m- « «■ h fl-- vT •» .> * -« l1: O ■-! n

0 a O e '^ '' O e 0

w ■* n * ■»

- K y * ■# *• * w ^ * «■ •* ^ *• '-5

■■■; "i -;> 0 O a 3 O O ■i M

»fr*1**-»- V) c « — qt-if» ■!* " p- ri, » *v ■«*■ ■«

^•"«rv---*— *»"*«

^^<e — »♦f« — — — - o-««oocococ ooeeaecooo

<r«*oooococo cocooococo

C^J — *-^--"-#

7 *<• ^. « « * fNi "i 'x <« -• -JW fl*-* — O" — "O oeocaocooo OOöOO^«OOO

J •* »w !/'■■•• ir o » ^ *■ c

^fSiOOOOOCOC oowoooooo:

■»»M^-ift* * o r 9

^Ol'■*p«,B*'**,—•- y»—e»o —o-*'^*'*' -IO'V*'^*—o 000 ^OOOOOOQOO 0000000030

* — a^rf*^**-* t ©^•*) — <->*e»-«#^

v — "-©^*^ — *ffa r — — 5- -/• « ^ • — ir» M».« « *'-ocooao

•v — OCCOOOOO OO0CC0C103

«*»«*.« — ^|fN*iO» F Ba-» is* r« O »•"*■* ^ O ^^■»«OO — — — — — —

«.aooftooooci f^ooco-rsocoa

i » - < • ■« i% — B* * I

• ~ o < ? o o c 5 G O C

S,l i *V *■*■■*■■*••■•■ (P D

44

Page 56: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

> p. «B #*■>■•#■ C ^ #■ t *- «? « r, ^ * <* *, «<• ». a ^ ä ^-ss « t-.

— «w j^ » <r. *.»#■** ^ -• ««-«»£>£ -ö o » <ä

-#—«■•—•• ♦•—•

^s — «t — « »« fe *- O * IS(

©oi»sei<— - «- - « Sv "w ^ t* w « o o o c » s

!,*:■>)*.* Ä «• »V ••» «I » »B)#. — — If^^.»»«.» "^«-.o-Tcöoce

8 .••,.-.....

»^«jt-^öN"«» — — _* « Ä * — • ■« O *■ C5 *•

jr « e # r*** « ««— *• j. ♦-*<(#—*'•. e e ••

a t , i i J i « (I* .*•-#*■• *.fc » -'

J^*»" — ^.»»**©^ — »oo —ooooo

„.rv — *''M««*>»'v — e —

oocoooeooo (TV I >

t »*->« B« *■ *-*■»*• •*

r a — C O O D O 3 o ^

r *- « o * —o »■ • ^ •* « o •»■ — c # * *> « *

VW'S'•*■♦"''•*•- — *»»>. — — ocooocce oaoocooooc

O 1 i ■

^^(B — fc*.**^^ *J*'<»'0»*i-'lPB**' ■<"■•-

-**i *o — * — — a'*- ^.#v<»«o —oo—oo oaoocoooco

i • i it

^o^^eÄ^o-" — ■"

*-. — oooooco oooooooooo

• • • * *• -A ir * .- * *i

(_»*^0 — ->*^-— — ^ ir'**»,»-# — — <ro — „i ir » «• r ^ *, •» * e- *

ooocoooooo

*oo—oooooc ooaooooooo

O > I I < I < ■r

OOOO t> OOOOO

r'W-'*^ — w — "■-

ocesorooooo c ' t * ' *

* »• IV ff ff »w * » ^

^ «»>-.•-■ 1 Oiv«»> j « * — "A.fV^aO"«!

soosceoooo

i - ^* «« « • • « *.

«.*•• « M r, C *• O ?>

^.—• — '*»#—«•. ^C

<■ — *■.- -

- O !* — » *

« »W — -«.-O O O O O

■•-■• a SA o ■"■-•» o

ocoooocoeo

— »f,-. — — caoo

-^,'-*tfi cleft's

s

soooeoooeo

F »•• »^- • (5 ^ — ■# O

* © e «■ o » o o o ö coecooceae

*. — ©cococoo

n»*1*-» * • *•- 3" ■^■fy w •..*-.»*> — *. p" o *- * »» * * OS «»*>«*«*• »»

o — ooeooooo

f- *•«».«!* O

(»«•«•«■'«MO*

«*■* **->♦**« .4««*—-«»«er

ft ••>•• —OQ fy-O eooecoeooe

S »*« — <■ — — ops coaooooee

» — «—A; — -ooe <s>f eoaoeäöo

# « « « *-•<' g ■»*

jr—^»»"-. — — —*-#■

»Of *e —-o —o ceonoooooo

*«0-«#'»— ♦••*

Ätf-f^*^*—-t « —— * '»?. — «.*,*»< »r

o—ocooeoco

o

• •» S«m # « — <!•-*' O

» O *•«»•"*■##'*• «

-.*#-« O O - — O o-*oooooooo

O — « <«On.*-# » » S<» # * —*>* *e 6 « «t»^««»-*«-—e»

^•«-•♦ —»«»«•^■^t «•^ooceoeoo ooooeeoAO «ii [ t

r % «•( e** CM-e * • Mo i««c » «t#<ti«ö

^-yf- «***'■#'* — » »«co**«#—*> — — oo—eoooooo ii > i * t

— *«o**" —o*« — M^— >«««■•»•••»>

«ö — »y«»*fe —g — f)cocoooooe t >t :

O » ■*«»*>.<•» o». «» #« « — .«•♦.-*■—«**•

OOMOOOCOOO

I It*

o««- a » «n«"- » «> « » ^«S - • • 5 -.*»» A

~'NC'<*'«0-'-«ÖO e^oooeeooo

n m « i" « — p ^ «» ^ «

y — O « ^ * * < "• *

_« "«•»• O ♦ * * P -« •* •►

oooppoooe

(«»«.*•*■*.—•-•.

j * *^ *> « C» Op* M^oooeeopn poocaepoon

( it • P

-i* * -••«•^♦PO o*. *— — —popp PPPPPPOPOP

^—•-•■■* Al*-«*«.*- XnffO—»ft«* —*•

*>—o — ococoo OPCCOOPOOP

ocoooowcoo

y—fM«*<vo*^e

»««■•■•«««DO«*» ■j © » »* »* •- «'vistvp

oooooooooo

C-t<l"u — — o — Id OOOOOCOOOO

■rfM — OopOOC^ CSCOCJOOCOOO

. « — - *« « i" K

» m »* •* a a» ■■*-

»oooopocoo

v*n—•0»f>-»<'0*-*» jrw-o*fc o i? — ♦ * —

—"OOO—OOOO riCCöooPwoe

*i*-#«p'»-««

^ «* .- - - - P* If! o o

pMpoopppco OOOPOOPQpO

o c ' * t * » t* I

_**-» — <«»•■■-<-*»Ö

OPOPPOPOOP

;B «t ,*-»>. m *• «K ^ » «> ^•'fkrf'» —MO»—•* •vMOOSPOOOO OOOPPOOOOP

O I I > I * • •■»•«■•a —er»"»

O^lS.— *^ — #0*.*

— ■# — CJO- — OüO OOPOPCPOPO

Omp«.*. ««isiKtn»

E*«ICK.I*».3'«*> ^r—— OO * *. Ö o o

««.o ——oooopo opoooooopo

o . . I i ' I i I

»«^r^W'dppM w #^ • • ••' o^ * *

-jo««(r«-'«o>-o *• — OßOOOOOP OOOOOOOOPO

»». — -p*-**««»

«*<—OO»—"»»"«« ^#«0»V — »M^-OO •nocaoooopo PPOOOOOOOP

p ' ' «

, JM*.#->*p««*»«

C<*»«<r<^tf>«««P _*o<"p»»irisc* — — SM-—nopoooo

PSOCOOOPOP

45

Page 57: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

« — f* ♦ S — o •■*- *

s^rtjassss rf»^*«'* * C * '- • *- *>«_~*ft-#-»*^» s;sgi:j;;s:

o 3SSSS;5?SS

0

össöissssi öSSSSSSSgg

1- «*«••--'»-* *

» ta ^> —• « I» ^ a « •>

*ni=|H23i "ssslsllilg ös«llt;sħ 0000000000

• O

:2s;;;£Sj^ -■ O O • * * *■ r. *> 0 O Z*» « -OO V » - » - ;:S;si:li;s

« „ 'isllillili *-. -0 0 Soo 0 0000000000

f 2 ...... o ' t s ? .;_^m.,^

w--»e*'?o«- -»* 0 ?5;i9j5H:5i *—o—oooacc

Seee«ooc eo - osocoeoocc • oeocooocoo

1

#*#'^«e». »—*

3 i 0

--C-00000 0 f $ -«e^1 —-«■•«*eeoo -■oo«?co5«o© 0000009900 ft. <o^oo«-Jeeocf 0000000000

rf Ü * * ' * t * * * .* * i 0 '•*■'* ,* * * ■ ■ .**.'*,** * .' *

« r V» ^*»»- — O""»"*- A ^J»*-^«*-^-»* »-. — »1^ «(p # »». 0 *• • P- * ■»■ — rf- - -^ « ^ n

s.* *«•'■* •-"'sr-i»'

« — occpoooe ooooeossooe • ■ gssigsssss

i »-«■**-c«»1.»»« «.«s«*.-..»«*-. 3

P*'.^ «O «• « «. » 9 n« «•••««««N««

«■«•»^o«-**»-- — -■ ., O **.«>***•»« -

0-, — oo«e—es OC — — oce-f«e

s aanrooootto ooooooeooe ocncoaocoo

tfipK.-A,«:-s*M-.C

s . •»»«•-««3«#

Iff'^»»*' — •*■*** — f*.».*.-.. —5-»-.ö ^«««o-ot-ooo

c-oo^ooooc OOOOOOOSOO i ;s§8l8iS§s s^oooooo — c » 0-500000003

a 0 0 -eooooooo

' t ■ ' ■ , * , *

'"""'"■"" m —

* w*

V — »a •- « " « •• M • O

- -

_j* —^^miro —^.t« -<••■ «f^ *»•»»* •*© —

ooooocoooo «»«.oocooooo *(SO—OOCS — 0

ooeoooeooo o

eoooeooeoo O

ooeeeoooco

oooeoocöoe

Jf»-«©«»-^-**. ».OO —OÜQOOO oooocooooS

»*'*«*SI«*-»»*»>»*'

«oe^eo — cooQ — — 00000000 0000000000

m 1«

«fw•i(,*^l"»0•• —

^sjrSüSSSit ^ars:ss;§5g .M ^ •. >. At a «t « « ^ ■> r«o*o«*<»>««a Jsisiiiiiii j«*o*o^—-»«

M^-ooo5eoo « « oooeocoooo OttOOOOOOOO

t s .. > ¥ O . 1 , , , 0

i * O*- O * ~ <**■ 9 O y J 0 - •• • 0 ^ *•-•— »O**^-**^—0»<" N •v

N-nO — O-QOOO •-000000050 ooooeeccoo ■ oooooooooc "i oocooooooo

i 3

O

^«*-.fc-.*-* — «O«««*«?-«'-« *.». #0 — »""^fw»» »«^«"■■-«««O -» — ^ «-*•♦»* —'•

J ••• ^ * — ♦^.v * ^-»^♦^^.öooo

~«tr«»«*<-*'*< —

1 *.*oooooo — 0 "SSS^SgSSSg ooeooooooo 0000000000 •. oöooeortoco oeeooooooo ' * * ,' ,* * * :' * * ..•»...•.. i ' ' ,',•,'

rf» * S -1Sfc^.^».*.0'»* • •■•<%.•* — «.o*« O ^.♦A-n»»«f.*oni^ • JI»;5E::Es < *.»o••♦*,♦ — «"*■ 0 ♦ 0*SiM*i*'»MW*'"

oeeooooooo ooooeon oeo ooSoöooeoo **. — — ocooo — oeooeooooo

a

i a '

»■•*o*»«<»»-

^-•ff'N.^OO--» 2 »o • •• — ♦ «'s-« ♦ »■».ji^O-ve^o

-»OO-—-OOO 0—OOOOOOOO

0 '

fN<-)V-— ♦-.-OO ■*ooooooooo

o oooeoooooo O-OOOOOOOO

e »SI

oooooooooe

O

»•-«o* — »o-* • o-«»,1''-*««*« -.«-.^^^«o—o « •»»»«»•»•"«d»

8 • ©-«.»OOff-*-. ^»^»-''»^frO'M-. «0«^«<r-0%^« _.*»-<••(» — 0-*O

8 »■-«-.»-.»or* y/'-*OiM-#^-«'#*<

« « «J (f ■* «- # » ^ « M

e*o--096o- «•ooooooooo s — poooooooo

odesoaoooo «a*---* — M« 'S « S gsSggllggg

O ■3000000000

0 to * r / * i .''lilt * * to 1 * ...... * ",' ','*••• • < — um 1«

r-~'"*rft**'«»o y-*s,»*^jSK.«f»0 SU 0 V «rt ,-^-,,«...,a

■"

46

Page 58: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

_.*<*•**■—«^c — * — oo*oor«N.- — eoeoocoeeo

e i » » . . i

• •« — *»*o—■■-•#

Occcooaooo

•>-#« — *'*#•« *•, —r» — ec—^

^ #*-.»- » * • C - .00 — — ÖOO — s eooeoooooo

«-* — ^ — -,#»#; » *►«.»■ — *—P- « #

oeocoaoooo

^«^ ^ — y^-W^', -

_>•*,«-«■*■ a -■.' t-^ •^^cö — — — e-ei

C 1 .... .

o •«•* • •■ • ► o ♦ »

■j*^ — *— — -»r « O n.*w— OCOcOöO oeoeoeoooo

« — «»■*—•-■•*

pre^1»—fc^ufi»- — ■^•—•». — <* — — — oe ooooooooeo 030©C»OOCO

© . < I 1 1 f

• *•—rf'fcO*« — «

-i — vo**.— ocooe 7 OOOOOOOOOO o oooonooooo

» *0 — »v—o — oe oooeoooooo

o II 1 >

• »««««pfv^r —

j,*.»-^»-. »-•■# — *o •«. — — ooooooe oooeoooooo

^•■»»■ — **•-•"' ♦*> xv^o*-<«^^«o JOOI^«* — N^O* **00 — COQOO OOOOOOOOOO

2 •••,•,•■•,••: . —o--»» — *o«<

• »-'"•#*-*■-«*■«

„.«»« — o — * — «s,^«. », — — — ooo — oa oococooooo

»*t«. # ~> _<». » o «

r*#^o<" — <*►•• _(*.>»0',v«0*- — — «oosoooooo OOOOOOOOOO

O . 1 > 1 1 .

U»-'M?'«*0— —•-*'

-• — OOOOOOOO OOOOOOOOOO

_,»■, — «#00 — ^c •«aoooooooo CTOOOOOOOOO

a 1 i i 1 >

^•^•-■OOO—o— — Soooooooonc

OOOQ OOOOOO

• ••■••JO»««'* c » A.-*- • * r —■* — Wf- T • * o ^ » —* - M.,O « •■ M**«09 eeooeooece

•».♦»'S*»—»-*>^ ro—**^#6"Tro

*>••>■ tr *«■«>'« ^ C 0 ooooeoor-oo

»a»»— i-o——

^ —5«««».o» «•- »*:0 — ***■•■■ «-C» «nie«Kft—a — o oeooaococo

^oo«»««*»*»-

_, — *■ — «*-^ — — --.

* — «t^ — — •» — 00 OOOOOOOOOO

-♦-'»«*-«*0 ^•"*— #'<S.»-^-S»«

^#»**»« — *,* # — ♦ »*^»»<*c*-»o» .{'^■• — '>«*-•«—*.

OftDOOOOOCO

• *0*^«»i*s««*

» »^ *• # ♦ »v • * * — *- -!0«-*»iS*S.«P IM« ^O'««—*»oo — OOOOOOOOOO

**. 1* m *•'■**■*'*'* ■■— •»•'•■—•o»r*.'n

«—^»•O'* — »•#* -t* Ä-» — •*■< — «

'S. — — — «MOOOOO OOOOOOOOOO

«>'«* .« •• — o r « «

v —•• — <■ — «#>»o« ^O*"» — — ••o**»^*« « — 00#0-»0"0 0000000300

« ^ » «o*> — »«^-^

«.is«— — Mt>«oO OOOOOOOOOO

It I III

•■ —e«««»«*-o

^«naO'*"»"'«"'«^

-JO —••*«*'^«"» — *.- 1S»"*0—o — OOOOOOOOOO

— * *•*«.«*»« — * #«00«ntO«o«

««o««—•»»*•* »»»•»V0"»«.*00«

4PO — ««SiO—"OO OOOOOOOOOO

»»»»O^iStO»-« ^.»i*« — ^ •>* o o « fcj -^ .•!•.- ^ *. F- » ^,»*.

»♦oooo-^»»*»- — *—«••tfvOC — o ooooooocoo

»M-O»-»'««'«» —

■«*»*'*«*0<f«*i*' Jf-.K,««^0««~<# ^••Off » « o •«■ o © ♦ •KM««* — — PilOO ooooeooaoo

»-** — ^•M#«ir »000#r«*-»ir

'•I — «'Sl««n<»4*w —

_,«#*«fc-^0»* »-o-e^-^e- —o OOOOOOOOOO

■"•««••"«-■«'Si «* — *■»*—«**•

v<»*>i*n. — •»«—«-O

.«.WO—mM-na^fMo M — OM —— 00 — - ooononooeo

O O iT *- ■* C<f>44'M

>J^^tf— •»•O'KW

-;M«« — «■■—»# « «■, — *(»00<J00 OOOOOOOOOO

•.»•.-»•«■•• o» ^ »»s-r » c -s. £ » * •

**w — OOO — COO oeeeoooono

s ••;•.•,•','■

• « «^ •>• ^ M % *> r n. *•—**«©«■«*

^©«•^ — — #4*^*- >»«•—«-»-««o ^•.•.».»-.Ö^'^C o -o «-•.000-0 oooococooo

w*^«e«*«» ♦ » *• x « »,fc •- ^-.^ ««- -

e Mc © O 9 o- - O o OOOOOOOOOO

O 1 ■ 1 - ■

»o«o—•>••«•>-«

w**-?-. — «£-«»c ^OM^CO»**"- — •S.IW-^OOOOO oooeocoeoe

So —M*-—»**©

m *■" * * *■ m*- * * *• _".**•• — •«■o—* ♦-00—00000 oeaoocooeo

O iti.

0»*>«««n>««-"0 v* ^ » #«o —— *■■- r«i««>M^AiMi»<w^ ^•■**« — *•*•*♦•*"• ^M—eoooooo OOOOOOOOOO

— «.♦• — «•-—j«-- *■*« — ♦#♦•♦•• ■A » •< M O » »b M «« O »

r«—*,*#« — »»oif wo — « — oooeco — eocooeeoc oooeoooooo

O 1 1 . ■ .

j O »-«. — --- o - S OOOOOOOOOO

OOOOOOOOOO

— » — %«•♦<■ ♦•-••o t^t —

«M— »©»♦»'Mtf'

MO— PXVO— ÖOO OOOOOOOOOO

g ■'■■■•■'■■ •■ •■ ■ . —Kftf^«««©««

l0«#'«'y*fc«r — #■ w««»MV ♦«"•<•*•# — ««■POAiO — OO OOOOOOOOOO

«©•M.«>OMtf*> -» -M 4 « «OOP«"

^«■M»M»«««^. « r««m«Ntf>o«»» — W«>M*knM«M-M#w «o — — — OOP©- OOOOOOOOOO

O 'ill * ' »*.••♦ — «•» — - -#«*o#»-»oo

y«.©*1—•irr*'«- —

—«©—0—0000 OOOOOOOOOO

«* — »«MOW- * »»«»• — •"— »At»

J#©»*.»IS»- — • — •• "»♦'O'wO-OOOO OOOOOOOOOO

e 1 i 1.1 ♦

Ofcik.o*"**««»»'«

-*#•«•'»**, OO»M »p^o — 0-000 osoooeoooo

IÄ ■*.* ^ *•#■••* * r«o«i — o«>a^»i>« _JO — ■■^♦OOftOO —noopopooo ooooooocoo

© 1 1 1 t . '

• o#>*>—*"© — MM« — *•»«. o » - -" o «

¥ »»■*'*»%*<■*♦ _* «--*,-- e - e o

So-tppeogapo ooooooooeo

r*»a*«o»»#« •••■•V*»»- — — — o OOOOOOOOOO

» ««OO»—fc*«1«» •v — p»«**«**

^♦OC"» — *■"-«-* eoooooccca

e»»»*--MC # — #•»'#>«-»«-o«o

^^■»♦•«p" — •>•- »©♦■♦o###*.—» ^«»•"■•»♦•^•* ««.♦^«.-©-»hC eoooocoooo

» ••"■o-ac©-«- M "♦""«• ^ ^ •■ C *

•> — •^■♦«.O'^C- oocoopoooo

w>«—»v«»«a«*>- j»—#■ — — j-*.»-*«.

»• «.* - «c - - M o ooeooooooa

« — — — os^«»r» • —•,*#•»♦•«"- —

»«•■■••*■ * « # o — »■ w — *voo* «»*«•*■

*> —*. fc. rf. ».•(.•.p — oooaocoooo

» «— ->fcr-«-c?--'> *•*•(%■■•»«#• —

■»^e»*1*« — MO* "N FO* — "■•*oO — w ^•i»*,*-OC',»0 — MO»wO«»pO*»CC oooo«5ä--:oe

o «, ».»*•■••»«».

iJ * -<•**«*••»»■*

wp^oa««**»^»« »1.0*—-OOPC - 00003000*0

»•«*.*«4* .■ — • .» p

•»♦«-♦«(•--** «N»«««^* Or-»«»»» «>'*i —©»—•>«•« « # ««««..•««♦op oooooeopop

* OO <S( o «#—*-» « -• # » • «O «* C -

^•©♦M«**»-p«» «««A» — O»**» — •J»»e*»«««*>*» S«A —«.nt —O — p eooeopooo

•»■0©*0»"»*- — « V • « # ^ •«# - •♦**■ w«n — «»^-• — *««♦

■*»P«M<«,*a*«>*OP OOPOOPOOOO

o ' ' t » ft. « O « *■ # •-- «

ljtftOM---P««-'« ^«••»«"-«©»■■Tfs p#ir„ — _ — _.p«0 PPPOOOOOOO

«•»^ — ««a»»

rpK«o^^v«*« j***»«i»»e'0#e

0000000000

• #K»»W —»««>»«

A|*>— I^A) — -POP pooooooopp

»• 1* A* o «e »- o « - w-^tf><M<np — r>— « 8-0 * fv O - - O O

ooooeonpp

o • * •» « IS,*- »^ « M • ©^•PlSiN»*^-' wo#o#*>«o»»« 1 * * •> • ^ ^-ll" « ^««»•«■>»**p — PMPö© — — O — O PPPOOPOP©©

5 O D

47

Page 59: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

«■ • « « 4 «. «• — - 1 # • • — •* • « • « « 'sjiilfsisl « •— • « 4 ■> * ' «

• — e , .. « C

-— 5. c e C ft 9 s s

^•♦• — ft-*-*-*

* —• » • »- ■ * r »

cc sosescsc

• ♦—*•-*« — » — ■■•*•»*- — 41— — *■•■

aoeasecass

_«*■— 3«<—— » « r • » *».-*«——»»

e o —•»■■• — D*^— * oscosssoao

■^ — -- - «-»**■—•.

•*C O — O SOCOO

O : ■ ■ t

^«•«^» — £-—O» X *■—«•■ -- # — ■ » _,«s. — «*■ — <- «•«,—

r -JOOO — 300S- O 0330=53030

"■->■»— occooo OOCOOCOOoO

O I 11

U<r«>'nO'*k«" — *- c or —'-«»•■c^^w1»»*

oooooooeoo

^•"•♦M— SO«-»* — — »«.OOOOOCO ^.ooaoooooo

O I

«iM>MOO — OOOC OOOCOCJOUCO

I I t

""OOOÖOOOOO

jjj'w*0^-N*ir « — •VO — OCOOOOC oeooooooco

'VOOOOOOOOO oooooonsoc

O ■!• |i

_>*>«^^ «IM«*....

JO—(Mf^-* — ^iC-i — SO — 3COOUOOO

0000003000

#«»«r»* — «* • «

»• • •• t • •

c • • * * - ». - « •

* ^ - - * - ■*,*■ « t

« v —««•>£-^~ -ts-«=ef«ft

• «*"*.» r .

?■ - ~ * o « « —— —

^^*^ — «»o» » eoesoec ceo

: or — =sc» = o

- — *-v*r--v*-*-

• -•«.?/•»<**•.■> — ^• — ♦^w — O*^

f«C»0»90«ta — ■* -«.-*. O -C ^ — O-v Ä -• — fc^rf- — o — yce ooooocoooo

— **» ♦^o — ^ ***

zr^*^* — — -«o —

rS — o^-O* — --C — OCOOOODOOO

• •»vO •««•—-.

J*» —— »p^—o» o — **> — '• — OOfMOO o — o — oooooo

»-OO* — ft".— «B« ^»♦OO^^^frO*-

WMOftO^ — ooo oooooooooo

»♦ — (».ft^e.^.01^

z»**»« — o#o**^

iSf> O"- — — O — Co OCO — OOOOOo

(II II til

t^O^O" **• ^^•*% ZO•,0',J«'«■♦*'•,■*

"9 fv M O tA C1 ■* O O OOOOOOC O O o

— ?■# — OdC»-»«*« 0«->rv«l>«",0'0'0

«»^••»♦^►-irft — r'oo-'^»-«-« — «J« _. «J x — « *■ c -» * — o

— o^O^-ir— — "■ — OOO-'OOOOOO

JE"* — — »iNftffO^C Ji/1 — ** — O^w^O

Crf> — — o^vo — o — oooocooeoo

^O^'-I^O'NJO^IA

-JO'V»-*»^ O*SI — OO ■"-o* — — ■iooo OOOOOOOOOO

-■-*«*■• »■ - I - • * • * «■ * « • - «■*■ «•

■»• • — *••«•.» • •ft ft f♦ ••* ft

• —• ;* • —•• * .««••««« «)«»• • »ft * —— ft : — «, -

ftftSCftftftSftC

ft «.•■ .ft «_^**. ^•-- * = «■ - 5 « -

«■ftftft^ft^C «k^-« ft —ft^S «»•♦- = --' — »•ft«*C*'-

— — i C S 5- r .OS »CftOftSC = T =.

ft«***»** •*•• *3«-«^. —-ft —

„»*-.*—--w — - —

-ft^ —^^»•■»e— « ^* c—— cccsc ffc scscrscc

ft*.«*««***- • *••»•■■« — #—ft

»ft«"» — »••■••^ „ft*««»—«'--- — ceceso^ re ooseesaooo

• •->• — — — ft«-«*- ^ft*^«^*-» — «* ft^^-ft«*^-^» ft -. « •■ »ft —-k-ftC^. «ooeooecoo ocoooccsoc

vn « «—■♦^•v—^ •■i.— Cft—ft-»— ♦

rf-**^-* — *—i»o ft»ft^C^«tf>— «■» ^O — fc— » — » 0 im^

'•OOCOCOOCO ooocecoooc

"•* — • — — — «•• — •WftOft-ft—-• — »

^»■»ft***- — — <- X—— •^»••ftt» ^. o W"'%^0«Vft*0*'0 ^o^coocooo oooooooooo

Ä»- ««W-ftMft»«!.?

OAt<s>'-000000 oooooeoceo

Oft—'ofti-'ft^On. ^ftM«>v^Ma«ft

^ftftOftftftft"«ftf« o^o——oooo— oooooooooo

Oftftft««^tf>»><» MftftOfttftftQ-'ft

•/» — ^«»■»rfl»**' ft ^•"•iV^^Oft-**« j^O^Oft«"-«»" —

f^nt — eoooooo oooooooooo

O^^ft — ««ft^ft O*--" — OO* — ?s.* — zo-'ft^^^ — iMie» j-O'-O'^'* — *■«- — *'*'00 — —ooo — OOOCOCOOCO

b^«»— — — 9 tr m o *• X '~ *• »xO^ft» — «si j^Oftrw^^rw — i^fc- -*ooo — OOOOO OOOOOOOOOO

O — i-"**-! — «r-««^ "•Oft» — 1*»^- — "-■

o — '«'^ft — ir'si«r"-o

^»•»■/'»^-fte^O is.O — OOOOOOO oooooooeoo

«MfttriN<'nps.«9>-'0 <AftO — OMftN-a«« rft**^***»»*!/* — »O WMfflfth-ftlAOOOO OOOOOOOOOO OOOOOOOOOO

^ft»>ftO«O«^0 NM> «n p ft ^. ^ « lA ft

a — ♦MOiNttrO1* — »

_, — n^^oo — — DO o — noOooooo OOOOOOOOOO

»«•JftBftft«*

•*ft*^X»*** —•ft»— ft ft— ft ».ft - #ft*ft—'ftVftftftC

ftft^^ — • —— « — ftftft—«• S X ft ft

"ftM^ftft—ftr«^ ftft—ftftft*^ — ft« _ — — « ft — » 4 « « « ••^•—ft«^ft—

— ^ft *««.*■—ft.. •ftftftft^e«—- ^^^ftft —ftft-eeft P— Oftft—ft-»0—ft - — ——ft *■«• — —ft

oc-oceeetoe

«■».O—••«^'•Cft ftCftft— »'•■■ft ^—ft—'*ftft«ft«ft

Z'ftC^ftft^ftO—

— «^»ft—ft—» ft — — *— ft-.^-'-teO

Wft^ft — ftftftftft ft^ft — •• —•*••-• — ftft^^ft » — • —»h

— ••o«.oo —CO ooC — coooeo

-.O^OO^-MaftftC o- — » — C>-. or — eoooeocoort

— — O — — ftftftft* ftft --ft-^» — -mffc

V—» ft«*1— O—»w — fte***ftftftftftOft w»—ftftftftCft — —

-.O-s. — — ^ — 003 O — 00330000

— OftftftftOftft«* »t-O — •»—«< — *,

O^ftOftft*»*-«*-© V-. - ft « o — — OiA n<

ft —ftOOMOTQ»«^ — mo—ooooao

t/lfw««ft — ft*t^ft»<ft

_lft — ftftOfttftOfttf« -•«.O*-—rf> — — oo OOOOOOOOOO

«ftftft«'«tf>ftftft — Oft'"* —»«••-ft^

Oft<N'»«ft«^*k'Mft zftK«lft«ftftl»ft-. _,0«>'- — ftftftftft«r

*-er*~t~> — oooo OOO — oooooo

II II II

MOftftftfttftftO

w« — ffrf'ftff OM^'A^- Z^ftO — SO'Mft"*'« _)«»i~ — «-i/'i-ift'S',

a—r>« — «ftmoitir OOOOOOOOOO

ftfttf* — ftrnOfM**. O^ftftft—^Oft^f" jrfto»*'ft»\ft'»*»*'"

• ftftftftfti'in* — O 0 3 00000000

III I l l I I I

rv^ftOftftkOO» ^ -> »v. ftOOtft — OOft »O^-ft*»«» —— ftftf* -j^ftOOO^'VOft —

r^iNO'^'yiNi'st'—'"» — OOOOOOOOOO

^ ««-»»«gOVftf*1* OftMO'ftftft-**».

.iirftiMNNOftO^ft — *oir-.-oooo OOOOOOOOOO

I till I

^.■*(*ftS>ftp>.«»0

48

Page 60: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

'hlilli:!: sHHitirsr uizimii - • . «4 -

t rxsssrsss: ' yHHHHH KZSSS^III « . * ^ * — t • ^« «

sssssiss«! "istsilH;! '::i:2::»l

-H5£££nsr

■ -

;;•-£•*?:? «-««>« «^.* •**■«

• -trssjsssss -s:i5S:S555 •

f 3 esses-ec«»©

i % •••eeveeo«

»«-•o-a«-«« e

• »*.•»••—•* o «^ssisrris $*o ««»*'•«■• —

'Hliiillil 'lifillrlll • • s '. o o = 9 ae oc

«•«« — »-•■e*'—^

i e

isrtsssrss • zztssztszsz 55j:5::s:=s • »■••••*e—**"* zzttzzsazt

f sooaeoaeoo * « oeocooosoo ooooovoeo« ' . ■ > .

*»•••«►»»» «•• o * ^r;t«^x«-»* «».-••©•.•♦—*■ ■ .. — »^.* —^»—*o "

oocceooooe

Zi~tzzt*zz7 a

» ,***'"' t' f" I* '

k-

a •.C-w^O»*-»*1

o

6 <•.«-*■— O-O —3*

#•- O — *♦■—«••• "• »■•o* *-««oa«v« .-*»*0**iO— '-S

»-■^oo —<>0«»3» -•ooooocaoo c e © «• o «r r e & C' C 4,> ca » «3 O t> 49 s

O

» w o o » c ca o o o

o • ; . , . « m 3 sssjissirsr *i:;5st;::;s o«»-«'««««»-«« »Sissrissss

30ÖOCCCOCC I gsssssgggs 3 0303090000 oooeoo^oao

Ml

« - - - -

:::SJ;;JS: *••*«*♦^-•-•-♦#*,

ssslssssss sssgggfgig S o

0«MM«M^tMi»» S .«.,«.f.^« « « e S >* 7 ^ r « M • «. —— ♦O«« i"^« •» *t«M«MMf>. «*.•«.- • oS5=s»2=:ss

» «t » « »-* tft ^ • M «

ssssssllls 1

s^ssjsssss?: J32§:2S8SSS #«fvO«oooor>o o«"o —— oooeo eooocooeoo

i i i i i i

ooeooooooo

t t i <

ooeooooooo

iii i <

o Mmmo««^—«• «»0«-«tf(*»*«fsiO

m

• ►- » o * » o ow* r #**■>•**—«o« • »VM«««^?«^,» #

v*^«««>«»n»*OK.« «o»^^«6^^«« r«*<"« — «»—o^'

■ »st —«O O O OO O o ra —^OOOC—OO StiZiZSSSS «•v — ooooooo

3 ooeooooooo oooooooooo 4

i 3 OOOOOOOOOO oooooooooo

• •«») «fWfS««'« pV M ««»ft>»t**0^-"M o gcisiscj;:: s o«re —»oa^M«

_l««tf>— «««At.*« _«*«o» — o—— ■#« -*»>*-o#o-o*«»# J«Sgs2iSgsS • ?

cooooooooo oooooooooo

till ( i OOOOOOOOOO oooeeeooeo

i i i i i ,

«r

^■♦^■»^oo*-» 9 ** IO G *,*• & O <* O-

e

— •^•^♦Otra«« »«•* — K*1

« — -e«»«-'"' sssissseatss s _j«««* — O — 'W'"

if« — "JOOCOOO J

OfMO'-OOO — OO ♦OOOOOOOOO «MO — (NMtoomo

* ooooeooooo ooeooooooo & OOOOOOOOOO oooooooooo

* * i i ' * t ' 1 ' 1* 1* * ' 1* ' o 1* 1 1 , 1* 1* 1* * * * ( *

* •»* —♦ffO«m^C #tft9^««<"««>« e «•«**» — «O*« uir^^po*" —^-K* roc«««« — O'"»«

U«M»»«««^«M iJOtf'O****-**»*'

— ■N.«<0 —o—ooo oeoooooeoe i§g?gg§§gg ■ <NOO<VOÖ-000

ooeooooooo >■

ggSSgSSgög III III 1

5 »•e«putf>»oro — wt»>»|h.«c>Atft*«0

o

f*#«*i»«»«S — w«

^■• —oe—eooo oooooooooo

> i i i i o

noopoooooe

i t < iii

oooooooooo o

aooeoooooo

8 s i(css:3ij;i5 ¥»>om «-» ^CA» W4—OW* «#««•«> ■ o

S s gggggggggs oooooooooo a oooooooooo

o Uf — wo

u «

t i 1 1 1 i • 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 ■ i i i i

"■ "" —

49

Page 61: ÜSAAML TECHNICAL REPORT 65-13 AN EXPERIMENTAL … · 2018-11-08 · 61 Üsaaml technical report 65-13 an experimental investigation of rotor harmonic airloads including the effects

v « • • « •••*-»•*.

• *** — ;-

• • c * c «^ o«a

*»*■»-. c ♦•■ —-

— - ■? o e o to : oaeoooojc

M# o# # d « •••s* -. —— 3:—O-rt oeoeooo^c

*••»«-•■- — < jr-. — — — — •■-

»• —-i« — ——» « • « « «**'« «* T5—c==«rs=

— ©*■*« —^**^.e

oeo9eooeeo

s

r » * * —«► * — ^ -> -

*-«» — — — ©CO- oesGoccso:

^<««» — — ♦ « # —

OO — CCOOOOC

»■■"«^ — = -. -,*»»

^•*.*•*•* — ♦o*#

_,C««9*-0« — « — -fc-v — cc — o — o — oscoeooocc

■ —» - o «

' ♦ ^ « •» « ^ o

3003000"S00

• -v — *.-«*.«-3

««#«« — « a•—• *e —t —•« — e• • « » • « » r c c *

aococooces

■wo© — eocose 9ooooe>cooo

* —» 9- — ^

»**■<»-'? •» — *

z*»o — <-« _*o*»^^*^e o o o o o o c o o o o o o e

' — -■••^^■4*

«•* « <- e • «••

*« •«• •** * » —- *

» < - » •.- * c -r • «-■—-»i:«a

* *•* « -« o « * » — * *,«. — •■ a —o s — sececoeaes

9 —«_0* — # « »

»O—•»« — »» ——

cr — ocoeooe

»fcC«*"—*■*

-■^.■>.-».-fc—-*,*' ■• o

eooooseooo

««■—C«C — 9 —O 90—eoeoooo

• — «oo»« — — #^ -IN.»» O C *■•-*"• <" «*ücoocooe oocoooaoso

»■«■■■*-««-»v—«o«

-y*__ — n_o — OOOOOOOOOO

^ — *. - ? -- Ä '

— — o —— pooco eoooeooeoo

ON«**»OOOO OOOOOOOOOO

«Mtf^f«««« —OA> •-■*»**>*>»0»-0*' *9.««^«"— O'O^

1 • *• —e^o — ■-*■ **r*«»—OO^-C

oeeeeeooeo

¥ --if- «O"**" — **** OOOOOOOOOO

^ « »M IS. - — f^ * — «^

tf» • — * IM -1 z •« o •*■ • « _(■« MM.« * — o o o 00000

— * *1 rf- 7»

^ O « »■ iT »■*— — »««

Sr- M • r. OOOO

OOOOO

« •*> ■ e iro*

j——OS»'^'- « — C O O O • O O O O O O f

JO*»

— — •*,«-". — o««io ■^ — < — ^«n—«c — »**» — *■*■#* — *»

-« —«««M—»•«»« ««• ^M__OOO — Oo OOOOOOOOOO

©■»•'O'NO— OOO OOOOOOOOOO

*■«"*' — «^-QISi«»- .«-.ooc? — <* — -*- IT*- — **vO'^"-'MC — ^O^C4 C*« — ■#**

•"fttOCOOOOOO OOOOOOOOOO

o««<r«a>««*>o tM»*-*%aOriM»#t»M z*«** — ««-»*»«». ^ -•««»Mi —««k««« • ^OA. ^o — - O n. OOOOOOOOOO

111 III

■ Ml^f^VtO«"««« tftMO««OAi«aM

<.JO — — O^WOrf'«*' X *- «O — — «>« — — M

OOOOOOOOOO

I > till

« or ^•■ » « » » *• ■<

jo » a » .r e ? — c - > o c c 3 O O <

« o a * » •- 1 r- r o C « *• *

»««o^—o^ jrawsp^-<^»

O — ^ * O — ' 0 o o o o a (

. 9 K ■ «*«i ' * a

«o«o«9«a «• # M *•• «t •>■ *• a

•"»o — — *■#»• »-.JOAiOOO'V ^««<N«r'<FO *oooo — 00 00000000

O O o o

y Q * -^ m rf- K. . j _ ■»■ rf5 — — — -

— O o o o o t o e o o 0 o <

* * ~ 9 «ao — — *» —

— rr^aaaa«**

»»•"«O^iS — tf««*« _j — ^««■'^«ira'^'"

IN — ^- « — INl Py O W* O OOOOOOOOOO

(S.O« — ^»VOOfN*-

-JOO** — »** — O --OOOOOOnO OOOOOOOOOO 0150

150

D2

*)7

0)

00175)*

00

6810

8 00

17*9

6 005*0

7)

00

1)8

*0

00 1

6771

00

5721

5 00

1*00

1

0—00000000 OOOOOOOOOO

.80

LNC

01152))

-

Ot1

)9*2

05

2)10

1

- 0*

2960

7

01*2

97*

02^

*655

-

01)8

526

-

01

)*7

))

- 01

*015

9 -

0

0*7

)79

-

»-^«♦^«^.«»o

1 1 « 1 I

s 1.-«^!«.. • aao^—^«r^—

^mrvoa^mof-r« o* — 0—oooor- --»■♦-rvOOOO OOOOOOOCOC OOOOOOOOOO

" II III

za^f — ?a«*x'"* fiir»9«o«oaK-a

_<-«*IN»-O«O — < *OOOOPOOOO OOOO&OOOOO OOOOOOOOOO

»p~c*ona««*- oa«»a^ — »*-o

O — --MOOOOOo 00-0000000

»O'"«*-.«^«»^

1 1 1

z»»M*»s»a#<* A _i«a««'M*A'««s<o — OODOOOOOO

OOOOOOOOOO

*oeo — a-*tTOW) r>

»♦•rt^O««*'^^ *2:;:s3;sl| J^««« — 0«^OOM

r-'v*>*^*^«*o

OOOOOOOOOO

1 III 1

50